Exploiting the Omission of Irrelevant Data - Webdocs Cs Ualberta

Ḩ® ÄÈ ÊLḨÊg¯ 5©ƒÃ O $L³ šÃ4ÄS)à þ€ à5X@B þ á à•€ XYB • á 65zQtþ á ®6?HÊ ª ¬K­@®S³ Ü
w % % qortyK147H02sD795sk3 >o14Šz7sKrts£¡¨9;xz:
–QTD?QIDGJ?„4>@FHDC#CJ?¨RSOJ>YFLB8RSFHBkCU>š[4?GJ?¨[IDGJFH¹KMƒ¹D>@X@>YCJOU>šR#[4?2ZHGNML[DMgf
wu
šª ¬ © ³N³ 5À ­Y®ã¯ © ­Y®SÊ Èà 9’B“ ”• ¯;î
ð^¯ ³
³¨Ê È2 Ê­"Ļ® ÄÈ ÊLḨʯ 5©ƒÃ B ”¤ D Te•]
È ÊH¸ƒÉ®
T ”Q •]
5 à5GJ?CUI"n@_ B ”
N D Te•] B –QTD?ŸX@?CUCØIKF’?G°5DX
ðS¯ ³¼¬ © ³S³ 5À ­Y®Ç¯ © ­Y®SÊ È2à &>=14xK714u¦¥ $
•] ”• w’B“
D
þ
D
È5À ÄÈ ÊLḨʯ 5©ƒÃDÜ
¯ $HŪ®(Ļ®
³¬ © ³S³ ;À ­@®Q¯ © ­Y®SÊ $ ”• ÈÃw9’B“ ðS¯
Ü
à Ḩ® È B ”
N
T •]
à Ḩ® È
È ®S³¨® ÃK¨ ® ©°Ï-àµcB‰à5X@B; b á ” ”¨á Êg¯;¯ È25À $LŪ®(Ḩ® ÄÈ ÊLḨÊg¯ 5©ƒÃDÜ
¬
âLD>@OJ?[4>˧›?2GU?B4O-O~‚4IK?)F [4?ZLGNML[DMOJ>YFLB FDRRSDGJC->²QMB MH[Lf
Ù
‹QBz[4?G+ B ”4Q)•¤P D
o-7xbG#x‡09g¡¨9;xz:£
³(¬ © ³S³ 5À ­Y®¯ © í ñ « ­@®NÊ ÈÃ_9’B“ ”•
”Q)•¤P
¯;î B D
M ðS¯
D
ÄÈ 5©ƒÃDÜ Ḩ® ÊLḨÊg¯
³(¬ © ³S³ 5À ­Y®‰¯ © í ñ « ­@®NÊ ÈÃ_9’B“ ”• ¯5î B •¤P ”
N D M ðS¯
Ϩ©ƒÈ
à ± ¨S©Ã ³NŪÊ Ã ¯ § Š¦” Ü ïtî ³î © ­@ģ³ã®2É® Ã)šÃ ¯5îD®t¬ È ®^³¨® Ãz¨ ®
Ê
„HMX@D?m¹DX@FDRU“4>@BDZ)CU??2A8CQ„H?2GU‚¤MƒIDIDGJFHIDGJ>ÅMƒOU?Hn
X@?¨MƒGUBD>@BDZ
–QTD>@CŸIKMIz?GŸIDGJF„š[4?2CÔCJ?„H?2GNMX¦CUIz?¨RS>ËÒ›R
> b d {
Ï ¯5îD® È ® ³ùʃ­p³ ©$à N P > b d£ N P
> b d {
9’B“ ”• ¯5î à N P
> b d £ N P
b à~d 7 á ”gá Êg¯;¯ È25À $LŪ®
b àµd 7 á ”¨á Êg¯;¯ È25À $LŪ®
©~Ïùàµc 8)à;XYB b á ” ”gá ʯ5¯ È5À $L¯°®$Ḩ® ÄÂÈ ÊHĻÊg¯ 5©ÃDÜ
OU>@FLB"_HFƒ"OUTD?mCUFLGUO#OJTKMOA8>@ZHT4OMGU>@CJ?Q5GJFHA
M-BDFL>YCJ‚‰R^FHA8A½f
Ù [½>²§‡?GJ?B4O AoF½[½?X4GU?Z4MGN[½C OJTD?&[4?ZLGNMgf
BD>šRMƒOU>@FHBRJTKMBDBk?X~n
MC¤M}A¤MƒX@>ÅR^>YFLDCML[4„H?GJCNMƒGU‚4_ ’QTkFÑ“@FHBØIDGUFDRS?CJC
(+*,*(ü-œHh%-›MƒX@CUF-IDGUF„L?C>YO>@C#IzFHCJCU>@¹DX@?
OUFX@?¨MƒGUB_9’B“
–QTD?Q?SßDOJ?BK[4?¨[oIKMƒIK?2G
”•b’Q>YOJT"û
Ý ` Œ ;FHGUAkXÅMk_gOUTD?QCSMA8IkXY?Q[4>@CUOJGU>@¹DDOJ>@FHB"_OJTD?&¹kXYFDRJ“H?2G
OUTk?
MBz[(?„L?B)FHDGCUIz?¨RS>ËÒ›RbX@?¨MGJBD>@BDZ¿MƒXYZLFHGJ>YOJTDA¼_MƒBK[$TKMCCUFLA8?
RSXšMƒCUCU>ËÒ›R2MOU>@FLB BDFH>@CJ?(F \ c W à5Ì~ÍpÎÍ@_DCJOUFDRJTKMCJOU>šRMƒXYX@‚
RJTKMƒBDZH>@BDZ-OUTk?&XšM¹z?XDFƒÿMƒB>YBkCUONMƒBKRS?m’Q>YOJTIDGUFL¹KM¹k>YX@>@O~‚
Š
à5X@>@A8>@OJ?¨[ á IzF’?G#OUF)MX@OU?G?SßKMA8IkXY?2CÆ>@B8MƒB‰MƒGU¹D>@OUGSMGJ‚(µMƒCUT4f
>@FHB"n
¹zFHDBz[4?¨[¥¹4‚ \ á _
–QTD? B ”¡ T •]
5 MH[½„H?GJCNMGJ‚RMƒBRJTKMBDZL? kI(OUFw(MOJOUGU>@¹DkOU?C
D
MƒOUOUGJ>@¹DDOU?mBDFH>@CJ?&F N P > bk” h)à;̵ÍpÎÍ@_CJOUFDRJTKMCJOU>šRMƒXYX@‚
RJTKMƒBDZH>@BDZQOJTD?„HMX@D?FKMB(MƒOUOUGJ>@¹DDOU?’Q>YOJT-CUFHAo?"IDGJFH¹4f
Š
RSFLBDCUOSMB4O‹‡nt–QTKMOt>YCg_g5FLG"?¨MLRUT
>@B(?¨MLRUT>@BDCJONMƒBKRS?H_g;FHGCUFLA8?
” _HFLG
CUzRUT¥MOJOUGU>@¹DkOU?H_LOUTD?-MH[4„L?GUCSMGJ‚8RMBGJ?„H?¨MƒX›MƒB4‚FƒÆcD_
A¤MƒOUOU?2G¿’QTzMO)OUTD?¥MHRSOJKMX„HMX@D?>@C¨_tFHG)’QTD?OJTD?G)>@O
aD_BkF
’QMCQFHGJ>@ZH>@BKMX@X@‚(¹DX@FDRJ“H?¨[ÿn#‹QB45FLGUOJDBKMOJ?X@‚‡û
Mƒ¹D>@XY>@O~‚)¹KFLDBK[4?g[¥¹4‚ á n
’ ?(RMƒB X@?¨MGJB¥>YB¥OJTD?(IDGJ?CU?BzRS?F
|~O&MX@CJF8[4>@CNRSDCJCU?C-’QTD?2B
RSFLA¹D>@BKMOJ>YFLBDC#FƒÆ„HMGJ>@FHDCQ[4?ZLGNMH[kMOU>@FLB¤IkGUFDRS?CJCU?Cgn
o-7xbG#x‡09g¡¨9;xz:£¢
ìÑé´æ ì•£)ë ¡ åké´æ
5 á [4?Sf
R2MB)FHBDX@‚[4?2ZHGNML[4? ¬ © ³ ¯ É® à;GU?CJI"n@_HBD?2Z@„H? á CNMAf
ZHGSMH[4?2G
IDX@?Cgn
CU‚4CJOU?AoC¾MƒGU?[4?CJ>@ZHBD?¨[»OJF ’FHGU“»¹z?CUO
Ž¥FLCUO¢X@?¨MƒGUBD>@BDZ
’QTD?B)OUTk?QOUGNMƒ>@BD>@BDZ&[DMOSM-RSFHBDCJ>@CUOUCF›RSFLA8IDX@?OJ?X@‚LfµCJIK?¨R^>²Òz?¨[
MOJOUGJ>Y¹kDOU?Sf~„HMX@D?OUDIDX@?Cgn"–FmOUTD??SßDOU?B4OOUTzMO"OJTD?>YCJCUD?TKMƒC
¹z??BÑRSFHBDCJ>š[4?GU?g[‡_"Ao>@CUCU>@BDZMOJOUGJ>Y¹kDOU?)„HMX@D?CmTKMg„H?$ZH?BD?2G~f
5 Ḩ® ÄÈ ÊHĻÊg¯ 5©Ã O Ïg©È Ê Ã ± ¨S©Ã ³SŪÊ Ã ¯ ‡Ü ïtî ³mî © ­@ģ³
B ”Q T
MX@X@‚Q¹z??B)GU?Z4MGN[½?¨[MƒC"?SßDOJGU?Ao?X@‚&DBK[½?CU>@GNMƒ¹DX@?Hnt–QTD?#A¤Mƒ>@B
IzFH>@B4O¿FƒãOJTD>@C(IKMƒIK?G$>YC$OUTKMƒO¿CJFHAo?OU>@A8?2C&OUTk?FHIDIzFHCJ>YOJ?>@C
®2É® ü Ï ¯5îD® È ® ³$ʃ­p³ ©à N P
b d£ N P > b d > {
OJTD?$µMHRSOmOUTKMƒO¿MƒBóMƒOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?>@C&Ao>@CUCU>@BDZ
OUGJD?Hn-=4FHAo?OU>@Ao?C
®2­Y®2ÉÊ ÃK¨ ® n)–QTD>@C
>@C-„H?GJ‚¼>@B45FLGUA¥MOU>@„L?Hû>YO-OJ?X@XYC-DC)M¹zFHDOÈ
b àµd 7 á ”gá Êg¯ «
>@B45FLGUA¤MƒOU>@FHB8R2MB¥¹K?)CUFkCU?S5kXÆOJTKMOQ„L?GU‚¥TKMƒGN[¥IkGUFH¹kXY?2A8C
¹z?¨RSFHAo?-OUGU>@„4>šMX~n
5 Ļ® ÄÂÈ Ê «
ïtî ³¤î © ­@ģ³ ®2É® à šÃ ¯;î½®
Ḩʯ ;©Ã O Ϩ©ƒÈ Ê Ã ± ¨S©ƒÃ ³S¯°Ê à ¯ ‡Ü
Ž¥FLGU?F„L?G¨_mOUTD>@Co?SßKMHRSOoCU>@OUKMƒOU>@FHBt_Q’QTD?GJ?¼Ao>YCJCU>@BDZ¦>@B45FHG°f
>@B¢IDGSMHRSOJ>ÅR^?Hn Ž¥FHCJO
A¤MƒOU>@FHB¢RMƒB¢¹z?ÑDCU?S;DX~_¿RMƒB¦FDRR^DG
Ê È¨À ¯ È Ê È ­Ë± RJTKMƒBDZH?m>@BDCUOSMBKRS?2C (pü "œLi%-°n£!QF’f
„H?2GUCNMƒGU‚8RMƒB
IKMƒCUCÑM
?„L?G¨_’?ÔMƒCUCJDA8?ØOUTKMƒO¼OJTD?¢MH[4„L?GUCSMGU‚{TzMCÑOUF
MƒBK[)GU?gRSFHGS[¥FHBDX@‚M-CUA¥MX@X
RSXšMCJCU>ËÒ›RMƒOU>@FHBoCU‚4CUOJ?A8CIz?G~5FLGUA
F#OJTD?(CU?2O¿Fƒ#IKFLCUCU>@¹DX@?)OU?CJOUC-OUFoGU?¨MLRJT¼M8RSXšMƒCUCU>ËÒDf
5GSMHRSOJ>YFLB
RMƒOU>@FHB"n#=½F>Ë"OUGSM>@BD>@BDZ[DMOSM(TzMCQ¹z??B¥IDGUFD[4zRS?¨[¥¹4‚CUzRUT
RS?GJONMƒ>YB´5GNMLRSOU>@FLB¼Fƒ&>YBkCUONMƒBKRS?C)DBKRJTKMƒBDZH?g[‡‘#Ì~ÍpÎÍ@_‡FHB¦?¨MLRUT
MH[4„L?GUCSMGJ‚¢’Q>@XYX~_’Q>@OUT IDGUFL¹KM¹k>YX@>@O~‚ ” ¨§z_
>@BDCUOSMBKR^?¼OJTD?
Ú MƒC >@BFHkG#A8FLOU>@„HMOJ>YBkZ&?SßKMAoIDX@? FƒÆM-CUOJK[4?B4O
M-CJ‚šRMƒXHGU?gRSFHGS[4CÚ,FLDGA8FD[4?XLFDCUkIK?G°ÖKDFLDC
?SßKMAo>@BD>@BDZ
OJTD?¥X@?¨MGJBD?G)?SßKMHRSOJXY‚¦OUTk?óMƒIDIDGJFHIDGJ>ÅMƒOU?¹DX@FDRJ“H?¨[´>@B4f
CUTkF’
CUOSMBKR^?Hn
!QF’?„H?2G¨_Q’Q>@OUTºIDGUFL¹KM¹D>@X@>@O~‚©§z_QOJTD?¼MH[½„H?GJCNMGJ‚
RMƒBÔGJ?IDXšMHR^? OUTD?¥>@BDCJONMBzRS? ’Q>@OUT
Ê Ã ±g¯;î šÃ½Ä ?X@CU?H_QMƒCXYFLBDZ
MC¥OJTD?ÑCNMƒA8?¼RSXšMƒCUC¥XšM¹z?X->YC¥DBzRUTzMBDZL?¨[‡nàQÍ ‡ÍY_>ËOUTD?
MX@ZHFƒf
IzMGUOJ>šMX@X@‚Hf~CUIz?¨RS>ËÒK?g[Ÿ>@B4f
GU>@OJTDA8COJTKMO8RMƒB¦[4?¨MƒX-’Q>YOJTŸOUTD?
CJ‚²Ò‡RMOJ>YFLB
)+ýÿþNý¥¤MƒBK[ÑOJTD? ¹DX@FDRJ“H?¨[´XšM¹z?X@?¨[
ONMƒGUZL?O8RSFHBzRS?IDOo>YC/
;ý þ ý R5 _zOUTD?MH[½„H?GJCNMGJ‚ A¤Mg‚GJ?IDXšMHR^?OJTD>@C
>@BDCUOSMBKR^?>@C
ýÿþ^ý5 _z?„H?B¦OUTkFHDZLT OUTD?RSFLGUGU?gRSO
>@BDCUOSMBKR^?’Q>@OUT}CNMg‚)
[4KR^?Hn
€Ñ? CJTDF’(_->@B¢IKMGJOU>šRSDXšMƒG¨_-OUTzMO¥>@OóR2MB ¹K?Ñ„L?GU‚
ýÿþNý#>@CBDFHO–(ng|~O#RMBkBDFHOg_TDF’?„H?Gg_GU?2IDXšMHRS?QOJTD>@C
]zÙ EØX@?¨MƒGUBD×[4?¨RS>@CJ>YFLBOUGJ??C¿MƒBK[ Ý ` Œ 5FLGUADXšMƒ?
?¨MƒCU‚OUF¦Õ
RSXšMCUCJ?C¥OUTKMƒÖ _Q[4?CJID>@OU? >@B4OU?2BDCU? CJOUK[½‚@BŸOUTD>@CA8FD[4?2XÚ
XšM¹z?XL5FHG
ý þ ý 7 _zBDFHGm?„H?B¦’Q>@OUT ;ý þ ý ‘7 n á
¹z?X@?¨MGJBKM¹DX@?>ËQOUTD?oXY?gMGUBk?G>@C-ZH>@„L?B
MGJ?BDFHO$“ËÒK?g[
’Q>YOJT
5ý þ ý R5
á [4?ZLGNML[DMOJ>YFLB"_gOUTD?
à;GU?CJI"n@_ B ”
N
•P D
MH[½„H?GJCNMGJ‚(TKMƒCÆOJTD?IKF’?GOUF(RJTKMBkZH?IKFLCU>@OU>@„H?bà5GU?2CUI"n@_LBD?Zf
¹z?¤?^ß½OJ?BK[4?g[ŸOUF¦>@BKRSGU?2A8?B4ONMƒX@XY‚}A8FD[4>Ë5‚
MX@ZLFHGU>@OJTDA8C(RMƒB
>@BD>@OU>šMƒX Ý ` Œ 5FLGUADXšMk_ÆMƒBK[´ÒKBKMX@X@‚Ñ?SßDOU?2BK[ŸFHkG
M¦ZH>@„L?B
MOJ>@„H? á ?SßKMƒA8IDX@?C>@B8OUTk>YC~MCUTk>YFLB"n
OUTD?
A8FD[4?2XÆOJF8TKMƒBK[4X@?)„HMGU>@FLDC-O~‚YFLBD×¥>@B
OUTzMO(M¥A8>@CJCU>@BDZ8„HMƒX@D?>@C(MB¦DBDGJ?Sf
¹DX@FDRJ“@BDZ¥IDGJFDRS?CUCoà5CJF
á _&MC’?X@X¿MƒCBDFH>@CJ?¤IkGUFf
X@>šM¹DX@?8>@BK[½>ÅR2MOUFLGF->YGJGU?X@?„HMƒBKRS?
RS?CJCU?Cgn
d
Ḩ® ÄÈ ÊLḨÊg¯ 5©ƒÃ8Ϩ©ƒÈ Ê Ã ± ¨S©Ã ³SŪÊ Ã ¯ § Š»” Ü ïtî ³î © ­@ģ³8®É® Ã