Spring Conference Review - reomac
Spring Conference Review - reomac
Spring Conference Review - reomac
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Ma y / Ju n e 2009<br />
REOMAC®<br />
updatetm<br />
t h e o f f i c i a l n at i o n a l p u b l i c a t i o n o f t h e<br />
As s o c i at i o n o f Re a l Es t a t e Ow n e d Ma n a g e r s , In c .<br />
<strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong> <strong>Review</strong>
REOMAC® 2009<br />
Board of Directors<br />
OFFICERS<br />
Shelley Kaye, President<br />
Beatrice Davis, Vice President<br />
Benton Neese, Vice President<br />
Donna La Porte, Secretary<br />
Kathy Jeffers-Volk, Treasurer<br />
BOARD MEMBERS<br />
Art Acosta<br />
LeeAnn Axcell<br />
Ivan Choi<br />
Frank Lougher<br />
John Murray<br />
Cynthia Nierer<br />
Mia Semo<br />
Sara Waite<br />
REOMAC® Headquarters<br />
Jennifer Blevins, CMP<br />
Account Executive<br />
John Berkowitz<br />
Publications Director<br />
Nathan Carlson<br />
Sponsorships<br />
Michael Cochran<br />
Webmaster<br />
Joseph Davis<br />
Account Executive<br />
Jessica Drake<br />
Administrative Assistant /<br />
Membership Coordinator<br />
Kim Ingersoll<br />
Advertising Administrator<br />
Erin René Nelson<br />
Meeting Planner<br />
Anissa Routon<br />
Director of Education<br />
Stephanie Schoen<br />
Special Projects<br />
Tricia Schrum, CPA<br />
Accountant<br />
Ma y / Ju n e 2009<br />
REOMAC®<br />
updatetm<br />
De pa r tm e n t s<br />
President’s Message – Shelley Kaye.......................................... 3<br />
Editor’s Message – Kathy Jeffers-Volk ......................................... 4<br />
Headquarters Happenings – Jessica Drake................................... 7<br />
<strong>Conference</strong> Wrap-Up – Diana Kendall........................................ 8<br />
Fe a t u r e s<br />
REOMAC® 2009 SPRING <strong>Conference</strong> —<br />
Thank You, Sponsors and Exhibitors! ............................................10<br />
SESSION I: Keynote Speaker, Christopher Gardner – Gary Tatar................ 25<br />
SESSION II: Economist, Christopher Thornberg, PhD. – Jim Conway. .......... 29<br />
SESSION III: Town Hall Session – Ronald S. Deutsch, Esq........................ 33<br />
EARLY BREAKOUT 1: Fraud: From Origination to REO – Mark Dorris ........... 37<br />
EARLY BREAKOUT 3: Commercial Properties +<br />
Mortgage Default = Are You Prepared? – Bruce Juenger.................... 41<br />
LATE BREAKOUT 2: Foreclosure and Loss<br />
Mitigation Evolvement – Benton Neese.................................... 43<br />
LATE BREAKOUT 3: Litigation Update – Berry F. Laws III, Esq................... 45<br />
REOMAC® Update Editor<br />
Kathy Jeffers-Volk<br />
REOMAC®<br />
2520 Venture Oaks Way, Suite 150<br />
Sacramento, CA 95833<br />
916-239-4090 • 916-924-7323 fax<br />
www.<strong>reomac</strong>.com • info@<strong>reomac</strong>.com<br />
Copyright 2009 © by the Association of Real Estate Owned Managers.<br />
No portion of this magazine may be printed without express written<br />
consent of REOMAC®. The writings within these pages do not<br />
necessarily reflect opinions of REOMAC®.<br />
REOMAC® is a not-for-profit corporation dedicated to the professional<br />
advancement of its Regular, Affiliate and Associate members<br />
nationwide. REOMAC® provides resources to anyone whose career<br />
interest revolves around pre- and post-foreclosure, loss mitigation<br />
and the management and disposition of distressed assets.<br />
The membership includes lenders and servicers; attorneys and<br />
vendors; and real estate brokers from across the country. REOMAC®<br />
members are dedicated to improving the quality of service they<br />
provide each other and the industry at large.<br />
With the exception of products or services, or articles specifically<br />
under REOMAC® control and supervision, it is the policy of REOMAC®,<br />
its Officers and board of directors and the Editor of this publication,<br />
NOT TO ENDORSE ANY PRODUCTS, SERVICES, OR OPINIONS<br />
EXPRESSED IN THIS PERIODICAL.<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 1
2 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Shelley Kaye<br />
2009 REOMAC® President<br />
Here we are, half way<br />
through the year. Our<br />
<strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong> has<br />
taken place and it was definitely<br />
the biggest and best educational<br />
conference that REOMAC® has<br />
ever presented. Thank you<br />
to Cynthia Nierer who put<br />
together the most compressive<br />
educational sessions that I have<br />
ever attended. Our conference<br />
chair, Diana Kendall did an<br />
incredible job in putting the<br />
conference together. And<br />
of course, our management<br />
company, led by Jennifer<br />
Blevins and Joseph Davis,<br />
made sure that everything ran<br />
smoothly and with their staff,<br />
assisted all attendees in all<br />
situations. There has been so<br />
much said and printed about<br />
the conference, that I would<br />
like to offer my overview.<br />
REOMAC® moved the<br />
conference to the Marriott<br />
Desert <strong>Spring</strong>s hotel in order<br />
to safely and comfortably<br />
conduct our sessions in a<br />
place large enough to hold the<br />
amount of people attending<br />
this conference. The hotel<br />
staff expressed their thanks<br />
to the REOMAC® conference<br />
attendees for their kindness<br />
and professionalism at the<br />
hotel. Every staff member was<br />
impressed by how nice they<br />
were treated by our group and<br />
are looking forward to the 2010<br />
<strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong>.<br />
The pre-conference certification<br />
classes were attended by over<br />
900 people. We hope to offer<br />
these types of certification<br />
courses on an ongoing basis.<br />
During the opening ceremonies,<br />
No Paws Left Behind was<br />
presented a check for $5,000<br />
to assist them in their fight<br />
to aid the animals left behind<br />
in vacant homes and those<br />
needing placement in a home<br />
when the owners cannot take<br />
them when they move out of<br />
the property. Cheryl Lang of No<br />
Paws Left Behind let me know<br />
that they raised over $10,000,<br />
due to the generosity of our<br />
attendees. Good job everyone.<br />
We can each make a difference<br />
in this great endeavor.<br />
Our keynote speaker,<br />
Christopher Gardner is an<br />
outstanding, inspirational<br />
s p e a ker. H i s s t or y of<br />
homelessness, and his desire<br />
to be the best father that he<br />
could be, reached out and<br />
affected all of us. Each of us,<br />
in our own way, could relate<br />
to his story and appreciate the<br />
desire and drive to be the best<br />
that one could be, even in the<br />
worst situation. REOMAC®<br />
was proud to present his<br />
story to the attendees and<br />
hoped everyone learned a<br />
lesson about perseverance and<br />
determination, and doing the<br />
right thing.<br />
As always, Dr. Christopher<br />
Thornberg presented a<br />
comprehensive analysis of<br />
the economy and the housing<br />
market, capturing the attention<br />
of every single person attending<br />
that session. Our Town<br />
hall session was incredibly<br />
stimulating with the panelists<br />
entering into heated debate<br />
on the state of the housing<br />
crisis. John Vella moderated<br />
the interactive debate with<br />
Dr. Thornberg, Peter Monroe,<br />
California State Senator Ronald<br />
S. Calderon and Rocky Rushing,<br />
Chief of Staff for Senator<br />
Calderon. Our closing session<br />
of the day discussed doing<br />
business with the companies<br />
that will be handling REO<br />
products for the FDIC.<br />
Tuesday’s sessions were also<br />
engrossing and timely and filled<br />
with information presented by<br />
the best and brightest people<br />
in the default industry. The<br />
finale of the afternoon was<br />
the opportunity to hear from<br />
the lenders/outsourcers that<br />
are responsible for selling the<br />
nations REO’s.<br />
The REOMAC® Board of<br />
Directors, along with our<br />
Management Company, and<br />
all of our committee members,<br />
worked endless long hours to<br />
ensure that this conference<br />
continued on page 47<br />
REOMAC®<br />
Committees<br />
<strong>Conference</strong> Committee<br />
Board Chair – LeeAnn Axcell<br />
Membership Committee<br />
Board Chair – Frank Lougher<br />
Education Committee<br />
Board Chair – Cynthia Nierer<br />
Certification Committee<br />
Board Chair – Sara Waite<br />
Chair – Art Acosta<br />
Public Relations/<br />
Marketing Committee<br />
Board Chair – Donna La Porte<br />
Scholarship Committee<br />
Board Chair – Mia Semo<br />
Publications/<br />
Communications Committee<br />
Board Chair – Benton Neese<br />
Chair – Kathy Jeffers-Volk<br />
Technology/<br />
Web Site Committee<br />
Board Chair – Ivan Choi<br />
Commercial Committee<br />
Board Chair – John Murray<br />
For information to participate on<br />
a committee, please contact the<br />
committee chair or REOMAC® at<br />
info@<strong>reomac</strong>.com.<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 3
Kathy Jeffers-Volk<br />
Editor<br />
What a wonderful<br />
educational conference<br />
we had in April.<br />
Christopher Gardner – fabulous,<br />
Christopher Thornberg – right<br />
on the money, Town Hall –<br />
rabble rousing ... well, you get<br />
the picture. The speakers for<br />
all sessions were outstanding<br />
– I came away feeling I had<br />
learned something from each<br />
of the sessions attended. I am<br />
looking forward to our Fall<br />
<strong>Conference</strong>.<br />
I have often written and said<br />
the conference could not be<br />
what it is without the many<br />
volunteers we rely upon. This<br />
conference was no exception.<br />
Within 30 minutes of sending<br />
out my request for volunteers<br />
I received over 400 responses –<br />
UNBELIEVABLE! We had first<br />
time attendees volunteering as<br />
well as those who attend and<br />
volunteer every year. Some<br />
attendees even had their whole<br />
family helping with the bag<br />
stuffing. THANK YOU ALL!<br />
2009 Publication Calendar:<br />
Issue:<br />
The reporters for this<br />
conference did an outstanding<br />
job. Thanks to all the reporters<br />
for taking time from their busy<br />
schedules to provide us with<br />
their coverage of the sessions.<br />
Gary Tatar, Millenia Real<br />
Estate, covered the Keynote<br />
Speaker, Christopher Gardner.<br />
Talk about an inspirational<br />
speaker! I believe everyone<br />
left the room with a positive<br />
“pursuit” attitude.<br />
Once again, Jim Conway of<br />
Regional Realty Group shared<br />
what he took away from the<br />
Economic Forecast as presented<br />
by Christopher Thornberg.<br />
Christopher’s sessions are<br />
always well attended – so<br />
much of the information he<br />
has provided over the last few<br />
years has been spot on.<br />
The Town Hall session was<br />
reported on by my “go-to”<br />
writer, Ron Deutsch of Cohn,<br />
Goldberg & Deutsch LLC.<br />
This was one of my favorite<br />
sessions – to have debate,<br />
disagreement and concurrence<br />
all on one stage and even from<br />
the audience (Judge Goldberg)<br />
made the time fly by. This<br />
session could have gone on<br />
for hours.<br />
Mark Dorris, First Team Real<br />
Estate, provided us with a<br />
detailed write up on the Fraud<br />
panel. He wrote on the panel’s<br />
insight into current fraud<br />
trends, what to look for when<br />
suspecting fraud is occurring<br />
and fraud prevention.<br />
Bruce Juenger of M.D. Webb &<br />
Associates, Inc., a Past President<br />
of REOMAC® and former<br />
Update Editor, reported on our<br />
first time Commercial Session.<br />
This standing room only session<br />
looked at the anticipated loan<br />
default market relating to<br />
commercial properties.<br />
Loss Mitigation was reported<br />
on by REOMAC®’s Vice<br />
President, Benton Neese<br />
Articles Due:<br />
Jul/Aug — Topics TBD.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . July 10<br />
Sep/Oct — Topics TBD.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . September 11<br />
Nov/Dec — Fall <strong>Conference</strong> Wrap-Up Edition....................................November 6<br />
of RMIC. Changes in the<br />
mortgage industry, emphasis<br />
on loan modifications and<br />
the increasing number of<br />
delinquent loans were topics<br />
covered in this session. As<br />
professionals in the default<br />
industry it is imperative that<br />
we not only look at foreclosures,<br />
but aid homeowners in the<br />
short sale and loan modification<br />
process. Our emphasis<br />
should be to prevent as many<br />
foreclosures as possible.<br />
The litigation session was<br />
reported by Berry Laws III of<br />
Martin, Leigh, Laws & Fritzlen,<br />
P.C. This session not only<br />
covered issues in California<br />
but addressed other State and<br />
Federal concerns also. Knowing<br />
the law was a recurring concern<br />
of the panelists. Much of the<br />
discussion was on bankruptcy<br />
and debtor’s rights.<br />
Remember – when you talk,<br />
you repeat what you already<br />
know; when you listen, you<br />
often learn something. Thank<br />
you, speakers and panelists, for<br />
sharing what you know and<br />
allowing each of us to learn<br />
something new.<br />
If you would like to write for<br />
the Update or be a reporter<br />
at one of the conferences<br />
please contact me at kjvlk@aol.<br />
com. I’m looking forward to<br />
receiving your article.<br />
4 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 5
6 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Jessica Drake<br />
Membership Coordinator<br />
It is hard to believe, but<br />
REOMAC® is already half<br />
way through 2009! Finding<br />
ourselves a few months out<br />
from our Fall <strong>Conference</strong> in<br />
Hollywood, Florida, there is a<br />
lot happening.<br />
For those interested in<br />
exhibiting and/or sponsoring<br />
at our Fall <strong>Conference</strong>, our<br />
Web site already has the<br />
necessary forms available,<br />
and it can all be done online.<br />
By the time you are reading<br />
this column, registration<br />
for attendees for the Fall<br />
<strong>Conference</strong> will open online<br />
for members. For nonmembers,<br />
registration will<br />
become available August 1 st .<br />
Our Web site stays up-to-date<br />
as things become available, so<br />
check frequently for pertinent<br />
conference information as the<br />
date approaches.<br />
In July REOMAC® will be<br />
awarding a minimum of<br />
fifteen scholarships with a<br />
maximum level of $3,000<br />
each. These scholarships are<br />
awarded based on academic<br />
achievement, financial need,<br />
extracurricular activities,<br />
community involvement<br />
and the letter enclosed in<br />
the application. Further<br />
requirements and details can<br />
be found on the application,<br />
which is available on our<br />
Web site.<br />
This summer is going to be<br />
busy with Dinner Meetings<br />
throughout the country. Our<br />
June 25th Dinner Meeting in<br />
Philadelphia included a predinner<br />
certification course on<br />
short sales. The dinner topic,<br />
presented by a distinguished<br />
panel, covered REO financing.<br />
Denver will be the host city<br />
for our August 19th Dinner<br />
Meeting. Don’t forget to mark<br />
your calendars now!<br />
REOMAC® would also like<br />
to introduce and welcome<br />
Anissa Routon as Director of<br />
Education.<br />
In closing, I have included<br />
some of the FAQs I receive<br />
here at Headquarters<br />
regarding membership and<br />
event registration:<br />
Why is membership for all<br />
categories closed right now?<br />
At this time, the Board<br />
of Directors is hard<br />
at work revising the<br />
application process to<br />
allow more people into<br />
the membership who<br />
will contribute to the<br />
REO industry and our<br />
organization. Please<br />
see the “Join REOMAC®”<br />
section of our Web site<br />
and click on the ‘notify<br />
me’ but ton for you r<br />
membership category<br />
so we can e-mail you<br />
when membership has<br />
reopened.<br />
Can a non-member attend<br />
REOMAC® events? How can<br />
I register?<br />
YES! Non-members are<br />
invited to attend our<br />
conferences and dinner<br />
meetings throughout the<br />
year. Event registration<br />
can be completed online<br />
as it’s available.<br />
Where and when is the Fall<br />
<strong>Conference</strong> happening, and<br />
how can I book my hotel<br />
room?<br />
The Fall <strong>Conference</strong> will<br />
be held in Hollywood,<br />
Florida at the Westin<br />
Diplomat. Thanks to our<br />
new registration system,<br />
y o u c o m p l e t e y o u r<br />
registration and book<br />
your hotel room online.<br />
Calls received by the hotel<br />
or Headquarters will be<br />
redirected to the Web site.<br />
You must be registered for<br />
the conference to book<br />
a room at the Westin<br />
Diplomat.<br />
continued on page 47<br />
Jennifer<br />
Blevins, CMP<br />
Account Executive<br />
Joseph Davis<br />
Account Executive<br />
John Berkowitz<br />
Publications<br />
Director<br />
Nathan Carlson<br />
Sponsorships<br />
Michael Cochran<br />
Webmaster<br />
Jessica Drake<br />
Membership<br />
Coordinator<br />
Kim Ingersoll<br />
Advertising<br />
Administrator<br />
Erin René Nelson<br />
Meeting Planner<br />
Stephanie Schoen<br />
Special Projects<br />
Tricia Schrum, CPA<br />
Accountant<br />
Anisa Routon<br />
Director of<br />
Education<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 7
Diana Kendall<br />
2009 <strong>Conference</strong> Chairperson<br />
Thank you for attending the<br />
<strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong> this<br />
year: “Quest for Excellence<br />
In a Changing Market.” The<br />
venue was beautiful and offered<br />
outstanding accommodations<br />
for our event – which had<br />
over 2500 attendees. The<br />
educational sessions were<br />
opened by our memorable<br />
and inspirational keynote<br />
speaker, Chris Gardner.<br />
The Education Committee<br />
organized an outstanding<br />
and informative program<br />
throughout the <strong>Conference</strong>.<br />
The <strong>Conference</strong> was kicked off<br />
with our Members’ Only Event<br />
with a Cirque du Soleil theme.<br />
Attendees enjoyed the golf<br />
tournament on Sunday, and –<br />
on Monday evening – enjoyed<br />
our Live and Silent Auctions<br />
followed by DJ Mario.<br />
Please thank the <strong>Conference</strong><br />
Committee for their hard<br />
work to make this the best<br />
conference ever for you:<br />
Shelley Kaye<br />
President<br />
LeeAnn Axcell<br />
Board Liaison<br />
Anngel Benoun<br />
Scholarship, Auction<br />
Marie Chung<br />
Sponsors and Exhibitors<br />
Kathy Jeffers-Volk<br />
Volunteers and Auction<br />
Donna LaPorte<br />
Public Relations<br />
Dorothy Macias<br />
Sponsors<br />
Cynthia Nierer<br />
Education<br />
Carole ONeill<br />
Auction<br />
Mia Semo<br />
Golf Tournament<br />
Patty Spano<br />
Auction<br />
Connie White<br />
Lender Roundtables,<br />
Scholarship<br />
The <strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong><br />
was better than ever this<br />
year – thanks to these great<br />
committee members and to<br />
you – our Sponsors, Exhibitors<br />
and Attendees – who help<br />
us continue our “Quest for<br />
Excellence in a Changing<br />
Market.”<br />
For questions regarding the<br />
Fall 2009 <strong>Conference</strong>, you<br />
may contact me at Diana@<br />
dianakendall.com. We look<br />
forward to seeing you at the<br />
Fall <strong>Conference</strong> in Hollywood,<br />
Florida!<br />
8 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Thank You Platinum Sponsor<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 9
Thank You Gold Sponsor<br />
10 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Thank You Silver Sponsor<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 11
Thank You Bronze Sponsor<br />
12 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Thank You Keynote Sponsor<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 13
Thank You Keynote Sponsor<br />
14 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Thank You Economist Sponsor<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 15
Thank You Key Auction Sponsor<br />
16 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Thank You Golf Sponsors<br />
Grand<br />
Platinum<br />
Grand<br />
Gold<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 17
Sunday<br />
Welcome Reception Sponsor<br />
Thank You Sponsors<br />
Monday<br />
Welcome Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Welcome Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Welcome Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Morning Break Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Luncheon Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Entertainment Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Entertainment Sponsor<br />
Mid State Realty<br />
Shannon Martin<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
David Secrest<br />
Joe Mayol<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
Monday<br />
Dinner Service Sponsor<br />
Nancy Nelson<br />
Olsen & Associates, Inc.<br />
Bob Siegmeth<br />
REO Sales and Services<br />
Tom Christensen<br />
Tuesday<br />
Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Tuesday<br />
Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Tuesday<br />
Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Tuesday<br />
Morning Break Sponsor<br />
All Pro Realty, Inc.<br />
Mary Berry<br />
Classic Estates<br />
Juan Cevallos<br />
Robert Hellman<br />
Tuesday<br />
Morning Break Sponsor<br />
Tuesday<br />
Morning Break Sponsor<br />
Tuesday<br />
Luncheon Sponsor<br />
Tuesday<br />
Luncheon Sponsor<br />
Jim Krasno<br />
Kimberly Brunson<br />
18 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Tuesday<br />
Luncheon Sponsor<br />
Thank You Sponsors<br />
Tuesday<br />
Luncheon Sponsor<br />
The Realty<br />
Team, Inc.<br />
Tuesday<br />
Reception Sponsor<br />
Tuesday<br />
Reception Sponsor<br />
Robert Smith<br />
David Golden<br />
Tuesday<br />
Reception Sponsor<br />
Grand Prize Sponsor<br />
<strong>Conference</strong> Tote Bags<br />
& Hotel Key Cards Sponsor<br />
Java Sleeves Sponsor<br />
DeAnna Allensworth<br />
Gladwin D’Costa<br />
Golf<br />
Continental Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Continental Breakfast Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
19 th Hole Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
19 th Hole Sponsor<br />
Dave Silverstein<br />
Sherman Oaks<br />
Phil Boroda<br />
Tom Daves<br />
Golf<br />
19 th Hole Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Margaritaville Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Corona Corner Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Beverage Cart Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Beverage Cart Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Beverage Cart Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
Jim O’Rourke<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
Associates San Diego<br />
Robert Weichelt<br />
of Santa Clarita<br />
Louie Guerrero<br />
Jeff Russell<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 19
Thank You<br />
Sponsors<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
RELIABLE Realty Inc.<br />
REO DIVISION<br />
Kellee Spillman<br />
Golf<br />
Eagle Tee Sponsor<br />
Donna Sanfilippo<br />
We Salute Our <strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong> Exhibitors for Their Support!<br />
Arcstone Financial Aspen Grove, Inc. Asset Management Servicing, LLP<br />
Asset Valuation & Marketing Britannia Development Co. Crest REO<br />
Cyprexx Services, LLC DS News Elite Escrow Services<br />
Energy Construction<br />
First American<br />
Document Solutions<br />
Gamut Construction &<br />
Preservation<br />
20 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
We Salute Our <strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong> Exhibitors for Their Support!<br />
Great Street Properties InSource Financial, LLC Instaclose Real Estate<br />
Island Advantage Realty, LLC Keystone Asset Management, Inc. Lender Processing Services, Inc.<br />
Marshall & Swift NationsREO No Paws Left Behind<br />
Nordhagen & Daughters<br />
Exterminating Nu-Set Lock PropertyFireSale.com<br />
Quantum Realtors RC Godsey – MGA Services Realtybid.com<br />
RealtyTrac, Inc. REO Allegiance, Inc. REO Maestro<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 21
We Salute Our <strong>Spring</strong> <strong>Conference</strong> Exhibitors for Their Support!<br />
REO Network REO Office Manager REOMAC®<br />
REOMagic REOTrans Res.net<br />
Ridgegate Escrow Safeguard Properties Sellstate NRES<br />
Sellsate Realty Systems<br />
Network, Inc. [no photo available] Sovereign Title Agency, LLC<br />
Tiempo Escrow II Titanium Solutions, Inc. Unifund<br />
Vacant Property Security, Inc.<br />
WinREO / Gadish Properties<br />
22 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
“SOUTH JERSEY REO”<br />
Real Estate Brokerage & Management Company<br />
Exclusive REO/Foreclosure Service & Sales<br />
609-383-9220<br />
GUARANTEED CLIENT SATISFACTION - ASSET MANAGERS WORK MADE EASY<br />
OVER 20 YEARS OF “REO” PROFESSIONALISM & SUCCESS<br />
RESIDENTIAL, COMMERCIAL AND LAND SALES<br />
LOSS MITIGATION, MANAGEMENT AND PROPERTY PRESERVATION<br />
PROUD MEMBER OF REOMAC®<br />
ADAM PALMISCIANO<br />
Broker/Owner<br />
adam@southjerseyreo.com<br />
Servicing South Jersey Counties<br />
Atlantic, Cape May, Cumberland<br />
Salem, Gloucester, Camden<br />
Burlington, Ocean<br />
Please visit our website:<br />
www.southjerseyreo.com<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 23
24 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
GENERAL<br />
SESSION I:<br />
Keynote<br />
Speaker,<br />
Christopher<br />
Gardner<br />
By Gary<br />
Tatar<br />
Three Words ... Great Motivational<br />
Speaker.... A real treat to hear a<br />
speaker that has not forgotten where<br />
he came from or what it took to be the<br />
success he is today.<br />
I had to ask myself, “What was so<br />
impressive about a man that went from rags<br />
to riches as a Stock Broker?” Many have<br />
done it before and many will do it again.<br />
Many have gone from the bottom to the<br />
top in business. Sure he had to overcome<br />
some obstacles, again many have and<br />
many will. It is not much different than<br />
the REO/Loss Mitigation business. Many<br />
have gone from entry level file clerks to<br />
Sr. Asset Managers, Retail Store Clerks<br />
to REO Brokers. Many have done it and<br />
many will do it again.<br />
First, a quick summary on Christopher<br />
Gardner. He was employed but disliked his<br />
job (like many). He saw a guy in a luxury<br />
sports car and asked him what he did for a<br />
living – he was a stock broker. Christopher<br />
decided that he wanted that job (like many<br />
others). He was married at the time and<br />
also had a very young son. He took a big<br />
risk and quit his job. His wife left him and<br />
took their son. She later showed up and<br />
gave him custody of his son right when he<br />
was starting an internship at a major stock<br />
brokerage firm. It’s a classic story. It could<br />
have been a movie ... oh wait, IT WAS.<br />
Many family members and friends would<br />
have told him that he should step up and<br />
get a real job (as some call it) to support his<br />
family. He was obviously capable of getting<br />
a job that paid more than the internship<br />
at the brokerage firm. So why did this<br />
intelligent and motivated man choose the<br />
path of poverty and homelessness? And<br />
yes, he did choose this because he could<br />
have changed paths at anytime and taken a<br />
so-called real job. When you do not make<br />
enough money for daycare, rent and food<br />
you need to make more choices, 99.99% of<br />
continued on page 26<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 25
Session I – continued from page 25<br />
the population would have quit and taken<br />
the easier path.<br />
That is what was so impressive about<br />
Christopher Gardner. He did something<br />
about it! He chose and pursued the career<br />
path he wanted. He had more faith in<br />
himself than thousands of other people<br />
put together. He was a man that knew in<br />
his mind and in his heart that he would<br />
be a success and was not willing to allow<br />
anything to stand in his way. He knew<br />
that hard work plus determination equaled<br />
success. He did not just sit back and dream<br />
about what could have been. He did not<br />
just sit and wait for something to happen<br />
in his life. He stepped up and did what<br />
it took to be the best he could be, with<br />
blinding determination and tenacity so far<br />
above the average person. It’s important<br />
to understand though that it was not the<br />
sports car he saw that day that he wanted.<br />
It was the independence and financial<br />
freedom. The Success…!<br />
Mr. Gardner did not make a few phone<br />
calls a day to build his book of business,<br />
he made 200. He didn’t make excuses, he<br />
created results. When he ran out of money<br />
for food and rent, he and his son lived and<br />
ate wherever they could. But everyday,<br />
he still made 200 phone calls. He did<br />
not let the circumstances of his life, his<br />
personal issues, his current financial issues<br />
dictate his future. He believed enough<br />
in himself. He knew that success would<br />
come if he worked hard and never gave<br />
up. When his break came, he was ready<br />
to seize the opportunity because he had<br />
laid the foundation that is so important<br />
in business and life.<br />
Christopher Gardner did not get to<br />
where he is today because he is a lucky<br />
man. He is where he is because he knew<br />
what he wanted out of life and worked<br />
very hard every single day to overcome<br />
major obstacles while staying focused on<br />
the prize.<br />
So, what I learned from this speaker is<br />
that ANYONE and everyone can be the<br />
person they want to be in life with a desire<br />
to succeed, extreme determination and<br />
a focus on the end result. But, this can<br />
only be accomplished if we don’t let our<br />
daily worries and obstacles take our eyes<br />
off of the prize. Very few if any are in the<br />
position that this man was in when he<br />
started on his road to success. Like Mr.<br />
Gardner, all of us started somewhere at<br />
the bottom and made choices to be where<br />
we are at today. Some of our choices have<br />
been good and some bad. It is our choices<br />
that determine our futures.<br />
The most memorable part of the<br />
presentation was when Mr. Gardner told<br />
the story of the time he met one of his<br />
largest clients. This client was a gentleman<br />
that always told racial jokes before placing<br />
his trade orders. He did not know that Mr.<br />
Gardner was African-American. At the<br />
end of meeting with his client personally<br />
for the first time (of which the client was<br />
obviously embarrassed and apologized for<br />
his remarks), Mr. Gardner told his client “It<br />
is not a Black Thing, It’s not a White Thing,<br />
It is a Green Thing.” After that, his client’s<br />
jokes went from racial in nature to knockknock<br />
jokes and the trades kept coming.<br />
And Yes ... Fortunately or Unfortunately<br />
Life is a Green Thing.<br />
LOS ANGELES REO EXPERTS<br />
• Over 20 years of experience handling thousands of REO properties<br />
• #1 Agents for the Greater Los Angeles County<br />
• #1 in sales for the #1 Coldwell Banker Office worldwide<br />
• The Essex & Harvey Group is the #1 REO Sales Team in L.A.<br />
• Providing full REO services, handling all REO needs<br />
Joyce Essex<br />
310-922-7476<br />
Joyce@EssexHarvey.com<br />
Danny Harvey<br />
310-777-6391<br />
DannyHarvey1@aol.com<br />
www.REOestates.com<br />
26 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
REOMAC® Plus t m !<br />
Your FIRST CHOICE resource<br />
for quick access to a REOMAC®<br />
Member REO Expert<br />
The industry experts know that to find a local default<br />
professional they simply go to www.<strong>reomac</strong>.com and<br />
click on the REOMAC® Plus t m logo.<br />
UP TO VALUE<br />
TRADE-UP TO A<br />
NUSET PROGRAM<br />
Your trusted resource for 23 years.<br />
A proven track<br />
record servicing the<br />
default industry!<br />
www.<strong>reomac</strong>.com<br />
• Ever bought an inferior lockbox that is just not getting the job done?<br />
• Do you have any old lockboxes that are doing nothing except collecting dust?<br />
• Would you like to turn those into $$$?<br />
For more information please visit our website at<br />
www.nusetlock.com or contact us at (800) 60-NUSET<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 27
28 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
GENERAL SESSION II:<br />
Economist Speaker,<br />
Christopher<br />
Thornberg, PhD.<br />
By Jim<br />
Conway<br />
Dr. Thornberg gave the REOMAC®<br />
<strong>Conference</strong> attendees his semiannual<br />
update on the state of<br />
the U.S economy with an emphasis on<br />
the troubles being experienced in our<br />
financial markets and the government’s<br />
efforts to both ameliorate the economic<br />
distress and to re-stimulate the real<br />
estate and financial markets. Christopher<br />
Thornberg is an expert in the study of<br />
regional economies, real estate dynamics,<br />
labor markets and business forecasting. In<br />
2006, he co-founded Beacon Economics,<br />
an economic research and consulting firm<br />
that specializes in real estate markets,<br />
local economic development, and public<br />
and private policy issues. Dr. Thornberg<br />
has established a reputation as one of the<br />
State of California’s leading economic<br />
forecasters. Prior to launching Beacon, he<br />
was an economist with UCLA’s Anderson<br />
Forecast where he regularly authored<br />
economic outlooks for California, Los<br />
Angeles and the East Bay.<br />
Dr. Thornberg believes that we are currently<br />
in a recession and not a depression and that<br />
we should be in a recovery by 2011. He<br />
stated the collapse of Lehman brothers<br />
in 2008 was not as big a factor in the<br />
subsequent troubles the U.S economy has<br />
experienced as many think. Dr. Thornberg<br />
believes that the housing plans that are<br />
aimed at keeping people in their homes are<br />
counter-productive in some cases and may<br />
even bury some homeowners who may not<br />
ever be able to build up equity or even be<br />
able to sell their homes due to the size of<br />
the mortgage. The plans, according to Dr.<br />
Thornberg, won’t work because they don’t<br />
deal with homeowners that are seriously<br />
under water. He also stated that it will<br />
have limited impact in turning around<br />
both banks and financial markets.<br />
As a possible curative, he offered what he<br />
called the: “Mulligan Solution.” In Golf, a<br />
Mulligan is a do-over of a bad shot (such as<br />
hitting your tee-shot into a water hazard).<br />
He proposes that the government legislate<br />
that anyone that had their home foreclosed<br />
between 2002 and 2009 be given a clean<br />
slate on their credit report which would<br />
continued on page 30<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 29
Session II – continued from page 29<br />
allow them to buy a home now at today’s<br />
greatly reduced prices and at today’s low<br />
interest rates. He did state that adjustable<br />
and gimmick loans should be eliminated<br />
and that buyers must be required to put<br />
5-10% down. Dr. Thornberg believes that<br />
this plan would also cause the lenders<br />
holding many of today’s upside-down<br />
mortgages to have a strong incentive to<br />
work harder at restructuring loans and<br />
short sales. The homeowners would be<br />
able to walk away from their current<br />
loan/home and immediately purchase<br />
another home at today’s market price<br />
and benefit from the lower mortgage<br />
rates. This program would allow for a<br />
quicker resolution and recovery and would<br />
cost all parties involved (government,<br />
homeowners, banks, tax-payers) less<br />
money. Dr. Thornberg then demonstrated<br />
with charts how a 40% reduction was<br />
necessary to get the Los Angeles areas<br />
real estate prices back in line with the<br />
70 year trend of 1% home value increases<br />
per year. These historical increases were<br />
directly tied to and moved in sync with<br />
average incomes and income/housing<br />
payment ratios.<br />
He summarized and concluded his<br />
presentation by looking at our present<br />
situation and looking forward with<br />
predictions for the next three years.<br />
He believes that we are currently in a<br />
recession but are about to enter a healing<br />
phase as prices are getting closer to their<br />
historical levels. Consumer weakness will<br />
continue, but won’t last forever. Business<br />
weakness will get worse based on profit<br />
issues, commercial REO’s are about to<br />
takeoff over the next 2 years. There is also<br />
a significant danger of inflation taking<br />
off due to the Federal Reserve’s huge<br />
expansion of the money supply (done in<br />
an effort to stimulate the economy). He<br />
referred to this huge expansion as a “big<br />
pile of kindling” that could turn into a big<br />
fire. Lastly, he concluded we are in the<br />
worst recession since World War II, but<br />
not in a depression. If everything goes the<br />
way he is predicting, the economy should<br />
begin to recover in early to mid 2010. A<br />
housing recovery should be in full-swing<br />
by 2012. Let’s hope he’s right.<br />
30 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
REO Home Repairs<br />
• Board ups<br />
• Carpentry<br />
• Carpet cleaning<br />
• Carpet Replacement<br />
• Demolition<br />
• Electrical<br />
• FHA repairs<br />
• Foundation Repairs<br />
• HVAC<br />
Home rehabilitation for banks,<br />
asset companies, realtors<br />
• Mildew Removal<br />
• Painting<br />
• Permits<br />
• Plumbing<br />
• Roofing<br />
• Interior Sales Cleaning<br />
• Termite Work<br />
• Trash-outs<br />
• Windows<br />
• Los Angeles<br />
• San Bernardino<br />
• Riverside<br />
• Orange<br />
• San Diego<br />
Serving Five Southern California Counties<br />
<br />
ZIP code lists<br />
can be found<br />
on our Web site<br />
www.reohomerepairs.com<br />
One Call<br />
Does it all<br />
Kelly Archer<br />
Bonded • Insured<br />
Licence #818991<br />
Ph (800) 497-4610<br />
Fax (800) 856-3041<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 31
32 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
GENERAL SESSION III:<br />
Town Hall Session<br />
Moderator:<br />
Panelists:<br />
John Vella, GMAC<br />
Senator Ronald S. Calderon, (D – Montebello)<br />
Peter Monroe, Esq., Wilhurst Oxford Venture Capital<br />
Rocky Rushing, Chief of Staff for Senator Calderon<br />
Christopher Thornberg, Ph.D, Beacon Economics<br />
By Ron<br />
Deutsch, Esq.<br />
A<br />
panel of distinguished speakers<br />
addressed a full auditorium at the<br />
REOMAC® conference held in Palm<br />
Desert, CA. These speakers included, John<br />
Vella of GMAC Mortgage LLC, Senator<br />
Ronald S. Calderon of California and a<br />
member of the Senate Banking Committee,<br />
Dr. Christopher Thornberg of Beacon<br />
Economics, Peter Monroe, former President<br />
of the RTC Oversight Board and Rocky<br />
Rushing, Chief of Staff to Senator Calderon.<br />
They discussed many topics including<br />
hastening foreclosures, proper government<br />
policy, loan workouts and other solutions to<br />
the banking problems facing the industry<br />
and country.<br />
Senator Calderon stated that a desired<br />
government goal is to have fewer homes<br />
on the real estate market and helping<br />
homeowners stay in their homes. Although<br />
he recognizes that foreclosures may still<br />
be inevitable in many cases, and keeping<br />
the homeowner in the house may not<br />
be possible. Senator Calderon also<br />
recognized that foreclosures benefit first<br />
time homebuyers to enter the real estate<br />
market and purchase their first home.<br />
Peter Monroe stated that he is “mad as hell”<br />
with respect to the current policy. In his<br />
prior role, the RTC seized banks and their<br />
assets. They did not prop up failing banks,<br />
instead allowing weak banks to fail. That<br />
said, he believes he sees the first ray of<br />
sunshine in Geitner’s PPIP program. The<br />
program provides for toxic assets to be<br />
purchased by creating a fund comprised of<br />
7% private investor money, 7% TARP funds<br />
and 86% non recourse capital. Monroe<br />
believes that private banks have no chance of<br />
surviving if asset values drop precipitously.<br />
The drop in asset values, reduce a bank’s<br />
regulatory capital requirements.<br />
Chris Thornberg, always a vocal presenter,<br />
stated that massive foreclosures are not<br />
the problem. He recognized that many<br />
people purchased homes that they could<br />
not afford or committed fraud in applying<br />
for their acquisition loans. Compounding<br />
the existing problem is a bad real estate<br />
market. He firmly believes that, Senator<br />
Calderon’s stated goal of keeping individuals<br />
in their homes, although well intentioned<br />
is misguided. Instead foreclosures should<br />
be allowed to occur quickly to flush the<br />
system. However, he advocated, that a<br />
“mulligan” rule should be implemented to<br />
benefit foreclosed borrowers. That is, the<br />
fact that a foreclosure occurred should be<br />
deleted from a borrower’s credit report.<br />
That would allow the former homeowner<br />
to enter the housing market again and to<br />
purchase a home again at a much lower<br />
affordable price.<br />
continued on page 34<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 33
Session III – continued from page 33<br />
Dr. Thornberg also stated that the<br />
government PPIP program is not a solution.<br />
It is encouraging investors to pay 80 cents<br />
for an asset worth 50 cents. Due to the<br />
non-recourse aspect of the program, the<br />
purchaser wins if it is a good purchase<br />
and the FDIC loses if it is a bad one as the<br />
FDIC will absorb the loss. That, he said, is<br />
equivalent to heads I win and tails you lose.<br />
Finally, he stressed, that the government<br />
is giving money to banks not to fail. He<br />
believes that this does not address the<br />
problem with the economy. He lays blame<br />
on consumers who were “spoiled brats” and<br />
demanded more than they could afford. He<br />
did note that consumers are now saving<br />
more.<br />
John Vella of GMAC Mortgage next<br />
discussed that banks are doing what<br />
they can to maintain home owners in<br />
their homes and to convert as many nonperforming<br />
loans into performing ones.<br />
It was noted however that the workouts<br />
are experiencing almost a 50% failure rate.<br />
New underwriting is necessary.<br />
Chris Thornberg, responded to John Vella’s<br />
position, by stating that home prices went<br />
to astonishing prices in California. One<br />
can’t modify a loan where home prices<br />
tripled and expect it to work. Even if an 80<br />
year loan at 1% was offered, a homeowner<br />
could not be successful in repaying a loan<br />
and equity would never be acquired. He<br />
strongly felt that the best program would<br />
be one to allow foreclosure, and permit<br />
borrowers to start over with a clean slate<br />
(the “Mulligan rule”).<br />
John Vella, countered Dr. Thronberg, by<br />
stating that many borrowers have emotional<br />
attachment to their homes and will continue<br />
to make payments even if making those<br />
payments do not make sense.<br />
Rocky Rushing relayed the current situation<br />
to the situation faced by farmers in<br />
Steinberg’s novel The Grapes of Wrath. A<br />
farmer watching a tractor driver about to<br />
level his home notices the tractor driver is<br />
a former neighbor. The driver states to the<br />
farmer it is the bank not me. Who is the<br />
bank? There is no face to the bank.<br />
Chris Thornberg then stated that the<br />
situation is not as desperate as portrayed.<br />
Former homeowners, in fact have a place to<br />
go. They can become renters. He stressed<br />
that renting is not bad and that 75% of<br />
residents of New York City currently rent<br />
their homes. He further stated that policy<br />
makers, although also well intentioned,<br />
were misguided in establishing a public<br />
policy to increase unsustainable home<br />
ownership rates. Moreover, he stressed that<br />
after non-paying homeowners are forced out<br />
after foreclosure, home prices will decline,<br />
creating demand from new buyers who can<br />
now afford a home. Although, he again<br />
suggested the “Mulligan” rule for those<br />
foreclosed upon.<br />
Senator Calderon, however, mentioned that<br />
it will be hard for those who are foreclosed<br />
upon to recover from the scar of the event.<br />
continued on page 35<br />
34 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Session III – continued from page 34<br />
Peter Monroe also noted that local liens<br />
slapped on properties destroy incentives<br />
to purchase vacant homes.<br />
Judge Goldberg, a California bankruptcy<br />
judge and an attendee of the discussion,<br />
offered that it is not helpful to make<br />
borrowers a slave to loans and to keep<br />
them in homes that they cannot afford.<br />
Equity participation sharing was also<br />
discussed in return for lowering interest<br />
rates and payments for homeowners during<br />
a workout.<br />
Chris Thornberg next discussed that since<br />
owners of loans are diverse; it is not easy<br />
to renegotiate defaulted loans. Pension<br />
funds in Norway and hedge funds are<br />
among owners of loan pools. He noted<br />
that homeowners sometimes purchase an<br />
identical home down the block and hand<br />
the first owned home back to the bank to<br />
force the bank to deal with it. Flushing<br />
the system is what he suggested is the<br />
solution.<br />
Peter Monroe next stated that propping up<br />
banks that have become too big to fail is<br />
only postponing the inevitable. This policy<br />
did not work in Japan and stagnation ensued.<br />
He also expects commercial defaults to<br />
triple or quadruple in the near future.<br />
John Vella, next stated that defaulting home<br />
owners might participate in short sales.<br />
Energizing local real estate brokers to help<br />
is another solution to the problem. Chris<br />
Thornberg disagreed and stated that banks<br />
are not part of the solution but are in fact<br />
the problem as they have not negotiated<br />
properly. Monroe disagreed and stated<br />
that vacant properties are causing greater<br />
problems and banks are in fact part of the<br />
solution. Vella reminded the audience that<br />
92% of loans are performing and accepting<br />
the “Mulligan” rule would create a moral<br />
hazard. Thornberg thought the real moral<br />
hazard was allowing Richad Fuld of Lehman<br />
Brothers to walk away with 400 million<br />
dollars. The only solution according to<br />
Thornberg is to flush the system and tighten<br />
underwriting standard for new borrowers.<br />
Borrowers should be required to invest at<br />
least 5%-10% as a down payment and prove<br />
creditworthiness.<br />
Monroe stated that propping up institutions<br />
results in propping up and rewarding the<br />
worst banks. This is a moral hazard and<br />
penalizes the whole system. Thornberg<br />
agreed and the country should not coddle<br />
banks, instead the worst banks should be<br />
allowed to fail. Stress test that are being<br />
utilized are “pure crap” according to<br />
Thornberg, and it is only diverting attention<br />
from the bank’s failure. The problem is at<br />
the top and legislators cannot allow the<br />
bottom to fix. Instead, government must<br />
force the banks to face reality. Banks should<br />
be allowed to fail, but they should be kept<br />
operating. Bankruptcy does not wipe out<br />
jobs, it just rejiggers equity ownership.<br />
Senator Calderon felt that since banks<br />
created problems they should help pull<br />
borrowers out.<br />
John Vella suggested PPIP will be successful<br />
since it will allow bad assets into the hands<br />
of asset managers who will work out the<br />
problems. On the other hand, Chris<br />
Thornberg, felt that taxpayers should be<br />
told the truth and the system in place is<br />
a big sham with no hold of taxpayers ever<br />
seeing the money repaid after given to the<br />
failing banks. Forcing write downs on<br />
principal abrogates constitutional property<br />
rights and tosses out a long history of legal<br />
precedents.<br />
Rocky Rushing stressed that human factor<br />
must be considered. Disagreeing with<br />
Chris Thornberg, he stated that you can’t<br />
just flush the system. Tossing folks out of<br />
homes with banks wiping out the family<br />
dream are issues that need to be considered.<br />
Economics cannot be taken in a vacuum.<br />
Bailing out blue bloods at banks but not blue<br />
collar workers in Detroit is not fair.<br />
Chris Thornberg disagreed and said<br />
neither the blue bloods at banks nor blue<br />
collar workers should be bailed out. There<br />
are 8000 banks in the United States and<br />
regulatory nightmare is being created.<br />
Allowing bank CEOs to take in big risks,<br />
hide it, make extraordinary profits and then<br />
walk away to leave the problems created for<br />
the government to correct is certainly one<br />
result that cannot be permitted, he said.<br />
It is clear, our country’s problems are quite<br />
complex and easy solutions are not possible.<br />
In the meantime debate stirs thought.<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 35
36 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
EARLY BREAKOUT SESSION 1:<br />
Fraud: From Origination to REO<br />
By Mark<br />
Dorris<br />
Moderator:<br />
Panelists:<br />
Paul Saffron, Attorney at Law, Becker & Poliakoff<br />
Steven Garfinkel, Special Agent, Federal Bureau of Investigation<br />
Eileen Newhall, Principal Consultant, Senate Committee on Banking, Finance, and Insurance<br />
Maureen Rodriguez, Esq., Deputy City Attorney, City of Los Angeles<br />
Alice Sorenson, COO, Lighthouse Real Estate Solutions<br />
Paul Saffron opened the discussion<br />
with what may be a wake up call<br />
to most of us. He shared that some<br />
may have assumed, as a result of the<br />
sub prime meltdown, that incidents of<br />
mortgage fraud would have declined given<br />
the extinction of the no income verification<br />
type loans and stricter underwriting<br />
guidelines. He believed a fair assumption<br />
is that mortgage fraud would have at least<br />
declined somewhat in the last year. But,<br />
he revealed results from a recent report,<br />
prepared by the Mortgage Asset Research<br />
Institute to the Mortgage Banker’s<br />
Association, indicating that last months<br />
numbers revealed that mortgage fraud<br />
has actually increased by 26% between<br />
2007 and 2008. Although we may have<br />
closed some loopholes for opportunities<br />
for mortgage fraud and fraud in general,<br />
for every loophole we closed it appears<br />
that people have found a way to open up<br />
another opportunity to commit fraud or<br />
take advantage of the system.<br />
TRENDS IN FRAUD<br />
Special Agent Steven Garfinkel was asked<br />
what he is seeing on the Federal end, in<br />
respect to trends in the mortgage fraud<br />
arena. Agent Garfinkel cited a recent<br />
article in the Wall Street Journal in which it<br />
stated large lending companies are veering<br />
away from working with mortgage brokers<br />
and Private Mortgage Insurance companies<br />
refusing to underwrite loans that originate<br />
with a mortgage brokers. In New York,<br />
most of their cases are with loans that<br />
originated with mortgage brokers. Also in<br />
New York, the mortgage broker business<br />
is filled with previous attorneys who have<br />
been disbarred, CPA’s who have lost their<br />
licenses, and people who have abandoned<br />
the securities industry. Agent Garfinkel<br />
mentioned a case he had two years ago,<br />
where an attorney was stealing escrow<br />
funds and had just finished his probation<br />
sentence. After bumping into him on<br />
the street one day, he found out that the<br />
ex-attorney was now a mortgage banker,<br />
Steven said he wasn’t surprised.<br />
Many of the types of schemes he is seeing<br />
are appraisal fraud, where there is collusion<br />
between the appraiser, seller and mortgage<br />
brokers engaged in property flipping. Also,<br />
the use of straw buyers and in conjunction<br />
with straw buyers, identity fraud. Identity<br />
fraud is becoming a major component in<br />
a number of these cases. So throughout<br />
the entire underwriting process it is<br />
very important to continually verify the<br />
person’s identity.<br />
Next, the discussion went to Maureen<br />
Rodriguez, who was asked about the post<br />
foreclosure arena and what she is seeing in<br />
the schemes in post foreclosure scenarios.<br />
Being in Los Angeles she can only speak to<br />
California Law, but realizes this problem<br />
runs across the country. She also wanted to<br />
continued on page 38<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 37
Early Session 1 – continued from page 37<br />
make it clear that she was speaking her own<br />
opinions and not necessarily the opinions<br />
of her employer, the City of Los Angeles.<br />
The area of concern they are seeing is in<br />
foreclosure process, particularly with<br />
unaware real estate agents who are<br />
attempting short sales when the property is<br />
in the foreclosure process. The problem is<br />
with people moving into those properties.<br />
Maureen outlined the following three basic<br />
ways she has seen situations with people<br />
moving into the property.<br />
1. They will move in for occupancy, where<br />
they actually move in and live in the house.<br />
These are people who can be individuals or<br />
rings in the Los Angeles and San Fernando<br />
Valley area. There was actually someone<br />
teaching classes on how to do this. What<br />
they do is move in and when the police<br />
show up they show the police a lease which<br />
gives them the right to be there. When<br />
the property goes to eviction, if it goes<br />
quickly, some go to the extent of filing<br />
bankruptcy and filing false claims on the<br />
deeds. She prosecuted one person who<br />
she traced back 11 years and had not paid<br />
rent. These people are very bold!<br />
2. The second scheme is where the people<br />
occupy the property to collect the cash for<br />
keys. As agents and brokers you must be<br />
careful because there are strict laws for<br />
cash for keys. In Los Angeles, there are<br />
situations where the minimum you can<br />
pay for cash keys is $ 7,000. In one case,<br />
the defendant was on the stand and there<br />
were three different agents who had each<br />
paid cash for keys to this person in the<br />
same month.<br />
3. The last scheme is rent skimming where<br />
someone has access to the property, but<br />
does not own it. They change the locks<br />
and advertise the property in Craig’s List,<br />
newspapers or by word of mouth. They<br />
rent the property and collect first, last<br />
and security and do this to several people<br />
before they skip town.<br />
The moderator, Paul Saffron commented<br />
that in Florida, the more complicated the<br />
process, the more ripe the opportunities<br />
for fraud and for misdealing.<br />
RED FLAGS<br />
Alice Sorenson was asked what the pink<br />
and red flags were in mortgage fraud.<br />
Being in operations, she made a list of all<br />
the things that came to mind. There are<br />
many flags that can alert you to fraud that<br />
is going on in a loan as follows:<br />
Title: Inconsistencies with title documents,<br />
appraisal documents and your sales<br />
contract. Multiple change of ownership<br />
within a 12 month period and depending<br />
on the market may extend from 6 to 18<br />
months. Watch for documents where<br />
there are lots of cross outs or whiteouts on<br />
the loan documents or the sales contract.<br />
Also, the use of straw buyers and being<br />
able to pin down the identity of your<br />
borrowers and knowing who they are is<br />
imperative.<br />
continued on page 39<br />
38 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
Early Session 1 – continued from page 38<br />
Loan application stage: Looking at<br />
cross outs again. If you have a borrower<br />
that is a renter and is purchasing it as an<br />
investment, you want to find out if this<br />
is their first endeavor into investing or<br />
is it a side business where they have had<br />
experience. Legitimate reasons need to<br />
be ascertained. If a borrower cannot<br />
explain exactly what they are doing with<br />
the money, maybe they are a straw buyer<br />
and haven’t been schooled well enough<br />
to give the right answers. Language and<br />
communication issues are other indicators<br />
of straw buyers.<br />
Processing Step: Multiple mortgage<br />
inquiries in last 90 days or unusually high<br />
income for the profile of the applicant.<br />
She once had a loan where the applicant<br />
stated that they were a gardener and<br />
making $19,000 per month after only one<br />
year in business. That is a good example<br />
of a red flag.<br />
Underwriting: This position is key.<br />
Underwriters need to be good qualified,<br />
well trained people. They are the<br />
ones responsible for qualifying the<br />
loan. They are the ones that should be<br />
catching inconsistencies of information<br />
on the application, sales contract and the<br />
preliminary HUD I. Change of ownership<br />
in the past 12 months, comparables used<br />
that do not seem reasonable. Inability<br />
to verify income, bank statements with<br />
several different types of font or huge<br />
balances, but showing NSF charges. One<br />
person getting multiple loans within a<br />
short period of time. Excessive repair<br />
bills on HUD I.<br />
Funding: This is the last chance to catch<br />
fraud before it actually becomes a loan.<br />
This is where you catch things like notary<br />
issues, forged documents, unrecorded<br />
deeds that are being paid off during your<br />
closing, pay offs to fake improvements,<br />
and down payments that come from<br />
third parties.<br />
Next, Eileen Newhall was questioned<br />
about what role the legislature plays in<br />
helping to reduce mortgage fraud. She<br />
stated that we have got to keep our eyes<br />
and ears open so we can close loopholes<br />
when they are identified. We also have to<br />
be careful that when we add law, we also<br />
add enforcement mechanisms to them.<br />
There is no single law that is going to<br />
prevent fraud, mortgage or otherwise if it<br />
cannot be enforced. One of her favorite<br />
enforcement mechanisms is making the<br />
law a licensing violation. She also warned<br />
that there must be adequate resources to<br />
enforce the violations. For example, The<br />
California Department of Real Estate is<br />
responsible for overseeing the activities<br />
of about 530,000 licensees and they have<br />
a staff of only 340 people.<br />
PREVENTION<br />
The panel was asked what agents can<br />
do to minimize exposure to foreclosed<br />
properties. Also, what checks and balance<br />
can be implemented and at what points to<br />
help protect against mortgage fraud.<br />
Ms. Rodriquez stated that she recommends<br />
taking pictures and changing the locks<br />
as soon as you know the property was<br />
foreclosed. Go to your local police<br />
department for a trespass letter and keep<br />
an eye on Craig’s list to make sure your<br />
property is not being advertised.<br />
Ms. Sorensen stated that there are many<br />
opportunities to implement checks and<br />
balances to protect ourselves. The first<br />
one and probably the strongest one is the<br />
staff you hire. Know your staff. She has<br />
a client who will not hire anyone unless<br />
they come through an internal referral<br />
and there has to be at least two people<br />
who already work for the company and<br />
know the prospective employee. They<br />
have very little turnover and zero incidents<br />
of fraud. Training of your staff, internal<br />
programs put in place and staff knowing<br />
how you do your business. Having<br />
processes in place that are adhered to<br />
and followed, that are documented so<br />
that when you have a brand new person<br />
who comes in, they have something that<br />
they can look at, a manual that step by<br />
step takes them through the process that<br />
they are supposed to follow. Have a very<br />
strong underwriting department, this is<br />
a key role in a company and is extremely<br />
important to a company’s success. Giving<br />
your underwriters the authority to check<br />
and to stop a loan if they see something<br />
wrong. Also let them know they will not<br />
be reprimanded for stopping a loan if they<br />
have concerns.<br />
Policies and procedures at the corporate<br />
and department level are very important,<br />
as well as ensuring that those policies<br />
procedures are followed. Internal audits<br />
should be performed to make sure they are<br />
following all the steps they are supposed<br />
to follow.<br />
Have an exception desk. Even if you<br />
have the best staff and processes, there<br />
will always be the deals that do not fit<br />
into the square box. There needs to be<br />
a procedure to handle those exceptions<br />
and the best way to do that is to have an<br />
exception desk.<br />
According to Ms. Newhall it is vastly<br />
easier to stop fraud if it is stopped before<br />
it occurs. She agreed with Alice in that<br />
clearly the best way of stopping fraud is to<br />
have great internal policies and procedures<br />
before it happens.<br />
Moving on to some of the legislation, she<br />
talked about a loophole closer. Senate Bill<br />
1737 was enacted last year and prevents<br />
real estate licensees that have lost their<br />
license to work in other aspects of real<br />
estate such as title, escrow, etc.<br />
Senate Bill 223 which was enacted on<br />
an emergency basis in 2007 made it a<br />
clear violation of the law to attempt to<br />
improperly influence an appraiser either<br />
through coercion, extortion or bribery.<br />
Senate Bill 385, also enacted in 2007, states<br />
that anyone being considered for a loan<br />
must be qualified at the fully indexed rate<br />
vs. the teaser rate.<br />
The panel agreed that prevention of fraud<br />
is the best way to eliminate it. The panel<br />
took time to answer questions from<br />
the audience. This session was most<br />
informative and all attendees should<br />
have gained valuable insights on how to<br />
be aware of different types of fraud and<br />
how it can be prevented.<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 39
40 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
By Bruce<br />
Juenger<br />
EARLY BREAKOUT SESSION 3:<br />
Commercial Properties + Mortgage Default =<br />
Are You Prepared?<br />
Moderator:<br />
Panel:<br />
Mathew Mandell, REO Property Specialists<br />
Brandy White Elk, Innovative Real Estate Strategies<br />
Don Rigsbee, JP Morgan Chase<br />
John Kohut, KCG Kohut Capital Group<br />
This session focused on the seldom<br />
mentioned, but growing potential,<br />
of commercial loan defaults and the<br />
consequential rise of financially distressed<br />
commercial properties that will need<br />
to be resolved, and the opportunities<br />
for individuals to become experts on<br />
what could be a highly active niche of<br />
the default industry. Most of the recent<br />
attention of the public, media and default<br />
servicing professionals has been focused<br />
on residential foreclosures. However, there<br />
is an immense level of commercial loan<br />
defaults lurking as a very real possibility<br />
in the near future. This will have profound<br />
repercussions on the real estate market and<br />
those who work in the industry.<br />
The session was opened by the moderator<br />
Mathew Mandell of REO Property<br />
Specialists who presented a PowerPoint<br />
that demonstrated the growing issue of<br />
commercial loan defaults. Mr. Mandell<br />
remarked that this topic was recently<br />
reported by the Wall Street Journal in a<br />
March 26, 2009 article titled: “Commercial<br />
Property Faces Crisis.”<br />
In the presentation it was noted that while<br />
less than 3% of the default industry is<br />
in commercial, the commercial default<br />
services niche is still in its infancy. In the<br />
recession of the early 1990’s there was<br />
a failure rate of approximately 1.8% in<br />
commercial loans. In the next five years,<br />
the number of commercial loan defaults is<br />
expected to soar to levels that will dwarf<br />
those. In the last six months alone the 30<br />
– 60 day delinquency rate has soared 300-<br />
400%. The aggregate delinquency rate is<br />
expected to reach 3.5% by the end of 2009,<br />
and as high as 5-6% by late 2010.<br />
The soaring commercial delinquencies<br />
are due to several factors. Of course<br />
the continuing economic recession is<br />
decreasing demand for retail and industrial<br />
real estate deflating rents and property<br />
values as much as 45%. There are as many<br />
as 700 banks that are in danger of failing<br />
over the next three years. Adding to the<br />
threat is the high number and the large face<br />
value of high-risk 5 year loans that are due<br />
in 2010-2012.<br />
This is creating a climate for a “perfect<br />
storm” of defaults in commercial real estate,<br />
one that will present major crises and<br />
opportunities for the experts in this field.<br />
The next panelist was Don Rigsbee, Special<br />
Assets Division Manager for J P Morgan<br />
continued on page 42<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 41
Early Session 3 – continued from page 41<br />
Chase. Mr. Rigsbee came to Chase through<br />
their recent acquisition of WaMu from<br />
the FDIC. He has a long history in the<br />
commercial default industry with several<br />
preceding institutions including American<br />
Savings Bank. The former WaMu loan<br />
portfolio represents the majority of their<br />
commercial real estate loans with 40,000<br />
loans, compared to Chase’s original 2,000<br />
commercial loans. The portfolio consists of<br />
primarily loans on multi-family residential<br />
properties with an average loan balance of<br />
$1.5 million.<br />
Rigsbee’s department takes an active<br />
approach in working on their commercial<br />
delinquencies. They keep current on<br />
values, primary through the use of real<br />
estate brokers to predict net present<br />
values combined with discount rate. The<br />
resolutions used include: loan restructures;<br />
discounted payoffs; short sales; foreclosure<br />
and REO sales. Each note is handled<br />
individually and they are not putting pools<br />
together at this time. Mr. Rigsbee noted<br />
that the large number of declining markets<br />
is creating new opportunities for those<br />
working in commercial loan default.<br />
Brandy White Elk with Innovative Real<br />
Estate Strategies discussed the next section<br />
of the session in which she outlined some<br />
of the details and nuances in working with<br />
commercial loan defaults. Ms. White<br />
Elk outlined how there are often many<br />
more moving parts in working through a<br />
commercial default scenario than there are<br />
in the typical residential default resolution.<br />
One primary method is to work off the<br />
premise of doing a short sale. It is important<br />
to find out exactly what the bank needs<br />
for a complete package before submission.<br />
Knowing and having the precise items and<br />
documentations required by that institution<br />
in the initial submission package will<br />
greatly increase the likelihood of reaching<br />
a successful resolution.<br />
In working thorough these transactions<br />
the industry professional must be prepared<br />
for the unusual and the unexpected and<br />
be resourceful to find solutions to those<br />
obstacles that may appear. For example,<br />
cross-collateralization with other assets<br />
is very common for many commercial<br />
borrowers, and these commitments must be<br />
worked with in the process. Issues like these<br />
will separate the experts from the novices<br />
in being able to resolve a commercial<br />
default transaction. And it will also make<br />
those experts a valued contributor to the<br />
process.<br />
The final panelist was John Kohut of KCG<br />
Kohut Capital Group, who discussed capital<br />
markets and what drives capital. Mr. Kohut<br />
is active in commercial mezzanine loans<br />
and preferred mezzanine loans, with $100<br />
million funded in 2008 and now reaching<br />
towards ½ billion in 2009. He spoke on<br />
how the historically low interest rates are<br />
impacting the value of everything. These<br />
low rates can drive capital and markets,<br />
sometimes in directions not always<br />
expected. He gave an example of the time<br />
period between 1969 and 1984 when the<br />
Dow Jones Industrial average closed exactly<br />
where it had started at 874, no increase<br />
in value for a 15 year period. He thought<br />
there is the potential for another prolonged<br />
stagnation in the stock and equities markets<br />
in the near future.<br />
Mr. Kohut gave comparison for how large<br />
this pending wave of commercial loan<br />
defaults could become. In the early 1990’s<br />
when 1,000 banks failed, there was a<br />
combined $48.5 billion in losses, of which<br />
approximately 7.9% was commercial debt.<br />
Today there is approximately $6.5 trillion<br />
of commercial real estate in the entire<br />
U.S., of which about 47% or $3.1 trillion<br />
is financed. So far in this recession, these<br />
commercial values have declined 35-45%<br />
from their peak, setting the stage for a<br />
massive default rate. By 2012, $154 billion<br />
in securitized commercial loans will need<br />
to be refinanced. And an additional $524<br />
billion in commercial whole loans held by<br />
banks will have to be rolled. Clearly, many<br />
institutions will not be able to survive<br />
this calamity. His advice: “Be aggressive<br />
in finding your information because the<br />
rules have changed.”<br />
This session was packed with new<br />
information on a branch of the default<br />
industry that many in the crowd had<br />
previously not paid much attention to in the<br />
past. However, once the scope and breath<br />
of the potential business in this particular<br />
niche was demonstrated, it was clear that<br />
this is a subject that has now become a much<br />
more important segment of the default<br />
industry. And it will likely become one of<br />
such significance that it will be impossible<br />
for any professional working in the default<br />
services industry to ignore.<br />
42 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
By Benton<br />
Neese<br />
LATE BREAKOUT SESSION 2:<br />
Foreclosure and Loss Mitigation Evolvement<br />
Moderator:<br />
Panel:<br />
Randy Miller, Esq., Randall S. Miller and Associates, PC<br />
Rick Sharga, RealtyTrac<br />
Courtenay Dunn, Esq., Goldbeck, McAfferty & McKeever<br />
Rhoan Burnard, Freddie Mac<br />
With the default industry changing<br />
so dramatically over the past<br />
couple of years, we have all had<br />
to adjust to survive. The changes will have<br />
to continue as our environment changes.<br />
This session was intended to present the<br />
challenges and opportunities facing our<br />
industry and some options available to the<br />
industry and the borrowers to deal with<br />
those challenges and opportunities.<br />
Mr. Miller started the session with a<br />
few brief comments. He congratulated<br />
everyone for taking the initiative to come<br />
to this conference to learn how we all must<br />
change and be the best we can be to the<br />
customers, clients and our companies<br />
in these difficult times. He stressed the<br />
importance of everyone to work towards<br />
a common goal of helping borrowers stay<br />
in their homes but being educated to the<br />
situation and realizing, in some situations,<br />
the best help for everyone is the smooth<br />
disposition of the property with minimum<br />
anxiety to the borrowers. He also said<br />
we all have to face the fact that the loss<br />
mitigation environment is changing and<br />
we have to be willing to change as well.<br />
Ms. Dunn, Esq. stated that many of the<br />
foreclosure laws and procedures are<br />
changing to assist with loss mitigation.<br />
In the Philadelphia area the sheriffs are<br />
trying to work with the lenders to assist<br />
with potential loss mitigation actions,<br />
including delaying foreclosure sales.<br />
In Pennsylvania, when the foreclosure<br />
action is filed, a hotline telephone number<br />
is sent to the borrower. The borrower<br />
is given a housing counselor prior to<br />
the foreclosure hearing. This housing<br />
counselor reviews the borrower’s situation<br />
and searches for any loss mitigation<br />
opportunities that may be available. The<br />
borrower may even be offered attorney<br />
assistance at no costs to the borrower.<br />
Mr. Sharga stated foreclosures were up 30%<br />
in February 2009 vs. February 2008! The<br />
number of REO properties shows an even<br />
greater increase. He said it is estimated that<br />
60% of American households will receive a<br />
foreclosure notice this year! His company,<br />
as well as nationwide lenders; have to stay<br />
on top of all of the law changes taking place<br />
right now in almost all of the 50 states.<br />
Most all of these changes are centered on<br />
giving the lender/ borrower more time to<br />
work out a mitigation solution. Mr. Sharga<br />
feels currently Pennsylvania and Colorado<br />
are the two states which seem to be more<br />
aggressive in helping the borrowers in<br />
a default situation. He also stated, with<br />
concurrence of the other panel members,<br />
that the key to the borrower receiving<br />
assistance is the ability to get the borrower<br />
and the lender together to discuss the issue<br />
with open minds.<br />
Ms. Dunn and Mr. Sharga agree that,<br />
in Pennsylvania, 75% of the potential<br />
foreclosures can be saved if the lender<br />
and the borrower get together prior to<br />
the foreclosure. The good news is that<br />
more and more of the states are making<br />
a stronger effort to assist borrowers with<br />
generous loss mitigation opportunities<br />
and longer timelines in the foreclosure<br />
process.<br />
Mr. Burnard with Freddie Mac started<br />
his discussion by stating that in a 2005<br />
continued on page 44<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 43
Late Session 2 – continued from page 43<br />
survey of borrowers 60% said they did not<br />
know they had the option to contact their<br />
lender and review assistance opportunities.<br />
He stated that Freddie Mac had made<br />
a strong push to improve this through<br />
borrower and lender education but when<br />
the survey was completed in 2007, 58.7%<br />
of the borrowers surveyed still said they<br />
did not know they had that option! Freddie<br />
Mac continues to address this problem by<br />
paying substantial fees to the servicers<br />
who complete borrower assistance and<br />
will counsel with servicers who maintain<br />
low workout numbers. Freddie Mac will,<br />
in some situations, lower the number of<br />
loans the servicer is managing for Freddie<br />
Mac and will, in severe cases, withdraw<br />
the servicer’s rights as a Freddie Mac<br />
servicing agent if the loss mitigation results<br />
remain low.<br />
Mr. Burnard pointed out that Freddie<br />
Mac is dedicated to supporting servicers’<br />
early intervention efforts, reducing<br />
the percentage of borrowers who go to<br />
foreclosure without contact with their<br />
servicer and trying to address borrower<br />
anxiety by promoting servicer efforts<br />
to assist borrowers who want to avoid<br />
foreclosure.<br />
Some interesting statistics that came<br />
from this session was the fact that<br />
unemployment or loss of income remains<br />
the number one reason for default, by an<br />
overwhelming margin (43.0% in 2007<br />
to 44.2% in 2008), but the number two<br />
reason moved from illness in family from<br />
2002-2007 to excessive obligations in 2008.<br />
This simply supports the contention of<br />
borrowers being pushed into homes they<br />
cannot afford and others living above<br />
their means.<br />
Everyone agreed, as an industry, we<br />
need to educate the borrowers that their<br />
responsibilities include making their<br />
mortgage payment their first priority,<br />
tighten their budgets to assist with the<br />
reduced income and try very hard to build<br />
their savings for future financial crises.<br />
At the same time, servicers must realize<br />
they must remain very strong in their<br />
proactive loss mitigation efforts and<br />
continue with these actions all the way up<br />
to the foreclosure sale.<br />
Fraud investigations with the FBI have gone<br />
from 102 in 2001 to 1,210 in 2008 and the<br />
Mortgage Fraud Suspicious Activity Report<br />
within the Freddie Mac Financial Crimes<br />
Enforcement Network reported 4,225<br />
cases in 2001 up to 46,717 in 2008! There<br />
has to be an awareness campaign to assist<br />
borrowers in being aware of predatory<br />
lenders and “foreclosure prevention” scams.<br />
Borrowers have to understand there is<br />
assistance available, but it needs to be<br />
through reputable companies or non-profit<br />
organizations such as HOPE Hotline or<br />
CCCS agencies.<br />
The panel agrees that cures of delinquent<br />
loans will not come from the government,<br />
but from the private sector working with<br />
the borrowers on a regular basis to prevent<br />
the number of foreclosures continuing<br />
to climb. It must be a team effort for our<br />
industry to survive but we will survive by<br />
all working together for the common goal<br />
of keeping as many borrowers as possible<br />
in their homes while minimizing losses<br />
for the lenders/investors.<br />
44 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
By Berry<br />
F. Laws III,<br />
Esq.<br />
LATE BREAKOUT SESSION 3:<br />
Litigation Update<br />
Moderator:<br />
Panel:<br />
Dean Talaganis, Morris, Hardwick, Schneider<br />
Greg Ruzicka, Ruzicka & Wallace<br />
Matt Abad, Burke, Constanza, Cuppy LLP<br />
Donna LaPorte, Wright, Finlay & Zak, LLP<br />
Judge Mitchell Goldberg, Bankruptcy Judge (retired), California<br />
The discussion began on the issues<br />
of federal, state and local trends.<br />
Current trends in federal and state<br />
courts include activism by judges and<br />
legislation to slow the foreclosure process,<br />
and court-ordered mediation (in the<br />
states of New York and Indiana). Money<br />
judgments are more difficult due to the<br />
requirement of proving debt; the lender<br />
must produce the note.<br />
Donna LaPorte emphasized the need to<br />
actually know the law. In California,<br />
both state and federal courts, “one must<br />
be well versed in the practice of law and<br />
have a strong knowledge of the rules of<br />
evidence.”<br />
Dean Talaganis addressed the issue of<br />
eviction, stating “it was essential to pull<br />
chain of title prove the date of the Deed<br />
of Trust.” Also in California, the file must<br />
reflect a return of service of process, as<br />
debtors are now challenging proof of<br />
service.<br />
Judge Mitchell Goldberg spoke regarding<br />
trends, which he divided into several<br />
categories: Trend 1, which was the<br />
prevailing course of action in the ‘90s to<br />
2005, that the courts’ view on relief from<br />
stay was very balanced. It was a simple<br />
philosophy, if debtor was not staying in<br />
the property, why make the plaintiff jump<br />
through hoops. This course of thinking<br />
changed in approximately 2005, when the<br />
outsourcing system (3 rd party outsourcers)<br />
became prevalent. Judge Goldberg<br />
explained that attorneys were coming to<br />
court with little authority, and the judges<br />
were unhappy with the results. In addition,<br />
in Chapter 13 bankruptcies, the judges<br />
believed the payoffs were incorrect, with<br />
hidden charges, and that often debtors<br />
got overcharged by thousands in late fees,<br />
time and time again, but only one party<br />
out of 100 were challenging.<br />
The second trend began to occur when the<br />
economy began to slide. With the advent of<br />
“securization,” new issues arose. Attorneys<br />
did not have any authority, and the loans<br />
were fractionalized in CDO’s. Another<br />
question was raised, “who was the real<br />
party in interest.” Debtors were unaware<br />
of who they were dealing with; the courts<br />
required full disclosure and transparency<br />
as to the owner of the note.<br />
Another trend has emerged in California<br />
courts. Debtors are going to state court,<br />
and Sheriff’s departments were requiring<br />
a higher standard. Before this trend, the<br />
courts would not give long breaks to<br />
continued on page 46<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 45
Late Session 3 – continued from page 45<br />
tenants, but the state courts are not letting<br />
lenders expel tenants as easily. This trend<br />
came about in part because the residences<br />
were not properly cleaned and maintained.<br />
Mr. Talaganis gave an example of the overbilling<br />
for yard mowing; a $300 charge<br />
was assessed.<br />
Greg Ruzicka commented that he believed<br />
the days of old are over, stating “now<br />
creditors must be much more prepared.”<br />
They must be armed with certified copies<br />
of the Deed of Trust and have common<br />
addresses, further commenting that “the<br />
courts are shifting towards borrowers and/<br />
or tenants, as society and the courts do not<br />
want empty vacated houses.”<br />
Ms. LaPorte also commented that unlawful<br />
detainers are now much harder to prove.<br />
The commissioners don’t know the law or<br />
are not up to date, and UCC rules are more<br />
difficult. Now defense counsel will not<br />
stipulate in cases where the commissioner<br />
does not know the law.<br />
Judge Goldberg emphasized that attorneys<br />
must know the law and recite it. “If<br />
creditors want courts to be in compliance<br />
with UCC and the law, then their attorneys<br />
must know the law,” he said. If attorneys<br />
are knowledgeable, the commissioner will<br />
listen to you. In a nutshell, he states, “be<br />
prepared.”<br />
Mr. Ruzicka further spoke about California<br />
loss mitigation, stating “the trend is to<br />
contact the borrowers and give them their<br />
rights.” Otherwise, it would be a matter<br />
of time until the borrowers advised that<br />
“you did not work with me to mitigate.”<br />
He advised the panel of adverse jury<br />
verdicts and separate actions brought to<br />
challenge sales. Attorneys were merging<br />
UD actions with challenges to sales and<br />
taking the issues to the Supreme Court,<br />
and Mr. Ruzicka stated that the UD<br />
judges were taking on issues beyond their<br />
jurisdiction.<br />
A discussion was lead by Ms. LaPorte<br />
regarding TILA actions. She said, “Be very<br />
selective on local counsel.” They must be<br />
knowledgeable, as there are fewer summary<br />
judgments granted. Matt Abad added that<br />
attorneys must be knowledgeable, but<br />
must be vigilant when courts go above<br />
and beyond the decider of law. He gave<br />
an example of when the Rules of Civil<br />
Procedure would not allow a plaintiff’s<br />
attorney to decide to use a special process<br />
server.<br />
Mr. Ruzicka commented that some judges<br />
in California were blatantly not following<br />
the law. He said that due to the costly<br />
appellate process, it was often better to<br />
dismiss and restart your action.<br />
Mr. Talaganis advised on Northern Ohio<br />
law, giving the example of a judge advising<br />
a debtor on the law to file Chapter 13,<br />
requiring mediation, dismissing cases if<br />
notes were not produced, and following<br />
a second dismissal rule, that if a case is<br />
dismiss twice, it becomes final. He stated<br />
that this occurred mostly in state courts,<br />
rather than federal.<br />
The topic of legislative activity was then<br />
discussed. Ms. LaPorte spoke on rent<br />
control and vacant property ordinances.<br />
She advised that Los Angeles required<br />
registering of property, with a right to<br />
recover. The eviction control ordinance<br />
limit was one year to avoid blight and<br />
empty houses and to prevent property<br />
devaluation. The key is that the rent is<br />
not controlled. Ms. LaPorte advised that<br />
the cash for keys issue was a “ticking<br />
time bomb,” that she believed it was only<br />
a matter of time until brokers begin to<br />
get sued.<br />
Ms. LaPorte further advises that the<br />
broker should ensure the rent was not<br />
controlled and they should make new<br />
rental agreements or leases and leave out<br />
the attorney’s fees. You can then demand<br />
rent, and if not paid, you have a remedy.<br />
She cautioned brokers to be extremely<br />
circumspect and make no demand until<br />
they know the facts. She stressed that<br />
there were eight suits in the City of<br />
Oakland against brokers and attorneys,<br />
and she advised that you should make<br />
sure you check with counsel and follow<br />
rules assiduously.<br />
Mr. Abad stated that he believed there<br />
will be an initiative to train borrowers and<br />
their attorneys on how to stop foreclosure<br />
and how to sue/counterclaim. Judges do<br />
not know who are the parties in interest<br />
if the plaintiff is a pools or a trust. An<br />
example is Countrywide, who has been<br />
sued for questionable underwriting and<br />
abusive lending practices, as evidenced by<br />
a settlement with the Attorney General.<br />
Mr. Abad also commented about the<br />
inability of a borrower to modify. “How<br />
can a borrower honor a modification if he<br />
or she cannot pay the loan?” Mr. Ruzicka<br />
gave an example of a $686,000 loan that<br />
was modified to $520,000 on the same<br />
tract. He believes the Obama initiative<br />
is not working because borrowers are<br />
already so far under water; it is a fallacy<br />
that borrowers can modify their way out<br />
of their predicament.<br />
Judge Goldberg further commented<br />
on Fannie Mae’s non-allowance of<br />
modification of principal. He believes a<br />
practice of cutting interest rates due to a<br />
temporary loss of job or cut back in hours<br />
could affect borrowers because the cost<br />
would be less than renting. He further<br />
believes the debtors will make payments on<br />
something they believe has equity. If the<br />
mortgage doubles, what is the price of the<br />
property? The value will never reach equity<br />
level, and a debtor is in servitude because<br />
the house is not worth the mortgage.<br />
In summary, the common thread of<br />
the panel discussion was that creditors’<br />
attorneys should be completely up to date<br />
on the law and have all of their evidence<br />
on hand, with copies of the relevant<br />
documents and information on the correct<br />
parties in interest. The trend is shifting<br />
toward debtors’ rights in this economy,<br />
and creditors’ attorneys must be prepared<br />
to respond to this trend.<br />
46 Ma y / Jun e 2009 REOMAC ® update tm
President’s Message – continued from page 3<br />
Headquarters Happenings<br />
– continued from page 7<br />
offered something for everyone. No<br />
member of the Board of Directors or our<br />
committees receives compensation for<br />
the many hours of hard work that it takes<br />
to prepare and put together a conference<br />
of this magnitude. REOMAC® is here to<br />
offer networking and education. We resent<br />
the perception that this conference is for<br />
anything other than to bring together<br />
industry professionals to network and<br />
learn from the brightest and best. We<br />
want to inspire you and offer you the<br />
experience and friendship of others doing<br />
the same type of work that you do. Any<br />
pre-conference or post conference events<br />
that are not presented by REOMAC®, are<br />
not sponsored or endorsed by REOMAC®.<br />
Should you throw an event or attend one<br />
of these unauthorized events, you should<br />
conduct yourselves in a professional<br />
manner. What you do during the time of<br />
this or any other conference is a reflection<br />
on those of us that attend these conferences<br />
to gain information and knowledge. The<br />
country is in a crisis. Millions of people<br />
are losing their jobs and their homes. We<br />
try to offer assistance to make it an easier<br />
transition for those that have to move<br />
out due to foreclosure. Please be more<br />
cognizant of the perception of those that<br />
do not know how hard you all work to do<br />
your jobs in the most ethical and honest<br />
way that it can be done.<br />
I am so honored and proud to be<br />
REOMAC®’s President this year. I have<br />
met the most incredible, hard working<br />
and kind people through my association<br />
with REOMAC®. I cannot and will not<br />
tolerate the bad press or misinformation<br />
that has circled around this industry and<br />
our conferences. I promise to do whatever<br />
I can to insure that we are perceived as<br />
professionals, now do your part.<br />
Our attitude toward<br />
life determines life’s<br />
attitude towards us.<br />
– Earl Nightingale<br />
Can I take any certification courses<br />
offered at the Fall <strong>Conference</strong> without<br />
attending the conference itself?<br />
No. The certification courses offered<br />
are in conjunction with the conference,<br />
for which you must be registered.<br />
What exactly is a conference guest<br />
registration?<br />
A guest registration is for a spouse<br />
or significant other of an attendee.<br />
Guests are only permitted to the<br />
social functions (i.e., the exhibit hall,<br />
the Gala Dinner, and the continental<br />
meals provided) and are not able to<br />
book a separate hotel room from<br />
the primary attendee of whom the<br />
individual is a guest or attend any of<br />
the educational sessions.<br />
Finally, if I may be of any service to<br />
you, please contact me or any of us<br />
at Headquarters. Thank you for your<br />
continued support of REOMAC®.<br />
REOMAC ® update tm Ma y / Jun e 2009 47
REOMAC® Newsletter Advertising<br />
Policies & Agreement to Advertise<br />
REOMAC® Headquarters<br />
2520 Venture Oaks Way, Suite 150, Sacramento, CA 95833<br />
(916) 239-4090 - phone • (916) 924-7323 - fax<br />
www.<strong>reomac</strong>.com • info@<strong>reomac</strong>.com<br />
Unless otherwise stated, ads for this publication may be Black<br />
& White (“Grayscale”) or 2-Color (black & blue–PMS 2955).<br />
ARTWORK SPECIFICATIONS<br />
Please submit ads digitally where possible (PC format, not Mac)<br />
either on CD, zip disk, floppy disk, or via E-mail. Such electronic<br />
submissions should be in EPS, TIF, or PDF format, including all<br />
fonts where applicable, and should be compatible with Adobe<br />
Photoshop, Illustrator, PageMaker, InDesign, or Acrobat. We<br />
will also accept camera-ready (printed) full-sized images suitable<br />
for scanning, at either 133 or 150 line screen. Please see<br />
above for specific ad sizes and dimensions. Artwork should<br />
be E-mailed to “Advertising c/o REOMAC®” at john@camgmt.<br />
com or mailed to:<br />
Advertising c/o REOMAC®<br />
2520 Venture Oaks Way<br />
Suite 150<br />
Sacramento, CA 95833<br />
I will be submitting my ad:<br />
❑ Camera-ready by mail<br />
❑ Digitally on disc ❑ Via E-mail<br />
❑ I need assistance designing a new ad<br />
(we will discuss design rates separately)<br />
PAYMENT TERMS<br />
All payments must be received before ANY ad will run. A frequency<br />
discount is given to those who agree in writing (ie. this signed contract)<br />
to advertise in every issue of the calendar year, or in an equal<br />
number of consecutive issues. If the written agreement is not fulfilled,<br />
the advertiser is liable for the one-time rate charges. Advertisers who<br />
submit an ad contract with payment, but fail to submit artwork by the<br />
publication deadline will not be given a refund or credit.<br />
AD SIZES AND RATES<br />
Ad Size (WxH) 1x Rate 6x Rate<br />
Outside Back Cover* 8½”x11” – (add 1/8” for bleed) $1,750 $8,750<br />
Inside Front Cover* 8½”x11” – (add 1/8” for bleed) $1,500 $7,500<br />
Inside Back Cover* 8½”x11” – (add 1/8” for bleed) $1,250 $6,250<br />
Full Page 8½”x11” – (add 1/8” for bleed) $750 $3,750<br />
½ Page Horizontal 7½”x4½” $375 $1,875<br />
¼ page 4½”x4½” (2 columns) $200 $1,000<br />
* As this premium advertising location becomes available, an e-mail notification will be sent to all<br />
members. The spot will be sold on a first-paid basis.<br />
Please note: All advertisers must be members in good standing of<br />
REOMAC®. If the artwork you submit does not conform to the above<br />
dimensions, we will make every effort to adjust the ad to fit the space<br />
available.<br />
PLACING YOUR AD<br />
To place an ad, complete the information below and mail or fax to: REOMAC®, 2520 Venture Oaks Way, Suite 150, Sacramento,<br />
CA 95833 • (916) 924-7323 - fax. REOMAC® will not run your ad without this contract and payment.<br />
Name of Individual Being Advertised:_______________________________________________________________________<br />
Billing Contact:____________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
Billing Address:____________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
Phone:____________________________ Fax:_____________________________ E-mail:________________________________<br />
Agency or Advertising Representative (if different from above):__________________________________________________<br />
Phone:___________________________ Fax:_____________________________ E-mail:________________________________<br />
Person to Contact with Artwork-specific Questions (if different from above):_______________________________________<br />
Phone:____________________________ Fax:_____________________________ E-mail:________________________________<br />
I agree to place a _______size ad in the following issue(s), and to pay a rate of $___________ per issue:<br />
(NOTE: The multiple-issue rate can apply to any consecutive series of issues starting at any point in the year. If you choose the multiissue<br />
rate, please number your first issue “#1” below, and the other issues as they occur chronologically. See condition #5, above.)<br />
___Jul/Aug ’09 ___Sep/Oct ’09 ___Nov/Dec ’09 ___Jan/Feb ’09 ___Mar/Apr ’09 _ _ _M a y /J u n ’ 0 9<br />
_Payment/Material Deadlines: 7/10/09 9/11/09 11/6/09 1/8/10 3/12/10 5/14/10<br />
METHOD OF PAYMENT<br />
Please check one:<br />
❑ Enclosed is check #____________ ❑ Charge my Credit Card ❍ MC* ❍ Visa* In the amount of $_____________<br />
Card #:_____________________________________________________ Expiration Date:________________________________<br />
Print Cardholder’s Name:___________________________________________ Signature:________________________________<br />
Cardholder’s Billing Address:_________________________________________________________________________________<br />
* We accept only MasterCard, VISA and American Express<br />
CONDITIONS<br />
1. Advertisers and advertising agencies are liable for all content (including<br />
text, representations, and illustrations) of advertisements and are responsible,<br />
without limitation, for any and all claims made thereof against<br />
REOMAC® Update, the association, its officers, agents, or vendors.<br />
2. No advertiser is guaranteed placement, but every attempt will be made<br />
to provide the desired position.<br />
3. Publisher reserves the right to revise, reject or omit any advertisement at<br />
any time without notice.<br />
4. REOMAC® accepts no liability for its failure, for any cause, to insert advertisement.<br />
5. Publisher reserves the right to publish materials from a previous advertisement<br />
if new materials are not received by material deadline.<br />
6. The word “advertisement” will appear on any ad that resembles editorial<br />
material.<br />
7. Drawings, artwork and articles for reproduction are accepted only at the<br />
advertiser’s risk and should be clearly marked to facilitate return.<br />
8. No verbal agreement altering the rates and/or terms of this rate card shall<br />
be recognized.<br />
9. All advertisements, layout and designs produced for the advertiser by<br />
REOMAC®’s Graphic Staff will remain the property of REOMAC®.<br />
10. All requests for advertising must be in writing, in the form of this signed<br />
contract, for the protection of both the advertiser and REOMAC®.<br />
11. Once an order for advertising is placed, it cannot be withdrawn or cancelled<br />
in whole or in part.<br />
12. By signing this contract, advertiser agrees to pay in full for reserved space,<br />
even if the ad is not run due to lateness or absence of materials.<br />
(rev. 6/09)
REOMAC ® 2009<br />
Fall <strong>Conference</strong><br />
Quest for<br />
Excellence in<br />
a Challenging<br />
Market<br />
October 14-17, 2009 • Westin Diplomat • Hollywood, FL<br />
— Save the Date —
Sid Covers Connecticut!<br />
More than 36 years of real<br />
estate experience, including<br />
21 years in REO exclusively!<br />
State-of-the-art computerization with electronic capability for BPO’s, digital<br />
photographs, listing agreements, purchase and sale agreements, and invoicing<br />
Cradle-to-Grave Capability 96% Sales Price to List Price Ratio<br />
REOs Exclusively Since 1990 Average 32 DOM Per Property<br />
• GRI • CRB • Professional Real Estate Association •<br />
• Greater Hartford Association of Realtors • Fairfield County Board of Realtors •<br />
• Eastern Connecticut Board of Realtors • Chamber of Commerce •<br />
Member of REOMAC®, REO Connection &<br />
The Connecticut Statewide MLS Service<br />
Sid F. Manning<br />
Coldwell Banker Manning Realty<br />
36 School Street<br />
Glastonbury, CT 06033<br />
(860) 633-1300 x102<br />
(860) 831-1000 – eFax<br />
(860) 202-5482 – Cell<br />
sidneymanning@aol.com<br />
www.sidcoversct.com