HIV/AIDS Prevention & Reproductive Health Project
HIV/AIDS Prevention & Reproductive Health Project
HIV/AIDS Prevention & Reproductive Health Project
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong><br />
<strong>Prevention</strong> &<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
LEARNING & CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
NEPAL RED CROSS SOCIETY<br />
Swiss Centre for<br />
International <strong>Health</strong>
Submitted to<br />
Nepal Red Cross Society &<br />
Swiss Agency for Development and<br />
Cooperation (SDC)<br />
Submitted by<br />
Ricarda Merkle<br />
Prakash Rimal<br />
With contributions from<br />
Bipul Neupane, Nepal Red Cross Society<br />
Bhojraj Thokar, Nepal Red Cross Society<br />
February 2007
Contents<br />
List of Abbreviations<br />
III Executive Summary<br />
IV Study Methodology<br />
1 Introduction<br />
4 Life Skills Development of<br />
Youth<br />
9 Teaching Sexual and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> at<br />
Schools<br />
13 Involvement of Parents and<br />
the Community<br />
19 Gender Equity and Equality<br />
23 Coordination at District<br />
Level<br />
26 Summary of<br />
Recommendations<br />
Annex<br />
28 I - Newspaper extracts<br />
30 II - Question Guide<br />
36 III - <strong>Project</strong> Documents and<br />
Consulted Literature<br />
ART<br />
BCC<br />
CBOs<br />
CCM<br />
DACC<br />
DDC<br />
FGD<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong><br />
HQ<br />
IDUs<br />
IEC<br />
IGA<br />
I/NGOs<br />
J/YRCC<br />
MoH<br />
NCASC<br />
NGOs<br />
NRCS<br />
PE<br />
PLWHA<br />
RH<br />
SDC<br />
SSI<br />
STI<br />
SRH<br />
UN<strong>AIDS</strong><br />
UNDP<br />
VDC<br />
VCT<br />
Anti Retroviral Therapy<br />
Behaviour Change and Communication<br />
Community Based Organizations<br />
Country Co-ordination Mechanism<br />
District <strong>AIDS</strong> Co-ordination Committee<br />
District Development Committee<br />
Focus Group Discussions<br />
Human Immunodeficiency Virus/Acquired<br />
Immune Deficiency Syndrome<br />
Headquarters<br />
Injecting Drug Users<br />
Information, Education and Communication<br />
Income Generating Activities<br />
International/Non-Governmental<br />
Organizations<br />
Junior/Youth Red Cross Circle<br />
Ministry of <strong>Health</strong><br />
National Centre for <strong>AIDS</strong> and STD Control<br />
Non-Governmental Organizations<br />
Nepal Red Cross Society<br />
Peer Educator<br />
People Living with <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong><br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong><br />
Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation<br />
Semi-structured Interviews<br />
Sexually Transmitted Infection<br />
Sexual and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong><br />
Joint United Nations Program on <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong><br />
United Nations Development Programme<br />
Village Development Committee<br />
Voluntary Counselling and Testing<br />
The contents of this publication<br />
may be reproduced in whole or<br />
in part on condition that due<br />
acknowledgement is given to the<br />
publication.
Executive Summary<br />
The Nepal Red Cross Society in partnership<br />
with the Swiss Agency for Development and<br />
Cooperation (SDC) has been implementing<br />
an <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong> in six districts - Dolakha,<br />
Ramechhap, Sindhuli, Bhaktapur, Baglung<br />
and Parbat - since 2000. The project will<br />
continue until February 2007.<br />
Focusing first on working with youth and<br />
teachers at secondary schools, the<br />
programme has increasingly reached out to<br />
the wider community, mainly through<br />
facilitation of women groups and public IEC<br />
(Information, Education and Communication)<br />
events. Peer Educators (PEs), who are<br />
members of the Junior/Youth Red Cross<br />
Circles (J/YRCC), school teachers and<br />
women groups act as facilitators and change<br />
agents. Interpersonal communication<br />
channels, such as teaching in class rooms,<br />
group discussions, door-to-door<br />
interventions, folk song competitions and<br />
street drama are the main information<br />
vehicles. They are supported by IEC materials<br />
including a quarterly bulletin, Yuva Chautari, a<br />
Youth's Forum, posters and show books for<br />
(partly illiterate) women in the community.<br />
The project has contributed to open up<br />
attitudes and discussion among youth,<br />
teachers and the community on issues<br />
related to <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong>. Moreover, capacities of teachers and<br />
peer educators to provide lessons and<br />
interactive IEC interventions on Sexual and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> have increased. <strong>Project</strong><br />
interventions have served to further<br />
strengthen the respective NRCS institutions<br />
and facilitated implementation of <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> prevention initiatives; in particular<br />
through NRCS youth circles, teacher<br />
volunteers and district offices.<br />
In all of the six districts the project was the<br />
first comprehensive initiative addressing <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> for<br />
youth at schools. The project filled a gap and<br />
contributed to putting the "on paper only"<br />
curriculum of Sexual and <strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong> into practice. Those involved<br />
unanimously welcomed the initiative.<br />
Schools that could not be covered felt that<br />
they were missing out. All activities were<br />
implemented through existing institutions<br />
with the aim of enhancing sustainability. All<br />
districts intend to continue the project<br />
activities and some districts have already<br />
started to do so with their own resources.<br />
Nevertheless, the level of activity is likely to<br />
slow down. Important inputs of the project<br />
needed to sustain the momentum of<br />
activities include trainings and provision of<br />
IEC materials.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
III
Study Methodology<br />
This capitalization document is primarily<br />
based on a qualitative study drawing on a<br />
number of participatory and exploratory<br />
techniques. As far as possible quantitative<br />
data was also investigated within the<br />
interviews to complement the analysis and<br />
expand the conclusion. The documenting<br />
process itself served for exchange and<br />
mutual learning for both the study teams and<br />
stakeholders at the district and central level.<br />
<strong>Project</strong> documentation and related literature<br />
was reviewed prior to the fieldwork and used<br />
as reference and for triangulation throughout<br />
the capitalization process. During the field<br />
visits additional documents and IEC<br />
materials relating to the project were<br />
gathered, reviewed and incorporated into the<br />
study.<br />
Prior to the fieldwork component, the team<br />
developed a question guide based on project<br />
documentation and the Terms of References.<br />
It included sections that were adapted for<br />
application to different stakeholder groups<br />
(Annex II). The question guide served the<br />
two teams to adopt a common methodology<br />
of semi-structured interviews (SSI) and<br />
open-ended stakeholder discussions. It was<br />
pre-tested in the first district that was jointly<br />
visited by the study team and then finalized.<br />
SSIs formed a major part of the field<br />
methodology, and were based on issues<br />
arising from pre-field meetings and<br />
documentation provided by the NRCS<br />
Headquarters (HQ). SSIs were used in key<br />
informant interviews and focus group<br />
discussions. Interactive interviews were<br />
conducted with NRCS district chapter,<br />
DACCs, DDC members, teachers,<br />
headmasters, peer educators and women<br />
group members in the six districts. All six<br />
SDC supported programme districts were<br />
visited for qualitative data collection. In each<br />
project district FGDs and SSI were held with<br />
2 groups of PEs, 2 women groups, 2<br />
teachers and the headmaster, NRCS district<br />
chapters including DACCs and DDC<br />
members.<br />
IV<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Introduction<br />
since the detection of the first the general population is high because of<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> case in Nepal in 1988, risks related to commercial sex, high<br />
Nepal has progressed from a rates of sexually transmitted diseases,<br />
"low-prevalence" country to low levels of condom use, pockets of<br />
one with a "concentrated<br />
intravenous drug users and low literacy<br />
epidemic" with relatively high prevalence rate. In 2005, a total of 959 <strong>AIDS</strong> cases<br />
in certain sub-groups of the population. and 5,828 cases of <strong>HIV</strong> infection were<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> prevalence is estimated at 17.3% reported to the Ministry of <strong>Health</strong>.<br />
among female sex workers, at 68%<br />
among injecting drug users and ranges Young people in Nepal constitute more<br />
from 4-10% among labor migrants to than one third of the population. Young<br />
India. The risk of an epidemic bridging to people are considered a priority group in<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
1
the National <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> Strategy.<br />
Young people in Nepal are becoming<br />
more vulnerable to <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong><br />
because of an increase in pre-marital<br />
sexual intercourse. Moreover, young<br />
people also tend to make up a large<br />
proportion of particular high-risk subgroups<br />
such as migrants, female sex<br />
workers, injecting drug users, and men<br />
who have sex with men. Vulnerability is<br />
further fuelled by gaps in access to<br />
Sexual and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> (SRH)<br />
knowledge, and skills and services. For<br />
young people to reduce their risk and<br />
vulnerability to <strong>HIV</strong>, they need a set of<br />
protective skills and to have access to<br />
appropriate services and products. They<br />
must also perceive their environments to<br />
be supportive of changing or maintaining<br />
safe behaviours. On their journey from<br />
childhood to adulthood youth are eager<br />
and perceptive to learn about SRH and<br />
thus bear high potential to apply<br />
protective skills and adapt their<br />
behaviour. Society-wide change is<br />
nevertheless a slow process. Changes<br />
achieved through Behaviour Change and<br />
Communication (BCC) will not be seen<br />
overnight. This is especially true when it<br />
comes to addressing <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong><br />
which requires national and community<br />
discussions on sex and sexuality, risk, risk<br />
settings and risk behaviours and forces<br />
them to confront cultural ideals and the<br />
practices that clash with them.<br />
The NRCS started to address <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> prevention for Youth in 1994 as one<br />
of the first main actors in this field in<br />
Nepal. The <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong>, funded<br />
through SDC, has adopted<br />
comprehensive approaches to address<br />
SRH education at schools. Today, NRCS<br />
promotes SRH at schools in 19 districts in<br />
Nepal, with support from SDC,<br />
Norwegian Red Cross (Norcross) and the<br />
UNDP. Altogether, the NRCS covers 54<br />
districts through <strong>HIV</strong> prevention<br />
activities. The programmes are<br />
implemented through the educational<br />
institutions which are closely linked with<br />
the NRCS network and reach down to the<br />
community level. The SRH youth<br />
programmes of the NRCS are embedded<br />
in the community development work of<br />
the NRCS; they are multi-sectoral in<br />
nature and contribute to a coordinated<br />
response through involvement of<br />
community members, leaders and other<br />
organizations. The programmes<br />
essentially built on the participation of<br />
youth, involvement of teachers and<br />
outreach to the community. Measures to<br />
address gender balance and social equity<br />
are an integral part of all programmes.<br />
2<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
The NRCS addresses <strong>HIV</strong> prevention and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> through the<br />
adapted use of BCC as a multi-level tool<br />
for introducing and sustaining riskreducing<br />
behaviour change. This involves<br />
the promotion and reinforcement of<br />
tailored messages through a variety of<br />
communication channels. In Nepal as a<br />
first step towards behaviour change the<br />
general level of awareness on issues<br />
related to <strong>HIV</strong> has considerably<br />
increased. What is needed further is to<br />
reinforce the message and address<br />
beliefs and practices that lead to<br />
behaviour change. This includes<br />
stimulating discussion around cultural<br />
beliefs and practices; facilitating the life<br />
skills needed to reduce vulnerability and<br />
improving access to youth friendly<br />
services. It further implies reaching out<br />
to population groups with less access to<br />
information and reinforcing an<br />
information cascade among teachers,<br />
peer educators, their parents and peers<br />
followed by the community at large.<br />
This capitalization study presents the<br />
activities, outcomes and lessons learnt of<br />
the SDC funded programme on <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong>, implemented from 2000 until<br />
2007 in the districts of Dolakha,<br />
Ramechhap, Sindhuli, Bhaktapur, Baglung<br />
and Parbat. The study highlights the main<br />
common features of different initiatives in<br />
the six districts, presenting them as the<br />
main pillars of the NRCS approach to SRH<br />
with a focus on youth at schools.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
3
Life skills<br />
development<br />
of Youth<br />
<strong>Project</strong> activities<br />
Almost all of the Peer Educators (PE) that are<br />
trained in the frame of this project are part of<br />
Junior/Youth Red Cross Circles (J/YRCC),<br />
also called the "youth wing" of the NRCS.<br />
The J/YRCCs are widespread groups of<br />
youth volunteers; almost every school in<br />
Nepal is hosting one or more circles.<br />
Throughout Nepal there are over 4,020<br />
school youth circles with more than<br />
800,000 members. Each circle is tended by<br />
a teacher - who is also a NRCS volunteer - as<br />
a first reference and supporting contact. The<br />
circles develop their own yearly work plans,<br />
4<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
organize monthly meetings and submit<br />
quarterly short activity reports to the district<br />
chapters of the NRCS. Activities range from<br />
emergency response and environmental<br />
work to sanitation and social protection.<br />
Moreover, circles constitute an important<br />
communication link between communities,<br />
schools and district chapters of the NRCS.<br />
Often they are the first to inform the district<br />
chapters or respond to the upcoming social<br />
and emergency needs in the community.<br />
Between 2-4 students are selected for a three<br />
day core PE training. Teachers and core PEs<br />
then jointly organize a two-day PE training at<br />
their school for 20 selected students. Topics<br />
of the training include <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong><br />
and <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> issues related to<br />
adolescence and life skills. PEs are expected<br />
to educate their peers in and out of school.<br />
Their role is to act as change agents,<br />
disseminating messages to their peers and<br />
the community. Usually some of the PEs<br />
trained 5-6 persons, take the lead and play a<br />
more active role. Interactive IEC initiatives to<br />
foster debate and youth participation include<br />
role plays, street drama and group<br />
discussions. Activities at schools usually take<br />
place once a week on a free afternoon. PEs<br />
may organize awareness sessions in<br />
different classes when teachers are absent.<br />
One school, for example, set a standard for<br />
every trained PE to hold at least one session<br />
after receiving training.<br />
Most activities are youth-initiated and based<br />
on shared decisions between youth and<br />
adults. The youth are involved in all steps of<br />
the programme; as participants in planning<br />
workshops, self-assessment exercises, when<br />
organizing and implementing<br />
communication events and through<br />
contributing to the production of IEC<br />
materials. They thus gain planning and<br />
organizational skills and learn to discuss and<br />
communicate plans to a wider audience.<br />
They are responsible for defining their<br />
working agenda, including monthly<br />
meetings, and for submitting quarterly<br />
reports to the district chapters of NRCS.<br />
Some of the IEC materials are completely<br />
designed by the youth; others are developed<br />
with their significant involvement. PEs, for<br />
example, contributed to compiling and pretesting<br />
a PE manual. It was developed through<br />
a rigorous one year process, has gained<br />
popularity and is today used by many other<br />
agencies in the country. One of the most<br />
popular IEC materials is a quarterly bulletin -<br />
Yuva Chautari - published at central level and<br />
distributed to all district chapters, schools and<br />
PEs. The bulletin is based on inputs from the<br />
youth who are invited to submit articles. On<br />
average submissions exceed the bulletins<br />
publishing capacity two or threefold! The<br />
bulletin includes a section where those<br />
questions are answered which schools and<br />
district chapters had difficulties to answer and<br />
which were therefore forward to the NRCS<br />
HQ.<br />
<strong>Project</strong> outcomes<br />
A main outcome of the project is that it<br />
considerably contributed to open up<br />
discussions among the youth about issues<br />
related to SRH and reducing the shyness<br />
surrounding them. As an example, people<br />
used to turn off the radio when <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention messages were disseminated,<br />
boys and girls would strictly stick to the<br />
opposite benches and women used to hide<br />
their sanitary towels during menstruation.<br />
Parents and elders usually avoided<br />
pronouncing words perceived to have<br />
"sexual connotations" in front of young<br />
people. These expressions of shyness are<br />
gradually disappearing. Students increasingly<br />
ask questions - and the teachers appreciate<br />
this as it supports them to overcome their<br />
own difficulties in teaching SRH.<br />
The project has contributed to removing<br />
barriers that existed at all levels - within the<br />
family, at school and in the wider<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
5
community. Sessions now include<br />
discussions on "intimate" issues such as<br />
menstruation, sterility, males' concern about<br />
masturbation, wet dreams, etc. Youth<br />
indicate that they are most of all interested in<br />
issues related to <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> and<br />
adolescence/life skills. This includes health<br />
issues such as hygiene, infection prevention<br />
and contraception which are relevant to the<br />
daily life of the youth. Hence, to capture the<br />
interest of the youth <strong>HIV</strong> needs to be<br />
integrated into the broader context of<br />
adolescence and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong>.<br />
Increased knowledge, new responsibilities<br />
and participation in activities all promote a<br />
set of life skills of PEs, including awareness,<br />
self-esteem and assertiveness. One youth<br />
commented that his main motivation to<br />
work as a PE is to challenge conservative<br />
attitudes. Being selected for the training is<br />
regarded as a privilege and other students<br />
would also like to receive the training. The<br />
project further enjoys popularity among the<br />
youth as it provides an open environment to<br />
exchange matters of their concern. Though<br />
many of the youth knew each other<br />
previously, the joint project activities<br />
intensified interaction and friendship among<br />
PEs. It is now noted to be relatively easy to<br />
gather the youth together for activities. The<br />
readiness to meet was further<br />
demonstrated when organizing focussed<br />
group discussions for this study.<br />
The project has resulted in an increased<br />
number of J/YRCCs and an increased level<br />
of their activity (one district, for example,<br />
had 8 new circles). Through the project<br />
activities J/YRCCs gained additional<br />
responsibilities that kept them more active,<br />
as expressed in an increased number of<br />
quarterly reports submitted by the youth<br />
circles to their NRCS district chapters. The<br />
project has thus played a catalytic role<br />
motivating youth to work as volunteers and<br />
to get involved in a range of community<br />
interventions and extra curricular activities<br />
that go beyond the issue of <strong>HIV</strong>.<br />
Although the NRCS is considerably successful<br />
with its volunteer based approach, incentives<br />
to keep the momentum of activities need also<br />
to be considered. Though the PEs do not<br />
receive any financial incentives, they have<br />
other incentives such as meeting peers and<br />
most importantly receiving trainings.<br />
Motivation though tends to slow down as the<br />
effect of the training fades away which often<br />
is the case approximately one year after the<br />
training. Also, youth request more in-depth<br />
knowledge on some issues - the module on<br />
life skills currently only covers 2 hours and<br />
many of the PEs find it to be very short. The<br />
yearly one-day refresher meetings are not<br />
considered to provide significant added value<br />
compared to the first trainings. Incentives are<br />
further related to belonging to the broader<br />
social movement of the NRCS. Activities are<br />
often integrated into the planning of J/<br />
YRCCs, but not all schools have a system in<br />
place where PEs can meet with one another,<br />
follow up and update their knowledge<br />
regularly.<br />
Often the formal role as educators for <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention is limited, given that PEs are<br />
unlikely to have sufficient level of <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
teaching expertise after a few days of<br />
training. An important part of information<br />
sharing is on an informal basis with close<br />
peers. These interactions are most intensive<br />
after the training when friends are curious to<br />
ask PEs what they have learnt. For direct<br />
questions PEs prefer to consult close friends<br />
and others of the same gender. Most<br />
interactions are with friends at school.<br />
Nevertheless, examples include talking with<br />
out of school peers, sisters/ brothers and, in<br />
some cases, parents. Interactions with other<br />
youth and the community are easier if they<br />
are supported by questions from the query<br />
box to be answered, and event and role plays<br />
such as the street drama.<br />
6<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
A BOX TO ENCOURAGE QUESTIONS FROM YOUTH<br />
A tool that is often used to conduct discussions are questions<br />
submitted by the youth anonymously to a Query Box. Query<br />
boxes are put up at schools for youth to submit any questions<br />
they have regarding adolescence and sexuality. With a couple of<br />
questions being normally submitted per week, query boxes<br />
present a continuing demand and a tool to shape sessions.<br />
Questions submitted are looked at jointly by PEs and teachers<br />
who contribute to the cooperation between teachers and PEs.<br />
Answers may be published at school notice boards or discussed<br />
in classes or other discussion sessions. If PEs and teachers have<br />
difficulties to answer the questions, they are forwarded to the<br />
NRCS Headquarters in Kathmandu, which answers and publishes<br />
them in its quarterly newsletter, Yuva Chautari. Some schools<br />
noted a decrease in queries submitted to the query box which<br />
was mainly attributed to an increased openness of students to<br />
ask questions directly during sessions.<br />
EDUTAINMENT WITH STREET DRAMA<br />
Youth receive a four-day training on street drama as performers<br />
and facilitators. The drama teams usually perform during<br />
festivals and public gatherings, attracting masses of around 500<br />
people. One district has performed around 20 sessions, one team<br />
around 4 in one year. Performances are interactive; a moderator<br />
involves the public with questions during the play. Street drama<br />
teams are also mobilized by a range of other institutions and<br />
organizations such as the military service, other district offices<br />
as well as private companies including Coca Cola - Nepal,<br />
Nebico Biscuits, etc. One team received substantial support in<br />
terms of equipment through another agency that was impressed<br />
by its performance.<br />
NATIONAL EXCHANGE BETWEEN PEs<br />
In 2005 for the first time a three day PE conference was<br />
organized in Bhaktapur. Four PEs and one teacher from each<br />
district were invited. The PEs were asked to submit abstracts<br />
according to a list of topics based on which some were selected<br />
for presentations. Youth were the main actors throughout the<br />
conference, to the point that teachers complained they felt<br />
neglected. Participation in the conference was stated by several<br />
youth as a highlight within their work as PEs. It gave them the<br />
opportunity to share and learn form others on practical issues<br />
related to the work as a PE.<br />
A major challenge for the sustainability of PE<br />
approaches is that the turn over of PEs is<br />
usually high. Young people grow up, have<br />
rapidly changing interests and environments<br />
and often find themselves on the look out for<br />
opportunities to generate income - in part<br />
due to sheer financial necessity. The more<br />
active PEs are often the older ones and when<br />
they leave school the younger PEs are<br />
required to take up the initiative. This project<br />
reduced the risk of low sustainability by<br />
using the J/YRCC as a continuing<br />
institutional base that provides its own<br />
incentives. In the majority of districts<br />
reference teachers of the J/YRCCs are<br />
involved in supporting the continuity of<br />
activities and providing guidance to younger<br />
PEs. In other districts voices were less<br />
optimistic stating that "the training has just<br />
made us stand, we need more to help us<br />
make the move." Furthermore, it needs to be<br />
kept in mind that reaching out to the<br />
community and changing behaviour is a<br />
longer process. "If we critically analyse the<br />
questions in the query box we find most of<br />
the questions coming from students indicate<br />
that they are still shy."<br />
The general statement was that to keep the<br />
same level of activity it will need a minimum<br />
level of external support mainly in terms of<br />
further trainings and provision of IEC<br />
materials. Small incentives have a high<br />
effect but their reliability and continuity<br />
needs to be assured. Youth are discouraged<br />
if, despite their initiative, support in terms of<br />
answered questions and provision of IEC<br />
materials is lacking. To increase the<br />
capacities of PEs an option may be to<br />
provide further training and some additional<br />
incentives to a selection of active PEs (2-4<br />
per schools) which in turn have to initiate a<br />
certain set of activities. Ideally, these PEs are<br />
selected by the other youth/PEs and thus<br />
have the mandate and trustworthiness of<br />
youth to function as their representatives,<br />
counsellors and role models.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
7
Lessons learnt<br />
Adolescents have many questions and<br />
doubts about what happens to them when<br />
they grow up and mature, about their sexual<br />
feelings and sexual life. <strong>Prevention</strong> of <strong>HIV</strong><br />
infection might be one area of interest, but it<br />
is neither the only nor the most important<br />
one. Perceptions about physical development<br />
and relationships, normality and abnormality,<br />
pregnancy, disease prevention, among<br />
others, all influence how girls and boys<br />
perceive their roles and options and influence<br />
how they behave. Initiatives therefore need to<br />
involve young people and take a broader<br />
perspective of their concerns related to<br />
reproductive health and sexuality instead of<br />
an <strong>HIV</strong> perspective only. <strong>Prevention</strong><br />
information must be coupled with everyday<br />
skills to increase the likelihood that<br />
individuals will translate their knowledge into<br />
action. Life skills based approaches are<br />
designed to do this by developing young<br />
people's abilities such as negotiation,<br />
assertiveness, and ability to cope with peer<br />
pressure; attitudes such as compassion, selfesteem,<br />
and tolerance; and knowledge about<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> transmission. When implemented with<br />
community involvement and support, these<br />
programmes foster a positive social<br />
environment. For the community<br />
environment to be conducive to safe sexual<br />
choices, coordinated interventions are<br />
needed that target parents, community<br />
leaders, teachers, and others with positive<br />
messages about <strong>HIV</strong> prevention.<br />
Youth involvement is an essential approach<br />
to foster life skills. Youth involvement refers<br />
to the degree of empowerment and decisionmaking<br />
that youth are able to assume. It<br />
needs both adequate training and<br />
supervision to increase youths' decisionmaking<br />
skills and proficiency in carrying out<br />
their responsibilities. Youth-adult<br />
partnerships constitute an advanced stage of<br />
youth involvement which in itself is a success<br />
story. However it usually needs adult staff<br />
members to initiate and facilitate the process<br />
supporting direct youth involvement, open<br />
communication, trustworthiness and mutual<br />
respect.<br />
An important factor to motivate youth to<br />
become involved is the camaraderie and<br />
friendship developed in a youth group. A<br />
shared vision and commitment to the<br />
programme and its goals are strong<br />
motivators to join, be active, and remain in a<br />
programme. The cooperation through group<br />
activities significantly contributes to the selfesteem<br />
and social skills of involved youth.<br />
Lessons learnt from the project:<br />
• Peer education is effective to increase<br />
communication between peers. Face-to-face<br />
exchange mostly takes place between close<br />
peers. Dissemination of information to other<br />
youth mainly takes place indirectly through<br />
public IEC events.<br />
• Peer education does not contribute<br />
significantly to increase communication<br />
between youth and parents or other adults in<br />
the community.<br />
• An institutional base such as the youth<br />
volunteer circles decreases the usually high<br />
level of fluctuation of PEs.<br />
• Trained teachers and PEs support and<br />
complement each other.<br />
• Youth bear a high potential of motivation<br />
and creativity to implement IEC activities.<br />
• Continuous support and incentives are<br />
required. Important incentives include:<br />
training; IEC materials, <strong>HIV</strong> prevention tools;<br />
belonging to a group of peers and a broader<br />
movement.<br />
• For a majority of students the school<br />
classes on <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> are among<br />
their favourite classes at school. Youth are<br />
eager to learn about reproductive health and<br />
thus there is high potential to convey<br />
messages on <strong>HIV</strong> prevention.<br />
• <strong>HIV</strong> alone however does not suffice to<br />
keep the interest of youth; it needs<br />
integration with other issues of their<br />
concern.<br />
8<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Teaching Sexual<br />
and <strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong> at schools<br />
<strong>Project</strong> activities<br />
Sexual and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> (SRH) is part<br />
of the national curriculum on health,<br />
population and environment science and<br />
compulsory for the grades 9 and 10. The<br />
policy is currently to start teaching SRH from<br />
grade 6 onwards. Though the institutional<br />
frame to teach <strong>HIV</strong> at schools exists, it<br />
essentially lacks capacities to teach SRH and<br />
teachers find it often difficult to teach these<br />
issues. Furthermore, the national curriculum<br />
is lecture based, does not include teaching<br />
approaches and the contents on <strong>HIV</strong> is<br />
limited to just a few pages. There is no<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
9
national system for distributing IEC<br />
materials on <strong>HIV</strong> prevention and RH at<br />
schools. The objective of the project is<br />
therefore to meet this gap and arm<br />
teachers with necessary skills to<br />
enhance teaching capacities with<br />
regard to SRH.<br />
The education sector has traditionally<br />
been a main coordinating partner of the<br />
NRCS. A majority of long term<br />
volunteers are teachers and many of<br />
the NRCS programmes use schools and<br />
J/YRCCs as a main link to the<br />
communities. J/YRCCs are often the<br />
first to report any incidences, needs<br />
and emergencies, within communities<br />
to the NRCS support teachers who then<br />
forward the information to the district<br />
chapters.<br />
The project implements most of its<br />
activities through this existing network<br />
of the NRCS and educational<br />
institutions. Schools are selected upon<br />
criteria including levels of vulnerability<br />
in the community and quality of<br />
cooperation with the NRCS. On average<br />
two teachers per school are trained for<br />
one week at the district headquarters.<br />
The teachers also receive a curriculum<br />
detailing different sessions for SRH<br />
including tools for interactive and<br />
participatory teaching approaches. One<br />
of the teachers selected for the training<br />
is usually the support teacher of the<br />
J/YRCCs. This increases the likelihood<br />
that the teacher has a social inclination<br />
and is trusted by the youth.<br />
The project also closely cooperates<br />
with the headmasters of schools. They<br />
receive a one day briefing workshop<br />
during the planning stage of the project<br />
and serve then as main reference<br />
persons. The project district chapters<br />
usually use the yearly district meetings for<br />
headmasters and add one day to brief and<br />
TRAINING GIVES A NEW START<br />
I am Amrita and work as a treasurer of Junior Red Cross Circle. I<br />
got an opportunity to participate in the peer education training<br />
organized by the <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong><br />
<strong>Project</strong>. This training has changed my life. After the training I have<br />
started taking care of my health and also the cleanliness of<br />
reproductive organs. I have also explained the importance of<br />
cleanliness and disease prevention to my family, friends and to the<br />
people of my community. The training has also helped me in<br />
developing communication skills. These days I find myself confident<br />
in expressing myself in large gatherings. It has changed the way I<br />
look at myself. The training has motivated us to take responsibility<br />
and do something for other people. I as well as my friends discuss<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong>, STDs and RH with the help of the query box and the<br />
wall news paper. I am also thankful to Yuva Chautari for keeping us<br />
in touch with the updated information.<br />
A HUMAN CAUSE TO WORK FOR<br />
I am Meena Khadka. I am interested in social work and have helped<br />
before some old age people the way I can. I am pleased to get an<br />
opportunity to participate in the peer educators’ training. The<br />
training has helped me to understand more about <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
reproductive health. As I found it very useful, I am disseminating the<br />
information among the people of the community. I also help the<br />
trainer of the district chapter in facilitating trainings. I have found<br />
people changing; those who were uncomfortable talking those<br />
sensitive issues now ask more questions. Today, people of the<br />
community, both male and female, are interested in reading Yuva<br />
Chautari. People who are illiterate ask other people to help them<br />
understand.<br />
Being involved with the Red Cross gave me the opportunity to learn<br />
many new things. I learned about <strong>HIV</strong> in general, how it transmits<br />
and how we can prevent ourselves from being infected. I also learned<br />
to take responsible decisions during the adolescent period. I believe<br />
that anybody who is involved in the Red Cross movement has<br />
motivation to serve for humanity. Being involved with the Red Cross,<br />
I have visited many places and made new friends. Now I can express<br />
my ideas fluently among friends, have overcome shyness, and I am<br />
committed to work for others.<br />
10<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
discuss the issue of teaching <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong>. Headmasters are<br />
therefore involved from the beginning; they<br />
receive briefing on the objectives and<br />
approaches of the project. This cooperation<br />
continues throughout the project with yearly<br />
briefing meetings.<br />
<strong>Project</strong> outcomes<br />
As a response to the training teachers have<br />
begun to feel more comfortable about<br />
teaching issues around SRH. Other teachers<br />
seek their advice and they are asked to step in<br />
to teach SRH in other classes than their own.<br />
In one district the trained teachers upon<br />
demand also taught at other schools.<br />
The school sessions on Sexual and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> (SRH) have become<br />
more lively with students forwarding<br />
questions openly including sensitive or<br />
intimate issues. For a majority of students the<br />
classes on <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> are their<br />
favourite classes at school. Still, when asked<br />
how the classes at schools<br />
compare to the trainings in most<br />
cases the training is more<br />
appreciated due to its higher level<br />
of interaction and open space for<br />
discussions.<br />
Teaching SRH remains a challenge<br />
and teachers openly describe how<br />
they try to deal with sensitive<br />
issues. Using questions submitted<br />
to the query box helps to<br />
introduce sensitive topics.<br />
Importantly, teachers value the<br />
support of the youth as they have<br />
become less shy to ask questions<br />
in and out of class. Teachers<br />
appreciate as PEs take the<br />
initiative to run classes on their<br />
own, sometimes even replacing<br />
an absentee teacher.<br />
Teachers are generally supportive and<br />
interested in the development of the youth.<br />
Ideally, youth are able to select the teacher<br />
they trust to talk about their concerns and<br />
more intimate issues. This is not feasible in<br />
the current setting. However, as teachers<br />
selected are also support teachers of the J/<br />
YRCCs there is an increased likelihood that<br />
they teachers provide a set of social qualities.<br />
In most cases, these teachers have been<br />
NRCS volunteers for long and generally<br />
share some social values. Apart from<br />
teaching in the classroom, teachers<br />
supporting the<br />
J/YRCCs are involved in the joint extra<br />
curricular activities with the J/YRCCs. This<br />
role increases their trustworthiness in front<br />
of the youth and facilitates a more open<br />
dialogue on both sides.<br />
Overall, the programme has contributed to<br />
increasing interaction between teachers and<br />
students. The youth generally feel well<br />
supported by their reference teachers. In one<br />
case, for example, after the brother of a PE<br />
EXPERIENCES OF PES TO TEACH SRH<br />
PEs from Bhaktapur said they stand in for teachers who are<br />
absent and talk to their classmates about SRH and <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong>.<br />
They said they would try to make the session as interactive as<br />
possible. According to the PEs, this was difficult in the beginning<br />
because their class mates would feel shy, especially girls. Both<br />
boys and girls, however, started to accept discussions regarding<br />
sexual and reproductive health.<br />
"Earlier it was quite difficult to show face with opposite sex<br />
while teaching reproductive health and we often thought why<br />
this topic was taught in the class room? The peer educators<br />
program helped us to know about boys and girls' problems,<br />
reduce confusion and have more clarity on subject matter, how<br />
to care our body and maintain personal hygiene. Nowadays we<br />
realize the importance of this topic. This program equally helped<br />
us to solve problems and communicate with each other more<br />
confidently on difficult subject like sexuality and <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong>."<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
11
forbade his sister to be involved in a street<br />
drama performance, the NRCS<br />
representative and the support teacher went<br />
to talk with the family of the PE. In most<br />
cases, teachers appreciate the support of PEs<br />
and encourage them to take the lead in<br />
organizing events. The example given at one<br />
school was that teachers would join as<br />
invitees while the youth stay in front of the<br />
event. A teacher admitted that PEs may have<br />
a better knowledge of life skills as they are<br />
closer to their peers in age.<br />
Lessons learnt<br />
Given the sensitivities that surround sex, SRH<br />
teachers often find it difficult to discuss <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>AIDS</strong> with their students. In addition,<br />
teachers may not be accustomed to<br />
interacting with students in the<br />
"participatory" methods, best suited for<br />
facilitating these subjects. This situation is<br />
made more difficult if teaching curricula and<br />
information materials take a knowledgeoriented<br />
and biomedical perspective,<br />
ignoring the kind of questions that are in the<br />
young people's minds. Life skills, in<br />
particular, are best learned through<br />
"experiential" and "learner-centered"<br />
methodologies designed to help young<br />
people examine attitudes and practise skills.<br />
Interactive teaching techniques allow<br />
discussion of social issues relating to<br />
relationships and opportunities to practise<br />
negotiation, communication, and own<br />
choices.<br />
Lessons learnt from the project:<br />
• Trained teachers serve as resource<br />
persons for all issues related to teaching<br />
SRH. Other teachers and schools also seek<br />
their advice and support.<br />
• It is essential that teachers for SRH enjoy<br />
the trust of the young people involved. The<br />
project benefited from working with teachers<br />
who are also NRCS volunteers. In general<br />
these teachers had a greater social<br />
commitment and do greatly support youth<br />
volunteer circles at schools.<br />
• If supportive, teachers play an important<br />
role to facilitate the work of PEs. They can<br />
have a motivational effect as role models.<br />
• Teachers who are NRCS volunteers are<br />
often also involved in other fields of<br />
community development. They are therefore<br />
in a good position to create a link between<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> prevention in and out of school.<br />
• Teachers value the fact that the young<br />
people involved are increasingly asking<br />
questions as it helps them to discuss<br />
sensitive issues. Similarly, answering<br />
questions which youth submit anonymously<br />
to a query box helps teachers to address the<br />
concerns of youth.<br />
• Teachers appreciate that PEs take the<br />
initiative to run sessions. They admit that<br />
"for some issues PEs are better qualified to<br />
talk to the youth."<br />
• Using an existing institutional network<br />
increases sustainability and facilitates<br />
monitoring of project activities.<br />
12<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Involvement of<br />
parents and the<br />
community<br />
<strong>Project</strong> activities<br />
In a preliminary phase the objective of the<br />
project was to use PEs at schools to also<br />
reach out to the communities. Support of the<br />
community to the PEs was<br />
however limited, their work<br />
was misunderstood and it<br />
was regarded as inappropriate<br />
for youth to talk about issues<br />
related to <strong>HIV</strong> and SRH to<br />
their seniors and elders at<br />
home or other older people in<br />
the community. Public IEC<br />
events such as street drama<br />
contributed to removing some barriers.<br />
Another approach was to directly include the<br />
community and shift the responsibility of<br />
sensitizing other adult community members<br />
to women groups.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
13
PEs disseminate messages related to <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> to the wider<br />
communities mainly through public IEC<br />
events - street drama or folk song<br />
competitions. Some interventions specifically<br />
target vulnerable population groups<br />
including dissemination of IEC materials to<br />
transport workers and sending letters on<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> to migrant workers. Youth<br />
perform interactive street drama sessions<br />
not only in the community but also on the<br />
roadside, truck and bus halting places.<br />
To gain parental support the project informs<br />
and involves parents through information<br />
sessions and distribution of IEC materials,<br />
for example, at parents' days. Parents are<br />
invited to public activities of PEs. There<br />
appears to be little resistance of parents<br />
regarding SRH education at schools.<br />
Opposing views are often related to the fear<br />
that teaching of SRH may increase<br />
promiscuity among the youth. Support<br />
teachers play a role to counter these fears.<br />
The project has increasingly made an effort to<br />
involve the People Living with <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong><br />
(PLWHA). While in general PLWHA are<br />
increasingly coming out, in many communities<br />
they are still invisible and the majority of youth<br />
and community members involved in the<br />
project have not met anybody living with <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>AIDS</strong>. Within the project, PLWHA are<br />
increasingly being referred to the NRCS for<br />
support. Three PLWHA were supported by the<br />
project when they publicly spoke out on the<br />
occasion of the condoms' day.<br />
In one district the project is supporting a self<br />
help group of 12 PLWHA. Members of the<br />
support group are in regular contact with the<br />
NRCS district office, they are invited to join<br />
the DACC meetings and receive small<br />
financial support mainly in terms of travel<br />
expenses to reach the treatment facilities in<br />
the next district, Kaski (Pokhara city). It is yet<br />
not widely known that treatment is available<br />
in Pokhara, even health facilities may not be<br />
aware of this. Dolakha, Ramechhap, Baglung,<br />
Parbat and Sindhuli districts until now do not<br />
have VCT facilities and people would need to<br />
travel to Kathmandu Valley for testing. The<br />
lack of close voluntary testing facilities<br />
appears to be a major deterrent to a<br />
comprehensive <strong>HIV</strong> response in the project<br />
districts. In one project district 7 people<br />
currently receive ART, 3 of them were<br />
referred by the project. They also receive<br />
support for travel expenses.<br />
Each district has constituted 10 women<br />
groups, each comprising 20 or more<br />
members. For each group 20 members are<br />
selected based on criteria including social<br />
status and vulnerability (e.g. wives of<br />
migrants working mainly in India). The<br />
women receive a 3-day training on <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong>, RH, and hygiene and sanitation. They<br />
meet once a month with a community-based<br />
facilitator to learn and discuss these issues.<br />
Occasionally, non-members also take part in<br />
these meetings as observers. Encouraged by<br />
the discussion and appreciative of the events<br />
organized by the women's groups, nonmembers<br />
have also expressed interest to join<br />
in as members. Many feel 'excluded' as their<br />
calls go unheeded. According to group<br />
members, however, larger groups are<br />
difficult to manage in the long run. Having to<br />
stay out of the group makes non-group<br />
members feel like 'lesser child of God,'<br />
particularly if they are Dalits. The project<br />
provides a small seed amount to set up a<br />
fund for social protection/IGA/emergency<br />
depending upon the modalities that are<br />
determined by the members. Though the<br />
funds are small and thus of limited scope,<br />
they contribute to a sense of membership<br />
and provide an incentive to meet regularly. In<br />
most cases members have used the funds to<br />
take loans. The number of women<br />
participating in the groups has increased<br />
steadily and some of the groups almost<br />
doubled in size. Demands are further issued<br />
14<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
y communities that are not<br />
included in the project and by<br />
men who also partly felt<br />
neglected.<br />
A common activity of women<br />
groups is to organize public<br />
events on occasions such as<br />
condoms' day and the World<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> Day. Other popular<br />
activities are song competitions<br />
and street drama performances<br />
with different topics on <strong>HIV</strong>.<br />
One women group, mainly<br />
comprising Dalits, was proud to<br />
have won a prize in a song<br />
competition. Different groups<br />
had performed several street<br />
dramas in the last year. Most of<br />
the women who have their<br />
husband working outside of<br />
Nepal send a standardized letter<br />
on <strong>HIV</strong> prevention targeting<br />
migrant workers. One district<br />
alone sent around 300 letters to<br />
migrant workers throughout<br />
the project phase and received<br />
15 responses from the<br />
migrants. Initiatives of women<br />
with regard to face-to-face <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention are more difficult.<br />
Women find it challenging to<br />
open discussions on these<br />
issues and in most cases appear<br />
to limit these talks to close<br />
friends.<br />
<strong>Project</strong><br />
outcomes<br />
Generally, families and<br />
communities have become<br />
more open towards issues<br />
related to SRH. Moreover,<br />
support of the community with<br />
regard to the work of PEs has<br />
IMPRESSIONS OF YOUTH MEETING PLWHA<br />
A group of PE from Dolakha that met a positive person<br />
commented: "With his healthy and active looks he will probably<br />
live for 20 more years." "He shared with us his views about<br />
positive living and it was an amazing experience listening to him,"<br />
said a PE from High School in Dolakha. "Getting to know about<br />
him and learn about how he was making himself a productive<br />
member of society was an inspiring story to listen to," the 10th<br />
grader said. "I got to learn from him that positive thinking is<br />
absolutely necessary once someone has been infected with <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and that care and support would make a lot of difference in the<br />
lives of those who have been infected with <strong>HIV</strong>."<br />
RECOGNIZING SYMPTOMS OF <strong>HIV</strong> AND <strong>AIDS</strong><br />
I am Sarita from Pang V.D.C. ward no. 2 in Parbat. I am a member<br />
of the women group. I have 12 members in my family. My husband<br />
worked for 8-9 years in Mumbai. When he returned he was very sick<br />
and died three years ago. During the training for the women group, I<br />
realized that my husband was <strong>HIV</strong> positive. When I talked to him,<br />
the trainer suggested me to visit the Voluntary Counselling and<br />
Testing centre in Kaski. I went there, received counselling and was<br />
tested. Thank God, it was negative! I realize now how much I was<br />
deprived of the information. There are many cases of death - like my<br />
husband - in my village. But there was nobody with whom we could<br />
talk. Therefore, we talk about <strong>HIV</strong> issues to our friends and the<br />
community and motivate people to participate in the activities like<br />
rallies, street drama shows, folk song competitions etc. organized<br />
by Mahila Samuha (Women Group).<br />
KNOWLEDGE SHARING BEYOND BORDERS<br />
I am Narahari from Parbat. Currently, I am working in Malaysia. My<br />
friends and I are thankful for receiving a letter from your<br />
organization, which contains message about <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> and<br />
how it transmits, how we can avoid the transmission and how to<br />
behave with a person testing <strong>HIV</strong> positive. As we found this<br />
information important we have photocopied the letter and sent it to<br />
our other fellows working in different factories and cities across<br />
Malaysia. Sending the letter made me feel important contributing to<br />
the prevention of the disease in our country.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
15
increased. "We were accused of being<br />
shameless while performing drama on <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>AIDS</strong>, but now our views are listened to<br />
and we are encouraged to continue the good<br />
work". "Before we were told that only bad<br />
girls and those who have <strong>AIDS</strong> provide peer<br />
education to others - but from our street<br />
drama we convinced them." Though youth<br />
recognize some changes, there are still many<br />
examples where the work of PEs is<br />
misunderstood, they are being teased or<br />
regarded as "shameless". For example, after<br />
a street drama performance where a girl<br />
played an <strong>HIV</strong> positive person, spectators<br />
went to her brother and told him his sister<br />
was an <strong>HIV</strong> positive. Indirect approaches<br />
such as the street drama are easier to<br />
implement, talking directly and individually to<br />
community members is more difficult.<br />
Moreover, increased direct communication<br />
between adults and youth on issues related<br />
to SRH is less likely to happen within such a<br />
short time frame.<br />
With regard to involving PLWHA, the project<br />
has reached PLWHA though their visibility in<br />
some districts remains limited. If PEs meet<br />
PLWHA this appears to have a direct and<br />
effective impact on their attitudes and<br />
effectively contributes to eliminate any<br />
stigmatizing prejudices that may have<br />
persisted (unconsciously) before. Members<br />
of a self-help group stated that<br />
discrimination especially in the district cities<br />
has decreased. Main reasons are that<br />
information on <strong>HIV</strong> is now being<br />
disseminated through different media which<br />
reduces misperceptions. Another important<br />
factor that decreases stigmatization is the<br />
availability of treatment.<br />
There are common features regarding the<br />
incentives needed to keep the interest of PEs<br />
and women groups: Integrating <strong>HIV</strong> into<br />
other issues related to <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> is<br />
essential to gain and keep the interest of the<br />
women. <strong>HIV</strong> as a stand alone issue is not<br />
sufficient to keep the interest and to fill the<br />
agenda of regular meetings in a longer term.<br />
Concerns of women are primarily related to<br />
other RH issues including family planning or<br />
the frequent problem of uterus prolapse.<br />
Also, the motivational effect of the training<br />
tends to fade away and it needs additional<br />
means to keep the interest up and the<br />
meetings busy. As one facilitator stated, she<br />
had told the women everything she learnt in<br />
the training and they would ask her for<br />
further information which she could not<br />
provide. One group used the quarterly<br />
bulletin to choose subjects for discussion.<br />
Another sets targets on activities for the next<br />
month and discusses them in the next<br />
meeting. Other incentives for the women<br />
groups to meet include collecting<br />
membership contribution for their funds and<br />
to have an open space to discuss common<br />
concerns and to meet up with "a reason for a<br />
break from work". These incentives enhance<br />
sustainability to some degree but are unlikely<br />
to suffice in the longer term. Women groups<br />
estimate that without additional incentives<br />
activities are likely to level out within 1-2<br />
years.<br />
Teaching or talking to others also requires a<br />
certain level of expertise that may not be<br />
assured through a few sessions. Members of<br />
a women group stated, for example, that they<br />
would teach their children but are not very<br />
sure regarding their level of knowledge. The<br />
women groups have contributed to create a<br />
more open environment on issues related to<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>, but often they have less potential to<br />
disseminate detailed technical knowledge.<br />
Self initiative of women to access<br />
knowledge has partly increased. Women,<br />
for example, approach health posts or the<br />
NRCS district offices to seek answer to their<br />
questions. Importantly, women gained<br />
awareness and skills to express issues<br />
16<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
elated to SRH. One group, for example, said<br />
that now, if they are blamed for not having a<br />
son they would turn this down saying that it<br />
is the men who determine the sex of the<br />
child. Many cases are described where<br />
women are now more open to discuss <strong>HIV</strong><br />
with their husbands and other community<br />
members. Some women even described<br />
how they would convince their husbands to<br />
have a blood test or use protection. Some<br />
cases where women previously have<br />
suffered in silence, they now approach the<br />
trained group members and seek advice.<br />
Women group members provide them with<br />
the answer and when they are not sure<br />
themselves the advice-seeking women are<br />
referred to the health facilities.<br />
However, barriers are naturally prevailing. In<br />
general women still find it easier to talk to<br />
close friends on issues related to SRH as<br />
compared to their children or husbands.<br />
Taking protective measures is further<br />
inhibited as there are no VCT centres in the<br />
proximity. In the western districts the closest<br />
VCT centre is in Pokhara, in the eastern<br />
districts it is in Kathmandu. "How can we tell<br />
spouses who come back after years to go<br />
back to Kathmandu, have their blood tested<br />
and then return home with a clean chit<br />
before having sex?"<br />
Compared to the youth, women are in a<br />
better position to address issues related to<br />
SRH to other adults in the community. Youth<br />
usually discuss with closer friends and, in<br />
some cases, also with other peers of their<br />
age and sisters or brothers. They prefer not<br />
to be responsible for sensitizing their<br />
parents. The project took account of these<br />
realities by including the women as<br />
mediators to reach the adult population. The<br />
women groups clearly contributed to<br />
opening up the environment and also<br />
increasing acceptance and support to <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention at schools and community<br />
initiatives of PEs.<br />
However, women groups do not have the<br />
same institutional links compared to the<br />
J/YRCCs and a main concern regards their<br />
level of sustainability. In more urban settings<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> prevention targeting the general adult<br />
population mostly focuses on mass media<br />
ideally combined with counselling at health<br />
facilities and work places. These approaches<br />
bear less potential in a rural setting and other<br />
more sustainable alternatives compared to<br />
the community initiatives may not be feasible<br />
or effective. <strong>Health</strong> posts and family planning<br />
volunteers provide information on <strong>HIV</strong>, but<br />
they contribute less to reducing barriers and<br />
stigma on issues related to <strong>HIV</strong>. Where<br />
women groups exist in the frame of other<br />
programmes they may be used to integrate<br />
the issue of <strong>HIV</strong>, provided that they bear a<br />
certain level of sustainability.<br />
Lessons learnt<br />
Involvement of parents and senior/elder<br />
members of the community provides PEs the<br />
critical support that they need to spread<br />
awareness about <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> and SRH.<br />
Proper understanding regarding <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong>, their symptoms and the modes of<br />
transmission also contributes to reducing<br />
stigma and discrimination attached to <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>AIDS</strong>.<br />
Moreover, the project initiatives bear the<br />
potential to increase inter-generational<br />
communication and raise awareness and<br />
openness among parents and other adult<br />
peers on issues of <strong>HIV</strong>. However, parents<br />
may find it difficult and be reluctant to talk<br />
about relationships and sexuality with their<br />
children out of embarrassment, lack of<br />
accurate information, or fear that they will<br />
appear to condone adolescent sexual activity.<br />
Similarly, youth prefer friends of the same<br />
age and gender to discuss issues on SRH,<br />
followed by sisters or brothers. Inter<br />
generational talk about SRH in all societies is<br />
a challenge for both the youth and parents.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
17
Adults furthermore tend not to be very<br />
receptive to teaching by the young, regarding<br />
any subject but even more so with regard to<br />
SRH. These are social commonalities that<br />
exist in any country or culture and may be<br />
reduced over time but are unlikely to<br />
disappear altogether simply by reducing<br />
culturally bound barriers.<br />
Lessons learnt from the project:<br />
• Compared to youth, women are in a better<br />
position to address issues related to SRH to<br />
other adults in the community.<br />
• After the short training many women still<br />
do not feel confident to disseminate detailed<br />
technical knowledge. A technical knowledge<br />
to teach others is unlikely to be achieved<br />
after a few days training<br />
• Women are most likely to talk to close<br />
friends and family members of the same age<br />
and gender regarding SRH. Increased<br />
communication between adults and youth on<br />
issues related to SRH is less likely to happen<br />
at all and more so within such a short time<br />
frame.<br />
• Indirect approaches such as the street<br />
drama are easier to implement, talking<br />
directly and individually to community<br />
members is more difficult. It needs "tools"<br />
and IEC materials to open up discussions.<br />
• Integrating <strong>HIV</strong> into other issues related to<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> is essential to gain and<br />
keep the interest of the women. <strong>HIV</strong> as a<br />
stand alone issue is not sufficient to keep the<br />
interest and fill regular meetings in a longer<br />
term.<br />
• The motivational effect of the training<br />
tends to fade away and it needs additional<br />
incentives to keep the interest up and fill the<br />
agenda of meetings.<br />
• If PEs meet PLWHA, this has a direct and<br />
effective impact on their attitudes and it<br />
effectively contributes to eliminate any<br />
stigmatizing prejudices that may have<br />
persisted (unconsciously) before.<br />
18<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Gender equity<br />
and equality<br />
<strong>Project</strong> activities<br />
Gender attitudes in the project districts were<br />
examined during a mid-term evaluation of<br />
the project. Boys and girls generally do have<br />
a "sense of being equal." Nevertheless girls<br />
feel more restricted than boys with regard to<br />
their social and economic options. Girls<br />
seem to have a higher sense of responsibility<br />
and are more concerned about their future,<br />
while boys show a more carefree attitude<br />
and some feelings of superiority. There are<br />
certain places where girls feel unsafe (sex<br />
abuse, molestation) while this is not the case<br />
for boys. Likewise, free and single movement<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
19
is not encouraged or allowed at all<br />
for girls. These examples show that<br />
even though boys and girls talk<br />
about "equality" and feeling "equal,"<br />
their daily and future life is guided by<br />
culturally entrenched gender roles.<br />
The project addresses gender and<br />
social equity - though to a limited<br />
extent - during Teacher Sponsors<br />
training and PE training to students.<br />
The project trained an equal number<br />
of female PEs, increasing their<br />
number to almost 50%. This increase<br />
in the number of female PEs is<br />
important as naturally many girls feel<br />
shy to talk about SRH issues to a male<br />
teacher, and most of the support<br />
teachers are male. The project has<br />
further contributed to ensuring the<br />
gender balanced representation at the<br />
boards of J/YRCC.<br />
In general there is a very low<br />
representation of female teachers in<br />
schools. Throughout the project the<br />
number of female teachers for the<br />
training was increased. Trained<br />
female teachers account for<br />
approximately 20% of the total. At<br />
times when no female teacher was<br />
available at secondary level, one<br />
from primary level was chosen.<br />
THANKS TO THE RED CROSS PROGRAMME<br />
I am a young girl of 21 years. I live in Khurkot VDC ward no 7, of<br />
Sindhuli district. As I was studying in class 9 at Aambegudin<br />
secondary school, I was introduced to a local boy who was a bus<br />
driver. After my final examination, he proposed me to accompany<br />
him to go to Janakpur. My family and the neighbours were against<br />
this. To make things easier, we got married. In the fourth month of<br />
our marriage, a friend and I participated in the PE training. After<br />
the training I realized I had sexually transmitted infection. I shared<br />
this with my friend, who had a similar problem. She advised me to<br />
visit the health post for treatment. I talked to my husband and we<br />
both went to the health post for treatment. I have explained all<br />
things to the health worker. The health post referred us to district<br />
hospital for treatment of STIs.<br />
SENDING INFORMATION ON <strong>HIV</strong> TO MY HUSBAND<br />
I am Hira Nepali from Sindhuli district. Often I am too busy with my<br />
household activities, but sometimes I participate in the meetings<br />
organized by the Red Cross Mahila Samuha (Women Group) of our<br />
community. After hearing about issues related to <strong>HIV</strong> I visited the<br />
field coordinator to talk as my husband works in India. He provided<br />
me with additional information. After my return I asked the<br />
community mobilizer to give me the letter with information on <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>AIDS</strong>, designed by NRCS. I wanted to send it to my husband<br />
along with the brochure containing information about how to<br />
prevent <strong>HIV</strong>. I also wrote the correct way of using condoms and its<br />
importance in the letter to my husband.<br />
The project uses selection criteria to<br />
prioritize women from Dalit castes to<br />
participate in the women groups. However,<br />
often this is difficult to fully implement in<br />
practice given that the women from the<br />
lower income groups generally have less<br />
time available. Most of the women groups<br />
include representatives from different caste<br />
groups, including Dalits and ethnic<br />
communities. In some groups however the<br />
majority of group members, and particularly<br />
those in the board, are from higher social<br />
classes. Dalit and ethnic women are largely<br />
'ordinary' members of the group.<br />
<strong>Project</strong> outcomes<br />
<strong>Project</strong> activities contributed to increase<br />
participation of girls in classes. Though<br />
generally boys still ask most of the questions,<br />
girls do so increasingly. Teachers and women<br />
note that interaction between boys and girls is<br />
increasing. One example given by a teacher is<br />
that girls and boys started to share the same<br />
benches what they never used to do before.<br />
They also welcome the opportunity in the<br />
mixed trainings to learn about the concerns of<br />
the opposite gender.<br />
20<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
CHANGE IN KALPANA<br />
I live in Tilahar village. My husband and I have a very good<br />
relationship but our economic condition is quite poor. He went to<br />
South Korea to earn money. He sent money home and I started to<br />
change my lifestyle, eating at the hotel, going to movies, etc. One<br />
day I met a boy called Rupak at a hotel. He's a policeman and he<br />
asked me to sleep with him. I heard later that he has had relations<br />
with other women in the past. One day, I got one <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong><br />
booklet from Red Cross and I knew about <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> and STIs.<br />
At the same time, I met one lady trainer of Red Cross, Meena, and I<br />
shared my story with her. Then I am afraid of having sex with<br />
unknown person, and I left that kind of relation. After meeting with<br />
that lady trainer I knew about how to manage conflict, how to say<br />
no, how to avoid sexual stress and build my decision making<br />
capacity. Now my life is very simple. I think this kind of problem will<br />
come with unknown people who have no knowledge about <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> and STIs. That's why, I thought information regarding these<br />
issues should be given to the community women. Nowadays I am<br />
passing information about <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong>, and STIs to our<br />
community people.<br />
Opinions of girls whether they prefer female<br />
teachers for the reproductive health classes<br />
are mixed. In general though the majority of<br />
girls would prefer and benefit from a higher<br />
number of female teachers to address their<br />
concerns. A female teacher stated, for<br />
example, that she has become a counsellor for<br />
female students. For more private issues they<br />
usually approach her out of class.<br />
In general and increasingly, men regard the<br />
involvement of women as positive.<br />
Statements are that women receive an<br />
education they need and which also benefits<br />
men when women share their knowledge and<br />
are less embarrassed to talk about SRH<br />
issues.<br />
Nevertheless, barriers do persist. All women<br />
groups state that their husbands are often<br />
curious and also suspicious about the topics<br />
and discussions in the women groups. Men<br />
tease women asking if they are not shy talking<br />
about these issues. In one community men<br />
stated that if women spend their time<br />
on these activities it means they did<br />
not find any (seasonal) work. In<br />
another case, while women were<br />
trained, the male would make<br />
comments about the trainer who<br />
dares to talk about these issues to so<br />
many women.<br />
Cases where men are clearly against<br />
the activities of women groups do<br />
persist. "My husband, who was<br />
working as a tailor in Kathmandu,<br />
returned to the village recently. He<br />
drinks and stays home all day. He<br />
doesn't want me to go to the women's<br />
group because he has no good<br />
opinion of such groups. He often<br />
quarrels with me and even beats me<br />
up," said Manju Nepali, member,<br />
Devisthan, Women Group,<br />
Bhaluwajor Village Development<br />
Committee.<br />
Women see a need for men to be addressed<br />
by the <strong>HIV</strong> training. Women argue that men<br />
are at higher risk compared to themselves. On<br />
the other side, men felt excluded, expressing<br />
their interest to know more about <strong>HIV</strong> or even<br />
asking for "male groups." As it is the case<br />
with the youth, women also prefer the option<br />
to have a mixed training with men, given that<br />
this would contribute to a higher mutual<br />
understanding of the other gender's<br />
concerns.<br />
Understandably - though perceived as<br />
negative by men - women would not want the<br />
men to take part in the meetings. "Once we<br />
went to the meeting held by women but they<br />
did not talk about anything seeing us there but<br />
when we left the place they resumed their<br />
discussion."<br />
In some project districts unwanted and early<br />
pregnancy often followed by early marriage<br />
reduced over the last years. The increase in<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
21
female PEs further contributes to reaching out<br />
to girls and women and addressing female<br />
issues related to SRH. Cultural beliefs and<br />
attitudes are gradually changing and<br />
misconceptions disappearing: "Women no<br />
longer stay away from the family during<br />
menstruation, which used to be an important<br />
old tradition," "women dry their underwears<br />
and sanitary towels in the sun before using<br />
them which did not use to be the case."<br />
Before, minor infections were feared as<br />
serious STDs or <strong>HIV</strong> and girls or women<br />
suffered in silence, without seeking medical<br />
treatment. Now they are more open to talk<br />
about any physical 'abnormality' and are less<br />
shy to visit health facilities for treatment or<br />
counselling. Although these achievements<br />
cannot be solely attributed to the NRCS Peer<br />
Education approach, this change process was<br />
invariably reinforced by NRCS efforts at the<br />
school youths and the communities.<br />
As those students who are already active in<br />
class are selected as PEs, this entails the risk<br />
that students from deprived social classes,<br />
who are less likely to be academically toppers<br />
at school, are precluded. However, within the<br />
groups of PE's joint initiatives, new<br />
responsibilities and a sense of friendship<br />
contributes to removing class barriers. At<br />
times youth from lower class backgrounds<br />
once they are supported become lively and<br />
active members.<br />
Lessons learnt<br />
Youth need to understand how gender<br />
influences their attitudes and behaviours.<br />
Training and supervision should cover not<br />
only biological differences but also the<br />
influence societal gender roles and norms<br />
have on <strong>HIV</strong> and reproductive health and<br />
on their performance as peer educators.<br />
Gender norms that affect females may<br />
include submissiveness, deference to male<br />
authority, dependence, virginity until<br />
marriage, and faithfulness during marriage.<br />
Norms for men, in contrast, are built<br />
around power and control, independence,<br />
not showing emotions, risk taking and<br />
sexual activity. Working in mixed groups in<br />
the field allows PEs to practise new roles<br />
while the PEs themselves can serve as role<br />
models for other youth. Importantly,<br />
reproductive health education contributes<br />
to reducing misconceptions and cultural<br />
beliefs and promoting preventive and safe<br />
behaviours.<br />
Lessons learnt from the project:<br />
• Organizing joint activities and talking more<br />
openly about issues related to Sexual and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> contributes to<br />
increasing interaction between boys and<br />
girls.<br />
• Education and raising awareness<br />
effectively reduces culturally entrenched<br />
misconceptions and gender attitudes and<br />
norms.<br />
• Selection of PE should be participatory and<br />
based on students' preference rather than<br />
teachers' preference and an effort should be<br />
made for equitable representation from all<br />
groups.<br />
• Direct information exchange on issues<br />
related to SRH mainly takes place between<br />
peers of the same gender, a balance between<br />
female and male PEs therefore is important.<br />
• Female teachers can play an important role<br />
as counsellors for girls.<br />
• Involvement of men is important to gain<br />
their support and raise awareness on <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention.<br />
• Women themselves have limited capacity<br />
to inform and involve the men, they feel that<br />
barriers will persist as long as men are not<br />
directly targeted.<br />
• Male and female want the other gender to<br />
know about their concerns. They therefore<br />
welcome a joint training. However, at the<br />
same time a discussion space with only the<br />
same gender is important to achieve in-depth<br />
discussion and exchange about more private<br />
issues.<br />
22<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Coordination<br />
at district level<br />
This section looks at the institutional setting<br />
of the NRCS as it determines the project<br />
implementation. It furthermore outlines the<br />
coordination at district level with the<br />
different institutions, district committees and<br />
sectors involved in the project.<br />
The NRCS has a decentralized structure with<br />
district chapters, subchapters and a network<br />
of volunteers including the junior circles and<br />
teachers that reach out to the community<br />
level. Countrywide representation and wide<br />
network down to the community level is one<br />
of NRCS's key strengths when it comes to<br />
project implementation and reaching out to<br />
the community. The close presence at the<br />
community level has furthermore enhanced<br />
experience and credibility at central and<br />
regional policy. The NRCS history of<br />
community based humanitarian work dates<br />
back to 1963. J/YRCCs as the "junior wing"<br />
of volunteers at NRCS was established in<br />
1965 and includes today over 4,020 circles<br />
with more than 800,000 members at<br />
schools. Staff and volunteers share social and<br />
humanitarian values as expressed in their<br />
motto "I serve." NRCS has implemented <strong>HIV</strong><br />
related activities in 54 districts, and Youth <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention projects are currently<br />
implemented in 19 districts. The Red Cross is<br />
today represented at various central and<br />
regional forums on <strong>HIV</strong>, including the<br />
National <strong>AIDS</strong> Coordination Committee and<br />
the Country Coordination Mechanism (CCM)<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
23
for Global Fund for <strong>AIDS</strong>, TB and Malaria<br />
(GFATM) 1 . Approaches of the NRCS have<br />
broadened from a focus on humanitarian<br />
assistance to working towards sustainable<br />
development and capacity building at system<br />
and community level. This combination places<br />
it well to address the continuum from <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention to care and support.<br />
In many districts the NRCS has taken a lead<br />
in promoting the District <strong>AIDS</strong> Coordination<br />
Councils (DACC) as the main coordination<br />
body for <strong>HIV</strong> initiatives, usually if it is the<br />
main agency working on <strong>HIV</strong> in the<br />
respective district. DACCs are responsible<br />
for needs assessment, planning and<br />
coordination of district activities in the field<br />
of <strong>HIV</strong>. Due to its relatively young existence<br />
and yet limited capacities DACCs have until<br />
now mainly a coordinating role. The NRCS or<br />
- if they are active in the district - other<br />
agencies support the DACC to organize<br />
meetings on a regular basis (monthly or<br />
once/twice a year) inviting all the district<br />
committees in the areas of development,<br />
health and education, NGOs and INGOs. The<br />
meetings are used to present and discuss<br />
current activities in the field of <strong>HIV</strong>. In<br />
addition, the NRCS and other agencies<br />
through the DACC join to organize events on<br />
occasions such as Condom's Day or World<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> Day. The NRCS has further initiated a<br />
review of the DACC to improve the<br />
effectiveness of its bureaucratic constitution.<br />
Currently a main constraint to the<br />
functionality of DACCs is that they are<br />
chaired by the head of the DDC who in<br />
general is occupied with a number of<br />
committees and may have other priorities.<br />
District chapters of the NRCS are autonomous<br />
and develop their local policies and yearly<br />
activity plan on <strong>HIV</strong> in coordination with the<br />
other actors in the field. The activity plan is<br />
integrated as part of the annual development<br />
plan published by the DDCs. The NRCS district<br />
chapter holds orientation meetings with<br />
different district representatives, usually on a<br />
quarterly basis. The NRCS equally participates<br />
in other district meetings, including, for<br />
example, quarterly meetings of the district<br />
health office - which includes reporting of<br />
health posts on <strong>HIV</strong> cases. Community<br />
representatives, district committees and other<br />
organizations participate in the planning<br />
process of projects and are informed with<br />
regard to strategies, work plans, and activities.<br />
Joint workshops included a comprehensive<br />
self-evaluation workshop or workshops to<br />
discuss the issue of sustainability. Information<br />
on project activities is published at public<br />
boards in the districts.<br />
A core approach to all activities is capacity<br />
building through training, supervision and<br />
delegation of responsibilities as it is the case<br />
in the frame of this project with J/YRCCs<br />
and women groups who develop their own<br />
activity plans. The project has further<br />
contributed to increasing capacity at the level<br />
of NRCS sub-chapters, jointly working on<br />
community development plans. This<br />
promotion resulted in an increase of subchapters.<br />
Despite the large network of the<br />
NRCS, distribution of IEC materials and<br />
frequent communication with the subchapters<br />
remains a challenge. Often<br />
community volunteers support the<br />
distribution of IEC materials.<br />
The education sector has traditionally been a<br />
main coordinating partner of the NRCS. A<br />
majority of long term volunteers are teachers<br />
and many of the NRCS programmes use<br />
schools and J/YRCCs as a main link to<br />
communicate with communities. J/YRCCs<br />
are often the first to report any incidences,<br />
needs and emergencies, within communities<br />
to the NRCS support teacher who then<br />
forwards the information to the district<br />
1<br />
Further partners include: South Asia Red Cross/Red Crescent Network on <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> (SARNHA), National Centre for <strong>AIDS</strong> and<br />
STDs control (NCASC), National Youth Co-ordination Council (NYCC), IEC Co-ordination Committee, NGO Coordination<br />
Committee, National NGO’s Networks against <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> Nepal (Nangan).<br />
24<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
chapters. Most of the project activities are<br />
implemented through schools. Using this<br />
institutional network increases sustainability<br />
and facilitates monitoring of project<br />
activities. In addition to teachers and<br />
J/YRCCs the project closely cooperates with<br />
the headmasters of schools. They receive a<br />
one day briefing workshop during the<br />
planning stage of the project and serve then<br />
as main reference persons. District chapters<br />
usually use the yearly district meetings for<br />
headmasters and add one day to discuss the<br />
issue of teaching <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong>. As a result, all sub-chapters and<br />
schools in a district are usually aware about<br />
the NRCS project. As a consequence schools<br />
that were not included felt neglected.<br />
The NRCS has developed a policy on<br />
mainstreaming <strong>HIV</strong> in 2000 and has since<br />
then integrated <strong>HIV</strong> in 3 community based<br />
programmes and 2 first aid programmes.<br />
Activities of J/YRCCs cover different sectors<br />
including community sanitation and hygiene,<br />
health promotion, clean water and<br />
environment, and social and emergency<br />
support. Given that activities on <strong>HIV</strong> will<br />
continue as an integrated part of the agenda<br />
of J/YRCCs, the project has achieved to<br />
mainstream <strong>HIV</strong> prevention work within the<br />
work of the circles.<br />
The project adapts a multisectoral approach<br />
with a focus on the educational and social<br />
development sector and further interventions<br />
in the health and private sectors. At its core<br />
the project is primarily working with<br />
educational institutions and community<br />
volunteers and groups. Some interventions<br />
are targeting the health sector through<br />
promoting youth friendly services and<br />
implementing <strong>HIV</strong> interventions in health<br />
camps. Private sector involvement, though<br />
minimal, includes working with retail<br />
shopkeepers and bus ticket counters.<br />
Overall, the project has strengthened the image<br />
and credibility of the Red Cross at the district<br />
level. Moreover, the NRCS District Chapters<br />
planning capacities' especially with regard to<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> prevention initiatives were strengthened.<br />
One district chapter, for example, has<br />
developed a project proposal to receive<br />
additional funding for its <strong>HIV</strong> programme. The<br />
project has been supported by the different<br />
sectors and their committees in the district,<br />
most of all with regard to the educational<br />
sector. Especially in districts where the NRCS is<br />
the main actor it largely contributed to<br />
initiating and strengthening the DACCs.<br />
Lessons learnt<br />
An effective response to <strong>HIV</strong> needs to come<br />
from within the communities where the<br />
epidemic emerges and begins to spread.<br />
While national strategies, coordinating<br />
mechanisms, monitoring and evaluation<br />
systems are essential they must reach down<br />
to the district and local levels. District and<br />
community authorities are closer to the front<br />
lines of the <strong>AIDS</strong> epidemic than national<br />
governments and they understand local<br />
circumstances, needs, social structures,<br />
attitudes, and traditions. With technical and<br />
financial support district and local authorities<br />
are well placed to implement a locally<br />
effective response to <strong>HIV</strong>. District authorities<br />
further play an important role with regard to<br />
coordination of different responses and<br />
mainstreaming <strong>HIV</strong>.<br />
Lessons from the project include:<br />
• Using the institutional network of schools<br />
increases sustainability and facilitates<br />
monitoring of project activities.<br />
• District chapters and DACCs can play an<br />
important role in designing district <strong>HIV</strong><br />
strategies. Due to their relatively young<br />
existence and yet limited capacities DACCs<br />
have until now mainly a coordinating role.<br />
• The implementation of project very much<br />
depends on the project coordinators at<br />
district chapters. While most district<br />
chapters demonstrated an impressive<br />
commitment to the projects, there is also an<br />
example where project implementation was<br />
jeopardized by poor implementation.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
25
Summary of<br />
Recommendations<br />
• Peer educators need a minimum level of<br />
external support mainly in terms of further<br />
trainings and provision of IEC materials.<br />
Small incentives have a high effect but their<br />
reliability and continuity needs to be assured.<br />
They will otherwise be discouraged if,<br />
despite their initiative, support in terms of<br />
answered questions and provision of IEC<br />
materials is lacking.<br />
• Selection of PE should be participatory and<br />
based on students' preference rather than<br />
teachers' preferences and an effort should be<br />
made for equitable representation from all<br />
groups.<br />
• To increase the capacities of PEs an option<br />
may be to provide further training and some<br />
additional incentive to a selection of active<br />
PEs (2-4 per schools) which in turn have to<br />
initiate certain set of activities. Ideally, these<br />
PEs are selected by the other youth/PEs and<br />
thus have the mandate and trustworthiness<br />
of youth to function as their representatives,<br />
counsellors and role models.<br />
• Women, teachers and youth that work as<br />
peer educators for <strong>HIV</strong> prevention need tools<br />
to do their work and additional IEC materials<br />
that can be used for sensitization are highly<br />
cost-effective.<br />
26<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
• It is essential that teachers are trustworthy<br />
and supportive of the youth. Where feasible,<br />
election of counselling teachers through youth<br />
should be considered. Female teachers can play<br />
an important role as counsellors for girls.<br />
• Women groups do not have the same<br />
institutional links compared to the youth peer<br />
educators and a main concern regards their<br />
level of sustainability. <strong>Health</strong> posts and family<br />
planning volunteers may be used as more<br />
sustainable resource persons to provide<br />
information on <strong>HIV</strong>. However, they<br />
contribute less to reducing barriers and<br />
stigma on issues related to <strong>HIV</strong>. Where<br />
women groups or any other community<br />
groups exist in the frame of other<br />
programmes they may be used to integrate<br />
the issue of <strong>HIV</strong> - provided they bear a<br />
certain level of sustainability.<br />
• Women alone have limited capacity to<br />
inform and involve the men, they feel that<br />
barriers will persist as long as men are not<br />
directly targeted. Both male and female want<br />
the other to know about their concerns. They<br />
therefore welcome a joint training. Involving<br />
men/boys is also important to gain their<br />
support and raise awareness on <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
27
Annex<br />
I Newspaper extracts<br />
Advising husband to use<br />
condom by telephone<br />
Women from Tatarkot village in Parbat<br />
district can now talk freely about <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong><br />
and reproductive health issues even as they<br />
are most backward socially, economically<br />
and academically.<br />
They said they are on a campaign to educate<br />
other community members what they have<br />
learned: those infected with <strong>HIV</strong> need care<br />
and support, women should keep their sex<br />
organs clean and stay away from unsafe sex.<br />
“We did not know why it was important to<br />
keep our sex organs and clothes clean during<br />
the menstruation cycle,” said Dhana Kumari<br />
Bishwakarma, President of Tatarkot<br />
Women’s Group. “We should practise safe<br />
sex, which is possible through using<br />
condoms and family planning methods. We<br />
used to feel shy and hide our face when<br />
somebody talked about these but now we<br />
ourselves talk freely and frankly about sexual<br />
and reproductive health issues.” The change,<br />
according to her, came after Nepal Red Cross<br />
28<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Society provided them with basic knowledge<br />
about <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> and sexual and<br />
reproductive health.<br />
Members of the Tatarkot Women’s Group<br />
have also been advising their spouses –<br />
migrant workers – on the phone to avoid<br />
unsafe sex and use condoms to protect<br />
themselves from <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong>, she said. Many<br />
have written letters to their husbands, who<br />
stay away from the family working abroad.<br />
Women are thankful to the Junior/Youth<br />
Red Cross Circle of Nepal Red Cross Society<br />
for raising awareness through school and<br />
community based peer education project<br />
about <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> and reproductive health.<br />
Another member of the Group, Sushma<br />
Bishwakarma said she had also spoken to her<br />
husband, now working in Qatar, about what<br />
she had learned from the project. “My<br />
husband was amazed listening to what I had<br />
to say and he appreciated for sharing it with<br />
him,” Sushma said. “After the training, I do<br />
not feel ashamed or shy talking about sexual<br />
and reproductive health issues any more.”<br />
Kopila Bishwakarma said of late her husband<br />
had started using condoms during sex.<br />
“Using condom is not just about <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong>,<br />
it also is an effective way to plan family.”<br />
According to Dhana Kumari, a Dalit couple in<br />
the adjoining village had died of <strong>AIDS</strong> related<br />
complications and another adult is suspected<br />
to have been infected with <strong>HIV</strong>. “We are<br />
investigating this. It is difficult to assess the<br />
number of the infected because there is a<br />
tendency of denial.”<br />
Tatarkot is home to about 150 Dalit<br />
households living in extreme poverty with<br />
farm producing barely meeting one quarter<br />
of their food needs. As a result, the Dalit<br />
adults go for employment, where they could<br />
be infected with <strong>HIV</strong> unknowingly. Nepal Red<br />
Cross Society’s Parbat district chapter<br />
implements the <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> and reproductive<br />
health project through 15 Youth Red Cross<br />
Circles and 10 women’s groups formed in<br />
different parts of the district.<br />
NRCS Parbat District Chapter President<br />
Sundar Prasad Joshi said the programme has<br />
had positive impact in school and<br />
communities and has also raised public<br />
awareness about <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> and sexual and<br />
reproductive health.<br />
Headmaster at a local high school in Khurkot<br />
Dronaraj Upadhya said the peer education<br />
approach in school had benefited students,<br />
their parents and the community members.<br />
“It also made students creative and motivated<br />
them to engage in service-oriented activities.”<br />
Teacher sponsor of the same high school<br />
Balkrishna Bastola said that peer education<br />
was very useful and it had not hampered the<br />
students’ study. “Peer education has created<br />
an atmosphere, where students can talk<br />
openly and frankly about sexual education.”<br />
Learning more and the right things about<br />
sex, sexuality and reproductive health issues<br />
will surely help the growing students change<br />
their behaviour in the long run and this will<br />
definitely reduce the risks of <strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong><br />
spread in the future, said another sponsor<br />
teacher Shanta Sharma.<br />
Extracted from Gorkhapatra daily, 19<br />
November 2006<br />
Women gifting condoms to<br />
dear ones<br />
Now their letters contain condoms and safe<br />
sex tips along with other private messages.<br />
Thanks to a campaign undertaken by the Red<br />
Cross, women of this area have become<br />
health conscious and they eagerly share their<br />
knowledge with their husbands and relatives<br />
living abroad, as well as with ignorant locals.<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
29
Under the initiation of District Red Cross, a<br />
group of women from Pang VDC – 7 was<br />
given one year health training.<br />
“The people’s mindset about sexual health<br />
has changed. Unlike earlier, they participated<br />
in discussions related to the subject and feel<br />
comfortable sharing their knowledge with<br />
locals ignorant on the matter,” said Dhan<br />
Kumari BK, chairperson of the group. She<br />
said that women now insist their husbands<br />
and also their relatives and neighbours to use<br />
condoms and have safe sex. “We have also<br />
been aware of safe maternity and benefits of<br />
having few children,” she added.<br />
“Now it has been our habit to write about<br />
sexual health to our husbands who are<br />
away from home. We worry that they<br />
might get infected with <strong>HIV</strong> as they are<br />
ignorant about the disease,” said Laxmi<br />
Sunuwar, a member of the group.<br />
“Hesitation to learn and confess problems<br />
does not solve any problem. One has to get<br />
the knowledge and implement that in life,”<br />
she added.<br />
Extracted from The Kathmandu Post, 16<br />
November 2006.<br />
II Question Guide<br />
Questions to Youth circles/ Peer<br />
Educators<br />
We would like to learn more about how this<br />
programme works, from your own personal<br />
perspective as young people. The<br />
information you share will be anonymous, so<br />
that none of the material we discuss will be<br />
linked with any individual. Let's start with<br />
some of the basic information about the<br />
programme and the steps you are involved<br />
in. WITH EVERY ANSWER, THINK OF<br />
HOW ANYTHING HAS CHANGED IN THE<br />
LAST YEARS BECAUSE OF THE PROJECT.<br />
The main objective of these questions is to<br />
find out how far the project contributed to<br />
behaviour change in terms of improved life<br />
skills. We will look at how far motivation,<br />
engagement, attitudes, interaction and<br />
communication between youth and adults,<br />
etc. have changed. We will further look at<br />
how far the management capacity of the<br />
youth circles have improved and how far<br />
gender roles are addressed.<br />
Life Skills development/ Behaviour<br />
Change<br />
• Describe the programme's goals and<br />
activities: What activities do you do<br />
30<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
specifically? Describe in some detail the<br />
different steps of activities you were involved<br />
in (selection process, training, activities,<br />
etc.).<br />
• Which activities did you enjoy most<br />
while implementing them? Why?<br />
• At which activities were participants<br />
most lively? Why?<br />
• What do you think attracted the most<br />
participant? How many?<br />
• Which activities do you think are most<br />
popular? Why?<br />
• Which are the topics youth are most<br />
interested in?<br />
• To how many people do you talk on<br />
issues related to <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> on average<br />
(f.e. per week)?<br />
• What are the greatest challenges for your<br />
work? What would you like to do<br />
differently? What is it that motivates or does<br />
not motivate you in your work?<br />
• Which parts of the training did you find<br />
most useful?<br />
• How did you become peer educators?<br />
Probe: What are reasons for joining (such<br />
as: a way to spend free time, possibility to
meet friends, better position in front of<br />
adults and teachers, pressure from teachers<br />
the community). Please give your reasons<br />
starting with the most important ones.<br />
• How has the work affected you personally<br />
(for example, position in the community,<br />
friends, future plans)?<br />
• Has your private life and your friendships<br />
changed in relation with your PE work? How<br />
often and in what way do you interact with<br />
your PE colleagues?<br />
• Were there discussions with your friends<br />
or others after attending sessions? If so,<br />
with whom and what were they about?<br />
• Have you talked about things related to<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> prevention outside of school? Were<br />
there any activities related to your work as a<br />
PE outside of school? Where and with<br />
whom?<br />
• Did participants stay in contact or come<br />
back with questions? (details) If the same<br />
youth attended different activities, did you<br />
notice a change in her/ his participation<br />
during sessions? (if so, detail some case<br />
studies from boys and girls)<br />
• To discuss about issues such as sexuality<br />
is quite a challenge. What do you think<br />
works best to introduce and discuss the<br />
subject? How do discussions often look like -<br />
when are they more lively and less lively?<br />
How did the programme help you to address<br />
the issue?<br />
• It is even more difficult to talk about these<br />
issues to the opposite gender. What is your<br />
experience of talking to classes with both girls<br />
and boys as well as different age groups?<br />
How comfortable do you feel about it?<br />
• Most of the youth today know how to<br />
protect themselves from <strong>HIV</strong>. But there are<br />
many reasons why doing so is always<br />
difficult. If you think of yours or your friend's<br />
experiences, what was most helpful to make<br />
protection easier? Was there anything that<br />
made it easier (over time)?<br />
• Do you know anybody living with <strong>HIV</strong>?<br />
What has been her/ his story? Does he/ she<br />
has friends and supporters?<br />
• There are many reasons why being<br />
supportive to PLWA can be difficult. It may<br />
not be accepted by our friends and family<br />
and we may not know what to do. What is<br />
your experience?<br />
• Do your parents support your<br />
involvement? How?<br />
• Issues related to family planning, <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention, etc. are often not at all talked<br />
about in families. What is your experience?<br />
Which topics are more common, which are<br />
less? Who do you normally talk to? Who<br />
would you normally not talk to?<br />
• The conflict increased the number of<br />
displaced and/ or out of school youth. Has<br />
this affected your activities?<br />
• How much interaction is there between inschool<br />
and out- of school youth? Has this<br />
changed during conflict?<br />
Management, cooperation and decision<br />
making capacity of Youth circles/ PEs:<br />
• Describe how the peer educators are<br />
involved in programme planning, training,<br />
activities, materials development, and<br />
decision-making.<br />
• What kind of administrative tools do you<br />
use? (Reports, record system, meeting<br />
minutes, reviews, etc.) Do you use some of<br />
them because of the project?<br />
• What type of adult support do you receive<br />
in your work? Probe: (in terms of<br />
supervision, technical support, emotional<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
31
support.) Do you think there is a youth-adult<br />
partnership in the programme? How would<br />
you describe the quality of the partnerships?<br />
• Describe how decisions are made in the<br />
programme. Probe: Who decides what<br />
activities to carry out? Who decides the<br />
content of these activities and the<br />
information materials used? Who decides<br />
programme planning and strategies?<br />
• Can you make suggestions? Are your<br />
suggestions and ideas taken seriously? What<br />
would you do to improve the decisionmaking<br />
process?<br />
Gender equity and equality<br />
• How are responsibilities and decisionmaking<br />
distributed between female and male<br />
PEs?<br />
• Describe how the programme addresses<br />
gender issues in the training and during<br />
programme activities.<br />
• What are the gender dynamics during<br />
sessions:<br />
• How often do girls say sth. during the<br />
sessions compared to boys?<br />
• Do girls or boys sometimes receive<br />
more or less attention by their friends during<br />
discussions? When may this be the case?<br />
• Are there activities where boys and girls<br />
are more interacting, more distant, more<br />
arguing, more agreeing, etc?<br />
• Describe favourite topics of girls and<br />
favourite topics of boys.<br />
• Are there discussions about gender roles<br />
during activities? How may the issue usually<br />
come up? What are main subjects of<br />
discussion? How often does this happen?<br />
• As a male/ female PE, how do you address<br />
issues of your own gender? Do peers of your<br />
own gender approach you to ask more<br />
private questions?<br />
Social equity<br />
• How are responsibilities and decisionmaking<br />
distributed between PEs of different<br />
castes?<br />
• Among the PEs, are there sub-groups with<br />
preference to their own castes? When and<br />
how are they all mixed?<br />
• What are the dynamics between different<br />
castes during sessions:<br />
• How often do students from lower<br />
castes say sth. during the sessions compared<br />
students form higher castes?<br />
• Do students from different castes<br />
receive more or less attention during<br />
discussions? How much interaction is there<br />
during lessons between students from<br />
different castes?<br />
Coordination with other initiatives:<br />
• Describe what the DACC and any other<br />
organization is doing on <strong>HIV</strong> (including care<br />
and support) in your district. How do they<br />
compare to the NRCS? Do you cooperate or<br />
are you supported by anybody?<br />
• What type of direct support does the<br />
community provide to the programme?<br />
Questions to Teacher sponsors<br />
We would like to learn more about how this<br />
programme works, from your own personal<br />
perspective. The information you share will<br />
be anonymous, so that none of the material<br />
we discuss will be linked with any individual.<br />
Let's start with some of the basic information<br />
about the programme and the steps you are<br />
involved in it. WITH EVERY ANSWER,<br />
THINK OF HOW ANYTHING HAS<br />
CHANGED BECAUSE OF THE PROJECT.<br />
We investigate how far the capacity of<br />
teachers to address issues of Sexual and<br />
<strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> (SRH) in classes has<br />
changed. We will further ask how far they<br />
think there have been any changes at the level<br />
of students and the community.<br />
32<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Teaching skills/ Behaviour Change<br />
• Describe the programme's goals and<br />
activities: What activities do you do<br />
specifically? Describe in some detail the<br />
different steps of activities you were involved<br />
in (selection process, training, activities,<br />
etc.).<br />
• Which activities did you enjoy most<br />
while implementing them? Why?<br />
• At which activities were participants<br />
most lively? Why?<br />
• What do you think attracted the most<br />
participant? When was this?<br />
• Which activities do you think are most<br />
popular?<br />
• Which are the topics youth are most<br />
interested in?<br />
• What are the greatest challenges for your<br />
work? What would you like to do<br />
differently? What is it that motivates or does<br />
not motivate you in your work?<br />
• How are teachers selected for the training?<br />
From which subjects? Which teachers do<br />
you think are best suited for teaching <strong>HIV</strong><br />
prevention?<br />
• Which parts of the training did you find<br />
most useful?<br />
• How has the work affected you personally<br />
(f.e. position in the community, your<br />
teaching capacities, your relation to the<br />
students)?<br />
• How active are students with questions?<br />
(details) If the same youth attended different<br />
activities, did you notice a change in her/ his<br />
participation during sessions? (if so, detail<br />
some case studies from boys and girls)<br />
• To discuss about issues such as sexuality<br />
is quite a challenge. What do you think<br />
works best to introduce and discuss the<br />
subject? How do discussions often look like -<br />
when are they more lively and less lively?<br />
How did the programme help you to address<br />
the issue?<br />
• Did you notice any impact of the training<br />
on your general teaching skills?<br />
• Do you know anybody living with <strong>HIV</strong>?<br />
What has been her/ his story? Does he/ she<br />
has friends and supporters?<br />
• There are many reasons why being<br />
supportive to PLWA can be difficult. It may<br />
not be accepted by our friends and family<br />
and we may not know what to do. What is<br />
your experience? Do you know any cases of<br />
PLWHA? What is their story?<br />
• Did you notice a change in attitude in the<br />
communities and among youth to discuss<br />
issues related to Sexual and <strong>Reproductive</strong><br />
<strong>Health</strong>?<br />
Management, cooperation and decision<br />
making capacity of Youth circles/ PEs<br />
• Describe how the youth circles/ peer<br />
educators are involved in programme<br />
planning, training, activities, materials<br />
development, and decision-making.<br />
• What kind of administrative tools do you<br />
use? (Reports, record system, meeting<br />
minutes, reviews, etc.) Do you use some of<br />
them because of the project?<br />
• What type of adult support do they<br />
receive? Probe: (in terms of supervision,<br />
technical support, emotional support.) Do<br />
you think there is a youth-adult partnership<br />
in the programme? How would you describe<br />
the quality of the partnerships?<br />
• Describe how decisions are made in the<br />
programme. Probe: Who decides what<br />
activities to carry out? Who decides the<br />
content of these activities and the<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
33
information materials used? Who decides<br />
programme planning and strategies?<br />
Gender equity and equality<br />
• How are responsibilities and decisionmaking<br />
distributed between female and male<br />
PEs?<br />
• Describe how the programme addresses<br />
gender issues in the training and during<br />
programme activities.<br />
• What are the gender dynamics during<br />
sessions:<br />
• How often do girls say sth. during the<br />
sessions compared to boys?<br />
• Do girls or boys sometimes receive<br />
more or less attention by their friends during<br />
discussions? When may this be the case?<br />
• Are there activities where boys and girls<br />
are more interacting, more distant, more<br />
arguing, more agreeing, etc?<br />
• Describe favourite topics of girls and<br />
favourite topics of boys.<br />
• Are there discussions about gender roles<br />
during activities? How may the issue<br />
usually come up? What are main subjects<br />
of discussion? How often does this<br />
happen?<br />
Social equity<br />
• How are responsibilities and decisionmaking<br />
distributed between PEs of different<br />
castes?<br />
• Among the PEs, are there sub-groups with<br />
preference to their own castes? When and<br />
how are they all mixed?<br />
• What are the dynamics between different<br />
castes during sessions:<br />
• How often do students from lower<br />
castes say sth. during the sessions compared<br />
students form higher castes?<br />
• Do students from different castes<br />
receive more or less attention during<br />
discussions? How much interaction is there<br />
during lessons between students from<br />
different castes?<br />
Coordination with other initiatives:<br />
• How far does the School management<br />
committee influence the issue of teaching of<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> at school?<br />
• Describe what the DACC and any other<br />
organization is doing on <strong>HIV</strong> (including care<br />
and support) in your district. How do they<br />
compare to the NRCS? Do you cooperate or<br />
are you supported by anybody?<br />
• What type of direct support does the<br />
community provide to the programme?<br />
Questions to DACC, headmasters and<br />
other stakeholders involved in the<br />
programme<br />
We would like to learn more about how this<br />
programme works, from your own<br />
perspective. The information you share will<br />
be anonymous, so that none of the material<br />
we discuss will be linked with any individual.<br />
Let's start with some of the basic information<br />
about the programme and the steps you are<br />
involved in. WITH EVERY ANSWER, THINK<br />
OF HOW ANYTHING HAS CHANGED IN<br />
THE LAST YEARS BECAUSE OF THE<br />
PROJECT.<br />
• Describe your relationship to the<br />
programme. In what ways do you support<br />
the programme?<br />
• What are the activities the NRCS is<br />
carrying out that you are aware of?<br />
• Which activities were most popular in the<br />
community?<br />
• What are the main achievements of the<br />
programme? Can you think of sth. that may<br />
be done in a different way?<br />
34<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
• Suppose the NRCS initiatives would stop -<br />
what do you think would happen with regard<br />
to <strong>HIV</strong> and youth activities in the respective<br />
schools and communities?<br />
• Are there other organizations in the field of<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> and youth? What do they do? If you<br />
compare them with the NRCS, what are<br />
differences?<br />
• What is your experience of working with<br />
NRCS staff? What are their qualities?<br />
(examples need to be specified, i.e. with<br />
regard to planning, implementation)<br />
Addressing Behaviour change:<br />
• Did you notice any change in what people<br />
do or say because of the NRCS activities?<br />
(Please describe the kind of change, whom it<br />
affects, when it took place, if it was more<br />
during certain periods and by whom or what<br />
it was caused).<br />
• Anything you do now (with regard to your<br />
management/ your engagement) you did not<br />
do before the activities?<br />
Questions to women group members<br />
We would like to learn more about how your<br />
programme works, from your own personal<br />
perspective. The information you share will<br />
be anonymous, so that none of the material<br />
we discuss will be linked with any individual.<br />
Let's start with some of the basic information<br />
about the programme and the steps you are<br />
involved in it. WITH EVERY ANSWER,<br />
THINK OF HOW ANYTHING HAS<br />
CHANGED IN THE LAST YEARS BECAUSE<br />
OF THE PROJECT.<br />
• Describe how your women group is<br />
structured:<br />
• How many women are participating?<br />
• Did you knew each other before?<br />
• Do members come from different age<br />
groups and castes?<br />
• What are the active and the less active<br />
members (different ages and castes)<br />
• Is the number changing? Who is<br />
coming and leaving?<br />
• Describe your meetings:<br />
• How often do you meet?<br />
• What are your activities?<br />
• What kind of support do you receive?<br />
• What are your reasons for joining the<br />
group? Which aspects of the women group<br />
do you enjoy or appreciate most? What is<br />
needed so that the women group stays<br />
active and interesting to you? Are there<br />
links with other women groups?<br />
• Did you talk with your partner or others<br />
about the group? With whom and what do<br />
you talk about? (for example, do you<br />
practice any letter writing to partners living<br />
abroad)<br />
• Did anything changed for you because of<br />
the women' group?<br />
• If you would have a question related to<br />
SRH, whom would you address?<br />
• What do you think of youth receiving <strong>HIV</strong><br />
education at school? (If positive: Did you<br />
think like this before)<br />
• Thinking of all IEC materials on <strong>HIV</strong>,<br />
which one did you like most?<br />
• Do you know anybody living with <strong>HIV</strong>?<br />
What has been her/ his story? Does he/<br />
she has friends and supporters?<br />
• There are many reasons why being<br />
supportive to PLWA can be difficult. It may<br />
not be accepted by our friends and family<br />
and we may not know what to do. What is<br />
your experience?<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007<br />
35
III <strong>Project</strong> documents and consulted literature<br />
<strong>Project</strong> documents:<br />
• Credit Proposal<br />
• <strong>Project</strong> documents<br />
• Yearly Plans of Operations and Progress<br />
Reports<br />
• IEC materials and trainers' manual<br />
• Report of previous evaluations of this<br />
programme<br />
• Publications, plans and policies of NRCS<br />
NCASC (2000), Country profile, The <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>AIDS</strong>/STD situation and the national<br />
response in Nepal, UN<strong>AIDS</strong>/HMG<br />
(NCASC), Kathmandu<br />
NRCS (2001), <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> prevention<br />
<strong>Project</strong>, Annual Report 2001, Nepal Red<br />
Cross, Junior Youth Department NHQs,<br />
Kathmandu<br />
NRCS (2002), A report on Self Evaluation of<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> & RH Programme<br />
of four Districts (internal document).<br />
NRCS (May 2002), <strong>Project</strong> Document <strong>HIV</strong><br />
and <strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> Programme July 2000-<br />
June 2003, Kathmandu Nepal<br />
NRCS (October 2000), A Study on<br />
Knowledge, Attitude and Practice concerning<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> STDs and RH among the<br />
Adolescent/youth of sis Districts: Baglung,<br />
Parbat, Bhaktapur, Dolakha, Ramechhap and<br />
Sindhuli - base line survey report, Nepal Red<br />
Cross Society, Kathmandu<br />
Sharma, Komal, (2003), Situation Analysis<br />
of Children and <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> in Nepal, Save<br />
The Children, Kathmandu, Nepal<br />
Sharma, M. Gautam, I. (2003), External<br />
Evaluation of the <strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong><br />
and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong>. NRCS, SDC.<br />
Sharma, M. (2002), Youth for Each Other<br />
Programme, A Participatory Baseline Study<br />
of youth of Balkot and Thimi, CEDPA/Nepal<br />
Red Cross Society.<br />
UNDP, (2004) From Involvement to<br />
Empowerment: People Living with <strong>HIV</strong> and<br />
<strong>AIDS</strong> in the Asia Pacific.<br />
36<br />
CAPITALIZATION STUDY<br />
<strong>HIV</strong>/<strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and <strong>Reproductive</strong> <strong>Health</strong> <strong>Project</strong><br />
NRCS/SDC 2000-2007
Nepal Red Cross Society<br />
National Headquarters<br />
Junior/Youth Red Cross Department<br />
<strong>HIV</strong> and <strong>AIDS</strong> <strong>Prevention</strong> and RH Programme<br />
P.O.Box: 217 Red Cross Marga, Kalimati, Kathmandu<br />
Phone No: 977-1-4270650, 971-1-4272761<br />
Fax: 971-4271915<br />
Email: hivaids@nrcs.org<br />
http://www.nrcs.org