bid evaluation report procurement of hospital, ophthalmology and ...

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS
PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE
INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012
S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country of Origin Warranty Currency
of offer
Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks
29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable
LGE
6 Strongman Medical Strongman 604-CT-05 Local PKR 32,500 195,000.00 32,500 195,000.00 195,000.00 1 Sample rejected
29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable 6 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel
Pakistan PKR 44,800 268,800.00 44,800 268,800.00 268,800.00 2 Sample not provided
LGE
Furniture
29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable
LGE
6 Winmed Win Industries WM410 Local PKR 55,000 330,000.00 55,000.00 330,000.00 330,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable
29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable 6 Paktech Instrument Hillbro HLB-WF-350 Pakistan PKR 88,667 532,000.02 88,667 532,000.02 532,000.02 4 Technically Acceptable
LGE
Co.
29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable
LGE
6 Standard Suppliers Medik Medical YA-MT7500IA China USD 110,000 660,000.00 1,025.00 6,150.00 592,860.00 5 Technically Acceptable
29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable
LGE
6 Mediurge CFS UNIT DOSE Italy Euro 0.00 1,115.00 6,690.00 840,999.90 6 Technically Acceptable
30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 Strongman Medical Strongman 616-RT-05 Local PKR 15,000 45,000.00 15,000.00 45,000.00 45,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable
30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 Standard Suppliers Caromed HS-02CHT25D China USD 65,000 195,000.00 575.00 1,725.00 166,290.00 2 Technically Acceptable
30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 Paktech Instrument
Co.
Hillbro Pakistan PKR 63,333 189,999.99 63,333 189,999.99 189,999.99 3 Technically Acceptable
30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 Mediurge CFS MINIDELTA Trolley Italy Euro 0.00 1,160.00 3,480.00 437,470.80 4 Technically Acceptable
31 Trolley Patient
Preparation/Dressing
4 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 28,500 114,000.00 28,500.00 114,000.00 114,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable
31 Trolley Patient
4 Paktech Instrument Hillbro HLB-WF-345 Pakistan PKR 70,933 283,733.32 70,933 283,733.32 283,733.32 2 Technically Acceptable
Preparation/Dressing
Co.
31 Trolley Patient
Preparation/Dressing
4 Standard Suppliers Caromed MT-750 China USD 110,000 440,000.00 1,025.00 4,100.00 395,240.00 3 Rejected, SS required
31 Trolley Patient
Preparation/Dressing
4 Mediurge CFS CFS 04 Italy Euro 0.00 990.00 3,960.00 497,811.60 4 Technically Acceptable
31 Trolley Patient
Preparation/Dressing
4 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 260.031/202.300/202.347 Germany Euro 0.00 1,179.00 4,716.00 592,848.36 5 Technically Acceptable
32 Trolley Plaster 4 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 28,500 114,000.00 28,500.00 114,000.00 114,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable
32 Trolley Plaster 4 Strongman Medical Strongman 530-OT-00 Local PKR 44,000 176,000.00 44,000 176,000.00 176,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable
32 Trolley Plaster 4 Mediurge CFS CFS 04 Italy Euro 0.00 990.00 3,960.00 497,811.60 3 Technically Acceptable
32 Trolley Plaster 4 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 260.031/202.300/202.347 Germany Euro 0.00 1,179.00 4,716.00 592,848.36 4 Technically Acceptable
32 Trolley Plaster 4 Paktech Instrument
Co.
Hillbro HLB-WF-345 Pakistan PKR 212,800 851,200.00 212,800 851,200.00 851,200.00 5 Technically Acceptable
33 Trolley Patient Transfer-Standard 20 Paktech Instrument Hillbro HLB-OTE-411 Pakistan PKR 81,067 1,621,333.40 81,067 1,621,333.40 1,621,333.40 1 Sample rejected
Accessories
Co.
33 Trolley Patient Transfer-Standard
Accessories
20 Strongman Medical Strongman 220-RH-02 Local PKR 87,000 1,740,000.00 87,000.00 1,740,000.00 1,740,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable
33 Trolley Patient Transfer-Standard
Accessories
33 Trolley Patient Transfer-Standard
Accessories
33 Trolley Patient Transfer-Standard
Accessories
33 Trolley Patient Transfer-Standard
Accessories
20 Strongman Medical Strongman 220-RH-01 Local PKR 102,000 2,040,000.00 102,000 2,040,000.00 2,040,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable
20 Standard Suppliers Medik Medical YA-J2B China USD 130,000 2,600,000.00 1,075.00 21,500.00 2,072,600.00 4 Technicaly Acceptable
20 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 285.100/285.050/207.147 Germany Euro 0.00 2,153.00 43,060.00 5,413,072.60 5 Technically Acceptable
20 Mediurge CFS L0503-211 Italy Euro 0.00 2,330.00 46,600.00 5,858,086.00 6 Technically Acceptable
Page 7 of 25