China
WcEiA
WcEiA
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Country starter pack<br />
Business practicalities in <strong>China</strong><br />
89<br />
Trade secrets<br />
• Trade secrets are technical or management<br />
information that is unknown to the public, but which<br />
is of practical value and can bring economic benefits<br />
to the rightful party. Product and brand elements<br />
such as unique names, packaging and ornamentation<br />
are also perceived to be trade secrets.<br />
• In <strong>China</strong>, trade secrets do not require registration.<br />
• The principal law governing trade secrets is the Anti-<br />
Unfair Competition Law.<br />
• The principal administrative enforcement agency is<br />
the Fair Trade Bureau of SAIC.<br />
Plant varieties<br />
Plant varieties are protected in <strong>China</strong> for a period of 15 or<br />
20 years, depending upon the type of plant.<br />
Technologies<br />
Since October 1, 2009 <strong>China</strong> has placed restrictions on<br />
the cross-border transfer of certain technologies.<br />
Violation of your IP<br />
Australian businesses should be prepared to act quickly<br />
and decisively to enforce their IP rights should they be<br />
infringed.<br />
There are several enforcement options for dealing with<br />
violation of IP:<br />
• Administrative enforcement<br />
• Civil litigation<br />
• Criminal law enforcement<br />
• Cease and desist (C&D) letters.<br />
Administrative enforcement<br />
The main way to deal with infringements is to file a<br />
complaint with one of the Chinese enforcement agencies<br />
that have specific powers to enforce IP rights:<br />
• Patents: SIPO<br />
• Trademarks: SAIC<br />
• Copyright: National Copyright Administration Office<br />
Customs and other agencies such as the Technology<br />
Supervision Bureau also have powers to deal with<br />
counterfeit goods. While their powers vary, these<br />
administrative agencies can usually fine offenders, seize<br />
goods or equipment and issue penalties. However,<br />
they do not have powers of arrest and cannot award<br />
compensation.<br />
While the administrative enforcement is usually very quick<br />
and low cost – it does not require any court procedure –<br />
it can be a limited deterrent and fines may be small. For<br />
complex IP cases, businesses may need to use the courts<br />
and for very large cases, may want to pursue a criminal<br />
prosecution. An administrative action can cost between<br />
$4,400 and $8,900.<br />
Civil litigation<br />
Companies can take civil action through a local People’s<br />
Court or an Intellectual Property Tribunal. The courts are<br />
suitable for dealing with:<br />
• More complex cases that cannot be handled by<br />
administrative authorities<br />
• Breaches where aggrieved parties seek damages, or<br />
want to send a strong message to the infringer.<br />
Civil litigation is more suitable where the infringer has<br />
assets and has the ability to pay damages. Though<br />
slower and more expensive than administrative action,<br />
companies increasingly are choosing the litigation path.<br />
Although damages awards for IP infringement are much<br />
lower than might be expected in Australia, they have been<br />
rising in recent years.<br />
Businesses seeking to bring a case to the courts should<br />
do so in larger cities, such as Beijing, Shanghai or<br />
Guangzhou, rather than in local courts which may have<br />
less IP expertise or which may be vulnerable to local bias.<br />
It is possible to combine administrative and civil action,<br />
so that an administrative ‘raid’ can be conducted first,<br />
followed by a civil suit to claim compensation. Costs for<br />
civil litigation can vary considerably depending on the<br />
complexity of a case, but may vary between $22,000<br />
and $44,000.<br />
Criminal prosecution<br />
<strong>China</strong>’s criminal law allows for prosecution of serious<br />
cases of piracy and counterfeiting. Only cases that are<br />
relatively large-scale, and where trademarks or copyright<br />
have been copied exactly, are eligible. The threshold for<br />
prosecution is based on a specific monetary value of<br />
the case, although valuing the case (by the number of<br />
counterfeit goods sold or seized) can be challenging. The<br />
police, as in many other countries, have limited resources<br />
and may be reluctant to investigate cases that they<br />
consider minor.<br />
Generally, the aggrieved party needs to prepare the<br />
details of the case in advance and report to the police,<br />
who do not simply act on preliminary leads. It is common<br />
for a case to be transferred from the administrative<br />
authorities if it’s considered large enough.<br />
Criminal cases require investment of time and resources<br />
to investigate leads and guide the case through the<br />
prosecution process. Costs can range from $22,000 to<br />
$44,000.<br />
Cease and desist letters<br />
C&D letters can be an effective way of putting a stop<br />
to infringement, if the infringer is too small in scale or<br />
not serious enough to warrant spending a lot of money.<br />
For example, traders on the internet are a suitable target<br />
for C&D letters demanding that they take down any<br />
infringing online products or logos.