03.11.2012 Views

Page 1 of 24 HEXUS.net : Review : ECS PF88 Extreme Hybrid ...

Page 1 of 24 HEXUS.net : Review : ECS PF88 Extreme Hybrid ...

Page 1 of 24 HEXUS.net : Review : ECS PF88 Extreme Hybrid ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> Mainboard<br />

Product: <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

Author: Tarinder<br />

Date Of <strong>Review</strong>: 12th May 2005<br />

Sample Provider: <strong>ECS</strong> ELITEGROUP<br />

print this review discuss in the forums email to a friend<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 1 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

Enthusiasts are a fickle bunch <strong>of</strong> people, if you ask me. One minute they're swooning over the creamy, hardto-elucidate<br />

quality that Intel brings to the table with its Hyper-Threading-equipped Pentium 4 processors.<br />

Next minute, the same enthusiasts are having performance pangs that only AMD's Athlon 64 S939 CPUs can<br />

satiate. That's why it's not uncommon for informed users to jump ship every so <strong>of</strong>ten, to really see if the<br />

grass is greener on the other side.<br />

The most fundamental question that a prospective PC purchaser needs to make, then, is which platform to go<br />

with. Once chosen, due to chipset and socket differences, you're stuck with a particular platform unless you<br />

take the drastic step <strong>of</strong> changing motherboards, which entails a long afternoon <strong>of</strong> hardware and s<strong>of</strong>tware<br />

changes. Think about it, no other PC-related component is so much hassle, and changing back is just as much<br />

trouble. ATI and NVIDIA's graphics cards all share the same interfaces, so it's a simple matter <strong>of</strong> uninstalling<br />

drivers, popping in another card, and installing new drivers; a 10-minute job at best. Changing system<br />

memory is a cinch, and SATA hard drives can now be plugged, on-the-fly, into most modern board's ports.<br />

The ideal state <strong>of</strong> affairs would be the ability to run both Intel and AMD's CPUs on one board, with one<br />

operating system. Whilst technically feasible, ATX PCB considerations and the extra cost <strong>of</strong> paying for a<br />

socket that may or may not be used has always stopped the adventurous motherboard makers from having a<br />

go. <strong>ECS</strong>, however, has decided to throw away any pre-conceived mainboard design ideas by launching a single<br />

motherboard with the capacity to support most <strong>of</strong> today's top-end performance platforms, beginning with<br />

Intel's LGA775 and AMD's Socket-939. You'll be wondering how it's done. Read on to find out.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 2 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

Take a few seconds to ponder the <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>'s layout. For all intents and purposes, barring the extralong<br />

connector (hint, hint) running through the middle <strong>of</strong> the board, it's a regular LGA775-supporting board. In<br />

fact, with 2 x16 PCI-Express slots you'd be forgiven for thinking it's <strong>ECS</strong>' take on Intel-based SLI, but, as you<br />

may have guessed, the second, orange-coloured PCI-Express x16 slot is reserved for something else. Can you<br />

figure it out?<br />

I'll discuss the merits <strong>of</strong> this standalone motherboard before detailing just how it can be transformed into a<br />

S939 board. In its basic form, then, the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> is a SiS chipset-powered PCI-Express LGA775<br />

mainboard, with a SiS656 northbridge and SiS965 southbridge, linked together via a 1GB/s interconnect.<br />

There's plenty <strong>of</strong> room around the socket area, and it makes for easy mounting <strong>of</strong> Intel's fiddly LGA775<br />

reference coolers. What's more, unlike Intel, the SiS656 supports the newest iteration <strong>of</strong> dual-core Pentium<br />

CPUs immediately.<br />

LGA775's designed to run with DDR2 memory in mind. The <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> carries the usual 4 DIMM slots that<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer dual-channel bandwidth by populating same-coloured slots (or all 4, for that matter). Right <strong>of</strong>f the bat,<br />

the <strong>PF88</strong>'s SiS656 northbridge, located just to the left <strong>of</strong> the CPU socket, supports dual-channel DDR2-533 and<br />

DDR2-667, bringing it in line with Intel's i9xx models. The northbridge also supports the first orange-coloured<br />

PCI-Express x16 slot, just to the left. Unlike most retail Intel 925-series, however, <strong>ECS</strong>/SiS implement 2 IDE<br />

ATA133 ports, great if you're still using a bunch <strong>of</strong> older hard drives and/or optical devices. A <strong>24</strong>-pin EPS 12v<br />

power connector is also something that we see on the majority <strong>of</strong> Intel boards. Indeed, thus far, and not<br />

looking to the left, this could quite easily be another generic i925XE we're reviewing.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 3 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

Coming on down the board and steadfastedly ignoring the two BIOS chips (another hint), the SiS965<br />

southbridge is a solid companion to the PCI-Express SiS656 northbridge. SiS integrates 4 independent SATA<br />

ports that can be setup in RAID 0, 1, 0+1, and JBOD configurations. Further, continuing the PCI-Express<br />

theme, it supports 2 x1 lanes. Amongst other notables, the '965 features 8-channel sound, albeit only AC'97, 8<br />

USB2.0 ports, 6 PCI slots, and a Gigabit Ether<strong>net</strong> MAC. SiS also has another southbridge, imaginatively titled<br />

SiS966, that supports high-definition audio, and it may well be included in a board revision.<br />

More SATA goodness is to be found via the use <strong>of</strong> Silicon Image's Sil3132 controller. As the name implies, it<br />

supports 2 ports, red on the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>, and rides <strong>of</strong>f the preferred x1 PCI-Express lane. I've bemoaned the<br />

lack <strong>of</strong> PCI-Express peripherals in the past, so it's nice to see <strong>ECS</strong> specify it instead <strong>of</strong> a regular PCI-based<br />

3112. It also gains points by supporting SATA2, and by consequence, Native Command Queuing (not present in<br />

SiS965). S<strong>of</strong>tware RAID 0 and RAID 1 are also available, as is RAID 5 and RAID 10 if run with the optional port<br />

multiplier.<br />

Other feature goodies include 2-port FireWire (VIA6307), 3 PCI slots, 8-channel sound routed through Realtek's<br />

trusty ALC850 CODEC, and a Marvell physical layer that serves as another routing device for the SiS965's<br />

Gigabit Ether<strong>net</strong> MAC.<br />

The I/O section reflects the feature-set well. There's 4 USB2.0 (another 4 available via on-board headers), a<br />

single FireWire 1394a port, RJ-45 for Gigabit Ether<strong>net</strong>, 2 Serial ports, and 6 speaker ports that combine to<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer 8-channel sound. Given the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>'s aggressive pricing <strong>of</strong> only £65 including VAT and the decent<br />

feature-set and layout on <strong>of</strong>fer, <strong>ECS</strong> would already be on to a winner. But there's more, oh so much more to<br />

it. Remember the purple-coloured slot and the second PCI-Express x16 slots from the previous page? It's kind<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>of</strong> hard to miss them. That's how, in essence, <strong>ECS</strong> is able to turn the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> from an Intel-only<br />

mainboard into, at the moment, a S939 AMD Athlon 64-supporting board.<br />

Bought separately for just over £30 including VAT, <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>of</strong>fers its SIMA platform converter card, the A9S.<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 4 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

And there you have it. An add-in card that fits into the purple-coloured Elite Bus connector on the <strong>PF88</strong><br />

<strong>Extreme</strong>. The A9S supports all current Socket-939 CPUs and will also run dual-core X2s with a BIOS update.<br />

Power-delivery circuits and a 4-pin cable (that you remove from the mainboard and attach here) give the card<br />

the necessary power stability and juice. 2 DDR1 slots <strong>of</strong>fer up to 2GB <strong>of</strong> system RAM that's run in dual-channel<br />

mode. <strong>ECS</strong> has chosen to go with incompatible DDR1 and DDR2 for AMD and Intel, respectively. It could have<br />

engineered the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> to run with LGA775 and DDR1, much like Intel's i915x chipsets. That would have<br />

eased the financial burden <strong>of</strong> switching over to AMD, as now you have to invest in not only a CPU but also in<br />

DDR1 RAM. <strong>ECS</strong> has tried to strike a balance between future-pro<strong>of</strong>ing LGA775, which is supported at 266MHz<br />

FSB and will rise in the future, and present DDR400 support for AMD's S939 CPUs. Given a choice, I'd liked to<br />

have seen DDR1 implemented on both sides. It would then have simply been a matter <strong>of</strong> purchasing the A9S<br />

and the S939 CPU <strong>of</strong> your choice.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 5 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

<strong>ECS</strong> has used a SiS756 PCI-Express-compatible northbridge on the convertor card. There's very good, practical<br />

reasons for it, too. It carries the dual-channel DDR400 memory controller which connects up to the DIMM slots<br />

mentioned above. Being PCI-Express, it also feeds down to the second orange-coloured x16 slot on the<br />

motherboard. The first, used in an Intel-based setup, can't be accessed as the convertor card blocks the slot<br />

completely. Even if it could, it's mapped out for the SiS656 northbridge. In a conventional AMD S939 setup,<br />

the SiS756 is usually paired with the '965 southbridge; exactly the same southbridge that's already featured<br />

here. The convertor card, once positioned in the Elite Bus slot and activated by removing a bank <strong>of</strong> jumpers,<br />

disables the SiS656-SiS965 interconnect and forces the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> to run with the AMD-designed SiS756-<br />

SiS965 combination, again through a 1GB/s interconnect. Having said that, power is still being delivered to<br />

the LGA775 northbridge.<br />

The space constraints <strong>of</strong> locating both an Athlon 64 socket and 2 DIMM slots are manifested in the inability to<br />

run a reference, PIB cooler that's shipped with high-end S939 CPUs. Note how, using Crucial Ballistix RAM, the<br />

first DIMM slot is blocked <strong>of</strong>f, thereby inadvertently disabling dual-channel memory.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 6 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

Installing an older AMD reference cooler or appropriate aftermarket heatsink cures the problem. A couple <strong>of</strong><br />

Corsair XMS3200XL sticks have just enough room to breathe.<br />

Look back to the previous page and you'll just be able to make out a two rows <strong>of</strong> black jumpers between the<br />

first PCI-Express x16 slot and the Elite Bus connector. These need to be removed when engaging the A9S addin<br />

SIMA card. What you get is........<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 7 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

Note how the A9S card and AMD cooler then block the access path to the first PCI-Express slot?. That's one<br />

reason why there's a second one behind.<br />

The A9S card is also the reason why there's 2 BIOS chips on the board. One for Intel and one for AMD. Once<br />

the convertor card is plugged in correctly, the board switches the BIOS to AMD's. The <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> ships with<br />

just the Intel chip in place, and AMD's is supplied with the A9S card.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 8 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

Once installed, the PCI-Express card is moved to the left. With an ATI RADEON X850 XT PE 256MB in situ one<br />

niggly problem arose. Accessing the clear CMOS jumper, which is on the far left, with the motherboard in a<br />

regular CoolerMaster WaveMaster case, is frustratingly difficult without removing the card. <strong>ECS</strong> should also<br />

have used a big-headed jumper, found primarily on ABIT boards.<br />

The same setup with an Intel CPU, cooler and DDR2 RAM in place. Much cleaner, but that's kind <strong>of</strong> obvious,<br />

isn't it?<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>ECS</strong> hasn't skimped on board features or packaging. The <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> arrives in an oversized box that's<br />

replete with goodies.<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 9 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

<strong>ECS</strong> bundles in a multi-purpose bracket that adds in 2 USB2.0 and a single 6-pin FireWire port. There's also a<br />

foot-long eSATA cable, designed to be used with Silicon Image's 3132 controller, attached to the back <strong>of</strong> a<br />

case, and provide on-the-fly connectivity to external SATA hard drives, usually in enclosures and powered<br />

from the mains. 4 orange-coloured SATA cables and black IDE/floppy cables are a nice touch. There's also a<br />

custom I/O shield, molex-to-SATA power connectors, and a decent manual, with colour illustrations, written<br />

in good English. I also liked the fact that <strong>ECS</strong> provided a one-touch s<strong>of</strong>tware installation CD, which took care<br />

<strong>of</strong> many <strong>of</strong> the board's drivers without the need to install each one manually. On the s<strong>of</strong>tware front, <strong>ECS</strong> adds<br />

in InterVideo's WinDVD 5, WinDVD Creator, WinRip 2. Pro Magic Plus, a Ghost-like app., ShowShifter, another<br />

media-related application, and InTouch, a remote-accessing tool, complete the bundle.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

The <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> arrives in two flavours. One is the regular bundle, as seen above. The other includes WiFi<br />

support through a USB extender and 802.11g dongle; handy for gaining a better signal than having the dongle<br />

plugged into the back. Pricing for the standalone <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> is £65 including VAT for the regular bundle<br />

and around £80 including VAT for the WiFi-equipped version. You could add 50% to those prices if the board<br />

had, say, ASUS' name on and not <strong>ECS</strong>'. A decent bundle to go along with a well-featured board.The <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong><br />

<strong>Extreme</strong>'s BIOS is a unique setup in that it has to cater for both Intel and AMD CPUs. When using either brand<br />

<strong>of</strong> CPU and appropriate BIOS, we see the following Phoenix AwardBIOS page.<br />

With respect to Intel CPUs, let's trundle on over to the frequency/voltage section first.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 10 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 11 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

CPU ratio only presents itself when using unlocked/engineering sample Intel-based processors. I found it<br />

impossible to run with anything other than the default multiplier. More <strong>of</strong> an early BIOS issue than anything<br />

else. CPU Front-Side Bus can be set, with respect to a 200MHz FSB CPU, to anything between default and<br />

450MHz. Further, the PCI bus can be locked to ensure that peripherals don't hinder overclocking efforts. PCI-<br />

Express speeds aren't expressly stated, though. CPU-to-DRAM ratios need to be doubled in order to correspond<br />

to what we're used to with other boards. For example, most i925XE's can be set to DDR533 using a 3:4 ratio.<br />

<strong>ECS</strong>, however, states DRAM frequency in DDR terms, so the same setting is achieved via a 3:8 ratio. Others<br />

available are SPD, 3:4 (DDR266), 3:5 (DDR333), 1:2 (DDR400), and 3:10 (DDR667, or SPD in the case <strong>of</strong> Crucial<br />

Ballistix DDR2 PC5400 RAM). <strong>ECS</strong> also <strong>of</strong>fers up to 0.075v extra juice for the CPU and 0.15v extra for DDR2. I'd<br />

liked to have seen extra adjustment on both lines, really.<br />

Intel-based DRAM control was best left at default settings, which translated into 4-4-4-12 timings at DDR533<br />

speeds.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

A relatively low 12v line didn't impact upon board stability in any way. Voltages were consistent as any other<br />

board's, too.<br />

AMD BIOS<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 12 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

It will come as no surprise that the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> uses a second BIOS that's used in conjunction with the A9S<br />

add-in, AMD-supporting card. Firing up the board with card, CPU and DDR1 in place shows, expectedly, a BIOS<br />

geared up towards S939 CPUs.<br />

Note the lack <strong>of</strong> parameter adjustment compared to the Intel's. There's no CPU or DDR voltage manipulation,<br />

although that may appear in later BIOSes. It's probably a sensible approach by <strong>ECS</strong>, given that AMD S939 CPUs<br />

are run <strong>of</strong>f an additional card and not the motherboard itself. FSB frequencies range from 200MHz-232MHz, so<br />

it's not aimed at the enthusiast, either.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

There's a reasonable degree <strong>of</strong> DDR parameter adjustment. Running with a couple 512MB Corsair's XMS3200XL<br />

sticks and leaving the settings on auto gave SPD timings <strong>of</strong> 2-2-2-5 1T, perfect for low-latency accesses.<br />

Using an original S939 cooler pushed up an FX-53's BIOS CPU temperature to 55c. Windows' load hovered at<br />

around 63c. Hot but not hot enough to prejudice results in any way. Heat is something that <strong>ECS</strong> will need to<br />

keep a close eye upon, especially when running with FX-55 or dual-core CPUs. The odd socket positioning,<br />

relative to most motherboards', didn't impact upon stability at all.<br />

Motherboard <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong><br />

CPU Support All LGA775 processors (including dual-core models)<br />

Northbridge SiS656<br />

Memory Support 4 slots, DDR-II only. Supports DDR2-400MHz, 533MHz, and 667MHz at 200MHz FSB. 4GB m<br />

AGP None<br />

PEG 2x x16 from SiS656/756<br />

Southbridge SiS965<br />

Audio 8-channel feed from SiS965 to Realtek ALC850 CODEC<br />

Audio Connectivity 6-port backplane speaker<br />

PCI 1x 32-bit 33MHz PCI 2.1 slots<br />

PCI Express 1x x1 slots<br />

IDE 2 ATA133 compliant ports from SiS965<br />

IDE RAID None<br />

SATA 4 ports from SiS965<br />

SATA RAID RAID0, 1, 0+1, and JBOD from SiS965<br />

SATA RAID #2 RAID0 and RAID1 from Silicon Image Sil3132 PCI-Express-based controller. SATA2 complia<br />

Networking Gigabit Ether<strong>net</strong> MAC controller on SiS965 via Marvell 88E1111 PHY<br />

USB 8 USB2.0 ports from SiS965. 4x backplane USB2.0 and 4x internal I/O USB2.0<br />

FireWire 2-port 1394a FireWire support from VIA VT6307 ASIC<br />

Other I/O PS/2, Parallel, 2x Serial<br />

Onboard connectors and pin headers Floppy, 2x ATA133, 4x USB2.0, 6x SATA, FireWire 1394a, Elite Bus connector, 3x usable<br />

Form Factor 305mm x <strong>24</strong>5mm, ATX<br />

Expected price £65 inc. VAT. £31 for SIMA card<br />

The strangest set <strong>of</strong> features yet!<br />

Hardware and S<strong>of</strong>tware<br />

Test Platforms<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 13 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

System <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> System Intel i925XE system A<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

Processor(s) Intel Pentium 4 660 & AMD Athlon 64 FX-53 (via A9S add-in card) Intel Pentium 4 660<br />

Mainboard <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> w/A9S card EPoX EP-5LWA+ 925XE<br />

Memory 1GByte (2x512MB) Crucial Ballistix DDR2-667 & 1GByte (2x512MB) 1GByte (2x512MB) Crucial Ballistix<br />

Corsair XMS3200XL<br />

DDR2-667<br />

Memory timings 4-4-4-12 for DDR2, 2-2-2-5 1T for DDR1 4-4-4-12<br />

Graphics Card ATI RADEON X850 XT PE - PEG16X - CATALYST 5.3<br />

Disk Drive 160GB WD IDE & 36GB SATA Raptor<br />

BIOS Version 16/4/05 for Intel, 25/04/05 for AMD 23/02/2005<br />

Operating System Windows XP Pr<strong>of</strong>essional, SP2<br />

Mainboard<br />

S<strong>of</strong>tware<br />

SiS 2.04a Intel INF Update Utility 6.3.0.1007<br />

Benchmark S<strong>of</strong>tware<br />

Notes<br />

<strong>HEXUS</strong>.in-house Cryptography Benchmark<br />

<strong>HEXUS</strong> Pifast Benchmark<br />

ScienceMark 2.0 (7th February 2005)<br />

Realstorm 2004<br />

CINEBENCH 2003 multi-CPU render<br />

<strong>HEXUS</strong>.in-house MP3 Encoding Benchmark using LAME 3.97a (Intel HT compiler) - 701MB WAV<br />

picCOLOR 32-bit v4.0<br />

KribiBench v1.1<br />

Micros<strong>of</strong>t Movie Maker 2.1<br />

SimpliS<strong>of</strong>t HDTach (USB2.0, SATA, and PATA transfer tests)<br />

DOOM 3 Timedemo 1<br />

3DMark2001SE b330<br />

UT2003 <strong>HEXUS</strong> Bot Match<br />

<strong>ECS</strong> gave us the opportunity <strong>of</strong> evaluating the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> motherboard in the full knowledge that both AMD<br />

and Intel BIOSes are works in progress. The board was manually updated to the latest available at the time <strong>of</strong><br />

writing, being 16/04 and 25/04 for Intel and AMD, respectively. However, even with these builds, a few<br />

problems were apparent. The board would <strong>of</strong>ten freeze on the OS-loading screen, necessitating a reboot.<br />

Reboots <strong>of</strong>ten didn't function correctly and a cold start was needed at times. Further, I was advised not to<br />

run AMD's BIOS with 5x HTT setting applied. Once successfully in Windows, though, the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>, with<br />

both Intel and AMD CPUs, was a paradigm <strong>of</strong> stability. I'm adamant that future BIOS releases will cure the test<br />

board's ailments.<br />

A single OS?<br />

Adding in the A9S card and removing jumpers takes but a minute. One can turn the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> from an<br />

Intel-based motherboard to an AMD's in a jiffy. However, when attempting to load the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>'s<br />

Pentium 4 edition <strong>of</strong> Windows XP Pr<strong>of</strong>essional with the A9S in place, each attempt was meet with abject<br />

failure, usually resulting in the system rebooting just as XP finished loading. The culprit in this case appears<br />

to be Windows XP itself, which isn't happy going from a 2-CPU (well, HT-equipped P4) to a single-CPU AMD<br />

system. Going the other way around, from AMD to Intel, worked flawlessly.<br />

I'll be comparing the <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>'s performance against two established motherboards based on Intel's<br />

premier i925XE and AMD/VIA's K8T890 chipsets. The <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> purports to <strong>of</strong>fer the best <strong>of</strong> both worlds,<br />

so it will be interesting to see just how competitive it is, in terms <strong>of</strong> performance, with two <strong>of</strong> the fastest<br />

boards on either platform.<br />

Explicit running speeds <strong>of</strong> the boards were as follows:<br />

3630.8MHz - EPoX 5LWA+ (i925XE) - Intel Pentium 4 660<br />

3600.5MHz - <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> - Intel Pentium 4 660<br />

<strong>24</strong>05.4MHz -ABIT AX8 (VIA K8T890) - AMD Athlon 64 FX-53<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 14 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

2399.8MHz - <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> - AMD Athlon 64 FX-53<br />

Note that the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>'s clock generator doesn't inflate the FSB, unlike EpoX's. Please bear the running<br />

speed in mind when comparing results. Other than clock speed, the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>, in both Intel and AMD<br />

guises, was setup in an identical manner to the two comparison boards. Looking at memory tests first.<br />

When using the A9S convertor card and AMD Athlon 64 FX-53 CPU, ScienceMark 2.0 would repeatedly crash<br />

before spitting out the result. That's the reason why there's no figure shown there. Note, that with identical<br />

settings, i925XE has almost a 10% memory bandwidth advantage over <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>.<br />

Latency, too, is much, much higher than Intel's 925XE.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 15 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 16 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

The performance colours to look out for are grey and orange, which represent the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> with either<br />

AMD or Intel CPUs. Pifast, though, runs just fine with the A9S card in place. In fact, the result is<br />

commendably close to a VIA K8T890's. On the Intel side <strong>of</strong> things, the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> is just over 5% slower<br />

than an i925XE, although 1% <strong>of</strong> that advantage is gained by using an inflated FSB.<br />

Our cryptography benchmark shows VIA K8T890 and <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>/A9S neck-and-neck. The P4 variant lags<br />

just a little behind.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

Commendable performance in KribiBench.<br />

Very little to choose between the three boards in Realstorm's raytracing benchmark.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 17 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 18 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

The results thus far show excellent comparative AMD performance and a reasonable Intel showing. It seems as<br />

if <strong>ECS</strong>' Intel-based memory controller isn't as hot as, you guessed it, Intel's.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

Once again, decent performance from the hybrid <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 19 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

There's nothing wrong with SiS' PATA controller. The average PATA read speed, from a 160GB Western Digital<br />

hard drive, is just where it should be.<br />

SATA performance is also right on the money.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 20 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 21 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

USB2.0 performance is the best <strong>of</strong> the lot. SiS' 965 southbridge, in storage speed terms, is plenty fast enough.<br />

Low CPU utilisation on all three counts, too.<br />

Excellent performance on the AMD side <strong>of</strong> things, once again, eclipsing the benchmark laid down by a welltuned<br />

VIA K8T890 mainboard. A lack <strong>of</strong> comparative bandwidth and latency pushes the P4-based score down<br />

by over 1,000 marks when compared to a class-leading i925XE's. The breakdowns and can be viewed here and<br />

here.<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 22 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

A similar story unfolds in DOOM 3, where there's general benchmark parity with the A9S convertor card and a<br />

lack <strong>of</strong> throughput when benchmarked in standard LGA775 form.<br />

UT2003's results echo what's been written above. Motherboards are intrinsically boring. Their primary role is<br />

to act as a conduit for the other parts <strong>of</strong> a system; the base on which everything is built upon. Refreshes<br />

come and go, and each new iteration <strong>of</strong> chipset sees some feature integrated into a bridge, be it PCI-Express<br />

or SATA2. Other chipset makers then follow suit and status quo is quickly re-established. That's why it was a<br />

pleasant surprise to see one <strong>of</strong> the largest motherboard produces, Elitegroup Computer Systems (<strong>ECS</strong>)<br />

attempt to do something totally different with the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>.<br />

<strong>ECS</strong> took on the challenge <strong>of</strong> designing a single motherboard that could accommodate the latest platforms<br />

without the need for swapping boards over. The solution that <strong>ECS</strong> came up with, in respect <strong>of</strong> catering for<br />

both LGA775 and S939 chipsets, is a novel one. Through the use <strong>of</strong> a proprietory interface, Elite Bus, and a<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

separate add-in SIMA card, a user is able to change over from the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>'s default LGA775 layout to<br />

S939 in a matter <strong>of</strong> minutes. On a technical level, it's accomplished by using a single, on-board southbridge<br />

that can be set to communicate with either northbridge, onboard or SIMA-attached. <strong>ECS</strong> also plans to<br />

introduce SIMA cards for AMD's S754 and Intel Pentium 4 CPUs, for extra platform flexibility.<br />

Breaking down the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong>'s attributes into manageable sections, the default configuration, sans SIMA<br />

card, provides for a competent SiS chipset-powered PCI-Express (single card) Intel LGA775-based system. All<br />

the features one would expect are thrown in, including 4 DDR2 DIMM slots, on-chip SATA, discrete SATA2,<br />

FireWire 1394a, 8-channel sound (non-HD, sadly), Gigabit LAN, and a bundle that reflects the board's deluxe<br />

nature. <strong>ECS</strong>' aggressive pricing ensures that the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> will retail for around £65 inc. VAT, and whilst<br />

the performance isn't quite up to i925XE standards and the BIOS could do with greater levels <strong>of</strong> adjustment,<br />

it's competent enough given the package's street price.<br />

Evaluating the <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> in ignorance <strong>of</strong> its multi-platform support is missing the entire point <strong>of</strong> the<br />

board, really. Adding in the ~£30 A9S SIMA card, any choice <strong>of</strong> S939 CPU, and a couple <strong>of</strong> decent stick <strong>of</strong> DDR1<br />

memory transforms the <strong>PF88</strong> into a high-performing AMD motherboard. The BIOS is lacking, certainly, and 2<br />

DIMM slots may not be ideal for all, but at least it opens up the way for you, the user, to experiment with the<br />

other side without having to install a new motherboard. It won't appeal to the die-hard enthusiast interesting<br />

in pushing components to the absolute limit, but system integrators should immediately recognise the value<br />

inherent in a fast turnaround <strong>of</strong> platforms. The one blot on <strong>ECS</strong>' multi-platform vision is the need to re-install<br />

or 'rescue' Windows XP when changing from Intel to AMD setups.<br />

I've been pleasantly surprised by the ease <strong>of</strong> switching between Intel- and AMD-based systems. With this<br />

initial release, it would perhaps have been prudent for <strong>ECS</strong> to run with DDR1 memory throughout, mimimising<br />

the upgrade/sideways cost <strong>of</strong> moving to AMD's S939 CPUs, via the optional SIMA card. I'd also like to see<br />

greater levels <strong>of</strong> BIOS adjustment, thereby pandering to the needs <strong>of</strong> the enthusiast, and a slight PCB redesign,<br />

with a single switch, rather than 20-odd jumpers, for enabling the SIMA card would be nice.<br />

<strong>ECS</strong> has brought something very new to the table - a motherboard that carries a number <strong>of</strong> modern features<br />

and one that opens up the way for multi-CPU support. In the <strong>of</strong>t-boring, stagnant world <strong>of</strong> motherboard<br />

design, the <strong>ECS</strong> ELITEGROUP <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> is a breath <strong>of</strong> very fresh air.<br />

<strong>HEXUS</strong>.awards<br />

<strong>HEXUS</strong>.right2reply<br />

to follow...<br />

All content on this site is Copyright © 1998 - <strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong>, all rights reserved.<br />

Use <strong>of</strong> content without written agreement is forbidden.<br />

This site is covered by UK Law and International Treaties.<br />

This site is classified via ICRA<br />

Website and Email Hosting by Fluent<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> 23 <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005


<strong>HEXUS</strong>.<strong>net</strong> : <strong>Review</strong> : <strong>ECS</strong> <strong>PF88</strong> <strong>Extreme</strong> <strong>Hybrid</strong> Mainboard<br />

page rendered in: 0.189 seconds<br />

[valid XHTML 1.0] [valid CSS 2]<br />

http://www.hexus.<strong>net</strong>/content/reviews/review_print.php?dXJsX3Jldmlld19JRD0xMTgx<br />

<strong>Page</strong> <strong>24</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>24</strong><br />

13/05/2005

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!