June 11, 2002 - Baltimore City Public Schools
June 11, 2002 - Baltimore City Public Schools
June 11, 2002 - Baltimore City Public Schools
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Board Meeting Minutes<br />
MS. WELCH: Opposed?<br />
MR. TILDON: I'd like to make some comments, if it's allowed.<br />
MS. WELCH: Dr. Tildon?<br />
MR. TILDON: During his presentation, Mr. O'Neill, I responded by telling him that I felt insulted. I<br />
think it's important that the public know, at least, my feelings on this issue. I think it's somewhat<br />
disingenuous for someone to imply that if we don't make a decision that's favorable to them that we lack<br />
courage. I think that anyone that has a sense of this Board knows the approach that we have used in our<br />
deliberations. We may error in our judgments, our actions, and our decisions, but there is nobody at this<br />
table that does not have the children of <strong>Baltimore</strong> totally in their eyesight. And I know from my work<br />
with all of the people at this table that we leave our egos at that door, we leave our agendas at that door,<br />
and we have an open mind to gather and understand our own assumptions, and to revisit them over and<br />
over again. I think that it's important, at least, for the public to understand my support of the CEO,<br />
because there has been a major public relations effort to castigate this System, and I think you ought to<br />
stop that. I think your efforts to promote your own educational programs should stand on their own<br />
rhetoric. To tell us about the 40-odd thousand children that have to go to summer school, as an<br />
indictment of this System, of this Board, equally of the Board, of the system, reeks of insult. But the fact<br />
of the matter is, considering the proposal that I received, I would describe them as ambiguous, lacking<br />
focus, and not having any substantial evidence to tell me that the group that has run an elementary<br />
school can now run a middle school. I appreciate your willingness to assist this System, and we will<br />
seek partners throughout wherever. We sat here and we heard the parents and the teachers provide us<br />
with their concerns. And, as a matter of fact, one of the things that stuck with me, Mr. Dugger said we<br />
shouldn't call these children kids, and he's right. So there are words of wisdom that come to us, and we<br />
incorporate them a lot. But, Mr. O'Neill, I have to tell you, I don't know what you had in mind, but the<br />
very statement you made insulted me, and I think this Board, and I did not accept your apologies.<br />
MS. WELCH: Commissioner Streuver?<br />
MR. STREUVER: I would also strike my vote void of the CEO's recommendation. As a Board<br />
representative, I think the Advisory Board has been one of the champions of the notion that it's on an<br />
important to innovate. Perhaps there's a better way to doing things that will benefit the entire System,<br />
using -- contracting out the management of the schools. And so over the last -- <strong>Baltimore</strong>'s really been a<br />
leader in this. We've been, I guess, Stay-in-School Student of the Year for all six years.<br />
MS. WELCH: It's been more than that.<br />
Page 35 of 41<br />
MR. STREUVER: So we've been asked this for some time, and we have a process for it. It's called the<br />
New School Initiative. And cycle 4 of those New School applications were due for the 2003/20003<br />
school year reviews in early December last year. And most of those that we -- that were approved for<br />
going forward in our planning year was in recognition that -- while we do believe in putting the pedal to<br />
the metal, as Commissioner Stringfield was saying, we need to do that with some careful thought and<br />
planning. And ensuring that we're experimenting with this model for innovation through New <strong>Schools</strong>,<br />
contracting out management, that we're balancing that with your larger efforts to move forward our<br />
reform agenda across the System. We've got 173 schools; 95,000 students. The responsibility really is to<br />
that entire student population. And we have, what I believe, is an exciting middle school reform action<br />
plan, we have an exciting high school reform action plan, and a top priority for us to put the pedal to the<br />
metal in moving forward and implementing that, in terms of our allocations of funding and staff<br />
resource. Booker T. Washington, I know Commissioner Murphy, in particular, has been hard at work<br />
file://S:\CMS_Content\meetings\<strong>2002</strong>\J<strong>11</strong>_02.html<br />
9/23/<strong>2002</strong>