02.06.2021 Views

The Star: June 03, 2021

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Latest Canterbury news at starnews.co.nz<br />

A retrospective look<br />

at floods in Canty<br />

Thursday <strong>June</strong> 3 <strong>2021</strong> <strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />

NEWS 17<br />

After earthquakes, flooding happens to be New<br />

Zealand’s second costliest natural hazard – and<br />

the weekend’s deluge in Christchurch reflects<br />

why. Science reporter Jamie Morton looks at<br />

three questions surrounding the disaster<br />

MANY AREAS in Canterbury<br />

have been struck by major<br />

floods during the past 150<br />

years. In Christchurch,<br />

floodwaters were sometimes<br />

knee-deep in the central city in<br />

the late 1800s and early 1900s.<br />

During early European settlement,<br />

regular river overflows<br />

occurred over the flood plain<br />

areas in and around Christchurch<br />

and Kaiapoi.<br />

Since the primary stopbank<br />

was completed in the 1930s,<br />

the Waimakariri River hasn’t<br />

flooded through the city.<br />

<strong>The</strong> most recent breakout,<br />

which happened in December<br />

1957, flooded parts of Coutts Island,<br />

in Belfast, and Kainga and<br />

was just under 4000 cumecs.<br />

Being built on the flood plain<br />

of the Waimakariri River,<br />

Canterbury is no stranger to<br />

heavy flooding no matter the<br />

season. <strong>The</strong> first stopbanks were<br />

built in the 1860s but floods still<br />

regularly happened.<br />

This week marks the anniversary<br />

of several of these<br />

events from the past. From 130<br />

to five years ago, all have caused<br />

damage, fear and anger, but<br />

also given reason to help each<br />

other out<br />

On February 4, 1868, a severe<br />

storm hit Canterbury causing<br />

wide spread damage across the<br />

region. <strong>The</strong> storm, which began<br />

the day before, continued over<br />

night, wrecking many ships at<br />

anchor in Lyttelton.<br />

<strong>The</strong> first alarm for Christchurch<br />

was raised by a Fendall<br />

Town (Fendalton) resident who<br />

reported that the Waimakariri<br />

River had flooded and broken<br />

through its banks. This, in turn,<br />

sent a surge of water towards<br />

Christchurch via the Avon.<br />

Just an hour later at 1pm,<br />

the Avon had raised so much<br />

that water had begun to trickle<br />

across the Madras St bridge.<br />

Those unfortunate enough<br />

to live near the Avon and its<br />

streams were now under water<br />

HISTORY: City buildings during the 1868 flood.<br />

PHOTO: PEELINGBACKHISTORY.CO.NZ<br />

– in some places four feet deep.<br />

Tearing away at its own banks,<br />

knocking down fences and<br />

drowning hundreds of hoof<br />

stock, quite a grand pile of<br />

debris rolled into the city with<br />

the torrent.<br />

Police and workmen from the<br />

city council were dispatched out<br />

into the affected areas, helping<br />

people to evacuate their homes<br />

and to clear away any dangerous<br />

debris from the waters.<br />

Victoria St was even dug up<br />

to form a stop bank in the hope<br />

this would halt the flood – it<br />

didn’t. By nightfall, Market<br />

Place (Victoria Square) was<br />

knee deep in water, wrecking<br />

the businesses that called the<br />

place home. One man had to<br />

be rescued when he attempted<br />

to make his way through the<br />

flood. He fell into a hole that<br />

had been dug away by the water<br />

and almost drowned.<br />

Throughout the night, cabbies<br />

drove people back and forth in<br />

their hansom cabs for six dimes<br />

per head. For years, many<br />

remembered the cab’s lanterns<br />

flickering over the eerie black<br />

waters.<br />

Christchurch was not the<br />

only town affected. Kaiapoi<br />

was completely under water<br />

and many bridges, roads and<br />

railways, had been swept away<br />

from the Waimakariri and<br />

Selwyn Rivers. Communication<br />

by telegraph had kept Canterbury<br />

in touch with the rest of<br />

the country but by the time the<br />

floodwaters began to drop back,<br />

only the line between Christchurch<br />

and Lyttelton remained.<br />

An engineer who predicted<br />

that the Waimakariri would<br />

flood eventually was William<br />

Bray (his farm is now the<br />

suburb of Avonhead). His<br />

warnings were not taken<br />

seriously though.<br />

<strong>The</strong> following poem was<br />

written by Crosbie Ward<br />

of <strong>The</strong> Lyttelton Times:<br />

At Avonhead lives Mr Bray,<br />

Who every morning used<br />

to say,<br />

“I should not be much<br />

surprised today<br />

If Christchurch city were<br />

swept away<br />

By the rushing, crushing,<br />

flushing, gushing<br />

Waimakariri River”<br />

He told his tale and he<br />

showed his plan,<br />

How the levels lay and the<br />

river ran;<br />

<strong>The</strong> neighbours thought<br />

him a learned man,<br />

But wished him further<br />

than Isfahan,<br />

With his wearing,<br />

tearing, flaring, scaring<br />

Waimakariri River<br />

Weekend storm a<br />

significant event<br />

WAS IT A one-in-100 year event?<br />

<strong>The</strong>re’s no question the weekend<br />

storm was a significant one.<br />

Places such as Akaroa, Methven<br />

and Winchmore received around<br />

twice their normal monthly rainfall<br />

in fewer than three days.<br />

At Lismore, near Ashburton,<br />

238mm dropped<br />

– that’s the same amount<br />

that it had received in the<br />

previous 187 days.<br />

Such was the storm’s intensity<br />

that some labelled<br />

it a “once in a century”<br />

downpour.<br />

But it’s really not that<br />

simple – and indeed such<br />

a calculation could be impossible<br />

to make.<br />

Dr Rob Bell, a scientist specialising<br />

in coastal hazards, said<br />

categorising events in such a<br />

way – as had become ingrained<br />

because of past practice – was a<br />

“problematic issue”.<br />

“We now face the ongoing<br />

influence of climate change on<br />

weather-related events that no<br />

longer fits with the assumption<br />

of no underlying change in our<br />

weather systems, climate or sea<br />

level.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> term has long been used as<br />

a measure of the likely time frame,<br />

on average, an event exceeds a<br />

certain level – whether that be<br />

a flood height, rainfall total, or<br />

storm-tide sea level – based on a<br />

Emily Lane<br />

record of historic measurements.<br />

That meant calculating a “onein-100-year”<br />

event from 50 years<br />

– or even 100 years of records –<br />

came with obvious uncertainties.<br />

Bell said a slightly better measure<br />

was the “annual exceedance<br />

probability”, or AEP.<br />

By this, a “one-in-100-<br />

year” event had a chance of<br />

one per cent each year of<br />

being reached or exceeded.<br />

“So the clock doesn’t get<br />

reset once such an event<br />

occurs, such that it won’t<br />

occur again for 100 years,”<br />

he said.<br />

“It’s like a computer<br />

picking randomly from numbers<br />

one to 100 and getting a one, then<br />

five rounds later it could be a one<br />

again.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> usual way the AEP of a<br />

flood is calculated was with river<br />

gauges, which measure the height<br />

of the water in a river at a given<br />

time.<br />

This was converted into a “flow”<br />

– or how many cumecs, or cubic<br />

metres of water, per second, were<br />

flowing down the river using a<br />

rating curve.<br />

“So for rivers where we have<br />

gauges, we have measurements<br />

of the flow in that river over<br />

time,” said Dr Emily Lane, a<br />

hydrodynamics scientist at<br />

NIWA.<br />

• Turn to page 18<br />

WIN<br />

$1000 *<br />

TOWARDS YOUR<br />

wardrobe<br />

TRANSFORMATION<br />

Request a free<br />

measure and quote<br />

from HomePlus and<br />

go into the draw to<br />

win $1000 towards<br />

your wardrobe<br />

transformation.<br />

Choose from the many<br />

stylish high quality<br />

systems - all custom<br />

made to fit your home<br />

and lifestyle.<br />

*<br />

Promotion closes 2nd August <strong>2021</strong><br />

Measured, made<br />

and installed by our<br />

team of experts.<br />

5 year warranty.<br />

AWNINGS & BLINDS BALUSTRADES FENCING & GATES INSECT SCREENS LOUVRE ROOFS SECURITY SCREENS SHOWERS WARDROBES & DOORS<br />

88 Gasson St, Sydenham | <strong>03</strong> 379 3740 | www.homeplus.co.nz

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!