Brushstrokes - October 2011 - Surface Coatings Association of New ...
Brushstrokes - October 2011 - Surface Coatings Association of New ...
Brushstrokes - October 2011 - Surface Coatings Association of New ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
A Naturally Occurring Sub-Micron Titanium<br />
Dioxide Extender for Decorative Paints<br />
Introduction<br />
By Simon Bussell*, Technical Sales Manager, Sibelco Speciality Minerals Europe * Corresponding author<br />
Mart Verheijen, Application Development Manager, Sibelco Speciality Minerals Europe<br />
In the first quarter <strong>of</strong> 2009 the price <strong>of</strong> titanium dioxide (TiO2)<br />
stood at $2,400/tonne for the US and Asia. Since that time<br />
regular increases have seen the price increase dramatically<br />
to $2,750-2,950/tonne by the end <strong>of</strong> 2010. Prices are even<br />
higher in Europe at up to €2,780/tonne.‚ At the same time<br />
supply has been severely limited with manufacturers rationing<br />
deliveries to customers. There are several causes for this,<br />
shortages <strong>of</strong> titanium ores such as ilmenite and rutile as well<br />
as other raw materials such as sulphuric acid, increased energy<br />
costs, increased demand from Asia and capacity reduction by<br />
suppliers. This situation has forced formulators to look again<br />
at the level <strong>of</strong> TiO2 in their coatings and consider options for<br />
reducing the quantities used. One such option is a complex<br />
carbonate extender produced by the Sibelco Group company<br />
Ankerpoort based a mixture <strong>of</strong> calcium and magnesium<br />
carbonates and hydrated carbonates. The material is marketed<br />
by Sibelco Speciality Minerals Europe (SSME) a new<br />
commercial group focused on the supply <strong>of</strong> functional fillers for<br />
coatings, polymers and adhesives. This work will show that the<br />
mixture, which occurs naturally as sub-micron, platy crystals,<br />
is an ideal TiO2 extender, maintaining and improving brightness<br />
and hiding power in comparison to other ultrafine extenders.<br />
Experimental<br />
Titanium Dioxide is responsible for two principle features <strong>of</strong><br />
paints and coatings, whiteness and opacity. TiO2 is the best<br />
pigment for these properties because <strong>of</strong> its high refractive<br />
index (2.75). This gives the highest level <strong>of</strong> scattering when<br />
light crosses the boundary between binder and TiO2 particle or<br />
air and TiO2 particle. Reduction <strong>of</strong> TiO2 content is a balancing<br />
act between the need to reduce cost and the need to maintain<br />
quality. To be effective a TiO2 extender must allow TiO2 levels to<br />
be reduced while maintaining whiteness and opacity levels.<br />
In the 1970’s a wall paint could contain more than 18% TiO2 by<br />
volume. 3 This has been steadily reduced since that time, typically<br />
by improving the dispersion and separation <strong>of</strong> TiO2 particles in the<br />
film. Figure 1 shows diagrammatically how this can be done by<br />
reducing the average particle size <strong>of</strong> the filler material.<br />
There is a limit to how effective this method can be. Beyond<br />
a certain particle size suitable finely ground fillers may not be<br />
available, and if they are binder demand, dispersant levels and<br />
dispersion time would all be increased. An alternative method<br />
is to use ultrafine particles to space the TiO2 particles in the<br />
interstitial voids between large filler particles (figure 2). Typically<br />
Figure 1 – improved TiO2 distribution by reduction <strong>of</strong> filler particle size<br />
(not to scale).<br />
particles <strong>of</strong> around twice the diameter <strong>of</strong> TiO2 particles (0.5-<br />
0.6µm) are found to be most effective.<br />
The purpose <strong>of</strong> this work was<br />
to determine how effective this<br />
complex carbonate mineral<br />
is as a TiO2 extender. To do<br />
this it was compared with four<br />
other materials commonly<br />
used for TiO2 extension, finely<br />
ground calcite, precipitated<br />
calcium carbonate, fine<br />
hydrous kaolin and calcined<br />
kaolin at two different TiO2<br />
volume concentrations.<br />
Figure 2 - TiO2 spacing by ultrafine extender (not to scale)<br />
Materials<br />
This work was undertaken at the SSME paint lab in Maastricht<br />
using a formulation (table 1) based on a styrene-acrylic<br />
emulsion. Initially two coatings were prepared using 7% TiO2 by<br />
volume and 3.5% TiO2 by volume. Selected coatings from these<br />
trials were repeated using a higher binder level. With the PVC<br />
above critical and a low level <strong>of</strong> TiO2 these coatings were felt to<br />
represent a general use interior wall paint.<br />
Fillers<br />
The complex carbonate extender is a mixed alkaline earth<br />
carbonate with the general formula Mg3Ca(CO3)4. It is formed<br />
by the weathering <strong>of</strong> magnesite or dolomite and subsequent<br />
deposition. Ankerpoort mine and partially process the material<br />
in Greece (figure 3) where the raw material is screened and<br />
beneficiated to provide a reasonably pure feedstock for further<br />
processing. The material is then shipped to The Netherlands<br />
where Ankerpoort have developed proprietary processing<br />
SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 5