29112020
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
PAGE 8—SUNDAY VANGUARD, NOVEMBER 29, 2020<br />
‘Why we may not<br />
exit recession in<br />
first quarter of 2021’<br />
By Peter Egwuatu, Assistant Business Editor<br />
A<br />
chartered stockbroker and Executive Vice<br />
Chairman, HIGHCAP Securities Limited, Mr.<br />
David Adonri, in this interview, speaks on how<br />
Nigeria got into recession, the implication and possible<br />
way out among other things.<br />
Nigeria found itself in another<br />
recession in five years. Could it have<br />
been avoided?<br />
Nigeria’s economy is prone to recession due<br />
to its fragility. The economy has not been built<br />
to last. It has inherent structural deficiencies<br />
preventing it from withstanding stress.<br />
Recession in Nigeria’s economy is an accident<br />
waiting to happen. The last time Nigeria’s<br />
economy entered recession was when GDP<br />
contracted in 2016. Then, it contracted by -<br />
0.67 percent in the first quarter and fell into<br />
recession in the second quarter when GDP<br />
contracted by -1.49 percent. At the end of 2016,<br />
GDP had contracted by -1.73 percent. The<br />
recession eventually ended when GDP grew<br />
by 0.55 percent in the second quarter of 2017,<br />
after a negative position in the first quarter of<br />
2017. That recession lasted for one year.<br />
For the second time in five years, Nigeria’s<br />
economy has fallen again into recession. The<br />
country’s GDP contracted by -3.62 percent in<br />
the third quarter of 2020, after contracting by<br />
-6.1 percent.<br />
Several factors contributed to the 2016<br />
recession, the most important being crash in<br />
crude oil price. The economic boom of 2013,<br />
which saw inflation rate at single digit and<br />
GDP growth rate of 5.49 percent, fizzled out<br />
in July 2014 as a result of crash in crude oil<br />
price from USD111.8 per barrel continuously<br />
to as low as USD30.7 per barrel in January<br />
2016. That drastic drop put serious pressure<br />
on Nigeria’s foreign reserve, causing scarcity<br />
of forex, high inflation rate and devaluation<br />
of the naira. The tapering of Quantitative<br />
Easing by US Federal Reserve Bank in 2014<br />
also complicated issues for the Nigerian<br />
economy which was already reeling from the<br />
tension soaked build-up to the 2015 general<br />
election. The economic decline from 2nd<br />
quarter of 2014 intensified amidst laxity by<br />
government to take necessary remedial<br />
measures to avert the recession of 2016. The<br />
current recession is not surprising because of<br />
the devastating impact of COVID-19<br />
pandemic. Almost every country in the world<br />
suffered COVID-19 induced recession. If the<br />
Nigerian economy was more resilient,<br />
perhaps the impact would have been milder,<br />
considering the slower rate of transmission of<br />
the disease locally. Before the onset of the<br />
pandemic in February 2020, signs of weakness<br />
in Nigeria’s economy were apparent. Due to<br />
its fragility, early in January 2020, a global<br />
rating agency, Moody’s & Fitch had<br />
downgraded the Nigerian economy from<br />
stable to negative. The widespread<br />
devastation of the pandemic, whose intensity<br />
surpasses 2008 global financial crisis, only<br />
worsened the country’s steadily deteriorating<br />
economy. Other than disruptions to global<br />
trade and financial flow caused by COVID-<br />
19, Nigeria’s economy has been terrorised by<br />
•Prof. Adonri<br />
worsening insecurity and debilitating selfinduced<br />
trade containment.<br />
Experts have predicted hard times.<br />
Would the times really be as hard as<br />
they predicted?<br />
Recession is a backward movement of the<br />
economy from a previous position. It is a<br />
difficult time for a country when there is less<br />
trade and industrial activity than usual and<br />
more factors of production are unemployed.<br />
During recession, national and household<br />
incomes drop. Non-performing debts escalate.<br />
Government, corporations and households<br />
are unable to meet their financial obligations.<br />
Recession escalates poverty and provokes<br />
social unrest.<br />
The present case of Nigeria is more pathetic<br />
than recession. Simultaneously, the economy<br />
is faced with galloping inflation. This terrible<br />
condition is known as<br />
Stagflation.<br />
Inflation rate has risen<br />
in Nigeria for fifteen<br />
straight months, moving<br />
steadily from 11.02<br />
percent in August 2019 to<br />
14.23 percent in October<br />
2020. It is projected to<br />
reach 15 percent in<br />
December 2020<br />
according to the forecast<br />
made in recent Nigeria<br />
Economic Sustainability<br />
Plan (NESP 2020).<br />
Hyperinflation reduces<br />
the buying power of<br />
money, weakens<br />
domestic currency,<br />
constricts the disposable<br />
income of households,<br />
deepens poverty and<br />
escalates the cost of<br />
projects. Economies<br />
crave non-inflationary<br />
growth for development<br />
to be meaningful.<br />
All the<br />
adverse<br />
consequences<br />
of<br />
population<br />
explosion on<br />
the socio<br />
economy<br />
are already<br />
evident<br />
How<br />
can<br />
g o v e r n m e n t<br />
e n c o u r a g e<br />
production and exports to earn foreign<br />
exchange and boost the economy?<br />
Stagflation means that the economy is<br />
shrinking while costs are increasing. Domestic<br />
industrial and agricultural outputs are falling.<br />
Nigeria’s fiscal economy (production and<br />
trade) has suffered a series of setbacks since<br />
independence which has weakened its<br />
foundation. It is highly import dependent.<br />
Nigerian industries rely heavily on imported<br />
capital goods and raw materials to survive.<br />
Any time there is shortage of forex, their<br />
production is crippled. Nigeria also lacks the<br />
engineering infrastructure to sustain the<br />
productive momentum of industries and make<br />
the economy competitive and internally selfregenerating.<br />
This is a structural defect that<br />
cannot be fixed overnight.<br />
Nigeria’s inflation is essentially caused by<br />
her deficient supply-side economy, worsened<br />
by insecurity and scarcity of forex. Boosting<br />
inflow of hard currency through export may<br />
not be immediately feasible as a second wave<br />
of COVID-19 hamper the demand for crude<br />
oil and diaspora remittances wane. Other<br />
than crude oil which is the mainstay of<br />
Nigeria’s export economy, now in limbo,<br />
insecurity has already dented the country’s<br />
economy. Additionally, Nigeria’s<br />
manufacturing sector lacks the capacity to<br />
compete in global market, thus limiting<br />
available options for a leap in foreign income.<br />
This is why government is running from pillar<br />
to post trying desperately to secure foreign<br />
survival loans.<br />
What could have been done by<br />
government to avert recession?<br />
The high frequency of Nigeria’s economic<br />
bust is not surprising. Whenever the economy<br />
is subjected to little stress, be it political, social,<br />
trade dislocation, or natural disaster, it falls<br />
into immediate crisis. Between independence<br />
and the 1970s, Nigeria’s four years<br />
development plan cycles planned and built<br />
the economy to pro-actively forestall threats<br />
in future. They were geared towards the laying<br />
of a solid foundation for self-reliance. That<br />
objective became a mirage after the fourth<br />
national development plan was jettisoned by<br />
the next federal administration. The<br />
subsequent strategic plans which ended in<br />
2000, 2010 and ending 2020, were more of<br />
sloganeering rather than<br />
genuine attempts at building a<br />
resilient economy that lasts.<br />
Nigeria’s economy rests on a<br />
shaky structural foundation,<br />
hence the resort to short term<br />
panic measures to tackle<br />
economic crisis. If the necessary<br />
economic structures were in<br />
place before onset of COVID-19<br />
pandemic, there would have<br />
been enough inventory of<br />
consumer goods and financial<br />
reserve to see us through the<br />
period of lockdown. Now, we<br />
would only have been grappling<br />
with recession like Europe, Asia<br />
and America and not the<br />
harshness of Stagflation. Credit<br />
must be given to government for<br />
early lockdown and timely<br />
reopening of the economy<br />
otherwise, the economic crisis<br />
would have been worse. Apart<br />
from China, no other country<br />
succeeded in averting current<br />
recession. China’s world-class<br />
engineering infrastructure and<br />
early stern measures to curtail<br />
spread of COVID-19, enabled<br />
the country to sustain its fiscal<br />
economy. Although Nigeria was<br />
still functioning at low rate internally, drastic<br />
decline in demand for crude oil and decline of<br />
imports overwhelmed the economy. These are<br />
factors beyond the control of government and<br />
they are still prevalent.<br />
Can the monetary and fiscal policies<br />
proposed by government yield positive<br />
GDP?<br />
The dichotomy between fiscal and monetary<br />
policies has almost disappeared in Nigeria.<br />
In addition to formulating and executing<br />
monetary policies, Nigeria’s monetary<br />
authority, Central Bank of Nigeria, CBN, now<br />
also formulates fiscal policies presumably to<br />
plug fiscal gaps. It engages in formulation of<br />
trade policies and dishes out stimulus<br />
packages to industries. Government engages<br />
in an administrative method which<br />
misallocates public hard currency in a manner<br />
detrimental to the integrity and efficiency of<br />
Nigeria’s macro economy.<br />
The federal government said Nigeria<br />
will exit recession in first quarter of<br />
2021 while the World Bank maintained<br />
that the nation is at a critical<br />
juncture…<br />
It will be miraculous if Nigeria exits<br />
recession in the first quarter of 2021. The<br />
headwinds against the economy are not likely<br />
to disappear fully in first quarter of 2021. It is<br />
not likely that farm security will be restored<br />
early next year as Boko Haram, bandits and<br />
herdsmen are increasing their rampage.<br />
Despite the euphoria surrounding the<br />
emergence of effective COVID-19 vaccine,<br />
disruptions by the pandemic may persist<br />
beyond first quarter of 2021, hampering<br />
Nigeria’s crude oil export and affecting<br />
diaspora remittances adversely. Agriculture<br />
and crude oil are the main drivers of the<br />
economy. Their probability of recovery in<br />
early 2021 is remote. There is also no<br />
indication that the land borders will reopen<br />
soon to facilitate intra African trade. Nigeria’s<br />
structural deficiencies cannot be corrected<br />
within such a short period warranting an<br />
optimistic view that manufacturing can close<br />
any gap. The social environment remains<br />
charged as law and order have broken down<br />
in parts of the country. Consequently, the basis<br />
for government’s optimism that the economy<br />
will exit recession in first quarter of 2021 is<br />
difficult to understand. Government appears<br />
to be concerned only about recession. They<br />
are oblivious of the dire consequences of<br />
galloping inflation.<br />
What options do you think should be<br />
explored?<br />
Nigeria’s economic crisis is deeper than<br />
recession. It is Stagflation which is a deadly<br />
crisis that is difficult to eliminate. The<br />
macroeconomic policies so far enunciated<br />
by government are principally targeted at<br />
combating the recession but may also<br />
intensify the galloping inflation. The<br />
situation can degenerate into a serious<br />
hyperinflation if CBN’s expansionary<br />
monetary policy fails to stimulate<br />
production. Stagflation is not an economic<br />
crisis you can just spend your way out from.<br />
It requires careful identification of the<br />
specific factors slowing the economy and<br />
those fueling inflation and acting to<br />
eliminate them one by one. This is an<br />
opportunity to address the long term<br />
structural deficiencies and imbalances that<br />
make the economy fragile and import<br />
dependent. If we do not start addressing<br />
them now, the environment that provokes<br />
recession will continue to hound the<br />
economy. A critical imbalance in the<br />
economy is the ever increasing demand<br />
pressure piled by uncontrolled growth of<br />
the population. Purpose of economy is to<br />
meet the needs of people. Between<br />
independence and now, Nigeria’s<br />
population has increased by 390 percent.<br />
All the adverse consequences of population<br />
explosion on the socio economy are already<br />
evident. Excessive growth of population has<br />
orchestrated consumption and hampered<br />
savings accumulation in the economy.<br />
Incidences of recession can be minimized<br />
in Nigeria if demand management through<br />
population control is also factored into<br />
macroeconomic policies.