exhibit 2 - SAP Lawsuit Portal
exhibit 2 - SAP Lawsuit Portal
exhibit 2 - SAP Lawsuit Portal
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Case4:07-cv-01658-PJH Document875-4 Filed09/16/10 Page19 of 27<br />
Moreover, the manner in which the themes of karma<br />
and redemption are expressed in [*66] each work is<br />
different. In Plaintiff's screenplay, the notion of karma<br />
has an obvious religious underpinning. At the beginning<br />
of the screenplay, Frankie's brother, who is a priest, tells<br />
Frankie: "you look like you've been out in the desert for<br />
forty days and forty nights! And the devils [sic] got the<br />
best of you." (Rubin Decl., Exh. D, at 85.) Frankie is then<br />
visited by an angel, who meets him at the Cemetery of<br />
the Blessed Virgin. The angel has divine powers; he stops<br />
the rain from falling and brings dying flowers back to<br />
life. The angel also can fly, and transforms himself into<br />
other beings, such as the blind homeless person and a<br />
white dove. The angel tells Frankie that he must take<br />
certain steps to save the soul of his unborn son, and when<br />
Frankie attempts to bargain with the angel, the angel tells<br />
him "it's not up to me anyway." (Id. at 91.) Later in the<br />
screenplay, Frankie asks the angel why he has chosen to<br />
guide Frankie, and the angel responds, "God believes he<br />
can resurrect all of his sons who have fallen." (Id. at 125.)<br />
As the screenplay progresses, Frankie turns his life<br />
around and begins to have faith in the power of God. For<br />
example, at the pivotal moment in the screenplay [*67]<br />
where Frankie goes undercover and successfully foils a<br />
major drug deal, his former Lieutenant tells Frankie that<br />
he did "real good." Frankie responds, "Yea, by the good<br />
grace of God." (Id. at 179.) (emphasis in the original).<br />
When the Lieutenant incredulously respond, ". . . God?<br />
As I recall, you never really believed in that sort of<br />
thing," Frankie responds, "Yea, well you could say I was<br />
baptized in that river." (Id.) (emphasis in the original). At<br />
the end of the screenplay, when Frankie dies, he turns<br />
into an angel. Frankie asks Angel Man about his wings,<br />
and Angel Man tells him, "You fell from grace, but<br />
you've earned them back." (Id. at 186.) The screenplay<br />
concludes with Frankie, now an angel, watching over<br />
Tori Ann. (Id. at 187-88).<br />
In sum, the religious overtone in Karma! is seen<br />
throughout the screenplay. Frankie's fall is "a fall from<br />
grace," and it is through his good works and his eventual<br />
acceptance of God that Frankie is redeemed. Frankie<br />
lives on after death, as an angel who watches over those<br />
he loves.<br />
In Earl, karma is not a religious concept, nor does<br />
Earl go through any type of faith-based transformation.<br />
Earl learns about Karma from Carson Daly, a Hollywood<br />
celebrity, [*68] during a televised interview. Daly is not<br />
a celestial being, he does not direct Earl to take any<br />
2010 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 77772, *65<br />
actions; indeed, he is not even speaking specifically to<br />
Earl. Daly never again appears in Earl, and does not<br />
"guide" or watch over Earl. Instead, Earl decides on his<br />
own to adopt Daly's karmic philosophy. In Earl, like in<br />
Karma!, the notion of karma is personified - Earl talks to<br />
"karma" in several episodes as though he were speaking<br />
to a person and implores karma to help him out of certain<br />
situations. However, the force of karma is not embodied<br />
in a celestial being, nor does it have a religious<br />
undertone. Unlike in Karma!, Earl is not saved "by the<br />
grace of God," he does not adopt any religious<br />
convictions, and he does not experience a religious<br />
rebirth.<br />
Thus, while both works share similar unprotectable<br />
themes, the expression of those themes is markedly<br />
different.<br />
b. Plot<br />
Page 18<br />
The story of redemption naturally begins with<br />
someone who needs to be redeemed, and ends with that<br />
same person doing good acts and making up for past<br />
wrongs. In this manner, both Earl and Frankie can quite<br />
easily be compared to Scrooge in Charles Dickens's A<br />
Christmas Carol. All three characters start as bad people,<br />
have [*69] a realization that their actions affect their<br />
future, and subsequently decide to lead better lives by<br />
making up for past wrongs. Again, this basic plot idea is<br />
not copyrightable. Berkic, 761 F.2d at 1293.<br />
Beyond these general plot ideas, and the fact that in<br />
both works the main character wins the lottery (discussed<br />
below), there is little in common between Earl and<br />
Karma! Earl is a small town low-life who steals, lies and<br />
bullies people on a regular basis. Although Frankie also<br />
steals once he is out of prison, Frankie is not just a<br />
low-life, but a disgraced detective who took bribes from<br />
criminals and associates with dangerous drug dealers.<br />
Further, the incarnation of each character's bad<br />
karma is markedly different. In Earl, karma retaliates for<br />
Earl's bad acts in random ways. For instance, when Earl<br />
undeservedly wins the lottery, he is hit by a car. Earl is<br />
motivated to do good deeds primarily to avoid karma's<br />
retribution against him. In Karma!, on the other hand,<br />
Angel Man tells Frankie that his bad karma will affect the<br />
life of his unborn son. Thus, Frankie is motivated to<br />
improve his own life, as well of the lives of others,<br />
including his son.