Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Continues from page 22<br />
BIVAS and Bandwidth<br />
On election day, they<br />
accredit voters, after the<br />
election, they snap the image<br />
of the polling units results<br />
and transmit them to the<br />
INEC portal. Bandwidth<br />
comes in only in two respects:<br />
when we configure the<br />
BIVAS before we deploy, and<br />
we take a number of days for<br />
us to do so. So, it is not<br />
something that has to be done<br />
within six hours and when we<br />
transmit, it is preserved. But<br />
the thing with the result is that<br />
once you transmit from the<br />
polling units, even if there is<br />
no network, as you move to<br />
where there is network, even<br />
if it is a freak network, it will<br />
transmit the result. On<br />
election day, some people<br />
think that we consistently<br />
operate on connectivity<br />
during voting. You don't<br />
require internet connectivity<br />
during voting. It is done<br />
offline once you configure the<br />
BIVAS. If there's a problem<br />
with the BIVAS and you want<br />
to reconfigure it then you<br />
need bandwidth but if it's<br />
operating normally at the<br />
polling unit, then it works<br />
offline.<br />
CUPP allegation and<br />
the Suit in Owerri<br />
trying to stop use of<br />
BIVAS<br />
Officially, INEC is not aware<br />
of it, we have not been served.<br />
When we are properly served,<br />
we would respond<br />
accordingly. And if the matter<br />
is in court, there's a limit to<br />
what we can say. Just like you<br />
read the story in the media,<br />
that was how we read it in the<br />
media.<br />
Attempt to hack INEC<br />
system<br />
People are worried about<br />
what I said last week but I did<br />
it in a context. All web<br />
resources are consistently<br />
attacked, whether it is a voter<br />
registration portal, or other<br />
resources, they are<br />
consistently hacked. It is the<br />
responsibility of the<br />
organisation to be fortifying<br />
and defending the system. I<br />
also added to the statement I<br />
made, that the whole attempt<br />
actually failed and we will<br />
continue to defend it. But we<br />
are not under any illusion that<br />
the system will be attacked. In<br />
Anambra, there were several<br />
attempts to attack the portal,<br />
in fact at one point we had to<br />
create a dummy portal to<br />
divert the hackers and we<br />
successfully delivered the<br />
Anambra election and posted<br />
the result online. So far, we<br />
used the portal to conduct 105<br />
by-elections, and off cycle<br />
elections nationwide without<br />
any incidence. I know that the<br />
general elections are huge,<br />
but we have learnt a lot from<br />
what we have done. As to the<br />
defences that INEC is going<br />
to employ to protect our web<br />
resources, that is not a matter<br />
of discussion in public.<br />
Discipline of INEC staff<br />
and the reward system<br />
The reward system is<br />
consistent with what can be<br />
done under the public service<br />
rule. They are among the most<br />
committed public servants in<br />
Vanguard, MONDAY SEPTEMBER 19, 2022 — 23<br />
'We are paying for lack of trust'<br />
•Prof Mahmood Yakubu<br />
I think the<br />
best thing we<br />
can do is to set<br />
an example, as<br />
a matter of<br />
principle the<br />
commission<br />
doesn't register<br />
underage<br />
voters and we<br />
don't encourage<br />
the violation of<br />
our constitution<br />
this country. As much as<br />
possible we do what we can<br />
to take appropriate steps<br />
against transgression but<br />
there's no electoral<br />
commission in the world that<br />
conducts elections on the basis<br />
of their regular staff strength.<br />
Some call it temporary staff,<br />
in Nigeria we call them<br />
ADHOC staff. We can't recruit<br />
1.4 million in INEC simply<br />
because you want to conduct<br />
elections once every four<br />
years. So we rely on<br />
temporary staff.<br />
Primary<br />
Election<br />
contributing<br />
to the cost of<br />
litigation<br />
We have more<br />
litigations<br />
challenging the<br />
conduct of the<br />
elections by<br />
political parties<br />
and litigations arising from<br />
the conduct of the elections<br />
by INEC. The primary<br />
elections conducted by<br />
political parties have become<br />
so acrimonious. But if you<br />
compare that to the number<br />
of cases challenging the<br />
conduct of the elections by<br />
INEC, it is insignificant.<br />
What it means is that we have<br />
to be working with the<br />
political parties to strengthen<br />
their own internal democracy<br />
so that primaries are less<br />
acrimonious and court cases<br />
are reduced.<br />
Challenge of<br />
underage voting in the<br />
Northern part of the<br />
country<br />
Recall that in 2017 or 2018,<br />
we were here in Lagos when<br />
in Kano State the SIEC<br />
conducted local government<br />
elections, there were so many<br />
pictures online of underage<br />
voting in that election. First,<br />
it's not an election conducted<br />
by INEC; and my surprise is<br />
that when elections are<br />
conducted by INEC, we go<br />
around and we don't see these<br />
underage voters. What I think<br />
will be helpful to us and to<br />
this country, when you come<br />
across this kind of situation,<br />
kindly draw the attention of<br />
the commission while the<br />
process is ongoing. That is<br />
one of the most effective ways<br />
of dealing with the problem.<br />
It is against the laws of this<br />
country for any Nigerian<br />
below the age of 18 to vote.<br />
I f they are voting by<br />
someone's identity,<br />
that is a different<br />
c a s e<br />
•Prof Mahmood Yakubu<br />
altogether. I think the best<br />
thing we can do is to set an<br />
example. As a matter of<br />
principle the commission<br />
doesn't register underage<br />
voters and we don't encourage<br />
the violation of our<br />
constitution.<br />
Electronic voting<br />
It would cut-out so many<br />
things, hiring of vehicles,<br />
printing of ballot papers<br />
among others. There are<br />
several conditions attached to<br />
electronic voting and you<br />
cannot do just the electronic<br />
balloting you are talking about<br />
as the first step. It comes as a<br />
last step. The first step is to<br />
have credible biometric<br />
registered voters. Until 2010,<br />
when the commission<br />
introduced the biometric<br />
register of voters, every<br />
general elections, citizens<br />
were required to register. With<br />
every election, we register<br />
afresh. But in 2010 when the<br />
biometric register was<br />
introduced, those that have<br />
already registered did not<br />
register again. For instance,<br />
the last CVR was open to those<br />
who turned 18, citizens who<br />
could not register in previous<br />
exercises. So,<br />
we have<br />
the biometric register and we<br />
are cleaning it up. The second<br />
condition is to have a<br />
biometric accreditation of<br />
voters and that is what this<br />
country has been<br />
experiencing from 2015<br />
through all the elections,<br />
initially with the smart card<br />
readers and now with the<br />
BIVAS. The third one is the<br />
electronic transmission of<br />
results and we have started<br />
using the INEC portal<br />
supported by law. When you<br />
get the three processes right,<br />
then everything is collated<br />
with a box called the<br />
electronic machine. So the<br />
simple answer to your<br />
question is that we are almost<br />
there. But there are steps you<br />
take before you get there.<br />
Quality of Elections<br />
and vote buying<br />
Elections cannot be better<br />
than the context in which they<br />
are conducted. I asked a<br />
question deliberately at the<br />
polling unit in Berlin: I asked<br />
the equivalent of the<br />
presiding officer, 'are ballot<br />
boxes snatched here’? He<br />
looked at me for a moment, I<br />
repeated the question, they<br />
looked at one another and<br />
whispered. They didn't<br />
understand what I was<br />
talking about. It is because<br />
they did not experience that<br />
in their history, but I was<br />
talking about the<br />
environment. The quality of<br />
election is a direct reflection<br />
of the quality of the<br />
environment but it's also a<br />
chicken and egg. The<br />
environment won't change<br />
until we have quality elections<br />
that produce quality leaders.<br />
So, if people have confidence<br />
in the process, why should<br />
they buy votes? So the<br />
environment is what I<br />
emphasised on, not<br />
politicians. On vote buying,<br />
there are a number of ways to<br />
deal with it, the election<br />
commission has its own part<br />
to play, and we all in our own<br />
ways also have a quality part<br />
to play. We did two things;<br />
one, we talked about the<br />
configuration of the polling<br />
units such that it will not be<br />
easy for people who make<br />
their choices in the cubicle to<br />
express their marked ballot<br />
papers before they drop them<br />
into the ballot boxes. But<br />
remember the law says we<br />
have to do an open secret<br />
ballot system. In 1979 and<br />
1983 we had envelopes and<br />
so the ballot papers were put<br />
in an envelope. When we<br />
tried it in the Ekiti<br />
governorship<br />
election in<br />
2018, we<br />
introduced a<br />
ban, not only<br />
on smart<br />
phones, but<br />
photographic<br />
devices while<br />
voters are in the<br />
cubicle making their<br />
choices.