‘renewable’ projects.7 Although, withinthat definition of ‘renewable’ a greatvariety of projects can qualify. As aresult, <strong>the</strong> PCF counts energyefficiency in <strong>the</strong> Czech Republic,waste management in Latvia,aforestation in Romania, wasteincineration in Mauritius, landfill gasextraction in South Africa and soilconservation in Moldou as ‘renewable’.While environmental groups such asGreenpeace define ‘renewable’ energystrictly in terms of solar and windpower, <strong>the</strong> PCF and its source, <strong>the</strong>Kyoto Protocol, include energy thatstretches th<strong>is</strong> definition to <strong>the</strong> limit. 8Ano<strong>the</strong>r prototype fund that came outof th<strong>is</strong> formula, <strong>the</strong> CommunityDevelopment <strong>Carbon</strong> Fund (CDCF),whose slogan <strong>is</strong> “carbon with a humanface,” was launched at <strong>the</strong> WorldSummit on Sustainable Development(WSSD) in Johannesburg 2002, with acapital<strong>is</strong>ation of US $100 million. It <strong>is</strong>intended to fund small-scalerenewable energy and energyefficiency projects and <strong>is</strong> a joint projectwith <strong>the</strong> industry lobby group, <strong>the</strong>International Em<strong>is</strong>sions TradingAssociation (IETA). 10<strong>The</strong> Bio <strong>Carbon</strong> Fund, launched in <strong>the</strong>beginning of 2002, <strong>is</strong> intended tosupport carbon sequestration projectssuch as forest sinks and reduceem<strong>is</strong>sions from agricultural practices. 11Environmental<strong>is</strong>ts are concerned that<strong>the</strong> Bank <strong>is</strong> pushing controversialforest sinks projects despite a lack ofscientific consensus on <strong>the</strong>ir ability toabsorb carbon, and mass oppositionfrom community groups andindigenous peoples worldwide.wind power 5geo<strong>the</strong>rmal 1afforestation 2biomass 2hydropower 3Meanwhile, <strong>the</strong> corporate sector <strong>is</strong>taking heart. A World Bank studyfound that after <strong>the</strong> launch of <strong>the</strong> Bio<strong>Carbon</strong> Fund carbon trades in <strong>the</strong> firstsix months of 2002 by companiesdoubled in volume from <strong>the</strong> previousyear. 12 <strong>The</strong> Bank estimates thatcarbon trades increased by 400 percent in 2002 as a result of its highprofile financial backing of <strong>the</strong>system. 13 By creating <strong>the</strong>se funds, <strong>the</strong>Bank toge<strong>the</strong>r with <strong>the</strong> partnercorporations and governments areestabl<strong>is</strong>hing norms and standardswhich will have an enormous influenceon <strong>the</strong> rules governing <strong>the</strong>seprojects. 14Type of projectNumberwaste management 3energy efficiency 528
5. Key PlayersA survey of current activity shows acombination of governmental andprivate sector initiatives, inside andoutside of <strong>the</strong> Kyoto Protocol tradingregime. A complex network ofconsultancies and individuals underpina significant element of market designin governmental committees, businessassociations and <strong>the</strong>Intergovernmental Panel on ClimateChange (IPCC). Corporations havebeen active in <strong>the</strong> national schemes in<strong>the</strong> UK and Denmark, and <strong>the</strong> projectbasedmechan<strong>is</strong>ms facilitated by <strong>the</strong>Dutch government and <strong>the</strong> WorldBank’s Prototype <strong>Carbon</strong> Fund. <strong>The</strong>rehas also been a great deal of privatesector activity independent of <strong>the</strong>Kyoto regime. North Americancorporations have been <strong>the</strong> mostprolific actors in trading so far,especially Canadian contractors whohave been involved in more than 50per cent of trades. 1<strong>The</strong>re has been an explosion innumerous types of carbon marketfinancial services in brokerage, projectdevelopment, consultancy,procurement, online trading, financialjournal<strong>is</strong>m, event planning, projectfinancing and so on. <strong>The</strong> branding <strong>is</strong> asmooth mix of cyber-environmentaland financial language, forming nameslike: CO2e.com, Eyeforenergy,Natsource and Ecosecurities. <strong>The</strong>reare also more proactive and advancedconstellations of expert<strong>is</strong>e forminginternational trading associations,stakeholder dialogue fora andconsortia to conceptual<strong>is</strong>e <strong>the</strong> wayexchanges may work in <strong>the</strong> future. <strong>The</strong>next few pages provide a glimpse of<strong>the</strong> inhabitants of <strong>the</strong> world ofem<strong>is</strong>sions trading. It <strong>is</strong> notcomprehensive as <strong>the</strong>re are manymore brokers, consultants,corporations, NGOs and financialinstitutions currently crowding into <strong>the</strong>market.5.1 International FinancialInstitutionsEBRD: <strong>The</strong> European Bank forReconstruction and Development hasestabl<strong>is</strong>hed a programme for <strong>the</strong>project-based Kyoto mechan<strong>is</strong>m,primarily intended for Central andEastern Europe countries, known asJoint Implementation (JI). However,th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> less significant than <strong>the</strong> workdone by <strong>the</strong> World Bank’s Prototype<strong>Carbon</strong> Fund. <strong>The</strong> Dutch governmenthas made numerous agreements withdevelopment banks to establ<strong>is</strong>hfacilities to purchase GHG em<strong>is</strong>sionreduction credits. <strong>The</strong>se developmentbanks include <strong>the</strong> EBRD, as well as<strong>the</strong> International Finance Corporation(IFC), <strong>the</strong> Andean DevelopmentCorporation (CAF) and <strong>the</strong>International Bank for Reconstructionand Development (IBRD). 2Community Development <strong>Carbon</strong>Fund: In September 2002, <strong>the</strong>Community Development <strong>Carbon</strong>Fund was launched, a project initiatedtoge<strong>the</strong>r with <strong>the</strong> InternationalEm<strong>is</strong>sions Trading Association (IETA).<strong>The</strong> World Bank and IETA have joinedforces to collaborate on <strong>the</strong> US $100million fund, saying: “Five years after itstarted, <strong>the</strong> global carbon financebusiness...<strong>is</strong> approaching <strong>the</strong> halfbilliondollar level in cumulative tradevalue. It <strong>is</strong> expected that <strong>the</strong> carbonmarket will exceed one billion dollars ayear by 2008. Yet right now mostdeveloping countries are m<strong>is</strong>sing outon <strong>the</strong> benefits of carbon financedollars. <strong>The</strong> Bank’s responsibility <strong>is</strong> tomake sure that an equitable share ofth<strong>is</strong> money, much of it private sector,ends up in <strong>the</strong> hands of <strong>the</strong> poorest, in<strong>the</strong> poorest areas of developingcountries.” 3Bio<strong>Carbon</strong> Fund: Launched inNovember 2002, <strong>the</strong> Bio<strong>Carbon</strong> Fund,will again, be admin<strong>is</strong>tered by <strong>the</strong>World Bank, with a target size of US$100 million. <strong>The</strong> Bio<strong>Carbon</strong> Fund <strong>is</strong>29