23.03.2013 Views

Generation XXX

Generation XXX

Generation XXX

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Generation</strong> <strong>XXX</strong><br />

Pornography Acceptance and<br />

Use Among Emerging Adults<br />

Jason S. Carroll<br />

Laura M. Padilla-Walker<br />

Larry J. Nelson<br />

Chad D. Olson<br />

Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah<br />

Carolyn McNamara Barry<br />

Loyola College in Maryland, Baltimore<br />

Stephanie D. Madsen<br />

McDaniel College, Westminster, Maryland<br />

Journal of Adolescent<br />

Research<br />

Volume 23 Number 1<br />

January 2008 6-30<br />

© 2008 Sage Publications<br />

10.1177/0743558407306348<br />

http://jar.sagepub.com<br />

hosted at<br />

http://online.sagepub.com<br />

This study examined correlates of pornography acceptance and use within a normative<br />

(nonclinical) population of emerging adults (individuals aged 18–26).<br />

Participants included 813 university students (500 women; M age = 20 years)<br />

recruited from six college sites across the United States. Participants completed<br />

online questionnaires regarding their acceptance and use of pornography, as well<br />

as their sexual values and activity, substance use, and family formation values.<br />

Results revealed that roughly two thirds (67% ) of young men and one half (49%)<br />

of young women agree that viewing pornography is acceptable, whereas nearly 9<br />

out of 10 (87%) young men and nearly one third (31%) of young women reported<br />

using pornography. Results also revealed associations between pornography<br />

acceptance and use and emerging adults’risky sexual attitudes and behaviors, substance<br />

use patterns, and nonmarital cohabitation values. The discussion considers<br />

the implications of pornography use during the transition to adulthood.<br />

Keywords: pornography; emerging adulthood; sexually explicit material;<br />

risk behaviors<br />

Pornography is becoming a prevalent part of life in the United States and<br />

in many countries around the world. Sex is reported to be the most<br />

Authors’ Note: Address correspondence to Dr. Jason S. Carroll, 2057 Joseph F. Smith Building,<br />

School of Family Life, Brigham Young University, Provo UT 84602; e-mail: jcarroll@byu.edu.<br />

6


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 7<br />

frequently searched topic on the Internet (Cooper, Delmonico, & Burg,<br />

2000), with pornographic search-engine requests totaling approximately 68<br />

million per day (25% of total search-engine requests). Although exact<br />

figures are difficult to ascertain, recent reports estimate that approximately<br />

40 million adults in the United States regularly visit Internet pornography<br />

sites; in terms of economic impact, the pornography industry annually generates<br />

an estimated $100 billion dollars worldwide, with over $13 billion in<br />

revenue from the United States (Ropelato, 2007).<br />

The proliferation of pornography in the current lives of Americans is<br />

undoubtedly linked to the changing technological context of modern<br />

society. The extensive availability of personal computers (beginning in<br />

1982–1985), the subsequent widespread access to the Internet (beginning in<br />

1995), and the advent of pay-per-view home movies (beginning in 1990–1995)<br />

have changed the technological context for accessing pornography (Buzzell,<br />

2005a). Cooper and colleagues (2000) suggest that these technological<br />

advances have created a “triple-A engine” that fuels an increased trend of<br />

pornography consumption, referring to the increased accessibility (millions<br />

of pornographic websites are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week), affordability<br />

(competition on the Internet keeps prices low, and there are a host of<br />

ways to get free pornography), and anonymity of sexually explicit materials<br />

(in the privacy of one’s own home, people perceive their accessing of pornography<br />

to be anonymous). These technological changes make questions about<br />

pornography particularly relevant to young people, who are coming of age in<br />

a context where computers and Internet access are ubiquitous in households<br />

and college campuses across America. Emerging adulthood (18–25 years)<br />

may be a time of particular interest because it is a period that is characterized<br />

by exploration in the areas of sexuality, romantic relationships, identity, and<br />

values, as well increased participation in risk behaviors (Arnett, 2006).<br />

Despite the documented increase of pornography during the last decade<br />

and its near-mainstream status in American culture, little attention has been<br />

given to the topic in leading research journals. For example, a targeted database<br />

search (using the PsychInfo database) of the top five adolescent journals,<br />

the top five developmental journals, and the top five family journals since 1995<br />

reveals that only one article has been published reporting on a study where<br />

pornography was a primary focus (Cameron et al., 2005) and only two articles<br />

where pornography was investigated as an issue of minor or secondary interest<br />

(Wang, Bianchi, & Raley, 2005; Young-Ho, 2001). Given this lack of attention<br />

in leading journals, little is known about the correlates and outcomes of<br />

pornography use in regard to individual development and family formation<br />

patterns. There is a growing literature on pornography in specialty journals


8 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

that address sexuality and the clinical treatment of sexual disorders, but<br />

these studies typically utilize nonnormative samples and rarely address core<br />

developmental processes and outcomes.<br />

For this project, pornography was defined as media used or intended to<br />

increase sexual arousal. Such material generally portrays images of nudity and<br />

depictions of sexual behaviors. Researchers have labeled this class of media<br />

using terms such as sexually explicit materials (Goodson, McCormick, & Evans,<br />

2001), erotica (Zillmann, 1994), and online sexual activity (Cooper et al., 2000).<br />

The purpose of this study was to examine levels of pornography use and<br />

acceptance among a normative sample of emerging adults (aged 18 to 26) in<br />

the United States and to compare usage rates across age cohorts within this<br />

developmental period. Analyses were conducted to investigate how patterns of<br />

pornography acceptance and use were associated with emerging adults’ sexual<br />

attitudes and behaviors, substance use patterns, and family formation values.<br />

These dependent variables were selected to investigate issues of importance to<br />

current functioning during emerging adulthood and future family formation.<br />

Pornography Literature<br />

A review of the scholarly research addressing pornography reveals a<br />

diverse literature that spans nearly 50 years. However, much of this literature<br />

is dated, in that it predates the current technological context of pornography<br />

(Buzzell, 2005a). Also, much of the existing literature is of limited<br />

use for our purposes here because it focuses on issues related to criminology<br />

and the clinical treatment of sexual compulsions rather than use among<br />

normative populations. Beginning as early as the 1970s and 1980s, scholars<br />

have investigated potential links between pornography and criminal<br />

behaviors such as violence and aggression (Allen, D’Alessio, & Brezgel,<br />

1995), sexual offenses (Bauserman, 1996), and child pornography (Quayle<br />

& Taylor, 2003). Although meta-analytic studies have frequently documented<br />

a link between pornography exposure and increased criminal and<br />

deviant behavior (Allen et al., 1995; Oddone-Paolucci, Genuis, & Violato,<br />

2000), inconsistent findings and limitations in the research have created<br />

divergent perspectives and an ongoing debate among scholars about the<br />

effects of pornography exposure on the subsequent behavior of individuals.<br />

Clinical research on pornography has increased in recent years as mental<br />

health professionals across disciplines have reported a marked increase<br />

in the number of clients seeking treatment for sexually addictive problems<br />

related to pornography (Mitchell, Becker-Blease, & Finkelhor, 2005).


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 9<br />

Using clinical samples, this line of research has begun to identify potential links<br />

between pornography compulsion and individual problems (Philaretou,<br />

Mahfouz, & Allen, 2005) and potential couple dynamics (R. M. Bergner &<br />

Bridges, 2002). Although criminal and clinical research studies examine a<br />

number of unique questions, they are typically based on nonnormative<br />

samples with existing disorders and are fairly limited in scope, in that they<br />

address only extremes of pornography addiction, psychopathology, and<br />

criminal behavior. We focus our review here on research that has been done<br />

with normative samples and that addresses correlates and outcomes of<br />

pornography use and acceptance among emerging adults.<br />

A small number of studies have examined pornography use in the general<br />

population (Cooper, Delmonico, Griffin-Shelly, & Mathy, 2004; Cooper et al.,<br />

2000; Cooper, Galbreath, & Becker, 2004; Cooper, Putnam, Planchon, &<br />

Boies, 1999) and have found that pornography use is highest among individuals<br />

aged 18–25 (Buzzell, 2005b). Research conducted to date suggests that<br />

approximately 50% of college students report viewing pornography on the<br />

Internet (Boies, 2002; Goodson et al., 2001). Goodson and colleagues (2001)<br />

examined Internet pornography use among 506 college students and found<br />

that 56% of men and 35% of women reported using the Internet for sex-related<br />

information. Boies (2002) examined Internet pornography use among 1,100<br />

university students and found that 72% of men and 24% of women reported<br />

using the Internet to view pornography, with 11% of users viewing sexually<br />

explicit materials once a week or more. Furthermore, those who reported<br />

greater exposure to pornography were more likely to be sexually experienced,<br />

report lower sexual anxiety, and have a higher number of sexual partners<br />

(Morrison, Harriman, Morrison, Bearden, & Ellis, 2004).<br />

In addressing the question of what motivates college students to participate<br />

in pornography use on the Internet, Goodson et al. (2001) found that<br />

30% of users reported accessing sexually explicit materials on the Internet<br />

out of curiosity, 19% to become sexually aroused, and 13% as a means of<br />

enhancing their offline sexual encounters. Boies (2002) found that a majority<br />

(82%) reported that viewing sexually explicit material online was sexually<br />

arousing, 40% reported that it satisfied curiosity, and 63% reported that<br />

they learned new sexual techniques. Although there is a disparity between<br />

the primary motivations for pornography use between these two studies, it<br />

is clear that becoming sexually aroused and fulfilling curiosity are salient<br />

motivations for Internet pornography use among emerging adults. Research<br />

also suggests that emerging adults’ use of sexually explicit materials online<br />

is primarily a solitary activity, with 35% of users reporting the use of<br />

Internet pornography while alone, 18% with offline partners, and 15% in a


10 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

group context (Goodson et al., 2001). This finding is further supported by<br />

research suggesting that 83% of young men and 55% of young women<br />

reported masturbating while viewing pornography (Boies, 2002).<br />

Although men of all ages overwhelmingly report greater pornography<br />

use than do women, Boies (2002) found that in younger samples, women<br />

viewed pornographic material at a higher proportion to males (3:1) than in<br />

older samples (6:1). Furthermore, Goodson et al. (2001) examined the emotional<br />

correlates of pornography use among college students and found few<br />

gender differences in reports of arousal in response to sexually explicit<br />

materials. Goodson and colleagues suggested that the use of sexually<br />

explicit material on the Internet is a valued activity for women and provides<br />

a safe medium through which women can explore their sexuality.<br />

Focus of the Study<br />

Existing studies provide some insight into the pornography patterns of<br />

emerging adults and some of the reasons behind their use of pornography,<br />

but there continue to be unanswered questions regarding how pornography<br />

might be associated with salient developmental features of emerging adulthood.<br />

For example, there is little research examining correlates of pornography<br />

use with variables other than sexual attitudes and behaviors, such as<br />

substance use and family formation values. Given that emerging adults<br />

appear to be using pornography as much or more than any other age group<br />

and may also have more aspects of their lives in transition than do other age<br />

groups (Arnett, 2006), it is important to understand how pornography use<br />

during this developmental period might be related to other values and<br />

behaviors that are important for positive development.<br />

This study was designed to examine how pornography use and acceptance<br />

are associated with emerging adults’ sexual attitudes and behaviors, substance<br />

use patterns, and family formation values. Dependent variables were selected<br />

to investigate issues of importance to current functioning during emerging<br />

adulthood and future family formation. For example, family scholars have<br />

found certain premarital behaviors, such as permissive sexuality (Heaton,<br />

2002; Kahn & London, 1991; Larson & Holman, 1994; Teachman, 2003)<br />

and nonmarital cohabitation (DeMaris & Rao, 1992; Dush, Cohan, &<br />

Amato, 2003; Kline et al., 2004), to be associated with less marital stability<br />

in future marriages. Conversely, sexuality (Lefkowitz & Gillen, 2006)<br />

and substance use patterns (Schulenberg & Zarrett, 2006) are more<br />

commonly examined arenas of exploration and experimentation during


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 11<br />

emerging adulthood. This study was designed to address two primary<br />

research questions:<br />

Question 1: What are the levels of acceptance and use of pornography among<br />

emerging adults, and how do these patterns vary across age cohorts within this<br />

developmental period?<br />

Question 2: To what extent are levels of pornography acceptance and use associated<br />

with sexuality, substance use, and family formation patterns in emerging adulthood?<br />

Furthermore, this study was designed to address five limitations that<br />

exist in pornography research to date:<br />

Limitation 1: Findings suggest that the use of one medium of media to access<br />

pornography (i.e., the Internet) is highly correlated with the use of other forms<br />

of pornography use, such as reading pornographic magazines and viewing<br />

videotapes (Goodson et al., 2001) as well as going to offline public venues to<br />

view pornographic entertainment (Boies, 2002). Thus, focusing solely on<br />

Internet pornography likely results in an underestimation of the frequency of<br />

pornography use among emerging adults, especially when considering that adolescents<br />

and emerging adults report using offline pornography more frequently<br />

than online pornography (Boies, 2002; Ybarra & Mitchell, 2005). Thus, the current<br />

study examined overall pornography use across media in an attempt to<br />

obtain a more accurate understanding of the frequency of pornography use.<br />

Limitation 2: Our review of the literature revealed that results are mixed in regard<br />

to the frequency of pornography use (ranging from 40%–90%) and the correlates<br />

of this behavior among emerging adults. These inconsistencies are likely the<br />

result of (a) past researchers not examining men and women separately in their<br />

analyses and (b) their utilizing small samples, typically recruited from a single<br />

university location. In an attempt to obtain a more representative sample, data<br />

from the current study were gathered from six geographically diverse universities<br />

across the United States, and all analyses were separately computed for<br />

emerging adult men and women.<br />

Limitation 3: Scholars examining correlates of pornography use have rarely controlled<br />

for other variables that may be affecting the relationship between pornography<br />

use and other behaviors, thereby posing a threat to the validity of the<br />

findings and to the inferences made from them. For example, although scholars<br />

have explored links between religiosity and pornography use (Goodson,<br />

McCormick, & Evans, 2000), studies rarely control for religiosity when investigating<br />

the affects of pornography. Without these control variables, scholars<br />

cannot rule out plausible alternative explanations for their findings. Controlled<br />

analyses are particularly needed when examining links between pornography<br />

use and risk behavior or sexual activity because the observed relation may be<br />

due to a third variable, such as impulsivity (see Peter & Valkenburg, 2006) or


12 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

relationship status (A. J. Bergner, Bergner, & Hesson-Mcinnis, 2003). To minimize<br />

the likelihood of identifying spurious correlations, all analyses in this study controlled<br />

for the religiosity, impulsivity, age, and relationship status of the participants.<br />

Limitation 4: Much of the existing literature on pornography use is limited in value<br />

because the researchers measured usage patterns with personally defined<br />

response codes (e.g., never, seldom, sometimes, often) rather than temporally<br />

based response codes that provide actual frequencies of use (e.g., weekly, every<br />

other day, daily). To better ascertain frequency patterns, this study measured<br />

pornography use with a temporally based response pattern.<br />

Limitation 5: Finally, many pornography studies only look at patterns of pornography<br />

use but do not simultaneously investigate rates of acceptance of pornography,<br />

whether personally used or not. Studying values related to pornography<br />

may be a critical addition to the literature, in that it allows scholars to look at<br />

how widely accepted pornography use is among certain developmental cohorts<br />

and to identify the degree to which this behavior is condoned or condemned by<br />

one’s peers. The study of values related to pornography may be particularly beneficial<br />

in the study of couple formation patterns where men’s and women’s usage<br />

patterns may differ, but acceptance or nonacceptance of a partner’s behavior may<br />

have implications for relationship dynamics and quality.<br />

Participants<br />

Method<br />

The participants for this study were selected from an ongoing study of<br />

emerging adults and their parents, entitled Project READY (Researching<br />

Emerging Adults’ Developmental Years). This project is a collaborative multisite<br />

study that is being conducted by a consortium of developmental and<br />

family scholars. The sample that was utilized in the current study consisted<br />

of 813 undergraduate and graduate students (500 women, 313 men) recruited<br />

from six college sites across the country: a small private liberal arts college<br />

and a medium-sized religious university on the East Coast, two large<br />

Midwestern public universities, a large religious university in the intermountain<br />

West, and a large public university on the West Coast. Participants ranged<br />

in age from 18 to 26, with the mean age being 20.0 years (SD = 1.84).<br />

Overall, 79% of the participants were European American, 4% were African<br />

American, 9% were Asian American, 3% were Latino American, and 5%<br />

indicated that they were “mixed/biracial” or of an other ethnicity. Furthermore,<br />

96% reported that their sexual preference was heterosexual, 2%<br />

reported a homosexual preference, and another 2% reported a bisexual preference.<br />

Study participants reported a variety of religious affiliations: Roman


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 13<br />

Catholic, 35.1%; conservative Christian, 16.6%; liberal Christian, 16.0%;<br />

Latter-day Saint (Mormon), 2.9%; other faiths (e.g., Jewish, Greek Orthodox,<br />

Muslim), 3.2%; atheist/agnostic, 7.9%; and no affiliation, 9.5%. All of the participants<br />

were unmarried (6.3% cohabiting with a partner in an intimate relationship),<br />

and 90% reported living outside their parents’ home in an<br />

apartment, house, or dormitory.<br />

Procedure<br />

Participants completed the Project READY questionnaire via the Internet<br />

(see http://www.projectready.net). The use of an online data collection protocol<br />

facilitated unified data collection across multiple university sites and<br />

allowed for the survey to be administered to emerging adults and their parents,<br />

who were living in separate locations throughout the country (parent data were<br />

not used in the current study). Participants were recruited through faculty<br />

announcement of the study in undergraduate and graduate courses. Professors<br />

at the various universities were provided with a handout to give to their<br />

students that had a brief explanation of the study, as well as directions for<br />

accessing the online survey. Interested students then accessed the study Web<br />

site with a location-specific recruitment code. Informed consent was obtained<br />

online, and only after consent was given could the participants begin the questionnaires.<br />

Each participant was asked to complete a survey battery of 448<br />

items. Sections of the survey addressed areas such as background information,<br />

family-of-origin experiences, self-perceptions, personality traits, values, risk<br />

behaviors, dating behaviors, prosocial behaviors, and religiosity. The survey<br />

also assessed attitudes and behaviors pertaining to couple formation, such as<br />

cohabitation, sexuality, and interpersonal competencies. Most participants<br />

were offered course credit or extra credit for their participation. In some cases<br />

(approximately 5%), participants were offered small monetary compensation<br />

(i.e., $10–$20 gift certificates) for their participation.<br />

Measures<br />

For the current study, we examined associations between emerging<br />

adults’ reports of their acceptance and use of pornography and their attitudes<br />

and behaviors related to potential risk behaviors (i.e., sexuality and<br />

substance use) and family formation values.<br />

Pornography acceptance and use. Two items were used to measure participants’<br />

levels of acceptance and use of pornography. Acceptance of


14 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

pornography was measured by asking respondents how much they agreed<br />

with the statement “Viewing pornographic material (such as magazines,<br />

movies, and/or Internet sites) is an acceptable way to express one’s sexuality.”<br />

Responses were recorded on a 6-point scale ranging from 1 (very<br />

strongly disagree) to 6 (very strongly agree). To assess pornography use,<br />

emerging adults were asked the question, “How frequently do you view<br />

pornographic material (such as magazines, movies, and/or Internet sites)?”<br />

Responses for this item were measured on a 6-point scale ranging from 0<br />

to 5 (0 = none, 1 = once a month or less, 2 = 2 or 3 days a month, 3 = 1 or<br />

2 days a week, 4 = 3 to 5 days a week, 5 = everyday or almost everyday).<br />

Risk behaviors. Emerging adults’ sexual permissiveness was measured<br />

using a two-item scale assessing how much participants agreed or disagreed<br />

with sexual value statements on a 6-point scale ranging from 1 (very<br />

strongly disagree) to 6 (very strongly agree). These statements related to<br />

their personal sexual ethics regarding premarital sexual relations (“It is all<br />

right for a man and woman to have sexual relations before marriage”) and<br />

uncommitted sexual relations (“It is all right for two people to get together<br />

for sex and not necessarily expect anything further”). Preliminary analyses<br />

found that this scale had strong internal consistency (emerging adult men,<br />

α=.84; emerging adult women, α=.84) and that, on average, emerging<br />

adult men (M = 3.92, SD = 1.36) reported higher levels of sexual permissiveness<br />

than did emerging adult women (M = 3.51, SD = 1.35).<br />

Participants’ agreement with extramarital sexuality was assessed with a single<br />

item (“It is all right for a married person to have sexual relations with<br />

someone other than his/her spouse”): emerging adult men, M = 1.36, SD =<br />

.78; emerging adult women, M = 1.22, SD = .67. Two items were used to<br />

assess participants’ sexual behavior. Open-response questions asked emerging<br />

adults to report the number of sexual partners that they have had in their<br />

lifetime (emerging adult men, M = 3.10, SD = 6.17; emerging adult women,<br />

M = 2.51, SD = 4.01) and within the last 12 months (emerging adult men,<br />

M = 1.19, SD = 1.70; emerging adult women, M = .97, SD = 1.29).<br />

Emerging adults reported their frequency of substance use using a fiveitem<br />

scale assessing alcohol consumption, binge drinking (i.e., drinking 4<br />

or 5 drinks or more in one occasion), cigarette smoking, marijuana use, and<br />

their use of other illegal drugs (e.g., cocaine, heroin, crystal meth, mushrooms).<br />

Responses were reported using a 6-point scale ranging from 0 to 5<br />

(0 = none, 1 = once a month or less, 2 = 2 or 3 days a month, 3 = 1 or 2<br />

days a week, 4 = 3 to 5 days a week, 5 = everyday or almost everyday).<br />

Preliminary analyses found that this scale had good internal consistency


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 15<br />

(emerging adult men, α=.76; emerging adult women, α=.76) and that, on<br />

average, emerging adult men (M = 1.19, SD = .96) reported higher levels of<br />

substance use than did emerging adult women (M = .86, SD = .76).<br />

Family formation values. Emerging adults’ values regarding family formation<br />

practices were assessed in the areas of nonmarital cohabitation and childbearing,<br />

marriage ideals, and views of parenting. Participants’ endorsement of<br />

cohabitation was measured using a six-item scale measured on a 6-point scale<br />

ranging from 1 (very strongly disagree) to 6 (very strongly agree). Value statements<br />

included in this scale included “It is all right for a couple to live together<br />

without planning to get married,” “It is all right for an unmarried couple to live<br />

together as long as they have plans to marry,” “Living together before marriage<br />

will improve a couple’s chances of remaining happily married,” “A couple will<br />

likely be happier in their marriage if they live together first,” “It is a good idea<br />

for a couple to live together before getting married as a way of ‘trying out’ their<br />

relationship,” and “Living together first is a good way of testing how workable<br />

a couple’s marriage would be.” Preliminary analyses found that this scale had<br />

very strong internal consistency (emerging adult men, α=.94; emerging adult<br />

women, α=.93) and that, on average, emerging adult men (M = 3.75, SD =<br />

1.21) reported higher levels of endorsement of cohabitation than did emerging<br />

adult women (M = 3.39, SD = 1.17). Participant’s agreement with out-of-wedlock<br />

childbirth was assessed with a single item (“I would personally consider<br />

having a child out-of-wedlock”) measured on a 6-point scale ranging from 1<br />

(very strongly disagree) to 6 (very strongly agree). Preliminary analyses found<br />

that, on average, emerging adult men (M = 2.24, SD = 1.23) and women (M =<br />

2.13, SD = 1.20) hold similar views on this approach to family formation.<br />

Carroll and colleagues (2007) have proposed that emerging adults develop<br />

a marital horizon, or marriage philosophy, that comprises at least three interconnected<br />

factors—marital importance, desired marital timing, and criteria for<br />

marriage readiness. Three items measured on a 6-point scale ranging from 1<br />

(very strongly disagree) to 6 (very strongly agree) were used to measure participants’<br />

ideals for marriage in these three domains. One measured participants’<br />

agreement to value statements regarding marital importance (“Being<br />

married is a very important goal for me”), emerging adult men, M = 3.77,<br />

SD = 1.31; emerging adult women, M = 3.44, SD = 1.35. The next assessed<br />

participant’s desired age for marriage (“What is the ideal age (in years) for an<br />

individual to get married?”), emerging adult men, M = 25.4 years old, SD =<br />

2.12; emerging adult women, M = 24.8 years old, SD = 1.83. A third item<br />

assessed desires for spousal independence in marital finances (“In marriage,<br />

it is a good idea for each spouse to maintain control over his/her personal


16 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

finances”), emerging adult men, M = 3.78, SD = 1.36; emerging adult<br />

women, M = 3.65, SD = 1.35. A three-item scale using the agreement<br />

responses mentioned previously was used to measure participants’ degree<br />

of child-centeredness, or positive appraisal of becoming a parent in the<br />

future. The three items were “Having children is a very important goal for<br />

me,” “Being a father and raising children is one of the most fulfilling experiences<br />

a man can have,” and “Being a mother and raising children is one<br />

of the most fulfilling experiences a woman can have.” Preliminary analyses<br />

found that this scale had strong internal consistency (emerging adult men,<br />

α=.86; emerging adult women, α=.84) and that, on average, emerging<br />

adult men (M = 4.83, SD = 1.08) and emerging adult women (M = 4.89,<br />

SD = .91) had similarly high levels of child-centeredness.<br />

Results<br />

The analyses for this study were conducted in a sequential format to test<br />

the two research questions detailed previously. Because of historical gender<br />

differences in the several variables measured—including average median<br />

age at marriage, sexual behaviors, and substance use—analyses were run<br />

separately for emerging adult men and women.<br />

Question 1: What are the levels of acceptance and use of pornography among<br />

emerging adults, and how do these patterns vary across age cohorts within this<br />

developmental period?<br />

Frequency levels of emerging adults’ acceptance and use of pornography<br />

were calculated for men and women (see Table 1). These analyses revealed<br />

that emerging adult men accepted and used pornography more frequently<br />

than did emerging adult women, although these differences were more pronounced<br />

in usage patterns. Two thirds (66.5%) of emerging adult men<br />

reported that they agreed, at some level, that viewing pornography is<br />

acceptable, whereas emerging adult women were evenly split (48.7% agree,<br />

51.3% disagree) on whether viewing pornography was an acceptable way<br />

to express one’s sexuality. With regard to actual usage rates of pornography,<br />

87% of emerging adult men reported using pornography at some level, with<br />

approximately one fifth reporting daily or every-other-day use (i.e., 3 to 5<br />

times a week) and nearly half (48.4%) reporting a weekly or more frequent<br />

use pattern. Women’s usage patterns were markedly different, with about<br />

one third (31%) reporting pornography use at some level. However, the


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 17<br />

majority of emerging adult women using pornography reported a once a<br />

month or less pattern of usage, and only 3.2% of women reported a use pattern<br />

of weekly or more. An intriguing pattern surfaced when the data on<br />

pornography acceptance were transposed on emerging adults’ reported<br />

usage rates of pornography. For emerging adult men, approximately 1 in 5<br />

reported that they used pornography but did not believe that it is an acceptable<br />

behavior, whereas among emerging adult women, approximately 1 in<br />

5 reported that pornography is acceptable, but they did not personally use<br />

pornography.<br />

In the absence of longitudinal data, the best way to ascertain if pornography<br />

usage and acceptance rates vary across emerging adulthood is to compare<br />

usage rates across age cohorts within the developmental period. As such, our<br />

sample was divided into three age cohorts (18- and 19-year-olds, n = 397; 20to<br />

22-year-olds, n = 337; and 23- to 26-year-olds, n = 79), and MANCOVA<br />

(multiple analysis of covariance) comparisons were computed on emerging<br />

adult men’s and women’s usage and acceptance rates of pornography. Because<br />

previous research has found that risk behaviors typically peak at about age 22<br />

(Arnett, 2006; Schulenberg & Zarrett, 2006), we included a measure of binge<br />

drinking (i.e., the item from the Substance Use Scale) in these age comparisons<br />

to investigate if pornography use followed a similar pattern.<br />

These analyses revealed that for emerging adult men, there were significant<br />

differences between the age cohorts on binge-drinking rates but not on<br />

pornography use or acceptance (MANCOVA: emerging adult men, F = 3.50,<br />

df = 3, p < .05). In particular, emerging adult men followed the expected<br />

pattern, with men aged 23 to 26 reporting significantly less (p < .01) binge<br />

drinking (M = 1.21, SD = 1.26) than their younger counterparts (18- and 19year-olds,<br />

M = 1.84, SD = 1.47; 20- to 22-year-olds, M = 1.86, SD = 1.42).<br />

Although slight declines in pornography use and acceptance were found for<br />

men aged 23 to 26, these differences did not reach statistical significance.<br />

Emerging adult women followed a similar pattern (MANCOVA: emerging<br />

adult women, F = 5.08, df = 3, p < .01), with older emerging adults reporting<br />

significantly less (p < .01) binge drinking behavior (23- to 26-year-olds, M =<br />

1.07, SD = 1.10) than younger women (18- and 19-year-olds, M = 1.37, SD =<br />

1.31; 20- to 22-year-olds, M = 1.32, SD = 1.28); however, pornography use<br />

patterns remained steady across the three groups, and a significant increase<br />

(p < .01) in the acceptance of pornography was identified between women<br />

aged 23 to 26 (M = 3.63, SD = 1.20) and women aged 18 or 19 (M = 3.05,<br />

SD = 1.29). It is interesting to note that although gender differences in pornography<br />

use remain consistent across the three age cohorts, increases in the<br />

acceptance of pornography among older emerging adult women place men’s


18 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

Table 1<br />

Acceptance and Use of Pornography Among<br />

Emerging Adults (in Percentages)<br />

Emerging Adult Emerging Adult<br />

Men (n = 313) Women (n = 500)<br />

Pornography acceptance a<br />

Very strongly disagree 8.0 14.5<br />

Strongly disagree 7.4 11.3<br />

Disagree 18.0 25.5<br />

Agree 45.3 39.0<br />

Strongly agree 9.6 6.3<br />

Very strongly agree 11.6 3.4<br />

Pornography use b<br />

None 13.9 69.0<br />

Once a month or less 16.8 20.7<br />

2 or 3 days a month 21.0 7.1<br />

1 or 2 days a week 27.1 2.2<br />

3 to 5 days a week 16.1 .8<br />

Everyday or almost every day 5.2 .2<br />

a. “Viewing pornographic material (such as magazines, movies, and/or Internet sites) is an<br />

acceptable way to express one’s sexuality.”<br />

b. “During the past 12 months, on how many days did you view pornographic material (such<br />

as magazines, movies, and/or Internet sites)?”<br />

and women’s acceptance of pornography at the same level by the time that<br />

they reach their mid twenties.<br />

Question 2: To what extent are levels of pornography acceptance and use associated with<br />

sexuality, substance use, and family formation patterns in emerging adulthood?<br />

Three types of analyses were used to investigate the study’s second<br />

research question. First, partial correlations were calculated to determine<br />

the direction and strength of the associations between the pornography<br />

items and the other study variables. Next, to examine specifically how<br />

pornography use was related to salient features of emerging adulthood, we<br />

ran a series of group comparison analyses. For emerging adult men, we ran<br />

a series of MANCOVAs with five pornography use groups: Group A, never<br />

use (none); Group B, seldom use (once a month or less); Group C, monthly<br />

use (2 or 3 days a month); Group D, weekly use (1 or 2 days a week); and<br />

Group E, daily use (3 to 5 days a week or everyday or almost everyday).<br />

Because of the relatively low usage rates among women, we ran ANOVA


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 19<br />

Table 2<br />

Correlations Between Pornography Variables and Control Variables<br />

Emerging Adult Emerging Adult<br />

Men (n = 313) Women (n = 500)<br />

Pornography Pornography Pornography Pornography<br />

Control Variables acceptance use acceptance use<br />

Age .02 .06 .13 ** .08<br />

Current dating status a .01 –.02 .11 ** .18 ***<br />

Religiosity b –.39 *** –.30 *** –.44 *** –.20 ***<br />

Impulsivity c .22 *** –.19 *** .06 .04<br />

a. Current dating status: 1 = not dating at all, 2 = casual/occasional dating, 3 = have a<br />

boy/girlfriend (in an exclusive relationship), 4 = engaged, or committed to marry.<br />

b. Religiosity (“My religious faith is extremely important to me”): 1 = very strongly disagree,<br />

2 = strongly disagree, 3 = disagree, 4 = agree, 5 = strongly agree, 6 = very strongly disagree.<br />

c. Impulsivity (two-item scale; emerging adult men, α=.77; emerging adult women, α=.68;<br />

“Fight with others/lose temper,” “Easily irritated or mad”): 1 = never, 2 = seldom, 3 = sometimes,<br />

4 = often, 5 = very often.<br />

** p < .01. *** p < .001.<br />

comparisons between two groups: nonusers (Group A) and users (Group B)<br />

of pornography. We also calculated subgroup frequencies on the behavior<br />

items to further examine patterns of sexuality and substance use. Preliminary<br />

analyses revealed that age, current dating status, religiosity, and impulsivity<br />

were all correlated to some degree with pornography use and acceptance,<br />

with religiosity and impulsivity related to men’s pornography patterns and<br />

with religiosity, current dating status, and age related to women’s pornography<br />

patterns (see Table 2). To increase confidence that the associations<br />

identified between study variables were related to study hypotheses and not<br />

due to spurious correlations, we included items measuring age, current dating<br />

status, religiosity, and impulsivity as control variables in all partial correlation<br />

and group comparison analyses.<br />

Risk behaviors. As noted in Table 3, pornography use was found to be<br />

significantly related with emerging adult men’s sexual values and behaviors.<br />

Partial correlation analyses revealed a small but significant connection<br />

between pornography use and number of lifetime sexual partners among<br />

emerging adult men and their acceptance of extramarital sexual behavior.<br />

Also, the more that men accepted and used pornography, the more likely<br />

they were to be accepting of premarital and casual sexual behavior. Group<br />

comparisons revealed that the most distinctive sexual values were found


Table 3<br />

Correlations and Group Comparisons Between Pornography Variables and Emerging Adult Factors<br />

20<br />

Emerging Adult Men (n = 313) Emerging Adult Women (n = 500)<br />

Pornography Use Pornography Use<br />

None Seldom Monthly Weekly Daily No Yes<br />

Accept (r) Use (r) (= a) (= b) (= c) (= d) (= e) Accept (r) Use (r) (= a) (= b)<br />

Sexual values<br />

Sexual permissiveness .61*** .34*** 2.64bcde 3.59ade 3.92ae 4.23ab 4.68abc .55*** .15** 3.23b 4.12a Extramarital sexuality .08 .15** 1.07e 1.27 1.34 1.50 1.45a .13** .05 1.20 1.24<br />

Sexual behavior: With how many partners have you had sexual intercourse?<br />

“With how many . . .” .09 .11* 1.30e 2.37e 4.25 1.96 5.28ab .19*** .17*** 1.89b 3.75a None 58.1% 28.8 23.1 41.7 22.7 46.4 22.9<br />

3 or more partners 9.3% 25.0 33.4 25.0 40.9 26.9 46.4<br />

With how many partners have you had sexual intercourse in the past 12 months?<br />

“With how many . . .” .02 .06 .63ce 1.04 1.14 1.26 .15 .22*** .09* .85b 1.22a None 67.4% 30.8 27.7 46.4 28.8 50.6 24.2<br />

3 or more partners 2.3% 9.6 15.4 9.5 22.7 7.7 11.1<br />

Substance use<br />

Substance Use Scale .15* .20*** .35bcde 1.14a 1.42a 1.30a 1.38a .28*** .16*** .77b 1.08a Alcohol use<br />

None 51.2% 19.2 3.1 13.1 7.6 22.4 8.5<br />

Weekly or more 18.6% 46.2 69.2 60.7 60.6 38.8 47.1<br />

Binge drinking<br />

None 69.8% 26.9 15.4 27.4 22.7 46.2 24.8<br />

Weekly or more 11.6% 32.7 49.2 46.4 51.5 22.9 29.4<br />

Note: Controlling for age, dating status, religiosity, and impulsivity. Alphabetic superscripts indicate significant group mean differences at the p < .05 level.<br />

*p < .05. **p < .01. ***p < .001.


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 21<br />

among the emerging adult men who never used pornography and reported<br />

markedly more conservative sexual values than their pornography using<br />

peers and among men who used pornography on a daily basis who reported<br />

the most liberal sexual values (MANCOVA: emerging adult men, F = 5.99,<br />

df = 5, p < .001). The daily users had, on average, nearly 5 times more lifetime<br />

sexual partners than nonusers had, and the majority of nonusers<br />

reported that they had not had sexual intercourse. Among emerging adult<br />

women, pornography acceptance and use were found to be related to sexual<br />

values and sexual behaviors, with pornography acceptance being a stronger<br />

correlate of these variables than actual pornography use. Significant group<br />

differences were found on all sexual variables (p < .001) except agreement<br />

with extramarital sexual behavior. Emerging adult women who accepted<br />

and used pornography were found to have significantly higher levels of<br />

acceptance of casual sexual behavior and to report higher numbers of<br />

sexual partners within the last 12 months and across their lifetimes.<br />

As noted in Table 3, pornography use and acceptance were also found to<br />

be significantly correlated with emerging adults’ substance use patterns.<br />

Specifically, pornography acceptance and use were correlated significantly<br />

with men’s substance use patterns. Comparisons of subgroup frequencies<br />

revealed that emerging adult men who did not use pornography had<br />

markedly lower levels of drinking and binge drinking than did their counterparts,<br />

who used pornography on a regular basis. Similar but more pronounced<br />

patterns were found among emerging adult women, among whom,<br />

pornography use and acceptance were found to be significantly correlated<br />

with higher substance use. Group comparisons documented that these differences<br />

were statistically significant (p < .01) between emerging adult<br />

women who used pornography and those who did not.<br />

Family formation values. As noted in Table 4, pornography acceptance<br />

was found to be significantly related to young people’s values and approaches<br />

to family formation; however, pornography use patterns had little correlation<br />

with these variables. Emerging adult men and women who were more<br />

accepting of pornography were also more accepting of nonmarital cohabitation,<br />

but only women who accepted pornography were found to be more<br />

likely to consider having a child out of wedlock. No correlations were<br />

found between pornography acceptance and emerging adult men’s and<br />

women’s goals for marriage. However, acceptance of pornography was<br />

found to be significantly correlated with desires for later marriage, financial<br />

independence between spouses within marriage, and lower levels of<br />

child-centeredness for emerging adult men and women. Similar to the


22<br />

Table 4<br />

Correlations and Group Comparisons Between Pornography Variables and Family Formation Values<br />

Emerging Adult Men (n = 313) Emerging Adult Women (n = 500)<br />

Pornography Use Pornography Use<br />

None Seldom Monthly Weekly Daily No Yes<br />

Accept (r) Use (r) (= a) (= b) (= c) (= d) (= e) Accept (r) Use (r) (= a) (= b)<br />

Nonmarital cohabitation and childbearing<br />

Endorsement of .41*** .11 3.11de 3.45d 3.70 4.13ab 4.08a .37*** .04 3.24b 3.71a cohabitation<br />

Out-of-wedlock childbirth .07 .06 1.82 e 2.27 2.19 2.33 2.45a .21*** .05 1.99b 2.42a Marriage and parenting<br />

“Being married is a very .06 –.02 5.08 4.76 4.86 4.52 4.49 –.08 –.03 4.96 4.93<br />

important goal for me.”<br />

Ideal age for marriage .15** .09 24.8e 25.0 25.3 26.0a 25.7 .13** .08 24.7 b 25.1a (in years)<br />

Spousal independence .17*** .03 3.58 3.51 3.70 3.76 3.66 .14*** .01 3.73 3.81<br />

Child-centeredness –.15** .01 5.01 4.86 4.87 4.84 4.81 –.13** –.06 4.97b 4.72a Note: Controlling for age, dating status, religiosity, and impulsivity. Alphabetic superscripts indicate significant group mean differences at the<br />

p < .05 level.<br />

**p < .01. ***p < .001.


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 23<br />

analyses involving the sexuality and substance use variables, group comparison<br />

analyses revealed that much of the variance in these correlations<br />

was attributed to the more traditional views of nonpornography using men<br />

(MANCOVA: F = 6.20, df = 6, p < .001) and women (four of six comparisons,<br />

p < .001) and their peers who used pornography.<br />

Discussion<br />

The current study examined levels of pornography use and acceptance<br />

among emerging adults in the United States. Comparisons were made<br />

between early (18- and 19-year-olds), middle (20- to 22-year-olds), and late<br />

emerging adults (23- to 26-year-olds). Additional analyses were conducted<br />

to see if patterns of pornography acceptance and use were correlated with<br />

sexual attitudes and behaviors, substance use patterns, and family formation<br />

values among emerging adults. Results suggest that pornography is a<br />

prominent feature of the current emerging adulthood culture. Pornography<br />

use was particularly prevalent among emerging adult men, with nearly half<br />

reporting that they viewed pornography at least weekly and about 1 in 5<br />

reporting that they used pornography daily or every other day. In contrast,<br />

emerging adult women were less accepting and much less likely to use<br />

pornography on a frequent basis. Given the lack of attention to pornography<br />

habits in the leading developmental, adolescent, and family journals,<br />

these findings raise a number of questions for scholars about how intentional<br />

exposure to sexually explicit material may influence the developmental<br />

patterns of the rising generation in the United States. We organize<br />

our discussion of these findings around gender differences in pornography<br />

patterns, perspectives on pornography as young people transition in and out<br />

of emerging adulthood, and considerations of how pornography may influence<br />

couple formation during and after emerging adulthood.<br />

Gender Differences in Pornography Patterns<br />

Perhaps the most notable finding of this study was the marked difference<br />

in pornography use and acceptance among emerging adult men and emerging<br />

adult women in our sample. These results suggest that pornography use<br />

is as common as drinking is among college-age men. It also appears that a<br />

sizable number of emerging adult men “binge” on pornography, with a similar<br />

frequency and intensity that define binge drinking on American college<br />

campuses. In fact, the comparison between pornography use and binge


24 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

drinking may be justified, in that pornography use was found to be moderately<br />

correlated with emerging adult men’s frequency of alcohol consumption<br />

and their rates of binge drinking, even after controlling for a number of<br />

variables that may be thought to contribute to both of these behaviors (e.g.,<br />

impulsivity, religiosity). Emerging adult women were split when it came to<br />

the topic of pornography. About half of emerging adult women were<br />

accepting of pornography use among their peers, but only about 1 in 10<br />

viewed pornography with any regularity. It may be possible that the measures<br />

that were utilized in this study influenced this finding, in that they<br />

assessed visual media of pornography (Internet, magazines, movies) rather<br />

than narrative-based erotica, which may be more appealing to women.<br />

However, even with this consideration, the differences between pornography<br />

use and acceptance among emerging adult men and women form a<br />

notable finding that requires exploration in future research.<br />

Another notable finding of this study was that the acceptance of pornography<br />

was as strongly correlated with emerging adults’ attitudes and behaviors<br />

as their actual pornography use was (or more so). This finding suggests<br />

that pornography should be regarded as much as a value stance or a personal<br />

sexual ethic as it is a behavioral pattern. This may be a particularly<br />

salient finding for emerging adult women who report higher levels of<br />

acceptance than actual use of pornography. Furthermore, pornography<br />

acceptance among women was a stronger correlate with permissive sexuality,<br />

alcohol use, binge drinking, and cigarette smoking than was actual<br />

pornography use. For men, the acceptance of pornography was more highly<br />

correlated with their sexual attitudes and family formation values than was<br />

pornography use. These findings highlight that scholars need to define<br />

pornography in terms of both values and behavior.<br />

Transitions in and out of Emerging Adulthood<br />

In addition to examining the overall usage rates of pornography among<br />

emerging adults, subanalyses were also run to determine if rates of pornography<br />

use differed significantly for early, middle, and late emerging adults.<br />

These analyses identified that the rates of pornography use were relatively<br />

stable across emerging adulthood. These patterns also suggest that pornography<br />

patterns are established during adolescence or are rapidly developed<br />

in emerging adulthood. The much lower levels of reported pornography use<br />

among adolescents (Ybarra & Mitchell, 2005) suggest that the latter explanation<br />

is more plausible, but future research is needed to confirm this possibility.<br />

The age pattern found in the current study is notable because it


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 25<br />

varies from the identified pattern of exploratory behaviors during emerging<br />

adulthood, which finds that for the majority of the population, most of these<br />

types of behaviors peak at about age 22 and then decrease from that time forward<br />

(Schulenberg & Zarrett, 2006). Thus, pornography use may be largely a<br />

personal pattern that is not as contingent on the peer-centered experimental<br />

context of emerging adulthood as drinking may be. This possibility is supported<br />

by research suggesting that pornography use is largely a solitary activity<br />

(Boies, 2002; Goodson et al., 2001), and it suggests that the solitary nature<br />

of pornography use may distinguish it from other exploratory behaviors that<br />

are common during emerging adulthood. The solitary pattern of pornography<br />

use may contribute to its being more frequently carried over into young adulthood<br />

than peer-centered experimental behaviors.<br />

A better understanding of how the transition from emerging adulthood<br />

to young adult life influences and is influenced by pornography will help<br />

clarify these processes. A key question in this line of research will be to<br />

identify whether pornography acceptance and use rates remain similar as<br />

emerging adults get older or if they change as young people transition into<br />

adult roles and relationships. For example, our data set included responses<br />

on the pornography acceptance item from 280 fathers and 343 mothers of<br />

the emerging adults sampled for this study. A post hoc frequency analysis<br />

of these responses revealed that only 36.6% of fathers and 20.4% of mothers<br />

agreed at some level that pornography was an acceptable expression of<br />

one’s sexuality. By way of comparison, emerging adults were much more<br />

accepting of pornography than their parents were, with daughters even<br />

reporting more acceptance (48.7%) than their fathers. Longitudinal<br />

research is needed to determine if this pattern reflects a life course trajectory,<br />

with acceptance of pornography decreasing as individuals move into<br />

adulthood, or if this pattern reflects a generational difference, with the rising<br />

generation being more socialized than previous generations toward<br />

pornography across the life span.<br />

Another question that arises from the pornography usage rates identified in<br />

this study is whether there is a link between the high level of habitual use<br />

among men across emerging adulthood and the development of addictive and<br />

compulsive patterns associated with pornography use. At least two alternative<br />

trajectories seem possible. First, it is possible that the high rates of pornography<br />

use among the emerging adult men identified in this study simply<br />

reflect the explorative nature of emerging adulthood and that, similar to<br />

rates of binge drinking and other risk behaviors that peak during the early<br />

twenties (Schulenberg & Zarrett, 2006), pornography rates will taper off and<br />

have few lasting negative effects on development. A second possibility is that


26 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

for some young men, habitual use of pornography during adolescence and<br />

emerging adulthood will act as the genesis for future problematic behaviors.<br />

Data on binge drinking reflect this type of pattern. Although the majority<br />

of young people who engage in binge drinking during late adolescence<br />

and emerging adulthood do not continue these patterns into adult life, there<br />

is a notable minority (6%–8%) that engage in frequent binge drinking during<br />

college (Brower, 2002), which may linger through life. Cooper and colleagues<br />

(Cooper, Delmonico, et al., 2004; Cooper, Galbreath, et al., 2004)<br />

have developed a typology of pornography use that demonstrates how it<br />

might affect individuals differently. Specifically, they identify three groups<br />

of users of online sexual activity: Recreational users are those who access<br />

online sexual material out of curiosity or for entertainment purposes and are<br />

not typically seen as having problems associated with their online sexual<br />

behavior. At-risk users are those who, if it were not for the availability of<br />

the Internet, may never have developed a problem with online sexuality.<br />

Finally, sexual compulsive users who, because of a propensity for pathological<br />

sexual expression, use the Internet as one forum for their sexual<br />

activities. Therefore, there may be a population of predisposed individuals<br />

for whom early exposure to pornography can lead to compulsive<br />

sexual problems. Thus, future studies should examine links between<br />

common use during adolescence and emerging adulthood and later adult<br />

patterns, including sexual compulsion.<br />

Pornography and Couple Formation<br />

Two findings from this study are of note for research on couple formation<br />

in emerging adulthood and later adult life. First, pornography was not<br />

significantly associated with young people’s goals for marriage and parenthood.<br />

Although pornography users were found to be more accepting of<br />

nonmarital cohabitation than nonpornography users were, both groups<br />

shared a mutually high regard for eventually getting married and becoming<br />

parents. Therefore, pornography use and acceptance should be interpreted<br />

within a framework that examines how these attitudes and behaviors influence<br />

young people’s marital competence and family capacities (Carroll,<br />

Badger, & Yang, 2006). However, it should also be noted that pornography<br />

use was linked to permissive sexuality and nonmarital cohabitation, two<br />

variables that have been found to be associated with less marital stability in<br />

future marriages (Dush, Cohan & Amato, 2003; Heaton, 2002; Kline et al.,<br />

2004). Furthermore, although young people who accept and use pornography<br />

identify marriage and parenthood as important life goals, it is not


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 27<br />

known if pornography influences how young people define marriage. Men<br />

who used pornography and women who accepted pornography were significantly<br />

more likely to accept a married person’s having sexual relations<br />

with someone other than his or her spouse than were their peers who did<br />

not use or accept pornography. It may be that this finding merely reflects<br />

the fact that sexually liberal people who endorse nonmarital sexual activity<br />

are more likely to use pornography as emerging adults. However, future<br />

research should examine if pornography influences people’s views of the<br />

ethos of monogamy, which accompanies traditional views of marriage.<br />

A second finding of note relating to couple formation patterns was the<br />

identified pattern that roughly half of emerging adult women expressed a<br />

disapproving view of pornography whereas nearly 9 out of 10 emerging<br />

adult men reported using pornography to some degree, with nearly half<br />

viewing pornography on a weekly or more frequent basis. This disparity<br />

raises a number of questions about couple formation patterns between men<br />

and women. What happens to men’s and women’s pornography patterns<br />

when they enter serious romantic relationships? Do men decrease or stop<br />

their pornography use when they enter a relationship? Do men continue to<br />

use pornography but do so covertly in an effort to hide their behaviors from<br />

an unaccepting partner? Do women start or increase their use when they<br />

become romantically involved with a man who uses pornography? Does a<br />

new pattern of pornography use arise during the coupling process that shifts<br />

from individual use to couple use? The answers to these developmental<br />

questions are not well understood in the pornography literature to date. In<br />

likelihood, their answers differ from couple to couple, and the patterns that<br />

emerge likely influence future couple dynamics and outcomes.<br />

Limitations and Future Directions<br />

Despite addressing a number of limitations in existing pornography<br />

research, this study has a number of restrictions that should be considered<br />

in interpreting these results. First, the sample consists of only college<br />

students, who may not be representative of the larger population. Indeed,<br />

Cooper et al. (2000) identified college students as a group that is at risk for<br />

cybersex compulsion. However, it is not clear whether this is due to their<br />

age or status as students. Future work is needed using noncollege participants,<br />

to be confident in the generalizability of these findings. Second,<br />

despite the fact that the item assessing pornography use had a temporally<br />

based response code, future research would benefit from more detailed<br />

measurement of pornography use, assessing it separately across different


28 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

contexts (e.g., erotica, Internet pornography use, videos) to determine how<br />

different media of pornography might be differentially related to outcomes.<br />

Third, research would benefit from a more detailed examination of acceptance<br />

of pornography use. The item in the current study assessed general<br />

acceptance, but it is possible that acceptance would vary if participants<br />

responded to a temporally based response code (e.g., “Daily pornography<br />

use is an acceptable way to express one’s sexuality”). This is especially<br />

salient for women, who may perceive their own minimal use of pornography<br />

to be acceptable but who may perceive men’s much higher use as being<br />

less acceptable, particularly, use that is considered habitual. It will also be<br />

important for future research to examine acceptance in various life periods<br />

and among relationship statuses (e.g., dating, engaged, married) because<br />

acceptance of pornography may vary among single, committed, and married<br />

individuals. Finally, because of the cross-sectional nature of the current<br />

data, causal inferences could not be made. The age-related trends in the current<br />

study certainly justify the need for longitudinal data, following individuals<br />

from adolescence to emerging adulthood to later adult life. Despite<br />

these limitations, the current study provides a more complete understanding<br />

of pornography use among a normative (nonclinical) population of<br />

emerging adult college students and raises a number of important questions<br />

for future research, including the importance of examining the impact of<br />

pornography use and acceptance on current functioning during adolescence<br />

and emerging adulthood and on future couple and family formation.<br />

References<br />

Allen, M., D’Alessio, D., & Brezgel, K. (1995). A meta-analysis summarizing the effects<br />

of pornography II: Aggression after exposure. Human Communication Research, 22(2),<br />

258-283.<br />

Arnett, J. J. (2006). Emerging adulthood: Understanding the new way of coming of age. In<br />

J. J. Arnett & J. L. Tanner (Eds.), Emerging adults in America: Coming of age in the 21st<br />

century (pp. 3-20). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.<br />

Bauserman, R. (1996). Sexual aggression and pornography: A review of correlation research.<br />

Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 18(4), 405-427.<br />

Bergner, A. J., Bergner, R. M., & Hesson-McInnis, M. (2003). Romantic partner’s use of<br />

pornography: Its significance for women. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy, 29, 1-14.<br />

Bergner, R. M., & Bridges, A. J. (2002). The significance of heavy pornography involvement<br />

for romantic partners: Research and clinical implications. Journal of Sex and Marital<br />

Therapy, 28, 193-206.<br />

Boies, S. C. (2002). University students’ uses of and recreations to online sexual information<br />

and entertainment: Links to online and offline sexual behavior. Canadian Journal of<br />

Human Sexuality, 11, 77-89.


Carroll et al. / Pornography and Emerging Adulthood 29<br />

Brower, A. M. (2002). Are college students alcoholics? Journal of American College Health,<br />

50, 253-255.<br />

Buzzell, T. (2005a). Demographic characteristics of persons using pornography in three technological<br />

contexts. Sexuality & Culture, 9, 28-48.<br />

Buzzell, T. (2005b). The effects of sophistication, access, and monitoring on use of pornography<br />

in three technological contexts. Deviant Behavior, 26, 109-132.<br />

Cameron, K. A., Salazar, L. F., Bernhardt, J. M., Burgess-Whitman, N., Wingood, G. M., &<br />

DiClemente, R. J. (2005). Adolescents’ experience with sex on the Web: Results from<br />

online focus groups. Journal of Adolescence, 28, 535-540.<br />

Carroll, J. S., Badger, S., & Yang, C. (2006). The ability to negotiate or the ability to love?<br />

Evaluating the developmental domains of marital competence. Journal of Family Issues,<br />

27(7), 1001-1032.<br />

Carroll, J. S., Willoughby, B., Badger, S., Nelson, L. J., Barry, C. M., & Madsen, S. (2007).<br />

So close yet so far away: The impact of varying marital horizons on emerging adulthood.<br />

Journal of Adolescent Research, 22(3), 219-247.<br />

Cooper, A., Delmonico, D. L., & Burg, R. (2000). Cybersex users, abusers, and compulsives:<br />

New findings and implications. Sexual Addiction and Compulsivity, 7, 5-29.<br />

Cooper, A., Delmonico, D. L., Griffin-Shelly, E., & Mathy, R. M. (2004). Online sexual activity:<br />

An examination of potentially problematic behaviors. Sexual Addiction and Compulsivity,<br />

11, 129-143.<br />

Cooper, A., Galbreath, N., & Becker, M. (2004). Sex on the Internet: Furthering our understanding of<br />

men with on line sexual problems. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 18(3), 223-230.<br />

Cooper, A., Putnam, D. E., Planchon, L. A., & Boies, S. C. (1999). Online sexual compulsivity:<br />

Getting tangled in the net. Sexual Addiction and Compulsivity, 6(2), 79-104.<br />

DeMaris, A., & Rao, V. (1992). Premarital cohabitation and subsequent marital stability in the<br />

United States: A reassessment. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 54(1), 178-190.<br />

Dush, C. M., Cohan, C. L., & Amato, P. R. (2003). The relationship between cohabitation and marital<br />

quality and stability: Change across cohorts? Journal of Marriage and Family, 65(3), 539-549.<br />

Goodson, P., McCormick, D., & Evans, A. (2000). Sex on the Internet: College students’ emotional<br />

arousal when viewing sexually explicit materials on-line. Journal of Sex Education<br />

and Therapy, 25, 252-260.<br />

Goodson, P., McCormick, D., & Evans, A. (2001). Searching for sexually explicit material on<br />

the Internet: An exploratory study of college students’ behavior and attitudes. Archives of<br />

Sexual Behavior, 30, 101-117.<br />

Heaton, T. B. (2002). Factors contributing to increasing marital stability in the United States.<br />

Journal of Family Issues, 23, 392-409.<br />

Kahn, J. R., & London, K. A. (1991). Premarital sex and the risk of divorce. Journal of<br />

Marriage and the Family, 53, 845-855.<br />

Kline, G. H., Stanley, S. M., Markman, H. J., Olmos-Gallo, P. A., Peters, M. S., Whitton,<br />

S. W., et al. (2004). Timing is everything: Pre-engagement cohabitation and increased risk<br />

for poor marital outcomes. Journal of Family Psychology, 18(2), 311-318.<br />

Larson, J., & Holman, T. B. (1994). Premarital predictors of marital quality and stability.<br />

Family Relations: Interdisciplinary Journal of Applied Family Studies, 43(2), 228-237.<br />

Lefkowitz, E. S., & Gillen, M. M. (2006). “Sex is just a normal part of life”: Sexuality in emerging<br />

adulthood. In J. J. Arnett & J. L. Tanner (Eds.), Emerging adults in America: Coming of age in<br />

the 21st century (pp. 235-255). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.<br />

Mitchell, K. J., Becker-Blease, K. A., & Finkelhor, D. (2005). Inventory of problematic<br />

Internet experiences encountered in clinical practice. Professional Psychology: Research<br />

and Practice, 36(5), 498-509.


30 Journal of Adolescent Research<br />

Morrison, T. G., Harriman, R., Morrison, M. A., Bearden, A., & Ellis, S. R. (2004). Correlates<br />

of exposure to sexually explicit material among Canadian post-secondary students.<br />

Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality, 13, 143-156.<br />

Oddone-Paolucci, E., Genuis, M., & Violato, C. (2000). A meta-analysis of the published<br />

research on the effects of pornography. In C. Violato, E. Oddone-Paolucci, & M. Genuis<br />

(Eds.), The changing family and child development (pp. 48-59). Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.<br />

Peter, J., & Valkenburg, P. M. (2006). Adolescents’ exposure to sexually explicit material on<br />

the Internet. Communication Research, 33, 178-204.<br />

Philaretou, A. G., Mahfouz, A. Y., & Allen, K. R. (2005). Use of Internet pornography and<br />

men’s well-being. International Journal of Men’s Health, 4, 149-169.<br />

Quayle, E., & Taylor, M. (2003). Model of problematic Internet use in people with sexual<br />

interest in children. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 6(1), 93-106.<br />

Ropelato, J. (2007). Internet pornography statistics. Retrieved March 27, 2007, from<br />

http://internet-filter-review.toptenreviews.com/internet-pornography-statistics.html<br />

Schulenberg, J. E., & Zarrett, N. R. (2006). Mental health during emerging adulthood:<br />

Continuity and discontinuity in courses, causes, and functions. In J. J. Arnett & J. L.<br />

Tanner (Eds.), Emerging adults in America: Coming of age in the 21st century (pp. 135-<br />

172). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.<br />

Teachman, J. (2003). Premarital sex, premarital cohabitation and the risk of subsequent marital<br />

dissolution among women. Journal of Marriage and Family, 65(2), 444-455.<br />

Wang, R., Bianchi, S. M., & Raley, S. B. (2005). Teenagers’ Internet use and family rules: A<br />

research note. Journal of Marriage and Family, 67(5), 1249-1258.<br />

Ybarra, M. L., & Mitchell, K. J. (2005). Exposure to Internet pornography among children and<br />

adolescents: A national survey. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 8, 473-486.<br />

Young-Ho, K. (2001). Korean adolescents’ health risk behaviors and their relationships with<br />

the selected psychological constructs. Journal of Adolescence Health, 29(4), 298-306.<br />

Zillmann, D. (1994). Erotica and family values. In D. Zillmann, B. Jennings, & A. C. Huston<br />

(Eds.), Media, children, and the family: Social scientific psychodynamic, and clinical perspectives<br />

(pp. 199-213). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.<br />

Jason S. Carroll, PhD, is an associate professor in the School of Family Life at Brigham<br />

Young University.<br />

Laura M. Padilla-Walker, PhD, is an assistant professor in the School of Family Life at<br />

Brigham Young University.<br />

Larry J. Nelson, PhD, is an associate professor in the School of Family Life at Brigham<br />

Young University.<br />

Chad D. Olson, BS, is a graduate student in the Marriage and Family Therapy Program at<br />

Brigham Young University.<br />

Carolyn McNamara Barry, PhD, is an assistant professor of psychology at Loyola College<br />

in Maryland.<br />

Stephanie D. Madsen, PhD, is an associate professor of psychology at McDaniel College.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!