17.05.2015 Views

Bulletin - Vlada Crne Gore

Bulletin - Vlada Crne Gore

Bulletin - Vlada Crne Gore

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

• <strong>Bulletin</strong>IV<br />

• April - June 2006


REPUBLIC OF MONTENEGRO<br />

MINISTRY OF FINANCE<br />

BULLETIN IV<br />

APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

www.ministarstvo-finasija.vlada.cg.yu<br />

TAX ADMINISTRATION: www.poreskauprava.vlada.cg.yu<br />

CUSTOMS OFFICE: www.gom.cg.yu/carine<br />

ANTI-CORRUPTION DIRECTORATE: www.antikorup.vlada.cg.yu<br />

DIRECTORATE FOR ANTI-MONEY LONDERY: www.gom.cg.yu/aspn<br />

DIRECTORATE FOR REAL ESTATES: www.nekretnine.cg.yu


TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

4-5<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

- Igor Lukšić, PhD, Minister of Finance<br />

6-9<br />

LAW ON PROPERTY-LEGAL RELATIONS<br />

- Assistant to the Minister of Finance, Krsto Racković<br />

10-12<br />

LAW ON STATE PROPERTY<br />

- Milodarka Novosel, Senior advisor<br />

13-14<br />

RESTITUTION<br />

- Đorđina Lakić, Director of the Compensation Fund<br />

15<br />

BY RESTITUTION BONDS TO THE STATE PROPERTY<br />

- Assistant to the Minister of Finance, Krsto Racković<br />

16-17<br />

LAW ON TAX ADVISORS<br />

- Koviljka Mihailović, Assistant Minister of Finance, - Antoaneta<br />

Krivokapić - Senior advisor<br />

18-23<br />

PROCEDURES IN THE TAX PROCEDURE<br />

- Chief of the Department for the Second Instance Administrative<br />

and Customs Procedure, Pero Mrdak<br />

2


TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

24-25<br />

PROJECT "1000 HOUSING LOANS "<br />

- Senior Employee, Dragan Darmanović<br />

26-28<br />

INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION - EBRD<br />

- Jadranka Radunović, International Co-operation and<br />

EU Integrations Department, Co-ordinator<br />

29<br />

30-31<br />

32-33<br />

34-35<br />

36<br />

37-39<br />

40-48<br />

TRANSFER OF THE ARMY PROPERTY<br />

TO THE REPUBLIC OF MONTENEGRO<br />

- Predrag Stamatović, Advisor to the Minister<br />

SUPPORT TO REFORM PROCESSES<br />

OF THE DEFENCE SYSTEM<br />

- Mijajlo Savović, M.A., Advisor for the Defence Budget<br />

in the Ministry of Finance<br />

OVERVIEW OF THE ACTIVITIES OF THE MINISTER OF<br />

FINANCE - PR SERVICE OF THE MINISTRY<br />

- Ana Miljanić, Spokesperson, Maja Bašić, Senior Employee I<br />

OVERVIEW OF OTHER NEWS<br />

- PR SERVICE<br />

OLD FOREIGN CURRENCY SAVINGS<br />

REPORT ON ACCOUNT OF PUBLIC DEBT OF THE<br />

REPUBLIC OF MONTENEGRO UP TO 30. JUNE 2006<br />

- Department for Debt and Cash Management,<br />

Indebtedness Analysis and International Co-Operation<br />

SneŽana Ivanović, Mersija Purišić, Mina Jovović, Nikola<br />

Vukićević<br />

16. MACROECONOMIC ANALYSIS<br />

- Stanko Jeknić, PhD, Co-ordinator of the Macroeconomic<br />

Analysis and International Co-Operation Department,<br />

Vladislav Karadžić, Senior Employee I, Macroeconomic<br />

Anaysis and International Co-Operation Department<br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong> of the Ministry of Finance<br />

April - June 2006<br />

NUMBER:<br />

4<br />

PUBLISHED:<br />

quarterly<br />

PUBLISHER:<br />

Republic of Montenegro<br />

The Ministry of Finance<br />

FOR PUBLISHER:<br />

Igor Lukšić Ph.D.<br />

EDITOR-IN-CHIEF:<br />

Ana Miljanić<br />

EDITORIAL BOARD:<br />

Koviljka Mihailović,<br />

Milorad Katnić M.A., Krsto Racković<br />

TRANSLATOR:<br />

Jelena Čađenović<br />

Design:<br />

Adil Tuzović<br />

CONTACT:<br />

PR Office of the Ministry of Finance<br />

TEL:<br />

+381 81 224 581<br />

FAX:<br />

+381 81 224 450<br />

E-MAIL:<br />

mf@mn.yu<br />

WEB:<br />

www.ministarstvo-finansija.vlada.cg.yu<br />

ADDRESS:<br />

Stanka Dragojevića 2, Podgorica<br />

PRINT:<br />

Grafotisak<br />

COPYES:<br />

400<br />

3


Introduction<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Minister of Finance<br />

IGOR LUKŠIĆ, PH.D.<br />

CONTACT:<br />

PHONE:<br />

+381 81 242-835<br />

FAX:<br />

+381 81 224 450<br />

E-MAIL:<br />

mf@mn.yu<br />

WEB:<br />

www.ministarstvo-finansija.vlada.cg.yu<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

DEAR READERS,<br />

Successfully conducted Referendum on Independence, then very fast international<br />

recognition of Montenegro, and express membership in the<br />

United Nations Organization, represent the beginning of the new political<br />

period of Montenegro. Democratic consolidation of the system, which<br />

will progress through parliamentary elections and the draft of the new Constitution,<br />

creates conditions for economic positioning of our country in a new<br />

context.<br />

Taking over of the full responsibility<br />

for implementation of economic<br />

policy, and the participation in full capacity<br />

in the integration processes,<br />

should give a strong impetus to the<br />

economic growth and development<br />

in medium and long term. Recent<br />

continuation of negotiations on Montenegro's<br />

membership in the World<br />

Trade Organization, then expected<br />

new mandate for negotiations with<br />

European Commission on Stabilisation<br />

and Association Agreement, and<br />

recently ended Mission of IMF on the<br />

subject of medium-term macroeconomic<br />

policy and structural reforms, represent<br />

and will represent positive<br />

signal, first of all to foreign but undoubtedly<br />

to domestic investors too.<br />

Stability of the system and predictable<br />

economic policy are of great importance<br />

for business planning. If we<br />

add to that reform of property laws,<br />

chances for higher investments and<br />

therefore an opening of new job vacancies,<br />

become more certain.<br />

In this respect, it is necessary to<br />

start preparation of specific Agenda<br />

2010, or activities as a follow-up of<br />

economic reforms conducted in the<br />

period 2002-2006. Achieved macroeconomic<br />

stability, high percentage of<br />

privatised public capital, and legal<br />

4


Introduction<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Ministy of Finance<br />

grounds in many areas, represent specific<br />

platform for further transformation<br />

and modernization of Montenegrin<br />

economy and society. Combination<br />

of structural reforms together<br />

with control of public spending and<br />

reduction of tax rates represent policy<br />

which should additionally stimulate<br />

economic freedom, but also make<br />

easier the exchange of property<br />

rights with lower transaction costs.<br />

Main structural reforms are reflected<br />

in the continuation of privatization,<br />

and enabling of long-term concessions<br />

with business systems such as:<br />

Electric Power Company, Port of Bar,<br />

Airports or Montenegro Airlines, and<br />

in next phase of pension reforms, introduction<br />

of II pillar or individual capitalized<br />

savings. Particularly sensitive,<br />

but unavoidable reform in that<br />

context is a reform of labour market,<br />

through its liberalization. Falling<br />

trend of unemployment is obvious,<br />

and soon it will fall under 16%, but<br />

that is still very high level which is not<br />

possible to be reduced with the liberalization<br />

of labour legislation. At the<br />

same time, in combination with gradual<br />

reduction of income tax to the<br />

level of 9%, terms are created for the<br />

largest share of grey economy to be<br />

introduced into the real sector.<br />

In that context, the main challenge<br />

for public finance will be the public<br />

debt policy of general public sector,<br />

which should until 2011 be reduced<br />

below 30%. That kind of policy for<br />

public debt would create conditions<br />

for growth of state credit rating, reducing<br />

the risk premium in Montenegro.<br />

That implies the fall of interest rates,<br />

and therefore has positive influence<br />

not only to business, but also<br />

to the living standard of all citizens<br />

who are referred to the banking sector,<br />

allowing a wider range of possibilities<br />

to them. At the same, with the reduction<br />

of public debt, tax and privatisation<br />

receipts are allocated more<br />

dynamically to the development of<br />

infrastructure and therefore to achieving<br />

a high economic growth rate in<br />

the long-term.<br />

Sincerely,<br />

Igor Luksić, PhD<br />

5


Law on property-legal relations to be adopted soon<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

LAW ON PROPERTY<br />

- LEGAL RELATIONS TO BE<br />

ADOPTED SOON<br />

THE PROPERTY LAW MUST TAKE HOLD IN ORDER TO BECOME THE RIGHT OF PRACTICE.<br />

EVERY NEW TIME REQUIRES ALSO NEW SOLUTIONS. WE ARE SURE THAT THIS LAW'S DIREC-<br />

TION IS TOWARDS THE NEW TIMES<br />

The Ministry of Finance through relevant Work<br />

Group composed of the representatives of the<br />

Faculty of Law, Ministry of Finance and Ministry of<br />

Justice managed by Prof. Dr. Zoran Rašović, prepared<br />

Draft Law on Property -Legal Relations<br />

Property -legal relations in Montenegro have not been<br />

still regulated integrally by the law. Property, as entirety of<br />

economic relations in society and social condition of<br />

existence, is fundamental base for the overall social reform.<br />

Complete and entire normative regulation of property-legal<br />

relations is necessary for implementation of<br />

the initiated changes in th economic and legal system of<br />

the Republic and it is an important condition for faster<br />

realization of constitutional concept of private property<br />

and freedom of entrepreneurship.<br />

Subject-matter of the property-legal relations is regula-<br />

ted by the Law on Elements of property-legal relations<br />

and numerous separate laws (tenant ownership, mortgage,<br />

pledge, fiduciary transfer of property rights etc.). To<br />

the extent to which they are still not regulated by the new<br />

regulations, pre-war legal rules can still be applied to these<br />

relations, under the general conditions contained in<br />

the Law on Invalidated Legal Relations adopted before<br />

April 6, 1941 and During the Occupation Period in 1946.<br />

Drafting the Law on property-legal relations in Montenegro,<br />

subject-matter of the real right is gathered in one<br />

place. In that process were used past experinces, provisions<br />

of our big general property code of Montenegro, judicial<br />

practice, comparative legal decisions as well as decisions<br />

from the European law, expecially Convention on<br />

protection of fundamental human rights and freedoms as<br />

well as practice of the European Court of Justice.<br />

6


Law on property-legal relations to be adopted soon<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Assistant to the<br />

Minister of Finance<br />

Krsto Racković<br />

As it is known, according to earlier constitutional decisions,<br />

legislative competence for regulating property-legal<br />

relations was divided so that Federation regulated basic<br />

property-legal relations and other issues came within<br />

the competence of the Republics. Thus, the Law on Basic<br />

Property-Legal Relations in 1980 was adopted ("Official<br />

Gazette of the Socialistic Federal Republic of Yugoslavia",<br />

No. 6/80), which regulated: right to property (holders and<br />

facilities, acquiring, protection, discontinuation), real easement,<br />

mortgage (pledge o chattels is regulated by the<br />

Law on Obligatory Relations), possession actual, rights of<br />

foreign physical and legal persons and meritory right in<br />

case of inetrnal conflict of laws. Cetain issues from these<br />

fields, which are not included in this law as well as the other<br />

legal areas (co-ownership, joint ownership, tenant<br />

ownership, fiduciary ownership, shareholders ownership,<br />

personal easement and neighborly rights) were subject-matter<br />

of legal regulation of the republics and they<br />

are partially already regulated by certain separate laws.<br />

We can state that numerous property and other real-legal<br />

relations haven't been still regulated legally.<br />

By adoption of the Law on property-legal relations,<br />

Montenegro will entirely regulate the general legal system<br />

of issues and rights. The holders will be provided<br />

with these rights, in terms of the real rights, to the same<br />

extent as holders in other European states.<br />

The draft law mostly assumed provisions from the former<br />

federal law. Thus, along with additional regulation of<br />

unregulated relations, a single, consistent and entire text<br />

on property-legal relations was offered.<br />

The past Law on Law on Basic Property-Legal Relations<br />

regulated certain institutes, but not comprehensively<br />

and entirely, leaving to the republican legislation to<br />

normatively regulate the remainder of relations and institutes.<br />

Now, these are completely regulated by the draft<br />

law, which contributes to codification requirements in<br />

certain areas of social relations. In that way complex institues,<br />

which came earlier within a divided legislative competence,<br />

are now integrated. Joint regulation of propertylegal<br />

relations has got all advantages in terms of complete<br />

regulation, good layout of decisions and their internal<br />

adjustment. Purpose-serving reasons also point to joint<br />

regulation of these issues.<br />

This draft law regulates also the assumed subject-matter<br />

about tenant ownership, fiduciary transfer of ownership<br />

rights and mortgage, what enables better adjustment<br />

and systematic quality of the legal text, facilitates<br />

the entire insight into the subject of regulation as well as<br />

regulation itself. As Prof. Dr. Zoran Rašović says, this codification<br />

proposal brings about deeper intervention in<br />

terms of the existing real right and at the same time<br />

brings together the existing real right, which was until<br />

now regulated by several laws, into one separate unity.<br />

Orientation of the proposer towards single integral method<br />

of regulation of these relations will contribute also to<br />

7


Law on property-legal relations to be adopted soon<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

easier practical application of the law.<br />

Konstantinovic's model of legal norms formulation<br />

was mostly used in the course of drafting this law. The<br />

model is characterized by transparency, good layout and<br />

elegance of the legal text, and in this process were used<br />

the best experiences in comparative law adjusted to our<br />

reality and adjusted to the international standards in this<br />

field.<br />

In the course of drafting this law we transparently determined<br />

subjects, objects and principles of real rights as<br />

well as general principles on which they are based (definiteness,<br />

prohibition to abuse real rights, limitations of ownership<br />

rights etc.) Legal notion of ownership, social function<br />

of ownership, possibility and manner of ownership limitation<br />

are determined and other real rights are determined<br />

and defined (easement, real burden and pledge, ownership<br />

rights of the state etc.) The law also regulates the issues<br />

of acquiring and termination of the ownership rights<br />

on the basis of legal affairs, inheritance, decision of the public<br />

authority under the conditions determined by the law<br />

etc. Certain, so called original ways of acquiring ownership<br />

rights are separately regulated (non-owners' acquiring of<br />

ownership) such as creation of a new object, modification,<br />

unification, constructing at somebody else's land, longstanding<br />

plants, fruits separation, actual possession, acquiring<br />

from non-owners etc. then occupation, planting and<br />

sowing at somebody else's land, reclaimed piece of land,<br />

deposit, river flow alteration, abandoned river bed, new river<br />

island, swarm of bees etc.<br />

The law separately regulates the issues of co-ownership<br />

rights, rights of joint ownership and tenant ownership.<br />

Of course, easement rights, personal easement and<br />

neghborly rights are also regulated in a relevant manner.<br />

Right to pledge, as right of creditors (pledge or mortgage<br />

creditor and pledgee) to enforce their claims before<br />

all the other creditors, is also regulated by this law.<br />

Because of uniqueness of regulating all the property<br />

relations there is, of course, also fiduciary ownership, i.e.<br />

fiduciary transfer of ownership rights, what was until<br />

now regulated by a separate law.<br />

Easement, as factual ownership of objects, is also regulated<br />

by this law.<br />

This law separately regulates also issues of foreign<br />

persons rights in terms of acquiring ownership rights to<br />

movable and immovable objects. These issues are particularly<br />

significant from the aspect of privatization and foreign<br />

investments, i.e. possibility that foreign legal and<br />

physical persons invest their capital without being disturbed.<br />

In relation to the existing decisions from the mentioned<br />

federal law, decisions in this law in this area, are significantly<br />

more liberal and the rights of foreign physical<br />

and legal persons to acquire real estate in Montenegro,<br />

along with existence of reciprocity, are equalized with<br />

the rights of our citizens.<br />

Special significance and quality of this law in terms of<br />

establishment of clear ownership relations and determination<br />

of titular of ownership, i.e. elimination of quasiownership<br />

terms of reference from the legal system as<br />

well as terms such as "usage", "permanent usage" and other<br />

relapses of social ownership, is contained in transitional<br />

and final provisions of this law. Namely, separate<br />

articles regulate the issue of ownership rights transfer<br />

from social ownership and registration of real owners'<br />

ownership right. Thus, real legal institutes of ownership<br />

are established and outdated terms of ownership rights,<br />

especially in the framework of construction land are eliminated<br />

from the real estate register. Exactly that undefined<br />

land ownership caused significant difficulties and<br />

problems in transition in the past period, in particular in<br />

the privatization procedure of economic associations or<br />

parts of their property.<br />

Constitutionally guaranteed full ownership rights of<br />

all entities - holders of ownership rights, starting from citizens<br />

to economic associations and local governance<br />

will be established by enforcement of this law in the part<br />

of transitional and final provisions. Therefore, two constitutionally<br />

guaranteed forms of ownership, private and<br />

state, with full capacities of disposal and enjoyment of<br />

ownership rights will play a role.<br />

Prototype of this decision can be found in the Law on<br />

Restitution of Dispossessed Ownership Rights and Indemnification<br />

("Official Gazette of the RoM", No. 21/04)<br />

by which the unjustifiably dispossessed property within<br />

the construction land is not returned to the former owners<br />

for usage but as their ownership.<br />

As it is known, in the first years after the World War II<br />

radical measures of disempowerment of the owners of<br />

production instruments in Yugoslavia were carried out on<br />

the basis of confiscation of property, regulation on agrarian<br />

reform and nationalization of priovate and economic<br />

enterprizes, buildings, construction land and other regulations<br />

on ownership right disempowerment and its transfer<br />

to social, i.e. national ownership. Socialization of construction<br />

land is continued because according to the Constitution<br />

of SFRY from 1974 private ownership right to<br />

construction land in the towns and populated places as<br />

well as in the other areas envisaged for housing and other<br />

complex constructions was not allowed.<br />

Constitution of the Republic of Montenegro from<br />

1992 terminated social ownership and established single<br />

8


Law on property-legal relations to be adopted soon<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

ownership system, which guarantees right to ownership<br />

and inheritance without any limitations. Inviolability of<br />

the ownership right is raised to the level of the highest values<br />

of the constitutional order. However, although social<br />

ownership is terminated, in the legal system of the Republic<br />

of Montenegro remained "right to usage" of construction<br />

land by the owner of construction facility as a real relict<br />

of outdated relations. Therefore, there is an illogical<br />

combination in the cadastar registars, i.e. citizen who is<br />

the owner of construction facility (family housing building,<br />

business premises etc., which he constructed in accordance<br />

with the legal procedure) is not the owner, but<br />

only user of the construction land, i.e. construction lot on<br />

which the facility is built. Everyday practice derogates<br />

each day these legal illogicalities and gradually introduces<br />

universal legal principles, which are appropriate to<br />

the European standards, and which are based on full disposal<br />

of property and even construction land of the holders,<br />

who acwquired thier rights in the legal procedure.<br />

As Prof. Rašović points out, exactly the illogicallity<br />

must be resolved by adopting the Law on Property-Legal<br />

Relations in the aforesaid manner, by registering the<br />

ownership right to the past holders of "right to usage",<br />

"permanent usage", possibly "management" etc.<br />

By adoption of the set of other laws in the field of property<br />

(Law on State Property, Amendments and Supplemnts<br />

to the Law on Construction Land and Law on<br />

State survey and real estate cadastre) which are envisaged<br />

by the Agenda of the Government of the Republic of<br />

Montenegro in the first half od 2006 , and which were being<br />

adjusted during thier drafting and now make a complementary<br />

and compatible entirety, the overall subjectmatter<br />

of this sphere in Montenegro will be regulated in<br />

a completely new and modern way, relevant to the European<br />

standards. Clear and adequate legal institutes of<br />

ownership, disposal and possibility of property transactions,<br />

which are relevant to the rights of entities that are<br />

holders of ownership rights in the modern world, are established<br />

in that way.<br />

On these principles, from the Draft Law on Property-<br />

Legal Relations the Ministry of Finance prepared a completely<br />

new version of the Law on State Property, with<br />

ambition to perform further diferentiation in the framework<br />

of property rights and authorizations in relation to<br />

state property with clearly defined ownership position<br />

and authorizations of municipality (separate attachment<br />

in this bulletin).<br />

On the basis of the mentioned principles, from the<br />

Draft Law on Property-Legal Relations and Draft Law on<br />

State Property, in the ownership registers, i.e. register of<br />

real estate the ownership rights, which remined undefined<br />

until now (usage, permanent usage etc.), which were<br />

acquired in a legally valid manner, at the request of<br />

owners of these rights would be registered as the ownershp<br />

right. In addition, on the basis of the mentioned legal<br />

principles real titulars of private and state property<br />

will be determined and protected, and clear diferentiation<br />

of ownership rights and obligations of municipality<br />

will be executed in the framework of state property.<br />

By amendments and supplements to the Law on Construction<br />

Land, with much more clear and modern decisions,<br />

the procedures of overall treatment of property of<br />

the ownership rights holder in the framework of construction<br />

land will be integrated and simplified and the<br />

holder's rights and obligations will be regulated in a new,<br />

quality manner.<br />

In that way, the legislative framework would be integrated<br />

and real property-legal relations and all actions<br />

and procedures with reference to the property of the<br />

ownership rights holder would be completely established.<br />

By adoption of the Law on Property-Legal Relations<br />

Montenegro will obtain a new system of property-legal<br />

relations, i.e. real rights. Property-legal relations are in<br />

every country a foundation of legal relations in general.<br />

That is why drafting of this law implied good knowledge<br />

about the past legal system (regulations, judicial practice,<br />

legal theory). Preparation of such a comprehensive law<br />

in the filed of property-legal relations at the moment<br />

when the system goes through a significant turn and the<br />

need to resolve many relations, which occurred in the<br />

meantime and which are resolved through the judicial or<br />

extra-judicial procedures, represented a really great challenge.<br />

This law creates prerequisites, resolutions to many various<br />

relations established by physical and legal persons.<br />

It is expected that iots resolutions would be inspirative<br />

for judicial and other practice, for legal theory and comparative<br />

legal studies, in which process the property Codex<br />

of Montenegro is a big step forward towards the legal<br />

partnership with the European Union.<br />

Finally, as Prof. Rašović would say - adoption of the property<br />

codex belongs to big state issues. The property<br />

law must take hold in order to become the right of practice.<br />

Every new time requires also new solutions. We are<br />

sure that this law's direction is towards the new times.<br />

KRSTO RACKOVIĆ,<br />

Assistant to the Minister of Finance<br />

9


New draft Law on state property<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

NEW<br />

DRAFT<br />

LAW ON<br />

STATE<br />

PROPERTY<br />

Senior Advisors<br />

Milodarka Novosel<br />

STATE OF AFFAIRS<br />

Ministry of Finance, in cooperation<br />

with the Ministry<br />

of Justice, Ministry of Environment<br />

and Physical Planning and<br />

Real Estate Administration, has drafted<br />

a new Law on State Property and has<br />

sent it to the Government working<br />

groups for a related procedure.<br />

Legal standards governing the property<br />

and property rights have been<br />

completed by drafting this Law, together<br />

with other regulations in this field.<br />

For a better understanding of this<br />

field as well as importance of the suggested<br />

solutions for the legal system of<br />

the Republic of Montenegro, it is necessary<br />

to point to the following:<br />

Conditions and procedure for sale<br />

of property located on agricultural,<br />

building and forest land, or in structures<br />

or buildings were defined under<br />

the Law on Sale of Property ("Official<br />

Gazette of the SR of Montenegro", No.<br />

27/75), which was subsequently amended<br />

in 1989, 1991, 1992 and 1994. Certain<br />

provisions of this Law are still applicable.<br />

The provisions under this Law stipulate<br />

that the property is of public<br />

use, while organizations of associated<br />

labour, self-governing communities of<br />

interest, socio-political communities,<br />

local communities and other self-managing<br />

organizations and communities<br />

or social legal persons are holders<br />

of right of use with respect to sociallyowned<br />

property.<br />

For example, in case of alienation<br />

of the structures or buildings, with respect<br />

to which a right of use exists, a<br />

right to a land appurtenant to such<br />

building is also transferred, including<br />

a land serving for a regular use, and a<br />

10


New draft Law on state property<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

new owner acquires a right of ownership<br />

with respect to the building, while<br />

with respect to socially-owned land,<br />

a right of use is acquired as long as the<br />

building is located on such land.<br />

Rights and obligations of state authorities<br />

with respect to the property<br />

management were defined under a separate<br />

Law on Rights and Obligations<br />

of Socio-Political Communities' Organs<br />

with respect to Socially-Owned<br />

Resources used by them ("Official Gazette<br />

of SR of Montenegro", No. 21/84).<br />

Accordingly, the said laws governed<br />

the rights for socially-owned movable<br />

and immovable property management<br />

in the Socialist Republic of<br />

Montenegro.<br />

For the ex Yugoslav countries as<br />

well as for other socialist countries, the<br />

reforms in the field of property rights<br />

and related authorizations are essential<br />

in their process of transition. Namely,<br />

as it can be seen from the said<br />

laws, all movable and immovable property<br />

was socially-owned, with no<br />

clear rightful claimant, meaning "common<br />

property equals nobody's responsibility".<br />

Reforms in the transition process<br />

are aimed at designating a clear rightful<br />

claimant with respect to property<br />

management, thus protecting the property<br />

from usurpation, allowing it to<br />

be privatized and valorized through<br />

various types of the receipts stemming<br />

from the property.<br />

Republic of Montenegro adopted a<br />

new Law on Property of the Republic<br />

of Montenegro ("Official Gazette of<br />

RoM", No. 44/99). The objective of this<br />

Law was to remove all dilemmas relating<br />

to the former system and sociallyowned<br />

property. However, it was not<br />

done adequately. Namely, the Law has<br />

not been sufficiently implemented,<br />

mainly due to the fact that many issues,<br />

which were to be clearly defined,<br />

remained in general and imprecise<br />

terms, resulting in non-adoption of relevant<br />

by-laws provided for under the<br />

Law.<br />

Besides, there were certain legal<br />

oversights in this field, such as the provisions<br />

of the Law on Education, according<br />

to which the Ministry of Education<br />

is entitled to the state property<br />

management; Law on Tourism which<br />

empowered municipalities to manage<br />

the state property (mineral waters,<br />

which is contrary to the basic right that<br />

may be exercised with respect to the<br />

state property) etc.<br />

Such inappropriate legal solutions<br />

also caused problems in the privatization<br />

of certain public enterprises (a facility<br />

in the ownership, land for use);<br />

unclear registration of the property in<br />

the Real Estate Register as well as an incorrect<br />

registration of the state property<br />

belonging to the Republic in favour<br />

of a municipality; irregularities with<br />

health, education and cultural institutions,<br />

etc.<br />

Following adoption of this Law, in<br />

line with the set developmental goals,<br />

the reforms were launched in many<br />

areas, particularly in the field of public<br />

administration, local self-government,<br />

budget, public prosecutor's office etc.<br />

Relevant legal regulations were adopted<br />

to this end, such as Law on Budget<br />

("Official Gazette of RoM", No. 40/01),<br />

Law on Local Self-Government ("Official<br />

Gazette of RoM", No. 42/03), Law<br />

on State Audit Institution ("Official Gazette<br />

of RoM ", No. 28/04), Law on<br />

Chief Prosecutor ("Official Gazette of<br />

RoM ", No. 40/01), as well as many other<br />

laws that the Law on Property of<br />

the Republic of Montenegro has to be<br />

harmonized with.<br />

All listed arguments as well as a need<br />

for drafting simpler and more precise<br />

legal solutions required drafting<br />

of a new law governing the state property<br />

issues.<br />

AN OBJECTIVE SET<br />

WHILE DRAFTING THE<br />

NEW LAW ON STATE<br />

PROPERTY<br />

While defining certain solutions in<br />

the Draft Law on State Property, main<br />

intention was to define all terms in this<br />

field and determine clear authorizations<br />

with respect to right to the state<br />

property management, running,<br />

using, exchange etc, and to ensure recording<br />

and assessment of the state property<br />

and establish relevant authorities<br />

which will be responsible for management<br />

and protection of the said<br />

property (a State Property Authority<br />

and an Inspector for the State Property).<br />

While drafting the Law, opinions of<br />

all relevant institutions in the Republic<br />

were taken into account, such as competent<br />

ministries, Secretariat for Legislation,<br />

State Audit Institution, all municipalities<br />

in the Republic and union of<br />

municipalities, state Funds etc. Experiences<br />

and certain solutions were also<br />

provided from ex Yugoslav republics<br />

and foreign consultants, such as Barents<br />

and its institutions, which were<br />

very useful in making the final text version<br />

of the Draft Law.<br />

MAIN PURPOSE OF<br />

THE LAW<br />

Drafting process of the Law on State<br />

Property started from the following<br />

facts:<br />

- That the state property represents<br />

a direct and most comprehensive<br />

legal power of the state, or its authorities,<br />

organizations and services<br />

with respect to the material property.<br />

In terms of a civil law, a state is a holder<br />

or bearer of the most comprehensive<br />

power over the objects like other<br />

legal entities (natural and legal persons).<br />

In terms of a public law, a state<br />

property is a set of public law authorizations<br />

and obligations that a state has<br />

with respect to public property, and<br />

accordingly it is a holder of power<br />

(imperium). A state property entity is<br />

a state as a collective or as an entity<br />

that has a sovereign management over<br />

the public property by means of public<br />

law or civil law enactments. These<br />

are state authorities, local self-government<br />

units (municipalities) and public<br />

services. The Constitution of the<br />

Republic of Montenegro guarantees a<br />

right of ownership to natural and legal<br />

11


New draft Law on state property<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Waters etc. ).<br />

PENAL, TRANSITIONAL<br />

AND FINAL PROVISIONS<br />

persons and its inviolability. This rule<br />

is also applicable to a private and public<br />

property;<br />

- According to the provisions under<br />

the Draft Law, property rights and<br />

authorizations with respect to the state<br />

property are exercised by the Government<br />

of the Republic of Montenegro,<br />

or a local self-government authority<br />

designated under the Statute of the<br />

municipality. Government or a competent<br />

local self-government authority<br />

decides on the state property management,<br />

unless otherwise provided for<br />

under the law.<br />

Therefore, state of Montenegro is a<br />

holder or bearer of the most comprehensive<br />

legal power over the stateowned<br />

property. State property entities<br />

have ownership powers over such<br />

property, including state-owned building<br />

land.<br />

In the context of given solutions,<br />

the Draft Law clearly defines or delineates<br />

the state property over which the<br />

Republic or a municipality respectively<br />

exercises ownership rights or authorizations.<br />

The Draft Law also clearly distinguishes<br />

a state property serving for<br />

functioning of the Republic or its<br />

agencies and public services on one<br />

hand, and for functioning of a municipality,<br />

or its authorities and public services<br />

on the other, clearly defining the<br />

state property which represents a<br />

common good (recourses of common<br />

interest and use).<br />

The Draft Law clearly defines the<br />

terms relating to the state property<br />

management, use and running, clarifying<br />

their respective meanings.<br />

We particularly emphasize that the<br />

Draft Law governs a procedure related<br />

to recording of the state property and<br />

establishing of a Register. Special obligation<br />

and responsibility to this end is<br />

given to the competent Republic and<br />

municipal authorities using and supervising<br />

the state property (state property<br />

which is governed by separate laws,<br />

such as Law on Coastal Management,<br />

Law on Roads, Law on Forests, Law on<br />

In case of non-implementation of<br />

the provisions under the Law, penal<br />

provisions shall apply to the state authorities,<br />

municipal authorities and public<br />

services as well as to responsible<br />

persons in a state authority or a municipal<br />

authority failing to manage the<br />

state property in conformity with the<br />

Law<br />

With a view to removing dilemmas<br />

and illogicalities caused by the previous<br />

registration of rights of use or permanent<br />

use of a building land in the<br />

cadastre, transitional and final provisions<br />

stipulate that such rights shall be<br />

changed into a right of ownership of<br />

the Republic or local self-government<br />

unit, unless an interested entity proves<br />

that it acquired a right of ownership<br />

over certain land by means of a valid<br />

legal transaction<br />

The Draft Law also stipulates that<br />

the following laws shall not remain in<br />

force: Law on the Property of the Republic<br />

of Montenegro; Law on Sale of<br />

Property; Article 15a of the Law on<br />

Education, and Article 53, paragraph 6<br />

of the Law on Tourism.<br />

Establishing of an authority responsible<br />

for property, introduction of<br />

the state property Register and assessment<br />

of the state property as new solutions<br />

relevant for this field deserve<br />

to be separately discussed in a next issue<br />

of the <strong>Bulletin</strong>.<br />

Senior Advisor<br />

MILODARKA NOVOSEL<br />

12


Restitution<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

RESTITUTION<br />

LEGAL FOUNDATION FOR RESTITU-<br />

TION AND COMPENSATION OF FOR-<br />

MER HOLDERS FOR THE PROPERTY<br />

RIGHTS EXPROPRIATED IN FAVOUR<br />

OF NATIONAL WIDE, NATIONAL, PU-<br />

BLIC AND COMMON PROPERTY IS<br />

CONTAINED IN THE LAW ON RESTI-<br />

TUTION OF EXPROPRIATED PRO-<br />

PERTY RIGHTS AND COMPENSA-<br />

TION ("OFFICIAL GAZETTE ROM",<br />

NO.21/04), WHICH ENTERED INTO<br />

FORCE ON 9TH APRIL 2004.<br />

Director of the Compensation fund<br />

Đorđina Lakić<br />

According to the provisions of the Law, former<br />

holders have right to demand restitution<br />

or compensation, if their property<br />

rights were expropriated in favour of national wide,<br />

national, public or common property, without just or<br />

market compensation. In the settlement of matters<br />

that are subject of this Law, provisions of the Law,<br />

which regulate property-legal relations, debenture<br />

and other relations shall be applied if they are in accordance<br />

with this Law. In the procedures for exercising<br />

rights by this Law, the Law on General Administrative<br />

Procedure is applied.<br />

13


Restitution<br />

BILTEN Ministarstva finansija <strong>Crne</strong> <strong>Gore</strong>/april-jun 2006.<br />

Gaining of property rights for real estate and other<br />

property rights, or reimbursement realised according<br />

to this Law is not a subject to tax payment.<br />

Persons under obligation of restitution of objects<br />

and rights are natural and legal persons who are their<br />

owners at the moment of the entering into force of the<br />

Law, except in cases when those persons gained property<br />

right in accordance to the Law. Republic of Montenegro<br />

is under obligation of restitution of former<br />

holders and it will provide funds for the Compensation<br />

Fund. Therefore, former holder has right for compensation<br />

in case when expropriated objects and<br />

rights are not object of restitution.<br />

Practical application of the Law started with formation<br />

of the Municipal Commissions for Restitution and<br />

Compensation, and in the second half of 2005, first<br />

restitution of expropriated property started. Finally,<br />

first payments were made by way of compensation of<br />

former holders or their successors in November 2005.<br />

were issued by way of compensation of former holders<br />

in bonds to total amount of 3.684.075,00 EUR.<br />

Until now 658.350,00 EUR has been realised through<br />

the exchange market.<br />

Compensation Fund makes payments, according<br />

to provisions of the Article 22 of the Law on Restitution<br />

of Property Rights and Compensation, every six<br />

months according to the available funds until their final<br />

payment.<br />

Payments upon decisions refer to the expropriated<br />

property rights of former holder, but in most cases<br />

compensation is paid to the successors on which the<br />

total amount is divided, on six-month instalments.<br />

By now, 53 valid and enforceable decisions, whose<br />

total value is 9.530.388,66 EUR were delivered to the<br />

Compensation Fund, by Municipal Commissions for<br />

Restitution and Compensation.<br />

First payments of the compensation started year<br />

and a half after the day of enactment of the Law, which<br />

is significantly shorter period when compared to<br />

countries in the region, which even initiated restitution<br />

process several years ago. In those countries the<br />

procedure is still not over, and payment of the compensation<br />

in bonds started only after four years and<br />

more from the enactment of the Law on Restitution.<br />

(Slovenia 1992, Macedonia 1996, et al.).<br />

With the enactment of the Decree on Bond Issue<br />

Method and the Procedure of Exercising of Rights for<br />

Reimbursement of Former Holders and Decision on<br />

Bonds Issue of the Republic of Montenegro Based on<br />

the compensation of former holders, conditions were<br />

met for compensation to be performed also in bonds.<br />

Bonds can be sold or used for purchase of stocks,<br />

shares and other property of the Republic of Montenegro<br />

and state funds, in accordance to the regulations<br />

on privatisation. Trade with bonds on the market<br />

is performed according to the regulations that regulate<br />

securities trading, or at the exchange market, through<br />

authorised participant in the equity market.<br />

According to the provisions of the Article 25 of the<br />

Law and the Decision on Bond Issue, 28 certificates<br />

Decisions were delivered by following municipal<br />

commissions: Podgorica (5), Budva(1), Cetinje(2), Nikšić(9),<br />

Pljevlja (29), Danilovgrad (4) and Bijelo Polje<br />

(3).<br />

Upon all decisions that came in first six-months instalment<br />

was paid to the total amount of 527.259,05<br />

EUR.<br />

Upon all individual decisions during 2006, payment<br />

of the second and third six-month instalment<br />

matures.<br />

Deadline for submission of claims of former holders<br />

for restitution of expropriated property has expired<br />

in all commissions except in Commission Kotor (it<br />

expires at the beginning of 2007), and in Žabljak the<br />

Commission still has not been formed.<br />

Director of the Compensation Fund<br />

ĐORĐINA LAKIĆ<br />

14


By restitution bonds to the state property<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

BY RESTITUTION BONDS<br />

TO THE STATE PROPERTY<br />

Goverment of the Republic of Montenegro<br />

Government of the Republic of Montenegro at its session<br />

dated June 20, 2006, made a Decision on<br />

Amendments and supplements to the Decision on<br />

Conditions and Procedure of Purchase of the Property of<br />

the Republic of Montenegro by Bonds of Foreign Exchange<br />

Savings of the Citizens. The aforementioned changes of the<br />

existing decision enables purchasing of the state property -<br />

real estate by means of bonds of the Fund for Indemnification.<br />

By amendments to this legal act by means of bonds of<br />

the Fund for Indemnification it is possible to buy property<br />

of the Republic, which is determined by the Government for<br />

that purpose, equally as with the bonds of old foreign exchange<br />

savings. By enforcement of the mentioned amendments<br />

apart from shares of economic associations in the state<br />

property and property of state funds, it will be possible to<br />

buy certain real estate from the state property fund with the<br />

restitution bonds.<br />

In the essence, the amendments serve to completely<br />

equalize the bonds of the Fund for Indemnification in terms<br />

of possibility of their usage for purchase of shares and property<br />

of the state and state funds with the bonds of old foreign<br />

currency savings.<br />

On that occasion, along with amendments and supplements<br />

to the Decision the Ministry of Finance proposed an<br />

additional list of state property for this purpose, which will<br />

also be published in the "Official Gazette of the RoM". The<br />

list consists of one residential building in Bar, hotels "Šavnik"<br />

and "Boan", several business premises in Budva, Bijelo Polje,<br />

Nikšić, Šavnik, three premises in Podgorica, department<br />

store in Šavnik, house with a courtyard in Žabljak, facility for<br />

catering business in Plav etc. The extended list will also consist<br />

of a building in noneconomic business in Bijelo Polje.<br />

The list will be supplemented with new real estate, which<br />

will be proposed to the Government of the RoM by the Ministry<br />

of Finance. The practice will be continued and it will<br />

increase the offer to the owners of foreign exchange bonds<br />

and bonds of the Fund for Restitution, in order that they realize<br />

them before the time of their maturity.<br />

KRSTO RACKOVIĆ,<br />

Assistant to the Minister of Finance<br />

15


Contents of draft law on tax advisors<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

CONTENTS OF DRAFT LAW<br />

ON TAX ADVISORS<br />

RATIONALE OF LAW<br />

Adoption of a separate Law on Tax Advisors is aimed at<br />

ensuring a more favourable environment and infrastructure<br />

required for efficient implementation of the tax and customs<br />

regulations in practice. Introduction of a tax advisor as<br />

an independent expert will allow the taxpayers to be advised<br />

about the tax and customs issues in a qualified and professional<br />

manner. The tax advisors shall be authorized to represent<br />

the taxpayers professionally before administrative<br />

authorities (Tax Administration, Customs Administration<br />

and Ministry of Finance) as well as before competent courts.<br />

Draft Law on Tax Advisors (hereinafter referred to as:<br />

Draft Law), which was drafted by the Ministry of Finance,<br />

has been placed at the Ministry's web site: www.ministarstvo-finansija.vlada.cg.yu,<br />

and all interested persons may<br />

send related remarks or suggestions. The Law is expected to<br />

be adopted in the Parliament by the end of 2006.<br />

WHAT IT TAKES TO BE A TAX ADVISOR<br />

According to the Draft Law, the tax advisory services<br />

may be provided by a natural person as an independent activity<br />

or a legal person (partnership) specialized in providing<br />

tax advisory services. A natural person who provides<br />

tax advisory services independently, may not be employed<br />

with another natural or legal person.<br />

The Draft Law defines general and special conditions to<br />

be met by a person who wants to become a certified tax advisor.<br />

General conditions to be met: a tax advisor shall (1) be a<br />

Montenegrin citizen; (2) have general physical and mental<br />

abilities and (3) have no criminal records that make him/her<br />

ineligible for doing the tax advisor's activities, such as criminal<br />

offence against: property; payment operations and commercial<br />

operations; state authorities; judiciary and legal duty,<br />

during the period of five years following validity of relevant<br />

court decree.<br />

Special conditions to be met: a tax advisor shall (1) be a<br />

graduate lawyer or economist; (2) have at least 10 years of<br />

working experience in tax or customs related assignments<br />

and (3) have passed an exam for becoming a tax advisor and<br />

have approval for work.<br />

In order to become a certified tax advisor, a person shall<br />

have to pass an exam for tax advisor. The exam shall be taken<br />

before a special commission to be established by the Ministry<br />

of Finance, which shall be composed of at least five<br />

members, half of them being from the Ministry of Finance,<br />

Tax and Customs Authority, while the other members shall<br />

be experts in economics and law theory and practice respectively.<br />

Exam for becoming a tax advisor shall be taken in compliance<br />

with a program to be recommended by the Chamber<br />

of Tax Advisors and adopted by the Ministry of Finance.<br />

A person taking the exam shall bear related expenses, while<br />

the amount shall be determined by the Ministry of Finance<br />

at the proposal of the Chamber.<br />

According to the Draft Law, the Ministry of Finance<br />

shall be authorized to issue a license for work to a certain<br />

number of recognized tax advisors (but not more than five)<br />

without taking a special exam. The above has been suggested<br />

for the purpose of speeding up the process of establishing<br />

a professional association (the Chamber), which<br />

requires recruitment of 10 tax advisors in order to become<br />

16


Contents of draft law on tax advisors<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Assistant Minister<br />

Koviljka Mihailović<br />

Senior Advisor<br />

Antoaneta Krivokapić<br />

operational.<br />

The Chamber shall issue a license for work to a tax advisor,<br />

which shall be subject to renewal every five years. A tax<br />

advisor who has been engaged in tax or customs business<br />

over the last three years may not be awarded a contract on<br />

tax advisory services within a year from a date of obtaining<br />

the license.<br />

RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS<br />

OF TAX ADVISORS<br />

services.<br />

The Draft Law provides for liability insurance in case of<br />

possible damage caused to a client by a tax advisor or specialized<br />

partnership while discharging their duties. The lowest<br />

insurance rate per a tax advisor amounts 10.000,00 eur.<br />

State authorities and legal persons having public authority<br />

shall be obliged to provide a tax advisor with all information<br />

that he/she may require.<br />

JOINING THE CHAMBER<br />

According to the Draft Law, a tax advisor shall be authorized<br />

and obliged to represent taxpayers in line with the tax<br />

regulations and his/her personal principle. A tax advisor<br />

shall be obliged to abide by the principles of legality, scrupulousness,<br />

competence and professional code to be enacted<br />

by a competent Chamber. A written contract on tax advisor's<br />

services shall be concluded, while the provision of services<br />

shall be charged at a rate to be determined by the<br />

Chamber with prior approval from the Ministry of Finance.<br />

A tax advisor shall discharge his/her duties based on data<br />

and documents provided by a client with whom a contract<br />

is concluded. The tax advisor shall keep such data confidential.<br />

One or more tax advisors may establish a specialized association<br />

for tax advisory services (partnership). The Chamber<br />

shall give an approval for registration of such partnership<br />

into the relevant register of companies. All rights and<br />

obligations related to the tax advisors shall also apply to the<br />

partnerships for tax advisory services. Competent Chamber<br />

shall supervise the work of the partnership for tax advisory<br />

According to the Draft Law, tax advisors shall be obliged<br />

to join the professional Chamber (Chamber of Tax Advisors),<br />

being an independent and self-governing organization<br />

having a legal person capacity. The Chamber shall introduce<br />

tax advisors, promote their work and represent their<br />

common interests. The Chamber shall also be obliged to keep<br />

relevant registers (on passed exams, issued licenses<br />

etc).The Chamber shall, under its Statute, more precisely define<br />

issues related to its organization, membership fee and<br />

other issues relevant for its work.<br />

KOVILJKA MIHAILOVIĆ,<br />

Assistant Minister<br />

ANTOANETA KRIVOKAPIĆ,<br />

Senior Advisor<br />

17


Procedures In the tax procedure<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

PROCEDURES<br />

IN THE TAX PROCEDURE<br />

NORMATIVE DECISIONS<br />

• Law on Tax Administration (''Official Gazette of the<br />

RoM'', No. 65/01 and 80/04);<br />

- Regulations on Form and Contents of Statements of<br />

Witholding Taxes Payments (''Official Gazette of the RoM'',<br />

No. 31/02, 33/02 and 67/02);<br />

- Regulations on Criterion for Determination of Big<br />

Taxpayers (''Official Gazette of the RoM'', No. 16/05);<br />

- Decree on Level of Tax Obligations Enforcement<br />

(''Official Gazette of the RoM'', No. 24/05);<br />

- Regulations on Form and Contents of Registration<br />

Form for Taxpayers (''Official Gazette of the RoM'', No.<br />

24/05);<br />

- Regulations on Manner of Tax Base Determination by<br />

Means of Evaluation (''Official Gazette of the RoM'', No.<br />

36/05);<br />

- Regulations on the Manner of Sale of Taxpayer's Property<br />

in the Procedure of Enforcement of Claims (''Official<br />

Gazette of the RoM'', No. 36/05, 73/05 and 33/06);<br />

Subsidiary application of the following Laws:<br />

• Law on General Administrative Procedure (''Official<br />

Gazette of the RoM'', No. 60/03);<br />

• Law on Inspection Control (''Official Gazette of the<br />

RoM'', No. 39/03);<br />

• Law on Executive Procedure (''Official Gazette of the<br />

RoM'', No. 23/04);<br />

• Law on Mortgage (''Official Gazette of the RoM'', No.<br />

52/04);<br />

• Law on Pledge (''Official Gazette of the RoM'', No.<br />

38/02).<br />

BASIC CHARACTERISTICS<br />

OF THE LAW ON TAX<br />

ADMINISTRATION<br />

- Law on Tax Administration is based upon the positive<br />

experiences from the Anglo-Saxon and European Tax Legislation,<br />

as well as the legislations of certain countries in transition<br />

(countries of former Yugoslavia and Eastern European<br />

countries);<br />

Chief of the Department for the Second Instance<br />

Administrative and Customs Procedure<br />

- It represents a codification of legal standards (procedures),<br />

which regulate the procedure of determination, control<br />

and collection of taxes and other duties depending on the<br />

type of tax as well as other issues, which should have been<br />

regulated in a different manner than in the manner regulated<br />

by the general regulation due to their peculiarity;<br />

- Subsidiary application of the Law on General Administrative<br />

Procedure and the Law on Inspection Control is regulated<br />

for all the issues of procedure that have not been regulated<br />

by this law, while the instructing norm for application<br />

of the Law on Executive Procedure, Law on Mortgage or<br />

Law on Pledge is offered for certain issues;<br />

- Self-taxation is the basic principle in the procedure of<br />

determination and enforcement of taxes and other duties;<br />

- Assessment principle has been established as authorization<br />

and obligation of the tax authority in the situations<br />

when tax determination is not executed or incompletely or<br />

wrongly executed by the principle of self-taxation, or if it is<br />

regulated by the tax law.<br />

SELF-TAXATION<br />

IN THE TAX SYSTEM<br />

Pero Mrdak<br />

- Self-taxation is voluntary participation of a taxpayer in<br />

tax events in accordance with the tax laws;<br />

18


Procedures In the tax procedure<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

For implemetation of the system of self-taxation it is necessary:<br />

- To execute registration of taxpayer with the competent<br />

tax authority and assign him/her a tax identification number<br />

(TIN);<br />

- To provide that the taxpayer, tax authority and all the<br />

mediators in tax events to use the tax identification number<br />

in the way that TIM is filled in all the documents and it becomes<br />

the basic connection in relation to all taxpayer's transactions;<br />

- To publish all the laws and other tax regulations duly in<br />

the ''Official Gazette of the Republic of Montenegro'';<br />

- To produce and make available in due time and free of<br />

charge registration forms, tax returns, statements, records<br />

etc., as well as the instructions to fill in the same to taxpayers<br />

and tax mediators;<br />

- That taxpayer duly keeps business records, executes documentation<br />

composing in due time and provides other data<br />

and information, which he/she can use to calculate the tax<br />

obligation in accordance with the requests of the tax law;<br />

- That the taxpayer prepares and files a tax return in due<br />

time and accurately, without previous consultation with the<br />

tax authority;<br />

- That the taxpayer, according to his own initiative or initiative<br />

of tax authority, corrects in due time the incomplete<br />

or wrongly filled tax returns;<br />

- That the tax authority provides for a fair and impartial<br />

relation to all the taxpayers, treating the tax return data with<br />

full confidentiality, and keeps records of the declared tax<br />

amount in the account of taxpayer without any check up, as<br />

well as all the changes, which occur according to the proposal<br />

of taxpayer or on the basis of the findings of the inspection<br />

control of the tax authority;<br />

- That tax authority consistently applies offence and other<br />

sanctions regulated by the law and calculates interest rate<br />

in accordance with the law aimed at change of the taxpayer's<br />

behaviour and creation of tax discipline, not in any<br />

case for the purpose of reprisal due to non-execution of the<br />

law;<br />

- That tax authority establishes efficient tax administration,<br />

supported by powerful information system, connected<br />

to the integral information system of the Republic;<br />

- This system may not be open to negotiations, bargaining,<br />

arbitrary approvals or non-acceptance of tax credits,<br />

postponement of obligations to file tax returns, statements,<br />

payments and slective approach in relation to taking measures<br />

of enforcement of claims against taxpayers.<br />

TAX AUTHORITY COMPETENCE<br />

- Activities of determination, collection and control of taxes,<br />

which are introduced by the Republic, are performed by<br />

the competent Republic administration authority - Tax Administration<br />

of the Republic of Montenegro;<br />

- Activities of determination, collection and control of taxes,<br />

which are introduced by the Office of Local Governance,<br />

are performed by the competent authority of the local<br />

governance;<br />

AUTHORIZATION<br />

OF THE TAX AUTHORITY<br />

• In realization of its competences regulated by the law<br />

the tax authority is authorized to:<br />

- Perform inspection activities, take collection measures<br />

and other actions and activities it is in charge of according<br />

to the laws;<br />

- Make decisions on the rights of taxpayers;<br />

- Register taxpayers and keeps tax register;<br />

- Perform determination of taxes in the way and according<br />

to the procedure regulated by the law;<br />

- Request from the taxpayers and other legal persons to<br />

submit the documentation and offer other necessary information<br />

for determination of tax obligation;<br />

- Invite persons to participate in the tax procedure;<br />

- Come in and search the business premises, in which are<br />

kept or may be kept the business documents and records or<br />

other objects necessary for tax regulations application;<br />

- Exclude the business documents and records and other<br />

objects necessary for tax regulations application in accordance<br />

with the law;<br />

- Pronounce penalties for tax offences regulated by tax<br />

laws;<br />

- Use services of experts and masters, physical and legal<br />

persons in the procedure of determination of tax obligations,<br />

when professional knowledge is necessary;<br />

- Institute and conduct first instance administrative and<br />

offence proceeding;<br />

- Plan and implement training of employees;<br />

- Keep tax records;<br />

- Inform the taxpayers on inspection control development<br />

and on their rights and obligations in that procedure;<br />

- Offer professional assistance to the taxpayers in relation<br />

to application of tax regulations;<br />

- Provide the taxpayers with a tax return form free of<br />

charge;<br />

- Keep tax secret;<br />

- Refer to taxpayers and other persons with respect and<br />

consideration;<br />

- File criminal charges, economic offence charges i.e. request<br />

for instituting offence proceeding;<br />

- Send the information, including tax secrets, which were<br />

revealed during criminal investigation or which were come<br />

across during such due dilligence, to the authorities in charge<br />

of law implementation, when there is a founded suspicion<br />

that an offence or criminal act were committed;<br />

- Apply international agreements and contracts on avoidance<br />

of double taxation and other advantages related to<br />

19


Procedures In the tax procedure<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

tax payment;<br />

- Prepare statements about situation in the field of taxes;<br />

- Give initiative for adopting regulations and other acts<br />

for arrangement of tax system and tax policy of the Ministry<br />

of Finance;<br />

- Cooperate with other authorities and organizations in<br />

the country and abroad about issues related to criminal tax<br />

acts and in accordance with the international contracts or<br />

agreements;<br />

- Take measures that are necessary for tax officers' security;<br />

- Take measures for preventing corruption of officers in<br />

performing their official duties;<br />

- Organize functioning of Single Information System in<br />

the field of taxes;<br />

- Provide for execution of statements and conclusions of<br />

the Government in the field of taxes.<br />

authority in due time and in the manner determined by tax<br />

regulations;<br />

- Report to the tax authority in charge any change of the<br />

main place of doing business, i.e. residence and other data<br />

from the register of taxpayer;<br />

- Keep business books and records in the regulated manner<br />

and maintain them in accordance with the law;<br />

- Settle tax obligations in the manner and within terms<br />

determined by the law and other regulation adopted pursuant<br />

to the law;<br />

- Submit documents and other data, which are necessary<br />

for determination of tax obligation at the request of tax authority;<br />

- Enable undisturbed work of employees of the tax authority<br />

in performing their legal authorizations;<br />

- Execute other obligations determined by the tax regulations.<br />

RIGHTS OF THE TAXPAYER<br />

REGISTRATION OF TAXPAYERS<br />

• Taxpayer is entitled to:<br />

- Be informed about all issues, which enable him/her to<br />

file and pay the tax obligations accurately and in due time;<br />

- Request from the tax authority to keep secret the collected<br />

data about tax obligation determination and use<br />

them i.e. reveal it only to the institutions and bodies in the<br />

manner and according to the procedure regulated by this<br />

law;<br />

- Request reexamination and new determination of<br />

his/her tax obligation, in the way which is regulated by this<br />

law;<br />

- Get free of charge from his/her tax authority information<br />

on tax regulations, rights and obligations, which arise<br />

from them;<br />

- Get tax return form and other tax forms;<br />

- Enjoy respect and consideration of the tax authority;<br />

- Represent his/her own interests to the tax authorities,<br />

alone or through his/her authorized person;<br />

- Use tax reliefs in accordance with the tax regulations;<br />

- Get insight into data on determination and collection of<br />

tax obligation, which are kept about him/her with the tax<br />

authority and request change of inaccurate and incomplete<br />

data;<br />

- Attend the inspection control;<br />

- Use also other rights envisaged by the law.<br />

OBLIGATIONS OF TAX PAYER<br />

• Taxpayer is obliged to:<br />

- File a tax return for the purpose of registration to the<br />

tax authority in charge;<br />

- Calculate accurately the tax and file tax return to the tax<br />

• Registration of taxpayers is performed by entry into<br />

the register of taxpayers, which is kept by the tax authority<br />

in charge:<br />

- Registration is performed on the basis of registration<br />

forms PR-1 and PR-2, which are submitted by the taxpayer;<br />

- Registration form PR-1 is submitted by the taxpayers, legal<br />

persons or organizations, which earn income in the Republic<br />

or outside the Republic and foreign legal persons or<br />

organizations, which earn their income in the Republic;<br />

- Registration form PR-2 is submitted by physical persons,<br />

who earn their income or possess property in the Republic<br />

or outside the Republic and foreign physical persons, who<br />

earn their income or possess property in the Republic;<br />

- Legal persons and organizations submit their registration<br />

forms to the tax authority, which is in charge of that person's<br />

main place of doing business, i.e. organization within<br />

five working days from the day of entry into the court or other<br />

register;<br />

- Physical persons submit their registration form to the<br />

tax authority according to the place of residence, i.e. living<br />

place of these persons within five working days from the<br />

day of earning the taxable income, entry into the relevant register,<br />

i.e. acquiring the property, which is subject to taxation;<br />

- Physical persons, who do not have residence, i.e living<br />

place, submit their registration form to the tax authority headquarters,<br />

within five working days from the day of earning<br />

taxable income, i.e. acquiring property, which is subject<br />

to taxation;<br />

- Legal persons - big taxpayers, listed according to the criteria<br />

for determination of big taxpayers, submit their registration<br />

form to the the headquarters of the tax authority;<br />

- Along with the registration form the taxpayers submit<br />

also evidence about identification (act on registration of le-<br />

20


Procedures In the tax procedure<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

gal person or entrepreneur, personal ID, passport, driving licence,<br />

certificate on Household, title deed, evidence about<br />

emplyment);<br />

- If legal or physical person does not submit a registration<br />

form within the regulated deadline, the tax authority<br />

will submit the form for these persons on the basis of available<br />

data;<br />

- For the purpose of identification of taxpayer, the tax<br />

authority makes decision about registration, by which the legal<br />

and physical persons are given PIB;<br />

- PIB is single and only number of legal i.e. physical person<br />

for all kinds of taxes and it is kept in case of change of<br />

registered office, residence i.e. living place of the taxpayer;<br />

• PIB is entred into:<br />

- Act, which is submitted to the tax authority, state authorities<br />

and authorities of local administration by the taxpayer;<br />

- Act, which is submitted to the taxpayer by the tax authority;<br />

- Order according to which the taxpayer pays the tax<br />

obligation.<br />

DETERMINATION OF TAX<br />

OBLIGATION BY MEANS OF<br />

TAX RETURN (SELF-TAXATION)<br />

- Tax procedure is started by filing a tax return in the way<br />

and within the terms regulated by the law, which regulates<br />

certain types of taxes.;<br />

- Tax return is filed by taxpayer to the tax authority,<br />

which entered him/her in its register of taxpayers;<br />

- If the tax return is not filed by taxpayer within the envisaged<br />

term, the tax authority will file it within three days<br />

from the day it got information that the tax return is not filed;<br />

- The tax authority is authorized to fill up the incomplete<br />

and correct the wrongly completed tax return, immediatelly<br />

after it got information about omissions and mistakes in the<br />

filed tax return and to inform the taxpayer about that;<br />

- Taxpayer is entitled to file a changed tax return within<br />

10 days from the day of expiration of term for filing the tax<br />

return, in case of a mistake or omission in the tax return;<br />

- The tax return is filed by filling up the form regulated by<br />

the Ministry of Finance in accordance with the law, which<br />

regulates individual types of taxes;<br />

- Tax return is filed by the taxpayer himself or through<br />

the authorized person;<br />

- The tax return must consist of the PIB of the taxpayer<br />

and authorized person, if the tax return is filed by that authorized<br />

person;<br />

- Tax return is filed to the tax authority directly, by postl<br />

or electronic mail;;<br />

- Tax authority is obliged to receive the filed tax return regardless<br />

of its accuracy, and if the tax return is filed directly,<br />

the tax authority will on the basis of visual control, indicate<br />

to the taxpayer obvious mistakes or omissions, which<br />

he/she can correct within the term for its filing;<br />

- Determination of tax obligation is performed by the<br />

taxpayer on the basis of data from the business records and<br />

documentation, which he is obliged to keep according to<br />

the law, i.e. the newly registered taxpayer on the basis of estimate<br />

of the income to be earned in the tax period for<br />

which he/she files the tax return.<br />

DETERMINATION OF<br />

TAX OBLIGATION BY THE<br />

TAX AUTHORITY<br />

• The tax authority determines the tax obligation if:<br />

- Taxpayer did not file a tax return;<br />

- The tax return is filed incorrectly or incompletely and<br />

the mistake is not corrected or the new tax return is not filed<br />

within the legal term;<br />

- During the inspection control procedure, on the basis<br />

of new facts and circumstances, the inspection states that<br />

the taxpayer did not determine the tax properly;<br />

- It is regulated by the tax law (assessed taxes);<br />

- Determination of tax obligation is performed by the tax<br />

authority on the basis of business books, records of the taxpayer;<br />

- If the tax authority can not determine the tax obligation<br />

on the basis of business books and records of the taxpayer<br />

then it will determine the tax obligation on the basis of the<br />

tax base estimate;<br />

• In the course of tax obligation determination by tax base<br />

estimate, the tax authority proceeds from:<br />

- Available duly business documentation, if it is not entered<br />

in the books;<br />

- Available duly business documentation about doing business<br />

within a certain period, which is shorter than the taxation<br />

period (daily, weekly or monthly);<br />

- Data and facts about achieved turnover (daily, weekly<br />

or monthly) found by the inspection control;<br />

- Data obtained by making comparison with other taxpayers,<br />

who do the same or similar business in the same or<br />

similar location under approximately same conditions;<br />

- Other relevant data and facts the tax authority disposes<br />

of;<br />

- The tax authority determines the tax obligation by tax<br />

decision, against which an appeal may be filed, which does<br />

not put off its non-execution.<br />

• Determination of assessed taxes<br />

- Tax authority always makes decision on determination<br />

of assessed taxes when it is regulated by the law;<br />

• Assessed taxes are:<br />

- Tax on real estate determined by the municipal tax authority;<br />

- Tax on turnover, and<br />

- Tax on turnover of used motor vehicles, vessels, airpla-<br />

21


Procedures In the tax procedure<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

nes and aircrafts.<br />

• These two taxes are determined by the Tax Administration<br />

of the Republic of Montenegro.<br />

DETERMINATION<br />

OF TAX OBLIGATION<br />

BY THE PAYING AGENT<br />

• Determination (calculation, suspension and payment)<br />

of witholding tax is done by the tax paying agent, i.e. mediator,<br />

through tax return (report) he/she files to the tax authority<br />

reskom organu as follows:<br />

- collective tax return on the same day when payment of<br />

of revenue is made and the individual tax return on January<br />

31 of the current year for the previous year at the latest.<br />

TAX OBLIGATION<br />

PAYMENT<br />

- Tax obligation is paid by the taxpayer within the term<br />

regulated by the law, which regulates individual type of tax;<br />

- Tax obligation payment is made, by rule, through the<br />

holder of payment operations, by making payments on the<br />

relevant payment accounts;<br />

- Day of tax obligation payment is considered the day<br />

when the tax obligation payment is received on the relevant<br />

payment account;<br />

- Tax obligation, which is determined in the procedure of<br />

self-taxation, is paid simultaneously with filing the tax return;<br />

- Tax obligation, which is determined by the tax decision,<br />

is paid within 10 days from the day of submitting the decision,<br />

provided that it is not regulated otherwise by the tax<br />

law.<br />

SUBJECT OF ENFORCEMENT<br />

OF CLAIMS<br />

• Subject of enforcement of claims can be:<br />

- Funds of the taxpayer;<br />

- Monetary claims of the taxpayer;<br />

- Property (movable and immovable) of the taxpayer.<br />

PLEDGE, I.E. MORTGAGE<br />

- For the purpose of tax claims security, the taxpayer's property<br />

can be mortgaged or right to pledge can be determined<br />

in the course of procedure of enforcement of claims;<br />

- Determination of right to pledge, i.e. mortgage is performed<br />

in the manner regulated by the Law on Pledge, i.e<br />

Law on Mortgage.<br />

ENFORCEMENT OF CLAIMS<br />

FROM THE FUNDS<br />

- Enforcement of claims from the funds of taxpayer is<br />

performed by transfer of funds from the account of the taxpayer<br />

to the account of the one to whom tax obligation payment<br />

is made;<br />

- Enforcement of monetary claims of the taxpayer is performed<br />

in the manner and according to the procedure regulated<br />

by the Law on Executive Procedure;<br />

- Conclusion on enforcement of claims is performed by<br />

the Central Bank of Montenegro.<br />

COLLECTION OF TAXES<br />

FROM THE PROPERTY<br />

ENFORCEMENT OF CLAIMS<br />

RELATED TO TAXES<br />

- If the taxpayer does not pay the tax obligation in the<br />

course of filing the tax return i.e. when the tax decision became<br />

executive, the tax authority undertakes the procedure<br />

of enforcement of claims;<br />

- The enforcement of claims procedure is initiated by the<br />

conclusion on enforcement of claims related to tax obligations;<br />

- An appeal can be filed against the decision on enforcement<br />

of claims related to tax obligation and the appeal does<br />

not put off the execution of conclusion.<br />

- Enforcement of claims related to tax obligations<br />

from the property of the taxpayer consists of attachment<br />

and sale of property (movable and immovable) and usage<br />

of funds obtained through the sale or other procedure to collect<br />

the tax obligation.<br />

PROPERTY ATTACHMENT<br />

- Attachment consists of inventory and estimate of property;<br />

- Attachment is [erformed by an officer of the tax authority<br />

in the presence of two witnesses;<br />

- Attachment procedure lasts until the tax obligatin is settled<br />

or until the enforvcement of claims is discontinued;<br />

22


Procedures In the tax procedure<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

- The authorized officer makes minutes about the implemented<br />

attachment procedure, in which he states apart<br />

from the title of the authority, names and surnames of the<br />

authorized officer and witnesses, name and surname, title,<br />

residence i.e base and PIB of the taxpayer, inserts also the<br />

place and time of attachment, debt amount, interest rate and<br />

costs of the attachment, name, sign and description of the attached<br />

object, value of the attached object according to the<br />

estimate, surname, name, address and residence of the person<br />

to which the attached object is left to keep it;<br />

- The taxpayer and other persons from which the property<br />

was attached are each given a copy of the attachment minutes.<br />

ATTACHED PROPERTY SALE<br />

- Attached property sale is done by the tax authority that<br />

carried out the attachment, through an announcement of<br />

the property sale, which is announced in the media and in<br />

the notice-board of the tax authority within five days from<br />

the day of attachment;<br />

- Officers of the tax authority, spouse, ancestors and descendants<br />

of the officers, then ancestors and descendants of<br />

his/her spouse can not take part in the announcement for<br />

public bidding neither directly nor indirectly;<br />

- In case that the attached property is nondurable, when<br />

the value of the attached property is less than 10 thousand<br />

Euro and when the tax authority estimates that there are extremely<br />

important circumstances, which justify unpostponable<br />

sale, the sale can be executed by direct deal;<br />

- The funds earned through the attached property sale<br />

are used to settle the tax obligations in the following order:<br />

procedure costs, interest rate, tax.<br />

INSPECTION CONTROL<br />

- Inspection control includes the procedure of checking<br />

the facts and data that are important for the taxpayers and<br />

other persons' taxation and taking measures in accordance<br />

with the law;<br />

- Inspection control is performed by the tax authority<br />

through tax inspectors;<br />

• The inspection control procedure is initiated by the order<br />

for incpection control, which contains:<br />

- Subject of the inspection control,<br />

- Period of the inspection control,<br />

- Form of the inspection control (office or on-site control),<br />

- Time (start) of the inspection control,<br />

• Order for the inspection control is submitted to the<br />

taxpayer 15 days i.e. to big taxpayers 30 days before starting<br />

the control.<br />

MEASURES<br />

OF THE INSPECTION<br />

• In the course of inspection the tax inspector is obliged<br />

and authorized to order taking following measures:<br />

- Submit needed documentation and data;<br />

- Temporary dipossess the documentation, equipment<br />

and working devices;<br />

- Compulsory open or close the facilities for the purpose<br />

of inspection activities;<br />

- Prohibit disposal of the funds on the account;<br />

- Prohibit performing the activities, i.e. performing certain<br />

activities for a certain period of time;<br />

- Temporary dispossess illegally obtained property benefits;<br />

- Temporary dispossess raw materials, production materials,<br />

semi-manufactured products, finished products and<br />

goods which are not accompanied with the evidence about<br />

supply, when the goods are put into circulation by a person,<br />

who is not registered for that or does not have evidence oabut<br />

the origin of goods, when the circulatiion of products is<br />

done without a proscribed mark, when the goods are transported<br />

without obligatory documentation and when the<br />

goods are sold outside the business registered office or other<br />

place, which is determined by the competents state authority;<br />

- Files a complaint to the competent authority for a committed<br />

criminal act or economic offence and submits a request<br />

for instituting the offence proceeding;<br />

- Pronounces mandatory penalty;<br />

- Take other measures that he is authorized by means of<br />

the law and other tax regulations.<br />

LIMITATIONS<br />

- Limitation period for the right to tax obligation determination<br />

is five years from the expiry of the year in which<br />

the obligation was to be determined;<br />

- Limitation period for the right to tax obligation collection<br />

is three years from expiration of the year in which<br />

the tax was determined;<br />

- Limitation period for return of the excess payment<br />

of tax obligation is three years from expiration of the year in<br />

which the excess payment was made;<br />

- Limitation period for the right to determination, collection<br />

and return of tax is always 10 years from the expiry<br />

of the year in which the tax was to be determined, collected<br />

i.e. in which the excess payment was made.<br />

Prepared by: PERO MRDAK,<br />

Chief of the Department for the Second Instance<br />

Administrative and Customs Procedure<br />

23


„1000 housing credits”<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

PROJECT OF THE<br />

GOVERNMENT OF MONTENEGRO<br />

„1000 HOUSING CREDITS”<br />

In order to help certain number of citizens, and employees<br />

in the public administration bodies to solve housing<br />

issues, Ministry of Finance and Commission for Housing<br />

Issues of the Government of Montenegro created the project<br />

"1000 housing credits". The project was worked out in<br />

order to provide opportunity to persons with inadequately<br />

solved housing issues to purchase new housing objects, and<br />

the reconstruction of the existing ones, through credit allocation,<br />

with subsidized interest rates.<br />

For the purpose of stated project, Government of Montenegro<br />

has made conclusions at the session on 16th March<br />

2006 and entrusted with them the Ministry of Finance and<br />

the Commission for Housing Issues to prepare and to deliver<br />

to the Government directions for method and criteria of<br />

allocation of funds earmarked for project realisation, and to<br />

make adequate contracts with commercial banks.<br />

In accordance to that, Commission for Housing Issues<br />

of the Republic of Montenegro has formed Work<br />

group for implementation of procedure of credit indebtedness<br />

in the Project "1000 housing credits". Work group<br />

has prepared the procedure and determined criteria for<br />

credit allocation on public administration bodies, and<br />

the content of the Public invitation for Project "1000 housing<br />

credits".<br />

Based on the conclusions of the Government of the Republic<br />

of Montenegro, Ministry of Finance and the Commission<br />

have included into the project commercial banks in<br />

Montenegro. In accordance to that, contracts have been concluded<br />

with Crnogorska komercijalna banka, Montenegro-<br />

NLB Bank, Podgoricka- Societe Generale Bank, Hypo-Alpe-<br />

Adria Bank and Niksicka Bank. Those contracts define<br />

rights and liabilities of the Ministry of Finance, of the Commission,<br />

banks and ultimate credit beneficiaries.<br />

In order to introduce the content of the project to citizens<br />

and employees in the public administration bodies, Ministry<br />

of Finance and Commission have announced Public<br />

24


„1000 housing credits”<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

claims, provided for under the Public invitation, banks and<br />

state authorities were obliged to process the received claims<br />

in the period of 20 days, and deliver lists of approved claims<br />

to the Commission. By consideration of mentioned lists it is<br />

determined that the total number of claims is 184, which have<br />

met conditions of banks, which was less than the determined<br />

quota of 200 credit claims projected for citizens. Therefore,<br />

Work group has accepted lists from all banks, with all<br />

claims and amounts, as they were submitted to the Commission.<br />

In accordance to that, the Work group sent the draft<br />

conclusion to the Commission to verify mentioned lists of<br />

banks and to inform banks about that.<br />

Senior employee<br />

Dragan Darmanović<br />

invitation for participation in allocation of "1000 housing<br />

credits".<br />

Public invitation was announced on 10th May 2006, and<br />

it lasted for 15 days. During that period, as it was defined by<br />

the Public invitation, citizens submitted their claims to<br />

banks, while employees in the public administration bodies<br />

submitted their claims in bodies where they work.<br />

Public invitation defines that project "1000 housing credits"<br />

should comprise following credit lines:<br />

• 200 credits for reconstruction to the amounts up to<br />

5.000 eur, and repayment period up to 5 years;<br />

• 300 credits for enlargement and/or supplemental purchase<br />

of the housing to the amounts up to 15.000 eur and repayment<br />

periods up to 10 years; and<br />

• 500 credits for solving of housing issue to the amount<br />

up to 30.000 eur and repayment periods up to 20 years.<br />

Of anticipated 1000 housing credits, 800 credits were<br />

earmarked public servants, out of which: 600 housing credits<br />

for employees in the government administration bodies,<br />

200 housing credits for employees in the Health Insurance<br />

Fund of the Republic and other public medical institutions.<br />

For citizens of the Republic of Montenegro 200 housing credits<br />

were projected.<br />

Public invitation determined that claimants should submit<br />

data on whether they possess housing or is it inadequate,<br />

on the years of service, and on number of family members.<br />

The project estimated that the total interest rate of the<br />

bank is 6,4% yearly. For ultimate credit beneficiaries interest<br />

rate was 4% yearly, while the Government of the Republic of<br />

Montenegro accepted to subsidize rate with 2,4% yearly.<br />

Subsidized interest rate amount Ministry of Finance would<br />

pay by more instalments, during the period not longer than<br />

3 years.<br />

After the expiration of the deadline for submission of<br />

Commission verified and approved the lists and informed<br />

the banks regarding that. After the approval, banks started<br />

the procedure of concluding contracts with citizens, for<br />

the purpose of realisation of the approved housing credits.<br />

Furthermore, the Commission also received lists of employees<br />

in the governmental bodies, which have submitted<br />

their claims to heads of the governmental bodies where they<br />

work in. Bodies made lists where the employees were ranked<br />

according to the terms specified in the Public invitation<br />

(years of service, number of household members and solved<br />

housing issue). After the consideration of the received<br />

claims, Work group stated that the large number of claims<br />

was received from public administration bodies (over two<br />

thousand), and has made credit reallocation based on the<br />

previously fixed quota and methodology. Based on that,<br />

Work group has made credit allocation according to bodies,<br />

and determined how many credits belong to which body.<br />

After the claim analysis, 595 credits were granted, out of<br />

which 301 to the amount up to 30.000eur, 183 up to 15.000<br />

eur and 111 credits up to 5.000 eur. To the Health Insurance<br />

Fund of the Republic and other medical institutions, for<br />

which 200 credits were provided for under the Public invitation,<br />

185 credits were allocated, 93 credits up to 30.000 eur,<br />

56 up to 15.000 eur and 36 up to 5.000 eur, while the remaining<br />

15 credits will be subsequently allocated within the<br />

medical institutions.<br />

Commission adopted the suggestions of the Work group<br />

at the session held on 14.06.2006, and informed governmental<br />

bodies and banks about its decision, so that signing of<br />

contract between employees in the governmental bodies<br />

and banks could begin.<br />

Public servants, who according to the rank-list made by<br />

the public administration bodies have passed the selection,<br />

will conclude with banks contracts on allocation of housing<br />

credits, if they fulfil terms of the banks.<br />

Senior advisor<br />

DRAGAN DARMANOVIĆ<br />

25


European Bank for Reconstruction and Development<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

EUROPEAN BANK FOR<br />

RECONSTRUCTION<br />

AND DEVELOPMENT<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

European Bank for Reconstruction and Development<br />

(EBRD) was established in 1991 with a view to speed up<br />

and strengthen market reform process and transition in<br />

Central and East European countries and create conditions<br />

for efficient functioning of open market economies<br />

in these countries. It is owned by 60 countries and two intergovernmental<br />

institutions. EBRD, with its capital, is the<br />

largest single investor in the region.<br />

The Bank uses its relationship with the governments<br />

in the region to promote creating of better and more efficient<br />

business environment. The mandate of the EBRD<br />

stipulates that it must only work with the countries that<br />

are committed to democratic principles. Respect for the<br />

environment is an integral part of the strong corporate<br />

governance attached to all EBRD investments.<br />

EBRD, inter alia, provides project financing for banks,<br />

industries and business, both new ventures and investments<br />

in existing companies. The Bank also supports privatization<br />

process, restructuring of state-owned companies<br />

and improvement of municipal services.<br />

MEMBERSHIP OF THE STATE UNION<br />

SERBIA AND MONTENEGRO<br />

TO THE EBRD<br />

Former Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia was<br />

one of founders of the European Bank for Reconstruction<br />

and Development since 1991. Accordingly, the SFRY<br />

was entitled to use the Bank funds.<br />

After break-up of the SFRY, State Union Serbia and<br />

Montenegro (which was Federal Republic of Yugoslavia<br />

until 2003), regulated its membership to the EBRD in January<br />

2001, on the basis of Resolution No. 81 adopted by<br />

the EBRD Board of Governors on 13 December 2000 on<br />

SaM membership to the EBRD.<br />

It is noteworthy that State Union Serbia and Montenegro<br />

(SaM) hosted EBRD Annual Meeting. Namely, 14th<br />

Annual Meeting was held in Belgrade from 21-23 May<br />

2005. Serbia and Montenegro, as a host country, successfully<br />

presented and promoted its economy and potential<br />

opportunities and projects for making foreign investments<br />

to the representatives of governments, central<br />

banks, international financial institutions, banks and major<br />

companies that were present at the Annual Meeting.<br />

26


European Bank for Reconstruction and Development<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

International Co-operation and EU Integrations Department,<br />

Co-ordinator<br />

Jadranka Radunović<br />

INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS IN<br />

THE REPUBLIC OF MONTENEGRO<br />

Following renewal of SaM membership to the EBRD,<br />

Montenegro has intensively co-operated with the EBRD<br />

representatives. Over the last couple of years, EBRD invested<br />

significant funds in Montenegro by providing<br />

loans for projects in the area of transportation, air and<br />

road infrastructure as well as for the privatization of companies.<br />

• Pre- Privatization Loan for Aluminum Plant Podgorica<br />

(KAP) aimed to facilitate the preparation and implementation<br />

of the KAP privatization, with the assistance of<br />

an independent privatization adviser and independent<br />

adviser for the Project Implementation Unit.<br />

• Podgorica and Tivat Airports Modernization Project<br />

for ensuring a higher level of safety and better services in<br />

compliance with the International Civil Aviation Organization<br />

(ICAO) standards. The funds were earmarked for<br />

construction of a new passenger terminal; modernization<br />

and runway lightings of the Podgorica Airport; extension<br />

of existing passenger terminal at the Tivat Airport;<br />

procurement of fire-fighting equipment; and consulting<br />

services.<br />

• Future Air Traffic Management Modernization and<br />

Upgrading System. The credit funds were earmarked for<br />

modernization of air traffic control with a view to improving<br />

air traffic safety and capacity increasing.<br />

• Montenegro Regional Road Rehabilitation Project.<br />

The Project is aimed at rehabilitation of the road and stabilization<br />

of slopes on Mioska-Kolasin road, and construction<br />

of climbing lane at Obzovica, on the section of<br />

Cetinje-Budva road.<br />

Namely, EBRD invested in Montenegro credit funds<br />

amounting 28,18 mil. eur, out of which following projects<br />

were funded:<br />

The Bank is interested in further investing in Montenegro,<br />

primarily in terms of providing loans for projects<br />

related to improvement of transport and energy sector<br />

and regional infrastructure in the country; projects related<br />

to environmental protection along the Montenegrin<br />

Coast that are relevant for development of tourism which<br />

represents a potential for investment growth and impro-<br />

27


European Bank for Reconstruction and Development<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

EBRD<br />

vement. In order to improve tourism, the Bank is interested<br />

in funding the projects, which are mainly related to<br />

water supply; addressing the waste water disposal issue;<br />

coastline pollution etc.<br />

It is important to note that the EBRD has been funding<br />

the following programs:<br />

TurnAround Management (TAM) Program, aimed at<br />

increasing of industry-specific know-how and confidence<br />

and management level in enterprises, and<br />

Business Advisory Services (BAS) Program, providing<br />

business consulting services, where local consultants<br />

provide assistance to SMEs in their business operations,<br />

TAM and BAS programs have been financed with a view<br />

to support economic reforms in countries in transition,<br />

enabling companies to successfully conduct their<br />

business operations under market economy conditions.<br />

The programs imply business advisory services which<br />

are provided by most renowned experts in the field of<br />

business, organization of work, marketing, finance etc.<br />

The programs have been mainly financed from EU<br />

funds- through the European Agency for Reconstruction<br />

(EAR), Europe Aid, PHARE, and TASIC and from bilateral<br />

donations (Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France,<br />

Greece, Italy, USA etc.).<br />

In order to apply for participation in the TAM and<br />

BAS programs, a company needs to meet certain criteria,<br />

i.e. it should be a private local company, which may not:<br />

offer any financial and banking services; produce any military<br />

equipment and tobacco; and organize any games<br />

of chance. The company should: have developmental potentials;<br />

require consulting services and have capacities<br />

in place for implementation of assistance which has been<br />

hereunder provided.<br />

State Union Serbia and Montenegro has been included<br />

in the said program since 2000. For the purpose of<br />

the BAS Program realization, a regional office was established<br />

and became operational in Podgorica in 2003.<br />

106 projects have been launched through the regional office,<br />

which have been mainly financed from the EAR<br />

funds.<br />

Following regaining of the state sovereignty, Montenegro<br />

has undertaken steps to speed up a renewal of its<br />

membership to the EBRD and continue successful cooperation<br />

in implementation of credit arrangements that<br />

have already been or are to be launched. During the Conference<br />

of a prominent British Agency "Euromoney" in<br />

London, from 19 - 21 July 2005, the EBRD representatives<br />

and Montenegrin delegation exchanged their views on<br />

current political and economic situation in Montenegro<br />

following renewal of independence, including current<br />

projects funded by the EBRD and future projects as well,<br />

focusing on a future status and membership of Montenegro<br />

in this multilateral institution. President of the Bank,<br />

Mr. Jean Lemierre announced opening of a permanent<br />

EBRD Office in Podgorica due to increasing investment<br />

interest and for the purpose of institutional co-operation<br />

strengthening.<br />

International Co-operation<br />

and EU Integrations Department,<br />

Co-ordinator,<br />

JADRANKA RADUNOVIC<br />

28


Transfer of army property to the Republic of Montenegro<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

TRANSFER OF ARMY PROPERTY<br />

TO THE REPUBLIC<br />

OF MONTENEGRO<br />

Rule over the immovable property, which was in the former<br />

country given for utilization to the Army of Serbia<br />

and Montenegro, is one of the issues that during the<br />

past period were objects of great interest of the home-public,<br />

but also of the significant number of foreign investors.<br />

Property, which in certain procedures had been estimated<br />

as unnecessary for the Army, and for which investors have<br />

shown interest, was transferred to former Fund for the Reform<br />

of the Defence System of the Serbia and Montenegro,<br />

and all funds that were realized by sale were transferred to<br />

the accounts of the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of<br />

Montenegro. Ten objects were sold this way and the realized<br />

income was 14.1 mil eur.<br />

After the 3 June, all immovable property used by the Army<br />

at the territory of the Republic of Montenegro, became<br />

the property of the State of Montenegro. The Government<br />

of Montenegro at the session held on 08.06.2006, made conclusions<br />

which refer to the transfer of army property to the<br />

Republic of Montenegro. The conclusions defined procedures,<br />

deadlines and obligations of responsive military and other<br />

services in charge of their implementation and entrusted<br />

Ministry of Finance for coordination of activities on<br />

their realisation.<br />

Considering the fact that it is a large number of locations,<br />

out of which a significant number is very attractive, a special<br />

commission which is to perform evaluation of real necessities<br />

of the defence system in Montenegro, will be formed in<br />

the forthcoming period. Those locations which are found to<br />

be unnecessary for functioning of the new defence system<br />

shall be assigned to other governmental bodies for usage or<br />

will be subject to possible sale, rent, forming of special business<br />

companies, pooling of property etc. toward which the<br />

Government of Montenegro shall take a stand regarding<br />

each individual case.<br />

Advisor to<br />

the Minister<br />

Predrag<br />

Stamatović<br />

It is to be expected that, because of the attractiveness of<br />

locations, especially those located at the coast, a large number<br />

of international companies shall become part of this<br />

process. Aggravating circumstance for investors is that these<br />

locations are not urbanized, so a secret partnership should<br />

be made between the State as seller, local self-governments<br />

and future investors. Beside the significant income that will<br />

be realized this way, another goal that we find to be very important<br />

goal will be accomplished and that is further valorisation<br />

of space in accordance to the strategic development<br />

commitments.<br />

Advisor to the Minister<br />

PREDRAG STAMATOVIĆ<br />

29


Support to reform processes of the defence systems<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

MINISTRY OF FINANCE<br />

- SUPPORT TO REFORM PROCESSES<br />

OF THE DEFENCE SYSTEM<br />

Advisor for the Defence Budget in the<br />

Ministry of Finance<br />

of the Republic of Montenegro<br />

Mijajlo Savovic, M.A.<br />

By gaining independence and sovereignty, and by forming<br />

Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Montenegro,<br />

one of the few common functions of the State<br />

union, related to the Ministry of Defence and Army has ceased<br />

to exist.<br />

Montenegro now has chance to fully complete its defence<br />

system and the activities on that plane are in full swing.<br />

Since the transition to the territorial principle of financing<br />

(May 2003), Montenegro has been creating conditions<br />

and has taken specific actions for successful Army reform<br />

and independent performance of the defence functions,<br />

which can be seen in the following:<br />

- Determination of the government officials of the Republic<br />

of Montenegro regarding the necessity and course of<br />

Army reform was clearly noticeable, and the support to reform<br />

process was also given by the Army itself;<br />

- Since January 2004 until June 2006, number of persons<br />

that receive salary from the Army, with planned and transparent<br />

process has been reduced for 3.236, or for 47%, so that<br />

in June it amounted 3.624 persons;<br />

- Social program for the surplus of manpower in army<br />

was fully financed and for that purpose circa 5 million EUR<br />

was spent;<br />

- Total stability in the army financing was achieved;<br />

- Expenditures for defence in the estimated GDP were reduced,<br />

from 2,53% in 2005, to 2,40% for 2006;<br />

- Accounting center was formed as important body of<br />

30


Support to reform processes of the defence systems<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

the Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Montenegro for<br />

logistic support for payroll accounts, keeping of the financial<br />

books, control of business operations and relations with<br />

the Treasury;<br />

- The payment of military pensions for beneficiaries on<br />

the territory of the Republic of Montenegro was taken over,<br />

after Social Insurance Fund for Social Insurance of Military<br />

Insurees Beograd had unilaterally suspended further payments<br />

in the second half of 2005;<br />

- Two non-profitable army-income institutions were liquidated<br />

(''Ribnica'' and ''Lovcen'') with about 200 employees;<br />

- Privatisation procedure of the Military Medicine Centers<br />

Meljine and TRZ ''Sava Kovacevic'' Tivat had started;<br />

- Through active and cooperative work in the Fund for<br />

Defence System Reform of the State Union, assets were provided<br />

from the sale of the part of the real estate, which Commission<br />

of the Council of Ministers for Property Division<br />

proclaimed to be the property unnecessary for further functioning<br />

of Army, and after that Government of the Republic<br />

of Montenegro consigned to the Fund for Reform of the Defence<br />

System for sale. Funds acquired from sale were, in accordance<br />

to Conclusions of the Government of Montenegro,<br />

spent for necessities of Army (social program, payment<br />

of wages arrears and material expenses, and one part fell to<br />

the share of the Restitution Fund);<br />

- After the analysis of funds with which Republic of Montenegro<br />

participates in the financing of the functions of the<br />

State Union and with the projection of optimal expenses,<br />

the conclusion has been reached that Montenegro can perform<br />

those functions independently;<br />

Activities on arranging and organisation of functioning<br />

of unique defence system of the Republic of Montenegro<br />

are underway or forthcoming, regarding:<br />

- Enactment of the Law on Defence and Law on Army of<br />

Montenegro, and of related by-laws and other doctrinaire<br />

documents;<br />

- Total professionalisation of Army which, among other<br />

things, implies abolition of recruitment;<br />

- Defining of amount and structure of Army of Montenegro,<br />

and further activities on reform which will last for a longer<br />

period of time;<br />

- Realisation of the assignment of professional army<br />

members, which expressed wish to continue their service<br />

on the territory of the Republic Serbia (552), and those<br />

which want to continue their service from the territory of<br />

the Republic Serbia to the territory of the Republic of Montenegro<br />

(13);<br />

- Planning of the budgetary expenditures in accordance<br />

to the international standards and the projection of expenditures<br />

of independent forming of military forces, which<br />

includes continuation of the trend of reduction of costs for<br />

defence at circa 2% of GDP, change of structure of costs, defining<br />

of social program for surplus of manpower, and earmarking<br />

of resources for modernisation and equipping of<br />

Army;<br />

- Defining of property needed for functioning of the Army<br />

and procedure with property which is no longer necessary<br />

for the Army (sale of the part of that property for purpose<br />

of Army needs of high priority - solving on housing<br />

matters etc.);<br />

- Reforms of health care and pension and pension and<br />

disability insurance of military insurees;<br />

- Inclusion of military pensions into Pension and Disability<br />

Security Fund of the Republic of Montenegro - by the<br />

Fund, taking over of the logistics for accounts and payment;<br />

- Admission in Partnership for Peace, NATO, and other<br />

international organisations and institutions, for the purpose<br />

of development and maintenance of collective and national<br />

safety.<br />

Furthermore, two important questions arise due to their<br />

actuality, which are to be solved in the forthcoming period,<br />

and those are:<br />

1. Ministry of Defence of the State Union left to Montenegro<br />

one very serious problem regarding large number of litigations<br />

of professional and pensioned army members because<br />

of the mismatched wages for some years past;<br />

2. By taking over of the payment of military pensions<br />

Montenegro gained right and possibility to claim from the<br />

Fund for Social Security of Military Insurees Belgrade (Republic<br />

Serbia), revalorised or in other method determined<br />

amount of investment in the Fund during the employment<br />

of professional soldiers at the territory of the Republic of<br />

Montenegro.<br />

Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Montenegro is<br />

highly involved in the reform processes of the Army and defence<br />

system in total, and it gives support to those processes<br />

full.<br />

MIJAJLO SAVOVIĆ, M.A.,<br />

Advisor for the Defence Budget<br />

in the Ministry of Finance<br />

of the Republic of Montenegro<br />

31


Most important activities of the minister of finance<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

REVIEW OF THE MOST IMPORTANT<br />

ACTIVITIES OF THE MINISTER OF<br />

FINANCE APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

28.06.2006. -Meeting of the Ministers of Finance and<br />

Central Bank Governors: Luksic - Dinkic - Jelasic - Krgovic<br />

Minister of<br />

Finance in the<br />

Government of<br />

Montenegro Igor<br />

Luksic: "To Montenegro<br />

belongs<br />

5.88 percent of<br />

44.6 million $,<br />

which will be reduced<br />

for certain liabilities to Serbia. Serbia will pay 30 million<br />

EUR balance to Montenegro, out of which 1.5 million<br />

EUR is for membership in international financial institutions.<br />

Membership deposits depend on economic strength<br />

of country, therefore it is possible that they will be lower for<br />

Montenegro".<br />

Minister of Finance in the Government of Serbia Mladan<br />

Dinkic: "Existing quota in IMF amounts 467.7 million of Special<br />

Drawing Rights or 698 million $ and Serbia succeeds it.<br />

Montenegro will get 5.88 percent or 41 million $".<br />

At the meeting they discussed about old foreign currency<br />

savings, and it has been agreed that future talks should be<br />

held on the level of former SFRY. Military pensions were also<br />

discussed, for which negotiators had no mandates to make<br />

any specific agreements.<br />

Dinkic and Jelasic congratulated yesterday to citizens of<br />

Montenegro on raising of flag at East River.<br />

20. 06.2006. - Minister of Finance Igor Luksic held talks<br />

with the President of the European Bank for Reconstruction<br />

and Development Jean Lemier<br />

During the meeting, views<br />

were exchanged on the current<br />

political and economic situation<br />

in Montenegro after the gaining<br />

of independence, and both sides<br />

have expressed satisfaction<br />

with the democratic atmosphere<br />

and overall economy plan.<br />

Also, they discussed current projects financed by ERBD,<br />

and possible future programs, with emphasis on future status<br />

and membership of Montenegro in that multilateral institution.<br />

The mutual satisfaction was expressed with progress<br />

in economic and overall reforms, and with past cooperation,<br />

and the president of EBRD Jean Lemier announced the opening<br />

of permanent office of that institution in Podgorica-<br />

Montenegro, due to growing investment interest and strengthening<br />

of institutional cooperation.<br />

13.06. 2006.god. - Minister of Finance Igor Luksic held<br />

talks with Head of Delegation of the IMF, Peter Doyle:<br />

"I had a chance today, together with the president of the<br />

Council of the Central Bank, Mr Ljubisa Krgovic first of all to<br />

talk to Mr Peter Doyle, new chief of IMF Mission for Serbia<br />

and Montenegro within the mission that recently started<br />

and actually has officially started with the meeting we had<br />

today. We are talking about the visit of IMF with the purpose<br />

of analysis of macroeconomic situation in Montenegro<br />

and Serbia and at the same time with the purpose of analysis<br />

of forthcoming medium-term challenges in that period"…<br />

02. 06.2006. - Sveti Stefan: Opening statement of Igor<br />

Luksic, Minister of finance at the Regional Conference of Ministers<br />

of Finance and Governors of Central Banks of South-<br />

East Europe<br />

"It is my pleasure to welcome you on behalf of the Government<br />

of Montenegro. We are grateful for the occasion<br />

to be hosts of the conference as eminent as this. These gatherings<br />

always represent a good opportunity for improvement<br />

of cooperation and establishment of strong relations<br />

between our countries…<br />

At the very beginning, I would like to emphasise that previously<br />

realised economic independence and sustainability<br />

of Montenegro had its logical sequence - the gaining of formal<br />

independence. The issue of state-legal status of Montenegro<br />

has been solved and we expect this to have a great influence<br />

at the further development of our economy. Positioning<br />

itself as one of European centers, instead as a part of<br />

32


Most important activities of the minister of finance<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

non-functional<br />

union allows our<br />

country to participate<br />

and stimulate<br />

economic integration<br />

processes on<br />

equal terms. This<br />

way, it will promote<br />

easier numerous<br />

resources that<br />

will have for goal economic development."<br />

26.04.2006: - Minister of finance Igor Luksic, PhD,<br />

anent signing of Cooperation Agreement between Ministry<br />

of Finance of Montenegro and Ministry of Finance of Iceland:<br />

"I had a pleasure today to sign the Agreement on cooperation<br />

between two Ministries with my colleague, Minister<br />

of finance of Iceland Arni Mathiesen. Small countries are<br />

oriented to each<br />

other, especially if<br />

they have significant<br />

similarities.<br />

For us in Montenegro,<br />

especially after<br />

the renewal of<br />

sovereignty, experience<br />

of Island is<br />

very interesting,<br />

because it can represent<br />

a model for a faster growth and development, what<br />

is in today world characteristic of smaller countries..."<br />

24.04.2006: - Working visit to Washington continued<br />

with talks with American administration<br />

Representatives of the American administration showed<br />

special interest in current political moment in Montenegro<br />

and projection of future relations with IMF and World Bank.<br />

In that contest, Minister Luksic stated that political developments,<br />

organisation<br />

of referendum<br />

and later of<br />

elections, shall<br />

have no negative<br />

influence on economic<br />

performance<br />

and has<br />

repeated willingness<br />

of the Government<br />

of<br />

Montenegro to discuss with the Government of Serbia<br />

about all maters of mutual interest in the period after the referendum...<br />

24.04.2006: - Delegation of Montenegro continued<br />

working visit to Washington with talks with representatives<br />

of the IMF<br />

Delegation of Montenegro, headed by Minister of finance,<br />

Igor Luksic, PhD and President of the Central Bank, Ljubisa Krgovic<br />

continued its working visit to Washington with talks<br />

with the representatives of the IMF: Ann Kruger, deputy director<br />

of IMF, Michael Deppler, director of IMF for Europe, and<br />

new chief of Mission Peter Doyle. Topic of the talks was current<br />

economic situation in Montenegro and audit of just finished<br />

arrangement, and framework for future arrangement…<br />

24.04.2006:- Spring meetings of the IMF and World<br />

Bank' talks of Montenegrin delegation with USAID<br />

Delegation of the Republic of Montenegro, during Spring<br />

meetings of the IMF and World Bank, met the director for Balkans<br />

in the USAID, Mr<br />

Edward Dickens. Fiscal<br />

movements in<br />

Montenegro and relations<br />

with international<br />

financial institutions<br />

were analysed.<br />

The question of realisation<br />

of current<br />

USAID projects was<br />

emphasised, as was the question of program for the next 3<br />

years, especially in infrastructural and other development areas…<br />

Minister of Finance, Igor Luksic, PhD and the president<br />

of the Council of Central Bank of Montenegro, Mr Ljubisa<br />

Krgovic, within the contacts with the business community<br />

had meeting with investment group from New York, Pickwick<br />

Capital. They discussed about economic ambient for<br />

private investments in Montenegro. They emphasised the<br />

special interest of this investment group for areas: tourism,<br />

energetics, health, education and financial services.<br />

PR SERVICE<br />

Spokesperson, ANA MILJANIĆ<br />

Senior Employee I, MAJA BAŠIĆ<br />

33


Review of other news<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

REVIEW OF OTHER NEWS<br />

- ACTIVITIES OF THE MINISTRY<br />

OF FINANCE<br />

Draft Law Amending and Supplementing Law on Personal<br />

Income Tax for Private Persons since Friday 1st - 15th<br />

July 2006 on public debate.<br />

All interested subjects can send their proposals, suggestions<br />

and opinions at e-mail address of the Ministry of Finance<br />

mf@mn.yu or on fax: 224 450.<br />

This will initiate the consideration of the amendments to<br />

the Law on Personal Income Tax for Private Persons, which<br />

is planned to introduce the proportional tax rate and its significant<br />

reduction, and which should in 2010 be 9% (as is the<br />

rate for profit tax for legal persons)<br />

Payment of the third instalment to the owners of the<br />

old foreign currency savings - 3rd July 2006.<br />

To the owners of old foreign currency savings, which<br />

mature on 1st July 2006, payment of the third instalment to<br />

the amount defined by their plan of amortization will start<br />

on Monday 3rd July in commercial banks and regional centres<br />

of Central Bank of Montenegro. For the payment of<br />

this, the third bond series from the Budget of the Republic is<br />

planned 8,7 million EUR. Depositors that have after 1st July<br />

reported to their bank and thus registered themselves at<br />

CDA as bond owners based on converted savings can draw<br />

the third instalment in regional centres of the Central Bank<br />

of Montenegro and Pljevaljska Bank AD Pljevlja, depending<br />

on their residence, based on their identification document<br />

(identification card and passport).<br />

The owners of old foreign currency savings, which haven't<br />

used their right on payment of the first and second<br />

bond series to the amount of 380 and 530 EUR can draw all<br />

three instalments. They are to go to the bank in which they<br />

have their savings deposit book, or to the related counter of<br />

the Central Bank, where they will receive certificate on conversion<br />

of savings into bonds.<br />

Ministry of Finance of Montenegro has paid funds for<br />

military pensions- for May 2006<br />

Ministry of Finance has paid funds for military pensions<br />

today (for May 2006). The payment will start on Saturday<br />

24th June 2006.<br />

Final announcement of the International Monetary<br />

Fund Mission after the visit of that delegation to Montenegro<br />

Independence for Montenegro represents the new beginning.<br />

In that context, our goal is to offer suggestions on<br />

how to use the best this unique chance in the macroeconomic<br />

sphere.<br />

Many things are progressing well. Inflation is low, public<br />

debt has tendency to fall, collection of the VAT contributes<br />

to the good realisation of income, direct foreign investments<br />

are growing with new ones expected to come, banks are privatized,<br />

credit activity is expanding, access to EU markets is<br />

realised with allowances, and chances for achievement of<br />

the Stabilisation and Association Agreement and for membership<br />

in WTO and Partnership for Peace are good.<br />

Your ambitions are appropriate. You are trying to achieve<br />

permanent increase of economic growth, employment<br />

and real income, both as independent goals and as basis for<br />

entering EU one day.<br />

These goals are achievable. For their achievement will<br />

be necessary, first of all, operating, in order to provide maintenance<br />

of regular terms for economic activity in the context<br />

of independence, and second, bigger emphasis on middle-term<br />

than on short-term goals in formulation of macroeconomic<br />

policies, especially in terms of flexibility, sustainability<br />

and offer.<br />

Independence<br />

- Your sovereignty should be fully reflected in legal solutions,<br />

which regulate your international economic relations.<br />

It is necessary to be understood that agreements previously<br />

made between Serbia and Montenegro and international<br />

community on questions like free trade in the region, veterinary<br />

standards, double taxation, etc. now you yourselves<br />

should accomplish in order to provide continuing regular<br />

terms for economic activity. Furthermore, legal regulations<br />

concerning economic relations with Serbia should be clarified.<br />

Main issues are matter of stay of citizens from one sta-<br />

34


Review of other news<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

te in another and exercise of rights from the sphere of social<br />

security and working permits. Agreement on free trade zone<br />

would ensure undisturbed continuation of former trade<br />

arrangements. Moreover, the total account of former net fiscal<br />

transfers to State Union is recommended. It should reduce<br />

budgetary transfers to the Union for costs that will now<br />

pay as functions of the Union that are delegated to the Budget<br />

of Montenegro. This will help realisation of the budget<br />

for 2006 and making of the budget for 2007.<br />

Draft Law on Tax Advisors - public dispute 22.06.2006<br />

This Law regulates activity of the tax counselling as independent<br />

and autonomous occupation, authorisation and<br />

obligations of tax and customs advisors (hereinafter: tax advisors),<br />

and other matters significant for performance of<br />

those activities... You can send your proposals, suggestions<br />

and opinions at the e-mail address of the Ministry of Finance<br />

mf@mn.yu or at fax: 224-450 in the next 15 days.<br />

Visit of the delegation of International Monetary Fund<br />

to Montenegro 12 June 2006<br />

Aim of the mission and talks with Montenegrin officials<br />

and institutions is analysis of the implementation of agreed<br />

policy, and of further reforms of the financial sector in Montenegro.<br />

Also, creating of macro economic policy and setting<br />

of medium-term macroeconomic goals will be in the focus.<br />

After the completion of the mission on 22nd June, we<br />

expect that representatives of IMF publish final statements<br />

concerning the results of held talks. It is also important to<br />

remember that Montenegro has successfully concluded at<br />

the beginning of 2006 so called "extended arrangement"<br />

with IMF which lasted from 2002. The outcome of that arrangement<br />

and its successful conclusion led to, beside the significant<br />

positive image of Montenegro at the financial market,<br />

and to further write-off of debt of Montenegro to Paris<br />

Creditors Club to the amount of circa 26 million EUR.<br />

Commission for issuance of licences for auditors -Activities<br />

-<br />

Commission for Issuance of licences for auditors in the<br />

period from 1st January to 30th June 2006, held 10 sessions<br />

on which it issued 29 licences to the auditors and those are:<br />

to Milovan Popovic, Dejan Krivokapic, Krsto Spaic, Veselin<br />

Milacic, Zorica Vujovic, Ljerka Momcilovic, Branka Bojovic,<br />

Predrag Rakocevic, Ljiljana Velimirovic, Ibro Sabovic, Jelena<br />

Jakovac, Vesna Kotlaja, Ljiljan Milinovic, Momcilo Mihaljevic,<br />

Senka Popovic-Mitric, Maja Krstic, Vesna Radunovic, Mladen<br />

Ognjenovic, Kristina Bukilic, Dejan Savic, Sava Obradovic,<br />

Goran Strahinja, Lidija Matovic, Branka Vuksanovic, Drasko<br />

Popovic, Vladimir Carapic, Nada Guzina, Milos Macura and<br />

Vladimir Filipovic.<br />

List and data of auditors with licence can be found at the<br />

website of the Ministry of Finance of Montenegro www.ministarstvo-finansija.vlada.cg.yu.<br />

For the purpose of control of financial reports of the Ministry<br />

of Finance supplemented lists with data in auditors,<br />

Spokesperson<br />

Ana Miljanić<br />

after each newly issued licence, is forwarded to business<br />

courts.<br />

Commission also issued two approvals for choice of the<br />

audit company for performing of audit of accounting statements<br />

for 2005, to Crnogorska Komercijalna Bank and Atlasmont<br />

Bank. For that period 3 requests for issuance of licence<br />

were turned down because they did not meet the conditions<br />

proscribed by the Law on Accounting and Revision<br />

("Official gazette RoM ", no.69/05).<br />

Draft Law on Check- public dispute - 31st May 2006<br />

You can send all proposals and suggestions concerning<br />

Draft Law on Check at the email address of the Ministry of<br />

Finance mf@mn.yu or on fax 224 - 450 during next 15 days.<br />

Representatives of the work group for drafting of sub<br />

legal regulations in the sphere of public procurement held<br />

working meeting with experts of OECD/SIGMA<br />

During the talks, Secretary of the Public Procurement<br />

Commission Katarina Radovic, reminded that the new Law<br />

on Public Procurement will constitute new institutional frame<br />

and new procedures, harmonized with EU legislation.<br />

Spokesperson of the Ministry of Finance Ana Miljanic, emphasised<br />

the necessity of systematic instalment of mechanisms<br />

for as transparent procedures of public procurement<br />

as possible, for the purpose of establishment of more efficient<br />

system. Realisation of determined activities will provide<br />

conditions for full implementation of the Law, from the moment<br />

of its entering into force. For education of all subjects,<br />

involved in the public procurement system, and presentation<br />

of new procedures to them, sub legal regulations will<br />

be drafted prior to the deadline set under the Law.<br />

Spokesperson<br />

ANA MILJANIĆ<br />

35


Payment of third instalment of old foreign currency<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

PAYMENT OF THIRD INSTALMENT<br />

OF OLD FOREIGN CURRENCY<br />

Payment of the third instalment to the amount determined<br />

by their plan of amortization, which matures<br />

on 1st July 2006, will start from Monday 3rd July to<br />

the owners of old foreign currency savings in commercial<br />

banks and regional centres of the Central Bank of<br />

Montenegro. For the payment of the third bond series, 8,7<br />

million EUR is determined by the Budget of the Republic.<br />

Depositors that after 1st July 2004 reported to their<br />

banks and thus have registered themselves in the CDA as<br />

owners of bonds on the basis of converted savings, can<br />

draw the third instalment in the regional centres of the<br />

Central Bank of Montenegro and Pljevaljska Bank AD<br />

Pljevlja, depending on their residence, based on the document<br />

of identification (identity card and passport).<br />

Owners of old foreign currency savings, which haven't<br />

used their right for the payment of the first and second<br />

bond series to the amount of 380 and 530 EUR, from 3rd<br />

July this year can draw all three annuities. They are to go to<br />

the bank where they have their savings deposit book, or to<br />

the related counter of the Central Bank, where they will<br />

receive certificate on conversion of savings into bonds.<br />

Former depositors of Montenegrobanka AD Podgorica<br />

and Jugobanka AD Podgorica in bankruptcy should report<br />

to the related counter of Central Bank of Montenegro.<br />

Legal persons that have acquired old currency savings<br />

bonds by purchase of bonds at the exchange market can<br />

draw the third instalment at the counter of Nikšićka Bank<br />

AD Nikšić.<br />

For new owners of bonds, which acquired bonds on the<br />

basis of the deed of donation, notice of probate of will or<br />

purchase at the exchange market, arrangement of counters<br />

at which they can draw the third instalment depending on<br />

the residence is also determined.<br />

If the owner of old currency savings bonds is not able to<br />

come to the bank, authorized person based on the notarized<br />

court authorisation can draw determined amount of<br />

the third series, instead of the owner.<br />

Owners of old currency savings bonds that have lost<br />

their certificate will be able to get the transcript of ownership<br />

of old foreign currency savings bonds in the Central<br />

Depositary Agency (CDA).<br />

Successors of old foreign currency savings bonds, which<br />

acquired them based on the valid notice of probate of will<br />

for additional information on exercise of their right can<br />

obtain further information in CDA at phone number<br />

081/230-084, contact person Rajka Dragićević.<br />

Detailed information and arrangement of payment<br />

places will be announced by the Ministry of Finance on<br />

Friday, 30th June 2006 in all journals. This information will<br />

be available on all payment places in regional centres of the<br />

Central Bank of Montenegro and in commercial banks.<br />

In June, while the bond payment was temporarily<br />

stopped as was the exchange market trade for better preparation<br />

for free payment of second instalment, data from all<br />

banks on payment of the first instalment and data from the<br />

capital market on bonds that were subjects of the exchange<br />

market trade were unified, which provided security of data<br />

on owners of bonds as securities.<br />

PR SERVICE OF THE MINISTRY<br />

36


Report on account of public debt of Montenegro<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

REPORT ON ACCOUNT OF PUBLIC<br />

DEBT OF MONTENEGRO<br />

BY 30TH JUNE 2006.<br />

1. AMOUNT AND STRUCTURE OF<br />

PUBLIC DEBT OF<br />

MONTENEGRO<br />

Public debt of Montenegro amounted 644,4 million EUR<br />

as of 30.06.2006. Domestic debt amounted 167,7 million EUR<br />

or 26,0% of total debt while the foreign debt amounted 476,7<br />

million EUR or 74,0% respectively . It is primarily due to ongoing<br />

negotiations and allocation of debt, ongoing negotiations<br />

on succession of former SFRY and impossibility to quantify<br />

explicit liabilities assumed under the Law on Restitution of<br />

Expropriated Property Rights and Compensation that this<br />

amount has not been fully clear-cut. According to current estimations,<br />

no great divergences are likely to arise following<br />

conclusion of negotiations on allocation of financial assets<br />

and liabilities with the Republic Serbia.<br />

In 2002, public debt amounted over EUR 1 billion. It is the<br />

amount which was determined prior to debt rescheduling<br />

with the International Bank for Reconstruction and<br />

Development and Paris Donors Club and prior to final agreement<br />

with Serbia concerning liabilities to the London<br />

Creditors Club.<br />

The largest share of public debt of Montenegro refers to<br />

inherited long-term liabilities of the old system (former SFRY<br />

and SRY). This share primarily refers to foreign debts<br />

assumed by the Law on Regulation of Liabilities and Claims<br />

arising out of foreign debt and foreign currency savings of citizens,<br />

which at the end of June 2006, amounted 404,9 million<br />

or 62,8% of the public debt, mostly loans extended by the<br />

International Bank for Reconstruction and Development and<br />

Paris Donors Club.<br />

Beside old foreign debts, "assumed" public debt is also<br />

1-2 - According to Maastricht Criteria the amount of public debt does not include debts of public enterprises, including the ones with government guarantee,<br />

except it is certain that those debts will be paid from the State Budget or are already being paid, as is the case with the credit of EIB for Port Bar to the amount<br />

of 6 million EUR.<br />

37


Report on account of public debt of Montenegro<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

consisted of liabilities on the basis of old foreign currency<br />

savings, assumed by the same Law. Liabilities on the basis of<br />

old foreign currency savings, at the end of 2004, amounted<br />

123 million EUR, at the end of 2005, 117 million EUR, and at<br />

the end of first half-year 114,0 million EUR which is 17,7 % of<br />

public debt. Therefore, at the end of June 2006, assumed<br />

long-term liabilities of old system represent 80,5% of total<br />

public debt of Montenegro. Remaining 19,5% refer to new<br />

indebtedness which arouse in the period from 2000 to June<br />

2006, liabilities in the basis of credits, treasury bills, local selfgovernments<br />

debts and outstanding budgetary liabilities.<br />

2. FOREIGN PUBLIC DEBT<br />

Foreign public debt amounted 476,7 million EUR. The<br />

share of that is "old" debt 404,9 million EUR or 84,9% and the<br />

new amounts 71,9 million EUR or 15,08%. Share of foreign<br />

debt in Gross domestic product which shows the level of foreign<br />

indebtedness of the country had trend from 68,7%<br />

before the debt rescheduling to 27,1%, which is his amount at<br />

the end of June 2006.<br />

In the table 3 you can see the structure of foreign debt to<br />

creditors.<br />

Decision of the Government in November 2005, assumed<br />

credit of the European Investment Bank, which in June<br />

amounts 15 million EUR (is withdrawn in total). Debt on the<br />

basis of credit of 24 million EUR to the European Investment<br />

Bank for the construction of Sozina tunnel is excluded from<br />

the public debt, without public enterprises and has become<br />

the debt of the public enterprise Monteput.<br />

2. Debt to Paris Donors Club on 31. December 2005,<br />

amounted 151,6 million EUR, and is shown in the reduced<br />

debt amount for 51%, which represents the write-off in the<br />

first phase. After the expiration of the three-year arrangement<br />

with the IMF and positive opinion on macroeconomic trends<br />

in Montenegro, the expected reduction has happened to the<br />

total amount of 24,3 without the debt reduction towards Italy<br />

with which negotiations are not over yet and which has not<br />

entered the total calculation of the liabilities to the Club. The<br />

reduction is expected to be 2-4 million EUR.<br />

Old or refinanced debts are also liabilities to Council of<br />

Europe Bank and to International Financial Corporation<br />

(IFC) and debt arrears to the Anglo Yugoslav Bank. Liabilities<br />

to Handlowy Bank are settled in total with the payment of the<br />

final instalment on 15th June 2006.<br />

Smaller share of long-term liabilities is related to the<br />

As shown on the previous table, in the structure of foreign<br />

public debt of Montenegro, at the end of June 2006, the<br />

biggest share has foreign refinanced debt to World bank -<br />

41,1% or 264,9 million EUR.<br />

Debt reduction when compared to 2005, to the absolute<br />

amount was caused by two reasons:<br />

1. From the 1st January 2006 debt of the public enterprise<br />

Željeznica <strong>Crne</strong> <strong>Gore</strong> is calculated as public debt since by the<br />

indebtedness after 2001, when Montenegro as a part of SRY,<br />

and State Union Serbia and Source: Montenegro Ministry regulated of Finance its membership<br />

and relations with international financial institutions<br />

and made new arrangements. New concluded, and at the<br />

same time withdrawn, foreign loans until 31.06.2006 amount<br />

71,9 million EUR. These loans include indebtedness in:<br />

European Investment Bank, European Community and<br />

German Bank for Reconstruction. The total amount of debt to<br />

European Bank for Reconstruction and Development based<br />

on the indebtedness for advisor in the privatisation of the<br />

38


Report on account of public debt of Montenegro<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Kombinat Aluminijuma Podgorica, was settled after successful<br />

process of privatisation of this company.<br />

2. INTERNAL PUBLIC DEBT<br />

Internal public debt of Montenegro consists of liabilities<br />

based on old foreign currency savings, liabilities based on<br />

credits taken from domestic financial and other institutions,<br />

liabilities based on the issue of short-term treasury bills, debt<br />

of local self-governments and payment arrears from the<br />

budget.<br />

Table 3. Structure and amount of internal public debt.<br />

the country, from 30% to 50% indicates the medium indebtedness<br />

of the country, having in mind that Montenegro with<br />

21,1% belongs to less indebted countries, and share of over<br />

50% the high indebtedness of the country. Just for comparison,<br />

at the end of 2004, with certain number of countries in<br />

the process of transition this indicator was: Bulgaria 57,6%;<br />

Czech Republic 37,4%; Croatia 79,9%; Lithuania 43,2%;<br />

Hungary 59,0%; Romania 39,8%; Slovenia 50,1%.<br />

When compared to the gross domestic product anticipated<br />

for 2006, gross public debt of Montenegro at the end of<br />

2006, amounts 36,6%. This is "significantly" lower from the<br />

defined fiscal criterion, of the maximum allowed public debt,<br />

of the European Union, which makes the Montenegro meet<br />

one of two Maastricht criteria which proscribe that the total<br />

debt should not cross 60% of the gross domestic product.<br />

In the indebtedness structure is noticeable the indebtedness<br />

reduction based on treasury bills and almost total<br />

elimination of the debt based on bank credits so that the<br />

indebtedness based on treasury bills amounted 6,5 million<br />

EUR. Until 30th June 2006, about 3 million EUR of old foreign<br />

currency savings bonds have been paid. Also, there has<br />

been a significant further reduction of liabilities based on<br />

outstanding budgetary payments for 15,2 million EUR. To<br />

the total amount, domestic debt in first two quarters of 2006,<br />

was lower for 19,4 million EUR when compared to<br />

31.12.2005.<br />

This indicator is considered to be the most important indicator<br />

of the debt sustainability.<br />

According to value of mentioned indicators, Montenegro<br />

is ranked in countries with low indebtedness with tendency<br />

of further improvement.<br />

5. INDICATORS FOR<br />

INDEBTEDNESS OF<br />

MONTENEGRO- FINAL<br />

OBSERVATIONS<br />

According to the methodology of World Bank (Debt<br />

Reporting System) share of foreign debt in the gross domestic<br />

product lower than 30% indicates the low indebtedness of<br />

DEBT AND CASH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT<br />

SNEŽANA IVANOVIĆ, MERSIJA PURIŠIĆ,<br />

MINA JOVOVIĆ, M.A. NIKOLA VUKIĆEVIĆ<br />

3 - According to the projection of the Deutsche Bank Research<br />

39


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

REPORT ON MACROFISCAL<br />

DEVELOPMENTS FOR THE FIRST<br />

FIVE MONTHS 2006<br />

Macroeconomic Analysis and International Co-Operation Department<br />

STANKO JEKNIĆ, PhD, Co-ordinator<br />

VLADISLAV KARADžIĆ, Senior Advisor I<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

Assessment of the public spending of the Republic of Montenegro for 2006 is based on the data on GDP developments,<br />

including data on public spending developments in the period from 2001-2006. Public spending policy for 2006 is based on<br />

assessment of Montenegro's fiscal potential and macroeconomic trends defined under the Montenegro's Economic Reform<br />

Agenda of April 2005. In accordance with the economic policy goals and objectives defined under the Economic Reforms<br />

Agenda, 2006 Budget will be further balances, with relative cut in deficit as a share in GDP. Basic fiscal policy parameters will<br />

also be adjusted to the frameworks and objectives agreed with the IMF and World Bank. They will also be harmonized with the<br />

EU Directives.<br />

Assessment of the Budget revenues for 2006 is based on projected data on GDP developments, including data on Budget<br />

revenues developments in the period from 2001-2006. Macroeconomic indicators projection under the Montenegro's<br />

Economic Reforms Agenda indicates that 2006 GDP will amount 1.759 mil. eur (current prices), while the real growth rate<br />

will be 4,5 %.<br />

Data on GDP are taken from analysis prepared by the IMF and the Ministry of Finance. According to the data, GDP growth<br />

and average annual rate show a stabile economic growth trend in the period from 2003. Projections indicate that GDP will amount<br />

1.794,00 mil.eur in 2006, while the nominal growth rate will be 7%.<br />

40


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Projected GDP influenced assessment of the total pubic spending in Montenegro for 2006. Public spending level and its relative<br />

share in GDP are given in the Table below:<br />

Relative cut in public spending share in GDP will be ensured<br />

with a slower growth of Government Budget spending and volume<br />

of health protection than GDP growth. Economic Reforms<br />

Agenda provides for that 2006 public spending share in<br />

GDP will be by 43%. However, 2006 projections show relative<br />

public spending share in GDP by 44,21%, which is not in line<br />

with the objectives set under the Agenda. This deviation comes<br />

from unreal planning of local governments' spending for 2005<br />

and 2006. When 20 mil eur is deducted from underestimated local<br />

government spending, consolidated public spending amounts<br />

43% of GDP, which is in accordance with the Agenda.<br />

I CONSOLIDATED PUBLIC SPENDING<br />

Public spending analysis for 2006 was conducted on the basis of preliminary data disclosed under the financial statements<br />

of the Government Budget, extra-budgetary funds and local governments. The financial statements were produced on the basis<br />

of cash flow statements and were systematized in a single form with a view to providing an objective methodological approach<br />

in tabular presentations and analysis of the public spending system functioning in 2006.<br />

2006 public spending is based on economic policy goals for 2006, projecting employment rate growth, companies' restructuring<br />

and privatization, poverty reduction and real growth of living standards, while main objectives of public spending are aimed<br />

at increase in Budget revenues, rationalization of Government Budget and HIF spending as well as intensifying the reforms<br />

in the field of judiciary, education and public administration.<br />

1. PLAN AND REALIZATION OF PUBLIC SPENDING FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY-MAY 2006<br />

Public revenues in this period were realized to the<br />

amount of 322,19 mil.eur, which is by 16,08 mil.eur more<br />

than planned for the said period. Tax collection was higher<br />

by 24,78 mil eur than planned, primarily due to a more<br />

efficient collection of VAT and corporate income tax<br />

than planned. Collection of fees, charges and contributions<br />

has been slightly increased as compared to the<br />

planned, while other revenues have been significantly<br />

decreased. The reason for such decrease lies in a much<br />

poorer collection of outstanding tax liabilities from the<br />

previous period - only 20% than planned.<br />

41


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Public expenditures were executed to the amount of<br />

334,35 mil.eur, which is by 52,23 mil.eur less than planned<br />

for the period January - May 2006. Lower salary disbursements<br />

than planned are result of an average duration<br />

of salaries disbursement of about 5 days, so realization<br />

of a part of the plan is transferred from the current<br />

month into the following month. Lower realization of expenditures<br />

for material and capital expenditures is a result<br />

of a change in the structure of disbursements from<br />

the Republic Budget, which were in the first five months<br />

earmarked for repayment of outstanding liabilities by<br />

9,64 mil eur more than as was planned for the five<br />

months.<br />

Public spending deficit for the period January-May<br />

2006 amounts 12,8 mil.eur, out of which Pension and Disability<br />

Insurance Fund accounts for 0,96 mil.eur , Budget<br />

13,44 mil. eur, Employment Agency 2,75 mil.eur and<br />

local self-government 0,29 mil.eur. At the same time, HIF<br />

surplus amounted 4,64 mil.eur, so that consolidated deficit<br />

in the period January-May 2006 amounts 12,8 mil. eur,<br />

accounting for 0,71 % of GDP. Public spending deficit<br />

was financed from the privatization receipts, foreign credits<br />

and donations. At the same time 14,91 mil eur of deposit<br />

was drawn, resulting in repayment of domestic credit<br />

liabilities to the amount of 6,5 mil eur.<br />

Salaries and other earnings were decreased<br />

by 0,33 mil.eur as compared to<br />

the plan, and their realization is estimated<br />

to be 99,89 % of the plan for 2006.<br />

Current expenditures were reduced<br />

by 0,12 mil.eur and were projected<br />

to amount 465,53 mil.eur.<br />

All public expenditures are mostly<br />

as planned, except for repayment of<br />

outstanding liabilities, which was<br />

increased by 12,5 mil euros, thanks to<br />

better collection of public source revenues.<br />

42


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

II BUDGET OF THE REPUBLIC OF MONTENEGRO<br />

1. PLAN AND REALIZATION OF THE BUDGET OF THE REPUBLIC OF MONTENEGRO FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY-<br />

MAY 2006<br />

Source revenues were realized to the amount of 195,4mil.eur, while total expenditures were executed to the amount of 208,8<br />

mil.eur. Current and capital expenditures with net loans and repayment of guarantees were executed to the amount of 217<br />

mil.eur, while59 mil.eur was disbursed by transfers to the Funds and local self-government. Budget spending is less than planned<br />

by 13% in the period January-May 2006. Lower disbursements for salaries than planned are result of average duration of salary<br />

disbursements of about 5 days, so realization of a part of the plan is transferred from current month into next month. Lower<br />

realization of expenditures for material and capital expenditures is a result of a change in the dynamics of required spending,<br />

being less than planned, which influenced allocation of certain amount of available funds for repayment of outstanding<br />

liabilities to the amount of 26,3 mil.eur.<br />

Source revenues of the Republic Budget for the first five months 2006 were realized to the amount of 195,4 mil.eur or by<br />

11,5 % more than planned for the same period. Positive trends were particularly realized with respect to the following types of<br />

revenues:<br />

• Corporate income tax, the realization of which is :<br />

- Higher by 33,8% as compared to the plan for the first five months 2006<br />

• Value added tax, the realization of which is:<br />

- Higher by 30,7% as compared to the plan for the first five months 2006<br />

43


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Expenditures of the Republic Budget for the period January-May 2006 were executed to the amount of 208,8 mil.eur, which<br />

accounts for 87 % of total planned expenditures for the said period. For current and capital expenditures with net loans, 217<br />

mil.eur was disbursed, while59 mil.eur was disbursed by transfers to the Funds and local self-government,.<br />

Lower level of disbursements on account of planned expenditures for the first five months 2006 had no influence on increase<br />

in outstanding liabilities, indicating that spending units, while planning monthly spending decided on a higher level of<br />

spending in the first and second quarter 2006. Real lower level of spending, particularly with respect to capital expenditures, allowed<br />

repayment of credit and outstanding liabilities from previous years on account of less disbursed amounts for current and<br />

capital expenditures<br />

III PENSION AND DISABILITY INSURANCE FUND (PIO FUND)<br />

From the PIO Fund, for the period January-May 2006, funds for pension disbursement were provided to the amount of<br />

62,50 mil.eur.<br />

Pension amounts are adjusted from the semi-annual amount based on the statistic data on cost of living and average earnings<br />

of employees from the previous semi-annual period. Increase in number of pensioners is planned to decline in 2007,<br />

as a result of enforcement of a new Law on Pension and Disability Insurance, which can be seen based on data on average number<br />

of pensioners in 2005 (93.033) and average number of pensioners for the period from January-May 2006 (92.159)<br />

1. PLAN AND REALIZATION OF THE FUND PIO BUDGET<br />

FOR THE PERIOD FROM JANUARY-MAY 2006<br />

Current revenues of the Fund PIO were realized to the amount of 49,84 mil.eur and are lower than planned by 2,60 %. Transfers<br />

from the Republic Budget were realized to the amount of 20,44 mil.eur and were executed 68,4 % as compared to the plan.<br />

Total spending of the Fund PIO for the period January-May 2006 amounted 71,24 mil.eur, being less than planned by 11 %.<br />

Lower level of the Fund PIO spending is a result of lower execution of liabilities to the Pensioners Health Insurance Fund. In<br />

this period, surplus of the Fund PIO is planned to amount 4,00 mil eur. However, due to lower realization of transfers, it amounts<br />

1,00 mil eur.<br />

The Table below shows realization of the receipts and execution of the Fund PIO budget for the first five months 2006, including<br />

deficit and financing:<br />

44


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

45


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

IV REPUBLIC HEALTH INSURANCE FUND (HIF)<br />

1. PLAN AND REALIZATION OF THE HIF BUDGET FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY-MAY 2006<br />

Current revenues of the Health Insurance Fund were realized to the amount of 38,45 mil. eur, which is by 18,75 % more than<br />

planned. Revenues from contributions amount 35,71 mil. eur and are higher than planned by 11,76 %, while received transfers<br />

amount 9,2 mil. eur, and are less than planned by 5,7 mil.eur. In the first five months, less than 3,52 mil.eur was transferred from<br />

the Republic Budget, and 5,7 mil.eur from the PIO Fund. From the Period January-May, the HIF realized a surplus to the amount<br />

of 4,66 mil eur , increasing a deposit to 2,87 mil eur and net domestic debt repayment to the amount of 1,78 mil eur.<br />

46


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

V EMPLOYMENT AGENCY OF MONTENEGRO<br />

1. PLAN AND REALIZATION OF THE EMPLOYMENT AGENCY BUDGET FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY-MAY 2006<br />

Employment agency of Montenegro have realized current revenues to the amount of 5,95 mil. eur, which is by 30% more<br />

than planned. Revenues from contributions amount 2,06 mil. eur and are less than planned by 6,5 %, other revenues amount<br />

2,36 mil.eur and are higher than planned by 2,4 mil.eur. Received transfers amount 2,32 mil. eur and are in line with the plan..<br />

47


Macroeconomic Analysis<br />

BULLETIN OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE/APRIL - JUNE 2006<br />

Projected expenditures of the Agency for the period January - May amounted 6,16 mil.eur, and were executed to the amount<br />

of 11,03 mil.eur, which is by 4,84 mil.eur more than planned for the said period. Deficit was realized to the amount of 2,75 mil.eur,<br />

which was financed from the privatization receipts to the amount of 1,1mil.eur , while the deposit was reduced by 1,6 mil eur.<br />

VI LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT<br />

1. PLAN AND REALIZATION OF THE LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT BUDGET FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY-MAY 2006<br />

Municipal revenues for the period January - May 2006 were projected to amount 39,72 mil.eur, out of which source revenues<br />

account for 38,87 mil.eur, Republic Budget transfers amount 0,85mil.eur, and the revenues in this period were realized to the<br />

amount of 33,8 mil.eur.<br />

Expenditures were projected to amount 39,2mil.eur, and were executed to the amount of 33,49 mil.eur. Realized deficit of<br />

the local self government for the period January-May amounts 0,29 mil. eur.<br />

48

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!