BusinessDay 06 April 2018
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
4 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Friday <strong>06</strong> <strong>April</strong> <strong>2018</strong><br />
NEWS<br />
Lassa fever hits 20 states with 142<br />
deaths, 400 confirmed cases<br />
… NCDC confirms first case, fatality in Abia<br />
... Two health workers affected with one death in a week<br />
ANTHONIA OBOKOH<br />
Lassa fever has continued<br />
to spread in<br />
Nigeria with 400 confirmed<br />
cases and 142<br />
deaths in 20 states,<br />
according to latest figures released<br />
yesterday by the Nigeria<br />
Centre for Disease Control<br />
(NCDC).<br />
According to the agency, following<br />
the increasing number of<br />
Lassa fever cases in the reporting<br />
week 14, six new confirmed<br />
cases were recorded from five<br />
States while two new healthcare<br />
workers were affected with one<br />
death and twenty-five health<br />
care workers have been affected<br />
since the onset of the outbreak<br />
in eight states.<br />
“From 1st January to 1st <strong>April</strong><br />
<strong>2018</strong>, a total of 17<strong>06</strong> suspected<br />
cases and 142 deaths have been<br />
reported actively in Edo, Ondo,<br />
Bauchi, Nasarawa, Ebonyi,<br />
Anambra, Benue, Kogi, Imo,<br />
Plateau, Lagos, Taraba, Delta,<br />
Osun, Rivers, FCT, Gombe, Ekiti,<br />
Kaduna and Abia makig twenty<br />
states at least one confirmed<br />
case across 57 Local Government<br />
Areas,” says the report.<br />
“This year 81 per cent of all<br />
confirmed cases are from Edo<br />
(42%) Ondo (23%) and Ebonyi<br />
(16%) states.”<br />
Lassa fever is an acute viral<br />
haemorrhagic illness, transmitted<br />
to humans through contact<br />
with food or household items<br />
contaminated by infected rodents.<br />
Person-to-person transmission<br />
can also occur, particularly<br />
in hospital environment in<br />
the absence of adequate infection<br />
control measures.<br />
The agency further stated<br />
that since the onset of the <strong>2018</strong>,<br />
4,274 contacts have been identified<br />
from 20 states and of these,<br />
662 (15.0 per cent) are currently<br />
being followed up, 3,605 (84.8<br />
per cent) have completed 21<br />
days follow up while 7(0.2 per<br />
cent) were lost in follow up. 27<br />
(40 per cent) of the 67 contacts<br />
have tested positive in five states<br />
(Edo-12, Ondo- seven, Ebonyithree,<br />
Kogi -3 and Bauchi -one).<br />
“World Health Organisation<br />
(WHO) and NCDC have scaled<br />
up response at national and<br />
state levels,” it added.<br />
9Mobile sale: NCC chairman’s letter to...<br />
Continued from page 1<br />
significantly more than the $300<br />
million submitted by Smile Communications,<br />
which was in turn<br />
announced as the reserve bidder.<br />
Teleology was then asked to<br />
make a non-refundable deposit<br />
of $50 million within 21 days from<br />
the announcement. This payment<br />
was made and acknowledged by<br />
United Capital Trustees in a letter<br />
dated 21st March <strong>2018</strong>. The payment<br />
was made two days earlier<br />
than the deadline, and failure to<br />
make this payment would have<br />
meant that Smile, the reserve<br />
bidder, would have been invited<br />
to replace Teleology.<br />
Teleology and United Capital<br />
Trustees signed the Share<br />
Purchase Agreement (SPA) and<br />
Loan Purchase Agreement (LPA)<br />
on 21st March <strong>2018</strong>. The CBN<br />
and NCC were present at the ceremony,<br />
our sources say.<br />
However, <strong>BusinessDay</strong> learnt<br />
from sources watching the sale<br />
process that the letter from the<br />
Chairman of NCC’s board suggests<br />
or implies that; “NCC will<br />
only approve the transaction if<br />
the company has telecom infrastructure<br />
on the ground - in other<br />
words, if the company is an existing<br />
operator.”<br />
As a result, issues were raised<br />
suggesting that the regulator may<br />
be sneakily trying to disqualify<br />
Teleology and unethically bring<br />
Smile in as the preferred bidder<br />
through a back door. This is especially<br />
as no such criteria were<br />
included in the start of the bidding<br />
process until this time.<br />
According to <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
sources, “NCC and CBN were<br />
constantly updated on the whole<br />
process and had the opportunity<br />
to raise any objections if any. No<br />
such objection was raised by the<br />
NCC at any time.”<br />
Nigeria’s telecommunications<br />
sector remains mired in recession<br />
with the ICT sector contracting<br />
by -1.5 percent in Q4, 2017, up<br />
from the -4.5 percent contraction<br />
recorded in Q3, 2017, according to<br />
the most recent National Bureau<br />
of Statistics (NBS), data.<br />
Total number of active mobile<br />
phone subscribers fell by<br />
5.3 percent in the past year from<br />
155.113 million in January 2017,<br />
to 142 million active subscribers<br />
in January <strong>2018</strong>, according to the<br />
most recent NCC data.<br />
Analysts tell <strong>BusinessDay</strong> that<br />
the NCC Chairman’s letter is like<br />
trying to create a new goal post at<br />
the end of a match, and is similar<br />
to how Nigeria procrastinated<br />
with the NITEL sale until it had<br />
lost most of its value, by the time<br />
it was sold.<br />
“Why change the rules in the<br />
middle of the game, that is inappropriate,”<br />
Bismarck Rewane,<br />
CEO of Fianancial Derivatives told<br />
<strong>BusinessDay</strong> on phone.<br />
“It will erode the country’s<br />
credibility and ability to attract foreign<br />
direct investments (FDI) as<br />
such will increase the stereotype<br />
of the bad reputation the country<br />
already has.”<br />
Foreign Direct Investments<br />
into Nigeria slumped to a fouryear<br />
low of $981 million in 2017.<br />
The first decline in FDI since<br />
<strong>BusinessDay</strong> started compiling<br />
data in 2013.<br />
By comparison, Egypt attracted<br />
$8.7 billion in the fiscal year ended<br />
June 2017, while South Africa<br />
attracted $3.2 billion, according<br />
to data from the United Nations<br />
Conference on Trade and Development<br />
(UNCTAD).<br />
Kenya attracted $394 million<br />
in 2016, according to most recent<br />
data by UNCTAD, while Ghana<br />
attracted $4.19 billion of FDI in<br />
2017, according to data by the<br />
Bank of Ghana.<br />
The NCC on its part told <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
that the regulators are<br />
still expecting Teleology’s $450<br />
million balance of its committed<br />
bid (due in 3 months) in-order to<br />
finalise the sale process.<br />
Umar Garba Danbatta, Executive<br />
Vice Chairman of the<br />
NCC told <strong>BusinessDay</strong> yesterday<br />
that there was no cause for<br />
alarm, as the Commission has<br />
been involved in the 9mobile sale<br />
L-R: Ikenna Ikeme, general manager, regulatory affairs, MTN Nigeria; Ladi Barnabas Banka, wife of the deputy governor,<br />
Kaduna State; Danladi Mohammed, director, MTN Foundation, and Cecilia Musa, representing Jema’a Local<br />
Government Area, Kaduna, during the launch of the MTN Foundation, Yellow heart Initiative in Kaduna, yesterday.<br />
process from the onset, and has<br />
clearly identified Teleology as the<br />
preferred bidder.<br />
“Teleology emerged as preferred<br />
bidder and paid the $50<br />
million non-refundable deposit<br />
which was a condition for the process<br />
and that was not contested.<br />
However, Smile Communications<br />
was named reserve bidder, so it is<br />
only in the event that Teleology<br />
fails to pay the balance of $450<br />
million in the next three months,<br />
that is when the offer will go to<br />
the reserve bidder,” Danbatta told<br />
<strong>BusinessDay</strong>.<br />
When asked if the commission<br />
is in anyway inclined to favoring<br />
Smile Communications to allow<br />
for some sort of consolidation,<br />
since the company has technical<br />
infrastructure and expertise<br />
on ground and more than three<br />
years operational history in Nigeria,<br />
which meets up with the new<br />
criteria stated in the Board Chairman’s<br />
letter to the CBN, Danbatta<br />
said the decision for consolidation<br />
is not up to the NCC.<br />
“Consolidation in the industry<br />
will come from the operators<br />
themselves. The NCC will not<br />
stand in the way of the operators<br />
if they want to consolidate. We will<br />
wait, and if it happens then we will<br />
comment on it,” Danbatta said.<br />
Olusola Teniola, President, Association<br />
of Telecommunications<br />
Operators of Nigeria (ATCON)<br />
told <strong>BusinessDay</strong> in a telephone<br />
interview that the process cannot<br />
be concluded until the full payment<br />
of Teleology’s bid commitment<br />
has been received.<br />
“The purchase has to be in full<br />
before we can start talking about<br />
any transfer of shares, and the<br />
regulatory approval for license can<br />
only be done after payment. That<br />
is how it is done everywhere in the<br />
world. A company cannot just be<br />
handed over to another company<br />
for takeover after only a deposit<br />
has been paid. Teleology needs<br />
to balance its initial payment and<br />
also re-assure the NCC that they<br />
can turn around 9mobile.<br />
A regulator would always want<br />
to ensure that the Telco is in<br />
capable hands and that the new<br />
owners will not run down the<br />
company,” Teniola said.<br />
Sources however tell <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
that the final leg in the<br />
process is for the NCC as the telecom<br />
Industry Regulator to give a<br />
formal approval to the transfer of<br />
United Capital Trustees interest<br />
to Teleology. Teleology is then to<br />
make payment of its committed<br />
sum within 90 days and take over<br />
running 9Mobile.<br />
“This new criteria of “technical<br />
expertise” and “at least 3 years<br />
operational history” is strange and<br />
probably an illegal, unethical and<br />
dis-ingenious way to disqualify<br />
Teleology and bring Smile in as<br />
the preferred bidder through a<br />
back door. No such criteria was<br />
included in the bid process until<br />
this time,” an insider with knowledge<br />
of the transaction, speaking<br />
to <strong>BusinessDay</strong> anonymously<br />
because of the sensitivity of the<br />
matter said.<br />
Sources say the CBN Governor<br />
and NCC EVC were constantly<br />
abreast of the 9mobilebid process<br />
with the CBN presenting updates<br />
to the Board of the NCC.<br />
The NCC was also represented<br />
at critical events in the 9mobile<br />
sale process including the stage of<br />
presentation of technical bids and<br />
the final bids held on 4 Dec 2017.<br />
The NCC was present at the<br />
signing of the SPA between Teleology<br />
and United Capital Trustees<br />
and no objection was raised<br />
throughout the process by the<br />
NCC.