22.04.2018 Views

Saunton Historic Report 2017-07

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Historic</strong>al Study Of The East Course At <strong>Saunton</strong> Golf Club


Young caddy watches on as one of the Pitts Tucker<br />

founders plays his shot<br />

References:<br />

Richard Bass - 1996, Guide to the US Assault Training Centre North Devon (Un-published).<br />

http://www.assaulttrainingcenter.com/<br />

The History of <strong>Saunton</strong> Golf Club 1897 -1987<br />

<strong>Saunton</strong> Golf Club 1897-1997


Timeline<br />

1929 Clubhouse Opening Exhibition Match,<br />

James Braid putting on the pre-war 2nd green<br />

<strong>Saunton</strong> Golf Club first formed<br />

Thomas Dunn 9 holes<br />

Clubhouse opened<br />

9 Holes extended to 12 holes<br />

12 Holes extended to 18 holes<br />

4 Holes rearranged<br />

WWI Outbreak - Course reduced to 12 holes due to lack of labour<br />

Exhibition match between Harry Vardon & J.H. Taylor<br />

Resumption of club - W.H. Fowler engaged to re-design the course<br />

Moving into the natural dune land - The same layout as today apart<br />

from the 1st, 2nd, 17th & 18th holes<br />

New club house built in location recommended by W.H. Fowler<br />

celebrated with exhibition match between J.H.Taylor , James Braid,<br />

Henry Cotton & Bradbeer (<strong>Saunton</strong> Pro)<br />

Second 18 holes commissioned W.H. Fowler to design & build<br />

WWII Outbreak - Clubhouse requisitioned<br />

Ken Cotton invited to restore the Old Course - 13 holes almost put<br />

back as they were with a few minor changes but altered the 1st,2nd,<br />

6th, 17th & 18th holes<br />

Course reopened<br />

Frank Pennink engaged to design the West Course<br />

9 Holes open on the West course<br />

Full 18 holes open on the West Course<br />

POW from Normandy tasked with clearing the war debris<br />

US Assault Training Centre created by US Engineers and used by the<br />

US 146th Engineer Combat Battalion in preparation for D-Day<br />

The Committee decide to move the 1st Green on the East Course left<br />

as original position deemed too close to the 17th West fairway and<br />

could be dangerous<br />

Practice ground created<br />

1st Green East Course moved back towards original location - 2nd<br />

green East moved back and right<br />

Donald Steel engaged to redesign the 2nd fairway on the West Course<br />

Donald Steel engaged to rebuild all 18 greens on the West Course -<br />

Irrigation added to all tees and greens and 7th, 11th, 12th , 16th &<br />

18th fairways on the East Course<br />

1897<br />

1906<br />

19<strong>07</strong><br />

1908<br />

1912<br />

1914<br />

1919<br />

1923<br />

1929<br />

1935<br />

1939<br />

1943<br />

1944<br />

1950<br />

1952<br />

1972<br />

1974<br />

1975<br />

1975<br />

1979<br />

1980<br />

1987<br />

1992


Thomas Dunn<br />

Born Blackheath, England, 29th December 1849. Died Blagdon 1902 , aged 52.<br />

Tom Dunn became a professional at Wimbeldon Common (London Scottish) in 1870. The<br />

course had originally been laid out by his father , Old Willie Dunn, with 18 holes, but over<br />

the years it had been reduced to 7. In his first year at the club, Tom extended it to 18. He went<br />

on to hold professional positions at North Berwick, Tooting Beck, Meyrick Park amongst<br />

others.<br />

Dunn had four top-10 finishes in The Open Championship his best effort coming 6th in<br />

1869.<br />

He was the most prolific golf course architect of his day. He produced layouts that were<br />

inexpensive and serviceable, making it possible for increasing numbers of all social classes<br />

to take up the sport.<br />

He was a great salesman and is quoted as telling his clients; “God meant this site to be a golf<br />

course.” The first designer to work on inland courses rather than links he was a firm believer<br />

in a cross bunker requiring a forced carry from the tee, another for the approach and even a<br />

third on a three shot hole.<br />

Dunn himself considered Broadstone to be one of his greatest achievements where he was<br />

“not stinted for men, money or materials”. He felt Meryick Park the greatest challenge because<br />

of the densley covered heather, gorse and pine forest terrain.<br />

Tom was married to Isabel Gourlay, “the greatest women golfer of her day”. Tom travelled<br />

to America on several occasions visiting his brother Willie Dunn Jnr. (who also went on to<br />

become an architect). Despite his visits to the US, it is doubtful that he ever laid out a course<br />

there. While many American courses claim<br />

to have a Tom Dunn course, it is more<br />

likely they were laid out by one of the other<br />

Dunns.<br />

Tom’s work in Great Britain and on the<br />

Continent was extensive with more than<br />

137 courses.<br />

This timeline has been constructed<br />

using information from various<br />

sources, such as club histories, club<br />

websites, “The Architects of Golf ” by<br />

Cornish and Whitten.<br />

Born 1849<br />

Ashley Wood, Dorset - 9 holes 1893<br />

London Scottish Golf Club - Added 9 holes 1870<br />

Bath 1880<br />

Bramshaw - Manor Course 1880<br />

Felixstowe Ferry - 9 holes 1880<br />

Kinsdown 1880<br />

Cork - Ireland 1880<br />

Northe Berwick- Remodel 1883<br />

Brighton & Hove - 9 holes 1887<br />

Seaford 1887<br />

Dinard, France 1887<br />

Coubert - France 1888<br />

Blairgowrie 1889<br />

Bromley: Bude & North Cornwall GC 1890<br />

Eltham Warren 1890<br />

Tooting Bec 1890<br />

Ganton 1891<br />

Huddersfield 1891<br />

Lindrick 1891<br />

Northwood 1891<br />

Richmond 1891<br />

Royal Cinque Ports - 9 holes 1892<br />

Royal Mid Surrey 1892<br />

Royal Worlingon & Newmarket - 9 holes 1892<br />

Seacroft 1892<br />

Ventnor - 9 holes 1892<br />

Weston-Super-Mare 1892<br />

Enfield 1893<br />

Hastings & St. Leonards 1893<br />

Hastings 1893<br />

Royston 1893<br />

Woking 1893<br />

Haagsche - Netherlands 1893<br />

Buscott Park & Chiselhurst GC 1894<br />

Hampstead - 9 holes 1894<br />

Lansdown 1894<br />

Meyrick Park 1894<br />

Surbiton 1895<br />

Frinton 1896<br />

<strong>Saunton</strong> 1897<br />

Broadstone 1898<br />

Maidenhead 1898<br />

London Scottish Golf Club - Remodel 1901<br />

Bulwell Forest 1902<br />

Sheringham; Sherwood Forest - 9 holes 1904<br />

Erewash Valley 1905<br />

Beckenham Place Park 19<strong>07</strong><br />

Burhill - 9 holes 19<strong>07</strong><br />

North Oxford 1908<br />

Nottingham City 1908<br />

Whickham 1911<br />

Ralara - Canary Islands<br />

Unknown<br />

Littlestone - Remodel<br />

Unknown<br />

Died 1902


William Herbert Fowler<br />

Born Edmonton, England, 28th May 1856. Died London 13th April<br />

1941, aged 85<br />

Arthur Croome, one of Fowler’s design partners once write that:<br />

“Mr W. Herbert Fowler is a true aristocrat if ever there was one...Had<br />

he lived in Paris at the time of the revolution the mob would certainly<br />

have searched the city for a lantern high and strong enough to finish him<br />

off. The marks of your true aristocrat are a firm belief that the best dog<br />

must come out on top eventually, an instinct for discovering the best of<br />

everything and an unshakeable conviction that what he selects as the best<br />

is the best... You will very soon find that his real contempt is reserved for<br />

what is second-rate, ignorant or ignoble. That is why he has so seldom<br />

been proved wrong about golf, though he has given utterance in the most<br />

unequivocal terms to more categorical statements than most people.’<br />

This short quotation says a great deal about the man. He was born into a<br />

wealthy family and matured into a fine sportsman. He concentrated on<br />

cricket and played county cricket and for the MCC before discovering<br />

golf at the relatively old age of 23. Within a decade, he had achieved a<br />

handicap of scratch and was competing in The Amateur where he made<br />

the quarter finals before being soundly thrashed by Harold Hilton and<br />

in The Open where he tied for 26th in 1900. This rapid rise demonstrates<br />

just what an able sportsman he was. He was a large man, measuring a<br />

strong 6’3”.<br />

Around the turn of the century, his brother-in-law, Sir Cosmo Bonsor,<br />

approached him about a possible project south of London which was<br />

later to become Walton Heath, the course that launched his career<br />

as a golf course architect in 19<strong>07</strong>. By 1913, he had teamed up with<br />

Tom Simpson forming one of the great partnerships in golf course<br />

architecture that lasted until the late 1920s when Fowler was in his 70s.<br />

They worked across Europe and Fowler made several trips to the USA,<br />

designing Eastward Ho! (named after his beloved Westward Ho!) and<br />

Los Angeles Country Club as well as re-designing courses including<br />

creating the 18th hole at Pebble Beach.<br />

Both he and Simpson (pictured in the cartoon to the left) were highly<br />

intelligent and controversial figures. Fowler did not write all that much<br />

about architecture but Simpson certainly did, contributing regularly<br />

to Country Life, Golf Monthly and being featured in numerous other<br />

periodicals. He also co-authored with Joyce and Roger Wethered’s<br />

father one of the great books on golf course architecture called<br />

“The Architectural Side of Golf ”. His clear views were most probably<br />

formulated in discussions with Fowler.<br />

Despite Fowler’s background, his life was dogged by financial difficulties<br />

and it would appear that he was not great at managing money. In 1902,<br />

he was on the brink of bankruptcy when he was forced to sell his estate<br />

in Devon, moving close to London to find gainful employment in the<br />

form of designing Walton Heath. By 1912, things had turned for the<br />

good and he moved into a purpose built house near Walton Heath<br />

designed by Sir Edwin Lutyens. But late in his life, however, his troubles<br />

returned and in 1928 he was declared bankrupt, living out the rest of<br />

his life in accommodation and full board provided by Walton Heath<br />

Golf Club.<br />

“He will plant a difficulty just the least bit nearer<br />

to the hole than any other architect, for the shot is<br />

nearly good, he has little mercy.”<br />

Horace Hutchison<br />

The magnificent 1935 portrait of Fowler by Sir James Gunn RA


William Herbert Fowler Timeline<br />

Born 1856<br />

Cricket (Essex, Somerset and MCC)<br />

Started golf 1879<br />

Joined The R&A 1894<br />

Down to Scratch 1889<br />

Tied for 26th in The Open 1900<br />

To last 16 of The Amateur Championship, losing to Harold Hilton in his prime 1901<br />

Heavily indebted, sells up his house in Devon and moved close to Walton Heath. 1902<br />

Joined The R&A Green Committee 1902<br />

Walton Heath Old Course designed 1902<br />

Walton Heath Old Course opened 1904<br />

Walton Heath New Course designed 19<strong>07</strong><br />

Westward Ho! re-opened after major work by Fowler 1908<br />

Fountainbleu, France 1910<br />

Delamere Forest - original layout 1910<br />

West Surrey, Surrey 1910<br />

Simpson joined Fowler 1910<br />

LA Country Club (initial consultation) 1911<br />

Moved into “Chussex” a house designed in classical style by Edwin Lutyens and with a garden by Gertrude Jekyll close to WHGC 1912<br />

Beau Desert, Staffs 1912<br />

North Foreland, Kent Main 18 1912<br />

Woodcote Park, Surrey (CW) 1912<br />

Walton Heath New Course opened 1913<br />

Bull Bay, Wales (Club website) 1913<br />

Bickley Park Estate, Chislehurst, Kent 1914<br />

Shirley Park, Croydon Surrey 1914<br />

Dieppe, France 1914<br />

Spent much of WWI in the USA 1914- 1918<br />

West Kent, Kent 1916<br />

Yelverton, Devon (Club website) 1919<br />

<strong>Saunton</strong> East Course, Devon (Club Website) 1919<br />

Delamere Forest - revised layout 1920<br />

Fowler working on Eastward Ho! & Los Angeles Country Club 1920<br />

Fowler and Simpson set up an office in California 1920<br />

North Foreland, Kent Short Course 1920<br />

Fowler, Simpson, Abercromby and Croome formed 1921<br />

Eastward Ho! USA 1921<br />

Pebble Beach, California - extended 18th hole to its current design 1922<br />

Abbeydale, Yorkshire 1922<br />

Bradford, Yorkshire 1923<br />

Blackwell, Worcestershire 1923<br />

Crystal Springs, California 1924<br />

Knole Park, Kent 1924<br />

Cruden Bay, Scotland 1926<br />

Fowler, Simpson, Abercromby and Croome disbanded 1927<br />

Declared bankrupt 1928<br />

The Berkshire Red Blue opened 1928<br />

Manor House Hotel, Devon (now Bovey Castle) Mostly Abercromby? 1930<br />

<strong>Saunton</strong>, Devon 1935<br />

Died 1941<br />

“An erratic genius...<br />

perhaps the most daring<br />

and original of all golf<br />

course architects”<br />

Bernard Darwin<br />

This timeline has been constructed<br />

using information from various<br />

sources, such as club histories, club<br />

websites, “The Architects of Golf ”<br />

by Cornish and Whitten.


The Words of William Herbert Fowler<br />

“Bunkers should only act as hazards for wide shots.”<br />

“I think that a bunker should mean on average the loss of one<br />

stroke, .......the ball should always be in the bottom of the bunker,<br />

and not hard up against the face”<br />

“I have often thought that the importance of the hazards of<br />

a course is very much under-estimated by makers of courses,<br />

Green Committees, and players generally, and yet I think that<br />

good hazards are really almost the most important feature of a<br />

course. To my mind it is a near thing between the hazards and the<br />

greens as to which is more important to the making of a first class<br />

course.” (from Golf Greens and Greenkeeping, edited by Horace<br />

Hutchinson, 1911)<br />

“In my opinion, a course of from 6,300 to 6,500 yards is amply<br />

long enough, and the latter should not be exceeded. For all<br />

championships I think there should be specially laid-out courses,<br />

one in England and one in Scotland, and then one could have a<br />

course which would be long enough to test even the longest hitters.<br />

Some day, no doubt, this will be made, but until it arrives I do<br />

hope courses will be kept to a reasonable length.” (c1920 Lecture<br />

to Golf Greenkeepers’ Association)<br />

On Selecting a suitable Club Secretary, he advised Abbeydale<br />

Golf Club in Sheffield:<br />

“What you want is a man of character, who is capable, has good<br />

manners, and is patient with idiots.”<br />

“A great deal has been written of late years in favour of making<br />

holes of one, two and three full shots in length, as if this would<br />

make such holes interesting. Such theories are upset by the first<br />

strong wind that blows; but a hole which is properly guarded can<br />

be made interesting, and as difficult as desired, by the proper<br />

placing of hazards, no matter what its length may be.” (from Golf<br />

Greens and Greenkeeping, edited by Horace Hutchinson, 1911)<br />

“We want more cross bunkers in addition to the flanking ones<br />

to curtail the long drivers from getting nearer the green than a<br />

certain distance to play their approaches.” Golfing 1915<br />

“There is one test of a good slope from a bank. One should never be<br />

able to point to any spot where the slope ends. There is a lot more<br />

in this than one would at first imagine.” (c1920 Lecture to Golf<br />

Greenkeepers’ Association)<br />

“In laying out a course, great care should be taken to see that the<br />

one-shot holes are of the best possible quality. Personally, I think<br />

a course is never a good one unless this class of hole is really firstclass.<br />

Now that inventors have so spoilt the game by making it<br />

possible to hit the ball to impossible distances, the only thing a<br />

golf architect can do to get decent two shot holes is to increase the<br />

number of holes of the one-shot variety.”<br />

(c1920 Lecture to Golf Greenkeepers’ Association)


The Words of William Herbert Fowler<br />

This text is taken from a chapter that Fowler wrote in a book<br />

called “Golf Greens and Greenkeeping”, edited by Horace<br />

Hutchinson and published in 1911 a few years after Walton Heath<br />

Old Course opened and shortly after he and Simpson teamed<br />

up. They were both inspired by the work of John Low and Stuart<br />

Paton at Woking Golf Club, Simpson so much so that it prompted<br />

him to change career from law to golf course design.<br />

This early article by Fowler shows that at this stage his thinking<br />

was relatively under-developed and his thinking evolved over the<br />

years. Simpson was a great thinker and prolific writer about golf<br />

design and the two men must have spent hours debating topics as<br />

they were both outspoken characters.<br />

These quotations give a good impression of Fowler’s approach to<br />

design which is helpful. He did not write too much about the strategic<br />

approach that Horace Hutchison mentioned in his quote:<br />

“He will plant a difficulty just the least bit nearer to the hole<br />

than any other architect, for the shot is nearly good, he has<br />

little mercy.”<br />

It is interesting, though, that by 1922, the Fowler, Abercromby,<br />

Simpson and Croome brochure dedicated an entire page to the<br />

following clear statement:<br />

“It is true to say that at least 90% of those who play golf<br />

are firmly convinced that courses are planned<br />

for the benefit of the scratch player.<br />

One moment’s reflection should dispel the idea<br />

that courses are laid out for 1% of those who play golf.<br />

We are business men, and do not lay out courses<br />

for the benefit of our health,<br />

and if in fact we only consulted the interests of 1%<br />

we should soon cease to have a business,<br />

for no one would employ us or recommend us.”


<strong>Historic</strong> Club Photographs<br />

Note the open sand areas in this post war shot of the 18th designed by Ken Cotton around 1950


Drive from the then 1st Tee Before WWII<br />

<strong>Historic</strong> Club Photographs


11th Green<br />

Archive photograph - 8th August 1946


<strong>Historic</strong> Newspaper Articles<br />

“Golf.” Times [London, England] 12 June<br />

1925: Bernard Darwin<br />

“..one of the courses<br />

of the world”<br />

“..there is scarcely an<br />

artificially cut bunker”<br />

“Parliament.” Times [London, England] 10 Apr. 1913:<br />

Bernard Darwin


<strong>Historic</strong> Newspaper Articles<br />

“Golf.” Times [London, England] 9<br />

Nov 1935: Bernard Darwin<br />

“Golf.” Times [London, England] 8 Aug. 1929:<br />

Bernard Darwin<br />

“..What more<br />

can a golfer<br />

want?”


The Course Evolution


1st Course Layout 9 Holes - 1984 (As Remembered By Philip Harris)<br />

<strong>Saunton</strong>’s original 9 hole Course is credited to Thomas Dunn


2nd Course Layout 18 Hole (As Remembered By Philip Harris)


Course Layout - 1921 W. H. Fowler


Course Layout - 1935<br />

Hole Yards Par<br />

1 210 3<br />

2 380 4<br />

3 384 4<br />

4 460 5<br />

5 120 3<br />

6 400 5<br />

7 440 5<br />

8 375 4<br />

9 386 5<br />

Out 3155 38<br />

10 316 4<br />

11 360 4<br />

12 460 5<br />

13 140 3<br />

14 475 5<br />

15 480 5<br />

16 421 5<br />

17 170 3<br />

18 418 5<br />

In 3240 39<br />

Out 3155 38<br />

Total 6395 77


Course Layout - 1951 (C. K. Cotton)


Current Course Layout - 2016<br />

12<br />

11<br />

7<br />

13<br />

14<br />

6<br />

15<br />

10<br />

8<br />

16<br />

3<br />

9<br />

5<br />

17<br />

2<br />

4<br />

18<br />

1


World War II the Occupied Years


The US Assault Training Centre Occupied 1939 - 1951<br />

In 1943 work started on The Assault Training Centre based at <strong>Saunton</strong>. It was created due to an oversight at the<br />

highest levels of the American War Planning Office which had assumed that American troops sent to lead the<br />

spearhead assault into Europe would be trained for assault. This was not the case as most infantry divisions were<br />

‘green’ or inexperienced in combat and this had to be addressed urgently with the invasion planned only a few<br />

months ahead.<br />

At this time, the only published advice in the US Army Field Manual was “Fortified areas are to be avoided in<br />

the initial assault and then taken from the rear.” The plan to attack the Normandy coastal defences would require<br />

a head on beach assault using multi skilled teams or ‘Assault Sections’ including demolitions, rocket launchers,<br />

flame throwers and machine gunners.<br />

The ATC (Assault Training Centre) brief was to train these assaults sections under realistic conditions including<br />

overcoming on and off-shore obstacles, reduction of fortifications, repulsing of counter attacks and establishing of<br />

the beach head.<br />

The British and Canadians were well ahead with their training and had already claimed all suitable beaches except<br />

Woolacombe. Woolacombe had been deemed too stormy for amphibious landing craft by the British. Many<br />

natural features including the sand type, dune-scape and tides made Woolacombe an almost exact match for their<br />

destination ‘Omaha beach’ in Normandy. The ATC was divided into lettered areas along the coastline from A-M,<br />

<strong>Saunton</strong> being allocated ‘D’ containing the greatest concentration and variety of assault and training facilities.<br />

The 398th Engineer General Service arrived on 1st September 1943 and were given orders to build replicas of<br />

structures included a full-scale German-type ‘Hedgehog’ that the American troops were likely to encounter<br />

in Normandy. Once the initial construction had been carried out, the 146th Engineer Combat Battalion took<br />

charge in September 1943 of maintenance and rebuilding. American Troops were to visit the ATC for 3 weeks of<br />

training.<br />

After D-Day, the ATC was occupied by the 18th Field Force Replacement Depot to house and feed replacement<br />

troops on their way to Europe. It is certain that the training and research that took place at <strong>Saunton</strong> and all along<br />

the 16 mile stretch of coastline that was used by the ATC was vital to the success of D-Day. Colonel Paul W.<br />

Thompson, the then commandant said “If the battle of Waterloo was won on the playing fields of Eton, then the<br />

Assault Training Centre contributed in no small measure to the success of D-Day”.


The US Assault Training Centre Occupied 1939 - 1951<br />

Obstacle Course<br />

Concrete wall<br />

Target Pits<br />

Ships Sides<br />

Tank Trap<br />

Wire Cutting<br />

Anti-Aircraft<br />

Battery<br />

Clubhouse<br />

Troops billeted in<br />

Nissan huts<br />

Pillboxes<br />

LCVP-LCM Mock Up Area<br />

LCVP Landing Craft Vehicle Personnel<br />

LCM Landing Craft, Mechanized<br />

Flame Thrower Range<br />

‘Hedgehog’ Mock Up Area<br />

The hedgehog defence is a military tactic for defending against a<br />

mobile armoured attack, or blitzkrieg. The defenders deploy in<br />

depth in heavily fortified positions suitable for all-around defence.<br />

The attackers can penetrate between these “hedgehogs”, but each<br />

position continues to fight on when surrounded. This keeps large<br />

numbers of attacking troops tied up, attacking the well-defended<br />

strong-points, while allowing the defenders to successfully<br />

counter-attack against the units that bypass these strong-points<br />

with their own armoured reserves by cutting them off from their<br />

supporting elements.<br />

Dragon’s Teeth<br />

Mine & Booby<br />

Trap Area


<strong>Historic</strong> & Current Day Aerial Photography


<strong>Historic</strong> Aerial Photography<br />

Points of Interest<br />

1. The aerial photographs where taken by RAF 58 (1916 to 1976) & 540 (1942 to<br />

1956 ) photo-reconnaissance Squadrons of the Royal Air Force mainly operating<br />

Mosquitoes and Anson’s. Based at RAF Benson in South Oxfordshire, England.<br />

2. The aerial photography shows the essential part that <strong>Saunton</strong> played in the<br />

American preparations for World War II D-Day assault on the Normandy<br />

beaches. The first aerial from 1946, shows the extent of the destruction that took<br />

place during occupation by tanks, landing craft, demolition practice etc.<br />

3. The aerial photographs provide information regarding the evolution of green<br />

shapes and sizes, the number of bunkers, the bunker locations, bunker sizes,<br />

bunker shapes, open sand areas, fairway widths and the extent and nature of the<br />

vegetation.<br />

4. In terms of the greens, its seems as though a number of the greens may have<br />

survived the war. The actual green boundaries are hard to make out on the 1946<br />

aerial.<br />

5. Tees locations have been adjusted over the years as would be expected with the<br />

advances in ball and club technology. The centre lines shown on the hole by hole<br />

comparison plans are those of today to illustrate just how far tees have gone<br />

backwards and directions of play have been adjusted for some of the holes.<br />

6. The aerial photographs are interesting in what they reveal with respect to the<br />

bunkers. The 1946 aerial shows no man-made bunkers but there are vast blown<br />

out sand dunes/ craters, however, as well as a number of smaller size sand scrapes<br />

that look like they could have been bunkers from the pre-war course left by the<br />

Americans and maybe some of these were original features of Fowler’s Course.<br />

Certainly, the plan from 1935 shows the locations of ‘sand pits’ and bunkers.<br />

There is a significant change in sizes and shape of the bunkers between the 1957<br />

and the 1989 aerial, with the 1989 larger and distinctly more rounded shapes.<br />

The average size of the bunkers between 1989 and the current 2016 aerial have<br />

reduced but the number of bunker has increased from 38 to 56.<br />

7. The fairway widths look as though they were generous by comparison with those<br />

of today. This is a common finding in historical studies of courses.


Bunker Analysis<br />

Histotrical Bunker Count<br />

1935 Bunker count = 25 /12 open sand<br />

1957 Bunker count = 45/18 os<br />

1989 Bunker count = 38<br />

2016 Bunker count = 56


The Evolution Of The Course<br />

The 4th Hole<br />

Fairway widths<br />

Fairway widths have tended to reduce as it has become easier to hit the ball straighter and as new fairway<br />

mowers have been introduced.<br />

The 7th Hole<br />

Bunker Style<br />

There is little evidence of the early bunker style. The<br />

earliest plan showing bunkers is from 1935 and this<br />

shows a combination of man-made bunkers and ‘sand<br />

pits’. In 1925 Bernard Darwin wrote “..And though<br />

there is such a profligate wealth of trouble there is<br />

scarcely an artificially cut bunker on the course”. Over<br />

time, bunkers have become simpler in shape as has<br />

occurred on many links courses.<br />

5th July 1957<br />

5th July 1957 4th May 1989 Current Day


May 1946 RAF Aerial Photography<br />

12<br />

11<br />

7<br />

13<br />

14<br />

6<br />

15<br />

10<br />

8<br />

17<br />

16<br />

3<br />

9<br />

5<br />

18<br />

2<br />

4<br />

1


November 1952 RAF Aerial Photography<br />

12<br />

11<br />

7<br />

13<br />

14<br />

6<br />

15<br />

10<br />

8<br />

16<br />

3<br />

9<br />

5<br />

17<br />

2<br />

4<br />

18<br />

1


July 1957 RAF Aerial Photography<br />

12<br />

11<br />

7<br />

13<br />

14<br />

6<br />

15<br />

10<br />

8<br />

16<br />

3<br />

9<br />

5<br />

17<br />

2<br />

4<br />

18<br />

1


May 1989 RAF Aerial Photography<br />

12<br />

11<br />

7<br />

13<br />

14<br />

6<br />

15<br />

10<br />

8<br />

16<br />

3<br />

9<br />

5<br />

17<br />

2<br />

4<br />

18<br />

1


Current Day Aerial Photography<br />

12<br />

11<br />

7<br />

13<br />

14<br />

6<br />

15<br />

10<br />

8<br />

16<br />

3<br />

9<br />

5<br />

17<br />

2<br />

4<br />

18<br />

1


Hole By Hole Comparisons Of The<br />

1946, 1949, 1952, 1957, 1989 & Current Day Layouts


East Course - Hole 1 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Major destruction to<br />

original Course<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Ken Cotton green location<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 1 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Large blow out sand area<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Original green location<br />

All that remains of natural bunkers<br />

4th May 1989<br />

More rugged bunker shapes<br />

Left bunker has gone<br />

New bunkers<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 2 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Original direction of play<br />

Mock up ships sides<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current Day<br />

New green


Hole 2 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Ken Cotton green location<br />

New green location<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 3 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Large sand craters<br />

Blown out dune<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 3 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 3 - 1957 Oblique View<br />

Green<br />

Tees<br />

2nd Hole


East Course - Hole 3 - Current Day Oblique View<br />

West 10th Hole<br />

West 9th Hole<br />

West 6th Hole<br />

West 5th Hole<br />

15th Hole<br />

2nd Hole


East Course - Hole 4 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Blown out dunes<br />

Crater bunker<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 4 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Remnant bunkers?<br />

Blown out dunes<br />

5th July 1957<br />

One left bunker<br />

4th May 1989<br />

One right bunker remains<br />

New right bunker<br />

4 bunkers<br />

Left bunker has returned<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 5 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Original bunkers?<br />

5th May 1946<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Crater bunkers<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 5 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Large sandy areas in carry<br />

Green extended<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Bunker off to the right<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Bunker filled<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 5 - 1957 Oblique View<br />

Tees<br />

Green


East Course - Hole 5 - Current Oblique View


East Course - Hole 6 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

No evidence of green<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Greens back<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 6 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Open sand scrape<br />

5th July 1957<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 7 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Three humps<br />

Bunkers made sense<br />

in bogey 5 hole<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 7 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

2 Bunkers<br />

The fairway was much wider and<br />

extended further back towards the tees<br />

Remains of old bunkers<br />

Green-side bunker enlarged<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Two bunkers merged into one<br />

Current Day<br />

This bunker is out of range<br />

from the tee and irrelevant of<br />

par 4<br />

Bunker moved


East Course - Hole 8 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Concrete wall<br />

Blown out dune<br />

5th May 1946<br />

The characteristic amphitheatre<br />

8th green<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Blown out dune left after the<br />

demolition of the wall<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 8 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 9 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

The flame thrower range<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 9 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

No drive bunkers<br />

Approach bunker added<br />

4th May 1989<br />

A ‘threesome’ on the green<br />

Green extended further right<br />

Approach bunker moved to<br />

green edge<br />

Current Day<br />

Drive bunkers added


East Course - Hole 10 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current foregreen is green<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 10 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Green has reduced in size<br />

Large expanse of fairway for the<br />

landing area<br />

Two approach bunkers added<br />

4th May 1989<br />

These two approach bunkers<br />

have been enlarged<br />

The green surface was<br />

mown out to the bases of the<br />

surrounding mounds<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 11 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Trenches?<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 11 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

The fairway was mown out to the left<br />

Greenside bunker in the hollow<br />

5th July 1957<br />

The 11th green was historically<br />

played from the opposite direction.<br />

The 5th hole on the 9 hole 1st course<br />

and the 4th hole on the 18 hole 2nd<br />

course. This accounts for the fall on<br />

the green.<br />

Two small bunkers<br />

Original direction of play<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Two small bunkers<br />

merged into one<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 12 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Trenches<br />

5th May 1946<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 12 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Single greenside bunker<br />

Left-hand greenside bunker added<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 13 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Bunkers?<br />

Bunker at the rear of the green<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Bunkers<br />

Large sand crater<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 13 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 14 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

The obstacle course<br />

Blown out sand dune<br />

Blown out sand dune<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Blown out sand dunes<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 14 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Left hand bunker has appeared<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Single bunker<br />

Left hand bunker has gone again<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Old bunker<br />

2 bunkers<br />

Current Day<br />

Old bunker<br />

4 bunkers


East Course - Hole 15 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Blown out sand dune<br />

Blown out sand dune<br />

24th November 1952<br />

No bunkers<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 15 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Two bunkers set into the humps<br />

and hollows<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 16 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Open sand crater<br />

Ships sides<br />

5th May 1946<br />

Pillboxes<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Blown out sand dunes<br />

Original 8th green<br />

location (9 hole layout)<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 16 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

Large rough edged bunker<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Approach bunker added<br />

Drive bunker reduced in size<br />

Current Day<br />

These bunker have<br />

since been moved


East Course - Hole 16 - 1957 Oblique View<br />

Green


East Course - Hole 16 - Current Oblique View


East Course - Hole 17 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th May 1946<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Ken Cotton green location<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 17 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

5th July 1957<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Back tee positioned to the left<br />

Green moved to current location<br />

Current Day<br />

Bunker configuration has changed<br />

since 1989


East Course - Hole 18 - 1946, 1952 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Barracks<br />

5th May 1946<br />

No bunkers surrounding the<br />

green just humps and hollows<br />

24th November 1952<br />

Ken Cotton 18th hole<br />

Current Day


East Course - Hole 18 - 1957, 1989 & Current Day Aerial Photograph Comparison<br />

Current day centre line<br />

shown on all plans<br />

Approach bunker<br />

5th July 1957<br />

4th May 1989<br />

Drive bunker added<br />

Approach bunker enlarged<br />

3 Drive bunkers<br />

Current Day<br />

5 Greenside bunkers

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!