FIVEANDINTRODUCTIONBroadly speaking, there are two categories <strong>of</strong> development. First, anything in the nature <strong>of</strong> construction operationwhich involves the erection and alteration <strong>of</strong> buildings, and engineering works on, above or under ground.Second, any material change in the use <strong>of</strong> existing buildings or land, which may or may not involve constructionoperation.<strong>The</strong> Government has always given the maximum freedom to private initiative. While detailed control <strong>of</strong> thedesign and use <strong>of</strong> building is considered inappropriate, certain degree <strong>of</strong> restrictive regulations and legislations areconsidered necessary:• to ensure that land is available for government projects and publicfacilities;• to encourage the separation <strong>of</strong> incompatible uses such as housing andheavy industry or obnoxious trades;• to control the building volume in order to limit the population to thatwhich can reasonably be provided in the area with road access, utilityservices and basic community facilities; and• to control the bulk <strong>of</strong> buildings allowing basic requirement <strong>of</strong> daylightpenetration and ventilation.Legislations and policies with implications on development control can be found in many ordinances andgovernment policy papers. In practice, development control is achieved by both statutory and non-statutorymeans, and quite a number <strong>of</strong> government departments/<strong>of</strong>fices are involved to implement these developmentcontrol measures.DEVELOPMENT CONTROL IN A REGIONAL CONTEXTAbout 75% <strong>of</strong> the land in <strong>Hong</strong> <strong>Kong</strong> is hilly. However, these rugged areas are valuable assets to the people <strong>of</strong><strong>Hong</strong> <strong>Kong</strong> in terms <strong>of</strong> their recreational and scenic potentials, as well as their vegetation and, to a lesser extent,wildlife habitation. <strong>The</strong>y also function as the water catchment areas channelling rain water to reservoirs.In order to protect water from pollution, catchment areas has to be relatively free from development. Under theWaterworks Ordinance, a map <strong>of</strong> 'gathering grounds' was prepared and approved by the Governor to empowerthe Government to resume land and control development within the designated gathering grounds. Watercatchments <strong>of</strong> various types covered more than 30% <strong>of</strong> the total land area <strong>of</strong> the Territory (Diagram 5.1).<strong>The</strong> Country Parks Ordinance, which came into effect in early 1976, provides for the designation, control andmanagement <strong>of</strong> country parks, enabling them to be conserved for recreational purposes. Where the Director <strong>of</strong>Agriculture and Fisheries considers that any use or proposed use <strong>of</strong> any leased land within a country park wouldsubstantially reduce the enjoyment and amenities <strong>of</strong> the country park as such, he may request the appropriateLand Authority to discontinue or modify the uses or prohibit the proceeding <strong>of</strong> the proposed use. <strong>The</strong>re are now21 country parks throughout the Territory, covering about 40% <strong>of</strong> the land area (Diagram 5.2).<strong>The</strong>se two ordinances have empowered the Government to exercise very restrictive development control in therural areas against urban sprawl and have practically 'frozen' them from development.STATUTORY CONTROLTown Planning Ordinance<strong>The</strong> Town Planning Ordinance, first enacted in 1939, provides for the appointment <strong>of</strong> a Town Planning Board andthe procedure to be adopted in preparing and approving statutory town plans. <strong>The</strong>se plans, outline zoning plans,are prepared for existing and potential urban areas. <strong>The</strong>y show areas zoned Tor Residential, Commercial,Industrial, Government, Institution and other purposes. Once a draft outline zoning plan is gazetted for publicinspection, it has statutory effect/Existing non-conforming uses are not affected by the plan; however, any newdevelopment—including building works and/or change <strong>of</strong> use—should conform with the zoning shown on the plan.<strong>The</strong> Ordinance provides no sanction nor penalities. <strong>The</strong> only 'teeth' are contained in Section 13 that reads:'Approved plans shall be used by all public <strong>of</strong>ficers and bodies as standards for guidance in the exercise <strong>of</strong> anypowers vested in them'. <strong>The</strong> exercise <strong>of</strong> development control mainly rests with the Crown lease conditions and theprovision <strong>of</strong> the Buildings Ordinance.Attached to and forming part <strong>of</strong> each draft or approved statutory plan is a Schedule <strong>of</strong> Notes which sets out,for each zoning shown on the plan, the following:• ' . • • • •:;-'' . • . ' • • • • . ' 2 2 • ' • , ' .-:.:. , • ' • • ' • •
• a list <strong>of</strong> uses which are always permitted under the zoning, in the firstcolumn;• a list <strong>of</strong> uses which may be permitted with or without conditions onapplication to the Town Planning Board, in the second column; and« such remarks qualifying special uses or special exceptions as may beappropriate (e.g. plot ratio imposed in the case <strong>of</strong> R(C) zoning), in thethird column.If a proposed development is a use under 'Column T, there is no need to apply for planning permission and thedevelopment can proceed as <strong>of</strong> right as long as it complies with the Crown lease, the Buildings Ordinance andother relevant legislation. If the proposed development is a use under 'Column 2' a planning application to theTown Planning Board is required. <strong>The</strong> Board in this case may either refuse the application or grant permission,subject to any conditions or restrictions that it may impose. If the proposed development is a use not shown under'Column 1' or 'Column 2', then it is not permissible for the development or redevelopment to proceed.On receiving the planning application, the Statutory Planning Section <strong>of</strong> the Town Planning Division willcirculate the application to relevant government departments/<strong>of</strong>fices for comments. Apart from the districtplanning authorities, the Transport Department, Buildings Ordinance Office, Lands Division, Fire ServicesDepartment, Urban Services Department and Environmental Protection Agency are the government bodies morecommonly involved. <strong>The</strong> practice <strong>of</strong> departmental circulation has become an important channel to solicit differentviews within Government on a specific issue <strong>of</strong> development control. <strong>The</strong>ir comments will be processed bythe Statutory Planning Section and presented to the Town Planning Board for consideration.From the above it can be seen that the Town Planning Ordinance is unique in a number <strong>of</strong> ways when comparedwith planning legislation in other countries. First, it covers the preparation <strong>of</strong> statutory outline zoning plans forexisting and potential designated urban areas. In other words, statutory planning does not cover the entireTerritory. Second, it has no direct power <strong>of</strong> development control. It relies on other legislations/documents toenforce its planning decisions. Third, there is no provisions within the Ordinance for compensation should alandowner be affected by a zoning proposal.Buildings OrdinanceLegislations on buildings existed as early as mid-19th Century. <strong>The</strong> early legislation arose from the need forresuming insanitary dwellings and later control set out the relationship between building height and the width <strong>of</strong>street onto which a building abuts. <strong>The</strong> Buildings Ordinance currently in force which governs the erection andalteration <strong>of</strong> buildings was enacted in 1955 and recently revised in 1981. It prescribes the maximum height, amount<strong>of</strong> open space, width <strong>of</strong> private streets and lanes, and all structural details. <strong>The</strong> Ordinance is administered by theBuildings Ordinance Office <strong>of</strong> the Building Development Department.<strong>The</strong> Ordinance has stated the grounds on which the Building Authority may refuse to give his approval <strong>of</strong> anyplans <strong>of</strong> building works where:• the carrying out <strong>of</strong> the building works would contravene the provisions <strong>of</strong>this Ordinance, the lease conditions or <strong>of</strong> any other enactment, or wouldcontravene any approved or draft plan prepared under the Town PlanningOrdinance.• the carrying out <strong>of</strong> the building works would result in a building differingin height, design, type or intended use from buildings in the immediateneighbourhood or previously existing on the same site.<strong>The</strong> Building (Planning) Regulations <strong>of</strong> the Buildings Ordinance contain provisions regarding heights andvolumes <strong>of</strong> buildings, projection, open spaces within sites, access lanes, lighting and ventilation, staircases and fireescapes, etc. and special clauses relating to domestic and temporary buildings.<strong>The</strong> Regulations carry very significant impacts on building volumes and ultimately on population density.Before 1955, the plot ratio <strong>of</strong> buildings averaged no more than 3 and the buildings were usually less than 25 metres(80 feet) high. Regulations introduced in 1956 permitted plot ratios <strong>of</strong> 6, and in some cases as high, as 20 whichfacilitated the erection <strong>of</strong> large multi-storey buildings. <strong>The</strong> intensity <strong>of</strong> development, combined with highoccupancy rates, led to congestion <strong>of</strong> the transport system, overloaded services, and inflated land values. As aresult <strong>of</strong> these problems, the Regulations were revised on several occasions. <strong>The</strong> latest amendment was introducedand has been in force since 1976.<strong>The</strong> schedules <strong>of</strong> the Building (Planning) Regulations cover the relationship between the heights <strong>of</strong> building, sitecoverages, plot ratios and use. As the building height and plot ratio increase, the permitted site coveragedecreases.Crown Lease ConditionsLand is sold or granted to the private sector for development on leasehold terms. <strong>The</strong> lease conditions are drawnup by the Lands Division <strong>of</strong> the Lands Department after consultation with the Town Planning Division and otherrelevant government departments. <strong>The</strong> Government could impose any conditions for development in the Crownlease when sites are sold or granted to the private sector for development. <strong>The</strong> lease conditions normally coveraspects <strong>of</strong> development control such as density, height, use, access, car parking and site formation, as well as moremundane matters such as drainage.23