29112020
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
PAGE 10—SUNDAY VANGUARD, NOVEMBER 29, 2020<br />
Recession ‘ll trigger withdrawals of<br />
FDIs, FPIs — Sanni<br />
•Urges govt to open borders for regional trade<br />
By Nkiruka Nnorom<br />
Group CEO, Emerging Africa<br />
Capital Group, Mrs. Tonyi<br />
Sanni, speaks on Nigeria’s entry<br />
into the second recession in five years and<br />
the way forward..<br />
COVID-19 pandemic and even<br />
#EndSARS protest have been blamed<br />
for the recent recession, but beyond<br />
these two things, what other<br />
mistakes do you think led the nation<br />
into this second recession?<br />
Although the novel virus and EndSars<br />
protest have been blamed in some quarters<br />
for Nigeria’s current economic situation,<br />
from an analytic point of view, our<br />
challenges began long before the<br />
#EndSars protest. Recall that Nigeria had<br />
recorded a significant decline in GDP (-<br />
6.1%) even before the protest started in<br />
October.<br />
Africa’s biggest economy slid into<br />
recession due to the reduction in revenues<br />
following the crash in oil prices and other<br />
negative impacts of the virus in the<br />
country.<br />
For example, the lockdown brought<br />
about reduced consumption and<br />
production, disruptions in supply chains<br />
as producers could not produce during the<br />
period.<br />
Again, increased pressure on the naira<br />
due to falling reserves also affected our<br />
currency price whilst protracted border<br />
closure contributed to the rise in inflation<br />
rate and reduced purchasing power for<br />
household economies.<br />
With complete shutdown in<br />
business activities as curtailment for<br />
the COVID-19, do you think Nigeria<br />
could have escaped this considering?<br />
It is unrealistic to compare a fragile<br />
economy like Nigeria which had only just<br />
come out of a recession four years ago<br />
and has other structural challenges such<br />
as commodity dependence and import<br />
dependence to developed economies with<br />
more established financial systems. There<br />
are, however, steps we could have taken<br />
to ease the pressure on the populace<br />
including more impactful stimulus<br />
and palliative measures. However,<br />
we have the challenge of low fiscal<br />
headroom.<br />
In what ways do you<br />
think the situation will<br />
affect the ordinary<br />
Nigerian and the entire<br />
nation?<br />
The National Bureau of<br />
Statistics (NBS) reports are<br />
historical in the sense that they<br />
are recorded in the period of<br />
reference. So, it reflects the actual<br />
effect of the nation’s economic<br />
stance.<br />
The actual confirmation of the recession<br />
may further affect Nigerians by triggering<br />
further withdrawal of already reduced<br />
Foreign Direct Investments (FDIs) and<br />
Foreign Portfolio Investments (FPIs) into<br />
our economy and could discourage<br />
domestic investment in the short term.<br />
Inflation is on the rise, foreign<br />
•Sanni<br />
reserves are dropping<br />
and the manufacturing sector is<br />
shrinking, how can the government<br />
encourage production and exports to<br />
earn foreign exchange and boost the<br />
economy?<br />
Government can encourage production<br />
by improving the security environment for<br />
farmers to boost the agriculture sector.<br />
Second, government can also improve<br />
access to finance for manufacturers, re-open<br />
the borders to encourage regional trade and<br />
also manage our currency transparently and<br />
realistically.<br />
The federal government has said<br />
that Nigeria will get out of the<br />
recession in first quarter 2021, do you<br />
think we have the right monetary and<br />
fiscal policies to navigate out of this<br />
so soon?<br />
I believe this projection is hinged<br />
significantly on expectations of the<br />
availability of Covid-19 vaccine in major<br />
economies by Q1 which is expected to<br />
trigger increased demand for oil and<br />
correspondingly the recovery of our oil<br />
revenue dependent economy.<br />
Is government getting it right in<br />
the area of diversification?<br />
We must not only diversify our<br />
income source beyond crude oil sales<br />
revenue to other exports of agricultural<br />
products and solid minerals, we must<br />
also drive the process of conversion of<br />
primary produce to finished products.<br />
Our policies must encourage investment<br />
in production and in job-creating<br />
ventures. Security, political stability,<br />
rule of law and a transparent judicial<br />
system and financial inclusion are<br />
equally essential to our economic<br />
recovery and growth.<br />
What is the way forward?<br />
Political stability, good<br />
governance, transparency and<br />
elimination of corruption, fiscal<br />
prudence and responsibility and<br />
continuous building of trust of<br />
both domestic and international<br />
investors are the way forward.<br />
We also need the consistent<br />
implementation of balanced, even-handed,<br />
and consistent policies that create a<br />
conducive environment for investment.<br />
Property rights must be protected and so<br />
must human rights.<br />
COMMON MAN: How this recession will affect you<br />
Continued from page 7<br />
thing to hell is here. For millions of our<br />
people, especially rural subsistence farmers,<br />
hell is definitely here. Hell is here, not only<br />
because COVID-19 might trigger another<br />
lockdown, but because criminals –<br />
herdsmen, kidnappers, cattle rustlers and<br />
bandits – have now shut down a significant<br />
percentage of Nigeria’s farmlands.<br />
Zamfara, Kaduna, Niger, Katsina, Sokoto<br />
and Borno states together accounted for<br />
about 30 to 35 per cent of our annual food<br />
production. Today, even two battalions of<br />
soldiers cannot guarantee the safety of<br />
farmers and their harvests in Borno State<br />
where the governor had escaped two<br />
assassination attempts. In Zamfara and<br />
Katsina states, the governors openly<br />
announce their negotiations with bandits in<br />
order for farmers to be allowed to work in<br />
peace. Invariably, the armed hoodlums<br />
break their promises and still attack farmers.<br />
Recent kidnap of senior police officers, on<br />
their way to Gusau, at the border of Katsina<br />
and Zamfara states, revealed what ordinary<br />
people suffer on those routes.<br />
The atrocities committed daily on the<br />
Abuja-Suleija-Kaduna highway only tell<br />
some of the story of food high-jacking by<br />
bandits in Kaduna and Niger States. Going<br />
to farm in many parts of the North has<br />
become a suicide mission; none but the<br />
bravest and most desperate now attempts it<br />
anymore.<br />
Chief Olu Falae, former Secretary to the<br />
Federal Government, former Minister of<br />
Finance, serves proxy for all farmers in the<br />
South besieged by suspected herdsmen.<br />
Herdsmen had been visiting Falae’s part of<br />
the South from time immemorial without<br />
creating havoc. Change came in 2015 when<br />
suspected herdsmen openly dropped their<br />
shepherd’s staffs and picked up AK-47s.<br />
Falae was kidnapped and ransom was paid<br />
and nobody was apprehended for it. A few<br />
days before I started to write this special<br />
report, suspected herdsmen devastated parts<br />
of Falae’s farm once again. If Falae had<br />
depended exclusively on farming for his<br />
livelihood, herdsmen would have forced him<br />
to stop farming as hundreds of thousands<br />
had done in the South.<br />
When criminal herdsmen went on the<br />
rampage, it never occurred to the powersthat-be<br />
that widespread famine would result.<br />
Large scale famine is now a reality with<br />
which government must now deal with. It<br />
will remain with us for a while because it is<br />
easier to destroy than to build. Millions of<br />
Nigerians have been forced to leave farms<br />
they have taken years to cultivate and turn<br />
into food machines for all of us.<br />
The devastation of farms and the<br />
impoverishment of millions of farmers have<br />
contributed in large measure to the current<br />
recession. As aggregate personal income has<br />
plummeted with the recession, demand for<br />
meat has also dropped sharply. Shortly after<br />
receiving call from the Sunday Editor to<br />
write this article, Head Butchers in seven<br />
Lagos markets were contacted to ask about<br />
demand for beef, goat and ram meats. The<br />
result was startling. On the average, there<br />
has been about 25 per cent drop in cows,<br />
goats and rams slaughtered and sold. A stop<br />
at the cattle market – Kara – revealed that<br />
there is a strong correlation between what<br />
the butchers reported and the reduction in<br />
cattle sold. Lagos cattle dealers are now<br />
sending back cattle. The tragedy has come<br />
full circle.<br />
Unfortunately, reduced demand is not the<br />
only problem facing herdsmen. Some of the<br />
cattle rustlers carrying off their animals were<br />
once farmers whose farms were devastated<br />
by suspected herdsmen. Information<br />
reaching us indicates that some displaced<br />
farmers are now imposing a sort of rural<br />
jungle justice – suspected herdsmen destroy<br />
farms; farmers seize their cattle in<br />
retaliation. Paradoxically, the cattle rustlers<br />
have discovered that it is more profitable to<br />
rustle cattle than to farm. Few of them will<br />
return to farming until government finds a<br />
way to restore security to rural areas.<br />
Agriculture, which was always the first<br />
sector to lead economic recovery after a<br />
recession, might not play that role now. The<br />
sector is in bad shape. Consequently, food<br />
prices will continue to rise.<br />
Manufacturing mauled<br />
“Consumption is the sole purpose of<br />
production.”<br />
This is an axiom in economics which<br />
pertains more to manufacturing than any<br />
other sector. Despite its importance,<br />
manufacturing will be touched only briefly<br />
in this write up. The situation here is not<br />
different from that in agriculture.<br />
Warehouses are full of finished products –<br />
unsold; and selling slowly. The demand for<br />
manufactured goods naturally lags behind<br />
request for food. With many Nigerians<br />
struggling to feed; manufactured goods are<br />
not top priority now.<br />
Hospitality and<br />
Entertainment<br />
This sector was simply wiped out during<br />
the lockdown. Many of the investors might<br />
never recover. And just as some people were<br />
looking towards the Yuletide to, at least, reopen<br />
shop, another lockdown is threatened.<br />
Millions of Nigerians have lost their jobs<br />
from the first lockdown. Another one will<br />
dash all hopes of getting re-engaged any<br />
time soon. Ali Baba and comedians will have<br />
to wait.<br />
Remittances<br />
reduced<br />
Close to twelve per cent of foreign<br />
exchange coming into Nigeria is from legal<br />
and illegal remittances. The foreign<br />
exchange coming through that source has<br />
helped to moderate domestic exchange<br />
rates. Global COVID-19 and universal<br />
lockdown had dealt a mortal blow to<br />
remittances. Nigerians abroad who were<br />
just barely surviving had little left to send<br />
home. Round two of global lockdown<br />
means that Nigerian recipients of money<br />
from abroad are in for a tough time in the<br />
early months of 2021 at least.<br />
IMMEDIATE<br />
FUTURE IS BLEAK<br />
“There are no desperate situations; only<br />
desperate men” - Joseph Goebbels, 1897-<br />
1945, VBQ p 38.<br />
Worldwide government officials are<br />
desperate as this year’s global recession<br />
appears likely to continue till at least the<br />
first half of next year. Aggregate demand<br />
for crude will remain low; so will the<br />
average price. Nigeria lacks any other<br />
exportable commodity which will provide<br />
the revenue we need to achieve the targets<br />
set out in the 2021 budget – which is already<br />
demolished even before the year starts.<br />
Try as the Central Bank might, it is going<br />
to be difficult to keep exchange rates from<br />
deteriorating in 2021. Galloping inflation<br />
will follow and a greater percentage of the<br />
national revenue will go into debt-servicing.<br />
SEVEN IMPERATIVES<br />
TO GET NIGERIA’S<br />
ECONOMY GROWING<br />
“Well my friend, get me out of danger. You<br />
can make your fine speech afterwards” -<br />
Jean De La Fontaine, 1621-1695, VBQ p<br />
68.<br />
As a friend of Nigeria, I feel duty bound to<br />
obey the French writer by offering some (only<br />
some) of the ideas that will help us out of<br />
crisis.<br />
Most economic “miracles” in history have<br />
hinged on the countries involved selecting<br />
and removing certain obstacles to progress.<br />
Each was unique and cannot be totally<br />
duplicated elsewhere. To me, Nigeria will<br />
progress rapidly if:<br />
•Government checks the activities of<br />
herdsmen, bandits and kidnappers of<br />
farmers. Without this the exodus from farms<br />
will continue.<br />
•Central Bank of Nigeria, CBN, has made<br />
credit facilities available for expansion of<br />
agriculture. But, farmers are not able to<br />
access the funds because there is a bottle<br />
neck which must be removed.<br />
•Government should concession<br />
everything that can possibly be.<br />
•Federal and state governments should<br />
consider and introduce toll gates. Toll is a<br />
user’s surcharge. If you don’t use, you don’t<br />
pay. Non-users should not be subsidising<br />
users.<br />
•Downsize governments; there are too<br />
many ministries and agencies.<br />
•Federal and state governments should<br />
aim at cost recovery for services provided;<br />
while making special allowance for the aged<br />
– 70+<br />
• EVERY LOAN TAKEN MUST BE FOR<br />
A SPECIFIC PROJECT WHICH WILL<br />
REPAY THE LOAN WITH INTEREST. NO<br />
MORE LOANS SHOULD BE TAKEN TO<br />
FUND CONSUMPTION.