02.12.2016 Views

(Part 1)

JBTM_13-2_Fall_2016

JBTM_13-2_Fall_2016

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

JBTM Book Reviews<br />

119<br />

One of the weaknesses of the volume was the inconsistent assessment of the imputation<br />

of sin. For example, Macleod’s chapter presents two Reformed views of imputation in<br />

the Reformed tradition, the mediate view (inherited corruption which later results in guilt)<br />

and the immediate view (inherited guilt) (139–41). Contributors such as Yarborough and<br />

Hamilton speak of the inheritance from Adam in terms of sin, death, and corruption, and<br />

their chapters are consistent with the mediate view. However, Madueme locates the denial<br />

of inherited guilt with Pelagius (226). Also, Schreiner argues against both the interpretations<br />

of both Pelagius and Blocher’s mediate view of imputation (275–78). A reader might<br />

infer from the views of Madueme and Schreiner that one must explicitly affirm inherited<br />

guilt. However, Yarborough and Hamilton do not affirm inherited guilt in their biblicaltheological<br />

treatments of original sin. It seems that the Reformed tradition remains unclear<br />

on whether one must explicitly affirm inherited, or alien, guilt.<br />

Another weakness of the book was the insertion of human inability when discussing<br />

human sinfulness (253). One can affirm the universal sinfulness of humanity while rejecting<br />

the extreme positions of both human goodness and human inability. Finally, neither<br />

the title nor the subtitle reflect the organization of the material in the book. Presently,<br />

the book promises by its title to address Adam, the fall, and original sin. In the subtitle, it<br />

promises to address theological, biblical, and scientific perspectives. However, the major<br />

parts of the book deal with “Adam in the Bible and Science” (part 1), “Original Sin in History”<br />

(part 2), “Original Sin in Theology” (part 3), and “Adam and the Fall in Dispute” (<strong>Part</strong><br />

4). Perhaps in a subsequent edition, book chapters could be reorganized to reflect the order<br />

of topics presented in either the book’s title or its subtitle.<br />

Even with weaknesses noted above, the book should be required reading for all who<br />

desire to consider a comprehensive case for a historical Adam, his fall, and the doctrine<br />

known as original sin.<br />

- Adam Harwood, New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary, New Orleans, Louisiana<br />

Advances in the Study of Greek: New Insights for Reading the New Testament. By Constantine<br />

R. Campbell. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2015. 253 pages. Paperback, $34.99.<br />

Constantine R. Campbell is associate professor of New Testament at Trinity Evangelical<br />

Divinity School in Deerfield, Illinois, where he has served on faculty since 2013. He previously<br />

served as a senior lecturer in Greek and New Testament at Moore Theological College<br />

in Sydney, Australia. Campbell received a PhD from Macquarie University and is the<br />

author of several books including Basics of Verbal Aspect in Biblical Greek, Keep Your Greek:<br />

Strategies for Busy People, and Paul and Union with Christ: An Exegetical and Theological Study.<br />

His most recent work is Colossians and Philemon: A Handbook on the Greek Text.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!