bid evaluation report procurement of hospital, ophthalmology and ...

More documents

Recommendations

Info

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012 S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country of Origin Warranty Currency of offer Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks 58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Radiant Medical Water Loo USRLA3369 M-Series USA USD 0.00 10,252.00 123,024.00 11,859,513.60 9 Technically Acceptable 58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Medequips Nihon Kohde/Armstrong Medical PAPE-1/TEC-5531K Japan/USA USD 0.00 11,080.00 132,960.00 12,817,344.00 10 Technically Acceptable 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 La Computa Vision Anjue Medical Equipment Co. AED 7000 China USD 0.00 1,400.00 16,800.00 1,619,520.00 1 Rejected. Chinese origin. No FDA approved. 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Biotech Pakistan Physio-Control LP-1000 USA USD 0.00 1,890.00 22,680.00 2,186,352.00 2 Technically Acceptable 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 La Computa Vision Yangzhou guo Tai 8000B, Defi Monitor, China USD 0.00 3,200.00 38,400.00 3,701,760.00 3 Rejected, not AED Co. Desktop 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Artema Medical Innomed Cardio 8 360B Hungry Euro 0.00 3,500.00 42,000.00 5,279,820.00 4 Technically Acceptable 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Sherazi Trading G.E. R-AED USA USD 0.00 5,100.00 61,200.00 5,899,680.00 5 Technically Acceptable 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Bios Osatu Reanibex-700 Spain Euro 0.00 4,290.00 51,480.00 6,471,550.80 6 Technically accpetable 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Radiant Medical Zoll AED Pro USA USD 0.00 6,190.00 74,280.00 7,160,592.00 7 Technically Acceptable 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Medequips Nihon Kohden TEC-5531K Japan USD 0.00 6,500.00 78,000.00 7,519,200.00 8 Technically Acceptable 59 Defibrillator - AED 12 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Heart Start XL+ Europe USD 0.00 7,292.00 87,504.00 8,435,385.60 9 Technically Acceptable 60 Diagnostic Set 40 La Computa Vision Medico Industries China PKR 9,744 389,760.00 9,744 389,760.00 389,760.00 1 Sample not provided. 60 Diagnostic Set 40 Biologic Medical F. Bosch Diagnostic Germany Euro 0.00 85.00 3,400.00 427,414.00 2 Rejected. F Bocsh does not make Systems diagnostic sets 60 Diagnostic Set 40 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 22,500 900,000.00 22,500 900,000.00 900,000.00 3 Rejected, local 60 Diagnostic Set 40 Latif Brothers Neitz BX-Alpha-134 Japan JPY 0.00 43,900.00 1,756,000.00 2,053,115.20 4 Technically Acceptable 60 Diagnostic Set 40 Mediurge Riester GmbH 3744-550 RI-SCOPE L Otoscope/Opthalposcope Germany Euro 0.00 465.00 18,600.00 2,338,206.00 5 Technically Acceptable 60 Diagnostic Set 40 Biotech Pakistan Welch Allyn USA USD 0.00 680.00 27,200.00 2,622,080.00 6 Technically Acceptable 60 Diagnostic Set 40 Ameer Din Instruments Heine K180 Germany PKR 68,750 2,750,000.00 68,750 2,750,000.00 2,750,000.00 7 Technically Acceptable 61 External Pace Maker Single Chamber 12 Med-Elec. Corp FIAB S.p.a. 4427 Italy Euro 0.00 900.00 10,800.00 1,357,668.00 1 Rejected, no details given 61 External Pace Maker Single 12 Radiant Medical APC Cardio EV-4543 UK/USA GBP 0.00 798.00 9,576.00 1,480,736.88 2 Technically Acceptable. However Single Chamber Vascular Chamber. Package price is higher then Limited/Oace Medical Medtronics. 61 External Pace Maker Single Chamber 12 ACP Systems Medtronics 5348 USA PKR 140,000 1,680,000.00 140,000.00 1,680,000.00 1,680,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable 61 External Pace Maker Single Chamber 62 External Pace Maker Dual Chamber 62 External Pace Maker Dual Chamber 62 External Pace Maker Dual Chamber 12 Mediland Pakistan Maquet Getinge Group T10 Germany Euro 0.00 1,899.00 22,788.00 2,864,679.48 4 Technically Acceptable 4 ACP Systems Medtronics 5388 USA PKR 325,000 1,300,000.00 325,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable 4 Mediland Pakistan Maquet Getinge Group 4 Radiant Medical APC Cardio Vascular Limited/Oace Medical T20 Germany Euro 0.00 2,800.00 11,200.00 1,407,952.00 2 Technically Acceptable Micro-Pace EP=4580 UK/USA GBP 0.00 3,085.00 12,340.00 1,908,134.20 3 Technically Acceptable Page 12 of 25
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012 S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country of Origin Warranty Currency of offer Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Noor International Doctor.Mach GmbH Mach 115 (Helogen) Germany Euro 0.00 550.00 4,400.00 553,124.00 1 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Biologic Medical Systems Acem StarLED1 Evo Italy Euro 0.00 595.00 4,760.00 598,379.60 2 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Biotech Pakistan Welch Allyn GS-600 44605** USA USD 0.00 970.00 7,760.00 748,064.00 3 Technically Acceptable (LED) 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 QFR Enterprise ORDISI L21-25R Spain Euro 0.00 1,400.00 11,200.00 1,407,952.00 4 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Hoora Pharma Maquet Blue 30 MOB France Euro 0.00 1,419.00 11,352.00 1,427,059.92 5 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 All Med Solution KLS Martin Germany Euro 0.00 2,160.00 17,280.00 2,172,268.80 6 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Technology Links Trilux AURINIO L50 SD Mobile Germany Euro 0.00 2,200.00 17,600.00 2,212,496.00 7 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Radiant Medical Trumpf Truelight-1000 Germany Euro 0.00 2,353.00 18,824.00 2,366,365.04 8 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Mediurge Derungs Licht AG D med Triango 30 F Switzerland Swiss Franc 0.00 3,995.00 31,960.00 3,331,190.80 9 Technically Acceptable 63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Ameer Din Instruments Heine HL5000 Germany PKR 67,000 536,000.00 67,000 536,000.00 536,000.00 10 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 QFR Enterprise ORDISI FLH2310 Spain Euro 0.00 125.00 2,500.00 314,275.00 1 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Biologic Medical Systems Burtom Medical LE35 USA USD 0.00 320.00 6,400.00 616,960.00 2 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Noor International Doctor.Mach GmbH Makrolux Germany Euro 0.00 300.00 6,000.00 754,260.00 3 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Biotech Pakistan Welch Allyn GS-300 44415** USA USD 0.00 435.00 8,700.00 838,680.00 4 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Ameer Din Instruments Heine HL1200 Germany PKR 43,000 860,000.00 43,000 860,000.00 860,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Mediurge Derungs Licht AG D med Oculux 12PLX Switzerland Swiss Franc 0.00 1,350.00 27,000.00 2,814,210.00 6 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Hoora Pharma Maquet Blue 30 W France Euro 0.00 1,976.00 39,520.00 4,968,059.20 7 Technically Acceptable 64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Technology Links Trilux AURINIO L50 SD Mobile Germany Euro 0.00 2,200.00 44,000.00 5,531,240.00 8 Technically Acceptable 65 Nebuliser Heavy Duty 2 Muslim Medical Services Philips Respironics 90543 China USD 0.00 31.50 63.00 6,073.20 1 Technically Acceptable 65 Nebuliser Heavy Duty 2 Muslim Medical Services Philips Respironics Pro China USD 0.00 47.00 94.00 9,061.60 2 Technically Acceptable 65 Nebuliser Heavy Duty 2 Mediurge HIRTZ & Co GmbH HICO-Ultrasonet 810 Germany Euro 0.00 899.00 1,798.00 226,026.58 3 Technically Acceptable 66 Nebuliser Ultrasonic 8 Mediurge HIRTZ & Co GmbH HICO-Ultrasonet 810 Germany Euro 0.00 1,225.00 9,800.00 1,231,958.00 1 Technically Acceptable 66 Nebuliser Ultrasonic 8 Hoora Pharma Maquet U 910 Germany Euro 0.00 1,562.00 12,496.00 1,570,872.16 2 Technically Acceptable 68 Pump Syring 100 QFR Enterprise Beijing XinFeng Medical Tecgnology FA312 China USD 0.00 300.00 30,000.00 2,892,000.00 1 Rejected. Chineses origin. 68 Pump Syring 100 Bios SINOMDT SN-50C6 China USD 0.00 345.00 34,500.00 3,325,800.00 2 Technicaly accpetable. However, not considered due to chinese origin. 68 Pump Syring 100 Biotech Pakistan Mindray SK500II China USD 0.00 500.00 50,000.00 4,820,000.00 3 Rejected. Chineses origin. 68 Pump Syring 100 Ittefaq Sons Advanced SP-100S USA USD 0.00 771.40 77,140.00 7,436,296.00 4 Technically Acceptable but no installed base 68 Pump Syring 100 B. Braun Sharing Expertise B.Braun Perfusor Compact S Germany USD 0.00 850.00 85,000.00 8,194,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable 68 Pump Syring 100 Noor International Top Coop. Top-5300 Japan USD 0.00 900.00 90,000.00 8,676,000.00 6 Technically Acceptable 68 Pump Syring 100 Hospicare Systems Medima S Poland Euro 0.00 725.00 72,500.00 9,113,975.00 7 Technically Acceptable 68 Pump Syring 100 Mediurge FRESENIUS Injectomat Aglia France Euro 0.00 765.00 76,500.00 9,616,815.00 8 Technically Acceptable 68 Pump Syring 100 Standard Suppliers Viltechmeda SEP 10S Europe Euro 110,000 11,000,000.00 790.00 79,000.00 9,931,090.00 9 Technically Acceptable Page 13 of 25
Page 1 and 2: COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL C
Page 11: COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL C
Page 25: COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL C

bid evaluation report procurement of hospital, ophthalmology and ...

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?