You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>The</strong> 2010 four year TSR for the Top 10 mining<br />
companies (excluding Coal India which listed in<br />
2010) provides insight into challenging performance<br />
stories. While a four-year period is arguably a short<br />
time frame for the industry, we have seen the highs<br />
and lows of a commodity cycle, albeit a short one,<br />
during this period. <strong>The</strong> results show the importance<br />
of holding Tier one assets and being the leader in<br />
chosen markets.<br />
Top 10 TSR 2007–2010<br />
230%<br />
180%<br />
130%<br />
80%<br />
30%<br />
-20%<br />
BHP<br />
Billiton<br />
Vale<br />
Rio<br />
Tinto<br />
China<br />
Shenhua<br />
Energy<br />
Anglo<br />
American<br />
Freeport-<br />
McMoran<br />
Barrick<br />
Gold<br />
Note: Coal India figures are excluded due to lack of comparative data as it<br />
<strong>has</strong> only listed in 2010.<br />
Source: Bloomberg and PwC analysis.<br />
Xstrata<br />
PotashCorp<br />
Ag 47<br />
107.868<br />
<strong>The</strong> state of Silver<br />
Silver made headlines in<br />
2010 and Silver Wheaton<br />
had the highest one year<br />
TSR of the Top 40. Investor<br />
interest in a minor metal,<br />
commonly considered a byproduct<br />
by most miners was<br />
enormous. This reinforces<br />
the story that commodity<br />
markets have become more<br />
dynamic in the last year.<br />
<strong>The</strong> formation of silver<br />
ETFs five years ago <strong>has</strong><br />
clearly driven new interest<br />
in the market. From May<br />
2006 to early <strong>2011</strong>, the<br />
largest of these (iShares<br />
Silver Trust) moved from<br />
holding just over 600<br />
tonnes to over 11,000<br />
tonnes of silver.<br />
Much of the rise in the<br />
price of silver <strong>has</strong> been on<br />
the back of speculation,<br />
although there are some<br />
growing commercial uses,<br />
such as the importance<br />
of silver in solar cells. It is<br />
clear, however, that ETF’s<br />
are playing an increasing<br />
role in the volatile silver<br />
market—indeed at the time<br />
of writing this volatility<br />
<strong>has</strong> caused significant<br />
price fluctuations.<br />
Understanding how<br />
financial investors will act<br />
is increasingly as important<br />
as understanding demand<br />
and supply characteristics<br />
in the short-term.<br />
<strong>Mine</strong>–<strong>The</strong> <strong>game</strong> <strong>has</strong> <strong>changed</strong> 7