The Star: February 18, 2021
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
• By Anna Leask<br />
A WOMAN badly injured<br />
in the <strong>February</strong> 22, 2011,<br />
earthquake and wrongly cut<br />
off from ACC payments is<br />
owed more than $236,000 in<br />
backdated compensation – but<br />
more than half will be used to<br />
refund another Government<br />
department for benefits she was<br />
forced to seek to survive.<br />
Tattoo artist Bonnie Singh is<br />
now appealing the “debt” and<br />
feels ACC should repay it out<br />
of its own coffers, saying if her<br />
weekly compensation wasn’t<br />
stopped she never would have<br />
needed benefits.<br />
Singh, who lives in Lyttelton<br />
with her teenage daughter, was a<br />
receptionist at the Southern Ink<br />
tattoo studio in <strong>February</strong> 2011.<br />
When the quake shook the<br />
city, Singh was crushed by falling<br />
concrete and knocked unconscious<br />
but managed to drag<br />
herself through a tiny hole in the<br />
rubble to safety.<br />
She broke eight vertebrae,<br />
suffered a head injury and concussion<br />
and was diagnosed with<br />
post-traumatic stress disorder.<br />
Unable to work after the quake<br />
and with ongoing medical issues,<br />
Singh was initially covered by<br />
ACC payments.<br />
In early 2013 she was advised<br />
that she had been assessed as being<br />
able to work 30 hours a week<br />
or more in her pre-injury employment<br />
– and that she was no longer<br />
entitled to weekly compensation<br />
and “all other supports”.<br />
She protested at the time but<br />
got nowhere. So, believing she<br />
was no longer entitled to ACC<br />
and still unable to work because<br />
of ongoing pain, she applied<br />
for other Government benefits<br />
through Work and Income New<br />
Zealand under the Ministry of<br />
Social Development.<br />
From 2013 to 2019 Singh, believing<br />
she could not get support,<br />
had no contact with ACC.<br />
But last year, fed up with struggling<br />
to make ends meet, she<br />
asked advocate Fiona Radford to<br />
look at her case.<br />
Latest Canterbury news at starnews.co.nz<br />
5<br />
Quake victim may have to repay benefits<br />
She hoped to get funding for<br />
pain management acupuncture<br />
but Radford found she was entitled<br />
to much more.<br />
In November the NZ Herald<br />
revealed that ACC agreed Singh<br />
should not have been cut off,<br />
saying its initial decision had<br />
been replaced and she was now<br />
deemed “incapacitated for preinjury<br />
employment” from the<br />
week compensation was cut in<br />
2013 until now – seven years.<br />
ACC then calculated a lumpsum<br />
back payment for Singh.<br />
Singh has given the Herald<br />
permission to report that ACC<br />
agreed to pay her $236,165<br />
(before tax) in backdated weekly<br />
compensation.<br />
DISAPPOINTING:<br />
Bonnie Singh has<br />
received $236,000<br />
in backdated ACC<br />
but more than<br />
half of that is<br />
needed to refund<br />
other Government<br />
support she was<br />
forced to seek.<br />
PHOTO:<br />
SARAH IVEY<br />
However, $129,642 must be repaid<br />
to WINZ for benefits Singh<br />
received since 2013 – leaving her<br />
with $106,523.<br />
An additional “debt” of<br />
just over $27,000 is also owed<br />
to WINZ for other support<br />
supplements she received.<br />
Just days before the 10-year<br />
anniversary of the devastating<br />
quake Singh received her portion<br />
of the money.<br />
Although she appreciated the<br />
cash as it would allow her to<br />
work less and finally focus more<br />
on her healing – she was disappointed<br />
the WINZ repayments<br />
were not being paid by ACC.<br />
Radford was appealing ACC’s<br />
decision around the payment<br />
Thursday <strong>February</strong> <strong>18</strong> <strong>2021</strong> <strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
and also the WINZ “debt”.<br />
ACC chief operating officer<br />
Mike Tully said ACC looked into<br />
covering the outstanding debt as<br />
a payment “outside of scope”.<br />
“We found there was no error<br />
on our behalf and declined this<br />
outside of scope payment.<br />
“We do not believe we have<br />
made an error nor did we cut<br />
off her entitlements – we weren’t<br />
paying weekly compensation<br />
to Bonnie for around six years<br />
because there was no contact<br />
from her nor her GP during this<br />
period.<br />
“We agreed that Bonnie hadn’t<br />
recovered from her 2011 injuries<br />
and have confirmed we will reinstate<br />
and backdate her weekly<br />
compensation.”<br />
Tully said he was “satisfied<br />
there is no error” and the MSD<br />
had to be paid back under New<br />
Zealand law.<br />
“When we agree to backdate<br />
weekly compensation, our legislation<br />
requires us to repay the<br />
Ministry of Social Development<br />
for any benefit a client receives for<br />
periods covered by the backdated<br />
weekly compensation,” he said.<br />
“This is to avoid people in<br />
effect being paid twice.”<br />
Tully said ACC was<br />
“committed to working with<br />
Bonnie” to make sure she had<br />
the help and support she needed.<br />
– NZ Herald<br />
rockmelon ........................................ 2<br />
Bagged Capsicums 1kg .......... 2<br />
Yellow Nectarines ................. 3<br />
Perlas Potatoes 1.5kg ......... 5<br />
Baby Heirloom Tomatoes<br />
200g ........................................................... 1<br />
new season<br />
Bagged Carrots 1.5kg .......... 1<br />
Beef Porterhouse Steak ... 21<br />
pork leg steak ............................ 10<br />
lamb leg steak ........................... 17<br />
Skin-on Chicken Breast .... 8<br />
beef bolar roast ..................... 12<br />
.99<br />
each<br />
.99<br />
each<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
.99<br />
each<br />
.99<br />
each<br />
.99<br />
each<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
At<br />
we have...<br />
FRIDAY TO<br />
SUNDAY ONLY<br />
Raspberries 125g ....................... 3<br />
watermelon ................................... 1<br />
Butterflied Lamb Legs ..... 16<br />
Chicken Breast<br />
Schnitzel ........................................... 10<br />
.99<br />
each<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
.99<br />
kg<br />
Check our website for<br />
your local stores opening hours<br />
All our fresh meat is 100% NZ FARMED. specials VAlid<br />
15th <strong>February</strong> - 21st <strong>February</strong> <strong>2021</strong>.<br />
WHILE STOCKS LAST! ONLY AVAILABLE AT RAEWARD FRESH HAREWOOD RD, TOWER JUNCTION<br />
WWW.<br />
.CO.NZ<br />
Like us on<br />