Corporate Governance Compliance Report - Zorlu Enerji
Corporate Governance Compliance Report - Zorlu Enerji
Corporate Governance Compliance Report - Zorlu Enerji
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong><br />
<strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
CONTENTS<br />
1- Declaration of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management<br />
SECTION I- SHAREHOLDERS<br />
2- Department of Relations with Shareholders<br />
3- Utilization of Shareholders Right of Getting Information<br />
4- Information about the General Board Meeting of Shareholders<br />
5- Voting and Minority Rights<br />
6- Profit Distribution Policy and Time for Profit Distribution<br />
7- Assignment of Shares<br />
SECTION II- INFORMING THE PUBLIC AND TRANSPARENCY<br />
8- Company Policy for Releasing Information<br />
9- Announcements About Special Situation<br />
10- Company Website and Contents<br />
11- Announcement of the Real Person Final Dominant Shareholder, Right Holder<br />
12- Disclosure to the Public the Names of Persons that may have insider trading information<br />
SECTION III- BENEFICIARIES<br />
13- Informing the Beneficiaries<br />
14- Beneficiaries’ Contribution to Administration<br />
15- Human Resources Policy<br />
16- Information about Relations with Customers and Suppliers<br />
17- Social Responsibility<br />
SECTION IV- BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />
18- Structure of the Board of Directors, its Constitution and Independent Members<br />
19- Attributes of Board of Directors Members<br />
20- Mission, Vision and Strategic Goals of the Company<br />
21- Risk Management and Internal Control Mechanisms<br />
22- Authorities and Responsibilities of Board of Directors Members<br />
23- Principals of Activity for Members of Board of Directors<br />
24- Conducting Business with the Company and Rule of Competition<br />
25- Rules of Ethic<br />
26- The Number, Structure and Independence of Committees Established in the Board of Directors<br />
27- Financial Rights Granted to the Board of Directors<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong> 29
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
1- Declaration of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. is at the stage of<br />
completion of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management mechanisms<br />
in the company, started in 2005 and implemented in<br />
the concept of Conformity with Principles of<br />
<strong>Corporate</strong> Management. In this declaration, there are<br />
information about the conformity level of the<br />
company to these principles, and subjects that are<br />
not in conformity.<br />
In order to perform its liabilities to corporate and<br />
individual shareholders, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim<br />
A.fi. has decided to implement the Principles of<br />
<strong>Corporate</strong> Management. During the works done,<br />
great amount of effort is used in order to conform to<br />
the Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management, all<br />
administrative staff and employees believed in<br />
necessity of implementing these principles at all levels<br />
of activities, and they worked together with the<br />
principles of transparency, equality, responsibility and<br />
accountability. Following the adaptation of Principles<br />
of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management to the company,<br />
<strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Report</strong> stating that the<br />
company activities will be performed in conformity to<br />
principles of transparency, equality, responsibility and<br />
accountability has been disclosed to public. Through<br />
the previous works done and its determination about<br />
conforming the Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. has shown its<br />
awareness for company’s responsibilities to all<br />
shareholders, without the consideration of the<br />
amount of shares held.<br />
In this declaration, together with the conformity to<br />
Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management of SPK (Capital<br />
Markets Committee), the subjects that are not in<br />
conformity with the principles are explained with the<br />
reasons. The works done in <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik<br />
Üretim A.fi. for the implementation of Principles of<br />
<strong>Corporate</strong> Management are as follows:<br />
In order to increase the effectiveness of Board of<br />
Directors, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi.<br />
implemented some arrangements through the<br />
Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management. By means of<br />
these arrangements, two independent members<br />
assigned to take part in the Board of Directors and<br />
the Board is structured in conformity with Principles<br />
of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management.<br />
In order to perform the Board of Directors meetings<br />
in an organized way, to keep and to archive the<br />
minutes of meetings and to allow easy access by<br />
Members to company information, a secretariat<br />
connected with the Board of Directors has been<br />
formed.<br />
In order to organize the relations with the investors,<br />
an “Investor Relations Department” has been formed<br />
in the company, as well as the responsibility of any<br />
publicized information, responsibility of the website<br />
has been given to this department.<br />
Company policy for releasing information has been<br />
prepared written and presented to attendants in<br />
General Meeting.<br />
Website has been recreated in conformity with the<br />
Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management.<br />
Scheduled General Meeting held on May 16, 2006,<br />
Main Contract of the company has been amended in<br />
accordance to Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management,<br />
with the acceptance of the majority of shareholders.<br />
The outlines of amendments made on Company’s<br />
Main Contract are as follows:<br />
• New rights are entitled to the minority shareholders, the rate of<br />
10% of the capital stated in Turkish Trade Law for<br />
representation of minor share holders has been changed, and<br />
in accordance to the article 11 of Law of Capital Markets<br />
amended by law no.4487, “minority shareholders rights are<br />
used by shareholders representing the minimum 1/20 of the<br />
paid capital of the Company” has been added to main<br />
contract (Article 20).<br />
• Shareholders representing minimum of 1/20 of company<br />
capital are entitled with the right of calling Board of Directors<br />
Meeting, by means of a written summon stating the reason of<br />
call (Article 9).<br />
• An article stating, “the transfer of company shares is<br />
unrestricted” has been added to the Main Contract of the<br />
Company (Article 21).<br />
• The subject of disclosure of the reasons of the independent<br />
members’ negative votes in Board of Directors has been<br />
regulated in the Main Contract (Article 9).<br />
30 <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong>
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
• The subject of assigning independent members of Board of<br />
Directors has been added to main contract as “the number of<br />
independent members will be 1/3 of total members of board,<br />
but not less than 2” (Article 7).<br />
• The decision about the subject that the majority of the<br />
Members of the Board of Directors will not take part of<br />
execution, and different persons will perform duties of<br />
Chairmanship and Executive Chairmanship has been added to<br />
the Main Contract. Also, the principle of age limit for Member,<br />
which is not one of the Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management of<br />
CMC (Capital Markets Committee), however, one of the<br />
principles recognized internationally, has been started being<br />
implemented by the company and this subject also has been<br />
added to the main contract (Article 7).<br />
• In accordance to Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management, the<br />
subject of monthly wages of independent members of Board<br />
of Directors assigned, or, the subject that their welfare rights<br />
are not going to affect their independency has been added to<br />
the Main Contract (Article 12).<br />
• The subject that the permissions for Members’ right of<br />
conducting business and competition granted by the General<br />
Board Meeting of Shareholders can only be granted with the<br />
approval of the 2/3 majority of shareholders attended to the<br />
General Board Meeting of Shareholders has been added to<br />
the Main Contract (Article 13).<br />
• Committees connected with the Board of Directors and<br />
regulations about these committees have been added to the<br />
Main Contract (Article 13A)<br />
• General Board Meeting of Shareholders will elect two company<br />
auditors out of shareholders or people nominated by the<br />
shareholders, for maximum three years, and, the General<br />
Board Meeting of Shareholders will determine their salaries;<br />
this subject has been added to the Main Contract. Also,<br />
shareholders representing the 5% of the public shares of the<br />
Company can request from General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders to assign special auditor for investigation of a<br />
specific financial situation. In case that request is rejected by<br />
the General Board Meeting of Shareholders, shareholders<br />
representing the 1/20 of Company capital will have the right to<br />
go to the competent court with the request of assigning an<br />
auditor to investigate the specific situation and reach a result;<br />
this subject is clearly stated in the Main Contract (Article 14).<br />
• The subject that the company’s annual financial reports and<br />
other interval reports required by Capital Markets Regulations<br />
are to be audited by an independent audition firm approved by<br />
General Board Meeting of Shareholders and company can<br />
work maximum five consecutive fiscal years with the same<br />
independent audition firm has been added to the Main<br />
Contract of the Company (Article 15A).<br />
• The subject that other assigned shareholders or persons out of<br />
shareholders at General Board Meeting of Shareholders can<br />
represent the shareholders is stated in the Main Contract. The<br />
subject that the type of Authorization Document for<br />
Representation and implementation in accordance to Capital<br />
Markets Committee regulations will be based on Board of<br />
Directors decision has been stated in the Main Contract<br />
(Article 19).<br />
• In order to encourage and increase the attendance to General<br />
Board Meeting of Shareholders, it has been decided that an<br />
announcement should be made three weeks prior to the<br />
Meeting and this subject is stated in the Main Contract. Also,<br />
together with this announcement, information and documents<br />
related to the agenda should be provided in company center,<br />
branches and should be informed to the public (Article 23).<br />
During the process of implementing Principles of<br />
<strong>Corporate</strong> Management, some principles that don’t<br />
match with the Company structure and some that<br />
may have negative effects on activities are not<br />
applied. Respective principles and reasons for no<br />
implementation are summarized below:<br />
Accumulated vote implementation: Company does<br />
not apply the method of accumulated vote. However,<br />
by means of the independent members in the Board<br />
of Directors representation that can be achieved by<br />
accumulated vote method is provided.<br />
In the Main Contract, any amendment about some<br />
important subjects, such as “division and transfer of<br />
shares, purchase/sale of tangible/intangible assets at<br />
high value, rent to/from such, transfer of any<br />
immovable by method of donation or issuing bail, lien<br />
for the benefit of third parties” are not made. The<br />
reason of that is the Company makes lots of<br />
sale/purchase and rent because of the nature of the<br />
business sector, which the Company is in. Since that<br />
will not be possible for General Meeting of Board of<br />
Shareholders to get together for each conduct, this<br />
subject was not added to Main Contract. In order to<br />
accelerate the business transactions and avoid<br />
missing the opportunities, this subject is not placed in<br />
the Main Contract.<br />
With this declaration, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> adopts a method of<br />
transparent and open management, and targets to<br />
form a responsible, accountable method of<br />
management for all its shareholders especially for the<br />
minority shareholders.<br />
Improvements that will be done in time in accordance<br />
to Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management will be<br />
disclosed on Company’s website.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong> 31
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
SECTION I – Shareholders<br />
2- Department of Relations with Shareholders<br />
By making the plan of forming Department of<br />
Relations with Shareholders real, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik<br />
Üretim A.fi., has formed Department of Relations<br />
with Shareholders in 2006 as one step of the project<br />
of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management started in 2005.<br />
In managerial unit formed in 2006 to follow the<br />
activities related to investors, Fatih Y›lmaz is on duty,<br />
investors can get all kind of information about the<br />
company through phone lines: 0212 4562300, 0212<br />
4562196, 0212 4562199 as well as the company’s<br />
website, also by sending an email to<br />
yatirimci@zoren.com.tr.<br />
In this period, 30 questions by email and 80<br />
questions by phone are directed to the department.<br />
All the questions asked are replied meticulously<br />
verbal and/or written, in consideration of policy of<br />
giving information and following the principles of<br />
confidentiality.<br />
3- Utilization of Shareholders Right of Getting<br />
Information<br />
In 2006, 110 requests for information were received<br />
by <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Accounting Department, and all are<br />
replied in details. Details about the number of<br />
requests received are as follows:<br />
Request of Information by Number<br />
E-Mail 30<br />
Fax -<br />
Mail -<br />
Telephone 80<br />
Total 110<br />
In 2006, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Department of Relations with<br />
Investors replied all 110 requests for information in<br />
details. 90% of the requests received by the<br />
department were about activities and financial<br />
performance of the Company, 10% were about<br />
investments, changes in share values, information<br />
about General Board Meeting of Shareholders, etc. In<br />
order to present most possible information in shortest<br />
time, correct, fast, complete and in an understandable<br />
way to investors, Company reorganized its website.<br />
Special attention is given to Website including detailed<br />
information in accordance to investors’ right of being<br />
informed, also all subjects covered in Capital Markets<br />
Committee Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management are<br />
presented in company’s website.<br />
At the year 2006 Periodic General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders, the amended article of Main Contract<br />
about assigning a special auditor is as “Shareholders<br />
representing the 5% of the public shares of the<br />
Company may request from General Board Meeting<br />
of Shareholders to assign special auditor for<br />
investigation of a specific financial situation. In case<br />
that request is rejected by the General Board Meeting<br />
of Shareholders, shareholders representing the 1/20<br />
of Company capital will have the right to go to the<br />
competent court with the request of assigning an<br />
auditor to investigate the specific situation and reach<br />
a result”; in this period, there was no request for<br />
assigning a special auditor.<br />
4- Information about the General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders<br />
For year 2005, Periodic General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders has been held in Bursa Organized<br />
Industrial Zone on May 16, 2006 at 13:00 o’clock.<br />
Invitation for the meeting has been done in time in<br />
accordance to the related laws and as stated in the<br />
Main Contract, call for the meeting including the<br />
agenda has been published in Turkish Trade Registry<br />
Journal no.6546, dated 01.05.2006, Dünya<br />
Newspaper dated 02.05.2006 and Bursa Hakimiyet<br />
Newspaper dated 02.05.2006; shareholders which<br />
have issued stocks on their name and shareholders<br />
which has bearers bond, who have their addresses in<br />
the records are informed by registered letters.<br />
Although the General Board Meeting of Shareholders<br />
is open to public and media, beneficiaries and media<br />
did not attend the meeting.<br />
54.790.835.990 YTL of the company capital<br />
representing 5.479.083.599 shares, representing 67%<br />
of total 8.166.535.000 shares equal to 81.665.350<br />
YTL of company capital, 4.662.430.099 acting as<br />
32 <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong>
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
principal, out of 816.635.500 Group A issued on<br />
name and 7.349.881.500 Group B issued on name<br />
has been represented in the meeting. General Board<br />
Meeting of Shareholders was held with 67% of<br />
attendance. There was no vote used by<br />
representatives.<br />
In order to assure the attendance of the shareholders<br />
bearing registered shares, no time for registering in<br />
book of shares is determined.<br />
Before the General Board Meeting of Shareholders,<br />
annual report and financial reports were kept ready<br />
for shareholders, at the company and holding center.<br />
Company Main Contract is also provided for<br />
requesting investors. Company’s Main Contract and<br />
documents regarding to General Board of<br />
Shareholders can also be provided at<br />
www.zoren.com.tr.<br />
During the General Board Meeting of Shareholders,<br />
shareholders are given right to ask questions. All<br />
questions asked by shareholders are answered in<br />
details.<br />
to beneficiaries and media.<br />
The minutes of General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders kept at the Company and Holding<br />
Center for shareholders’ inspection. With the new<br />
updates in company’s website, all announcements<br />
and documents regarding General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders are provided for informing all<br />
shareholders and beneficiaries.<br />
5- Voting and Minority Rights<br />
All shares of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. contain<br />
equal rights. There are no privileges regarding right of<br />
voting and share of profit. This subject also exists in<br />
Company’s Main Contract.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri ‹nflaat Ticaret A.fi.,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri ‹flletme ve Bak›m Hizmetleri<br />
A.fi., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas Petrol, Gaz ve Petrokimya Ürünl.<br />
‹nfl. San. ve Tic. A.fi., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si ‹thalat<br />
‹hracat ve Toptan Tic. A.fi., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Do¤algaz ‹thalat<br />
‹hracat ve Toptan Tic. A.fi., Trakya Bölgesi Do¤algaz<br />
Da¤›t›m A.fi., Gazdafl Gaziantep Do¤algaz Da¤›t›m<br />
A.fi, which are partners of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim<br />
A.fi.’ have no shares in the Company.<br />
Shareholders did not present any proposals or offers<br />
regarding to Company’s business.<br />
In the Main Contract, there is no article stating that<br />
General Board Meeting of Shareholders makes<br />
decision about “division and transfer of shares,<br />
purchase/sale of assets at high value, rent to/from<br />
such”. The reason is the Company makes lots of<br />
sale/purchase and rent because of the nature of the<br />
business sector, which the Company is in. It will not be<br />
possible for General Meeting of Board of Shareholders<br />
to get together to make a decision for each conduct of<br />
purchasing, buying or renting. Therefore, this subject<br />
did not take place in the Main Contract.<br />
Assigned two independent members in the Board of<br />
Directors represent minority shares. Since the<br />
independent members of the Board of Directors are<br />
qualified to execute their duties without being under<br />
any pressure, all rights of shareholders including the<br />
ones holding minority shares are protected and<br />
represented equally in the Board of Directors.<br />
Company does not apply accumulated voting<br />
method. However, by means of the independent<br />
members in of the Board of Directors, representation,<br />
which can be provided by accumulated voting<br />
method, can also be obtained.<br />
Since all the shares of the company are registered on<br />
names, meeting invitation, agenda and other<br />
information regarding to the agenda has been sent to<br />
all shareholders. Also, announcement for the meeting<br />
was publicized in Dünya and Bursa Hakimiyet<br />
Newspapers, in order to inform the investors. General<br />
Board Meeting of Shareholders has been held open<br />
6- Profit Distribution Policy and Time for Profit<br />
Distribution<br />
Regarding to profit distribution, there are no<br />
privileged shares in Company. Each share of<br />
Company has equal amount of profit share.<br />
The proposal about the profit of 2005 stated in<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong> 33
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
General Board Meeting of Shareholders’ agenda<br />
(Article 8) has been explained to attendants and<br />
accepted in General Board Meeting of Shareholder<br />
unanimously.<br />
The results of year 2005 are 4.448.346 YTL<br />
consolidated net profit and 33.590.146 YTL loss<br />
according to records held in accordance to tax laws<br />
applied, since it is stated in decision, no. 7/242,<br />
dated 25.02.2005, of Capital Markets Committee that<br />
if financial tables prepared according to Capital<br />
Markets Committee or legal records shows loss in<br />
any fiscal period, company do not perform a<br />
distribution of profit, therefore, company did not<br />
perform a distribution of profit, since the company’s<br />
legal records are closed with loss for the year 2005.<br />
7- Assignment of Shares<br />
In the Main Contract of the Company, there is no<br />
regulation limiting the assignment of shares. The<br />
statement “Assignment of shares is permitted with<br />
the condition of compliance to Turkish Trade Law<br />
regulations of, Capital Markets Committee and<br />
Energy Market Regulation Committee and Main<br />
Contract of the Company” constitutes the Article 6 of<br />
the Main Contract.<br />
SECTION II- Informing the Public and Transparency<br />
8- Company Policy for Releasing Information<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi.’s Company Policy for<br />
Releasing Information has been formed around the<br />
Capital Markets Committee Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong><br />
Management in 2005, and, during the 2006 Periodic<br />
General Board Meeting of Shareholders, presented to<br />
the investors as an attachment to the Annual <strong>Report</strong>.<br />
Company Policy for Releasing Information is also<br />
presented to public through company’s website.<br />
The contents of the Policy for Releasing Information<br />
are as follows:<br />
• Any information disclosed to public should be clear, isochronal<br />
and correct<br />
• Contents of the information to be disclosed to public<br />
• Frequency of public disclosures and media<br />
• Information tools<br />
• People authorized to do the disclosures<br />
• Relations of the members of the Board of Directors and the<br />
managers with the press.<br />
• Meetings for Investors<br />
• General Board Meetings of Shareholders<br />
• Announcements made for press and media<br />
• Efficiency of the website<br />
• Future oriented announcements<br />
Company Policy for Releasing Information is<br />
approved by Board of Directors. Board is responsible<br />
for following up, controlling and developing the<br />
Company Policy for releasing Information. Investor<br />
Relations Unit will be responsible for supervision and<br />
proceedings of the policy.<br />
9- Announcements About Special Situation<br />
The Company made 40 announcements about<br />
special situations in 2006, these announcements<br />
have been sent to Capital Markets Committee and<br />
Istanbul Stock Exchange Market. For two of those<br />
announcements, ISE and Capital Markets Committee<br />
have requested additional information. The unit<br />
responsible for explaining special situations is<br />
Investor Relations Unit. Since the company’s stocks<br />
are not in foreign markets, announcements were<br />
made only inside the country.<br />
10- Company website and contents<br />
Company has an active and easy accessible website.<br />
On the website, www.zoren.com.tr, all the<br />
information given in Capital Markets Committee<br />
Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management Section II –<br />
Article I.11.5 are provided. Website has been<br />
rearrenged at the beginning of 2006 and deficiencies<br />
determined in 2005 have been corrected.<br />
11- Announcement of the Real Person Final<br />
Dominant Shareholder, Right Holder<br />
There is no real person as a decisive shareholder.<br />
Partners of the Company are as follows:<br />
Nominal Value<br />
Partners Capital Share (%) of Shares (YTL)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.fi. 43.21 35.288.432,74<br />
Korteks Mensucat San. ve Tic.A.fi. 17.55 14.330.198,11<br />
Prime Emerging M. 3.50 2.858.287,25<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Linen Dokuma Empirme<br />
Konf. San.ve Tic. A.fi. 0.53 428,743,09<br />
Linens Pazarlama A.fi. 0.47 383.827,15<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Tic. ve San. A.fi. 0.23 191.913,57<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Gayrimenkul Gel. ve Yat.A.fi. 0.35 287.870,36<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Grand Otel ‹flletmeleri A.fi. 0.23 191.913,57<br />
Vestel Elektronik San. ve Tic. A.fi. 0.40 326.661,40<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> D›fl Tic. A.fi. 4.12 3.361.276,00<br />
Open to Public 29.41 24.016.226,76<br />
TOTAL 100,00 81.665.350,00<br />
34 <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong>
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
12- Disclosure to the Public the Names of Persons<br />
that may have insider trader information<br />
Company has disclosed to public the names of the<br />
people known from inside. The list below shows the<br />
persons can be known from inside.<br />
Name<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Yüksel Yalova<br />
Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Türkan <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik<br />
Berrin <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Zuhal Bereket Bafl<br />
fierif Ar›<br />
Hakan Efltürk<br />
Murat Sungur Bursa<br />
M.Salim Arslanalp<br />
Title<br />
Chairman of the Board of Directors<br />
Deputy Chairman of the Board of Directors<br />
Member of the Board of Directors<br />
Member of the Board of Directors<br />
Member of the Board of Directors<br />
Member of the Board of Directors<br />
Member of the Board of Directors<br />
Auditor<br />
Auditor<br />
Chief Executive Officer<br />
General Manager / <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> A.fi.<br />
Mehmet B. Akdevelio¤lu General Manager / <strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel A.fi.<br />
M. Erdo¤an Günefl General Manager / <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M A.fi.<br />
‹. Sinan Ak Deputy General Manager / Energy Group<br />
Nurflah Koflar<br />
Hüseyin Morkoyun<br />
Vedat Gülen<br />
U¤ur Bayr›<br />
Ayten Eslek<br />
Erol Birinci<br />
Ahmet Tansel Varan<br />
Nahit Kahraman<br />
fieref Ekinci<br />
Hasan Ayd›n<br />
Fatih Y›lmaz<br />
At›lay Y›lmaz<br />
Bülent Çilingir<br />
Gürcan Okumufl<br />
Hüseyin Gül<br />
Serhat fiimflek<br />
Türkan Güngör<br />
Müjgan Selik<br />
Salih Gürleyen<br />
Erdal Kural<br />
Cenk Teber Ordu<br />
Burcu Tekin<br />
Hüseyin Atabay<br />
Mehmet Çavuflo¤lu<br />
Osman Karabay<br />
fierif Ar›<br />
Hakan Efltürk<br />
Deputy General Manager<br />
Deputy General Manager / Natural Gas<br />
Group<br />
Projects and Investments Director<br />
Planning and Business Development<br />
Director<br />
Accounting Manager<br />
Accounting Manager<br />
Human Resources and <strong>Corporate</strong><br />
Communications Director<br />
Project Manager<br />
Projects and Investments Director<br />
Finance Manager<br />
Finance and Investor Relations Specialist<br />
Manager of Kayseri Power Plant<br />
Purchasing and Logistics Director<br />
Manager of Bursa Power Plant<br />
Manager of Lüleburgaz Power Plant<br />
Manager of Ankara Power Plant<br />
Accounting Assistant Manager<br />
Chief Accountant<br />
Chief Accountant<br />
Budget Chief<br />
Contracts Manager<br />
Finance Specialist<br />
Project Manager<br />
System Development and Project Manager<br />
Geothermal Investments Director<br />
Ar›lar Independent External Inspection<br />
Ar›lar Independent External Inspection<br />
SECTION III- Beneficiaries<br />
13- Informing the Beneficiaries<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. reorganized the<br />
website in order to inform the beneficiaries about the<br />
subjects concerning them, and any kind of<br />
information in the frame of Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong><br />
Management. Also, in order to inform the employees,<br />
there is an “intranet” system in the company, and<br />
personnel can provide the information they needed<br />
from the system as their authorization level of access.<br />
All information in details needed by employees are<br />
presented in intranet system.<br />
In order to inform customers and suppliers,<br />
informative meetings are organized upon requests<br />
coming from them. In case of any requests coming<br />
from investors and agencies, one-to-one or group<br />
meetings are organized.<br />
14- Beneficiaries’ Contribution to Administration<br />
Beneficiaries do not take part in administration.<br />
However, care is given for participation of employees<br />
to meetings of boards of directors to indicate their<br />
opinions. Any other model for other beneficiaries to<br />
take part in administration is not developed.<br />
15- Human Resource Policy<br />
Human Resource Policy is prepared as to cover<br />
hiring, promoting, dismissing, training and<br />
compensation systems. In order to increase the<br />
productivity of employees, training programs are<br />
organized in certain times, and employees<br />
attendance to these programs is encouraged.<br />
There is not an assigned representative to organize<br />
the relations with the employees. If there will assign<br />
an independent member in the Board, this member<br />
will represent all beneficiaries as well as the<br />
employees in the Board of Directors.<br />
All employees are given equal opportunities for<br />
trainings, having a career, promotions and other<br />
subjects, with no discrimination.<br />
There is no complaint about discrimination received<br />
from employees.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong> 35
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
16- Information about the Relations with<br />
Customers and Suppliers<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. gives customer<br />
satisfaction a great importance. Demands coming<br />
from customers are replied in shortest time possible,<br />
all effort is used to find solutions for any issues.<br />
In order to achieve customer satisfaction, Customer<br />
Services Department has been established. This<br />
department usually provides technical and financial<br />
support. For the issues customers are having with<br />
EPDK (EMRA-Energy Market Regulatory Authority)<br />
and Treasury, same department acts also as an<br />
intermediary agent. Complying with the EPDK<br />
Directives, customers’ meters are replaced with new<br />
ones, and in order to provide remote supervision,<br />
modems are installed.<br />
Since the company has no direct relations with the<br />
customers, customer satisfaction is related with the<br />
discount rate applied.<br />
17- Social Responsibility<br />
In 2006, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> has all required and legal<br />
inspections related to environmental protection done.<br />
In the same direction, ÇED (Environmental Impact<br />
Assessment) documents related with the installations<br />
are taken from Ministry of Environment, every year.<br />
Until today, no violation regarding environmental<br />
protection is determined in environmental influence<br />
reports, and all implementations are done in<br />
consideration to environmental factors. Company<br />
also has three certifications regarding environmental<br />
protection, issued by ISO.<br />
In 2006, no negative effect to environment was<br />
determined and there is no law suit filed against the<br />
Company.<br />
All kinds of works regarding Social Responsibilities<br />
are performed group based by Mehmet <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Foundation, and <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi.<br />
contributes to these as a Company in the Group.<br />
SECTION IV- Board of Directors<br />
18- Structure of the Board of Directors, its<br />
Constitution and Independent Members<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. Board of Directors<br />
consists 7 members. Almost no member of the Board<br />
takes any part in execution. The Chairman of the<br />
Board, Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong>, acts as a member taking no part in<br />
execution. The General Manager of the Company is<br />
Salim Arslanalp. Different persons act as Chairman of<br />
the Board and Executive Directors.<br />
Member Title Attribute of Member<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> Chairman of the Takes no part in execution<br />
Board of Directors<br />
Yüksel Yalova Deputy Chairman Takes no part in execution<br />
of the Board of Directors<br />
Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong> Member Takes no part in execution<br />
Türkan <strong>Zorlu</strong> Member Takes no part in execution<br />
Berrin <strong>Zorlu</strong> Member Takes no part in execution<br />
Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik Member Takes part in execution<br />
Zuhal Bereket Bafl Member<br />
Takes no part in execution<br />
In accordance with the <strong>Corporate</strong> Management<br />
implementation two independent members are<br />
assigned and the Board of Directors has seven<br />
members including the independent members.<br />
Independent members bear the independency criteria<br />
provided in Capital Markets Committee Principles of<br />
<strong>Corporate</strong> Management. For the Board Members,<br />
there is no limitation regarding to undertake other<br />
duty or duties outside the Company.<br />
19- Attributes of Board of Directors Members<br />
Following the amendments to be done on Main<br />
Contract at Periodic General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders, minimum specifications to be borne by<br />
Board Members will be added to Main Contract.<br />
Specifications, which will be added to the Main<br />
Contract, will be as same as the ones mentioned in<br />
Capital Markets Committee Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong><br />
Management Section IV. Article 3.1.1, 3.1.2 and 3.1.5.<br />
<strong>Corporate</strong> Management Committee, which will be<br />
acting connected to <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi.<br />
Board of Directors, decided to organize training<br />
programs, if necessary, for the members who do not<br />
bear the specifications; until now, there have been no<br />
training program implemented for Board Members.<br />
36 <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong>
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
20- Mission, Vision and Strategic Goals of the<br />
Company<br />
22- Authorities and Responsibilities of Board of<br />
Directors Members<br />
Board of Directors has determined the mission and<br />
vision of the Company and announced them to public:<br />
Mission: From the source to the socket, provide<br />
quality and reliable services, to give energy to life.<br />
Vision: In all levels of energy sector, to become the<br />
leader in Turkey and a preferred bridge of energy in<br />
the world.<br />
Board of Directors confirms the strategic goals<br />
determined by directors. <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim<br />
A.fi. Board takes grate care in considering the<br />
opinions and proposals of related departments, when<br />
the strategic goals are being determined. Proposals<br />
about the strategic goals are reported to Board and<br />
works to implement the goals are started immediately.<br />
The levels of achieving the goals are evaluated by<br />
means of the results in financial charts and based on<br />
activities in year-end reports. Board of Directors, once<br />
a year, performs an annual evaluation to determine<br />
the level of achieving the goals, activities and previous<br />
performances.<br />
21- Risk Management and Internal Control<br />
Mechanisms<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. Board of Directors<br />
uses SAP system in the Company, in order to achieve<br />
Risk Management and internal control. By means of<br />
SAP system, all integrated work process can be<br />
operated/recorded by computer systems and<br />
productivity can be increased. Also, with this system,<br />
employees and managers, as their level of<br />
authorization allows, can access any kind of<br />
information and reports they need.<br />
In order to provide internal control, a problem-solving<br />
program is installed in Company’s intranet system and<br />
is operated effectively. Any problem faced is directed<br />
to related managers and solved immediately. <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
<strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. Board defined all existing<br />
and potential risks and determined policies against<br />
those risks.<br />
In Main Contract of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi.,<br />
authorities and responsibilities of Board of Directors<br />
did not take place in details. With the amendments<br />
made in 2005 General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders, authorities and responsibilities of Board<br />
of Directors members took place in main contract.<br />
Authorities and responsibilities of Board of Directors<br />
took place in Main Contract are as follows:<br />
• Determining the mission and vision of the Company and announce<br />
them to public, following up and supervising the proceedings on<br />
the way to determined goals;<br />
• Representing the company to shareholders and third parties and<br />
determining the policies to do;<br />
• Approving the annual budgets and business plans of the company;<br />
• Protecting the company activities to comply with the directives,<br />
main contract and internal regulations;<br />
• Having the company records kept properly;<br />
• Preparing company balance sheet, preparing profit/loss accounts,<br />
preparing annual report, and presenting those to shareholders<br />
attention before the General Board Meeting of Shareholders;<br />
• Presenting to General Board of Shareholders a proposal about the<br />
way of profit distribution;<br />
• Calling General Board of Shareholders for ordinary or extraordinary<br />
meeting and providing the procedure for General Board Meeting of<br />
Shareholders;<br />
• Ensuring the decisions made by Shareholders during General<br />
Board Meeting to be realized;<br />
• Determining the rules followed by Company employees, including<br />
the ethic rules to be followed;<br />
• Determining the Company Policy for Releasing Information and<br />
disclose it to public;<br />
• Forming the committees connected to the Board of Directors,<br />
assigning the members and determining the work principles,<br />
ensuring the effective and productive work of such;<br />
• Evaluating the recommendations of corporate management<br />
committee about top-level managers of the Company.<br />
23- Principals of Activity for Members of Board of<br />
Directors<br />
The Chairman of the Board and Members determine<br />
Board meeting agendas. While determining the<br />
agenda, requests coming from directors are also<br />
taken into consideration. In the Article 9 of Main<br />
Contract, it is stated that the Board will gather at least<br />
once a month. Board of Directors Meetings are held<br />
at least 12 times a year.<br />
A secretariat inside the Company working connected<br />
with Board of Directors has been formed, in the<br />
concept of Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management. Duty<br />
of the Secretariat is to keep the records of the Board<br />
Meetings, to archive the records and provide updated<br />
information for the members of the Board. Also,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong> 37
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Governance</strong> <strong>Compliance</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />
agenda and information about the agenda, as well as<br />
the reports, are delivered to the Members, at least<br />
one week prior to meetings.<br />
During the Meetings, any opposite opinions and<br />
detailed information about the reasons of voting<br />
against the common practice are decided to be put<br />
into records and passed to the auditors, but so far<br />
such a situation did not occurre. Following the<br />
approval of Main Contract by General Board Meeting<br />
of Shareholders, if independent members have a<br />
different opinion, the reasons of voting against shall<br />
be disclosed to the public through the website. The<br />
actual participation of the members to the board<br />
meetings is required for articles that need to be<br />
approved by the members of the board of directors<br />
indicated in Section IV article 2.17.4 of the Principles<br />
of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management of the Capital Markets<br />
Committee. None of the Board members, including<br />
the Chairman, have more voting rights and/or the right<br />
to veto. All members and chairman has equal vote.<br />
24- Conducting Business with the Company and<br />
Rule of Competition<br />
The Subject of having business conducts with the<br />
Company or competing with the Company is<br />
presented in the agenda for approval of General<br />
Board of Shareholders, every year. In year 2006, no<br />
case regarding business conducts with the Company<br />
or competition of Members of the Board is occurred.<br />
In case that any situation occurs related to business<br />
conduct and competition with the company, in<br />
concept of Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong> Management, the<br />
profit disputes arise will be disclosed to public.<br />
25- Rules of Ethic<br />
Ethic Rules of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi. prepared<br />
in form of writing and delivered to all employees.<br />
Maximum care is given to the implementation of rules<br />
of ethics having been established for the Board of<br />
Directors, the company and its employees.<br />
26-The Number, Structure and Independence of<br />
committees established in the Board of Directors<br />
The Board of Directors has established an Audit<br />
Committee for auditing the financial and operational<br />
activities in accordance with the bulletin of the Capital<br />
Markets Committee with Series Seri X, No:19 Article 3<br />
The <strong>Corporate</strong> Management Committee has not yet<br />
been established. However, with the appointment of<br />
independent members to the Board of Directors and<br />
within the framework of the Principles of <strong>Corporate</strong><br />
Management of the Capital Markets Committee, it is<br />
planned that the <strong>Corporate</strong> Management Committee<br />
be established under the chairmanship of an<br />
independent chairman. The principles of working have<br />
been established in writing and in a detailed manner<br />
within the framework of this plan. The establishment<br />
of the Committee shall commence after the Ordinary<br />
General Meeting. The working plans of the Audit<br />
Committee and the <strong>Corporate</strong> Management<br />
Committee has been established in writing and in a<br />
detailed manner.<br />
The Audit Committee comprises of two persons, who<br />
are Türkan <strong>Zorlu</strong> and Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik. Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Melik from among the committee members is a<br />
member with executive powers while Türkan <strong>Zorlu</strong> is a<br />
member who does not have executive powers.<br />
The Board of Directors resolved that as of 2006, the<br />
Audit Committee holds meetings each quarter and<br />
meet at least 4 times in year.<br />
Board secretariat will be responsible for keeping the<br />
records of decision of meetings. Committee performs<br />
its duties in accordance to working principles<br />
prepared in details and in form of writing.<br />
27- Financial Rights Granted to the Board of<br />
Directors<br />
General Board of Shareholders determines social<br />
benefits given to Members of the Board of Directors.<br />
In 2006, total of 100.000 YTL. is paid to Board<br />
Members of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.fi., in<br />
conformity with sector average. Each of Board<br />
Auditors is paid 2.232YTL. Gross per year.<br />
A performance appraisal is not conducted for<br />
members of the Board of Directors. A rewarding<br />
system reflecting the performance of the Company<br />
has not been established.<br />
The Company did not give any debt or loan to any<br />
member of the Board of Directors and the managers.<br />
38 <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> 2006 Annual <strong>Report</strong>