You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Theorizing school bullying: insights from Japan<br />
that teacher violence in the form of ‘corporal punishment’ is not<br />
rare in Japanese schools, and that the majority of teachers who<br />
use violence against students do so with impunity. Corporal<br />
punishment operates as institutional violence against students.<br />
Statistics on corporal punishment also give an indication of the<br />
political nature of discourse on school violence. The number of<br />
teachers who were reprimanded for the use of corporal<br />
punishment in the special survey mentioned above was almost 7<br />
times as many as that reported in the official data collected<br />
annually by the Ministry of Education. The Ministry reported<br />
around 400 teachers per year from 2003 to 2011, in contrast to<br />
the 2,752 cited in the special survey 205 . Miller points out that<br />
official statistics, which have been used to record details of<br />
corporal punishment since 1990, ceased to exist in 2004 206 .<br />
Now, the statistics collected annually on corporal punishment<br />
are limited to the number of teachers disciplined, which is only<br />
a fraction of the actual incidence as seen above. Miller argues<br />
that the status of corporal punishment as a ‘problem’ has been<br />
marginalized in Japan 207 .<br />
What Miller 208 alludes to in relation to corporal punishment is<br />
the need to look at ‘youth problems’ from a social constructivist<br />
perspective which focuses on the process of how a particular<br />
issue comes to be problematized 209 . With regard to student-tostudent<br />
bullying in Japan, Toivonen and Imoto demonstrated<br />
how its discourse ‘has been linked to powerful actors in<br />
educational reform agendas as well as to a new ‘industry’ of<br />
205 Hirai, 2013 <br />
206<br />
Miller, 2012 <br />
207<br />
Miller, 2012:89. <br />
208<br />
Miller, 2012 <br />
209<br />
Goodman et al., 2012<br />
131