22.05.2019 Views

Credit Management June 2019

The CICM magazine for consumer and commercial credit professionals

The CICM magazine for consumer and commercial credit professionals

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

CREDIT MANAGEMENT<br />

CM<br />

JUNE <strong>2019</strong> £12.50<br />

THE CICM MAGAZINE FOR CONSUMER AND<br />

COMMERCIAL CREDIT PROFESSIONALS<br />

The Big Issue<br />

Debt advice: the elephant<br />

in the room<br />

80<br />

YEARS<br />

HMRC’s plans to<br />

become a preferred<br />

creditor. Page 15<br />

The pan-European market<br />

for Non-performing loans.<br />

Page 21


Taking control of debt<br />

HCE Group helps you take back control of debt owed to you<br />

or your client. With our wide range of enforcement services,<br />

skilled enforcement agents and outstanding recovery rates,<br />

our team is on hand to help.<br />

When you choose us to enforce your writs of control, you<br />

will find that we put service and performance right at the<br />

heart of everything we do. We aim to not just meet, but also<br />

exceed your expectations.<br />

Instruct us for<br />

Enforcement of judgments and tribunal awards<br />

Eviction of activists, squatters and travellers<br />

Eviction of commercial and residential tenants<br />

Commercial landlord services<br />

Tracing and process serving<br />

Vehicle recovery and enquiry<br />

To find out more or instruct us<br />

08450 999 666<br />

www.hcegroup.co.uk


23<br />

15<br />

VIEW FROM<br />

THE SEA FRONT<br />

DAVID ANDREWS<br />

JUNE <strong>2019</strong><br />

www.cicm.com<br />

CONTENTS<br />

– INSOLVENCY<br />

The impact of HMRC’s plans to become a<br />

preferred creditor.<br />

18 – COVER STORY<br />

The future funding of debt advice<br />

remains a large elephant in the room.<br />

23 – VIEW FROM THE<br />

SEA FRONT<br />

David Andrews considers whether bank<br />

managers still exist.<br />

24 – STAR PERFORMER<br />

Julian Winfield outlines the pan-<br />

European market for Non-performing<br />

loans.<br />

40<br />

LEGAL MATTERS<br />

PETER WALKER<br />

26 – COUNTRY FOCUS<br />

Is Ethiopia the new land of opportunity<br />

for exporters?<br />

30 – OPINION<br />

International agreements require<br />

different terms for different regions.<br />

40 – LEGAL MATTERS<br />

The danger of dividends and a polluted<br />

river.<br />

CICM GOVERNANCE<br />

View our digital version online at www.cicm.com. Log on to the Members’<br />

area, and click on the tab labelled ‘<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> magazine’<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> is distributed to the entire UK and international CICM<br />

membership, as well as additional subscribers<br />

Reproduction in whole or part is forbidden without specific permission. Opinions expressed in this magazine do<br />

not, unless stated, reflect those of the Chartered Institute of <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong>. The Editor reserves the right to<br />

abbreviate letters if necessary. The Institute is registered as a charity. The mark ‘<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong>’ is a registered<br />

trade mark of the Chartered Institute of <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong>.<br />

Any articles published relating to English law will differ from laws in Scotland and Wales.<br />

26<br />

COUNTRY FOCUS -<br />

ADAM BERNSTEIN<br />

President Stephen Baister FCICM / Chief Executive Philip King FCICM CdipAF MBA<br />

Executive Board Pete Whitmore FCICM – Chair / Debbie Nolan FCICM(Grad) – Vice Chair<br />

Glen Bullivant FCICM – Treasurer / Larry Coltman FCICM, Victoria Herd FCICM(Grad), Bryony Pettifor FCICM(Grad)<br />

Advisory Council Sarah Aldridge FCICM(Grad) / Laurie Beagle FCICM / Kim Delaney-Bowen MCICM / Glen Bullivant FCICM<br />

Lauren Carter FCICM / Larry Coltman FCICM / Victoria Herd FCICM(Grad) / Philip Holbrough MCICM / Laural Jefferies MCICM<br />

Diana Keeling FCICM / Martin Kirby FCICM / Christelle Madie FCICM / Julie-Anne Moody-Webster MCICM<br />

Debbie Nolan FCICM(Grad) / Ute Ogholoh MCICM / Bryony Pettifor FCICM(Grad) / Allan Poole MCICM / Phil Rice FCICM<br />

Chris Sanders FCICM / Paul Taylor MCICM / Pete Whitmore FCICM.<br />

Publisher<br />

Chartered Institute of <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

The Water Mill, Station Road, South Luffenham<br />

OAKHAM, LE15 8NB<br />

Telephone: 01780 722900<br />

Email: editorial@cicm.com<br />

Website: www.cicm.com<br />

CMM: www.creditmanagement.org.uk<br />

Managing Editor<br />

Sean Feast FCICM<br />

Deputy Editor<br />

Alex Simmons<br />

Art Editor<br />

Andrew Morris<br />

Telephone: 01780 722910<br />

Email: andrew.morris@cicm.com<br />

Editorial Team<br />

Imogen Hart, Rob Howard and Iona Yadallee<br />

Advertising<br />

Grace Ghattas<br />

Telephone: 020 3603 7946<br />

Email: grace@cabbell.co.uk<br />

Printers<br />

Stephens & George Print Group<br />

<strong>2019</strong> subscriptions<br />

UK: £112 per annum<br />

International: £145 per annum<br />

Single copies: £12.50<br />

ISSN 0265-2099<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 3


EDITOR’S COLUMN<br />

The benefit of naming<br />

and shaming<br />

Sean Feast FCICM<br />

Managing Editor<br />

AND so, at last, it happened.<br />

Seventeen signatories to<br />

the Prompt Payment Code<br />

‘named and shamed’ for<br />

failing to honour their<br />

commitments to paying 95<br />

percent of all supplier invoices within 60<br />

days.<br />

Some of the names may have been a<br />

surprise: Vodafone; Rolls Royce; DHL.<br />

Others perhaps less so: Balfour Beatty;<br />

Costain; Laing O’Rourke. The wave<br />

of negative publicity surrounding the<br />

construction industry, in particular,<br />

suggests that other names are sure to<br />

follow.<br />

The reaction from in-house and external<br />

PRs to the respective businesses has ranged<br />

from ‘take it on the chin’ to outright denial.<br />

One suggested that their client had never<br />

been notified, and had to go into fast retreat<br />

when it was proven that they had not only<br />

been told, but had also responded. Another<br />

that it was unfair that their client had been<br />

‘singled out’, when there were many other<br />

firms that were just as bad. That, as our<br />

Chief Executive Philip King FCICM points<br />

out in his opinion piece (page 10), is akin to<br />

justifying a speeding ticket by saying that<br />

everyone else is doing it.<br />

Since the PPC was launched, it has never<br />

been in the remit of the Compliance Board<br />

to publish the names of those signatories<br />

that have been suspended or removed. This<br />

changed with the announcement of the<br />

Secretary of State for Business, Energy &<br />

Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Greg Clark last<br />

year that he would name and shame the<br />

transgressors.<br />

That it took so long from his<br />

announcement to the publication of this<br />

new list is perhaps a story for another<br />

time, but one might look at certain<br />

names on the list and draw one’s own<br />

conclusions. Fear of publishing certain<br />

names cogniscent of the damage that<br />

it might cause to their reputation and<br />

future profitability is, arguably, total<br />

confirmation that the Prompt Payment<br />

Code is a force to be reckoned with.<br />

The metaphorical handcuffs that<br />

were previously around the Compliance<br />

Board’s wrists have undoubtedly<br />

contributed to the negative publicity<br />

that has accompanied the Code in recent<br />

months. It is difficult to defend a Code<br />

against accusations of not having any<br />

teeth when you have a gag around your<br />

mouth. Now that is changing. Now at<br />

last the Code, and the Compliance Board,<br />

are free to demonstrate just what the<br />

Code is capable of – changing payment<br />

behaviour. And it is working. Of the<br />

seventeen companies named, fifteen have<br />

committed to changing their payment<br />

practices with action plans that will be<br />

closely monitored.<br />

The metaphorical handcuffs that were<br />

previously around the Compliance Board’s<br />

wrists have undoubtedly contributed to the<br />

negative publicity that has accompanied<br />

the Code in recent months.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 4


We provide companies around the<br />

globe with faster cash allocation,<br />

clearer information, and better<br />

control over cash flow using AI<br />

Intelligent Cash Allocation & <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> Software<br />

We’re the only truly<br />

Global Solution<br />

We work with any currency, any<br />

bank, any ERP, any country and in<br />

any language. Over 50 countries<br />

worldwide rely on Rimilia.<br />

Built by Finance<br />

Professionals<br />

Built by finance professionals,<br />

for finance professionals. We<br />

know what matters to you, so<br />

we can enable instant ROI<br />

and success.<br />

Industry-leading<br />

Artificial Intelligence<br />

We’re on the cutting-edge of<br />

finance AI development,<br />

allowing faster, better<br />

decision making.<br />

Get in touch…<br />

01527 872 123<br />

enquiries@rimilia.com • www.rimilia.com<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 5


CMNEWS<br />

A round-up of news stories from the<br />

world of consumer and commercial credit<br />

Written by – Sean Feast FCICM and Alex Simmons<br />

BUSINESSES NAMED AND<br />

SHAMED FOR FAILING TO PAY<br />

THEIR SUPPLIERS ON TIME<br />

SEVENTEEN companies who<br />

fail to meet the standard of the<br />

Prompt Payment Code (PPC)<br />

have been removed or suspended<br />

in the first of a quarterly series<br />

of announcements expected from the<br />

Chartered Institute of <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

(CICM) throughout the year.<br />

Rolls Royce, Vodafone, and DHL were<br />

among the best-known brands to have<br />

been named alongside a tranche of<br />

businesses from the construction sector<br />

including John Sisk & Son Limited, Costain<br />

Limited, and Interserve Construction.<br />

A further company – The Go-Ahead<br />

Group Plc, a passenger transport provider,<br />

has been re-instated to the Code after filing<br />

data to show that it has been paying 95<br />

percent of all invoices within 60 days for<br />

the last reported period. Go-Ahead<br />

Group has also provided the Prompt<br />

Payment Code Compliance Board with<br />

assurance that it will continue to honour<br />

both the spirit and the mandatory<br />

requirements of the Code going forward.<br />

Thousands of companies who sign up<br />

to the Code, administered by CICM on<br />

behalf of the Government, pledge to uphold<br />

its best practice for payment standards<br />

in order to help end the culture of late<br />

payment, particularly for small businesses.<br />

This includes a commitment to pay 95<br />

percent of all supplier invoices within 60<br />

days.<br />

Based on the new Payment Practices<br />

Reporting data that large businesses must<br />

publicly report, the CICM is reviewing<br />

whether businesses are meeting the<br />

standards of the Code and paying their<br />

suppliers promptly. The first phase of<br />

these reviews has identified 17 businesses<br />

to be removed or suspended, with more<br />

removals and suspensions expected in<br />

the second phase of review currently<br />

underway. Companies are already taking<br />

action to improve, which is welcomed<br />

and supported by CICM. Interserve<br />

Construction, for example, has improved<br />

its performance based on an action plan<br />

agreed with the CICM, which has seen the<br />

business reduce the number of payments<br />

over 60 days by ten percent over the<br />

second half of last year; the company is<br />

continuing to improve towards compliance<br />

over the next six months.<br />

The Prompt Payment Code Compliance<br />

Board, chaired by CICM’s Chief Executive<br />

Philip King FCICM and including the<br />

Small Business Commissioner Paul Uppal,<br />

regularly reviews the data reported by<br />

large companies under the Payment<br />

Practices Reporting Regulations to ensure<br />

they are upholding their commitments.<br />

Businesses suspended from the Code are<br />

invited to produce an action plan setting<br />

out how they will achieve compliance<br />

with the Code within an agreed period.<br />

When they have achieved compliance<br />

their status as a Code signatory will be<br />

reinstated. If they do not, then they will be<br />

removed.<br />

Philip said he is disappointed with<br />

the actions of a minority who continue<br />

to treat their suppliers unfairly: “I take<br />

no satisfaction in having to name them<br />

publicly,” he explained. “Conversely, we are<br />

encouraged by the actions taken by The<br />

Go-Ahead Group which has now positively<br />

engaged with the Board and given us<br />

the reassurances we need to allow them<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 6


THE NOT–SO DIRTY DOZEN<br />

Twelve businesses have been suspended from the PPC, for not paying their suppliers<br />

in line with the Code, but they have committed to make changes to meet the standards<br />

of the Code and pay suppliers promptly. They include:<br />

Atos IT Services UK&I – an IT services business and main UK subsidiary of Atos SE;<br />

Balfour Beatty Plc – an international infrastructure group;<br />

British Sugar UK – a British producer of sugar for the UK food market;<br />

Costain Limited – a construction and engineering company;<br />

Engie Services Limited – a facilities management services company, part of Engie<br />

Group.<br />

Interserve Construction – a construction company owned by Interserve Group Limited;<br />

Kellogg Brown & Root Limited – a facilities management and construction engineering<br />

company, part of KBR Inc;<br />

Laing O’Rourke – an international engineering business;<br />

Persimmon Homes Limited – a UK house building company;<br />

Rolls-Royce Plc – an engineering business focused on power and propulsion systems;<br />

SSE – electrical and telecoms provider; and<br />

Vodafone Limited – a telecoms company, part of the multinational Vodafone Group<br />

Limited<br />

Kelly Tolhurst<br />

Minister for Small Business<br />

’’By naming<br />

transgressors we<br />

are supporting small<br />

businesses in the<br />

supply chain”<br />

to remain a Signatory to the Code. We<br />

will continue to monitor their position<br />

to ensure future reported data shows the<br />

expected improvements and compliance.<br />

“As part of our work driving culture<br />

change to end late payments, we will<br />

continue to challenge signatories to the<br />

Code if the obligatory Payment Practice<br />

Reporting data suggests that their<br />

practices are not compliant with the Code.”<br />

Small Business Commissioner Paul<br />

Uppal, a PPC Compliance Board member,<br />

said he will continue to support Philip<br />

and the CICM in removing or suspending<br />

non-compliant signatories from the code:<br />

“It is essential the code has credibility and<br />

demonstrates a commitment to ensure<br />

small businesses are treated fairly. My<br />

team has already recovered more than<br />

£3.5 million in late payments and is ready<br />

and available to support small businesses<br />

experiencing poor payment practices”.<br />

News of the suspensions builds on a<br />

government announcement in November<br />

2018, where failure of companies to<br />

demonstrate prompt payment to their<br />

suppliers could result in them being<br />

prevented from winning government<br />

contracts.<br />

From 1 September <strong>2019</strong>, any supplier<br />

who bids for a government contract above<br />

£5 million per annum will be required to<br />

answer questions about their payment<br />

practices and performance. The expected<br />

standard is to pay 95 percent of invoices in<br />

60 days across all their business.<br />

Any supplier who is unable to<br />

demonstrate that they have systems in<br />

place that are effective and ensure a fair<br />

and responsible approach to payment of<br />

their supply chain may be excluded from<br />

bidding.<br />

Kelly Tolhurst, Minister for Small<br />

Business believes the Prompt Payment<br />

Code is a positive force for good: “By<br />

naming transgressors we are supporting<br />

small businesses in the supply chain,” she<br />

claimed.<br />

“We remain committed to supporting<br />

small businesses against poor payment<br />

practice and are delighted to see that the<br />

Prompt Payment Code Compliance Board<br />

has acted to expose those whose payment<br />

practices fall outside of their obligations to<br />

treat suppliers fairly.”<br />

In October the Business Secretary Greg<br />

Clark announced that further reforms to<br />

the Prompt Payment Code were being<br />

considered, including whether the Small<br />

Business Commissioner should have a<br />

greater role in its administration as part of<br />

his wider role in tackling late payment.<br />

Philip King FCICM<br />

Chief Executive of the CICM<br />

“I take no satisfaction<br />

in having to name<br />

them publicly”<br />

THE INFAMOUS FIVE<br />

Five companies have been removed<br />

from the Code for non-compliance and<br />

not providing a plan for how they will<br />

meet the terms of the Code, but three of<br />

the five have since committed to make<br />

changes.<br />

BHP Billiton – a global resources<br />

business;<br />

DHL – a global logistics business;<br />

GKN Plc – a multinational aerospace<br />

and automotive components business;<br />

John Sisk & Son Limited – an<br />

international construction company;<br />

R. Twining and Company Limited – a<br />

purchaser and seller of tea, coffee and<br />

other beverages<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 7


NEWS<br />

IN BRIEF<br />

Collections industry welcomes<br />

new ‘Fairness’ statement<br />

New top brass at IPA<br />

THE Insolvency Practitioners Association<br />

(IPA), the membership body and regulator<br />

for those specialising in insolvency practice,<br />

has appointed Carrie-Ann James as its<br />

new President for the coming year. Carrie<br />

will serve as a key representative of the<br />

association and Chair of its board of directors.<br />

A licensed insolvency practitioner, Fellow<br />

of the IPA and long-standing member of the<br />

IPA Council and Member Services Committee,<br />

Carrie has more than 20 years’ experience in<br />

corporate and personal insolvency, working<br />

for both large and small practices.<br />

Samantha Keen has been elected as the<br />

IPA’s next Deputy Vice-President and is<br />

expected to become President in April 2021.<br />

Samantha has worked in the restructuring<br />

field for over 25 years and is a serving<br />

member of Council. She will support the work<br />

of the President and Vice-President over the<br />

next two years.<br />

insolvency-practitioners.org.uk<br />

Duty of care<br />

THE Treasury Select Committee has proposed<br />

that banks should be subject to a legal duty to<br />

always act in customers’ best interests. The<br />

committee suggested that regulators clamp<br />

down on lenders following a long-running<br />

string of scandals that has seen banks pay<br />

out more than £30 billion to compensate<br />

consumers for mis-sold endowment<br />

mortgages, PPI and pensions. The committee<br />

also believes that banks should not be allowed<br />

to ignore communities when choosing to<br />

close branches or cash machines.<br />

parliament.uk<br />

Company Watch<br />

COMPANY Watch has launched its new<br />

scoring mechanism, TextScore for UK<br />

companies. While traditional scoring is<br />

based on financial figures contained within<br />

annual and interim financial reports for<br />

publicly listed and large private companies,<br />

Company Watch says it has looked at how the<br />

supporting text can also give a credit score.<br />

TextScore uses a natural language processing<br />

(NLP) approach to look specifically at the<br />

text in a company’s financial accounts to<br />

give another perspective on the company’s<br />

financial health. The scoring is calculated<br />

using advanced AI techniques to identify<br />

the patterns of words or phrases that may be<br />

indicative of financial distress.<br />

companywatch.net<br />

Crash Course<br />

ONGUARD has created a ten-part video<br />

crash course on best practices in credit<br />

management. The course, titled ‘Customer<br />

Centric order-to-cash’, shares tips and tricks<br />

for the everyday credit manager, collector and<br />

CFO to help them maintain strong customer<br />

relationships while also ensuring cashflow<br />

despite customer late payments. The course<br />

is suitable for all levels of experience.<br />

onguard.com<br />

THE debt collection industry<br />

has reacted positively to an<br />

announcement by the Government<br />

that seeks to bring a consistent<br />

approach to how people in debt are treated.<br />

The announcement, published on the<br />

Cabinet Office website in May, took the form<br />

of a joint statement between the Cabinet<br />

Office and the Fairness Group, a group<br />

comprising leaders from central and local<br />

government, the debt advice sector, and the<br />

debt collection industry.<br />

The principal aim of the group is said to<br />

be to continually improve how government<br />

interacts with people in debt, particularly<br />

those in vulnerable circumstances and/<br />

or experiencing financial hardship. Peter<br />

Wallwork, Chief Executive of the <strong>Credit</strong><br />

Services Association (CSA), said the<br />

Association was fully supportive of the need<br />

to apply new ‘Fairness Principles’ to the<br />

collection of all debts, in line with industry<br />

best-practice: “It not only reflects our own<br />

strategy of achieving a level playing field (i.e<br />

clear comparability between government<br />

and non-government debt) but will also<br />

enable the public sector to benefit from the<br />

best-practice experience and learnings<br />

of our own members,” he said. “It means<br />

the customer will be treated fairly and<br />

consistently across every part of the debt<br />

collection sector.”<br />

The statement lists how the Government<br />

will seek to understand the impact that<br />

debt collection practices can have and how<br />

to improve them, and implement a joint<br />

programme of work to further examine<br />

practices in central and local government<br />

debt management which support<br />

vulnerable people, and make evidencebased<br />

recommendations for change.<br />

Peter Tutton, Head of Policy at<br />

StepChange Debt Charity, said that it<br />

was heartening to see the Government’s<br />

commitment to bringing local and national<br />

government debt collection practices in line<br />

with industry best practice: “Government<br />

debt collection practice does not always<br />

The statement lists<br />

how the Government<br />

will seek to understand<br />

the impact that debt<br />

collection practices<br />

can have and how to<br />

improve them.<br />

match best practice, so this commitment<br />

from Government is a significant stepping<br />

stone to matching standards of fairness we<br />

see elsewhere.”<br />

Gillian Guy, Chief Executive of Citizens<br />

Advice, added: “Unfair and aggressive<br />

debt collection has a serious impact on<br />

those in financial difficulty. We’re pleased<br />

government is looking to improve these<br />

practices and collaborate more with the<br />

money advice sector.”<br />

Mr Wallwork sounded a note of caution:<br />

“The challenge now will be whether the<br />

government will be able to put into practice<br />

its well-stated intentions,” he continued.<br />

“The CSA will continue to work with other<br />

members of the Group to help government<br />

achieve a successful outcome.”<br />

Kevin Foster, Minister for the<br />

Constitution, concluded: “The Cabinet Office<br />

plays a vital role in setting the strategy to<br />

ensure those who can pay their debts do<br />

so on time, whilst providing proportionate<br />

support to those who need it.”<br />

The Government’s Fairness Principles,<br />

developed with the debt advice sector,<br />

are aligned to FCA guidelines on Treating<br />

Customers Fairly. The Fairness Group was<br />

developed through cross-government<br />

collaboration with Citizens Advice,<br />

StepChange, Money Advice Trust, The<br />

Money and Pensions Service, the CSA,<br />

PayPlan and Indesser.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 8


SMEs get the cold shoulder<br />

A report published by Oxford Economics<br />

has found that a decade after the financial<br />

crisis, bank lending to small businesses<br />

has failed to recover significantly.<br />

The ‘Big Business of Small Business’<br />

report, launched in partnership with<br />

Funding Circle, finds that small business<br />

lending makes up a tiny proportion of<br />

banks’ overall balance sheets. In the UK,<br />

small business lending accounts for only<br />

two percent of banks’ balance sheets, and<br />

this figure is even less in countries such as<br />

the US (0.7 percent) and the Netherlands<br />

(0.6 percent).<br />

Despite the vast economic output<br />

generated by SMEs, who are responsible<br />

for 60 percent of all jobs in industrialised<br />

countries and 50-60 percent of GDP, banks<br />

are continuing to focus on loans to larger<br />

firms. Since 2015 in the UK, lending to<br />

large firms has increased by 43 percent<br />

since 2015, whilst during the same period<br />

lending to SMEs has decreased by three<br />

percent.<br />

The report also reveals that when small<br />

businesses can access finance from<br />

their bank, it is typically on worse terms<br />

than those received by larger businesses,<br />

both in cost and the terms associated with<br />

the loans. This is a trend seen across the<br />

UK, US, Germany and the Netherlands.<br />

This ongoing stagnation in bank<br />

lending to SMEs is in stark contrast to the<br />

continued rapid expansion in SME activity.<br />

In the UK, the report states that the total<br />

number of SMEs has increased by over<br />

260,000 since 2015, and separate studies<br />

found that the number of small Dutch firms<br />

has grown by 4.5 percent since 2007 and<br />

240,000 more SMEs were established in<br />

the US in 2016. In Germany, the number of<br />

people employed by SMEs has increased by<br />

22 percent since 2008.<br />

Bank net lending to UK small businesses<br />

has fallen significantly, totalling £518<br />

million in 2018 compared with an average<br />

of £2 billion previous three years.<br />

oxfordeconomics.com<br />

STEP BY STEP<br />

KATHERINE Gilmour has won the StepChange Money and Debt Advice Prize. After<br />

graduating with a degree in psychology, she has worked for not-for-profit and charitable<br />

organisations in Birmingham helping vulnerable people to better manage their health<br />

conditions and finances. She studied for the CICM Money and Debt Advice Diploma<br />

while working in her current role as a Debt Advisor (DRO intermediary) for StepChange<br />

Debt Charity and achieved the highest marks in 2018. Pictured are CICM Chair of<br />

Education Committee Jane Abramson presenting Katherine with her prize at StepChange<br />

Headquarters in Leeds.<br />

stepchange.org<br />

Rising insolvencies lead to call<br />

for better regulation<br />

A continued rise in personal insolvencies<br />

has led to calls for more stringent<br />

regulation of consumer debt.<br />

New figures from the Office for National<br />

Statistics (ONS) have revealed that in the<br />

first quarter of <strong>2019</strong>, the number of personal<br />

insolvencies had grown by 16 percent<br />

year-on-year, while Individual Voluntary<br />

Arrangements (IVAs) rose by 24 percent<br />

over the same period.<br />

In the first quarter of the year, personal<br />

insolvencies exceeded 30,000 for the<br />

first time since 2011, and recorded the<br />

highest first-quarter total since 2010.<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> card debt and consumer credit<br />

have been blamed for the rise in personal<br />

insolvencies, although economic<br />

stagnation and the problematic roll-out of<br />

Universal <strong>Credit</strong> have also been named as<br />

driving factors.<br />

Richard Haymes, Financial Difficulties<br />

Expert at Equifax, believes debt is a<br />

wider issue that goes beyond regulatory<br />

bodies, charities and government: “Every<br />

facet of society must also burden some<br />

responsibility,” he says.<br />

“We urge individuals struggling with<br />

debt repayments to talk to their creditors<br />

as soon as possible, and compel creditors<br />

of all types to use data-driven methods<br />

to identify customers at risk of financial<br />

difficulties and support them in accessing<br />

high quality advice.” ons.gov.uk<br />

See David Kerr’s article on page 14.<br />

>NEWS<br />

IN BRIEF<br />

FCA calls for input<br />

on debt advice<br />

THE Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)<br />

has launched a Call for Input asking for<br />

feedback on its proposed approach to<br />

reviewing the Retail Distribution Review<br />

(RDR) and the Financial Advice Market<br />

Review (FAMR).<br />

The FCA’s review will consider whether<br />

these initiatives have been successful<br />

in achieving their objectives. The review<br />

will look at what consumers want from<br />

the market and how the market works to<br />

deliver this. It will also consider how new<br />

market trends and developments might<br />

affect the future development of advice<br />

and guidance services.<br />

Christopher Woolard, Executive Director<br />

of Strategy and Competition at the FCA<br />

says millions of people look for help and<br />

support in making financial decisions<br />

every year: “The aim of the RDR and FAMR<br />

was to help the market develop the right<br />

advice or guidance services consumers<br />

need to make those decisions.<br />

"Consumers and the market are<br />

changing rapidly, as technology,<br />

employment patterns and intergenerational<br />

challenges change the<br />

way consumers interact with financial<br />

services. As well as looking at how the<br />

market has evolved since RDR and FAMR,<br />

it’s important that our work looks ahead<br />

to see how we ensure that this important<br />

sector works well in the future.<br />

"We want the market to deliver a range<br />

of good quality, affordable advice and<br />

guidance services that meet consumer<br />

needs."<br />

The FCA is seeking initial feedback to<br />

the Call for Input by 3 <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong>. The FCA<br />

will hold several stakeholder events and<br />

collect further data through consumer<br />

research and surveying a sample of firms.<br />

It intends to publish its final report in<br />

2020. fca.org.uk<br />

CICM Essentials<br />

RECENT briefings include details of how to<br />

book for the CICM Learning Conference on<br />

20 <strong>June</strong>, the latest Virtual Classes running<br />

throughout <strong>June</strong>, the CICM AGM, and the<br />

Fellows’ lunch.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 9


NEWS SPECIAL<br />

Stepping Out<br />

The Prompt Payment Code has taken another<br />

Client: Gravity PR Coverage Yellow News<br />

significant step on a potentially very long journey.<br />

Source: News & Star<br />

Date: 01/05/<strong>2019</strong><br />

Page: 16<br />

Reach: 1753<br />

Value: 1028.08<br />

AUTHOR – Philip King FCICM<br />

Philip King FCICM<br />

Chief Executive of the CICM<br />

LAST month the CICM<br />

announced the suspension<br />

of 17 signatories from the<br />

Prompt Payment Code which<br />

the Institute administers<br />

for The Department for<br />

Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy<br />

(BEIS). As one might have expected, it<br />

has generated a significant amount of<br />

media interest, particularly across trade<br />

publications and websites in sectors that<br />

are prominent in the 17 organisations.<br />

Historically, the CICM and the PPC<br />

Compliance Board have had to face<br />

heavy and prolonged criticism about the<br />

Code, and the volume of criticism has<br />

intensified in recent months. Many have<br />

said that the Code lacked teeth, or that<br />

it was not as effective as it might be. Our<br />

response to those criticisms has always<br />

been consistent over several years: action<br />

can only be taken when there is evidence<br />

of poor practice, and that evidence has<br />

only been available from suppliers or<br />

business organisations willing to raise a<br />

challenge.<br />

Despite repeated calls and commentary<br />

from our side, only one trade body or<br />

business organisation has ever raised a<br />

challenge, even though they are the ones<br />

best placed to do so because they don’t<br />

have the accompanying commercial risk.<br />

While they have been quick to criticise,<br />

they have been commensurately slow to<br />

actually do anything about it; carping from<br />

the sidelines is clearly much easier and<br />

helps secure column inches. Ironically,<br />

however, it does little or nothing to help<br />

those members they represent.<br />

Some suppliers, however, have<br />

chosen to raise a challenge themselves.<br />

Where they have done so, the Code has<br />

achieved significant success including<br />

the generation of payments totalling over<br />

£3m since 2014. The Code has also led<br />

to changes to company processes and<br />

procedures, modifications to contractual<br />

terms, mediation where views are at<br />

different ends of the spectrum, and<br />

education of both buyers and sellers<br />

in how to improve their trading<br />

relationship and employ sound credit<br />

management.<br />

Leaving this issue to one side for a<br />

moment, one might ask – quite reasonably<br />

– why we appear to be suddenly ‘naming<br />

and shaming’ companies whose<br />

names have been removed from the<br />

Code. Companies have been removed<br />

historically, but never named publicly, so<br />

what has changed?<br />

DUTY TO REPORT<br />

To answer that, we need to go back to<br />

The Small Business, Enterprise and<br />

Employment Act of 2015. In it, Matt<br />

Hancock, the then Small Business<br />

Minister, introduced a requirement that<br />

large businesses should publicly report<br />

on their Payment Practices behaviour.<br />

The requirement was brought into force<br />

by the Regulations that came into effect<br />

in April 2017 and the process (sometimes<br />

referred to colloquially as ‘Duty to Report’<br />

but more formally known as Payment<br />

Practices Reporting) is now established.<br />

The first reports were submitted towards<br />

the end of 2017 and we are now at a point<br />

where all large businesses should have<br />

published their payment performance. If<br />

they haven’t, a criminal offence is being<br />

committed and they need +44 to (0) 20 be 7264 brought 4700 to<br />

services@kantarmedia.com<br />

book.<br />

www.kantarmedia.com<br />

Where the reported payment record is at<br />

variance with the commitments they have<br />

voluntarily made (i.e by being a signatory<br />

to the Code), we now have a published<br />

reference point from which we can make a<br />

judgement, without a Challenge having to<br />

be raised. We can decide that their names<br />

should be removed from the Code unless,<br />

and until, they report compliance. This is<br />

why 17 have been named as suspended,<br />

and more names are likely to follow in the<br />

weeks and months ahead.<br />

There have been some hefty responses<br />

but the action has been taken based on<br />

those companies’ own data. The fact that<br />

there might be other equally culpable<br />

organisations yet to be named in the same<br />

way is no excuse. Some PR companies<br />

from the respective firms have asked<br />

‘why us and not so and so.’ That is a false<br />

1 of 1<br />

Coverage is reproduced under license from the NLA, CLA or other copyright owner. No further<br />

copying (including the printing of digital cuttings) digital reproductions or forwarding is permitted<br />

except under license from the NLA, http://www.nla.co.uk (for newspapers) CLA<br />

http://www.cla.co.uk (for books and magazines) or other copyright body.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 10


We’ve updated our comments.<br />

Tap here to see more<br />

<br />

NEWS SPECIAL<br />

AUTHOR – Philip King FCICM<br />

Larger companies ‘are ignoring rules’<br />

over paying their bills<br />

James Hurley, Enterprise Editor<br />

April 29 <strong>2019</strong>, 12:01am, The Times<br />

DHL, the transport specialist, is among the companies to have been “named and shamed”<br />

over its payment practices<br />

ALAMY<br />

<br />

and disingenuous argument. It is like<br />

Share<br />

Save<br />

complaining about a parking or speeding<br />

PREVIOUS ARTICLE NEXT ARTICLE <br />

fine because others have committed the<br />

same offence and not been caught.<br />

Is the Payment Practices reporting<br />

perfect? No, far from it. There are certainly<br />

examples of businesses that are required<br />

to report but have as yet failed to do.<br />

There is also legitimate confusion in<br />

some cases about what exactly has to be<br />

reported, and how, and there are inevitably<br />

inconsistencies in the data reported so<br />

we might on occasions be comparing<br />

apples with pears, and more clarity is<br />

required. But – and it’s a big but – the<br />

introduction of reporting is a major step<br />

forward and has enabled the Prompt<br />

Payment Code to look proactively at<br />

what businesses are saying about their<br />

own performance. The PPC Board did<br />

not previously have either the resources<br />

or the remit to investigate poor payment<br />

behaviour, at least without a Challenge<br />

having been raised. Now that has<br />

changed, although resource still remains<br />

a major issue.<br />

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/business/larger-companies-are-ignoring-rules-over-paying-their-bills-lf7sdsrfw 1/5<br />

POSITIVE FOCUS<br />

But let’s focus on the positives, and let us<br />

remind ourselves – and remind the more<br />

vocal commentators – about what the<br />

Code is actually intended to achieve. It is<br />

designed to change payment behaviour,<br />

<br />

and to that end, I am delighted to report<br />

that many of the named organisations<br />

have submitted, or are preparing to<br />

submit, an action plan setting out how<br />

they will become compliant and thus<br />

be reinstated to the Code. Our principal<br />

aspiration in removing signatories from<br />

the Code is to see payment practice<br />

improve in the interests of business and<br />

the economy.<br />

Signatories clearly see a benefit in<br />

being on the Code; they see the damage<br />

that can be done by being removed from<br />

it. For this reason, if nothing else, this<br />

shows that the Code is working.<br />

I’ve always said there is no silver<br />

bullet to resolving late payment. What is<br />

required is a change in culture through<br />

the use of all the tools at our disposal until<br />

we get to the point where paying late is<br />

considered unprofessional, irresponsible<br />

and unacceptable. The PPC is one such<br />

tool.<br />

We’ve made another big step in that<br />

journey, and the CICM is pleased and<br />

proud to be playing its part.<br />

Philip King FCICM, Chief Executive<br />

of the Chartered Institute of <strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong>.<br />

Our principal aspiration<br />

in removing signatories<br />

from the Code is to<br />

see payment practice<br />

improve in the interests<br />

of business and the<br />

economy.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 11


Auditors blamed for<br />

Carillion's collapse<br />

A<br />

survey<br />

of the supply chain conducted by<br />

public sector procurement specialists<br />

Scape Group has found that more than<br />

nine out of ten (93 percent) of suppliers<br />

think the relationship between Carillion and<br />

KPMG enabled the outsourcer’s true financial<br />

position to be concealed.<br />

Over half of suppliers polled think the<br />

accounting policies at Carillion were ‘not<br />

discharged in good faith’ and that the<br />

subsequent collapse was ‘facilitated by poor<br />

management.’ Some 64 percent of suppliers<br />

believe that Carillion’s downfall was due to ‘debt<br />

mismanagement, acquisitions and long payment<br />

terms, created by a focus on revenue rather than<br />

profit.’<br />

The survey also claims the construction<br />

industry would ‘support a shake-up of the ‘big four’<br />

accounting firms, with 57 percent of suppliers<br />

polled saying they thought this was required.’<br />

The devastating collapse of Carillion in 2018 put<br />

thousands of jobs and the supply chain at risk, led<br />

to substantial financial losses, and brought into<br />

question the model of public outsourcing. Mark<br />

Robinson, Scape Chief Executive, says its research<br />

suggests that mismanagement, rising debt and the<br />

active concealing of the true extent of Carillion’s<br />

debt were to blame, not the outsourcing model<br />

itself: “We need to be able to have faith in company<br />

accounts and the work auditors are carrying<br />

out, especially when public sector contracts and<br />

people’s livelihoods are at risk.<br />

“We found that the supply chain were not<br />

comfortable with the relationship between<br />

Carillion and KPMG, and that a reform of the ‘big<br />

four’ auditing firms would bring comfort to the<br />

construction industry that failures like this will<br />

not be repeated. Greater oversight and closer<br />

management of auditing practices are needed<br />

to rebuild trust in the industry, but we also need<br />

to make sure we are putting in place sensible<br />

reforms that do not put increased cost pressures<br />

on an industry that is already contending with the<br />

cost of materials and reduced access to labour.<br />

“Given that SMEs are the lifeblood of the<br />

economy, the sustained growth and prosperity of<br />

local businesses should be a key priority for the<br />

public sector.”<br />

Elsewhere, a survey of 11,000 people in 11<br />

countries around the world by the Association<br />

of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA)<br />

suggests that auditors should be doing more to<br />

prevent company failures. More than half of those<br />

questioned also believe auditors are responsible<br />

for avoiding company failures.<br />

scapegroup.co.uk<br />

>NEWS<br />

IN BRIEF<br />

Vulnerability requires<br />

constant focus<br />

THE Money Advice Trust has welcomed the<br />

Treasury Select Committee’s wide-ranging<br />

report into consumers’ access to financial<br />

services.<br />

Joanna Elson OBE, Chief Executive<br />

of the Money Advice Trust says it is<br />

particularly pleased to see the Treasury<br />

Select Committee’s strong support for<br />

the vulnerability agenda: “This includes<br />

recommending that the FCA sets clear<br />

expectations for firms in its forthcoming<br />

guidance, and highlighting the central<br />

importance of training for financial services<br />

staff.<br />

“As the report notes, demand for the<br />

Money Advice Trust’s vulnerability training<br />

is increasing significantly – and we have<br />

now worked with more than 220 creditors to<br />

train more than 19,000 staff. “However, the<br />

Committee is right to highlight that progress<br />

has not been uniform – and as our collective<br />

understanding of vulnerability improves,<br />

this is an issue that requires a constant focus<br />

from firms of all sizes.<br />

"The FCA's forthcoming guidance is a<br />

good opportunity to renew momentum on<br />

vulnerability across the industry. We look<br />

forward to working with the FCA and with<br />

firms to continue to improve in this crucial<br />

area." moneyadvicetrust.org<br />

Brits live beyond their means<br />

MORE than a quarter (28 percent) of<br />

British adults ran a ‘deficit budget’ in the<br />

past month, spending more during the<br />

month than they received in income,<br />

according to new research from R3.<br />

One in six British adults (17 percent)<br />

spent up to £100 more than they received<br />

in income over the past month; seven<br />

percent spent between £100 to £300 more;<br />

and three percent spent over £300 more.<br />

R3’s research follows statistics from the<br />

ONS which show that households have<br />

been in a budget deficit for a record nine<br />

consecutive quarters (Oct 2016-Dec 2018),<br />

while the average UK household spent<br />

£900 more than it received in income in<br />

2017.<br />

Nearly a quarter (22 percent) of<br />

respondents to R3’s research said they do<br />

not have any savings at all at the moment,<br />

showing that levels of financial resilience<br />

are low for many people.<br />

Those aged 25-34 years were likeliest<br />

of all age groups to report spending more<br />

than they received in monthly income (43<br />

percent). By contrast, the corresponding<br />

figure for those 65+ was only 12 percent.<br />

People’s housing situation also made a<br />

difference: A third of renters (35 percent)<br />

said in the past month they spent more<br />

than they received in monthly income,<br />

compared to a quarter of homeowners (24<br />

percent). Renters (24 percent) were more<br />

likely than homeowners (14 percent) to<br />

have overspent by up to £100 in the last<br />

month. For amounts between £100 to £300<br />

(eight percent of renters v six percent of<br />

homeowners) and over £300 (renters three<br />

percent versus homeowners four percent),<br />

respondents’ housing situation made<br />

relatively little difference.<br />

The research found that seven percent<br />

of British adults reported that they have<br />

borrowed £100 or more from family or<br />

friends in the last month. r3.org.uk<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 12


NEWS<br />

IN BRIEF<br />

“Given that<br />

SMEs are the<br />

lifeblood of<br />

the economy,<br />

the sustained<br />

growth and<br />

prosperity<br />

of local<br />

businesses<br />

should be a<br />

key priority<br />

for the public<br />

sector.”<br />

Stephen Allinson MCICM joins Apex<br />

APEX Litigation Finance has appointed<br />

Stephen Allinson MCICM, Chairman of<br />

the Board of The Insolvency Service,<br />

as a company adviser and to sit on its<br />

investment committee.<br />

Stephen is a Solicitor and Licensed<br />

Insolvency Practitioner, and has specialised<br />

in credit, debt and insolvency work since<br />

1987. Stephen was appointed Chairman<br />

of the Board of The Insolvency Service in<br />

January 2017 and is also the Chairman of<br />

the Joint Insolvency Examination Board<br />

(JIEB), the Deputy Independent Examiner<br />

for the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries<br />

and a Visiting Lecturer on business and<br />

commercial law at the University of Law.<br />

In addition, he serves as a member<br />

of both the Chartered Institute of Legal<br />

Executives Qualifications Committee and<br />

the Legal and Technical Committee of the<br />

Civil Court Users Association, and as a<br />

Director of The Money Charity.<br />

Apex Litigation Finance, which launched<br />

in April <strong>2019</strong>, will work with leading<br />

law firms, insolvency practitioners and<br />

corporates to fund small to medium sized<br />

claims. Apex has partnered with legal<br />

AI specialist CourtQuant which provides<br />

risk assessment tools to analyse probable<br />

litigation outcomes.<br />

Stephen Allinson says litigation<br />

funding has a crucial role to play in the<br />

development of the insolvency profession:<br />

“I am thrilled to work with committed and<br />

innovative colleagues at Apex as we seek<br />

to bring a new approach to this fast-moving<br />

area for the benefit of both practitioners<br />

and creditors.” apexlitigation.com<br />

Numbers up<br />

ACCORDING to the National Numeracy<br />

Day campaign, around half the UK’s<br />

adults have poor numeracy skills, yet<br />

evidence suggests becoming a ‘numbers<br />

person’ can help save money and make<br />

money – and it’s ‘never too late to learn’.<br />

StepChange Debt Charity says it is<br />

contacted by over 2,000 new clients a<br />

day, implying that around 1,000 people<br />

every day could benefit from numeracy<br />

skills to help them as they seek to<br />

manage their debt problems.<br />

Low levels of numeracy skills are<br />

estimated to cost the UK economy over<br />

£20 billion a year.<br />

stepchange.org<br />

Strong arm<br />

JCB’s finance arm has revealed that<br />

total lending to help hirers and<br />

contractors buy machines has hit an<br />

all-time high. As demand soars for new<br />

plant total lending has broken through<br />

the £1 billion barrier. JCB Finance says it<br />

has facilitated the purchase of more than<br />

250,000 machines over the past 49<br />

years, lending more than £13 billion to<br />

UK businesses to help them grow and<br />

invest.<br />

jcb-finance.co.uk<br />

Bridge programmes<br />

CROWD2FUND has been named as<br />

one of 10 UK firms to benefit from<br />

two new fintech bridge programmes<br />

with Hong Kong and Australia. The<br />

Department for International Trade<br />

(DIT) and the Treasury said that the pilot<br />

programmes will help to bolster existing<br />

frameworks and build on previous<br />

fintech bridge agreements signed with<br />

China, Singapore and South Korea. The<br />

programmes will involve collaboration<br />

between the various governments and<br />

their regulatory bodies, as part of their<br />

remit to improve trade and innovation<br />

across borders. According to the DTI,<br />

Australia and Hong Kong have almost<br />

1,000 active fintech companies between<br />

them. crowd2fund.com<br />

Boom time for bars<br />

THE hot Easter weekend delivered starkly<br />

different outcomes for Britain’s managed<br />

pub and restaurant groups, according to<br />

latest figures from the Coffer Peach Business<br />

Tracker. While pub sales surged in the<br />

sunshine, restaurants struggled in the heat.<br />

Pub and bar chains reported collective<br />

like-for-like sales up 5.3 percent for the fourday<br />

break compared to Easter 2018, with<br />

drink-led pubs up 10.9 percent as the public<br />

headed outdoors.<br />

However, the overall eating and drinkingout<br />

market was actually down 3.6 percent<br />

over the four-day weekend, as in stark<br />

contrast to pubs restaurant chains saw<br />

collective like-for-like sales tumble a<br />

massive 18.6 per cent against last Easter’s<br />

trading.<br />

Regionally, London saw a fall in like-forlike<br />

trading, down 0.7 percent on last April,<br />

while outside the M25 was up 1.7 percent on<br />

a like-for-like basis for the month. cga.co.uk<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 13


NEWS SPECIAL<br />

Onward and upward<br />

Are rising numbers of IVAs a<br />

cause for celebration?<br />

AUTHOR – David Kerr FCICM<br />

David Kerr FCICM<br />

THE latest insolvency statistics<br />

produced by The Insolvency<br />

Service could be read one<br />

of two ways, depending<br />

on whether you applaud a<br />

voluntary, market-driven<br />

solution to the UK’s personal debt problem,<br />

or see it as a regulatory nightmare with the<br />

potential to threaten the very existence<br />

of the present model of self-regulation<br />

governing the insolvency profession.<br />

If that sounds too grand a statement,<br />

then consider this – against a background<br />

of GDP growth, the number of Individual<br />

Voluntary Arrangements (IVAs) is at its<br />

highest since the procedure was first<br />

introduced into English law in 1986/7. True,<br />

the first quarter of the year saw a slight<br />

drop on the peak at the end of 2018, but the<br />

overall trend is upward and has been for<br />

the last four years.<br />

The Government statistics do not quite<br />

tell the full picture, because they don’t<br />

register debt management plans and other<br />

informal solutions, but of the 31,000 people<br />

who sought a formal debt solution in the<br />

quarter to 31 March <strong>2019</strong>, two thirds (20,000)<br />

entered into an IVA. Of the remainder, just<br />

4,000 went into bankruptcy (mainly on their<br />

own petitions/applications), with 7,000<br />

instead seeking a Debt Relief Order (DRO)<br />

(available to those with no or low assets and<br />

under £20,000 of debts).<br />

CREDITOR HAT<br />

From a creditor perspective this could<br />

be considered relatively good news. The<br />

prospects of recovery from those in DROs<br />

is nil, and from those in bankruptcy<br />

negligible. So at least the majority are<br />

subjecting themselves to a process which is<br />

designed to return some value to creditors,<br />

albeit over five years typically. And the Q1<br />

stats show an increase of 23 percent on the<br />

IVA take-up, compared to the same quarter<br />

last year.<br />

So where is the problem? Well, the IVA<br />

market is led by a handful of entrepreneurial<br />

operators whose business models depend<br />

on high volumes of low-maintenance cases<br />

derived from leads generated by sometimes<br />

unregulated finders. Some complain that<br />

they push IVAs at the expense of more<br />

suitable (for the debtor) alternatives, and<br />

that the regulated insolvency practitioners<br />

at the helm of these cases are unable to<br />

effectively control their cases because of<br />

the sheer volumes and in some instances<br />

their lack of influence in the enterprises<br />

running the caseload.<br />

Whether those criticisms are fully<br />

justified or not is almost secondary to<br />

the fact that the rationalisation of the<br />

IVA market is such that there is now a<br />

concentration of this work in a handful of<br />

‘firms’, and their influence over the sector is<br />

being questioned. A failure of one of these<br />

corporate entities, through commercial or<br />

regulatory pressures or a combination of<br />

the two, would cause a real headache for<br />

regulators at a time when The Insolvency<br />

Service is reviewing the effectiveness of the<br />

regulation regime run by the professional<br />

bodies.<br />

GOOD NEWS<br />

So, for the moment, creditors might quietly<br />

rejoice at news that:<br />

i) for one reason or another most<br />

insolvent individuals seem content to<br />

make monthly contributions towards their<br />

liabilities;<br />

ii) the banks are actively exercising their<br />

rights to vote and supress fees and other<br />

costs (with more success on the former<br />

than the latter); and<br />

iii) regulators are looking for new ways<br />

to keep pace with innovations in the sector,<br />

so as to make sure those operating in it can<br />

be held to account when things go wrong.<br />

But the returns that IVAs can produce<br />

for creditors might be under threat; the<br />

number of cases is increasing, but the<br />

present balance between low cost for<br />

creditors and financial sustainability for<br />

operators is a fragile one. Fixed fees may<br />

be part of the solution, though as one<br />

operator commented, it’s ‘‘still developing<br />

and therefore not yet possible to say how<br />

successful it will be at stabilising the volume<br />

market providers.’’ The balance may have<br />

to be reassessed if we want to see viable<br />

providers working to the highest standards<br />

and continuing to produce insolvency<br />

outcomes that serve both debtors and<br />

creditors.<br />

David Kerr is an insolvency practitioner<br />

with extensive regulatory experience<br />

and a member of the CICM Technical<br />

Committee.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 14


INSOLVENCY<br />

Keeping the balance<br />

The need for careful implementation of the new<br />

HMRC preferential creditor regulation.<br />

AUTHOR – Michelle Thorp<br />

Michelle Thorp<br />

MANY readers may<br />

be aware of HMRC’s<br />

plans to restore its<br />

pre-Enterprise Act<br />

2002 status as a<br />

preferential creditor<br />

in insolvencies, unexpectedly announced<br />

in the Chancellor’s 2018 Budget.<br />

Specifically, HMRC will become a<br />

secondary preferential creditor, meaning<br />

that secured creditors with fixed charges<br />

will be unaffected, for example banks and<br />

other asset-based lenders. The other group<br />

not affected are ordinary preferential<br />

creditors such as employees entitled to<br />

statutory payments including wages and<br />

holiday pay. These groups will all be above<br />

HMRC in the hierarchy, as will the costs of<br />

insolvency.<br />

Those below HMRC will be affected,<br />

in particular secured creditors with<br />

a floating charge, groups including<br />

suppliers, contractors and customers<br />

that have paid a deposit (non-preferential<br />

unsecured creditors) and shareholders.<br />

The new measure would see HMRC hold<br />

more statutory rights for the repayment of<br />

PAYE, VAT, CIS and employee NIC.<br />

Taxes such as income tax, capital gains<br />

tax, corporation tax and employer NI<br />

contributions, i.e. those directly assessed<br />

on the individual or business, remain<br />

unchanged, as will HMRC’s status as a<br />

non-preferential unsecured creditor for<br />

these taxes.<br />

HMRC has also set out that employee<br />

debts will be separated from employer<br />

debts.<br />

The plans are due to come into effect<br />

on 6 April 2020. At the time of this<br />

article’s publishing, the IPA will have<br />

just submitted its responses to HMRC’s<br />

questions on the proposal, after working<br />

through them with its Standards, Ethics<br />

and Regulatory Liaison (SERL) Committee.<br />

MODERN FINANCIAL LANDSCAPE<br />

The government’s thinking behind the<br />

new measure is to recover more of the<br />

taxes it argues have already been collected<br />

on HMRC’s behalf, rather than the funds<br />

going to other creditors.<br />

At one time, UK banks were the country’s<br />

biggest lenders, though over the years<br />

things have changed due to the growth<br />

of asset-based finance and secondary<br />

lenders. In its consultation document,<br />

HMRC gives some interesting projections<br />

on tax revenue that could be recovered<br />

under the scheme. In the financial year<br />

leading up to implementation, income<br />

from insolvencies is listed as £5 million.<br />

In the following initial year under the<br />

scheme, this could rise sharply to £60<br />

million, before peaking two years later<br />

at £185 million and decreasing slightly to<br />

£175 million in 2023/24.<br />

Comparing the maximum forecast<br />

given of £185 million to the £57 billion<br />

lent by banks to small and medium<br />

enterprises (SMEs) in the 12 months to<br />

July 2018, HMRC doesn’t expect the new<br />

regulation to have any real impact on<br />

lending. It reports that this is due to the<br />

proportionately miniscule amount of debt<br />

that would be no longer recoverable.<br />

PROTECTING BUSINESS<br />

There is a concern that these figures may<br />

well turn out to have understated the<br />

change.<br />

The measure of £57 billion cited in the<br />

proposal is the total lent to SMEs, rather<br />

than to those SMEs that become insolvent<br />

– therefore not reflecting the impact on<br />

the risk of loans to such enterprises.<br />

Furthermore, floating charge holders,<br />

ranking as creditors behind HMRC<br />

under the proposed new regime, may<br />

face a disincentive to lend to distressed<br />

businesses – with the knock-on effect of<br />

reducing the possibility for trading under<br />

administration and Company Voluntary<br />

Arrangements (CVAs).<br />

The Federation of Small Businesses<br />

(FSB) reports that SMEs, at the start of<br />

2018, accounted for 99.9 percent of all<br />

private sector businesses and claimed<br />

52 percent of all private sector turnover<br />

and 60 percent of the UK’s private sector<br />

employment.<br />

The potential increased risk to UK<br />

business under the new rules can look,<br />

from this perspective, rather stark.<br />

To mitigate this risk, there could be a<br />

time limit placed on debts payable to<br />

HMRC in order to stop excessive funds<br />

being redistributed away from floating<br />

charge creditors and ordinary unsecured<br />

creditors. History serves us well here,<br />

as the new proposal is a departure from<br />

the precedent of time limits imposed<br />

on preferential creditors before the<br />

implementation of the 2002 Enterprise<br />

Act. And of course, if significant sums<br />

are involved in insolvency proceedings,<br />

there would be implications if unsecured<br />

creditors face no return at all.<br />

DEVIL IN THE DETAIL<br />

The need for us to work through the finer<br />

details doesn’t rest here when you consider<br />

the possibility of successive insolvency<br />

proceedings taking place either side<br />

of the proposed implementation date.<br />

We’ve requested both clarification of<br />

the categories of preferential debt in<br />

this scenario and an implementation<br />

timetable. The transitional arrangements<br />

need to be clear to minimise any<br />

market distortion as floating charge and<br />

unsecured creditors press for formal<br />

insolvency to happen before the new class<br />

of preferential creditors comes into effect.<br />

Government will soon be considering<br />

all responses to the consultation and then<br />

progress to detailed policy design and<br />

an implementation framework. Though<br />

it’s been made clear that a shift to a<br />

significantly different proposal is not part<br />

of the consultation.<br />

It is possible to appreciate, when you<br />

think about the overall benefit to the<br />

public purse, why HMRC has gone for<br />

the change, though we need to make<br />

certain of the implementation details<br />

and timetable, and, avoid unreasonably<br />

prejudicing other creditors.<br />

Michelle Thorp is CEO, Insolvency<br />

Practitioners Association.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 15


CICMQ<br />

A refreshing approach<br />

to credit management<br />

THE <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

team at Britvic Soft<br />

Drinks Ltd has delivered<br />

outstanding results<br />

to achieve CICMQ<br />

accreditation.<br />

Most of the team have only been<br />

with the company for under two years,<br />

some for less and have replaced a<br />

vastly experienced group of credit<br />

controllers.<br />

“The CICMQ Workshop approach<br />

was the ideal opportunity to build<br />

the team and start to transform<br />

the department,” says Ciaran<br />

Grace MCICM, Sales Operations<br />

Manager at Britvic, who initiated the<br />

accreditation. “Giving individuals<br />

team leader responsibilities boosted<br />

confidence and had a big impact.”<br />

“We now have 60 percent of our team<br />

studying with the CICM and we have<br />

plans to introduce individual study<br />

paths for all new starters.”<br />

Sharon Adams FCICM, CICMQ<br />

Assessor, says Britvic delivered<br />

outstanding results: “The <strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong> team at Britvic made a<br />

huge success of the CICMQ Workshop<br />

approach. They are a highly motivated<br />

team, who displayed camaraderie<br />

throughout to achieve the same goal.”<br />

“The results are more meaningful<br />

when considering that Ryan Kerr<br />

ACICM helped lead the process<br />

at Team Leader level. Such<br />

transformations are usually performed<br />

at a more senior level.”<br />

Britvic Soft Drinks Ltd is one of<br />

the leading branded soft drinks<br />

businesses in Europe and South<br />

America, operating in and exporting<br />

to over 50 countries. The <strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong> Team is made up<br />

of ten credit controllers and the<br />

organisation’s most recent financial<br />

statement reported a turnover of<br />

£1,503.6 million.<br />

TOP 50 UK law firm Weightmans has<br />

achieved CICMQ re-accreditation,<br />

demonstrating that the firm continues<br />

to meet ‘Best Practice’ in <strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong>.<br />

The recently restructured <strong>Credit</strong><br />

Control team at Weightmans is now<br />

made up of 21 people – more than<br />

twice the team size that last achieved<br />

accreditation in 2016. Pete Taggart<br />

AB Agri<br />

Adecco<br />

Adler and Allan Ltd<br />

Aggregate Industries<br />

Aimia Foods Ltd<br />

Allied Bakeries<br />

Amey<br />

Anixter Ltd<br />

Ascent Performance Group Ltd (Collections)<br />

Avnet Technology Solutions Ltd<br />

Britvic<br />

EDF Energy – I&C Revenue <strong>Management</strong><br />

Equinix<br />

Ford Retail Ltd<br />

Gazprom Energy<br />

Hays Specialist Recruitment Limited<br />

Health and Social Care Online (HSCNI)<br />

Hilti (GB) Ltd<br />

Postitive verdict for law firm<br />

and Jane Morrey have been promoted<br />

to Commercial and Insurance <strong>Credit</strong><br />

Managers for their respective<br />

divisions.<br />

Bob Granger, Finance Director at<br />

Weightmans, says: “It’s very important<br />

for us to know that we are still utilising<br />

best practice in light of the many<br />

changes within the <strong>Credit</strong> Control<br />

team. During the last few years we<br />

CICMQ ACCREDITED COMPANIES<br />

HSBC Invoice Finance (UK) Ltd<br />

ID Medical (Milton Keynes)<br />

Impellam UK Limited<br />

Imperial College London<br />

John Lewis Partnership<br />

Kier Group PlC<br />

Local World Ltd<br />

Marshalls Group Plc<br />

Marston’s Brewery<br />

Matthew Clark Wholesale Limited<br />

Moreton Smith<br />

NHS Blood and Transplant<br />

npower Industrial & Commercial<br />

Omnicom Media Group<br />

Pearson UK Shared Services<br />

Partnership Services, John Lewis plc<br />

QA Ltd<br />

Roche Diabetes Care Limited<br />

obtained buy-in from the stakeholders,<br />

which has enabled a new, more<br />

collaborative working approach right<br />

across the business.<br />

“We’re focused on the improvement<br />

and development of our people, and<br />

have recently registered 11 affiliate<br />

members from within the team, plus,<br />

encouraging ongoing professional<br />

development”<br />

Royal Mail Group Ltd<br />

RS Components Ltd<br />

Shell International Downstream <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

Siemens Plc – CIT/GSS UK <strong>Credit</strong> Services<br />

SIG Trading Ltd (SIG Distribution)<br />

Silver Spoon Company<br />

Sony DADC UK Ltd (UK Operations)<br />

Synseal Extrusions Ltd<br />

Tata Global Beverages GB Ltd<br />

The <strong>Credit</strong> Centre Ltd (Amari Metals)<br />

Travis Perkins plc<br />

United Utilities<br />

Veolia Environmental Services UK Plc<br />

Weightmans<br />

Worldline IT Services UK LTD<br />

Xoserve Limited<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 16


presents<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

www.ddisoftware.co.uk<br />

sales@ddisoftware.co.uk<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 17


OPINION<br />

Herd Mentality<br />

The issue of future funding of debt advice is an<br />

elephant that refuses to leave the room.<br />

Peter Wallwork<br />

AUTHOR – Peter Wallwork MCICM<br />

I<br />

was surprised and disappointed<br />

recently to read that Sir Hector<br />

Sants, the Chairman of the Money<br />

and Pensions Service (MaPS –<br />

formerly the Single Financial<br />

Guidance Body), is suggesting<br />

that the Financial Services community<br />

should be ploughing even more money<br />

into the debt advice sector.<br />

Surprised because the FS community<br />

already contributes vast sums (almost £60<br />

million) into funding debt advice, and<br />

disappointed because as yet nobody has<br />

even attempted to address the very real<br />

concerns and questions the CSA and its<br />

members have raised in relation to how<br />

the funding is currently being spent.<br />

Neither have they answered whether even<br />

the current levels of funding are fairly<br />

contributed and efficiently managed.<br />

Mr Sants, in his interview, said that<br />

the FS sector needed to spend more<br />

money on what he called ‘prevention’,<br />

and equipping individuals to become<br />

financially empowered. He said there<br />

needed to be a strategic shift in the<br />

balance of engagement from remediation<br />

to prevention. Making this shift would<br />

give better outcomes to consumers, and<br />

enable a ‘high quality dialogue’ between<br />

the consumer and the advisor.<br />

Looking at the comment trail that<br />

followed the online piece, Sir Hector’s<br />

proposals have not been particularly well<br />

received. To suggest that ‘remediation’<br />

and ‘prevention’ are interchangeable is<br />

stretching the argument. His proposal,<br />

as one commentator recently put it, is<br />

akin to suggesting that greengrocers<br />

should pay for people to be educated<br />

about the benefits of fresh fruit and veg,<br />

or that car manufacturers should pay for<br />

driving lessons because cars are rather<br />

complicated things!<br />

But all of this again comes back to the<br />

fundamental point. There is still a clear<br />

lack of transparency and data regarding<br />

the current funding channels and sources.<br />

It is why finding a solution is proving<br />

such a challenge. We are agreed that any<br />

future funding contributions should be<br />

fair, equitable and transparent, but any<br />

future thinking must remember that it is<br />

not only financial services businesses that<br />

‘benefit’ from debt advice and informal<br />

debt repayment plans.<br />

We need to address this tired and<br />

rather elderly elephant in the room,<br />

as he has been there for some time and<br />

should have been dealt with long ago.<br />

There are clearly firms and organisations<br />

that benefit from debt advice, but who<br />

currently contribute nothing towards it.<br />

They may contribute in other ways, but<br />

without data, we have no way of knowing.<br />

Without transparency on who contributes<br />

currently, the industry ends up blaming<br />

one another and pointing fingers.<br />

The CSA is continuing to make<br />

representations to MaPS, and has already<br />

completed much positive work with the<br />

advice sector who principally agree with<br />

our concerns around transparency and<br />

efficiency. The CSA also has a positive<br />

dialogue with the Chief Executive of<br />

MaPS, John Govetts, to challenge MaPS<br />

position on asking for more money before<br />

addressing our genuine and well-reasoned<br />

concerns.<br />

Mr Govetts has suggested that the CSA<br />

should propose what a future funding<br />

model should look like, and it will use<br />

its Buyers Forum (on <strong>June</strong> 5) to gauge its<br />

buyers members’ opinions prior to further<br />

discussions planned with MaPS shortly<br />

after. But this could be a case of the cart<br />

before the horse. How can you get to the<br />

bottom of what a good funding model<br />

looks like if we don’t have the answers to<br />

our original set of questions? If we don’t<br />

have transparency, and if the funding<br />

burden is not fairly distributed, then why<br />

should members accept that they have to<br />

pay more?<br />

On this issue, as well as the issue of<br />

future fees, we are led to believe that the<br />

authorities/regulators are in listening<br />

mode. Let us hope that is the case, for<br />

if we are expected to ‘fit the bill’ on any<br />

future budget that MaPS decides to set,<br />

then we should have an input into what<br />

that budget may look like.<br />

But with an impression that fees<br />

are already on the rise, and the mood<br />

music from Sir Hector in relation to<br />

future funding, we might well have to be<br />

shouting very loud to be heard.<br />

Peter Wallwork MCICM is Chief Executive<br />

of the <strong>Credit</strong> Services Association (CSA).<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 18


DO YOUKNOWTHE TRUE<br />

IDENTITY OF YOUR<br />

CUSTOMERS?<br />

Our<br />

AML check<br />

will confirm it in<br />

5seconds! Business<br />

checks take alittle longer;<br />

1-2 minutes!<br />

We use the very best quality data todeliver our AML<br />

identity check for aresult you can rely on. Sanction &PEP<br />

screening isautomatically included along with Daily Monitoring<br />

and Automated Enhanced Due Diligence all at no additional cost.<br />

Call us now to book afree demonstration on:<br />

0113 333 9835<br />

Or visit us online:<br />

SMARTSEARCHUK.COM<br />

POWEREDBY<br />

SmartSearch delivers UK and International Business checks in the UK and International<br />

Markets with inclusive Worldwide Sanction &PEP screening, Daily Monitoring, Email<br />

Alerts and Automated Enhanced Due Diligence.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 19


OPINION<br />

CUSTOM<br />

MADE<br />

Access to HMRC data for CRAs will enable<br />

better credit decisions.<br />

AUTHOR – Tim Vine<br />

THE latest statistics<br />

from the Federation of<br />

Small Businesses confirm<br />

that small and medium<br />

enterprises (SMEs) make up<br />

99.9 percent of all private<br />

sector businesses in the UK. SMEs form<br />

the backbone of our economy and play an<br />

essential role in the growth of the UK going<br />

forward.<br />

Back in 2013, the Government published<br />

a consultation paper showing that the four<br />

largest banks held an 85 percent share of<br />

the SME lending market. This document<br />

highlighted the need for increased<br />

competition to support the best interests<br />

of the market.<br />

In 2015, the Government launched<br />

the Small Business, Enterprise and<br />

Employment (SBEE) Act that was<br />

dedicated to supporting the growth of<br />

small businesses, increasing exports and<br />

encouraging innovation.<br />

INCREASING COMPETITION<br />

Funding and investment are vital for<br />

growth, and one of the aims of the new<br />

bill was to improve access to finance for<br />

SMEs by encouraging greater competition<br />

in banking to address the imbalance in<br />

the market. Key to this objective was<br />

ensuring that alternative providers and<br />

challenger banks were better able to<br />

assess the credit risk of SMEs. By driving<br />

increased transparency this would deliver<br />

a more level playing field across the UK’s<br />

commercial lending market.<br />

The Government announced that they<br />

would require certain banks (above a<br />

certain market share threshold) to share<br />

their commercial credit lending data with<br />

designated <strong>Credit</strong> Reference Agencies<br />

(CRAs). This would deliver more equal<br />

access to data and make it easier for SMEs<br />

to seek funding from alternative finance<br />

providers as well as traditional banks.<br />

This new commercial credit data sharing<br />

scheme is administered on behalf of the<br />

Government by the British Business Bank.<br />

CRAs must apply to the British Business<br />

Bank and complete a thorough application<br />

process to receive designation.<br />

OPENING UP THE DATA<br />

The scheme requires the nine designated<br />

banks (Royal Bank of Scotland, Barclays,<br />

HSBC, Lloyds, Santander, Clydesdale<br />

Bank, Bank of Ireland, AIB and Northern<br />

Bank) to share current account data and<br />

information on existing loans and credit<br />

cards of their small and medium business<br />

customers. This data is provided under<br />

a strict framework to approved <strong>Credit</strong><br />

Reference Agencies who then integrate the<br />

information into their workflow to provide<br />

more accurate insights on an SME’s<br />

financial performance. There are currently<br />

four designated CRAs; <strong>Credit</strong>safe, Dun &<br />

Bradstreet, Equifax and Experian.<br />

Greater access to this data makes it<br />

easier for other finance providers to check<br />

the credit worthiness of potential SME<br />

business customers and better inform<br />

credit decisions. The aim is to provide<br />

more open access to stimulate more<br />

competition in the SME lending market<br />

and increase the range of funding available<br />

to businesses who are looking to grow, and<br />

to support start-ups seeking initial capital.<br />

THE IMPACT TO DATE<br />

The scheme appears to be making an<br />

impact, with the British Business Bank’s<br />

recently published Small Business Finance<br />

Report confirming that the growth of<br />

alternatives to bank finance is continuing<br />

(although the pace has slowed) and<br />

awareness of finance options outside of<br />

traditional lending is also increasing.<br />

Dun & Bradstreet research in November<br />

2018 also found that over two thirds (67<br />

percent) of SMEs believe the availability<br />

of finance has a significant impact on<br />

their business success. When asked if they<br />

received financial support, 43 percent of<br />

respondents had received funds and 57<br />

percent had not, with the most popular<br />

source still a business loan from a bank<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 20


OPINION<br />

AUTHOR – Tim Vine<br />

(42 percent) followed by a personal loan from a<br />

friend or family member (27 percent).<br />

WHAT THIS MEANS<br />

As well as supporting the growth of small and<br />

medium sized businesses, opening up this<br />

type of commercial credit lending data will<br />

undoubtedly enable better, more informed<br />

credit decisions across the industry. It will<br />

enable a more comprehensive view for credit<br />

managers on an SME’s financial health by<br />

providing access to current account and other<br />

data that has previously been unavailable to<br />

review.<br />

Increased transparency is something the<br />

industry has been championing for some time,<br />

led by organisations such as the CICM, and BIPA<br />

(Business Information Providers Association)<br />

which represent the seven principal credit<br />

information providers in the UK. BIPA’s<br />

primary purpose is to facilitate greater access<br />

to business information to promote access to<br />

credit, help reduce the risks associated with<br />

credit decisions, and prevent fraud.<br />

BIPA has supported the release of VAT<br />

registration data to support small business<br />

growth, working with the Government to<br />

demonstrate the economic benefits to the UK<br />

economy of making this information more<br />

widely available. This data is now available to<br />

Commercial <strong>Credit</strong> Reference Agencies who<br />

meet the disclosure requirements mandated in<br />

the SBEE Act.<br />

THE FUTURE IS OPEN<br />

Alongside the commercial credit data sharing<br />

scheme there are also other initiatives<br />

impacting our industry and opening up more<br />

data to drive competition. In January 2018,<br />

the Government launched the Open Banking<br />

initiative, which mandates the nine designated<br />

banks to allow customer information to be<br />

shared with other regulated financial service<br />

providers, subject to securing the customer’s<br />

permission. Data is shared via secure APIs<br />

(Application Programming Interfaces) and<br />

is helping to deliver more choice in an<br />

increasingly competitive and digitised banking<br />

sector.<br />

One example quoted in a recent Institute of<br />

Chartered Accountants in England & Wales<br />

(ICAEW) article is small business finance<br />

provider, Iwoca, who use bank account data<br />

as part of their credit decision process. The<br />

fintech has relationships with several of the<br />

large banks and is reported to be providing<br />

more SME overdraft approvals than several<br />

high street banks.<br />

Going forward, we can expect even<br />

greater transparency and availability of data<br />

across the industry, which is good news for<br />

small businesses, and good news for credit<br />

professionals too.<br />

Tim Vine is Head of European Trade <strong>Credit</strong><br />

at Dun & Bradstreet.<br />

Tim Vine<br />

Dun & Bradstreet<br />

This data is provided under<br />

a strict framework to<br />

approved <strong>Credit</strong> Reference<br />

Agencies who then<br />

integrate the information<br />

into their workflow to<br />

provide more accurate<br />

insights on an SME’s<br />

financial performance.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 21


VIEW FROM THE SEA FRONT<br />

BRANCHING OUT<br />

Whatever happened to bank managers<br />

and real money?<br />

AUTHOR – David Andrews<br />

It is partly because<br />

people are going<br />

cash less, thanks<br />

to the rise in<br />

popularity of new<br />

payment methods<br />

such as contactless<br />

transactions.


VIEW FROM THE SEA FRONT<br />

AUTHOR – David Andrews<br />

DO bank managers still exist?<br />

I mean, in the old-fashioned<br />

sense of the term. You know,<br />

like back in the days when you<br />

needed to borrow some cash<br />

and there was not an instantly<br />

approve (or reject) online facility. In ye distant<br />

far off times, the protocol was to make contact<br />

with your bank, and, invariably, request an<br />

interview with the Chief Beak.<br />

Those were of course also in the days when<br />

our high streets were festooned with bank<br />

branches, as opposed to wall to wall charity<br />

shops and – if you are really lucky – a branch or<br />

two. The more rural the location, the less likely<br />

you are going to find a ‘proper’ bank branch in<br />

<strong>2019</strong>.<br />

Today, like millions of my fellow citizens,<br />

I bank online, and for the most part via the<br />

fabulous apps on my mobile telephone. First<br />

Direct – which I initially joined in 1991 when it<br />

debuted as the UK’s first all singing, all dancing<br />

telephone bank, now offers a superb online<br />

service, and it is rare indeed for me to have to<br />

physically call the bank. Likewise, with my<br />

other lender, HSBC – which happens to own<br />

First Direct.<br />

On the occasions when I need to pop into<br />

my local HSBC branch to discuss my company<br />

account, I am ushered into the Business Pod,<br />

where my account is dealt with politely and<br />

efficiently.<br />

BANK BASHING<br />

Banks have of course taken many knocks over<br />

the years. And I don’t just mean the<br />

investment arms of the international lending<br />

establishments, whose complex intra bank<br />

lending were seen by most analysts of the 2008<br />

crash to have been responsible for the near<br />

collapse of the UK’s banking system and the<br />

overnight annihilation of our economy.<br />

No, the current bad boy image is largely<br />

down to the fact that banks are not only closing<br />

physical branches in increasing numbers of<br />

provincial towns and rural villages – not to<br />

mention inner cities – but many fear they are<br />

not doing enough to counter the shutting down<br />

of ATM machines across the UK.<br />

So, first the bank branches go, and then the<br />

cash machines. According to a recent Which?<br />

report (March <strong>2019</strong>), around 3,000 ATMs were<br />

closed in the last six months of 2018. Currently,<br />

around 300 machines are being shut every<br />

month. It is a worrying trend.<br />

It is partly because people are going cash less,<br />

thanks to the rise in popularity of new payment<br />

methods such as contactless transactions. My<br />

kids – as I am sure other parents of a certain age<br />

have discovered – never, ever have any cash.<br />

But it is also because cash machine operators<br />

such as Cardtronics and Note Machine, that<br />

get a fee from our banks each time we use one,<br />

are finding that fewer of their machines are<br />

economic to run.<br />

David Andrews<br />

Funny to<br />

think, how four<br />

decades ago<br />

I couldn’t get<br />

hold of cash –<br />

back then pretty<br />

much the only<br />

way so many<br />

things could be<br />

paid for. You try<br />

buying a beer on<br />

a debit card in<br />

the University<br />

of Essex student<br />

union in 1979.<br />

OUT IN THE STICKS<br />

A myriad of reasons then, and it’s fair to say<br />

that for those of us who live in major cities, it is<br />

not a problem – yet. But for millions of<br />

countryside dwellers – many of whom now must<br />

rely on driving or using public transport just to<br />

access a cash machine – it is a significant issue.<br />

Speaking as one who was perpetually skint<br />

through university days, getting hold of cash<br />

was mainly an issue as I seldom had any money<br />

in my bank account.<br />

Not that this stopped me from going<br />

vertiginously overdrawn, seemingly after the<br />

first couple of weeks of term time – even though<br />

you could get four pints for a quid in my student<br />

union bar in the late 70s.<br />

In fact, the last time I had a physical, face<br />

to face meeting with my old NatWest bank<br />

manager (Colchester branch, January 1979) he<br />

benignly asked if I had my cheque book and<br />

bank card with me. I do, I said. Thank you,<br />

may I have them please, said the affable boss,<br />

whose name has escaped me down the mists of<br />

time.<br />

Passing them across the forbidding terrain<br />

of an enormous teak desk, my then manager<br />

calmly relieved me of the offending<br />

merchandise, while simultaneously retrieving<br />

an enormous pair of scissors from a drawer and<br />

expertly snipping my bank card and cheque<br />

book into small pieces.<br />

Like confetti, I recall thinking at the time.<br />

Chastised, I nodded solemnly as he outlined<br />

a repayment plan for me to pay off the bank.<br />

According to the Office for National Statistics’<br />

composite price index, £300 in 1979 is today<br />

equivalent to £1,505. So, I get why the senior<br />

beak was keen to shred my card and cheque<br />

book. I’m not going to sell my vinyl collection,<br />

I vowed silently. Or my 60s golden age Marvel<br />

comics (reader, I still have them as the collection<br />

is today worth a small fortune).<br />

But I did clear the debt, slowly but surely,<br />

and while it probably took a good while to<br />

restore my credit rating to anything less than<br />

toxic, that audience with an unamused bank<br />

manager taught me a few harsh lessons in fiscal<br />

balancing 40 years back.<br />

Funny to think, how four decades ago I<br />

couldn’t get hold of cash – back then pretty<br />

much the only way so many things could<br />

be paid for. You try buying a beer on a debit<br />

card in the University of Essex student union in<br />

1979.<br />

And now today, I am thankfully not short<br />

of a bob or two but worry that for many of my<br />

fellow citizens – particularly the vulnerable and<br />

the elderly – that cash is becoming increasingly<br />

harder to come by.<br />

As Shakespeare said, ‘The wheel is come full<br />

circle.’<br />

David Andrews is a freelance<br />

business writer.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 23


OPINION<br />

Star Performance<br />

The prospect of future growth for<br />

non-performing loans in Europe in 2020.<br />

AUTHOR – Julian Winfield<br />

Julian Winfield<br />

NON-performing loans are an<br />

essential part of the lending<br />

business, and the likelihood of<br />

non-repayment is an inherent<br />

risk. Risk of loss is part of the<br />

credit rating banks assign to<br />

borrowers and is, therefore, included in the cost<br />

of borrowing. Loan losses and NPLs generally<br />

encompass non-performing loans, insolvency<br />

proceedings and debts where customers’<br />

payments fail to meet the contractual terms.<br />

The probability that a loan will be repaid<br />

in full is substantially lower once the loan<br />

has been classified as non-performing. As a<br />

result, debt purchasing organisations, such as<br />

Hoist Finance, can acquire NPL portfolios at a<br />

significant discount to the loans’ nominal total<br />

value.<br />

Perhaps not surprisingly, the banks<br />

themselves (i.e. the ‘sellers’) often have a<br />

different view of the value of their loans,<br />

which has hampered NPL divestments. Slow<br />

procedures and structural inefficiencies in debt<br />

recovery have been instrumental in limiting the<br />

transaction market.<br />

ADVANTAGES TO DIVESTMENT<br />

The principal advantages of divesting NPLs<br />

from a banking perspective is to reduce risk.<br />

But it is more than this. NPL sales not only<br />

reduce the sellers’ risk exposure, but they also<br />

release credit reserves and strengthen capital<br />

ratios by reducing risk-weighted assets.<br />

NPL sales translate into up-front cash<br />

payments that improve the selling banks’<br />

liquidity positions. It also enables them to focus<br />

more directly on their core business; recovering<br />

debt can be a distraction. It takes time, resources<br />

and specialised expertise to recover NPLs, so<br />

by selling the debt, banks avoid the costs and<br />

challenges associated with maintaining an inhouse<br />

debt recovery operation.<br />

Divestment of NPLs also contributes to an<br />

improved return on equity, which is vital to<br />

meeting shareholder demands for continuously<br />

improved returns.<br />

Most banks today have sophisticated sales<br />

processes, and the quality of portfolio data is<br />

improving. Risks have, therefore, been reduced<br />

and sellers can feel more certain that they<br />

will receive an accurate and fair market price.<br />

Having started by selling unsecured loans,<br />

banks have become more comfortable with<br />

selling other asset classes as well.<br />

This is part of the ongoing development<br />

trend. With fewer risks associated with selling<br />

and acquiring loans, the price of loan portfolios<br />

has risen. This trend has developed to varying<br />

degrees in different countries, with the UK<br />

among the markets where it has proceeded the<br />

farthest.<br />

VARYING PERFORMANCE<br />

Performance, however, is by no means uniform<br />

across Europe. In the under-developed markets<br />

such as Spain and Portugal, there have been<br />

few if any sales. The quality of data tends to be<br />

poor, and the bid-ask price particularly broad<br />

which means there is little appetite to engage.<br />

There are some early adopters, and these tend<br />

to be the consumer credit companies and<br />

international banks. But growth is hampered<br />

by cultural barriers and ‘denial’ among banks<br />

which means that portfolios that are sold tend<br />

to be old and of very poor quality.<br />

In the growth markets, which include<br />

Spain and Poland, the picture is rather more<br />

encouraging. There is a healthy competition<br />

among NPL purchasers and decreasing bid-ask<br />

spreads. Local banks are gradually becoming<br />

more active, portfolios are more ‘current’ and<br />

the quality of NPLs being sold is of a generally<br />

higher standard.<br />

In the most mature markets, such as the UK<br />

and Germany, NPL sales are an integral part of<br />

the financial ecosystem. Two particular trends<br />

are evident: firstly, the quality of the NPLs<br />

portfolios being sold; and secondly, the trend<br />

towards increased consolidation resulting in a<br />

fewer number of larger debt purchasers.<br />

PRICE INCREASES<br />

Competition for loan portfolios is a contributing<br />

factor to the price increase, which puts pressure<br />

on margins. This development has been driven<br />

over the past five or six years by lower borrowing<br />

costs, which appear to have bottomed out in<br />

2018 and are on the way up again.<br />

While prices may be rising, the total amount<br />

NPLs are decreasing. In Europe, the volume<br />

of outstanding NPLs in the banking sector<br />

decreased to approximately SEK 7,143 billion<br />

as per Q3 2018, compared to approximately SEK<br />

10,000 billion in 2017. This amount represents<br />

around 3.4 percent of all loans, compared<br />

with five percent in 2017. The decrease, while<br />

gradual, is partly due to legislation facilitating<br />

trade in receivables aimed at reducing the<br />

number of receivables in the European banking<br />

system.<br />

There are a number of trends that affect<br />

market development and that the debt<br />

purchasers are now planning for. These<br />

include: the impact of strong market growth;<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 24


OPINION<br />

AUTHOR – Julian Winfield<br />

Most banks today have sophisticated sales<br />

processes, and the quality of portfolio data<br />

is improving. Risks have, therefore, been<br />

reduced and sellers can feel more certain<br />

that they will receive an accurate and fair<br />

market price.<br />

the demand for increased operational<br />

efficiency that is in turn driving industry<br />

consolidation; increasing funding costs;<br />

and continued regulation of the market<br />

and greater market maturity.<br />

It is crucial to reduce the number<br />

of non-performing loans in Europe’s<br />

financial system. Household and SME<br />

over-indebtedness causes banks to restrict<br />

their lending, and small businesses are<br />

unable to invest; this inhibits economic<br />

growth. The transaction market is<br />

nevertheless growing, due partly to the<br />

fact that the market continues to develop<br />

and become more sophisticated.<br />

NEW REGULATIONS<br />

Another factor to consider in exploring<br />

the future market is the impact of new<br />

legislation. The introduction of IFRS 9 as<br />

from 2018, for example, requires banks<br />

to calculate and make provisions for<br />

expected credit losses as early as initial<br />

recognition following the granting of<br />

new loans. The new rules have had some<br />

positive effects, in that banks are required<br />

to report their expected credit losses at<br />

an earlier stage. The purpose of the new<br />

accounting standard for classification<br />

and measurement of financial assets is to<br />

enable earlier prediction of credit losses.<br />

Additional regulations in this area are to<br />

be expected in coming years.<br />

A few well-respected companies<br />

have emerged as the European market<br />

matures, and Hoist Finance holds a strong<br />

position as a partner to international<br />

banks and financial institutions. The<br />

company is among the five largest in<br />

Europe measured by ERC (Estimated<br />

Remaining Collections). Efficiency and<br />

cost savings are high on the agenda<br />

for these companies and help fuel the<br />

consolidation trend, and the degree of<br />

consolidation is likely to remain greater in<br />

those mature markets with lower prices.<br />

Market consolidation is taking place<br />

in parallel with an increase in regulation.<br />

Several major and minor transactions<br />

have been conducted in recent years, and<br />

this trend is expected to continue.<br />

Julian Winfield is UK Chief Executive<br />

of Hoist Finance.<br />

The new rules have had some positive<br />

effects, in that banks are required to<br />

report their expected credit losses at<br />

an earlier stage.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 25


COUNTRY FOCUS<br />

The African nation<br />

showing signs of real<br />

growth prospects.<br />

Part One: Ethiopia<br />

Out of Africa<br />

ETHIOPIA is not a country that<br />

many give much thought to, but<br />

it’s one that ought to be moving<br />

up the corporate agenda. With a<br />

prehistory tied to the ancestors of<br />

man that reaches back 4.2 million<br />

years, sites linked to anatomically modern man<br />

that are around 200,000 years old, and more<br />

‘recently’ a series of kingdoms and dynasties<br />

from the eighth century, it’s clear that Ethiopia<br />

has a long and notable culture.<br />

Ethiopia is also the world’s most populous<br />

landlocked country with a population of more<br />

than 108 million (CIA World Factbook) spread<br />

over an area of 420,000 sq. miles. It is the second<br />

most populous country in Africa after Nigeria.<br />

The population is made up of more than 14<br />

ethnic groups and just as many languages,<br />

although Amharic is the official national tongue.<br />

The population is young with 43 percent under 14<br />

years, 20 percent aged 15-24, 30 percent aged 25 to<br />

54, four percent aged 55 to 64 and just three percent<br />

over 65. Just under 21 percent of the population<br />

lives in urban areas.<br />

However, in recent memory the country has<br />

been troubled having had a communist regime<br />

from 1974 to 1991 and troubles within the federal<br />

republic that followed, notably a war with Eritrea,<br />

protests against several governments, and interethnic<br />

clashes in 2017 that led to 400,000 people<br />

being displaced. A new government, led by Abiy<br />

Ahmed has sought to end local conflicts, reform<br />

the country and has made censored websites<br />

available again.<br />

Politically speaking, the country as a federal<br />

parliamentary republic, has a figurehead<br />

president, executive prime minister and bicameral<br />

legislature. Administratively, the<br />

country is divided into ten regions and thee<br />

chartered cities that includes the capital, Addis<br />

Ababa.<br />

doing business (161 in 2017). In comparison, New<br />

Zealand is number one and the UK is ninth.Being<br />

situated close to the Horn of Africa, Ethiopia<br />

is well placed for those wanting to access the<br />

Middle East, Djibouti and its neighbours of<br />

Sudan, Kenya and Somalia. And while Ethiopia<br />

has the fastest growth rate of an economy in the<br />

region, it is starting from a low base point. The<br />

World Bank’s data that the country saw growth<br />

of 10.7 percent in 2017 (compared to 0.8 percent<br />

for Nigeria and 7.1 percent for Tanzania). The<br />

regional average was 5.4 percent. It also believes<br />

that Ethiopia is one of the poorest nations in the<br />

region with per capita income of $783. The World<br />

Bank says that Ethiopia aims to reach lowermiddle-income<br />

status by 2025.<br />

Ethiopia is predominantly an agricultural<br />

country – more than 80 percent of the population<br />

live in rural areas. Although the total fertility<br />

rate has declined, the population continues to<br />

grow. Ethiopia’s population growth is putting<br />

increasing pressure on land resources and is<br />

degrading the environment – food shortages are<br />

not uncommon.<br />

Adam Bernstein is a freelance business writer.<br />

ETHIOPIAN ECONOMICS<br />

According to Trading Economics – which quotes<br />

the World Bank’s annual ratings – the country is<br />

ranked 159 out of 190 economies for the ease of<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 26


TRADE TALK<br />

Export Controls<br />

The vital role that controls play for exporters.<br />

AUTHOR – Lesley Batchelor OBE FCICM<br />

Lesley Batchelor<br />

EXPORT and import controls<br />

and trade sanctions are now<br />

a global norm for businesses<br />

looking to trade or facilitate<br />

trade. They form a key role in<br />

ensuring that the movement<br />

of goods, technology, software and services<br />

around the world is safe and secure.<br />

Controls are only applied for very<br />

specific traded goods – both tangible and<br />

intangible. The worries that seemingly<br />

innocent materials could be used to<br />

develop weapons of mass destruction is<br />

very real. This is the same with certain<br />

products that could also be used in<br />

different ways that might cause the abuse<br />

or violation of people’s human rights or<br />

safety. Furthermore, controls are often<br />

used for the imposition of sanctions or<br />

arms embargoes from the European<br />

Union or the United Nations. These are<br />

very important monitoring tools for the<br />

protection of global trade.<br />

Controls do not just apply to obviously<br />

dangerous products (i.e. weapons) – though<br />

the defence industry is undoubtedly most<br />

affected by them. There are some ‘dualuse’<br />

products which are liable to controls<br />

– i.e. outwardly innocuous goods, software<br />

or services that could otherwise be used<br />

towards the construction of dangerous<br />

weapons. Items like batteries, goods<br />

containing chemicals like chlorine or<br />

component parts in certain computers are<br />

all on the government’s ‘Control List’.<br />

Exporters of such products will therefore<br />

need to apply for an ‘Export Licence’<br />

and ensure compliance with controlrelated<br />

regulations, both domestic and<br />

international.<br />

ENSURING COMPLIANCE<br />

Although there is some international<br />

commonality in approach, regulations<br />

can differ considerably from jurisdiction<br />

to jurisdiction. Regulations are also<br />

under frequent review, and changes may<br />

be significant. The penalties for noncompliance<br />

can be severe, including<br />

multi-million pound fines, loss of<br />

permission to trade and even custodial<br />

sentences. Even where the penalties are<br />

minor, the impact on reputation, access<br />

to trade facilitations, and therefore<br />

business, may prove costly.<br />

However, demonstrable compliance<br />

with export and import controls and trade<br />

sanctions can also offer a competitive<br />

advantage both in terms of being able to<br />

conduct business with certain countries<br />

and access to trade facilitations. It also<br />

ensures goods and technology can flow in<br />

a timely and cost-effective manner which<br />

is good for both exporters and importers<br />

businesses.<br />

To ensure both compliance and<br />

expeditious trade, exporting and<br />

importing organisations such as industry<br />

and academic institutions, need access to<br />

good-quality and up-to-date information<br />

from all relevant jurisdictions. Many<br />

appoint export control professionals and<br />

points of contact who develop Internal<br />

Compliance Programmes.<br />

However, until now, there has been no<br />

industry-approved recognition of what<br />

the professional knowledge and skills<br />

around export controls are.<br />

EXPORT CONTROL PROFESSION<br />

It is for this reason that the Institute of<br />

Export & International Trade (IOE&IT)<br />

is launching a new ‘Export Control<br />

Profession’, with the support of the Export<br />

Control Joint Unit of the Department for<br />

International Trade (the UK’s regulator in<br />

issues relating to export controls), HMRC<br />

and ADS.<br />

The new profession seeks to enable<br />

and promote excellence in compliance<br />

with export and import control, and trade<br />

sanction regulations. As a membership<br />

body it will represent Export Control<br />

Professionals, providing them with<br />

essential resources, professional points<br />

of contact and learning support for the<br />

industry.<br />

MEMBERS WILL BE ABLE TO:<br />

• Gain professional recognition of their<br />

knowledge and competence through<br />

post-nominal letters, which will only<br />

be accredited to those with sufficient<br />

experience or qualifications<br />

• Gain professional and career<br />

development through a combination of<br />

qualifications and an industry specific<br />

Continuous Professional Development<br />

(CPD) programme<br />

• Register for accreditation of consultancy<br />

work/training expertise<br />

• Enter a support network through which<br />

they can connect and share information<br />

with other compliance professionals,<br />

both home and abroad<br />

• Access regular bulletins with the<br />

latest local, national and international<br />

developments in the industry.<br />

Employers will also be able to access<br />

the profession using their membership<br />

of the IOE&IT, ensuring the competence<br />

and knowledge of their staff through<br />

the qualifications and CPD programme,<br />

thereby reducing their risks of noncompliance<br />

and the associated costs<br />

of fines and other sanctions. Further,<br />

through the new body they will gain access<br />

to a pool of accredited export control<br />

specialists – a valuable recruitment<br />

resource.<br />

This new profession is an essential step<br />

to ensuring compliance and competence<br />

among our exporting community.<br />

To find out more visit: export.org.uk/<br />

page/ExportControls<br />

Lesley Batchelor OBE FCICM is Director<br />

General of the Institute of Export and<br />

International Trade.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 27


INTERNATIONAL<br />

TRADE<br />

Monthly round-up of the latest stories<br />

in global trade by Andrea Kirkby.<br />

RUSSIAN STAGNATION<br />

IT'S been a while since I covered<br />

Russia but things don't feel as<br />

if they've moved on much. Q1<br />

shows GDP growth slowing from 2.7<br />

percent in the last quarter of 2018 to<br />

0.8 percent year-on-year, and growth<br />

prospects for the medium term are<br />

only modest. While GDP is still ahead,<br />

real disposable incomes are falling,<br />

and this, together with a population<br />

that's declining by a quarter of a<br />

million a year, will keep the consumer<br />

market subdued.<br />

The structure of exports has hardly<br />

changed over the last decade; oil and<br />

gas accounts for 60 percent and other<br />

commodities have a big impact, too.<br />

No wonder the ruble has halved in<br />

value over the last ten years.<br />

The good points? Russia is<br />

relatively protected from external<br />

shocks by high reserves and low<br />

external debt.<br />

It's a hard market to make money<br />

in – particularly if you don't keep an<br />

eye on DSOs, because enforcement is<br />

an absolute nightmare. But firms in<br />

engineering, pharma, and chemicals<br />

have done well there – and British<br />

brands and education are well<br />

regarded in Russia. You might make<br />

it work – but make sure you have the<br />

right payment terms and watch that<br />

currency, too.<br />

THE BIG SWITCH<br />

EULER Hermes' recent study 'The Big Switch'<br />

makes for interesting reading. Euler Hermes<br />

identifies three things that are changing<br />

this year. Firstly, China replacing the US as<br />

a source of global growth; secondly, a switch<br />

from a trade war to new pragmatism; and<br />

thirdly, a move away from recent hawkishness<br />

on the part of central banks, leading to further<br />

economic stimulus.<br />

Although President Trump talks a good<br />

fight, the US is now a highly indebted economy<br />

with a disorderly budget setting process, and<br />

Euler Hermes thinks the investment cycle<br />

is stalling. That will affect growth in 2020<br />

onwards. On the other hand, China is now<br />

taking actions to stimulate the economy, and<br />

could see improvement from Q2 this year.<br />

That will help the Asian economies which are<br />

highly integrated into Chinese supply chains.<br />

Moving to trade pragmatism and away from<br />

protectionism will help export orientated<br />

economies. In Europe, Germany will benefit<br />

from this trend – so will highly export focused<br />

Asian economies like Vietnam.<br />

Monetary dovishness, on the other hand,<br />

should help emerging markets. Euler Hermes<br />

looks for countries which have introduced<br />

economic reforms, which are exporters, or<br />

do well from China or all three: Ivory Coast,<br />

Kenya, South Korea, Taiwan and Hong Kong<br />

are the top picks.<br />

It's an interesting argument. I'm not<br />

completely sure things will work out as<br />

expected, but I might run the slide rule over<br />

a couple of those countries to see how the<br />

fundamentals stack up.<br />

EXPORTING IS NOT<br />

GREAT AT ALL<br />

I took a trip to export.great.gov.uk and Global<br />

Britain turns out to be rather a bust, to judge<br />

from this website. There are only five country<br />

guides available at the moment, and there<br />

seems to be less really crunchy information<br />

than there used to be. For instance, you're told<br />

that Brazil ‘has complex import regulations’<br />

and the site suggests you can go somewhere<br />

else to find out about them.<br />

Meanwhile looking at the legacy pages on<br />

gov.uk – ‘exporting to India’ was last updated<br />

in November 2016 – as were a lot of the other<br />

pages. There's very little really up-to-date<br />

information.<br />

The message I'm getting? ‘Exporting<br />

is something we can spare a junior civil<br />

servant a few hours a week to work on.’<br />

Nice rebranding – but you're better going to<br />

credit insurance companies or a Chamber of<br />

Commerce to get the facts.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 28


INDIAN elections could trim Narendra<br />

Modi's sails, but his reforms have already<br />

made a big difference. For the first time,<br />

India has become a national single market,<br />

with national sales taxes and no inter-state<br />

barriers to trade. That should help India<br />

continue to achieve high rates of growth –<br />

at seven percent, economic growth is now<br />

higher than China's, and domestic demand<br />

is robust. Low external debt and fiscal<br />

consolidation put the country in a stable<br />

position as far as its credit and budgets are<br />

concerned.<br />

Though some problems remain – the<br />

bank sector is highly indebted, and some<br />

reforms have been stymied – there's an<br />

atmosphere of innovation. Even tourist<br />

Spotlight on India<br />

More insurance, more claims<br />

SOME interesting announcements<br />

from the insurance industry recently<br />

show mixed news. The Association<br />

of British Insurers (ABI), for instance,<br />

says trade credit payouts last year<br />

hit their highest levels since 2009 –<br />

though that's mainly UK specific, it's an<br />

experience that seems to have<br />

been reflected elsewhere. The Berne<br />

Union and The International <strong>Credit</strong><br />

Insurance & Surety Association (ICISA)<br />

expect insolvencies to increase in<br />

<strong>2019</strong>, with a significant worsening of<br />

China cashflow crisis<br />

ONE reason I'm not quite sure about<br />

the 'Big Switch' is that China has been<br />

looking rather fragile of late. Coface<br />

says payment delays have surged. Since<br />

2015, there's been a continuing trend to<br />

longer and longer payment times – 2018<br />

saw an increase from 76 days to 86 days.<br />

Corporate bond defaults and<br />

insolvencies are both rising. 40 percent<br />

of firms are seeing increasing levels of<br />

payment delay, and 55 percent (up from<br />

47 percent in 2017) are experiencing<br />

ultra-long delays (80 percent of which<br />

become unrecoverable). That looks<br />

nasty. But in fact, it's very sector<br />

dependent. Automotive, transportation,<br />

construction, and energy are the main<br />

sectors involved – and they're largely<br />

those where the government has been<br />

trying to dampen down the investment<br />

visas have loosened up with multi-year,<br />

multi-entry visas now being offered – a<br />

world first.<br />

Even so, India's not the easiest market<br />

to target. Very few sectors work on a truly<br />

national level, so you'll need to target<br />

each state separately. But there are some<br />

great opportunities. Healthcare and<br />

sustainability are huge areas of investment<br />

at the moment, and education also offers<br />

immense potential. Besides which, India is<br />

rapidly innovating and that gives an entree<br />

to consultancy as well as tech businesses.<br />

Just one warning. The rupee isn't the<br />

world's strongest currency by a long way,<br />

so be very careful how you deal with<br />

currency issues.<br />

the risk environment. That adds up to a<br />

more dangerous world for exporters.<br />

But the Berne Union also reckons<br />

its members' deal pipelines are<br />

increasing, particularly in Asia and<br />

sub-Saharan Africa (intriguingly, not so<br />

much in Latin America). There's huge<br />

opportunity in renewable energy, with<br />

positive trends in other infrastructure<br />

and transportation, too. Good news<br />

for insurers – but underlining the<br />

fact that exporters really do need that<br />

insurance.<br />

boom and reduce corporate leverage.<br />

On the other hand, if you're in pharma,<br />

chemicals, or agrifoods, you won't<br />

have noticed any adverse trends.<br />

And what's particularly interesting is<br />

that China is now pushing economic<br />

stimulus in a new direction – towards<br />

the consumer market – according to<br />

Pictet Asset <strong>Management</strong>. So, if you<br />

export consumer goods or services,<br />

China might just have become a more<br />

attractive market for your products.<br />

The one sector that I'd really worry<br />

about is IT. That's not one of the 'usual<br />

suspects’ and given that the IT sector<br />

supply chains are Asia-centric, it could<br />

have quite an impact on the rest of the<br />

region – particularly export orientated<br />

countries like Vietnam, South Korea,<br />

Taiwan and Malaysia.<br />

Dangerous Chemicals<br />

COFACE has just downgraded its views on<br />

the chemicals sector. The automotive sector<br />

has been weak for a while – now that's<br />

flowing through to suppliers, including<br />

petrochemicals/plastics. They're getting<br />

really squeezed, with higher feedstock<br />

prices leading to tight margins on lower<br />

volumes of business.<br />

But more generally, this is a warning<br />

call for all cyclical sectors. If Coface is right<br />

about where we're sitting in the industrial<br />

cycle, they're all going to get hit. So, if you<br />

supply customers in cyclical sectors, keep<br />

a close eye on your Days Sales Outstanding<br />

(DSOs) and be ready to react to the first sign<br />

of changing payment behaviours.<br />

Construction – the<br />

East shows Red<br />

IT'S not just China that is having problems in<br />

the construction sector. South Korea, too, is<br />

looking exposed thanks to the government<br />

shifting spending away from infrastructure.<br />

So is the Middle East, particularly Saudi<br />

Arabia, and Turkey, which had a minibuilding<br />

boom. If you haven't seen the video<br />

of abandoned Turkish ‘chateaux’ at Burj<br />

al-Babas yet, it's worth seeing – it gives you<br />

some idea of the Pharaonic scale of ambition<br />

of some developers, and the massive debt<br />

hangover, too.<br />

Given that construction is already one<br />

of the industries with the longest payment<br />

terms and the longest payment delays, that<br />

could result in severe pain for suppliers – so<br />

mind how you go.<br />

Someting fishy<br />

LANDIA’S fourth BioChop is heading for<br />

the Faroes. The machine breaks down dead<br />

fish into silage for biogas production or pet<br />

food, which isn't a glamorous business but<br />

is a good way of dealing with unwanted fish<br />

morts.<br />

The big lesson here is never to<br />

underestimate the power of the 'long tail',<br />

as internet citizens say. Once you've got a<br />

customer, keep them happy and sell them<br />

more. It works in domestic markets and it<br />

works extremely well for export too.<br />

EXCHANGE RATES VISIT<br />

CURRENCYUK.CO.UK OR<br />

CALL 020 7738 0777<br />

Currency UK is authorised and regulated<br />

by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).<br />

HIGH LOW TREND<br />

GBP/EUR 1.1717 1.1521 Up<br />

GBP/USD 1.3175 1.2869 Up<br />

GBP/CHF 1.3298 1.2959 Down<br />

GBP/AUD 1.8598 1.8115 Up<br />

GBP/CAD 1.7580 1.7323 Up<br />

GBP/JPY<br />

CURRENCY UK<br />

146.896 143.849 Up<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 29


OPINION<br />

DISPUTING<br />

TERMS<br />

The importance of setting different<br />

terms for different regions.<br />

AUTHOR – Jamie Ashford<br />

IN international business it is common<br />

practice for companies to enter<br />

agreements based on their standard<br />

operating terms – and sensibly so.<br />

The agreed terms are likely to govern<br />

the entire relationship with a trade<br />

partner and ensuring their accuracy, relevance,<br />

and incorporation will have a profound impact<br />

when it comes to potential future conflict.<br />

While it is common for companies to ensure<br />

their terms are incorporated, it is less common<br />

for them to employ the consistent practice of<br />

revisiting their terms on a regular basis.<br />

Regularly reviewing terms ensures their<br />

relevance to a growing business and an evolving<br />

business environment. It is usually only at the<br />

point of an issue or dispute a company’s terms<br />

are brought into question. Most often, this is too<br />

late. Has this happened to you? Or could it? To<br />

avoid being caught out in the future here are<br />

some key considerations.<br />

GOVERNING LAW AND JURISDICTION<br />

In the event of a dispute, it is in the interest of<br />

both parties to have clarity on certain issues. In<br />

international trade one of the most fundamental<br />

concerns is clarifying the law upon which the<br />

agreement is governed.<br />

When conducting business with an<br />

international company, you cannot assume<br />

that the law of your country is applicable. If it<br />

is not expressed in the agreement, you may find<br />

that your customer’s law applies, which in the<br />

event of a dispute may lead to a longer judicial<br />

process and/or translation fees. It is therefore<br />

imperative that you include a governing law<br />

clause.<br />

In addition to selecting the applicable law,<br />

agreements ought to express the relevant<br />

jurisdiction (i.e. where court proceedings will<br />

take place in the event of a dispute) and possibly<br />

the forum (i.e. mediation or arbitration may be<br />

more suitable than immediately taking a case to<br />

Court).<br />

Companies often fail to reconsider their<br />

law and jurisdiction clause when entering<br />

new international agreements. Or worse, use<br />

the same terms for their group companies<br />

in all countries in which they operate. Be<br />

mindful, especially when conducting business<br />

internationally, one size certainly does not fit<br />

all. So, why not make your country’s law and<br />

jurisdiction applicable for all your business<br />

agreements?<br />

A risk with selecting your own country’s<br />

law and jurisdiction for all agreements is if a<br />

claim is successful on your own turf, it may not<br />

automatically mean the title (i.e. the judgment<br />

obtained) is enforceable against a debtor based<br />

elsewhere. In some scenarios, it is preferable to<br />

sue them in their ‘own back yard’.<br />

If your standard terms omit a law and<br />

jurisdiction clause, or if the clause appears<br />

poorly drafted, you could be setting yourself<br />

up for a long and costly process in the event a<br />

dispute arises. Seek legal advice! A good lawyer<br />

can advise upon which governing law and<br />

jurisdiction would be most suitable.<br />

RIGHT TO COSTS<br />

In many jurisdictions, there will be laws<br />

governing how costs will be awarded in a<br />

dispute. Often, they allow the successful party<br />

to recover what is reasonable and proportionate.<br />

However, despite this right, it is still advisable to<br />

include provision for costs within your terms.<br />

This may remove scope for a dispute on the<br />

issue and in some cases will strengthen your<br />

right to recover costs in the pre-legal phase.<br />

RIGHT TO INTEREST<br />

As with costs, there will often be a provision to<br />

recover statutory interest on overdue invoices<br />

by law. However, within your standard terms,<br />

you have the flexibility to elect alternate rates,<br />

which in most cases will override the statutory<br />

rates so can be set higher.<br />

On this point, it is advisable to include a note<br />

on your invoices reminding customers of your<br />

contractual right to claim interest. This has<br />

two benefits: firstly it encourages customers<br />

to pay on time; and secondly it weakens any<br />

later argument from your customer about the<br />

incorporation of the interest rate clause.<br />

RETENTION OF TITLE (ROT)<br />

If your trade is the supply of goods, it would<br />

be prudent to retain title on those goods after<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 30


OPINION<br />

AUTHOR – Jamie Ashford<br />

Jamie Ashford<br />

International Debt<br />

Recovery Lawyer<br />

delivery, which in essence means they still<br />

belong to you until expressed conditions are<br />

met i.e. until the goods are paid for in full by<br />

your customer. In the event goods are not paid<br />

for, if you have retained title, you may have a<br />

right to take them back, which should mitigate<br />

your loss.<br />

Please note the law on retaining title varies<br />

considerably from country to country, so you<br />

may wish to seek legal advice and/or vary the<br />

clause depending on who you are contracting<br />

with.<br />

DELIVERY OF GOODS<br />

Disputes in respect of sale of goods often center<br />

around issues occurring during transit. For<br />

this reason, you should ensure that your terms<br />

accurately and unequivocally set out where your<br />

responsibilities end and where the receiver’s<br />

responsibilities begin, or vice versa.<br />

A pre-defined series of commercial terms<br />

(Incoterms/ International Commercial Terms)<br />

are commonly used and include among other<br />

things; ‘the seller electing the location of where<br />

the goods will be available’ (EXW/Ex Works) or<br />

‘the seller delivers the goods at their own risk to<br />

a named location’ (FCA/Free Carrier) etc.<br />

VARIATION/AMENDMENT<br />

On occasion, there will be clauses within your<br />

terms and conditions that need amending. This<br />

is often the result of a change in the commercial<br />

relationship, or a structural change within your<br />

business. It could be something as simple as<br />

changing the address to which formal notices<br />

are to be served, or as extreme as your core price<br />

or credit terms.<br />

While it is<br />

common for<br />

companies to<br />

ensure their terms<br />

are incorporated,<br />

it is less common<br />

for them to employ<br />

the consistent<br />

practice of<br />

revisiting their<br />

terms on a regular<br />

basis.<br />

It isn’t uncommon for a variation clause to<br />

allow unilateral changes meaning you shouldn’t<br />

have to wait for the express agreement of the<br />

other party to make the change. However, before<br />

relying upon a unilateral clause, it would be<br />

sensible to ensure its enforceability by seeking<br />

legal advice. Bear in mind that in situations<br />

where a trade partner’s terms apply it may also<br />

have a unilateral right to amend.<br />

Your terms should clarify how to validate an<br />

amendment.<br />

Although relatively rare for assignments to take<br />

place, it certainly isn’t unheard of, especially in<br />

the event your company is undergoing structural<br />

changes. A well-drafted assignment clause could<br />

allow you greater flexibility shaping a ‘new look’,<br />

while simultaneously retaining vital business.<br />

The above suggestions are just a few of the<br />

clauses you may wish to consider revising and/<br />

or adding to your standard terms. In addition,<br />

you may also wish to consider how your<br />

standard terms are incorporated by your staff<br />

into your agreements on a contract-by-contract<br />

basis. It is important that you leave no doubt in<br />

the mind of your trading partners that it is your<br />

terms that apply.<br />

If you are a global entity or part of a group<br />

company, you should be particularly mindful<br />

as to whether your terms have been suitably<br />

adapted for international trade. Don’t delay,<br />

check them today.<br />

Jamie Ashford, International Debt Recovery<br />

Lawyer, Bierens Debt Recovery Lawyers.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 31


ADVERTORIAL<br />

THE FORGOTTEN<br />

ART OF E-BILLING<br />

Finding the most efficient approach<br />

to the collections process requires<br />

investment in intelligent automation.<br />

AUTHOR – Joe Pettit<br />

IN the 60s, the communication<br />

of business processes between<br />

companies was slow and errorprone.<br />

Instead of electronically<br />

exchanging invoices and other<br />

essential business documents,<br />

trading partners had to send each other<br />

paper documents to fulfil their requests.<br />

Slow processes, delays and errors were an<br />

obstacle for companies who wanted fast<br />

shipments, fast payments, and who valued<br />

accurate information exchanges with their<br />

business partners.<br />

The introduction of electronic data<br />

interchange (EDI)(1) and emails should have<br />

resulted in an electronic revolution that<br />

changed the credit management landscape,<br />

but did it? While we have moved on, mainstream<br />

credit management departments are<br />

still grappling with the paper hangovers of<br />

the 60s. It appears that many UK companies<br />

have forgotten the art of e-billing and how<br />

this simple change can transform cash<br />

collection.<br />

Today collections teams are under intense<br />

pressure to meet collection targets, while<br />

maintaining a healthy relationship with<br />

the customer. The need for e-billing and<br />

intelligent AR automation has never been<br />

greater. A new breed of technology has<br />

emerged that’s helping tech-savvy credit<br />

leaders who refuse to allow cashflow to be<br />

held to ransom, but are you being left behind?<br />

ULTIMATE FLEXIBILITY<br />

No matter how bespoke your customer<br />

billing requirements, getting the invoice<br />

delivered in a format that meets these<br />

demands is key to getting paid faster. The<br />

flexibility e-billing provides from both<br />

a customer and organisational view is<br />

impressive. Today, the technology is available<br />

to support servicing the customer better,<br />

while releasing the collection team to chase<br />

real debt.<br />

SAVING THE DAY AND THE PLANET<br />

For credit leaders e-billing is a critical factor<br />

for eliminating paper billing, reducing print<br />

and post and lowering their organisations’<br />

carbon footprint and costs.<br />

E-BILLING IS SIMPLE<br />

Setting up e-billing is not as complicated as<br />

one might expect. Integrating e-billing into a<br />

collections strategy gives credit management<br />

teams valuable invoice receipt information,<br />

helping them to take corrective action long<br />

before the due date.<br />

Indeed, organisations which adopt<br />

e-billing are incredibly successful in<br />

cash collection. Improved cashflow,<br />

communications and reduced DSO are only<br />

a few of the benefits forward thinking AR<br />

departments are experiencing. The time<br />

savings and freedom to chase real debt lifts<br />

morale and improves internal and external<br />

relationships. Customers utilising selfservice<br />

portals are rewarded with transparent<br />

transactional information which facilitates<br />

speedier cash collection. The news is that<br />

organisations embracing e-billing by rolling<br />

out new initiatives, can comfortably achieve<br />

an 87 percent paper to e-billing conversion<br />

rate(2).<br />

E-BILLING AND CUSTOMER ADOPTION<br />

For organisations embarking on this<br />

transformational journey they should first<br />

consider their audience demographics. This<br />

research helps identify clusters of customers<br />

and how they are best served, not only for<br />

invoice delivery but preferences throughout<br />

the collection process. Communications<br />

and delivery channel options should be<br />

provided to ensure adherence of customers’<br />

preferences.<br />

For positive customer relationships<br />

everything needs to be transparent, satisfying<br />

the customer who requires print and post, to<br />

the business who still work with fax, email,<br />

or just a URL, and finally those customers<br />

that need EDI. Unless you offer all the<br />

options, you will find it challenging to<br />

satisfy and maintain progressive business<br />

relationships. Providing customers with the<br />

option to work within their business process<br />

is the way forward.<br />

ADAPT OR DIE<br />

Consolidated invoicing, in all forms, involves<br />

heavy lifting by collections teams to ensure<br />

that customer invoices expedite in a timely<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 32


ADVERTORIAL<br />

‘I never received<br />

the invoice, I didn't<br />

get the statement’,<br />

without any<br />

validation of the<br />

invoice, then cash<br />

collection effort<br />

will always be<br />

disrupted.<br />

and efficient manner. The work doesn’t<br />

stop there, throw in the individual<br />

payment arrangements made by the<br />

sales team and the pressure builds on an<br />

already overstretched collections team,<br />

trying to meet the needs of the business,<br />

and the customer and the whole process<br />

starts to wobble.<br />

Sadly, tactical digging-in and getting<br />

the job done ensues, at the cost of<br />

strategic direction. A direction that could<br />

bring about positive change, in terms<br />

of systems and platforms that assist<br />

the collection teams automate invoice<br />

to cash cycle. Many organisations are<br />

lost in their bespoke systems. Just when<br />

the team come up for air, another monthend<br />

hits them, and so the cycle continues.<br />

These organisations perpetuate their<br />

inefficiencies and are particularly<br />

risk-averse when it comes to new<br />

collection techniques and technologies.<br />

Long-term these choices don’t bode<br />

well in today’s adapt or die business<br />

landscape.<br />

THE PROCESS STARTS WITH BILLING<br />

When considering how billing influences<br />

the complete collection process, the<br />

process starts with billing. Get billing<br />

wrong, and it doesn't matter how effective<br />

the collection processes are. If customers<br />

are continually reporting that, ‘I never<br />

received the invoice, I didn't get the<br />

statement’, without any validation of<br />

the invoice, then cash collection effort<br />

will always be disrupted. Underinvestment<br />

at the start of the process; namely,<br />

‘e-billing’ will have a detrimental impact on<br />

cashflow. Investment starts with e-billing<br />

and ends with cash allocation systems.<br />

E-BILLING DOESN’T STOP WITH<br />

INVOICES<br />

Too many e-billing systems concentrate<br />

only on invoices with other key customer<br />

documents being seldom considered.<br />

About Joe Pettit<br />

Joe is an e-billing and<br />

collection expert and<br />

evangelist. He has worked<br />

with numerous industries<br />

throughout his career, helping<br />

them to achieve more efficient<br />

processes. As a member of<br />

the Data Interconnect team,<br />

Joe brings his knowledge<br />

and expertise to bear and has<br />

crafted Corrivo Billing, Dispute,<br />

Collection and Allocation to<br />

provide one powerful suite of<br />

AR automated collection tools<br />

that help organisations reach<br />

their collection targets faster.<br />

If your e-billing or your billing strategy<br />

only covers thinking around invoices, it is<br />

one dimensional, and will never provide<br />

the flexibility to deliver the full suite of<br />

documents customers require.<br />

THE GOOD NEWS IS THAT<br />

E-BILLING IS SELF-FUNDING<br />

E-billing projects are self-funding, the<br />

reduction in postage costs, manual<br />

handling savings, and the lowered<br />

outbound call costs, offset the e-billing<br />

system expenditure. Putting e-billing front<br />

and centre of your payment process, will<br />

have a positive effect on your cashflow and<br />

automatically queue up better collections,<br />

disputes and allocations management.<br />

SOURCE<br />

[1] The history of EDI – by Steve Brewer.<br />

[2] Data Interconnect Customer<br />

conversion rate.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 33


CICM Learning<br />

Conference<br />

<strong>2019</strong><br />

MANAGING RISK<br />

IN UNCERTAIN TIMES<br />

Thursday 20 <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong><br />

LIMITED<br />

FREE MEMBER<br />

PLACES –<br />

BOOK TODAY!<br />

This year we have put together an exciting and varied programme based around<br />

the theme of ‘Managing risk in uncertain times’. All the basic principles of<br />

cashflow and credit management are even more important in times of uncertainty<br />

and change: we have a programme of activity, discussion, debate and workshop.<br />

To find out more and to book your place visit www.cicm.com<br />

info@cicm.com<br />

www.cicm.com<br />

01780 722900


AWARD WINNERS<br />

WINNING TICKET<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> asked the winners of the <strong>2019</strong><br />

British <strong>Credit</strong> Awards what it means to them to win<br />

one of the prestigious awards.<br />

Managing Risk Award:<br />

Vodafone UK <strong>Credit</strong><br />

and Risk Team<br />

VODAFONE was absolutely thrilled to<br />

win at the CICM Awards earlier this year<br />

within the category of Managing <strong>Credit</strong><br />

Risk.<br />

2018 was a turn-around year for the<br />

credit risk area at Vodafone, with the<br />

team growing in capacity, knowledge<br />

and skills, which all helped to deliver<br />

instrumental changes to our decision<br />

making across the customer lifecycle<br />

and as a result has led to significant<br />

benefits to our operational performance<br />

and customer profitability.<br />

Being shortlisted and then going on<br />

to win the award is evidence of all of the<br />

effort from the team here at Vodafone.<br />

The industry level recognition of<br />

the huge achievements over the last<br />

year, has also further motivated an<br />

already fantastic team to continue to<br />

drive improvements in their ongoing<br />

activities.<br />

Penelope Clarke<br />

Rising Star of the<br />

Year Award:<br />

Paradigm Housing<br />

WINNING CICM’s Rising Star of the<br />

Year Award means so much to me<br />

and I am so thankful to have won.<br />

The award has been instrumental in<br />

raising my profile and opening doors<br />

to new and exciting opportunities.<br />

Prior to joining CICM I was anxious<br />

about starting my <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

course. It had been 20 years since I<br />

was last in education and the thought<br />

of studying part time while working<br />

seemed overwhelming.<br />

I am really glad I did, the course and<br />

the range of networking events held<br />

by CICM have been fantastic! Winning<br />

the award has set me on a trajectory,<br />

it has given me a boldness to continue<br />

pushing forward in my profession,<br />

to overcome hurdles and set new<br />

standards in both <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

and the Housing Sector. I am excited to<br />

see all that the future holds.<br />

Salma Shah<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Professional of the Year and Winner of<br />

Winners:<br />

npower Business Solutions<br />

TO win <strong>Credit</strong> Professional of the Year was incredible, but to then hear my name<br />

being called out as ‘Winner of Winners’ was beyond belief. As someone who is<br />

passionate about the world of credit, striving to make a difference within the<br />

company I work for and the people I work with, it was an absolute honour to even<br />

be nominated at such a prestigious event and to be shortlisted against some great<br />

people – and, as it transpired, some great companies.<br />

I’m always excited by the challenges we face in our sector and it is this that<br />

encourages me to keep on top of my game and to ensure I am always developing,<br />

both as a professional and a person. I am privileged to have a good team around<br />

me and therefore it is very important to me that their development and futures are<br />

invested in too.<br />

I am very humbled to have won these awards yet feel there is still much for me to<br />

both learn from and bring to our most wonderful industry.<br />

Matthew Roberts MCICM<br />

Learning and<br />

Development Award:<br />

ABB<br />

WINNING this award is so important<br />

as it recognises the efforts of<br />

everyone; the learners, the course<br />

developers and deliverers, the<br />

local line management and the<br />

administrators. It legitimises, and<br />

values, the investment in learning<br />

and development (L&D). So often,<br />

Learning and Development can be<br />

seen by managers as an imposition<br />

yet when the results of the programme<br />

(in terms of improved personal,<br />

team and business performance) are<br />

viewed, it reinforces the belief of all<br />

L&D professionals that ‘training is<br />

important and effective’.<br />

The judges commented that the<br />

award was given due to the level of<br />

support given to the learners. This<br />

vindicates our approach to being<br />

helpful to the learners, allowing them<br />

time and space to develop without<br />

undue pressure, and providing positive<br />

motivation to achieve their outcomes.<br />

The programme itself is unique<br />

in that the design aims to provide<br />

a full understanding of the order<br />

to cash cycle, so that wherever a<br />

learner is situated in the process<br />

they understand the effect of those<br />

upstream, and how they affect those<br />

downstream. This has led to numerous<br />

examples of better teamwork at the<br />

interfaces. Winning this award also<br />

recognises that design philosophy.<br />

David Dyer training provider from<br />

Improvement Through People on<br />

behalf of ABB<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 35


Peninsula Case study<br />

Peninsula helps small businesses worldwide, but how?<br />

Consisting of 13 companies worldwide, Peninsula<br />

has been providing professional services to<br />

small businesses across the UK since 1983.<br />

Originally specialising in employment law and HR,<br />

Peninsula has since expanded to cover health,<br />

safety management, insurance and employee<br />

wellbeing.<br />

In the past five years, Peninsula has acquired and<br />

absorbed a number of companies worldwide.<br />

Carl Lancaster, Group Head of Collections,<br />

explained: “As we grew, it became clear that our<br />

existing credit management systems weren’t able<br />

to cope with the growing volume of transactions<br />

and the influx of business we were experiencing<br />

as a result of the acquisitions.” Based on this,<br />

Peninsula decided it was time to look for a new<br />

credit management solution. Peninsula invited the<br />

top five credit management software companies<br />

to pitch their solutions in order for it to decide<br />

which was would be best-suited to its business.<br />

Following tender negotiations, the decision was<br />

made to adopt Onguard’s <strong>Credit</strong>Manager.<br />

RESULTS AND BENEFITS<br />

• Cash flow increase of 20%<br />

• Card payments have doubled<br />

per day<br />

• Smooth implementation<br />

• Improved customer<br />

communication<br />

HANDLING A GROWING<br />

VOLUME OF TRANSACTIONS<br />

When looking at a new credit<br />

management software solution, Peninsula had<br />

several requirements. Not only was it vital that<br />

the new system could deal with the large volume<br />

of transactions Peninsula was processing but it<br />

was also required to consolidate all debts across<br />

the group. Peninsula also wanted the solution<br />

to improve the quality of communication with<br />

clients, both in terms of its visual impact and its<br />

content, produce consistent outputs and improve<br />

the resultant reporting.<br />

According to Lancaster: “We chose Onguard<br />

primarily due to the fact it offers greater flexibility<br />

in terms of its workflow integration. We also saw<br />

that there would be potential in the future to<br />

take on new features and gain a wider range of<br />

capabilities should we want to. Additionally, we<br />

found that it offered a great user-experience as<br />

the software is user-friendly and intuitive.”<br />

WHY ONGUARD?<br />

“Onguard has been very involved in the<br />

implementation of the new software and has<br />

been key to the delivery. We are convinced we<br />

made the right decision in choosing Onguard,<br />

implementation has been running smoothly and<br />

we are happy with what the solution has allowed<br />

us to achieve so far.”<br />

ATRADIUS, ONGUARD AND THE CICM INVITE YOU TO JOIN US AT A<br />

DYNAMIC AND PRACTICAL SEMINAR ON: ‘CREDIT MANAGEMENT<br />

– WHERE IT’S BEEN, WHERE IT IS, AND WHERE IT’S GOING’.<br />

SIGN UP VIA WWW.ONGUARD.COM/CMEVENT


Redefining order-to-cash<br />

Onguard is specialist in credit management software and market leader in innovative solutions<br />

for order-to-cash. Our integrated platform ensures an optimal connection of all processes in the<br />

order-to-cash chain and allows sharing of critical data.<br />

Intelligent tools that can seamlessly be interconnected and offer overview and control of the<br />

payment process, as well as contribute to a sustainable customer relationship. In more than 50<br />

countries the Onguard platform is successfully used for successful credit management.<br />

Find out more at: www.onguard.com/cm or call us at +44 (0) 20 396 683 24.


PAYMENT TRENDS<br />

Topsy Turvy<br />

The latest monthly business to business<br />

payment performance statistics.<br />

AUTHOR – Jason Braidwood FCICM(Grad)<br />

THE most recent payment performance<br />

statistics were encouraging, with<br />

the majority of sectors and regions<br />

successfully reducing their payment<br />

terms. This month’s results provide<br />

more fluctuation, however, with<br />

a number of sectors and regions moving back<br />

in the wrong direction and only a few making<br />

improvements. The average Days Beyond Terms<br />

(DBT) figures across regions and sectors increased<br />

by 0.6 and 0.9 days respectively.<br />

SECTOR SPOTLIGHT<br />

It has been a disappointing month for the majority<br />

of sectors, with all but five of the 22 sectors<br />

increasing their payment terms. The biggest<br />

improvements have been in the Financial and<br />

Insurance and Real Estate sectors, reducing DBT by<br />

5.7 and 4.0 days respectively. Public Administration<br />

continued its improvement with a further reduction<br />

of 2.3 taking its overall DBT to 5.4 days, making it<br />

the best performing sector. Manufacturing (-2.3)<br />

and Agriculture, Forestry and Fishing (-0.7) also<br />

reduced their DBT.<br />

It’s been a particularly poor month for the<br />

Business from Home and Transportation and<br />

Storage sectors, with both increasing DBT by 5.5<br />

days. Business Admin and Support also struggled,<br />

with payment terms increasing by 4.1 days. A<br />

further increase of 1.4 days means that Mining and<br />

Quarrying remains the worst performing sector<br />

with an overall DBT of 22.6 days.<br />

REGIONAL SPOTLIGHT<br />

The regional standings are similarly<br />

underwhelming, with all but three of<br />

the regions increasing payment terms.<br />

Northern Ireland continued its slump,<br />

remaining the worst performing region<br />

after a further increase of 2.9 days. Perhaps<br />

surprisingly, Scotland also had a poor<br />

month, also experiencing an increase of 2.9<br />

days to its payment terms.<br />

There have been more positive signs<br />

from the West Midlands however, with a<br />

further reduction of 1.2 days making it the<br />

new best performing region with an overall<br />

DBT of 12.5 days. Wales (-0.2) and the North<br />

West (-0.1) were the other regions to make<br />

improvements.<br />

Jason Braidwood FCICM(Grad) is Head of<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> and Collections at <strong>Credit</strong>safe for<br />

Business Solutions.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 38


PAYMENT TRENDS<br />

Top Five Prompter Payers<br />

Sector April 19 Change from March 19<br />

Public Administration 5.4 -2.3<br />

International Bodies 7.0 2.4<br />

Agriculture, Forestry and Fishing 8.7 -0.7<br />

Health and Social 9.4 0.7<br />

Education 10.0 1.6<br />

Getting Better<br />

-5.7 Financial and Insurance<br />

-4.0 Real Estate<br />

-2.3 Public Administration<br />

-2.3 Manufacturing<br />

-0.7 Agriculture, Forestry and Fishing<br />

Top Five Prompter Payers<br />

Region March19 Change from April 19<br />

Yorkshire and Humberside 11.8 0.6<br />

West Midlands 12.5 -1.2<br />

South West 12.7 0.8<br />

Scotland 12.8 2.9<br />

Wales 13.2 -0.2<br />

Bottom Five Poorest Payers<br />

Sector April 19 Change from March 19<br />

Mining and Quarrying 22.6 1.4<br />

Business from Home 18.9 5.5<br />

Transportation and Storage 18.4 5.5<br />

Business Admin and Support 17.8 4.1<br />

Dormant 16.9 2.9<br />

Getting Worse<br />

0.1 Entertainment<br />

0.9 Energy Supply<br />

1.2 Construction<br />

1.4 Mining and Quarrying<br />

2.4 International Bodies<br />

Bottom Five Poorest Payers<br />

Region March 19 Change from April 19<br />

Northern Ireland 17.8 -2.9<br />

London 15.0 1.6<br />

East Anglia 13.8 1.6<br />

South East 13.6 2.4<br />

North West 13.5 -0.1<br />

Region<br />

Getting Better – Getting Worse<br />

-2.9<br />

-1.2<br />

-0.2<br />

-0.1<br />

1.6<br />

2.9<br />

2.4<br />

0.8<br />

1.6<br />

Northern Ireland<br />

West Midlands<br />

Wales<br />

North West<br />

East Anglia<br />

Scotland<br />

South East<br />

South West<br />

London<br />

NORTHERN<br />

IRELAND<br />

-2.9 DBT<br />

SCOTLAND<br />

2.9 DBT<br />

NORTH<br />

WEST<br />

-0.1 DBT<br />

YORKSHIRE &<br />

HUMBERSIDE<br />

0.6 DBT<br />

WALES<br />

-0.2 DBT<br />

WEST<br />

MIDLANDS<br />

-1.2 DBT<br />

EAST<br />

ANGLIA<br />

1.6 DBT<br />

There have been more positive signs<br />

from the West Midlands however, with<br />

a further reduction of 1.2 days making<br />

it the new best performing region with<br />

an overall DBT of 12.5 days.<br />

SOUTH<br />

WEST<br />

0.8 DBT<br />

LONDON<br />

1.6 DBT<br />

SOUTH<br />

EAST<br />

2.4 DBT<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 39


LEGAL MATTERS<br />

Cash Flows<br />

A polluted river and ill-considered dividends<br />

led to an interesting case of fraud.<br />

AUTHOR – Peter Walker<br />

THE effects of a river<br />

polluted with polychlorinated<br />

biphenyls – thankfully<br />

shortened to PCBs<br />

– have flowed from its<br />

source in the USA to<br />

London’s Court of Appeal, where there<br />

was a significant judgment in the area<br />

of defrauding creditor. Section 423 of the<br />

Insolvency Act 1986 regarding ‘transactions<br />

defrauding creditors’ figured prominently<br />

in the case. The judgment started<br />

with a reference to its chemical origins in<br />

BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA [<strong>2019</strong>] EWCA<br />

Civ 112.<br />

Chemicals caused the pollution of<br />

the Lower Fox River in Wisconsin in<br />

the 50s and 60s. In 1978 BAT Industries<br />

had acquired paper businesses<br />

‘responsible for extensive pollution’ of<br />

the river, but the claims in the USA under<br />

the Comprehensive Environmental<br />

Response, Compensation and Liability<br />

Act 1980 (CERCLA) only commenced<br />

in the 90s. Businesses manufacturing<br />

carbonless paper had dumped the<br />

resulting toxic chemicals into the river.<br />

Carbonless paper was useful in the days<br />

before the convenience of personal<br />

computers and printers, because you<br />

could write on the top paper and the<br />

writing would be transferred to perhaps<br />

as many as five or six pages underneath.<br />

In the 80s I designed for a company a<br />

stock control and ordering system based<br />

on this technology, when I was unaware<br />

of the toxic results of the manufacturing<br />

of this paper.<br />

Much later in 1998 the Lower Fox River<br />

paper manufacturing businesses agreed<br />

among themselves how to share the<br />

environmental liabilities. The CERCLA<br />

obligations embraced cleaning-up<br />

costs and damages of natural resources<br />

including the river pollution. There were,<br />

however, various changes of ownership<br />

of the companies and consequent<br />

indemnities against liabilities.<br />

In the year 2000, for example, a<br />

company known as Sequana bought<br />

another company known as AWA,<br />

which owned the paper manufacturing<br />

companies. It later sold those businesses<br />

subject to an indirect indemnity relating<br />

to the agreement made in 1998. It also<br />

purchased a guaranteed investment<br />

policy to provide funds for all aspects<br />

of the Lower Fox River liability. By<br />

2008 its value was US$250 million, but<br />

consequently AWA ceased to be a trading<br />

company.<br />

BALANCE SHEET AND DIVIDEND<br />

It was, however, a subsidiary of Sequana,<br />

to which it paid the proceeds of the sale<br />

of the businesses and other receipts. This<br />

indebtedness was an asset in AWA’s books<br />

as was the policy, but on the other hand it<br />

had contingent indemnity liabilities. Its<br />

balance sheet showed net assets of €517<br />

million made up of share capital of €318.6<br />

million, a share premium account of<br />

€69.8 million and distributable reserves<br />

of €128.6 million.<br />

In the light of this information the<br />

Directors of AWA decided in December<br />

2008 to pay a dividend of €443 million.<br />

To do that the paid-up share capital<br />

was reduced to €1 million, and the<br />

share premium account was cancelled.<br />

No money changed hands, but the<br />

indebtedness of Sequana was reduced to<br />

€142.5 million.<br />

That was December, but early in the<br />

following year there was the question<br />

of whether the contingent liability<br />

concerning the environmental liability<br />

should be included in the accounts<br />

for the year ended 31 December 2008.<br />

There was, of course, the guaranteed<br />

investment policy, and it was decided<br />

that it was sufficient to cover any<br />

contingent liability, so there was no need<br />

to include a provision for such a liability<br />

in the accounts. I am mystified at such<br />

a conclusion, but perhaps I am just a<br />

grumpy old-fashioned accountant. There<br />

was consequently a distributable reserve<br />

of €137 million in the balance sheet.<br />

The directors of AWA therefore decided<br />

in May to pay a dividend of around €135<br />

million to the parent company Sequana.<br />

No money changed hands, because the<br />

indebtedness of that company to its<br />

subsidiary was reduced by that amount<br />

to about €3.1 million. The decision to<br />

pay this dividend was influenced by the<br />

desire of the Sequana directors to sell<br />

AWA to another company. The directors<br />

thought that the sale of AWA under these<br />

conditions would mean that Sequana had<br />

limited, perhaps excluded, any guarantee<br />

under the Lower Fox River risk.<br />

COULD OR SHOULD NOT PAY<br />

Both dividends of December and of May<br />

were challenged in the lower court on<br />

the basis that they were not lawfully<br />

paid in accordance with Part 23 of<br />

the Companies Act 2006 (a ‘could-notpay’<br />

claim). The second challenge was<br />

that the dividend was in breach of the<br />

directors’ duties regarding creditors (a<br />

‘should-not-pay’ claim). Mrs Justice Rose,<br />

however, decided that the claim against<br />

the directors in respect of the December<br />

dividend failed. She also concluded<br />

that the May dividend was caught by<br />

the provisions of section 423(1) of the<br />

Insolvency Act 1986.<br />

That section defines ‘transactions<br />

defrauding creditors’. They include gifts<br />

or transactions for which there is no<br />

consideration (s 423(1)(a)). There are<br />

also transactions at an undervalue (s<br />

423(1(c)). One remedy is to restore the<br />

original position as if the transaction<br />

had not happened (s 423(2)(a)), while<br />

another is to make an order protecting<br />

the interests of the transaction’s victims<br />

(s423(2)(b)). The court, for example, may<br />

only make an order if the purpose was<br />

to place the assets beyond the reach of<br />

someone making or potentially making a<br />

claim (s423(3)(a)). The court alternatively<br />

should be satisfied that the purpose of the<br />

transaction was to prejudice the position<br />

of an actual or potential claimant.<br />

In the Court of Appeal Richards LJ<br />

asked if a dividend was a transaction at<br />

an undervalue, and he answered himself<br />

that the declaration of a dividend created<br />

a debt owed by the company to its<br />

shareholders. It was also not a transaction<br />

as a gift, because a dividend was a return<br />

on the shareholders’ investment.<br />

Richards LJ then considered whether<br />

a dividend was a transaction for no<br />

consideration. He favoured the view of<br />

Lord Millett in a tax case, Inland Revenue<br />

Commissioners v Laird Group plc [2003] 1<br />

WLR 2476. At that time Lord Millett said<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 40


LEGAL MATTERS<br />

AUTHOR – Peter Walker<br />

that the directors in exercising their powers to declare a dividend<br />

were effectively releasing funds due to the shareholders.<br />

But section 423 supposes that there is a transaction. Richards<br />

LJ noted, however, that the section refers to a gift, so it is wider<br />

than, say, a contractual bilateral transaction with consideration<br />

between two parties. Lord Reid in another case, Greenberg v<br />

IRC [1972] AC 109, where he was considering whether dividends<br />

were transactions relating to securities, said that they could be<br />

activities in which only one person was involved. Richards LJ<br />

therefore concluded that a dividend could be a transaction.<br />

He then considered the section’s statutory purpose. In this<br />

respect AWA was a non-trading company set up to contain the<br />

Lower Fox River liability. Richards LJ agreed with the finding<br />

of the lower court that the first dividend had been declared<br />

lawfully, but circumstancess had changed by the time of the<br />

May dividend. At that time the directors wanted to sell the<br />

company to prevent claims. That second dividend prejudiced<br />

the creditors because of the depletion of AWA’s assets, with the<br />

result it had no call on Sequana. Sequana would have to pay<br />

US$138.4 million to BTI, the successor to BAT, as recompense<br />

for the amount paid by BAT for clean-up costs plus interest.<br />

DIRECTORS’ DUTIES<br />

There were other issues considered by the Court of Appeal, such<br />

as the ‘general duties of directors defined in the Companies Act<br />

2006. Section 172 refers to the need for directors to act in good<br />

faith ‘to promote the success of the company for the benefit<br />

of its members as a whole’. There is a list of considerations<br />

including the likely consequences of any decision in the long<br />

term (s172(1)(a)), the impact of the company’s operations on<br />

the community and the environment (s172(1)(d), and there are<br />

others. S172(3) adds the duty of the directors, subject to some<br />

provisos ‘to consider or act in the interests of the creditors of<br />

the company’.<br />

In this respect the accounts considered by the directors were<br />

important, but they revealed no deficit in the balance sheet at<br />

the time the directors were considering the May, or second,<br />

dividend. There was no duty in relation to creditors at that time.<br />

The judges of the Court of Appeal furthermore considered<br />

other situations where that duty may be triggered. Richards<br />

LJ observed that in other cases the companies concerned were<br />

insolvent.<br />

A DIVIDEND FOR CREDITORS<br />

Insolvent companies are sometimes a depressing factor in the<br />

work of credit managers, but the judgment in the Sequana case<br />

can be helpful to creditors. Directors’ decisions to pay dividends<br />

can be challenged if they amount to transactions defrauding<br />

creditors. Those directors must have regard to the financial<br />

state of the company, if they are considering the declaration of a<br />

dividend or of a reduction of capital. If there is any doubt about<br />

the financial health of the company, particularly with regards<br />

to contingent liabilities, the directors must take professional<br />

advice.<br />

Those reviewing the affairs of an insolvent company<br />

should check if there have been declarations of dividends in<br />

circumstances covered by section 423 of the Insolvency Act<br />

1986. It is to be hoped that if the Court of Appeal’s judgment<br />

should be appealed to the Supreme Court, that the principle<br />

will be upheld.<br />

Peter Walker is a freelance business writer.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 41


INTRODUCING OUR<br />

CORPORATE PARTNERS<br />

For further information and to discuss the opportunities of entering into a<br />

Corporate Partnership with the CICM, please contact corporatepartners@cicm.com<br />

Hays <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> is a national specialist<br />

division dedicated exclusively to the recruitment of<br />

credit management and receivables professionals,<br />

at all levels, in the public and private sectors. As<br />

the CICM’s only Premium Corporate Partner, we<br />

are best placed to help all clients’ and candidates’<br />

recruitment needs as well providing guidance on<br />

CV writing, career advice, salary bench-marking,<br />

marketing of vacancies, advertising and campaign<br />

led recruitment, competency-based interviewing,<br />

career and recruitment trends.<br />

T: 07834 260029<br />

E: karen.young@hays.com<br />

W: www.hays.co.uk/creditcontrol<br />

The Company Watch platform provides risk analysis<br />

and data modelling tools to organisations around<br />

the world that rely on our ability to accurately predict<br />

their exposure to financial risk. Our H-Score®<br />

predicted 92 percent of quoted company insolvencies<br />

and our TextScore® accuracy rate was 93<br />

percent. Our scores are trusted by credit professionals<br />

within banks, corporates, investment houses<br />

and public sector bodies because, unlike other credit<br />

reference agencies, we are transparent and flexible<br />

in our approach.<br />

T: +44 (0)20 7043 3300<br />

E: info@companywatch.net<br />

W: www.companywatch.net<br />

HighRadius is a Fintech enterprise Software-as-a-Service<br />

(SaaS) company. Its Integrated Receivables platform<br />

reduces cycle times in the Order to Cash process through<br />

automation of receivables and payments across credit,<br />

e-invoicing and payment processing, cash allocation,<br />

dispute resolution and collections. Powered by the RivanaTM<br />

Artificial Intelligence Engine and Freeda Digital<br />

Assistant for Order to Cash teams, HighRadius enables<br />

more than 450 organisations to leverage machine<br />

learning to predict future outcomes and automate routine<br />

labour intensive tasks.<br />

T: +44 7399 406889<br />

E: gwyn.roberts@highradius.com<br />

W: www.highradius.com<br />

Forums International has been running <strong>Credit</strong> and<br />

Industry Forums since 1991 covering a range of<br />

industry sectors and international trading. Attendance<br />

is for credit professionals of all levels. Our forums<br />

are not just meetings but communities which<br />

aim to prepare our members for the challenges<br />

ahead. Attending for the first time is free for you to<br />

gauge the benefits and meet the members and we<br />

only have pre-approved Partners, so you will never<br />

intentionally be sold to.<br />

Chris Sanders Consulting (Sanders Consulting<br />

Associates) has three areas of activity providing<br />

credit management leadership and performance<br />

improvement, international working capital<br />

improvement consulting assignments and<br />

managing the CICMQ Best Practice Accreditation<br />

programme on behalf of the CICM. Plans for<br />

<strong>2019</strong> include international client assignments in<br />

India, China, USA, Middle East and the ongoing<br />

development of the CICMQ Programme.<br />

Key IVR provide a suite of products to assist<br />

companies across Europe with credit management.<br />

The service gives the end-user the means to make<br />

a payment when and how they choose. Key IVR<br />

also provides a state-of-the-art outbound platform<br />

delivering automated messages by voice and<br />

SMS. In a credit management environment, these<br />

services are used to cost-effectively contact debtors<br />

and connect them back into a contact centre or<br />

automated payment line.<br />

T: +44 (0)1246 555055<br />

E: info@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

W: www.forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

T: +44(0)7747 761641<br />

E: chris@chrissandersconsulting.com<br />

W: www.chrissandersconsulting.com<br />

T: +44 (0) 1302 513 000<br />

E: sales@keyivr<br />

W: www.keyivr.co.uk<br />

American Express® is a globally recognised provider<br />

of business payment solutions, providing flexible<br />

capabilities to help companies drive growth. These<br />

solutions support buyers and suppliers across the<br />

supply chain with working capital and cashflow.<br />

By creating an additional lever to help support<br />

supplier/client relationships American Express is<br />

proud to be an innovator in the business payments<br />

space.<br />

T: +44 (0)1273 696933<br />

W: www.americanexpress.com<br />

Building on our mature and hugely successful<br />

product and world class support service, we are<br />

re-imagining our risk awareness module in <strong>2019</strong> to<br />

allow for hugely flexible automated worklists and<br />

advanced visibility of areas of risk. Alongside full<br />

integration with all credit scoring agencies (e.g.<br />

<strong>Credit</strong>safe), this makes Credica a single port-of-call<br />

for analysis and automation. Impressive results<br />

and ROI are inevitable for our customers that also<br />

have an active input into our product development<br />

and evolution.<br />

T: 01235 856400<br />

E: info@credica.co.uk<br />

W: www.credica.co.uk<br />

Bottomline Technologies (NASDAQ: EPAY) helps<br />

businesses pay and get paid. Businesses and banks<br />

rely on Bottomline for domestic and international<br />

payments, effective cash management tools, automated<br />

workflows for payment processing and bill review<br />

and state of the art fraud detection, behavioural<br />

analytics and regulatory compliance. Every day, we<br />

help our customers by making complex business<br />

payments simple, secure and seamless.<br />

T: 0870 081 8250<br />

E: emea-info@bottomline.com<br />

W: www.bottomline.com/uk<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 42


Each of our Corporate Partners is carefully selected for<br />

their commitment to the profession and best practice in the<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Industry and the quality of services they provide.<br />

We are delighted to showcase them here.<br />

THEY'RE WAITING TO TALK TO YOU...<br />

Onguard is a specialist in credit management<br />

software and a market leader in innovative solutions<br />

for Order to Cash. Our integrated platform ensures<br />

an optimal connection of all processes in the Order<br />

to Cash chain and allows sharing of critical data. Our<br />

intelligent tools can seamlessly interconnect and<br />

offer overview and control of the payment process,<br />

as well as contribute to a sustainable customer relationship.<br />

The Onguard platform is successfully used<br />

for successful credit management in more than 50<br />

countries.<br />

T: +31 (0)88 256 66 66<br />

E: ruurd.bakker@onguard.com<br />

W: www.onguard.com<br />

The Atradius Collections business model is to support<br />

businesses and their recoveries. We are seeing a<br />

deterioration and increase in unpaid invoices placing<br />

pressures on cashflow for those businesses. Brexit<br />

is causing uncertainty and we are seeing a significant<br />

impact on the UK economy with an increase in<br />

insolvencies, now also impacting the continent and<br />

spreading. Our geographical presence is expanding<br />

and with a single IT platform across the globe we can<br />

provide greater efficiencies and effectiveness to our<br />

clients to recover their unpaid invoices.<br />

T: +44 (0)2920 824700<br />

W: www.atradiuscollections.com/uk/<br />

With 130+ years of experience, Graydon is a leading<br />

provider of business information, analytics, insights<br />

and solutions. Graydon helps its customers to make<br />

fast, accurate decisions, enabling them to minimise<br />

risk and identify fraud as well as optimise opportunities<br />

with their commercial relationships. Graydon<br />

uses 130+ international databases and the information<br />

of 90+ million companies. Graydon has offices in<br />

London, Cardiff, Amsterdam and Antwerp. Since 2016,<br />

Graydon has been part of Atradius, one of the world’s<br />

largest credit insurance companies.<br />

T: +44 (0)208 515 1400<br />

E: customerservices@graydon.co.uk<br />

W: www.graydon.co.uk<br />

Rimilia provides intelligent, finance automation<br />

solutions that enable customers to get paid on time<br />

and control their cashflow and cash collection in<br />

real time. Rimilia’s software solutions use sophisticated<br />

analytics and artificial intelligence to predict<br />

customer payment behaviour and easily match and<br />

reconcile payments, removing the uncertainty of<br />

cash collection. Rimilia’s software automates the<br />

complete accounts receivable process improving<br />

cash allocation, bank reconciliation and credit management<br />

operations.<br />

T: +44 (0)1527 872123<br />

E: enquiries@rimilia.com<br />

W: www.rimilia.com<br />

Improve cash flow, cash collection and prevent late<br />

payment with Corrivo from Data Interconnect.<br />

Corrivo, intelligent invoice to cash automation<br />

highlights where accounts receivable teams should<br />

focus their effort for best results. Easy-to-learn,<br />

Invoicing, Collection and Dispute modules get collection<br />

teams up and running fast. Minimal IT input required.<br />

Real-time dashboards, reporting and self-service<br />

customer portals, improve customer communication<br />

and satisfaction scores. Cost-effective, flexible Corrivo,<br />

super-charges your cash collection effort.<br />

T: +44 (0)1367 245777<br />

E: sales@datainterconnect.co.uk<br />

W: www.datainterconnect.com<br />

Dun & Bradstreet Finance Solutions enable modern<br />

finance leaders and credit professionals to improve<br />

business performance through more effective risk<br />

management, identification of growth opportunities,<br />

and better integration of data and insights<br />

across the business. Powered by our Data Cloud,<br />

our solutions provide access to the world’s most<br />

comprehensive commercial data and insights<br />

supplying a continually updated view of business<br />

relationships that help finance and credit teams<br />

stay ahead of market shifts and customer changes.<br />

T: (0800) 001-234<br />

W: www.dnb.co.uk<br />

Shared Services Forum UK Limited<br />

Shared Services Forum UK is a not-for-profit<br />

membership organisation. with one vision, to form<br />

the largest community of people from the business<br />

world and facilitate a platform for them to work<br />

together to mutual benefits.<br />

Benefits include; networking with like-minded<br />

professionals in Shared Services. The criteria is a<br />

willingness to engage in our lively community and<br />

help shape our growth and development.<br />

T: 07864 652518<br />

E: forum.manager@sharedservicesforumuk.com<br />

W: www.sharedservicesforumuk.com<br />

C2FO turns receivables into cashflow and payables<br />

into income, uniquely connecting buyers and<br />

suppliers to allow discounts in exchange for<br />

early payment of approved invoices. Suppliers<br />

access additional liquidity sources by accelerating<br />

payments from buyers when required in just two<br />

clicks, at a rate that works for them. Buyers, often<br />

corporates with global supply chains, benefit from<br />

the C2FO solution by improving gross margin while<br />

strengthening the financial health of supply chains<br />

through ethical business practices.<br />

T: 07799 692193<br />

E: anna.donadelli@c2fo.com<br />

W: www.c2fo.com<br />

Tinubu Square is a trusted source of trade credit<br />

intelligence for credit insurers and for corporate<br />

customers. The company’s B2B <strong>Credit</strong> Risk<br />

Intelligence solutions include the Tinubu Risk<br />

<strong>Management</strong> Center, a cloud-based SaaS platform;<br />

the Tinubu <strong>Credit</strong> Intelligence service and the<br />

Tinubu Risk Analyst advisory service. Over 250<br />

companies rely on Tinubu Square to protect their<br />

greatest assets: customer receivables.<br />

T: +44 (0)207 469 2577 /<br />

E: uksales@tinubu.com<br />

W: www.tinubu.com.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 43


INTRODUCING<br />

OUR<br />

CORPORATE<br />

PARTNERS<br />

For further information and<br />

to discuss the opportunities<br />

of entering into a Corporate<br />

Partnership with the CICM,<br />

please contact<br />

corporatepartners@cicm.com<br />

THEY'RE<br />

WAITING TO<br />

TALK TO YOU...<br />

Serrala optimizes the Universe of Payments for<br />

organisations seeking efficient cash visibility<br />

and secure financial processes. As an SAP<br />

Partner, Serrala supports over 3,500 companies<br />

worldwide. With more than 30 years of experience<br />

and thousands of successful customer projects,<br />

including solutions for the entire order-to-cash<br />

process, Serrala provides credit managers and<br />

receivables professionals with the solutions they<br />

need to successfully protect their business against<br />

credit risk exposure and bad debt loss.<br />

T: +44 118 207 0450<br />

E: contact@serrala.com<br />

W: www.serrala.com<br />

Esker’s Accounts Receivable (AR) solution removes<br />

the all-too-common obstacles preventing today’s<br />

businesses from collecting receivables in a timely<br />

manner. From invoice delivery to cash application,<br />

Esker automates each step. Esker's automated AR<br />

system powered by TermSync helps companies<br />

modernise without replacing their core billing and<br />

collections processes. By simply automating what<br />

should be automated, customers get the post-sale<br />

experience they deserve and your team gets the<br />

tools they need.<br />

T: +44 (0)1332 548176<br />

E: sam.townsend@esker.co.uk<br />

W: www.esker.co.uk<br />

<strong>2019</strong> CICM<br />

EVENTS NOT<br />

TO MISSED<br />

Workshops<br />

Round<br />

Table Events<br />

New CICM<br />

Learning<br />

Conference<br />

CICM Best<br />

Practice<br />

Webinars<br />

Just another great<br />

reason to be a member<br />

See full programme at<br />

www.cicm.com/events<br />

www.cicm.com | +44 (0)1780 722902<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 44


CASE STUDY<br />

Table<br />

Turning<br />

Following last month’s sector focus,<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> takes a look at one restaurant<br />

that has turned its fortunes around.<br />

WHEN a newly opened<br />

French-English<br />

restaurant in Monmouth<br />

struggled<br />

for funding from<br />

its bank, it was a<br />

funding solution from Liberis Finance,<br />

and hard work from the owners, that saved<br />

the day. And now the future looks very<br />

bright indeed, with plans to increase the<br />

capacity, refurbish the dining room and<br />

invest in a new kitchen garden.<br />

Owner Paul Smith had previously<br />

worked as a chef in kitchens all over<br />

the world. Over the years he became<br />

somewhat disillusioned with cooking as<br />

he noticed a number of restaurants that<br />

were resorting to using sous vide meals<br />

that could be microwaved instead of<br />

serving fresh cooked food.<br />

Changing course, he set up his own<br />

building company and worked for<br />

Network Rail for 24 years. When his wife<br />

Shelley, a professional gardener, suggested<br />

embarking on a new business venture in<br />

South Wales six years ago, Paul jumped at<br />

the chance.<br />

The couple renovated a dilapidated<br />

outbuilding and began selling imported<br />

plants from Holland and serving tea and<br />

cakes, calling their new business The<br />

Potting Shed. Soon the food side of the<br />

business took over and they were serving<br />

breakfasts and light lunches.<br />

But then, four years ago, the landlord<br />

decided not to renew their lease. Paul and<br />

Shelley moved the business into a 19th<br />

century barn in nearby Whitchurch. The<br />

restaurant’s reputation continued to grow<br />

and it began serving Sunday lunches and<br />

evening meals such as locally-sourced<br />

sea bass with lemon and herb butter, and<br />

Tournedos Rossini.<br />

As a new business, they struggled<br />

to find funding from their bank, just at<br />

the point that their cashflow was being<br />

squeezed with the quieter months ahead.<br />

That’s when their landlord suggested<br />

talking to Liberis. Through its Business<br />

Cash Advance solution, £5,000 in funding<br />

relieved the immediate cashflow pressure<br />

and also gave the couple a budget for<br />

some advertising. The advance is linked<br />

directly to the business’ customer card<br />

transactions; in this case, 15 percent of<br />

each card transaction is automatically<br />

taken until the advance amount has been<br />

paid. This means the payments are better<br />

matched to a company’s cashflow.<br />

“We have now been able to partfund<br />

the renovation and expansion of<br />

our business. It’s stress and hassle free,<br />

completely seamless and it means all our<br />

effort and energy can be invested in the<br />

restaurant.”<br />

Paul and Shelley have big plans<br />

for the restaurant. Further funding is<br />

part-financing the construction of an<br />

Orangery. It will also help to pay for the<br />

creation of a kitchen garden where many<br />

of the vegetables such as tomatoes, edible<br />

flowers and herbs from the menu are<br />

grown.<br />

“Considering where we started with<br />

the business just six years ago, the growth<br />

has been fantastic. Once the expansion<br />

is completed our turnover will be<br />

transformed which will allow us to cater<br />

for more people and events.”<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 45


Are you making the most of<br />

CICM and your membership?<br />

.<br />

ó<br />

Qualifications<br />

Business news<br />

and industry<br />

updates<br />

<strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong><br />

magazine<br />

Webinars<br />

!<br />

,<br />

M<br />

$<br />

Advice line<br />

Apprenticeships<br />

Mentor<br />

service<br />

Case<br />

studies<br />

-<br />

B<br />

Tailored<br />

training<br />

elearning<br />

CICMQ<br />

Knowledge<br />

Hub<br />

K<br />

P<br />

s<br />

Benevolent<br />

fund<br />

Local<br />

events<br />

Workshops<br />

Thought<br />

leadership<br />

What is the CICM? For you, for your team, for business<br />

The CICM is the largest recognised professional body in the world for the credit community. When<br />

you join us, our network of members across the world becomes your professional family.<br />

We have been promoting the importance of credit management, influencing government policy and<br />

regulation and supporting credit professionals through their careers since 1939. It is our reason for<br />

being, and our passion for expertise in the credit and collections profession is second to none.<br />

info@cicm.com<br />

www.cicm.com<br />

01780 722900


Tailored<br />

and bespoke<br />

training for<br />

your credit<br />

team<br />

Your specialism is<br />

our specialism<br />

At the CICM we know that credit and collections is a unique profession, and your business<br />

calls for a training solution that is not ‘off-the-peg’.<br />

We take pride in delivering practical and effective learning to credit and collections teams.<br />

Our training is designed and tailored to your business needs and to deliver results.<br />

Your team will learn from our specialist trainers, who all have vast experience in the<br />

profession and will share their real experiences and successes.<br />

WWW.CICM.COM<br />

Our specialist team will manage everything from<br />

start to finish. To find out more information contact –<br />

T: 01780 722907: E: training@cicm.com: W: www.cicm.com<br />

Tailored and bespoke training in...<br />

Developing <strong>Credit</strong> Strategy; Building Business; Managing Risk; Complying with Regulations; Improving<br />

Customer Relations; Collecting the Cash; Negotiating and Influencing; Psychology of Collections; Achieving<br />

Targets; Debt Recovery; Insolvency; <strong>Management</strong> Skills.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 47


EDUCATION – INTERVIEW<br />

Chain<br />

Reaction<br />

Global value chains have created huge<br />

opportunity – and risk – for UK exporters.<br />

Jon Walden<br />

THERE is little doubt that the<br />

development AUTHOR of global - Ga<br />

value<br />

chains, often involving exciting<br />

new and emerging markets, has<br />

created huge opportunities for UK<br />

exporters. However, risk has to be<br />

carefully managed. International trade is complex<br />

– every transaction involves four key pillars –<br />

Commercial, Transport, Regulatory and Finance<br />

– and the weak-point is always the intrinsic links<br />

between these pillars. Commercial is all about<br />

contracting, transport is the physical movement<br />

of the goods across international borders,<br />

regulatory encompasses customs, licensing and<br />

standards issues and, last but certainly not least,<br />

the financial pillar is about getting paid the right<br />

amount, in the right currency, at the right time.<br />

IS THERE A TOOL TO STRENGTHEN THE<br />

WEAK-POINT, THE LINKAGES?<br />

Yes, this is the good news. Incoterms<br />

(International Commercial Terms) provides the<br />

glue to hold the pillars together. It is generally<br />

said that selection of the most appropriate<br />

Incoterm at contracting stage reduces the<br />

occurrence of disputes between the contracting<br />

parties and provides a level of certainty<br />

throughout the four pillars of the contract.<br />

CAN YOU GIVE AN EXAMPLE OF THIS?<br />

One of the key elements of Incoterms is that the<br />

term used identifies exactly where legal delivery<br />

by the seller or exporter, to the buyer takes place.<br />

It can be confusing, for some of the terms legal<br />

delivery is on despatch and physical delivery is,<br />

actually, on arrival at the agreed geographical<br />

point. Even though Incoterms do not determine<br />

the point of revenue recognition it has become<br />

a widespread norm to link legal delivery with<br />

the point at which revenue is recognised. Also,<br />

legal delivery is where documents have to be<br />

made available by the seller to the buyer, often<br />

triggering payment through such mechanisms as<br />

documentary presentations under documentary<br />

letters of credit and documentary collections.<br />

Thus, a clear link between the commercial pillar,<br />

which identifies the Incoterm to be used, and the<br />

financial pillar.<br />

WHO PUBLISHES INCOTERMS AND HOW<br />

REGULARLY ARE THEY USED?<br />

Incoterms are published by the International<br />

Chamber of Commerce, the first version was in<br />

1936. Statistics vary but by far the majority of<br />

cross border trade is contracted using Incoterms,<br />

possibly over 90 percent. Having said that, they<br />

are often used incorrectly and inappropriately.<br />

DO THE TERMS REFLECT CURRENT<br />

PRACTICE IN EXPORTING AND<br />

IMPORTING?<br />

This is a very important point. The way<br />

companies trade internationally, and the<br />

processes and procedures applied, change<br />

frequently. For example, traditional port-toport<br />

or airport-to-airport logistics models are<br />

quickly migrating to a door to door basis. New<br />

procedures are constantly introduced, a recent<br />

example is the requirement for exporters<br />

to legally declare the weight of cargoes in<br />

containers, known as Verifying Gross Mass. Some<br />

changes are not nearly as quick as expected, for<br />

example, the migration to electronic messages<br />

in place of paper documents. Incoterms have to<br />

reflect real and current practice otherwise they<br />

become ineffective.<br />

HOW ARE THEY KEPT UP-TO-DATE<br />

AND RELEVANT?<br />

Incoterms tend to be reviewed every ten years.<br />

There is no rule about this but the cycle seems<br />

to work well. The current version is Incoterms<br />

2010 but Incoterms 2020 is on the way and will<br />

take effect from 1 January 2020. The review<br />

process takes around three years and involves<br />

opinions, discussions and critical analysis from<br />

International Chamber of Commerce national<br />

committees, globally. It really is a very thorough,<br />

informed and detailed process.<br />

CAN EXPORTERS AND<br />

IMPORTERS EXPECT MANY CHANGES?<br />

The final draft of Incoterms 2020 has been<br />

agreed, the content is embargoed until global<br />

launch in September this year. As usual,<br />

companies can expect some very critical and<br />

fundamental changes and also a number of<br />

smaller updates, enhancements and investments.<br />

At this stage, do not believe anything Google<br />

contributors may say, or predict, on the subject<br />

– just look forward to the September release.<br />

Incoterms are the most important protocol in<br />

international trade contracting and it is hugely<br />

important to understand the changes, ensuring<br />

the terms are applied correctly and effectively.<br />

IT SEEMS INCOTERMS ARE REALLY<br />

IMPORTANT IN EXPORT TRANSACTIONS.<br />

WHO NEEDS TO UNDERSTAND THEM?<br />

Everyone involved in the export process but,<br />

critically, finance, credit control, shipping,<br />

documentation/invoicing, order processing sales<br />

and export managers.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 48


CICM<br />

KNOWLEDGE<br />

HUB<br />

Access over 1,000 credit<br />

and collection resources<br />

anytime, anywhere.<br />

CICM Knowledge Hub is a new online platform for credit<br />

professionals, providing one location to easily find the tools<br />

and information you need to help you in your job.<br />

‣ Tailored elearning courses ‣ CM Magazine articles<br />

‣ Research papers from industry experts ‣ Webinars<br />

‣ Best practice guidance.<br />

CICM Members get free access to CICM Knowledge Hub and much<br />

more from just £8 * a month. Join now to explore all the benefits of<br />

CICM Membership.<br />

National and<br />

regional events<br />

Qualifications<br />

and training<br />

Mentor<br />

Hub<br />

Monthly<br />

e-newsletter<br />

Branches around<br />

the country<br />

*Price shown is for Affiliate Grade. Does not include joining fee. Subject to Terms & Conditions.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 49


HR MATTERS ROUNDUP<br />

COMPENSATION<br />

CULTURE<br />

A case of an agency worker that is paid a different rate<br />

to a permanent employee and makes a claim.<br />

AUTHOR – Gareth Edwards<br />

DATA from a recent ONS<br />

Labour Force Survey<br />

suggested that the total<br />

number of agency workers<br />

in the UK currently stands<br />

at around 865,000 and this<br />

figure is expected to rise to one million by<br />

2020. With rules being in place for some<br />

years now – in the form of the Agency<br />

Workers Regulations 2010 (AWR) – a recent<br />

case involving London Underground and<br />

the Court of Appeal should be of interest<br />

to hirers. In this case, the Court held<br />

that the hirer (or end-user) should pay<br />

compensation to agency workers supplied<br />

by an independent agency.<br />

THE LONDON UNDERGROUND CASE<br />

An agency, Trainpeople.co.uk (TP),<br />

placed the claimants on a temporary<br />

basis to work for London Underground<br />

(LU). The claimants were being paid less<br />

than comparable employees that were<br />

employed directly by LU, contrary to the<br />

AWR. Although LU flagged this issue and<br />

readjusted the payment to TP as well as<br />

making a payment in respect of back pay<br />

to TP for them to pass on to the claimants,<br />

TP failed to pay the claimants any of the<br />

extra money and subsequently went into<br />

liquidation.<br />

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT)<br />

held that LU was accountable for 50 percent<br />

of the failure but that they did not have to<br />

pay the compensation to the claimants<br />

as it was not ‘just and equitable’ because<br />

they had already paid the back pay once.<br />

The Court of Appeal (CoA) overturned the<br />

second aspect, finding that given LU was<br />

liable for 50 percent of the failure, it should<br />

pay 50 percent of the compensation owed<br />

to the claimants regardless of the payment<br />

already made to TP.<br />

WHAT IS THE LAW?<br />

Under the AWR, once an agency worker<br />

has worked for 12 continuous weeks in the<br />

same role, they are entitled to ‘the same<br />

basic working and employment conditions’<br />

as they would have been entitled to, had<br />

they been recruited by the hirer directly to<br />

do the same job. This includes the right to<br />

be paid the same for the work they do as<br />

direct recruits.<br />

Where there has been an infringement<br />

of the AWR, for instance where agency<br />

workers have been paid less than directly<br />

employed workers, those workers can bring<br />

a claim against whoever is ‘responsible for’<br />

the infringement. If a claim is brought, the<br />

tribunal must identify the responsibility of<br />

the hirer and the temporary work agency.<br />

The temporary work agency and the<br />

hirer will be liable for their share of any<br />

infringement, attributed on a percentage<br />

basis. Once liability is decided, the tribunal<br />

must decide whether to order either the<br />

temporary work agency or the hirer to pay<br />

compensation.<br />

WHY WAS THE HIRER LIABLE?<br />

The initial reason for the agency workers<br />

being paid less, was due to both TP and<br />

LU mistakenly relying on the exception<br />

known as the Swedish Derogation. Under<br />

this exception, agency workers forego<br />

their right to equalised pay arrangements<br />

if they are employed by their agency and<br />

receive pay from the agency in between<br />

assignments.<br />

LU was not at fault for this original error,<br />

but LU was at fault because as a result of<br />

various errors at their end. The information<br />

that TP needed to enable them to pay the<br />

workers the increased amount was not<br />

provided until eight months after the issue<br />

had been flagged – this information should<br />

have been provided to TP within around a<br />

month.<br />

The following factors were taken into<br />

account when deciding if LU were liable<br />

and by how much: it was LU's choice to use<br />

agency workers in the first place because<br />

of the savings that they would make; it was<br />

LU's choice to contract with TP, rather than<br />

another agency; LU was partly responsible<br />

for the original under-payment; and the<br />

claimants were in a weaker ‘bargaining<br />

position’ than either TP or LU.<br />

BEST PRACTICE<br />

This decision has resulted in LU paying<br />

back pay to the agency workers twice – once<br />

to TP and once to the agency workers direct<br />

following TP's demise. This highlights the<br />

importance of carrying out proportionate<br />

checks about the financial stability of<br />

temporary work agencies before entering<br />

into contracts with them and building<br />

appropriate safeguards into the contracts<br />

themselves.<br />

Whether the AWR apply and what<br />

rights they will confer on workers will vary<br />

depending on the status of those workers.<br />

Hirers and agencies should not rely on the<br />

word of the other party as to whether or not<br />

the AWR apply.<br />

Although the Swedish Derogation<br />

exception is due to be abolished in 2020,<br />

establishing whether or not the AWR<br />

apply will remain a crucial and often<br />

complex exercise. Hirers and agencies<br />

should work together and ensure that any<br />

information required is provided as early as<br />

possible.<br />

Gareth Edwards is a partner in the<br />

employment team at Veale Wasbrough<br />

Vizards.gedwards@vwv.co.uk<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 50


ANNUAL<br />

GENERAL<br />

MEETING<br />

The fifth Annual General Meeting of the Chartered<br />

Institute of <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> will be held on<br />

Thursday 13 <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> at CICM HQ, The Water Mill,<br />

Station Road, South Luffenham, Oakham, LE15 8NB at<br />

13:00 (or at the rising of the Advisory Council from its<br />

preceding meeting, whichever is later).<br />

By order of the Executive Board<br />

Philip King FCICM<br />

Chief Executive<br />

To read the Notice, visit:<br />

http://www.cicm.com/about-cicm/governance/<br />

THAMES VALLEY AND SUSSEX AND SURREY<br />

Annual Southern<br />

Branch <strong>Credit</strong> Day<br />

25 <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> – 09:00 -16:00<br />

FREE OF CHARGE – REFRESHMENTS SERVED<br />

CPD<br />

6<br />

Care about your career?<br />

Want to expand your network?<br />

Still want to ‘stay relevant’?<br />

Please join your local CICM<br />

branches and Philip King FCICM,<br />

from CICM HQ for a day dedicated<br />

to providing you with the latest<br />

developments in a variety of credit<br />

related areas. Hear from speakers<br />

representing industries such as<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Risk, Collections, Litigation<br />

and Cash application.<br />

Venue<br />

Verizon, Basingstoke Road,<br />

Reading RG2 6DA<br />

(J11 of M4)<br />

Other subjects will also be covered<br />

including diversity and of course<br />

BREXIT!<br />

Guest speaker - Sir John Madejski<br />

Organiser<br />

For more information please visit the<br />

Thames Valley or Sussex & Surrey branch<br />

pages at www.cicm.com.


SOAPBOX CHALLENGE<br />

SLAMMING<br />

SUPPRESSANTS<br />

The rise in celebrity endorsements on social media.<br />

AS someone who is a part of the Generation<br />

Z community, whenever I venture onto my<br />

various social media I am suddenly bombarded<br />

with campaigns and sponsorships trying to<br />

shove ‘slim tea’ or ‘gummy hair bears’ down my<br />

throat through my eyes. The illusion of celebrity<br />

endorsement on these sites gives the pretence that these are the<br />

products you need in your life. And yes, I am aware that the whole<br />

point of advertising is to make you feel that you need the product<br />

in your life, and I concur that isn’t evil or bad, it is just simply<br />

good advertising. However, given platforms like Instagram, which<br />

is most popular with my age demographic, already promote the<br />

appearance of ‘the perfect life’, and how amazing someone looks,<br />

and what a wonderful time that person is having. In conjunction<br />

with this, it seems that the only way they can look like their role<br />

models and their favourite celebrities, is to starve themselves and<br />

only eat foods that make you not want to eat.<br />

The Kardashians are known for their prominent presence on<br />

various platforms. They are also very well known for their ad<br />

campaigns on appetite suppressant foods. Kim Kardashian most<br />

notably posted on Instagram that she was ‘in love’ with these meal<br />

replacement lollipops and drinks that prevent hunger – they were<br />

apparently ‘unreal’. However, Jameela Jamil took to Twitter to<br />

slash apart the ad, labelling it ‘terrible and toxic’. Jamil says she<br />

was speaking up for the young girls who will see these kinds of<br />

pictures, and instead of swallowing these questionable ideals,<br />

they should be able to say: “they live a good life working hard and<br />

being successful and playing with their kids and having fun with<br />

friends and be able to say other things at the end of your life apart<br />

from ‘I had a flat stomach’”. I couldn’t agree more.<br />

This is a harmful thing to promote onto young impressionable<br />

teenagers. It’s not enough for these people who are only valued<br />

for their appearances. Celebrities endorsing such products project<br />

these insecurities into the minds of all who see these ads which can<br />

lead to body dysmorphic thoughts, eating disorders, depression<br />

and much worse. These adverts are essentially saying that it is so<br />

important to look good on these apps that you should resort to<br />

not doing the thing that gives you life, that is eating regular food.<br />

How stupid is that? If someone told you that you shouldn’t eat, you<br />

would not listen to them because you need food to survive and it’s<br />

good for you. Yet when it is jazzed up in the form of a lollipop and<br />

a celebrity, it suddenly is the ‘new craze’ or ‘it’s trendy’ when in<br />

reality, you have just been brainwashed by a celebrity endorsing<br />

chemical sweets.<br />

I could say that this shows good marketing skills and that it<br />

is the fault of the people who don’t do their research on the<br />

product, and leave each person to their opinions and conclusions.<br />

However, that would mean I would be denying the fact that these<br />

companies are preying on and exploiting vulnerable children and<br />

promoting anorexic thinking. People could go on to see these<br />

images constantly, and most likely end up with numerous mental<br />

health issues, but hey, at least they’ll be skinny. There needs to be<br />

a balance and social media companies need to do more to protect<br />

the young and impressionable.<br />

Max Cohen is young but has good intentions.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 52<br />

SOAPBOX<br />

challenge


REVIEW<br />

Technically speaking<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> asked members of the CICM<br />

Think Tank what tech they can’t do without and why.<br />

Martin Roseweir,<br />

Bill Gosling.<br />

THE one piece of software that we<br />

rely on day in and day out is Workday,<br />

which we use for both our Financial<br />

<strong>Management</strong> functions and our Human<br />

Capital <strong>Management</strong>.<br />

Having direct access to run<br />

numerous financial reports from<br />

your desktop allows us to keep a<br />

temperature check on the business<br />

easily. Whether this is reviewing<br />

full monthly Profit and Loss (PnLs),<br />

budgets by cost centre, salaries or<br />

spends by supplier, the software gives<br />

a complete 360 degree view of the<br />

business.<br />

Being able to access financial<br />

information on the go, complete<br />

expenses, review and approve invoices,<br />

review revenue projections, ensures<br />

that the business doesn’t slow down<br />

when we are out of the office.<br />

From a Human Capital <strong>Management</strong><br />

standpoint reviewing resource,<br />

requesting vacations and completing<br />

performance reviews are just a small<br />

selection of the functionality that<br />

Workday gives us.<br />

Additionally, Workday Learning<br />

allows us to deliver bespoke and<br />

targeted training right into the inbox of<br />

our staff. This computer-based training<br />

can take many different formats<br />

including videos and PowerPoint<br />

presentations with full reporting to<br />

allow us to track in detail all training<br />

that has been completed.<br />

This is only a small sample of what<br />

Workday brings to our business, in<br />

reality it is one of the most powerful<br />

systems we have adopted in recent<br />

years.<br />

Nigel Fields FCICM ,<br />

Twentieth Century Fox.<br />

THIS is an easy one for me and my<br />

team. We are now all using Microsoft<br />

OneNote. This is a completely free<br />

application from Microsoft (advert<br />

free too) so is available for everyone<br />

and available on all platforms<br />

including desktop and mobile and<br />

even Mac.<br />

OneNote is a digital notebook that<br />

automatically backs up to Microsoft’s<br />

Office 365 Cloud. OneNote notebooks<br />

can be shared (or kept private) for<br />

real-time collaboration. It allows<br />

me to capture just about anything;<br />

writing notes, recording audio, adding<br />

pictures or videos, or attaching other<br />

documents. I can then organise<br />

everything into sections, and pages<br />

and share across groups. The notes<br />

are also saved to the cloud so I can<br />

switch from PC to phone and pick up<br />

right where I left off.<br />

My team and I now all share<br />

various documents, tasks and meeting<br />

notes, we store in a very organised<br />

way (built in function) that makes it<br />

all very easy to find. I spend at least 50<br />

percent of my time in meetings and<br />

calls so inevitably, I come out with<br />

lots of ideas, questions, follow ups or<br />

to-dos. Before using OneNote, I would<br />

try to capture this all in a regular<br />

notebooks but as someone who has<br />

extremely bad hand writing; and has<br />

a hard time keeping up with slips of<br />

paper, I was constantly losing things.<br />

Frances Coulson FCICM,<br />

Moon Beever Solicitors.<br />

I suppose we can all ‘do without’<br />

technology but as more and more<br />

pressure on time mounts we need it to<br />

stay on top of things. I find the ability to<br />

respond to emails, which are then autosaved<br />

and time recorded to my files<br />

while I am out and about, absolutely<br />

invaluable.<br />

Before I had this facility I effectively<br />

had to replicate every day capturing<br />

advices given unless I wanted to lug a<br />

heavy laptop everywhere. Another must<br />

have is Mimecast – I can find almost<br />

anything and it facilitates large data<br />

transfers securely.<br />

Finally, I simply cannot do without<br />

my family, my horses and dogs<br />

otherwise I really would explode! Life<br />

outside work should be more important<br />

than work (work to live don’t live to<br />

work) but if you enjoy work as I do then<br />

you can manage a balance of both!<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 53


CAREERS ADVICE<br />

Changing skillset<br />

Some of the skills required by a modern credit<br />

professional might be quite unexpected.<br />

AUTHOR – Karen Young<br />

Karen Young<br />

AS skills shortages continue<br />

to affect a variety of<br />

sectors across the globe,<br />

the core skills needed for<br />

a role in credit management<br />

have also remained<br />

in demand. Almost half of accountancy<br />

and finance employers (43 percent) revealed<br />

in the ‘Hays Salary and Recruiting<br />

Trends <strong>2019</strong>’ guide that finance skills<br />

were most needed by their organisations.<br />

However, to get ahead in today’s<br />

competitive recruitment environment,<br />

credit professionals need to possess more<br />

than just core finance abilities. So, what<br />

are the other skills a credit professional<br />

needs and how can they utilise these in a<br />

current or future role?<br />

A CREATIVE APPROACH<br />

Technology is influencing our world<br />

of work at a faster pace than it ever has<br />

before, changing the skills landscape<br />

dramatically. As roles are adapting and<br />

evolving, it is innate, human skills, such<br />

as our creativity, which will hold the<br />

highest value. As creative skills cannot<br />

be borrowed, replicated or programmed<br />

by a machine, these skills will remain<br />

unaffected by automation and their<br />

demand across all professions will only<br />

continue to rise.<br />

Equally, employers<br />

favour jobseekers who<br />

are comfortable speaking<br />

with people at all levels<br />

of an organisation in a<br />

professional manner.<br />

Creativity is valuable to a role in<br />

credit management as it is a crucial<br />

part of problem solving, strategising<br />

and generating the ideas that will drive<br />

businesses forward. Although for many<br />

credit professionals numerical skills come<br />

more naturally than creative ones, taking<br />

a creative approach to work is important.<br />

With creativity set to become an even<br />

more desirable skill requirement over the<br />

next decade, professionals in credit are<br />

encouraged to focus on this aspect of their<br />

role in the near future. A first step for<br />

credit professionals to take is changing<br />

longstanding habits and routines inside<br />

and outside of work. If you’ve been in<br />

your current role for a long period of time,<br />

you may benefit from revaluating your<br />

routine to eliminate elements that may be<br />

hampering your ability to think creatively.<br />

Question whether your current set-up is<br />

allowing you to be engaged, inquisitive<br />

and innovative inside and outside of your<br />

work.<br />

INTERPERSONAL SKILLS<br />

Maintaining a creative approach to<br />

your work is crucial to your career, but<br />

developing creativity is ill-spent if you<br />

don’t possess the ability to communicate<br />

it effectively. Good communication is<br />

the difference between bringing an<br />

innovative idea to the table and making<br />

it have a proper impact on the business.<br />

Employers in credit want professionals<br />

who can keep discussions on-task and<br />

professional, who listen to employees and<br />

respect other’s ideas. Equally, employers<br />

favour jobseekers who are comfortable<br />

speaking with people at all levels of an<br />

organisation in a professional manner.<br />

For credit professionals to work<br />

successfully with their customers<br />

and clients, communication skills are<br />

vital. This involves building positive<br />

relationships with customers and clients<br />

who will have different requirements<br />

and maintaining clear channels of<br />

communication. As well as external<br />

communication, working successfully<br />

with colleagues within your organisation<br />

also requires good communication skills<br />

and can be instrumental in advancing<br />

your career.<br />

Good communication depends on being<br />

clear and concise, and not overloading<br />

a colleague when an immediate action<br />

may be more necessary. While a focus on<br />

detail is important in the technical aspect<br />

of credit management, knowing when to<br />

keep it short will serve you well. As an<br />

extension of this, knowing when to speak<br />

up versus when to appreciate a calmer<br />

moment is an ability that goes with a<br />

strong communicator.<br />

WILLINGNESS TO LEARN<br />

A willingness to learn is the most<br />

requested soft skill in the world of<br />

work today. Hiring managers across all<br />

disciplines want the ideal candidate to<br />

be proactive and take the initiative to<br />

continuously develop themselves and<br />

their career. According to our research,<br />

career development and CPD was the<br />

most important benefit for 15 percent of<br />

accountancy and finance staff, indicating<br />

that this section are committed to their<br />

learning and development.<br />

Maintaining a willingness to learn<br />

will be crucial for credit professionals<br />

considering the emergence of AI in<br />

the workplace. In-demand skills are<br />

still changing in the face of constant<br />

technology innovation so credit<br />

professionals are encouraged to embrace<br />

new skills in their roles to ensure they can<br />

continue to develop and progress in their<br />

careers. As almost half of accountancy<br />

and finance staff (46 percent) feel there is<br />

no scope for career progression in their<br />

current organisation, remaining open to<br />

learning new skills may help those feeling<br />

pessimistic about their career prospects.<br />

In today’s connected world there are<br />

so many accessible ways to learn. Outside<br />

of work credit professionals can benefit<br />

from taking advantage of listening to<br />

webinars and podcasts on their commute<br />

as well as staying up to date with news and<br />

movements in financial markets. While<br />

at work, seek customer feedback and stay<br />

up-to-date with what your competition is<br />

doing. By keeping an eye on changes not<br />

only within credit management, but also<br />

with regards to the sector you work in,<br />

your knowledge will develop to spot new<br />

gaps in your industry, and potentially<br />

seek to bridge them.<br />

Karen Young is Director at Hays<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong>.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 54


www.cicm.com<br />

‘‘<br />

If you are serious<br />

in furthering your<br />

career in credit<br />

management,<br />

being a member<br />

is essential<br />

Andrew Barbaro<br />

FCICM<br />

The value<br />

of CICM<br />

membership<br />

Andrew Barbaro FCICM<br />

Director of Customer Financial Services MEA<br />

Emerson Automation Solutions is a Fellow of<br />

the CICM.<br />

Read more about his story and join your<br />

credit community by visiting:<br />

www.cicm.com/value-of-cicm-membership/<br />

info@cicm.com<br />

www.cicm.com<br />

01780 722900


NEW AND UPGRADED MEMBERS<br />

Do you know someone who would benefit from CICM membership? Or have<br />

you considered applying to upgrade your membership? See our website<br />

www.cicm.com/membership-types for more detail, or call us on 01780 722903<br />

Studying Members<br />

NEW MEMBERS<br />

Neelam Akhtar<br />

Randy Bainbridge<br />

Patrick Bradley<br />

Hannah Bradshaw<br />

Louise Brailsford<br />

Ashton Brookes<br />

Sophie Brown<br />

Marc Anthony Chitty<br />

Laura Clement<br />

Leanne Cookson<br />

Victoria Davies-Short<br />

Mitchel Davis<br />

Ciaran Dillon<br />

Aaron Dougherty<br />

Kevin Dowdall<br />

Hannah Dundas<br />

Lisa Dundee<br />

Ellis Fagan<br />

Kathy Faulkner<br />

Emma Foley<br />

Christine Hardy<br />

Ian Hooper<br />

Michelle Hoyte-Morgan<br />

Matthew Lecoche<br />

Sharon Lynch<br />

Anne-Marie Maxwell<br />

Anthony Millard<br />

David Moran<br />

Mandy Norley<br />

Shannon O'connor<br />

Carly Phillips<br />

Vicki Richardson<br />

Irene Rodger<br />

Frederick Roe<br />

Farbod Setayesh<br />

Stacey Sheldon<br />

Ian Skingsley<br />

Rebecca Smith<br />

Christa Smith<br />

James Stafford<br />

Elvira Tassios<br />

Laura Tipping<br />

Russell Troman<br />

Pamela Urmston<br />

Shanthalakshmi Venkatasubramanian<br />

Jordan Watekila<br />

Sacha Wells<br />

Lee Wells<br />

Asmara Whiskey<br />

Member by exam<br />

Ian Glover<br />

Affiliate<br />

Paul Bennett<br />

Rebecca Cubbin<br />

Abigail Gaston<br />

Sharon Grugel<br />

Richard Hammons<br />

Mark Herlihy<br />

Dorota Kocent-Kijewska<br />

Joanne Loughran<br />

Karen McIvor<br />

Carol Palmer<br />

Simon Renshaw<br />

Helen Stoddart<br />

Joseph Tirelli<br />

Eva Van Der Grijn<br />

Alastair Velzian<br />

Associate<br />

Charlie Daisley-Smith<br />

Lyndsay Harrison<br />

Reece Ingley<br />

Baiju John<br />

John Sewell<br />

Gillian Sprunt<br />

Xhiljola Xhixhi<br />

Member<br />

Helen Daniel<br />

Sharmistha Roy<br />

Fellow<br />

Ian Hirst<br />

Congratulations to our current members who have upgraded their membership<br />

Upgraded members<br />

David Kerr FCICM<br />

Caroline Asquith-Turnbull FCICM<br />

Tom Hope MCICM<br />

Nicola Jones MCICM<br />

Margaret Kervin MCICM<br />

Seija Langley MCICM(Grad)<br />

Dalbinder Dulai ACICM<br />

Thomas Fowler ACICM<br />

Lynn Macdonald ACICM<br />

Lynne Robson ACICM<br />

James Rutter ACICM<br />

Hannah Shirtcliffe ACICM<br />

Key Account Manager at Arvato Financial Solutions<br />

TOM HOPE MCICM<br />

“I recently applied to be upgraded to MCICM as I feel it’s vitally<br />

important to be part of CICM for the learning and development it<br />

provides; so I can meet my future goals for career progression. It also<br />

gives employers reassurance that you meet a recognisable standard<br />

and raises your profile.”<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 56


As the Winners of the Legal Team<br />

of the Year <strong>2019</strong>, Debt Recovery<br />

is nothing new to Keebles.<br />

We recovered over £5.7 million of<br />

debt for clients this financial year<br />

Having practised successfully in this area for<br />

many decades, you can be confident inour<br />

experience and ability.<br />

We appreciate the needs of our clients and<br />

understand that each client’srequirements<br />

are different. Whether you are alarge<br />

organisation requiring regular management<br />

reports and file reviews, orasmall business<br />

growing rapidly, but with little experience<br />

of the debt recovery process, wehave the<br />

flexibility tocater for your needs.<br />

We work closely with our clients and will<br />

tailor aservice level agreement sothat<br />

we both know exactly what needs tobe<br />

achieved and at what cost.<br />

No Recovery No Fee<br />

We do not charge for issuing aLetter Before<br />

Action. Wewill only charge you commission,<br />

at an agreed rate, onany sums recovered.<br />

If we are unable to recover your debt at this<br />

stage itwill cost you nothing.<br />

No Hidden Costs<br />

For many cases, where it is necessary<br />

to issue legal proceedings, we can offer<br />

service on afixed fee basis with nohidden<br />

costs and, where possible, wewill make<br />

additional claims on your behalf for interest<br />

and compensation under The Late Payment<br />

of Commercial Debts legislation to further<br />

minimise the recovery cost to you.<br />

Success is the Key<br />

Over the past 5years we have successfully<br />

recovered over 80% of our Clients’ debts in<br />

full or by way ofanagreed settlement.<br />

Call now totalk to amember of<br />

the Debt Recovery Team:<br />

0113 399 3470<br />

charise.marsden@keebles.com<br />

www.keebles.com


BE ONE CLICK AWAY<br />

FROM OUR WEBSITE<br />

How to set up a great one click link to the CICM website on<br />

your mobile phone. Follow these four simple steps...<br />

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4<br />

Go to cicm.com > Click highlighted icon at bottom of screen > Click add to Home screen icon<br />

> Click add icon at top right of screen > CICM icon will appear on your screen<br />

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4<br />

Open cicm.com in Google Chrome browser > Tap Menu button > Tap add shortcut to Home screen<br />

> Icon will appear on your screen. Menu button on other Android devices may be displayed differently.<br />

THE RECOGNISED STANDARD IN CREDIT MANAGEMENT<br />

T: +44 (0)1780 722900 | WWW.CICM.COM<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 58


BRANCH NEWS<br />

60SECONDS<br />

WITH<br />

FULL NAME: Claire Cape.<br />

CURRENT JOB TITLE: <strong>Credit</strong> Control<br />

Supervisor.<br />

CURRENT COMPANY NAME: MWUK.<br />

YEARS IN CREDIT MANAGEMENT: Ten<br />

YEARS IN CURRENT ROLE: Seven.<br />

Tracking debtors down<br />

Sheffield Branch<br />

SHEFFIELD Branch members and<br />

guests gathered at the Mercure<br />

Parkway Hotel for the second<br />

branch meeting of <strong>2019</strong>. After<br />

networking over refreshments<br />

and an early evening buffet, Mark Hodgson<br />

and Karl Brooker of Tremark Investigations<br />

in Leeds gave an enlightening and detailed<br />

presentation on the lawful investigation,<br />

surveillance, tracing and profiling of<br />

debtors.<br />

Mark is Founder and Managing Director<br />

of Tremark and explained the historical<br />

journey of the business of investigators and<br />

the regulations and statutes that prevent or<br />

legitimise the enquiries of others. He went<br />

on to highlight the high-profile Government<br />

inquiries such as Operation Motorman that<br />

resulted in the Private Security Industry<br />

Act 2001 and the ‘phone hacking’ scandals<br />

of the last few years culminating in the<br />

Leverson Inquiry. This was followed by the<br />

game changing GDPR imposing good data<br />

practice, compliance and accountability.<br />

We then heard in more detail about<br />

the impact of data protection, legitimising<br />

conditions such as consent and legitimate<br />

interest, and followed through a detained<br />

investigative matrix for legitimate<br />

information gathering, data enhancement<br />

techniques, tracing and profiling. There<br />

was practical help for members and guests<br />

with how to guides for GDPR Impact<br />

Assessments when instructing outsource<br />

companies to make legitimate enquiries on<br />

their behalf. Finally, there was a short video<br />

of surveillance footage taken by Mark’s<br />

team highlighting the potential difficulties<br />

in gathering usable evidence, and how it<br />

became a successful operation that had<br />

broken a fraudulent holiday compensation<br />

claim scam leading to numerous arrests<br />

and a change in the law.<br />

After a short question and answer<br />

session Mark conducted a prize draw<br />

sponsored by Tremark with the winning<br />

member receiving a bottle of bubbly!<br />

Author: Myron Fedak MCICM<br />

WE WANT<br />

YOUR NEWS!<br />

Get in touch with Andrew Morris by emailing<br />

andrew.morris@cicm.com with your branch<br />

news and event reports. Please only send up<br />

to 400 words and any images need to be high<br />

resolution to be printable, so 1MB plus.<br />

HOW DID YOU GET INTO CREDIT<br />

MANAGEMENT? Quite by accident! I was<br />

covering reception as a temp and credit<br />

control needed someone to assist with their<br />

admin. I started to call for remittances and<br />

the rest is history. I was lucky to have the<br />

mentor I did and still do.<br />

WHAT IS THE BEST THING ABOUT<br />

WHERE YOU WORK? The great team of<br />

people I have around me in the department.<br />

They are all exceptional at what they do.<br />

WHAT MOTIVATES YOU? The ethos of the<br />

business and setting a great example to my<br />

colleagues.<br />

WHAT SKILL DO YOU THINK HAS<br />

HELPED YOU MOST IN YOUR CREDIT<br />

CAREER SO FAR? The ability to adapt with<br />

the changing environment and requirements<br />

of the role. Strong communication skills are<br />

also very important.<br />

NAME THREE PEOPLE YOU WOULD<br />

INVITE TO A DINNER PARTY AND<br />

WHY? David Attenborough, Nick Cave and<br />

Christopher Walken. The knowledge, the<br />

music, the life.<br />

WHAT IS YOUR FAVOURITE PASTIME/<br />

RELAXATION ACTIVITY? Singing.<br />

Anywhere, anytime, anything!<br />

WHAT IS THE BEST/WORST QUALITY<br />

IN A LEADER? Patience/impatience.<br />

WHO IS YOUR BUSINESS OR PERSONAL<br />

HERO? Marie Bailey. My mentor and<br />

current manager. We have been together for<br />

over ten years now and I still learn so much<br />

from her.<br />

WHAT CAN'T YOU LIVE WITHOUT? My<br />

family.<br />

WHAT’S BEEN YOUR MOST<br />

REWARDING MOMENT IN YOUR<br />

CREDIT CAREER? Every day is rewarding<br />

but becoming Supervisor was the most<br />

rewarding so far.<br />

WHAT HAS SURPRISED YOU THE MOST<br />

ABOUT WORKING IN CREDIT? That it’s<br />

more than just numbers.<br />

IF YOU WEREN’T WORKING IN<br />

CREDIT MANAGEMENT, WHAT<br />

WOULD YOU BE DOING? Counselling or<br />

nursing.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 59


TAKE CONTROL OF<br />

YOUR CREDIT CAREER<br />

GLOBAL CREDIT MANAGER<br />

TRUSTED BUSINESS PARTNER,<br />

BIAS TO ACTION, SIMPLIFY<br />

London (zone 1), market leading salary<br />

+ targeted bonus + excellent benefits<br />

A fantastic opportunity has arisen for a global credit<br />

manager to join a large, global B2B travel/tech company<br />

based in central London. In this key role you will lead a<br />

global credit team, building trusted long term relationships<br />

with customers and senior internal stakeholders, defining<br />

strategy, implementing processes/systems and mentoring<br />

your team to success. Significant international client<br />

experience including working with multiple currencies,<br />

group treasury operations and collateralisation strategies<br />

is essential. This excellent opportunity will suit an<br />

experienced global credit professional who has a desire<br />

to build a market leading credit operation, with a passion<br />

to nurture and develop the talent in their team and an<br />

ability to promote creativity, accountability and a focus<br />

on continuous improvement. Ref: 3591741<br />

Contact Julia Foster on 020 3465 0020<br />

or email julia.foster2@hays.com<br />

CREDIT ACCOUNTS SUPERVISOR<br />

MANAGE CREDIT RISK<br />

Newark, £28,000 + benefits + study support<br />

A highly entrepreneurial service provider is looking<br />

for a commercially minded credit specialist to take<br />

responsibility for all aspects of credit, managing a team of<br />

four in sales and purchase ledger. You will focus on credit<br />

risk, managing customer credit limits, credit facilities,<br />

escalation issues and aged debt including non-UK<br />

customer accounts, daily bank reconciliations and sales<br />

credit notes. Ideally, you will have varied B2B exposure<br />

and strong communication and staff management skills.<br />

Previous people management experience is essential.<br />

This is a great opportunity to join a growing company<br />

and to widen your exposure to other ledgers and<br />

commercial areas of the business. Ref: 3134053<br />

STRATEGIC PEOPLE MANAGER<br />

COACH A WINNING TEAM<br />

Glasgow, c.£40,000<br />

An opportunity has arisen for a strategic people manager<br />

to join a transactional finance team looking after credit<br />

management. Reporting into the senior management<br />

team you will be responsible for driving efficiencies within<br />

the credit process, coaching, mentoring and setting KPIs<br />

for the team and assisting the senior management team<br />

to set key deliverables. You will be a motivating people<br />

manager and be a hands-on leader. Hours of work are<br />

Monday to Thursday 8am-5pm, with a 4pm finish on<br />

a Friday although this is flexible and the organisation<br />

is easily accessible by public transport. Ref: 3579762<br />

Contact Lauren Hamilton on 0141 212 3665<br />

or email lauren.hamilton@hays.com<br />

CREDIT CONTROLLER<br />

INNOVATIVE RESEARCH COMPANY<br />

Watford, £26,400 + benefits + study support<br />

This innovative, world-leading multi-site business is<br />

looking for a credit controller to join its team in Watford.<br />

The company is well-established and has been trading<br />

for nearly 100 years. Your responsibilities will include<br />

monitoring and chasing debt to minimise DSO and<br />

resolving queries. You will be part of a company that<br />

has a strong work ethic and encourages flexibility on<br />

hours to maintain a healthy work-life balance. Ideally,<br />

you will have previous credit control experience and<br />

be a team player.<br />

Ref: 3579069<br />

Contact Charlotte Clarke on 01923 205286<br />

or email charlotte.clarke@hays.com<br />

Contact Lisa Francis on 01522 313300<br />

or email lisa.francis@hays.com<br />

hays.co.uk/creditcontrol<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 60


PROFESSIONAL SERVICES<br />

CREDIT CONTROLLER<br />

CHALLENGE YOURSELF<br />

Birmingham, £24,000-£26,000 + study support<br />

This well-known legal firm with offices across the UK<br />

in the major cities, is looking for a professional services<br />

credit controller to join its team. Your responsibilities<br />

will include supporting the Midlands branches, ensuring<br />

best practice is adhered to and cashflow is maximised.<br />

You will have strong negotiating and people skills.<br />

In return, you will receive a competitive salary and<br />

study support.<br />

Ref: 3582096<br />

Contact Peter Kidd on 0121 212 1814<br />

or email peter.kidd@hays.com<br />

CREDIT CONTROLLER<br />

MAKE A DIFFERENCE<br />

Poole, up to £25,000<br />

A rare opportunity has arisen to join a vibrant apparel<br />

brand based on the South Coast. The role will have a<br />

strong emphasis on pro-active debtor chasing and this is<br />

a fantastic role for you if you enjoy working autonomously<br />

as part of a progressive company. You will have previous<br />

credit control experience, an excellent telephone manner<br />

and the ability to build positive working relationships.<br />

This a great opportunity for a forward-thinking, well<br />

organised and proactive individual with experience of<br />

reducing aged debt and cash collection.<br />

Ref: 3577971<br />

Contact James Cuesta on 01202 048611<br />

or email james.cuesta@hays.com<br />

AR SPECIALIST<br />

LEAD THE AR FUNCTION WITH IMPACT<br />

Belfast, £25,000 + study support<br />

This NI based business is a highly innovative global leader<br />

in its field and exports to over 55 countries worldwide.<br />

It is looking for an AR specialist to join its team. You will<br />

be responsible for operating the accounts receivable<br />

function for the global business, work closely with the<br />

Belfast based accounts function and liaise daily with<br />

sales reps and teams all across the world. With a strong<br />

background in an AR setting, you will have a high degree<br />

of accuracy and possess first class communication skills.<br />

Exposure to export markets and letters of credit would be<br />

advantageous but not essential. Ref: 3580264<br />

Contact Nicola McCallum on 028 9044 6911<br />

or email nicola.mccallum@hays.com<br />

HEAD OF DEBT RECOVERY<br />

STRATEGIC RECOVERY AND LITIGATION<br />

Newcastle, £competitive + benefits<br />

One of the largest law firms in the North East is looking<br />

for a head of debt recovery to join and lead its growing<br />

debt recovery team. You will be part of a firm that has an<br />

outstanding reputation for its values and vision and provide<br />

a high quality, efficient, cost effective and bespoke service<br />

to its existing portfolio of clients. You will be responsible for<br />

developing relationships with new clients to sell the services<br />

that the firm offers as part of its strategy for growth.<br />

Ideally, you will be an excellent communicator and strong<br />

at building new and existing relationships. This is a fantastic<br />

role with opportunities for career progression if you have a<br />

passion to drive and deliver results. Ref: 3585800<br />

Contact Sarah Smith on 0191 261 3996<br />

or email sarah.smith2@hays.com<br />

This is just a small selection of the many<br />

opportunities we have available for credit<br />

professionals. To find out more email<br />

hayscicm@hays.com or visit us online.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 61


FORTHCOMING EVENTS<br />

Full list of events can be found on our website: www.cicm.com/events<br />

We are inviting all members to bring a colleague to a CICM membership<br />

event, free of charge. For more information, email events@cicm.com<br />

CICM<br />

EVENTS<br />

6 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM West Midlands Branch<br />

BIRMINGHAM<br />

Annual Awards Night and BBQ<br />

This event is Free for members and nonmembers.<br />

Contact : Kim Delaney-Bowen. Please visit our<br />

online events calendar for booking details.<br />

VENUE: The Studio, 7 Cannon Street,<br />

Birmingham, B2 5EP<br />

6 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM Thames Valley Branch<br />

SLOUGH<br />

Curry Night, Please come and join your local<br />

Thames Valley committee for a social curry<br />

evening at Memories of India, Farnham Common,<br />

Slough. Members and non-members will be<br />

made most welcome.<br />

Contact: Please visit our online events calendar<br />

for booking details.<br />

VENUE: Memories of India, Ashley House,<br />

6 Beaconsfield Road, Farnham Common, Slough<br />

SL2 3QL<br />

7 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM FELLOWS’ CELEBRATORY LUNCH<br />

London<br />

We invite all Fellows to help us celebrate<br />

80 years of CICM at this year’s special<br />

Fellows’ Celebratory Lunch.<br />

Contact: Email fellowslunch@cicm.com to book.<br />

VENUE: Churchhill War Rooms, Clive Steps,<br />

King Charles Street, London, SW1A 2AQ.<br />

7 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM South Wales<br />

CARDIFF<br />

Take to the Water<br />

Contact: This was a popular event last year so<br />

book asap call Diana Keeling 07921 492348.<br />

VENUE: Atlantic Wharf Cardiff Bay, Cardiff,<br />

CF10 5BZ<br />

11 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM Sheffield and Yorkshire Ridings<br />

WAKEFIELD<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Circuit Training 2CPD. Refreshments to be<br />

served on arrival. Members and non-members<br />

will be made most welcome at this FREE event.<br />

Contact : Paula Uttley. Please visit our online<br />

events calendar for booking details.<br />

VENUE: Yorkshire Sculpture Park, West Bretton,<br />

Wakefield, WF4 4LG<br />

UP AND COMING EVENTS<br />

12 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM Sussex and Surrey Branch<br />

SURREY<br />

Future Proofing your <strong>Credit</strong> Function – 2CPD<br />

We anticipate that this will be a popular event,<br />

and therefore advance booking is essential<br />

before 3 <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong>, for booking and catering.<br />

Contact: Please visit our online events calendar<br />

for booking details.<br />

VENUE: Silvermere Golf and Leisure Ltd<br />

Redhill Road, Cobham, Surrey KT11 1EF<br />

12 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM London Branch<br />

LONDON<br />

Payments and Poppadoms<br />

Numbers are strictly limited to 24 persons<br />

maximum so, to reserve your place, please pay<br />

the £10 deposit by Friday 7 <strong>June</strong>.<br />

Contact: Please visit our online events calendar<br />

for booking details.<br />

VENUE: The Coriander, 55 Aldersgate Street,<br />

Barbican, London EC1A 4LA<br />

18 <strong>June</strong><br />

Atradius, Onguard, CICM – <strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong> – Where it’s been, where it is<br />

and where it’s going?<br />

CARDIFF<br />

Atradius, Onguard and the CICM invite you to join<br />

us at a dynamic and practical session on: ‘<strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong> – where it’s been, where it is, and<br />

where it’s going’.<br />

Contact: Please visit our online events calendar<br />

for booking details.<br />

VENUE: TBC<br />

20 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM LEARNING CONFERENCE <strong>2019</strong><br />

LONDON<br />

This year we have put together an exciting and<br />

varied programme based around the theme of<br />

‘Managing risk in uncertain times’. All the basic<br />

principles of cash flow and credit management<br />

are even more important in times of uncertainty<br />

and change: we have a programme of activity,<br />

discussion, debate and workshop.<br />

Contact: Please visit our online events calendar<br />

for booking details.<br />

VENUE: Arundel House, 6 Temple Place, London,<br />

WC2R 2PG<br />

25 <strong>June</strong><br />

CICM Thames Valley and Sussex & Surrey<br />

Branch<br />

READING<br />

Annual Southern Branch <strong>Credit</strong> Day 6CPD.<br />

Members and non-members will be made<br />

welcome at this FREE event.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 62<br />

Contact : Please visit our online events calendar<br />

for booking details.<br />

VENUE : Verizon Reading International Business<br />

Park, Basingstoke Road, Reading, RG2 6DA<br />

OTHER EVENTS<br />

5 <strong>June</strong><br />

Forums International Webinar<br />

ONLINE<br />

The Fastest Growing Industry<br />

Contact : Please visit our online events calendar<br />

for booking details.<br />

6 <strong>June</strong><br />

Forums International<br />

STRATFORD UPON AVON<br />

Senior <strong>Management</strong> Forum<br />

Contact : For an information pack email<br />

smf@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

11 <strong>June</strong><br />

Forums International<br />

STRATFORD UPON AVON<br />

Pharmaceuticals & Medical Devices <strong>Credit</strong> Forum<br />

Contact : For an information pack email<br />

pmf@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

13-14 <strong>June</strong><br />

Forums International<br />

LONDON<br />

International Telecoms Risk Forum (ITRF)<br />

Contact : For an information pack email<br />

itrf@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

18 <strong>June</strong><br />

Forums International<br />

LONDON<br />

The Fraud Team<br />

Contact : For an information pack email<br />

info@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

9 July<br />

Forums International<br />

BRACKNELL<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Professionals Forum<br />

Contact : For more information email<br />

cpf@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

VENUE : Coppid Beech Hotel, John Nike Way,<br />

Bracknell, RG12 8TF<br />

10 July<br />

Forums International<br />

LONDON<br />

SAP User Group<br />

Contact : For more information email<br />

sapug@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

VENUE : Moore Stephens, London


3<br />

YEARS<br />

IN 2018<br />

<strong>Credit</strong><br />

Controller<br />

Accounts Receivable<br />

Specialist<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Control<br />

Supervisor<br />

Head of<br />

<strong>Credit</strong><br />

Billing<br />

Administrator<br />

CELEBRATING 30<br />

YEARS OF MATCHING<br />

EXCEPTIONAL TALENT<br />

TO LEADING BRANDS<br />

ACROSSTHE UK.<br />

Portfolio <strong>Credit</strong> Control, part of the Portfolio Group, have been supplying the highest calibre permanent,<br />

temporary and contract staff for 30 years and our dedicated Consultants have specialist expertise in the<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Control market.<br />

We’ve opened our <strong>Credit</strong> Control Division in Manchester<br />

Centrally located, we are nowable to provide apersonal level of service<br />

in aclose proximity to our clientsbased in: MANCHESTER &THE NORTH<br />

WEST •LEEDS &YORKSHIRE •NEWCASTLE &THE NORTH EAST<br />

Contact one of our dedicated Recruitment Consultants to fill<br />

your current vacancy or find your next career move!<br />

LONDON 020 7650 3199<br />

THIRD FLOOR, 1FINSBURYSQUARE, LONDON EC2A 1AE<br />

MANCHESTER 0161 836 9949<br />

THE PENINSULA, VICTORIA PLACE, MANCHESTER M4 4FB<br />

www.portfoliocreditcontrol.com<br />

recruitment@portfoliocreditcontrol.com<br />

www.facebook.com/theportfoliogroup<br />

linkedin.com/company/portfolio-credit-control<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 63<br />

WE ARE RATED 9OUT OF 10<br />

@portfoliocredit


Cr£ditWho?<br />

CICM Directory of Services<br />

COLLECTIONS<br />

COLLECTIONS LEGAL<br />

COURT ENFORCEMENT SERVICES<br />

Atradius Collections Ltd<br />

3 Harbour Drive,<br />

Capital Waterside,<br />

Cardiff Bay, Cardiff, CF10 4WZ<br />

United Kingdom<br />

T: +44 (0)2920 824700<br />

W: www.atradiuscollections.com/uk/<br />

Atradius Collections Ltd is an established specialist in business<br />

to business collections. As the collections division of the Atradius<br />

Crédito y Caución, we have a strong position sharing history,<br />

knowledge and reputation.<br />

Annually handling more than 110,000 cases and recovering over<br />

a billion EUROs in collections at any one time, we deliver when<br />

it comes to collecting outstanding debts. With over 90 years’<br />

experience, we have an in-depth understanding of the importance of<br />

maintaining customer relationships whilst efficiently and effectively<br />

collecting monies owed.<br />

The individual nature of our clients’ customer relationships is<br />

reflected in the customer focus we provide, structuring our service<br />

to meet your specific needs. We work closely with clients to provide<br />

them with a collection strategy that echoes their business character,<br />

trading patterns and budget.<br />

For further information contact: Hans Meijer, UK and Ireland Country<br />

Director (hans.meijer@atradius.com).<br />

INTERNATIONAL COLLECTIONS<br />

Premium Collections Limited<br />

3 Caidan House, Canal Road<br />

Timperley, Cheshire. WA14 1TD<br />

T: +44 (0)161 962 4695<br />

E: paul.daine@premiumcollections.co.uk<br />

W: www.premiumcollections.co.uk<br />

For all your credit management requirements Premium Collections<br />

has the solution to suit you. Operating on a national and international<br />

basis we can tailor a package of products and services to meet your<br />

requirements.<br />

Services include B2B collections, B2C collections, international<br />

collections, absconder tracing, asset repossessions, status reporting<br />

and litigation support.<br />

Managed from our offices in Manchester, Harrogate and Dublin our<br />

network of 55 partners cover the World.<br />

Contact Paul Daine FCICM on +44 (0)161 962 4695 or<br />

paul.daine@premiumcollections.co.uk<br />

www.premiumcollections.co.uk<br />

COLLECTIONS LEGAL<br />

Lovetts Solicitors<br />

Lovetts, Bramley House, The Guildway, Old Portsmouth<br />

Road, Guildford, Surrey GU3 1LR<br />

T: +44(0)1483 457500 E: info@lovetts.co.uk<br />

W: www.lovetts.co.uk<br />

Lovetts has been recovering debts for 30 years! When you<br />

want the right expertise to recover overdue debts why not use a<br />

specialist? Lovetts’ only line of business is the recovery of<br />

business debts and any resulting commercial litigation.<br />

We provide:<br />

• Letters Before Action, prompting positive outcomes in more than<br />

80 percent of cases • Overseas Pre-litigation collections with<br />

multi-lingual capabilities • 24/7 access to our online debt<br />

management system ‘CaseManager’<br />

Don’t just take our word for it, here’s recent customer feedback:<br />

“...All our service expectations have been exceeded...”<br />

“...The online system is particularly useful and is extremely easy<br />

to use... “...Lovetts has a recognisable brand that generates<br />

successful results...”<br />

Yuill + Kyle<br />

Capella, 60 York Street, Glasgow, G2 8JX, Scotland, UK<br />

T: 0141 572 4251<br />

E: scowan@yuill-kyle.co.uk<br />

W: www.debtscotland.com<br />

Do You Have Trouble Collecting Debts in<br />

Scotland? We Don’t<br />

Yuill + Kyle is one of Scotland’s leading debt recovery and credit<br />

control law firms. With over 100 years of experience, we are<br />

specialists in resolving disputed and undisputed debts. Our track<br />

record for successful recoveries means you have just moved one step<br />

closer to getting your money back.<br />

How we can help you:<br />

• Specialist advice for all of your legal matters<br />

• A responsive and straightforward approach<br />

• Providing you with solutions-driven advice<br />

• Delivering cost certainty and value for money<br />

Our services<br />

• Pre-sue • Fast track collections • Judgement enforcement<br />

• Insolvency • Bankruptcy • Liquidation<br />

CONSULTANCY<br />

Court Enforcement Services<br />

Wayne Whitford – Director<br />

M: +44 (0)7834 748 183 T : +44 (0)1992 663 399<br />

E : wayne@courtenforcementservices.co.uk<br />

W: www.courtenforcementservices.co.uk<br />

High Court Enforcement that will Empower You!<br />

We help law firms and in-house debt recovery and legal teams to<br />

enforce CCJs by transferring them up to the High Court. Setting us<br />

apart in the industry, our unique and Award Winning Field Agent App<br />

helps to provide information in real time and transparency, empowering<br />

our clients when they work with us.<br />

• Free Transfer up process of CCJ’s to High Court<br />

• Exceptional Recovery Rates<br />

• Individual Client Attention and Tailored Solutions<br />

• Real Time Client Access to Cases<br />

CREDIT INFORMATION<br />

Company Watch<br />

Centurion House, 37 Jewry Street,<br />

LONDON. EC3N 2ER<br />

T: +44 (0)20 7043 3300<br />

E: info@companywatch.net<br />

W: www.companywatch.net<br />

Organisations around the world rely on Company Watch’s industryleading<br />

financial analytics to drive their credit risk processes. Our<br />

financial risk modelling and ability to map medium to long-term risk as<br />

well as short-term credit risk set us apart from other credit reference<br />

agencies.<br />

Quality and rigour run through everything we do, from our unique<br />

method of assessing corporate financial health via our H-Score®, to<br />

developing analytics on our customers’ in-house data.<br />

With the H-Score® predicting almost 90 percent of corporate<br />

insolvencies in advance, it is the risk management tool of choice,<br />

providing actionable intelligence in an uncertain world.<br />

Blaser Mills Law<br />

40 Oxford Road,<br />

High Wycombe,<br />

Buckinghamshire. HP11 2EE<br />

T: 01494 478660/478661<br />

E: Jackie Ray jar@blasermills.co.uk or<br />

Gary Braathen gpb@blasermills.co.uk<br />

W: www.blasermills.co.uk<br />

A full-service firm, Blaser Mills Law’s experienced Commercial<br />

Recoveries team offer pre-legal collections, debt recovery,<br />

litigation, dispute resolution and insolvency. The team includes<br />

CICM qualified staff, recommended in both Legal 500 and<br />

Chambers & Partners legal directories.<br />

Offices in High Wycombe, Amersham, Rickmansworth, London<br />

and Silverstone<br />

Sanders Consulting Associates Ltd<br />

T: +44(0)1525 720226<br />

E: enquiries@chrissandersconsulting.com<br />

W: www.chrissandersconsulting.com<br />

Sanders Consulting is an independent niche consulting firm<br />

specialising in leadership and performance improvement in all aspects<br />

of the order to cash process. Chris Sanders FCICM, the principal, is<br />

well known in the industry with a wealth of experience in operational<br />

credit management, billing, change and business process improvement.<br />

A sought after speaker with cross industry international experience in<br />

the business-to-business and business-to-consumer markets, his<br />

innovative and enthusiastic approach delivers pragmatic people and<br />

process lead solutions and significant working capital improvements to<br />

clients. Sanders Consulting are proud to manage CICMQ on behalf of<br />

and under the supervision of the CICM.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 64<br />

CoCredo<br />

Missenden Abbey, Great Missenden, Bucks, HP16 0BD<br />

T: 01494 790600<br />

E: customerservice@cocredo.com<br />

W: www.cocredo.co.uk<br />

CoCredo’s award winning credit reporting and monitoring systems have<br />

helped to protect over £27 billion of turnover on behalf of our customers.<br />

Our company data is updated continually throughout the day and access<br />

to the online portal is available 365 days a year 24/7.<br />

At CoCredo we aggregate data from a range of leading providers in<br />

the UK and across the globe so that our customers can view the best<br />

available data in an easy to read report. We offer customers XML<br />

Integration and D.N.A Portfolio <strong>Management</strong> as well as an industry-first<br />

Dual Report, comparing two leading providers opinions in one report.


FOR INFORMATION,<br />

OPTIONS AND PRICING<br />

PLEASE EMAIL:<br />

grace@cabbell.co.uk<br />

CREDIT INFORMATION<br />

CREDIT MANAGEMENT SOFTWARE<br />

CREDIT MANAGEMENT SOFTWARE<br />

Experian<br />

The Sir John Peace Building, Experian Way<br />

NG2 Business Park, Nottingham NG80 1ZZ<br />

T: 0844 481 9920<br />

W: www.experian.co.uk/business-information/<br />

For over 30 years Experian have been processing, matching and deriving<br />

insights to provide accurate, up-to-date information that helps B2B<br />

organisations to make more effective, fact based decisions, reduce<br />

risks and meet regulatory standards. We turn complex data into clear<br />

insights that help manage UK and international businesses to maximise<br />

opportunities for growth and identify and minimise the associated risks.<br />

Blending our business and consumer data we can offer a truly blended<br />

score for sole traders and enhanced scoring on SME’s to tell you more<br />

about the business and the people behind the business. Experian can<br />

support with new business, acquisition through to collections while<br />

managing KYC requirements online or via our suite of APIs.<br />

Keyivr<br />

T: +44 (0) 1302 513 000<br />

E: sales@keyivr W: www.keyivr.co.uk<br />

Key IVR are proud to have joined the Chartered Institute of <strong>Credit</strong><br />

<strong>Management</strong>’s Corporate partnership scheme. The CICM is a<br />

recognised and trusted professional entity within credit management<br />

and a perfect partner for Key IVR. We are delighted to be providing<br />

our services to the CICM to assist with their membership collection<br />

activities. Key IVR provides a suite of products to assist companies<br />

across the Europe with credit management. Our service is based<br />

around giving the end-user the means to make a payment when and<br />

how they choose. Using automated collection methods, such as a<br />

secure telephone payment line (IVR), web and SMS allows companies<br />

to free up valuable staff time away from typical debt collection.<br />

Data Interconnect Ltd<br />

Units 45-50<br />

Shrivenham Hundred Business Park<br />

Majors Road, Watchfield<br />

Swindon, SN6 8TZ<br />

T: +44 (0)1367 245777<br />

E: sales@datainterconnect.co.uk<br />

W: www.datainterconnect.com<br />

Data Interconnect provides Intelligent Invoice to Cash Automation.<br />

Corrivo Billing, Collection and Dispute modules seamlessly integrate<br />

for a rich, end-to-end A/R user experience. Branded customer<br />

portals, real-time dashboards, advanced reporting, available in 15<br />

languages as standard; are some of the reason why global brands<br />

choose Data Interconnect.<br />

Graydon UK<br />

66 College Road, 2nd Floor, Hygeia Building, Harrow,<br />

Middlesex, HA1 1BE<br />

T: +44 (0)208 515 1400<br />

E: customerservices@graydon.co.uk<br />

W: www.graydon.co.uk<br />

Graydon UK is a specialist in <strong>Credit</strong> Risk <strong>Management</strong> and Intelligence,<br />

providing access to business information on over 100 million entities<br />

across more than 190 countries. Its mission is to convert vast amounts<br />

of data from diverse data sources into invaluable information. Based<br />

on this, it generates economic, financial and commercial insights that<br />

help its customers make better business decisions and ultimately<br />

gain competitive advantage. Graydon is owned by Atradius, Coface<br />

and Euler Hermes, Europe's leading credit insurance organisations. It<br />

offers a comprehensive network of offices and partners worldwide to<br />

ensure a seamless service.<br />

THE ONLY AML RESOURCE YOU NEED<br />

SmartSearch<br />

SmartSearch, Harman House,<br />

Station Road,Guiseley, Leeds, LS20 8BX<br />

T: +44 (0)113 238 7660<br />

E: info@smartsearchuk.com W: www.smartsearchuk.com<br />

KYC, AML and CDD all rely on a combination of deep data with broad<br />

coverage, highly automated flexible technology with an innovative<br />

and intuitive customer interface. Key features include automatic<br />

Worldwide Sanction & PEP checking, Daily Monitoring, Automated<br />

Enhanced Due Diligence and pro-active customer management.<br />

Choose SmartSearch as your benchmark.<br />

ONGUARD<br />

T: +31 (0)88 256 66 66<br />

E: ruurd.bakker@onguard.com<br />

W: www.onguard.com<br />

Onguard is specialist in credit management software and market<br />

leader in innovative solutions for order to cash. Our integrated<br />

platform ensures an optimal connection of all processes in the order<br />

to cash chain and allows sharing of critical data.<br />

Intelligent tools that can seamlessly be interconnected and offer<br />

overview and control of the payment process, as well as contribute to<br />

a sustainable customer relationship.<br />

In more than 50 countries the Onguard platform is successfully used<br />

for successful credit management.<br />

Tinubu Square UK<br />

Holland House, 4 Bury Street,<br />

London EC3A 5AW<br />

T: +44 (0)207 469 2577 /<br />

E: uksales@tinubu.com<br />

W: www.tinubu.com<br />

Founded in 2000, Tinubu Square is a software vendor, enabler of the<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> Insurance, Surety and Trade Finance digital transformation.<br />

Tinubu Square enables organizations across the world to significantly<br />

reduce their exposure to risk and their financial, operational and technical<br />

costs with best-in-class technology solutions and services. Tinubu<br />

Square provides SaaS solutions and services to different businesses<br />

including credit insurers, receivables financing organizations and<br />

multinational corporations.<br />

Tinubu Square has built an ecosystem of customers in over 20 countries<br />

worldwide and has a global presence with offices in Paris, London, New<br />

York, Montreal and Singapore.<br />

Proud supporters<br />

of CICMQ<br />

Rimilia<br />

Corbett House, Westonhall Road, Bromsgrove, B60 4AL<br />

T: +44 (0)1527 872123 E: enquiries@rimilia.com<br />

W: www.rimilia.com<br />

Operating globally across any sector, Rimilia provides intelligent,<br />

finance automation solutions that enable customers to get paid on time<br />

and control their cashflow and cash collection in real time. Rimilia’s<br />

software solutions use sophisticated analytics and artificial intelligence<br />

(AI) to predict customer payment behaviour and easily match and<br />

reconcile payments, removing the uncertainty of cash collection. The<br />

Rimilia software automates the complete accounts receivable process<br />

and eliminates unallocated cash, reducing manual activity by an<br />

average 70% and achieving best in class matching rates recognised<br />

by industry specialists such as The Hackett Group.<br />

HighRadius<br />

T: +44 7399 406889<br />

E: gwyn.roberts@highradius.com<br />

W: www.highradius.com<br />

HighRadius is the leading provider of Integrated Receivables<br />

solutions for automating receivables and payment functions such<br />

as credit, collections, cash allocation, deductions and eBilling.<br />

The Integrated Receivables suite is delivered as a software-as-aservice<br />

(SaaS). HighRadius also offers SAP-certified Accelerators<br />

for SAP S/4HANA Finance Receivables <strong>Management</strong>, enabling<br />

large enterprises to maximize the value of their SAP investments.<br />

HighRadius Integrated Receivables solutions have a proven track<br />

record of reducing days sales outstanding (DSO), bad-debt and<br />

increasing operation efficiency, enabling companies to achieve an<br />

ROI in less than a year.<br />

CEDAR<br />

ROSE<br />

R<br />

Cedar Rose<br />

3, Georgiou Katsonotou Street,3036, Limassol, Cyprus<br />

E: info@cedar-rose.com T: +357 25346630<br />

W: www.cedar-rose.com<br />

Cedar Rose has been globally recognised as the expert for<br />

credit reports, due diligence and data for the Middle East<br />

and North African countries since 1997. We now cover over<br />

170 countries with the same high quality, expert analysis<br />

and attention to detail we are well-known and trusted for.<br />

Making best use of artificial intelligence and technology, Cedar<br />

Rose has won several awards including <strong>Credit</strong> Excellence<br />

& European Business Awards. Our website is a one-stopshop<br />

for your business intelligence solutions. We are the<br />

ultimate source; with competitive prices and friendly customer<br />

service - whether you need one or one thousand reports.<br />

Credica Ltd<br />

Building 168, Maxell Avenue, Harwell Oxford, Oxon. OX11 0QT<br />

T: 01235 856400E: info@credica.co.uk W: www.credica.co.uk<br />

Our highly configurable and extremely cost effective Collections and<br />

Query <strong>Management</strong> System has been designed with 3 goals in mind:<br />

• To improve your cashflow • To reduce your cost to collect<br />

• To provide meaningful analysis of your business<br />

Evolving over 15 years and driven by the input of 1000s of <strong>Credit</strong><br />

Professionals across the UK and Europe, our system is successfully<br />

providing significant and measurable benefits for our diverse portfolio<br />

of clients.<br />

We would love to hear from you if you feel you would benefit from our<br />

‘no nonsense’ and human approach to computer software.<br />

Redwood Collections Ltd<br />

0208 288 3555<br />

enquiry@redwoodcollections.com<br />

Airport House, Purley Way, Croydon, CR0 0XZ<br />

“Redwood Collections offers a complete portfolio of debt collection<br />

services ranging from sensitive client-debtor mediation through to<br />

legal and insolvency action.<br />

Incorporated in 2009, we are pleased to represent in excess of<br />

11,000 clients. Whatever your debt collection needs, we have the<br />

expertise and resources to deliver a fast, efficient and cost-effective<br />

solution.”<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 65 continues on page 66 >


Cr£ditWho?<br />

CICM Directory of Services<br />

FOR INFORMATION,<br />

OPTIONS AND PRICING<br />

PLEASE EMAIL:<br />

grace@cabbell.co.uk<br />

DATA AND ANALYTICS<br />

Dun & Bradstreet<br />

Marlow International, Parkway Marlow<br />

Buckinghamshire SL7 1AJ<br />

Telephone: (0800) 001-234 Website: www.dnb.co.uk<br />

Dun & Bradstreet Finance Solutions enable modern finance<br />

leaders and credit professionals to improve business performance<br />

through more effective risk management, identification of growth<br />

opportunities, and better integration of data and insights across the<br />

business. Powered by our Data Cloud, our solutions provide access<br />

to the world’s most comprehensive commercial data and insights<br />

- supplying a continually updated view of business relationships<br />

that helps finance and credit teams stay ahead of market shifts and<br />

customer changes. Learn more here:<br />

www.dnb.co.uk/modernfinance<br />

FINANCIAL SERVICES<br />

C2FO<br />

15 Statton Street, Mayfair,<br />

London W1J 8LQ<br />

T: 07799 692193<br />

E: anna.donadelli@c2fo.com W: www.c2fo.com<br />

C2FO turns receivables into cashflow and payables into income,<br />

uniquely connecting buyers and suppliers to allow discounts in<br />

exchange for early payment of approved invoices. Suppliers access<br />

additional liquidity sources by accelerating payments from buyers<br />

when required in just two clicks, at a rate that works for them.<br />

Buyers, often corporates with global supply chains, benefit from the<br />

C2FO solution by improving gross margin while strengthening the<br />

financial health of supply chains through ethical business practices.<br />

SERRALA<br />

Serrala UK Ltd, 125 Wharfdale Road<br />

Winnersh Triangle, Wokingham<br />

Berkshire RG41 5RB<br />

E: a.velzian@serrala.com W: www.serrala.com<br />

T: +44 1182 070 464 M: +44 7802 881 797<br />

Serrala optimizes the Universe of Payments for organisations seeking<br />

efficient cash visibility and secure financial processes. As an SAP<br />

Partner, Serrala supports over 3,500 companies worldwide. With<br />

more than 30 years of experience and thousands of successful<br />

customer projects, including solutions for the entire order-tocash<br />

process, Serrala provides credit managers and receivables<br />

professionals with the solutions they need to successfully protect<br />

their business against credit risk exposure and bad debt loss.<br />

FINANCIAL PR<br />

Gravity London<br />

Floor 6/7, Gravity London, 69 Wilson St, London, EC21 2BB<br />

T: +44(0)207 330 8888. E: sfeast@gravitylondon.com<br />

W: www.gravitylondon.com<br />

Gravity is an award winning full service PR and advertising<br />

business that is regularly benchmarked as being one of the best<br />

in its field. It has a particular expertise in the credit sector, building<br />

long-term relationships with some of the industry’s best-known<br />

brands working on often challenging briefs. As the partner agency for<br />

the <strong>Credit</strong> Services Association (CSA) for the past 13 years, and the<br />

Chartered Institute of <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> since 2006, it understands<br />

the key issues affecting the credit industry and what works and what<br />

doesn’t in supporting its clients in the media and beyond.<br />

FORUMS<br />

FORUMS INTERNATIONAL<br />

T: +44 (0)1246 555055<br />

E: info@forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

W: www.forumsinternational.co.uk<br />

Forums International Ltd have been running <strong>Credit</strong> and Industry<br />

Forums since 1991. We cover a range of industry sectors and<br />

International trading, attendance is for <strong>Credit</strong> Professionals of all<br />

levels. Our forums are not just meetings but communities which<br />

aim to prepare our members for the challenges ahead. Attending<br />

for the first time is free for you to gauge the benefits and meet the<br />

members and we only have pre-approved Partners, so you will never<br />

intentionally be sold to.<br />

PAYMENT SOLUTIONS<br />

American Express<br />

76 Buckingham Palace Road,<br />

London. SW1W 9TQ<br />

T: +44 (0)1273 696933<br />

W: www.americanexpress.com<br />

American Express is working in partnership with the CICM and is<br />

a globally recognised provider of payment solutions to businesses.<br />

Specialising in providing flexible collection capabilities to drive a<br />

number of company objectives including:<br />

•Accelerate cashflow •Improved DSO •Reduce risk<br />

•Offer extended terms to customers<br />

•Provide an additional line of bank independent credit to drive<br />

growth •Create competitive advantage with your customers<br />

As experts in the field of payments and with a global reach,<br />

American Express is working with credit managers to drive growth<br />

within businesses of all sectors. By creating an additional lever to<br />

help support supplier/client relationships American Express is proud<br />

to be an innovator in the business payments space.<br />

Testimonial<br />

We have been regular advertisers<br />

in <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> (CM)<br />

magazine for more than ten<br />

years and have found it to be an<br />

excellent medium for raising our<br />

brand awareness and securing<br />

major contracts.<br />

By way of example, one of the<br />

largest logistics firms in the world<br />

approached us for our services<br />

having seen our profile in CM.<br />

This led to a very successful<br />

relationship and gained us<br />

significant credibility.<br />

We would recommend advertising<br />

in CM magazine to other<br />

businesses.<br />

RECRUITMENT<br />

Portfolio <strong>Credit</strong> Control<br />

1 Finsbury Square, London. EC2A 1AE<br />

T: 0207 650 3199<br />

E: recruitment@portfoliocreditcontrol.com<br />

W: www.portfoliocreditcontrol.com<br />

Portfolio <strong>Credit</strong> Control, solely specialises in the recruitment of<br />

permanent, temporary and contract <strong>Credit</strong> Control, Accounts<br />

Receivable and Collections staff. Part of an award winning recruiter<br />

we speak to and meet credit controllers all day everyday understanding<br />

their skills and backgrounds to provide you with tried and tested credit<br />

control professionals. We have achieved enormous growth because we<br />

offer a uniquely specialist approach to our clients, with a commitment<br />

to service delivery that exceeds your expectations every single time.<br />

RECRUITMENT<br />

PORTFOLIO<br />

CREDIT CONTROL<br />

ESKER<br />

Sam Townsend Head of Marketing<br />

Northern Europe Esker Ltd.<br />

T: +44 (0)1332 548176 M: +44 (0)791 2772 302<br />

W: www.esker.co.uk<br />

LinkedIn: Esker – Northern Europe<br />

Twitter: @EskerNEurope<br />

Esker.blog<br />

Esker’s Accounts Receivable (AR) solution removes the all-toocommon<br />

obstacles preventing today’s businesses from collecting<br />

receivables in a timely manner. From invoice delivery to cash<br />

application, Esker automates each step. Esker's automated AR<br />

system powered by TermSync helps companies modernise without<br />

replacing their core billing and collections processes. By simply<br />

automating what should be automated, customers get the post-sale<br />

experience they deserve and your team gets the tools they need.<br />

Bottomline Technologies<br />

115 Chatham Street, Reading<br />

Berks RG1 7JX | UK<br />

T: 0870 081 8250 E: emea-info@bottomline.com<br />

W: www.bottomline.com/uk<br />

Bottomline Technologies (NASDAQ: EPAY) helps businesses<br />

pay and get paid. Businesses and banks rely on Bottomline for<br />

domestic and international payments, effective cash management<br />

tools, automated workflows for payment processing and bill<br />

review and state of the art fraud detection, behavioural analytics<br />

and regulatory compliance. Businesses around the world depend<br />

on Bottomline solutions to help them pay and get paid, including<br />

some of the world’s largest systemic banks, private and publicly<br />

traded companies and Insurers. Every day, we help our customers<br />

by making complex business payments simple, secure and seamless.<br />

Hays <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

107 Cheapside, London, EC2V 6DN<br />

T: 07834 260029<br />

E: karen.young@hays.com<br />

W: www.hays.co.uk/creditcontrol<br />

Hays <strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong> is working in partnership with the CICM<br />

and specialise in placing experts into credit control jobs and credit<br />

management jobs. Hays understands the demands of this challenging<br />

environment and the skills required to thrive within it. Whatever<br />

your needs, we have temporary, permanent and contract based<br />

opportunities to find your ideal role. Our candidate registration process<br />

is unrivalled, including face-to-face screening interviews and a credit<br />

control skills test developed exclusively for Hays by the CICM. We offer<br />

CICM members a priority service and can provide advice across a wide<br />

spectrum of job search and recruitment issues.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 66


FROM THE<br />

ARCHIVE<br />

<strong>Credit</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />

magazine from 52 years ago.19<br />

67<br />

IN <strong>June</strong> 1967 the Six Day War concludes with a U.N. brokered<br />

ceasefire after Israel seized the Sinai Peninsula and the Gaza Strip<br />

from Egypt, the West Bank and East Jerusalem from Jordan, and<br />

the Golan Heights from Syria. The US House of Representatives<br />

unanimously votes to make burning the American flag a federal<br />

crime, the first automatic teller machine (ATM) begins service at<br />

the Enfield branch of Barclays Bank, the fifth James Bond film You<br />

Only Live Twice premieres in London, Aretha Franklin’s ‘Respect’<br />

reaches number one.<br />

PUBLICITY<br />

FOR THE<br />

INSTITUTE<br />

A special committee<br />

is created to consider<br />

ways in which the<br />

Institute can market<br />

itself to become<br />

more widely known<br />

in the business<br />

community and<br />

ultimately increase<br />

memberships.<br />

CUTHBERT GREIG, C.B.E., F.C.I.S., F.I.C.M.<br />

Members learn of the sad news that the founder of the Institute and<br />

then-Vice President Cuthbert Greig has died suddenly. Alongside<br />

some of the country’s leading credit professionals, Greig formed the<br />

Institute until the war led to activities being suspended until 1946;<br />

he would go on to be named the Chairman of Council before being<br />

elected as the first President.<br />

The Recognised Standard / www.cicm.com / <strong>June</strong> <strong>2019</strong> / PAGE 67


There are easier ways to achieve<br />

peace of mind.<br />

Like buying credit reports<br />

from Cedar Rose.<br />

cedar-rose.com<br />

+357 25 346630

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!