14.04.2018 Views

ENERGY Caribbean Yearbook (2013-14)

  • No tags were found...

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

The annual review of the <strong>Caribbean</strong> energy industry<br />

YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong>


YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

Contents<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> energy map 2-3<br />

Section 1: the big issues<br />

World energy outlook 4<br />

Caricom energy policy 1 6<br />

Caricom energy policy 2 7<br />

Energy security 8<br />

The future of gas 9<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> gas market 10<br />

The green agenda 11<br />

Going international 12<br />

Alternative fuels 13<br />

Trinidad & Tobago’s oil revival 1 <strong>14</strong><br />

Trinidad & Tobago’s oil revival 2 15<br />

Cross-border gas 16<br />

Deep water exploration 17<br />

Independents 18<br />

Climate change 19<br />

Local content 20<br />

Gas-based development 21<br />

Section 2: the energy producers<br />

Trinidad and Tobago 22<br />

Suriname 28<br />

Barbados 30<br />

Belize 32<br />

Jamaica 33<br />

Guyana 34<br />

Cuba 35<br />

Section 3: company profiles<br />

Atlantic 36<br />

CIBC First<strong>Caribbean</strong> International Bank 38<br />

Gasfin Development SA 40<br />

Methanex Trinidad 42<br />

The National Gas Company 44<br />

Repsol Trinidad & Tobago 46<br />

Solaris Energy 48<br />

Written by<br />

David Renwick<br />

Editor<br />

Jeremy Taylor<br />

Sales<br />

Denise Chin<br />

Design<br />

Bridget van Dongen<br />

Administration<br />

Joanne Mendes, Jacqueline Smith<br />

Cover photo<br />

Drilling (courtesy Petrotrin)<br />

The <strong>ENERGY</strong> <strong>Caribbean</strong> <strong>Yearbook</strong> is<br />

published annually<br />

by Media & Editorial Projects Ltd.,<br />

6 Prospect Avenue, Maraval,<br />

Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago<br />

Tel: (868) 622-3821<br />

Fax: (868) 628-0639<br />

energy@meppublishers.com<br />

Sales: dchin@meppublishers.com<br />

Distributed free to subscribers of the bimonthly<br />

<strong>ENERGY</strong> <strong>Caribbean</strong> newsletter<br />

Retail price US$25 + p/p<br />

For subscription and retail information<br />

please visit<br />

www.meppublishers.com<br />

or call<br />

(868) 622-3821<br />

© Media & Editorial Projects Ltd. <strong>2013</strong><br />

All rights strictly reserved.<br />

ISSN 1811-1726<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

1


Mississippi R.<br />

Houma<br />

New Orleans<br />

Tallahassee<br />

Orlando<br />

Daytona Beach<br />

USA<br />

Gulf<br />

Miami<br />

of<br />

Nassau<br />

Mexico<br />

Havana<br />

Bahamas<br />

Cuba<br />

Villahermosa<br />

Cayman Islands<br />

Jamaica<br />

Kingston<br />

Ha<br />

Port-au-Prin<br />

Flores<br />

Belize<br />

Tuxtla Gutierrez<br />

C a r i b<br />

Honduras<br />

b e a n<br />

S<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

energy map<br />

Nicaragua<br />

San José<br />

Maraca<br />

Oil or gas field<br />

Costa Rica<br />

Panama<br />

Panama<br />

Refinery<br />

LNG train<br />

Eastern <strong>Caribbean</strong> gas pipeline<br />

English-speaking territory<br />

French-speaking territory<br />

Dutch-speaking territory<br />

Spanish-speaking territory<br />

P a c i f i c<br />

O c e a n<br />

C<br />

2


A t l a n t i c<br />

O c e a n<br />

Haiti<br />

ort-au-Prince<br />

Maracaibo<br />

Dominican<br />

Republic<br />

S e a<br />

Santo Domingo<br />

Aruba<br />

Oranjestad Curaçao<br />

Bonaire<br />

Willemstad<br />

Valencia<br />

San Juan<br />

Puerto Rico<br />

Caracas<br />

Virgin Islands<br />

Philipsburg St Maarten<br />

St Kitts & Nevis Antigua<br />

Basseterre St John<br />

Montserrat<br />

Pointe-á-Pitre<br />

Guadeloupe<br />

Roseau Dominica<br />

Fort-de-France Martinique<br />

Castries<br />

St Lucia<br />

St Vincent &<br />

the Grenadines<br />

Barbados<br />

Kingstown Bridgetown<br />

St George’s<br />

Grenada<br />

Scarborough Tobago<br />

Port of Spain<br />

Trinidad<br />

N<br />

Venezuela<br />

Georgetown<br />

Colombia<br />

Guyana<br />

Paramaribo<br />

Cayenne<br />

Suriname<br />

French<br />

Guiana<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong> 3


Energy<br />

issues<br />

world energy outlook<br />

Oil price will stay high<br />

Companie<br />

In the <strong>Caribbean</strong>, the international energy outlook is a good deal brighter for<br />

Countries<br />

supply challenge. LNG projects these days are notoriously difficult to deliver.” With<br />

4<br />

oil and gas producers than for consumers.<br />

With reviving economic growth in North America and continued economic<br />

expansion in the Far East, the price of oil is likely to stay within the $95-100<br />

range, well above the cost of production of any reasonably efficient company.<br />

The gas price will probably remain lower in the United States than has been the<br />

case until recently, moving between $4 and $4.50 per mmbtu. But it will continue<br />

strong in major Eastern markets such as Japan, South Korea and Taiwan, and even<br />

in the European Union, where demand for LNG is rising.<br />

Until the US starts to export LNG late in the current decade, pressures on pricing<br />

will intensify. Several LNG projects in other countries are having difficulty getting<br />

off the ground, because of spiralling costs for LNG construction, most notably in<br />

Australia, Canada and Qatar, and because of infrastructural deficiencies in areas<br />

like East Africa, the new hotspot for LNG development.<br />

Spokesmen for the BG Group in the UK, a major LNG trader which operates in<br />

Trinidad and Tobago, insist that “it is not going to be easy to meet an enormous<br />

LNG expected to comprise <strong>14</strong>% of all globally traded gas by 2025, there is clearly<br />

a challenge in bringing enough supply projects on stream to be able to meet this<br />

demand.<br />

The price of oil is likely to stay within the $95-100<br />

range, well above the cost of production of any<br />

reasonably efficient company<br />

Another piece of bad news is that coal could be making a comeback, thanks<br />

to the high cost of oil. The Paris-based International Energy Agency (IEA)<br />

suggests, startlingly, that “demand for coal could catch up with oil by 2022.” As<br />

early as 2017, global coal consumption could stand at 4.32 billion tonnes of oil<br />

equivalent, compared with 4.4 billion tonnes for oil itself, the IEA predicts.<br />

This, of course, will be terribly unhealthy for the environment, since coal is<br />

the most polluting fossil fuel, and already over 66% of climate change-causing<br />

emissions emanate from the energy sector.<br />

The expectation was, of course, that energy-importing countries would turn to<br />

the more climate-friendly natural gas. But, with export projects facing long delays,<br />

coal could bridge the gap in the market.<br />

The price competitiveness of coal also poses a threat to the development of<br />

renewable energy (RE) sources in <strong>2013</strong> and beyond. If coal is cheaper and the gas<br />

price remains high outside North America, electric utilities will ask themselves:<br />

why convert to RE?<br />

Governments could artificially depress the price of RE to make it attractive to<br />

Atlantic LNG tank (courtesy bptt)


Energy<br />

the consumer, but at a time of constrained budgets everywhere, this is hardly an<br />

appealing strategy.<br />

issues<br />

One energy concern has now been taken off the table and will no longer be<br />

exercising the energy planners’ minds in <strong>2013</strong> and beyond – peak oil. The day<br />

when oil production reach its zenith and starts to decline has now been pushed<br />

well into the future – and may not occur at all, because new sources of fossil fuel<br />

energy are coming into the picture to add to existing oil output.<br />

These are the “unconventional” fuels – shale oil, shale gas, tar sands, coal<br />

bed methane, biofuels – that are being retrieved in greater quantities and will<br />

replace (and probably add to) conventional production from existing geological<br />

structures.<br />

If coal is cheaper and the gas price remains high<br />

outside<br />

Compani<br />

North America, electric utilities will ask themselves:<br />

why convert to renewables?<br />

Countries<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

5


caricom energy policy 1<br />

Energy<br />

issues<br />

The <strong>Caribbean</strong>’s<br />

nightmare import bill<br />

Except for Trinidad and Tobago,<br />

the countries of Caricom have<br />

long faced the acute problem<br />

of having to import the energy<br />

they need for their economies<br />

to function.<br />

This dependence has been worsening.<br />

“The total cost of the annual fuel import<br />

bill for the region today is around (US)<br />

$8-9 billion,” says Desiree Field-Ridley,<br />

officer in charge of trade and economic<br />

integration at the Caricom secretariat in<br />

Guyana, “with the tendency to be rising.”<br />

Compare that with $2.5 billion in<br />

2006, when the Caricom task force,<br />

appointed three years earlier with a<br />

mandate to “develop mechanisms for<br />

a regional energy policy,” was finalising<br />

its draft report. The magnitude of the<br />

dependence is staggering.<br />

With so much foreign exchange<br />

going to pay for one product, however<br />

essential, there is a “deleterious effect”,<br />

as Field-Ridley puts it, “on the economic<br />

and social development of the net<br />

Traffic in St. John’s, Antigua (courtesy Hugh Fiske/Flickr)<br />

energy-importing countries of Caricom.”<br />

The effort made by Venezuela in 2005<br />

to ease that “deleterious effect” through<br />

the PetroCaribe oil supply programme<br />

only plunged the 13 Caricom states<br />

who signed up for it further into debt<br />

and did little to ease their foreign<br />

exchange liability, according to Field-<br />

Ridley’s figures. After a down-payment<br />

of part of the commercial price would<br />

be made, buyers would pay the balance<br />

over several years.<br />

Companie<br />

Countries<br />

Caricom’s energy-importing countries<br />

Despite PetroCaribe, when the price<br />

of oil soared to $<strong>14</strong>7 a barrel in 2008,<br />

“were almost at a panic stage”, to<br />

quote Joseph Williams, manager of the<br />

secretariat’s energy unit. The secretariat<br />

responded with a programme named<br />

C-SERMS (Caricom Sustainable Energy<br />

Road Map and Strategy), to help<br />

accelerate the move towards renewable<br />

energy and more efficient usage in<br />

member states.<br />

C-SERMS has now been subsumed<br />

into the Caricom Energy Policy, which<br />

updates and completes the 2007 task<br />

force report. It was adopted by regional<br />

energy ministers at a special Council<br />

for Trade and Economic Development<br />

meeting in Port of Spain on March 1,<br />

<strong>2013</strong>, and was due to go forward to the<br />

Caricom heads of government in July<br />

for formal ratification.<br />

The major petroleum products on<br />

which Caricom depends are residual<br />

fuel oil for power generation (57% of the<br />

total in 2008) and motor gasolene for<br />

transportation (16%). “Other petroleum<br />

products” accounted for 13%.<br />

The larger Caricom states like<br />

Jamaica and Guyana have to divert 40-<br />

60% of their total export earnings to<br />

pay for this lifeline, leaving relatively<br />

little for other imports, including food<br />

and medicines.<br />

As the Caricom Energy Policy points<br />

out, “for the tourism/services-oriented<br />

countries, such as Belize, Grenada,<br />

St Vincent and the Grenadines and<br />

Barbados, petroleum imports range<br />

from 13% to 30% of export earnings.”<br />

When export income falls, as it did in<br />

Grenada in the year under review (2008),<br />

“a higher oil import/foreign exchange<br />

earnings ratio” has to be faced.<br />

In Caricom, Jamaica is most heavily<br />

dependent on imported energy. It<br />

requires crude oil to feed its 36,000 b/d<br />

Petrojam refinery and refined products<br />

to run the various parts of its economy.<br />

In 2008, it imported 16.3 million<br />

barrels of fuel oil for power generation,<br />

and 4.3 million barrels of gasolene<br />

and 3.6 million barrels of diesel for<br />

transportation.<br />

6


Energy<br />

caricom energy policy 2<br />

issues<br />

Is the <strong>Caribbean</strong> serious<br />

about renewable energy?<br />

The principal purpose of<br />

the Caricom Energy Policy<br />

is to reduce substantially<br />

the Community’s historic<br />

dependence on imported<br />

petroleum products.<br />

Once approved by the regional<br />

heads of government, it will provide a<br />

measure of energy security that has not<br />

been possible when the cost of oil can<br />

fluctuate widely overnight and import<br />

needs are decided by the state of the<br />

economy from year to year.<br />

A major source of Caricom’s petroleum<br />

Compani<br />

imports is actually one of its own –<br />

Trinidad and Tobago. But that is small<br />

comfort, since Trinidad and Tobago sells<br />

its refined products at prices related<br />

to international crude benchmarks.<br />

Caricom states do get some relief<br />

from the part-payment they make on<br />

Venezuelan oil, but that too is little<br />

comfort when deliveries fall short, as<br />

they have often tended to do.<br />

Hence the problem: how to adjust<br />

the energy mix so that oil plays a less<br />

burdensome part?<br />

The Caricom Energy Policy settles<br />

unsurprisingly for a multi-pronged<br />

approach, focusing on enhanced<br />

renewable energy alongside efficiency<br />

measures to reduce the amount of<br />

energy needed to create each dollar of<br />

GDP. It lists renewable inputs as solar,<br />

wind, biomass, landfill gas, bio-ethanol,<br />

hydro, geothermal, waste-to-energy,<br />

marine energy (including tidal and<br />

wave), and even hydrogen.<br />

Countries<br />

Even geothermal-fired electricity<br />

Most of those resources are available<br />

domestically and do not involve the<br />

use of precious foreign exchange once<br />

plant and equipment are installed. Their<br />

very presence enhances energy security.<br />

exchanged between two members<br />

could be regarded as a national source.<br />

The Caricom policy document points<br />

out that, though some progress has<br />

been made with renewable energy in<br />

the region, “the overall proportion of<br />

[its] contribution in primary energy<br />

still remains quite low”. The creation<br />

of a “sustainable energy path” will<br />

require “commitments to increasing the<br />

contribution of both RE and EE.”<br />

EE (energy efficiency) may prove<br />

more difficult to adopt than RE<br />

(renewable energy) because it requires<br />

a conscious change in human behaviour.<br />

Governments are urged to make EE a<br />

more attractive exercise through “fiscal<br />

and other incentives”, especially “solarthermal<br />

systems for hot water production<br />

in all sectors” and setting “minimum<br />

efficiency standards that require electric<br />

utilities to decommission inefficient<br />

generation plant and conduct demand<br />

side management programmes.”<br />

The electricity sector is seen as the<br />

main channel for increasing RE,<br />

since renewable sources can “provide<br />

direct replacement for fossil fuels as the<br />

principal source (base-load type) for<br />

generating electricity at the national<br />

level.”<br />

The 2009 C-SERMS initiative (the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> Sustainable Energy Road Map<br />

and Strategy) will take responsibility for<br />

promoting both RE and EE. It is expected<br />

to set “quantitative targets for sustainable<br />

energy and “provide an implementation<br />

framework, engaging all member states<br />

and actors in the energy sector.”<br />

The Caricom Energy Policy focuses on increasing<br />

renewable energy while simultaneously pursuing<br />

efficiency<br />

Wigton wind farm, Jamaica (courtesy pcj.com)<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

7


Energy<br />

issues<br />

energy security<br />

A price you can’t afford<br />

Energy security is said to be the ultimate goal of the<br />

Caricom Energy Policy (CEP). But what exactly does<br />

that mean?<br />

According to the policy document, it means: “The<br />

availability of, and timely access to, energy resources<br />

of an acceptable quality at competitive prices that are both<br />

affordable for consumers and reasonable for producers and<br />

reflect true final costs for producing and supplying energy.”<br />

There’s a mouthful for you.<br />

In fact, Caricom has always enjoyed energy security, thanks<br />

to Trinidad and Tobago, the only energy exporter in the region.<br />

A spokesman for Petrotrin, whose refinery has traditionally<br />

supplied gasolene, diesel and fuel oil to the <strong>Caribbean</strong>, once<br />

observed to this YEARBOOK: “Refined products from Trinidad<br />

and Tobago have always been essential to the lifeblood of<br />

the region. Refining started in Trinidad in 1911 and we have<br />

always had a tradition of supplying oil to the <strong>Caribbean</strong>. We<br />

have always met our commitments, through good and bad<br />

times. The other islands could always have relied on Trinidad<br />

for oil – even when they did not pay their bills.”<br />

Supplying a scattered archipelago made up of relatively<br />

small markets is no easy task. As the Petrotrin spokesman<br />

pointed out: “Petrotrin is a merchant refiner, meaning that we<br />

buy crude oil, we have some of our own and we make product<br />

and people order it, with required specifications – sulphur is a<br />

certain range, diesel of a cetane number, we will make that for<br />

you. This demands extraordinary flexibility from the refinery.<br />

We respond to specific customer needs.”<br />

That historic security role was ostensibly taken over by<br />

Venezuela when it launched its PetroCaribe programme in<br />

2005. Trinidad and Tobago energy minister Kevin Ramnarine<br />

acknowledged recently that “some security is now being<br />

provided by the Venezuelans”, adding: “But Trinidad and<br />

Tobago still provides significant volumes of fuel to the Caricom<br />

member states.” The reason for that is refinery flexibility, which<br />

Venezuela’s PdVSA has been unable to match on a consistent<br />

basis.<br />

So “availability of and timely access to energy resources”<br />

is not a problem for Caricom. “Competitive prices”, however,<br />

have been a serious challenge in recent years. Soaring oil costs<br />

have hit Caricom companies and households hardest through<br />

the cost of gasolene at the pump (governments have had to<br />

bargain with fuels retailers to keep rises to a minimum) and in<br />

the cost of electricity.<br />

Companie<br />

“The other islands could always have<br />

relied on Trinidad for oil – even when<br />

they did not pay their bills”<br />

Fuel costs represent 40-50% of generation costs, says the<br />

regional utilities body, Carilec. The average regional fuel<br />

cost was $150 per megawatt hour in 2010. This has translated<br />

into crippling electricity bills throughout Caricom, except in<br />

Trinidad and Tobago (see box).<br />

Affordable pricing is thus the big challenge. Carilec itself<br />

has called for “the creation of an enabling environment, both<br />

regulatory and institutional, for the introduction of indigenous<br />

renewable energy into the national energy mix.”<br />

Countries<br />

The CEP comes down heavily on the side of RE. But will that,<br />

at least in its early days, really help to make power costs “more<br />

affordable” for consumers?<br />

Carilec itself has cast doubt on the likelihood of that<br />

happening. The Jamaican public utility restructuring and<br />

regulation consultant, Winston C. Hay, has categorically told<br />

this YEARBOOK: “RE is not the immediate answer to costs.<br />

I believe it ought to be encouraged and governments are<br />

developing incentives for individuals and small companies to<br />

get involved in RE, but, if anything, it will increase the price of<br />

electricity in the short term.”<br />

Caricom electricity prices<br />

Selected countries<br />

(US$ per Kwh, 2012)<br />

Antigua 0.38<br />

St Vincent 0.36<br />

Barbados 0.36<br />

Grenada 0.35<br />

St Kitts/Nevis 0.34<br />

Guyana 0.34<br />

Jamaica 0.32<br />

Trinidad and Tobago 0.06<br />

Source: Energy Dynamics<br />

8


Energy<br />

the future of gas<br />

issues<br />

Regional policy<br />

undervalues gas<br />

Many, perhaps most, of the electric utilities in<br />

Caricom want to switch to natural gas for<br />

power generation instead of the high-priced<br />

diesel and the light and heavy fuel oil they<br />

Energy Policy (CEP) does not appear to grasp the significance<br />

of that.<br />

In a document meant to outline the energy path that<br />

regional states are expected to travel in the coming decades,<br />

only perfunctory mention is made of gas.<br />

True, the policy does encourage member states to<br />

“implement programmes and projects which aim to<br />

incorporate and optimise the use of natural gas in the energy<br />

mix” and to “establish natural gas as a key energy transitional<br />

have traditionally used. But the Caricom<br />

Compani<br />

source for the region”. But it fails to note the fact that specific<br />

gas-supply investments are already going ahead.<br />

These are, of course, the Eastern <strong>Caribbean</strong> gas pipeline,<br />

which will take gas from Trinidad and Tobago to Barbados,<br />

and the small LNG plant proposed for La Brea in southwest<br />

Trinidad.<br />

Compressed natural gas is touted as another gas source for<br />

Caricom, but the CEP appears much more enthusiastic about<br />

renewable energy, and urges the adoption of “geothermal,<br />

hydro, bio-fuels, solar power, wind power and waste-toenergy,<br />

which can provide direct replacement for fossil fuels as<br />

the principal source (base load type) for generating electricity<br />

at the national level and can support regional, or cross-border,<br />

supply of electricity.”<br />

That last reference is to Nevis and Dominica, which have<br />

plans for developing geothermal power and exporting<br />

it by undersea cable to neighbouring territories. It is also a<br />

reminder of Guyana’s long-held desire to use its large rivers<br />

for hydro-electricity and to export surplus power to the island<br />

archipelago.<br />

As the CEP points out: “Cross-border transmission of<br />

electricity can facilitate a paradigm shift where more member<br />

states can become exporters of energy” – rather than<br />

just Trinidad and Tobago with its existing trade in refined<br />

petroleum products, and regional gas delivery to come.<br />

Trinidad and Tobago might justly feel aggrieved that the<br />

gas it is prepared to offer its fellow Caricom members as an<br />

alternative to oil has been so casually treated in the CEP.<br />

Countries<br />

According to the St Lucia-based <strong>Caribbean</strong> Electric Utility<br />

Services Corporation (Carilec), the regional “trade union” for<br />

the power sector, only 5% of primary energy consumption is<br />

derived from natural gas, with 2% from RE, with oil accounting<br />

for the remaining 93%.<br />

Gas evangelists urge governments to increase that 5%<br />

rather than to undertake the complex and expensive<br />

exercise of creating geothermal and hydro-electric facilities, at<br />

least in the short term.<br />

Indeed, the 2010 Nexant study for the World Bank on<br />

“Regional Energy Solutions for Power Generation in the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong>” recommended gas more often than RE as part of<br />

the strategy to reduce energy costs up to 2028.<br />

Gas was identified as the main substitute energy source for<br />

oil for Barbados, Jamaica, St Lucia, the Dominican Republic and<br />

Haiti. With specific reference to the <strong>Caribbean</strong> gas pipeline,<br />

Nexant said it would be a “highly economic” investment for<br />

Barbados “if it displaces heavy fuel oil and diesel”, as it will.<br />

Barbados’s own National Energy Policy (2007) envisaged<br />

that 70% of its power would be generated by natural gas by<br />

2030, with only 10% from oil and 20% from RE. The country<br />

will need about 46 mmcfd of gas to achieve this goal, which<br />

suggests it may be in line for LNG as well as pipeline gas.<br />

While natural gas is guilty of higher greenhouse gas<br />

emissions than RE, they are still far lower than oil’s. CO 2 releases<br />

from natural gas are 117,000 pounds per billion British thermal<br />

units of energy input, while those of oil are 164,000. The figure<br />

for coal, by comparison, is 208,000 pounds.<br />

Natural gas releases 92 pounds of nitrogen oxide per billion<br />

btu of energy input, compared with 448 for oil, and one pound<br />

of sulphur dioxide compared with 1,122 pounds from oil.<br />

Potential gas demand<br />

Power generation capacity (peak demand) in line<br />

for conversion to gas<br />

Antigua<br />

Bahamas<br />

Grenada<br />

Guyana<br />

Jamaica<br />

St Lucia<br />

St Vincent<br />

Suriname<br />

Source: <strong>Caribbean</strong> Energy Policy, <strong>2013</strong><br />

51MW<br />

308MW<br />

30.5 MW<br />

94MW<br />

644 MW<br />

55.9 MW<br />

24.5 MW<br />

<strong>14</strong>5 MW<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

9


caribbean gas market<br />

Energy<br />

issues<br />

TT must get moving<br />

Is Trinidad and Tobago moving fast<br />

enough to secure the emerging<br />

market for natural gas in the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong>? Many energy analysts<br />

think not.<br />

At the time of writing, Gasfin<br />

Development SA, the Luxembourgbased<br />

company leading the way in<br />

trying to push the country into making<br />

sales contracts with <strong>Caribbean</strong> electricity<br />

utilities, had still not been able to line<br />

up an assured gas supply with which to<br />

approach potential customers.<br />

Only about 70 million cubic feet a day<br />

(mmcfd) is required for the first train of<br />

about 500,000 tonnes a year that Gasfin<br />

would like to see sited at the Labidco<br />

industrial estate at La Brea to liquefy gas<br />

for regional export. Perhaps frustrated<br />

by Trinidad and Tobago’s apparent<br />

slothfulness, Gasfin’s CEO Roland Fisher<br />

has hedged his bets by also seeking<br />

permission from the US Department<br />

of Energy to export low-priced shale<br />

gas from a plant he wants to build in<br />

Louisiana.<br />

He was quickly given the green light,<br />

though he now has to clear his 1.5<br />

million tonne per year complex, which<br />

he wants to build in phases, with the<br />

Albert G. Nahas (courtesy Cheniere)<br />

Companie<br />

2020, so Trinidad and Tobago still has the<br />

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.<br />

Gasfin does not expect to be ready to<br />

export LNG from the US much before<br />

opportunity to get in first and capture<br />

the market before Gasfin Development<br />

USA decides to target that customer<br />

base.<br />

One piece of luck for the La Brea<br />

project, which Fisher is calling Project<br />

Constantine, is that his US company, at<br />

least for now, will be permitted to export<br />

only to countries with which the US has<br />

a free trade agreement. Puerto Rico and<br />

the US Virgin Islands (which are part<br />

of the US anyway) and the Dominican<br />

Republic are the only parts of the insular<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> that qualify, so Fisher will be<br />

limited to seeking markets there.<br />

Countries<br />

This leaves 21 other potential markets<br />

in the <strong>Caribbean</strong> archipelago to which<br />

La Brea LNG could theoretically sell gas.<br />

Even Guyana, Suriname and French<br />

Guiana, the first two of which are<br />

members of Caricom, could be potential<br />

targets.<br />

Gasfin Development USA is not the<br />

only company gunning for the <strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

market: Pacific Rubiales in Colombia<br />

is also planning a small LNG export<br />

project. As a competitor, Colombia is an<br />

unknown quantity.<br />

But even if Fisher chose not to try and<br />

sell in the <strong>Caribbean</strong>, and others such<br />

as Cheniere did, Trinidad and Tobago<br />

might very well hold its own. Albert<br />

G. Nahas, Cheniere’s vice president<br />

for international government affairs,<br />

believes that “Trinidad and Tobago is<br />

perfectly capable of competing in the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> gas market. After all, gas will<br />

still be cheaper in TT than in most of the<br />

rest of the world, except the US.” Fisher<br />

himself has told this YEARBOOK that<br />

he would prefer to supply <strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

markets that materialise from Trinidad<br />

and Tobago rather than the US.<br />

La Brea LNG will open markets near<br />

to home for Trinidad and Tobago<br />

LNG. But it could also present the<br />

country with a unique value-chain<br />

opportunity through the National<br />

Gas Company or its subsidiary, the<br />

National Energy Corporation, not<br />

only in the LNG train itself but in the<br />

ships needed to transport the gas<br />

and the re-gasification facilities at the<br />

receiving end.<br />

At the moment, NGC holds a 10%<br />

share in Atlantic’s train one and 11.1%<br />

in train four, which gives it a quota<br />

of 88 mmcfd. Until recently, this was<br />

sold internationally on its behalf. It has<br />

recently taken back 30 mmcfd to market<br />

on its own account, thus giving it some<br />

experience in these matters prior to any<br />

involvement in La Brea LNG.<br />

Gasfin has been working closely<br />

with EdF, the electricity company in<br />

Martinique and Guadeloupe, with a<br />

view to supplying 200,000 tonnes of<br />

LNG to each French department to run<br />

the gas turbines both are installing.<br />

This would provide a market for 80%<br />

of the capacity of La Brea train one, but<br />

no deal can be struck until a gas supply<br />

from NGC is pinned down.<br />

Roland Fisher (courtesy Gasfin)<br />

10


Energy<br />

issues<br />

the green agenda<br />

It will take a long time to<br />

replace fossil fuels<br />

The “green energy movement”<br />

is slowly gaining momentum<br />

in the <strong>Caribbean</strong>, reflected<br />

for renewable energy and<br />

efficient use of fossil fuel energy. These<br />

initiatives are dealt with elsewhere in<br />

this YEARBOOK, in the context of the<br />

Caricom Energy Policy.<br />

But it’s going to be a hard slog. Oil<br />

will not willingly surrender its position<br />

in the growing enthusiasm<br />

Compani<br />

as the region’s leading energy source.<br />

The International Energy Agency<br />

(IEA), which looks after the interests<br />

of western industrialised countries,<br />

predicts that fossil fuels “will still<br />

account for 80-85% of overall world<br />

energy consumption by 2030.” And<br />

coal, the least green<br />

fossil fuel, is making<br />

something of a<br />

comeback, and could<br />

even reach energy use<br />

parity with oil before<br />

the end of the present<br />

decade.<br />

Gas, the least emissions-intensive<br />

of the three, makes the strongest<br />

claim. Even the Caricom Energy<br />

Policy acknowledges that “compared<br />

with crude oil, natural gas is a less<br />

expensive and cleaner fossil fuel which<br />

can be used not only to generate<br />

electricity efficiently, by deploying<br />

advanced technologies, but also<br />

as a feedstock for the manufacture<br />

of petrochemical products, fuel for<br />

the manufacturing sector and for<br />

vehicular transportation.”<br />

Countries<br />

The policy document urges Caricom<br />

members to “satisfy their demand<br />

for natural gas from the resources<br />

Roger Salloum (courtesy Green Building Council)<br />

“Fossil fuels will still account for 80-85% of<br />

overall world energy consumption<br />

in 2030”<br />

of those member states with such<br />

resources.” The only Caricom state<br />

with exportable gas resources,<br />

Trinidad and Tobago, can take that<br />

as an endorsement of its role in the<br />

emerging Caricom market for LNG<br />

and possibly CNG, and rejection of<br />

the deals US exporters will want to do<br />

with Caricom customers.<br />

With significant take-up of RE some<br />

decades away, most energy analysts<br />

see natural gas as a “bridging fuel”<br />

between oil era and RE.<br />

Other initiatives to move the “green<br />

agenda” forward are slowly<br />

taking shape. Trinidad and Tobago, a<br />

late convert to energy sustainability,<br />

even has a Green Building Council,<br />

established in September 2010, to<br />

preach the virtues of green buildings.<br />

The Council’s president, Roger Salloum,<br />

says its mission is to “transform the way<br />

Trinidad and Tobago’s buildings are<br />

built and communities are designed,<br />

built and operated.”<br />

Salloum claims that “green buildings<br />

can increase worker productivity” by<br />

being “more comfortable and healthier<br />

for the occupants, as compared with<br />

conventionally constructed and<br />

maintained buildings.” Greening,<br />

he suggests, includes a range of<br />

very simple practical steps such as<br />

installing energy-saving<br />

bulbs, recycling plastics<br />

and other materials, and<br />

collecting rain water<br />

for wetting plants and<br />

flushing toilets.<br />

The energy ministry<br />

in Port of Spain wants<br />

citizens to set airconditioning<br />

units a few degrees<br />

warmer, turn off electronic devices<br />

when not in use, and unplug<br />

bedside lamps, TV sets, video games,<br />

computers etc. until they are needed.<br />

Thirteen years ago, Trinidad<br />

and Tobago established a Green<br />

Fund, financed through an annual<br />

tax of 0.1% on gross company<br />

sales. It now has well over TT$2.5<br />

billion available. NGOs and other<br />

groups (but not corporations) that<br />

promote “reforestation, remediation,<br />

environmental education and public<br />

awareness of environmental issues”<br />

can apply to it for assistance.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

11


Energy<br />

issues<br />

going international<br />

Can state energy companies<br />

make the grade?<br />

Almost every famous name in the energy business<br />

has been involved in Trinidad and Tobago’s<br />

energy sector at one time or another. Yet, despite<br />

105 years of commercial production, no local<br />

company has ever gone abroad to invest in oil or<br />

gas exploration and production.<br />

There was a very short-lived alliance between Petrotrin<br />

and Venezuela’s Inelectra in the early 2000s for exploration<br />

in the Gulf of Paria East block. Petrotrin even set up a special<br />

subsidiary, Petrotrin de Venezolana, for the purpose. But after<br />

one well had been drilled, the arrangement was aborted.<br />

Petrotrin toyed with the idea of investing in the Cuban oil<br />

sector at one point, but that never went very far either.<br />

It’s not hard to guess why the many companies formed<br />

locally to dabble in domestic upstream activity never<br />

considered going overseas. Most of them didn’t last very long,<br />

and none had the financial muscle, even in the <strong>Caribbean</strong>.<br />

But times and attitudes have changed. The local company<br />

Trinity Exploration and Production, armed with US$90 million<br />

of shareholders’ funds from a listing in London early in <strong>2013</strong>,<br />

is mulling the possibility of investing in oil and gas activity<br />

outside Trinidad and Tobago.<br />

But the real thrust in this direction is coming from the<br />

energy ministry itself, which is anxious for state-owned firms<br />

in the energy sector, having demonstrated that they can<br />

perform competently at home, to spread their wings abroad.<br />

The companies involved are:<br />

• NGC (National Gas Company: gas trader, pipeline operator,<br />

LNG exporter)<br />

• Petrotrin (the Petroleum Company of Trinidad and<br />

Tobago: oil and gas producer, refiner)<br />

• NP (the National Petroleum Marketing Company: bunkerer,<br />

refined fuels wholesaler/retailer)<br />

• PPGPL (Phoenix Park Gas Processors: gas liquids extractor/<br />

marketer).<br />

The first three are fully owned by the government: the last<br />

is 51% owned by NGC.<br />

The major role in this international outreach has been<br />

assigned to the NGC, probably the most profitable<br />

domestically-owned firm in Caricom, public or private. Its<br />

turnover was TT$19 billion in fiscal year 2011, TT$5 billion<br />

more than the year before. Its after-tax profit was TT$4.6<br />

Companie<br />

billion, compared with TT$2 billion in 2010.<br />

Energy minister Kevin Ramnarine has pinned his faith on<br />

NGC to an extraordinary degree. He sees it “becoming to<br />

Trinidad and Tobago what Petrobras is to Brazil or Petronas<br />

to Malaysia. Petrobras is almost as powerful in Brazil as the<br />

Brazilian government. There is also the wonderful story of<br />

state company Ecopetrol in Colombia. It was worth a couple<br />

of billion dollars a few years ago and now is being quoted at<br />

over US$100 billion, creating tremendous value for the people<br />

of Colombia, who are its shareholders.”<br />

NGC’s successful foray abroad is therefore essential to<br />

the minister’s grand vision. It has been mandated to “look<br />

at investment opportunities around the world” in order to<br />

expand.<br />

Countries<br />

West and East Africa, where there have been several major<br />

oil and gas discoveries in recent years, is particularly<br />

in the frame. “We are keen on establishing an investment<br />

portfolio in Africa through the vehicle of the NGC,” says<br />

the minister, noting that “natural gas has the potential for<br />

eradicating poverty in East Africa through the provision of<br />

cheap electricity to the populations in Tanzania, Kenya and<br />

Mozambique. These are just some of the possibilities as we<br />

seek to internationalise the Trinidad and Tobago energy<br />

model.”<br />

In its African initiatives, NGC has worked closely with PPGPL,<br />

the specialist in gas liquids extraction and marketing, a likely<br />

activity for state investment in Africa.<br />

PPGPL has already initialled a memorandum of<br />

understanding with the Tanzania Petroleum Development<br />

Corporation for “technical and expert services” in conjunction<br />

with a 500 km pipeline being built by the Chinese Petroleum<br />

Development Services to take gas from discoveries offshore<br />

southern Tanzania to the capital, Dar es Salaam.<br />

PPGPL’s president Eugene Tiah confirms that “there are lots<br />

of opportunities in Africa, but you have aggressive countries<br />

like China that are not waiting around. If we don’t take<br />

advantage of the opportunities, they will be gone soon.”<br />

Nearer to home, Central America is seen as a fruitful area<br />

for state energy company outreach, particularly Panama,<br />

with whom an MOU was signed in March 2012. Potential<br />

avenues for Trinidad and Tobago state company investment<br />

there include bunkering facilities (Petrotrin), a blending plant<br />

and refined products retailing (NP), and gas-based industries<br />

(NGC/PPGPL).<br />

12


Energy<br />

alternative fuels<br />

issues<br />

Fuel switching is not<br />

catching on<br />

Only Trinidad and Tobago,<br />

and to some extent<br />

Jamaica, which has<br />

experimented with an<br />

the pump, are showing any interest in<br />

alternatives to gasolene and diesel as<br />

transportation fuels. But the <strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

Energy Policy (CEP) devotes a whole<br />

chapter to the subject.<br />

This means that the adoption of<br />

non-traditional fuels for transport is<br />

now an imperative to which Caricom’s<br />

15 member nations will have to adhere<br />

E10 (ethanol) mixture at<br />

Compani<br />

(though the CEP is not a mandatory<br />

guideline, only voluntary).<br />

“Fuel switching”, as the CEP<br />

describes it, is designed to encourage<br />

the use of “cleaner energy sources and<br />

a more efficient transportation sector.”<br />

Transport is seen as “contributing a<br />

high level of emissions, including<br />

greenhouse gases,” thus making it “a<br />

serious environmental matter” in the<br />

eyes of the CEP.<br />

Transport in Caricom is also “highly<br />

vulnerable to dependence on imported<br />

fuel supplies and unpredictable spikes<br />

in oil prices.” So, not surprisingly,<br />

the CEP recommends greater use of<br />

compressed natural gas and biofuels<br />

like ethanol and bio-diesel, as well as<br />

“electric and hybrid vehicles.”<br />

Trinidad and Tobago has about<br />

4,500 vehicles equipped with CNG<br />

(out of some 650,000 registered). A few<br />

hybrids have been imported by motor<br />

vehicle dealers, including one for the<br />

ministry of energy, to boost “energy<br />

efficiency awareness among the<br />

driving population”. It is not clear how<br />

many motorists in Jamaica have opted<br />

for E10, but it can’t be very many.<br />

Countries<br />

In other words, the adoption of nonconventional<br />

transport fuels has a very<br />

long way to go in Caricom.<br />

While Trinidad and Tobago is not<br />

dependent on imported fuel<br />

supplies, the driver for fuel switching is<br />

the need to reduce the use of gasolene<br />

and diesel and cut the government<br />

subsidy on the price of these fuels at the<br />

pump, which is costing several billion<br />

TT dollars a year. The energy ministry is<br />

still seeking a way of enticing motorists<br />

to add CNG capability to their vehicles.<br />

One approach under consideration is to<br />

fund the cost in whole or in part.<br />

CNG has some advantages, but it<br />

also has some disincentives, as even the<br />

ministry concedes. The vehicle becomes<br />

heavier, it loses trunk space to the CNG<br />

cylinders, the system has to be inspected<br />

annually (instead of every three years<br />

for gasolene and diesel vehicles over a<br />

certain age), stricter safety measures are<br />

applied, engine power is reduced 5-10%<br />

by conversion, and range falls to 200-<br />

250 km compared with 400-550 km for<br />

gasolene/diesel vehicles.<br />

With such an array of negatives, it is<br />

perhaps unsurprising that CNG had<br />

not enjoyed the take-up the ministry<br />

would like to see. If and when natural<br />

gas deliveries finally arrive in the rest<br />

of Caricom, the same hesitation will<br />

presumably be seen.<br />

Hybrid car donated to the Ministry of Energy<br />

It is hard to predict whether electricity<br />

would fare any better. Purely electric<br />

vehicles are not on the immediate<br />

horizon for Caricom, since charging<br />

points are unlikely to be available for<br />

a long time.<br />

The halfway house is the hybrid<br />

vehicle, powered by gasolene or<br />

diesel but equipped with a battery<br />

which does not need a recharging<br />

station. “The motion of the wheels<br />

as the car moves charges a battery,”<br />

minister Ramnarine explains, “and at<br />

the opportune time, when the battery<br />

is charged, the vehicle switches to the<br />

battery.”<br />

Another unconventional fuel source<br />

is methanol, made from natural gas<br />

blended with gasolene or diesel, or<br />

even used on its own.<br />

An experiment in 2011, involving<br />

Petrotrin and Trinidad and Tobago’s<br />

two methanol giants, Methanol<br />

Holdings and Methanex, was said<br />

to have produced “encouraging”<br />

results. But the initiative was not<br />

taken any further by Petrotrin, whose<br />

participation in any long-term addition<br />

of methanol to gasolene is essential for<br />

any real progress to be made.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

13


TT oil revival 1<br />

Energy<br />

issues<br />

After three decades of<br />

decline ...<br />

Trinidad and Tobago’s<br />

petroleum liquids production<br />

peaked at 229,589 barrels<br />

a day (b/d) in 1978, almost<br />

all of it crude oil. By 2012 it<br />

had fallen to 81,735 b/d, of which crude<br />

represented 69,062 b/d (the rest was<br />

condensate). The loss of 160,527 b/d<br />

over 34 years translates into billions<br />

of dollars of lost foreign exchange<br />

earnings and government revenue.<br />

A former minister of energy, Senator<br />

Conrad Enill, once suggested that<br />

80,000 b/d of crude output should set<br />

alarm bells ringing. He could hardly<br />

have envisaged how quickly that<br />

scenario would come to pass and how<br />

much worse it might get.<br />

What has saved the day, to some<br />

extent, is the fact that oil prices have<br />

held up remarkably well in the last few<br />

years, at $90-100 a barrel: even with a<br />

staggering drop in production, oil sales<br />

still provide the Trinidad and Tobago<br />

treasury with 55% of its revenue from<br />

hydrocarbons. Gas yields 45%, despite<br />

the fact that it out-produces oil by a<br />

factor of seven in terms of barrels of oil<br />

equivalent.<br />

Finance minister Larry Howai pegged<br />

his oil tax inflows for the 2012-3 fiscal<br />

year at $75 a barrel and gas at $2.75<br />

per mmbtu netted back to Trinidad and<br />

Tobago.<br />

One reason for the headlong decline<br />

in crude retrieval is the fact that<br />

older reservoirs (which means most of<br />

them) are delivering 8-10% less every<br />

year (Petrotrin’s land fields and the<br />

Repsol-Petrotrin-NGC Teak/Samaan/<br />

Poui block off the east coast are prime<br />

examples).<br />

Other reasons are the fall of 12,726<br />

b/d in production from Trinmar,<br />

Companie<br />

Petrotrin’s Gulf of Paria unit, between<br />

2004 and 2010, and the failure of<br />

the Kairi and Canteen oil discoveries,<br />

operated by BHP Billiton T&T in block<br />

2c off Trinidad’s north east coast, to<br />

live up to expectations. The latter was<br />

producing 50,542 b/d on average a few<br />

months after start-up in 2005, but had<br />

dwindled to 12,479 b/d by 2012.<br />

A further factor in this unsettling<br />

decline situation has been the inability<br />

of companies signing production<br />

sharing contracts with the energy<br />

ministry in the last 20 years to find<br />

new oil resources. Out of 36 such<br />

agreements, only two – yes, two –<br />

resulted in discoveries of crude, both<br />

Countries<br />

of them by BHP Billiton T&T and its<br />

partners, in block 2c (see above) and in<br />

block 3a, where no development has<br />

yet begun.<br />

The development of block 2c and<br />

the fact that Trinmar has held relatively<br />

steady in the last three years means<br />

that crude production still comes<br />

primarily from offshore – about 47,519<br />

Galeota platform (courtesy Petrotrin)<br />

b/d in 2012, compared with 21,543 b/d<br />

from onshore.<br />

In his first public address after<br />

becoming energy minister in 2011,<br />

Senator Kevin Ramnarine declared<br />

that the “number one priority” of his<br />

stewardship (which ends in May 2015)<br />

was to “increase national oil production.”<br />

At the time of writing, he had not<br />

achieved much success in that regard.<br />

But he remains optimistic, predicting<br />

“a major increase in oil production<br />

around the period May/June <strong>2013</strong>.”<br />

By February <strong>2013</strong>, according to the<br />

latest data available, there had been<br />

only a very marginal improvement:<br />

the average 69,163 b/d of crude being<br />

lifted that month was 101 b/d above<br />

the 2012 average.<br />

It remains to be seen what will<br />

happen during the rest of <strong>2013</strong>. The<br />

following story in this YEARBOOK<br />

recounts what is being done, and what<br />

can still be done, to achieve a muchdesired<br />

turnaround.<br />

<strong>14</strong>


Energy<br />

tt oil revival 2<br />

issues<br />

How to increase oil<br />

production<br />

What is the key to reviving crude oil production<br />

in Trinidad and Tobago, which, as already<br />

noted, has crashed from 229,589 b/d 34<br />

years ago to 69,062 b/d today?<br />

But there have been precious few of those by companies<br />

working under the current system of production-sharing<br />

contracts (PSCs).<br />

Companies operating under the older exploration and<br />

production (E&P) licences have been a little more successful.<br />

Bayfield Energy (now absorbed by Trinity Exploration and<br />

Production) has identified what it said were about 32 million<br />

barrels of recoverable oil with its FG8 exploratory well in the<br />

Galeota block off southeast Trinidad, while Petrotrin found<br />

The obvious answer is new discoveries.<br />

Compani<br />

about 48 million barrels of “new hydrocarbon potential” in<br />

the course of a five-well exploration programme in the East<br />

Soldado area, subsequently named Jubilee in honour of the<br />

50th anniversary of the country’s independence. Both finds<br />

were made in 2012. Some new oil was also discovered in the<br />

Cory Moruga block on land in 2010.<br />

Further discoveries may be made in the course of the<br />

extensive exploratory drilling due to take place in the course<br />

of <strong>2013</strong>: among others, by Trinity in the Point Ligoure, Guapo<br />

Bay, Brighton Marine (PGB) block in the Gulf of Paria, and in<br />

the Galeota block; by Niko in the Mayaro/Guayaguayare block,<br />

which runs from the onshore to the offshore in south Trinidad;<br />

and by Parex Resources in the Central Range Shallow and<br />

Deep blocks on land.<br />

Under renewed E&P licences, Petrotrin has to drill four<br />

exploratory wells for Trinmar and two in the North Marine<br />

block. Following the interpretation of its 2012 3D seismic<br />

survey, it will also be doing exploratory drilling on land in late<br />

<strong>2013</strong> and beyond.<br />

Exploratory drilling is risky and results can not be guaranteed,<br />

but development drilling in an already producing location<br />

is of course much less so and can at least replace reserves.<br />

Trinity plans to sink 12 development wells onshore in <strong>2013</strong>,<br />

and 12 in the Galeota block. Lease operators, farmout<br />

operators and incremental production service contractors will<br />

all be doing similar work.<br />

Energy minister Kevin Ramnarine has put great faith<br />

in Petrotrin as being “at the centre of the strategy for oil<br />

Countries<br />

production”, and Trinmar as “at the centre of that centre.”<br />

Concurrent with its exploratory activities in Trinmar, Petrotrin<br />

is reactivating its South West Soldado field, now producing<br />

The energy ministry says it will<br />

offer three land blocks for<br />

exploration this year<br />

about 6,000 b/d, in the belief that it can be boosted to 8,000<br />

b/d by the end of <strong>2013</strong>. Sixty wells which were capped ten<br />

years ago are being gradually returned to production: a few<br />

are already producing again, and the rest will come on line as<br />

they are worked over by a rig hired for that purpose.<br />

New block allocations are an important part of minister<br />

Ramnarine’s oil revival plan. In conjunction with Petrotrin, the<br />

ministry says it will offer three land blocks for exploration this<br />

year. More deep water and some shallow water blocks are also<br />

carded for allocation before the end of <strong>2013</strong>.<br />

New blocks, and exploratory and development drilling<br />

in existing blocks, are all essential, but many analysts<br />

point out that for decades companies have ignored oil that<br />

is known to exist and which could have contributed long ago<br />

to arresting the production decline – both heavy oil and “leftbehind”<br />

medium-gravity crude in reservoirs that have ceased<br />

to produce, or are producing very little.<br />

Geologist Dr Krishna Persad has estimated that there is<br />

probably well over two billion barrels of crude left behind in<br />

reservoirs where natural pressure or even pumping no longer<br />

works. As for heavy oil, minister Ramnarine suggests there are<br />

“seven billion barrels in places like Trinmar and the southern<br />

basin on land.”<br />

Even if the correct figure is only half that or less, it represents<br />

a vast unexploited resource that could help achieve the<br />

country’s oil restoration goals.<br />

The government has offered incentives over the years to<br />

encourage companies to invest in mature marine and land<br />

fields, via a 20% tax credit, and to use enhanced oil recovery<br />

measures for lifting heavy oil. In the current national budget,<br />

it introduced a special supplemental petroleum tax rate of<br />

25% for the development of small discovered oil pools lying<br />

inactive. Deep horizon drilling both on and offshore was<br />

encouraged with the offer of a 40% uplift on exploration costs.<br />

The deep horizon, like the deep water, could be an entirely<br />

new source of crude which the ministry has been urging<br />

companies to target.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

15


cross-border gas<br />

Energy<br />

issues<br />

Venezuela lethargy keeps<br />

gas stranded<br />

The cross-border gas straddling the maritime<br />

boundary between Trinidad and Tobago and<br />

Venezuela southeast of Trinidad and northeast of<br />

the Orinoco Delta looks likely to remain out of reach<br />

indefinitely, because the two countries seem unable<br />

to move the commercialisation process forward.<br />

That means that 1.8 trillion cubic feet (tcf) of confirmed gas<br />

reserves in the Manatee discovery in Trinidad and Tobago’s block<br />

6d (which partners the Loran find in Venezuela’s Plataforma<br />

Deltana block 2), and around 1 tcf of gas in the Manakin discovery<br />

in block 5b (linked with Coquina in Plataforma Deltana block 4),<br />

will not be available for use in Trinidad and Tobago’s reviving<br />

downstream gas-based industrial development programme.<br />

Such a waste of badly-needed gas at a time when current<br />

exploitable reserves are almost all committed is clearly<br />

unacceptable.<br />

The problem, as energy analysts see it, is that Venezuela<br />

feels no urgency in developing cross-border gas because it has<br />

dumped plans – for how long, no one knows – to get into the<br />

LNG business.<br />

Its Plataforma Deltana reserves were always destined for<br />

the export trade. Chevron, the operator of block 2, has made<br />

no secret of the fact that under its licence it must provide 90%<br />

of the 6.2 tcf in Loran for use as LNG and the remaining 10%<br />

for domestic use in Venezuela. It has a 39% holding in block 2,<br />

Venezuela’s PdVSA holding the other 61%.<br />

With LNG off the table, the government in Caracas sees<br />

little sense in rushing to commercialise the gas. The 10% that<br />

was destined for domestic use can be sourced from other gas<br />

discoveries closer to the mainland, such as the very large one<br />

that Repsol made in the Gulf of Venezuela recently, or even the<br />

proven reserves in the Paria Norte region.<br />

Trinidad and Tobago’s energy minister Kevin Ramnarine<br />

could scarcely conceal his impatience when he last spoke<br />

publicly about the cross-border gas matter. In an address at<br />

the Austin Jackson School of Geosciences at the University of<br />

Commercialisation has long been<br />

under way with the development of<br />

Kapok<br />

Companie<br />

“It is very hard to get the Venezuelans<br />

to meet with us on this issue”<br />

Texas in Austin in March <strong>2013</strong>, he said: “It is very hard to get the<br />

Venezuelans to meet with us on this issue.”<br />

He noted that he had “been in contact with minister Rafael<br />

Ramírez” (who has been retained as minister of energy and<br />

petroleum in the new Maduro government) and had also<br />

“spoken with Chevron” (the operator of both Manatee and<br />

Loran), but did not seem to hold out much hope for crossborder<br />

monetisation any time soon.<br />

The project appears to be stuck at the stage of selecting a<br />

unit operator. A unit directing committee representing all the<br />

stakeholders in the matter – the two energy ministries, Chevron,<br />

Countries<br />

the BG Group and PdVSA – was supposed to select the operator<br />

early last year, but the Venezuelans failed to turn up in Port of<br />

Spain for the scheduled technical meeting.<br />

Then President Chávez’s lengthy illness and death, and the<br />

election of Nicolás Maduro Moros as his successor, put a stop to<br />

decision-making in Caracas on matters like cross-border gas for<br />

most of 2012; and the post-electoral situation does not seem to<br />

have changed anything.<br />

As far as the Manakin (BP/Repsol) and Coquina (Statoil/<br />

PdVSA) discoveries are concerned, no unitisation<br />

agreement has been signed. The reservoir joint working group,<br />

comprising officials from both sides, has identified the total<br />

volume of gas reserves they believe to be there. But the specific<br />

amount on each side has not yet been determined. A “best<br />

guess” estimate is about 1 tcf in each discovery.<br />

The situation in the third pair of cross-border gas blocks<br />

– bpTT’s Kapok discovery on the Trinidad side and the<br />

Dorado find by PdVSA in block 1 in Venezuela – is different,<br />

in that commercialisation has long been under way with the<br />

development of Kapok. The estimated combined reserves in<br />

the two blocks is about 1 tcf, and PdVSA has allowed bpTT to<br />

produce what it can from the two reservoirs.<br />

When the exact amount on each side is determined, if<br />

production from the Kapok field has exceeded the allocated<br />

reserves allocated, bpTT would agree on some form of<br />

compensation for PdVSA.<br />

16


Energy<br />

issues<br />

Deep water exploration<br />

The last real frontier?<br />

Deep geological horizons on land and offshore<br />

are a possible new oil and gas play in Trinidad<br />

and Tobago (and received incentives in the<br />

2012-<strong>2013</strong> national budget), but the real last<br />

The ministry has bent over backwards<br />

to make deep water activity<br />

economically attractive, which it has<br />

not been in the past<br />

frontier for substantial hydrocarbon discovery<br />

Compani<br />

is exploration in deep water, at whatever geological depth.<br />

Deep water is defined by the energy ministry in Port of<br />

Spain as a water depth of 1,000 metres and more.<br />

No exploration beyond about 1,500 metres has actually<br />

taken place before. Eight wells were sunk in the continental<br />

slope in the late 1990s and early 2000s in water depths of<br />

750-1,500 metres, but only one find of non-commercial<br />

gas was made.<br />

In 2012, the BP Group signed two production-sharing<br />

contracts for exploring in the Atlantic deep water off the<br />

east coast. Water depth in the two blocks, 23a and TTDAA<br />

<strong>14</strong>, is around 2,000 metres.<br />

BP is leading the first assault on real deep water acreage<br />

in Trinidad and Tobago. It will be followed by BHP Billiton,<br />

which was awarded four other blocks – TTDAA 5-6 and<br />

TTDAA 28-9 – in the subsequent bid round (see map on<br />

p26-27).<br />

Deep horizon exploration, on land or offshore, could<br />

itself result in the identification of a new play, if the<br />

incentive offered – a <strong>14</strong>0% write-off on exploration costs<br />

– is enough to entice explorationists. “Deep horizon” has<br />

been defined by the ministry as 8,000 feet or more on land<br />

and 12,000 feet or more offshore.<br />

While he would clearly be pleased with a deep horizon<br />

discovery, Trinidad and Tobago’s energy minister<br />

Kevin Ramnarine is betting on the deep water. He believes<br />

that “both BP and BHP Billiton, two long-established<br />

players in the country, stand poised to take us into a period<br />

of exciting deep water exploration” and that “the deep<br />

water in Trinidad is one of the holy grails of geologists, who<br />

have long suspected its vast hydrocarbon potential.”<br />

This potential has been estimated by the energy<br />

ministry at 4.7-8.2 trillion cubic feet (tcf) of gas in the two<br />

BP blocks (no estimate has been given publicly for possible<br />

oil resources), and 2.4-23.6 tcf of gas and 428-4,200 million<br />

barrels of oil in BHP Billiton’s four blocks.<br />

The latter would have had its own reasons for bidding<br />

so aggressively on four of the five blocks that attracted<br />

companies’ attention in the 2012 deep water auction, but<br />

the ministry has bent over backwards to make deep water<br />

activity economically attractive, which it has not been in<br />

the past. These attractions are intended to “reduce risk and<br />

offer companies a more competitive environment,” and<br />

include:<br />

• Cost recovery (“cost oil or gas”) increased from 60 to<br />

80%<br />

• A 35% petroleum profits tax and an 18% supplemental<br />

petroleum tax payable on oil only. This allows the<br />

company to claim a higher share of “profit oil or gas”<br />

since the government’s take under the productionsharing<br />

system is based on these two taxes<br />

• A <strong>14</strong>0% write-off for deep water exploratory wells,<br />

further enhancing the companies’ share of “profit oil or<br />

gas”.<br />

Countries<br />

The ministry is following up on its 2010 and 2012 deep<br />

water bid rounds with another in <strong>2013</strong>, which it hopes<br />

will attract new companies into the hydrocarbon sector.<br />

Minister Ramnarine told this YEARBOOK: “companies which<br />

did not bid in 2012 have told us they will bid in <strong>2013</strong> ... In<br />

one case, they told us that they had a restructuring exercise<br />

“BP and BHP Billiton, two long-established<br />

players in the country, stand<br />

poised to take us into a period of<br />

exciting deep water exploration”<br />

going on in 2012, and another said it had quite a lot on<br />

its plate at the time. So, I think that we have stimulated<br />

widespread interest in our deep water bid rounds.”<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

17


independents<br />

Small and medium-sized<br />

petroleum enterprises in<br />

Trinidad and Tobago, the<br />

“independents”, are expected<br />

to play a key role in the revival<br />

of oil production.<br />

There is no formal definition of an<br />

“independent” in terms of assets or<br />

reserves, though when companies<br />

producing up to 3,500 b/d were<br />

exempted from petroleum production<br />

levy payment nine years ago, this<br />

was generally taken as an indication<br />

of independent status. It’s only a<br />

rough guide, however, because some<br />

“independent” upstreamers are already<br />

close to that level or beyond it.<br />

A more reliable definition of an<br />

independent in the Trinidad and Tobago<br />

context might be an operator which is<br />

not state-owned, and does not belong<br />

to a major international group like BHP<br />

Billiton or Repsol (oil), bpTT, BG T&T or<br />

EOG Resources (condensate).<br />

On that basis, independents were<br />

responsible for about 10,241 b/d of<br />

crude output on average in 2012, out of<br />

69,062 b/d from all companies (another<br />

12,673 b/d was condensate, taking the<br />

liquids total up to 81,735 b/d). Petrotrin’s<br />

contribution was 34,818 b/d (oil) from<br />

its onshore and offshore fields.<br />

Nobody is likely to challenge Petrotrin<br />

in the future, unless some major<br />

discovery of crude is made in deeper<br />

geological horizons or in the deep water.<br />

Petrotrin’s dominance is secure, given<br />

the extent of its acreage compared with<br />

that of the independents.<br />

But 10,241 b/d out of 69,062 b/d<br />

(almost 15%) is a good performance,<br />

when you consider that most of those<br />

companies are lifting crude from wells<br />

Petrotrin itself abandoned or from very<br />

small tracts of farmed-out land.<br />

18<br />

Energy<br />

issues<br />

A key contribution to<br />

oil revival<br />

Independents could be<br />

pioneers in the application<br />

of carbon dioxide<br />

(co2) injection for enhanced<br />

oil recovery<br />

There are about 17 independents<br />

active in the local petroleum sector<br />

today, occupying different niches. Some<br />

are lease operatorships (in 1989 Trintopec<br />

Companie<br />

independent of all, straddles the whole<br />

Countries<br />

handed over idle and low-producing<br />

wells to smaller independent operators<br />

who might do a better job with them).<br />

Others are farm-out operators, who have<br />

obtained larger areas on which to sink<br />

new wells if they want.<br />

Joint venture arrangements involve<br />

whole blocks, where the independent<br />

company is obliged to undertake seismic<br />

surveying and exploration. Incremental<br />

production service contractors are a new<br />

breed invented by Petrotrin in 2009 to<br />

help generate more production from<br />

its southeastern onshore fields, which<br />

had found themselves neglected over<br />

the years. There is also one standalone<br />

independent, Mora Oil Ventures<br />

(Moraven), which only operates<br />

offshore, not on land at all, unlike the<br />

rest of the independent sector.<br />

Trinity, shaping up to be the biggest<br />

spectrum, being simultaneously a lease<br />

operator, farm-out operator and joint<br />

venturer.<br />

All knowledgeable observers of the<br />

Trinidad and Tobago energy scene<br />

expect the independents to enlarge<br />

their contribution to crude production<br />

in the years ahead. Energy minister<br />

Kevin Ramnarine has begun regular<br />

meetings with the sector to hear and try<br />

to resolve its problems.<br />

David Borde, managing director of<br />

PetroCom Technologies, the company<br />

promoting a “smart pumping” system<br />

that could help independents improve<br />

well productivity, sees their role<br />

in oil revival as “absolutely critical”.<br />

Geologist Dr Krishna Persad, a farmout<br />

operator through his company<br />

KPA and Associates, has just acquired<br />

Trinidad Exploration and Development<br />

in southwest Trinidad, and strongly<br />

believes the independents could be<br />

pioneers in the application of carbon<br />

dioxide (CO 2 ) injection for enhanced oil<br />

recovery.<br />

Minister Ramnarine has mandated<br />

the National Gas Company to examine<br />

the feasibility of a CO 2 pipeline from<br />

the Point Lisas industrial estate to the<br />

oilfields of the southern basin.<br />

Trinity Exploration and Production<br />

is aiming for production of 5,000 b/d<br />

by the end of <strong>2013</strong>. Range Resources<br />

is targeting 4,000 b/d, and Touchstone<br />

Exploration 3,300 b/d.<br />

Independents were responsible for about 10,241<br />

b/d of crude output on average in 2012, out of<br />

69,062 b/d from all companies


Energy<br />

climate change<br />

issues<br />

What should the <strong>Caribbean</strong> do?<br />

Caricom’s 15 member nations have pledged to<br />

measure and reduce the level of greenhouse<br />

gas emissions in the region, in keeping with<br />

the Caricom Energy Policy (CEP). Targets will be<br />

influenced by Caricom’s “international obligations<br />

and voluntary commitments under the United Nations<br />

Framework Convention on Climate Change and the Alliance<br />

of Small Island States’ climate change negotiating strategy and<br />

objectives.”<br />

This initiative is part of the agenda of Caricom’s <strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

Sustainable Energy Road Map and Strategy (C-SERMS).<br />

Determining the baselines for greenhouse gas emissions<br />

has become more urgent with global emission levels reaching<br />

their highest point in over two million years. Carbon dioxide<br />

(CO 2 ) emissions, by far the major contributor to global<br />

warming, hit 400 parts per million in May, a jump of 85 ppm<br />

in 55 years.<br />

The world is now pumping 38.2 billion tons of CO 2 into the<br />

Compani<br />

atmosphere every year, China being the worst offender with<br />

10 billion. The United States, the second worst offender, has<br />

actually been lowering its CO 2 discharges, which are now<br />

down to 5.9 billion tons a year. The reasons are said to be the<br />

rapid switch to gas-fired power generation and the growth of<br />

fuel-efficient vehicles.<br />

The 400 ppm reading augurs badly for governments’ goal of<br />

holding the rise in average temperature below two degrees<br />

Celsius. Beyond that, it is feared that catastrophic warming<br />

becomes unstoppable, with all the predicted weather threats<br />

such as more intense hurricanes, rising sea levels, floods and<br />

drought.<br />

The <strong>Caribbean</strong>, being mainly composed of small island<br />

developing states, is more vulnerable to the results of global<br />

warming than most. Indeed, according to an Inter-American<br />

Development Bank survey, “extreme events” already cost<br />

US$135 billion in losses in <strong>14</strong> <strong>Caribbean</strong> countries between<br />

1970 and 2008.<br />

Some hoteliers in the region are seriously thinking of<br />

moving to higher ground because their beach locations leave<br />

them completely exposed to rising sea levels, flooding and<br />

storms.<br />

As noted elsewhere in this YEARBOOK, Caricom’s contribution<br />

to resisting global warming is to develop renewable energy<br />

sources and to use fossil fuels more efficiently. These are<br />

the twin pillars on which C-SERMS is mounted. But with the<br />

outlook for mitigation so bleak and Caricom’s likely effect on it<br />

so minuscule, the region will have to embrace climate change<br />

adaptation more vigorously.<br />

Countries<br />

and Tobago’s Institute of Marine Affairs is<br />

Trinidad developing a vulnerability and risk agreement for<br />

southwest Tobago based on climate change scenarios. The<br />

idea of moving hotels further inland could be one element<br />

of adaptation. The CEP focuses on adaptation initiatives in<br />

energy, particularly electricity, the key factor in regional states<br />

without indigenous oil or natural resources.<br />

Hurricanes can cause “catastrophic damage to the overhead<br />

transmission and distribution facilities in the region,” CEP points<br />

out, urging member states to “support the development and<br />

implementation of a regional rapid response strategy for the<br />

restoration of electricity facilities.”<br />

On the wider energy front, Caricom is supposed to create a<br />

plan for “maintaining regional reserves of crude oil and energy<br />

products to be accessecy or crisis.”<br />

Grenada is among those already seeking assistance from<br />

multilateral bodies for climate change adaptation. The German<br />

Agency for International Cooperation and the United Nations<br />

Development Programme are funding a four-year, US$6.5<br />

million programme to “increase the resilience of vulnerable<br />

communities and ecosystems to climate change risks through<br />

integrated adaptation approaches.”<br />

Contribution to climate<br />

change<br />

Trinidad and Tobago (2009)<br />

• CO 2 emissions per capita<br />

• CO 2 emissions per unit of GDP<br />

• Total CO 2 emissions<br />

• Breakdown:<br />

40 tonnes per person*<br />

1.9 kg per dollar*<br />

52 million tonnes**<br />

Petrochemical plants 58% Power generation 23%<br />

Landfill 7% Transport 6%<br />

Process emissions (oil & gas) 3% Agriculture 2%<br />

Domestic cooking 1%<br />

* second highest in the world that year<br />

** 54th highest in the world that year<br />

Source: Dr Donnie Boodlal, University of Trinidad and Tobago<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

19


local content<br />

Successive Trinidad and Tobago governments have<br />

tried to maximise local content in the energy<br />

sector, with varying degrees of success.<br />

The greatest progress has been made with<br />

support services for oil or gas exploration and<br />

development. But many of the 450 local service companies<br />

have complained that foreign service providers are<br />

being favoured in the current round of drilling activity by<br />

international companies.<br />

Local platform fabricating was a success story, and nine<br />

such structures were built at the La Brea fabrication yard<br />

between 2004 and 2010. But that activity seems to have<br />

come to a standstill, as companies opt for tying back new<br />

producing wells to existing platforms.<br />

Energy minister Kevin Ramnarine has spoken of his vision<br />

for Trinidad and Tobago as “a major international energy<br />

services hub.” This will require the “structured development<br />

of local companies along the entire value chain of the<br />

energy sector, from the upstream to the midstream to the<br />

downstream and possibly even beyond that.”<br />

With the lack of work at home, some local services firms<br />

have already expanded internationally, especially in their<br />

own region and more recently to African states such as Ghana<br />

and Nigeria. The ministry is anxious to establish relations<br />

with countries entering the oil and gas business.<br />

Explorationists and producers are urged by the ministry<br />

to use as much local content as feasible; so are major<br />

downstream gas-based industrial plants. Construction of<br />

Atlantic’s LNG trains was a landmark in this regard; a budget<br />

was agreed for the amount of work to be awarded to local<br />

contractors.<br />

Legislation may be forthcoming to enforce a percentage<br />

of local content in all energy projects. The energy<br />

ministry says it is currently reviewing the local content and<br />

local participation policy and framework, prepared as long<br />

ago as 2004, “which will guide the way for the drafting of<br />

local content legislation.” This “will seek to strengthen the<br />

existing local content policy, while allowing for consistent<br />

application” reflects the importance placed on local content<br />

20<br />

Energy<br />

issues<br />

Government may prescribe<br />

level of local input<br />

Companie<br />

The government should “enact<br />

into law the local content policy<br />

for the oil and gas industry as<br />

soon as possible”<br />

in the ministry’s 2012-2016 strategic plan.<br />

The ministry has a broad definition of local content in<br />

the energy sector, encompassing not only firms offering<br />

traditional services like drilling, cementing, casing, open hole<br />

logging, wireline, coil tubing and so on, but also companies<br />

involved in upstream oil and gas exploration, production<br />

Countries<br />

and finance.<br />

Locally-owned upstream “independents” have been<br />

disappearing in recent times, on the back of take-overs by<br />

foreign firms, an area that may need special attention.<br />

Lennox Sirjuesingh, president of the Trinidad and Tobago<br />

Local Content Chamber, formed in early 2011 primarily<br />

to promote more local involvement in energy, regards<br />

legislation as long overdue. He has called on the government<br />

to “enact into law the local content policy for the oil and gas<br />

industry as soon as possible.”<br />

The allocation of gas for downstream use is also being used<br />

as a tool to encourage the wider embrace of local content.<br />

Early in the life of the present government, the ministry laid<br />

out a gas allocation policy in which local content accounted<br />

for 15 points out of 100 when an applicant’s eligibility for a<br />

gas supply was scored.<br />

Local content in gas-based activity was defined in relation<br />

to ownership, local debt/equity financing, engineering<br />

design, feasibility studies, project management, technical<br />

skills, the number of permanent jobs per unit of capex,<br />

number of permanent jobs for operations, peak employment<br />

during construction, and average employment during<br />

construction.<br />

Legislation may be forthcoming to enforce a percentage of local content in<br />

all energy projects


Energy<br />

GAS-BASED DEVELOPMENT<br />

issues<br />

Will there be enough gas<br />

for everyone?<br />

Trinidad and Tobago’s gas-based heavy industrial<br />

development programme has been in abeyance<br />

since the opening of Methanol Holdings’ ammoniaurea-melamine<br />

1 plant at Point Lisas in 2010. But it is<br />

springing back to life in <strong>2013</strong>, with a number of new<br />

projects identified and moving forward.<br />

The only question hanging over this resurgence is whether<br />

there will be enough gas to service all the new entrants.<br />

The most recent Ryder Scott audit (2011) identified 13.2<br />

trillion cubic feet (tcf) of proven gas reserves, which are almost<br />

all spoken for by the existing petrochemical and steel industries<br />

at Point Lisas and the four LNG trains at Point Fortin. Another 6<br />

tcf of probable gas reserves could be transferred to the proven<br />

category with minimal drilling and reservoir reappraisal.<br />

Compani<br />

The “unrisked exploratory resources” of 30.4 tcf are probably<br />

the best insurance for the future. As Ryder Scott’s managing<br />

senior vice president, Herman Acuna, points out: “This shows<br />

upside potential for gas and sustainability of supply, which is<br />

really what you should be looking at.”<br />

Energy minister Kevin Ramnarine takes a bullish view of<br />

the matter, pointing to bpTT’s discovery of around 1 tcf of<br />

new gas with its Savonette 4 well in late 2012, which doubled<br />

the recoverable reserves in the field to 2 tcf. He expects the<br />

2012 gas reserves audit to be “positively impacted” by this<br />

development.<br />

The largest of the forthcoming projects is the Mitsubishi/<br />

Neal and Massy Holdings methanol to dimethyl ether plant.<br />

Ramnarine has confirmed that “the Ministry of Energy and<br />

Energy Affairs and the National Gas Company are in dialogue<br />

with an established natural gas supplier in Trinidad and Tobago<br />

who has advised that it could have gas available by 2016.”<br />

The projects spearheading the revival of gas-linked industrial<br />

development are:<br />

Methanol-to-DME<br />

The US$800 million Mitsubishi/Neal and Massy Holdings plant<br />

will convert 100 mmcfd of gas into one million tonnes a year<br />

(t/y) of methanol, of which <strong>14</strong>0,000 t/y will be diverted to the<br />

production of dimethyl ether (DME), a versatile chemical that<br />

can be used in power generation, transport, cooking and<br />

heating, among other things.<br />

It is considered a major move in the ministry’s policy of going<br />

as far as possible downstream in the gas-based chemical chain.<br />

(This was also the case with AUM 1, which delivered melamine<br />

Countries<br />

for a range of light manufacturing applications.)<br />

The government has been offered a 20% share in the<br />

methanol/DME project and has agreed to buy the <strong>14</strong>0,000 t/y<br />

of DME at cost price, to supply to investors who want to use<br />

it in connection with other investments. Mitsubishi, Neal and<br />

Massy and the other shareholders will make their money in the<br />

methanol market.<br />

Formaldehyde/Melanine<br />

This Chemtech cluster will obtain formaldehyde from methanol<br />

and melamine from ammonia, justifying its gas-based status on<br />

those grounds. It is envisaged as a US$200 million investment.<br />

The downstream products will be melamine-based resin,<br />

oriented strand board and veneer.<br />

Steel<br />

Neal and Massy Holdings and Metal Dom (of the Dominican<br />

Republic) propose a steel plant and rolling mill that will require<br />

45-55 mmcfd of gas for heating purposes. The estimated cost is<br />

US$116 million. The plant will produce billets, reinforced bars,<br />

flats and angles, a very diversified range for a <strong>Caribbean</strong> steel<br />

plant.<br />

LNG<br />

The Gasfin (Luxembourg)/National Energy Corporation “midscale”<br />

LNG plant at La Brea, southwest Trinidad, will cost US$400<br />

million, with a 500,000 tonne-a-year capacity; it will need about<br />

70 mmcfd of gas. It has been named Project Constantine after<br />

Trinidad and Tobago’s late legendary cricketer.<br />

One major downstream initiative has been temporarily<br />

delayed: MHTL’s AUM 2, the successor to AUM 1. This is a<br />

larger project than its predecessor – 595,350 t/y of ammonia,<br />

903,900 t/y of urea, 33,000 t/y of ammonium sulphate and<br />

39,600 t/y of melamine. It has been costed at US$1.9 billion.<br />

A final investment decision has been held up by a dispute<br />

between the government (now the majority holder since<br />

it assumed ownership of the 56.53% formerly held by C L<br />

Financial) and the minority 43.47% shareholder Consolidated<br />

Energy, a consortium of three German firms, MAN Ferrostaal,<br />

Helm and Proman. The matter has gone to arbitration. A<br />

resolution is expected before the end of <strong>2013</strong>.<br />

Another potential downstream project has been abandoned.<br />

Saudi Arabia’s SABIC and China’s Sinopec formed a joint venture<br />

but failed to reach an agreement with the government on gas<br />

pricing and supply. The partners were to have invested in two<br />

major complexes. Methanol to olefins would have opened<br />

the way to the production of propylene, polypropylene and<br />

plastics, while methanol to petrochemicals would have led to<br />

acetic acid, acetic anhydride and pharmaceuticals like asprin.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

21


Countries<br />

trinidad and tobago<br />

A year of heavy drilling<br />

In <strong>2013</strong> Trinidad and Tobago’s energy sector should<br />

experience its busiest year for a very long time. Hundreds<br />

of millions of dollars will be spent drilling over 100 wells of<br />

all types – exploratory, developmental and recompletions,<br />

plus workovers to keep declining wells flowing.<br />

Virtually every company has plunged into a drilling<br />

programme, including bpTT, BG, Repsol, EOG Resources and<br />

Centrica Energy. Niko Resources and Parex will be sinking<br />

wells, as will Petrotrin, which intends to be busy both onshore<br />

and in its Gulf of Paria Trinmar unit.<br />

Large companies<br />

• BPTT says it may drill another appraisal well in the<br />

Savonette producing field, where it found a trillion cubic<br />

feet (tcf) of proven reserves in November 2012, to see if it<br />

can bump that up even further.<br />

• BG Trinidad and Tobago is launching its four-well<br />

development drilling programme for the Starfish discovery.<br />

• EOG Resources will be drilling one exploration and three<br />

development wells in its Osprey field in block 4a.<br />

• Centrica Energy, which so far has no production of its own<br />

in Trinidad and Tobago, is sinking an appraisal well to its<br />

Cassra discovery in block 22 north of Tobago, as well as<br />

drilling an exploratory well, Jasmine, in its NCMA 4 block<br />

and an appraisal well to the Iris discovery.<br />

Drilling in Fyzabad (courtesy Petrotrin)<br />

• Repsol says it will drill two appraisal wells and six in-fill<br />

wells in its Teak/Samaan/Poui block offshore Trinidad’s east<br />

coast.<br />

• Petrotrin, already the country’s largest single crude<br />

producer, is expected to drill 25 development and<br />

enhanced oil recovery wells onshore, while undertaking<br />

rig workovers to bring back on line as many as possible of<br />

the 57 wells still shut-in in its most productive Trinmar field,<br />

South West Soldado.<br />

• BHP Billiton has the dubious distinction of being the only<br />

large company not sinking any wells in <strong>2013</strong>, though it<br />

will be signing off on the four deep water blocks it was<br />

awarded in the 2012 deep water bid round, TTDAA 5-6 and<br />

TTDAA 28-29. It will then have to start a work programme,<br />

which will include seismic acquisition and exploratory<br />

drilling in subsequent years.<br />

Medium/small foreign and local companies<br />

• Trinity Exploration and Production, mainly locally-owned<br />

but a member of the Alternative Investment Market in<br />

London, plans four exploratory wells split between its Point<br />

Ligoure/Guapo Bay/Brighton Marine acreage in the Gulf<br />

and its newly-acquired Galeota block off the southeast<br />

coast, taken over from the former Bayfield Energy, plus 12<br />

development wells onshore and eight in Galeota.<br />

• Touchstone Exploration, working through its subsidiary,<br />

Territorial, plans 16 development wells in its various land<br />

blocks plus 2 recompletions.<br />

• Range Resources will be drilling in all three of its licences:<br />

Morne Diablo (40 wells), South Quarry (up to 10 wells) and<br />

Beach Marcelle (6 existing wells to be deepened).<br />

• Leni Gas and Oil will drill one exploratory well in Moruga<br />

North and two development wells in Goudron.<br />

• Niko Resources will embark on its NCMA 2 block work<br />

programme with one exploratory well<br />

• Parex is supposed to begin its own exploration with one<br />

exploratory hole in the Central Range Shallow and Deep<br />

blocks and an appraisal well to its Snowcap discovery in<br />

the Moruga E block.<br />

Besides this extensive drilling activity, two block auctions<br />

are expected in <strong>2013</strong>, for three blocks on land and for more<br />

acreage in the deep water.<br />

Two bid rounds in the same year are rare, but the country<br />

needs to identify new crude reserves to stop the haemorrhage<br />

in oil production, and also needs new gas reserves to<br />

underpin the heavy industrial development programme – and<br />

continuous exploration activity is the only way of doing it.<br />

22


Countries<br />

TT energy profile<br />

Crude oil<br />

production<br />

(average b/d)<br />

1970 39,855<br />

1971 129,041<br />

1972 <strong>14</strong>0,273<br />

1973 166,301<br />

1974 186,575<br />

1975 215,342<br />

1976 212,876<br />

1977 229,041<br />

1978 229,589<br />

1979 2<strong>14</strong>,246<br />

1980 212,057<br />

1981 189,335<br />

1982 177,038<br />

1983 159,845<br />

1984 169,513<br />

1985 176,052<br />

1987 155,180<br />

1988 150,829<br />

1989 134,051<br />

1990 151,194<br />

1991 <strong>14</strong>5,395<br />

1992 137,057<br />

1993 124,604<br />

1994 131,532<br />

1995 130,574<br />

1996 129,011<br />

1997 123,881<br />

1998 122,794<br />

1999 125,332<br />

2000 119,432<br />

2001 113,959<br />

2002 130,906<br />

2003 134,865<br />

2004 123,902<br />

2005 <strong>14</strong>4,339<br />

2006 <strong>14</strong>4,266<br />

2007 121,754<br />

2008 1<strong>14</strong>,634<br />

2009 107,169<br />

2010 98,246<br />

2011 91,919<br />

2012 81,735<br />

<strong>ENERGY</strong> SECTOR<br />

Share of GDP 45.2% (2011)<br />

of which<br />

Exploration and production 19.2%<br />

Refining (inc. LNG) 7.6%<br />

Petrochemicals 12.7%<br />

Others (energy services, etc) 5.7%<br />

Share of government revenue 57.5% (2011)<br />

of which<br />

Oil/gas exploration and production 47.5%<br />

Other taxes (royalties, oil impost, &c) 10.0%<br />

Share of merchandise exports receipts 85.4% (2009)<br />

of which<br />

Extracted (crude oil) 12.9%<br />

Refined (inc. LNG, natural gas liquids) 62.9%<br />

Processed (inc. petrochemicals) 9.6%<br />

Share of total employment 3% (2011)<br />

Share of bank credit (2010)<br />

Loans and advances<br />

TT$1.4 billion<br />

Percentage of total 3.1%<br />

<strong>ENERGY</strong> RESERVES<br />

Oil (2007)<br />

Proven<br />

Probable<br />

Possible<br />

Natural gas (2011)<br />

Proven<br />

Probable<br />

Possible<br />

Unrisked exploratory resources<br />

317.9 million barrels<br />

119.3 million barrels<br />

1,046 million barrels (inc. tar sands)<br />

13.2 trillion cubic feet (tcf)<br />

6.0 tcf<br />

6.1 tcf<br />

30.4 tcf<br />

Production (2010)<br />

Crude oil/condensate<br />

35.8 million barrels<br />

Crude oil imports<br />

24.9 million barrels<br />

Refinery throughput<br />

46.1 million barrels<br />

Refinery output<br />

44.0 million barrels<br />

Capacity utilisation<br />

77% (capacity 165,000 b/d)<br />

Natural gas production<br />

4.3 billion cubic feet daily (bn cfd)<br />

Natural gas sales<br />

4.0 bn cfd<br />

of which petrochemicals<br />

1.1 bn cfd<br />

Electricity generation<br />

293 million cubic feet daily (mmcfd)<br />

LNG<br />

2.3 bn cfd<br />

Natural gas liquids production 17.2 million barrels (mm b)<br />

Exports<br />

16.9 mm b<br />

Ammonia production 6.2 million tonnes (mm t)<br />

Exports<br />

5.9 mm t<br />

Methanol production<br />

5.9 mm t<br />

Exports<br />

5.9 mm t<br />

Sources: Central Bank Annual Economic Survey (2011), MEEA Draft Green Paper on energy<br />

policy (unpublished), <strong>ENERGY</strong> <strong>Caribbean</strong> archives<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

23


OPEN<br />

0 500,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

2,000,000<br />

ST VINCENT<br />

BEQUIA<br />

CANOUAN<br />

UNION<br />

MAYREAU<br />

1,500,000<br />

CARRIACOU<br />

GRENADA<br />

TTDAA 30<br />

89879 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 31<br />

94092 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 32<br />

113043 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

-2000<br />

TTDAA 24<br />

112042 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 25<br />

100086 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 26<br />

100086 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 27<br />

100086 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 28<br />

101609 Ha<br />

BHP Billiton Petroleum Ltd<br />

1,000,000<br />

-1000<br />

BLOCK 21<br />

132015 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

OPEN<br />

30783 Ha<br />

-400<br />

BLOCK 22<br />

CENTRICA / PETROTRIN<br />

BLOCK 23(a)<br />

259908 Ha<br />

BPEOC<br />

OPEN<br />

44254 Ha<br />

TRINIDAD & TOBAGO & VENEZUELA<br />

NCMA 2<br />

101,931.8 Ha<br />

NIKO RESOURCES (CARIBBEAN) LIMITED / RWE Dea AG/<br />

PETROTRIN<br />

NCMA 4<br />

NCMA 1<br />

BGTT /CENTRICA /<br />

1<br />

EMI<br />

182,946.2 Ha<br />

CENTRICA <strong>ENERGY</strong><br />

Scarborough<br />

NCMA 3 NCMA 5<br />

210,622.5 Ha<br />

231,098.8 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

NIKO RESOURCES/<br />

PETROTRIN<br />

TOBAGO<br />

-400<br />

-1000<br />

BLOCK 23(b)<br />

257920 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

BLOCK 24<br />

3401<strong>14</strong> Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

500,000<br />

VENEZUELA<br />

BLOCK<br />

1(a)<br />

INTERNATIONAL BOUNDARY<br />

CENTRICA /<br />

PETROTRIN<br />

TRINMAR<br />

LINE BETWEEN<br />

PETROTRIN<br />

20 579 Ha<br />

4<br />

OPEN<br />

3<br />

BLOCK 1(b)<br />

CENTRICA /<br />

PETROTRIN<br />

BLOCK 1(b)<br />

5<br />

4<br />

2<br />

Port of Spain<br />

OPEN<br />

TRINIDAD<br />

PAREX / VOYAGER / PETROTRIN<br />

San<br />

Fernando<br />

CENTRAL<br />

BLOCK<br />

CENTRAL RANGE<br />

BLOCK<br />

BGTT<br />

8<br />

8<br />

8<br />

8<br />

TNA<br />

BLOCK 2(ab)<br />

133,504 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

9<br />

(B)<br />

10<br />

10<br />

(A)<br />

11<br />

OPEN<br />

40048 Ha<br />

12<br />

bpTT/ REPSOL<br />

BLOCK 3(a)<br />

13<br />

bpTT/ REPSOL<br />

<strong>14</strong><br />

OPEN<br />

74345 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

5736<br />

Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

96<strong>14</strong> Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

74345 Ha<br />

BLOCK 3(b)<br />

64513 Ha<br />

BLOCK 4(a)<br />

EOG RESOURCES<br />

PRIMERA<br />

CHEVRON<br />

6(b)<br />

OPEN<br />

16 17<br />

BGTT / CHEVRON<br />

BLOCK 4 (b)<br />

75328 Ha<br />

NIKO RESOURCES<br />

(CARIBBEAN) LIMITED<br />

BLOCK<br />

5(c)<br />

BGTT<br />

SONDE<br />

RESOURCES<br />

CORP<br />

BLOCK 5 (d)<br />

68420 Ha<br />

BLOCK 25(a)<br />

138860 Ha<br />

BG<br />

INTERNATIONAL<br />

Plc<br />

OPEN<br />

BLOCK 25(b)<br />

139129 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

BLOCK 26<br />

119569 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

BLOCK 27<br />

117915 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

6<br />

7<br />

SOUTH MARINE<br />

52384 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

NIKO<br />

VOYAGER <strong>ENERGY</strong><br />

(TRINIDAD) LIMITED<br />

PETROTRIN<br />

bpTT/ REPSOL<br />

NGC/PETROTRIN 15<br />

EOG RESOURCES<br />

bpTT/ REPSOL<br />

BLOCK 6(d)<br />

BGTT /<br />

CHEVRON<br />

18<br />

LOWER REVERSE 'L'<br />

36378 Ha<br />

0<br />

VENEZUELA<br />

OPEN<br />

0 500,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

BLOCKS 2010/2011 DEEP WATER BID ROUND<br />

BLOCKS 2012 DEEP WATER BID ROUND<br />

BLOCKS <strong>2013</strong> DEEP WATER BID ROUND<br />

Geographical positions are based<br />

on the Clarke 1858 Spheroid.<br />

Cassini Grid Coordinates are in links.<br />

Geographical Coordinates of Origin:<br />

Latitude 10° 26' 30" N<br />

Longitude 61° 20' 00" W.<br />

24


1,500,000<br />

2,000,000<br />

2,000,000<br />

TTDAA 29<br />

100195 Ha<br />

BHP Billiton Petroleum Ltd<br />

Block BLOCK OPERATOR LICENSEE<br />

BARBADOS 1 Block_9 BGTT PETROTRIN<br />

2 EAST_BRIGHTON_A SOOGL SOOGL 65%_PRIMERA 35%<br />

EAST BRIGHTON B SOOGL SOOGL 45.5%/ PETROTRIN 30%/ PRIMERA 24.5%<br />

3 BRIGHTON MARINE TRINITY EXPL. AND PROD. TRINITY EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION / PETROTRIN<br />

4 POINT LIGOURE TRINITY EXPL. AND PROD. TRINITY EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION / PETROTRIN<br />

5 SOUTH WEST PENINSULA TED TED / PETROTRIN<br />

6 ISLOTE BAY TED TED<br />

7 ERIN BAY TED TED<br />

8 Area_b PETROTRIN PETROTRIN<br />

9 MAYARO_GUAYAGUAYARE BAY NIKO RESOURCES NIKO RESOURCES / PETROTRIN<br />

10 GALEOTA TRINITY EXPL. AND PROD. TRINITY EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION / PETROTRIN<br />

11 GALEOTA RIDGE MORAVEN MORAVEN<br />

12 2c BHP BHP 45%/ TOTAL 30%/CHAOYANG (CNOOC 12.5%, SINOPEC 12.5%)<br />

13 3a BHP BHP 25.5%/KERR MCGEE 25.5%/CHAOYANG(CNOOC 12.75%,<br />

SINOPEC 12.75%)/PETROTRIN 15%/TOTAL 8.5%<br />

<strong>14</strong> MODIFIED U (a) EOG EOG<br />

15 MODIFIED U (b) EOG EOG<br />

16 BLOCK E BGTT BGTT/CHEVRON<br />

17 BLOCK 5(a) BGTT BGTT/CHEVRON<br />

18 BLOCK 5(b) bpTT bpTT/REPSOL<br />

19 NORTH MARINE PETROTRIN PETROTRIN<br />

-2000<br />

-3000<br />

-4000<br />

1,500,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

TTDAA <strong>14</strong><br />

99808 Ha<br />

BPEOC<br />

TTDAA 15<br />

98632 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 16<br />

99336 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 11<br />

100150 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 12<br />

100057 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 13<br />

100052 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 17<br />

101198 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 20<br />

101537 Ha<br />

TTDAA 8<br />

99809 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 9<br />

99349 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 10<br />

99337 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 18<br />

101153 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 22<br />

105227 Ha<br />

TTDAA 23<br />

91<strong>14</strong>2 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 4<br />

100185 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 6<br />

99747 Ha<br />

BHP Billiton Petroleum Ltd<br />

TTDAA 7<br />

99783 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 19<br />

102917 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 21<br />

101194 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

500,000<br />

TTDAA 2<br />

104755 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 5<br />

109559 Ha<br />

BHP Billiton Petroleum Ltd<br />

TTDAA 3<br />

109722 Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

TTDAA 1<br />

1192<strong>14</strong> Ha<br />

OPEN<br />

Scale<br />

10<br />

0<br />

10<br />

20<br />

25 Ml.<br />

10<br />

0 10<br />

20<br />

30<br />

40 Km.<br />

0<br />

1,500,000 Lk.<br />

2,000,000 Lk.<br />

2,500,000 Lk.<br />

Rectangular Coordinates of Origin:<br />

Easting = 430,000 Links.<br />

Northing = 325,000 Links.<br />

Water depth contour in metres<br />

GOVERNMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO<br />

MINISTRY OF <strong>ENERGY</strong> AND <strong>ENERGY</strong> AFFAIRS<br />

UPSTREAM ACTIVITY MAP<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong> 25


trinidad and tobago<br />

Energy timeline<br />

Countries<br />

Early years<br />

1857 First oil well drilled by Merrimac near La Brea<br />

1866 First successful well drilled by Walter Darwent<br />

1902-7<br />

Successful wells drilled in Guayaguayare by Randolph Rust<br />

and John Lee Lum<br />

1908 Commercial oil production begins at La Brea<br />

1910 First export shipment of crude oil<br />

1911 Small refinery build at Brighton<br />

1917 Refinery built at Pointe-à-Pierre<br />

1930 First crude oil imports for local refining<br />

1933 First enhanced oil recovery at Forest Reserve<br />

1937 Labour protests<br />

Development<br />

1953 First commercial use of gas, for power generation<br />

1953 Marine exploration off southeast coast by Dominion Oil<br />

1954 Apex Oil Company drills to 16,155 feet in Fyzabad<br />

1955 Non-associated natural gas discovered on land<br />

1955 First offshore production, in Soldado field in Gulf of Paria<br />

1956 Texaco buys Pointe-à-Pierre refinery from Trinidad Leaseholds<br />

1959<br />

WR Grace subsidiary Federation Chemicals uses BP gas for<br />

petrochemical production<br />

1961 First exploration off Trinidad’s east coast<br />

1967 Peak oil production on land – 111,883 b/d<br />

The gas age<br />

1968 e east coast by Amoco<br />

1968 Peak oil production off the west coast – 76,948 b/d<br />

1968 First seismic survey off the north coast<br />

1969 Amoco finds commercial quantities of oil off the east coast<br />

1969 Government takes over BP’s land fields with Tesoro<br />

1970 Tesoro finds oil off the southeast coast<br />

1970 First competitive bidding for offshore blocks<br />

1971 Natural gas discovered off the north coast<br />

1972 Commercial oil production from Amoco’s Teak field<br />

1972 National Petroleum launched to take over BP’s gas stations<br />

1972<br />

Delta Exploration acquires speculative 2D seismic survey over<br />

northern Gulf of Paria and east coast of Trinidad<br />

1974<br />

First large-scale commercial gas production, from Amoco’s<br />

Teak field off the east coast; reserves estimated at 1.1 trillion<br />

cubic feet<br />

Expansion<br />

Trintoc created as the government’s first upstream and refining<br />

1974 company after purchase of Shell’s oilfields and Point Fortin<br />

refinery<br />

1974 16-inch, 24-mile pipeline brings gas ashore from east coast fields<br />

1975 National Gas Company (NGC) established<br />

1977<br />

Gas-based industrial development begins at Point Lisas with<br />

Tringen ammonia plant<br />

1977<br />

South East Coast Consortium (SECC) makes first east coast gas<br />

discovery since Amoco in 1968<br />

1977 24-inch, 40-mile pipeline increases transmission capacity<br />

1978 Peak east coast oil production – 139,163 b/d<br />

1978 Peak national oil production – 240,000 b/d<br />

1978 First marine platforms built locally and installed off southeast coast<br />

Heavy industry<br />

1980 Government-owned ISCOTT steel plant established at Point Lisas<br />

1981 FERTRIN ammonia plant at Point Lisas (government holds 51%)<br />

1983 Government establishes urea plant at Point Lisas<br />

1983 Amoco’s giant Cassia gas field comes on stream<br />

1983 Government builds new 30-inch, 40-mile offshore gas line<br />

1983<br />

South West Soldado oilfield off west coast is estimated at 100<br />

million barrels<br />

1984 First methanol plant established at Point Lisas (government-owned)<br />

1985 Government buys Tesoro, which becomes Trintopec<br />

1985<br />

Government acquires Texaco’s land fields and Pointe-à-Pierre<br />

refinery, amalgamating operations with Trintoc<br />

1986 First compressed natural gas available as motor fuel<br />

1987 Last well drilled in the Northern Basin to 7,700 feet in Claxton Bay<br />

1989<br />

1989<br />

1990<br />

Rationalisation<br />

Lease operatorship/farmout programme introduced by<br />

Trintopec<br />

British Gas takes over Tenneco’s international assets and enters<br />

Trinidad and Tobago<br />

Government-owned Trintomar starts gas production from<br />

Pelican field in SECC<br />

26


1991<br />

Phoenix Park Gas Processors pioneers large-scale gas liquids<br />

extraction<br />

1992 Unsuccessful exploration off south coast<br />

1992 NGC takes over National Energy Corporation<br />

1993<br />

CL Financial establishes <strong>Caribbean</strong> Methanol at Point Lisas –<br />

first fully-owned private sector gas-based petrochemical plant<br />

1993<br />

Unsuccessful exploration in deeper zones on land by Exxonled<br />

Southern Basin Consortium<br />

1993 First production-sharing contract, with BG/Texaco<br />

1993 Enron invited to salvage SECC block as a natural gas producing unit<br />

1993<br />

Product-related pricing system for natural gas sales<br />

introduced: major factor in gas monetisation success<br />

1993<br />

Petrotrin created to bring all government upstream assets<br />

under one company<br />

1994<br />

First oil company listed on Trinidad and Tobago stock<br />

exchange (Moraven Holdings)<br />

1994<br />

Amoco drills first horizontal well off southeast coast – 2,477<br />

feet through 40-foot thick sands at 8,000 feet depth<br />

1996<br />

BG/Texaco begin supplying gas to NGC from east coast<br />

Dolphin field<br />

Gas eclipses oil<br />

1996<br />

Natural gas production overtakes oil, marking shift from an oil<br />

to a gas economy<br />

1998 Amoco’s Trinidad and Tobago assets acquired by BP Group<br />

1999 Petrotrin forms alliances to boost activity in undeveloped acreage<br />

1999<br />

Trinidad and Tobago becomes the only LNG producer in Latin<br />

America/<strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

1999<br />

Shell drills first of eight wells in deep water; Exxon and BP<br />

follow suit. No oil discovered<br />

2000<br />

NGC’s natural gas sales top one billion standard cubic feet a<br />

day for the first time<br />

2001<br />

BHP Billiton makes first east coast offshore oil discovery since<br />

Amoco in 1968 with Kairi and Canteen wells<br />

2001<br />

Second non-associated gas find on land, by Vintage in the<br />

Central Block<br />

2002<br />

BG drills deepest deviated wells, to 22,000 feet in Hibiscus<br />

field off the north coast<br />

2002 BPTT commits to maximum local content upstream<br />

2002<br />

BPTT installs world’s largest offshore gas processing unit off<br />

southeast coas<br />

2003 NGC’s profit crosses TT$1 billion<br />

2003 Natural gas production off north coast by BG and partners<br />

Record breaking<br />

2004<br />

World’s first mega-methanol plant commissioned at Point<br />

Lisas for Atlas Methanol<br />

2004<br />

National Energy Corporation responsible for gas-based<br />

investment projects, industrial sites and harbours<br />

2004<br />

Petrotrin given automatic position in all exploration/<br />

production arrangements with foreign companies<br />

2005 NGC invests in upstream gas development<br />

2005<br />

World’s largest LNG train – Atlantic train 4, with a capacity of<br />

5.2 million tones a year – begins production at Point Fortin<br />

2005<br />

World’s largest methanol plant – locally-controlled Methanol<br />

5000 – comes on stream<br />

2005 Government increases royalty on gas exported by bpTT to 10%<br />

2005<br />

Cross-border gas reserves confirmed by Chevron in block 2<br />

and Venezuela’s Plataforma Deltana<br />

Declining oil<br />

BPTT’s Ibis Deep, the deepest vertical well ever sunk in<br />

2006 Trinidad and Tobago, reaches 19,068 feet in SECC block but<br />

fails to find hydrocarbons<br />

2006<br />

Government stiffens PSC terms to add a direct tax element,<br />

which does not go down well with oil companies<br />

2006 Unsuccessful eight-block ultra-deepwater auction<br />

2006<br />

BHP Billiton in block 3a makes first oil discovery since Kairi<br />

and Canteen in 2001<br />

2006 NGC inaugurates largest gas pipeline in the western hemisphere<br />

2007<br />

Eastern <strong>Caribbean</strong> gas pipeline given formal go-ahead by first<br />

customer, Barbados<br />

2007<br />

New gas discoveries in offshore blocks 5c (southeast coast)<br />

and 22 (north of Tobago)<br />

2007<br />

Venezuela’s PetroCaribe deferred-payment and soft loan<br />

initiative threatens Trinidad and Tobago’s markets<br />

2007<br />

Cross-border natural gas estimated at 10 tcf, of which 27% is<br />

on the Trinidad side<br />

2007<br />

8.39MW demonstration methanol-fired power plant<br />

established at Point Lisas<br />

2008 Global economic recession<br />

Petrotrin refinery upgrade; revised fiscal arrangements; new<br />

2010 exploration block auction; Tobago supplied with gas directly from<br />

Angostura field; concern over continued decline in oil production<br />

Eleven blocks offered in deep water auction, only two bids<br />

2011 successful – for 23a and TTDAA <strong>14</strong>, both to BP Exploration<br />

Operating Co.<br />

Proven non-associated natural gas reserves downgraded to<br />

2011 13.46 tcf by Ryder Scott consultants, the seventh straight year<br />

of decline<br />

2011<br />

Sales missions to Ghana, Suriname and Brazil by energy<br />

service companies breaking into international markets<br />

2012<br />

First PSCs for ultra-deep blocks signed with BP Exploration<br />

Operating Co. for 23a and TTDAA <strong>14</strong> from 2010 bid round<br />

2012 PSC for block 5d signed with BG Group, 5 tcf of gas resources predicted<br />

2012<br />

Six blocks offered in 2012 deep water round; BHP Billiton<br />

awarded four of them – TTDAA 5-6, 28-29<br />

Centrica Energy continues negotiation with Puerto Rico<br />

2012 Electric Power Authority (Prepa) for supply of gas from<br />

Trinidad in pioneering marine CNG form<br />

2012<br />

Beowulf Energy/First Reserve, joint majority owners of Eastern<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> Gas Pipeline Co., confirm pipeline gas supply to Barbados<br />

2012<br />

Trinidad and Tobago and Grenada sign framework agreement<br />

on energy cooperation<br />

2012<br />

Fiscal incentives for development of small oilfields offshore<br />

and deep horizon drilling.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

27


Countries<br />

suriname<br />

Keen interest in the<br />

deepwater blocks<br />

Suriname is billing itself as the<br />

“next giant”, meaning that<br />

in due course it expects to<br />

make a discovery as large as<br />

Zaedyus in next-door French<br />

Guiana.<br />

In late 2011, 840 million barrels<br />

of oil on a P10 basis were found<br />

by the Zaedyus well, which has<br />

transformed prospects for the Guyana/<br />

Suriname basin to the west. Zaedyus<br />

encountered oil in a fan system similar<br />

to that found in Tullow Oil’s Jubilee<br />

field offshore Ghana in West Africa:<br />

Zaedyus discover off French Guiana (courtesy Tullow)<br />

Suriname is naturally hoping these geological<br />

conditions extend westwards into its own waters<br />

Tullow’s geologists thought this could<br />

be replicated on the western side of<br />

the Atlantic – and so it proved. Shell<br />

and Northpet Investments are Tullow’s<br />

partners in the Guyana Maritime<br />

licence where Zaedyus was drilled.<br />

Suriname is naturally hoping<br />

these geological conditions extend<br />

westwards into its own waters (Guyana<br />

is keeping its fingers crossed that<br />

its own offshore may be similarly<br />

favoured).<br />

Suriname’s national energy company<br />

Staatsolie, which deals with oil and gas<br />

matters on behalf of the government,<br />

has offered four blocks for bidding,<br />

which it believes to be in the path of<br />

any westward hydrocarbon trend – 54,<br />

55, 56 and 57. Bids close on July 26 and<br />

the company hopes to be able to sign<br />

production sharing contracts with the<br />

winners by year’s end.<br />

These blocks are sited in the<br />

Demerara Plateau, described by<br />

Staatsolie as “a prominent submarine<br />

plateau located 5 degrees north of<br />

the coasts of Suriname and French<br />

Guiana and, based on available data,<br />

interpreted as a margin segment,<br />

comprising thinned continental crust,<br />

bound to the north and south by<br />

transform-type zones in which transtensional<br />

extension is accommodated.”<br />

That will be music to the ears of<br />

geologists. Wim Dwarkasing, deputy<br />

director of exploration and production<br />

contracts for Staatsolie, enthuses<br />

that “these blocks are all based on<br />

structures and the success rate is<br />

usually higher with such blocks.” He<br />

adds: “The Demerara Plateau is all part<br />

of what you have seen on the west<br />

coast of Africa where they have had<br />

these very good finds, so that’s also an<br />

attractive feature of the bid round.”<br />

28


135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST oly line<br />

135 P0COAST oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST oly line<br />

135 10 P0COAST<br />

ol<br />

y lin<br />

e<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

P0COAST 135 oly linle<br />

ine<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly l i ne<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST oly line<br />

P0COAST<br />

135 oly l ine<br />

135 P0COAST oly n135 P0COAST<br />

0eol<br />

y li<br />

n<br />

e<br />

135 P0COAST oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

P0COAST<br />

135 oly line<br />

135 0P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

P0COAST<br />

135 oly line<br />

P0COAST<br />

135 oly line<br />

P0COAST<br />

135 oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

P0COAST 135 oly line<br />

135 P0COAST<br />

oly line<br />

P0COAST 135 oly line<br />

32<br />

35<br />

Tullow Oil<br />

46<br />

55<br />

Block 47<br />

Kosmos Energy<br />

Block 42<br />

Murphy Oil<br />

Block 48<br />

56<br />

50<br />

Apache<br />

Block 53<br />

Block 45<br />

Kosmos Energy<br />

54<br />

57<br />

1<br />

Nickerie<br />

Block<br />

43<br />

Suriname-Guyana Maritime Border<br />

51<br />

2 3<br />

Coronie Block<br />

44<br />

Calcutta Block<br />

Block 52<br />

Petronas<br />

Block 31<br />

Inpex<br />

13 <strong>14</strong> 15<br />

4 5<br />

6 7<br />

Tambaredjo Block<br />

Uitkijk Block<br />

Weg naar Zee<br />

Block<br />

Commewijne Block<br />

37<br />

36<br />

Suriname-French Guiana Maritime Border<br />

0 50 100 150 km<br />

Legend:<br />

Blocks under contract Blocks Bid Round <strong>2013</strong><br />

(28/01/<strong>2013</strong> - 26/07/<strong>2013</strong>)<br />

Blocks not on offer<br />

Staatsolie operated blocks<br />

Staatsolie Oil Fields<br />

Suriname block map (courtesy Staatsolie)<br />

April <strong>2013</strong><br />

Zaedyus appears to have triggered a rush into the<br />

Suriname deep water.<br />

Tullow itself had been first, with block 47 in 2010. The US’s<br />

Kosmos, which was associated with Tullow in the Jubilee<br />

find offshore Ghana, came in shortly after, taking blocks 42<br />

and 45, and was quickly joined by a major, the US’s Chevron,<br />

which farmed in for 50%.<br />

Murphy Oil, which had earlier held block 37 further south,<br />

relinquished that after sinking two unsuccessful wells, and<br />

moved further north to block 48. Apache was awarded<br />

block 53 in a “short-listed bid round” in mid-2012, and<br />

Malaysia’s Petronas block 52.<br />

The arrival of a company from the other side of the world<br />

has been particularly satisfying for Staatsolie. Dwarkasing<br />

notes, “This is the first time an oil company from Malaysia<br />

has come into our part of the <strong>Caribbean</strong> to explore.” He<br />

might be even more pleased had he known that Petronas<br />

had declined, three years ago, to participate with Petrotrin<br />

to explore in deep water block 27 in Trinidad and Tobago<br />

because it saw little prospectivity there.<br />

Staatsolie itself is planning a leap of faith into the offshore,<br />

but closer to the coast, in about 20 metres of water. It is<br />

using its subsidiary, Paradise Drilling, to undertake what<br />

will probably be a ten-well exploration programme in block<br />

4, one of seven nearshore blocks Staatsolie is keeping for<br />

itself.<br />

“We have a good feeling about block 4,” Dwarkasing says.<br />

“The 3D ocean bottom cable seismic did produce good<br />

data. Since it’s shallow water, we can drill at reasonable cost.”<br />

The first quarter of 20<strong>14</strong> “is a realistic date to start the<br />

drilling programme,” he notes, “but all efforts are being<br />

made to commence in the fourth quarter of <strong>2013</strong>, if we can.”<br />

About 40 exploratory wells will also be sunk by Staatsolie in<br />

various blocks on land in the course of the year.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

29


Countries<br />

barbados<br />

Getting to grips with the<br />

offshore again<br />

Andre Braithwaite (courtesy Andre Braithwaite)<br />

The high point of energy<br />

activity in Barbados in <strong>2013</strong><br />

will almost certainly be the<br />

signing of exploration and<br />

production (E&P) contracts<br />

with the Anglo-Australian explorer/<br />

producer BHP Billiton, for two blocks<br />

in deep water acreage southeast of the<br />

island. The blocks adjoin each other,<br />

Carlisle Bay (2,498 sq km) directly to the<br />

north of Bimshire (2,506 sq km).<br />

These two pieces of exploratory<br />

acreage were first offered for auction<br />

in Barbados’s ill-fated 2007 bid round.<br />

But it is probably better late than<br />

never for Barbados, which is anxious<br />

for offshore exploration to be resumed<br />

in earnest. There has been no activity<br />

offshore since November 2001, when<br />

what is now ConocoPhillips drilled the<br />

unsuccessful US$35 million Sandy Lane<br />

1 well in 6,500 feet of water.<br />

Barbados’s minuscule 900 b/d of oil is<br />

derived from onshore fields, worked<br />

by the Barbados National Oil Company<br />

(BNOC). Around 2 million cubic feet<br />

(mmcfd) of associated gas is used in<br />

the fields or sold to the sole electricity<br />

provider, Barbados Light and Power.<br />

Barbados is the only Caricom oil<br />

producer to have stuck with the E&P<br />

agreement model for offshore. All<br />

others have preferred productionsharing<br />

contracts, first introduced in<br />

1993 by Trinidad and Tobago (which<br />

still uses E&P agreements for onshore<br />

activity).<br />

Barbados’s position has always<br />

been that E&P contracts are better<br />

suited for a country at its stage of<br />

hydrocarbon development wanting<br />

to attract explorationists. The work<br />

programme agreed with BHP Billiton<br />

has not been formally announced, but<br />

is almost certain to include 3D seismic<br />

and one or two exploratory wells, once<br />

prospectivity is revealed. A carried share<br />

for BNOC – at least in the exploration<br />

phase – was a biddable item in the block<br />

auction and could be as much as 25%.<br />

BNOC is excited at going offshore<br />

for the first time on the back of a major<br />

international oil company. General<br />

manager Winton O’D. Gibbs told this<br />

YEARBOOK that “we will take up any<br />

stake with enthusiasm. We know<br />

offshore is expensive, but the rewards<br />

are much better.”<br />

BHP Billiton presumably sees<br />

opportunities in the Barbados<br />

offshore, despite ConocoPhillips’<br />

disappointing experience, or it would<br />

not have persevered as long as it<br />

has. It has had to overcome various<br />

negotiating obstacles along the way,<br />

including a change of government in<br />

early 2008. Perhaps fortunately for the<br />

company, the Democratic Labour Party<br />

retained power in the general election<br />

in February <strong>2013</strong>, though with a severely<br />

reduced majority.<br />

ConocoPhillips’ failure to find<br />

commercial quantities of oil has not<br />

dampened the experts’ positive view of<br />

the Barbados deep water either. Mervyn<br />

Gordon, BNOC’s technical manager,<br />

believes that “both oil and gas will be<br />

found off Barbados, not just gas, as<br />

some people have said. Drilling will be<br />

taking place in about 6,000-7,000 feet of<br />

water and you can go another 10,000-<br />

15,000 feet. I expect we will find some<br />

oil. I am very confident of that.”<br />

Andre Brathwaite, director, natural<br />

resources, in the division of energy<br />

and telecommunications in the office<br />

of prime minister Freundel Stuart,<br />

believes that “a discovery of oil or gas<br />

will be made offshore Barbados in the<br />

years ahead. I base that confidence on<br />

the geology.” He points out that “the<br />

more than <strong>14</strong>,000 lines of offshore<br />

seismic we now have shows that we<br />

have prospectivity in the east, west<br />

and south,” and cites extensive seismic<br />

coverage as one of the reasons why<br />

“international companies are now<br />

showing interest in Barbados again.”<br />

Onshore, BNOC will be continuing<br />

its development drilling programmes<br />

in <strong>2013</strong>, following the exploration and<br />

appraisal wells it sunk in 2011-2012,<br />

which added at least 64,000 barrels to<br />

proven reserves.<br />

Development drilling is important not<br />

only because it maintains or increases<br />

production, but also because it often<br />

leads to an upgrade of reserves. The<br />

2011-2012 programme added 822,000<br />

barrels, according to Gibbs.<br />

30


Barbados Block Map (courtesy Barbados Division of Energy)<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

31


Countries<br />

belize<br />

Plenty of setbacks –<br />

but not fatal<br />

Belize became a Caricom oil<br />

producer in 2005 after 50 years<br />

of trying, and was doing quite<br />

well until it suffered a number of<br />

body blows that will make <strong>2013</strong><br />

a difficult year for the industry.<br />

The first blow is that production from<br />

its two fields, Spanish Lookout and Never<br />

Delay in western Belize, has plummeted.<br />

Belize Natural Energy (BNEL) identified<br />

retrievable oil reserves with its first<br />

exploratory well eight years ago, and<br />

output rose rapidly to over 5,000 b/d. But<br />

it has since declined to about 2,550 b/d,<br />

not only depriving the government of<br />

much-needed revenue but reducing the<br />

associated gas and liquefied petroleum gas<br />

available for the local market.<br />

The second blow is that other<br />

explorationists have not been able to replicate BNEL’s initial<br />

success. New World Oil and Gas was forced to plug and<br />

abandon its Rio Bravo 1 exploratory well in northwestern<br />

Belize after failing to find oil, on the heels of a similar failure<br />

with its Blue Creek 1 and 2 wells. The company is putting<br />

a brave face on it, and pledges to return to the Blue Creek<br />

area in due course, because “with multiple prospects already<br />

identified, we believe it is only a matter of time before we<br />

locate a trap of significant size.”<br />

The third blow has the biggest disruptive potential for the<br />

short to medium term: the Belize Supreme Court ruled<br />

that all drilling contracts for offshore exploration issued by<br />

the government between 2004 and 2007 are “null and void.”<br />

It decided that proper environmental impact assessments<br />

had not been carried out before the signing of contracts, as<br />

required by law. It also declared that the companies involved,<br />

which include Island Oil Belize, Tropical Energy, Petro Belize,<br />

Princess Petroleum, Providence<br />

Energy and Sol Oil, “had failed to<br />

prove an ability to contribute the<br />

necessary funds, assets, machinery,<br />

equipment, tools and technical<br />

Hon. Senator Joy Grant (courtesy<br />

www.belize.gov.bz)<br />

expertise to drill safely.”<br />

The suit was brought by two<br />

environmental organisations, Citizens<br />

Organised for Liberty through Action and<br />

the Belize Coalition to save our Natural<br />

Heritage. The latter has been agitating for<br />

some time to stop offshore exploration<br />

following BP’s Macondo well blowout in<br />

the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.<br />

The government responded by offering<br />

a referendum on the matter, but that has<br />

been on hold for some time. An appeal<br />

against the judgment will probably be<br />

made but, in the meantime, Belize’s<br />

offshore acreage is out of bounds for<br />

exploration, a fact which will hardly<br />

encourage international oil companies to<br />

look seriously at offshore prospects.<br />

The bidding rounds which the<br />

government says it wants to introduce will have to be confined<br />

to the onshore for the foreseeable future.<br />

But the future for hydrocarbons in Belize is not entirely bleak,<br />

since companies which already hold onshore licences will<br />

want to get started on exploration. These include Marenco, US<br />

Capital Energy, Treaty Energy and the French firm Parenco.<br />

Belize’s minister of energy, A. Joy Grant, is prepared to<br />

predict “a spate of exploratory drilling over the next few years,<br />

based on what the companies see as promising potential in<br />

their blocks.”<br />

Belize is committed to renewable energy, as a participant in<br />

the Caricom Energy Plan.<br />

Minister Grant contends that already generates more<br />

electricity from renewable resources – 68% – than any other<br />

Caricom member, thanks to the wide use of sugar cane<br />

residue, bagasse, to heat boilers for the industry’s own power<br />

needs, the surplus being passed on to the national grid.<br />

Belize generates more electricity from renewable<br />

resources – 68% – than any other Caricom member<br />

32


Countries<br />

jamaica<br />

Restarting the<br />

exploration drive<br />

Jamaica will be trying in<br />

<strong>2013</strong> to get its derailed<br />

programme for offshore<br />

exploration back on track,<br />

and to find more reliable<br />

companies on which to pin its faith for a hydrocarbon<br />

future.<br />

Last year, its minister of science, technology, energy<br />

and mining, Phillip Paulwell, had to terminate production<br />

sharing agreements with three companies – Finder/Flow,<br />

Sagres/Rainville and Proteam. They had failed to live up to<br />

the seismic or drilling obligations in the licences they had<br />

acquired over the last eight years for a total of 12 blocks off<br />

Jamaica’s south and southeast coasts.<br />

Both Finder/Flow and Sagres/Rainville had come close<br />

to meeting their obligation to sink an exploratory well<br />

following the completion and interpretation of seismic,<br />

but neither was apparently able to find financial partners<br />

to help fund what was certain to be an expensive drilling<br />

project.<br />

Minister Paulwell, back in his old job following the return<br />

of the People’s National Party to office, has taken a nononsense<br />

approach to the lagging exploration programme.<br />

“I am not going to allow any company to hold on to any<br />

licence without living up to its obligations,” he warned. “We<br />

have to send a strong signal to the marketplace that we<br />

mean business.”<br />

If Jamaica wants to make any progress at all towards<br />

realising its long-held desire for at least some energy<br />

independence, it now has to start exploration again after a<br />

long hiatus. Eleven wells were drilled for oil between 1955<br />

and 1982, two in the offshore, but none found hydrocarbon<br />

reservoirs. Some of those were sunk by big names in the<br />

business at the time – Union Texas, Occidental, and Italy’s<br />

Agip (which is still around).<br />

Minister Paulwell thinks he will be best served by going<br />

that route again but attracting stronger companies into<br />

the drilling campaign than the three most recent licencees.<br />

“We recognise the need to get larger players and we are<br />

pursuing a number of them,” he told this YEARBOOK.<br />

“I am not going to allow any company to hold on to<br />

any licence without living up to its obligations”<br />

The production-sharing agreements with Finder/Flow,<br />

Sagres/Rainville and Proteam emerged from the 2005<br />

block round. The most recent block auction, in 2010-2011,<br />

produce no acceptable bids.<br />

Paulwell is now taking a different approach and will engage<br />

in bilateral negotiations with selected companies. He<br />

thinks this will afford more flexibility in agreeing terms.<br />

“My view is that the open-tender system does not seem<br />

to have worked. We will now engage companies in direct<br />

negotiations and come away with arrangements that we<br />

negotiate, rather than having a public bid.”<br />

This view has been strengthened by the lack of success<br />

in the 2010-2011 block auction, which Paulwell insists “was<br />

not marketed properly” (it opened during the time of the<br />

previous Jamaica Labour Party government). He says that<br />

more recent data has become available which “will make<br />

Jamaica far more attractive now,” and intends to “impress<br />

on some of the major corporations the raw data that we<br />

have which will show the substantial reserves we think<br />

Jamaica has.”<br />

On this basis, even the four land blocks that have been<br />

so far ignored by bidders – Negril, Portland, Santa Cruz and<br />

Windsor – might conceivably seem more attractive.<br />

While struggling to get the exploration process back on<br />

track, Paulwell is also preoccupied with the long-running<br />

problem of the Jamaican refinery, Petrojam, 51% of which<br />

is owned by the Petroleum Corporation of Jamaica (PCJ).<br />

Petrojam urgently needs to be upgraded from its present<br />

limited capacity of 35,000 b/d to around 50,000 b/d.<br />

Venezuela’s PdVSA, which has acquired the other 49%, is<br />

pledged to fund the upgrading. But if it does not happen,<br />

“we will have to shut it down. It’s as simple as that,” says<br />

Paulwell. The government has already decided to sell<br />

off one PCJ subsidiary – its fuels retailer, the Petroleum<br />

Company of Jamaica, better known as Petcom.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

33


Countries<br />

guyana<br />

Could luck change with the<br />

Stabroek block?<br />

If the geological structures that<br />

trapped oil off Ghana and other<br />

West African countries are really<br />

replicated off South America, it<br />

has yet to be demonstrated in<br />

Guyana, despite the evidence of oil<br />

off nearby French Guiana.<br />

Neither the US$71 million Eagle<br />

1 well in CGX Energy’s Corentyne<br />

block nor the Jaguar 1 well in the<br />

Georgetown block found oil or<br />

gas in 2012. Repsol is the operator,<br />

partnering Tullow Oil, YPF Guyana and<br />

CGX itself.<br />

Jaguar was stopped at 4,878<br />

metres instead of being drilled to<br />

the Late Cretaceous horizon, as<br />

planned, because “pressure design<br />

limits for safe operations prevented<br />

further drilling,” according to a Tullow<br />

spokesman. There was a glimmer of<br />

hope in that “samples of light oil were<br />

recovered from two Late Cretaceous<br />

turbidite sands above the primary<br />

objective.”<br />

How soon operators will return to<br />

drilling is uncertain. CGX’s intentions<br />

towards Corentyne are unknown,<br />

while Repsol says it considers the<br />

Georgetown block “still interesting”<br />

and may drill again, but “not before<br />

late <strong>2013</strong>/early 20<strong>14</strong>.”<br />

CGX holds several other Guyana<br />

offshore blocks – Corentyne Annexe<br />

(100%), Pomeroon (100%) and,<br />

onshore, the majority share in Berbice<br />

through its fully-owned subsidiary,<br />

ON Energy. But it has not said when it<br />

will try its luck again – and Berbice has<br />

probably been ruled out after three<br />

unsuccessful wells.<br />

There has been no word from<br />

ExxonMobil and Shell, who hold the<br />

Stabroek block in a 75/25% equity<br />

relationship.<br />

The most recent international<br />

oil company to take an interest<br />

in Guyana, Anadarko Petroleum<br />

Corporation, has said it will “study<br />

available data” for its block, named<br />

Roraima, “with a view to identifying<br />

leads that could result in prospects<br />

favourable for drilling.”<br />

So the possibility of some Guyanese<br />

offshore blocks being on trend with<br />

the Zaedyus find in French Guiana<br />

should not altogether be ruled out.<br />

Apart from Berbice, there is another<br />

licensed block onshore Guyana –<br />

Takutu in the interior, regarded as<br />

cross-border with Brazil. It is held 65%<br />

by Canacol, 25% by Sagres Energy and<br />

10% by Takutu Oil and Gas, formerly<br />

Groundstar Resources. The Apoteri K2<br />

well was drilled there, though without<br />

success, and the acreage may even<br />

The possibility of some Guyanese offshore blocks<br />

being on trend with the Zaedyus find in French<br />

Guiana should not altogether be ruled out<br />

Most hopes now lie with ExxonMobil/Shell,<br />

whose Stabroek block is by far the largest piece of<br />

offshore acreage Guyana has licensed<br />

have been surrendered.<br />

Next-door Suriname has also failed<br />

so far to identify offshore oil or gas.<br />

Two wells drilled in 2010-2011 by<br />

Murphy Oil in block 37 (Aracara and<br />

Caracari) and by Inpex in block 31<br />

(Aitkanti) all failed to find retrievable<br />

volumes.<br />

Most hopes now lie with<br />

ExxonMobil/Shell, whose<br />

Stabroek block is by far the largest<br />

piece of offshore acreage Guyana<br />

has licensed. It extends from the<br />

Venezuelan maritime border in<br />

the west to the Suriname maritime<br />

border in the east, and could contain<br />

a wide sweep of prospects. The two<br />

companies were only obliged to<br />

undertake 2D seismic, which was<br />

completed, but they opted for another<br />

2D exercise to fill in some blank spots.<br />

Newell Dennison, manager of the<br />

petroleum division in the Guyana<br />

Geology and Mines Commission,<br />

suggests that ExxonMobil/Shell might<br />

consider 3D acquisition. But they will<br />

have to make up their minds soon<br />

about sinking an actual well, since<br />

they keep losing parts of Stabroek<br />

through mandatory relinquishments<br />

which, in Dennison’s words, “are<br />

aggressive.” He says: “ExxonMobil<br />

has told us they are not interested in<br />

dragging the situation out, so may<br />

drill eventually.” It remains to be seen<br />

whether that happens in <strong>2013</strong>.<br />

34


Countries<br />

cuba<br />

Deep water seems to be dry<br />

Cuba had high hopes of<br />

success from its deep water<br />

drilling campaign in the Gulf<br />

of Mexico. But they were well<br />

and truly dashed in 2012<br />

and into <strong>2013</strong>, and no further offshore<br />

exploration is planned for the rest of the<br />

year.<br />

The list of well failures has been<br />

dispiriting. After drawing a blank with<br />

Jaguey 1, Repsol declined to drill a<br />

second well, and said it would quit the<br />

Cuban deep water. Malaysia’s Petronas<br />

and Russia’s Gazpromneft had no<br />

more success with the Catoche 1 well<br />

– a statement issued by the Cuban<br />

state oil company Cubapetroleo said<br />

that “the rocks are very compact and<br />

do not have the capacity to deliver<br />

significant quantities of petroleum or<br />

gas, so the well can not be classified as<br />

a commercial success.”<br />

Venezuela’s national energy company<br />

PdVSA had no luck with its Cabo de<br />

San Antonio well, not did Russia’s<br />

Zerubezhneft with its exploratory well.<br />

The Angolan state energy company<br />

Sonangol, Vietnam’s Petro Vietnam<br />

and India’s ONGC promised to try<br />

their hand in the deep water, where<br />

Cuba has delineated 59 blocks in its<br />

exclusive economic zone: but they are<br />

understood to be unlikely to proceed.<br />

Petro Vietnam said it would wait for<br />

the results of PdVSA’s work, which was<br />

unsuccessful, while ONGC reportedly<br />

told Cuban officials it needed partners<br />

to help finance wells in one of its two<br />

offshore blocks. On current trends, such<br />

partners are unlikely to come on board.<br />

However, while the deep water may<br />

be sidelined for the foreseeable<br />

future, Zerubezhneft is staying on to drill<br />

some wells nearshore northern Cuba,<br />

and even plans to move onshore into<br />

blocks 9 and 12, where wells abandoned<br />

many years ago are considered ripe for<br />

revival.<br />

For now, it seems that Cuba’s crude oil<br />

production from onshore and nearshore<br />

wells will remain stuck at around 52,000<br />

b/d, forcing it to continue importing<br />

about 110,000 b/d of refined products<br />

like gasolene, diesel and fuel oil, plus<br />

crude for its four refineries at Cienfuegos,<br />

Mantanzas, Habana and Santiago de<br />

Cuba, which is largely sourced from<br />

Venezuela.<br />

Upgrades are planned for three of<br />

these refineries, with Habana slated<br />

to be shut down. Combined nominal<br />

capacity is 300,000 b/d, but the four can<br />

deliver no more than about 104,000 b/d<br />

at present.<br />

Cienfuegos has actually exported<br />

a small amount of refined products<br />

(about 16,000 b/d) since PdVSA came on<br />

board as a partner with Cubapetroleo.<br />

Venezuela is pledged to fund an<br />

expansion programme at Cienfuegos<br />

under the two countries’ Cuvenpetrol<br />

joint venture, which will raise production<br />

from 65,000 b/d to 150,000 b/d.<br />

Financing for the expansion was<br />

to have been provided by Venezuela,<br />

Repsol declined to drill a second well, and said it<br />

would quit the Cuban deep water<br />

using funds from China under a cashfor-oil<br />

credit scheme. But under its<br />

new president Nicolás Maduro, Caracas<br />

may be having second thoughts about<br />

all these arrangements, which enable<br />

Venezuela to undertake development<br />

projects at home and abroad while<br />

pledging oil supplies as repayment in<br />

the future.<br />

So it is not entirely surprising to hear<br />

from Cuvenpetrol that, at the time of<br />

writing, no contract for the Cienfuegos<br />

upgrading had been signed with the<br />

chosen contractor, China National<br />

Petroleum’s Huanqui Contracting and<br />

Engineering Unit.<br />

Alongside the Cienfuegos upgrade,<br />

other infrastructure is planned for the<br />

area: an LNG regasification plant, to<br />

handle LNG imports of around 2 million<br />

tonnes a year; a petrochemical complex;<br />

and power generation facilities.<br />

Cuba has long been in the frame<br />

for imported LNG, with Trinidad and<br />

Tobago a possible long-term supplier,<br />

since no US LNG exporter would be<br />

allowed to trade with the country.<br />

As in many other <strong>Caribbean</strong> states<br />

these days, Cuba is probably having<br />

more success with renewable energy<br />

than with hydrocarbons. Early in <strong>2013</strong><br />

it announced a major programme<br />

of wind-farm construction, with six<br />

facilities across the country, generating<br />

280MW. Officials reckon that this could<br />

save 184,000 tonnes of CO 2 emissions,<br />

compared with oil-fired generators.<br />

280MW is only scratching the surface<br />

of wind power, since Cuba is said to<br />

be capable of as much as 1,200MW of<br />

wind-generated energy.<br />

energycaribbean YEARBOOK <strong>2013</strong>/<strong>14</strong><br />

35


Companies<br />

atlantic<br />

A global benchmark<br />

for LNG<br />

Countries<br />

In <strong>2013</strong> Atlantic, Trinidad and<br />

Tobago’s much-admired LNG<br />

complex at Point Fortin, should<br />

achieve the status of a global<br />

benchmark for LNG trains, according<br />

to its former CEO, Oscar Prieto.<br />

Prieto’s successor, Nigel Darlow, has<br />

not publicly confirmed that status yet,<br />

but clearly believes it is possible, since<br />

Atlantic is already close to it in areas<br />

like “safety performance, production<br />

reliability and corporate sustainability”.<br />

One aspect he concedes still needs<br />

attention is “cost efficiency.”<br />

“Sustainability” is a buzz word taken<br />

to mean different things by different<br />

interests. In Caricom’s new energy<br />

policy it refers to “renewable energy<br />

and energy efficiency”, at least in an<br />

upstream sense.<br />

Atlantic is a “midstream” company but<br />

efficiency in the use of its main input,<br />

natural gas, of which it is the prime<br />

consumer in Trinidad and Tobago (2.1<br />

bn cfd in 2012), is equally important.<br />

The less gas used to make a tonne of<br />

LNG, the lower the costs of production<br />

and the higher the LNG output.<br />

Cost management is one of five focus<br />

areas that Darlow has identified<br />

as Atlantic becomes a benchmarking<br />

model for the LNG world. The others:<br />

personal safety, people development<br />

and talent management, project delivery<br />

of the plant optimisation programme,<br />

and production and reliability.<br />

Efficiency, the CEO stresses, “very<br />

much includes procurement, how we<br />

spend our supply-chain budget. We<br />

need to be cost-conscious and have a<br />

prudent approach to cost management.”<br />

Darlow is keenly conscious that the<br />

country’s precious natural gas reserves<br />

must be economically used. “We will<br />

continue to be a significant revenue<br />

generator for our shareholders and the<br />

government and people of Trinidad<br />

and Tobago for a very long time to<br />

come,” he says. “Our offtakers have been<br />

very successful at accessing high-class<br />

markets.”<br />

He has at least a 20-year timeframe for<br />

Atlantic, pointing out that “we’ve got to<br />

work to ensure that we compete in the<br />

global market, [and] get the gas supplies<br />

we need to enable the facility to last for<br />

another 20-plus years – that’s the goal.”<br />

Darlow is confident that Atlantic –<br />

whose shareholders are BP, BG,<br />

Summer Soca LNG liquefaction SA<br />

(train one only), and the National Gas<br />

Company (trains one and four only),<br />

soon to be joined by Royal Dutch Shell,<br />

which has bought out Repsol’s share<br />

Atlantic’s LNG complex at Point Fortin (courtesy Atlantic)<br />

– “will always have a market for LNG<br />

because, despite all the plants that are<br />

planned, the consensus in the industry<br />

is that demand for LNG will continue<br />

to outstrip supply. Worldwide, gas<br />

is increasingly becoming the fuel of<br />

choice to replace oil and coal.”<br />

Atlantic is one of the few companies<br />

in the energy sector that publishes an<br />

annual sustainability review (and does<br />

so very attractively too, with a wealth of<br />

information about its activities).<br />

It is even completely honest about a<br />

subject few big-name companies want<br />

to talk about – its contribution to global<br />

warming. In its 2011 sustainability report,<br />

Atlantic revealed that its greenhouse<br />

gas (GHG) emissions were 5.31 million<br />

tonnes for the year. It “monitors and<br />

manages GHG emissions from the<br />

production process through multiple<br />

approaches, including efficiencies in<br />

operation and reductions in flaring.”<br />

36


Companies<br />

CIBC firstcaribbean international bank<br />

FCIB aspires to be the<br />

region’s energy bank<br />

Countries<br />

CIBC First<strong>Caribbean</strong> International<br />

Bank, successor<br />

to the Barclays and CIBC<br />

operations in the region<br />

(making it the largest<br />

banking institution in the Englishspeaking<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong>), will continue to<br />

seek out funding opportunities in the<br />

energy sector in <strong>2013</strong>.<br />

It has been most successful so far<br />

in the area of electricity, where it has<br />

helped fund the Jamaica Public Service<br />

Company (with whom the Bank says it<br />

has a “strong relationship”), the Jamaican<br />

IPP West Kingston Power Partners, the<br />

Bahamas Electricity Corporation and St<br />

Lucia Electricity Services. It has also been<br />

lead arranger/underwriter for an equity<br />

issue by the Canadian power company<br />

Emera Inc., in relation to its <strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

acquisitions.<br />

But it is likely to pay more attention<br />

in the future to upstream oil and<br />

gas activity, downstream projects,<br />

renewable energy and energy efficiency,<br />

all of which are likely to need injections<br />

of loan capital as new initiatives ramp up<br />

in various parts of the region, including,<br />

of course, Trinidad and Tobago.<br />

The Bank has already taken part in a<br />

US$235 million syndicated loan facility<br />

for the Suriname national oil company,<br />

Staatsolie, to which it contributed US$10<br />

million, for production and refinery<br />

expansion.<br />

As the recently-approved Caricom<br />

Energy Policy moves into its<br />

implementation phase, with the<br />

emphasis on greater take-up of<br />

renewable energy (RE) and the adoption<br />

of energy efficiency measures in the<br />

region, CIBC First<strong>Caribbean</strong> International<br />

will have even greater scope for<br />

extending financial support to energyrelated<br />

activity.<br />

It already has an RE project to its<br />

credit, having been part of a syndicate<br />

that underwrote a US$54 million<br />

secured term loan facility to NuCuraçao<br />

Windparken BV for 30MW of wind<br />

power generation. This represents,<br />

according to the Bank, “almost 20% of<br />

Curaçao’s annual energy demand.”<br />

Sharaz Ahamad, CIBC First<strong>Caribbean</strong>’s<br />

director for origination and capital<br />

market products in the Southern<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong>, points out that the Bank has<br />

even ventured into biomass-to-energy,<br />

by “funding the first stage of a waste<br />

recycling plant for a company called<br />

Sustainable Recycling in Barbados,<br />

which will collect household waste<br />

and bundle it so it can be used in an<br />

incinerator to provide energy to the<br />

grid.”<br />

Though Trinidad and Tobago has<br />

signed on to the “sustainable energy”<br />

that underpins the Caricom Energy<br />

Policy, Ahamad has his doubts about<br />

whether RE will catch on easily in a<br />

“The economics of RE will be challenging in Trinidad<br />

and Tobago: I don’t see a huge project in<br />

solar or wind here”<br />

country already self-sufficient in both<br />

oil and gas sold at attractive prices for<br />

electricity generation, transport and<br />

cooking/water heating.<br />

“The economics of RE will be<br />

challenging in Trinidad and Tobago,” he<br />

says, “I don’t see a huge project in solar<br />

or wind here – the economics don’t<br />

really lend themselves to it.”<br />

He may be in for a pleasant surprise,<br />

however, since the energy ministry in<br />

Port of Spain seems determined to woo<br />

consumers into looking more kindly on<br />

RE and is itself active in promoting it.<br />

Ahamad does concede that<br />

Trinidad and Tobago may be a<br />

strong candidate for the application<br />

of energy efficiency measures, since<br />

the very cheapness of energy tends to<br />

encourage laxity in its conservation.<br />

“There’s a huge opportunity here in all<br />

Caricom members,” he insists. “Energy<br />

costs are very high in most regional<br />

states. The hotel plant in particular is a<br />

very good candidate. In fact, we have<br />

a programme of loans to hotels to<br />

improve energy efficiency.”<br />

Downstream industries from the<br />

core petrochemical plants in Trinidad<br />

and Tobago is another area where CIBC<br />

First<strong>Caribbean</strong> is keen to be active. Two<br />

such investments in which it has had<br />

mild initial involvement – the Carisal<br />

caustic soda/calcium chloride plant and<br />

the EthylChem ethanol dehydration<br />

facility – do not now appear to be<br />

going forward, but no doubt other<br />

loan opportunities will arise in the<br />

downstream part of the energy sector<br />

in due course.<br />

38


Innovative Financing and Hedging Solutions<br />

for the Energy and Utilities Sector<br />

At CIBC First<strong>Caribbean</strong> our dedicated team of investment banking professionals is committed to delivering the best<br />

financing and hedging solutions to meet the needs of the Energy and Utilities sector.<br />

We provide you with one-on-one service that addresses your business needs with innovative financing and hedging<br />

solutions to complement your business strategy.<br />

Benefits of Working with<br />

Our Investment Banking Team:<br />

• Market expertise with regional and international<br />

links with access to a full range of financial and<br />

advisory services.<br />

• A leading Investment Banking presence in the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> region providing project financing to<br />

the energy and utilities sector.<br />

• A world-class transaction execution process with<br />

significant experience and distribution capability<br />

throughout the English and Dutch speaking<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong>.<br />

• A solid group balance sheet and part of the CIBC<br />

group which has an A+/Stable credit rating from<br />

the Standard & Poor’s credit rating agency.<br />

For more information on how we can assist you please contact:<br />

INVESTMENT BANKING<br />

<strong>ENERGY</strong> & UTILITIES TEAM<br />

Sharaz Ahamad<br />

Director, Origination and<br />

Capital Markets Products<br />

Southern <strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

Tel: 1 868 822-5071<br />

Mobile: 1 868 779-2994<br />

E-mail: sharaz.ahamad@cibcfcib.com<br />

Gillian Charles-Gollop<br />

Associate Director, Sector Specialist<br />

Energy & Utilities<br />

Tel: 1 246 467-8723<br />

Mobile: 1 246 232-8700<br />

E-mail: gillian.gollop@cibcfcib.com<br />

CORPORATE & INVESTMENT BANKING,<br />

TRINIDAD & TOBAGO<br />

Duane Hinkson<br />

Managing Director,<br />

Trinidad & Tobago Operations<br />

Tel: 1 868 822-5080<br />

E-mail: duane.hinkson@cibcfcib.com<br />

Anthony Seeraj<br />

Deputy Managing Director, Corporate<br />

& Investment Banking<br />

Tel: 1 868 628-4685<br />

E-mail: anthony.seeraj@cibcfcib.com<br />

HEDGING<br />

Winville Larcher<br />

Director, Client Solutions Group<br />

Tel: 1 246 367-2133<br />

E-mail: winville.larcher@cibcfcib.com<br />

The CIBC logo and For What Matters are trademarks of Canadian Imperial<br />

Bank of Commerce, used by First<strong>Caribbean</strong> International Bank under license.


Companies<br />

gasfin development sa<br />

Small LNG plant can<br />

transform TT gas exports<br />

Countries<br />

Gasfin Development SA, a Luxembourgregistered<br />

“right-sized LNG solutions” company,<br />

as it describes itself, is anxious to establish a<br />

small LNG plant in Trinidad and Tobago, and has<br />

been trying to persuade the energy ministry and<br />

its gas promotion agency, the National Gas Company (NGC),<br />

towards that end for almost four years, without success up to<br />

the time of writing.<br />

Why is Gasfin Development so keen on Project Constantine,<br />

as it has named its LNG project?<br />

Because it thinks Trinidad and Tobago, the only country<br />

capable of exporting gas in the <strong>Caribbean</strong> and Central<br />

America, should be taking advantage of the expected<br />

demand from regional power utilities for small and mediumsized<br />

(i.e. “right-sized”) cargos of LNG for fuel. The high cost<br />

of conventional fuel oil and diesel is translating into crippling<br />

electricity bills for businesses and households.<br />

There is no government intervention in fuel costs in the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> except in Trinidad and Tobago itself, so local<br />

utilities have to bear the full brunt of market prices.<br />

Gasfin’s CEO Roland Fisher, who has been pressing for a<br />

500,000-tonne-per-year single train (at first), reckons that gas<br />

would be eminently competitive at the mmbtu equivalent<br />

price of fuel oil or diesel.<br />

He has identified several markets in the <strong>Caribbean</strong> and<br />

Central America that would be willing to convert to gas if<br />

they could be assured of a regular supply that significantly<br />

reduced their energy costs.<br />

Gasfin designed and delivered the<br />

first mid-scale LNG plant and built<br />

the first mid-scale mixed-use LNG<br />

carrier<br />

The small size of these regional power utilities means that<br />

their LNG requirements would be modest, in the range of<br />

50,000 to 100,000 tonnes a year (7 million to <strong>14</strong> million cubic<br />

feet of gas a day).<br />

The total gas requirement for the LNG train which Fisher<br />

wants to site at La Brea in southwest Trinidad would therefore<br />

be only 70 mmcfd, which could probably be squeezed out of<br />

NGC’s current gas contracts, which amount to about 1.7 bn<br />

cfd. Another 2.3 bn cfd is already diverted to LNG production<br />

by direct deals between gas-producing companies and<br />

Atlantic at Point Fortin.<br />

Gasfin comes with impeccable credentials as a “right-sized<br />

LNG solutions” company. It designed and delivered the first<br />

mid-scale LNG plant – 400,000 tonnes a year – to China in<br />

2004. It built the first mid-scale mixed-use LNG carrier, the<br />

7,500 cubic metre Coral Methane, in 2009.<br />

If floating storage and regasification units are required –<br />

which is likely to be the case with the market Gasfin wants to<br />

service in the French <strong>Caribbean</strong> departments of Martinique<br />

and Guadeloupe – then it can construct those too. The<br />

company claims its type C LNG cargo tank “is the only<br />

tank design able to withstand pressure build-up from LNG<br />

storage.”<br />

Trinidad and Tobago, through Atlantic, already services<br />

about 21 LNG markets in the world, but the unique value<br />

of the <strong>Caribbean</strong> and Central American market is its scaleddown<br />

size. A local company, in the form of NGC, can handle<br />

this in such a way that Trinidad and Tobago, as a country, is<br />

directly involved in the LNG value chain, rather than indirectly<br />

through companies such as BP, BG and Repsol.<br />

Fisher believes that La Brea LNG will bring tangible benefits<br />

to Trinidad and Tobago by positioning it as “the world<br />

pioneer of mid-scale LNG exporting” through the “capture of<br />

long-term premium markets in the <strong>Caribbean</strong>.”<br />

What’s more, with a small LNG plant up and running, LNG<br />

for the first time could be used domestically for industry and<br />

transport, even rivalling CNG as an alternative motor fuel.<br />

40


Delivering gas to the <strong>Caribbean</strong><br />

Right-sized LNG solutions<br />

Gasfin, building on its extensive global<br />

references in Mid-scale LNG, stands ready to<br />

assist Trinidad & Tobago to win the race to serve<br />

the <strong>Caribbean</strong> gas market.<br />

For more information visit www.gasfin.net or call +44 20 3369 9690<br />

At every step...in every size...on land or sea...across the globe


Companies<br />

methanex trinidad<br />

Happy with TT operation –<br />

but no expansion<br />

Countries<br />

Methanex<br />

Corporation,<br />

the world’s largest<br />

methanol supplier (7.5<br />

million tonnes in 2012),<br />

is in expansionist<br />

mode – but not, curiously, in Trinidad<br />

and Tobago, where one of its major<br />

production facilities is sited at the Point<br />

Lisas industrial estate.<br />

One reason for that could be its<br />

caution about what newly-appointed<br />

president and CEO John Floren<br />

describes as “concentration – having<br />

too many plants in one location.”<br />

Methanex’s capacity in the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong>’s oil and gas capital is<br />

already up to 2.5 million tonnes<br />

annually – 850,000 tonnes from Titan,<br />

of which it is the sole owner, and 1.7<br />

million tonnes from Atlas, which it<br />

operates with a 63.1% equity holding,<br />

partnered by bpTT (36.9%).<br />

“Concentration” has obliged<br />

Methanex to relocate two of its four<br />

methanol plants in Chile to the US Gulf<br />

Coast state of Louisiana. Those units<br />

have not actually been producing for<br />

some time, because of problems with<br />

gas supply, so it made sense to site<br />

them in a place with gas coming out of<br />

its ears thanks to the shale revolution,<br />

and at a very attractive price.<br />

“We wanted gas from Argentina, but<br />

that became a low-profitability in the<br />

short term”, Floren explains, “so running<br />

four plants in Chile was not feasible on<br />

a long-term basis.”<br />

Since the plants were idle, the two<br />

million tonnes of methanol they will<br />

be producing by 2016 are regarded as<br />

new output.<br />

Methanex’s 7.5 million tonnes a<br />

year represents 15% of global<br />

methanol sales, and the Vancouverbased<br />

corporation is determined to<br />

maintain that share of the market. To<br />

do that, says Floren, it must “grow by<br />

one million tonnes every two years.”<br />

The two Louisiana facilities will help<br />

meet that target.<br />

In New Zealand, Methanex is<br />

increasing capacity at its Motunui<br />

plant by 700,000 tonnes through a<br />

de-bottlenecking process, and is restarting<br />

the Waitara Valley unit, which<br />

will add another 500,000 tonnes to<br />

production.<br />

Two years ago, it brought back on<br />

stream its 470,000-tonne methanol<br />

facility in Medicine Hat, Alberta, which<br />

had been idle for several years, and will<br />

boost capacity up to 580,000 tonnes<br />

this year. Its 60% owned and operated<br />

plant in Egypt, with a capacity of 1.3<br />

million tonnes, is said to be “one of<br />

the most energy-efficient methanol<br />

production facilities in the world,” and<br />

delivered its first cargo in 2011.<br />

Besides the risk in “concentration”,<br />

Methanex has experienced difficulties<br />

in Trinidad and Tobago in recent years<br />

– supplies of oxygen from Air Products<br />

and Air Liquide, gas delivery from the<br />

National Gas Company, “technical<br />

problems” in running the huge Atlas<br />

To maintain that share of the market, Methanex<br />

must “grow by one million tonnes every two years”<br />

John Floren (courtesy Methanex)<br />

plant. All these factors may have<br />

affected thoughts of expansion.<br />

But overall, Floren says he is “happy”<br />

with his Trinidad and Tobago assets<br />

and is “making progress with getting<br />

the plants to be more reliable.” With<br />

the methanol price hovering around<br />

US$400 a tonne, “all of our operations<br />

are very profitable.”<br />

Methanex Trinidad is already<br />

prepared for any future local expansion:<br />

as Floren points out, it has “available<br />

land around our plant at Point Lisas, for<br />

which we pay a million dollars a year to<br />

keep.”<br />

But he is careful to stress that any<br />

future growth in Trinidad and Tobago<br />

will involve producing more methanol,<br />

not going downstream. “We have no<br />

interest in going there. When we look<br />

downstream, we don’t see the same<br />

type of market conditions as we do in<br />

methanol. We can not see any industry<br />

downstream that is as attractive as<br />

methanol.”<br />

42


Companies<br />

National gas company (NGC)<br />

NGC is set to expand<br />

Trinidad and Tobago’s National Gas Company (NGC)<br />

Countries<br />

should be finalising agreements to participate in<br />

the local operation of three multinational energy<br />

companies in <strong>2013</strong>.<br />

Its intention, as energy minister Kevin Ramnarine<br />

has indicated, is to “acquire all or part of their assets in Trinidad<br />

and Tobago.”<br />

One of those acquisitions is Total’s interest in the productive<br />

block 2c (30%) and in the Greater Ruby/Delaware Market<br />

Development Area in block 3a (8.5%), both off the northeast<br />

coast of Trinidad.<br />

Total has decided to sell because what it has in Trinidad and<br />

Tobago is small potatoes and it needs to focus investment and<br />

management time on areas of the world where it has grander<br />

prospects. Those include nearby French Guiana, where it holds<br />

25% in the Guyane Maritime licence in which the Zaedyus oil<br />

discovery was made in late 2011. By contrast, its holdings in 2c<br />

provide it with a 30% share in only 12,479 b/d of oil and 431<br />

mmcfd of gas (2012 average).<br />

In NGC’s quest to go upstream, where it is currently limited<br />

to 15% in the Repsol-operated Teak/Samaan/Poui block, even<br />

modest access to oil and gas production is welcome. It already<br />

buys 220 mmcfd from the BHP Billiton-operated block 2c; now<br />

it will be regaining some of that in revenue from its ownership<br />

position. Block 3a is an undeveloped play at the moment, but<br />

there could be significant amounts of oil and gas available<br />

from that source in the future.<br />

NGC’s new president, Indar Maharaj, has not confirmed<br />

the company’s takeover of Total’s holdings, nor the names<br />

of the other two intended acquisitions, only conceding in<br />

an interview with this YEARBOOK that “the discussions are at<br />

different stages at the moment.” The company’s strategic goal,<br />

he explains, is “to get into all aspects of the value chain – once<br />

the risk is acceptable, since I have to be very, very careful with<br />

risk. But if I want to go upstream and I see an entity that is<br />

already in operation and doing well, then I’m minimising my<br />

risk while getting an opportunity.”<br />

In 2012, NGC struck out boldly in another value-adding area<br />

– marketing the three cargos of LNG produced from the 30<br />

mmcfd of gas it buys for export from EOG Resources Trinidad.<br />

Previously, these were sold internationally on its behalf by BP,<br />

but even before the new president came on board, NGC had<br />

been moving to insert itself into the LNG trading business.<br />

Its first cargo, of about 118,000 cubic metres, was sold to the<br />

international trading company Gunvor at US$9.25 per mmbtu,<br />

minister Ramnarine has revealed. This was considerably more<br />

than the US$1.60 per mmbtu that NGC earned when BP Gas<br />

Marketing was doing the job.<br />

Subsequently, two other cargos were bought by Brazil’s<br />

Petrobras and Trafigura, at steadily increasing prices.<br />

According to Anand Ragbir, NGC’s vice president, commercial:<br />

“We earned about six times more for our second cargo than we<br />

used to get from BP, and about eight times more for the third.”<br />

Clearly, the company has been a quick learner and appears to<br />

have mastered the intricacies of global LNG marketing.<br />

On the home from, NGC will be helping to make compressed<br />

natural gas (CNG) a more attractive fuel for motorists in <strong>2013</strong>.<br />

“The establishment of a new company to promote the concept<br />

is one of the options being considered,” Maharaj confirms. It<br />

will probably be partnered by its fellow state firms, Petrotrin<br />

and National Petroleum (NP).<br />

Such a company would have to deal with all aspects of<br />

the CNG initiative – service stations, vehicle conversions, and<br />

pipelines to take gas to the pumps. But Maharaj asserts: “We’ve<br />

got to break this cycle of indecision over CNG.”<br />

Anand Ragbir (courtesy NGC)<br />

44


Companies<br />

repsol trinidad and tobago<br />

Repsol slims itself down<br />

Repsol finds itself a much smaller player in the<br />

Countries<br />

Trinidad and Tobago energy sector in <strong>2013</strong> than it<br />

was only a year earlier.<br />

Its major asset – its shareholding in Atlantic’s<br />

four LNG trains – has, from all accounts, been<br />

purchased by Royal Dutch Shell, leaving Repsol with no<br />

ownership interest in the 15.2 million tonnes a year of gas<br />

liquefaction capacity in the world’s sixth largest LNG trader,<br />

though it may well continue to buy LNG from Trinidad and<br />

Tobago to service its own supply commitments.<br />

That Atlantic holding amounted to 20% in train one, 25%<br />

in trains 2 and 3, and 22.2% in train 4.<br />

However, Repsol’s presence is still significant. It owns<br />

30% of bpTT, the biggest upstream company in the<br />

energy sector, which produces around 408,000 barrels of oil<br />

equivalent a day (boed), mainly natural gas. It has 70% and<br />

operatorship in the Teak/Samaan/Poui (TSP) block off the<br />

east coast, which produces close to 12,000 b/d of oil and 30<br />

mmcfd of gas.<br />

Repsol is concentrating on the one<br />

asset of which it is in charge – the<br />

TSP block – and maximising its<br />

performance<br />

Repsol Headquarters, Trinidad (courtesy Repsol)<br />

Repsol’s major asset – its shareholding<br />

in Atlantic’s four LNG trains – has,<br />

from all accounts, been purchased<br />

by Royal Dutch Shell<br />

Repsol is also a 30%, non-operating shareholder in block<br />

5b, on the maritime boundary line with Venezuela southwest<br />

of Trinidad, where around 2 trillion cubic feet of gas was<br />

identified by the Manakin 1 exploration well 13 years ago.<br />

The Coquina 1 well sunk by Venezuela’s PdVSA in 1982 also<br />

encountered gas, in shallower horizons.<br />

This is a significant asset from Repsol’s point of view,<br />

but it can’t be monetised until agreement is reached with<br />

Venezuela on unitising the reservoirs on each side. The latest<br />

word on the matter from Norman Christie, regional president,<br />

Trinidad, for bpTT (the operator of 5b), is that “the reserves<br />

have been decided but divisions have not yet been agreed.”<br />

Not surprisingly, Christie sees Manakin as “a medium-term<br />

development matter.”<br />

Repsol also partnered BHP Billiton in the 2010 deep water<br />

acreage auction to bid for block 23b. The bid was not<br />

acceptable to the energy ministry in the terms in which<br />

it was couched, and the parties were supposed to hold<br />

discussions “with a view to attaining a mutually acceptable<br />

proposal.” Those discussions have not yet concluded, as far<br />

as this YEARBOOK is aware, and it is possible that BHP Billiton<br />

may no longer be interested in them, having been awarded<br />

no fewer than four other deep water blocks – TTDAA 5-6 and<br />

28-29 – in the 2012 deep water bid round.<br />

Which leaves Repsol to concentrate on the one asset<br />

of which it is in charge – the TSP block – and maximise its<br />

performance in <strong>2013</strong>. It is attempting to do that by drilling<br />

two appraisal wells and six in-fill wells, the latter in the Teak<br />

field, the old workhorse of the block. Some non-rig work will<br />

also be undertaken to improve the wells’ flow.<br />

TSP, being old fields, are declining fast, and Repsol’s<br />

challenge is how to arrest, and even reverse, that slide. It<br />

has done a commendable job so far, even managing to push<br />

production up a little between 2011 (average 11,771 b/d)<br />

and 2012 (average 11,961 b/d).<br />

46


Countries<br />

Solaris Energy is the result of an adroit move by a<br />

48<br />

Companies<br />

solaris energy<br />

Oil producer jumps<br />

into renewables<br />

small Trinidad and Tobago oil producer, Moraven<br />

Holdings, into renewable energy (RE), well before<br />

any of its fellow independents have thought of the<br />

idea. It’s an obvious case of hedging your bets, on<br />

the assumption that RE is going to claim a growing share of<br />

the energy market in Caricom in the years ahead, once its<br />

15 members act on the basis of their own regional energy<br />

policy (see elsewhere in this YEARBOOK).<br />

Moraven Holdings, a public company quoted on the<br />

second tier of the Trinidad and Tobago stock exchange,<br />

is at the bottom end of the oil production scale, lifting an<br />

average of only 229 b/d in 2012, according to the ministry<br />

of energy and energy affairs. This comes from its subsidiary<br />

Mora Oil Ventures’ Mora A production platform off Trinidad’s<br />

southeast coast.<br />

Presumably seeing the writing on the wall, Moraven<br />

Holdings set up Solaris Energy in 2010. It acts as distributor<br />

for the flat plate and vacuum tube solar water heaters and<br />

photovoltaic solar panels made by Solaris Global Energy in<br />

Barbados, of which it is the majority owner. The Barbados<br />

entity was formerly Aqua Sol Components, a company with<br />

30 years’ experience in manufacturing solar energy products.<br />

Barbados has long led the way in Caricom in using<br />

solar energy for water heating in place of electricity or<br />

liquefied petroleum gas. It has “the third highest penetration<br />

of solar water heaters in the world,” according to Vincent<br />

McClean, Solaris Global Energy’s chief innovation officer. The<br />

company is one of three manufacturing solar products in<br />

Barbados; there is another in St Lucia – and that’s about it as<br />

far as Caricom is concerned.<br />

Solaris regards itself as being head and shoulders above<br />

the competition: its new 8,000 sq foot factory at the Six<br />

Roads industrial estate in St Phillip, opened in October 2012<br />

and, powered by a 50kW photovoltaic system, generates<br />

enough electricity to be able to feed back into the Barbados<br />

Light and Power’s national transmission grid.<br />

In short, it is not only preaching the benefits of renewable<br />

energy (RE) to its clients but using RE itself: Solaris Global<br />

Energy is the only RE products producer in the region<br />

running fully on RE.<br />

Barbados’s ministry of transport and works has received<br />

that message loud and clear, and recently installed a 10kW<br />

wind turbine at its Chance Hall depot in St Lucy, mounted<br />

on a 48-foot structure. Excess energy is stored in batteries,<br />

which makes the facility completely self-sufficient. Unlike<br />

Solaris’s own 50kW photovoltaic system, the wind turbine is<br />

not tied into the national grid, and does not need to be, since<br />

it relies entirely on its own resources.<br />

Solaris Global Energy has broken into the export market<br />

and says its products are now “distributed regionally in<br />

more than a dozen countries” (not surprisingly, it expects to<br />

have a turnover of Bds$12 million “in the near future”). This<br />

is a clear indication that RE is gradually catching on in the<br />

<strong>Caribbean</strong> archipelago.<br />

McClean sees this as an inevitable development. “The high<br />

cost of fossil fuels, except in the case of Trinidad and Tobago,<br />

impacts the economies of those countries so harshly that it<br />

is a natural tendency to move in the direction of renewable<br />

energy,” he told this YEARBOOK. “The use of RE has a very<br />

beneficial influence on the economic viability of the hotel<br />

industry in the <strong>Caribbean</strong>.”<br />

He forecasts that solar water heaters “will be the most<br />

popular RE system in the region for some time”, but that,<br />

within 20 years, “solar electricity (photovoltaics) will take<br />

over, simply because of its far greater usefulness.”<br />

Vincent McClean, Solaris Global Energy Ltd. Director and Chief Innovation<br />

Officer; Sen. Hon. Darcy Boyce, Minister of State in the Barbados Office of<br />

the Prime Minister; and Keith Scotland, Solaris Energy Ltd. Chairman discuss<br />

a solar water heating unit at Solaris Energy’s new factory gala opening on<br />

October 20, 2012.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!