12.10.2013 Views

JOURNAL OF EURASIAN STUDIES

JOURNAL OF EURASIAN STUDIES

JOURNAL OF EURASIAN STUDIES

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

October-December 2009 <strong>JOURNAL</strong> <strong>OF</strong> <strong>EURASIAN</strong> <strong>STUDIES</strong> Volume I., Issue 4.<br />

_____________________________________________________________________________________<br />

virtues; side b. lists the points the jury can give (A-DU) to the kid in question. HT 86 has no real<br />

numbers, since:<br />

10 : TÍZ; TŰZ; TeSZ; T_Z/T_SZ : ten (=tíz) pronounced vith ű: pin, stitch, fire; with e: do, put, place, lay,<br />

make; T_Z/T_SZ<br />

20 : HÚSZ; -HOZ/-HEZ/-HÖZ, HOZZÁ; HOZ; HOSSZ/ú; H_Z/SZ : twenty; to, towards sy; bring, carry;<br />

length/long; H_Z/H_SZ<br />

Tablet HT 86 is about a big and strong, i.e. ox-like (A-KA-RU KU-{NI+ZO}-SU : ÖKöR-KiNéZéSű : with<br />

ox-like apperance) dog (komondor, the Hungarian sheep-dog!), which is given (A-DU) to guards and<br />

rescuers (MI-NU-TE 20 : MeNTő+HöZ : to/for rescuer).<br />

See in details at the end of this article.<br />

Fractions (and what used to be called fractions [D, DD])<br />

• Since ABB occurs (KH 86), is seems logical that A is greater than BB; if B is 1/3, A may be 5/6.<br />

There is no such fraction! A frac = PA!<br />

The ABB group of signs on KH 86 can be and should be read as FA-FA/FA-RO-RO. The conclusion that<br />

“A may be 5/6” is contradicted in summary by 1/6. From A = 1/6 follows ABB = 5/6 and retrograde! For A<br />

= 5/6 and B = 1/3 follows ABB = 1½ = 1J, why bother with ABB than?<br />

On HT 91, there is a list with A frac values: 5/6 (or 1/6?) of an olive or olive tree or a fig make no sense. The<br />

tablet is about trees/woods: FIC PA = FüGe-Fa = fig tree, OLE+MI PA = _L+M_ Fa = aLMa-Fa = apple tree,<br />

OLIV PA is unusual, because in oLiVa Fa “Va” is the Fa altered (oliva < olifa > olajfa > έλαιφα), so lit. it is<br />

oil tree tree.<br />

• B (1/3?). B occurs singly, once as a pair (KE Wc 2b), once as a pair after A (1/6; KH 86.2), once after<br />

E (1/4). Since EB occurs (KH 9.2), it would seem logical that B is less than 1/4 (E is 1/4; see below);<br />

but on KH 9.2, EB occurs after K (1/16?), and it is therefore tempting to read this set of fractions<br />

retrograde (BEK); if so, then a descending sequence could be maintained (1/3, 1/4, 1/16). B occurs<br />

singly and in pairs (ZA 8.2-3, 6, ZAa.2).<br />

“Since ABB occurs (KH 86), is seems logical that A is greater than BB”, to maintain this same “logic” you<br />

have to “read retrograde” the KEB sequence. This is a very arbitrary step for which is not given any<br />

reason.<br />

Let us take a closer look into this KH 86 tablet: this is a good quality picture, which doesn’t show any<br />

fracture in the second vertical line of “ABB” seen on the facsimile drawing.<br />

The next tablet in the series, KH 87 would disprove the whole “fraction” preposition, if transliterated<br />

properly. For the BOSm, which is actually a ligature, [PA+U = BŰ (= big, rich) as BIson] one horizontal<br />

line is missing, therefore it should read “AB”, but there is a big problem with that: “JAB 1” = “1/2 1/6 1/3<br />

1” is a rather strange fraction! Isn’t it?<br />

To make things worst, there is NO KEB sequence on KH 9.2! The sequence is K frac FIC E frac B frac , where<br />

K frac follows and modifies VIR from the first line. Hard to imagine what sequence 1/16 of a man and 7/12<br />

of a fig would make!<br />

_____________________________________________________________________________________<br />

© Copyright Mikes International 2001-2009 128

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!