bid evaluation report procurement of hospital, ophthalmology and ...

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS
PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE
INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012
S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country of Origin Warranty Currency
of offer
Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks
54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Paktech Instrument
Co.
Dimeda 33.326.05 Germany Euro 0.00 8,029.00 16,058.00 2,018,651.18 1 Technically Acceptable
54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Mediurge MicroAire Surgical
Instruments
USA USD 0.00 15,230.00 30,460.00 2,936,344.00 2 Technically Acceptable
54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Fazal Din and Sons Aygun Turkey Euro 0.00 12,058.00 24,116.00 3,031,622.36 3 Technically Acceptable
54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Med-Elec. Corp De Soutter MPX 610/DPX676 UK GBP 0.00 11,076.50 22,153.00 3,425,518.39 4 Technically Acceptable
54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Sherazi Trading B Braun Acculan 3Ti Drill Germany Euro 0.00 21,035.00 42,070.00 5,288,619.70 5 Technically Acceptable
55 Drill ENT 2 Paktech Instrument
Co.
Dimeda 39.112.00 Germany Euro 0.00 5,563.00 11,126.00 1,398,649.46 1 Technically Acceptable
55 Drill ENT 2 Sherazi Trading B Braun MicroLAN 100 Germany Euro 0.00 7,000.00 14,000.00 1,759,940.00 2 Technically Acceptable
55 Drill ENT 2 Mediurge MicroAire Surgical
Instruments
USA USD 0.00 9,900.00 19,800.00 1,908,720.00 3 Technically Acceptable
55 Drill ENT 2 Endo Kare EG70339050 USD 0.00 11,828.00 23,656.00 2,280,438.40 4 Technically Acceptable
55 Drill ENT 2 Fazal Din and Sons Conmed-Linvatec USA USD 0.00 12,354.00 24,708.00 2,381,851.20 5 Technically Acceptable
55 Drill ENT 2 All Med Solution Karl Storz Karl Storz Drill ENT Germany Euro 0.00 10,696.00 21,392.00 2,689,188.32 6 Technically Acceptable
56 Arthroscope System 1 Nasa Medical Corp. Mahe Germany Euro 0.00 24,291.00 24,291.00 3,053,621.61 1 Rejected, camera not HD
56 Arthroscope System 1 Mediurge Ginni GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 39,786.00 39,786.00 5,001,498.06 2 Technically Acceptable
56 Arthroscope System 1 Biologic Medical
Systems
Beholzer GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 44,150.00 44,150.00 5,550,096.50 3 Technically Acceptable
56 Arthroscope System 1 Paktech Instrument
Co.
Dimeda 33.308.35 Germany Euro 0.00 55,049.00 55,049.00 6,920,209.79 4 Technically Acceptable
56 Arthroscope System 1 Noor International LUT GmbH Arthroscope System Germany Euro 0.00 59,000.00 59,000.00 7,416,890.00 5 Rejected, camera model quoted not
specified, Scopes not quoted
56 Arthroscope System 1 All Med Solution Karl Storz Arthroscope System Germany Euro 0.00 77,235.00 77,235.00 9,709,211.85 6 Technically Acceptable
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Nasa Medical Corp. Mahe Germany Euro 0.00 31,452.00 31,452.00 3,953,830.92 1 Technically Rejected.
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Mediurge Ginni GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 31,786.00 31,786.00 3,995,818.06 2 Technically Acceptable. Qty increased 2
Nos.
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Paktech Instrument
Co.
Dimeda Germany Euro 0.00 40,360.00 40,360.00 5,073,655.60 3 Technically Acceptable
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Sherazi Trading B Braun Laproscope Germany Euro 0.00 47,553.00 47,553.00 5,977,887.63 4 Technically Acceptable
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Biologic Medical Beholzer GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 63,714.00 63,714.00 8,009,486.94 5 Technically Acceptable - Instruments
Systems
quoted seperately for selection
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Noor International LUT GmbH Laproscope System Germany Euro 0.00 53,812.39 53,812.39 6,764,755.55 6 Rejected, camera not HD
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 All Med Solution Karl Storz Laproscopic Surgery
System
Germany Euro 0.00 56,307.00 56,307.00 7,078,352.97 7 Technically Acceptable
57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Endo Kare Olympus Japan PKR 10,760,950 10,760,950.00 10,760,950 10,760,950.00 10,760,950.00 8 Technically Acceptable
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Biologic Medical
Systems
Innomed Cardio 8 200B Hungry Euro 0.00 3,225.00 38,700.00 4,864,977.00 1 Technically Acceptable, crash cart local
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Hospicare Systems Primedic XD10 Germany Euro 0.00 4,500.00 54,000.00 6,788,340.00 2 Technically Acceptable
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Biotech Pakistan Mindray AVALO + BeneHeart D3 China USD 0.00 6,570.00 78,840.00 7,600,176.00 3 Technically Acceptable
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Standard Suppliers Medsis Life Point Pro Biphasic
Defibrillator
Turkey PKR 650,000 7,800,000.00 650,000 7,800,000.00 7,800,000.00 4 Rejected, no AED, No Pacemaker
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Sherazi Trading G.E. R2K USA USD 0.00 7,500.00 90,000.00 8,676,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Biotech Pakistan Caspa Solution and AVALO+LP20e
Physio-Cintrol
USA USD 0.00 7,750.00 93,000.00 8,965,200.00 6 Technically Acceptable
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Hospicare Systems Primedic XD110 Germany Euro 0.00 6,200.00 74,400.00 9,352,824.00 7 Technically Acceptable
58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Bios Osatu/Hersill Reanibex-700/R-8002 Spain Euro 0.00 6,735.00 80,820.00 10,159,882.20 8 Technically acceptable with minor
devoation in cart configuration.
Defibrilator Rejected as pacing and
memory not quoted
Page 11 of 25