Exploiting the Omission of Irrelevant Data - Webdocs Cs Ualberta

] ˜ !mœHck_›PQEa4dHd%-#TKMg„L?CJTDF’QB
!QF’?„L?G¨_‡GJ?¨RS?B4O(CJOUK[½>Y?2C"(
FLGUXš[ [DMƒONMƒCU?OJCùMƒGU?)A8>@CUCJ>@BDZA8FLGU?-OUTKMƒB
OUTzMO&A¥MB4‚8GJ?¨MXËf~’
À ­ ©g¨SÁ ®S¸îD® à ¯5îD®±(Ê È ® ÁÃK© à ¯ ©À ® šÈÈ ®2­Y®2ÉÊ Ã ¯ Ϩ©ƒÈ&¨ ­@Êg³ «
· ¨ Êg¯ 5©ƒÃ¤©ÈmÈ ®S¸$ à ĻÊ Ã ¯ ¯5î Ï ®Nʯ $ È ®S³¿Êƒ­ È ®SÊL¸±¬ È ®S³¨® à ¯ šÃ
³
MGJOU>šRSDXšMƒOU?-OUTD?(RSXšMƒCUCU>ËÒ›R2MOU>@FLB¤IkGUFDRS?CJC¿OJTD?‚¥MGU?-DCJ>@BDZKn
( –DGNœ W -ù[4>@CSRSDCUCJ?C M¦A8FD[4?XOUTzMO¤MƒX@CUFÑMCUCJDA8?2C
–DGUBk?‚
(
/?9@=z×>YC-M)IKM>@G, (
C$¹D>@XY?L_"Ao?XšMBKRJTDFLXY‚ MƒBK[
IKMƒGUOU>šRSkXÅMƒG(OU?2CUOUCFƒãOJTD?8IzMOU>@?B4O
5c ” ” ” RSFHGJGU?CJIKFLBK[4COJF
IDTDX@?ZLA¼n)–QTD?BÑOJTD?8>@BDCJONMƒBKRS?
[4FLA¦XšM¹z?X@?¨[-?^ßkMƒA8IDX@?C& (
bHc>degfihkjmlnfno_pLdqsr]jsrt8et8u§vGwxvgfidu£y£z©tz©fnlnl>wxeeq{hktRv|}w~vXtxw~G|
d6u{tLd~odu§lip‚vgzƒd„mfievgfius8vS…6w†liqst8e8yR‡†ˆm‰8Š6‹yƒw~us„
w~vvrgfi€sqsvt|}w~e
z©d „§fievgfiu{BvRHlŽwxeet8e8y£zrgfivvt8u‚‡8©‰G‘‹§’\“gv
v|}w~vv|{tBrtŒw~rtdu§lipv
è "!$#&% é´è"'
Ž¥FHCJO">@A8IkXY?2A8?B4OU?g[
x¢¡¨9;y4s£¡¨9;xz:8sD:#r¥.143;s£¡¨1Dr¥¤{xK7§¦©¨
FLGU“Ñ?S§‡?¨RSOJ>Y„L?X@‚Ÿ’QTD?B¢„L?GU‚
X@?¨MGJBD>@BDZ¦CU‚4CUOJ?A8COJ?BK[ŸOJFÑ’
;?¨MOJDGU?C-MGJ?(A8>@CUCJ>@BDZK_DMƒBK[o’QTD?B OJTD?CU?)A8>@CJCU>@BDZ$5?¨Mgf
5?’
MHRSGJFHCUCÑOJTD?ŸCNMƒA8IDX@?Cgn
OUkGU?CŸMGU?ØGNMƒBK[4FHAoX@‚¦[4>@CUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?¨[
Œ FHX@X@F’Q>YBkZ(CUOSMBK[DMƒGN[}IDGNMLRSOU>šRS?L_‡’ ?$>Å[½?B4OU>Ë5‚¥?¨MHRJT¼[½FHA¤Mƒ>@B
>@BDCUOSMBKR^?¢’Q>@OUT MºÒKBD>@OU?º„H?¨RSOJFHGØF ¹KF4FLXY?gMB MOJOUGU>@¹DkOU?C
¹K?OUTD?CU?2O#F›MƒX@XHIzFHC~f
ý) 5ýÿþ Sý ‘X@?O©* +)-,Âc ”§.
CU>@¹DX@?[½FHA¤Mƒ>@B>YBkCUONMƒBKRS?Cgn&–QTk?(X@?¨MGJBD?G&>@CmOUGU‚4>@BDZOJF8X@?¨MGJB
RSFLBKRS?IkO0/_t’QTD>šRUTÑ’?„4>@?’ MƒCMBÑ>@BK[4>šRMƒOUFLG&;DBKRSOJ>YFLB
M
TKMƒX²8Fƒ¤OJTD?Ñ5?gMOUkGU?Ÿ„HMX@D?CŽ¥FHGJ?F„H?Gg_OUTk?CU?Ÿ„HMX@D?2C
Ê È ® ª ³S³ šÃ4Ä
MGJ?¼BkFHO8GSMBK[½FHA8X@‚ѹDX@FDRJ“H?¨[ÿ_Q¹DDOo>YBǵMHRSOØÕ
2134,65 87 . _z’QTD?GU? ( ý:9* ¼>@C¿MA8?A¹z?GQFƒ;/Ø>²§
/oû£*
ý á )@C¿MCJONMƒOU>@FHBKMƒGU‚
’QTD>šRJTGNMƒBK[4FLA >@B4f
OUTk?&CUIzMHRS?-FÆ[½FHA¤Mƒ>@B(>@BDCUOSMBKRS?2C¨_4;GUFHA
CU>@OJKMOJ>YFLB RSFHBkCU>š[4?GJ?¨[Ø>YBØOUTD>@C)IKMIz?Goà5CJ?? Ý ?^ÒKBD>@OU>@FHB
OUTk>YC¥?AoID>@GU>šRMƒX&FH¹kCU?GJ„HMOU>@FLB"_-BDFHOJ?
–F’ãMƒGN[4C¥?SßDIDXšMƒ>YBk>YBkZ
M [4>šMƒZHBDFLCU>@C8Fƒ5OU?B{RSFLGUGU?2CUIzFHBK[4C¦OUF¢Ḿ CU>@BDZHX@?¦IKMOJT
OUTzMO
CUOSMBKR^?CãMƒGU?&[4GSMg’QB>@BK[4?Iz?BK[4?2B@BD>@BDZ
MBz[8OJ?CUOJ>@BDZFOUTD?(X@?¨MƒGUBD>@BDZMX@ZLFHGU>@OJTDA¼n
MBz[ÑCUF¦A¤Mg‚}GU?¨âLD>@GU?
OUTkGUFHkZHTÔMƒBkf~BDFD[4?¤[½?¨RS>@CU>@FHBŸOJGU??
á OU?CJOUCg‘K>@BOJTD>@CãRMƒCU?-OUTk?GU?(RMƒB8¹z?ùMƒC A¥MB4‚
FHBkXY‚)àHX@FLZ
–FRSFHB4OJ>YB4D?ŸOJTD?¢?¨MƒGUX@>@?GÑ?SßKMAoIDX@?H_CUkIDIKFLCU?¢OJTD?ŸÒKGJCUO
>@B OUTD?Ÿ>@BDCUOSMBKR^? ( ýE) ;ý‡þSý£F R^FHG~f
MOJOUGJ>Y¹kDOU?¢ýÿþ
á OU?2CUOQ„HMX@D?2C OJTKMOQMGJ?¿CJ>@A8IDX@‚(>@GUGJ?X@?„HMB4Ogn
MC)àLXYFLZ
MƒIDIDX@>šRM¹DX@?
—mDG¥A8FD[4?XQFƒX@?¨MGJBD>@BDZÔR2MB"_QOJTD?GJ?S5FHGJ?H_-¹z?
¹DX@F4FD[ OU?CJO MBK[ OJTD? CJD¹DCU?gâHk?B4O MO~f
GU?2CUIzFHBK[4CÑOJF¢OUTk?
_(ý MBK[ ý F RSFHGJGU?CJIKFLBK[ à5GJ?CUIz?¨RSOJ>Y„L?X@‚ á OJF
OUGJ>@¹DDOU?2C¼ý
OUF}A¤MB4‚¥[4>šMZHBkFHCUOJ>šR)ONMCJ“4C¨_MBK[¦’Q>@X@X¹K??CJIK?gRS>šMX@X@‚¼DCJ?Sf
5DX‡’QTk?GU?(OJTD?(?SßDIz?GUOJC¿MƒGU?-DBKMg„HMƒ>YXšMƒ¹DX@?QFHG&MGJ?-DBKM¹kXY?-OJF
M}IKMOJ>Y?2B@X@?H_-A8?2XÅMƒBKRJTDFHX@‚ŸMBK[
FHBkXY‚)M-CUD¹kCU?OF‡OUTD?
OUTzMO#?SßDIz?GUOJC >@B4OU?2B@FHBKMƒXYX@‚-Iz?G~5FLGUA
Ù CUCJDA8?mOUTKMƒOQOUTD?)RSFHBKR^?IDO¿MƒCUCJF½R^>ÅMƒOU?¨[
’?GU?MƒX@X‡IKFLCU>@OU>@„H?Ln
©¦¡¨ RSFHGJGU?CJIKFLBK[4C8OJF¼MB4‚ OJDIDX@? ;ý‡þSý£F
’Q>@OUT)¢¥¤¡¦¡¨
OJ?CUOJC¨n&!Q>@CA8FD[4?2X@¹DX@?
n‡˜‚8RSFHB4OJGNMCJÖ _4>@BFHkG
RSFLCUOOUF[4?gRS>š[4?-’QTD>šRUTOJ?CUOJCQOUF(FLA8>@Ö
DCJ?CQOU?2CUO~f~GU?2XY?2„HMBKRS?-OJF
A8FD[4?2Xµ_ƒOUTD?m?B4„@GJFHBDAo?B4ON•OJ?¨MHRJTD?2G
n
[4?¨R^>Å[½?(’QTD>šRJT¤OJ?CUOJC&OJFIDGU?CJ?B4Ö
þ ) ” FHGѹzFHOJT ý ) c{MƒBK[ ý )
’QTD?GJ?¢?>@OUTk?GÔý
n !Q?BzRS? XšM¹z?X@?¨[¦?SßKMAoIDX@?C(Fƒ&OUTD? RSFLBKRS?IDO ¢¥¤¡¦¡¨© ¦¡¨
”
” Sc ” ” G5 _ ” Sc Sc Sc H5 _ ;c Sc ” ” G5 _
>@BKRSX@K[4?
;c ” Sc Sc B7 n Œ DGJOUTD?2G¨_£C)à ( ý á CUIz?¨RS>ËÒK?CmOUTD?mIDGUFL¹KMgf
MBz[
€¢TD>@X@?OUTD?GJ?(MGU?QCJ?„H?2GNMX‡X@?¨MƒGUBD>@BDZ-CJ‚šRJT8MGJ?¿[4?Sf
CU>@ZLBD?¨[¦OUF}TKMBK[½XY?>@BKR^FHA8IkXY?2OU?>@B45FLGUA¤MƒOU>@FHB¥>@BÑOUTk?CNMAf
’Q>@OJTOUTD?mIKMGJOU>šRSDXšMGCU?O
¹D>@X@>@O~‚(F"?BzRSFHDB4OJ?GU>@BDZM-IKMƒOU>@?B4O
( ý‡‘KÎƒÍ ‡Í@_£C)à ” Sc ” Sc Uá )¦cpc ”
F#CJ‚ËÒK?¨[¥¹4‚
(p˜ Œ —-=Dd e _mD>šœLj4_"Pmd V - á _kOUTD?2‚¼MX@X"MIkIK?¨MƒG&OJF
IDX@?C$à^¨ÐÏÜš_
M [½>²§‡?GJ?B4OAoF½[½?X ( =*(œHh4_"=*(œ e -Un|~BÑOJTD>@C
¹z?¹KMCJ?¨[ÑFLB
”I F"OUTk?&OU>@Ao? ’?&’Q>@X@X›[½?¨MXz’Q>@OUT8M$IKMOJ>Y?2BYOJT
A8?gMBDC
IzFHCU>@OJ>Y„L?&¹DX@F4FD[8MƒBK[Ao?XšMBKRJTDFLXY‚$OU?CJOUC¨_k¹DDOBD?Z4MOU>@„L?&¹D>@X@?
FLGUXš[$IDGUFD[4KR^?CãM-RSFLA8IDX@?OJ?X@‚LfµCJIK?¨R^>²Òz?¨[
A8FD[4?2Xµ_MÂ5OU?GOJTD?Q’
MƒOGNMBz[4FHA¦_¨MmCU?¨R^FHBK[¦ÕJ¹DX@F½RJ“4>@BDZH×mIDGUFDRS?2CUCmà5’QTD>šRJT
CNMƒA8IDX@?
OJ?CUOJC¨n
MBz[8IkTDX@?ZHA
ÕUBzMOUkGU?× á TD>š[4?CQOUTk?¿„HMƒX@D?CF R^?GUOSM>@B MO~f
MX@CJF‰RSFLDXš[¹z?
ʯ È Ê Ã ¸ ©ƒªn¥`QFLOU?oOUTKMƒO¿BkF DCU?^5DX>YB½5FHGJA¤MOJ>@FHB
OUGJ>@¹DDOU?2C
M
|~B{ZH?2BD?GNMƒX~_MŸX@?¨MƒGUBD>@BDZ¢MX@ZLFHGU>@OJTDAKJ»TKMCÑMHR2RS?CUC¦OUF
CUFLDGNR^?(FXÅMƒ¹K?2XY?g[?SßKMAoIDX@?COUTKMƒOãMƒXYX@F’QCJÑOJF8[4GNMg’¢GSMB4f
>@B
>@C¿RSFLB4„H?‚L?¨[¥¹4‚¥OUTD?-~MHRSOmOUTKMƒO¿MB¦MOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?>@CQTD>š[D[½?B
?^ßkMƒA8IDX@?Hn
M)IKMƒGUOU>šRSkXÅMƒG
8/à ( ý á MHRRSFLGN[4>@BDZmOUFmOUTD? [½>YCJOUGJ>²f
ý
á RSFHBzRS?IDO
¹DDOJ>@FHBLC¢MƒBK[$XÅMƒ¹K?2XY?g[(¹4‚-OUTD?QOSMGJZH?Oà5kBD“4BDF’QB
C#FHkOUIDDO>YCM&T4‚4IzFHOUTk?CU>@CO&9¼j§PRQà;’QTD>šRJTA¤Mg‚
/M9N=nJ
X@OJTDFHDZLTÑOUTD?¥AoF½[½?X#>@BÑOUTD>@C)IKMIz?G8MƒXYCJF¼MCJCUDAo?C)OUTKMƒO
Ù
IkGUFDRS?CJC&>@C ZL?BD?GSMOJ>YBkZ8RSFHAoIDX@?OU?QOJDIDX@?CQ’QTD>šRJT
M$GNMBz[4FHA
á n€Ñ?Q[4>@CNRSDCJC ¹z?X@F’ŸTDF’ OJTD>@C#A8FD[4?2X
FHGA¤Mg‚-BDFHO¹K?Q>@B=
GU?2XÅMƒOU?COUF$FHDG#AoFD[4?XDFƒ›¹DX@FDRJ“4>YBkZK_HMƒBK[)OUTD?2B¤[4>@CNR^DCUCTDF’
[4?¨MƒX²f
MGJ?OJTD?BÑIKMƒGUOJ>ÅMƒX@XY‚o¹DX@FDRU“L?¨[‡_‡FLDG-A8FD[4?X[4>˧›?2GUC(¹4‚
¹DX@FDRJ“4>YBkZ¼IDGJFDRS?CUCJ?C OJTKMOoà5OJGU‚ŸOUF á ¹DX@FDRJ“ FLBDX@‚
>@BDZ¦’Q>YOJT
’?¿?2„HMX@KMOJ?SJQn
ÕU>@GJGU?X@?„HMƒB@¹DkOU?C’QTDFLCU?Q„HMX@D?2CÆ[4F-BDFLO
C‰RSXšMƒCUCU>ËÒ›R2MOU>@FLB"n !b?BKRS?L_#’?8[4F BDFLO
Mg§‡?¨RSO)OUTk?8>@BDCUOSMBKR^?
x"rt143 x£TKUDV(3;xXW¦K1DrZY1YB½5FHGJA¤MOJ>@FHB(>ËÆMB8MƒOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?&>@C
~MHRSOg_"’?
„HMX@D?)>@C-BDFHO-BD??g[4?¨[¦;FHG-OUTD?8R^XÅMƒCUCJ>²Ò‡RMOJ>YFLB"n)|~B
XÅMƒ¹K?2XY?g[ >@BDCUOSMBKRS? ( ý 8/#à (
X@?¨MGJBD>@BDZ{A8FD[4?2XYCg_?¨MLRUT
>@C
IKMƒCUCU?g[
ÕNMƒC>YCJ×¼OJFÑOUTD?¦RSXšMCUCJ>ËÒK?G¨nŸ|~BŸFLDGA8FD[4?X~_TDF’f
X@?¨MGJBóM)X@FLOQ¹@BDZOUTKMƒO&MB MOJOUGJ>Y¹kDOU?(>@Cm>YGJGU?X@?Sf
RMƒB
„HMB4Ogn"`QFLOU?#OJTKMO‡OJTD>@C"BDFLOU>@FHBmFDGU?X@?„HMƒBKRS?>@C‡BDFHO"Mƒ¹DCUFLXYkOU?Hû
?„L?G¨_)OUTk?ÔX@?¨MƒGUBD?2G¼>@BDCJOU?¨ML[{FHBkXY‚ CU?2?CÔM
ÕJ¹DX@FDRU“L?¨[{„L?G~f
CU>@FLBD× F (
ý á ×Kn Ù
ý á _’QGU>@OUOJ?BÕ_^à (
¹kXYFDRJ“H?2G
ý 8/à (
ý á B/à (
MB)MOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?QA¤Mg‚Q¹z?Q>@GUGU?2XY?2„HMB4O">@B)OUTD?QRSFHB4OJ?SßDOÆFƒ›RS?GJONMƒ>YB
FHOJTD?G-MOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?-„HMX@D?Cg_DMBK[oGU?2XY?2„HMB4OQ>@B8FHOJTD?G-RMCJ?C¨n
û`* 3 ,Âc ” 8a .
GU?IDXšMLRS?C RS?2GUONMƒ>@B MƒOUOUGJ>@¹DDOU?
^
ÕU¹DX@FDRJ“H?¨[4×+à;FHG{>@B+FHDGR2MCU?L_ ÕN[½FHB O
„HMX@D?2C{¹YG á GJ?X@?„HMBKR^?× ( aYOSdHd%-
’Q>@OUTŸFHOJTD?GoBDFHOJ>YFLBDC)F
(+*(Ž œLi-U_¦MBK[»[4>˧›?2GU?B4OU>šMƒOU?C >@O ;GUFHA
MBz[úÕJOU?¨MLRUTk?GUCJ×
fieXvrgfi…fŽw†l>vdt8”§vt8us„Sv|mfiewxuDw8lip§egfievd8dusegfi„{tBrw•lŽw~r–6t8rR—˜}umfivtxš
X@?¨MGJBKM¹k>YX@>@O~‚ A8FD[4?X@C ’QTD>šRJT
?>@OUTD?2GÑFHA8>@O OJTD?¢RSXšMCJCÑXÅMÂf
rGw~us–tdxo>jDd6eegfi€mlitkw~vvrgfi€sqsvt‘…6w†liqst8e8yw~us„›lŽw~r–6t8r—˜Du§fivtxš©et8v©dxo
( Ù =kœ ” _ Œ *$Ž ] œ e -U_HFLGQ’QTD>šRUT RJTKMƒBDZH?-CUFLA8?&MƒOUOUGJ>@¹DDOU?
¹z?X
=¿dHd4_£ÿ>@ONœ ” _¥*(=Dœ W -°n
„HMX@D?2C,(
j
HlŽwxeet8e8’