March/April 2009 www.FAOToday.com

More documents

Recommendations

Info

Department Compliance Beyond Governance Investing in Relationship Management up front can mean the difference between outsourcing success and failure. By David Borowski It is common for an organization entering into an FAO relationship to have completed a financial justification for the initiative, and to have a stellar business case to prove the value of outsourcing. However, actual results do not always meet expectations. As an example, according to a contract management benchmark report by the Aberdeen Group, surveyed CFOs believe that only 35 percent of negotiated savings are actually realized. While such failures have varied causes, poor Relationship Management practices are a common culprit. FAO contracts often adequately describe governance practices and considerations, such as risk and issue management, vendor performance management, and change control, but the parties subsequently fail to implement such practices effectively. Instead, they end up reacting to the issue du jour, neglecting to follow the protocols conceived and captured among the contract schedules. A complementary approach to governance is prioritizing the relationship practices outside the strictures of the contract. Best Practices Often, focusing on the following relationship management best practices leads to a more beneficial partnership with an FAO vendor and makes realization of business case projections more likely: 1. Align on approach: Every client-vendor relationship is unique, not only in the traditional sense of size, scale, and geographical span, but also in terms of personalities, styles, cultures, and preferred interaction approach. It is important to establish each party’s interaction expectations early in the relationship—some clients are very hands-on and prefer to manage processes at a very detailed level, while others prefer to manage exceptions only and leave day-to-day operations to their outsourcer. While both approaches can be successful, if the approach is not discussed up front and there is resulting misalignment (e.g., client assumes hands-off and vendor assumes hands-on), significant effort is required to overcome the resulting issues and also to recalibrate the approach. 2. Prioritize the relationship: Process owners, subject matter experts, and relationship managers have busy schedules. It’s easy to miss an occasional operations meeting as other responsibilities become more important. It is also easy for this behavior to become the norm once a precedent is set, often resulting in risks not being identified and addressed before they become issues. It is important to make the relationship a priority—establish and maintain an interaction cadence, which demonstrates a mutual commitment to dialogue and improvement. 3. Solve problems together: It is common to hear the phrase “That’s not my problem,” uttered by client personnel involved in supporting outsourced business processes. Often, this stems from the notion of a “black box” solution, when client resources believe that the recipe for success involves “throwing an issue over the wall” and requiring the outsourcer to resolve the issue independently. Effective problem solving in an outsourced environment requires both parties to put blame on hold, work collaboratively to identify the true root-cause of an issue, and take responsibility for resolving the components that each is best positioned to address. 4. React to data, not innuendo: Trust is established over time and only with demonstrated success. Until an FAO provider has earned that trust, client personnel—especially those with previously bad outsourcing experiences—are often naturally resistant to the process. During the initial trust-building stage of the partnership, client relationship management advocates must vigilantly separate perception from reality. A proven way to combat unwarranted reluctance is through the use of data. Through proper utilization of data and facts to substantiate a recommendation or decision, objectivity supersedes subjectivity, and emotion is removed from the equation. 5. Be accountable for outsourcing success: Many clients take a hands-off approach to a vendor partnership, preferring to think of the vendor delivery of services as a spin-off. It is more meaningful and critical, especially during the beginning of the relationship, to treat it as a joint venture, or extension of the organization. While this type of approach has been a challenge for many clients to institutionalize, success begins with recognizing that the relationship depends equally on contributions from both the outsourcer and the client. By acknowledging accountability up front, a client embraces the role of facilitator and acknowledges that success is improbable without the appropriate level of relationship support. Integrating these practices into an outsourcing client’s Relationship Management approach will help reduce the chance of retrospective qualifiers such as “we didn’t communicate well enough” or “expectations weren’t aligned.” Instead, they proudly serve as vendor references in support of their outsourcing partner’s latest business opportunity. FAO David Borowski is a senior associate with Pace Harmon and has extensive experience in business process and IT outsourcing, contract manufacturing, global operations and sourcing process improvement, and complex project execution. Pace Harmon is an outsourcing advisory services firm providing proven guidance to Fortune 500 and high-growth middle-market organizations on outsourcing and strategic sourcing transactions, process optimization, and vendor program governance. 10 FAO Today March/April 2009 www.faotoday.com
TODAY Page Category 12 Accounts Payable Processing (AP) 16 Accounts Receivable Management, Credit & Collections, Recovery Audit (AR) 20 Compliance Management (CM) 22 Customer Service & Call Center Management (CS) 23 Enterprise Level FAO (EN) 24 Financial Reporting & Risk Management (FR) 28 General Accounting, Financial Risk Management, & Indirect Procurement (GA) 32 Investor Relations (I) 33 Payroll Processing & Expense Management (P) 37 Procurement (PRO) 38 Recordkeeping, Accounting & Tax Administration (REC) 40 Sourcing Consultants, Advisors & Legal Counsel (S) 42 Statement Processing (SP) 44 Tax Management (TM) 2 0 0 9 RESOURCE GUIDE The 2009 Resource Guide is an ever-growing compendium of service providers angling for your business. That means you have more choices than ever, which can only be good in a flagging economy. This year’s FAO Resource Guide is the best tool we’ve offered yet to help shoppers find all the providers and their areas of expertise in one place. The 2009 guide includes more than 616 vendors covering 16 domains within FAO. You won’t find a more comprehensive directory of service vendors anywhere. In addition, make sure you visit www.faotoday.com for an expanded, online version of the Resource Guide, which features even more in-depth information about the providers listed here. As a “living document,” the electronic version is updated on a rolling basis, so if your tax department is overworked or you need to outsource payroll to a capable provider, find what you’re looking for in the following pages or on the FAOT web site. All you need to do is register there, and you’ll be ready to go shopping for a new FAO partner. 47 Treasury & Investment Management (TI) 49 Trustee Services & Trust Administration (TS) www.faotoday.com March/April 2009 FAO Today 11
Page 1 and 2: March/April 2009 www.FAOToday.com
Page 3 and 4: Contents Page 50 New FAO Strategies
Page 5 and 6: Creative Sourcing for a Challenging
Page 7 and 8: Mergers, Deals, and More News quate
Page 9: JOIN THE FAO ASSOCIATION A few word
Page 13 and 14: F A O T O D A Y 2 0 0 9 R E S O U R
Page 51 and 52: Cover Story ‘We wanted (Infosys)
Page 53 and 54: Cover Story opined that the days of
Page 55 and 56: Feature and increasing cross-functi
Page 57 and 58: Shared Services Feature BENEFITS AN
Page 59 and 60: Feature from comparable companies r
Page 61 and 62:
Feature nally, FAO allows mid-marke
Page 63 and 64:
AMR Research Expert Advice Teamwork
Page 66 and 67:
Expert Advice Ask Chris Getting Sma
show all

March/April 2009 www.FAOToday.com

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?