DRAFT IS-GPS-705A Comment Resolution Matrix - GPS.gov

More documents

Recommendations

Info

IS-GPS-705 CRMCID Originator/Org. Page/Para Importance Comment PO Resolution & Concurrence Notesnot know where all the redundancies are, theyshould not be putting forth any proposedinterface changes until they identify where all theredundancies are.79 M DashPage: Gen CPO Resolution: RejectGPAPara:Comment: There is no document identifying therequirements redundantly repeated in200/705/800 documents.From:Final To: Provide a document of some kindidentifying common/redundant requirements in200/705/800 so that reviewers know what thePOC is intending to manage as common Rationale:Previous comments to remove redundancies byhaving 705 and 800 simply refer to 200 have beenrejected or deferred. As long as the redundanciesexist, the POC and reviewers now have theadditional burden of crosschecking 200/705/800to make sure the redundantly statedrequirements don’t diverge or contradict eachother. Particularly in the case of Army review, theprimary interest is 200. However, since 705 and800 contain information redundant of 200 thatthe Army cares about, all three documents haveto be reviewed. A document identifying theredundant areas would focus the Army review (aswell as other military reviewers) to the sectionsthey really care about.” There was also asimilar/related comment submitted against thebaseline 800 which was deferred.Rationale: Duplicate of the original comment #78made by GPC.Concurrence: Non-concurRationale:GPC rejects PO Resolution as referencedduplicate comment has not been answeredat this time, thus this comment remains ineffect. (05/21/09) 08-13-09: this is outsideof SE&I's scope and would requireadditional funding…SE&I stands byrejection.0 GPA Page:Para:CRationale: There was also a similar/relatedcomment submitted against the baseline 800which was deferred.Comment:From:PO Resolution: RejectRationale:GPC rejects PO Resolution as referencedduplicate comment has not been answeredat this time, thus this comment remains ineffect. (05/21/09) 08-13-09: this is outside38
IS-GPS-705 CRMCID Originator/Org. Page/Para Importance Comment PO Resolution & Concurrence NotesFinal To: These documents should be pulled from Concurrence: Non-concurof SE&I's scope and would requirethe CCB agenda until the sections in all threeadditional funding…SE&I stands bydocuments containing redundant requirements Rationale:rejection.are identified. The document identifying theredundancies is essential in performing the reviewand providing comments.80 KawakamiGPDPage: 35aPara: 6.3.4CRationale: It’s critical that changes to IS-GPS-200originate in the IS-GPS-200 ICWG process, and notfirst initiated as part of a change to 705 or 800.The only way to ensure this does not happen is tomodify the wording in 705 and 800 to refer to 200to the maximum extent possible. Assuming thePOCs for these documents understands where allthe redundancies are, putting something togethershould be a relatively minor task, and would beused by reviewers to identify the sections thatshould be referring back to 200. If the POCs donot know where all the redundancies are, theyshould not be putting forth any proposedinterface changes until they identify where all theredundancies are.Comment: The description of the additional PRNsequences is not consistent between IS-GPS-200,IS-GPS-705 and IS-GPS-800. When the previousversion of IS-GPS-800 was approved, the ICCassured that all three of the public ISs wouldcontain the same description. The ICC alsodecided that the additional PRN values would notbe moved to a separate document and that theISs would not point to a common document thatwould contain the official description of theadditional PRN sequences.PO Resolution: DeferRationale: Duplicate of comment #59Concurrence: ConcurRationale:(04/30/09) 11/19/08: Comment is in work.Action to Mike Munoz. Will remain open.20-aug-09: the resolution resides within AI#16 10-sept-09: this is also based on thePRN expansion AI for Karl Kovach. ChangedPO resolution to deferFrom: 6.3.4 Additional PRN Sequences. Among allunique L5-code sequences that could begenerated using different initial states asdescribed in Section 3.2.1.1, 74 sequences (37 I5and 37 Q5) are selected and assigned in Table 3-I.39
Page 4 and 5: IS-GPS-705 CRMCID Originator/Org. P
Page 72: IS-GPS-705 CRMCID Originator/Org. P

DRAFT IS-GPS-705A Comment Resolution Matrix - GPS.gov

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?