Summary of Submissions Report - Environmental Protection Authority
Summary of Submissions Report - Environmental Protection Authority
Summary of Submissions Report - Environmental Protection Authority
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
SUMMARY OF SUBMISSIONS REPORT<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway<br />
Proposal<br />
September 2012<br />
Submission period<br />
Saturday 14 July 2012 – Friday 10 August 2012<br />
www.epa.govt.nz
Table <strong>of</strong> Contents<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
Table <strong>of</strong> Contents .................................................................................................................................. 2<br />
1. Executive <strong>Summary</strong> ......................................................................................................................... 3<br />
2. Structure <strong>of</strong> this report .................................................................................................................... 3<br />
3. Limitations <strong>of</strong> this report ................................................................................................................. 4<br />
4. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 4<br />
4.1 Background .................................................................................................................................. 4<br />
4.2 Notification ................................................................................................................................... 5<br />
5. <strong>Submissions</strong> ..................................................................................................................................... 5<br />
5.1 <strong>Submissions</strong> received .................................................................................................................. 5<br />
5.2 Positions <strong>of</strong> submitters ................................................................................................................. 5<br />
5.3 <strong>Submissions</strong> by location and whether they wish to be heard ...................................................... 6<br />
5.4 <strong>Submissions</strong> received outside <strong>of</strong> time ......................................................................................... 7<br />
5.5 <strong>Submissions</strong> received by sector .................................................................................................. 7<br />
5.6 Trade Competition ....................................................................................................................... 8<br />
6. High-level issues raised in submissions ....................................................................................... 8<br />
Appendix One - Abbreviations ........................................................................................................... 10<br />
Appendix Two – Schedule <strong>of</strong> Submitters (submitter number) ....................................................... 14<br />
Appendix Three – Schedule <strong>of</strong> Submitters (alphabetical) ............................................................... 18<br />
Appendix Four - <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> Table ........................................................................... 22<br />
2
1. Executive <strong>Summary</strong><br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
The New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) has lodged an application for a Notice <strong>of</strong> Requirement<br />
and 29 Resource Consents with the <strong>Environmental</strong> <strong>Protection</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> (EPA) for the MacKays to<br />
Peka Peka Expressway Proposal (the proposal).<br />
Of the 725 submissions the EPA received on the proposal:<br />
408 submitters (56.3%) oppose the proposal either in full or in part, 302 submitters (41.7%) support<br />
the proposal either in full or in part, and 14 submitters (1.9%) are either neutral in full, in part, or<br />
have a mixed position. One submitter chose not to state a position.<br />
The majority <strong>of</strong> submitters are from Waikanae (27.3%) and Paraparaumu (18.5%).<br />
234 submitters wish to be heard at the hearing.<br />
Fifty-one submissions were received out <strong>of</strong> the submission period; <strong>of</strong> which 49 have been accepted<br />
by the Board <strong>of</strong> Inquiry.<br />
A wide range <strong>of</strong> concerns have been raised in the submissions.<br />
2. Structure <strong>of</strong> this report<br />
This report is structured to assist the MacKays to Peka Peka Proposal Board <strong>of</strong> Inquiry (the Board <strong>of</strong><br />
Inquiry) and parties in identifying the following matters:<br />
The nature <strong>of</strong> submissions (submitter position);<br />
The number <strong>of</strong> submissions received by location;<br />
The number <strong>of</strong> submitters that wish to be heard;<br />
The number <strong>of</strong> submissions received incomplete, non-complying or outside <strong>of</strong> the submission<br />
period, and the Board’s determination on these.<br />
Trends within the submissions, including submissions received per sector<br />
The number <strong>of</strong> submitters that are trade competitors;<br />
The high level concerns raised in submissions.<br />
Appendix One includes a list <strong>of</strong> commonly used abbreviations within both this report and the<br />
Appendices. Appendix Two provides an index <strong>of</strong> submitters by submission number. Appendix Three<br />
provides an index <strong>of</strong> submitters alphabetically.<br />
The ‘<strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong>’ Table provided in Appendix Four describes the nature <strong>of</strong> each<br />
individual submission, and summarises the general concerns raised in each <strong>of</strong> the individual<br />
submissions.<br />
The discussion provided in the body <strong>of</strong> this report therefore draws on the submissions themselves and<br />
the tabulated information contained within the ‘<strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong>’ table.<br />
3
3. Limitations <strong>of</strong> this report<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
Identification <strong>of</strong> trends and concerns within the report are based on information provided by<br />
submitters in their written submissions lodged during the submission period.<br />
Information is accurate at time <strong>of</strong> receipt <strong>of</strong> submission and takes into account changes requested<br />
by parties following close <strong>of</strong> submissions up to 30 August 2012.<br />
For the purpose <strong>of</strong> section 5.2 <strong>of</strong> this report, if a submitter has indicated a position both ‘in full’ and<br />
‘in part’, ‘in full’ has been recorded as their overriding position.<br />
The categorisation <strong>of</strong> information in section 5.5 <strong>of</strong> this report were based on the submitter name on<br />
the submission form and does not reflect if an individual submission refers to businesses or other<br />
types <strong>of</strong> groups in their submission.<br />
It is not unusual for submissions received on notified proposals <strong>of</strong> this nature to cover a broad<br />
range <strong>of</strong> issues and <strong>of</strong>fer differing levels <strong>of</strong> detail. Whilst each submission can be unique, the<br />
summary <strong>of</strong> the submissions necessarily involves a degree <strong>of</strong> generalisation. Summaries are<br />
therefore not a replication <strong>of</strong> the original submission. The original submission should be referred to<br />
at all times for the full content <strong>of</strong> the submission. Full copies <strong>of</strong> all <strong>of</strong> the submissions are available<br />
as PDF (Portable Document Format) files on the EPA website.<br />
The <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> table in Appendix Four needs to be regarded with caution. The<br />
analysis is based solely on the content <strong>of</strong> the submission form and the stated position <strong>of</strong> the<br />
submitter. In some cases it is not immediately evident what decision a submitter seeks from the<br />
Board <strong>of</strong> Inquiry with respect to the information provided in their submission. If the submitter has<br />
strongly inferred through the reasons for the submission and/or their stated submitter position, the<br />
EPA has interpreted this inference and stated (inferred) in Appendix Four.<br />
4. Introduction<br />
4.1 Background<br />
On 20 April 2012, the <strong>Environmental</strong> <strong>Protection</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> (EPA) received an application from the<br />
NZTA for a Notice <strong>of</strong> Requirement and 29 Resource Consents ("the matters") for the MacKays to Peka<br />
Peka Expressway Proposal (the proposal).<br />
The proposal involves the construction, operation, and maintenance <strong>of</strong> an approximately 16 km<br />
section <strong>of</strong> State highway, formed to an expressway standard, from 2 kms north <strong>of</strong> MacKays Crossing<br />
to Te Kowhai Road, Peka Peka in the Kāpiti Coast District.<br />
The proposal will provide for an Expressway with two lanes <strong>of</strong> traffic in each direction, connections<br />
with local roads at four interchanges, new local roads and access roads to maintain local connectivity,<br />
and an additional bridge crossing over the Waikanae River.<br />
The EPA recommended to the Minister for the Environment to direct the matters to a board <strong>of</strong> inquiry<br />
for decision. The Minister has accepted the EPA’s recommendation and directed the matters to be<br />
4
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
decided by a board <strong>of</strong> inquiry under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The role <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Board <strong>of</strong> Inquiry is to hear and decide these matters.<br />
4.2 Notification<br />
The proposal was publicly notified on Saturday 14 July 2012 and closed at 5pm on Friday 10 August<br />
2012, by way <strong>of</strong> public notices in the New Zealand Herald, the Dominion Post, The Press, and the<br />
Otago Daily Times. A public notice was also placed in the Kapiti Observer on Monday 16 July 2012.<br />
The 20 working day submission period was from 14 July 2012 to 10 August 2012.<br />
A submission form tailored to the proposal was prepared by the EPA, and made available to<br />
submitters, in hard copy, electronic copy, and through an online form on the EPA website.<br />
5. <strong>Submissions</strong><br />
5.1 <strong>Submissions</strong> received<br />
The EPA received 676 complete submissions before the close <strong>of</strong> the submission period at 5pm Friday<br />
10 August 2012.<br />
On 28 August 2012 the Board <strong>of</strong> Inquiry granted a waiver to accept an additional 49 submissions the<br />
EPA received as incomplete, late or non-complying.<br />
The total number <strong>of</strong> submissions received on the proposal is 725.<br />
5.2 Positions <strong>of</strong> submitters<br />
A total <strong>of</strong> 408 submitters (56.3%) opposed the proposal either in full or in part, whilst a total <strong>of</strong> 302<br />
submitters (41.7%) supported the proposal either in full or in part. These positions were received<br />
either as a check box on the submission form, or within the written submission itself if a submission<br />
form was not used. For the purpose <strong>of</strong> this report, if a submitter has indicated a position both ‘in full’<br />
and ‘in part’, ‘in full’ has been recorded as their overriding position. Further information is provided in<br />
the table below.<br />
September 2012<br />
5
Table 1: Total Number <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> by submitter position<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
Submitter Position No. <strong>of</strong> submissions Proportion<br />
Oppose in Full 362 49.9%<br />
Oppose in Part 44 6.1%<br />
Oppose & Neutral in Part 2 0.3%<br />
Oppose in full/part (total) 408 56.3%<br />
Support in Full 282 38.9%<br />
Support in Part 20 2.8%<br />
Support in full/part (total) 302 41.7%<br />
Neutral in Full 9 1.2%<br />
Neutral in Part 3 0.4%<br />
Support & Oppose in Part 2 0.3%<br />
Neutral in full/part & mixed (total) 14 1.9%<br />
Did not state 1 0.1%<br />
Total 725 100%<br />
5.3 <strong>Submissions</strong> by location and whether they wish to be heard<br />
The location <strong>of</strong> submitters is outlined in the table below. Those located from other areas than those<br />
stated in the table below have been grouped into the ‘other’ category. Of the 725 submitters, 234<br />
(32.3%) indicated that they wish to be heard in support <strong>of</strong> their submission.<br />
6
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
Table 5.2: Total Number <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> by location & whether they wish to be heard<br />
Location<br />
September 2012<br />
No. <strong>of</strong><br />
submissions<br />
Proportion<br />
No. that wish to<br />
be heard<br />
Proportion<br />
Waikanae 196 27.0% 64 27.3%<br />
Paraparaumu 134 18.5% 35 15%<br />
Other 87 12.0% 32 13.7%<br />
Raumati Beach 71 9.8% 27 11.5%<br />
Raumati South 67 9.2% 24 10.2%<br />
Paraparaumu Beach 53 7.3% 10 4.3%<br />
Waikanae Beach 28 3.9% 7 3%<br />
Paekakariki 27 3.7% 14 6%<br />
Otaki 24 3.3% 10 4.3%<br />
Otaihanga 18 2.5% 6 2.6%<br />
Te Horo 11 1.5% 1 0.4%<br />
Peka Peka 9 1.3% 4 1.7%<br />
Total 725 100% 234 100%<br />
5.4 <strong>Submissions</strong> received outside <strong>of</strong> time<br />
Fifty-one submissions were:<br />
Received outside <strong>of</strong> time;<br />
Received incomplete during the submission period, requiring further details that were received<br />
outside <strong>of</strong> time;<br />
Served on the NZTA, but not the EPA.<br />
On behalf <strong>of</strong> the Board <strong>of</strong> Inquiry, the chairperson granted a waiver to accept 49 <strong>of</strong> these 51<br />
submissions on 23 August 2012.<br />
The remaining two submissions (numbers 738 and 739) were provided prior to the submission period<br />
starting and the EPA have been unable to contact the parties to obtain relevant details. The Board <strong>of</strong><br />
Inquiry will consider accepting these submissions should further information be provided.<br />
5.5 <strong>Submissions</strong> received by sector<br />
The highest sector <strong>of</strong> submissions was from individuals, the proportion <strong>of</strong> businesses, advocacy<br />
groups, and other organisations is provided in the table below.<br />
7
Table 5.3: Total Number <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> by Sector<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
Sector Number Proportion<br />
Individual 650 89.7%<br />
Business 32 4.4%<br />
Advocacy group 25 3.5%<br />
District/Regional Councils & Government Agencies 12 1.6%<br />
Other organisations 4 0.5%<br />
Iwi groups 2 0.3%<br />
Total 725 100%<br />
5.6 Trade Competition<br />
Of the 725 submissions received, no submitters indicated they were trade competitors. It is also noted<br />
that a number <strong>of</strong> submitters did not answer this question.<br />
6. High-level issues raised in submissions<br />
The submissions raised a range <strong>of</strong> issues covering the following:<br />
Location & alternative options available (e.g. Western Link Road)<br />
Size and type <strong>of</strong> road (e.g. expressway vs local road)<br />
Traffic congestion, travel times and road saftey<br />
Local road connections and access to facilities<br />
Separation <strong>of</strong> local traffic from through traffic<br />
SH1 road resilience and natural hazard resilience<br />
Emergency services access and freight movement<br />
Need to consider an integrated transport system<br />
Air pollution, noise, dust and vibration from construction and operation<br />
General adverse environmental effects, including flora and fauna<br />
Effects on waterways, wetlands, streams and ecological areas<br />
Stormwater storage areas and treatment<br />
Flooding<br />
Peat replacement and CO2 emissions from peat<br />
Community severance and social/community effects<br />
Cultural, archaeology and heritage effects<br />
Lifestyle and recreational disruption<br />
Visual/landscape changes<br />
Health, wellbeing and stress<br />
Removal <strong>of</strong> houses<br />
8
Property de-valuation<br />
Economic viability and regional growth<br />
Costs<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
9
Appendix One - Abbreviations<br />
AEE<br />
BoI<br />
BCR<br />
CEMP<br />
CO2<br />
CPTED<br />
CNVMP<br />
DOC<br />
EPA<br />
KCDC<br />
LTCCP<br />
M2PP<br />
No.<br />
NZ<br />
NZHPT<br />
NZTA<br />
PPF<br />
PT<br />
QE Park<br />
RMA<br />
RoNS<br />
SAHA<br />
SH<br />
SH1<br />
TGM<br />
US<br />
WCC<br />
WLR<br />
WRC<br />
September 2012<br />
Assessment <strong>of</strong> <strong>Environmental</strong> Effects<br />
Board <strong>of</strong> Inquiry<br />
Benefit Cost Ratio<br />
Construction <strong>Environmental</strong> Management Plan<br />
Carbon Dioxide<br />
Crime Prevention through <strong>Environmental</strong> Design<br />
Construction Noise and Vibration Management Plan<br />
Department <strong>of</strong> Conservation<br />
<strong>Environmental</strong> <strong>Protection</strong> <strong>Authority</strong><br />
Kāpiti Coast District Council<br />
Long Term Council Community Plan<br />
Mackays to Peka Peka Expressway<br />
Number<br />
New Zealand<br />
New Zealand Historic Places Trust<br />
New Zealand Transport Agency (the applicant)<br />
Protected Premise and Facility<br />
Public Transport<br />
Queen Elizabeth Park<br />
Resource Management Act 1991<br />
Roads <strong>of</strong> National Significance<br />
SAHA International Limited<br />
State Highway<br />
State Highway One<br />
Transmission Gully Motorway<br />
United States <strong>of</strong> America<br />
Wellington City Council<br />
Western Link Road<br />
Greater Wellington Regional Council<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
10
List <strong>of</strong> Matters<br />
[1]<br />
[2]<br />
[3]<br />
[4]<br />
[5]<br />
[6]<br />
[7]<br />
[8]<br />
[9]<br />
[10]<br />
[11]<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
NSP 12/01.001 Notice <strong>of</strong> Requirement: Notice <strong>of</strong> requirement for a new designation for the<br />
construction, operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> a State highway (MacKays to Peka Peka<br />
Expressway) from 2km north <strong>of</strong> MacKays Crossing to Te Kowhai Road, Peka Peka, in the Kāpiti<br />
Coast District.<br />
NSP 12/01.002 Resource Consent: The site to which the consent application relates is at 55<br />
Rata Road, Paraparaumu. Land use consent for disturbing soil containing contaminants where<br />
there is a risk to human health and changing the use <strong>of</strong> land containing contaminants where there<br />
is a risk to human health pursuant to Regulation 10 <strong>of</strong> the Resource Management (National<br />
<strong>Environmental</strong> Standard for Assessing and Managing Contaminants in Soil to Protect Human<br />
Health) Regulations 2011 (SR 2011/361).<br />
NSP 12/01.003: Land use consent to disturb soil in areas identified as being erosion prone, and<br />
undertake large scale vegetation clearance for the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.004: Land use consent to disturb soil for the construction <strong>of</strong> roading and tracking for<br />
the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.005: Discharge permit to discharge sediment and chemical flocculent in treated storm<br />
water run<strong>of</strong>f to water, and to land where it may enter water, in association with bulk earthworks for<br />
the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.006: Land use consent to undertake the following activities within Queen Elizabeth<br />
Park Drain:<br />
To place structures (culverts, rip rap, and storm water outlets) and the associated diversion<br />
and reclamation <strong>of</strong> a section <strong>of</strong> the bed in this catchment; and<br />
To remove an existing culvert;<br />
including the associated disturbance <strong>of</strong>, and deposition <strong>of</strong> material on, the bed <strong>of</strong> the watercourse<br />
in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.007: Water permit to temporarily divert the full flow <strong>of</strong> the Queen Elizabeth Park Drain<br />
during construction <strong>of</strong> the culvert and associated structures in the bed <strong>of</strong> the waterway in the<br />
vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.008: Water permit to permanently divert the full flow <strong>of</strong> the Queen Elizabeth Park<br />
Drain in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.009: Land use consent to undertake the following activities within and over Drain 7, an<br />
unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong> Drain 7 and the Wharemauku Stream:<br />
To place structures ([bridges], culverts, rip rap, and storm water outlets) and the associated<br />
diversion and reclamation <strong>of</strong> a section <strong>of</strong> the bed in this catchment; and<br />
To remove an existing culvert;<br />
including the associated disturbance <strong>of</strong>, and deposition <strong>of</strong> material on, the bed <strong>of</strong> the<br />
watercourses in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.010: Water permit to temporarily divert the flow <strong>of</strong> Drain 7, an unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong><br />
Drain 7 and the Wharemauku Stream during construction <strong>of</strong> the culvert and bridges and<br />
associated structures in the bed <strong>of</strong> the waterway in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka<br />
Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.011: Water permit to permanently divert the full flow <strong>of</strong> Drain 7 and an unnamed<br />
tributary <strong>of</strong> Drain 7 in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
[12] NSP 12/01.012: Land use consent to undertake the following activities within and over<br />
11
[13]<br />
[14]<br />
[15]<br />
[16]<br />
[17]<br />
[18]<br />
[19]<br />
[20]<br />
[21]<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
Mazengarb Drain, Waste Water Treatment Pond Drain, Landfill Drain, Otaihanga Drain, an<br />
unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong> the Muaupoko [Stream], Muaupoko Stream and the Waikanae River:<br />
To place structures ([bridges], culverts, rip rap, storm water outlets) and the associated<br />
diversion and reclamation <strong>of</strong> a section <strong>of</strong> the bed in this catchment; and<br />
To remove an existing culvert;<br />
including the associated disturbance <strong>of</strong>, and deposition <strong>of</strong> material on, the bed <strong>of</strong> the<br />
watercourses in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.013: Water permit to temporarily divert the flow <strong>of</strong> Mazengarb Drain, Waste Water<br />
Treatment Pond Drain, Landfill Drain, Otaihanga Drain, an unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong> the Muaupoko<br />
[Stream] and the Waikanae River; during construction <strong>of</strong> the culvert and bridges and associated<br />
structures in the bed <strong>of</strong> the waterway in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.014: Water permit to permanently divert the full flow <strong>of</strong> the Mazengarb Drain, Waste<br />
Water Treatment Pond Drain, Landfill Drain, Otaihanga Drain, an unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Muaupoko [Stream], Muaupoko Stream and the Waikanae River in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to<br />
Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.015: Land use consent to place structures (bridges, culverts, rip rap, and storm water<br />
outlets) within and over Market Garden Drain and Waimeha Stream; and the diversion and<br />
reclamation <strong>of</strong> a section <strong>of</strong> the bed in this catchment, including the associated disturbance <strong>of</strong>, and<br />
deposition <strong>of</strong> material on, the bed <strong>of</strong> the watercourses in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka<br />
Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.016: Water permit to temporarily divert the flow <strong>of</strong> the Market Garden Drain and<br />
Waimeha Stream during construction <strong>of</strong> the culvert and bridges and associated structures in the<br />
bed <strong>of</strong> the waterway in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.017: Water permit to permanently divert the full flow <strong>of</strong> the Market Garden Drain in the<br />
vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.018: Land use consent to undertake the following activities within and over Ngarara<br />
Creek, Kakariki Stream, Smithfield Drain, unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong> Paetawa Drain and Paetawa<br />
Drain:<br />
To place structures ([bridges], culverts, rip rap, and storm water outlets) and the associated<br />
diversion and reclamation <strong>of</strong> a section <strong>of</strong> the bed in this catchment; and<br />
To remove an existing culvert;<br />
including the associated disturbance <strong>of</strong>, and deposition <strong>of</strong> material on, the bed <strong>of</strong> the<br />
watercourses in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.019: Water permit to temporarily divert the flow <strong>of</strong> the Ngarara Creek, Kakariki Stream<br />
(at the local road bridge), Smithfield Drain, an unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong> Paetawa Drain and the<br />
Paetawa Drain; during construction <strong>of</strong> the culvert and bridges and associated structures in the<br />
bed <strong>of</strong> the waterway in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.020: Water permit to permanently divert the full flow <strong>of</strong> the Ngarara Creek, Kakariki<br />
Stream (at local road and Expressway bridges), Smithfield Drain, an unnamed tributary <strong>of</strong><br />
Paetawa Drain and the Paetawa Drain; in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.021: Land use consent to undertake the following activities within Hadfield/Te Kowhai<br />
Stream:<br />
To place structures (culverts, rip rap, and storm water outlets) and the associated diversion<br />
and reclamation <strong>of</strong> a section <strong>of</strong> the bed in this catchment; and<br />
To remove an existing culvert;<br />
12
[22]<br />
[23]<br />
[24]<br />
[25]<br />
[26]<br />
[27]<br />
[28]<br />
[29]<br />
[30]<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
including the associated disturbance <strong>of</strong>, and deposition <strong>of</strong> material on, the bed <strong>of</strong> the watercourse<br />
in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.022: Water permit to temporarily divert the flow <strong>of</strong> the Hadfield/Te Kowhai Stream;<br />
during construction <strong>of</strong> the culvert and bridges and associated structures in the bed <strong>of</strong> the<br />
waterway in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.023: Water permit to permanently divert the full flow <strong>of</strong> the Hadfield/Te Kowhai<br />
Stream; in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.024: Land use consent for the construction <strong>of</strong> bore holes for groundwater extraction,<br />
and for the formation <strong>of</strong> holes for bridge piles where this may intercept groundwater.<br />
NSP 12/01.025: Water permit to take groundwater for bore testing, dewatering <strong>of</strong> excavations,<br />
dust suppression and construction purposes.<br />
NSP 12/01.026: Water permit to divert groundwater from wetlands adjacent to the MacKays to<br />
Peka Peka Expressway.<br />
NSP 12/01.027: Land use consent for the partial reclamation <strong>of</strong> wetlands (defined as lakes),<br />
being the Raumati Manuka Wetland, Otaihanga Southern and Northern Wetlands and El Rancho<br />
Wetland, in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Project alignment, including the<br />
associated disturbance <strong>of</strong> the beds.<br />
NSP 12/01.028: Land use consent to remove vegetation in the beds <strong>of</strong> various watercourses and<br />
wetlands (defined as lakes), being the Raumati Manuka Wetland, Otaihanga Southern and<br />
Northern Wetlands and El Rancho Wetland, including the associated disturbance <strong>of</strong> the beds.<br />
NSP 12/01.029: Discharge permit to discharge treated cement contaminated water to water, and<br />
to land where it may enter water.<br />
NSP 12/01.030: Discharge permit to discharge contaminants to land from contaminated sites.<br />
13
Appendix Two – Schedule <strong>of</strong> Submitters (submitter number)<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
1 Mr Peter Knewstubb 31 Mr Tim Armstrong 61 Miss Nina Miller 92 Marico Marine NZ 122 Mr Anthony Marsh 153 Mr Peter Blackler<br />
2 Mrs Helen Booth 32 Mr Michael Welch 62 Dr Ronald Miller 93 Mr Charles Davies 123 Mr Howard Fletcher 154 Mr Jeff Wastney<br />
3 Mr Guy Weaver 33 Mr James Simpson 63 Mr Donald McFedries 94 Mrs Lorraine Davies 124 Ms Vicki Schleider Bunch 155 Mr Paul Franssen<br />
4 Mr Ian and Judith Pears 34 Mrs Norrey Simmons 64 Mr Keith Oldham 95 Mr Jeffry Adlam 125 Mr Ray & Mrs Rosemary Foss 156 Mr Anthony Ryan<br />
5 Mr Howard Ellis 35 Mr David Betteridge 65 Mr Eric Cornick 96 Mrs Lynley Davidson 126 Mr Charles Steward Hall Watson 157<br />
14<br />
Mr Stephen and Mrs Elly<br />
Simpson<br />
6 Mr Stephen Sharpe 36 Mrs Gai Foskett 66 Ms Samantha Hutcheson 97 Mr Robbie McGavin 127 Mr Clive Williams 158 Mr Trevor Morgan<br />
7 Mr Derek Chapman 37 Ms Vicki Simpson 67 Ms Mandy Wakeford 98 Mr Robert Strong 128 Mr Brian Hogg 159 Mr Ross Leggett<br />
8 Mrs Kathleen Hunter 38 Mr Warwick Wyatt 68 The Paetawa Trust 99 Mr Ross Meek 129 Ms Gillian Hill 160 Mrs Gillian Riding<br />
9 Mr Malcolm Hamilton Faulls 39 Mr John Granville 69 Ms Ann Verboeket 100 Mr Trevor Hosking 130 Mr Maurice Richardson 161<br />
Mr Robert and Mrs Cristine<br />
McGechan<br />
10 Mr Jeffrey Short 40 Mr Robin McCandless 70 Ms Sahra Kress 101 Mrs Marionne Dixon 131 Mr Steve Ferguson 162 Mr Craig Bardell<br />
11<br />
Mr Peter and Mrs Mary-Anne<br />
Smith<br />
41 Mr David Dews 71 Dr Robin Falconer 102 Mr Stephen Hudson 132 Mr John Grant 163 Mr John Edward Aburn<br />
12 Mr Jonathan Shorer 42 Ms Norma McCallum 72 Ms Dinah Hawken 103 Mrs Brenda Frazer 133 Mr Max Hooper 164 Mrs Marian Williams<br />
13 Ms Jean Murrey 43 Mr John Rapley 73 Mr Gordon Ford 104 Mrs Barbara Bourke 134 Mrs Jocelyn Vrede 165 Ms Kirsten Dobbertin<br />
14 Mrs Florence Maher 44 Mrs Lesley Blenkiron 74 Mr Jude Simpson 105 Mrs Vicky Cooper 135 Mr David Funnell 166 Mr David Milliner<br />
15 Mr Alun Hughes 45 Mr Graeme Blenkiron 75 Mrs Leanne Chapman 106 Ms Andrea Hadfield 137 Mrs Clare Borst 167 Mr Jordan Dallimore<br />
16 Ms Jamie Bull 46 Ms Ruth McKenzie 76 Ms Jane Stevenson 107 Mr William Ferguson 138 Mr Gary Cameron 168 Miss Kasey Beverdige<br />
17 Mr C. T. Brown 47 Miss Laura Dews 77<br />
Paraparaumu Beach Golf Club<br />
Inc<br />
108 Mrs Annette Parry 139 Mr T R Griffith 169 Mr Alan Hurst<br />
18 Mrs E.M. Brown 48 Mr John O'Sullivan 78 Mr Leo Barber 109 Mr Hugh Guthrie 140 Miss Jennifer Ramage 170 Mr Mark Gibbin<br />
19<br />
NZ Forest Owners Association<br />
Inc<br />
49 Mr Richard Moulton 79 Mr Rob Klaassen 110 Mr David Hanbury-Sparrow 141 Mr Brian Milne 171 Miss Kaye Nichols<br />
20 Mr Paul Judd 50 Mr Tony Lester 80<br />
Mr John and Mrs Wendy<br />
Huston<br />
111 Mrs Julie Wintle 142 Mr Ray and Mrs Allison Philpott 172<br />
Mr Krzyszt<strong>of</strong> Zajaczkowski and<br />
Ms Aleka Beaumont<br />
21 Mr Murray Lobb 51 Mr Michael Fulton 81 Mr Alan Tennyson 112 Mrs Esther Consedine 143 Mr Nathan McColl 173 Mrs Anna Douglas<br />
22 Mr Graeme Barrell 52 Mr David Foulds 82 Mr Ian Mitchell 113 Mr Peter Hawker 144 Mr David Kenchington 174 Mr Peter Lawton<br />
23 Ms Janet Milne 53 Mr Christopher Blanchard 83 Mr Malcolm Ward 114 Mr Mervyn Martin 145 Mr Stuart Pritchard 175 Mrs Mary Oldham<br />
24 Dr Kenneth Milne 54 Mr Stephen Lange 84 Office Angels Limited 115 Dr George Stuart 146 Ms Joanne Gibbons 176 Mr Bryan Anderson<br />
25 Kapiti Office Products Depot 55 Mr Michael Gilbert 85 Mr Mark Ternent 116 Mrs Jane Martin 147 Mr Wal Marshall 177 Mrs Diane Jennings<br />
26 Mr Stuart Ayres 56<br />
Ms Amanda Hager and Mr Brian<br />
Laird<br />
87 Ms Ann Ryder 117 Mr Paul Bennett 148 Mr Richard Mason 178 Transpower NZ Ltd<br />
27 Filter Clean NZ Ltd 57 Mr Derek Lynch 88 Mr Chris Stone 118 Mr Colin Kells 149 Mr Peter Jones 179 Mr Ian Basire<br />
28 Mrs Ann Saunders 58 Mr Chris Turver 89 Mrs Jennifer Adlam 119 Ms Jacky Renouf 150 Dr Kelly Hare 180 Ms Angie Cairncross<br />
29 NZ Contractors Federation 59<br />
Friends <strong>of</strong> the Waikanae River<br />
Inc.<br />
90 Nga Manu Nature Reserve 120 Mr Warwick Vrede 151 Mr Simon Jones 181 Mr Denis and Mrs Joan Joyce<br />
30 Ms Helen Potusa 60 Road Transport Forum NZ 91 Mrs Anita Schurmann 121 Mr Ralph Macquisten Wallace 152 Mrs Vera Jones 182 Mr Josef and Mrs Anne Jaeger
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
183 Mr John William Tanner 213 Mrs Beverly Vera James 243<br />
184<br />
Mr Terence and Mrs<br />
Alexandra Davies<br />
The Trustees <strong>of</strong> the Arthur<br />
Bills Resettlement Trust<br />
(property owner) and Directors<br />
<strong>of</strong> Harrisons Country<br />
Gardenworld Ltd (tenant).<br />
273 Dr Brian Hooper 304 Mrs Janis Erica Scrimshaw 334 Ms Barbara McNay<br />
214 Mrs Eleonore Franzika Wheeler 244 Mrs Shirley Barrell 274 Mr Terry McAviney 305 Mrs Jean Taylor 335 Mr Lawrence Ordish<br />
185 Ms Joanne Robertson 215 Mrs Jacqueline Williams 245 Mr Gareth Griffis 275 Mr David Moger 306 Mr Neville Taylor 336 Ms Heather Hopkirk<br />
186 Mr Alison Tanner 216 Dowco Associates Ltd 246 Mr Antony Graham Cooke 276<br />
187 Mrs Emma Maitland 217 Miss Karin Andersen 247<br />
Mr Roy John and Mrs Meryl<br />
Brenda Opie<br />
Mr Michael and Mrs Veronica<br />
Weir<br />
277 Mr Tony Lloyd 308<br />
307 Mr Patrick John Scrimshaw 337 Ms Elizabeth Ann Laing<br />
Mr Royden and Mrs Josette<br />
Bardsley<br />
338 Mr Neil K Woodbury<br />
188 Mr Anthony Staniford 218 Mr Arnold Regan 248 Bullen Consultancy 278 Ms Teresa Neches 309 Ms Loretta Anne Pomare 339 Mr James & Mrs June Kelly<br />
189<br />
190<br />
Mrs Winifred and Mr Graeme<br />
Kennedy<br />
Kapiti Emergency Medical<br />
Services Trust<br />
219 Mr David Livingston 249 Mr Mike Redman 279 Mr Richard Marshall 310 Mr Edward Laurence Cornell 340 Te Ra School<br />
220 Mrs Christine Bright 250 Mr William Reginald Morrison 280 Mr Lawrie Duncan 311 Mr William Gordon Painter 341 Ms Rachel Tandy<br />
191 Mrs Beatrice Tennyson 221 Mrs Maxine Livingston 251 Mr William Mansfield 281 Mr Gerald Ponsford 312 Mrs Linda Caroline Schager 342 Mrs Liz Welch<br />
192<br />
Mr Ross and Mr Jocelyn<br />
Fletcher<br />
222 Mr Paul Frederick Wheeler 252 CentrePort Limited 282 Mr Brian Ainger 313 Mr Clifford Driver 343 Dr Kevin & Mrs Kym Baker<br />
193 Mr Simon Frazer 223 Miss Wendy Eleanor Batterbee 253 Mr Richard Jury 283 Mr John David Barber 314 Dr Susan Mary Watterson 344<br />
194 Mrs Branka Cicak 224 Mr Stefan and Mrs Carolyn Hori 254<br />
195 Miss Jessica Jennings 225<br />
Mr Norman John and Mrs Eileen<br />
Florence Gould<br />
Whanganui Employer's<br />
Chamber <strong>of</strong> Commerce<br />
15<br />
Mr Anthony Llewellyn<br />
Watmough<br />
284 Mrs Jill Lloyd 315 Mr Aylwyn Cedric Patterson 345 Ms Susan Heald<br />
255 Mr Nigel White 285 Mrs Winsome Duncan 316 Mr Peter Watterson 346 Mr John Downie<br />
196 Mr Pieter Bosteels 226 Mr A Pullenger 256 Mr James Dryburgh 286 Mr Harold Brown 317<br />
Mrs Elaine Maree and Mr Anton<br />
Adolf Vos<br />
347<br />
Mr Alan Roy & Mrs Ann<br />
Margaret Parsonnage<br />
197 Mr Murray Hopping 227 Four Seasons Caravans 1980 Ltd 257 Mr Michael John Jensen 287 Mrs Michael Hanbury-Sparrow 318 Mr Charles Richard Fawthorpe 348 Miss Frances Vagg<br />
198 Mrs Caren June Ashford 228<br />
Mr Lennard James and Mrs<br />
Pamela Elaine Tong<br />
258 Mr Mark Edgar 289 Ms Maria Gyles 319 Mrs Sally Morton 349 Mr Gordon W Shr<strong>of</strong>f<br />
199 Ms Mary Mountier 229 Dr Susan Grace Ansell 259 Mr Tony Jack 290 Dr S Finlay 320 Ms Margaret Nixon 350 Ms Marion Isabel Sherley<br />
200 Mr Bruce Phillipps 230 Fourways Enterprises Ltd 260 Mrs Julie Margaret Jensen 291 Mr David Swann 321 Ms Sarah Biddiscombe 351 Mr Kevin H Henderson<br />
201 Mr Brian Wheeler 231 Mrs Vicki Bryden 261<br />
Dr Christopher William and<br />
Mrs Monica Dearden<br />
202 Mrs Judith Wheeler 232 Mrs Margaret Smith 262 Mr Gavin Ashworth Wright 293<br />
292 Mr Shane Walbran 322 Mr Matthew Beldham 352<br />
Dr Joy Anderton & Ms. Jill<br />
Abigail.<br />
Mr Leov Gary & Pamela Joyce<br />
Nicholson<br />
323 Mr Bernard Harrison 353 Mr Colin Duke Clayton<br />
203 Mr Richard Mansell 233 Mr Robert Smith 263 Mrs Liz Morgan 294 Mr Michael Brendan Cartmer 324 Mr Steven Tomlinson 354 Dr April S Walker<br />
204 Mr Nicholas Wheeler 234 Mr Peter Canvin 264 Mr David Ian McCrae 295<br />
Mr Michael George and Mrs<br />
Janice Merle Wood<br />
325 Mrs Sally Harrow 355 Mr Bob Cowper<br />
205 Mr Stuart and Mary Pritchard 235 Ms Jan Morgan 265 Dr Sabien van Riessen 296 Mrs Joan Kathleen Painter 326 Mr Alan Power 356 Mrs Ann Cherrington<br />
206<br />
Mr Howard Trevor and Mrs<br />
Josephine Isobel Patten<br />
236 Mr Martin Armstrong 266<br />
207 Mr David John Hare 237 Mr Adrian Aldridge 267<br />
Automobile Association<br />
Wellington District<br />
Mr Daniel Ronald and Mrs<br />
Dionne Carol Waterson<br />
297 Ms Hariata Mei Higgott 327<br />
Mr Neil Saxby & Ms Barbara<br />
Breta Mountier<br />
298 Mr Glen Wiggs 328 Mrs Prue Sisarich 358<br />
357 Mrs Catherine Keno<br />
Quinovic Property<br />
Management - Kapiti-Mana<br />
208 Mr Warwick Dobbie 238 Mr Bruce Davie 268 Mr Ruben Blok 299 Mr Martin Burton 329 Ms Christine Cecil Lenk 359 Mrs Charmaine Brauer Fluker<br />
209 Miss Marie Hare 239 Mrs Sara Boeyen 269 Mrs Pip McCarroll 300 Mr Michael Leggott 330 Religious Society <strong>of</strong> Friends 360 Mr David Forsythe<br />
210 Mr Leonard John Taylor 240 Mr Stewart Macpherson 270 Dr Bob Gregory 301 Ms Alana Bowman 331 Mr Warren David Sisarich 361 Mr Neil Kane<br />
211 Ms Diana Mary Evans 241 Miss Joanne Watson 271 Mrs Jessica Luhn 302 Mr Henry Fullerton-Smith 332 Mr Warren & Mrs Prue Sisarich 362 Mr Graham Coe<br />
212 Mr Robert Gary James 242 Mr Dean Anderson 272 Mr Alan Lough 303 Mrs Patricia Frances Wright 333 Mr S P Richardson 363 Mr David Jennings
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
364 Kapiti Gateway Motel 400 Mr Richard Cherrill 432<br />
Mrs Elizabeth and Mr Brent<br />
Waterhouse<br />
368 Mr Graeme Eric Brown 401 Mrs Judith Cherrill 433 South Pacific Roses 2011 Ltd 463 Mr Marc Pettie 493<br />
462 Mr Collin Minnaar 492 Mr Brent Hume Cherry 522 Miss Lisa White<br />
Mr Patrick John O'Brien and Ms<br />
Joanne Fisher Gray<br />
523 Mr Gary Peter Allen<br />
369 Mr John Alexander Fluker 402 Mr Iain Mackay 434 Mrs Caroline Joan Beaufort 464 Mrs Tara Lemana 494 Ms Donna Kieboom 524 Mrs Linda Diane Allen<br />
370 Mr Peter Vere-Jones 403 Mr Sam Jennings 435 Mr Laurence Petherick 465<br />
371 Mr David Simpson 404 Mrs Rachel Mackay 436 Mr Rein Purre 466<br />
372 Mrs Suzanne Vere-Jones 407 Mr Jay Brass 437<br />
Mr Andrew and Mrs Lynnette<br />
Pritchard<br />
Mr Kane Joseph and Mrs Mary<br />
Ann Pomare<br />
Mr Wilson Edward and Mrs<br />
Deborah Mary Lattey<br />
374 Mr Neels Du Plessis 408 Mrs Michelle Brass 438 Mrs Hazel Purre 468 Department <strong>of</strong> Conservation 498<br />
495 Mr Robert Allen Pugh 525 Kapiti Coast Airport Limited<br />
496 Ms Wendy Frost 526<br />
16<br />
Mr Peter Graeme and Mrs<br />
Marion Milne<br />
467 Ms Andrea Breu 497 Ms Rachel Mason 527 Ms Dianna Fary<br />
Mr Basil Hugh & Mrs Jane<br />
Elizabeth Pritchett<br />
528 Ms Sonia Minnaar<br />
375 Mr David Blair 409 Mr John Wraight 439 Miss Serena Hastie 469 Mr Peter Reedy 499 Mr Nigel Wilson 529 Dr Janet Weber<br />
376 Ms Jane George 410 Mr Murray Eggers 440 Mr Henning Blem 470 Mrs Ruth Love 500 Ms Susan Christina Bull 530 Mr Peter Avery<br />
377 Dr Grant Hannis 411 Mr Frank Cherrill 441 Public Transport Voice 471 Mr Christopher Glover 501 Paraparaumu/Raumati<br />
Community Board<br />
531<br />
Mr John Short and Ms Gisella<br />
Schwass<br />
378 Mr Mitchell Anderson 412 Ms Maria van Lent 442 Mrs Shirley Goggin 472 Mr Ian G Jensen 502 Dr Kerstin Marianne Allan 532 Mr Wayne Hamilton<br />
380 Dr Jackie Cumming 413 Mr Tim Wilson 443 R W Thomson Ltd 473 Dr Dennis Page 503 Living Streets <strong>of</strong> Wellington 533<br />
381 Ms Ailsa Parker 414<br />
Miss Katherine Sarah Elizabeth<br />
Sloane<br />
444 Mr David Goggin 474<br />
Waikanae Property<br />
Development Ltd<br />
Mr Michael and Mrs Queenie<br />
Hyland<br />
504 Dr Susan Macdonald 534 Ms Maureen Ellis<br />
382 Mrs Petra Aregger 415 Kapanui School 445 RW Thomson Ltd 475 Mr Trevor Henderson 505 Save Kapiti Incorporated 535<br />
Mr Alexander & Mrs Marion<br />
Shanks<br />
383 Ms Te-Aroha Jennings 416 Ms Monique Lepionka 446 Mr David Bright 476 Mr Quentin Haines 506 Miss Julie Midgley 536 Ms Kathleen Pivac<br />
384 Hyde Park Museum Te Horo 417 Mr Trevor Daniell 447 Ms Wendy McGregor 477<br />
Waikanae Christian Holiday<br />
Park Inc.<br />
507 Mr William A Moore 537 Generation Zero<br />
385 Mr Douglas Hipkins 418 Ms Beverley Jean Yaldwyn 448 Mrs Patricia Mallia 478 Mr Patrick Morgan 508 Miss Eleanor Dawidowski 538 Mrs Karina Bergin<br />
386 Mrs Karen McCall 419 Mr David Ruddlesden 449 Ms Vlasta Pilatova 479 Mr Te Roera Puna 509 Miss Cathleen Devenport 539 Mr Simon Doran<br />
387 Mr John Backler 420 Mr Grant Pearson 450 Mr Frank Mallia 480 Mr Graham Lewis 510 Ms Stacey Gasson 540 Mr Steven Bright<br />
388 Mrs Fiona Jeffries 421 Ms Kathryn Watson 451<br />
389<br />
Mr Steven and Mrs Kathleen<br />
Ransley<br />
422<br />
Mr Colin and Mrs Isolde Annette<br />
Baxter<br />
452<br />
Mr Douglas Stewart and Mrs<br />
Rona Janette Ritchie<br />
Mr Michael and Mrs Brenda<br />
Malone<br />
481 Mr Jonathan Paul Gradwell 511 Mr Craig Phelps 541 Mr Graham C T Bathgate<br />
482 Ms Karen Whibley 512<br />
Mr Desmond Keith & Mrs<br />
Margaret Edna Ellis<br />
542 Highway Occupants Group<br />
390 Mr Graham McCall 423 Mr Anthony Britton 453 Mrs Ann O'Rorke 483 Lynwood Nursery Limited 513 Miss Sarah Ramakers 543 Mrs Susie Mills<br />
391 Mr Marco Wuest 424<br />
Mrs Karen Gwen and Mr Shaun<br />
Bernard Gray<br />
392 Ms Brigitte Wuest 425 Mrs Jane McNamara 455 Mr Hallard O'Rorke 485<br />
393 Miss Dina Wuest 426<br />
Mr Roger Anthony and Mrs<br />
Pamela Anne Childs<br />
454 Mr John Leighton 484 Smart Transport Network 514 Waikanae on One 544<br />
Implementation Group <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Kapiti Coast District Council<br />
Advisory on Cycleways,<br />
Walkways and Bridleways<br />
Mr Air Commodore PG Tyler<br />
OBE<br />
515 New Zealand Fire Service 545 Dr Rochelle J Wilson<br />
456 Mrs Amanda Raymond 486 Dr Viola Palmer 516 Ms Paula Keene 546 Mr Frank Borren<br />
394 Mr Herbert Aregger 427 Mrs Michelle Lewis 457 Mrs Wendy Reid 487 Mr Johannes Sijbrant 517 Mr Steven William Edbrooke 547 Dr Robert Kieboom<br />
396 Mrs Sue Gardiner 428 Mr Robert Brass 458 Mr Mark & Mrs Elaine Jones 488 Mrs Marion Edbrooke 518<br />
397 Mr Maurice Bly 429 Mr Bill and Jane Inge 459 Ms Sylvia Madden 489<br />
Mr Brian and Mrs Rita Ann<br />
Cashmore<br />
Mrs Elizabeth and Mr Terence<br />
O'Brien<br />
548 Mr Gavin Welsh<br />
519 Mrs Sarah Jane Penny 549 Mr Reece Baker<br />
398 Mr Martin Cooke-Willis 430 Dr Joanna Humphries 460 Mrs Lenore Winterburn 490 Ms Andrea Beechey 520 Mrs Deryn Groves 550<br />
399 Dr Andrew Cherrill 431 Mr Ian Michael Bagshaw 461 Mr David Groves 491<br />
Mr Derek and Mrs Andrea<br />
Paterson<br />
Mrs Lynne Rosemary<br />
Cruickshank<br />
521 Paraparaumu Medical Centre 551 Mr Hugo Tyler
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
552 Miss Kimbra Taylor 583 Ms Morag McNaughton 614 Mr I & Mrs J Butler 645 Mr Stafford Robert Coombe 676 Mr Roger Henry Frederic Brittain 709 Mrs Errolyn Jones<br />
553 Mr Colin Albert Mackinnon 584 Mr Dale Pfeiler 615 Ms Anne White 646<br />
Equestrian Representative,<br />
Cycleways, Walkways,<br />
Bridleways GRP.<br />
554 Miss Caroline Lisa Howard 585 Ms Luca Duckworth 616 Ms Diane Connal 647 Historic Places Trust 678<br />
555 Mrs Robyn Elisabeth Ash 586 Mr Jake and Dr Rebekah Roos 617 Mr John & Diane Baldwin 648<br />
556 Mr John Paul Edgar 587<br />
Mr Bryan & Mrs Elizabeth<br />
Couchman<br />
557 Miss Alison McEwen 588 Mr Jeremy Martyn 619<br />
Mr David Simmons & Mrs Sally<br />
Walker-Simmons<br />
677<br />
Action to Protect and Sustain<br />
our Communities (APSOC)<br />
Mr Martin Craig & Ms Jennifer<br />
Ann Anderson<br />
710 Mr Dominic Saint<br />
17<br />
711 Mrs Jocelyn Thornton<br />
679 Ferndale Trust 712 Mr Stephen Lewis<br />
618 Penray Gardens 649 Mr Jan Nisbet 680 Mr Glen Raymond Hooker 713 Mr Mark & Mrs Julia Harris<br />
Mr Neville Graham Alexander<br />
& Ms Rosemary Anne Neilson<br />
650 Mr Tony Brown 681 Mr Keith Dreyer 714 Mrs Debbie Mattingley<br />
558 Mr Matthew Thomas Howard 589 Mr Richard John Starke 620 Mr Richard Frank Williment 651 Mr Tonchi Begovich 682 Kapiti Coast District Council 715 Mrs Gina Woodward<br />
559 Mr Anthony R Gray 590 Miss Nicki Young 621 Ms Nicola Easthope 652 Ms Anca Soncodi 683 Ms Helene Donaldson 716 Mrs Jocelyn Prvanov<br />
560 Ms Suzan Wrinn 591 Ms Jean Luke 622 Ms Beth Lindsay 653 Ms Karen Apperley 684 Wellington Regional Council 717 Mr Alistair Barnett<br />
561 Mr Eric John Robinson 592 Miss June Beryl Robinson 623<br />
562 Paekakariki Community Board 593 Mr Grant Brian Robertson 624<br />
563 Miss Lorraine Robertson 594<br />
Mrs Elizabeth Jane Leonard-<br />
Taylor<br />
625<br />
Ms Fiona Melanie & Mr Nigel<br />
John Vining<br />
Kapiti Coast Grey Power<br />
Association Inc.<br />
Te Ati Awa/Ngati Awa ki<br />
Waikanae nga Iwi<br />
654<br />
655<br />
Mr Brent Mckay & Ms Tordis<br />
Flath<br />
Hutt Valley Chamber <strong>of</strong><br />
Commerce and Industry Inc.<br />
564 Dr Maram Wardakyn 595 Mr John Harding 626 Miss Samantha Coombes 657 Ms Judith Owen 688<br />
565 Miss Tessa Mackay 596 Mrs Micaela Young 627 Miss Holly Gaskin 658 Kapiti Coast Youth Council 689<br />
566<br />
Ms Sandy Houston and Mr<br />
Rod Lord<br />
685 Mr Merlin Wayne McKenzie 718 Mr Derek Schulz<br />
686 Land Matters Limited 719<br />
Ms Linda Niccol & Mr Eion and<br />
Mrs Eve Abernethy<br />
656 Ms Anna Carter 687 Dr Martin Richard Manning 720 Miss Robyn Snyders<br />
Wellington Employers Chamber<br />
<strong>of</strong> Commerce<br />
Ms Bronwyn Drysdale & Mr Ray<br />
Levy<br />
721 Mr Paul Hamilton Densem<br />
722<br />
Mrs Judith Christine Gray<br />
Petry<br />
597 Mr Zac Beechey-Gradwell 628 Miss Brittany Connell 659 Mr Christopher John Benge 690 Mrs Maureen Starke 723 Ms Sandra Woods<br />
567 Ms Susan Arnold 598 Ms Sally Ann Heppenstall 629 Miss Hannah Cosgrove 660<br />
Mr Brian Karl & Ms Robyn<br />
Usmar<br />
691 Mr James Chappèll 724 Ms Jennifer Wheatcr<strong>of</strong>t<br />
568 Ms Judy Frost-Evans 599 Ms Valerie Jacobs 630 Dr Adele Cherrill 661 Mr Gerhard Pallo 692 Mr John Francis Rice 725 Mrs Rachel Elizabeth Palmer<br />
569 Mr Tony Rutledge 600<br />
Mr Kees Nauta and Ms Dee<br />
Jones<br />
631 Miss Guinevere Cherrill 662 Miss Eleanor Jayne Staple 693 Mrs Donna & John Peters 726 Mrs Gaya Pilaar<br />
570 Mr Michael David McGirr 601 Kapiti Cycling Incorporated 632 Miss Phillippa Cherrill 663 Ms Nicky Beechey 694 Porirua City Council 727 Mr Howard Farr<br />
571 Miss Susanne Hurst 602 Mr Henry Smith 633 Mr Peter Kerschbaumer 664 Mr John & Mrs Judith Le Harivel 695<br />
572<br />
Alliance for a Sustainable<br />
Kapiti Inc<br />
603 Mrs Rosemary Childs 634 Mr Kevin Gardner 665<br />
Kapiti Coast Chamber <strong>of</strong><br />
Commerce<br />
696<br />
Vintage Car Club <strong>of</strong> NZ -<br />
Wellington Branch<br />
Ms Patricia Wood & Mr Allan<br />
Moul<br />
728 Ms Kathleen Knebel<br />
729 Mr Raymond Julius<br />
573 Ms Sandy West 604 Ms Julie Leibrich 635 Baray Holdings Ltd 666 Mr Richard P Caldwell 697 Mr Jon Marten Nicholas Kooij 730 Lorax Partnership<br />
574 Mr Desmond Laughton 605 Mrs Heather McKenzie 636 Mr Stanley Francis Goodman 667<br />
575 Mr Robert Dussler 606 Mr Wayne Love 637<br />
Mr Guy Richard Stewart<br />
Forrest<br />
Mr Mercia & Mrs Bernadette<br />
Clarke<br />
668 Mrs Heather Chambers 700<br />
576 Ms Chriss Bull 607 Ms Kath Saint 638 BusinessNZ 669 Ms Bianca Dragica Begovich 701<br />
699 Miss Joanna Davies 731 Ms Jennifer F. Hall<br />
Mr Mervyn Barrett & Ms Janet<br />
Horncy<br />
Mr Albert (Des) Desmond &<br />
Madeleine Jeanne Capewell<br />
732<br />
Mr Alister & Mrs Kay<br />
MacKenzie<br />
733 Ms Joy Maree Svendsen<br />
577 Mrs Sheena Staniland 608 Metlifecare Kapiti Limited 639 Mr Richard John Halliday 670 Mr Debbie Hager & Neil Miller 702 Ms Ilene Wilson 734 Ms Pam Strike<br />
578 Mr Martin Vernazoni 609 Ms Diane Susan Benge 640 Mr Graham Ibell 671 Mr Archibald McKeown 703 Takamore Trust 735 Mrs Jenny Scott<br />
579 Ms Aleisha Grifith 610 Mr Nick Fisher 641 Ms Jan Lattie 672 Mr Albert Belcher 704 Mr Ian Lindsay Barnett 736 Ms Elaine Engman<br />
580<br />
Friends <strong>of</strong> the Wharemauku<br />
Stream<br />
611 Rational Transport Society 642 Ms Kathleen Salome Kennard 673 Ms Ellen Dale Hinkley 705 Ms Maureen Roxburgh 737 Ms Norma Jean Stacy<br />
581 Ms Roshana Fernando 612 Kapiti Car Clinic Limited 643 Mr Donald Goldie Roberts 674<br />
Mr Brendon (Bos) Francis<br />
O'Sullivan<br />
582 Dr Meaburn Staniland 613 Ms Tink Stephenson 644 St Heliers Capital Limited 675 Dr Marie Therese O'Sullivan 708<br />
707<br />
Raumati South Residents'<br />
Association Inc<br />
Te Runanga o Ati Awa Ki<br />
Whakarongotai Inc<br />
740 Mr Nicholas Barr
Appendix Three – Schedule <strong>of</strong> Submitters (alphabetical)<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
719<br />
Abernethy and Niccol, Eion,<br />
Linda and Eve<br />
26 Ayres, Stuart 659 Benge, Christopher John 540 Bright, Steven 691 Chappèll, James 550 Cruickshank, Lynne Rosemary<br />
163 Aburn, John Edward 387 Backler, John 609 Benge, Diane Susan 676 Brittain, Roger Henry Frederic 630 Cherrill, Adele 380 Cumming, Jackie<br />
677<br />
Action to Protect and Sustain<br />
our Communities (APSOC)<br />
431 Bagshaw, Ian Michael 117 Bennett, Paul 423 Britton, Anthony 399 Cherrill, Andrew 167 Dallimore , Jordan<br />
95 Adlam, Jeffry 343 Baker, Kevin & Kym 538 Bergin, Karina 17 Brown, C. T. 411 Cherrill, Frank 417 Daniell, Trevor<br />
89 Adlam, Jennifer 549 Baker, Reece 35 Betteridge, David 18 Brown, E.M. 631 Cherrill, Guinevere 96 Davidson, Lynley<br />
282 Ainger, Brian 617 Baldwin, John & Diane 168 Beverdige , Kasey 368 Brown, Graeme Eric 401 Cherrill, Judith 238 Davie, Bruce<br />
237 Aldridge, Adrian 635 Baray Holdings Ltd 321 Biddiscombe, Sarah 286 Brown, Harold 632 Cherrill, Phillippa 93 Davies, Charles<br />
619<br />
Alexander & Neilson, Neville<br />
Graham & Rosemary Anne<br />
283 Barber, John David 153 Blackler, Peter 650 Brown, Tony 400 Cherrill, Richard 699 Davies, Joanna<br />
502 Allan, Kerstin Marianne 78 Barber, Leo 375 Blair, David 231 Bryden, Vicki 356 Cherrington, Ann 94 Davies, Lorraine<br />
523 Allen, Gary Peter 162 Bardell, Craig 53 Blanchard, Christopher 576 Bull, Chriss 492 Cherry, Brent Hume 184<br />
524 Allen, Linda Diane 308 Bardsley, Royden and Josette 440 Blem, Henning 16 Bull, Jamie 426<br />
572<br />
Alliance for a Sustainable<br />
Kapiti Inc<br />
Childs, Roger Anthony and<br />
Pamela Anne<br />
717 Barnett, Alistair 45 Blenkiron, Graeme 500 Bull, Susan Christina 603 Childs, Rosemary 261<br />
18<br />
Davies, Terence and<br />
Alexandra<br />
508 Dawidowski, Eleanor<br />
Dearden, Christopher William<br />
and Monica<br />
217 Andersen, Karin 704 Barnett, Ian Lindsay 44 Blenkiron, Lesley 248 Bullen Consultancy 194 Cicak, Branka 721 Densem, Paul Hamilton<br />
176 Anderson, Bryan 740 Barr, Nicholas 268 Blok, Ruben 124 Bunch, Vicki Schleider 667 Clarke, Mercia & Bernadette 468 Department <strong>of</strong> Conservation<br />
242 Anderson, Dean 22 Barrell, Graeme 397 Bly, Maurice 299 Burton, Martin 353 Clayton, Colin Duke 509 Devenport, Cathleen<br />
678<br />
Anderson, Martin Craig &<br />
Jennifer Ann<br />
378 Anderson, Mitchell 700<br />
293<br />
Anderton and Abigail, Joy and<br />
Jill<br />
244 Barrell, Shirley 239 Boeyen, Sara 638 BusinessNZ 362 Coe, Graham 41 Dews, David<br />
Barrett & Horncy, Mervyn &<br />
Janet<br />
2 Booth, Helen 614 Butler, I & J 616 Connal, Diane 47 Dews, Laura<br />
179 Basire, Ian 546 Borren, Frank 180 Cairncross, Angie 628 Connell, Brittany 101 Dixon, Marionne<br />
229 Ansell, Susan Grace 541 Bathgate, Graham C T 137 Borst, Clare 666 Caldwell, Richard P 112 Consedine, Esther 165 Dobbertin, Kirsten<br />
653 Apperley, Karen 223 Batterbee, Wendy Eleanor 196 Bosteels, Pieter 138 Cameron, Gary 246 Cooke, Antony Graham 208 Dobbie, Warwick<br />
394 Aregger, Herbert 422<br />
Baxter, Colin and Isolde<br />
Annette<br />
382 Aregger, Petra 434 Beaufort, Caroline Joan 301 Bowman, Alana 701<br />
104 Bourke, Barbara 234 Canvin, Peter 398 Cooke-Willis, Martin 683 Donaldson, Helene<br />
Capewell, Albert (Des)<br />
Desmond & Madeleine Jeanne<br />
645 Coombe, Stafford Robert 539 Doran, Simon<br />
236 Armstrong, Martin 490 Beechey, Andrea 407 Brass, Jay 656 Carter, Anna 626 Coombes, Samantha 173 Douglas, Anna<br />
31 Armstrong, Tim 663 Beechey, Nicky 408 Brass, Michelle 294 Cartmer, Michael Brendan 105 Cooper, Vicky 216 Dowco Associates Ltd<br />
567 Arnold, Susan 597 Beechey-Gradwell, Zac 428 Brass, Robert 489 Cashmore, Brian and Rita Ann 310 Cornell, Edward Laurence 346 Downie, John<br />
555 Ash, Robyn Elisabeth 669 Begovich, Bianca Dragica 359 Brauer Fluker, Charmaine 252 CentrePort Limited 65 Cornick, Eric 681 Dreyer, Keith<br />
198 Ashford, Caren June 651 Begovich, Tonchi 467 Breu, Andrea 668 Chambers, Heather 629 Cosgrove, Hannah 313 Driver, Clifford<br />
266<br />
Automobile Association<br />
Wellington District<br />
672 Belcher, Albert 220 Bright, Christine 7 Chapman, Derek 587 Couchman, Bryan & Elizabeth 256 Dryburgh, James<br />
530 Avery, Peter 322 Beldham, Matthew 446 Bright, David 75 Chapman, Leanne 355 Cowper, Bob 689<br />
Drysdale & Levy, Bronwyn &<br />
Ray
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
374 Du Plessis, Neels 123 Fletcher, Howard 55 Gilbert, Michael 595 Harding, John 558 Howard, Matthew Thomas 709 Jones, Errolyn<br />
585 Duckworth, Luca 192 Fletcher, Ross and Jocelyn 471 Glover, Christopher 207 Hare, David John 102 Hudson, Stephen 458 Jones, Mark & Mrs Elaine<br />
280 Duncan, Lawrie 369 Fluker, John Alexander 444 Goggin, David 150 Hare, Kelly 15 Hughes, Alun 149 Jones, Peter<br />
285 Duncan, Winsome 73 Ford, Gordon 442 Goggin, Shirley 209 Hare, Marie 430 Humphries, Joanna 151 Jones, Simon<br />
575 Dussler, Robert 637 Forrest, Guy Richard Stewart 636 Goodman, Stanley Francis 713 Harris, Mark & Julia 8 Hunter, Kathleen 152 Jones, Vera<br />
621 Easthope, Nicola 360 Forsythe, David 225<br />
September 2012<br />
Gould, Norman John and<br />
Eileen Florence<br />
323 Harrison, Bernard 169 Hurst, Alan 181 Joyce, Denis and Joan<br />
488 Edbrooke, Marion 36 Foskett, Gai 481 Gradwell, Jonathan Paul 325 Harrow, Sally 571 Hurst, Susanne 20 Judd, Paul<br />
517 Edbrooke, Steven William 125 Foss, Ray & Rosemary 132 Grant, John 439 Hastie, Serena 80 Huston, John and Wendy 729 Julius, Raymond<br />
556 Edgar, John Paul 52 Foulds, David 39 Granville, John 72 Hawken, Dinah 66 Hutcheson, Samantha 253 Jury, Richard<br />
258 Edgar, Mark 227<br />
Four Seasons Caravans 1980<br />
Ltd<br />
410 Eggers, Murray 230 Fourways Enterprises Ltd 424<br />
512<br />
Ellis, Desmond Keith &<br />
Margaret Edna<br />
559 Gray, Anthony R 113 Hawker, Peter 655<br />
Gray, Karen Gwen and Shaun<br />
Bernard<br />
Hutt Valley Chamber <strong>of</strong><br />
Commerce and Industry Inc.<br />
361 Kane, Neil<br />
345 Heald, Susan 384 Hyde Park Museum Te Horo 415 Kapanui School<br />
155 Franssen, Paul 270 Gregory, Bob 351 Henderson, Kevin H 533 Hyland, Michael and Queenie 612 Kapiti Car Clinic Limited<br />
5 Ellis, Howard 103 Frazer, Brenda 245 Griffis, Gareth 475 Henderson, Trevor 640 Ibell, Graham 525 Kapiti Coast Airport Limited<br />
534 Ellis, Maureen 193 Frazer, Simon 139 Griffith, T R 598 Heppenstall, Sally Ann 485<br />
736 Engman, Elaine 59<br />
646<br />
Equestrian Representative,<br />
Cycleways, Walkways,<br />
Bridleways GRP.<br />
580<br />
Friends <strong>of</strong> the Waikanae River<br />
Inc.<br />
Friends <strong>of</strong> the Wharemauku<br />
Stream<br />
Implementation Group <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Kapiti Coast District Council<br />
Advisory on Cycleways,<br />
Walkways and Bridleways<br />
665<br />
19<br />
Kapiti Coast Chamber <strong>of</strong><br />
Commerce<br />
579 Grifith, Aleisha 297 Higgott, Hariata Mei 429 Inge, Bill and Jane 682 Kapiti Coast District Council<br />
461 Groves, David 542 Highway Occupants Group 259 Jack, Tony 624<br />
Kapiti Coast Grey Power<br />
Association Inc.<br />
211 Evans, Diana Mary 496 Frost, Wendy 520 Groves, Deryn 129 Hill, Gillian 599 Jacobs, Valerie 658 Kapiti Coast Youth Council<br />
71 Falconer, Robin 568 Frost-Evans, Judy 109 Guthrie, Hugh 673 Hinkley, Ellen Dale 182 Jaeger, Josef and Mrs Anne 601 Kapiti Cycling Incorporated<br />
727 Farr, Howard 302 Fullerton-Smith, Henry 289 Gyles, Maria 385 Hipkins, Douglas 213 James, Beverly Vera 190<br />
Kapiti Emergency Medical<br />
Services Trust<br />
527 Fary, Dianna 51 Fulton, Michael 106 Hadfield, Andrea 128 Hogg, Brian 212 James, Robert Gary 364 Kapiti Gateway Motel<br />
9 Faulls, Malcolm Hamilton 135 Funnell, David 670 Hager & Miller, Debbie & Neil 680 Hooker, Glen Raymond 388 Jeffries, Fiona 25 Kapiti Office Products Depot<br />
318 Fawthorpe, Charles Richard 396 Gardiner, Sue 56<br />
Hager and Laird, Amanda and<br />
Brian<br />
273 Hooper, Brian 363 Jennings, David 660 Karl & Usmar, Brian & Robyn<br />
131 Ferguson, Steve 634 Gardner, Kevin 476 Haines, Quentin 133 Hooper, Max 177 Jennings, Diane 516 Keene, Paula<br />
107 Ferguson, William 627 Gaskin, Holly 731 Hall, Jennifer F. 336 Hopkirk, Heather 195 Jennings, Jessica 118 Kells, Colin<br />
581 Fernando, Roshana 510 Gasson, Stacey 639 Halliday, Richard John 197 Hopping, Murray 403 Jennings, Sam 339 Kelly, James & June<br />
679 Ferndale Trust 537 Generation Zero 532 Hamilton, Wayne 224 Hori, Stefan and Carolyn 383 Jennings, Te-Aroha 144 Kenchington, David<br />
27 Filter Clean NZ Ltd 376 George, Jane 110 Hanbury-Sparrow, David 100 Hosking, Trevor 472 Jensen, Ian G 642 Kennard, Kathleen Salome<br />
290 Finlay , S 170 Gibbin, Mark 287 Hanbury-Sparrow, Michael 566<br />
Houston and Lord, Sandy and<br />
Rod<br />
260 Jensen, Julie Margaret 189<br />
Kennedy, Winifred and<br />
Graeme<br />
610 Fisher, Nick 146 Gibbons, Joanne 377 Hannis, Grant 554 Howard, Caroline Lisa 257 Jensen, Michael John 357 Keno, Catherine
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
633 Kerschbaumer, Peter 503 Living Streets <strong>of</strong> Wellington 251 Mansfield, William 671 McKeown, Archibald 600 Nauta and Jones, Kees and Dee 725 Palmer, Rachel Elizabeth<br />
494 Kieboom, Donna 219 Livingston, David 92 Marico Marine NZ 425 McNamara, Jane 278 Neches, Teresa 486 Palmer, Viola<br />
547 Kieboom, Robert 221 Livingston, Maxine 122 Marsh, Anthony 583 McNaughton, Morag 90 Nga Manu Nature Reserve 77<br />
September 2012<br />
20<br />
Paraparaumu Beach Golf Club<br />
Inc<br />
79 Klaassen, Rob 284 Lloyd, Jill 279 Marshall, Richard 334 McNay, Barbara 171 Nichols, Kaye 521 Paraparaumu Medical Centre<br />
728 Knebel, Kathleen 277 Lloyd, Tony 147 Marshall, Wal 99 Meek, Ross 352<br />
Nicholson, Leov Gary & Pamela<br />
Joyce<br />
501 Paraparaumu/Raumati<br />
Community Board<br />
1 Knewstubb, Peter 21 Lobb, Murray 116 Martin, Jane 608 Metlifecare Kapiti Limited 649 Nisbet, Jan 381 Parker, Ailsa<br />
697 Kooij, Jon Marten Nicholas 730 Lorax Partnership 114 Martin, Mervyn 506 Midgley, Julie 320 Nixon, Margaret 108 Parry, Annette<br />
70 Kress, Sahra 272 Lough, Alan 588 Martyn, Jeremy 61 Miller, Nina 29 NZ Contractors Federation 347<br />
Parsonnage, Alan Roy & Ann<br />
Margaret<br />
337 Laing, Elizabeth Ann 470 Love, Ruth 497 Mason, Rachel 62 Miller, Ronald 515 NZ Fire Service 491 Paterson, Derek and Andrea<br />
686 Land Matters Limited 606 Love, Wayne 148 Mason, Richard 166 Milliner, David 19<br />
NZ Forest Owners Association<br />
Inc<br />
206<br />
Patten, Howard Trevor and<br />
Josephine Isobel<br />
54 Lange, Stephen 271 Luhn, Jessica 714 Mattingley, Debbie 543 Mills, Susie 647 NZ Historic Places Trust 315 Patterson, Aylwyn Cedric<br />
466<br />
Lattey, Wilson Edward and<br />
Deborah Mary<br />
591 Luke, Jean 274 McAviney, Terry 141 Milne, Brian 493<br />
O'Brien and Gray, Patrick John<br />
and Joanne Fisher<br />
4 Pears, Ian and Judith<br />
641 Lattie, Jan 57 Lynch, Derek 390 McCall, Graham 23 Milne, Janet 518 O'Brien, Elizabeth and Terence 420 Pearson, Grant<br />
574 Laughton, Desmond 483 Lynwood Nursery Limited 386 McCall, Karen 24 Milne, Kenneth 84 Office Angels Limited 519 Penny, Sarah Jane<br />
174 Lawton, Peter 504 Macdonald, Susan 42 McCallum, Norma 526<br />
Milne, Peter Graeme and<br />
Marion<br />
64 Oldham, Keith 618 Penray Gardens<br />
664 Le Harivel, John & Mrs Judith 402 Mackay, Iain 40 McCandless, Robin 462 Minnaar, Collin 175 Oldham, Mary 693 Peters, Donna & John<br />
159 Leggett, Ross 404 Mackay, Rachel 269 McCarroll, Pip 528 Minnaar, Sonia 247<br />
Opie, Roy John and Meryl<br />
Brenda<br />
435 Petherick, Laurence<br />
300 Leggott, Michael 565 Mackay, Tessa 143 McColl, Nathan 82 Mitchell, Ian 335 Ordish, Lawrence 722 Petry, Judith Christine Gray<br />
604 Leibrich, Julie 732 MacKenzie, Alister & Kay 264 McCrae, David Ian 275 Moger, David 453 O'Rorke, Ann 463 Pettie, Marc<br />
454 Leighton, John 553 Mackinnon, Colin Albert 557 McEwen, Alison 507 Moore, William A 455 O'Rorke, Hallard 584 Pfeiler, Dale<br />
464 Lemana, Tara 240 Macpherson, Stewart 63 McFedries, Donald 235 Morgan, Jan 674<br />
O'Sullivan, Brendon (Bos)<br />
Francis<br />
511 Phelps, Craig<br />
329 Lenk, Christine Cecil 459 Madden, Sylvia 97 McGavin, Robbie 263 Morgan, Liz 48 O'Sullivan, John 200 Phillipps, Bruce<br />
594<br />
Leonard-Taylor, Elizabeth<br />
Jane<br />
14 Maher, Florence 161<br />
McGechan, Robert and<br />
Cristine<br />
478 Morgan, Patrick 675 O'Sullivan, Marie Therese 142 Philpott, Ray and Allison<br />
416 Lepionka, Monique 187 Maitland, Emma 570 McGirr, Michael David 158 Morgan, Trevor 657 Owen, Judith 726 Pilaar, Gaya<br />
50 Lester, Tony 450 Mallia, Frank 447 McGregor, Wendy 250 Morrison, William Reginald 562 Paekakariki Community Board 449 Pilatova, Vlasta<br />
480 Lewis, Graham 448 Mallia, Patricia 654 Mckay & Flath, Brent & Tordis 319 Morton, Sally 473 Page, Dennis 536 Pivac, Kathleen<br />
427 Lewis, Michelle 452 Malone, Michael and Brenda 605 McKenzie, Heather 49 Moulton, Richard 296 Painter, Joan Kathleen 465<br />
Pomare, Kane Joseph and<br />
Mary Ann<br />
712 Lewis, Stephen 687 Manning, Martin Richard 685 McKenzie, Merlin Wayne 199 Mountier, Mary 311 Painter, William Gordon 309 Pomare, Loretta Anne<br />
622 Lindsay, Beth 203 Mansell, Richard 46 McKenzie, Ruth 13 Murrey, Jean 661 Pallo, Gerhard 281 Ponsford, Gerald
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter No. Submitter<br />
694 Porirua City Council 692 Rice, John Francis 307 Scrimshaw, Patrick John 737 Stacy, Norma Jean 68 The Paetawa Trust 564 Wardakyn, Maram<br />
30 Potusa, Helen 130 Richardson, Maurice 535 Shanks, Alexander & Marion 188 Staniford, Anthony 243<br />
The Trustees <strong>of</strong> the Arthur Bills<br />
Resettlement Trust (property<br />
owner) and Directors <strong>of</strong><br />
Harrisons Country Gardenworld<br />
Ltd (tenant).<br />
326 Power, Alan 333 Richardson, S P 6 Sharpe, Stephen 582 Staniland, Meaburn 711 Thornton, Jocelyn 432<br />
437<br />
Pritchard, Andrew and<br />
Lynnette<br />
145 Pritchard, Stuart 451<br />
160 Riding, Gillian 350 Sherley, Marion Isabel 577 Staniland, Sheena 324 Tomlinson, Steven 267<br />
Ritchie, Douglas Stewart and<br />
Rona Janette<br />
205 Pritchard, Stuart and Mary 60 Road Transport Forum N.Z. 531<br />
498<br />
Pritchett, Basil Hugh & Jane<br />
Elizabeth<br />
12 Shorer, Jonathan 662 Staple, Eleanor Jayne 228<br />
Short and Schwass, John and<br />
Gisella<br />
Tong, Lennard James and<br />
Pamela Elaine<br />
154 Wastney, Jeff<br />
21<br />
Waterhouse, Elizabeth and<br />
Brent<br />
Waterson, Daniel Ronald and<br />
Dionne Carol<br />
344 Watmough, Anthony Llewellyn<br />
690 Starke, Maureen 178 Transpower NZ Ltd 126 Watson, Charles Steward Hall<br />
643 Roberts, Donald Goldie 10 Short, Jeffrey 589 Starke, Richard John 58 Turver, Chris 241 Watson, Joanne<br />
716 Prvanov, Jocelyn 593 Robertson, Grant Brian 349 Shr<strong>of</strong>f, Gordon W 613 Stephenson, Tink 544<br />
Tyler, Air Commodore PG Tyler<br />
OBE<br />
421 Watson, Kathryn<br />
441 Public Transport Voice 185 Robertson, Joanne 487 Sijbrant, Johannes 76 Stevenson, Jane 551 Tyler, Hugo 316 Watterson, Peter<br />
495 Pugh, Robert Allen 563 Robertson, Lorraine 648<br />
Simmons & Walker-Simmons,<br />
David & Sally<br />
88 Stone, Chris 348 Vagg, Frances 314 Watterson, Susan Mary<br />
226 Pullenger, A 561 Robinson, Eric John 34 Simmons, Norrey 734 Strike, Pam 412 van Lent, Maria 3 Weaver, Guy<br />
479 Puna, Te Roera 592 Robinson, June Beryl 371 Simpson, David 98 Strong, Robert 265 van Riessen, Sabien 529 Weber, Janet<br />
438 Purre, Hazel 586 Roos, Jake & Dr Rebekah 33 Simpson, James 115 Stuart, George 69 Verboeket, Ann 276 Weir, Michael and Veronica<br />
436 Purre, Rein 705 Roxburgh, Maureen 74 Simpson, Jude 733 Svendsen, Joy Maree 370 Vere-Jones, Peter 342 Welch, Liz<br />
358<br />
Quinovic Property<br />
Management - Kapiti-Mana<br />
419 Ruddlesden, David 157 Simpson, Stephen and Elly 291 Swann, David 372 Vere-Jones, Suzanne 32 Welch, Michael<br />
443 R W Thomson Ltd 569 Rutledge, Tony 37 Simpson, Vicki 703 Takamore Trust 578 Vernazoni, Martin 688<br />
140 Ramage, Jennifer 445 RW Thomson Ltd 328 Sisarich, Prue 341 Tandy, Rachel 623<br />
513 Ramakers, Sarah 156 Ryan, Anthony 332 Sisarich, Warren & Prue 186 Tanner, Alison 695<br />
389 Ransley, Steven and Kathleen 87 Ryder, Ann 331 Sisarich, Warren David 183 Tanner, John William 317<br />
43 Rapley, John 710 Saint, Dominic 414<br />
Sloane, Katherine Sarah<br />
Elizabeth<br />
Vining, Fiona Melanie & Nigel<br />
John<br />
Vintage Car Club <strong>of</strong> NZ -<br />
Wellington Branch<br />
Vos, Elaine Maree and Anton<br />
Adolf<br />
305 Taylor, Jean 134 Vrede, Jocelyn 254<br />
Wellington Employers<br />
Chamber <strong>of</strong> Commerce<br />
684 Wellington Regional Council<br />
548 Welsh, Gavin<br />
573 West, Sandy<br />
Whanganui Employer's<br />
Chamber <strong>of</strong> Commerce<br />
611 Rational Transport Society 607 Saint, Kath 484 Smart Transport Network 552 Taylor, Kimbra 120 Vrede, Warwick 724 Wheatcr<strong>of</strong>t, Jennifer<br />
707<br />
Raumati South Residents'<br />
Association Inc<br />
28 Saunders, Ann 602 Smith, Henry 210 Taylor, Leonard John 477<br />
Waikanae Christian Holiday<br />
Park Inc.<br />
201 Wheeler, Brian<br />
456 Raymond, Amanda 505 Save Kapiti Incorporated 232 Smith, Margaret 306 Taylor, Neville 514 Waikanae on One 214 Wheeler, Eleonore Franzika<br />
249 Redman, Mike 327<br />
Saxby & Mountier, Neil &<br />
Barbara Breta<br />
11 Smith, Peter and Mary-Anne 625<br />
Te Ati Awa/Nga Awa ki<br />
Waikanae nga Iwi<br />
474<br />
Waikanae Property<br />
Development Ltd<br />
202 Wheeler, Judith<br />
469 Reedy, Peter 312 Schager, Linda Caroline 233 Smith, Robert 340 Te Ra School 67 Wakeford, Mandy 204 Wheeler, Nicholas<br />
218 Regan, Arnold 718 Schulz, Derek 720 Snyders, Robyn 708<br />
Te Runanga o Ati Awa Ki<br />
Whakarongotai Inc<br />
292 Walbran, Shane 222 Wheeler, Paul Frederick<br />
457 Reid, Wendy 91 Schurmann, Anita 652 Soncodi, Anca 81 Tennyson, Alan 354 Walker, April S 482 Whibley, Karen<br />
330 Religious Society <strong>of</strong> Friends 735 Scott, Jenny 433 South Pacific Roses 2011 Ltd 191 Tennyson, Beatrice 121 Wallace, Ralph Macquisten 615 White, Anne<br />
119 Renouf, Jacky 304 Scrimshaw, Janis Erica 644 St Heliers Capital Limited 85 Ternent, Mark 83 Ward, Malcolm 522 White, Lisa
No. Submitter<br />
255 White, Nigel<br />
298 Wiggs, Glen<br />
127 Williams, Clive<br />
164 Williams, Marian<br />
215 Williams, Jacqueline<br />
620 Williment, Richard Frank<br />
413 Wilson, Tim<br />
499 Wilson, Nigel<br />
545 Wilson, Rochelle J<br />
702 Wilson, Ilene<br />
460 Winterburn, Lenore<br />
111 Wintle, Julie<br />
295<br />
Wood, Michael George &<br />
Janice Merle<br />
696 Wood, Patricia & Moul, Allan<br />
338 Woodbury, Neil K<br />
723 Woods, Sandra<br />
715 Woodward, Gina<br />
409 Wraight, John<br />
262 Wright, Gavin Ashworth<br />
303 Wright, Patricia Frances<br />
560 Wrinn, Suzan<br />
391 Wuest, Marco<br />
392 Wuest, Brigitte<br />
393 Wuest, Dina<br />
38 Wyatt, Warwick<br />
418 Yaldwyn, Beverley Jean<br />
590 Young, Nicki<br />
596 Young, Micaela<br />
596<br />
Zajaczkowski, Krzyszt<strong>of</strong> &<br />
Beaumont, Aleka<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
22
Appendix Four - <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> Table<br />
September 2012<br />
MacKays to Peka Peka Expressway Proposal <strong>Summary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Submissions</strong> report<br />
23