September 2011 - Jewish Federation of New Mexico
September 2011 - Jewish Federation of New Mexico
September 2011 - Jewish Federation of New Mexico
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>September</strong> <strong>2011</strong> A Service <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Federation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>New</strong> <strong>Mexico</strong> The <strong>New</strong> <strong>Mexico</strong> <strong>Jewish</strong> Link 5<br />
The Summer <strong>of</strong> Our DisconTent<br />
By Boaz Fletcher<br />
I remember a time, not too long<br />
ago, when a man could pitch his<br />
tent on a main avenue and not attract<br />
hundreds <strong>of</strong> copycats and the<br />
TV cameras that inevitably follow. –<br />
Facebook posting, mid-August<br />
Just How Expensive is it to Live in Israel?<br />
As the Arab Spring waxed into<br />
the Arab Summer with a sleepy<br />
eye on fall, with former presidents<br />
strapped into moveable beds and<br />
caged for their own show-trials, and<br />
with the Syrian army playing war<br />
games with its own citizens, our<br />
small corner <strong>of</strong> the Eastern Mediterranean<br />
seemed a little too quiet. It<br />
had been a few months since anyone<br />
tried to breach a border, a few<br />
Lebanese soldiers were confused<br />
by the meaning <strong>of</strong> cease-fire, and<br />
here and there were rumblings and<br />
mumblings about <strong>September</strong>.<br />
In a panic, someone realized<br />
that cottage cheese had suddenly<br />
become outrageously expensive<br />
and started a whole protest movement<br />
dedicated to not buying cottage<br />
cheese. Labaneh and plain yoghurt<br />
were unaffected.<br />
This was soon followed by a<br />
sympathetic protest movement to<br />
not buy gasoline – also horrifically<br />
expensive. This was a hugely successful<br />
protest for the day it lasted,<br />
the streets littered with stalled cars<br />
whose owners were, in any event,<br />
not on the way to the supermarket<br />
due to solidarity around the high<br />
price <strong>of</strong> chunky, somewhat liquid,<br />
cheese. Many people rediscovered<br />
their feet, which perhaps they<br />
hadn’t seen in a while due to the<br />
unfathomable quantities <strong>of</strong> cottage<br />
cheese they had previously been<br />
consuming.<br />
The combination <strong>of</strong> cheese and<br />
gasoline fomented discontent. (Any<br />
other combination <strong>of</strong> gasoline and<br />
cheese, well, that’s just gross.) The<br />
middle class was wondering what<br />
else they could protest, since the<br />
middle class, by virtue <strong>of</strong> its being<br />
in the middle, has to pay for everyone<br />
else.<br />
And then on a hot, muggy, Tel<br />
Aviv night, someone put up a tent.<br />
They were tired <strong>of</strong> paying more<br />
than a third <strong>of</strong> their net income in<br />
order to rent a small apartment that<br />
had no air conditioning and minimal<br />
utilities and realized that they<br />
could, for no fee at all, set up a<br />
TENT with no air conditioning and<br />
minimal utilities. And so they did.<br />
Right in the middle <strong>of</strong> the pedestrian<br />
path which cleaves one <strong>of</strong> Tel<br />
Aviv’s main thoroughfares and historic<br />
streets, home <strong>of</strong> many <strong>of</strong> the<br />
country’s elite financial institutions:<br />
Rothschild Boulevard.<br />
And they saw it was Good, and<br />
by the Third Day, others saw it was<br />
Good as well. So they brought tents.<br />
Word got around and more people<br />
brought tents. By this point, it was<br />
starting to get confusing, so people<br />
brought couches. They also started<br />
writing their names on their tents<br />
since all tents pretty much look<br />
alike, although their spouses do<br />
not, and this was a protest movement,<br />
not a rock festival. Hmm, except<br />
that it was, as you will soon<br />
see.<br />
It is written somewhere that it<br />
isn’t a protest if no one’s singing a<br />
protest song. Now, with the proper<br />
conditions in place – a captive audience,<br />
padded furnishings, and sultry<br />
evenings – the rock stars could<br />
come out. Israeli rock stars, who<br />
make a decent living and probably<br />
don’t live in tents, are mostly real<br />
people just like you and me. Some,<br />
however, tend to wander the streets<br />
with guitars slung over their backs,<br />
just in case they come upon groups<br />
<strong>of</strong> people who want to exercise their<br />
fundamental right to sing-alongs.<br />
Word got out that music was<br />
being sung for free which attracted<br />
more tent-people. Word that there<br />
were more tent-people attracted<br />
more troubadours. Word reached<br />
people in other cities that they<br />
could stop ripping music <strong>of</strong>f the internet<br />
and still get it for free if they<br />
pitched a tent in a park, and it was<br />
so.<br />
The Summer <strong>of</strong> DisconTent<br />
movement was underway.<br />
Among the bites <strong>of</strong> sushi, smoking<br />
<strong>of</strong> water pipes, and special song<br />
dedications by the rockers – who at<br />
this point were forced to perform<br />
on stages and not in loungers –<br />
came suggestions <strong>of</strong> a Cause. And<br />
they called it Social Justice.<br />
And with the words Social Justice,<br />
out came the politicians.<br />
There are many things that ail<br />
the State <strong>of</strong> Israel, and especially<br />
its middle class. It is disproportionately<br />
expensive to live here, relative<br />
to income and other developed<br />
economies. The middle class carries<br />
the brunt <strong>of</strong> reserve duty, pays<br />
the majority <strong>of</strong> both direct and indirect<br />
taxes (about 50% <strong>of</strong> the cost <strong>of</strong><br />
gasoline goes to the government),<br />
pay more than a third <strong>of</strong> their net<br />
income in rent or mortgage payments,<br />
make ends meet (mostly)<br />
but have no savings, although pay<br />
less for a cup <strong>of</strong> good c<strong>of</strong>fee than<br />
you pay for those dregs you get at<br />
Starbucks.<br />
When the politicians <strong>of</strong> all<br />
stripes and flavors come out and<br />
declare their unanimous support<br />
for the Cause, at least some <strong>of</strong> them<br />
must be wrong, and according to<br />
all <strong>of</strong> them, it’s the fault <strong>of</strong> the other<br />
ones. When nefarious NGOs throw<br />
in their financial support and quietly<br />
whisper their agenda in the ears<br />
<strong>of</strong> the organizers, the Cause turns<br />
into a circus, or more aptly, street<br />
theatre.<br />
An estimated 350,000 people<br />
hit the streets all over the country<br />
on a Saturday night to wave banners,<br />
chant slogans, listen to really<br />
expensive rock musicians (not the<br />
wandering-minstrel kind) play on<br />
big stages, and wave at the TV cameras.<br />
Maybe post a picture or two to<br />
their Facebook pr<strong>of</strong>ile.<br />
The Summer <strong>of</strong> DisconTent will<br />
play itself out. Come <strong>September</strong><br />
there will be other small things to<br />
worry about and perhaps bigger<br />
things as well. The government will<br />
move some money around to appease<br />
certain groups, but it won’t<br />
fall.<br />
Most people will go home, having<br />
camped out for free during the<br />
summer. A few will be left. In some<br />
months one <strong>of</strong> the television news<br />
channels will do a follow up on<br />
someone who had a few moments<br />
<strong>of</strong> public glory. But Rothschild Boulevard<br />
is not Tahrir Square, there is<br />
no revolution here, just discontent.<br />
By Jessica Steinberg<br />
JERUSALEM (JTA) -- What began<br />
in Israel in June as a Facebook-driven<br />
rebellion against the rising cost <strong>of</strong><br />
cottage cheese, then morphed in July<br />
into tent encampments protesting<br />
soaring real estate costs, has since<br />
turned into a full-scale Israeli social<br />
movement against the high cost <strong>of</strong><br />
living in the <strong>Jewish</strong> state.<br />
From Tel Aviv’s tent-filled Rothschild<br />
Boulevard to marches in<br />
Beersheva, hundreds <strong>of</strong> thousands<br />
<strong>of</strong> Israelis have participated in one<br />
protest or another. The movement’s<br />
targets have expanded from housing<br />
and cheese prices to everything from<br />
the costs <strong>of</strong> child care and gas -- not<br />
to mention salaries.<br />
All this begs the question: Just<br />
how expensive is it to live in Israel?<br />
A close examination <strong>of</strong> some key<br />
metrics show that compared to the<br />
United States and Europe, Israeli<br />
costs <strong>of</strong> living are a mixed bag. Salaries<br />
are lower, but so are health care<br />
costs. Consumer goods and services<br />
costs are nearly double those in the<br />
United States, and owning a car can<br />
run about six times as much relative<br />
to one’s salary.<br />
So how do Israelis make it? Israeli<br />
retailers and banks <strong>of</strong>fer easy credit<br />
on everything from big-ticket items<br />
like summer vacations to everyday<br />
purchases like groceries; all can<br />
be paid in monthly installments.<br />
The result is that many Israelis are<br />
perennially in debt and are increasingly<br />
frustrated by their inability to<br />
cover costs with their monthly paychecks.<br />
Here’s a closer look at some <strong>of</strong><br />
the costs <strong>of</strong> living in Israel.<br />
Housing<br />
The most expensive and desirable<br />
places to live in Israel are in the<br />
center <strong>of</strong> the country, where the vast<br />
majority <strong>of</strong> the population resides<br />
and works.<br />
According to figures from the<br />
real estate company RE/MAX Israel,<br />
apartment prices in central Tel Aviv<br />
run $5,714 to $7,142 per square<br />
meter. In Jerusalem, the peripheral<br />
neighborhoods <strong>of</strong> East Talpiot and<br />
Kiryat Hayovel <strong>of</strong>fer housing from<br />
$4,285 to $5,714 per square meter,<br />
while prices in the tonier neighborhoods<br />
<strong>of</strong> Baka, the German Colony<br />
and Rechavia range from $7,000 to<br />
$8,571 per square meter.<br />
That means that in Baka or the<br />
German Colony, a typical two-bedroom<br />
apartment starts at $428,571,<br />
according to Alyssa Friedland, a<br />
broker for RE/MAX. In the peripheral<br />
neighborhoods, some <strong>of</strong> which<br />
are built on territory captured from<br />
Jordan in the 1967 Six-Day War,<br />
a two-bedroom apartment runs for<br />
about $343,000. According to RE/<br />
MAX figures, two-bedroom apartments<br />
in Beersheva, Haifa, Hadera<br />
and Afula cost between $143,000<br />
and $286,000.<br />
Mortgage rates are about 4.5<br />
percent, according to Friedland,<br />
but the required down payment is<br />
usually about 40 percent.<br />
“Young couples are getting the<br />
money from their parents because<br />
they don’t typically have savings like<br />
that,” she said.<br />
As the economist Daniel Doron<br />
noted recently in The Wall Street<br />
Journal, “A small apartment can cost<br />
the average Israeli worker 12 years<br />
in annual salary.”<br />
See ISRAEL. . Page 6<br />
Manzano Day School<br />
Manzano Day School admits students without regard to religion, race, color, creed, gender,<br />
gender identification, disability, age, sexual orientation or ethnic background.<br />
Joy in Learning ® Since 1938<br />
Accepting Applications for the<br />
2012-2013 school year<br />
Independent, non-prot<br />
pre-kindergarten through grade ve<br />
Bus service available from the Westside<br />
& NE Heights<br />
1801 Central Avenue NW | 505-243-6659<br />
www.manzanodayschool.org<br />
L’Shanah tovah<br />
tekatev v’ techatem<br />
Pearl F. Gross<br />
Shanah Tovah to all from<br />
the Gottlieb family.<br />
Let’s make it a great year.<br />
Wishing a healthy & happy<br />
<strong>New</strong> Year to our <strong>New</strong> <strong>Mexico</strong><br />
friends and family<br />
~~ L’Shana Tova<br />
Jill Bulmash & Linda Friedman<br />
La Shana Tova<br />
Sabra Minkus & Family<br />
Shana Tovah to<br />
our new community!<br />
Rabbi Harry Rosenfeld<br />
& Michele Hope