22.02.2014 Views

Mine 2011: The game has changed

Mine 2011: The game has changed

Mine 2011: The game has changed

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>The</strong> 2010 four year TSR for the Top 10 mining<br />

companies (excluding Coal India which listed in<br />

2010) provides insight into challenging performance<br />

stories. While a four-year period is arguably a short<br />

time frame for the industry, we have seen the highs<br />

and lows of a commodity cycle, albeit a short one,<br />

during this period. <strong>The</strong> results show the importance<br />

of holding Tier one assets and being the leader in<br />

chosen markets.<br />

Top 10 TSR 2007–2010<br />

230%<br />

180%<br />

130%<br />

80%<br />

30%<br />

-20%<br />

BHP<br />

Billiton<br />

Vale<br />

Rio<br />

Tinto<br />

China<br />

Shenhua<br />

Energy<br />

Anglo<br />

American<br />

Freeport-<br />

McMoran<br />

Barrick<br />

Gold<br />

Note: Coal India figures are excluded due to lack of comparative data as it<br />

<strong>has</strong> only listed in 2010.<br />

Source: Bloomberg and PwC analysis.<br />

Xstrata<br />

PotashCorp<br />

Ag 47<br />

107.868<br />

<strong>The</strong> state of Silver<br />

Silver made headlines in<br />

2010 and Silver Wheaton<br />

had the highest one year<br />

TSR of the Top 40. Investor<br />

interest in a minor metal,<br />

commonly considered a byproduct<br />

by most miners was<br />

enormous. This reinforces<br />

the story that commodity<br />

markets have become more<br />

dynamic in the last year.<br />

<strong>The</strong> formation of silver<br />

ETFs five years ago <strong>has</strong><br />

clearly driven new interest<br />

in the market. From May<br />

2006 to early <strong>2011</strong>, the<br />

largest of these (iShares<br />

Silver Trust) moved from<br />

holding just over 600<br />

tonnes to over 11,000<br />

tonnes of silver.<br />

Much of the rise in the<br />

price of silver <strong>has</strong> been on<br />

the back of speculation,<br />

although there are some<br />

growing commercial uses,<br />

such as the importance<br />

of silver in solar cells. It is<br />

clear, however, that ETF’s<br />

are playing an increasing<br />

role in the volatile silver<br />

market—indeed at the time<br />

of writing this volatility<br />

<strong>has</strong> caused significant<br />

price fluctuations.<br />

Understanding how<br />

financial investors will act<br />

is increasingly as important<br />

as understanding demand<br />

and supply characteristics<br />

in the short-term.<br />

<strong>Mine</strong>–<strong>The</strong> <strong>game</strong> <strong>has</strong> <strong>changed</strong> 7

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!