July | August 2006 - Boston Photography Focus
July | August 2006 - Boston Photography Focus
July | August 2006 - Boston Photography Focus
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
ook review<br />
Left: Edward Burtynsky, Bao Steel #8, Shanghai, China, from the China Series, 2005. Digital chromogenic print.<br />
Right: Emmet Gowin, Aeration Pond, Toxic Water Treatment Facility, Pine Bluff, Arkansas, 1989. Toned gelatin silver print.<br />
Imaging a Shattering Earth<br />
by Claude Baillargeon<br />
The catalogue is co-published by the Meadow Brook Art Gallery,<br />
College of Arts and Sciences, Oakland University, and CONTACT<br />
Toronto <strong>Photography</strong> Festival, 2005<br />
Review by Rebecca A. Senf, Ph.D. Candidate,<br />
Art History Program, <strong>Boston</strong> University<br />
The recent exhibition catalogue Imaging a Shattering Earth: Contemporary<br />
<strong>Photography</strong> and the Environmental Debate brings together<br />
powerful photographs, supports them with thought-provoking essays,<br />
and provides useful short biographies of the artists. The provocative<br />
title and compelling list of photographers represented in the exhibition,<br />
which originated at the Meadow Brook Art Gallery at Oakland<br />
University in Rochester, Michigan last fall, are tantalizing to anyone<br />
interested in contemporary landscape photography. The fully illustrated<br />
catalogue features fifty-six photographs by Edward Burtynsky,<br />
John Ganis, Peter Goin, Emmet Gowin, David T. Hanson, Jonathan<br />
Long, David Maisel, David McMillan, Robert and Shana ParkeHarrison,<br />
John Pfahl, and Mark Ruwedel. These “testimonies” record the<br />
damage we have done to our Earth, and present the evidence in an<br />
undeniable language.<br />
“Our world is changing. We are destroying it; destroying the air<br />
we breathe, the water we drink, the land that sustains us. We are<br />
laying waste to the only home we have.” So begins Robert F. Kennedy<br />
Junior’s introductory essay. This book led me to a disheartening<br />
epiphany: if our world’s leaders have allowed the environmental<br />
disasters recorded here, we are doomed. What these photographs<br />
illustrate, however, is that our leaders not only have allowed them,<br />
but at times were (or currently are) sponsoring the pollution, degradation<br />
and waste. How can we expect individuals to recycle or<br />
relinquish gas-guzzling SUVs, when our leadership betrays us so<br />
Both main essays mention that except for Robert and Shana<br />
ParkeHarrison’s collaboration, men made all of Shattering Earth’s<br />
photographs. The curator, Claude Baillargeon, wanted photographers<br />
whose direct, yet distanced, observation of the earth’s altered<br />
topography created a 21st century parallel to the 1975 landmark<br />
exhibition New Topographics. Maia-Mari Sutnik’s essay discusses<br />
women photographers who grapple with environmental issues, but<br />
whose approach was either more personal or journalistic than Baillargeon<br />
wanted.<br />
These photographs gain strength grouped as they are here. I shared<br />
the book with two friends: one mentioned how difficult, painful it<br />
was to look at the images, the other said how beautiful they were.<br />
Put Shattering Earth on your coffee table and let it begin conversations<br />
about where we went so wrong, and how we will set things<br />
right again.<br />
www.prcboston.org | book review