WELLSTAR_CHNA_REPORT_2016
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Your HEALTH. Our MISSION.<br />
Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)<br />
WellStar Cobb Hospital<br />
Austell, GA<br />
WellStar Douglas Hospital<br />
Douglasville, GA<br />
WellStar Kennestone Hospital<br />
Marietta, GA<br />
WellStar Paulding Hospital<br />
Hiram, GA<br />
WellStar Windy Hill Hospital<br />
Marietta, GA<br />
Cobb Hospital, Inc.<br />
EIN#: 58-0968382<br />
3950 Austell Road SW<br />
Austell, GA 30106<br />
Douglas Hospital, Inc.<br />
EIN#: 58-2026750<br />
8954 Hospital Drive<br />
Douglasville, GA 30134<br />
Kennestone Hospital, Inc.<br />
EIN#: 58-2032904<br />
677 Church Street<br />
Marietta, GA 30060<br />
Paulding Medical Center, Inc.<br />
EIN#: 58-2095884<br />
2518 Jimmy Lee Smith Pkwy.<br />
Hiram, GA 30141<br />
Kennestone Hospital, Inc.<br />
EIN#: 58-2032904<br />
677 Church Street<br />
Marietta, GA 30060
This report serves to identify and assess the health needs of the community served by WellStar<br />
Health System and its five not-for-profit hospitals. Submitted in fiscal year ended June 30, <strong>2016</strong> to<br />
comply with federal tax law requirements set forth in Internal Revenue Code section 501(r) and to<br />
satisfy the requirements set forth in IRS Notice 2011-52 and the Affordable Care Act for hospital<br />
facilities owned and operated by an organization described in Code section 501(c)(3).<br />
Website <strong>CHNA</strong> report is publicly available: www.wellstar.org/chna<strong>2016</strong><br />
Date <strong>CHNA</strong> adopted by WellStar Board of Trustees: June 2, <strong>2016</strong><br />
Date <strong>CHNA</strong> report made publicly available: June 30, <strong>2016</strong><br />
Date <strong>CHNA</strong> report required to be made publicly available<br />
(per Notice 2011-52): June 30, <strong>2016</strong><br />
Community input is encouraged.<br />
Please address <strong>CHNA</strong> feedback to chna@wellstar.org.
<strong>CHNA</strong> Executive Leadership:<br />
Kim Menefee<br />
Senior Vice President, Strategic Community Development<br />
Chair, WellStar Community Health Collaborative Task Force and Oversight Committee<br />
WellStar Community Health<br />
Collaborative Task Force:<br />
Vickie Beckler BSN, RN<br />
Program Coordinator, Lung Cancer Screening<br />
Brenda Brown BSN, RN<br />
Director, WellStar Diabetes Services<br />
Ryan E. Breshears, Ph.D., LP<br />
Chief Behavioral Health Officer, Clinical Psychologist<br />
Kristin Caudell<br />
Director, WellStar Community Education & Outreach<br />
Darold Etheridge<br />
Vice President, Finance and Chief Financial Officer,<br />
WellStar Cobb Hospital, Hospital Community Benefit Liaison<br />
Steven Fraime, BSN, M.B.A., M.H.A.<br />
Director, WellStar Center for Health Transformation<br />
Christopher “Shane” Greene<br />
Chief Financial Officer, WellStar Douglas Hospital<br />
Hospital Community Benefit Liaison<br />
Kristyn Greifer, M.D.<br />
Vice President, Population Health Management<br />
Cindy Holcomb, BSN, RN<br />
Heart Failure Program Manager<br />
Meridith Kelly<br />
Consultant, HighLand Productions, Inc.<br />
Janet Memark M.D., M.P.H., F.A.C.P.<br />
Medical Director, WellStar Kennestone Clinic<br />
Associate Program Director, WellStar Kennestone Hospital<br />
Internal Medicine Residency Program<br />
Kim Menefee<br />
Senior Vice President, Strategic Community<br />
Development<br />
Elaine Morgan<br />
Director, Brand Development and Marketing<br />
Carol O’Connell<br />
Assistant Vice President, Long Term Care and<br />
Support Services, WellStar Paulding Hospital<br />
Renee Owen, M.Div.<br />
Director of Pastoral Care, WellStar Kennestone Hospital<br />
Hospital Community Benefit Liaison<br />
Chirag Patel, M.D.<br />
Medical Director, Population Health<br />
Cecelia Patellis<br />
Assistant Vice President, Community Education & Outreach<br />
Tyler Pearson<br />
Director of Public Relations<br />
Lindsay Rehn, M.B.A.<br />
Executive Director of Finance and Operations,<br />
WellStar Paulding Hospital and Nursing Facility<br />
Hospital Community Benefit Liaison<br />
Kathy Sitten, RN<br />
Manager, Care Coordination, WellStar Kennestone Hospital<br />
Kamela Sooknanan<br />
Assistant Vice President, Population Health Management<br />
Julie Stebbins, M.S.<br />
Director, WellStar Cardiac Wellness & Rehabilitation<br />
Jeffrey L. Tharp, M.D., M.P.H.<br />
Chairman, Board Safety & Quality Committee Chief, Medicine<br />
Service Line, WellStar East Paulding Primary Care Center<br />
Mary Weatherby, LMSW<br />
Supervisor, Care Coordination, WellStar Kennestone Hospital<br />
D. Leigh Webb, M.P.H., CTR<br />
Manager, WellStar Cancer Data Center<br />
Community Partner<br />
Representatives:<br />
Belisa Urbina<br />
Executive Director, Ser Familia<br />
Kacie McDonnell, M.P.A.<br />
Director of Stewardship, Good Samaritan Health<br />
Center of Cobb<br />
Chris Fields<br />
Senior Vice President, Programs and Administration,<br />
MUST Ministries<br />
Frank Smith<br />
Director, The CarePlace<br />
Sandy Ingram, RN<br />
Practice Manager, Bethesda Community Clinic
WellStar Community Benefit<br />
Oversight Committee<br />
Candice Saunders, President & CEO<br />
David Anderson, Executive Vice President, Human Resources, Organizational Learning and Chief Compliance Officer<br />
Stephen Badger, Chief Administrative Officer, WellStar Medical Group<br />
John Brennan, M.D., Executive Vice President, Chief Clinical Integration Officer<br />
Jim Budzinski, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer<br />
Val Akopov, M.D., Senior Vice President, Hospital Division and Co-President of WellStar Medical Group<br />
Joe Brywczynski, Senior Vice President, Health Parks Development and Administration<br />
Amy Carrier, Senior Vice President and WellStar Cobb and Windy Hill Hospital President<br />
Jill Case-Wirth, Senior Vice President, Nursing Services, Chief Nursing Executive<br />
Barbara Corey, Senior Vice President, Managed Care<br />
Kristyn Greifer, M.D., Vice President, Population Health Management<br />
Mark Haney, Senior Vice President and WellStar Paulding Hospital President<br />
Kim Menefee, Senior Vice President, Strategic Community Development<br />
Kem Mullins, Executive Vice President, Ambulatory and Business Development<br />
Jon Morris, M.D., Senior Vice President, Chief Information Officer<br />
Alan Muster, M.D., Senior Vice President, Specialty Division and Co-President of WellStar Medical Group<br />
Craig Owens, Senior Vice President and WellStar Douglas Hospital President<br />
Carrie Plietz, Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Hospital Division<br />
Leo Reichert, Executive Vice President and General Counsel<br />
Dan Woods, Senior Vice President and WellStar Kennestone Hospital President
Executive Summary | Community is CARE 6<br />
Community Benefit Defined<br />
Triple Aim Framework<br />
Research Methods and Process<br />
Key Findings and Themes<br />
Priority Health Needs<br />
Community Health Needs Research<br />
Implementation and Outcome Goals<br />
Tracking WellStar Progress<br />
WellStar and the Community Served | Community is COMMITMENT 16<br />
The Enterprise<br />
The Entity<br />
Expansion for Innovation and Access<br />
Community Profile<br />
WellStar Hospitals’ Community At A Glance<br />
Socioeconomic Gradient in Health<br />
County Level Data Links<br />
Table of Contents<br />
Needs Assessment Overview | Community is CONTRIBUTION 32<br />
Process<br />
Research Methods and Timeline<br />
<strong>CHNA</strong> Collaboration<br />
Data Collection and Analysis<br />
Data Sources<br />
Community Input | Community is CONNECTION 38<br />
Community Collaborators<br />
Community Health Needs | Community is COMPASSION 42<br />
Major Health Challenges and Drivers<br />
Significant Needs<br />
Prioritization Process<br />
Priority Needs<br />
Needs Not Addressed<br />
Community Health Assets | Community is COLLABORATION 50<br />
Strategic Community Partnerships<br />
Potentially Available Community Resources<br />
Evaluation of Impact: Tracking WellStar’s Progress | Community is CHANGE 60<br />
2013 Implementation Update<br />
Tracking System-Wide Progress<br />
Tracking Hospital-Specific Progress<br />
Report References 72<br />
Significant Health Needs Data Summaries 79
COMMUNITY IS<br />
BUILDING A BIGGER TABLE
IT TAKES A GREAT WORK TO MEET GREAT NEEDS.<br />
A snapshot of community health needs.<br />
WellStar’s culture of health is as strong as our ability to instill a shared value of health<br />
in the community. Resilience is a skill when your aim is to impact community health.<br />
As a community-based not-for-profit health system, WellStar Health System’s<br />
(“WellStar”) vision to provide world-class healthcare extends beyond the patients we<br />
treat to the community we serve.<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
BENEFIT DEFINED<br />
Delivered by the WellStar Community Health Collaborative 1 and WellStar’s<br />
five hospitals, community benefit is an organized and measured approach<br />
WellStar takes to respond to identified community health needs. 2 The<br />
term implies collaboration with a “community” to “benefit” its residents.<br />
We provide community benefit by creating better access to healthcare<br />
and services, advancing medical and health knowledge through research,<br />
education and outreach and forging collaborative partnerships that reduce<br />
the burden on government and other tax-exempt organizations.<br />
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY<br />
In compliance with federal tax laws under the Affordable Care Act 3 , WellStar<br />
tracks and reports community benefit in the following categories:<br />
1: Financial Assistance (Charity Care)<br />
2: Government-Sponsored Means-Tested Health Programs<br />
(Provided in hospitals and hospitals’ outpatient facilities)<br />
3: Community Benefit Services (As an integrated health system, most<br />
services are delivered at a System-level in our hospital communities via<br />
the WellStar Community Health Collaborative and its partners; not by<br />
individual hospitals.)<br />
The provision of community benefit 4 is essential to the mission of WellStar to<br />
deliver the most advanced level of care to the community we serve. It also is<br />
a requirement to sustain WellStar’s status as Georgia’s largest not-for-profit<br />
healthcare system. In fiscal year 2015, WellStar invested 11 percent of total<br />
operating expenses in community benefit financial assistance, unreimbursed<br />
care and services totaling more than $220 million.
TRIPLE AIM<br />
FRAMEWORK<br />
WellStar is the community’s lead investor in facilities, services and programs to achieve<br />
the Institute of Healthcare Improvement’s (IHI) “Triple Aim” framework 5 to:<br />
(1) Improve the patient care experience 6<br />
(2) Improve the health of a population 7<br />
(3) Reduce healthcare costs<br />
This framework provides the criteria for actionable community benefit services to<br />
address priority health needs and for collaboration with vital community partners<br />
whose assets enhance and broaden the scope of WellStar and its hospitals’ capacity<br />
and expertise.<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
HEALTH NEEDS<br />
RESEARCH<br />
WellStar deployed a systematic approach 8 to collecting, analyzing and using data and<br />
community input to identify significant health needs and determine where current<br />
assets of WellStar and community partners enable action to help improve the health<br />
of the community, especially among the most vulnerable:<br />
Assessment Planning<br />
Driven by Community Input /<br />
Internal Audit<br />
Data Collection and<br />
Analysis and Prioritization<br />
of Health Needs<br />
Action /<br />
Implementation Planning<br />
From September to December 2015, Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)<br />
research was conducted by a third-party consultant and the Georgia Health Policy<br />
Center 9 on behalf of WellStar’s five not-for-profit hospitals - WellStar Cobb, Douglas,<br />
Kennestone, Paulding, and Windy Hill hospitals. 10<br />
To capture the health status of more than 1.4 million residents in WellStar’s five-county<br />
primary service area 11 (Bartow, Cobb, Cherokee, Douglas, and Paulding counties), the<br />
following questions guided the process:<br />
1. What is the current health status of the community WellStar serves?<br />
2. What are the major risk factors and causes of poor health in our community?<br />
3. What actions by WellStar and its partners are needed to address the risk<br />
factors and causes?<br />
4. What are the existing WellStar and community assets, programs and services that<br />
can help address the needs?<br />
5. Who are the partners or potential partners with the expertise and resources to<br />
help expedite a connection to healthcare, education and resources?<br />
8 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
RESEARCH<br />
METHODS<br />
AND PROCESS<br />
A broad spectrum of primary (qualitative) and secondary (quantitative) research methods<br />
were used including:<br />
• Surveys and interviews with multi-sector key stakeholders<br />
• Web-based health status survey of the community-at-large<br />
• Community focus groups in high need areas<br />
• Photo testimonies<br />
• Health status and resource assessment survey of the WellStar Medical Group<br />
• Extensive community health and utilization data across multiple sites and databases<br />
• Listening sessions with safety net clinic patients and uninsured/underserved<br />
members of faith-based organizations<br />
The full body of research was aggregated by the predominance of key findings and<br />
themes. Significant health needs were reviewed by leaders in WellStar Population Health<br />
Management and Strategic Community Development, the Georgia Health Policy Center, and<br />
Kennesaw State University’s (KSU) A.L. Burruss Institute of Public Service and Research. 12<br />
This was done in preparation for the WellStar Community Health Collaborative’s Health<br />
Needs Summit held on Feb. 25, <strong>2016</strong> – the platform for prioritizing significant health needs.<br />
KEY FINDINGS<br />
AND THEMES<br />
Although the five counties in the WellStar primary service area rank in Georgia’s top<br />
quartile for health, 13 there are pockets of poor health in every county. Many of affected<br />
communities are those we call “vulnerable populations” which include and may have<br />
the following attributes: the underinsured/uninsured, low income, 14 lower education<br />
attainment, limited English proficiency, poor health literacy, minorities, the elderly, and<br />
those who are transient and/or live in an unsafe physical environment and/or food desert. 15<br />
Many of the health challenges identified in the 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> remain relevant for each hospital.<br />
These include the disease burden from chronic disorders 16 (including cardiovascular<br />
disease, diabetes, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and cancer) and chronic disease<br />
primary drivers - obesity, tobacco use, poor nutrition, and physical inactivity.<br />
Economic security is either the greatest door or barrier to access healthcare and preventive<br />
services to keep people healthy. Income is a key driver of health status and where you live<br />
can largely determine how healthy you are.<br />
9
Underemployment and unemployment, due to low education attainment or other<br />
factors, challenge the mind, body and spirit of indigent and low-income residents.<br />
Community safety net clinic patients testify to the fiscal barriers which cause frustration<br />
and hopelessness which often leads to unhealthy behaviors and mental health issues, a<br />
health concern growing in prevalence.<br />
With unaffordable healthcare costs, the most vulnerable in our community feel disqualified<br />
from the preventive side of health, including tests and screenings. They seek care as a<br />
last resort. “Why spend money if nothing is wrong?” This is not just a sentiment among<br />
the 20 percent uninsured adult population in the five-county region 17 , but also for those<br />
who have rising Affordable Care Act premiums and other high deductible plans.<br />
Many “last resort” residents present in WellStar Emergency Departments (ED) with<br />
ambulatory care sensitive conditions and preventable hospital readmissions. According to<br />
internal data, approximately 22 percent of WellStar’s total ED visits in FY2015 were for<br />
non-emergent conditions that potentially could have been treated in an outpatient setting.<br />
There is a growing concern among key stakeholders representing vulnerable populations<br />
about the underuse of primary care (due to both access and cost barriers), unaffordable<br />
medication and specialist care, mental health issues, and substance abuse (specifically<br />
the rise of opioids/heroin). In addition to health disparities, transportation and physical<br />
environment factors like a lack of parks/sidewalks and neighborhood safety also were<br />
commonly cited among residents living in vulnerable areas. These factors also contribute<br />
to physical inactivity which increases the risk for obesity and chronic disease.<br />
Health disparities are compounded by the low provider-resident ratio in Bartow, Douglas<br />
and Paulding counties, although it’s still a level of concern community-wide. Underuse<br />
of primary care remains a barrier to navigating healthcare including accessing affordable<br />
medications and insurance / financial assistance programs.<br />
Health fairs, education and free screenings in the community are deemed beneficial, but<br />
with the lack of or awareness of low or no cost resources for follow-up care to manage<br />
a revealed or unmanaged condition, the services may be a point of stress among the<br />
vulnerable population. “Then what?” was a common question amplifying the need for<br />
a more seamless prescription of resources and self-management education. These<br />
needs were echoed by key stakeholders who serve this population.<br />
Many cite more collaborative efforts among the public health system 18 as the biggest<br />
catalyst for change and improvement in community health. Stakeholders noted the<br />
need to leverage the expertise of organizations that already address significant health<br />
needs and strategically pool funding and resources to maximize outcomes.<br />
10 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
After a thematic analysis of health needs data, priorities were identified by the WellStar Community Health<br />
Collaborative Task Force at a February <strong>2016</strong> Health Needs Summit. The task force, made up of a broad spectrum<br />
of WellStar team members and community stakeholders representing vulnerable populations, used the Triple<br />
Aim framework and current assets / capacity measures 19 to prioritize significant health needs.<br />
The overriding question:<br />
Which health needs, when collaboratively addressed, will make the greatest difference in care access,<br />
care quality and costs to improve the health of the community, especially the most vulnerable?<br />
The task force identified the following as priority health needs<br />
for the WellStar community’s five hospitals:<br />
11
PRIORITY HEALTH NEEDS<br />
Access to Care<br />
• Underuse of primary care<br />
- Lack of care capacity in community<br />
safety net clinics<br />
- Overuse of Emergency Department for<br />
non-emergent needs<br />
Healthy Lifestyles 20<br />
• Cancer<br />
• Cardiovascular Disease<br />
• Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease /<br />
Asthma<br />
• Type 2 Diabetes<br />
• Obesity
IMPLEMENTATION<br />
AND OUTCOME<br />
GOALS<br />
Recognizing health and social factors are closely intertwined, the priority health needs<br />
require collaborative public health and primary care interventions (see the figure below)<br />
to help prevent disease and injury, promote health and well-being, assure conditions in<br />
which people can be healthy, and provide timely, effective and coordinated healthcare. 21<br />
Social, economic & environmental<br />
conditions that act as the primary<br />
determinants of individual and<br />
population health<br />
Health services and education<br />
+ +<br />
Clinical care interventions<br />
Public health activities that<br />
target populations and<br />
address individual health<br />
behaviors<br />
= IMPROVED<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
HEALTH<br />
PRIMARY AREAS OF <strong>WELLSTAR</strong> INFLUENCE<br />
TO PROVIDE THE RIGHT CARE<br />
AT THE RIGHT PLACE<br />
Galvanizing efforts and resources to achieve optimal community health outcomes is vital to:<br />
• Improve access to care.<br />
Help break access barriers (includes cost of care) and bridge service gaps,<br />
especially for the most vulnerable.<br />
• Improve community health status.<br />
Support a healthier community by providing health needs-specific preventive<br />
health services and education focused on reducing the incidence and prevalence<br />
of chronic disease.<br />
• Strengthen and build strategic community partnerships 22 .<br />
Collaborate to leverage and maximize assets/capacity and prescribe resources<br />
to address priority health needs, drivers and disparities.<br />
14 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
TRACKING<br />
<strong>WELLSTAR</strong>’S<br />
PROGRESS<br />
Since the inaugural 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong>, WellStar has made a seismic shift from a volume-based<br />
care delivery system to an integrated, value-based care delivery system 23 . With a focus on<br />
prevention and wellness, we’re transforming care delivery and recalibrating System-wide<br />
community benefit strategy to more effectively and efficiently align with the health priorities<br />
of our residents, Public Health (public and private-sector partners) and key stakeholders.<br />
Progress made on WellStar’s two-phased community benefit implementation strategy 24<br />
has created a more sustainable framework for actionable community benefit services, yet<br />
was too broad in scope. More work is needed in the structure, delivery and evaluation of<br />
these activities and to replicate the community benefit model across multiple hospitals in an<br />
expanding Georgia footprint.<br />
A more detailed<br />
progress report<br />
based on<br />
community<br />
benefit<br />
categories is<br />
on page 60.<br />
In other areas, WellStar’s taken a non-linear approach to addressing health needs by initiating<br />
evidence-based care models, such as developing an integrated behavioral health network to<br />
address growing mental health issues and the expansion of prevention-based education and<br />
clinical care services. This includes clinical training for smoking cessation and a Comprehensive<br />
Care Clinic focused on chronic disease management and treatment of high-risk patients.<br />
Partnerships with community safety net clinics are being redefined and expanded laying the<br />
groundwork for more collaborative and affordable community benefit services and education.<br />
This includes leveraging the compassion, expertise and health knowledge of team members and<br />
care providers via the new WellStar 4-1 Care Network 25 . The network is a conduit for reducing<br />
Emergency Department utilization through hospital-based care coordination, navigation to<br />
the right care at the right place and WellStar Medical Group (WMG) physicians and advanced<br />
practice professionals volunteerism in community safety net clinics to help build needed care<br />
capacity to serve more medically underserved and uninsured residents.<br />
We established two more hospital outpatient community clinics in areas of high need to provide<br />
access to OB/GYN and internal medicine. Care will be delivered by attending physicians and<br />
residents participating in the new Graduate Medical Education program.<br />
Through the WellStar Center for Health Transformation, we innovated ways to improve care<br />
delivery in alliance with multi-sector partners, leading research institutes and technology to<br />
energize and enable cutting-edge solutions that improve care and reduce healthcare costs 26 .<br />
We brought quality community-based outpatient care and services to more neighborhoods<br />
via our convenient and cost-efficient Health Park model – a lauded concept for improving care<br />
access modeled nationwide – with two operational parks and one currently under construction<br />
in Vinings.<br />
We instituted WellStar Clinical Partners, a physician-led, clinically integrated organization, to<br />
help optimize the wellbeing of the community. Its collaborative health management focus is<br />
foundational to maximize value for patients and improve the delivery of and access to worldclass<br />
care. To date, the organization is comprised of 1,167 affiliated physicians, including nearly<br />
600 WMG physicians in more than 220 practice locations.<br />
We established disease-specific clinics for leading causes of death (e.g. heart disease and<br />
COPD) to provide more comprehensive care management and behavior/lifestyle modification<br />
tools and education to improve community health.<br />
15
COMMUNITY IS
STRENGTHENING SCALE<br />
BROADENING CAPABILITIES<br />
ENHANCING EFFICIENCY<br />
IMPROVING QUALITY<br />
WellStar and the Community Served<br />
WellStar is Georgia’s largest not-for-profit health system, a national leader in the<br />
transformation of healthcare delivery 27 and recognized as the fifth most integrated<br />
healthcare delivery system 28 in the nation.<br />
THE<br />
ENTERPRISE<br />
The WellStar Mission for our community:<br />
To create and deliver high quality hospital, physician and other healthcare-related<br />
services that improve the health and well-being of the individuals and community<br />
we serve.<br />
The WellStar Vision for our community:<br />
To deliver world-class healthcare to our community. Our vision manifests itself<br />
through a wide variety of supportive endeavors by which we provide excellent,<br />
compassionate and holistic care. That means making preventive health screenings,<br />
educational support and the highest quality of medical care available to everyone.<br />
17
153,000 community members had access to<br />
health fairs and community education.
Partnerships with community safety net clinics allow<br />
medically underserved and uninsured patients to receive<br />
WellStar lab and radiology services at no or reduced cost.<br />
have benefited from WellStar’s<br />
eighth in the nation-ranked<br />
Accountable Care Organization<br />
(ACO) 29
DELIVERY OF COMMUNITY BENEFIT SERVICES<br />
Categories:<br />
Community Health Improvement Services<br />
Subsidized Health Services<br />
Health Professions Education<br />
Research<br />
Cash and In-Kind Contributions<br />
Community Building Activities<br />
$8,113,000<br />
$14,380,000<br />
$7,660,000<br />
88%<br />
INCREASE<br />
ACCESS TO CARE SINCE 2013 30<br />
IN THE INVESTMENT IN COMMUNITY<br />
BENEFIT PROGRAMS AND SERVICES<br />
DESIGNED TO IMPROVE HEALTH AND<br />
FY2013<br />
FY2014<br />
FY2015<br />
20 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
THE<br />
ENTERPRISE<br />
(CONTINUED)<br />
The majority of WellStar’s community benefit dollars provide indigent (below 125 percent<br />
of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) 31 and charity care (between 125 and 300 percent FPL) to<br />
eligible patients 32 at all hospital and hospital-based facilities.<br />
WellStar also provided an additional $47.5 million in unreimbursed care in FY2015 to those<br />
who didn’t apply for charity care, but were unable to pay for services (the cost of delivering<br />
care). The amount is a 27.3 percent decrease from 2014 after a significant increase (23.3<br />
percent) in care provision from 2013 to 2014 33 .<br />
“Hotspot” Maps: Population<br />
Below 125% FLP – Indigent<br />
Below 300% FPL - Charity<br />
Population percentage<br />
at or above 300 FPL<br />
Do not qualify for WellStar<br />
Community Financial Assistance<br />
Percentage of that population<br />
at or above 300 FPL that is<br />
uninsured<br />
21
THE ENTITY<br />
Geographically enlarging the community’s access to care and clinically integrating the<br />
way healthcare is provided improves patient satisfaction, health outcomes and overall<br />
community health.<br />
Delivering Care In Your Neighborhood<br />
WellStar Congregational<br />
Health Network<br />
Hospitals<br />
Urgent Care Center<br />
Health Park<br />
Community Clinic or Partner Safety Net Clinic 34<br />
WellStar Medical Group locations<br />
22 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
EXPANSION FOR<br />
INNOVATION<br />
AND ACCESS<br />
On April 1, <strong>2016</strong>, WellStar Health System expanded its footprint beyond its historic<br />
Northwest Georgia base. WellStar brought its vision of world-class healthcare to new<br />
communities and patients, following due diligence, regulatory review and thorough<br />
integration planning.<br />
With the acquisition of Tenet Healthcare’s five Georgia-based hospitals (in Butts, Fulton,<br />
Jackson and Spalding counties) and a new partnership with West Georgia Health in<br />
LaGrange (Troup County), WellStar becomes the largest health system in Georgia and<br />
one of the largest not-for-profit health systems in the country. With approximately<br />
20,000 team members, the new 11 hospital system will expand upon its proven clinical<br />
care models and patient safety programs that have resulted in increased quality and<br />
improved access to healthcare in its new communities.<br />
Joining WellStar’s existing five hospitals are: WellStar Atlanta Medical Center, WellStar<br />
Atlanta Medical Center South, WellStar North Fulton Hospital, WellStar Spalding<br />
Regional Hospital, WellStar Sylvan Grove Hospital and WellStar West Georgia Medical<br />
Center. All facilities will now be operated as not-for-profits.<br />
WellStar Medical Group, one of the largest employed physician groups in the Southeast,<br />
will expand to more than 1,000 physicians and advanced practice professionals across<br />
more than 220 medical office locations and numerous outpatient facilities.<br />
With ever-changing government regulations and reimbursement pressures, health<br />
systems across the country are looking for new efficiencies. To better serve its<br />
patients, WellStar chose to be proactive to secure the future of high-quality care in its<br />
communities. The geography of West Georgia Health and Tenet’s five Georgia hospitals<br />
complements WellStar’s current footprint. With a larger integrated system, WellStar<br />
will continue its strategic focus on the Triple Aim—higher quality, improved access and<br />
affordable healthcare.<br />
23
COMMUNITY PROFILE<br />
Residents living in a five-county region (Bartow, Cobb, Cherokee, Douglas, and Paulding counties)<br />
comprise the primary community served by WellStar Cobb, Douglas, Kennestone, Paulding, and<br />
Windy Hill hospitals. Community is defined geographically, by WellStar hospitals’ intersecting 90<br />
percent catchment areas irrespective of county lines, and statistically, by the demographics and<br />
determinants of health reported in the <strong>CHNA</strong>.<br />
Bartow<br />
COUNTY POPULATION<br />
101,736<br />
35<br />
Cherokee<br />
COUNTY POPULATION<br />
230,985<br />
BELOW 18 ABOVE 65<br />
26% 12%<br />
BELOW 18 ABOVE 65<br />
27% 11%<br />
Paulding<br />
COUNTY POPULATION<br />
148,987<br />
BELOW 18 ABOVE 65<br />
28% 9%<br />
WellStar Community is<br />
51% FEMALE<br />
24 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
Cobb<br />
COUNTY POPULATION<br />
730,981<br />
Douglas<br />
COUNTY POPULATION<br />
138,776<br />
BELOW 18 ABOVE 65<br />
25% 10%<br />
BELOW 18 ABOVE 65<br />
27% 10%<br />
County Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
Percentage of uninsured<br />
adults 18-65 36 22% 19% 21% 21% 18% 21%<br />
Median age of the<br />
uninsured is 34<br />
Total Number of uninsured 37 18,408 33,169 124,371 23,771 20,712<br />
Percentage of<br />
uninsured<br />
Hispanic/Lation<br />
16 28 31 18 10<br />
Population on<br />
Medicaid/means tested<br />
13,506 15,895 58,383 16,161 13,382<br />
public coverage 38<br />
Georgia was among 39 states whose uninsured rate dropped by more than three<br />
percentage points after the insurance changes debuted in 2014, yet the state’s percentage of people without<br />
coverage is still among the highest in the nation. 39<br />
25
40
SOCIOECONOMIC<br />
GRADIENT IN<br />
HEALTH<br />
A mission-driven approach to profile a community’s health is to encapsulate it by<br />
the “socioeconomic gradient in health.” This refers to the stepwise fashion health<br />
outcomes improve as socioeconomic position improves. This gradient can be<br />
measured by:<br />
1. Income 41<br />
2. Occupation<br />
3. Level of education achieved 42<br />
INCOME<br />
Children Living in Poverty 43<br />
Georgia – 26%<br />
Bartow - 21%<br />
Cherokee – 13%<br />
Cobb – 18%<br />
Douglas – 20%<br />
Paulding – 16%<br />
+<br />
+<br />
OCCUPATION<br />
Unemployment 44<br />
Georgia – 7 %<br />
Bartow - 7%<br />
Cherokee – 6%<br />
Cobb – 6%<br />
Douglas – 7%<br />
Paulding – 6%<br />
EDUCATION ATTAINMENT<br />
<strong>2016</strong> Estimated Population Age 25+ in 90% Hospital Catchment Area<br />
Cobb<br />
Some High School,<br />
no diploma 7%<br />
High School Graduate<br />
(or GED) 26%<br />
Some College, no degree 22%<br />
Bachelor’s Degree 22%<br />
Other 24%<br />
Douglas<br />
Some High School,<br />
no diploma 8%<br />
High School Graduate<br />
(or GED) 31%<br />
Some College, no degree 24%<br />
Bachelor’s Degree 16%<br />
Other 21%<br />
Kennestone<br />
Some High School,<br />
no diploma 6%<br />
High School Graduate<br />
(or GED) 24%<br />
Some College, no degree 22%<br />
Bachelor’s Degree 24%<br />
Other 24%<br />
Paulding<br />
Some High School,<br />
no diploma 8%<br />
High School Graduate<br />
(or GED) 31%<br />
Some College, no degree 24%<br />
Bachelor’s Degree 17%<br />
Other 21%<br />
Windy Hill<br />
Some High School,<br />
no diploma 6%<br />
High School Graduate<br />
(or GED) 24%<br />
Some College, no degree 21%<br />
Bachelor’s Degree 24%<br />
Other 24%<br />
“You have families with a<br />
lot of health issues, a lot of<br />
problems, struggling…Why<br />
finish high school when (you)<br />
can get a job and help your<br />
family?”<br />
- Good Samaritan Health Center<br />
of Cobb patient<br />
28 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
HEALTH OUTCOMES<br />
=<br />
Bartow<br />
38<br />
2013/61<br />
Paulding<br />
9<br />
2013/25<br />
Health<br />
Cherokee<br />
6<br />
2013/6<br />
Outcomes<br />
<strong>2016</strong> County Health<br />
Outcomes 45<br />
Bartow Ranking<br />
(out of 159 counties)<br />
Douglas<br />
36<br />
2013/27<br />
Cobb<br />
7<br />
2013/6<br />
In addition to socioeconomic factors, health outcomes also are based on<br />
three other determinants of health factors:<br />
Health Behaviors<br />
Clinical Care<br />
Physical Environment<br />
Bartow<br />
47<br />
2013/50<br />
Paulding<br />
14<br />
2013/16<br />
Cherokee<br />
6<br />
2013/5<br />
Douglas<br />
45<br />
2013/28<br />
Cobb<br />
7<br />
2013/7<br />
Health Factors<br />
<strong>2016</strong> County Health Factors Ranking<br />
29
GEORGIA<br />
16%<br />
Health Behaviors 46<br />
GEORGIA<br />
25%<br />
PAULDING<br />
15%<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
17%<br />
ADULT<br />
SMOKING<br />
COBB<br />
14%<br />
BARTOW<br />
17%<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
14%<br />
PAULDING<br />
28%<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
34%<br />
GEORGIA<br />
29%<br />
ADULT<br />
OBESITY 47<br />
COBB<br />
22%<br />
BARTOW<br />
34%<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
26%<br />
PAULDING BARTOW<br />
26%<br />
27%<br />
PHYSICAL<br />
INACTIVITY<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
26%<br />
22%<br />
COBB<br />
18%<br />
Primary Care Physicians 48<br />
Residents to One Provider Ratio<br />
Clinical Care<br />
Mental Health Providers<br />
Residents to One Provider Ratio<br />
GEORGIA<br />
BARTOW<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
COBB<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
PAULDING<br />
1,540: 1<br />
2,150: 1<br />
2,920: 1<br />
1,540: 1<br />
2,310: 1<br />
7,730: 1<br />
GEORGIA<br />
1,050:<br />
850:<br />
BARTOW<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
COBB 700:<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
PAULDING<br />
GEORGIA COBB<br />
15%<br />
BARTOW<br />
17%<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
Severe Housing Problems 49<br />
1,150:<br />
1,240:<br />
Physical Environment<br />
18%<br />
15%<br />
16%<br />
18%<br />
1<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
PAULDING<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
2,810:<br />
1<br />
30 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
Top 5<br />
Leading Causes of Death 50<br />
County Level Data<br />
DIG IN<br />
For more in-depth county health<br />
status profiles, 51 send a request to<br />
chna@wellstar.org.<br />
Bartow<br />
Cherokee<br />
Cobb<br />
Douglas<br />
Paulding<br />
31
COMMUNITY IS
<strong>CHNA</strong> PROCESS<br />
The broad spectrum of qualitative and quantitative data collected in this <strong>CHNA</strong> report<br />
reflect the health needs of the WellStar community. For assessment planning and<br />
gathering community input, the following steps were taken:<br />
• Created a timeline for gathering and obtaining community input<br />
• Located and obtained existing community health data<br />
• Secured commitment from strategic community partners for data collection<br />
(e.g. sites and patient recruitment for focus groups/listening sessions, partners<br />
to distribute online survey and as key informants)<br />
• Developed research tools based upon health indicators, input from other health<br />
systems/organizations and the MAPP process used for the 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> 52<br />
• Identified populations from which to obtain data (e.g. low-income population, faith<br />
community, care providers, minorities, medically underserved and uninsured)<br />
• Considered language barriers for data collection (Spanish translation of community<br />
survey provided and three Spanish-language focus groups conducted)<br />
• Developed quantitative survey tools and a distribution plan<br />
• Determined and developed qualitative methodology of focus groups/listening<br />
sessions<br />
• Secured approval of research tools/guides and participant consent forms<br />
• Collected community input data via email, phone, web-based survey reports, group<br />
meetings (focus groups/listening sessions), onsite interviews, WellStar hospital<br />
president meetings, Facebook links, and surveys posted on community partner and<br />
agency websites<br />
• Solicited assistance to gather health indicator data mirroring Healthy People 2020 53<br />
(including demographic data, social and economic factors, education attainment,<br />
health behaviors, and access to clinical care) - assessed using databases of national<br />
and state agencies, public health and non-profit health systems.<br />
Community Health Needs Assessment Overview<br />
33
RESEARCH<br />
METHODS AND<br />
TIMELINES<br />
• Quantitative data mining (multiple sources): November – March <strong>2016</strong><br />
• Focus groups in high need areas: November – December 2015<br />
• Listening sessions with low-income residents (safety nets and congregations):<br />
October 2015<br />
• Key informant interviews and surveys: September – December 2015<br />
• Photo testimonies: October 2015<br />
• Online community health status survey: September – November 2015<br />
• Online WellStar Medical Group survey: October 2015<br />
<strong>CHNA</strong><br />
COLLABORATION<br />
To support the development of the <strong>2016</strong> <strong>CHNA</strong> and to foster broad collaboration among<br />
health systems and hospitals, WellStar engaged Georgia Health Policy Center (GHPC) 54<br />
in the Andrew Young School of Policy Studies at Georgia State University to work with<br />
its third-party <strong>CHNA</strong> consultant to leverage the research it does for Kaiser Permanente.<br />
As a result, GPHC’s data collection and analysis contributed to the <strong>CHNA</strong>s of four<br />
health systems (WellStar Health System, Grady Health System, Kaiser Permanente, and<br />
Piedmont Healthcare), a health plan and an urban county health department.<br />
Specific tasks of WellStar’s third-party consultant with assistance from the GHPC<br />
included:<br />
• Collecting, analyzing, and synthesizing state, county-specific and local level data<br />
• Soliciting community input<br />
• Coordinating WellStar team members for internal data and program information<br />
• Assimilating stakeholder, community member and clinical team recommendations<br />
• Leading the prioritization process with WellStar team members and community<br />
partners<br />
• Identifying community-based organizations and other institutional assets engaged in<br />
health improvement<br />
• Ensuring 501(r) regulations are met<br />
WellStar also partnered with KSU’s Burruss Institute to help facilitate the health needs<br />
prioritization summit of the WellStar Community Health Collaborative Task Force which<br />
includes key community stakeholders.<br />
34 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
DATA COLLECTION<br />
AND ANALYSIS<br />
Insights from 99 WellStar Medical Group (WMG) representatives 55 regarding patient<br />
health status and community resources were gleaned from an online survey tool sent<br />
to WMG providers (MDs and nurse practitioners) and registered nurses.<br />
A wide net was cast for community input using a similar online survey tool (English and<br />
Spanish) capturing demographics and overall personal health status and behaviors<br />
of 447 community members. 56 Community clinics, health e-newsletters, workplace<br />
partners, a Public Health Department, a school system, a Hispanic non-profit, and<br />
faith-based organizations disseminated the online link via email and social media. It’s<br />
approximated the survey link was distributed to 5,000 people.<br />
61 key informant surveys/interviews (all WellStar driven except eight by GHPC) were<br />
conducted with multi-sector leaders representing diverse organizations including<br />
Public Health Departments, governmental agencies, community safety net clinics,<br />
business leaders, and regional health board representatives. Collecting information<br />
from a wide range of experts with first-hand knowledge about the community provided<br />
insight on health issues and care barriers along with recommended interventions.<br />
To provide a broader base of input and use the <strong>CHNA</strong> process as a means to strengthen<br />
community partnerships, seven listening sessions (three in Spanish) were conducted<br />
with 58 medically underserved and uninsured community members. Sessions were<br />
with partnering community safety net clinic patients (Bethesda Community Clinic in<br />
Cherokee, Good Samaritan Health Center in Cobb, The CarePlace in Douglas), Latino<br />
community members (WellStar Congregational Health Network members Iglesia de<br />
Dios in South Cobb and McEachern UMC in Powder Springs), Ser Familia community<br />
members 57 , and the Paulding County Health Department 58 . Two of the three sessions<br />
conducted in Spanish were facilitated by the Hispanic Health Coalition of Georgia.<br />
The Executive Director of Ser Familia co-conducted the third session with WellStar’s<br />
third-party consultant. In each listening session, a few community members provided<br />
a photo testimony to communicate their greatest health-related need.<br />
To fortify the seven listening sessions and gain a broader base of input, GPHC also<br />
conducted five focus groups with 41 participants in high need areas in each county in<br />
WellStar’s primary service area. Locations of this primary research are mapped out on<br />
the following page.<br />
35
Approximated Locations of the <strong>CHNA</strong> Listening Sessions<br />
and Focus Groups at Safety Nets and in High Need Areas<br />
BARTOW<br />
FG<br />
FG<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
LS<br />
LS<br />
LS<br />
PAULDING<br />
COBB<br />
LS<br />
Paulding County<br />
Health Department<br />
FG<br />
LS<br />
McEachern<br />
United Methodist Church<br />
LS<br />
FG<br />
LS<br />
LISTENING SESSION<br />
LS<br />
FG<br />
FOCUS GROUP<br />
The CarePlace<br />
FG<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
36 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
DATA SOURCES<br />
Secondary Data (Quantitative county-level summaries of demographic and health<br />
information for the hospitals’ service area)<br />
Assigning statistics to core health indicators gave a broader, overarching view of the<br />
community's health status.<br />
WellStar:<br />
• Georgia Student Health Survey (Behavioral Risk Survey)<br />
• Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Community Health Improvement Navigator 59<br />
• Cobb & Douglas Public Health data<br />
• Community Commons<br />
• County Health Ranking and Roadmaps - includes data from the CDC’s Behavioral<br />
Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) 60<br />
• Georgia Department of Public Health<br />
• WellStar Enterprise Intelligence for Emergency Department utilization<br />
• Catholic Health Association<br />
• Vulnerable and At-Risk Populations Resource Guide 61<br />
GHPC sources included publicly available datasets 62 :<br />
• Community Commons <strong>CHNA</strong> Portal 63<br />
• Georgia’s Online Analytical Statistical Information System (OASIS) 64<br />
• U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Dataset 65<br />
• Area Resource File<br />
• County Health Rankings and Roadmaps which utilizes myriad of data sources<br />
• Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for HIV/AIDS,<br />
Viral Hepatitis, STD, and TB Prevention<br />
Primary Data<br />
In addition to the community safety net clinic patients and residents in high need areas,<br />
an extensive list of leaders and community members representing Public Health and<br />
multi-sector and non-profit organizations serving the broader community are listed in<br />
the Community Input section that follows.<br />
37
COMMUNITY IS<br />
YOUR STORY IS OUR STORY
COMMUNITY<br />
COLLABORATORS<br />
Requests for input from individuals with a stake in community health representing the<br />
broad interests of the community 66 began in August 2015 with feedback continuing<br />
through December 2015. Some stakeholders solicited for input did not respond 67 .<br />
The <strong>CHNA</strong> contributions of the following organizations were vital to gather a wide<br />
array of insight, expertise and data to identify community health needs, assets and<br />
barriers to care.<br />
WellStar acknowledges and thanks the following for their participation. All were key<br />
informants except where noted. Organizations in italics were contacted by the GHPC<br />
as part of the collaborative <strong>CHNA</strong> research conducted by Grady, Kaiser Permanente,<br />
Piedmont Healthcare, and WellStar.<br />
A.L. Burruss Institute for Public Service & Research – <strong>CHNA</strong> health needs review/<br />
feedback, facilitation of health needs prioritization<br />
Allatoona Resource Center<br />
American Cancer Society – Cobb2020 68 Steering Committee member<br />
American Cancer Society – Marietta Health Department, Client Navigation Program<br />
Atlanta Regional Commission<br />
Austell Community Task Force – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
Bartow Public Health Department<br />
Bethesda Community Clinic (Cherokee County) - key informant, listening session<br />
site and community representative on WellStar Community Health Collaborative<br />
Task Force<br />
The CarePlace (Douglas County) – key informant, listening session site and<br />
community representative on WellStar Community Health Collaborative Task Force<br />
Center for Pan Asian Community Services<br />
Chattahoochee Technical College – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
Cherokee County Department of Family & Children Services<br />
Cherokee County Health Department<br />
Cherokee County School District<br />
Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
City of Marietta Police Department<br />
Clarke County Commissioner<br />
Clarkston Community Center<br />
Cobb Chamber of Commerce – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
Cobb County Board of Commissioners (District 4) – Cobb2020 Steering<br />
Committee member<br />
Cobb County Fire and Emergency Services<br />
Cobb County Government – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
Cobb County Public Services Agency<br />
Cobb County Safety Village<br />
Cobb County Sheriff’s Office – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
Cobb 2020 Leadership (Cobb & Douglas Public Health) – distribution of key<br />
informant survey<br />
Cobb Douglas Public Health<br />
Cobb Senior Services<br />
Community Foundation of Greater Atlanta<br />
Community Health Center in Austell<br />
Community Input<br />
39
Davis Direction Foundation<br />
DeKalb County Commissioner<br />
District Health Director, Assistant, District 1-2 North Georgia<br />
District Health Director District 2<br />
District Health Director District 3-4<br />
District Health Director District 3-3<br />
District Health Director District 4<br />
District Health Director District 3-5<br />
Douglas CORE – A Community Organizing Resources for Excellence, Inc.<br />
Douglas County School System – key informant and online community survey<br />
distribution<br />
Fulton County Commissioner<br />
Fulton County Policy Analyst, District 302<br />
Georgia Department of Education<br />
Georgia Health News – health news relating to community served<br />
Georgia Health Policy Center at Georgia State University – <strong>CHNA</strong> collaboration and<br />
research<br />
Grady Health System – <strong>CHNA</strong> research collaboration<br />
Good Samaritan Health Center of Cobb – key informant, site of listening session,<br />
Cobb2020 Steering Committee member, and community representative on WellStar<br />
Community Health Collaborative Task Force<br />
Helping Hands of Paulding County<br />
Hispanic Health Coalition of Georgia – key informant and facilitator of two Hispanic<br />
listening sessions<br />
Kaiser Permanente – <strong>CHNA</strong> research collaboration<br />
Kennesaw State University – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
Kennesaw State University, Center for Health Promotion and Wellness<br />
Marietta City Schools – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
Marietta Kiwanis Club – Cobb2020 Steering Committee member<br />
MUST Ministries – key informant and community representative on WellStar<br />
Community Health Collaborative Task Force<br />
North Georgia Health District (1-2)<br />
Northeast Health District Director, 10 Athens<br />
NorthStar Psychological Services<br />
Northwest Georgia Health District<br />
Paulding Community Health & Resource Center Steering Committee members<br />
Paulding County Health Department – key informant, site for listening session and<br />
distribution of online community health survey<br />
Paulding County Sheriff’s Office<br />
Piedmont Healthcare – <strong>CHNA</strong> research collaboration<br />
SafePath Children’s Advocacy Center, Inc.<br />
Senior Citizens Council of Cobb County<br />
Ser Familia – key informant, site for listening session, Cobb2020 Steering Community<br />
Health Collaborative Task Force, and community representative on the WellStar<br />
Community Health Collaborative Task Force<br />
40 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
Smyrna Fire/Emergency Management<br />
T. Lee Associates / City of Marietta<br />
United Way of Metro Atlanta<br />
WellStar Center for Health Transformation – internal data<br />
WellStar Cobb Hospital President<br />
WellStar Cobb and Kennestone Community Clinics – internal data<br />
WellStar Community Education & Outreach – internal data<br />
WellStar Congregational Health Network:<br />
Hickory Flatt UMC – Canton, GA - online survey participants<br />
Iglesia de Dios – Austell, GA - listening session site<br />
McEachern United Methodist Church – listening session site<br />
WellStar Douglas Hospital President<br />
WellStar Enterprise Intelligence – internal data<br />
WellStar Regional Health Board Trustees including:<br />
Bethel Gardens Assisted & Memory Care (Cobb)<br />
Caldwell Insulation, Inc. (Cobb)<br />
Community Bank of the South (Cobb)<br />
John L. Stone – (Douglas)<br />
Keep Paulding Beautiful – (Paulding)<br />
Paulding Quick Bail, Inc. (Paulding)<br />
Puckett EMS – (Douglas)<br />
Southeast Cooler – (Douglas)<br />
WellStar Kennestone Hospital President<br />
WellStar Medical Group, Director of Practice Operations<br />
WellStar Paulding Hospital President<br />
WellStar PR, Marketing and Internal Communications – production of survey tools<br />
YMCA – Northwest Georgia - posting of online community health survey<br />
41
COMMUNITY IS
MAJOR HEALTH<br />
CHALLENGES<br />
AND DRIVERS<br />
Since the initial 2013 health assessment across the WellStar community, health needs<br />
remained consistent and similar health challenges and drivers were cited:<br />
• Chronic disease prevention and management<br />
• Access and affordability of healthcare, health insurance or viable alternatives 69<br />
(those that have insurance can’t afford rising premium costs and deductibles)<br />
• Health equity and literacy; lack of resources that are linguistically and culturally<br />
appropriate<br />
• A concern about the prevalence of patient education and health fairs/ events with<br />
health screenings without a connection to needed follow-up care<br />
• Lack of knowledge of available health resources, services and navigation assistance<br />
• A decrease in Public Health Department funding and staffing<br />
• Low-income residents and those who are fearful of their illegal status (undocumented<br />
Hispanics) are slow to seek medical attention<br />
Community Health Needs<br />
• Inequalities in determinants of health 70<br />
• Medication access and affordability<br />
• Targeted, prevention-based education to address health needs to combat the lack of<br />
understanding of how lifestyle choices affect health<br />
• Health education programs built on behavior change and physical activity are not<br />
equal across all counties<br />
• Transportation for care access<br />
• Increase of heroin use by teenagers and young adults<br />
• Lack of healthy food options in areas where vulnerable populations live<br />
• Underuse of preventive care among men<br />
• Lack of good health in early childhood / maternal and infant health<br />
• Lack of affordable dental care<br />
• Culture of violence and stress among vulnerable populations<br />
43
SIGNIFICANT<br />
HEALTH NEEDS<br />
The following process was used to identify significant community health needs in<br />
advance of the prioritization work by the WellStar Community Health Collaborative Task<br />
Force:<br />
Quantitative Data<br />
(data platforms,<br />
other numeric data)<br />
Qualitative Data<br />
(focus groups, key<br />
informant interviews)<br />
Poor performance<br />
against benchmark<br />
Themes<br />
Health Issue<br />
Health Issue<br />
Issue comes up across<br />
multiple data sources<br />
= COMMUNITY HEALTH NEED<br />
44 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
The significant health needs related to access to care stem from<br />
socioeconomic and clinical care barriers. These barriers create<br />
health disparities in the communities WellStar serves especially<br />
among the most vulnerable populations (low-income, uninsured,<br />
low education attainment, elderly). Underuse denotes lack of<br />
capacity /access and cost of the care.<br />
Lack of Care Capacity<br />
in Community Safety<br />
Net Clinics<br />
Lack of Care Capacity<br />
in Community Safety<br />
Net Clinics<br />
The significant health needs related to healthy lifestyles primarily<br />
stem from health behaviors causing chronic disease and/or<br />
behavioral health issues. These needs require intervention<br />
and management through clinical care, lifestyle modification<br />
(primary prevention) and education and “prescribing resources”<br />
(secondary prevention).<br />
45
PRIORITY<br />
HEALTH NEEDS<br />
PROCESS<br />
Focused on preventable health behaviors and access to care, priority health needs<br />
were identified by the WellStar Community Health Collaborative task force using the<br />
Triple Aim criteria.<br />
Does the need:<br />
Improve<br />
population<br />
health?<br />
Enhance patient<br />
experience/<br />
outcomes?<br />
Reduce<br />
healthcare<br />
costs?<br />
PRIORITY HEALTH NEED<br />
Health needs were plotted by A.L. Burruss Institute of Public Service and Research<br />
during the Summit using a Qualtrics survey that measured the severity of need and<br />
capacity to address the need assigned by each task force member. The health needs<br />
with the highest need and highest capacity were identified as the priority needs.<br />
Implementation-driven questions were considered as task force members<br />
brainstormed actionable strategies for addressing the needs:<br />
• How severe is the issue against benchmarks?<br />
• Are there clear disparities/inequities?<br />
• Are there existing assets, facilities and resources dedicated to the issue?<br />
• Is there an opportunity to intervene at the prevention level?<br />
• Do feasible and effective evidence-based interventions exist?<br />
• Do we have a solution that has the potential to solve multiple problems leveraging<br />
existing and/or potential collaborative community partners and assets?<br />
46 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
PRIORITY NEEDS<br />
The following <strong>2016</strong> access to care and healthy lifestyles (for chronic disease prevention)<br />
priority health needs, with the exception of underuse of primary care, track with the<br />
trends and research findings in the inaugural 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> report:<br />
UNDERUSE OF PRIMARY CARE - ED UTILIZATION - CARE CAPACITY IN CLINICS<br />
CANCER<br />
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE<br />
COPD & ASTHMA<br />
OBESITY<br />
TYPE 2 DIABETES<br />
Community Health Needs Rated by Importance & Capacity<br />
5<br />
4.5<br />
4<br />
3.5<br />
MEAN CAPACITY<br />
3<br />
2.5<br />
2<br />
1.5<br />
1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5<br />
MEAN IMPORTANCE<br />
47
When implementing strategies to address priority health needs, many other significant<br />
needs also will be addressed as a byproduct of meeting community benefit objectives.<br />
Examples of intersecting needs include:<br />
• The underuse of preventive screenings and tobacco use are actionable areas to help<br />
reduce cancer’s prevalence (also COPD / asthma).<br />
• Increased access to more affordable medications results from more low-income<br />
community members receiving primary care in community clinics with<br />
prescription assistance programs.<br />
• Physical inactivity / poor nutrition are addressed with obesity-related, heart disease<br />
and diabetes initiatives.<br />
• Also, behavioral health is an integral part of all care WellStar provides – from mental<br />
health assessments conducted in the EDs to the new oncology integrated behavioral<br />
health services program designed to optimize management of the emotional,<br />
behavioral, and cognitive challenges experienced by patients following cancer<br />
diagnosis and treatment.<br />
NEEDS NOT<br />
ADDRESSED<br />
Health needs not identified as priority fall into one of three categories:<br />
1) Beyond the scope of WellStar services, e.g. dental care which is addressed by<br />
safety nets clinics<br />
2) Needs further intervention, but no plans for expanding current community benefit<br />
services at this time, e.g. maternal/infant health<br />
3) Relying on community partners with expertise to lead efforts in these areas<br />
with WellStar in a supportive role, e.g. substance abuse, violence, suicide, STDs,<br />
transportation<br />
48 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
If you have any additional feedback regarding the identified<br />
and prioritized health needs, please email<br />
chna@wellstar.org.
COMMUNITY IS
STRATEGIC<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
PARTNERSHIPS<br />
Forging well-defined<br />
collaborative<br />
partnerships helps<br />
build a comprehensive<br />
low-cost health delivery<br />
system.<br />
Community assets are people, places, and relationships that may be used to achieve<br />
the most equitable and optimal functioning of a community. WellStar is on a continuous<br />
quest to transform the healthcare community’s culture of working independently<br />
(mutual awareness) toward collaborative interdependence (partnership). It's the optimal<br />
way to ensure WellStar, public health, governmental agencies, non-profits, community<br />
safety net clinics, and other community stakeholders share the responsibility of care<br />
and costs while offering access to a full continuum focused on prevention and wellness.<br />
Access to Care<br />
There are deficits and demands in our community for primary care, behavioral health<br />
and specialty care/services to vulnerable populations. WellStar will help fill the gap<br />
with the WellStar 4-1 Care Network, providing needed services and creating a conduit<br />
for physicians and advanced practice professionals to serve community safety net<br />
clinics to increase care capacity. Providing vulnerable community members with the<br />
“right care at the right place” helps maximize and leverage partnerships outside of<br />
WellStar facilities and optimize patient outcomes.<br />
The diagram shows WellStar’s care partnerships serving the medically underserved<br />
and uninsured populations. Through these partnerships, more community members<br />
can be served. 71<br />
Community Health Assets<br />
COBB<br />
Good Samaritan Health<br />
Center of Cobb<br />
Ser Famillia / SafePath<br />
MUST Ministries<br />
YWCA<br />
Community Health Center<br />
Kennestone<br />
Community Clinic<br />
Cobb<br />
Community Clinic<br />
PAULDING<br />
Paulding Community<br />
Health & Resource<br />
Center<br />
Coming Soon<br />
WellStar<br />
4-1 CARE<br />
Network<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
Bethesda Community<br />
Clinic<br />
DOUGLAS<br />
The CarePlace<br />
51
Strengthening these partnerships creates a more comprehensive and sustainable lowcost<br />
healthcare system. By coordinating medical services and community resources to<br />
leverage assets and bridge care gaps, the WellStar Community Health Collaborative<br />
can serve as an organizational launching pad for partners to meet growing and costly<br />
healthcare needs.<br />
To address mounting behavioral health needs in the community, the WellStar<br />
Behavioral Health Network (WBHN) initiative was introduced in 2015. The network's<br />
aim is to organize and coordinate a coalition of behavioral health service providers to<br />
increase access to care for community members with mental health and substance<br />
abuse conditions, including the most vulnerable. It also aims to reduce unnecessary<br />
Emergency Department utilization and readmissions for those needing behavioral<br />
health services.<br />
Comprised of formal partnerships with the WellStar Behavioral Health Service Line 72 ,<br />
mental health services are accessed through a centralized Behavioral Health Assessment<br />
& Resource Center (ARC) to expedient care access and assure quality consistency in<br />
care delivery standards. WBHN partnerships 73 will be forged to fill service gaps and<br />
address key behavioral health needs in a manner that creates access across WellStar’s<br />
expanding community.<br />
Healthy Lifestyles<br />
Community partnerships are vital to improving access to care and healthy lifestyle<br />
interventions through public health policies, referral processes, community-based care<br />
and services, health education programs, and other community benefit initiatives.<br />
WellStar’s Community Education & Outreach Department is a conduit for outreach<br />
and delivery of community benefit services to help meet priority health needs in<br />
communities with health disparities.<br />
Creating partnerships helps maximize collective resources to maximize community<br />
health improvement efforts.<br />
52 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
Community Education & Outreach has forged local community partnerships for community health education,<br />
programs and services (including screenings and immunizations): THIS MAY NOT BE AN ALL-INCLUSIVE LIST.<br />
American Cancer Society<br />
American Diabetes Association<br />
American Heart Association<br />
American Lung Association<br />
Atlanta Blaze<br />
Atlanta Community Food Bank<br />
Atlanta Regional Commission<br />
Bright Horizons Foundation<br />
Camp Kudzu<br />
Cherokee County School District<br />
Cherokee Senior Services<br />
Children’s Haven Inc.<br />
City of Kennesaw<br />
City of Marietta<br />
Cobb 2020 Healthy Lifestyles Committee<br />
Cobb County Department of Public Safety<br />
Cobb County Safety Village<br />
Cobb County School District<br />
Cobb & Douglas Public Health<br />
Cobb Master Gardeners<br />
Cobb Senior Services<br />
Congregations/Faith Based Organizations<br />
Davis Direction Foundation<br />
Douglas County School District<br />
Douglas Senior Services<br />
Family Life Resource Center<br />
Family Promise of Cobb County<br />
Georgia Faith Community Nurses Association<br />
Georgia Healthcare Decisions<br />
Goshen Valley Boy’s Ranch<br />
Graduate Marietta Student Success Center<br />
It’s the Journey<br />
Kennesaw State University<br />
LakePoint Sports Complex<br />
Live Healthy Douglas<br />
March of Dimes<br />
Marietta City Schools<br />
Medical Association of Georgia<br />
MUST Ministries<br />
Nobis Works<br />
Osher Lifelong Learning Institute<br />
Paulding County School District<br />
Paulding Senior Services<br />
Positive Athlete Georgia<br />
Safe Kids Cobb County<br />
Safe Kids Georgia<br />
SafePath<br />
Susan G. Komen Greater Atlanta<br />
Town Center at Cobb<br />
Wal-Mart<br />
YWCA of Northwest Georgia<br />
National/International Partnerships:<br />
Safe Kids Worldwide<br />
Spirit of Women<br />
53
WellStar Congregational Health Network Partners<br />
70+ congregations and faith-based organizations are conduits for community-based continuing care,<br />
screenings and education:<br />
Acworth United Methodist, Acworth<br />
Allen Temple AME, Woodstock<br />
Antioch Loving Spirit Missionary Baptist, Mableton<br />
Bethel AME Church, Acworth<br />
Beulah Baptist Douglasville<br />
Bible Way Ministries International, Atlanta<br />
Calvary Baptist Church, Austell<br />
Calvary Christian Ministries, Powder Springs<br />
Catholic Church of St. Ann, Marietta<br />
Cedarcrest Church, Acworth<br />
Christians Networking Training Center, Kennesaw<br />
Clarkston International Bible Church, Clarkston<br />
Cornerstone Baptist Church, Lithia Springs<br />
Divine Order Church, Marietta<br />
Douglasville SDA Church, Douglasville<br />
East Cobb Church of Christ, Marietta<br />
East Cobb United Methodist, Marietta<br />
Ewing Road Baptist, Austell<br />
Faith Christian Center, Smyrna<br />
Galilee Missionary Baptist Church, Marietta<br />
Golden Memorial United Methodist, Douglasville<br />
Gospel Nation Christian Fellowship, Powder Springs<br />
Grandview Seventh Day Adventist, Austell<br />
Hickory Flat United Methodist, Canton<br />
Highpoint Christian Tabernacle, Smyrna<br />
Hiram Seventh Day Adventist, Hiram<br />
Holy Family Catholic, Marietta<br />
Holy Trinity Lutheran, Marietta<br />
Iglesia de Dios Nueva Vida, Marietta<br />
Judah Family Worship Center, Austell<br />
Kennesaw United Methodist, Kennesaw<br />
Kenyan American Community Church, Marietta<br />
Larger Than Life Christian Ministries, Douglasville<br />
Liberty Church , Marietta<br />
Lithia Springs Assembly of God, Lithia Springs<br />
Little River United Methodist , Woodstock<br />
Mableton First Christian, Mableton<br />
Marietta Adventist, Marietta<br />
Marietta Christian, Marietta<br />
Marietta First Christian (Disciples of Christ), Marietta<br />
Mars Hill Presbyterian, Acworth<br />
McEachern Memorial United Methodist,<br />
Powder Springs<br />
Mt. Zion AME, Kennesaw<br />
New Mountain Top Baptist Church, Winston<br />
Nurses Changing Communities, Inc., Sugar Hill<br />
Oasis Family Life Church, Dallas<br />
Philadelphia Seventh Day Adventist, Douglasville<br />
Piedmont Baptist, Marietta<br />
Pine St. Missionary Baptist Church, Marietta<br />
Pleasant Grove Missionary Baptist, Marietta<br />
Roswell Street Baptist, Marietta<br />
Salem Seventh Day Adventist, Mableton<br />
Shiloh Seventh Day Adventist, Smyrna<br />
Smyrna First United Methodist, Smyrna<br />
Smyrna Life Church Assembly of God, Smyrna<br />
St. Andrew United Methodist, Marietta<br />
St. Catherine’s Episcopal, Marietta<br />
St. John Vianney Catholic, Lithia Springs<br />
St. Joseph Catholic Church, Marietta<br />
St. Mark AME, Atlanta<br />
St. Phillip Benizi Catholic Church, Jonesboro<br />
St. Teresa’s Episcopal, Acworth<br />
St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic, Smyrna<br />
StoneBridge Church, Marietta<br />
Sweet Home Missionary Baptist, Hiram<br />
The Pointe Church, Canton<br />
Transfiguration Catholic, Marietta<br />
Turner Chapel AME, Marietta<br />
Unity North Atlanta, Marietta<br />
Walker Tabernacle Baptist Church, Atlanta<br />
Zion Baptist Church, Marietta<br />
54 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
OTHER<br />
POTENTIALLY<br />
AVAILABLE<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
RESOURCES<br />
The WellStar region has a multitude of community and organizational assets<br />
including local healthcare facilities, faith-based institutions and independent<br />
community groups. 74 This section identifies resources that exist to provide low<br />
or no cost care access points for the most vulnerable and provide prevention<br />
education and health improvement services to the broader community. This list<br />
provided by the GHPC is not all-inclusive of the myriad health assets in Georgia or<br />
in the WellStar legacy hospitals' community nor does it capture the full scale of<br />
ongoing and potential partnerships to meet community needs.<br />
Documented health assets fall into three primary focus categories: healthcare,<br />
community-focused, and education. The analysis of community assets 75 in the<br />
WellStar service area was focused on those providing health and health-related<br />
services. A priority is placed on representing organizations that provide services<br />
to vulnerable populations, as well as organizations that provide free or sliding scale<br />
services in order to better meet the identified health needs of the community.<br />
Community assets and resources include existing health care facilities as access<br />
is a major factor to achieving and sustaining good health. Each of the region’s<br />
counties has within its boundaries or is proximate to the basic community assets<br />
of schools, parks and healthcare facilities. Several areas of the region have a high<br />
number of facilities to enhance access to care, while other areas are medically<br />
underserved such as Bartow County.<br />
HOSPITALS<br />
Acute Care Hospitals in the WellStar Region<br />
Cartersville Medical Center (HCA) Cartersville Bartow<br />
Northside Hospital – Cherokee Canton Cherokee<br />
WellStar Cobb Hospital Austell Cobb<br />
WellStar Douglas Hospital Douglasville Douglas<br />
WellStar Kennestone Hospital Marietta Cobb<br />
WellStar Paulding Hospital Dallas Paulding<br />
WellStar Windy Hill Hospital Marietta Cobb<br />
Higgins General Hospital Bremen Haralson<br />
(Tanner Health System)<br />
Piedmont Mountainside Jasper Pickens<br />
(Piedmont Healthcare)<br />
55
STATE-WIDE<br />
RESOURCES<br />
Boys and Girls Club - Provides a structured and positive environment and<br />
programs for young people. http://bgcncg.org/<br />
SERVES: Bartow, Cherokee, Cobb, Douglas, Paulding<br />
The Center for Family Resources - Works to stabilize and empower families so<br />
they may become self-sufficient. http://thecfr.org/about-cfr/<br />
SERVES: Cobb and Metro Atlanta<br />
Communities in Schools - The nation’s largest dropout prevention organization<br />
champions the connection of needed community resources with schools to help<br />
young people successfully learn, stay in school and prepare for life.<br />
http://www.communitiesinschools.org<br />
SERVES: Cobb, Douglas<br />
Georgia Family Connection - Collaborative organizations operating<br />
independently in counties bringing community partners together to develop,<br />
implement, and evaluate plans that address the serious challenges facing<br />
Georgia’s children and families. http://www.gafcp.org<br />
SERVES: All Counties<br />
Georgia Head Start – Provides early childhood and family development services<br />
to children from birth to five-years-old, pregnant women and families including<br />
medical, dental, and mental health; nutrition; parent involvement and family<br />
support. http://www.georgiaheadstart.org<br />
SERVES: All Counties<br />
United Way - Seeks to provide for the immediate needs of those in crisis<br />
situations, meet long-term needs through the educational, emotional and<br />
moral guidance of children and enable financially or physically disabled<br />
people to become self-supporting.<br />
Websites are regional, e.g. https://www.unitedwayatlanta.org<br />
SERVES: Bartow<br />
YMCA - Focuses on youth development, healthy living and social responsibility.<br />
Website are regional, e.g. http://www.ymcaatlanta.org<br />
SERVES: Bartow, Cherokee, Cobb<br />
YWCA of NW Georgia - Delivers programs and services that increase the<br />
awareness and reduce the occurrence of domestic violence and sexual assault to<br />
victims over the age of 13. www.ywca.org<br />
SERVES: Cobb, Cherokee, Paulding<br />
56 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
SAMPLING OF<br />
COUNTY-<br />
SPECIFIC<br />
RESOURCES<br />
BARTOW<br />
Advocates for Children is dedicated to preventing and treating child abuse. A<br />
national program, CASA trains volunteers to help abused and neglected children in the<br />
juvenile court system. http://www.AdvoChild.org<br />
Allatoona Community Action Partnership assists low income individuals and families<br />
to acquire useful skills and knowledge, to gain new opportunities, and achieve selfsufficiency.<br />
Programs include: adult basic education/GED assistance, job readiness<br />
training, holistic case management, and emergency housing assistance.<br />
http://www.tallatoonacap.org/<br />
Allatoona Resource Center provides the residents of South Bartow with assistance<br />
programs and educational and employment resources/opportunities. Features a gym<br />
facility providing programs and recreation for youth.<br />
http://www.bartowga.org/departments/social_services_indigent_care/allatoona_<br />
resource_center/arc_links.php<br />
Good Neighbor Homeless Shelter provides men, women, and families with temporary<br />
shelter and physical, emotional, and spiritual support. They assist guests with<br />
developing and prioritizing goals for their return to the community as productive<br />
members. http://www.goodneighborshelter.org<br />
CHEROKEE<br />
Bethesda Community Clinic delivers healthcare to the underserved, uninsured and<br />
underinsured populations of Cherokee County and the surrounding areas. They offer<br />
physical exams, well-woman exams, limited dental care, acute care, chronic disease<br />
management, diabetes education and nutrition classes, wellness coaching, prescription<br />
assistance, and blood lab testing including STD/HIV testing.<br />
http://www.bethesdacommunityclinic.org<br />
Cherokee Day Training Center assists Cherokee County residents with developmental<br />
disabilities by providing training services, recreational activities and community based<br />
employment opportunities. http://cherokeetrainingcenter.com/<br />
Cherokee Family Violence Center provides free services to meet the needs of victims of<br />
domestic violence, educate stakeholders, and hold batterers accountable so victims and<br />
the community are safe. http://cfvc.org/<br />
Georgia Breast Cancer Coalition is a non-profit education and advocacy organization<br />
founded by breast cancer survivors to focus the attention of Georgians on the epidemic<br />
proportions of breast cancer. http://www.gabcc.org/<br />
57
LEAD (Launch, Expose, Advise, Direct) provides at-risk, inner city, male youth with<br />
access to higher education and civic engagement. Using the sport of baseball as the<br />
motivating tool, LEAD provides young men with programming that shows them how to<br />
be productive citizens. http://lead2legacy.org/<br />
COBB<br />
Anchor of Hope is a Christian organization providing financial and spiritual support,<br />
encouragement, community resources and services to families with disabilities.<br />
https://www.anchorofhopefoundation.com/<br />
Adaptive Learning Center for Infants and Children, Inc. maximizes the potential of<br />
young children with disabilities, and creates awareness and acceptance between nondisabled<br />
people and people with disabilities. http://www.adaptivelearningcenter.org<br />
The Adult Disability Medical Home (ADMH) is an innovative and comprehensive<br />
program providing health and wellness to teens and adults with developmental<br />
disabilities. http://www.adaptivelearningcenter.org<br />
The Community Health Center (CHC) / Grassroots Dental is a nonprofit organization<br />
whose mission is to provide quality, affordable medical and dental healthcare to the<br />
communities in north-west metro Atlanta. http://www.chcaustell.org/<br />
Good Samaritan Health Center of Cobb is a Federally Qualified Health Center (FQHC)<br />
that provides a comprehensive range of medical, dental, prescription, and select social<br />
services for patients without health insurance or the means to afford care.<br />
http://www.goodsamcobb.org/<br />
Cobb Community Collaborative is a membership of nonprofit organizations, local<br />
government, businesses, faith- based organizations, educational institutions,<br />
professional organizations, associations and citizens who share ideas, expertise and<br />
resources to meet the needs of Cobb County. http://www.cobbcollaborative.org/<br />
MUST Ministries cares for those in need in the Marietta, Smyrna and Canton/<br />
Cherokee communities. http://www.mustministries.org/<br />
58 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
DOUGLAS<br />
Good Samaritan Center of Douglas County assists needy families in the Douglasville area<br />
with utility bills, prescriptions, food, and spiritual counsel. The Center is a food bank and<br />
emergency assistance center for Douglas County residents.<br />
http://www.goodsamaritancenter-douglasville.com<br />
Douglas C.O.R.E. (Community Organizing Resources for Excellence) focuses on teen<br />
pregnancy, physical and mental health disparities, childhood immunization, and truancy<br />
rates. Douglas.gafcp.org/<br />
The D.A.N.N.Y. (Developing and Nurturing Needy Youth) Center, Inc. serves as a centralized<br />
resource for the community for both Douglas and Cobb counties to enrich the lives of<br />
the youth in our community and serve as facilitators that provide education, career, and<br />
recreational opportunities for all youth who can benefit from them.<br />
http://www.dannycenter.org<br />
PAULDING<br />
The Paulding Community Health & Resource Center has received 501(c)(3) status and has<br />
a working Board and Standing Committees comprised of multi-sector community leaders.<br />
Its mission is to serve as a community wellness resource and safety net solution for those<br />
who are underserved and most vulnerable at a centralized location. Board and committee<br />
members represent county-specific organizations that are potential community partners.<br />
Other potential partners were recommended by WellStar key informants and<br />
are included in the supplemental appendices under Key Informant Input.<br />
59
COMMUNITY IS<br />
EMPATHY CONNECTS US.
IMPLEMENTATION<br />
STRATEGY UPDATE<br />
Community benefit<br />
expansion takes<br />
people, resources<br />
and partners.<br />
Areas Needing<br />
Improvement<br />
Phase 1 of the five-year 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> Implementation Strategy to expand access<br />
to care and improve healthy lifestyles through collaborative partnerships and via<br />
existing and proposed WellStar facilities, providers, resources, and programs is still<br />
underway with a more targeted approach to delivering community benefit services.<br />
Since 2013, WellStar audited its delivery of essential prevention, education and<br />
wellness programs and adapted to changes in regulations, laws and technology<br />
to meet the demands of our growing population. With the addition of community<br />
benefit liaisons appointed by the hospital presidents, each facility is able to measure<br />
its specific community benefit services not captured at a System level.<br />
Phase II’s stated goal has shifted. In lieu of creating an independent non-profit,<br />
WellStar is developing defined, outcomes-driven partnerships with community<br />
safety net clinics and other non-profit organizations to provide more affordable<br />
and accessible care to the most vulnerable. These WellStar Community Health<br />
Collaborative’s Partners in Health also will share responsibility for the health of the<br />
community by promoting healthy lifestyles focused on the priority health needs.<br />
No public comments were received after publication of the 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> report<br />
although feedback was received that the report was reviewed and data was utilized<br />
by other health-related organizations. As soliciting public input was part of the<br />
final <strong>CHNA</strong> requirements (December 2015), an email for feedback is now available:<br />
chna@wellstar.org.<br />
Continued process improvements are needed to better track, measure and report<br />
community benefit services, exclusive of indigent, charity and unreimbursed care,<br />
for evaluation purposes and to better tell our story 76 .<br />
Evaluation of community benefit services is an area of improvement for WellStar as<br />
much Phase 1 work was focused on auditing services and building an infrastructure<br />
for accountability and realignment. Baseline data and outputs to assist in stating<br />
the anticipated impact of implementation strategies is a necessity. Processes<br />
are either in place or being developed for these evaluation methods in the <strong>2016</strong><br />
Implementation Strategy.<br />
A more precise shift and allocation of resources to better align services and<br />
education with prioritized health needs and in areas with health disparities also is<br />
needed. This will be done in strategic collaboration with WellStar's new community<br />
benefit services programs and community assets already serving to bridge health<br />
disparity gaps through initiatives and outreach.<br />
Evaluation of Impact: Tracking WellStar’s Progress<br />
61
TRACKING<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
BENEFIT<br />
SERVICES<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
HEALTH IM-<br />
PROVEMENT<br />
SERVICES<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
HEALTH<br />
IMPROVEMENT<br />
SERVICES<br />
The initiatives outlined in the 2013 Implementation Strategy were organized<br />
using community benefit categories outlined by the Catholic Health Association 77<br />
and tracked by the community benefit software, CBISA. The stated 2013 goals<br />
were to improve access to care to vulnerable populations and promote healthy<br />
lifestyles via preventive care, programs and activities. The categories now highlight<br />
progress in the delivery of community benefit services and initiatives underway.<br />
This is not an all-inclusive list of the community benefit services provided System-wide<br />
or by the hospitals. Also, WellStar discloses that some of the stated 2013 initiatives were<br />
not implemented or fully implemented due to either its ongoing, five-year approach to<br />
the 2013 implementation plan, competing priorities, or limited staffing / resources.<br />
COMMUNITY HEALTH EDUCATION:<br />
WellStar’s aim to promote healthy lifestyles via preventive care, programs and activities<br />
is primarily accomplished through the education and clinical services categories.<br />
• Community Education & Outreach intersected with the lives of more than 153,000<br />
people in FY2015 providing education, screenings and services.<br />
• More than 15,000 free health screenings via Community Education & Outreach<br />
health fairs and events in FY2015 at congregations, workplaces, civic organizations,<br />
and community events provided opportunity for education and follow-up care<br />
with those with identified health risks. Screenings/services provided:<br />
• Blood pressure<br />
• Glucose<br />
• Total cholesterol<br />
• Weight assessment<br />
• Bone density<br />
• Flu shots<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Improve prevention-focused education<br />
resources and the referral process to free or reduced cost healthcare clinics for<br />
continuity of care. Still in progress.<br />
3<br />
• 2,800 school-based health programs provided education to more than 62,000<br />
students in Cherokee, Cobb, Douglas, and Paulding counties on nutrition, safety,<br />
personal hygiene, and physical activity.<br />
• Child injury programs reached more than 17,000 children and parents through<br />
partnership with Safe Kids Cobb County in FY2015.<br />
62 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
• Health information and educational opportunities are communicated to more than<br />
13,000 community subscribers of demographic and disease-specific e-newsletters.<br />
• Women’s health education is prevalent in the WellStar community via Spirit of<br />
Women 78 /Speaking about Wellness for Women outreach. <strong>2016</strong> marks the 10th<br />
anniversary of the women-centered programming, including a robust speaker series,<br />
free health screenings, national signature events, and a health and wellness eNewsletter.<br />
• Healthy aging is promoted by The Good Life Club to more than 4,000 seniors in the<br />
community including Speaking about Wellness for Healthy Aging and via community<br />
partnerships.<br />
• The Population Health Management team collaborates with Cobb Senior Services to<br />
help enroll patients in Cobb Senior Center programs, volunteers in outreach projects<br />
and provides education and screenings. Also, to bridge care access gaps in the senior<br />
population, the outpatient case management team engages with patients in the<br />
community and works with other community agencies to find resources to help<br />
with mental health, medication assistance, transportation, meals at home and other<br />
needs that are identified. The case managers work in a geographically aligned model<br />
with physicians to support the senior patients in all aspects of their care.<br />
• Worksite wellness program aligns with the Affordable Care Act's national public<br />
health strategy to help address the prevalence of chronic disease in the workplace.<br />
COMMUNITY-BASED CLINICAL SERVICES:<br />
These are health services and screenings, provided on a one-time basis or as a special<br />
event in the community, to meet identified health needs.<br />
• Wellness and health promotion programs (self-help groups) abound for the community<br />
creating a supportive network of preventive care. Support groups are available for heart<br />
health, stroke, diabetes, COPD, weight management, nutrition, and cancer survivors<br />
and caregivers.<br />
• Clinical engagement in tobacco cessation and prevention education is underway.<br />
Providers and case managers at multiple WellStar locations are undergoing smoking<br />
cessation training in partnership with Pfizer utilizing its “Advise to Quit” curriculum. In<br />
the community, WellStar participated in the American Lung Association’s state-wide<br />
“Nobody Quits Like Georgia” campaign.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Increase cancer prevention and education<br />
community outreach (including smoking cessation program) utilizing the WellStar Cancer<br />
Program team.<br />
3<br />
63
• To address mental health issues and substance abuse, WellStar is developing<br />
the WellStar Behavioral Health Network, a coalition of behavioral health service<br />
providers/partnerships to increase access to care for community members, including<br />
the most vulnerable. The network will expand WellStar’s capacity with referrals to<br />
partnering agency mental health providers, resources and education via the telesite<br />
Behavioral Health Assessment & Resource Center (ARC).<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Develop a more collaborative delivery<br />
system for behavioral health services/resources though partnerships.<br />
3<br />
• To expedite examinations and assessments of alleged child abuse, WellStar has<br />
embedded a nurse practitioner at Cobb County’s SafePath Children’s Advocacy Center.<br />
• Primary care delivered by WellStar Community Clinics on the Cobb and Kennestone<br />
hospital campuses helps reduce hospital Emergency Department visits and hospital<br />
admissions among low-income, uninsured patients needing non-emergent care.<br />
• Endorsed by the Lung Cancer Alliance as a Screening Center of Excellence, 79 lung<br />
cancer screenings are provided to low-income, high-risks patients in needs via the<br />
WellStar Foundation at nine WellStar imaging centers.<br />
• Grant-funded vouchers from community partners provide free mammogram<br />
screenings to women in need. Partners include the Susan B. Komen Atlanta Chapter,<br />
East/West Church in Austell, Biker’s Battling Breast Cancer, It’s the Journey, National<br />
Breast Cancer Foundation, and generous gifts from WellStar team members through<br />
the WellStar Foundation.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Expand free health screenings to the<br />
underinsured and uninsured through WellStar Community Education & Outreach.<br />
3<br />
• The impact of WellStar Community Clinics' (Cobb and Kennestone outpatient<br />
service) referrals from the Emergency Departments (ED) is a more than 50 percent<br />
reduction in ED visits and a 40 percent reduction in hospital admissions.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Reduce preventable hospital admissions,<br />
readmissions and Emergency Department visits by redirecting care to community<br />
clinics and primary care via the hospital-based care management program.<br />
3<br />
64 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
• Partnerships with community safety net clinics that provide free or low cost health care<br />
to the medically underserved and uninsured 80 receive support via free or reduced costs<br />
labs and radiology services and limited specialist care. Revised collaboration agreements<br />
are in effect to better track and measure outcomes of patients served and referred by<br />
WellStar to partnering clinics.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Strengthen collaborative partnerships with<br />
community stakeholders to increase access to preventative and primary care,<br />
improve quality and reduce cost.<br />
3<br />
• The new 4-1 Care Network will leverage the expertise and skill of WMG providers as<br />
care partners in community safety net clinics.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Increase the number of hospital-affiliated / WMG<br />
providers and specialists providing free or reduced cost healthcare.<br />
3<br />
HEALTHCARE SUPPORT SERVICES:<br />
Provided to increase access and quality of care to individuals, especially those in vulnerable<br />
populations.<br />
• WellStar’s Accountable Care Organization (ACO) ranks in the nation’s Top 10 as a<br />
pioneer in managing the care and improving the clinical outcomes of its aging Medicare<br />
community of more than 65,000 people. A focus on prevention and chronic disease<br />
management decreases costs and improves health and quality of life.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Provide community benefit leadership/consultation<br />
for the prevention and management of diabetes, cancer and cardiovascular disease.<br />
3<br />
• Established in <strong>2016</strong> to meet the multi-faceted needs of high-risk Medicare and other<br />
community members with chronic disease, the Comprehensive Care Clinic provides<br />
fully-integrated care featuring self-help programs and clinical management to help<br />
reduce ED utilization and preventable hospital admissions.<br />
• Hospital-based care coordinators have increased the number of referrals of frequent<br />
Emergency Department visitors with chronic disease to outpatient community clinics<br />
to receive needed primary care services and management. This is an area of needed<br />
process improvement.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Reduce preventable hospital admissions,<br />
readmissions and Emergency Department visits by redirecting care to community clinics<br />
and primary care via the hospital-based care management program.<br />
3<br />
65
• The “Green Belt Project” has boosted hospital, WMG referrals and community clinic<br />
referrals for outpatient Diabetes Self-Management Education (DSME). DSME is<br />
available at no cost to patients below 125 percent FPL, those considered indigent, and<br />
at a reduced cost to patients qualifying for Community Financial Assistance.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Expand the accessibility to hospital inpatient<br />
and outpatient Diabetes Self-Management Education and services to the medically<br />
underserved and uninsured.<br />
3<br />
• The WellStar Congregational Health Network’s upcoming pilot program at WellStar<br />
Paulding Hospital will take patient care beyond routine discharge planning. Adaptation<br />
of the MEMPHIS Model for better health navigation and care transitions from hospital<br />
to home will assist patients to better manage chronic disease and, as a result, decrease<br />
hospital readmissions. The model builds congregational health ministries and trains<br />
liaisons to help with education, prevention and continuum of care post-discharge.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Engage faith-based organizations in coordination<br />
and provision of care (MEMPHIS Model).<br />
• To help eliminate language barriers in the EDs, medical interpreters are onsite to help<br />
the Latino population communicate with care providers.<br />
• Expanding low-cost medication access through centralized reduced cost Pharmaceutical<br />
Patient Access Programs (PAP) and the Federal 340B Drug discount Program 81 are under<br />
evaluation. Currently, there are no structured PAPs at the hospitals, but Paulding is<br />
looking into a discount card program in the ED to reduce costs to the patients and the<br />
health system. Vouchers are used in the WellStar retail pharmacies to reduce drug cost<br />
for certain brand medications.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Improve medication access through centralized<br />
reduced cost Pharmaceutical Patient Access Programs and the Federal 340B Drug Pricing<br />
Program for the management of chronic disease and to reduce complications.<br />
• 770-956-STAR provides referrals to community services and registration for free or<br />
low-cost community health education programming.<br />
• WellStar Cardiovascular Medicine (CVM) wellness coaches are available in the CVM<br />
practices to offer mentoring, risk modification strategies and navigate patients to other<br />
heart health services.<br />
• The WellStar Cardiac Network’s outpatient diagnostic team at WellStar Kennestone<br />
Hospital provides free heart screenings at the start of each semester for Kennesaw<br />
State University athletes using the American Heart Association’s 14-element checklist to<br />
determine if an athlete has a higher risk of sudden cardiac death. All incoming student<br />
athletes receive an electrocardiogram or echocardiogram read by a cardiologist as part<br />
of their physical. This provides an extra layer of safety for the student athletes.<br />
3<br />
3<br />
66 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
• Recognized as a Certified Advanced Comprehensive Stroke Center by The Joint<br />
Commission in February 2015, WellStar Kennestone Hospital meets the highest<br />
standards for treating the most complex stroke cases with advanced imaging,<br />
staff capability and the presence of neuro-trained intensive care unit. WellStar’s<br />
commitment to treating stroke is evident by the recent addition of WMG Neuroscience.<br />
• WellStar Connect, the Epic electronic health record, is implemented across the<br />
entire System and community clinics for integrated, seamless and safe patient<br />
care. Its Open Notes functionality shares outpatient provider notes with patients<br />
who have activated a MyChart account (patient portal). WMG’s participation in<br />
this important and innovative step makes WellStar the first and only organization<br />
in Georgia to bring patients the benefit of online access to provider notes.<br />
HEALTH<br />
PROFESSIONS<br />
EDUCATION<br />
• Groundwork is set for the accredited Graduate Medical Education (GME) Residency<br />
Program to launch in 2017 82 . The GME program will provide evidence-based training<br />
programs in internal medicine, emergency medicine, OB/GYN, family medicine, and<br />
general surgery. The GME program undergirds WellStar’s commitment to improve<br />
access to family-centered, prevention-focused care and protect the health status<br />
of the community WellStar serves by helping ensure top medical talent stays in<br />
the community. Medical residents will provide primary care support in outpatient<br />
community clinics to expand low-cost care capacity.<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Increase the number of hospital-affiliated<br />
/ WMG providers and specialists providing free or reduced cost healthcare<br />
and clinics via a Graduate Medical Education program. Upcoming.<br />
3<br />
• Each year, WellStar’s number of academic partnerships continues to grow. Currently,<br />
165 partnerships exist to help mentor, train and provide more than 1,850 clinical<br />
rotations to medical students, undergraduate nursing students, allied health<br />
students, graduate nursing students, physician assistants, anesthesia assistants,<br />
graduate pharmacy students, and others including observers.<br />
• Pediatric care is a top priority with WellStar hosting national and state American<br />
Academy of Pediatrics leaders and pediatricians across Georgia in a quality<br />
improvement initiative training to improve ADHD diagnosis and treatment<br />
processes (January <strong>2016</strong>).<br />
SUBSIDIZED HEALTH<br />
SERVICES<br />
Evaluate hospital-based subsidized health services to more effectively and efficiently<br />
allocate assets addressing prioritized health needs of the medically underserved and<br />
uninsured.<br />
• Since the last <strong>CHNA</strong>, subsidized health services investments have leaped $8.7<br />
million totaling more than $10.6 million in uncompensated cost in FY 2015 primarily<br />
attributed to assisting elderly community members living in skilled nursing facilities<br />
and the expansion in hospice services.<br />
67
• Women’s Health and Specialty Services at WellStar Kennestone Hospital provides<br />
complimentary new mom coaching and education and helps navigate Medicaid<br />
moms to needed resources.<br />
• In <strong>2016</strong>, all the hospitals and outpatient hospital facilities, including Cobb and<br />
Kennestone hospitals’ community clinics for the medically underserved and/<br />
or uninsured, expanded Community Financial Assistance (CFA) 83 eligibility<br />
requirements to 300 percent FPL. This adjustment helps broaden access to primary<br />
care to low-income community members.<br />
RESEARCH<br />
• With the largest research staff of any Georgia community cancer program and the<br />
highest clinical trial participation rate in the state, the WellStar Cancer Network<br />
offers advanced education to reduce cancer risk by promoting early detection.<br />
Clinical trials for many cancer types are offered through the network’s partnering<br />
practice, Northwest Georgia Oncology Centers. 84<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Increase cancer prevention and education<br />
community outreach (including smoking cessation program) utilizing the WellStar<br />
Cancer Network team.<br />
3<br />
• The WellStar Research Institute conducts research targeting community health<br />
needs for patient care innovation and safety. Current studies focus on priority health<br />
needs of cardiovascular conditions, COPD/asthma and stroke to promote optimal<br />
clinical outcomes and ensure the highest standard of care for the community.<br />
• Since 2013, investigators from the WellStar Center for Nursing Excellence have<br />
completed more than 20 nursing research studies, many of which have been<br />
published, to improve the practice environment and to deliver the highest<br />
standards of nursing care to patients.<br />
CASH & IN-KIND<br />
CONTRIBUTIONS<br />
• To better define a process for partnerships (community benefit) and sponsorships<br />
(marketing), requests are formally vetted via an online application process with<br />
prioritized community health needs objectives as the bellwether. Contributions<br />
are given as part of existing relationships, but the majority of granted requests now<br />
are a result of prioritized health needs. Current partnerships focus on a variety of<br />
health issues aimed at improving the health of the community.<br />
• Contributions to the WellStar Foundation are invested in vital community services<br />
including health screenings, education, safety programs for children and adults in<br />
addition to funding advancements in healthcare in the EDs and in cardiac, diabetes<br />
and cancer research arenas. WellStar Kennestone Cancer Center’s Survivorship and<br />
Support Services was newly renovated through a generous gift from the Foundation.<br />
It features a wellness kitchen for nutrition education, a chapel and a Patient Resource<br />
Center, the nation’s first IT collaboration with the American Cancer Society to provide<br />
access to web-based cancer information resources for the community.<br />
68 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
COMMUNITY<br />
BUILDING<br />
ACTIVITIES<br />
• Participation in multiple coalitions in task-specific projects 85 addressing health needs<br />
is an important part of WellStar’s People-Citizenship initiative. It encourages and<br />
recognizes team leaders’ community service and support to organizations focusing on<br />
skyrocketing needs such as:<br />
• Opioids / heroin use (Davis Direction Foundation)<br />
• Economic development (Cobb Chamber of Commerce)<br />
• Live Well, Marietta partnership between WellStar Kennestone Hospital and the City<br />
of Marietta strengthens the health and wellness of residents via health resources and<br />
information focused on women’s and men’s health, diabetes, nutrition, cancer, and heart<br />
health at the monthly Marietta Square Farmer’s Market<br />
• Environmental improvements (Green Prints Trail at Woodstock Elementary and Bright<br />
Space build out with CASA 86 )<br />
• YWCA – provision of clinical care for victims of sexual assault/domestic violence<br />
• Community support for Goshen Valley Boys Ranch in Cherokee<br />
• SafePath - helps children who are victims of sexual assault<br />
• Kennesaw State University’s Project IDEAL helps train WellStar Promotores to educate<br />
the Hispanic population with diabetes prevention, management and support<br />
• Advocacy for community health improvement and safety (i.e. Cobb & Douglas Public<br />
Health’s Cobb2020 Partnership, 87 Live Healthy Douglas, Fit City Kennesaw, Cobb County<br />
Senior Services’ Health and Wellness Advisory Committee, Safe Kids Cobb County, and<br />
Cobb County Safety Village)<br />
2013 Implementation Strategy Goal: Collaborate with Cobb2020 Healthy Lifestyles<br />
initiatives.<br />
3<br />
• WellStar team members participate in health-related community fundraising and<br />
awareness events during work hours tallying hundreds of coordination hours for events<br />
such as The Heart Association’s Heart Walk, the Atlanta Cancer Society’s Relay for Life<br />
and the March of Dimes’ March for Babies.<br />
COMMUNITY<br />
BENEFIT<br />
OPERATIONS<br />
Community benefit operations include costs associated with assigned staff and<br />
community health needs and/or assets assessment, as well as other costs associated<br />
with community benefit strategy and operations.<br />
• The WellStar Community Health Collaborative was established to lead community<br />
and clinical engagement in community benefit strategy and operations to address<br />
prioritized health needs. Overseen by the executive leadership of Strategic Community<br />
Development and Population Health Management.<br />
69
Tracking Hospital-Specific Progress<br />
via a Graduate<br />
Medical Educaon<br />
(GME) program<br />
In progress, part<br />
of new 4-1 Care<br />
Network.<br />
Referrals made to<br />
current capacity<br />
for WellStar<br />
clinics at Cobb and<br />
Kennestone.<br />
Developing a<br />
WellStar<br />
Behavioral<br />
Health<br />
Network<br />
Process and<br />
partnerships for<br />
more same day<br />
referrals in<br />
progress with<br />
community clinics.<br />
Improvements<br />
underway for<br />
resources and<br />
referrals<br />
to community<br />
safety net clinics<br />
for connuity<br />
of care.<br />
Program (2017)<br />
will expand<br />
low-cost<br />
primary care<br />
and OB/GYN<br />
access
on 2013 Implementation Strategy<br />
Led by Community Educaon<br />
& Outreach and WellStar<br />
Paulding Hospital.<br />
Realigning health-needs specific<br />
education to high-need areas via<br />
Live Well, a new community benefit<br />
services program.<br />
In progress ulizing WellStar Cancer<br />
Network and hospital-based outpaent<br />
imaging centers and via Live Well<br />
(cancer prevenon and screening).
<strong>REPORT</strong><br />
REFERENCES
COMMUNITY IS CARE 6<br />
1 The WellStar Community Health Collaborative is the name of WellStar’s Community Benefit Department (co-led by executive<br />
leadership of Strategic Community Development and Population Health Management) and its official Partners in Health who<br />
have agreed to collaborate and share responsibility to address community health needs. Its mission is to create innovative,<br />
low-cost ways to address health needs of vulnerable populations and to improve overall community health through communitybased<br />
outreach, education and preventive health services.<br />
2 More specifically, community benefit is a clinical or non-clinical program, service or activity with a low or negative margin<br />
that would likely be discontinued if the decision were made on a purely financial basis that is: (1) Responsive to identified<br />
health needs (access to care / healthy lifestyles). (2) Focused on people who are impoverished, elderly, disenfranchised and/<br />
or located in an area with disproportionate unmet health-related needs. (3) Integrated into WellStar’s strategic planning and<br />
budgeting process to increase access to care while lowering costs through preventative programming and services. (4) Planned<br />
and implemented with program objectives and measurable outcomes that are beneficial to community stakeholders and the<br />
community as a whole.<br />
3 Conducting a Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>) is a federal tax law requirement in section 501(r) of the Internal<br />
Revenue Code for non-profit hospitals to maintain tax-exempt 501 (c)(3) status. The requirement was added by the Patient<br />
Protection and Affordable Care Art (ACA) enacted on March 23, 2010 in Section 9007. Community benefit reporting for<br />
WellStar’s not-for-profit hospitals is required via Form 990, Schedule H. Under the ACA, hospitals are required to conduct<br />
community health needs assessments every three years and implement strategies to address those needs.<br />
4 ACA “…legislation contains numerous provisions aimed at improving community health through direct investments in<br />
wellness and prevention at the individual and community levels and by making population health improvement an integral<br />
part of efforts to improve the quality and efficiency of healthcare.” From “Principles to Consider for the Implementation of<br />
the Community Health Needs Assessment Process, June 2013, Sara Rosenblum, Department of Health Policy, The George<br />
Washington University School of Public Health Services.<br />
5 The IHI Triple Aim framework was developed by the Institute for Healthcare Improvement (www.ihi.org) and often functions<br />
as a statement of purpose for healthcare system transformation that will better meet the needs of people and patients. Its<br />
successful implementation results in fundamentally new systems contributing to the overall population health while reducing<br />
the cost to society.<br />
6 Patient experience encompasses the following Institute of Medicine dimensions: safe, effective, patient-centered, timely,<br />
efficient, and equitable.<br />
7 “True Triple Aim improvement cannot be realized by healthcare systems acting alone, or by solely delivering high-quality<br />
care at lower costs. Improving health is a challenge that requires the engagement of partners across the community to address<br />
the broader determinants of health.” IHI Leadership Blog, “A Primer for Defining the Triple Aim,” Sept. 23, 2015.<br />
8 Process informed by the Catholic Health Association, the Georgia Department of Public Health (Chronic Disease University<br />
PowerPoint, August 13, 2015, presented by Melissa Kinkoph, MPH, CHES, Program Manager, Healthy Communities) and valued<br />
input by the Cobb & Douglas Public Health’s Department of Epidemiology.<br />
9 WellStar joined forces with Kaiser Permanente, Grady Health System and Piedmont Healthcare to leverage the Georgia<br />
Health Policy Center’s <strong>CHNA</strong> research conducted for Kaiser’s 32-county service area footprint. Targeted data reports were<br />
provided for the shared counties served.<br />
10 Hospital facility census as of December 2015 at the close of <strong>CHNA</strong> research.<br />
11 As an integrated health system, the majority of WellStar’s community benefit services is managed and delivered System-wide<br />
by WellStar Community Health Collaborative’s community engagement arm, Community Education & Outreach. WellStar’s<br />
service area is deemed one community for this joint <strong>CHNA</strong> as hospital catchment areas overlap within the five-county primary<br />
service area and identified health needs are the same or similar.<br />
12 http://burruss.kennesaw.edu/about-institute.php<br />
13 www.countyhealthrankings.org – Health Outcomes based on length and quality of life out of 159 Georgia counties.<br />
14 Income inequality gaps are growing in the United States. Despite advances in medicine and education, the difference in<br />
life span after age 50 between richest and poorest has more than doubled since the 1970s with smoking, the single biggest<br />
cause of preventable death, helping to drive the disparity. Obesity is more ambiguous with the gap narrowing according to the<br />
National Academy of Sciences from 1990 to 2010 from 37 percent among the poorest to 31 percent among those on the higher<br />
end of the income ladder. Excerpts from The New York Times, “Disparity in Life Spans of the Rich and the Poor Is Growing,”<br />
Sabrina Tavernise, Feb. 12, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
15 Signifies limited access to healthy foods.<br />
16 Chronic diseases—such as asthma, cancer, diabetes and heart disease—cost Georgia approximately $40 billion dollars each<br />
year, keep kids out of school, cost Georgia employers, and results in more than 200,000 thousands of years of life lost. https://<br />
dph.georgia.gov/chronic-disease-prevention<br />
<strong>REPORT</strong> REFERENCES<br />
73
COMMUNITY IS CARE<br />
17 www.countyhealthrankings.org averaged data, <strong>2016</strong><br />
18 The public health system includes government and public health agencies, public sector agencies (schools, Medicaid) and<br />
private sector organizations whose actions have significant consequences for the health of the population.<br />
19 Other considerations: (1) The burden, scope, severity, and urgency of the need. (2) The estimated feasibility and effectiveness<br />
of possible interventions. (3) Health disparities associated with the need or the importance the community places on addressing<br />
the need.<br />
20 Healthy lifestyle needs primarily stem from unhealthy behaviors, which can lead to chronic disease. “High-cost patients are<br />
twice as likely as the rest of the population to have a chronic condition and four times as likely to have two or more chronic<br />
illnesses. In 2012, the top five most costly medical conditions in terms of healthcare expenditures were heart disease, traumarelated<br />
disorders, cancer, mental disorders, and COPD/asthma.” Excerpts from the Huffington Post blog post, “Healing the Sickest<br />
Patients: How ‘Hot Spotters,’ ‘Frequent Fliers,’ and ‘Super-Utilizers’ Impact Health Care in America” - August 18, 2015.<br />
21 Taken from the Institute of Medicine’s “Primary Care and Public Health” (Washington, D.C., 2012) p. S-1.<br />
22 “While the primary goal of the health system is improving health, another important goal is ensuring responsiveness to the<br />
legitimate expectations of the population.” (World Health Organization) This can be achieved with the help and expertise of the<br />
Public Health System as a whole and through formalized strategic community partners.<br />
23 “Government and private insurers are increasingly emphasizing quality of care in reimbursements, instead of just paying for<br />
the quantity of services delivered.” Excerpt from “Broader strategy: From local hospitals to regional players,” Georgia Health<br />
News, Dec. 10, 2015.<br />
24 From the 2013 Implementation Strategy Report: “To implement a five-year, two-phased Community Benefit program that<br />
is sustainable and strategically aligned with the WellStar Health System mission and vision to address the prioritized health<br />
needs of the uninsured and low-income populations. This is accomplished through expanding provider participation, education,<br />
outreach and prevention activities/programs to promote healthy lifestyles and access to care (Phase 1: 2013-2015) and creating<br />
a collaborative safety net organization for shared accountability to leverage and maximize complementary skills and capacity<br />
building (Phase 2: 2015-2018).”<br />
25 Expected rollout of the WellStar 4-1 Care Network is the fall of <strong>2016</strong>. The network relies on WMG physicians and advanced<br />
practitioners to help build care capacity in partnering community clinics. The name reflects the goal to treat and prescribe<br />
resources one person at a time to improve primary care access to the most vulnerable.<br />
26 WellStar’s Center of Health Transformation is the catalyst for developing pathways for improving patient safety, care efficiency<br />
and technology by bringing together not-for-profit health systems, universities and technology organizations to develop real-world<br />
health solutions through collaboration, research and innovation. It also serves as an incubator for promising new solutions to<br />
medical challenges in Northwest Georgia and beyond.<br />
COMMUNITY IS COMMITMENT 16<br />
27 An example is WellStar’s Center for Health Transformation builds a collaborative network of start-up tech, higher education and<br />
research institutes to develop new, innovative solutions to improve care delivery and lower costs.<br />
28 An integrated healthcare delivery system is not just comprised of acute care hospitals. WellStar provides access to comprehensive<br />
rehabilitation, education, outpatient services, and post-acute services to its patients.<br />
29 Since the inception of WellStar’s ACO in July 2012, providing better care at a lower cost has saved more than $37 million.<br />
30 These IRS defined community benefit categories are exclusive of uncompensated indigent care, charity care and bad debt.<br />
31 Federal poverty level is a measure of income level issued annually by the Department of Health and Human Services. FPLs are<br />
used to determine eligibility for certain programs and benefits.https://dch.georgia.gov/sites/dch.georgia.gov/files/related_files/<br />
document/2015_Federal_Poverty_Guidelines.pdf<br />
32 Guided by government policy, indigent care is care provided to those who do not have insurance and are not eligible for other<br />
healthcare coverage such as Medicare or Medicaid. Charity care is guided by hospital policy and is care provided for free or<br />
reduced prices to low-income patients. Community Financial Assistance (CFA) is available for qualifying community members.<br />
33 The reduction reflects the full implementation of the propensity to pay system which automatically identifies indigent patients<br />
and classifies them as charity without waiting for the completion of the CFA process.<br />
34 Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs) are in effect with community safety net clinics to help serve the uninsured,<br />
underserved and most vulnerable populations to improve community health. The MOUs are being reviewed and revised as part of<br />
the WellStar Community Health Collaborative.<br />
35 U.S. Census Bureau, 2014. Note population totals don’t align with the county profile data generated by the Georgia Health<br />
Policy Center who used 2010-2013 data.<br />
74 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
36 County Health Rankings, <strong>2016</strong><br />
37 U.S. Census Bureau, American Fact Finder. 2010-2014 American Community Survey 5-year estimates. www.factfinder.census.gov.<br />
38 U.S. Census Bureau American Fact Finder, 2010-2014 American Community Survey- 5-year estimates. www.factfinder.census.gov<br />
39 Excerpt from “Georgia’s Low Health Ranking Sinks Even Lower,“ Georgia Health News, Dec. 9, 2015, Andy Miller<br />
40 Hospital community demographic data based on 90 percent hospital catchment areas and <strong>2016</strong> estimates from The Nielsen<br />
Company, Pop-Facts Demographics, generated on 2/5/16 by WellStar Strategic Planning.<br />
41 In addition to providing means for purchasing healthcare, higher incomes can provide better nutrition, housing, schooling, and<br />
recreation. Independent of actual income levels, the distribution of income within countries and states has been linked to rates<br />
of mortality.<br />
42 “To the extent that education is key to health inequality, policies encouraging more years of schooling and supporting early<br />
childhood education may have health benefits. When policymakers debate the merits of increasing access to education, they<br />
rarely consider improvements in the health of the population. Other virtues—increasing human capital, boosting productivity,<br />
augmenting lifetime earnings, and improving the socialization of the next generation—follow from improvements in educational<br />
attainment as in others, collateral benefits such as decreasing health care costs also might emerge from increased investment<br />
in education.” Socioeconomic Disparities In Health: Pathways and Policies, Health Affairs blog. http://content.healthaffairs.org/<br />
content/21/2/60.full<br />
43 County Health Rankings, <strong>2016</strong><br />
44 County Health Rankings, <strong>2016</strong><br />
45 The county’s health outcomes ranking is where it ranks overall among Georgia’s 159 counties as measured by how long people<br />
live and how healthy people feel while alive. www.countyhealthrankings.org NOTE: Because ranks are relative, they aren’t as<br />
helpful in isolation – a county’s rank depends not only on what is happening in the county, but also on what happens in all the<br />
other counties in Georgia. In fact, if every county improved its health equally, the ranks would all stay the same. These ranks inform<br />
the county’s progress measurement, not drive it.<br />
46 All health factor statistics from County Health Rankings, <strong>2016</strong>.<br />
47 Percentage of adults that report a Body Mass Index (BMI) of 30 or more signifying obesity.<br />
48 Primary Care Physicians and Mental Health Providers is the ratio of the population to total primary care physicians. For primary<br />
care, the top US performers are 1,045:1 (90th percentile) and mental health is 385:1 (90th percentile).<br />
49 Severe Housing Problems is the percentage of households with at least one or more of the following housing problems:<br />
(1) housing unit lacks complete kitchen facilities, (2) housing unit lacks complete plumbing facilities, (3) household is severely<br />
overcrowded; and (4) household is severely cost burdened. County Health Rankings and Roadmaps used the U.S. Department of<br />
Housing Development (HUD) which periodically receives “custom tabulations” of data from the U.S. Census Bureau that are largely<br />
not available through standard Census products. This data, known as the “CHAS” data (Comprehensive Housing Affordability<br />
Strategy), demonstrates the extent of housing problems and housing needs, particularly for low income households.<br />
50 Georgia Department of Public Health, OASIS – Age-Adjusted Death Rate, Last 5-Year Aggregate, 2010-2014 <strong>CHNA</strong> Dashboard.<br />
A remarkable finding since the 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> is the upward move of mental and behavioral disorders in the top five leading causes<br />
of death reflecting the disparity in all counties served.<br />
51 County health status summary sources: Community Commons <strong>CHNA</strong> Portal, County Health Rankings and Roadmaps, U.S.<br />
Census Bureau - American Community Survey 5-Year Dataset, Georgia Department of Public Health Online Analytical Statistical<br />
Information System (OASIS), and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis, STD,<br />
and TB Prevention (NCHHSTP): www.cdc.gov/NCHHSTP/Atlas/<br />
COMMUNITY IS CONTRIBUTION 32<br />
52 For this report, the Cobb & Douglas Public Health’s Community Health Assessment did not align with WellStar’s <strong>CHNA</strong> timeline,<br />
so the resources and funding previously procured for the 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> were not available for this health needs assessment cycle.<br />
An initial meeting in July 2015 with Cobb Douglas Public Health’s Epidemiology helped to define data sources and methodology<br />
53 https://www.healthypeople.gov/<br />
54 GHPC provides evidence-based research, program development and policy guidance locally, statewide, and nationally to<br />
improve communities’ health status.<br />
55 A total of 172 WellStar Medical Group representatives engaged with the survey – 73 of which partially completed the tool and<br />
are not represented in the results in the supplemental appendices.<br />
56 A total of 559 community members engaged with the survey - 112 of which partially completed the tool and are not represented<br />
in the results in the supplemental appendices.<br />
57 Ser Familia is a social services community organization that gives Latino youth, couples, parents and families the tools they<br />
need for successful daily living through better relationships, leadership and life/communication skills to become emotionally<br />
strong and healthy.<br />
75
58 A listening session was conducted at the Paulding Health Department as there currently is no operating safety net clinic in<br />
Paulding County.<br />
59 http://www.cdc.gov/chinav/tools/index.html and Database of Interventions: http://wwwn.cdc.gov/chidatabase<br />
60 Some data from the 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> cannot be compared to the 2015 data as the BRFSS telephone survey has been traditionally<br />
done with people using land lines. An increasing number of people are only using cell/mobile phones. CDC recognized the need<br />
to include cell phone users in the survey in order to obtain data that better represents the diverse populations. Since the way<br />
information is gathered and processed, new data cannot be accurately compared to previous findings.<br />
http://www.cdc.gov/surveillancepractice/reports/brfss/brfss.html<br />
61 http://www.varpguide.com/<br />
62 Over a two-month period in the fall of 2015, the GHPC compiled service-area data including demographics, socioeconomic<br />
factors, health behaviors, health outcomes, workforce adequacy and assets. The latest U.S. Census data (2010-2014) was not yet<br />
released.<br />
63 www.chna.org<br />
64 www.oasis.state.ga.us<br />
65 www.census.gov<br />
COMMUNITY IS CONNECTION 38<br />
66 Federal regulations emphasize involvement by people who represent the “broad interests” of the communities served by<br />
nonprofit hospitals, including people with “special knowledge of or expertise in public health.” 78 Fed Reg at 20541 (to be codified<br />
at 26 CFR 1:501(r)-3(b)(5)).<br />
67 WellStar solicited more county-specific sources than noted for input. Representatives either didn’t respond to the inquiry,<br />
failed to fulfill to provide the requested information or declined due to competing priorities.<br />
68 The Cobb2020 Partnership is a partnership of community organizations and individuals dedicated to promoting healthy<br />
lifestyles and the delivery of essential health services in Cobb County.<br />
COMMUNITY IS COMPASSION 42<br />
69 An August 2015 report by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners found that Georgia had the highest percentage<br />
of “narrow” insurance networks (limited choice of doctors) in the 2014 health exchanges. “State senator expects legislation on<br />
insurance reform,” Georgia Health News, 12/15/15.<br />
70 Determinants of Health: (1) Biology and genetics. (2) Individual behavior. Examples: alcohol use, injection drug use (needles),<br />
unprotected sex, and smoking (3) Social environment. Examples: discrimination, income, and gender (4) Physical environment.<br />
Examples: where a person lives and crowding conditions (5) Health services. Examples: Access to quality health care and having<br />
or not having health insurance<br />
COMMUNITY IS COLLABORATION 50<br />
71 Revised Memorandums of Understandings were implemented in <strong>2016</strong> to provide more definitive processes to help refer<br />
patients, build capacity and measure/track outcomes. These partnerships help WellStar meet the primary care needs of the<br />
medically underserved and uninsured who qualify for WellStar’s Community Financial Assistance (indigent care
COMMUNITY IS CHANGE 60<br />
76 Better storytelling focuses not only on the patient experience but also on compelling stories of the heroes of health in our<br />
community.<br />
77 WellStar uses the Catholic Health Association’s categories of community benefit which tracks with the reporting software CBISA.<br />
https://www.chausa.org/docs/default-source/community-benefit-guide-2015/2015-cb-guide-categories-definitions.pdf?sfvrsn=4<br />
78 WellStar is a member of Spirit of Women, an elite coalition of hospitals and healthcare providers across the United States that<br />
ascribe to the highest standards of excellence in women’s health education and community outreach.<br />
79 WellStar is endorsed by the Lung Cancer Alliance as a Screening Center of Excellence because it’s committed to the principles<br />
identified in the National Framework. The Framework was modeled after the WellStar lung cancer screening program and is now<br />
used as the standard for screening centers across the country. http://www.lungcanceralliance.org/am-i-at-risk/national-frameworkfor-lung-screening-excellence.html.<br />
East Cobb Health Park and Douglas Imaging Center have received Lung Cancer Screening Center<br />
accreditation from the American College of Radiology.<br />
80 This also addresses the 2013 Implementation Strategy to Participate as a Cobb Access Health integrator/partner to build a<br />
low-income healthcare delivery system in Cobb County. The proposed non-profit organization, Cobb Access Health, is not being<br />
pursued. Instead, WellStar has formalized its community benefit services by creating a department, the WellStar Community Health<br />
Collaborative, and is improving access to care via partnerships with community safety net clinics and other non-profit organizations.<br />
81 The federal government’s 340B Drug Discount Card enables eligible healthcare organizations/covered entities to provide<br />
medications at significantly reduced prices through participating retail locations.<br />
82 http://gme.wellstar.org/<br />
83 Also known as a Financial Assistance Policy or FAP.<br />
84 www.ngoc.com<br />
85 This is not an all-inclusive list.<br />
86 In collaboration with Bright Horizons Foundation for Children, the Bright Space was created for children with open abuse and<br />
neglect cases through CASA - Court Appointed Special Advocates for Children In Canton (Cherokee County).<br />
87 Cobb2020 is a partnership of community organizations and individuals dedicated to providing healthy lifestyles and the delivery<br />
of essential health services in Cobb County. www.cobb2020.com<br />
77
<strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)<br />
78 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
SIGNIFICANT<br />
HEALTH NEEDS<br />
DATA SUMMARIES<br />
79
The significant health needs related to access to care stem from<br />
socioeconomic and clinical care barriers. These barriers create<br />
health disparities in the communities WellStar serves especially<br />
among the most vulnerable populations (low-income, uninsured,<br />
low education attainment, elderly). Underuse denotes lack of<br />
capacity /access and cost of the care.<br />
Lack of Care Capacity<br />
in Community Safety<br />
Net Clinics<br />
Lack of Care Capacity<br />
in Community Safety<br />
Net Clinics<br />
The significant health needs related to healthy lifestyles primarily<br />
stem from health behaviors causing chronic disease and/or<br />
behavioral health issues. These needs require intervention<br />
and management through clinical care, lifestyle modification<br />
(primary prevention) and education and “prescribing resources”<br />
(secondary prevention).<br />
80 <strong>2016</strong> Community Health Needs Assessment (<strong>CHNA</strong>)
[Healthcare Costs - Background]<br />
Economic security is either the greatest door or barrier to access care and preventive services. From all the<br />
<strong>2016</strong> primary research, income is a key driver of health status. Low income typically equals poor health. Most<br />
of the nation’s medical costs come from a small fraction of very sick patients. Knowing who they are is an<br />
efficient way to lower healthcare spending. In 2012, the top 5 percent of patients accounted for half of all<br />
healthcare spending and less than three percent of costs came from the bottom 50 percent, who remained<br />
relatively healthy. 1<br />
Although WellStar does not accept the Affordable Care Act exchanges, a theme among community clinic<br />
patients is that it does not help them gain access to care and is not affordable as rates are going up. “(The cost<br />
of) Obamacare puts you in a no-win situation.” Backing their claim are excerpts from the Georgia Health News<br />
article, “Exchange enrollment shows strong Atlanta area numbers,” published on Jan. 22, <strong>2016</strong>:<br />
Consumers face a higher penalty this year for not enrolling in ACA exchange coverage. The penalty is<br />
$695 per adult and $347 per child up to a family cap of $2,500 or 2.5 percent of household income,<br />
whichever is greater. (Last year’s penalty was $325 for adults, with a $975 maximum or 2 percent of household<br />
income.) Bill Custer, a health insurance expert at Georgia State University, said Georgia would have had<br />
stronger growth this year if health plan premiums had held steady. But as in other states, there were<br />
rate increases, which averaged six percent statewide.<br />
Also, in Georgia, 305,000 of poor, uninsured non-elderly adults fall into a “coverage gap” (
60.7 percent of the community surveyed could not see a doctor when needed because they could not afford it<br />
and 70.5 percent of those who were not able to get prescribed medication in the last 12 months cited cost/high<br />
co-pay.<br />
Underinsured / uninsured community members feel they are disqualified from participating in the prevention<br />
part of health due to high healthcare costs/co-pays.<br />
- They want better access to affordable medical care “Not everyone can get Medicaid. I was turned<br />
down for services. (It) makes you want to give up… You get kicked to the curb. You gonna kick your<br />
family to the curb? No. You’re gonna do everything in your power to do what you gotta do.”<br />
- They desire transparency and flat, up-front fees. “I believe there’s money (to help us)…but they don’t<br />
want you to know how to get it.” “You don’t know the actual cost of services (under after they are<br />
performed).”<br />
- They are willing to pay according to their income.<br />
- Among Hispanics, WellStar is viewed by the community as a hospital, but not as a health system, and is<br />
mostly related to expensive services.<br />
Nielson Pop Facts Demographics Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA U.S.<br />
% below 100% FPL 17.14% 9.83% 12.82% 16.11% 11.41% 18.20% 15.37%<br />
% below 200% FPL 38.25% 24.66% 28.98% 35.27% 27.69% 38.73% 34.23%<br />
% of population receiving<br />
Medicaid<br />
20.23% 10.42% 12.48% 18.99% 13.31% 20.18% 20.21%
[Primary Care Access]<br />
Access to regular primary care is important to preventing major health issues and emergency department visits.<br />
While high rates of specialist physicians have been shown to be associated with higher, and perhaps<br />
unnecessary utilization, a sufficient number of primary care physicians is essential for preventive and primary<br />
care, and when needed, referrals to appropriate specialty care.<br />
Primary Care Physicians<br />
(CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
Access to Primary Care (rate of<br />
physician per 100,000 population)<br />
Preventable hospital stays 4<br />
(CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
*Designated as a Health Professional Shortage Area<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA US<br />
2,150:1 2,930:1 1,430:1 2,310:1 7,730:1 1,540:1<br />
HPSA*<br />
43.7 32.1 68.6 41.8 12.4 63.6 74.5<br />
73 51 51 63 72 61 55<br />
Referrals from WellStar Emergency Departments (ED) to WellStar Community Clinics for patients with nonemergent,<br />
primary care needs have remained stagnate due to limited providers, 5 but partnering community<br />
safety net clinics help shoulder the load, but also struggle with inadequate staffing.<br />
FY 2015 (July 2014 –<br />
June 2015)<br />
Level 0-2 Outpatient<br />
Visits*<br />
% of Total ED<br />
Level 0-2<br />
Outpatients<br />
Visits<br />
ED Referrals to WellStar Community Clinics 2014 2015<br />
Cobb ED to Cobb Community Clinic 601 644 26,580 30.30%<br />
Kennestone ED to Kennestone Community Clinic 661 670 17,012 15.48%<br />
Douglas ED 18,906 31.29%<br />
Paulding ED 16,567 27.74%<br />
*Care levels 0-2 are non-emergent visits –visits that potentially could be treated in a primary care setting.<br />
According to the community’s vulnerable populations, “hours of primary care not aligned to accommodate the<br />
work schedule is a hindrance.” ED use has become a matter of convenience outside of work hours. Tension<br />
comes from their jobs that don’t pay a decent and livable wage to pay for the high cost of care. “Walk-in clinics<br />
are needed. We can’t play with peoples’ lives like this.”<br />
4 This indicator reports the patient discharge rate (per 1,000 Medicare enrollees) for conditions that are ambulatory care sensitive (ACS).<br />
ACS conditions include pneumonia, dehydration, asthma, diabetes, and other conditions which could have been prevented if adequate<br />
primary care resources were available and accessed by those patients. This indicator is relevant because analysis of ACS discharges<br />
allows demonstrating a possible “return on investment” from interventions that reduce admissions (for example, for uninsured or<br />
Medicaid patients) through better access to primary care resources. Hospitalization for diagnoses treatable in outpatient services<br />
suggests that the quality of care provided in the outpatient setting was less than ideal. The measure may also represent a tendency to<br />
overuse hospitals as a main source of care. County Health Rankings, 2012 data.<br />
5 In 2017, the WellStar’s Graduate Medical Education (GME) program will commence boosting the community clinics’ current active<br />
roster of 400 patients to more than 1,500 patients at the end of the first year of the residency program, 2,500 at year two and nearly<br />
4,000 at the end of year three.
A desire to shift from a sick system to a well system is hindered by patients’ lack of resources to cover<br />
preventative care (annual check-ups, screenings). “Why pay a co-pay if you’re fine? Why do I need them to tell<br />
me I’m OK?”<br />
Hispanic community members note “the insurance we can afford, doctors don’t accept.” Overall, the tendency<br />
is to, as one resident said, “…wait until we can’t wait anymore.” In the Acworth / Kennesaw area, everyone<br />
knows about Kennesaw Urgent Care which charges a $45 flat fee. They also go to CVS Minute Clinic and ED if<br />
there’s no other option.
[Children]<br />
Affordability of pediatric and adolescent health services impedes access to care, especially among those<br />
community members living in poverty.<br />
CHR <strong>2016</strong> Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
% of children living in<br />
21% 13% 20% 20% 16% 26%<br />
poverty<br />
(CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
% of children eligible for 52% 26% 41% 52% 34% 53%<br />
free lunch<br />
Number of children in a<br />
single-parent household 6 32% 25% 31% 36% 27% 37%<br />
Hispanic community members in Acworth (Cobb/Cherokee/Paulding) have babies at Kennestone, but they can’t<br />
find a pediatrician. “Discharge won’t help. You must look before baby is born.” Dr. Rodriguez doesn’t accept<br />
new patients unless it’s a sibling of a current patient. They also remarked on the need for positive parenting<br />
skills. “If I knew how to cope, my stress would diminish.”<br />
Paulding residents noted the lack of birthing center at the new hospital.<br />
6 Children in single-parent households are at greater risk of severe morbidity and all-cause mortality then their peers in two-parent<br />
households. Both adults and children in single-parent households are at risk for adverse health outcomes such as mental health<br />
problems (including substance abuse, depression, and suicide) and unhealthy behaviors such as smoking and excessive alcohol use.<br />
County Health Rankings <strong>2016</strong>.
[Care Capacity of Community Safety Net<br />
Clinics]<br />
The uninsured patient average across the WellStar five-county area is 20 percent. 7 Access to primary care<br />
providers in every county except Cobb far exceeds the state ratio of 1,540:1 primary care physician. As a result<br />
of being uninsured, Obamacare’s rising premiums costs, high deductible insurance plans, and the changing<br />
healthcare landscape in Georgia (including the current debate regarding expanding Medicaid), community safety<br />
net clinic demand exceeds the supply in the communities WellStar serves.<br />
Community safety net clinic patients are keenly aware of the need and see WellStar provider engagement as an<br />
answer to expanding community clinic hours, eliminating appointment wait time and onboarding new patients:<br />
- We need a free clinic in Paulding County or a better use of the Health Department for adults, not just children and<br />
pregnant women.” “If you have more providers available to serve the community that would be great.” “You<br />
have enough resources and enough doctors – top specialists – …you can’t give two hours out of a week to show<br />
somebody compassion…?” “…We are lucky to be in Good Samaritan, but there’s a waiting list to get in here.<br />
Unfortunately, a lot of people cannot get in because they don’t have the space, the doctors and what they need to<br />
serve us. I wish they had more doctors to help us.”<br />
The majority of WellStar Medical Group (WMG) respondents noted involvement in and support of free or lowcost<br />
community clinics as the best way we can help serve the healthcare needs of the medically<br />
underserved/uninsured and to decrease the burden on Emergency Department and primary care offices.<br />
- “We need to expand free clinics where patients can have follow-up as an outpatient.”<br />
- “We need to partner with community clinics that can see a larger number of patients…in each county that we<br />
serve. Utilize WMG physicians who want to volunteer.”<br />
- A majority would put skin in the game: Would you be interested in investing four hours a month of your time to<br />
help meet the growing patient demands of our partner community health clinics? (More clinician volunteers will<br />
help our partners caring for low-income and under/uninsured patients extend hours to provide much needed<br />
primary care and chronic disease management. As a byproduct, it will help reduce WellStar ED utilization to give<br />
patients a medical home.)<br />
No 41.1%<br />
Yes 58.9%<br />
(Represents 240 hours a<br />
care per month)<br />
7 County Health Rankings, <strong>2016</strong>
[Emergency Department Utilization]<br />
Frequent Emergency Department utilization for non-emergent healthcare needs is prevalent among the lowincome<br />
and uninsured populations.<br />
From June 2014<br />
– July 2015<br />
Total # of<br />
ED<br />
patients<br />
# of visits # of<br />
patient<br />
with 4+<br />
visits<br />
% of<br />
patients<br />
with 4+<br />
visits<br />
Total of 4+<br />
visits<br />
4+ visits as<br />
a % of<br />
total ED<br />
patients<br />
Cobb Hospital 62,616 99,430 3,618 5.78% 21,672 21.80%<br />
Douglas Hospital 38,768 66,662 3,042 7.85% 18,294 27.44%<br />
Kennestone Hospital 89,773 132,509 4,145 4.62% 23,939 18.07%<br />
Paulding Hospital 38,922 64,128 2,744 7.05% 15,247 23.93%<br />
System-Wide:<br />
Total # of ED patients: 215,285<br />
Total # of visits: 362,729<br />
Total patients 4+ visits: 15,683<br />
Total 4+ visits: 94,828<br />
The 4+ category represents 7.28 percent of all ED<br />
patients and 26.14 percent of total visits to the WellStar<br />
EDs. Self-pay (uninsured or OOP) represent nearly 25<br />
percent of all 4+ visitors.<br />
Payer Summary Group (PSG) for 4+ Visits<br />
% of PSG Patients % of PSG Visits % of PSG Total Charges<br />
Managed Care 2.84% 11.81% 12.57%<br />
Self-Pay 6.41% 24.48% 23.61%<br />
Medicaid 8.56% 28.28% 34.11%<br />
Medicare 10.27% 32.99% 30.84%<br />
Other 1.53% 7.00% 8.61%<br />
HIE 3.56% 14.13% 13.41%<br />
WHS Emp Plan 2.97% 11.22% 10.68%<br />
WellStar ED Service Levels 0-II represent lower acuity cases – those non-emergent conditions that potentially<br />
could be treated in a primary care setting.<br />
TOTAL OUTPATIENT ED VISITS<br />
SERVICE LEVEL 0-II<br />
July 2013 -<br />
June 2014<br />
July 2014 –<br />
June 2015<br />
Cobb Hospital Outpatient 29.18% 30.30%<br />
Douglas Hospital Outpatient 35.09% 31.29%<br />
Kennestone Hospital Outpatient 13.91% 15.48%<br />
Paulding Hospital Outpatient 26.80% 27.74%
A Good Sam community clinic patient explained the lack of options leading to an ED visit:<br />
“There’s a waiting list to get in Good Sam. My father-in-law can’t get in so he goes nowhere. If he got<br />
very sick we would get him to the emergency room. When you go, they do a great job and do whatever<br />
they have to do, but after that there’s no other place to go. They refer you to a specialist, but you<br />
cannot afford the specialist and there are no other clinics like this. We need more places (to go).”
[Medication Access & Affordability]<br />
Community clinic patients cite the residual expenses associated with managing their chronic disease and other<br />
medical conditions:<br />
- “I cherish my life and don’t want to die of something that could be fixed.” (The patient’s medications are<br />
over $100/month.)<br />
- “My biggest health challenge is figuring out what prescriptions I should take for my money.”<br />
- “You don’t do the medicine at $700/month.”<br />
- At Good Sam in Cobb medication is affordable via a prescription assistance program (PAP). “You get<br />
what you need here. It’s $100 on the outside and five or six dollars here.”<br />
- “You decide whether you’re gonna eat or get the medicine.”<br />
- “The ER will give you a 30-day supply of medicine then you go back to the ER. Thank God the<br />
pharmaceutical companies have programs where they give free or low cost medications. A vial of<br />
Lantus costs $200.”<br />
- A Bethesda Community Clinic nurse finds many patients in Cherokee County are put on expensive<br />
medications at an ER visit. “They can’t afford them so they just quit taking their meds and finally find us<br />
after two or three months… Their blood pressure or blood sugar is through the roof because they<br />
couldn’t afford to go back to the ER to get their refills. So they fall through the cracks.”<br />
WellStar Medical Group respondents say the biggest reason their patients have issues filling their medication is<br />
the cost factor (68 percent) followed by non-compliance (11 percent). This aligns with their cited reasons<br />
mental health patients have issues; along with the lack of education about maintenance medications.<br />
Of the 13.7 percent of the 447 online community health survey respondents who said “Yes, there was a time<br />
during the past 12 months when they could not get prescribed medication,” 70.5 percent said it was due to
cost/high co- pay. Other reasons cited included an issue with the pharmacy, not available in the pharmacy,<br />
insurance would not cover, needed to see a doctor to get the Rx refilled and did not have time to make an<br />
appointment – delayed six months in getting the meds.<br />
A blog article in The Huffington Post 8 (updated in August 2015) said “The Patient Protection and Affordable Care<br />
Act of 2010 (ACA) includes an important provision that prohibits insurers from denying coverage to patients with<br />
pre-existing conditions. This prohibition, however, may lead some insurers, hospitals, and providers to engage in<br />
unethical practices regarding the "sickest patients." For example, it has been reported that some insurers are<br />
placing high-cost medications for chronic conditions into the highest-priced tiers of drugs they cover, forcing<br />
patients to potentially pay thousands more dollars in co-payments out-of-pocket for essential medications to<br />
treat their illnesses. For example, a recent study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2015<br />
found that some plans offered through the health insurance marketplaces may be pricing HIV drugs out of reach<br />
for some patients in an effort to get around the health law's mandate prohibiting discrimination based on a<br />
person's pre-existing condition.<br />
8 “Healing the Sickest Patients: How 'Hot Spotters,' 'Frequent Fliers,' and 'Super-Utilizers' Impact Health Care in America,” Susan<br />
Blumenthal, M.D., Public Health Editor, The Huffington Post; Former U.S. Assistant Surgeon General
[Mental Health]<br />
A remarkable, yet not surprising, finding since the 2013 <strong>CHNA</strong> is the upward trend of mental and behavioral<br />
disorders in the top five leading causes of death.<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding<br />
1<br />
Heart disease Heart disease Heart disease Lung cancer Lung cancer<br />
Lung cancer Lung cancer Mental & behavioral<br />
2<br />
disorders<br />
All COPD (except Mental & behavioral Lung cancer<br />
3<br />
asthma)<br />
disorders<br />
4<br />
Stoke All COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Heart disease<br />
Heart disease<br />
Mental & behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
All COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Stroke Stroke Hypertension &<br />
hypertensive renal<br />
and heart disease<br />
Mental & behavioral<br />
Stroke<br />
COPD (except<br />
COPD (except<br />
5<br />
disorders<br />
asthma)<br />
asthma)<br />
Rankings from the Georgia Department of Public Health, OASIS, Age-Related Death Rate, Last 5-Year Aggregate, 2010-2014, <strong>CHNA</strong> Dashboard.<br />
Mental & behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
48.8 percent of community members surveyed would go to their doctor first to address a mental health issue<br />
followed by a private counselor/therapist (24.4 percent).<br />
-“Now thinking about your mental health, which includes stress, depression and problems with<br />
emotions, how many days during the past 30 days was your mental health not good?”<br />
Don’t know 5.9%<br />
More than 10<br />
days 23.5%<br />
1 to 5 days 41.2%<br />
6-10 days 29.4%<br />
WellStar Medical Group (WMG) providers rank mental health concern level as high (46.7 percent), medium (41<br />
percent) with 78.2 percent see gaps finding behavioral health services for Medicaid and/or uninsured patients.<br />
- 66.7 percent believe there is not reasonable access to care and/or education regarding mental health<br />
and for patients with insurance (67.3 percent).<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
Ratio of mental health providers 9 1,050:1 1,150:1 700:1 1,240:1 2,810:1 850:1<br />
% of depression among Medicare<br />
beneficiaries (GHPC data)<br />
19% 13% 14% 14% 16% 15%<br />
9 The ratio of the county population to the number of mental health providers including psychiatrists, psychologists, licensed clinical<br />
social workers, counselors, marriage and family therapists and advanced practice nurses specializing in mental health care: (<strong>2016</strong><br />
communityhealthrankings.org)
***As the mental health parity aspects of the Affordable Care Act create increased coverage for mental health<br />
services, many anticipate increased workforce shortages.<br />
The Hispanic community is “in denial about (mental health issues)…it will go away.” The need is big, but services<br />
are available in Spanish and/or they are too expensive.<br />
A Bethesda care provider and clinic patients confirm the high prevalence of depression due to job loss, diabetes,<br />
hypertension, and socioeconomic factors leading to family problems.<br />
- “Depression comes when all these thing happen. It’s a merry-go-round of stinking thinking. As much as<br />
you try to keep your head above water, they’re riding the whirlpool down the drain.”
[Dental Health]<br />
Engaging in preventive behaviors decreases the likelihood of developing future health problems. Oral health<br />
can highlight a lack of access to preventive care, a lack of health knowledge, insufficient provider outreach,<br />
and/or social barriers preventing utilization of dental services, especially among low-income populations.<br />
One community member remarked, “If you have a pain, you pull it (the tooth) out. Dental care means more<br />
money and more language barriers (to overcome).”<br />
Statewide, there is a dentist for every 2,060 residents. Only Cherokee and Cobb counties beat the state<br />
benchmark. (CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
Bartow: 3,080:1<br />
Douglas: 2,080:1<br />
Paulding: 7,450:1<br />
GHPC data Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA US<br />
Poor dental health 23.20% 12.30% 9.60% 12.10% 17.70% 16.70% 15.70%<br />
(adults over 18 who’ve had<br />
six or more teeth removed<br />
due to decay, disease or<br />
infection)<br />
No recent dental<br />
exam (adults over 18 who<br />
have not received dental<br />
care within the past year)<br />
30% 27% 23.20% 31.60% 23.20% 29.10% 30.70%<br />
Healthy People 2020 Target<br />
for people to have annual<br />
dental exams – 49%<br />
Access to dentist per<br />
100,000 population<br />
28.6 49.3 63.9 44.7 14.3 47.6 63.2
[Language & Cultural Barriers]<br />
Limited English Proficiency 10<br />
(CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
Linguistically isolated households 11<br />
– Total population<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
2% 3% 4% 2% 1% 3%<br />
2,380 6,670 29,486 3,917 1,937 325,741<br />
The lack of health information in Spanish and providers that speak Spanish are barriers to the Hispanic<br />
community adopting a healthy lifestyle. Health information is most prevalent coming from the schools to home,<br />
but it’s in English only.<br />
- “We’re not taken seriously. I’ve pretended not to know English to test the care. They take shortcuts…”<br />
Community clinic and Hispanic congregation members also expressed the need for more culturally appropriate<br />
education and materials to help them navigate the healthcare system and better participate in wellness.<br />
A WellStar Medical Group provider remarked “many of my patients complain that many of the medical staff are<br />
hard to understand due to their thick accents (English is their second language) and that causes a lot of<br />
frustration and anxiety…They have much less confidence in the person caring for them and the facility if they<br />
don’t know what’s going on.”<br />
10 Population with limited English proficiency (LEP): This indicator reports the percentage of the population age 5 and older that speaks a<br />
language other than English at home and speaks English less than "very well." This indicator is relevant because an inability to speak<br />
English well creates barriers to healthcare access, provider communications, and health literacy/education.<br />
11 This indicator reports the percentage of the population age five and older that lives in a home in which no person 14 years old and over<br />
speaks only English, or in which no person 14 years old and over speaks a non-English language and speak English "very well."
[Maternal & Infant Health]<br />
Women utilize more health care than men, in part because of their need for reproductive services. According to<br />
the U.S. Department of Labor, females of all ages accounted for 57 percent of all expenses incurred at doctors'<br />
offices in 2011.<br />
Core Indicators of health<br />
(Kaiser portal) Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
Low birth weight 12 8.20% 7.50% 8.30% 9.60% 7.30% 9.5%<br />
Infant mortality 13<br />
Healthy People 2020 Target: 6.0<br />
In Blacks<br />
15.10%<br />
In Blacks<br />
13.40%<br />
In Blacks<br />
12.20%<br />
In Blacks<br />
12.20%<br />
In Blacks<br />
11.30%<br />
6.9 4.6 6.7 7.3 7 7.6<br />
In Blacks<br />
12.6<br />
In Blacks<br />
10.7<br />
Lack of prenatal care Suppressed 7.12% 9.38% Suppressed Suppressed 13.80%<br />
Teen births (15-19) 54.3 27.1 28.9 37.8 25.3 45.3<br />
In Blacks<br />
36.1<br />
In Non-<br />
Hispanic<br />
Whites<br />
40.7<br />
By 2019, the Georgia Department of Public Health (GDPH) aims to reduce the preventable infant mortality rate<br />
from 6.3 (2013) to 5.3 per 1,000 births. (GDPH Strategic Plan, 8/5/15)<br />
Perinatal period conditions rank number four in the leading causes of premature deaths (before age 75) in<br />
Georgia according to the Georgia Department of Public Health. (OASIS Dashboard)<br />
The Bartow Public Health Nurse Manager noted a high incidence of infant deaths from co-sleeping or bed<br />
sharing. A recent Georgia Health News article (Jan. 31, <strong>2016</strong>), “Report underscores alarming problem of baby<br />
sleep deaths,” more than 30 percent were sleep-related and three in four of the deaths could have been<br />
prevented including “overlay” incidents. Among the sleep-related deaths, 61 percent were Black babies, 66<br />
percent were less than four months old and 60 percent occurred in an adult bed. .<br />
12 This indicator reports the percentage of total births that are low birthweight (Under 2500g). This indicator is relevant because low<br />
birthweight infants are at high risk for health problems. This indicator can also highlight the existence of health disparities.<br />
13 This indicator reports the rate of deaths to infants less than one year of age per 1,000 births. This indicator is relevant because high<br />
rates of infant mortality indicate the existence of broader issues pertaining to access to care and maternal and child health.
[Transportation]<br />
Our current transportation system contributes to physical inactivity—each additional hour spent in a car per day<br />
is associated with a six percent increase in the likelihood of obesity. 14 Also, the American Journal of Preventive<br />
Medicine found that the farther people commute by vehicle, the higher their blood pressure and body mass<br />
index. All WellStar countries have high percentages of people who commute over 60 minutes to work.<br />
Among the vulnerable populations, the lack of vehicle and/or the residents’ dependence on public transit<br />
(Cobb), taxi services, walkability factors, and a support system greatly diminishes quality of life and is a barrier to<br />
access care.<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
Commute to work alone in car 15 84% 81% 80% 80% 82% 79%<br />
Public transit stop within 0.5 mile 16 0 0 0.20% 0 0 3.78%<br />
Road network density (roads per square mile – 3.22 4.42 10.68 5.27 4.13 2.6<br />
relevant to air quality and tree canopy coverage)<br />
51.5 percent of community members surveyed said access to public transportation in their community was poor<br />
or very poor.<br />
Transportation challenges hit the community clinic patients and residents in high-need areas the hardest:<br />
- “I pay $12 to get to Kroger and back. That’s $12 I could use for my medicine.”<br />
- “I have to depend on CCT (Cobb Community Transit) buses to get around. The VA provides a way for<br />
their veterans to get to where they need to go. Why can’t they (Good Sam) provide a ride…What if our<br />
churches filled the gaps? Milford Church picks up people and brings them to the doctor.”<br />
- “They (government) are not doing anything about transportation issues.”<br />
- Paulding and Douglas community members cited the need for public transport and housing as CCT and<br />
Cherokee’s system don’t cross county lines.<br />
- Bartow Transit requires a 24-hour notice.<br />
A Cobb key informant remarked on the new Cobb Community Transit Flex program designed to provide<br />
sustainable transit options to the southern portion of Cobb County. It’s an on-demand service requiring a two<br />
14 Frank, Lawrence D., Martin A. Andresen, and Thomas L. Schmid. "Obesity relationships with community design, physical activity, and<br />
time spent in cars.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine 27.2 (2004): 87-96.<br />
15 CHR <strong>2016</strong>. This indicator reports the percentage of the population that commutes to work on a daily basis using a motor vehicle, and<br />
commutes as the only occupant of the vehicle. It’s relevant because it conveys information about the efficiency of the public<br />
transportation network, potential impacts on the environment (e.g. air pollution), and can inform policy, system and improve public<br />
transportation networks.<br />
16 GHPC county level data. This indicator measures the proportion of the population living within 0.5 miles of a GTFS or fixed-guide way<br />
transit stop. Access to public transportation can positively impact community safety and social capital, improve ability to access timely<br />
healthcare and employment and reduce air pollution in communities vulnerable to the health impacts of climate change.
to 24-hour reservation notice.<br />
http://www.cobbcounty.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3600&Itemid=1647
[Type 2 Diabetes]<br />
Diabetes increases the risk of death from heart disease or stroke and may indicate an unhealthy lifestyle /<br />
obesity. Community members with diabetes have a higher utilization rate of the health system and are at higher<br />
risk for other health issues. The chronic condition also has a high prevalence rate in our partnering community<br />
safety net clinics and, and according to the CDC, is the leading cause of kidney failure, lower-limb amputations<br />
other than those caused by injury, and new cases of blindness among adults.<br />
Of note, is the upward growth of the prevalence of diabetes in the WellStar service area as compared to the<br />
data in the 2013 Community Health Needs Assessment.<br />
Diabetes Prevalence<br />
% of adults aged 20 and above with<br />
diagnosed diabetes – CHR <strong>2016</strong><br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
10% 9% 9% 12% 9% 11%<br />
Compared to CHR 2013 9% 7% 9% 10% 11%<br />
% of diabetic Medicare enrollees ages 65-<br />
75 that receive HbA1c monitoring (CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
90% 87% 86% 86% 85% 85%<br />
Diabetes is a health challenge of 13.9 percent of community members surveyed which tracks slightly above the<br />
county-level estimates from the National Diabetes Surveillance System estimates using three years of data from<br />
CDC's Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) and data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s Population<br />
Estimates Program.<br />
-Only 26.2 percent said they receive adequate education and care assistance for chronic disease.<br />
57 percent of WellStar Medical Group survey respondents have seen an increase in newly diagnosed patient<br />
with diabetes in the last three years due to diet and lifestyle (obesity and physical inactivity).<br />
- Do you think there are adequate community resources to refer Medicaid or unfunded patient to for<br />
diabetes–related education and services? (WellStar Community Clinic indigent patients – below 125%<br />
FPL – can receive free diabetes education)
No 53.1%<br />
Yes 46.9%<br />
The care and education received by community clinic patients make the difference in behavior modification that<br />
leads to the best, sustainable change and management of their chronic disease: “I’ve been a diabetic for 15<br />
years and when I was insured I went to some good endocrinologists but they didn’t do as good of a job as when I<br />
came here (Bethesda Community Clinic) after I had no insurance and couldn’t afford to go anymore. They<br />
treated me, not just give me a bunch of medicine.”
[Cancer]<br />
Cancer is a health need related to health behaviors, clinical care, physical environment, and genetics. According<br />
to the Georgia Department of Public Health research from the National Centers for Health Statistics, cancers are<br />
the number one leading cause of premature death (before age 75) in Georgia. Related indicators to the<br />
incidence of cancer are tobacco use/secondhand smoke, lack of preventive cancer screenings (promoting the<br />
importance of early detection), poor nutrition, physical inactivity, air quality, and alcohol consumption.<br />
(GHPC county data) Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA US<br />
Cancer Mortality 190 157.1 151 174.3 173.1 171.3 168.9<br />
Incidence rate per 100,000:<br />
Breast Cancer<br />
119.9 126.8 132.4 121.3 118.2 123.5 123<br />
Cervical Cancer 7.7 8 6.6 7.7 6.5 8 7.7<br />
Colon and Rectum Cancer 55.8 34.7 40.2 46.4 43.8 42.3 41.9<br />
In 2013, 22 percent of Georgians died from cancer. Lung cancer is the most deadly type of cancer and is a<br />
leading cause of death in all the counties WellStar serves.<br />
(GHPC county data) Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding Georgia U.S.<br />
Lung cancer incidence (1) 95.6 76 59.6 78 80.4 68.8 63.7<br />
Adult Smoking (2) CHR <strong>2016</strong> 17% 14% 14% 17% 15% 16% -<br />
Air Quality – Particulate<br />
Matter 2.5 (3)<br />
3.30 2.48 3.48 3.70 2.86 2.31 1.19<br />
(1) Reports the age adjusted incidence rate (cases per 100,000 population per year) of colon and rectum cancer.<br />
(2) The percentage of adults age 18 and older who self-report currently smoking cigarettes some days or every day. This indicator is relevant<br />
because tobacco use is linked to leading causes of death such as cancer and cardiovascular disease.<br />
(3) Reports the percentage of days with particulate matter 2.5 levels above the National Ambient Air Quality Standard (35 micrograms per cubic<br />
meter) per year. The indicator is relevant because poor air quality contributes to respiratory issues and overall poor health, and is associated<br />
with the health impacts of climate change.<br />
4.3 percent of the community survey respondents (447) said cancer was a health challenge they face.
WellStar Health System Cancer Cases
[Tobacco Use]<br />
Each year approximately 443,000 premature deaths can be attributed to smoking. Cigarette smoking is<br />
identified as a cause of various cancers, cardiovascular disease, and respiratory conditions, as well as low<br />
birthweight and other adverse health outcomes. Measuring the prevalence of tobacco use in the population can<br />
alert communities to potential adverse health outcomes and can be valuable for assessing the need for<br />
cessation programs or the effectiveness of existing programs.<br />
% of adult smokers<br />
<strong>2016</strong> CHR<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding Georgia HP 2020<br />
17% ↓ 14% ↓ 14% ↓ 17% ↑ 15% ↓ 16% ↓ 12%<br />
CHR 2013 24% 18% 15% 13% 20% 19%<br />
No viable statistics could be found measuring the growing rate of adolescents, teenagers and young adults using<br />
e-cigarettes / vapor. 17<br />
Even though number of smokers has slightly decreased in all counties except Douglas, residents in high-need<br />
areas and community clinic patients noted tobacco use as a concern with a high awareness of tobacco’s overall<br />
effects on health.<br />
- “On the cigarette boxes it says if you smoke that causes cancer. I mean it’s written right there so<br />
everyone knows, but they do it anyway.”<br />
- “We always want the thing we’re not supposed to have. If they said cigarettes were good for us we<br />
wouldn’t want them.”<br />
Among Hispanics, smoking is perceived as part of the American culture, not theirs, and it is a perceived way for<br />
younger people to assimilate.<br />
The WellStar Medical Group survey respondents’ concern level of tobacco use is almost equally divided between<br />
a high concern at 39.6 percent and medium (37.7 percent). (Securing a baseline for the number of WellStar<br />
smokers is not a reportable field in WellStar Connect.)<br />
Of the self-reported smokers of the community surveyed, 47.4 percent said they stopped smoking for a day or<br />
longer because they were trying to quit, but 80 percent said they did not get help via prescribed medication or<br />
nicotine patches. This supports the need for clinical intervention.<br />
17 Electronic cigarettes and similar electronic nicotine delivery devices have not been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration<br />
as tobacco cessation devices. The only current safe and effective tools to quit nicotine and tobacco products are approved nicotine<br />
replacement therapy products, which contain controlled doses of nicotine.
[COPD/Asthma]<br />
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a top five leading cause of death in WellStar communities and<br />
is commonly caused by tobacco use, physical environment (air pollution/climate change), genetics, and asthma.<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding<br />
#1 Heart disease Heart disease Heart disease Lung cancer Lung cancer<br />
#2 Lung cancer Lung cancer Mental &<br />
behavioral<br />
Heart disease Heart disease<br />
#3 All COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Mental &<br />
behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
#4 Stroke All COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
disorders<br />
Lung cancer<br />
Mental &<br />
behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
All COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Stroke Stroke Hypertension &<br />
hypertensive renal<br />
and heart disease<br />
#5 Mental &<br />
behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
Stroke<br />
COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Mental &<br />
behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
Georgia Department of Public Health, OASIS – Age-Adjusted Death Rate, Last 5-Year Aggregate, 2010-2014 <strong>CHNA</strong> Dashboard.<br />
Asthma – Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disorder of the airways that is triggered by things including<br />
allergens, air pollution, smoke from cigarettes, exercise, and viral upper respiratory infections. Untreated<br />
asthma can permanently change the shape of the airways and reduce lung function possibly raising the risk of<br />
COPD later in life.<br />
Asthma Prevalence<br />
(adults over 18 who report they<br />
have asthma)<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
10% 15.40% 11.70% 12.80% 13.40% 13.50%<br />
Related health indicator: 0% 0% 0.27% 0.55% 0.49% 0.20%<br />
Air Quality Ozone 18<br />
Tobacco Use (CHR <strong>2016</strong>) 17% 14% 14% 17% 15% 16%<br />
One of the Georgia Department of Public Health’s (GDPH) strategic goals is by 2019 to eliminate all pediatric<br />
asthma deaths in Georgia. (GDPH Strategic Plan - 8/5/15)<br />
The importance of preventive care, smoking cessation interventions and access to care was exemplified by a<br />
community clinic patient: “I have COPD. I had an attack and they put me in the hospital for almost a week.<br />
They sent me to a pulmonologist and she made it sound like it was a death sentence because it was going to be<br />
so expensive for my treatment. I wished I would just go ahead and die.”<br />
18 This indicator reports the percentage of days per year with Ozone (O3) levels above the National Ambient Air Quality Standard of 75<br />
parts per billion (ppb). Figures are calculated using data collected by monitoring stations and modeled to include census tracts where no<br />
monitoring stations exist. This indicator is relevant because poor air quality contributes to respiratory health issues, including asthma<br />
prevalence and asthma hospitalizations, overall poor health, and community vulnerability to climate change.
[Cardiovascular Disease]<br />
Cardiovascular disease (CVD) remains a top leading cause of death in all the communities WellStar serves. In<br />
Georgia, the death rate is six percent higher than the national average. It is the second leading cause of<br />
preventable death (before age 75) in Georgia and contributes to 29 percent of deaths each year due to:<br />
Ischemic heart disease (46.2%)<br />
Hypertensive heart disease (9%)<br />
Other heart disease (44.7%)<br />
Preventive measures can be taken through diet and exercise which are known to be lacking among most<br />
residents, especially the most vulnerable. They have limited resources and/or healthcare access to self-manage<br />
their chronic disease(s), lack good nutrition and exercise habits.<br />
Clinical care also has an impact on heart health. A lack of management of diabetes, high cholesterol and<br />
hypertension (high blood pressure) is a related health indictor for CVD. 19 Of note is the 32 percent of Paulding<br />
County adults age 18 and older who self-report that they are not taking medication for their high blood<br />
pressure. This indicator is relevant because engaging in preventive behaviors decreases the likelihood of<br />
developing future health problems. When considered with other indicators of poor health, this indicator can<br />
also highlight a lack of access to preventive care, a lack of health knowledge, insufficient provider outreach,<br />
and/or social barriers preventing utilization of services.<br />
Leading Causes of Death in WellStar Communities<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding<br />
#1 Heart disease Heart disease Heart disease Lung cancer Lung cancer<br />
#2 Lung cancer Lung cancer Mental & behavioral<br />
Heart disease<br />
Heart disease<br />
disorders<br />
Georgia Department of Public Health, OASIS – Age-Adjusted Death Rate, Last 5-Year Aggregate, 2010-2014 <strong>CHNA</strong> Dashboard.<br />
GHPC data Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
% of adults over 18 who have ever 7.8% 7.5% 2.6% 5.7% 4.7% 4.4%<br />
kind of heart disease 20<br />
been told by a doctor they have any<br />
Mortality rate for ischemic heart<br />
disease 21 85.7 65.3 55.4 60 63.1 85.9<br />
19 According to the CDC, about half of US adults (47 percent) in the United States have at least one of the following major risk factors for<br />
heart disease or stroke: uncontrolled high blood pressure, uncontrolled high LDL cholesterol, or are current smokers. Ninety percent of<br />
Americans consume too much sodium, increasing their risk of high blood pressure.<br />
20 This indicator reports the percentage of adults who have ever been told by a doctor that they have any kind of heart disease. This<br />
indicator is relevant because coronary heart disease is a leading cause of death in the US and is also related to high blood pressure, high<br />
cholesterol, and heart attacks.<br />
21 This indicator reports the rate of death due to coronary heart disease per 100,000 population, age-adjusted to year 2000 standard.<br />
This indicator is relevant because heart disease is a leading cause of death in the U.S.
WellStar Medical Group survey respondents: Do you think there are adequate community resources to refer<br />
your Medicaid or unfunded patients to for cardiovascular and/or respiratory services?<br />
No 48.5%<br />
Yes 51.5%<br />
The mortality rate in Cobb County for ischemic heart disease for non-Hispanic whites is above the benchmark.<br />
There are significant race/ethnic group disparities: Blacks, Hispanic, Native Hawaiian, Native American were<br />
poor performers against the benchmark using health indicators 1) living in poverty (below 100 FPL), 2) education<br />
attainment and 3) uninsured.<br />
Percent of Discharges by Cause by Census Tract of WellStar Counties. High Blood<br />
Pressure, Hypertensive Heart Disease, Obstructive Heart Disease (incl. Heart Attack).<br />
2010-2014.<br />
In Georgia, the one of every six healthcare dollar spent on CVD in the U.S. equates to $6.1 billion spent<br />
statewide on total hospital charges with the average charge per CVD-related hospitalization in Georgia being<br />
$45,744.
[Stroke]<br />
Stroke remains as a top five leading cause of death in the communities WellStar serves in those residents<br />
primarily 55 years of age and older. According to the GDPH, strokes accounted for 17.4 percent of all<br />
cardiovascular disease deaths in Georgia. Lifestyle risk factors include obesity, physical inactivity, heavy drinking<br />
and illicit drug use. Diabetes, tobacco use, high blood pressure, and cardiovascular disease are medical risk<br />
factors that could lead to stroke.<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding<br />
#1 Heart disease Heart disease Heart disease Lung cancer Lung cancer<br />
Heart disease Heart disease<br />
#2 Lung cancer Lung cancer Mental & behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
#3 All COPD (except Mental & behavioral Lung cancer<br />
asthma)<br />
disorders<br />
#4 Stroke All COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Mental & behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
All COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Stroke Stroke Hypertension &<br />
hypertensive renal<br />
and heart disease<br />
#5 Mental & behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
Stroke<br />
COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
COPD (except<br />
asthma)<br />
Georgia Department of Public Health, OASIS – Age-Adjusted Death Rate, Last 5-Year Aggregate, 2010-2014 <strong>CHNA</strong> Dashboard.<br />
Mental & behavioral<br />
disorders<br />
GHPC data Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
Benchmark<br />
Stroke Mortality Rate 54 35.3 36.5 49.5 37 43.7<br />
This indicator reports the rate of death due to cerebrovascular disease (stroke) per 100,000 population, age-adjusted to year 2000<br />
standard. This indicator is relevant because strokes are a leading cause of death in the U.S. Kaiser Portal
[Obesity]<br />
The WellStar service area is below the benchmark in core indicators of a healthy weight including low<br />
fruit/vegetable consumption and the presence of food deserts signifying a lack of access to grocery stores.<br />
These are related health indicators to obesity.<br />
Obesity (a Body Mass Index or BMI > 30) is often the result of an overall energy imbalance due to poor diet and<br />
limited physical activity. It increases the risk for poor health status and many health conditions including<br />
coronary heart disease, type 2 diabetes, cancer, hypertension, dyslipidemia, stroke, osteoarthritis, sleep apnea,<br />
liver and gallbladder disease, and respiratory problems.<br />
Adult Obesity:<br />
Percentage of adults that report<br />
a BMI of 30 or more (CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
Overall in<br />
Georgia<br />
Healthy<br />
People<br />
2020 Target<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding<br />
34% 26% 22% 34% 28% 29% 30.5%<br />
The concern level about the obesity epidemic in WellStar communities is high at 76 percent among WellStar<br />
Medical Group (WMG) respondents as it relates to significant chronic disease issues including diabetes, heart<br />
disease and stroke.<br />
- 52.8 percent don’t think there are adequate and affordable community resources to refer patients to<br />
for obesity-related / healthy lifestyle education.<br />
- Have you seen an increase in patients who are overweight or obese in the last three years?<br />
No 14.1%<br />
Yes 85.9%<br />
Obesity may present from adverse socioeconomic situations that may affect self-esteem, stress levels and the<br />
ability to cope causing emotional eating. A CarePlace community clinic patient in Douglas County remarked, “All<br />
I have to do is eat and sit there and feel sorry for myself.” Another patient at Bethesda “…got depressed and put<br />
on 40 pounds.”<br />
Being overweight/obese was a health challenge of 40.9 percent of the community surveyed (447), 66 percent of<br />
all respondents were self-aware of their need to lose weight.
[Substance Abuse]<br />
Alcohol and drug (illegal and prescription) abuse is commonly driven by mental health issues and socioeconomic<br />
factors, although the recent boom of opioid/heroin use in WellStar communities is affecting middle and upper<br />
class teenager and young adults.<br />
ILLEGAL DRUGS:<br />
The CDC reports death from heroin overdose in all age groups doubled in the United States from 2010-2012.<br />
- The Georgia Bureau of Investigation Crime Lab has seen an increase of 300 percent of samples of seized<br />
heroin between 2011 and 2014. WSB-TV, 1/14/16.<br />
According to the New York Times, the drug overdose death rate for whites ages 25-34 in 2014 was five times the<br />
level in 1999 and the rate for 35-44 whites tripled during that period. The numbers cover both illegal and<br />
prescription drugs.<br />
59.4 percent of WellStar Medical Group (WMG) survey respondents said they don’t think there is adequate<br />
education available within our community concerning the risk of binge drinking, substance and tobacco use.<br />
WMG provider concern levels for substance abuse (drugs/alcohol):<br />
Low 16.2%<br />
High 37.4%<br />
Medium 46.5%<br />
As it relates to low education attainment – a key determinant of health - a community safety net clinic patient<br />
who dropped out of high school explains: “My family never had a lot of money so a lot of times people feel<br />
stuck. (They think) I can work this fast food job all my life and do nothing or I can sell drugs and make a whole<br />
lot more money.”<br />
- Need for awareness education in the schools. “They showed us in school how to make skirts and cook,<br />
but didn’t tell us anything about smoking and doing drugs and what it can do to you.” – Bartow resident<br />
- Need for medication monitoring. “I got addicted to painkillers prescribed my doctors. They didn’t tell<br />
me there was an alternative drug to take without narcotics in it.” - Bethesda patient in Cherokee<br />
- Need for law enforcement. “Meth is a problem out here.” – CarePlace patient in Douglas<br />
o A Cherokee resident in a high need area remarked kids are soaking gummy bears in alcohol and<br />
selling them at school. At WSB radio report in 2011 confirmed the story’s validity.
o<br />
A Good Sam patient noted the presence of drug dealers around her neighborhood school and<br />
knows a young boy who got addicted from drugs obtained at a neighborhood park.<br />
Drug overdose<br />
deaths 22 (CHR<br />
<strong>2016</strong>)<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
15 14 14 11 17 11<br />
ALCOHOL:<br />
GA Student Health Survey Data<br />
(% 12 th ) (2015) Paulding Bartow Cherokee Georgia<br />
Alcohol Use, past 30 days (≥1<br />
day(s) of use) 21 24.40% 26.70% 29.00% 22.20%<br />
From Cobb Douglas Public Health<br />
16 percent of Cherokee and Cobb county adults report excessive alcohol consumption 23 slightly higher than the<br />
state average of 14 percent. Binge drinking is a risk factor for a number of adverse health outcomes such as<br />
alcohol poisoning, hypertension, heart attack, sexually transmitted infections, unintended pregnancy, fetal<br />
alcohol syndrome, sudden infant death syndrome, suicide, interpersonal violence, and motor vehicle crashes.<br />
- Also, the percentage of driving deaths with alcohol involvement is higher in Cobb (26 percent) and<br />
Douglas (28 percent) counties than the state (24 percent).<br />
22 Drug Overdose Deaths are the number of deaths due to drug poisoning per 100,000 population. ICD-10 codes used include X40-X44,<br />
X60-X64, X85, and Y10-Y14. These codes used cover accidental, intentional, and of undetermined poisoning by and exposure to: 1) nonopioid<br />
analgesics, antipyretics and antirheumatics, 2) antiepileptic, sedative-hypnotic, antiparkinsonism and psychotropic drugs, not<br />
elsewhere classified, 3) narcotics and psychodysleptics [hallucinogens], not elsewhere classified, 4) other drugs acting on the autonomic<br />
nervous system, and 5) other and unspecified drugs, medicaments and biological substances.<br />
23 Excessive Drinking is the percentage of adults that report either binge drinking, defined as consuming more than 4 (women) or 5 (men)<br />
alcoholic beverages on a single occasion in the past 30 days, or heavy drinking, defined as drinking more than one (women) or 2 (men)<br />
drinks per day on average.
[Preventive Cancer Screenings]<br />
Preventive screenings allow for early detection and treatment and help decrease cancer mortality and chronic<br />
disease. This indicator of health can also highlight a lack of access to preventive care, a lack of health<br />
knowledge, insufficient provider outreach, and/or social barriers preventing utilization of services.<br />
Cancer<br />
Screenings Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA US HP 2020<br />
Mammogram 24 63% 64% 64% 58% 63% 62% 63%<br />
(CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
Pap Test 78.30% 84.70% 85.30% 81.80% 80.70% 82.70% 78.50%<br />
Colonoscopy 61.20% 68.20% 66.50% 60.90% 59.90% 62.40% 61.30% 70.5%<br />
GHPC county level data<br />
45 percent of WellStar Medical Group survey respondents said their concern level for clinical preventive cancer<br />
screenings is high, medium (29.4 percent) and low (25.5 percent). 87.9 percent believe patients have<br />
reasonable access to care and/or education regarding the screenings.<br />
Hispanics in listening sessions and focus groups are aware of the preventive screenings. When it’s a good<br />
service at an affordable cost, they are willing to pay. Paulding Health Department patients want more<br />
affordable screening services in the count, as cost is a monumental barrier to getting preventive care.<br />
Of the age-appropriate community survey respondents, 47.7 percent said they are diligent about getting<br />
preventive screenings. In the past 12 months:<br />
- 10.7 percent got a colonoscopy<br />
- Two percent got a lung cancer screening<br />
- 45.3 percent of men have not had a prostate cancer screening in past 12 months because it’s not<br />
affordable or it’s not indicated.<br />
- 70 percent of women got a breast cancer screening mammogram. The remaining 30 percent of women<br />
who did not get a mammogram cited the following reasons:<br />
24 Percentage of female Medicare enrollees ages 67-69 that receive mammography screening.
The main barrier to preventive cancer screenings for community clinic patients is money:<br />
“I don’t have $300-400 for a colonoscopy.” “If I can’t afford (the screening), why pay the money? Nine times<br />
out of ten you’re going to make the decision that’s going to benefit you right away, not long-term.”<br />
“My challenge is with the need<br />
for screenings to prevent future<br />
medical issues.”
[Men’s Health – Prostate]<br />
Women are the healthcare decision makers. They make approximately 80 percent of the healthcare decisions in<br />
their families. 25 Women take the lead role in choosing health plans, scheduling doctor’s appointments and<br />
making sure their loved ones are getting the care they need. Better health in men comes from equipping<br />
women with the tools and information they need.<br />
To most of WellStar’s vulnerable, high-risk residents, the attitude toward preventive healthcare is not negative.<br />
The negativity comes from the lack of resources live well and stay healthy:<br />
- “…They want men to get the prostate checked yearly and they’re wondering why they don’t. They are<br />
providers of the home and they have to take care of everybody else before they get taken of. If you<br />
have a $100 and five kids, then you’re out.”<br />
- There’s a high prevalence of depression in men leading to areas where there race disparities of reckless<br />
behavior (violence, STDs and suicide).<br />
A nurse at Bethesda Community Clinic admits they do better with women than men. She suggested flagging<br />
charts to get exams scheduled with male patients.<br />
Age-appropriate male respondents to the online community survey question, “Have you had a prostate cancer<br />
screening (PSA test) in the past 12 months?<br />
25 U.S. Department of Labor. General Facts on Women and Job Based Health. Retrieved 10 July 2013, from<br />
www.dol.gov/ebsa/newsroom/fshlth5.html
The reasons men did not get a prostate cancer screening include:
[Physical Inactivity]<br />
Lack of time and motivation are the biggest reasons people don’t exercise. A barrier to physical activity in adults<br />
is their long commute times in Metro Atlanta for WellStar community members.<br />
Physical Inactivity (Percentage of adults aged<br />
20 and over reporting no leisure-time physical<br />
activity)<br />
Factors:<br />
Drive Alone, more than 30 minutes<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
27% 22% 18% 26% 26% 25%<br />
38% 53% 48% 54% 64% 39%<br />
Commute over 60 minutes 10.83% 14.60% 9.77% 13.62% 21.37% 8.97%<br />
Park Access (% of population living within 0.5 1.41% 6.42% 23.96% 12.52% 3.32% 13.39%<br />
mile from a park)<br />
County Health Rankings <strong>2016</strong> and GHPC portal<br />
Although 47 percent of community online survey respondents (447) said they exercise a minimum of three times<br />
per week, 36 percent said they are too busy to exercise on a regular basis followed by “don’t like to exercise” (19<br />
percent) and “my neighborhood” (15 percent) due to safety issues, lack of sidewalks, etc.<br />
Lack of money for gym memberships, motivation, unsafe neighborhoods, recreation areas, sidewalks, and time<br />
were themes of the listening sessions and focus groups in high-risk areas and community clinics:<br />
- “Work and family responsibilities consume too much time.”<br />
- A Paulding resident said “there’s no safe place to exercise.”<br />
- Astutely noted: “People think their busyness is enough, but it isn’t. They aren’t focused on how<br />
exercise affects diabetes, blood pressure – all those things play together.”<br />
The Hispanic community is willing to learn healthy habits but lack of transportation, sidewalks and access to the<br />
gym prevents their community from exercising.
[Poor Nutrition]<br />
There is strong evidence that residing in a food desert is correlated with a high prevalence of overweight/<br />
obesity, chronic disease and premature death.<br />
The Food Environment Index ranges<br />
from 0 (worst) to 10 (best) and<br />
equally weights two indicators of the<br />
food environment.<br />
Food environment index 26<br />
(CHR <strong>2016</strong>)<br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
6.6 8.1 7.1 6.3 7.7 6.5<br />
Although related indicators include consumption of fruits and vegetables, diabetes incidence and mental health<br />
issues (depression), the biggest barriers to healthy eating for vulnerable populations is cost and lack of<br />
motivation.<br />
- “I have to walk to the food pantry to get something to eat.”<br />
- “It costs less to eat off the dollar menu than to buy a salad.”<br />
- “…Depression and anxiety leads to you want to eat yourself to death.”<br />
- “The most expensive aisle in Kroger is the healthy aisle.”<br />
- “We (Blacks) were never taught to read labels.”<br />
Hispanics are in need of education about the healthy ingredients they can find in in their new culture and how to<br />
cook and adapt those foods to their needs/likes.<br />
34 percent of the online community survey respondents (447) reported they eat at least five serving of fruits<br />
and vegetables each day, yet 27 percent eat fast food more than once a week.<br />
- The general community cites the following reasons they don’t eat well sometimes with time and<br />
temptation as the biggest triggers:<br />
26 1) Limited access to healthy foods estimates the percentage of the population who are low income and do not live close to a grocery<br />
store (“food desert”). Living close to a grocery store is defined differently in rural and non-rural areas; in rural areas, it means living less<br />
than 10 miles from a grocery store whereas in non-rural areas, it means less than 1 mile. Low income is defined as having an annual<br />
family income of less than or equal to 200 percent of the federal poverty threshold for the family size.<br />
2) Food insecurity estimates the percentage of the population who did not have access to a reliable source of food during the past year. A<br />
2-stage fixed effect model was created using information from the Community Population Survey, Bureau of Labor Statistics, and<br />
American Community Survey.
WellStar Medical Group survey respondents to the question: Do patients have reasonable access to care<br />
and/or education? -Obesity/Nutrition/Physical Activity said:<br />
No 42%<br />
Yes 58%
[Sexually Transmitted Diseases]<br />
HIV/AIDS, syphilis and other infectious, sexually-transmitted diseases (STDs) were noted as a significant health<br />
need in Cobb and Paulding counties from public health and key informants due to unsafe sex practices. Notable<br />
is Cobb and Douglas counties’ high prevalence of chlamydia, the most common STD in the United States, which<br />
often doesn’t present with symptoms and is treatable with antibiotics.<br />
GHPC data Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
STD – Chlamydia Prevalence 27 282.8 197 402.8 518.2 204.1 534<br />
HIV/STD/ Health Disparity: Higher<br />
prevalence in this population<br />
STD – HIV Prevalence<br />
NO HIV Screening – related clinical<br />
care health indicator<br />
Non-Hispanic Black<br />
189.5 142.6 301 150.5 36.8 428.8<br />
57.45% 60.87% 55.14% 51.13% 57.97% 55.12%<br />
27 This indicator reports incidence rate of chlamydia cases per 100,000 population. This indicator is relevant because it is a measure of<br />
poor health status and indicates the prevalence of unsafe sex practices.
[Violence]<br />
The quantitative data surrounding violent crime in WellStar communities tracks below the Georgia benchmark,<br />
but it remains an area of concern from residents desiring safe communities, especially among low-income<br />
residents and counties with a higher rate of crime - Bartow, Cobb and Douglas.<br />
36.5 percent of the community surveyed believes in the next five years their community will become a worse<br />
place to live. Many cite crime and demographic shifts for the lack of optimism.<br />
Residents from high-risk areas and community clinic patients echo the sentiment. “I have lived in Douglas<br />
County for 43 years and it has already changed for the worse with crime and violence.<br />
- Douglas Care Place patients attribute the violence to anxiety. “You get turned down and pushed away.<br />
What do they have to resort to? They don’t know what to do. They lose hope and start striking out.<br />
Oh my God, it’s right where we live.”<br />
- “People want to get out of their neighborhood. I, for one, do. They got to jail, get out and do the same<br />
thing – it’s all they know. There needs to be more education than just locking them up.”<br />
Not only can violent crime compromise physical safety and psychological well-being, it can deter residents from<br />
pursuing healthy behaviors. Increased stress may exacerbate other health needs including hypertension and<br />
other stress-related disorders and may contribute to an inactive lifestyle leading to obesity.<br />
Rate of violent crime offenses<br />
reported by law enforcement per<br />
100,000 residents<br />
(includes homicide, rape, robbery, and<br />
aggravated assault) - CHR <strong>2016</strong><br />
Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA US<br />
360 100 264 289 144 385 395.5<br />
The WellStar Medical Group survey respondents’ level of concern regarding injury and violence is low (45.2<br />
percent), medium (41.4 percent) and high (13.5 percent). Although they treat injuries from violence, this could<br />
be attributed to the inability of health providers to inform change and lead interventions in this area.<br />
- 72.2 percent believe patients have reasonable access to care and/or education regarding injury and<br />
violence.<br />
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE:<br />
The high rate of family violence in the Hispanic community was noted by a Bethesda care provider (“we have a<br />
lot of family abuse patient from Cherokee County Violence Center). The data is backed up by research<br />
independently conducted by Ser Familia as well as listening session participants.
[Suicide]<br />
Suicide is related to poor mental health. It is a documented concern among the Hispanic/Latino population, yet<br />
is most prevalent among non-Hispanic whites in all the communities WellStar serves and exceedingly high in<br />
Cherokee County.<br />
GHPC data Bartow Cherokee Cobb Douglas Paulding GA<br />
Mortality – Suicide 28<br />
16.7 12.5 10 11.9 15.9 11.8<br />
Healthy People 2020 Target: 10.2<br />
Suicide Race/Ethnic<br />
Disparities<br />
19.1<br />
among<br />
non-<br />
Hispanic<br />
whites<br />
14.5<br />
among non-Hispanic whites<br />
13.8<br />
among<br />
non-<br />
Hispanic<br />
whites<br />
Intentional Self Harm cases<br />
significantly higher than<br />
expected in Emergency Room<br />
visits 29 #14 no<br />
rank<br />
17.7<br />
among<br />
non-<br />
Hispanic<br />
whites<br />
no<br />
rank<br />
18.5<br />
among non-<br />
Hispanic<br />
whites<br />
#12<br />
GA Student Health<br />
Survey data (%12 th ) -<br />
2015<br />
Considered suicide<br />
in the past year<br />
Cobb Douglas<br />
Public Health<br />
Paulding<br />
Northwest Health<br />
District 1-1<br />
Bartow<br />
Northwest Health<br />
District 1-1<br />
Cherokee<br />
North Georgia<br />
Health District 1-2<br />
Georgia<br />
8.6% 7.9% 7% 11% 8.5%<br />
28 This indicator reports the rate of death due to intentional self-harm (suicide) per 100,000 population, age-adjusted to the year 2000<br />
standard. This indicator is relevant because suicide is an indicator of poor mental health.<br />
29 OASIS, <strong>CHNA</strong> Dashboard, 2010-2014.
[Health & Wellness Education - Strategy]<br />
Prevention-based health and wellness education as part of overall preventive care helps reduce the risk factors<br />
for approximately half of morbidity and mortality. 30<br />
1. Primary prevention– Avoids health issues by behavior and lifestyle modifications 31<br />
2. Secondary prevention – Provides education and resources for disease management / control<br />
3. Tertiary prevention– Manages complications to avoid unnecessary healthcare<br />
WellStar’s Community Education & Outreach Department is a conduit for outreach and realignment of<br />
community benefit services to help meet priority health needs in communities with health disparities.<br />
Community online survey respondents (447) reported having the following procedures done in the past 12<br />
months. Some of these could reflect the need for more education in the community. Some are age-appropriate and<br />
have a lower response rate due to demographics.<br />
Community clinic patients would like WellStar to better utilize faith-based congregations to educate on health<br />
and wellness topics as “the spiritual aspect of things gives you a better or different perspective of things that can<br />
lead to your physical well-being and it helps you make better choices, too.” – Bethesda patient<br />
- Many clinic patients, who are looking for hope, support and relief from depression due to<br />
socioeconomic factors, look to the church. This is especially true for the Hispanic/Latino community.<br />
- Some would be willing to participate as volunteers at community events/education if the timing and<br />
setting aligned with work and transportation needs.<br />
- “We don’t know how to be healthy, so weekend classes would be welcome.”<br />
- They understand their personal responsibility regarding their health, yet are motivated by empathy and<br />
personal relationships with their caregivers and others. “If (my nurse) was going to care enough for me<br />
30 Despite spending more than twice what most other industrialized nations spend on health care, the U.S. ranks 24th out of 30 such<br />
nations in terms of life expectancy. A major reason for this startling fact is that only 3 percent of our healthcare dollars is spent on<br />
preventing diseases (as opposed to treating them), when 75 percent of our healthcare costs are related to preventable conditions.<br />
31 The World Health Organization estimates that 80 percent of all heart disease, stroke, and Type 2 diabetes, as well as more than 40<br />
percent of cancer, would be prevented if Americans would stop using tobacco, eat healthy and exercise. From the Harvard School of<br />
Public Health slide on the cost of non-communicable diseases.
to hold me accountable, I need to do what I can to educate myself and do what I need to do to be<br />
educated and choose proper foods and exercise.<br />
- No community members at the Paulding Health Department listening session knew about 770-956-<br />
STAR. They suggested a resource list / calendar distributed at the schools so parents will receive.<br />
[Health Need-Specific Community Health<br />
Improvement Programs – Strategy]<br />
Investments in community health improvement programs and services is one of the key community benefit<br />
services sub-categories that can be fortified to target prioritized health needs to make measureable<br />
improvements in community health, including the vulnerable populations along with realignment and vetting of<br />
cash and in-kind contributions.<br />
Many WellStar Medical Group survey respondents cite wellness-focused community outreach and education as<br />
how WellStar can best meet health needs.<br />
- Do you think there are adequate community resources to refer your patient for obesity-related /<br />
healthy lifestyles education?<br />
No, it’s lacking 55%<br />
Yes 45%<br />
Comments from WMG regarding areas of need: Education about how obesity affects chronic conditions, free<br />
nutrition counseling, more affordable diet and exercise programs, resources for information, free physical<br />
activity/nutrition programming, comprehensive/integrated programs
Lack of awareness of free prevention and wellness education and resources is prevalent among vulnerable<br />
populations.<br />
- “Be more present in the community. I’m not aware of any community outreach programs in my area.”<br />
- “(My biggest health challenge is) knowing steps to prevent health problem or correct the health issues<br />
without using medications for everything.”<br />
- “Many people believe that chronic condition just happen to them. Please create program to heighten<br />
awareness of the direct impact of lifestyle on health.”<br />
# # #