BusinessDay 23 Aug 2018
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Thursday <strong>23</strong> <strong>Aug</strong>ust <strong>2018</strong><br />
A4 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
FT<br />
Facebook removes<br />
fake accounts...<br />
Continued from page A3<br />
of what Facebook calls “inauthentic<br />
behaviour” traced to Iran.<br />
The news comes a day after<br />
Microsoft said it had uncovered<br />
an effort by hackers with links to<br />
the Kremlin to target Republicanleaning<br />
political groups, triggering<br />
alarm on Capitol Hill.<br />
Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook’s<br />
founder and chief executive, said<br />
the social network was facing “sophisticated”<br />
and “well funded”<br />
adversaries. He added that the<br />
company’s investment in fighting<br />
such manipulation was beginning<br />
to pay off.<br />
“The shift we’ve made from reactive<br />
to proactive detection will make<br />
Facebook safer for everyone over<br />
time,” he said. Mr Zuckerberg added<br />
that several similar investigations<br />
were under way.<br />
Facebook also said on Tuesday<br />
that it would now rate users on<br />
their trustworthiness, in a bid to<br />
halt the spread of misinformation<br />
by enlisting the help of members of<br />
the network.<br />
The announcement came three<br />
weeks after Facebook said it had<br />
removed the first co-ordinated<br />
disinformation campaign targeting<br />
the US midterm congressional<br />
elections in November, which some<br />
American politicians identified as<br />
originating in Russia. The company<br />
did not specify there were any link<br />
with the latest fake accounts and the<br />
November vote.<br />
In the first evidence of interference<br />
backed by Iran, Facebook said<br />
one campaign, which had created<br />
pages in 2013 primarily to propagate<br />
posts about the Middle East, had<br />
switched their focus to US and UK<br />
politics last year. Facebook said it<br />
was still investigating the content,<br />
but had discovered no “significant”<br />
advertising by the pages ahead of<br />
the Brexit referendum in 2016.<br />
Senator Mark Warner, vicechairman<br />
of the Senate intelligence<br />
committee, said he had been stating<br />
for months that social media<br />
manipulation was not restricted to<br />
a single troll farm in St Petersburg,<br />
referring to campaigns by the Internet<br />
Research Agency.<br />
“We also learned today that<br />
the Iranians are now following the<br />
Kremlin’s playbook from 2016,” he<br />
said. “While I’m encouraged to see<br />
Facebook taking steps to rid their<br />
platforms of these bad actors, there’s<br />
clearly more work to be done.”<br />
Facebook said it had briefed the<br />
US Treasury and the state department<br />
because the Iranian accounts<br />
had been able to buy advertising.<br />
US sanctions allow companies to<br />
provide internet services to users<br />
in Iran for personal communications,<br />
but they are required to screen<br />
advertisers to ensure they are not in<br />
the country.<br />
Twitter also said on Tuesday<br />
that it had removed 284 accounts<br />
that it believed had originated in<br />
Iran for engaging in “co-ordinated<br />
manipulation”.<br />
Facebook was alerted to suspicious<br />
activity by a set of pages under<br />
the name of Liberty Front Press by<br />
FireEye, a cyber security company,<br />
and then identified additional accounts<br />
and pages.<br />
NATIONAL NEWS<br />
Malawi’s President Peter Mutharika (centre) says politics is at the root of his deputy’s allegations of corruption against him © AFP<br />
Malawi president dismisses graft allegations<br />
Mutharika’s dispute with deputy threatens resumption of aid donations<br />
Joseph CoTTerill<br />
Malawi’s President Peter<br />
Mutharika has described<br />
allegations of corruption<br />
levelled against him by his own<br />
deputy as “complete nonsense”,<br />
fuelling a stand-off that threatens<br />
to further delay the return of foreign<br />
aid to the southern African<br />
nation.<br />
Saulos Chilima, the vice-president,<br />
has accused his rival of<br />
high-level graft, including over a<br />
$4m contract to provide rations to<br />
Malawi’s police force. Mr Chilima,<br />
who left the president’s ruling<br />
party in June, has called the scandal<br />
over the police contract “the<br />
tip of the iceberg”.<br />
The acrimonious split at the top<br />
of the government — with Mr Chilima<br />
planning to run against Mr<br />
Mutharika in next year’s elections<br />
— comes as Malawi tries to recover<br />
EU vows to get tough on UK’s market access after Brexit<br />
Plan to step up oversight of ‘equivalence’ rules that finance sector will rely on<br />
Jim Brunsden<br />
The EU’s financial services chief<br />
has warned that Brussels will<br />
be strict in policing the Britain’s<br />
rights of access to the bloc’s<br />
market after Brexit.<br />
Valdis Dombrovskis said he<br />
welcomed UK proposals to build<br />
market access for the City of London<br />
around EU rules, known as “equivalence”.<br />
But he said market access<br />
could never be taken for granted,<br />
with Brussels determined to toughen<br />
its assessments of whether countries<br />
meet the conditions.<br />
The equivalence rules make it<br />
easier for non-EU financial institutions<br />
to operate in the single market<br />
if the European Commission<br />
decides that their home country’s<br />
financial regulations are as tough<br />
as the EU’s own.<br />
Mr Dombrovskis said Brussels<br />
was not offering any kind of “super<br />
equivalence” to the UK, and that<br />
assessments of whether Britain<br />
qualified would require individual<br />
assessments “sector by sector and<br />
legislation by legislation”.<br />
He also said Brussels was pressing<br />
ahead with measures to reinforce<br />
oversight of equivalence<br />
access, with stronger requirements<br />
for countries’ financial supervisors<br />
to share information with the EU<br />
and more monitoring of whether<br />
from the systemic looting of state<br />
coffers under former president<br />
Joyce Banda. The $50m Cashgate<br />
scandal in 2013-14, when a third<br />
of the government’s budget was<br />
stolen, led international donors<br />
who funded nearly half of Malawi’s<br />
budget to withdraw funding, leaving<br />
the economy foundering.<br />
Speaking to the Financial Times<br />
from his presidential palace in the<br />
capital Lilongwe, Mr Mutharika<br />
said politics was at the root of Mr<br />
Chilima’s claims.<br />
“He has simply decided he<br />
wants to be president,” said the<br />
79-year-old former law professor.<br />
“It is complete nonsense — it is<br />
all perception. Corruption is not<br />
greater now than it was before [the<br />
Cashgate revelations].”<br />
He continued: “We are doing<br />
more development than at any<br />
time in the country’s history. If<br />
there was so much corruption<br />
there would be no money to do<br />
jurisdictions continued to meet the<br />
criteria.<br />
“We see that there is a need to<br />
strengthen systemic monitoring of<br />
continued compliance,” said Mr<br />
Dombrovskis. “So this is one area<br />
where we will come with a more<br />
systematic approach.”<br />
Many EU officials privately assume<br />
that the UK — barring a sea<br />
change in its regulatory and supervisory<br />
approach — would have little<br />
difficulty in securing equivalence<br />
rights after Brexit, given that it already<br />
applies EU rules.<br />
But Mr Dombrovskis’ remarks<br />
are a sign of Brussels’ determination<br />
to prevent regulatory undercutting<br />
that could hand City firms an advantage<br />
over EU competitors.<br />
The British government, in a<br />
white paper on Brexit published<br />
in July, said it should benefit from<br />
a full set of equivalence rights after<br />
the end of its post-Brexit transition<br />
period in 2020. Britain also called<br />
for equivalence to be expanded<br />
to “encompass a broader range of<br />
cross-border activities”.<br />
Mr Dombrovskis said Brussels<br />
was open to discussion of adding<br />
more equivalence possibilities<br />
into EU law, noting that national<br />
governments were negotiating draft<br />
legislation that would clarify access<br />
rights for non-EU brokerages and<br />
other investment firms.<br />
what we are doing.”<br />
However, Mr Chilima, a<br />
45-year-old former telecoms chief<br />
executive, says corruption has<br />
worsened since Cashgate, echoing<br />
US President Donald Trump with<br />
calls to “drain the swamp”.<br />
Civil society groups have also<br />
accused Mr Mutharika of corruption<br />
after money linked to the<br />
$4m police contacts found its way<br />
into bank accounts of the ruling<br />
party. Malawi’s main opposition<br />
party has called for the president<br />
to resign over a scandal that has<br />
provoked popular anger.<br />
“Corruption is still going<br />
. . . They are taking from our<br />
pockets,” said Niziya Nyasula, 43,<br />
a trader in Lilongwe.<br />
Mr Mutharika insisted that<br />
about $200,000 received as a political<br />
donation from the contractor<br />
was returned as soon as the<br />
party discovered possible links to<br />
corruption.<br />
“We are, if you want, at a relatively<br />
early stage, because the UK<br />
white paper is actually the first time<br />
the UK clearly acknowledges that<br />
it is willing to build on this system<br />
of enhanced equivalence,” he said.<br />
“We can now get into more detail<br />
and discuss what exactly that<br />
means, what areas are covered, are<br />
there some important areas missing<br />
and so on.”<br />
The UK government, in slides<br />
published this week, said its proposals<br />
would allow each side to “retain<br />
autonomous judgment about access<br />
to their market” while also<br />
providing certainty and stability to<br />
businesses.<br />
The plans include a “bilateral<br />
agreement” that would require<br />
each side to consult the other before<br />
withdrawing access and provide a<br />
safeguard to make sure that “existing<br />
contracts can be fulfilled even if<br />
access is withdrawn”.<br />
Mr Dombrovskis said it was positive<br />
that Britain had embraced a<br />
“more realistic way forward” compared<br />
with earlier plans to bypass<br />
equivalence by securing broader, permanent<br />
access rights — an idea Brussels<br />
has comprehensively rejected.<br />
He also said that while equivalence<br />
was in the EU’s gift, Britain<br />
should not underestimate its stability.<br />
The EU has never reversed an<br />
access decision.<br />
Mortgage bond investors<br />
thaw on retail sector<br />
More retail properties are being securitised<br />
and a ‘big short’ trade has reversed<br />
Joe Rennison<br />
Commercial mortgages on<br />
US retail properties are<br />
making up an increasing<br />
percentage of the loans that are<br />
bundled together in bonds for sale<br />
to investors, reflecting a thawing<br />
of sentiment towards the sector.<br />
The percentage of retail mortgages<br />
in new “conduit” commercial<br />
mortgage-backed securities<br />
(CMBS), where multiple loans are<br />
combined for sale, has risen to 32<br />
per cent since the start of July, after<br />
almost two years of weak interest<br />
among investors.<br />
The figure so far this quarter<br />
compares with 24 per cent in the<br />
second quarter and a low of 22 per<br />
cent in the first, and with 24 per<br />
cent for 2017 as a whole, according<br />
to data from S&P Global.<br />
Investors have worried about<br />
the ability of shopping mall owners<br />
to make mortgage payments<br />
and repay loans in an age where<br />
ecommerce is taking a toll on traditional<br />
retailers. Many brick-andmortar<br />
retail chains have pulled<br />
out of second-tier malls as they<br />
cut store numbers and lay off staff.<br />
But <strong>2018</strong> has brought improved<br />
results for some companies that<br />
have been able to adapt. In the<br />
equity market, the S&P 500 department<br />
stores sector has risen more<br />
than 40 per cent in <strong>2018</strong>, and the<br />
large chains Macy’s and Kohl’s are<br />
both up over 45 per cent.<br />
The better performance has<br />
helped eased concerns among<br />
CMBS investors about exposure to<br />
retail loans, said Tracy Chen, head<br />
of structured credit at Brandywine<br />
Global Investment Management.<br />
“I think it shows investors have<br />
changed their view on the retail sector,”<br />
she said. “Last year, there was total<br />
panic and everyone tried to avoid retail,<br />
but this year things are different.”<br />
The CMBS market has been an<br />
area of intense trading for investors<br />
placing bets on the future of<br />
retail.<br />
The so-called CMBX 6, a derivatives<br />
index that tracks CMBS<br />
and was originated in 2012, which<br />
has a particularly large exposure to<br />
retail properties, was a particular<br />
favourite of short-sellers. After<br />
falling sharply in 2017, it is up 3<br />
per cent this year.<br />
The newly issued CMBS appear<br />
to include a narrower range of<br />
loans from the retail sector, excluding<br />
many of the regional malls most<br />
reliant on big-name “anchor” tenants<br />
to draw shoppers and focusing<br />
instead on top-tier properties.<br />
“Not all retail is bad,” said Ms<br />
Chen.<br />
Chris Acito, chief executive of<br />
Gapstow Capital Partners, said:<br />
“We went though a period where<br />
all retail was bad, but people have<br />
spent time studying the sector<br />
and developed a more nuanced<br />
view about which properties to<br />
be worried about. I think a more<br />
considered view of retail has really<br />
developed.”<br />
Other investors agree but also<br />
point out that the rise in retail<br />
loans being securitised comes at<br />
a time when interest rates remain<br />
at historic lows, meaning investors<br />
are willing to take on more risk for<br />
the sake of a higher yield.