Exploiting the Omission of Irrelevant Data - Webdocs Cs Ualberta

txw†l¤£+drgli„¦¥
w~h j§lit©¨Rt8ust8rGwxvdr
¢¡
š — §
–QTD>@C)IKMIz?G8RSFLBDCU>š[4?GJC ³$g¬½® È=< $
lid§¢6t8r
Š>Š\ˆ>ˆH‰©
—_“gusevGw~us8t
Š©XˆH‰
fieRqsu§lŽw~€DtHlitB„ yq{u§€§lid§4t8„}š
© $L³ « ÉÂʃ­ $D® À ­ ©g¨^Á ® È ³ ûÌ~ÍpÎÍ@_
:9g¡¨9;xD:BADC§UFE‡/HG1@¹DDOJ?C&MGJ?(>@BµMLRSOQ¹DX@FDRJ“H?¨[‡n
A8FD[4?2Xµ_mRSFHBDCJ>š[4?G OJTD?ѹK?2TKMg„4>YFLG¥F8M
–FŸA8FHOJ>@„HMOU?¥FLDG
OJGU??H_^
RSXšMCJCU>ËÒK?G©\@]DCU>@BDZ¥MCUOSMBK[kMGN[¦[4?¨R^>YCJ>@FHB
!Q?GJ?H_tZH>@„H?BÑMB4‚ >@BDCJONMƒBKRS?H_
mD>šœLj%-°n
Œ e FLG (p˜ ( —-=Dd -
àµMƒBK[¦GU?gRSFHGS[ ’Q>@X@X#Iz?G~5FLGUA á FHBDX@‚ OJTD?8OJ?CUOJCFLB M¥CU>@B4f
] \ `)fhgji
fie wReglnfi–|§vwx€{qsetd~ou{d6vGw~vgfid6u y}w~e k8c|§fie h w†pŒ€Dtevd§G|Dwxeml
vgfi’Xc|mfiexw8…txwxvw†liedLw~jsjmlnfitBe‘vd©ntH˜}umfivgfid6u Š6’
!
"$#%¦&(')#&
+,)-. **
+,2-. +,)-. /10 /10
+,)-. +,)-.
3 5 tBe7698•d
( MXšd e _ ü ] ¿d V -(OUFØCUIz?¨RS>Ë5‚¢OJTD?¼[4?CJ>@GU?¨[ Iz?G~;FHG~f
:9g¡¨9;xD:DuBCo M ­ ă©ƒÈ ¯;î ª J ]zÙ Ef
X@?¨MGJBDC Êm³¨®S¯ ©~Ï&¨S©ÃK¨ ®°¬D¯;³ =¼ Ϩ©È ÏO ³ ©ª ®¬ © ­Ë± ÃK©ª) ʃ­ Ï $ ÃK¨^«
q_pwvU3;14sD7:95:tŠhJ >o1@?
Ϩ©ƒÈ áO ʃ­š­zŪÊ È~Ä ®^¯ ¨S©ÃK¨ ®°¬D¯;³ /M9‚= O㸠³S¯ È25À $L¯ 5©Ã ³
¯ 5©Ã©xÿàXyyzy
O(Ê ¸¦® ¬DÊ È Ê ª ®SŪ® È C c J
à þ È2ÈN©È
à áO"Ê /V‚ ¸ © $LȲ¬¥$H¯;³¿Êùî@ZHkGU? ” û˜#X@FDRJ“4>YBkZ8Ž¥FD[4?X
á OJFH“H?2BÕBaƒ×K_t¹DDO)FHOJTD?GU’Q>@CJ?8X@?¨Mg„H?2C ( ýØMBK[´OUTD?oXÅMÂf
RMƒGU?×
OUTk?(OUGJ??Hn–QTD?(FLOUTD?Gm„HMGJ>ÅMƒ¹DX@?C¨_DR^FHGUGJ?Sf
ZHX@?-IKMƒOUT¥OUTDGJFHDZLT
OJTKMO [½F(BDFHOXšM¹z?XzBDFD[4?C#FLBOUTD>@CIKMƒOUT"_
CUIzFHBz[4>@BDZ(OUF-OJ?CUOJC
ý á >@B4ONMLRSÖ ‘}CU?? Œ >@ZHDGJ? ” n
¹z?X@/#à (
!Q?BzRS?H_¼M ¹kXYFDRJ“H?2G
A¤MI ” ” Nc ” H5 OJF _^à ” ” Sc ”Uá H5 )
RSFLDXš[
” 8a 8a 8a G5 _tFHG'_^à ;c ” Sc ” Já 87 ) ga ” Sc 8a 87 ‘
BkFHO(A¥MOUOJ?G¨û\@]&’Q>@X@X#GU?¨MLRJT OUTk?8CNMƒA8?RSFHBzRSX@DCU>@FHBÑBkF
[4F
’ ?ML[…SDCJO&OJTD?>@G&„HMƒXYk?C¨n&=½?¨RSOU>@FLB¼i?SßDOJ?BK[4C
A¤MƒOUOJ?GQTDF’
OUTk>YCQ>š[4?gM)OUF)ZH?BD?2GNMX Ý ` Œ ;FHGUAkXÅMƒ?Hn
¹DDO-BDF¥CJKRJT¼¹DX@FDRJ“H?G)RMB¦A¤MƒI ” ” Nc ” H5
OJF¤?2>YOJTD?G
” Sc Sc ” G5 _tFHG' ” ” Nc ” 8a n&‡?OS*;: ) ,Âc ” Ba .
[4?BkFHOU?$OUTD?-CU?2O&FIKFLCUCJ>Y¹kXY?->@BDCJONMBzRS? Ḩ®^³ ¨È2 ¬D¯ 5©Ã ³ n
¡g14795xz:R¨ €Ñ? DCJ? OJTD? CJONMƒBK[DMGS[
om147TUxK7uÑsD:Wƒ1qp-79
] GUFH¹zM¹DX@‚ Ù IDIDGJFgßD>YA¥MOJ?X@‚ EFLGUGJ?¨RSOU× à ]zÙ E á RSGJ>YOJ?Sf
Õ
GU>@FLB
¹DX@FDRJ“H?GJC(OUTKMƒO-FHBDX@‚¥¹DX@FDRU“¦MOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?„HMX@D?C-OJTKMO([4F¥BDFLO
CRSXšMCUCJ>ËÒ›RMOJ>@FHB"_ZL>Y„L?BÑOUTk?8„HMX@D?2C(F
Mg§‡?¨RSOMBÑ>@BDCJONMƒBKRS?
A¤MƒBKRS?ØF¤FLDGÑX@?¨MGJBD?GJC¨n
Œ FHG MB4‚{T4‚4IKFLOUTD?2CU>@C O"_XY?2O
ý áUá ¹K?$OUTD?(IkGUFH¹zM¹D>@X@>@O~‚OUTKMƒO
ÈÈLà î á ) C)à ( ý}û}/à ( r
ý áts
) Oÿà (
O¥’Q>@X@XKAo>@CNRSXšMCJCU>Ë5‚MB¥>@BDCUOSMBKR^? (
OUTk?¼FLOUTD?GoDB4¹DX@FDRU“L?¨[¢MƒOUOUGJ>@¹DDOU?¦„HMX@D?2C¨n{–FÑCUOSMOJ?¼OJTD>@C
A8FLGU?mIDGU?¨R^>YCJ?X@‚‡û
ý}[4GNMg’QBo5GJFHÀ
Cnt–QTD?Bt_
õ îD® È ®®NÊ ¨ î ST‘9,c ”§. ³‰Ê¤³µ¬D® ¨ · ®S¸¥ÉÂʃ­ $D® ø
U O
†>C 9ˆ‡ ¸ ³S¯ È;À $L¯ 5©ÃDÜ#©ƒÃ+* ‰‘/ 9‚=
/#àSLþSP XS á )
Nc á
/àSLþXSP Sc
³Ot¯5îD®-ÉÂʃ­ $D®^³ ©~Ï ¯;î½®b³$g¬½® $ © $L³ùÉÊ È2 Ê À ­Y®^³ù¸ ©
È=< ïtîDÊg¯
”
/V‚>@CtOUTD?)ÕUCJ>YÓ2?×-FKOJTD?&RSFHBzRS?IDO/ àµ[4?Sf
ÒKBD?g[¦¹K?X@F’ á
„}
Èȃà O á ×¥>@C
Œ
{ áwŠ _›MƒBK[}OUTD?IDGJFH¹KMƒ¹D>@X@>YO~‚ØÕBC)àr
|~B)OUTD>@CÆ[½?SÒKBD>@OU>@FLB"_Ž‚
MƒXYX‡CSMAoIDX@?C FƒÆOJTD?MIkIDGUFLIDGU>šMOJ?
ONMƒ“H?B¥F„L?GQOUTD?$CUIKMLRS?(F
CU>@Ó?L_D’QTD>šRJT8>@CQCU>@AoIDX@‚(OUTD?-IDGJFD[4KRSO&[4>@CJOUGU>@¹DkOU>@FHBo>YBz[4KRS?¨[
³¤Ê CUDIz?G~ÖzDFHDCo„HMX@D?
ý á n#`bFHOJ?MX@CUF)OUTzMOQOUTk?(B4DA¹K?2G Fƒ >@BDCJONMƒBKRS?CmCU??B
¹4‚NC)à (
¹4‚J
ʯ5¯ È5À $L¯°®^³ ,Âý PRQtþ
RMƒB¢¹K?¦MOA8FLCUOJ CGUDBkBD>@BDZÑOU>@A8?L_#MBK[ØOUT4DCo>@C
MX@CJF¤IzFHX@‚4BDFLA8>šMX‡>@B
þ€ _ þ MƒBK[B‚ /V‚Ën Œ >YBzMX@X@‚ÅR^?OUTKMƒO
OUTk?(X@?¨MGJBD?G&>@CQ?SßDIz?¨RSOJ?¨[¦OUF8MLRâLD>@GU?(MRSXšMCJCU>ËÒK?GmOUTKMƒO&TKMƒC
¬K­@®SŪ®­Ë±o³µ¬D® ¨ · ®S¸ >@BDCJONMƒBKRS?Cg_?„H?B
TD>@ZHTÑMHR2RSDGNMLRS‚ÑFHB¢¨S©ª
. Ü
Œ FHG#?SßKMƒA8IDX@?H_§^à ” Nc ” ”Uá ) aNc ” Ba >@C MƒXYX@F’?¨[ ©Ã ­²±
13WSP
Ï¢MƒXYX5FLDG>@BDCJONMƒBKRS?C 5c Sc ” Sc _ ;c Sc ” ” _ ” Sc ” Sc _
>@O&’QMC-OUGSM>@BD?¨[¥FLB ¹DX@FDRJ“H?¨[}„HMX@D?Cgn&–QTk>YCm>@C¿GJ?¨Mgf
OUTkFHDZLT
MCJCUDAo>YBkZ OUTKMƒÖ _Mg5OJ?GX@?¨MƒGUBD>@BDZz_OUTD?
CUFLBKM¹kXY?¥MC’?¤MƒGU?
á ’Q>@X@Xz¹K?->@B8M(IzFHCJ>@OU>@FHBoOUF)CUIz?¨RJf
RSXšMCJCU>ËÒK?G-à;GU?¨ML[ØÕN[4FDRSOJFHGU×
>Ë5‚OUTk?¿OJ?CUOJC-OUF¹z?¿Iz?G°5FHGJA8?¨[‡n
” Nc ” ” TKMg„H?mOUTD?-CNMƒA8?&RSXšMƒCUCU>ËÒ›R2MOU>@FLB"n Ù RR^FHGN[½>YBkZ
MBz[
BD?„L?G-¹DX@F½RJ“4C&MB4‚
OUFoOUTD>@C-[4?SÒKBD>@OJ>YFLB"_KM¦ÕJ¹DX@FDRU“L?GU×o’QTD>šRJT
!bF’ ?„L?G¨_QMƒC’?¥CU??¥XšMOJ?G¨_
MOJOUGJ>Y¹kDOU?C8MƒO‰MƒX@XãâLKMƒXY>ËÒK?2C¨n
MX@X&FƒOUTD?
OUTk?¼>@B4OU?GJ?CUOJ>@BDZ¦RMƒCU?C¼MƒGU>@CU?¦’QTD?GJ?ÑA8FLCUO8FLG
ox¡gs£¡g95xz:R¨ ‡?O‘9’B“ ”•m¹K?-OJTD?(CU?2O&F Ý ` Œ 5FHGJADXšM?H_
OU?2GUA8Cg‘KMƒBK[¥X@?OVw’B“
F„H?2GÆOJTD?Œ¹zF4FHX@?¨MƒB„HMƒGU>šM¹DX@?Cý‡þNýK_L’Q>@OUTMƒO#A8FLCUOH–
` Œ 5FHGJADXšM?&F„L?G&ýÿþ Sý›n Œ FHG&MƒB@B
9ˆ9’B“
Ê8­@Ê©`ba)ced
OU?2GUA8C)>@BKRSX@K[4?8MƒOAoFHCJOš¦X@>YOJ?GNMƒX@C¨n¦|~BÑIKMGJOU>šRSDXšMƒG¨_?¨MLRUT
>YC-M8[4>@C@…SDBKRSOJ>@FHB Fƒ OU?GJA8Cg_
i
?¨MLRUT¥Fƒ ’QTk>ÅRJToTKMCQFLBDX@‚N)à;XYFLZ á XY>@OJ?GNMƒXYCgn