Exploiting the Omission of Irrelevant Data - Webdocs Cs Ualberta

qTOKlM¡ ¦¢
!
!
#
!
’nŽM|‡‚¢}„}TˆzTw\zT}T ‚ © b ‰ §‡§Œ§ ‰ tTt€ƒŽ ‹E¾¦ ŽT‘’nŽTˆ‚ˆ¥3¥¿,wy|‡‚ &ŽT w\ˆT‰
TNMO•jTlT²ER © Š §Œ§Œ§
¨
'
w\zT‚¢¿Z¼‚{¼‚€ Ž(}T „‚ƒ’Ø ‚€ ‘- © b ‰ §Œ§Œ§ ‰ ¨ tTt,â‚
® © $¥D‹ ª
5©ÃÑ È ¸ Êg³­Y®SÊ ÈÃDšÃ4Ä ”•ošÃ 9’B“ ¯;î½®³S¯°Ê Ã4«
¯ ³Ê³î½Ê
¸ ª‰© Ḩ®2­ Ü È ĻÊ
Ü ð^¯ ³ šª ¬ © ³S³ 5À ­Y®¯ © ­@®NÊ 7 F”• ¯;î à ” Dc á Êg¯ «
¯ È5À $L¯°®(Ļ® ÄÂÈ ÊHḨʯ ;©ÃDÜ
ÈÃw’B“
ðS¯ ³{¬ ³S³ ­Y® © í &>=14xK714u;: ñ « ­Y®SÊ ÈÃ © 5À ¯
¯;î àµc 8 9
á ʯ5¯ È5À $L¯°®oḨ® ÄÂÈ ÊHĻÊg¯ 5©Ã¢õJÈ ®^³~¬ 8 9
ÜO à
”• 9’B“ M
® É® ³"¬ © ³S³ 5À ­@®¯ © í © ñ « ­Y®SÊ È2Ã-àCBzX@FHZR á ò¼©È ”•
¯
¯;î à&Nc á ʯ5¯ È5À $L¯°®(Ļ® ÄÂÈ ÊHḨʯ ;©Ã $L³ ÐÃ4Ä ¬ © ³ ¯ É®)®6?HÊ ª$«
¬K­@®S³Ê­ ©ƒÃ
ÈO
Ϩ©ƒÈ Ê Ã ± õ~ÁÃK© Ãgø ÉÂʃ­ $D® ©°Ï ÀS© $ à Ļ®N¸¦Ê§Ê±
O «9’B“ M
®O
” OJF a¦’Q>YOJTŸIDGUFL¹KM¹D>@X@>@O~‚ BQ D
þ
RSFLX@XY?gRSOU>@BDZ¼MƒX@X GP
65 J
!QF’?„L?G¨_’?¤RMƒBÑGU?¨R^F„H?GOJ?GUAoC(¹4‚
CJ>@Ó? CUk¹DCU?OJC¦Fƒ IzFHCJ>YOJ>@„H?{CNMƒA8IDX@?Cg_ MBK[ ÕU„LFHOJ>YBkZH×
à5CJ??)(pü¿Ž}P Q œ e - á n¥–QTzMO(>@C¨_t’?8RSFHBDCJOUGJKRSO8M¥OJ?GUA+;GUFHA
j@
?¨MLRUTCJ>@Ó?SfUj¦)CUk¹DCNMƒA8IDX@?#¹4‚RSFHBDCJ>š[4?GU>@BDZ-?¨MLRJT„HMGU>šMƒ¹DX@?
>@B8OJDGUB"_DMƒBK[CJ?OUOJ>@BDZ>@O OJF‰ck_ ” _LFHGŒa)MHRRSFLGN[4>@BDZ)OUF)’QTD>šRJT
„HMX@D?>@C#ZH>@„L?BAoFHCJOÆFƒ5OU?2BOUFý
ýT
>@BOJTD?&CJD¹DCNMƒA8IDX@?Hnt\„H?B T
‹QB½5FHGJOUDBKMƒOU?X@‚4_D’?RMƒB¼OJFHX@?GNMƒOU?(AzRUT¥X@?CJC¿[4?ZLGNML[DMOJ>YFLB
5FLGBD?2Z@„H?8?^ßkMƒA8IDX@?Cgn¦–QTD?5FLX@XYF’Q>@BDZ¥GJ?CUDX@OGJ?¨âLD>@GU?C
B*N b à~d D 7 á _z’QTD?2GU? 7 >@C&OUTk?à5IzFHX@‚4BDFHAo>šMXzCU>@Ó? á { Š
þ
IKJMLKNMOPQMRTS ÕØ×KÙ_ÚZÛ ^„`…ܢݡ £¢Ød1 ‰ ß ‰¥¤ f 8‰ œ — ˆ§‰8Šxš oMf:qT” rTsMmnj
© =
—lid6– b #
šH— =¥§©¨
liu ¨
šmk § * b QTOKlgPŒ˜ZPŒ˜KLdƒ–nJTNT²M³KjM- ¢KjMLTOKlMKjM—lE˜K•JTlE–njTJTjMZohTlESTmnJTjTh
¨
# mnNThgPQP ¯ jGhTlESTmnJTjTh*hTjTjE˜¤
liu
“TjMQ¡) * –nj—QMRnjVkPOKhMQ•lMQ—SnNThMQ =¥§¨
“TjMQ¡).-–nj•lTJTJ¢QMRnjžñjMLKlMQP ¯ j*hTlESTmnJTjTh*hTjTjE˜¤
á ¤ hE¬T–nhTjMQKh*NMk?) * ¤
“TjMQä–njphTjMQ•NMk±lTJTJ—hgPKj
© ‡6‹ ¤
šŒ˜ZPQP£lTJgPTj
TNMO•jTlT²ER © ‡ b ‰ §Œ§Œ§ ‰ ¥k § ‹ œ
® © "¥{‹ ª
!˜T¬TS ® — ‰¥"š © ª ‡ $# f $#
% &
® © · ¥{‹ ª
“TjMQ
˜T¬TS ® — ‰ · š © ª ‡ $# f $#
˜T¬TS ® — ‰46š © ª ‡ $# f $#
“TjMQ ® © lMOTLMSnl¦( ‡ ˜T¬TS ® d„², *)o:f¦)*œ ‡ Æ ‰ Å ‰¥+m‹‹
šk ²TNE˜KQTOKlMP£²MQ h*lMQ•JTjTlThMQ
!/. 01¡.
NMkpQMRnj*QKjMOMSnhpPŒ˜B).-…
ITT QKN ¤
2. 3.
¤
«KjMQM¬KOM˜—QMRnj*P£h">E¬Tñ²MQP£NE˜—NMk•QKjMOMSnh¢PŒ˜
ÕØ×KÙZÚ_Û ^a`ŠÜ¢Ý¡ £¢
ÇM˜K
Œ >@ZHDGJ? W û–QTD?.-0 a)c,2,3E4/56 MƒXYZLFHGJ>YOJTDA
5FHG-à ”cb ds þ¥465
”§b ds þ¥465
{
b à~d 7 á ”gá [4?ZHGSMH[DMƒOU>@FHBtn
ĻÊ È ¸ ª‰© Ḩ®2­ õ ¯5î ¨S©ª ¬K­@®SŪ®)Êg¯;¯ È;À $LŪ®S³ øHÜ
BCN D ML B*N D á [4?ZHGSMH[DMƒOU>@FHBOJF(BD?Z4MOJ>Y„L?
CUOSMBKR^?H_DMBK[oMIDIkXY‚oàKL
þ
á ʯ5¯ È5À $L¯°®oḨ® ÄÂÈ ÊHĻÊ «
YLÜ ô"®SÊ ÈÃDÐÃ4Ä9’B“ F”• ¯;î à þ
>@BDCUOSMBKR^?C¨û,!b?BKRS?H_tZH>@„L?B¼MB¦>@BDCUOSMBKR^? ” Sc 8a ” H5 _z>@O
’Q>@X@X&RUTzMBDZL?¼ý‡þ@)
_QMƒBK[
RJTKMBkZH?8ý0)
n‰˜DO
aoOJF¼à;CNMg‚ á” ’Q>@OUT¦IDGUFL¹KM¹k>YX@>@O~‚ BQ D
ZH>@„L?B(OUTk?Q>YBkCUONMƒBKRS? ” Sc 8a Sc B7 _ƒ>YOt’Q>@XYX4RJTKMBDZL?&ý þ ) ”
OUFa-’Q>@OUT8IkGUFH¹zM¹D>@X@>@O~‚ BCN D
_DMBz[RUTzMBDZL?¿ýŒ) a(OJFà5CSMg‚ á
” ’Q>@OUT)IDGJFH¹KMƒ¹D>@XY>@O~‚ B*N D
Ù C#’?QCU?2?&CUTkFHGUOJX@‚@OUTDAoCOJTKMO¥RMBºXY?gMGUBº’Q>YOJT
–QTD?GJ?
MƒA8FHkB@FHB"n Œ >@GUCJÖ _>@O>@CGJ?XšMOU>@„L?X@‚
CUA¥MX@X
[½>YCJGUDIkOU>@„H?Hn}|~B RSFHB4OJGNMCJÖ _FLDG(BD?SßDO
[DMƒOU>@FHBÑRMBعK?o„H?GJ‚
B*N D [4?ZLGNMH[kMOU>@FLB"n
GU?2CUDX@O&>@CDBKM§›?¨R^OU?¨[}¹4‚¤MGJ¹D>@OUGSMGU‚OL
OJF¼X@?¨MƒGUBØ5GJFHA+IKFLCU>@OU>@„L?¤?^ßkMƒA8IDX@?C)MX@FHBD?L_#’Q>@OUTØDI
?¨MƒCU‚
b á [4?ZLGNML[DMOJ>YFLB¼Fƒ ?>@OUTk?G-CU>@BDZHX@?)O~‚4IK?H_tMX@FHBD?Ln
OUF@)à;X@B;
?¨MLRJT¼RMCJ?H_zZH>@„H?2B¤OJTD>@C¿[4?2ZHGNML[DMOJ>@FHB¥’ ?)RMB ?^ß½Iz?¨RSO-OJF
|~B
OUTD? Ý ` Œ 5FLGUADXšM)MO-X@?¨MCJO
CU?2?OUTD?)>@A8IzFHGUOSMB4OQOU?2GUA8Cm>@B
?oGU?¨R^?>@„H? ¹zFHOJT IzFHC~f
!Q?2GU?H_OUTk>YC)GU?2CUDX@OCUTkF’QCOJTKMOg_#>Ë&’
?^ßkMƒA8IDX@?Cg_Q’?¼RMB{[4?¨MƒX-’Q>YOJT¢IzFHC~f
>@OU>@„H?¦MBK[ŸBk?Z@„H?
FHBzRS?H_QMBK[´>š[4?B4OU>Ë5‚ÑOJTD?A
MƒCCUKRJT à5GSMOUTk?G8OJTKMBŸMC8[4?Sf
NQP > á _m5FLGóMƒGU¹D>@OJGNMGJ‚ ÿn
>@OU>@„H?Ñ[4?ZLGNML[DMOJ>YFLB¦FƒFHGS[4?G‰à
ZHGSMH[4?g[ OJ?GUAoC á n-˜?X@F’(_‡’ ?)RSFHBDCJ>š[4?G MƒBK[ }XY?2CUC-OUTKMƒB
[4?ZLGNML[DMOJ>YFLB >YCÑCJ¡ ¤RS>@?B4OUX@‚ XšMGJZH?ŸOUTKMƒOÑ’ ?ºA¤Mg‚
–QTD>@C
MBŸ?B4OU>@GJ?X@‚ RSFHGJGU?¨RSO¦à;̵ÍpÎÍ@_RSFHAoIDX@?OU?2XY‚¦DB4f
BDFLO?„L?G8CJ??
Dc WD. 5FHG$CUFHAo?¤¨S©Ã ³SŪÊ Ã ¯ ÿn¥à5–QTD?¥MHRSOJKMXMXËf
A8>@B ,ƒ¡8 9
[4?ZLGNML[4?¨[ á OU?GJA¼_#’Q>@OJTD>@BÔIzFHX@‚4BDFLA8>šMX@X²‚}A¤MB4‚¦CNMƒA8IDX@?Cgn
ZHFLGU>@OUTkA8C MƒIDIK?gMG&>@B ( *
*(ü-œHh%-Un á
Dc á
)à•=
Êg¯;¯ È5À $HŪ®{Ḩ® ÄÈ ÊLḨÊg¯ 5©ƒÃgøO $L³ ÐÃ4Ä
€ X@B • á ®6?HÊ ª ¬K­@®S³
õJÈ ®^³~¬ ÜO )à• <
€ X@B • á ®A?ƒÊ ª ¬z­Y®^³ øOÊ Ã ¸ $L³ šÃ4Ä ©ƒÃ ­²±o¬ © ³ @«
¯ É®)®A?ƒÊ ª ¬z­Y®^³ Ü
>ËÿMùOU?GJA
>@C#DBDX@>@“H?X@‚(OJF(?„L?GãMƒIDIz?¨MG’Q>@OUTDFLDO MB4‚[4?ZLGNMgf
n—b›RSFLDGUCJ?H_
[DMƒOU>@FHB"_gOJTD>@C"„HFLOU>@BDZQIDGJFDRS?¨[4DGJ?¿RMƒB(GU?gRSF„H?G>@Ö
OUTk?&IDGJF½R^?¨[4DGJ?¿’Q>@X@XDMX@CUF$ZH?BD?2GNMOJ?&OJ?GUAoC#OUTKMƒO#CUTkFHDXš[)BDFLO
>@BKRSX@K[½?¨[(>@B-OUTk? X@?¨MƒGUBD?G CÆT4‚4IzFHOUTk?CU>@C¨‘L’? DCJ? OJTD?BD?Zf
¹z?
FLDOOUTD?CJ?->YBzMIDIDGJFHIDGJ>šMOU?mOU?GJA8Cgn
MOJ>@„H?Q?SßKMAoIDX@?C#OJF(ÒKX@OJ?G
ÏÈS©ª
” Ü
>@BKMX@X@‚@OJTѹKFLOUT O~‚4Iz?CF([4?ZLGNMgf
Œ
>@OUC&¹z?CJO¿X@>@ZHT4Og_4>YOm>@C&DCJ?S5DX
[DMƒOU>@FHB"n–F8CJ??)OUTD>@C&GJ?CUkXYOm>@B
âLKMB4OJ>YO~‚ZL>@„H?Bo>YB Œ >@ZHDGJ? W n
[4>@CJOU>@BDZHk>YCJT¼¹z?O~’??BØOUTD?8[4?2ZHGNML[DMOJ>@FHB¦GNMOJ?)5FHG-IzFHCJ>²f
OUF
OU>@„L?8>@BDCUOSMBKR^?C¤MƒBK[ÑBD?2Z@„H?8>@BDCJONMƒBKRS?CgnŸ|~BÔIzMGUOJ>šRSDXšMGg_
OUTk? 8ED
[4?ZHGSMH[DMƒOU>@FHB{AoFD[4?X(’Q>@X@XMIkIDX@‚
GFIHKJ”
HGJ” GF 1 J” F 1 J /F
&>=14xK714uSR
.-0 a)c,2,3E4/56 Ê­ ă©ƒÈ ¯;î ª õ ? @Ä $ È ®UT ø¦¨ Ê Ã ­Y®SÊ ÈÃ
ïtî½®
V
àKL
BQ D ML BQ D á MƒOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?[4?ZLGNMH[kMOU>@FLB¤OJF8?¨MLRJT IKFLCU>@OU>@„L?(>@B4f