Fall 2002 - Lone Star Chapter, Sierra Club
Fall 2002 - Lone Star Chapter, Sierra Club
Fall 2002 - Lone Star Chapter, Sierra Club
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Drop in Banner<br />
THE NEWSLETTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB, LONE STAR CHAPTER<br />
Vol. XXXVIII, No. 3, <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Photo courtesy of Justin Murrill<br />
Citizens rally to oppose Marvin Nichols Reservoir - page 3<br />
Regional Water Conferences Set for <strong>Fall</strong> - page 5
2 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n<br />
(ISSN 0195-1995) will be<br />
published four times this<br />
year; in spring, summer,<br />
fall and winter issues for<br />
$1 per year for members<br />
and $15 per year for<br />
nonmembers by the <strong>Lone</strong><br />
<strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
<strong>Club</strong>, 54 Chicon, Austin,<br />
TX, 78702, (512) 477-1729.<br />
Member/Subscriber:<br />
Send address changes to:<br />
P.O. Box 1931,<br />
Austin, TX 78767<br />
Advertising rates are<br />
available upon request from:<br />
Jennifer Walker,<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
P.O.Box 1931<br />
Austin, TX 78767<br />
(512) 477-1729 phone<br />
(512) 477-8526 fax<br />
lonestar.chapter@ierraclub.org<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n<br />
The Newsletter of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>, <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Vol. XXXVIII, No. 3, <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n will be published quarterly. Tentative publication<br />
dates for <strong>2002</strong> are March 1, June 1, September 1 and December 1.<br />
Submission deadlines are 4 weeks prior to publication.<br />
Feature<br />
3 Citizens Rally to Oppose the Proposed<br />
Marvin Nichols Reservoir<br />
5 Water for People and the Environment<br />
Your Environment<br />
6 Padre Island Gas Drilling Debate Flares Up Again -<br />
Turtles At Risk<br />
8 Texas Water Sentinels Campaign Continues Efforts to<br />
Protect the Leon River Watershed<br />
10 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Working to Reduce Air Pollution<br />
11 Conservation of Texas Land and Water Resources<br />
Highlighted at <strong>Chapter</strong> Conference<br />
13 Texas Parks & Wildlife Release Land & Water<br />
Conservation Plan<br />
15 New Economic Study Places Value of Recreation &<br />
Restoration on Texas National Forests Above<br />
Commercial Logging<br />
Environmental Education<br />
16 <strong>Sierra</strong> Cubs Camp Expands Throughout Texas<br />
State of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
18 Intern Justin Murrill Lends His Enthusiasm to the Work of<br />
the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
19 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Presents Awards for 2001<br />
at Dinner in Houston<br />
20 Get a Commanding View of Austin, the Texas Legislature<br />
& Upcoming Environmental Legislation<br />
21 Join Us October 19 & 20 for <strong>Sierra</strong> Celebration <strong>2002</strong><br />
General<br />
22 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Directory<br />
23 Regional Group Volunteer Leadership Directory<br />
24 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Calendar <strong>2002</strong>
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 3<br />
Feature<br />
Citizens Rally to Oppose<br />
the Proposed Marvin Nichols Reservoir<br />
Diverse Coalition Pushes Conservation over Development<br />
By Ken Kramer, Director, <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
“Meet the faces of a new coalition,”<br />
said Rita Beving, conservation<br />
co-chair of the Dallas Regional<br />
Group of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>, as<br />
she stood and spoke on July 22 to<br />
a rally of 150 people from North<br />
Central and Northeast Texas<br />
united to show their opposition to<br />
the proposed Marvin<br />
Nichols Reservoir.<br />
“They are loggers,<br />
farmers, ranchers,<br />
and private landowners…from<br />
Dalby<br />
Springs to Dallas,<br />
from Denton to<br />
Texarkana…in all<br />
my years as an<br />
activist I have<br />
never seen such<br />
dedication from a<br />
group united for a<br />
single cause,” added<br />
Beving.<br />
Indeed it was an<br />
impressive sight.<br />
Over 50 people had<br />
come by bus from<br />
Northeast Texas to Grand Prairie<br />
to join with 100 citizens from the<br />
Metroplex to attend a meeting of<br />
the Region C Water Planning<br />
Group, the water planning group<br />
for the region that includes the<br />
Dallas/Forth Worth metropolitan<br />
area. These somewhat unlikely<br />
allies were there to promote water<br />
conservation over water development,<br />
to argue for saving the<br />
taxpayers’ money as well as saving<br />
water.<br />
The Proposed Reservoir<br />
The immediate target of their<br />
passion was the proposed Marvin<br />
Nichols Reservoir. The reservoir,<br />
which is included in the current<br />
regional water plans for both<br />
Regions C and D, would be located<br />
in Region D (Northeast Texas) in<br />
the Sulphur River Basin.<br />
Although the reservoir is proposed<br />
to be located in Northeast Texas,<br />
80 percent of the water from the<br />
reservoir would be transferred by<br />
Citizens opposing the Marvin Nichols Reservoir vow “No Nickles for Nichols.”<br />
pipeline to the Dallas/Fort Worth<br />
region. Water customers in that<br />
region would be the ones primarily<br />
responsible for the $1.7 billion<br />
price tag for the project.<br />
The proposed reservoir project<br />
would be a large one by any standard.<br />
It would inundate about<br />
72,000 acres of forests, ranchland,<br />
and farmland along the Sulphur<br />
River in Red River, Bowie,<br />
Franklin, Titus, and Morris counties.<br />
The reservoir would yield<br />
619,100 acre feet of water per<br />
year. (An acre foot of water is the<br />
amount of water needed to flood<br />
one acre of land to a depth of one<br />
foot – it is equivalent to approximately<br />
325,000 gallons of water).<br />
The water from the reservoir<br />
going to the Dallas/Fort Worth<br />
region would travel in a pipeline<br />
about 170 miles long.<br />
The project would be built and<br />
managed by the Sulphur Basin<br />
River Authority (SBRA), a regional<br />
water authority created by the<br />
Texas Legislature<br />
in 1985. SBRA<br />
has the authority<br />
to control, store,<br />
conserve, and<br />
distribute surface<br />
water in the<br />
Sulphur River<br />
basin consistent<br />
with surface<br />
water rights<br />
granted by the<br />
State of Texas to<br />
varied water<br />
users in the<br />
basin. SBRA has<br />
contracted with<br />
two Texas engineering<br />
firms for<br />
studies of the<br />
feasibility of the reservoir.<br />
In its regional water plan,<br />
however, the Region D Water<br />
Planning Group did not identify<br />
any unmet water needs in its own<br />
region within the next 50 years.<br />
Thus, water from the Marvin<br />
Nichols Reservoir would primarily<br />
benefit only Region C for the<br />
foreseeable future, although some<br />
of the water in the reservoir would<br />
be available for Northeast Texas in<br />
the distant future.<br />
Photo courtesy of Justin Murrill<br />
The Opposition<br />
The citizens from Northeast<br />
Texas who oppose the reservoir do<br />
Continued next page
4 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Feature<br />
Continued from previous page.<br />
not see that future water supply or jobs associated<br />
with construction of the reservoir as providing any<br />
benefit to them, at least no benefit that outweighs<br />
the negative impacts on their communities and way<br />
of life. Among their primary concerns, of course, is<br />
the loss of their homes, their farms, their ranches,<br />
their forests, their traditional livelihood, and their<br />
cultural heritage as the reservoir drowns their land.<br />
Flooding of this land could cost the region in excess of<br />
$140 million annually due to loss of timber and<br />
agricultural production. Local opponents of the<br />
reservoir concerned about the economic and social<br />
impacts of the proposed project are organized as the<br />
Sulphur Oversight Society (SOS).<br />
These local landowners and other Northeast Texas<br />
citizens have joined forces with environmental<br />
groups such as the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
<strong>Club</strong> and regional <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> groups in North Texas,<br />
the National Wildlife Federation, and the Texas<br />
Committee on Natural Resources. Environmentalists<br />
oppose the Marvin Nichols Reservoir for a variety<br />
of reasons. One of the major reasons is the potential<br />
loss of bottomland hardwood forests. Over 36,000<br />
acres of such forests would be flooded and thus lost as<br />
a result of building the reservoir. The U. S. Fish and<br />
Wildlife Service considers bottomland hardwood<br />
forests as one of the most endangered ecosystems in<br />
the Southeastern United States.<br />
Waste of Water in the Dallas/Fort Worth<br />
Region<br />
Another reason for the opposition to the Marvin<br />
Nichols Reservoir from both environmentalists and<br />
Northeast Texas landowners is that the Dallas/Fort<br />
Worth region does not truly need the water from the<br />
proposed impoundment. Dallas and other cities in<br />
the region have been shown to use an incredible<br />
amount of water per capita, far more than most other<br />
large cities in Texas.<br />
Although estimates vary, Dallas, for example, uses<br />
in the vicinity of 250 gallons of water per person per<br />
day. That compares to approximately 146 gallons of<br />
water per person per day in San Antonio, a city that<br />
has made great strides over the past decade in<br />
trimming water consumption by its residents<br />
through a variety of measures. The Region C water<br />
plan predicted that the per capita water use in Dallas<br />
would actually increase over the next 50 years to a<br />
level of 264 gallons per capita per day – one of the few<br />
areas in the state where per capita use for expected<br />
to go up.<br />
By one analysis done by the National Wildlife<br />
Federation, if Dallas Water Utilities (the city’s water<br />
department) were to decrease its per capita water<br />
consumption by 2050 to just 200 gallons per day, that<br />
alone would provide the city with almost twice as<br />
A broad coalition of people attended the Region C water<br />
planning group meeting in July to promote water conservation<br />
as an alternative to the Marvin Nichols Reservoir.<br />
much water as it would gain from its share of the<br />
Marvin Nichols Reservoir project. Yet, despite the<br />
cost effectiveness of saving water rather than paying<br />
for an expensive new impoundment and pipeline, the<br />
City of Dallas and its North Central Texas neighbors<br />
have done little thus far to conserve water.<br />
Opponents of the reservoir see no reason for the<br />
building of a vast new impoundment of water in<br />
Northeast Texas to feed the unquenchable thirst of a<br />
neighboring region unwilling to curb its profligate<br />
use of water. There is no justification, they say, for<br />
a project that would have such a devastating impact<br />
on the environment and way of life of Northeast<br />
Texas just to water St. Augustine grass lawns in<br />
Dallas, Fort Worth, and their suburbs.<br />
Moving Forward<br />
The united opposition to the reservoir is beginning<br />
to make a difference. Local elected officials who<br />
have been sitting on the fence or speaking positively<br />
about the project are starting to express their opposition.<br />
Media coverage is building. Members of the<br />
Region C Water Planning Group have shown a willingness<br />
to take a closer look at their plan’s reliance<br />
on the proposed reservoir. Opposition to the reservoir<br />
on the Region D Water Planning Group has<br />
grown. The effort to defeat the reservoir is far from<br />
over, but the grassroots opposition is making its<br />
power felt.<br />
Photo courtesy of Justin Murrill
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 5<br />
Water for People and the Environment<br />
Second Round of Regional Water Conferences Set for the <strong>Fall</strong><br />
How do we get the water we need at a price we can afford How do we get serious about water<br />
conservation How much water is being wasted through leaks in our water lines How does water<br />
conservation protect fish and wildlife<br />
Are we overbuilding water projects to respond to droughts Is water reuse the answer to our problem<br />
or does it cause problems Is desalination the way to meet future water needs What are the<br />
energy and environmental costs of desal<br />
What are the current and emerging conflicts over water supplies What’s the latest on regional<br />
and state water planning<br />
Answers<br />
If you want the answers to these questions, plan to attend one or more of the following four regional<br />
water conferences to be conducted by the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> this fall:<br />
Feature<br />
Houston (Southeast TX Region)<br />
September 28, <strong>2002</strong><br />
University Hilton – UH Main Campus<br />
Dallas (North TX Region)<br />
October 5, <strong>2002</strong><br />
Downtown Public Library<br />
San Marcos (South Central TX)<br />
October 12, <strong>2002</strong><br />
Southwest Texas State University<br />
Mercedes (South TX Region)<br />
October 26, <strong>2002</strong><br />
Biblioteca Las Americas<br />
The conferences are sponsored by the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>in partnership with<br />
Environmental Defense, National Wildlife Federation, Texas Center for Policy Studies, Texas Committee<br />
on Natural Resources, & other organizations. Support for the conferences has been provided<br />
by The Houston Endowment, Inc.; The Meadows Foundation; The Brown Foundation, Inc.; and The<br />
Jacob and Terese Hershey Foundation as part of the Texas Living Waters Project.<br />
Last year’s conferences were a resounding success with approximately 400 people attending one or<br />
more of the conferences. This year’s round of conferences should prove to be equally informative and<br />
motivating. Cost of the conference (including lunch and materials is only $15 per person. A registration<br />
form accompanies this announcement.<br />
For more information check out: www.texas.sierraclub.org or contact the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> office<br />
at 512-477-1729 or lonestar.chapter @sierraclub.org.<br />
“WATER FOR PEOPLE & THE ENVIRONMENT”<br />
Regional Conferences on the Water Future of Texas Registration Form:<br />
Name__________________________________<br />
Address________________________________<br />
City/State/Zip Code_______________________<br />
Phone (including Area Code)_______________<br />
E-Mail Address__________________________<br />
Please register ____ person(s) for the following<br />
regional conference(s).<br />
____ Houston – September 28 (reg. deadline: Sept. 24)<br />
____ Dallas - October 5 (reg. deadline: Oct. 1)<br />
____ San Marcos - October 12 (reg. deadline Oct. 8)<br />
____ Mercedes - October 26 (reg. deadline Oct. 22)<br />
I/we (specify number: _____) prefer a vegetarian lunch.<br />
Enclosed is a check for $_____<br />
($15 per person per conference).<br />
Make check payable to “<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong>,<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>.”<br />
Charge my credit card for $_____<br />
Expiration Date: __________.<br />
Type of card: _____ Master Card _____ VISA<br />
Card # _______________________<br />
Signature: ______________________________<br />
Return form & payment to:<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong>, <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
ATTN: Regional Water Conferences<br />
P. O. Box 1931<br />
Austin, TX 78767
6 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Your Environment<br />
Padre Island Gas Drilling Debate<br />
Flares Up Again - Turtles At Risk<br />
Park Resumes Approval Process for 2 nd Drilling Operation<br />
by Erin Rogers, Grassroots Outreach Coordinator, <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Padre Island National Seashore<br />
is back at it again.<br />
The park has issued another<br />
review of a proposal by BNP Petroleum,<br />
Inc. of Corpus Christi to drill<br />
a gas well at the “Lemon/Lemon<br />
Seed” location in the dunes of the<br />
national seashore.<br />
The park approved a first well in<br />
February (Dunn-Murdock #1),<br />
which gave BNP the green light to<br />
bulldoze fragile dunes in a popular<br />
area of the park and drive dozens<br />
of 18-wheeler trucks up and down<br />
the beach each day in order to<br />
support the operation. Not surprisingly,<br />
the drilling ran over schedule<br />
and right into the height of the<br />
Kemp’s ridley sea turtle nesting<br />
season. Park managers allowed<br />
the drilling to continue unabated,<br />
despite the fact that the permit<br />
granted to BNP had no contingency<br />
plans for protecting the highly<br />
endangered Kemp’s ridley from the<br />
truck traffic.<br />
In response, the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
filed suit against Secretary of the<br />
Interior Gale Norton and the Park<br />
Service for failure to perform an<br />
adequate review of potential<br />
threats to the turtles, as required<br />
by the National Environmental<br />
Policy Act and the Endangered<br />
Species Act.<br />
Second Drilling Permit<br />
Meanwhile, the Park Service<br />
was busy issuing another environmental<br />
assessment for a second<br />
drilling permit (Lemon/Lemon<br />
Seed) desired by BNP. When the<br />
park issued that review, over a<br />
thousand <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> members<br />
responded with emails, faxes and<br />
letters urging the park to reject<br />
BNP’s application for a drilling<br />
permit, much less an operation<br />
that would occur during the height<br />
of the summer visitation and<br />
turtle nesting season.<br />
In May the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>’s legal<br />
team met with park managers and<br />
representatives from BNP in an<br />
attempt to address the issues<br />
raised in the <strong>Club</strong>’s legal complaint<br />
and in comments on the<br />
Lemon/Lemon Seed environmental<br />
assessment. While the discussions<br />
ended without any agreements<br />
being reached, the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
team made a strong case to park<br />
managers that even if the drilling<br />
is allowed to proceed, no operations<br />
should be permitted during<br />
the summer months when nesting<br />
turtles and high numbers of<br />
visitors would be forced to share<br />
the beach with heavy trucks.<br />
Sadly, park managers have<br />
rejected this accommodation. In<br />
the amended environmental<br />
review for the Lemon/Lemon Seed<br />
well the park staff has gone to<br />
Kemp’s Ridley Courtesy of Doug Perrine<br />
lengths to coat the proposal in a<br />
lawsuit-proof teflon, but they have<br />
done nothing to ensure greater<br />
protection for the turtles or for the<br />
visitor experience. In fact, the<br />
park concludes in the revised<br />
assessment that a restriction on<br />
drilling to the winter months has<br />
been ruled out as a possibility<br />
because that option would compound<br />
the impact of drilling operations<br />
on wintering piping plovers,<br />
an endangered bird.<br />
The park’s argument is incredible,<br />
given that the EA for Dunn-<br />
Murdock, as well as the original<br />
EA for Lemon/Lemon Seed, both<br />
dismissed the need for any consideration<br />
to be given to the possible<br />
impact of the drilling on the<br />
plovers. The EAs asserted that<br />
BNP’s operations would be nowhere<br />
near plover habitat (in the<br />
winter plovers feed along the mud<br />
flat shores of the Laguna Madre).<br />
Sadly, the park seems to be most<br />
concerned about the threat to<br />
endangered species when it is
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 7<br />
Your Environment<br />
convenient for BNP. When the presence of an endangered<br />
species isn’t convenient for BNP, the park finds<br />
it all too easy to gloss over the need to conduct further<br />
analysis, gather data, or take any of the other<br />
cautionary steps required by the National Environmental<br />
Protection Act. In its handling of BNP’s drilling<br />
campaign, the over-riding concern of the<br />
seashore’s management team seems to be avoiding<br />
any possible ire from Secretary Norton and the clique<br />
of oil industry supplicants running the Interior<br />
Department.<br />
Thanks to strong grassroots pressure and invaluable<br />
help from the <strong>Club</strong>’s legal staff, we succeeded in<br />
forcing NPS to re-evaluate its EA for Lemon/Lemon<br />
Seed, and that has kept BNP’s 18 wheelers at bay<br />
since June. But BNP has deep pockets and an army<br />
of hired gun attorneys, and it will take even greater<br />
efforts by the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> and others to fight off the<br />
next round of drilling. The stakes are high: thanks to<br />
a seasonal closure of the Gulf shrimp fishery, Kemp’s<br />
ridleys nested along the Texas coast in greatly<br />
improved numbers this year. But just as the turtle<br />
population seems invigorated, we are faced with the<br />
prospect of BNP plowing their heavy trucks through<br />
turtle nesting grounds for the next fifteen years!<br />
Radioactive Drilling Tool<br />
On a related note, the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> uncovered the<br />
fact that in February of this year BNP abandoned a<br />
highly radioactive drilling tool that became stuck in<br />
one of its wells just outside Padre Island National<br />
Seashore. The material in the tool will remain<br />
radioactive for 4,000 years.<br />
This latest discovery underscores the shoddy<br />
environmental record of BNP. The company was<br />
cited previously by state regulators for irresponsible<br />
management of oil waste pits in the Lower Rio<br />
Grande Valley.<br />
Drilling in National Parks<br />
As matter of principle, the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> believes<br />
that drilling for oil and gas is fundamentally incompatible<br />
with the purposes of national parks, which<br />
were created for public enjoyment and protection for<br />
future generations. Oil and gas drilling defeats both<br />
purposes. That sad contradiction appears to be lost<br />
on the Bush administration, however, which seems<br />
to have no comprehension of what national parks<br />
mean to the vast majority of Americans who cherish<br />
them as pristine examples of our natural heritage<br />
and havens for recreation.<br />
In May the Bush Administration agreed to buy out<br />
privately-held oil and gas holdings below Big Cypress<br />
National Preserve in Florida. While many agree that<br />
the buyout was a politically motivated to boost Governor<br />
Jeb Bush’s re-election effort, Texans have every<br />
right to expect that the Bush Administration should<br />
offer the same degree of protection to Padre Island<br />
National Seashore. In pursuit of that end, the <strong>Lone</strong><br />
<strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> is calling on state and federal officials<br />
to examine the cost of buying out the mineral rights<br />
beneath the seashore, which would put an end once<br />
and for all to drilling on the crown jewel of Texas<br />
beaches.<br />
SIGN UP NOW!<br />
For the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong>’s New E-mail Action Alert System!<br />
Since the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> Action Alert System was launched in March:<br />
• 1300 people have signed up<br />
• over 1000 faxes or e-mails have been sent to the Texas Parks and Wildlife<br />
Department to protect Texas’s wide open spaces<br />
• hundreds of comments have been sent to the Padre Island National Seashore<br />
superintendent objecting to new oil and gas drilling permits<br />
http://lonestar.sierraclubaction.org<br />
To participate in the system, simply go to the address above and enter your name, street address, and<br />
e-mail address so that the system can determine who your specific local elected officials are. Once<br />
you sign up you will receive an average of three to four e-mails per month about crucial decisions<br />
being made that affect air, water, wildlife, parks, and open spaces in Texas.
8 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Your Environment<br />
Texas Water Sentinels Campaign<br />
Continues Efforts to Protect the Leon<br />
River Watershed<br />
Central Texas <strong>Sierra</strong>ns Get<br />
First Hand Look at CAFO<br />
Operations<br />
By Justin Taylor, Water Quality Project<br />
Coordinator, <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
The Texas Water Sentinels Campaign,<br />
a project of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
funded by a national <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> grant,<br />
continued its efforts this summer to<br />
address water pollution from large-scale<br />
industrial dairy farms in Central Texas.<br />
The Water Sentinels Campaign is<br />
conducting ongoing water quality sampling,<br />
opposing permits for new and<br />
expanding dairy CAFOs (confined animal<br />
feeding operations), and working with<br />
regional <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> members and other<br />
citizens to educate and inform them<br />
about the dairy industry in this region.<br />
The rapid expansion of dairy CAFOs in Central Texas<br />
has contributed to the impairment of water quality in<br />
the Bosque and Leon River watersheds, and threatens<br />
the drinking water supplies of Lake Waco and<br />
Lake Belton.<br />
Wildcat Dairy Permit Expansion<br />
Approved<br />
On June 21 the Texas Natural Resource Conservation<br />
Commission (TNRCC) officially denied the seven<br />
motions to overturn the state permit for expansion of<br />
the Wildcat Dairy from 990 to 4000 head of dairy<br />
cattle. [See the Summer <strong>2002</strong> issue of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
<strong>Sierra</strong>n for details about the expansion of the dairy<br />
and the concerns about the impact on water quality<br />
in the Leon River watershed.] Adjacent landowners,<br />
the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>, the National<br />
Wildlife Federation, the Bell County Health<br />
District, and the cities of Temple, Belton, and Killeen<br />
filed the motions in April.<br />
The motions were filed out of concern that the<br />
dairy expansion would further degrade the already<br />
impaired Leon River and potentially threaten Lake<br />
Belton, an impoundment on the Leon River that<br />
serves as the drinking water supply for the three<br />
Justin Taylor talks with Central Texas <strong>Sierra</strong>ns about dairy waste<br />
issues at a stop to view the Frank Brand Dairy.<br />
cities noted above. Contaminated runoff from dairy<br />
CAFOs, a factor of the tremendous volumes of waste<br />
produced by hundreds or thousands of dairy cows,<br />
produces elevated levels of nutrients and pathogens<br />
and depresses oxygen levels in streams.<br />
The Commission, composed of three Commissioners<br />
appointed by the Governor, acted upon the recommendations<br />
of the TNRCC Executive Director. They<br />
issued the standard response to the concerns raised<br />
in the motions by the adjacent landowners, local<br />
governments, and environmental groups — that the<br />
dairy expansion is not a new source of pollution (and,<br />
therefore, does not require a higher level of regulation).<br />
The Commissioners let the time to respond to<br />
these motions expire, overruling them by an “operation<br />
of law.” Although the decision by the Commissioners<br />
was not surprising, their unwillingness to<br />
work with the variety of affected stakeholders in this<br />
case was more evidence of the failure of TNRCC to<br />
exercise strong regulatory oversight of the dairy<br />
industry in Central Texas.<br />
The final recourse to try and stop the expansion of<br />
the Wildcat Dairy is a lawsuit in state district court.<br />
The landowners have already filed to sue the Executive<br />
Director and the Commission for issuance of the<br />
Photo courtesy of Ken Kramer
in the suit on their behalf. As<br />
of this writing, the other entities<br />
who filed motions to overturn<br />
Executive Director’s initial decision<br />
to approve the expansion<br />
have not decided whether to join<br />
in the litigation. The case should<br />
go to court some time late this<br />
year. A victory in this case would<br />
set an important precedent affecting<br />
the fate of future permits for<br />
CAFO expansions in the Leon<br />
River watershed, which is currently<br />
seeing an explosion of<br />
requests for new and expanded<br />
dairies.<br />
Central TX <strong>Sierra</strong>ns Tour<br />
Dairy Locations<br />
On July 13 members of the<br />
Central Texas Regional Group of<br />
the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> took a tour of dairy<br />
locations in the Leon River watershed.<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Director<br />
Ken Kramer and I drove the<br />
members to an area with a high<br />
concentration of dairy CAFOs,<br />
stopping by several facilities to<br />
give the group a first-hand look at<br />
the facilities. Many of the tour<br />
group participants were surprised<br />
Photo courtesy of Ken Kramer<br />
at the size and density of these<br />
dairy facilities and their environmentally<br />
destructive potential. It<br />
was a good introduction to the<br />
actual state of the dairy industry<br />
in this area for those who had<br />
never seen it.<br />
A graphic demonstration of the<br />
pollution potential of the dairies<br />
was a dead cow in a creek bed by<br />
the side of one of the county roads<br />
the tour group traveled. The dead<br />
cow had probably been dumped<br />
upstream, and the body had<br />
washed down to its final resting<br />
place. The dead cow was sighted<br />
at practically the same spot where<br />
the bones from another dead cow<br />
that had been seen on an earlier<br />
visit were located.<br />
Central Texas <strong>Sierra</strong>ns had an<br />
opportunity during the tour to visit<br />
at the home of Carolyn and Paul<br />
Smith, some of the adjacent<br />
landowners in Comanche County<br />
who are opposing the expansion of<br />
the Wildcat Dairy. Carolyn Smith<br />
has lived in this area outside<br />
Gustine, Texas all of her life. As a<br />
girl she swam in South Leon River<br />
(which feeds into the Leon River)<br />
and her son grew up fishing in the<br />
Central Texas <strong>Sierra</strong>ns and Justin Taylor visit with Carolyn and Paul Smith,<br />
adjacent landowners apposing the expansion of the Wildcat Dairy.<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 9<br />
Your Environment<br />
same spot. Now she says that<br />
her cows will not even drink<br />
that water, much less does any<br />
human go into the water,<br />
which is the repository of runoff<br />
from the Wildcat Dairy.<br />
More Water Sentinels<br />
Campaign Activities<br />
The Water Sentinels Campaign<br />
is continuing to work<br />
with landowners, concerned<br />
citizens, and cities downstream<br />
of these dairies to keep them<br />
educated and informed of new<br />
developments and assist with<br />
opposing new permits as applications<br />
are filed with the state<br />
environmental regulatory<br />
agency (as of September 1 the<br />
TNRCC officially became the<br />
Texas Commission on Environmental<br />
Quality or TCEQ). On<br />
August 10 the project held a<br />
volunteer monitoring training<br />
program, where volunteers<br />
were trained to sample and<br />
analyze water quality from the<br />
Leon River and Lake Belton.<br />
In addition to activities in<br />
the Leon River watershed the<br />
Water Sentinels Campaign<br />
is also working with<br />
volunteers, area teachers<br />
and students, and the City<br />
of Waco in addressing<br />
concerns about dairy<br />
CAFO pollution in the<br />
Bosque River watershed.<br />
Lake Waco, an impoundment<br />
on the Bosque<br />
River, is the drinking<br />
water supply for the City<br />
of Waco, which has been<br />
an active leader in efforts<br />
to curb dairy CAFO<br />
pollution.<br />
For more information<br />
on the Water Sentinels<br />
Campaign, contact Justin<br />
Taylor at the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
State Conservation office<br />
in Austin at 512-477-1729<br />
or via email at<br />
justin.taylor@sierraclub.org.
10 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Your Environment<br />
On the Air Front<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Working to Reduce<br />
Air Pollution<br />
Many parts of Texas continue to<br />
be plagued by air pollution problems,<br />
and the U.S. Environmental<br />
Protection Agency (EPA) has<br />
recently questioned the efficacy of<br />
state air quality clean-up plans for<br />
two major metropolitan areas, in<br />
part due to lack of a viable source<br />
of funds for making air quality<br />
improvements. The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>, however,<br />
continues to make the<br />
reduction of air pollution in Texas<br />
a high priority, and the past few<br />
months have seen a flurry of<br />
activity related to that goal.<br />
Clean Air Director Neil Carman<br />
and several volunteer leaders,<br />
including <strong>Chapter</strong> Air Quality<br />
Chair George Smith of Houston,<br />
are conducting those efforts. To<br />
assure the most and efficient use<br />
of resources the <strong>Chapter</strong> is working<br />
closely with <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
regional groups in affected areas<br />
as well as with community activists<br />
and other environmental<br />
organizations. Environmental<br />
partners in this work include<br />
Environmental Defense, the<br />
Galveston-Houston Association for<br />
Smog Prevention (GHASP), Public<br />
Citizen, and Sustainable Energy &<br />
Economic Development (SEED)<br />
Coalition, and Texas Campaign for<br />
the Environment.<br />
Houston-Galveston<br />
Clean Air Plan<br />
This summer the Texas Natural<br />
Resource Conservation Commission<br />
(TNRCC) has been considering<br />
significant changes to the air<br />
quality clean-up plan (known<br />
officially by the acronym SIP, or<br />
“State Implementation Plan”) for<br />
the Houston-Galveston region.<br />
The <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> and the groups<br />
noted above, plus others, have<br />
concerns about those some of<br />
those changes – especially a<br />
proposed relaxation of pollution<br />
controls for the area’s largest<br />
industrial pollution sources –<br />
while supporting other changes.<br />
These groups issued a “<strong>2002</strong><br />
Citizens’ Clean Air Agenda” urging<br />
the TNRCC to strengthen rather<br />
than weaken the Houston-<br />
Galveston clean air plan in order<br />
to meet federal health standards<br />
for air quality by the 2007 deadline<br />
imposed by the federal Clean Air<br />
Act. The recommendations of the<br />
Citizens’ Clean Air Agenda<br />
include:<br />
(1) support for the state’s proposal<br />
to set strong pollution<br />
control limits on highly<br />
reactive volatile organic<br />
compounds (VOCs);<br />
(2) opposition to any rollback of<br />
controls on industrial point<br />
sources of nitrogen oxide<br />
(NOx), a rollback which was<br />
proposed by TNRCC under<br />
pressure from industry;<br />
(3) support for replacing the 55-<br />
mph speed limit with more<br />
effective, less inconvenient<br />
measures; and<br />
(4) a call for TNRCC to adopt<br />
specific reduction commitments<br />
for NOx emissions<br />
rather than just a description<br />
of how reductions might<br />
be calculated.<br />
In August Clean Air Director<br />
Carman submitted comments on<br />
behalf of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> on<br />
proposed TNRCC changes to its<br />
rules governing VOC emission<br />
controls in the Houston-Galveston<br />
clean air plan. The comments<br />
emphasized the need to improve<br />
the proposed revisions of the VOC<br />
control rules because there currently<br />
is no complete inventory of<br />
industrial emissions in the Houston<br />
area to be able to gauge the<br />
total air pollution problem and<br />
there has been no demonstration<br />
that the clean air plan will actually<br />
meet federal human health<br />
standards for air quality.<br />
Working with Citizens<br />
in Other Areas<br />
In addition to major efforts on<br />
the Houston-Galveston air quality<br />
problems the <strong>Chapter</strong> this year<br />
has continued to work with affected<br />
communities and neighborhoods<br />
in other areas of the state<br />
that are impacted by smog and/or<br />
toxic air pollution. Major emphasis<br />
has been on helping citizens<br />
in areas affected by air pollutant<br />
emissions from refineries and<br />
chemical plants, especially in the<br />
Beaumont-Port Arthur area but in<br />
many other parts of the state as<br />
well.<br />
For more information about the<br />
air quality work of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> contact Clean Air Director<br />
Neil Carman in Austin at 512-<br />
472-2267<br />
(neil_carman@greenbuilder.com)<br />
or Air Quality Chair George Smith<br />
in Houston at 713-862-1669<br />
(geoterrysmith@att.net).
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 11<br />
Your Environment<br />
Conservation of Texas Land and Water<br />
Resources Highlighted at <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Conference<br />
Conference Marks First Anniversary of Wide Open Spaces Campaign<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> celebrated the first anniversary of the Wide Open<br />
Spaces Campaign with a well-attended sixth annual <strong>Chapter</strong> Conservation Conference at the<br />
Armand Bayou Nature Center in Houston on July 20. This year’s conference, which drew in<br />
excess of 100 people, focused on the need to increase parkland and to protect open space and<br />
wildlife habitat in a variety of ways statewide and in East Texas.<br />
Keynote Presentation –<br />
Texas at the Crossroads<br />
The keynote speaker, Texas<br />
Tech University President Dr.<br />
David Schmidly, shared historical<br />
and current information over the<br />
past century using a time-lapse<br />
style presentation to<br />
document the changes<br />
in Texas population,<br />
landscape and wildlife<br />
diversity. Dr. Schmidly’s<br />
presentation, Texas at<br />
the Crossroads: A Historical<br />
Perspective on the<br />
Biological Diversity of<br />
Texas, emphasized the<br />
present critical stage of<br />
the State’s environmental<br />
movement. Dr.<br />
Schmidly compared<br />
primary data from a<br />
biological survey conducted<br />
a century ago by<br />
Vernon Bailey with<br />
current data from The<br />
Texas Parks and Wildlife<br />
for the 21 st Century report<br />
prepared by Texas Tech for Texas<br />
Parks and Wildlife Department<br />
(TPWD) in 2001.<br />
Based on this comparison Dr.<br />
Schmidly identified the most<br />
important threats facing biological<br />
diversity in Texas. The threats<br />
include (1) urban sprawl (the<br />
migration to and expansion of<br />
urban areas), (2) lack of ethnic<br />
diversity in the environmental<br />
movement, (3) land fragmentation,<br />
(4) non-native plants and animals,<br />
(5) loss of valuable terrains (i.e.,<br />
wetlands, hardwood bottom forests,<br />
prairies) and (6) an increase in<br />
numbers of rare, endangered, and<br />
extinct animals in Texas.<br />
Dr. Schmidly provided some<br />
guidance on how to address these<br />
Brian Sybert, Natural Resources Director for the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> and director of this year’s conservation conference,talks<br />
about the Wide Open Spaces Campaign.<br />
threats through what he termed<br />
“The Ten Commandments of<br />
Conservation.” These include<br />
finding a common ground, developing<br />
an adequate information base,<br />
recognizing the changing nature<br />
of the clientele, avoiding single<br />
species approaches to conservation,<br />
and focusing on sustainable<br />
resources and ecosytem management.<br />
The other “commandments”<br />
include strengthening<br />
scientific research, making<br />
conservation education a priority<br />
for the public, increasing participation<br />
of private landowners,<br />
expanding protected area acquisition<br />
and management, and promoting<br />
regionally-based conservation<br />
planning.<br />
State Land and<br />
Water Plan<br />
Dr. Schmidly’s presentation<br />
was followed by an<br />
overview of the Texas<br />
Parks & Wildlife<br />
Department’s statewide<br />
Land and Water Conservation<br />
and Recreation Plan<br />
by Jeff Francell and Emily<br />
Armitano. Francell is the<br />
Land Acquisition Director<br />
for TPWD and Armitano is<br />
a Policy Analyst for TPWD.<br />
Francell discussed how<br />
this plan was different<br />
from the Texas Tech study<br />
presented by Dr. Schmidly<br />
and the recommendations of the<br />
Governor Bush’s Task Force on<br />
Conservation. According to<br />
Francell this plan is different<br />
because it is actually being created<br />
by TPWD staff and will be<br />
adopted by the Texas Parks and<br />
Wildlife Commission, the governing<br />
body for TPWD.<br />
The plan was mandated by the<br />
Continued next page
12 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Your Environment<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
Legislature in 2001 with passage<br />
of SB 305, the bill continuing<br />
TPWD in existence after the<br />
sunset review process for the<br />
agency. The plan includes an<br />
inventory of all public and nonprofit<br />
lands that provide public<br />
access and an analysis of existing<br />
and future land and water conservation<br />
needs. The plan also includes<br />
recommendations on how<br />
TPWD will address the states land<br />
and water and recreation needs<br />
over the next ten years.<br />
[Editor’s Note: See related article<br />
in this issue of the <strong>Sierra</strong>n for<br />
an analysis of the plan.]<br />
Insights from a State<br />
Representative<br />
Rounding out the morning State<br />
Representative Edmund Kuempel<br />
gave an enthusiastic speech about<br />
the importance of citizens communicating<br />
their interest in<br />
parks and land conservation to<br />
their state legislators. Rep.<br />
Kuempel said that citizens must<br />
become involved in the process by<br />
which state government makes<br />
decisions if they want more<br />
parkland and protected wildlife<br />
habitat. Such involvement is<br />
especially important in light of an<br />
anticipated shortfall in the state<br />
budget next year.<br />
Purchase of<br />
Development Rights<br />
Julie Shackelford, Field Director<br />
for the American Farmland<br />
Trust, opened the afternoon with a<br />
presentation on how to reduce the<br />
loss of open space by preserving<br />
working landscapes. Shackelford<br />
noted that Texas leads the nation<br />
in land conversion from rural to<br />
urban.<br />
Purchase of Development Rights<br />
(PDR) is a tool that can be used to<br />
protect open space. A small farmer<br />
can sell his development rights<br />
(the appraised difference between<br />
farming value of the land and the<br />
developed value of the land) to the<br />
state, a local government, or a<br />
land trust. Funding options for a<br />
state PDR program include bonds,<br />
appropriations, lottery, cigarette<br />
tax and matching donations.<br />
Twenty-one states have these PDR<br />
programs in place, most often<br />
where local communities have<br />
taken the initiative, with Pennsylvania<br />
and Maryland leading as the<br />
oldest programs.<br />
Managing Urban Growth<br />
Comal County Commissioner<br />
Jay Millikin talked to conference<br />
attendees about the need to<br />
manage urban growth as a strategy<br />
for protecting open space.<br />
Commissioner Millikin discussed<br />
the differences between authorities<br />
that cities and counties have<br />
for managing such growth. According<br />
to Commissioner Millikin,<br />
counties in Texas need more<br />
ordinance making authority so<br />
that they may appropriately manage<br />
urban development.<br />
Special Places<br />
The conference concluded with<br />
presentations on two of the “special<br />
places” in Texas that the<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> and other groups are<br />
trying to preserve for the future:<br />
the Trinity River National Wildlife<br />
Refuge (NWR) and the Katy Prairie.<br />
Stuart Marcus, Refuge Manager<br />
for the Trinity River NWR, discussed<br />
conserving bottomland<br />
hardwood forest along the lower<br />
Trinity River. The Trinity River<br />
NWR was approved for 77,300<br />
acres. Thus far 4,4000 acres have<br />
been purchased. Once completed<br />
the refuge will protect high quality<br />
bottomland hardwood forest. The<br />
area contains broad and narrow<br />
leaf deciduous bottomland hardwood<br />
forest, which is wetland type<br />
that has experienced dramatic<br />
and damaging declines in the past<br />
decade. By 1980, 63% of all bottomland<br />
riparian forests in the entire<br />
Two of the leading<br />
conservation<br />
experts in Texas,<br />
Dr. David<br />
Schmidly of Texas<br />
Tech University<br />
and Dr. Pete<br />
Gunther of the<br />
University of<br />
North Texas,<br />
discuss land<br />
preservation<br />
issues during a<br />
break at the<br />
conference.<br />
state of Texas had been destroyed.<br />
Mary Anne Piacentini, Executive<br />
Director of the Katy Prairie<br />
Conservancy, gave an overview of<br />
the Katy Prairie. According to<br />
Piacentini, the Katy Prairie<br />
provides winter habitat for one of<br />
the densest concentrations of<br />
migratory waterfowl in North<br />
America and habitat for a large<br />
variety of other birds as well as for<br />
60 species of mammals (such as<br />
deer and coyotes), and 55 species<br />
of reptiles and amphibians. The<br />
Katy Prairie is continually threatened<br />
by urban development expanding<br />
westward from Houston,<br />
which destroys and degrades the<br />
ecological viability of the prairie’s<br />
wildlife habitat. Urban expansion<br />
and the resulting loss of open<br />
space significantly decreases<br />
floodwater protection and water<br />
quality. Increased incidence of<br />
flooding on the west side of Houston<br />
is the result of conversion of<br />
open space to commercial and<br />
residential development.<br />
Continued on page 14
Texas Parks & Wildlife Releases<br />
Land & Water Conservation Plan<br />
By Brian Sybert, Natural Resources Director, <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Note: In order to be included in this issue of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n this article had to be<br />
written before the Land & Water Conservation Plan was adopted by the Texas Parks &<br />
Wildlife Commission on August 29. As a result the final recommendations of the plan<br />
were not known when this article was written.<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 13<br />
Your Environment<br />
In June the Texas Parks and<br />
Wildlife Department (TPWD) released<br />
the draft statewide Land & Water<br />
Conservation Plan. The release of<br />
the draft initiated a formal public<br />
comment period on the statewide<br />
conservation plan. Thanks to the<br />
hundreds of citizens who commented<br />
and attended public hearings it is<br />
likely that the final plan adopted by<br />
the Texas Parks and Wildlife Commission,<br />
the governing board for<br />
TPWD, will be stronger that the draft.<br />
Overall the draft plan included<br />
several important recommendations<br />
for how TPWD would address Texas’<br />
rapidly growing conservation and<br />
recreation needs. However, the draft<br />
plan was seriously deficient in<br />
several areas.<br />
State Parkland<br />
In regard to state parkland the<br />
draft plan recommended that TPWD<br />
acquire four to six 5,000-acre or<br />
more state parks or combination<br />
state parks and wildlife management<br />
areas near major urban centers<br />
over the next ten years. While<br />
this recommendation is a good<br />
starting point it is not adequate for<br />
meeting our state’s growing need for<br />
parkland and habitat conservation.<br />
In comments submitted to TPWD<br />
the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
<strong>Club</strong> recommended that TPWD adopt<br />
the goal of providing 55 acres of<br />
parkland per 1000 people. At an<br />
absolute minimum, the <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
suggested that TPWD adopt the goal<br />
of acquiring 15 new state parks near<br />
the major urban centers of the state.<br />
These goals are based upon population<br />
growth and would allow TPWD to<br />
take action during the next 10 years<br />
to meet the state’s growing conservation<br />
and recreation needs while also<br />
avoiding placing the state in a<br />
position of facing unrealistically<br />
daunting challenges at the end of the<br />
10-year period.<br />
Local Parkland<br />
In regard to local parkland the<br />
draft plan recommended that TPWD<br />
continue to support local parkland<br />
needs through competitive grants to<br />
local governments. While this is an<br />
important goal it alone is not sufficient<br />
for meeting the growing need<br />
for more local parks.<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong>’s comments<br />
recommended TPWD should<br />
adopt the goal of working with local<br />
governments to provide 25 acres of<br />
local parkland per 1000 people<br />
through federal and state matchingfunds.<br />
This goal is also based on<br />
population growth and will allow<br />
TPWD and local governments to<br />
better meet local parkland needs.<br />
Wildlife Habitat<br />
To address conservation of wildlife<br />
habitat the draft plan recommended<br />
that TPWD increase private lands<br />
under wildlife management plans to<br />
14 million acres over the next ten<br />
years. While wildlife management<br />
plans are an important tool for<br />
protecting habitat on private lands<br />
they do not permanently protect<br />
lands from development and fragmentation.<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong>’s comments<br />
recommended that to effec-<br />
Continued next page<br />
Photo Courtesy of Texas Department of Transportation
14 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Your Environment<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
tively conserve habitat on private lands TPWD should<br />
advocate for a funded statewide private lands conservation<br />
program. One example of such a program is a<br />
Purchase of Development Rights (PDR) program. A<br />
PDR program, being actively promoted in Texas now by<br />
the American Farmland Trust, would buy development<br />
rights from willing landowners and compensate them<br />
for conserving wildlife, water, and open landscapes<br />
rather than selling family lands for development and<br />
further fragmentation.<br />
Water Resources<br />
In regard to water the draft plan recommended that<br />
TPWD continue to study the freshwater needs of river<br />
basins and bays and estuaries and that TPWD remain<br />
actively engaged in the regional water planning<br />
process. Though these studies are critical the draft<br />
plan falls short in recommending how TPWD would<br />
actually protect freshwater needs for fish, wildlife, and<br />
recreation. The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> commented that<br />
TPWD should set specific goals for acquiring water<br />
rights and support limits on new water diversions so<br />
that Texas streams and rivers maintain enough flow<br />
to help protect water quality and to support recreational<br />
activities and fish and wildlife.<br />
Financing Conservation<br />
One of the most critical issues – how TPWD will<br />
finance the final recommendations of the plan – was<br />
left out of the draft plan entirely. Funding options<br />
such as lifting the cap on revenue generated from the<br />
sales tax on sporting goods and authorizing the issuance<br />
of bonds for parkland and wildlife habitat acquisition<br />
should have been recommended in the plan.<br />
(Currently a portion of the revenue from the sporting<br />
goods sales tax is dedicated to spending for state and<br />
local parks, but that amount is capped at $32 million<br />
per year, far below the estimated total state revenue<br />
from that source.) The inclusion of options for funding<br />
acquisition of parkland and protected wildlife habitat<br />
would help to guide future debate and action on how to<br />
finance a state park and land conservation system.<br />
The Final Plan<br />
The Texas Parks and Wildlife Commission was<br />
scheduled to adopt the final plan on August 29. As of<br />
August 1, TPWD had already received hundreds of<br />
comments on the draft plan, most of them advocating<br />
the type of strengthening of the plan envisioned by<br />
the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>. It is hoped that this large volume of<br />
constructive criticism results in a plan that truly<br />
meets the needs of Texas and Texans in the 21 st<br />
century. An update on the outcome of the plan will be<br />
included in the Winter Issue of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n<br />
and will be available earlier on the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
website at www.texas.sierraclub.org.<br />
Conservation in Texas...<br />
Continued from Page 12<br />
Looking Ahead<br />
As a follow-up to this successful conference<br />
and the anticipated adoption of the TPWD Land<br />
and Water Plan, the next milestone in the <strong>Lone</strong><br />
<strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong>’s Wide Open Spaces Campaign is<br />
the publication this fall of a “special places”<br />
report that will provide a selective look at areas<br />
in Texas that need to be preserved for current<br />
and future generations. Check the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> website (www.texas.sierraclub.org) in<br />
October for the latest information on the special<br />
places of Texas.<br />
Public Meetings to be Held on<br />
Designation of Groundwater<br />
Management Areas<br />
The Texas Water Development Board (TWDB),<br />
the state water planning agency, was directed in<br />
SB 2, enacted by the Texas Legislature in 2001, to<br />
designate groundwater management areas covering<br />
all major and minor aquifers of the state. The<br />
initial designation is to be completed by September<br />
1, 2003. According to the statute: “Each groundwater<br />
management area shall be designated with the<br />
objective of providing the most suitable area for the<br />
management of the groundwater resources.”<br />
Following a stakeholder meeting in May the<br />
agency has developed a map of Texas with proposed<br />
groundwater management area boundaries and is<br />
seeking public input on the proposed designations.<br />
The map may be accessed through the TWDB web<br />
site at www.twdb.state.tx.us. The agency has<br />
scheduled eight public meetings around the state<br />
and one public meeting in Austin to take public<br />
input on the proposed designations. Complete<br />
information on the public meetings may be found<br />
on the agency web site. The dates and cities<br />
where meetings will be held is as follows (all are<br />
scheduled from 6 p.m. to 8:30 p.m.):<br />
September 5<br />
Plainview<br />
September 9<br />
San Angelo<br />
September 10<br />
Alpine<br />
September 12<br />
Fredericksburg<br />
September 18<br />
Corpus Christi<br />
September 19<br />
Wharton<br />
September 25<br />
Tyler<br />
September 26<br />
Stephenville<br />
The official public hearing on the proposal will be<br />
held on September 30 (1 to 5 p.m.) in Austin in<br />
Room 118 of the Stephen F. Austin Bldg., 1700 N.<br />
Congress Avenue.
New Economic Study<br />
Places Value of Recreation<br />
and Restoration on<br />
Texas’ National Forests<br />
Above Commercial Logging<br />
Report Shows Taxpayer Loss<br />
from Federal Logging Program<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 15<br />
Your Environment<br />
A new report released in August<br />
by the Ecology and Law Institute<br />
(ELI) and the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> finds<br />
that the logging program on Texas’<br />
national forests lost tens of millions<br />
of dollars between 1987-<br />
1999, and may in fact have created<br />
no new jobs during that time<br />
period. The National Forests in<br />
Texas: An Economic Case for Restoring<br />
Our Natural Treasures, which is<br />
based on a recent study by ELI,<br />
looks at the damage, both economic<br />
and environmental, from<br />
the commercial logging program<br />
on Texas’ four national forests and<br />
debunks the longstanding belief<br />
that East Texas economies depend<br />
on commercial logging on national<br />
forests.<br />
Some of the best hiking, hunting,<br />
camping and fishing in Texas<br />
occurs within our national forests.<br />
Houston’s clean water found in<br />
Lake Conroe, Lake Houston and<br />
Lake Livingston comes from these<br />
forests. Yet when logging roads are<br />
built and our national forests are<br />
spoiled, rain washes topsoil into<br />
our waterways.<br />
Revaluating Forest<br />
Economics<br />
For years, the U.S. Forest<br />
Service, using an accounting<br />
system recently criticized by the<br />
General Accounting Office (the<br />
investigative arm of Congress) and<br />
scrapped, claims that commercial<br />
logging on Texas’ national forests<br />
was good for the local economy.<br />
The new analysis completed by<br />
independent economists finds that<br />
the Forest Service in Texas keeps<br />
many significant costs, like<br />
prescribed burning and road<br />
removal, off its books. The Forest<br />
Service’s inaccurate accounting<br />
has inflated the value of building<br />
roads and selling timber from our<br />
national forests, and has undervalued<br />
the contribution recreation<br />
and clean water make to local<br />
communities, if those values are<br />
considered at all.<br />
“When logging roads are abandoned<br />
on the Sam Houston National<br />
Forest after an area is<br />
logged they become an erosion<br />
problem,,” said Ron Warner of<br />
Texas Black Bass Unlimited and<br />
owner of April Plaza Marina on<br />
Lake Conroe. “National forest land<br />
should be preserved, but when<br />
torrential rains wash soil from the<br />
neglected roads into the lake, the<br />
lake becomes contaminated with<br />
pesticides and oil, gas, and grease<br />
left behind from logging operations.<br />
My income is definitely<br />
affected when water quality drops<br />
and people don’t want to come<br />
here to fish, swim or ski.”<br />
Re-examining<br />
Subsidized Logging<br />
The report illustrates how,<br />
between 1988-2000, timber production<br />
in the state remained<br />
virtually constant while logging<br />
levels on national forests plummeted<br />
during that period. The vast<br />
majority of timber production in<br />
the region shifted to private lands.<br />
“The only reason logging exists on<br />
Texas’ national forests is because<br />
taxpayers subsidize it,” said<br />
Brandt Mannchen, Forestry Chair<br />
for the Houston <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>.<br />
“Private woodlot owners can meet<br />
our timber production needs and<br />
shouldn’t have to compete with<br />
low-cost lumber propped up by<br />
federal subsidies.”<br />
The report is designed to help<br />
policy makers, community leaders,<br />
land managers, and the public<br />
identify what money is being<br />
wasted logging Texas’ national<br />
forests and to understand the<br />
fiscal responsibility in conserving<br />
recreation opportunities and clean<br />
water for future generations of<br />
Texans to enjoy. Protecting what<br />
intact forests remain on Texas’<br />
national forests and shifting the<br />
Forest Service’s emphasis from<br />
timber production to restoration<br />
and recreation will leave our<br />
children a natural legacy of which<br />
we can be proud.<br />
For More Information<br />
To view the full report, go to:<br />
http://<br />
www.forestconservation.org/<br />
PublicationsandReports/pubs.htm.<br />
For more information, contact<br />
John Talberth of Ecology and Law<br />
Institute, 505-986-1163, or the<br />
Texas-Arkansas Field Office,<br />
512-472-9094.
16 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
Environmental Education<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> Cubs Camp Expands<br />
Throughout Texas<br />
For the first-time in Texas,<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> Cubs Nature Camps, part<br />
of the environmental education<br />
program of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>, were<br />
offered this summer in both<br />
Central and East Texas. The<br />
camp in Austin finished its<br />
sixth successful year and drew<br />
in campers from as far away as<br />
San Antonio. In Nacogdoches,<br />
the camp was an overwhelming<br />
success due to the communitywide<br />
involvement and effort<br />
from local <strong>Sierra</strong>ns, businesses,<br />
government agencies, and the<br />
local university. [See “thank<br />
you column” for details.]<br />
Both camps followed a similar<br />
pattern of guiding youth ages 6<br />
to 10 years old through instruction,<br />
EcoArt, and Earth Game<br />
activities in outdoor safety,<br />
native plants, wildlife, and<br />
geology. Sign language symbols<br />
and Spanish terms were also<br />
woven into camp curriculum.<br />
Their settings, however, were<br />
strikingly different. Austin’s<br />
campers cooled off under the<br />
shady arms of 500+ old live oak<br />
trees, and hiked alongside<br />
creekbeds in search of fossils.<br />
Meanwhile, Nacogdoches’<br />
campers, discovered a protected,<br />
fragile ecosystem resplendent<br />
with wetlands, springs, waterfalls,<br />
and endangered plants<br />
right in their town’s backyard.<br />
Each camp offered youth a<br />
unique opportunity to explore<br />
and connect with some of the<br />
special places in Texas, building<br />
their sensitivity to their natural<br />
environment for its future<br />
protection and preservation.<br />
For those interested in<br />
starting a <strong>Sierra</strong> Cubs Camp in<br />
their area of the state please<br />
contact Jackie McFadden, 512-<br />
990-9396, eeant@austin.rr.com.<br />
Austin<br />
Austin Regional Group<br />
of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
Annel Bautista<br />
Ann Bennett<br />
Melissa Burton<br />
Debra Cerda<br />
Debbie Deppe<br />
Pam Gonzalez<br />
Ken Kramer<br />
Lucy Nazro<br />
Jackie McFadden<br />
Tim McGee<br />
Bill Oliver<br />
Jim Perry<br />
REI<br />
St. Andrews Episcopal<br />
School<br />
Sally Scott<br />
Marvin Shelton<br />
Sophia Sherline<br />
Hunt Sparra<br />
Winnie Spitz<br />
Amy Sugeno<br />
Texas Mater<br />
Naturalists,<br />
Capital Area<br />
<strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Texas Parks &<br />
Wildlife Department<br />
Jennifer Walker<br />
Whole Foods<br />
Piney Woods<br />
Dian Avriett<br />
Dylan Baggett<br />
James Baggett<br />
Tim Baggett<br />
Vicki Baggett<br />
Dr. Selena Bradley<br />
Merry Anne Bright<br />
Janine Carpenter<br />
Jacque Cleverdon<br />
Dr. David Creech<br />
Richard Donovan<br />
Thank You<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
extends a huge tree<br />
hug to the following<br />
incredibly giving<br />
individuals,<br />
businesses, and<br />
groups who made the<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> Cubs Camps<br />
<strong>2002</strong> a total success.<br />
Kathy Greer<br />
Emily Goodwin<br />
Ruth Heino<br />
Steve Kahn<br />
Forest Lemon<br />
Jim Lemon<br />
Kerry Lemon<br />
Maya Lemon<br />
Mary Love<br />
Lunch Box (Lufkin)<br />
Chuck Norman<br />
Mark Norman<br />
Pineywoods Regional<br />
Group of the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
<strong>Club</strong><br />
Elyce Rodewald<br />
Susan Schinke<br />
Larry Shelton<br />
Stephen F. Austin State<br />
University<br />
David Tracey<br />
Toni Trees<br />
Adrian Van Dellen
EE BRIEFS<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 17<br />
Environmental Education<br />
Statewide EE Conference to be held in<br />
San Antonio<br />
The Texas Environmental Education Partnership,<br />
TEEP, will hold its second statewide environmental education<br />
conference in San Antonio, TX September 12-14,<br />
<strong>2002</strong>. Adults interested<br />
in being updated on EE<br />
happenings across the<br />
state in the past five<br />
years, needing professional<br />
training, or simply<br />
wanting to meet folks in<br />
the environmental<br />
education field, are<br />
invited to attend. To<br />
receive detailed conference<br />
information, see<br />
website http://<br />
ww.eih.uh.edu<br />
Registration Time for<br />
EE After School Sessions<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> offers the Nature<br />
Scientists after<br />
school environmental<br />
education program<br />
throughout<br />
Texas, and, is now<br />
registering school<br />
and home schooling<br />
sites for Winter and<br />
Spring 2003. These<br />
multi-week classes<br />
can be taught in<br />
English or adapted<br />
to a bilingual English/Spanish<br />
audience. Students<br />
can expect these<br />
60-minute sessions<br />
to be filled with fun,<br />
interactive, hands-on activities,<br />
while teachers and parents<br />
will be pleased to know<br />
their youth are building a<br />
strong, basic science foundation<br />
in the areas of: botany,<br />
geology, biology, and ecology.<br />
Upon completion of the program,<br />
students are awarded the<br />
Junior Nature Scientist certificate.<br />
For more information, or<br />
to set-up your school as a site,<br />
contact Jackie McFadden, 512-<br />
990-9396,<br />
eeant@austin.rr.com.<br />
New <strong>Sierra</strong> Cubs<br />
Camps 2003<br />
During 2003, the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
Cubs Camps will be offered in<br />
Central, East, and North Texas<br />
for youth ages six to nine.<br />
Additionally, in the Austinarea,<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> will hold a<br />
brand new camp for youth<br />
ages 10 to 13, especially<br />
created for those young<br />
scientists wanting to explore,<br />
and investigate connections<br />
in nature. See future issues<br />
of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n for<br />
more details.
18 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
State of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
Intern Justin Murrill Lends His Enthusiasm<br />
to the Work of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
St. Edward’s University Student Spends His Summer<br />
Working for the Environment<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of<br />
the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> was fortunate<br />
this summer to have<br />
the able assistance of<br />
Justin Murrill as an undergraduate<br />
student intern.<br />
Justin is a senior in the<br />
Honors Program at St.<br />
Edward’s University in<br />
Austin. He will graduate in<br />
December of this year with<br />
a Bachelors Degree in<br />
Business Administration.<br />
As Justin put it in a letter<br />
to <strong>Chapter</strong> Director Ken<br />
Kramer this past March<br />
inquiring about an internship,<br />
“while my degree will<br />
be in business, my passion<br />
has always been with the<br />
environment.”<br />
Infusing Passion<br />
into the <strong>Chapter</strong>’s<br />
Water Project<br />
Indeed Justin’s passion<br />
was quite evident all summer<br />
as he tackled one task<br />
after another while assisting<br />
the <strong>Chapter</strong> in its work<br />
for the Texas Living Waters<br />
Project, a joint undertaking of<br />
the <strong>Chapter</strong> with three other<br />
state-level environmental organizations<br />
to educate and mobilize<br />
Texans on water resources<br />
issues. Justin lent invaluable<br />
assistance to the effort to rally<br />
citizens in North Central Texas<br />
and Northeast Texas in July to<br />
demonstrate their opposition to<br />
the building of the proposed<br />
Marvin Nichols Reservoir [see<br />
related story elsewhere in this<br />
issue].<br />
Justin also proved to be an<br />
awesome researcher, pulling<br />
together much of the information<br />
that will be used in a water publication<br />
for the general public that<br />
will be a work product of the Living<br />
Waters Project. In fact Justin has<br />
become so dedicated to the water<br />
effort that he will be spending<br />
some volunteer time with the<br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> in the fall to put the<br />
finishing touches to that<br />
document.<br />
Looking to the Future<br />
After he graduates in December,<br />
Justin plans to spend several<br />
months traveling around<br />
the world in the spring<br />
before returning to the<br />
United States to begin work<br />
on a graduate degree in<br />
environmental management.<br />
Over the long-term<br />
Justin is interested in<br />
working to bridge the gap<br />
that sometimes exists<br />
between the business world<br />
and environmental protection<br />
efforts. If anyone will<br />
succeed in doing so, Justin<br />
will be the one. The staff<br />
and volunteer leaders of the<br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> express their<br />
sincere thanks to Justin<br />
for a job well done and wish<br />
him the best for the future.<br />
Internship<br />
Opportunities with<br />
the <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Graduate or undergraduate<br />
students interested in<br />
interning with the <strong>Lone</strong><br />
<strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
<strong>Club</strong> should contact the<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> State Conservation<br />
Office in Austin to discuss<br />
possible internships during the<br />
regular or summer semesters.<br />
The <strong>Chapter</strong> always has openings<br />
for students who want to make a<br />
contribution to the work of the<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> while developing the<br />
skills and the knowledge to become<br />
environmentally-responsible<br />
citizens in their years after<br />
college. Interning with the <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
<strong>Club</strong> is a great opportunity, and<br />
the <strong>Chapter</strong> appreciates the many<br />
contributions made by interns<br />
over the years.
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 19<br />
State of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Presents Awards<br />
for 2001 at Dinner in Houston<br />
Sen. David Bernsen Gives Special Address<br />
Each year the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> presents awards to<br />
hardworking <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> volunteers and others for their<br />
contributions of time, effort, and resources to the <strong>Club</strong> and<br />
the environment. This year the Awards Dinner was held<br />
in conjunction with the <strong>Chapter</strong> Conservation Conference<br />
in Houston. Senator David Bernsen gave a special address<br />
on the importance of protecting our coastal resources,<br />
water, and environment.<br />
Award Winners<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> is grateful to the following<br />
individuals and groups for their efforts to enhance<br />
enjoyment of the outdoors, to educate the public on<br />
environmental issues, and/or to protect public<br />
health and the environment. Eight awards were<br />
given this year recognizing the work of these individual<br />
and groups during 2001 and in prior years.<br />
The Orrin Bonney Award, the <strong>Chapter</strong>’s highest<br />
award, was given to Jackie McFaddin for her years<br />
of service to the chapter and community as Environmental<br />
Education Chair. Jackie has created the<br />
chapter’s successful environmental education<br />
program, which includes after-school naturalist<br />
programs, summer nature camps, and other<br />
activities.<br />
The Evelyn R. Edens Award for river protection<br />
was given to the San Marcos River Foundation<br />
(SMRF) for its efforts protect water quality and environmental<br />
flows in the San Marcos River and the<br />
Guadalupe River basin. SMRF has taken the bold<br />
step of applying to the Texas Natural Resource<br />
Conservation Commission (TNRCC) for a water rights<br />
permit to maintain instream flows in the Guadalupe<br />
River basin.<br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> Director Ken Kramer congratulates Jackie McFadden,<br />
winner of the Orrin Bonney Award.<br />
Sen. David Bernsen speaks to the <strong>Chapter</strong> Awards Dinner.<br />
The Hermann Rudenberg Award for coastal protection<br />
was given to Mary Lou Campbell from the Lower<br />
Rio Grande Valley Group for her tireless work to<br />
protect coastal resources. She is known for her<br />
efforts on a variety of issues over the years, including<br />
protection of Padre Island and Lower Laguna<br />
Madre.<br />
The Virginia Murray Brewer Award was given to<br />
Claudia Blalock for her contributions to the outings<br />
program of the Greater Fort Worth Regional Group.<br />
She has been active in leading and promoting group<br />
outings that have drawn many members into the<br />
Fort Worth Group.<br />
The <strong>Chapter</strong> Conservation Award was given to<br />
Dian Avriett for her success in revitalizing and<br />
effectively leading the Pineywoods Regional Group.<br />
She has made the group a force for conservation<br />
action in East Texas.<br />
The <strong>Chapter</strong> Service Award was given to Marsha<br />
Meredith for her long history of service to the Alamo<br />
Regional Group. She has served the group in a<br />
variety of positions that have contributed to the<br />
strength and effectiveness of the San<br />
Antonio area group.<br />
The Special Service Award was given to<br />
Carole Baker for her persistent and successful<br />
advocacy for water conservation.<br />
She was the person most responsible for the<br />
passage in the last state legislative session<br />
of new laws promoting efficient use of water<br />
resources.<br />
The Environmental Reporting Award<br />
was given to Richard Smith of the Waco<br />
Tribune-Herald for his excellent coverage of<br />
water quality issues in the Bosque River<br />
watershed (impacted by industrial dairy<br />
operations), the sunset review of TNRCC,<br />
and other environmental issues.
20 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
State of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
Support Projects in Texas Funded by The <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> Foundation<br />
Participate in the Earth Share of Texas<br />
Workplace Giving Program<br />
Many <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>ns have the opportunity to<br />
support the work of the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> through payroll deduction<br />
plans at work. The <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> Foundation,<br />
a charitable organization,<br />
provides funds for a number of environmental<br />
projects conducted in<br />
Texas by the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong>.<br />
Earth Share of Texas, an umbrella<br />
group for Texas’ leading environmental<br />
and conservation groups, represents<br />
The <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> foundation in<br />
workplace giving programs in this<br />
state.<br />
Most workplace giving campaigns<br />
are conducted from September<br />
through early November, so now is<br />
the time to look for Earth Share of<br />
Texas pledge cards in your workplace.<br />
Look for Earth Share of Texas in workplace giving<br />
campaign literature and on pledge cards at all state<br />
agencies; all state colleges and universities; federal<br />
agencies in most parts of Texas; Houston<br />
and Austin school districts; Austin,<br />
Dallas, El Paso and Houston municipal<br />
offices; and many private employers,<br />
including American Airlines, Compaq<br />
Computer Corporation, Dell Computer<br />
Corporation, Green Mountain Energy<br />
and Vignette.<br />
If your employer doesn’t offer the<br />
chance to support The <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
Foundation and the other Earth Share<br />
of Texas environmental groups, visit<br />
Earth Share of Texas on the web at<br />
www.earthshare-texas.org, call 1-800-<br />
GREENTX, or e-mail estx@earthsharetexas.org.<br />
You may also contact Sally<br />
Drews, <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Development Director at<br />
(512) 477-1729 or sally.drews@sierraclub.org.<br />
Get a Commanding View of Austin…<br />
and a Commanding Understanding<br />
of the Texas Legislature and<br />
Upcoming Environmental Legislation!<br />
Mark Your Calendars to Attend the 13 th Biennial <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> State Legislative Workshop<br />
When: Saturday, November 16, <strong>2002</strong><br />
Where: St. Edward’s University, Austin<br />
Who: Sessions by Environmental Leaders, Legislative<br />
Staff, State Agency Staff, Others<br />
FOR MORE INFORMATION:<br />
www.texas.sierraclub.org<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> State Conservation Office – 512-477-1729
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 21<br />
State of the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
Join Us October 19 & 20<br />
for <strong>Sierra</strong> Celebration <strong>2002</strong><br />
Annual Gathering for Texas <strong>Sierra</strong>ns to be Held at Selah, Bamberger<br />
Ranch in the Beautiful Texas Hill Country<br />
The <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> of the<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> will hold its annual<br />
gathering this year on October 19<br />
and 20 at Selah, near Johnson<br />
City. Selah is 5,500 acres of<br />
Texas hill country that have been<br />
lovingly restored from “ one of the<br />
worst examples of abused ranchland<br />
in central Texas” to a working<br />
ranch with large areas of<br />
balanced grassland, native trees—<br />
and thus, a return to something<br />
similar to its original riparian<br />
systems. It is “…a beautiful place<br />
in the Texas Hill Country where<br />
the visitor is invited to pause and<br />
reflect on Nature”.<br />
This is the largest private<br />
project of its kind in Texas, and is<br />
a tribute to David Bamberger and<br />
his wife Margaret, who spent a<br />
fortune and half a lifetime of<br />
hands-on work to make it happen.<br />
For many of us who love nature<br />
but are challenged when even<br />
facing a back yard project with<br />
native plants and grasses, this is<br />
the ultimate challenge, answered<br />
resoundingly.<br />
Taking the ranch tour, you will<br />
be amazed and impressed at the<br />
scale and vision of this project,<br />
which still continues. Visit the<br />
wonderful man-made bat cave, and<br />
the charming “country store”, a<br />
collection of many of the tools and<br />
domestic items inherited from<br />
David’s mother, who was a major<br />
inspiration. Join us to experience<br />
and celebrate Selah and enjoy the<br />
hospitality of the Bambergers and<br />
their staff.<br />
Logistics & Schedule of<br />
Activities<br />
We will gather late Saturday<br />
morning; have lunch in the lodge<br />
and then an afternoon tour of<br />
Selah on the open air “trolley” that<br />
will include much helpful information<br />
on grassland and riparian<br />
habitat restoration. Late afternoon<br />
we will gather again at the lodge<br />
for a social hour and then eat<br />
dinner, after which there will be<br />
special guests, music and presentations.<br />
Sunday we will have breakfast<br />
and then have the option of a visit<br />
and hike (7.5 miles as well as<br />
shorter trails) at nearby<br />
Pedernales <strong>Fall</strong>s State Park or a<br />
visit to Lyndon B. Johnson National<br />
Historical Park. We will<br />
officially depart Selah after breakfast<br />
Sunday when we leave on our<br />
visit to the parks. Those not<br />
visiting the State or National<br />
Parks may relax at Selah for the<br />
morning.<br />
All meals will be provided by<br />
Selah, refreshments by the chapter,<br />
and all are included in the<br />
$59.00 per person fee for the<br />
weekend. You are encouraged to<br />
bring your own linens; if provided<br />
they are $5 per person additional.<br />
Lodging is bunkhouse style, with<br />
separate quarters for men and<br />
women. Limited tent sites will be<br />
available at the same weekend<br />
price. No pets will be allowed.<br />
Directions to Selah will be sent<br />
with your confirmation of<br />
registration.<br />
For more information about<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> Celebration contact Jennifer<br />
Walker at the <strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
State Conservation Office, 512-<br />
477-1729 or by e-mail at<br />
lonestar.chapter@sierraclub.org.<br />
For more information about<br />
Selah, the Bamberger Ranch,<br />
check out the ranch web site at<br />
http://www.bambergerranch.org.<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> Celebration <strong>2002</strong> Registration Form<br />
Name:__________________________________<br />
Address:_______________________________<br />
City:_________________ State:_____ Zip:________<br />
Phone Number:_____________________________<br />
E-mail:_________________________________<br />
Please register ______ persons for <strong>Sierra</strong><br />
Celebration ($59 dollars per person provides<br />
lodging, meals, refreshments, and ranch tour).<br />
I will / will not bring my own linens.<br />
(Linens will be provided for a $5 per person fee.<br />
Children 12 years & younger are free.)<br />
I would like vegetarian meals ______(#).<br />
Total registration fee paid:____________<br />
Please make checks payable to:<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong>, <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Attn: <strong>Sierra</strong> Celebration<br />
Mail Payment and Registration Form to:<br />
P.O. Box 1931, Austin, TX 78767<br />
MC/VISA #:__________________________________<br />
Exp. Date:_____________ Amount:_____________<br />
Signature:___________________________________<br />
For more information, contact the <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong><br />
Office at 512/477-1729<br />
Registration Deadline: October 9th
22 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> Directory<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> State Conservation Office: Mailing: P.O. Box 1931,Austin 78767 512/477-1729<br />
Physical: 54 Chicon, Austin, TX 78702 (fax)512/477-8526<br />
http://www.texas.sierraclub.org lonestar.chapter@sierraclub.org<br />
Executive Committee:<br />
Chair Wendel Withrow, 1120 Metrocrest #200, Carrollton 75006 wwithrow@wfmlaw.com 972/416-2500<br />
Vice-Chair David Toner, 8901 Bluff Springs Road, Austin 78744 david_toner@juno.com 512/291-9152<br />
Conservation Andy Balinsky, 6601 Auburndale St., Austin 78723 balinsky@employees.org 512/926-7312<br />
Membership Jane Craig, 3107 Darnell Drive, Austin, TX 78745 janecraig@yahoo.com 512/280-7006<br />
Secretary Andy Balinsky, 6601 Auburndale St., Austin 78723 balinsky@employees.org 512/926-7312<br />
Karen Foley, 300 Lemon Drive, Arlington 76018 817/535-1152<br />
Frank Blake, 1010 Peden St. #3, Houston 77006 frankblake@msn.com 713/528-2896<br />
Ola Humphries, P.O Box 30422., Houston 77249 squeely450@aol.com 713/864-1553<br />
David Gray, 9432 Viewside Drive, Dallas 75311 dgray@rsn.hp.com 214/342-2019<br />
Page Williams, 4229 West Alabama, Houston, TX 77027 pagewilliams@cs.com 713/622-8533<br />
Legal Chair Roger Turner, P.O. Box 140663, Dallas, TX 75214 rturner@wfmlaw.com 214/328-7296<br />
Treasurer Hector Gonzalez, 615 Willow, San Antonio 78202 hjgonzalez@aol.com 210/226-6069<br />
Outings David Toner (see above)<br />
Alamo Group Rep. Hector Gonzalez (see above)<br />
Big Bend Group Rep. Susan Curry, 901 W. Sul Ross, Alpine 79830 curry@brooksdata.net 915/837-1477<br />
Cross Timbers Rep. Randy Wolf, 13026 Cobble Stone St., Aubrey 76227 rwolf@balconesresources.com 940/323-9472<br />
Dallas Group Rep. Rita Beving, 14605 Dartmouth ct., Addison 75001 antiquerita@aol.com 214/373-3808<br />
Galveston Group Rep. Mark Muhich, P.O. Box 1392, Galveston 77553 markmuhich@aol.com 409/763-0482<br />
Fort Worth Group Rep. Tolbert Greenwood, 6813 River Bend Rd, Ft. Worth tgreenwood@canteyhanger.com 817/877-2842<br />
Houston Group Rep. John Wilson, 518 Woodland, Houston 77009 wilson@ghasp.org 713/868-2601<br />
Lower Rio Grande Valley Ed Glaze, P.O. Box 128, Port Mansfield 78598 eglaze@vsta.com 956/944-2355<br />
Conservation Issue Chairs:<br />
Big Thicket Brandt Mannchen, 5115 Maple, Bellaire 77401 713/664-5962<br />
Clean Air George Smith, 6014 Woodbrook Lane, Houston 77008 713/862-1669<br />
Coastal Resources Mary Lou Campbell, RR #2 Box 88 Mercedes 78570 956/514-9321<br />
Mark Muhich (see above)<br />
Pat Suter, 1002 Chamberlain, Corpus Christi, 78404 361/852-7938<br />
Wildlife Conservation<br />
Page Williams (see above) and Ola Humphries (see above)<br />
National Forest Protection Brandt Mannchen, (see above)<br />
Water Resources Sheril Smith, Rt. 1, Box 337, McDade. TX 787650 512/273-1188<br />
Forestry Practices George Russell, 1401 19th St., Huntsville 77340 409/295-8286<br />
Population Molly Bean, 2502 Barton Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78704 512/441-1230<br />
Ed Glaze, P.O. Box 128, Port Mansfield 78598 956/944-2355<br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> Activity Chairs & Leaders:<br />
Env. Education Jackie McFadden, 2412 Rick Whinery Rd., Austin 78728 eeant@austin.rr.com 512/990-9396<br />
Legal Chair<br />
Roger Turner (see above)<br />
Political<br />
Ola Humphries (see above)<br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> Staff:<br />
<strong>Chapter</strong> Director Ken Kramer, P.O. Box 1931, Austin 78767 kenwkramer@aol.com 512/476-6962<br />
Natural Resources Dir. Brian Sybert, P.O. Box 1931, Austin, 78767 brian.sybert@sierraclub.org 512/477-1729<br />
Clean Air Prog. Dir. Neil Carman, P.O. Box 1931, Austin,78767 neil_carman@greenbuilder.com 512/472-1767<br />
Program Asstistant Jennifer Walker, P.O. Box 1931, Austin, 78767 jennifer.walker@sierraclub.org 512/477-1729<br />
Grassroots Outreach Erin Rogers, P.O. Box 1931, Austin, 78767 erinrogers1@earthlink.net 512/477-1729<br />
Communications Dir. Fred Richardson, P.O. Box 1931, Austin, 78767 fred.richardson@sierraclub.org 512/477-1729<br />
Water Quality Project Justin Taylor, P.O. Box 1931, Austin, TX 78767 justin.taylor@sierraclub.org 512/477-1729<br />
Development Director Sally Drews, P.O. Box 1931, Austin, TX 78767 sally.drews@sierraclub.org 512/477-1729<br />
Texas/Arkansas Field Office:<br />
Field Rep. Larry Freilich, 2906 Medical Arts, 78705 txar@earthlink.net 512/472-9094<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong> National Office:<br />
85 Second St., 2nd Floor, San Francisco, CA 94105-3441 415/977-5500
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong> 23<br />
Regional Directory<br />
Regional Group Directory<br />
Alamo: David Klar, Chair, P.O. Box 6443, San Antonio, TX 78209, (210) 222-8195, dklar63162@aol.com or<br />
http://www.sierraclub.org/chapters/tx/alamo, Mtgs: 3 rd Tuesday of the month, 7:15 p.m., Unitarian Church,<br />
806 Beryl, Loop 410 and IH-10, San Antonio.<br />
Austin: Karin Ascot, Chair, PO Box 4581, Austin 78765, (512) 443-1135, kascot@io.com or http://<br />
www.sierraclub.org/chapters/tx/austin, Mtgs: 1st Tuesday of the month, 6:30 p.m., LCRA Hancock Bldg.,<br />
3701 Lake Austin Blvd., Austin.<br />
Big Bend: Don Dowdey, Chair, 50 Sunny Glen, Alpine, TX 79830, (915) 837-3210, dwdmdb@overland.net<br />
Mtgs: 3rd Tuesday in February, March, April, May, September, October, November, and December. Time: 7<br />
p.m. Place: Lawrence Hall on the Sul Ross University Campus, Room 309. www.sierraclub.org/chapters/tx/<br />
bigbend.<br />
Brazos Valley: David Wade, Chair, 6304 Midwest Drive, Bryan, TX 77802, (979) 846-3538,<br />
dmwade@txcyber.com or http://www.sierraclub.org/chapters/tx/brazos, Mtgs: Call for time and location.<br />
Caprock: Sarah Learmonth, Chair, 3815 49 th , Lubbock, TX 79413, (806) 793-6864.<br />
sarah_learmonth@hotmail.com. Mtgs: 3 rd Tuesday of the Month at Texas Tech Law School, 7:00 PM.<br />
Central Texas: Anita Baez, Chair, P.O. Box 2775, Temple, TX 76503, (254) 778-5501. Murray McCarley, Co-<br />
Chair, (254) 771-3756. Mtgs: First Wednesday of every month. Call for time and location.<br />
Coastal Bend: Pat Suter, Chair, 1002 Chamberlain, Corpus Christi, TX 78404, (361) 852-7938,<br />
phsuter@aol.com or http://www.sierraclub.org/chapters/tx/coastalbend, Mtgs: 3rd Tuesday of the month,<br />
11:30 a.m., Art Community Center, 100 Shoreline Dr, Corpus Christi.<br />
Cross Timbers: Peggy La Point, Chair, tnplapoint@aol.com (940) 891-4984 The Cross Timbers Group does not<br />
hold group meetings, they communicate via e-mail and newsletters. Contact Peggy La Point at the above<br />
phone number and /or e-mail.<br />
Dallas: John Rath, Chair, (817) 488-3489, john.rath@fritolay.com or http://www.sierraclub.org/chapters/tx/<br />
dallas, Mtgs: 2nd Wednesday of the month, 7: 00 p.m., E.D. Walker School, corner of Monfort and Wozencraft<br />
(Mapsco 15S).<br />
Galveston: Mark Muhich, Chair, P.O. Box 1392, Galveston, TX 77553, (409) 763-0482,<br />
markmuhich@aol.com, Mtgs: 3 rd Thursday of every month, 7p.m. at Rosenberg Library.<br />
Golden Triangle: Bruce Sieve, Chair, 3155 French Road, Apt. 208, 409/892-4768.<br />
Mtgs: 1st Tues. of the month, Trinity Methodist Church, 3430 Harrison, Beaumont.<br />
Greater Ft. Worth: Tolbert Greenwood, Chair, 6813 River Bend Road, Ft. Worth, TX 76132, (817) 346-3140,<br />
tgreenwood@canteyhanger.com. Mtgs: 3rd Wednesday of the month, 7:00 p.m., North Texas College Science<br />
and Health Center at Camp Bowie and Montgomery, Fort Worth.<br />
Houston: Arlene Diehl, Chair, P.O. Box 3021, Houston, TX 77253-3021, (281)356-6837 arlenediehl@cs.com or<br />
http://lonestar.sierraclub.org/houston/ Mtgs: 1st Thursday of the month, 7.00 p.m. Central Presbyterian<br />
Church, 3788 Richmond (Parking lot accessible from Timmons).<br />
Lower Rio Grande Valley: Ed Glaze, Chair, P.O. Box 128, Port Mansfield, TX 78598-0128. (956) 944-2355,<br />
eglaze@VSTA.com. Group website: http://www.egroups.com/group/valleysierrans Mtgs: vary as to time and<br />
place.<br />
North East Texas: Richard LeTourneau, Chair, 903/643-0060, richardoii@aol.com. Call for meeting times<br />
and locations.<br />
Piney Woods: Dian Avriett, Chair, 936-639-6322, cdavriett@aol.com. Call for meeting times and locations<br />
Red River: Joy Parsons, Chair, 4723 Augusta Ln., Wichita <strong>Fall</strong>s 76302, (940)692-1220. Mtgs: 2nd Thursday of<br />
the month, 7:15 p.m., St. Stephens Episcopal Church, 5023 Lindale, Wichita <strong>Fall</strong>s.<br />
Two Rivers: Bruce Allen, Chair, 8924 Gladedale, Woodway, TX 76712. (254)776-3036 allenbw@earthlink.net.<br />
Mtgs: 1st Monday of the month, Waco McLennam Library, 1717Austin Ave
24 <strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n <strong>Fall</strong> <strong>2002</strong><br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Chapter</strong> Calendar <strong>2002</strong><br />
September 6 Steering Committee Meeting Austin<br />
September 28 Regional Water Conference Houston<br />
October 5 Regional Water Conference Dallas<br />
October 12 Regional Water Conference San Marcos<br />
October 19-20 <strong>Sierra</strong> Celebration Johnson City<br />
Selah (Bamberger Ranch)<br />
October 26 Regional Water Conference Mercedes<br />
November 16 State Legislative Workshop Austin<br />
November 17 Executive Committee Meeting Austin<br />
<strong>Lone</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>Sierra</strong>n<br />
<strong>Sierra</strong> <strong>Club</strong><br />
P.O. Box 1931<br />
Austin, TX 78767<br />
Non-Profit Org.<br />
U.S. Postage Paid<br />
Austin, Texas<br />
Permit # 2529