Kitsch Magazine: Fall 2015
Binaries
Binaries
- No tags were found...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
MULDER & SCULLY:<br />
MEANT TO BE<br />
even if the writers don’t think so<br />
byTia Lewis & Thelonia Saunders<br />
Even those who cringe at the acronym “OTP” (ourselves<br />
included) can’t deny it—the romance between FBI Agents Fox<br />
Mulder (David Duchovny) and Dana Scully (Gillian Anderson) in<br />
The X-Files harnesses an impressive chemistry. It goes beyond<br />
character, dialogue, and the actors themselves to become<br />
the very foundation of what makes the show great and, well,<br />
believable. For many who revel in the age of mid-90s sci-fi<br />
television trash, The X-Files has always been a tasty mix of the<br />
classic TV crime drama and science fiction-fantasy. A successful<br />
executive gamble, The X-Files has tackled its circuitous plot with<br />
gusto, covering perhaps every urban legend and mythology on<br />
earth, and has still found the time to fill an extraterrestrial<br />
storyline with Snowden-level government conspiracy theories.<br />
Despite its complexity, the dedication to the bizarre, and the<br />
nod to the American people’s distrust for their government, it’s<br />
Mulder and Scully’s ever-evolving relationship that undeniably<br />
holds the show together. But what happens when the beloved<br />
show is revived, and its writer does not know where else to go<br />
with the (spoiler alert) captivating romance he has created?<br />
Well, he splits them up, of course!<br />
In case you’ve been living in a different galaxy, here’s<br />
a little background. The X-Files is a franchise that began as<br />
a TV show on the Fox Network and ran from 1993 to 2001<br />
with nine seasons, 202 episodes, and two movies. It has been<br />
revived for a six-episode miniseries due to air next year, much<br />
to the unexpected bewilderment of many longtime fans. To<br />
add to that bewilderment was Fox’s announcement that in the<br />
revival, Mulder and Scully will have split up and essentially<br />
become estranged, despite the fact that they appeared happily<br />
and romantically involved in the 2008 film, The X-Files: I Want<br />
to Believe. It seems that the long will-they-won’t-they plot<br />
line was just too good for Carter to give up—or maybe, he just<br />
does not know how to continue writing an interesting, secure<br />
relationship between two characters. Of course, he isn’t the<br />
first writer to take back the obvious conclusion he’d so slowly<br />
built up. TV shows do this all the time, splitting up clearly “end<br />
game” couples to regain tension: take Nick and Jess in New<br />
Girl, or Blaine and Kurt in Glee. However, some shows commit<br />
to the relationships they create, and choose to advance them<br />
instead, like Leslie and Ben in Parks and Recreation and Mindy<br />
and Danny in The Mindy Project. So what’s your excuse, Chris<br />
Carter? When the majority of your fan base and even the<br />
actors on your show<br />
are rooting for the<br />
romance you’ve<br />
created, why tear<br />
apart the world’s<br />
most lovable<br />
alien-hunting FBI<br />
agents?<br />
Perhaps he<br />
doesn’t need to explain.<br />
Maybe it’s just who he is.<br />
Despite being the creator<br />
and frequent writer<br />
for the show, Carter<br />
has a longstanding<br />
history of being<br />
at odds with its<br />
fans. He has even<br />
inspired the trope<br />
of the “The Chris<br />
Carter effect,” which<br />
TV Tropes states is<br />
when “the fans decide<br />
that the writing team will<br />
never resolve its plots, [and]<br />
then... will probably stop following<br />
the work.” While some creators of<br />
popular shows, like Carter, love throwing in<br />
43