Exploiting the Omission of Irrelevant Data - Webdocs Cs Ualberta

#
tTt¹{¼}T !
®©¨£®© zTŽ‚Œ|¢ˆŽTØx{}T‹„‚Œx ŽT€„€ƒ‚„ x{¾ À©( Ò ÓEÒ ½‚w\{¼‚€X‘…wy|„x{}T‹ ‚ŒxÔ|„½ŽT€¢wy|¢vKˆ}T‹Œx{‚¢ Žx{}T‹„‚Œx Â
© mnNThgPQP ¯ j¹hTlESTmnJTjThžQMRnlMQ “TjMQ¡)* ®©¨£®© jgPQMRnjMO•²TlE˜,+ Q—²TJTlThThgPkTs—NMO±²TJTlThThgPkP£j£hžlTh¡
).- © ñjMLKlMQP ¯ jžhTlESTmnJTjTh¹QMRnlMQ ®/¨M®/ jgPQMRnjMOV²TlE˜,+ Qp²TJTlThThgPkTsVNMOp²TJTlThThgPkP£jTh¹lTh¢r-¤
© ) *10 “TjMQ ®/¨M®/ ¤
tTt%2 à ‚ à ½ w\ˆŒx{vKzT‚¨|i‹ ŽT{¼vKˆ43:}Tˆz¦‘Šwy|3¥Œx{}M|„|Œw5‚ z1’nŽM|‡w\ w¥&‚¢‚6†}T‘’Zx{‚Œ| ½}Tˆz({¼‚¢ ‚€ ‘¢|7'Œ€ƒŽT‘ ®©¨£®©ŒÃ
tTt19 à ‰ à ½-{¼‚¢ˆ‚ƒ‰T}T w¥&‚‚6T}T‘’Zx{‚ b4:
MBD?Z4MOU>@„L?>@BDCJONMBzRS?H_‡’QTD>šRJT¦CUTDF’QC-OUTzMO ^ Ï
’QTD?B¦ZH>@„L?B
Ý ` Œ fµ¹DX@FDRJ“H?G5FLG;/ Ï n–QT4DCŠ.-0 a)c,2,3456
âLKMX@>ËÒK?CQMCQM
>@O(>@C(ZH>@„L?B MO)X@?¨MCJO ‚ FR‚ Œ þ€HG–ÿXYBÿàµds áI X@B þ
¤RS>@?B4OmOUTKMƒB•.10 a)c,2,345/6 >Ë–LK$‘DCJ?? ( * *(ü-œHh -"5FLG
?
A8FLGU?-[4>@CNRSDCJCU>@FHBtn
k œ;) - ¿,wyx\xµ€ƒ‚‘…Ž"&E‚7'Œ€ŽT‘ {¼‚…º‚€„‘c| b }Tˆz :
Ð< u{d6v : b4= ½‹vK Ã
¤RS>@?B4O¿OJF8CJIK?¨R^>²;‚ TDF’
FCNMAoIDX@?CQA¤Mg‚4_4TDF’?„H?2G¨_‡¹z?(CU
Ù BDFHOJTD?GML[4„HMB4ONMƒZH?
OUFo>@A8IDGJF„H?(MoZH>@„H?B}>YBk>YOJ>šMX‡OUTk?FHGJ‚šMƒX/ OJFùR^XÅMƒCUCJ>²;‚à;DBDXšM¹z?X@?¨[ á >@BDCJONMBzRS?C MƒC"OUTk?‚
MGJ?QCU??2B"n#|;X/ CXšM¹z?XK>@Ct5FLDBK[$OUF(¹z?Q>@BKRSFHGJGU?¨R^Ö _4’?QOUTD?B
T]
A8FLGU? IDGU?gRS>@CU?X@‚4_’? MCJCUDAo? FHDG >YBk>YOJ>šMX
=4OSMOU?g[
/ OUTk?FHGJ‚ 8TzMC&RSXšMCJCU>ËÒ›RMƒOU>@FHB¥?GJGUFLG]\ ) TT]©99’B“
TT]_"/SÙaUW _H’QTD?2GU?k/SÙaWQ>YCOJTD?&RSFHGJGU?¨R^OQONMGJZH?OOUTD?Sf
C^Là}/ á
FHGJ‚ _"/ ÙaUW >YC$OUTD?oCU?O)F&>@BDCJONMBzRS?C)FHBÑ’QTD>šRJT
MƒBK[
MƒBK[ / ÙaUW [4>@CNMƒZHGJ??H‘OJTKMO¦>@C¨_->@O >@C¥OUTD?ØCU‚4A8Ao?O~f
/$TT] /$TT]
” A \n€Ñ?Q’QMB4OOUF[4F(OUTk>YCDCJ>YBkZ‰M$B4DAf
}4_4MOA8FLCUO
”cb \_ ”cb _LX@B&à ¹z?GQF"CSMA8IkXY?2C#OUTKMƒOQ>@C#IKFLX@‚šMƒX@B ”cb á } { {
A8?gMCUkGU?Hû
ÙaW á / / ÙaUW I ^Là / ÙaUW ) /$TT] ‚ ‚ /$TT]‚ ‚ /$TT]
oƒ8d6q{rety£v|§fie fVg · ed ®/¨M®/¥ fiev|{tŒet8vml „§fih£t8rt8us8tS€Dt¢l
vgzƒt8t8u v|stRet8vXd~ovt8rhke]fiuš fjg wxu{„Sv|stet8v]fiuš ®©¨£®© ’h£&tz©fnlnl
d~o vt8u…fit8z wn78lkNo drhŒqmlŽw wxew‘etBv•dxo¢fivevt8rh e8’
œ — ˆ§‰8Šxš oMfqT” rTsMmnj
IKJMLKNMOPQMRTS¡ £¢Z]ØY¥¤§¦Z^„`…ܢ݊d ®©¨£®© f:qT” rTsMmnj ‰ f ‰†‰
# QTOKlgPŒ˜ZPŒ˜KL$dƒ–nJTNT²M³KjM- …JTlE–njTJTjMZohTlESTmnJTjTh
qTOKlM ©
liu k
"!
tTt%$x{ ‚E€„ˆ}T w¥&‚ŒxÔ¾½Øw' w{|¢ˆŽTTˆŽT¿,ˆ w‘jsrgfidrgf ½:¿,‚>„}Tˆw ĝ|Œ ‚„}Tz>„ŽMx\x{‚
liu k
|Œ}T‘’Zx{‚Œ|
«KjESnN ¯ jžkTOKNES
lE˜KspQKjMOMS•QMRnlMQ±P£hp²TNEñhgP£hMQKjE˜ Q*PQMŔ hTNESnj*QKjMOMS$PŒ˜8).-¢¤
¤
«KjMQM¬KOM˜—P£h">E¬Tñ²MQP£N¨ṼNMkpQKjMOMSnhpPŒ˜
£¢Z]ØY¥¤§¦Z^a`ŠÜ¢Ý
ÇM˜K?
Œ >@ZHDGJ?ùikû–QTD?@BA Ì-ÊDC4E 3456 MƒXYZLFHGJ>YOJTDA 5FHGA8FD[4>Ë5‚4>@BDZ(MB¥>@BD>@OU>šMƒX Ý ` Œ 5FHGJADXšM
IKMƒOUT"n$–QTD?BzMOUkGNMX[4?¨RS>@CU>@FLB4fµOJGU??¹kXYFDRJ“H?2G¨_>^Ï4_›5FHG([4?¨R^>²f
MƒGU?QIz?G~5FLGUAo?¨[
CU>@FLBOUGU?2?9\-CJ>YAoIDX@‚-GU?OJDGUBDCOUTk?&OU?2CUOUCOUTzMO
\)>@B¥OUTk?¿IkGUFDRS?CJC&F#RSXšMCJCU>Ë5‚4>@BDZ‰M$ZH>@„L?B
’QTD?B¥OJGNMg„H?2GUCU>@BDZ
`bFHOU>šRS?$OUTKMƒOQOUTD>@CQA8?gMBDCR^Ï$GU?OJDGUBDC-M)OU?GJA F
>@BDCUOSMBKR^?Hn
OUTk?FHGJ‚ÔGJ?„4>@CU>@FHB¦MƒIDIDGJF@C8OJTKMO>@O~MHRS>@X@>@ONMOJ?C
F(OJTD?
ÕUX@?¨MƒGUBD>@BDZ)’QTD>@X@?([4FH>@BDZL×Kn–QTKMƒO&>@C¨_4’?RSFLDXš[8kCU?(OJTD?(>@BD>Ëf
/Ï-’QTD?B}ZH>@„H?B¥M)IKFLCU>@OU>@„L?¿>@BDCJONMƒBKRS?H_zMBK[¥M$OU?GJA
FƒX•/Ï
RSFLBDCUDX@O&MƒB8?SßDIz?GUOm’QTDFIkGUF„4>š[4?COUTD?(RSFLGUGU?gRSO&XšM¹z?X~_4IzFHC~f
á OUTk?(„HMX@D?CFOUTD?
CU>@¹DX@‚8MÂ5OU?G&MƒCU“4>@BDZ$5FHG-à~MBK[oGU?gRS?>@„4>YBkZ
RMƒB ¹z?8DCJ?¨[‡_’Q>@OUTDFLDORJTKMƒBDZH?H_OUF X@?¨MƒGUB M Ý ` Œ
GU?IDGJ?Sf
\zn !bF’ ?„L?G¨_mOUTk?­ÈâÉ,ʺËKÌ 3E4/Í MX@ZLFHGU>@OJTDA
CU?2BYFLB¦Fƒ
Œ >@ZHkGU?8j á XY?gMGUBkC(OUTD?¥[4?¨RS>@CJ>YFLBÑOUGJ??¤[4>@GJ?¨RSOUX@‚Ÿà;̵ÍpÎÍ@_‡MC)M
à
TzMH[o>@BKMIDIkGUFHIkGU>šMOJ?X@‚&…SK[4ZL?¨[
RSGJ>YOJ>šRMXMOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?C&OJTKMOŒ/
OUF¥¹z?8CJDIK?2G~ÖKDFLDC¨no–QTD?X@?¨MƒGUBD?GRMƒB¼DCJ?8OJTD>@C(>@B45FHGJA¤MÂf
OU>@FLB¼OJF8;FHGUA
MoBD?2’;FHGUAkXÅMk_KRMƒX@XÆ>@OS/þÂ_ÿ’QTD>šRUT¦>@O-OUTD?B
á MƒBK[Ñ[4F4?C)BDFHO)DCU?oOUTD? Ý ` Œ GU?IDGJ?CU?2BYFLBŸ?„H?B
OUGJ??
MƒB¢>@BšMOJ?¥CUOU?2I"n –QTD>@C MX@ZLFHGU>@OJTDAú>@C RSFHGJGU?¨RSOg_
MC
DCJ?C¿MƒCQ>YOJC&RSXšMCJCU>ËÒK?Ggn#–QTD?-OUTk?FHGJ‚¤GJ?„4>@CU>@FHB¥IDGJF½R^?CUCmOUTD?B
MƒB>@BKR^FHG~f
>@OU?GSMOJ?C¨û#RSFLBDCUkXYOJ>@BDZ&OJTD?Q?SßDIK?2GUO#>Ë\/þ#IDGJF½[½KRS?C
>@B OUTk?CSMA8? ]zÙ E CJ?BDCU?kCU?¨[}>@B –QTD?FLGU?A
” _z’QTD?BD?2„H?G
CNMƒA8IDX@?Cgn
J
Bk?’¦>@B4;FHGUA¥MOJ>YFLBOJFIkGUFD[4KRS?
GU?gRSO&XšM¹z?X~_4MBK[DCU>@BDZ)OUTKMƒO
M$BD?’?G¨_4¹z?OUOJ?Gk/£_DMƒBK[CJF(;FHGUOJT"n£!Q?GJ?H_DOJTD?&OJFHONMƒX‡B4DAf
à !b?GU?L_H–¹KFLDBK[4C-OUTk?B@B OJTD?8[4?¨RS>@CJ>YFLB
OUGJ??Hn á –QT4DC¨_‡OJTD>@C(MX@ZHFLGU>@OUTDA
RMƒB¼¹z?CU>@ZHBk>²Ò‡RMB4OUX@‚¥A8FLGU?
¹z?G&FƒÆ?SßDIz?GUO-RSFHBDCJDX@ONMƒOU>@FHBDCQRSFLDXš[8¹z?-AKRJT8X@?CJCQOUTKMƒB¤>Ë
MBo?A8IDO~‚OJGU??Ln
’?¿¹z?Z4MB¥’Q>@OUT
% wu &('*)LM‰.ONú.¹)QP¹+E,+"M
MX@GJ?¨MH[4‚ŸTKMg„L?¼MBº>YBk>YOJ>šMX
|~B¢A¥MB4‚ÑCU>@OUzMOU>@FLBDC¨_Q’?¦A¤Mg‚
` Œ Ý OJTKMO->@C(RSFHBDCJ>š[4?GU?g[ÑâHk>YOJ?‰MLRRSDGSMOJ?H_¹DDO-BDFLO
/$TT]
GU>šR}CU?O¦[4>˧›?GJ?BKRS?Ÿ¹z?O~’??B{>@BDCUOSMBKR^?C CNMƒOU>@C~Òz?¨[ ¹4‚¢OUTD?
nQ–QTk>YCmCUD¹kCU?¨RSOJ>@FHB¼[4?2CNRSGJ>Y¹z?C(’QMg‚4CQF#DCJ>YBkZ8M)CU?O
Iz?G~5?gRSÖ
>@AoIDGUF„L?2/ TT]S‘-Ì~Í ÎƒÍY_OUF´5FHGJA M
F)XÅMƒ¹K?2XY?g[ŸCNMƒA8IDX@?CoOUF
O~’F RSFLBKRS?IkOUC¨n —mDGZHF4MX>YCOJF¼IkGUFD[4KRS?¦M BD?2’
OJTD?FHGJ‚
/1HR9„9’B“
’QTDFLCU??GJGUFLG(>@C¨_‡’Q>@OUT}IDGUFL¹KM¹D>@X@>@O~‚ MO-X@?¨MCJO
BD?’ºOUTD?FLGU‚/SRUT]=]VTW OJTKMO>@C#CU>@Ao>YXšMƒG"OUF/ T T]J_4¹DDO#>@CQà;’Q>YOJT
TD>@ZHTÑIkGUFH¹zM¹D>@X@>@O~‚ á A8FLGU?MHRRSkGNMOJ?Hn¦€Ñ?X@?O A B 8X9~;-D
GJ?Sf
XY
5?GOJFÑOUTD>@CAoF½[½?XQ’QTD?GJ? OUTD? 5[Z
[4?CJ>@ZHBKMƒOU?CØÕU– TD?FLGU‚
?2„@CJ>YFLBD×K_-RSFLGUGU?2CUIzFHBK[4>@BDZ OUFºOUTD?ØA¤MB4‚Ÿ?SßD>@CUOJ>YBkZ¢CU‚4C~f
P
?CJCU?B4OJ>ÅMƒX@XY‚ŸOJTD?ÑCNMƒA8? OSMCU“‡_-MX@¹z?>@O
OU?2A8C8OJTKMO¥Iz?G~;FHGUA
OJTD?¦ÕN[4>˧‡?GU?BzRS?× ¹z?O~’??BÑFHkG
MBz[¥>@B¼CJFHA8?-Ao?¨MCJDGU?)F
MBz[+/ ÙaUW n Œ FLG OJTD>@CQIDDGJIKFLCU?H_z’?¿kCU?-OUTD?
RSDGJGU?B4OmOUTD?FLGU‚
!bFHGJB4f°R^XÅMƒDCU?$¹KMCJ?¨[ GJ?¨MCJFHBD>@BDZoCU‚4C~f
>@B¥OUTD?$5GNMƒA8?’FHGJ“F
( € ] œHi4_DŽ ˜dHdk_K—-Ž œHc4_¢ Ý P *(œ e -Un
OU?2A8C¨‘"¨ÐÏÜš_
–QTD?GJ?¤MƒGU?8CJ?„H?2GNMXQFL¹4„@FLDC(MH[4„HMƒB²f
CSRSGNMƒONRJTD×¥MIDIDGJF@CSRSDCUCJ?¨[
CU>@FLB¤F„L?GQOUTk?¤ÕJZHGJF’¢5GJFHA
¹z?O~’??B/ T T]KMBK[ /SÙaUW
’QTD>šRJT->YCtOUTD?CU‚4B4ONMHR^OU>šR#[4>˧‡?GU?BzRS?
Ì~ÍpÎÍ@_LOUTD?(OJFHOSMX"B4DA¹z?GF#OU?2GUA8CQOJTKMOQAkCUO¹K?(?2>YOJTD?G
Ú
Œ >@GUCJÖ _zBDFHOJ>šRS?-5GJFHA –QTD?2FHGU?2A ”
>@B¥OUTD?(IkGU?„4>@FHDCmCU?¨R^OU>@FHB"n
CNMƒA8IDX@?CmGU?¨âLD>@GU?g[ OJF¤¹kD>@XÅ[}M Ý ` Œ
OUTzMO-OUTD?)B4DA¹z?G&Fƒ
5FLGUADXšM>@C#IDGJFHIzFHGUOJ>@FHBKMƒX@Ó?&Fƒ›OJTD?ÒKBKMƒX45FLGUADXšMD_
MƒOUOJGU>@¹DDOJ?C¨n
’QTD>šRJT¤RMƒB8¹z?-?SßDIKFLBD?B4OU>šMX‡>@BOJTD?-B@C
/SÙaUW4n
5GJFHA M)CUOSMOJ>YFLBKMGJ‚8[4>@CUOJGU>@¹DDOJ>YFLB"_LOUTD?B
[4GSMg’QB¤MOQGSMBK[½FHA
MH[k[4?¨[}OUFK_ÿFHG&GJ?A8F„L?¨[o5GJFHA¦_/$TT] OUF5FHGJA
OUTD?8[4?2CU>@GU?¨[
FHBkXY‚¥M)CUA¥MX@X‡B4DA¹K?2GQF#XšM¹z?X@?¨[¥CNMƒA8IDX@?Cg_D’?
=4Fz_DZH>@„L?B
A¤Mg‚o¹K?)DBKMƒ¹DX@?OJF¥IDGUFD[4KR^?8MBÑMH[4?¨âLKMƒOU?)OUTD?2FHGU‚4_‡AKRJT
X@?CUCOJTD?#FHIkOU>@A¤MƒXFHBD?Hnt€Ñ?#CJTDF’ѹK?2XYF’¦OUTzMOOUTD>@CtCNMAo?CU?O
W