Acceptability, Comprehensibility and Reported Influence - BRAC ...
Acceptability, Comprehensibility and Reported Influence - BRAC ...
Acceptability, Comprehensibility and Reported Influence - BRAC ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Working Paper No. 21<br />
<strong>Acceptability</strong>, <strong>Comprehensibility</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Reported</strong> <strong>Influence</strong> of Behaviour<br />
Change Communication Tools:<br />
Experience from MNCH Programme in<br />
Nilphamari District of Bangladesh<br />
Atiya Rahman 1 , Margaret Leppard 2 , Hashima-E-Nasreen 1 , Sarawat Rashid 1<br />
1 <strong>BRAC</strong> RED, Bangladesh, 2 University of Aberdeen, UK<br />
May 2011<br />
Research <strong>and</strong> Evaluation Division, <strong>BRAC</strong>, 75 Mohakhali, Dhaka 1212, Bangladesh<br />
Telephone: (88-02) 9881265-72, 8824180-7 (PABX) Fax: (88-02) 8823542<br />
E-mail: research@brac.net, Website: www.brac.net/research
Working Paper No. 21<br />
Copyright © 2011 <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
May 2011<br />
Published by:<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong><br />
75 Mohakhali<br />
Dhaka 1212<br />
Bangladesh<br />
Telephone: (88-02) 9881265-72, 8824180-7 (PABX)<br />
Fax: (88-02) 8823542<br />
Website: www.brac.net/research<br />
Printing <strong>and</strong> Publication<br />
Altamas Pasha<br />
Cover design<br />
Md. Abdur Razzaque<br />
Design <strong>and</strong> layout<br />
Md. Akram Hossain<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong>/RED publishes research reports, scientific papers, monographs, working<br />
papers, research compendium in Bangla (Nirjash), proceedings, manuals, <strong>and</strong> other<br />
publications on subjects relating to poverty, social development <strong>and</strong> human rights,<br />
health <strong>and</strong> nutrition, education, gender, environment, <strong>and</strong> governance.<br />
Printed by <strong>BRAC</strong> Printers at Tongi, Gazipur, Bangladesh.
Abbreviations<br />
AIDS<br />
ANC<br />
BCC<br />
BHP<br />
E-E<br />
HIV<br />
IEC<br />
IPC<br />
MDG<br />
MNCH<br />
NHW<br />
PNC<br />
SS<br />
SK<br />
VD<br />
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome<br />
Antenatal Care<br />
Behaviour Change Communication<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> Health Programme<br />
Entertainment Education<br />
Human Immunodeficiency Virus<br />
Information, Education <strong>and</strong> Communication<br />
Interpersonal Communication<br />
Millennium Development Goal<br />
Maternal, Neonatal <strong>and</strong> Child Health<br />
Newborn Health Worker<br />
Post-natal care<br />
Shasthya Shebika<br />
Shasthya Kormi<br />
Village Doctor<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
iii
Glossary<br />
Behaviour Change Communication<br />
Behaviour change communication (BCC) is a research-driven approach for promoting<br />
<strong>and</strong> sustaining behaviour change in individuals <strong>and</strong> communities, <strong>and</strong> is implemented<br />
though the development <strong>and</strong> distribution of specific health messages via a variety of<br />
communication channels.<br />
Entertainment Education<br />
“Entertainment-Education is the process of purposely designing <strong>and</strong><br />
implementing a media message to both entertain <strong>and</strong> educate, in order to<br />
increase audience knowledge about an educational issue, create favorable<br />
attitudes, <strong>and</strong> change overt behavior” (Singhal <strong>and</strong> Rogers, 1999. Entertainment<br />
education: a communication strategy for social change. L.Erlbaum Assoc.)<br />
Mass Media<br />
Mass media include radio, television, print media (newspapers <strong>and</strong> magazines), <strong>and</strong><br />
other forms of traditional media, which may reach large numbers of target audience.<br />
iv RED Working Paper No. 21
Acknowledgements<br />
We are indebted to Dr. Kaosar Afsana, Associate Director, <strong>BRAC</strong> Health Programme<br />
(BHP) for giving us the opportunity to work in the rural Maternal, Neonatal <strong>and</strong> Child<br />
Health (MNCH) programme area. We are also thankful to Mr. Hasan Shareef Ahmed,<br />
Chief, Editing <strong>and</strong> Publications, <strong>BRAC</strong> Research <strong>and</strong> Evaluation Division for editing<br />
the final draft of the report. We acknowledge the support of research assistants<br />
during fieldwork. We want to thank the countless interview respondents <strong>and</strong> other<br />
assistants at the community level without whom effective data collection would not<br />
have been possible. We are also thankful to Shasthya Kormis (SK), Shasthya<br />
Shebikas (SS) <strong>and</strong> all other providers involved in this study for answering our<br />
questions.<br />
The Research <strong>and</strong> Evaluation Division (RED) is supported by <strong>BRAC</strong>'s core funds <strong>and</strong><br />
funds from donor agencies, organizations <strong>and</strong> governments worldwide. Current<br />
major donors of <strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>and</strong> RED include AED ARTS (USA), Aga Khan Foundation<br />
Canada, AIDA (Spain), AusAID (Australia), Bill <strong>and</strong> Melinda Gates Foundation (USA),<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong>-USA, Campaign for Popular Education (Bangladesh), Canadian International<br />
Development Agency, Department for International Development (UK), DIMAGI (USA),<br />
EKN (The Netherl<strong>and</strong>s), Emory University (USA), European Commission, Family<br />
Health International (USA), Fidelis, France, Government of Bangladesh, GTZ<br />
(Germany), Hospital for Sick Children (Canada), ICDDR,B (Bangladesh), Institute of<br />
Development Studies (UK), Inter-cooperation Bangladesh, Karolinska University<br />
(Sweden), L<strong>and</strong> O Lakes (USA), Manusher Jonno Foundation (Bangladesh),<br />
Micronutrient Initiative (Canada), NORAD (Norway), OXFAM NOVIB (The Netherl<strong>and</strong>s),<br />
Oxford University (UK), Plan International Bangladesh, Rockefeller Foundation (USA),<br />
Rotary International (Bangladesh), Save the Children (UK), Save the Children (USA),<br />
Scojo Foundation Incorporation (USA), Stanford University (USA), Swiss Development<br />
Cooperation (Switzerl<strong>and</strong>), The Global Fund (USA), The Population Council (USA),<br />
UNICEF, University of Leeds (UK), World Bank <strong>and</strong> World Food Programme.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
v
Abstract<br />
This operational research aimed to assess the acceptability, comprehensibility <strong>and</strong><br />
reported influence of behaviour change communication tools such as interpersonal<br />
communications (IPC), print materials, <strong>and</strong> entertainment education (E-E) used in the<br />
Maternal, Neonatal <strong>and</strong> Child Health programme of <strong>BRAC</strong>. A qualitative study was<br />
conducted during March-April 2010 in two unions in Nilphamari Sadar upazila of<br />
Nilphamari district in northern Bangladesh. Data were collected by using semistructured<br />
questionnaire, key informant interview, focus group discussion, <strong>and</strong><br />
document review. Respondents were selected using snowball sampling technique.<br />
Data were analyzed using framework <strong>and</strong> content analyses. Findings reveal that faceto-face<br />
IPC was unanimously accepted by the community members. The<br />
respondents requested increased frequency of IPC. Community members identified<br />
some inconsistencies in some of the pictures <strong>and</strong> messages on maternal danger<br />
signs. Other communication channels such as folksongs <strong>and</strong> street theatres were<br />
perceived to play strong supporting role in communicating the key messages. The<br />
community people made limited use of television <strong>and</strong> radio, although where<br />
accessible, community members perceived television as a useful medium to support<br />
adoption of new knowledge in certain groups of the viewers. Overall, the study<br />
reveals that well integrated IPC, use of modified printed materials, <strong>and</strong> E-E have<br />
potentials for motivating <strong>and</strong> supporting families <strong>and</strong> other community members to<br />
take healthy decision for birth planning <strong>and</strong> maternal <strong>and</strong> neonatal care-seeking.<br />
vi RED Working Paper No. 21
Introduction<br />
In Bangladesh the maternal mortality ratio in 2007 was 322 per 100,000 live births,<br />
infant mortality rate was 57 per 1,000 live births, <strong>and</strong> neonatal mortality rate was 37<br />
per 1,000 live births (1, 2). But irrespective of these positive trends to achieve<br />
Millennium Development Goals (MDG) 4 <strong>and</strong> 5, the issues of Maternal, neonatal <strong>and</strong><br />
child health (MNCH) remain a major national concern. The recent Bangladesh<br />
Demographic Health Survey (BDHS) shows that most births occur at home without<br />
skilled attendants (2). Thus, almost 80% of neonates do not receive post-natal care<br />
(PNC) from a trained provider within six days of births. The poor health outcomes of<br />
the mother <strong>and</strong> children are associated with a number of factors including poverty,<br />
poor social status of women, low education levels, limited rights <strong>and</strong> freedoms, <strong>and</strong><br />
cultural practices associated with pregnancy, childbirth, <strong>and</strong> the post-partum period<br />
result in mothers <strong>and</strong> babies being secluded in their homes <strong>and</strong> not permitted to<br />
leave home, even to seek appropriate care for problems <strong>and</strong> sickness (3-10). Overall,<br />
there is poor use of modern healthcare services by women, especially the rural <strong>and</strong><br />
younger women, in Bangladesh. About 13% of the deliveries in rural areas are<br />
attended by medically trained providers. Additionally, trained traditional birth<br />
attendants (TBA) assist in 11% of deliveries <strong>and</strong>, more than 75% of births in rural area<br />
are assisted by untrained TBAs, relatives, friends, <strong>and</strong> others (2).<br />
During the last quarter of the twentieth century, there had been notable trends in<br />
public health communication. The issues addressed include population <strong>and</strong> family<br />
planning, primary healthcare, maternal <strong>and</strong> child health, HIV/AIDS, water <strong>and</strong><br />
sanitation, <strong>and</strong> other communicable <strong>and</strong> non communicable diseases.<br />
Communication approaches have progressed from health education through<br />
information, education <strong>and</strong> communication (IEC) to behavior change communication<br />
(BCC). Overall, the role of communication in public health programme has been well<br />
established (11). However, researching the association between health communication,<br />
practice of healthy behaviours, <strong>and</strong> improved health is complex because of<br />
the extent <strong>and</strong> variety of confounding factors. Nonetheless, there is some evidence<br />
that public health communication affected health behaviour (12-17). Since the mid<br />
1990s <strong>and</strong> following the model of development communication, many donors,<br />
government, communication scholars <strong>and</strong> institutions have designed, implemented<br />
<strong>and</strong> evaluated innovative communication programme to achieve behaviour change<br />
rather than simply informing <strong>and</strong> educating. Lantican (undated) citing Piotrow <strong>and</strong><br />
Rimon (1999) highlighted some of the problems of lack of strategic approaches. It<br />
includes lack of audience segmentation, poor pre-testing of messages <strong>and</strong> materials,<br />
little application of communication theory, poorly developed indicators for assessing<br />
the effectiveness of programme <strong>and</strong> messages that are not coherent with services.<br />
With the development of communication technology the use of the Internet <strong>and</strong> text<br />
messaging are increasing (18). Nonetheless, Lantican concludes that the<br />
interpersonal channels are important as individuals <strong>and</strong> small groups analyze the<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
1
information garnered from various sources <strong>and</strong> apply what they have learned from<br />
their own lives. Increasingly we underst<strong>and</strong> the role not only of mothers but also<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> other important kin in the family. In Bangladesh, husb<strong>and</strong>s, mothersin-law<br />
<strong>and</strong> elder brothers of the women play a major role in decision making<br />
especially in the case of health problems (19, 20).<br />
Targeting behaviour change strategies, that address specific barriers <strong>and</strong> target<br />
segmented audiences, can play a significant role in increasing safe motherhood. In<br />
order to provide quality care at the community level <strong>and</strong> promote appropriate use of<br />
referral facilities, <strong>BRAC</strong> has initiated MNCH programme in rural Bangladesh in 2006.<br />
The aim was to reduce maternal, neonatal <strong>and</strong> child mortality <strong>and</strong> morbidity with<br />
especial focus on the poor <strong>and</strong> deprived people (21).<br />
Effective communication involves transmission of health knowledges through<br />
messages that can be readily understood, accepted <strong>and</strong> practiced by the audience.<br />
The communication strategy of MNCH programme uses existing social <strong>and</strong> cultural<br />
norms <strong>and</strong> traditions that offer culturally appropriate ways of enhancing the<br />
communication strategies in a comprehensible <strong>and</strong> credible form.<br />
Major BCC initiatives of <strong>BRAC</strong> MNCH programme<br />
The project currently covers four districts (Nilphamari, Gaib<strong>and</strong>ha, Rangpur <strong>and</strong><br />
Mymensingh) <strong>and</strong> has planned to scale up in six more districts (Kurigram,<br />
Lalmonirhat, Faridpur, Magura, Madaripur <strong>and</strong> Rajbari). In order to achieve improved<br />
maternal <strong>and</strong> neonatal health, the programme gives importance to not only pregnant<br />
<strong>and</strong> lactating women but also to others intimately involved in decisions about their<br />
well-being. These include mothers-in-law, husb<strong>and</strong>s of primary target audience,<br />
community health workers (CHW), <strong>BRAC</strong> staff, government staff at union health<br />
centre (UHC), Upazila Health <strong>and</strong> Family Welfare Centre (UHFWC), district hospital<br />
(DH), <strong>and</strong> Maternal <strong>and</strong> Child Welfare Centre (MCWC). In addition, the MNCH<br />
communication strategy seeks to reach other local government bodies, village elites,<br />
school teachers, village organization (VO) members <strong>and</strong> other community ‘movers<br />
<strong>and</strong> shakers’, <strong>and</strong> local representatives of non government organizations (NGO) <strong>and</strong><br />
national <strong>and</strong> international agencies concerned with improvement of MNCH.<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> seeks to increase communication between community members <strong>and</strong><br />
healthcare providers with the medium-term objective of increasing the accountability<br />
of local health system for better <strong>and</strong> wider access of disadvantaged women <strong>and</strong><br />
children to quality health services at community <strong>and</strong> facility levels (21).<br />
The communication component of the MNCH programme involves grassroot level<br />
healthcare providers like Shasthya Shebika (SS), Shasthya Kormi (SK) <strong>and</strong> newborn<br />
health worker (NHW). These health cadres provide a wide range of services at<br />
household levels encompassing: early identification of pregnancy <strong>and</strong> antenatal care<br />
(ANC), attendance at delivery, newborn care, post-natal care for mothers <strong>and</strong><br />
neonates, under-five care, detection, management <strong>and</strong> referral of MNCH<br />
complications to hospitals <strong>and</strong> family planning centres. They provide both information<br />
2 RED Working Paper No. 21
<strong>and</strong> support for behaviour change through interactive communications, such as,<br />
face-to-face interpersonal <strong>and</strong> group communications. SKs <strong>and</strong> SSs educate<br />
mothers <strong>and</strong> family members using pictorial messages (Annex 2 <strong>and</strong> 3) including<br />
pregnancy care such as effects of nutritious food, taking rest, heavy work load,<br />
antenatal check-up, cleanliness, etc., delivery preparedness, introducing maternal<br />
danger signs during pregnancy, delivery <strong>and</strong> post-partum, using cell phone number<br />
in case of emergency. In addition they also talk about newborn care <strong>and</strong> danger<br />
signs of newborn.<br />
Flip charts are used by the SKs during group discussion with families <strong>and</strong> other<br />
community members (Annex 2 <strong>and</strong> 3). A poster depicting danger signs of maternal<br />
<strong>and</strong> neonatal complication is posted on the wall of women’s house to reinforce<br />
knowledge about danger signs <strong>and</strong> what to do if such complications arise (Annex 2<br />
<strong>and</strong> 3). The publication of POs’ cell phone numbers encourages women to call <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
health providers when needed. Stickers list neonatal <strong>and</strong> maternal danger signs;<br />
PO’s cell phone number <strong>and</strong> what to do if such complications arise; the importance<br />
of effect of extra food intake during pregnancy <strong>and</strong> post-partum period (Annex 4).<br />
The programme also hosts advocacy workshops in the community to build<br />
awareness, support the roles of local elites in advocating improved health services,<br />
<strong>and</strong> empower the community people about MNCH care <strong>and</strong> practices. The <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
regional manager (RM) <strong>and</strong> PO conduct the workshop with local elites at every year<br />
in each union. The participants includes the chairman <strong>and</strong> members of the union<br />
parishad, teachers, imams (religious leaders), government <strong>and</strong> alternative healthcare<br />
providers, MNCH committee members <strong>and</strong> other local influential people.<br />
Local song in the form of folk music (jaarigan) <strong>and</strong> street theatre (naatak) are<br />
organized from time to time in the community to reach rural people. The folk music<br />
initiative offers messages specifically on ANC, safe delivery, post-partum care, family<br />
planning, <strong>and</strong> infant <strong>and</strong> child health. The street theatre introduces the SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs,<br />
<strong>and</strong> their role in ANC, birth preparedness including the selection of skilled birth<br />
attendant; newborn care <strong>and</strong> PNC. The street theatre also demonstrates how the<br />
practice of traditional beliefs held by elderly women in the family can compromise<br />
pregnancy outcomes.<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> MNCH programme information especially about maternal <strong>and</strong> neonatal danger<br />
signs is also periodically broadcasted on radio <strong>and</strong> television in national <strong>and</strong> private<br />
channels. Because of contamination <strong>and</strong> confounding factors, it is difficult to design<br />
research that describes the association between programme interventions <strong>and</strong><br />
behaviour change. Therefore this study focused on the acceptability, comprehensibility<br />
<strong>and</strong> reported influence of the BCC tools used in the <strong>BRAC</strong> MNCH programme.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
3
Objectives<br />
Broadly, the objective of the study was to investigate the application of <strong>BRAC</strong> MNCH<br />
BCC tools in the form of IPC, print materials, <strong>and</strong> E-E. The specific objectives were<br />
as follows:<br />
1. To identify acceptability of different BCC channels to the target audience<br />
2. To assess the comprehensibility of different BCC tools by the target audience<br />
3. To assess the reported influence of messages in MNCH health-seeking <strong>and</strong><br />
health- related behaviour of the target audience; <strong>and</strong><br />
4. To identify the barriers to acceptance of BCC messages regarding MNCH by the<br />
community.<br />
4 RED Working Paper No. 21
Methods<br />
Study design<br />
The study was exploratory in nature. Data were collected using qualitative methods<br />
including key informant in-depth interview (KII), interview with semi-structured<br />
questionnaire, <strong>and</strong> focus group discussion (FGD). Documents, for example, flipcharts<br />
on care of pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating women <strong>and</strong> newborn care, posters <strong>and</strong> stickers<br />
about maternal <strong>and</strong> newborn danger signs were reviewed (Annex 2 <strong>and</strong> 3).<br />
Research setting<br />
The study was conducted in two unions of Nilphamari district. <strong>BRAC</strong> health<br />
programme (BHP) initiated MNCH programme in Nilphamari in 2006 (21). <strong>BRAC</strong> has<br />
had other three core programmes in all over Bangladesh including Nilphamari namely<br />
microfinance, health <strong>and</strong> education. The MNCH intervention, with specially trained<br />
SSs, SKs <strong>and</strong> NHWs was implemented in addition to these core programmes. BCC<br />
tools were used as communication channels to convey messages to the target<br />
audiences. MNCH baseline <strong>and</strong> follow-up survey data show that the pilot activities in<br />
Nilphamari had positive effect on knowledge <strong>and</strong> practice in many indicators<br />
especially in ANC, family planning, birth preparedness, delivery care, post-natal care,<br />
newborn care practice, <strong>and</strong> immunization (21). It was perceived that BCC activities<br />
influenced people’s attitude <strong>and</strong> behaviour in relation to maternal <strong>and</strong> neonatal<br />
health. Considering this Nilphamari district was selected for the study.<br />
Study population<br />
The study population consisted of the primary target group of MNCH programme<br />
comprising pregnant women, mothers of newborns <strong>and</strong> under-5 children. Mothersin-law,<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>s of a pregnant women/father of a newborn/under-5 children of the<br />
primary respondents were also included as study population (Table 1).<br />
Study sample<br />
Respondents were purposively selected from two unions of Nilphamari Sadar in<br />
Nilphamari district. From these two working areas four SKs were selected r<strong>and</strong>omly.<br />
The initial 50 respondents were selected from these areas using snowball sampling<br />
techniques for conducting semi-structured interview. Participants for KII <strong>and</strong> FGD<br />
were selected from the initial 50 respondents. Thus, a total of 12 KII <strong>and</strong> 8 FGD<br />
sessions <strong>and</strong> informal group discussions (IGD) were conducted for data collection<br />
(Table 1).<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
5
Table 1. Types of interviews by respondent’s categories<br />
Group Type of respondents Semi-structured KII FGD IGD<br />
1 Pregnant women 8 3 2<br />
2 Mother of neonate <strong>and</strong><br />
child under 5 years<br />
15<br />
3 2<br />
3 Mother-in-law 15 3 2<br />
4 Father of neonate/child under 12 3 2<br />
5/Husb<strong>and</strong> of pregnant women<br />
5 SS <strong>and</strong> SK 3<br />
Total 50 12 8 3<br />
Tools <strong>and</strong> techniques<br />
A checklist was followed for KII <strong>and</strong> FGD. An interview guide was used for semistructured<br />
interview, with a range of topics included knowledge <strong>and</strong> practice<br />
regarding maternal, neonatal <strong>and</strong> child care; memorization/recall messages given by<br />
SSs/SKs; memorization/recall messages from print materials <strong>and</strong> E-E; frequency of<br />
visits by SSs/SKs at last one month before data collection, during pregnancy, <strong>and</strong><br />
post-partum, acceptability of the BCC tools; barriers to acceptances <strong>and</strong><br />
communication with the providers.<br />
To test the comprehensibility of the messages of print materials the respondents<br />
were asked several questions like-please tell me what do you see in this picture<br />
What is your opinion about this picture What does it look like to you <strong>and</strong> why Do<br />
you have any recommendation to improve this picture, or is the picture<br />
comprehensible to you Furthermore, we sought to discover how respondents did<br />
relate messages with own real life experiences.<br />
Triangulation<br />
Two types of triangulation has been made to check <strong>and</strong> establish validity (22). These<br />
includes data triangulation (includes pregnant women, mother, mothers-in-law, <strong>and</strong><br />
men) <strong>and</strong> methodological triangulation (includes semi-structured interview, FGD <strong>and</strong><br />
KII).<br />
Data collection, management <strong>and</strong> analyses<br />
Data were collected during March-April 2010. Notes were taken by the researcher<br />
during the field interview. The interviews were recorded on tape by research<br />
assistants. Verbal consent to use the tape recorder was obtained from all<br />
participants. The notes <strong>and</strong> recordings were used to produce a complete naturalized<br />
transcript of each interview in Bangla (23). Data were analyzed by content <strong>and</strong><br />
framework analyses. Data from semi-structured interviews; each transcript was<br />
analyzed using framework analysis technique. Five steps including familiarization,<br />
identifying a thematic framework, indexing, charting <strong>and</strong> mapping, <strong>and</strong> interpretation<br />
of the meaning were used as a process (24). The interview transcripts were read<br />
6 RED Working Paper No. 21
epeatedly <strong>and</strong> were coded by various themes according to the meaning. Emerging<br />
themes were compared <strong>and</strong> modified with each <strong>and</strong> every independent transcript.<br />
Furthermore, all themes were categorized under broader category. Each main theme<br />
was charted by completing a table where each case has its own row <strong>and</strong> columns<br />
representing the sub-topics. Cells contain relevant summaries from the data set. The<br />
process of analysis are described in Annex 1.<br />
Content analysis included several rounds of manual coding of the transcripts <strong>and</strong><br />
discussions with the entire research team <strong>and</strong> listing of key themes (25-27). An<br />
example of an emerging theme from framework analysis <strong>and</strong> content analysis are<br />
present in Table 2 <strong>and</strong> 3 respectively.<br />
Ethical considerations<br />
The research was approved by the Bangladesh Medical Research Council. Verbal<br />
consent was obtained from all study participants. The respondents were informed<br />
that the participation was voluntary <strong>and</strong> that confidentiality would be ensured<br />
throughout the research process. All procedures were approved by technical<br />
advisory group of the rural MNCH programme of <strong>BRAC</strong>. Technical Advisory group<br />
included members from <strong>BRAC</strong>, Bangladesh <strong>and</strong> University of Aberdeen, UK.<br />
Table 2. Examples of matrix table of one theme from framework analysis of<br />
sources of information about MNCH print materials<br />
Main Theme: Sources of information about MNCH print materials<br />
ID<br />
Sources of<br />
no<br />
information<br />
Type of<br />
respondents<br />
22 Pregnant<br />
mother<br />
SS <strong>and</strong> SK<br />
from <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
Printed<br />
material<br />
seen<br />
Perceived<br />
underst<strong>and</strong><br />
ability<br />
Content recall Reasons for<br />
liking (with<br />
quote)<br />
Yes Yes 5 maternal<br />
danger signs,<br />
pic e.g.<br />
headache,<br />
bleeding,<br />
convulsion,<br />
fever, babies<br />
h<strong>and</strong>/leg<br />
come out first<br />
I like all; these<br />
are for our<br />
well being. If<br />
someone get<br />
pregnant she<br />
could see<br />
these, follow<br />
<strong>and</strong> can be<br />
well<br />
Reasons<br />
for<br />
disliking<br />
(with<br />
quote)<br />
Nothing to<br />
dislike<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
7
Table 3. Examples of matrix table of one theme from content analysis of<br />
difficulty to reach messages to the women through entertainment education<br />
Transcript/Meaning unit<br />
All family members went<br />
there except 1 or 2. They had<br />
work in the home. Para was<br />
big so most of the women<br />
were there because it was<br />
near to their home (ID: R)<br />
Women of this village<br />
watched the programme of<br />
local song. They said local<br />
song was performed by<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong>. Apa (SS) asked to join<br />
there. I could not enjoy due<br />
to household work.(ID: R)<br />
Sub-category/<br />
possible closest<br />
meaning<br />
Most of the women<br />
can watch street<br />
theatre if the<br />
settings is near to<br />
their household.<br />
Women could not<br />
enjoy due to her<br />
work. Although SS<br />
informed her<br />
previously<br />
Category Sub-theme Theme<br />
importance of<br />
settings <strong>and</strong><br />
distance for<br />
street theatre<br />
Traditional<br />
norms of<br />
household<br />
work is barrier<br />
to not<br />
watching local<br />
song<br />
Barriers to<br />
watching<br />
street theatre<br />
Barriers to<br />
watching<br />
local song<br />
Difficulty<br />
to reach<br />
messages<br />
to the<br />
women<br />
through<br />
entertainm<br />
ent<br />
education<br />
8 RED Working Paper No. 21
Findings<br />
Source of information about MNCH<br />
To explore the attention of the audience towards messages <strong>and</strong> materials on<br />
maternal, neonatal <strong>and</strong> child care, the respondents were asked about their<br />
knowledge on MNCH <strong>and</strong> how they had become aware of the danger signs during<br />
pregnancy, delivery, <strong>and</strong> post-partum period. The respondents were fully cognizant<br />
of the MNCH programme <strong>and</strong> BCC tools used by the <strong>BRAC</strong> programme. All were<br />
familiar with door-to-door home visits <strong>and</strong> face-to-face IPC with SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs; the<br />
flipcharts which are used by the SKs, <strong>and</strong> the posters <strong>and</strong> stickers given to them<br />
during IPC.<br />
Most of the respondents knew about the jarigaan (folksong) <strong>and</strong> the street theatre.<br />
They reported of getting key information about MNCH-related messages from these<br />
communication tools. The respondents also reported that the government produced<br />
entertainment television drama called Shukhi Paribar (The happy family) as another<br />
source of messages regarding maternal <strong>and</strong> child health <strong>and</strong> more general health as<br />
well.<br />
Majority of the female respondents cited Shishu Mongol-the MCWC as another<br />
source. As village doctors (VD) were easily accessible in the community, some<br />
respondents said that they got messages from VDs too. Besides, neighbours,<br />
friends, co-workers, <strong>and</strong> elder members of the family were other sources of<br />
information <strong>and</strong> advice about maternal <strong>and</strong> newborn healthcare.<br />
Interpersonal communication (IPC) as most acceptable channels by<br />
community people<br />
According to the SSs/SKs <strong>and</strong> study participants, one-to-one IPC was commonly<br />
used by SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs through regular home visits to pregnant women’s house. The<br />
SKs <strong>and</strong> SSs reported that sometimes they tried to arrange a group meeting with<br />
pregnant womens, neighbours, elderly <strong>and</strong> other female members <strong>and</strong> talked with<br />
several aspects of pregnancy <strong>and</strong> delivery care with the help of flipchart <strong>and</strong> posters<br />
of maternal danger signs. The community people liked SS <strong>and</strong> SK <strong>and</strong> had<br />
acceptability in the community.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
9
Box 1.<br />
Muslema (19) has no education. Her husb<strong>and</strong> is a mason <strong>and</strong> has a daughter aged<br />
13 months. She consulted a SS when her baby had diarrhoea. SS gave oral saline<br />
but the diarrhoea did not stop for 3 days. Then SS took the mother <strong>and</strong> baby to<br />
Sadar hospital. Her baby was examined by a MBBS doctor <strong>and</strong> had given some<br />
medicines including 4 injections. After 4 days her child’s diarrhoea got cured.<br />
Box 2.<br />
Tajul Islam (30) had completed higher secondary education. He went to the SS’s<br />
house for consultation when his wife had urine infection during pregnancy. The SS<br />
not only gave advice but also took his wife to an MBBS doctor. The doctor gave<br />
some medicines <strong>and</strong> soon his wife was cured from urine infection.<br />
KII with the mothers, mothers-in-law <strong>and</strong> husb<strong>and</strong>s reveal that the SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs have<br />
good relationship with pregnant women, family members <strong>and</strong> neighbours also during<br />
the antenatal visits. Community people were asked whether they could directly<br />
communicate with SS if necessary. Because the SS resides in their localities <strong>and</strong><br />
verbal communication was easy for them. Therefore, the respondents felt that they<br />
could ask any question if they did not underst<strong>and</strong> the messages during antenatal<br />
visit. As noted in the cases of Muslema <strong>and</strong> Tajul (Box 1 <strong>and</strong> 2), they got services<br />
from SSs <strong>and</strong> the SKs in case of complications due to SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs effective IPC<br />
skills.<br />
Community people, especially pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating women, mostly liked this faceto-face<br />
IPC because of the easy access to health services delivered to their home. A<br />
key informant lactating women mentioned,<br />
“Don’t you think there is a difference between verbal communication by<br />
home visit <strong>and</strong> voices over mike To me this one is better (face-to-face).<br />
Suppose you have come, talking with me <strong>and</strong> I am listening to you.”<br />
According to the community people <strong>and</strong> SSs, <strong>and</strong> SKs they used local dialect.<br />
Therefore, the messages were easily understood by the community people. This<br />
process was comprehensible to the community members because the SKs used<br />
flipchart during message delivery. That is why they could easily recognize the<br />
terminology applied to the maternal complications (Table 4). In the semi-structured<br />
interview a pregnant woman said,<br />
“As we can ask question without any hesitation, they speak like us. I do not<br />
have any problems to recognize their language.”<br />
10 RED Working Paper No. 21
Table 4. Local term used by community people <strong>and</strong> health workers<br />
Local term Approx. Bengali term used Approx. English term used<br />
Shabalika Shorir kharap First menstruation<br />
Gaye theka Gorvoboti hoa Being pregnant<br />
Jhika jhiki Khichuni Convulsion<br />
Chechuni Khichuni Convulsion<br />
Osh nama Shorire pani asha Oedema<br />
Okto Rokto Bleeding<br />
Khalash kora Proshob Delivery<br />
Jhar Gorvoful Placenta<br />
Dai Dhatri TBA<br />
Dhattani Dhatri TBA (who cut the cord)<br />
Ghorshon dhari Dhatri TBA (who delivered the baby)<br />
Tej Atirikto roktokhoron Excessive bleeding<br />
Joraur mukh bhanga Joraur mukh khola Open the mouth of uterus<br />
Kachra Moyla Dirty object<br />
Napak Opobitro Impure<br />
Dushi gorvo Mora Bachha prosob Stillbirth<br />
Frequent visits by SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs were another noticeable factor associated with<br />
acceptance of face-to-face IPC. Some of the pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating women reported<br />
that generally SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs visited their home twice <strong>and</strong> once in a month,<br />
respectively. The respondents desired more home visits by the SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs.<br />
Because the respondents perceived that with more regular visits from the SSs <strong>and</strong><br />
SKs, they could memorize the massages more. A semi-structured interview with the<br />
pregnant day labourer said,<br />
“If the Shasthya Kormi apa comes frequently <strong>and</strong> makes us underst<strong>and</strong> then<br />
we will memorize more. They come once in a month. That is why we could<br />
not memorize those (messages).”<br />
The respondents, however, did comment on what could be improved. Some of the<br />
community people mentioned that, SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs concentrated more on the pregnant<br />
women <strong>and</strong> newborn but relatively the frequency of home visits was less for neonate<br />
<strong>and</strong> child. A lactating women reported,<br />
“When I was pregnant they (SS/SK) came again <strong>and</strong> again, but after that we<br />
did not hear anything from them.”<br />
FGD <strong>and</strong> semi-structured interviews with all types of respondents reveal that IPC with<br />
group discussions by SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs did not seem to be structured. Several<br />
respondents urged that CHWs should talk to the community in group settings. Most<br />
of the respondents mentioned that they followed the messages given by SS <strong>and</strong> SK<br />
in their activities of daily life but they wished to share their experiences in group<br />
meeting. Most of the respondents agreed with this pregnant women’s opinion,<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
11
“They (SS <strong>and</strong> SK) did enough. Still they should come <strong>and</strong> teach frequently.<br />
They can call a meeting, gather people <strong>and</strong> then talk <strong>and</strong> give advice”.<br />
In the eyes of local people, the presence of higher officials coming from head office in<br />
the group meetings brought more credibility to local workers. It was the common<br />
dem<strong>and</strong> of most of them. A typical comment, during semi-structured interview of a<br />
husb<strong>and</strong> of a pregnant woman,<br />
“The group meeting should take place once in a month <strong>and</strong> will be better if<br />
higher officers come <strong>and</strong> conduct these meetings other than Shebika or<br />
Kormi.”<br />
A few respondents were of the opinion that higher class people question about SSs’<br />
capacity to detect health problems. According to them, the community people<br />
believed that due to their lower level of education <strong>and</strong> social status the SS was less<br />
well accepted in their society. It was reported that these higher status people such as<br />
economically solvent villagers felt that the SS training was not sufficient to enable<br />
them to adequately support the pregnant mother. Therefore, some people felt that<br />
they could not depend on them for pregnancy management. As noted in the case of<br />
Rokeya (Box 3), she claimed they (SS/SK) could not identify the problem of the baby<br />
during her pregnancy. A husb<strong>and</strong> of a pregnant woman said,<br />
“Rich <strong>and</strong> higher educated person (in the village) think that SSs/SKs do not<br />
know anything. They do not have faith in their training. So they ignored<br />
them.”<br />
Another male respondent who was a VD also pointed out that,<br />
Box 3.<br />
“They (<strong>BRAC</strong>) should hire educated SS like at least HSC or SSC<br />
completed…..”<br />
Rokeya (32) has no education. She was pregnant for three times <strong>and</strong> has two living<br />
children. Her last delivery was at home with the help of a dai (TBA). During this<br />
pregnancy she had an ultrasonography <strong>and</strong> found the baby in reverse position<br />
(malpresentation). According to her, SK came each month for check-up but she<br />
(SK) could not find the abnormality. She reported that her water (amniotic fluid)<br />
broke 3 days before delivery. During delivery the baby’s leg came out first <strong>and</strong> then<br />
they called the SS. It took time to get baby’s head out, but the baby was dead by<br />
then. A village doctor was also called but it was too late. Baby had died before he<br />
came.<br />
12 RED Working Paper No. 21
Entertainment education as powerful channels to disseminate the messages<br />
The majority of the respondents were aware of folksong <strong>and</strong> street theatre, but few<br />
had the opportunity to actually listen to or watch those. People liked to listen to<br />
folksong <strong>and</strong> watch street theatre as those were both entertaining <strong>and</strong> informative.<br />
According to the community people, folksong <strong>and</strong> street theatre were mostly listened<br />
to or watched by children <strong>and</strong> women of all ages. They felt that the medium of<br />
folksong could get people’s attention very quickly; it could disseminate many<br />
messages in a short time <strong>and</strong> in an amusing way which was reported to be attractive<br />
to community members. Most of the pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating mothers felt that the<br />
messages conveyed through folksong could easily reach the community people of<br />
different ages. They also reported that when a SS or SK visited their home, most of<br />
the time their children either teenager or adult, household head <strong>and</strong> other family<br />
members were not present. Therefore, because this show was arranged in open<br />
place, these family members could enjoy <strong>and</strong> learn without any restriction. A<br />
pregnant woman cited that,<br />
“…..different types of people including young, adult, <strong>and</strong> married, unmarried<br />
like jaarigan. Shebika visits <strong>and</strong> talk only with pregnant women. But jaarigan<br />
is underst<strong>and</strong>able to all whether men <strong>and</strong> women”.<br />
Most of the respondents recognized the value of watching street theatre because it<br />
not only have the voice but also the visualization. They found it was both spellbinding<br />
<strong>and</strong> captivating <strong>and</strong> watching along with others offers the opportunity of mutual<br />
support <strong>and</strong> learning. A lactating woman mentioned,<br />
“Drama is performed in front of us. It is underst<strong>and</strong>able. It is performed so<br />
nicely. Many people come <strong>and</strong> watch together, <strong>and</strong> if I forget any point of the<br />
drama other people could help me to remember. That is why I like drama<br />
than other media.”<br />
Most memorable part of the drama<br />
Women who had watched the drama had good memorization of the messages.<br />
Some of the pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating women concentrated only on those messages<br />
commonly refuted by mothers-in-law such as, taking rest, ANC <strong>and</strong> giving extra food<br />
during the pregnancy. Mothers reported that often the mothers-in-law forced<br />
pregnant women to do heavy work. They do not allow SS <strong>and</strong> SK to give advice to<br />
their daughters-in-law about ANC. As a result the women had given birth to a<br />
stillborn baby. Most of the pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating women showed good<br />
comprehension of the messages. They urged that more attention should be paid to<br />
communicating with elderly people. Because they felt that, elderly people did not give<br />
importance to these matters rather they followed traditional views.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
13
Frequency of watching/hearing folksong <strong>and</strong> street theatre<br />
The respondents considered that frequent watching of street theatre or hearing the<br />
folksong can be more useful for memorizing the messages. Many participants<br />
reported they have heard folksong 1 to 2 times but theatre was rarely seen by them.<br />
Community people suggested a change in programming of folksongs <strong>and</strong> theatre.<br />
They wanted to hear folksong <strong>and</strong> watch theatre more frequently. The IGD<br />
participants also reveal that community people wanted to see these show’s once in<br />
every quarter.<br />
Inappropriate time <strong>and</strong> location as barriers to enjoy<br />
Semi-structured interview, KII <strong>and</strong> FGD with all groups reveal that folksongs <strong>and</strong><br />
street theatres are ahead of IPC in terms of enjoy ability, but they were far behind<br />
from IPC in terms of knowledge dissemination coverage because of timing <strong>and</strong><br />
location. Most of the pregnant women, lactating mothers <strong>and</strong> mothers-in-law could<br />
not watch folksong because it was arranged at the hours when they were busy with<br />
their household works. As a mother-in-law said,<br />
“No, I did not listen to jaarigan, I was busy with my cooking but I wanted to<br />
listen to.”<br />
Furthermore, they had no advance notice of the show. Most of the time it was<br />
arranged hurriedly <strong>and</strong> within short time it was finished. A lactating mother said,<br />
“We were not informed about it (jaarigan) beforeh<strong>and</strong>. It was arranged<br />
hurriedly. One day unexpectedly a Shebika came <strong>and</strong> told about the show…<br />
if she had informed us previously many people would be there.”<br />
The timing of folksong <strong>and</strong> theatre was also not suitable for men. Because men<br />
would work during daytime, thus they were absent during the show time. Most male<br />
respondents mentioned that they were aware of folksong, for example, that it was<br />
arranged by <strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>and</strong> was about MNCH, but they were not concerned about the<br />
subject matter. A husb<strong>and</strong> of a pregnant woman said,<br />
“I did not give attention, I just heard music from distance, I could not tell what<br />
they were saying.”<br />
Distance from home was another most important barrier to attend the folksong. In<br />
addition, for women it was important that they had their husb<strong>and</strong>s’ consent to<br />
attend. If anyone contravened these traditional norms they would to face unusual<br />
comments of the community. A pregnant woman mentioned,<br />
“I did not go there as my husb<strong>and</strong> was not at home. Women from<br />
neighbourhood also did not go. If I go there people would talk bad about<br />
me.”<br />
14 RED Working Paper No. 21
Therefore, when the folksong or drama was arranged near their homes or with<br />
adequate notice then it was more easily accessible to the women.<br />
Perceptions about pictures of posters/stickers/flipcharts<br />
Posters with smiling face of mother <strong>and</strong> child were reported to be very attractive to<br />
the respondents. After identification of the pregnancy SKs gave the posters of healthy<br />
mother <strong>and</strong> healthy child which had the contact number (cell phone number) of the<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> CHWs. Mothers also have had interest especially in this poster. A pregnant<br />
woman said,<br />
“I have lost this (healthy mother <strong>and</strong> healthy child) poster at my previous<br />
pregnancy. But now I wanted it from SS.”<br />
Respondents unanimously stated that they liked all those pictures as well as<br />
messages. To them pictures could explain those messages better. It also helped<br />
them to memorize the messages. A male respondent said,<br />
“Those pictures are better than words; pictures help us to memorize which<br />
word alone cannot do.”<br />
Community people liked the messages because they thought that those were for<br />
their betterment. These pictures <strong>and</strong> messages would alert them about any danger<br />
before its occurrence <strong>and</strong> would help them prepare for taking action. A mother- inlaw<br />
said,<br />
“They (SS/SK) came <strong>and</strong> gave these,…I glued it in my home. Whoever<br />
comes can see these <strong>and</strong> these can be noticed all the time, which will help<br />
us to be alart. If any problem occurs can be taken to the hospital. By seeing<br />
these pictures we can memorize these well.”<br />
A husb<strong>and</strong> of a pregnant woman stated,<br />
“When my wife started bleeding during her pregnancy, I instantly recognized<br />
it as danger because I had seen the picture of danger signs before <strong>and</strong><br />
Shebika apa gave the message too.”<br />
However, some of the community people perceived poster’s pictures of maternal <strong>and</strong><br />
neonatal danger signs might be a cause of ‘bad fate’ for both the mother <strong>and</strong> child.<br />
Interestingly the notion of bad fate derived from the fear that treatment of<br />
complications would be unavailable to them because of economic reasons.<br />
“We do not have money. How we feel good in the case of such danger I am<br />
scared of these if it happens to me. From where <strong>and</strong> how can we manage<br />
money How will we be saved” said a pregnant woman.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
15
During the antenatal visits SKs told women to glue the posters/stickers in a suitable<br />
place to enable other family members to easily see <strong>and</strong> read messages of the<br />
pictures. However, there were various reasons given for not displaying the stickers<br />
<strong>and</strong> posters openly. Some of the pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating mothers felt that displaying<br />
the pictures of maternal danger signs inside their room, where they could be seen by<br />
the male relatives <strong>and</strong> parents-in-law, would be a shameful thing. Some, therefore,<br />
glued the posters or sticker of maternal danger signs either at the corner of the room<br />
or on the back of the door where they were not immediately obvious. A pregnant<br />
woman mentioned,<br />
“What will he think, if a man (purush manush) comes <strong>and</strong> sees these<br />
pictures I feel shy. That is why I glued this picture to the back of the door.”<br />
Women also kept the sticker <strong>and</strong> poster of maternal danger signs inside the drawer<br />
of the table because their husb<strong>and</strong>s had objection towards the posters. Women also<br />
perceived these poster <strong>and</strong> stickers were only for the pregnant women.<br />
“I have three children. I do not need to take more babies. That is why I do<br />
not need to hang the sticker up. So, I kept it in my drawer.”<br />
According to SKs, elderly people did not like open display of the stickers inside the<br />
room. Elderly <strong>and</strong> some of the more pious community members believe that prayer<br />
(namaj) is impossible if the posters illustrating human beings would have been hung<br />
inside the room. In some cases, children of the household also removed the posters<br />
from the door.<br />
Easy access to help given by the display of health workers’ cell number on<br />
posters <strong>and</strong> stickers<br />
Most of the respondents perceived that poster or stickers containing cell phone<br />
number of <strong>BRAC</strong> CHW gave community people assurance about the accessibility of<br />
help. They believed that in any complication, if they made a phone call (phone<br />
number mentioned in poster), <strong>BRAC</strong> staff would be there to help. A lactating mother<br />
described the circumstances of her delivery as follows,<br />
“When I was in excessive bleeding (in local term ‘Tej’) during delivery, Monju<br />
Apa (SS) feed me a tablet (misoprostol). Then we called [telephoned] Shonali<br />
Apa (SK). She came very soon after calling her.”<br />
Some women reported to seek help from SK by using the cell phone numbers as<br />
shown in the case of Muslema (Box 4).<br />
16 RED Working Paper No. 21
Box 4.<br />
Muslema (19) lives in the central part of the study site. She has no education. Her<br />
pregnancy was being monitored by SS <strong>and</strong> SK. From them she got the cell phone<br />
numbers of <strong>BRAC</strong>. She was advised by SK to call any of these cell phone<br />
numbers on the posters in case of emergency. At night of the expected day of<br />
delivery the SK waited at her home for long time. When there was no signs of<br />
delivery, apa (SK) was called. She came <strong>and</strong> gave an injection that help to regain<br />
the pain but that did not work. Then in the next afternoon the village doctor came<br />
to try with no effect. Finally, she was taken to the hospital at night by the help of<br />
SK. Doctor gave injection <strong>and</strong> saline <strong>and</strong> then at 4 a.m. she delivered the baby.<br />
Sharing messages with family members/neighbours by community people<br />
Women cited that generally they would like to talk about the messages given by SSs<br />
or SKs with their neighbours <strong>and</strong> same age groups. Men had the same desire for<br />
message sharing process as reported from FGD <strong>and</strong> semi-structured interview.<br />
However, women also reported that they shared about the danger signs with their<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>s. A pregnant woman said,<br />
“I pasted the sticker/poster of maternal danger signs in my home. Later, I<br />
requested my husb<strong>and</strong> to look at these pictures <strong>and</strong> thereby learn about<br />
these danger signs. Men, including you, do not know these things.”<br />
However, it was particularly difficult for pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating women to share<br />
knowledge or new messages with elderly people within the family or in the<br />
community because they hold their own traditional views on that. KIIs with pregnant<br />
<strong>and</strong> lactating women reveal that elderly women often do not want to accept new<br />
ways of pregnancy care such as necessity of taking rest, avoiding heavy workload,<br />
<strong>and</strong> having more nutritious <strong>and</strong> extra food during pregnancy.<br />
“Elderly people do not give importance to new messages rather they wish<br />
women would follow traditional practices,” said a pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating<br />
woman.<br />
Reaching family members with messages through community health<br />
workers<br />
IGDs with SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs reveal that usually they tried to contact with family members,<br />
especially elderly people <strong>and</strong> husb<strong>and</strong>, during antenatal visits because they<br />
considered them as important persons involved in the healthcare decisions such as:<br />
• seeking routine care during pregnancy or any other preventive care,<br />
• increasing or changing women’s diet during pregnancy <strong>and</strong> post-partum period,<br />
additional rest for the pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating women,<br />
• birth planning or birth preparation,<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
17
• referring women or baby with problems or sickness to health facilities, <strong>and</strong><br />
• family planning.<br />
However, SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs reported that usually they failed to contact the husb<strong>and</strong><br />
because they were absent in the home during SS <strong>and</strong> SKs’ home visits. None of the<br />
pregnant or lactating women reported that the SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs had talked with their<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>s. Most of the time the women themselves informed their spouses about the<br />
visits of the SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs, <strong>and</strong> they also shared the messages with their husb<strong>and</strong>s.<br />
Women mentioned that when their husb<strong>and</strong>s saw the posters of maternal danger<br />
signs only then they asked where from they got these. A pregnant woman said,<br />
“SK left the sticker on the table. My husb<strong>and</strong> saw it <strong>and</strong> asked ‘who gave<br />
this card Why’Then I said, ‘Monoara apa (SK) gave this’. But he did not<br />
say anything about this matter.”<br />
Another pregnant woman said,<br />
“My husb<strong>and</strong> read the messages of the posters/stickers <strong>and</strong> said to my<br />
mother-in -law that we have to go to hospitals if any danger sign appears.<br />
My mothers-in-law did not know these things beforeh<strong>and</strong>.”<br />
Women also talked about the <strong>BRAC</strong> MNCH services to their neighbour <strong>and</strong> relatives.<br />
The advice they gave to their relatives <strong>and</strong> neighbours was that which they received<br />
from SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs during their pregnancy. A lactating woman said,<br />
“If anybody is pregnant I tell them to contact Monju apa (SS) <strong>and</strong> Shonali apa<br />
(SK). When I was pregnant they advised me on maternal danger signs, ANC,<br />
PNC, Newborn care etc. So you also communicate with them”.<br />
Clarity <strong>and</strong> comprehensibility of the pictures of posters/stickers/flipcharts<br />
To assess the respondents’ level of underst<strong>and</strong>ing we showed them existing pictures<br />
of flipcharts <strong>and</strong> asked them to describe the pictures <strong>and</strong> tell us what message they<br />
were getting from them. Most of those pictures were correctly described by the<br />
participants <strong>and</strong> also they could recount the exact message (Annex 1). However, they<br />
experienced some difficulty in recognizing certain pictures <strong>and</strong> messages, e.g.<br />
maternal danger signs. They could not recognize the state of the mother that is,<br />
whether it was before <strong>and</strong> after delivery. But the respondents knew that these danger<br />
signs could occur during pregnancy, delivery, <strong>and</strong> after delivery. They also suggested<br />
that it would have been easy to underst<strong>and</strong> if there was a baby lying beside the<br />
mother in those pictures indicating maternal danger signs after delivery (Annex 2).<br />
Some of the participants found the pictures of cutting the baby’s cord with germ-free<br />
blade <strong>and</strong> the message on exclusive breast feeding for six months not clear. They felt<br />
that the pictures were not informative. They understood them because SS explained<br />
the messages. The respondents articulated the same opinion about the picture of<br />
18 RED Working Paper No. 21
irth asphyxia. They indicated that the picture did not communicate the message<br />
properly.<br />
Almost all pictures of both the flipcharts about maternal <strong>and</strong> newborn care, sticker<br />
<strong>and</strong> posters of maternal <strong>and</strong> newborn danger signs were comprehensible except<br />
few, e.g prolonged labour, use of a sanitary pad, cleanliness during pregnancy,<br />
assistance during delivery, retained placenta, one should not put anything to baby’s<br />
cord, baby’s eye infection, examination of baby’s breathing. Respondents had<br />
difficulty in grasping messages from these pictures (Annex 2).<br />
The pictures of poster, sticker <strong>and</strong> flipchart were supposed to be explained to the<br />
community people by SK in a group meeting or at each antenatal visit. The women<br />
stated that sometimes CHWs were in a hurry to explain <strong>and</strong> show poster only once.<br />
The respondents felt that if CHWs avoided hurriedness <strong>and</strong> would show the posters<br />
repeatedly, people could memorize it easily <strong>and</strong> communication would be more<br />
effective. Some of the respondents also mentioned that SK left the posters for 2 days<br />
at the house of pregnant women to see the pictures. That was why they could not<br />
underst<strong>and</strong> some of the pictures. One pregnant woman said,<br />
“(She) showed it (flipchart) once <strong>and</strong> it was with me for 2 days. I had no<br />
ability to underst<strong>and</strong> myself. After 2 days she returned the flipchart with her.<br />
And again when she came for ANC then made me underst<strong>and</strong> the pictures.”<br />
Another pregnant woman also mentioned,<br />
“(She) did not show anything rather just gave some advice. She gave me the<br />
card (stickers of maternal danger sign) <strong>and</strong> said whatever you are seeing, try<br />
to maintain[do this].”<br />
Even the messages about newborn care were not accessible to the pregnant<br />
women. Most of the pregnant women did not see the flipchart of newborn care. Here<br />
are some comments.<br />
“Apa did not show this book”<br />
“No, it was not showed to me”<br />
“This book (She) did not show this picture book”<br />
“No, I did not see (this book)”<br />
KII with the mothers reveals that women did not disclose the extent to which they<br />
understood (or failed to underst<strong>and</strong>) the messages of the pictures. Women asked<br />
CHWs about any queries related to pregnancy <strong>and</strong> delivery, but actually they were<br />
not always able to underst<strong>and</strong>. A pregnant woman said,<br />
“That which I underst<strong>and</strong> I say I underst<strong>and</strong> it <strong>and</strong> that which I don’t<br />
underst<strong>and</strong>, I say I underst<strong>and</strong> that too.”<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
19
Another pregnant woman also provide the same response,<br />
“I asked her please make me underst<strong>and</strong> the pictures. She responded but I<br />
could not remember. Apa (SK) talked but I did not give effort to remember<br />
those things.”<br />
Accessibility, acceptability <strong>and</strong> comprehensibility of the messages from<br />
mass media<br />
Television was more accessible to the community people rather than radio. Pregnant<br />
<strong>and</strong> lactating women liked to watch television at their own house or in a neighbour’s<br />
house. Generally they enjoyed a variety of shows here, but a health-related drama<br />
‘Shukhi Paribar’ was very acceptable to them. According to them this national<br />
television drama was a good source of information on MNCH <strong>and</strong> general health as<br />
well. Generally, household female members, neighbours <strong>and</strong> children enjoyed the<br />
drama show together. They felt the stories which were based on rural communities,<br />
actor <strong>and</strong> actress speak rural accent, their movements, attire, attitude everything was<br />
similar to them. That is why they feel closely with the television drama show. A<br />
pregnant mother said,<br />
“I like this television drama because it represents our words (views). I can<br />
relate the situation with my real life by watching this programme”.<br />
Most of them had ability to recall the messages of this drama. It was found that<br />
visualization of drama helped pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating mothers to underst<strong>and</strong> the<br />
messages given by SSs/SKs. For example, they accurately recounted messages<br />
about ensuring pregnant women take extra food, rest <strong>and</strong> proper sleep during<br />
pregnancy <strong>and</strong> about colostrum feeding.<br />
A lactating mother also had the ability to recall the dialogue of this television<br />
drama, “Duti sontaner beshi noe, ekti holey valo hoe (Having no more than<br />
two child, but one is better).”<br />
Though this television show had good acceptability to the pregnant women most of<br />
the lactating mothers could not watch the show regularly because of their household<br />
work <strong>and</strong> nurturing the baby. Men had no interest in watching this. Most of the<br />
pregnant women mentioned that their husb<strong>and</strong>s generally watched other shows in<br />
television but not Shukhi Paribar. Husb<strong>and</strong>s perceived that the show was just for<br />
women only. A pregnant woman said,<br />
“What will we discuss (about the shukhi paribar) He does not like this<br />
programme rather he likes hindi movie. He has no interest in this programme.<br />
That is why I do not tell him anything about it.”<br />
A husb<strong>and</strong> of a pregnant woman also said,<br />
“I watch TV only when the football or other matches are shown.”<br />
20 RED Working Paper No. 21
But other male respondents mentioned that they did not have enough time to watch<br />
television due to their workload.<br />
“I worked outside. When I came (at home) all of a sudden I watch TV.<br />
Otherwise I do not have time to watch TV.”<br />
<strong>Influence</strong>s of messages on attitudes <strong>and</strong> practices<br />
Increasing awareness of mother-in-law<br />
Though elderly people have traditional beliefs on healthcare <strong>and</strong> seeking care about<br />
pregnancy <strong>and</strong> post-partum, findings reveal that some elder community members<br />
actually perceived the urgency of ANC <strong>and</strong> health promoting practices for the<br />
pregnant women. Some of the women mentioned that their mothers-in-law took<br />
initiative for ANC for their daughters-in-law.<br />
“When I was in the third month of pregnancy, my mothers-in-law talked with<br />
Monoara apa (SK) <strong>and</strong> brought her to my house. From then she (the SK)<br />
came to check-up regularly at every month.”<br />
Increasing realization about importance of pregnancy care<br />
Community people could easily recall those messages which were related with their<br />
real life experiences, for example antenatal check-up, tetanus toxoid (TT) vaccination,<br />
birth preparedness, delivery danger signs, <strong>and</strong> use of cell phone number.<br />
Growing dem<strong>and</strong> for MNCH services<br />
Community people received messages positively. They mentioned that the messages<br />
raised awareness. Most of the community people now know about facilities available<br />
to them through health workers communications, posters, stickers <strong>and</strong> also local<br />
songs <strong>and</strong> street theatres. Now they felt it was their responsibility, <strong>and</strong> that if they<br />
could not follow the instruction given through the messages, maternal <strong>and</strong> neonatal<br />
health would never improve. Overall, the respondents considered that people were<br />
more aware now a day <strong>and</strong> they did what the CHWs told them to do. A mother of an<br />
under-five child stated,<br />
“Now we keep clean ourselves <strong>and</strong> take good care of our babies what we<br />
did not do before. Earlier we did not maintain any health rules that we do<br />
now <strong>and</strong> it makes our lives healthy <strong>and</strong> better.”<br />
Not only had that but community people realized the importance of healthcare during<br />
pregnancy. An SS mentioned that pregnancy identification was becoming easier than<br />
previously <strong>and</strong> the IGD with SSs reveal that not only was there improving<br />
consciousness about health among community members but among CHWs too.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
21
Improving health consciousness<br />
According to different types of interviews with the respondents there is a reported<br />
change regarding the accessing of health facilities. People have become more<br />
sensitized about danger signs in delivery. People now know different health-related<br />
problems, what causes them <strong>and</strong> their remedies. They also know what to do, where<br />
to go for proper treatment, <strong>and</strong> they were practicing it. They did not even depend on<br />
CHWs now; they would go to the health centres by themselves. Several respondents<br />
cited that they called SS first then the village doctors in case of danger during<br />
pregnancy <strong>and</strong> delivery. A father of a child under one year said,<br />
“If we need any kind of treatment we would like to go Shishu Mongal<br />
(MCWC). For diarrhea <strong>and</strong> fever we like to go to the SS. If not cured, we<br />
prefer the village doctor because he is accessible to us.”<br />
Another woman stated,<br />
“Before if any problem persists, we just sit in the house <strong>and</strong> do nothing,<br />
nowadays if we face any problem, we go to shebikas <strong>and</strong> whenever the<br />
problem is serious we would go to hospital.”<br />
Taking right decision by mutual underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />
During the KIIs with the women it was found that the messages had some sort of<br />
influences on community member’s attitude that leads them to make health<br />
promoting decisions. A lactating mother went to enjoy the street theatre with her<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>. After the end of the show, her husb<strong>and</strong> told her about the importance of<br />
the healthcare,<br />
“Let’s drop the mistakes which we made before, the mistake which has<br />
occurred during our marriage, just let bygone be bygones. We watched,<br />
heard, <strong>and</strong> whatever learnt we will implement. We will not repeat the same<br />
mistakes in the case of our child.”<br />
Message application in personal life by health workers<br />
Health workers reported that they follow these messages in their own life for their<br />
own sake. They believe that they should practice these first before disseminating<br />
those messages <strong>and</strong> give advice to others to practice, otherwise they would not<br />
listen to <strong>and</strong> practice. One SK stated,<br />
“When we started giving de worming tablets to pregnant women there was<br />
confusion about its safety among women. At that time I was pregnant too<br />
<strong>and</strong> I took the tablet to prove <strong>and</strong> assure them that it was safe.”<br />
22 RED Working Paper No. 21
Discussion<br />
This research found that face-to-face IPC strategy by SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs was reported to<br />
influence community members to change their attitude <strong>and</strong> behaviour with respect to<br />
maternal <strong>and</strong> child healthcare. IPC channels have been most successful in influencing<br />
community’s knowledge, attitudes <strong>and</strong> motivating behaviour change, while mass<br />
media i.e, street theatre, folksong (jarigaan) <strong>and</strong> television were also important<br />
credible sources of information. In order to increase comprehensibility of the<br />
messages from print materials we identified revisions are need to reprint the BCC<br />
materials.<br />
A review of selected interventions in South Asia shows that IPC seems to be the<br />
strongest form of BCC in this region (28). In 2007, Hirondelle Foundation found that<br />
informal face-to-face communication was the most reliable source of information in<br />
the Timor-Leste (29). This study shows that in the community, IPC make it possible<br />
for people to exchange information, express their feelings, obtain immediate<br />
feedback, <strong>and</strong> respond to questions for removing doubts <strong>and</strong> misconceptions <strong>and</strong> to<br />
support one another as they implement new knowledge. Reasons for acceptability of<br />
IPC include common language, mutual underst<strong>and</strong>ing of cultural issues, rapport<br />
building, easy way of asking questions, <strong>and</strong> ability to direct communication with<br />
providers. Furthermore, from a gender perspective, female health workers (SS <strong>and</strong><br />
SK) were key in communicating with pregnant women <strong>and</strong> lactating mothers<br />
because women have some kind of fellow feeling with SS <strong>and</strong> SK as the latter come<br />
from within the community with more or less similar socioeconomic background.<br />
Leventhal noted that during IPC that the communicator can ensure receiver<br />
comprehension by asking questions <strong>and</strong> observing where underst<strong>and</strong>ing is faulty<br />
(30). Thus, this two-way interaction is essential for identifying the level of readiness for<br />
change <strong>and</strong> for convincing <strong>and</strong> supporting individuals to adopt health-prompting<br />
behaviour (31). This challenge <strong>and</strong> support can be delivered in one to one situations<br />
in highly customized way by the SS <strong>and</strong> SK although it was found that they are often<br />
hurried in their house to house visits. This is likely to limit the degree of<br />
personalization of the messages delivered <strong>and</strong> according to our findings, limits the<br />
extent to which they take feedback about whether messages are understood. MNCH<br />
programme should address the skill of taking feedback as part of the ongoing inservice<br />
training for SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs.<br />
On the other h<strong>and</strong>, the respondents also advocated for increased use of group<br />
meetings. The study further shows that the mechanisms by which effective<br />
communication was achieved included the fact that here both recipients <strong>and</strong><br />
providers could contribute essential information <strong>and</strong> ideas. For example, both spoke<br />
<strong>and</strong> listened to, both were asked questions, expressed opinions, <strong>and</strong> exchanged<br />
information, <strong>and</strong> both were able to fully underst<strong>and</strong> what the other was trying to say<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
23
(29). A community member who felt that they did not underst<strong>and</strong> or could not<br />
remember a message could ask a peer for clarity.<br />
Factors such as the degree of privacy, time selected for encounters, comfort, <strong>and</strong><br />
waiting time can also inhibit or enhance individual/group-provider interaction (29).<br />
Results reveal that messages did not effectively reach secondary audiences such as<br />
men <strong>and</strong> elderly due to their unavailability in the household at the time of visit of the<br />
SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs <strong>and</strong> because of the persistence of traditional beliefs <strong>and</strong> attendant<br />
resistance to modern healthcare systems. There was little evidence that men <strong>and</strong> the<br />
elderly engaged in peer support. In Tanzania, under the KINSHAI project, eight peer<br />
support groups were established to provide HIV/AIDS education to the community.<br />
Each group consists of 25 members aged at least 60. From each group four<br />
individuals were trained by KINSHAI. Members of the groups have reported reduced<br />
stigma from their communities <strong>and</strong> a greater sense of hope <strong>and</strong> well-being (32).<br />
MNCH programme may arrange group meeting with both the mother-in-law <strong>and</strong><br />
daughter-in-law about their role <strong>and</strong> relationship in pregnancy <strong>and</strong> delivery care.<br />
Flash cards including men’s role in pregnancy <strong>and</strong> delivery care of his wife,<br />
importance of ANC, delivery preparedness can be distributed to increase men’s<br />
comprehensibility in these issues. There is also room for more targeted<br />
communication with older members of the community.<br />
Effective communication programme could explore new ways to use peer groups to<br />
convey messages <strong>and</strong> also reinforce the practice of the key messages in their real<br />
life. However, depending on intervention site, peer educators are often illiterate, which<br />
especially in our study areas where there was discrimination against lower status <strong>and</strong><br />
poorly educated SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs could be considered to be a disadvantage to the peer<br />
education method (33).<br />
It was found that community had a perception of SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs as poorly educated<br />
<strong>and</strong> of low status. To overcome this perception, programmes should give importance<br />
of effective training which may increase rapport-building, communication <strong>and</strong><br />
negotiation skills. While SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs are given foundation or some basic training on<br />
MNCH <strong>and</strong> essential healthcare. Regular refresher training is also given for one day<br />
every month. If they are adequately trained <strong>and</strong> exposed to identify health problem,<br />
they will have adequate skills to assess, manage <strong>and</strong> take right decisions to save<br />
mother <strong>and</strong> newborn lives. However, the technical medical skills listed should be<br />
buttressed by further training in assertive communication. There are many<br />
programmes that report successful training of CHWs (34, 35). Soloman et al. found<br />
that in the Ghananian community health volunteer’s drug management skills were<br />
good, the response of the community was positive. In Ghana, community volunteers<br />
were trained for 7-18 days on diagnosis of trachoma, the use of azithromycine, <strong>and</strong><br />
side effect of the drugs. After training, each volunteer was asked to examine the<br />
member of household in the presence of doctor <strong>and</strong> ophthalmic nurse (35).<br />
24 RED Working Paper No. 21
It was revealed that village doctors still play an important <strong>and</strong>, at times, perverse role<br />
in the care of mothers <strong>and</strong> neonates. So, non-professional healthcare providers may<br />
also be included in the effective training on MNCH care.<br />
In the case of <strong>BRAC</strong>, MNCH committee could perform a significant role. As per rules<br />
<strong>and</strong> regulation MNCH committee members introduced the SSs as healthcare<br />
providers in the community. The process of introducing SS should be credible to the<br />
community.<br />
The flipcharts <strong>and</strong> posters were found to be popular materials, because the<br />
community people considered it for easy memorization of the danger signs, <strong>and</strong><br />
getting cell phone numbers for emergency of help. Religious <strong>and</strong> cultural reasons<br />
were found to be the barriers to adopt the pictures of maternal danger signs.<br />
Biologically each individual are unique, but culturally they belong to same ground<br />
where their beliefs st<strong>and</strong>s for. Pictorial forms of communication have been<br />
considered by many NGOs <strong>and</strong> the government as the best way to address people<br />
at the rural level, because if well designed <strong>and</strong> adequately pre-tested this<br />
communication medium is easy to underst<strong>and</strong> (33). Our findings reveal that<br />
community people had their own perceptions regarding the photos of flipchart <strong>and</strong><br />
posters. As most of the community people were not literate, CHWs should be<br />
capable of teaching them effectively taking account of their perceptions. The pictures<br />
which were misunderstood or found culturally unacceptable by community people<br />
should be revised. Our flipchart mostly gives one message per page. However, there<br />
is evidence that people could more easily underst<strong>and</strong> the pictures if it contains some<br />
stories <strong>and</strong> parables. In Niger, a popular flipchart tells the story of two characters,<br />
Aicha <strong>and</strong> Mariama, who have opposite experiences with nutrition <strong>and</strong> family<br />
planning. The village women used to discuss their stories as this flipchart was so<br />
popular to them (36).<br />
Effective <strong>and</strong> sustainable posters are essential for different target groups. In Nepal, a<br />
variety of innovative print materials have been produced under SUMATA (Care,<br />
Share, Prepare) initiatives including posters, lampshades, danglers, <strong>and</strong> prayer flags<br />
featuring the SUMATA images <strong>and</strong> messages of care, share <strong>and</strong> prepare. It was<br />
found that they had three different types of posters promoting care, share, <strong>and</strong><br />
prepare for both urban <strong>and</strong> rural couple, <strong>and</strong> mother-in-law. These print materials are<br />
used by Nepal Safe Motherhood Programme at mother-in-law <strong>and</strong> daughter-in-law<br />
meetings <strong>and</strong> adapted by local community-based organizations into own formats<br />
(37). However, flipcharts are expensive <strong>and</strong> cannot be mass-produced for each<br />
woman. It is, therefore, essential to make story-based flipcharts <strong>and</strong> h<strong>and</strong>outs by<br />
most community-based group/peer committees. It was found that peer-to-peer<br />
process of communication through flipcharts were successful in creating a<br />
sympathetic connection between a trainee <strong>and</strong> audience (35).<br />
The study quickly discovered that shukhi paribar-the national TV drama facilitates<br />
community people to think about care of pregnant mother. Many projects have<br />
supported the idea that entertainment media can play a positive role in educating the<br />
public about significant health issues (12, 38-42). In 1984, India began broadcasting<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
25
for 17 month the first soap opera titled ‘we people’. It was about promotion of family<br />
planning <strong>and</strong> elevation of the status of women. Research indicates that 70% of the<br />
viewers think that they had learned that women should have the freedom to make<br />
their personal decisions about life <strong>and</strong> family size (37). Nigeria, Maldives, South Africa<br />
<strong>and</strong> India also experienced similar success with television (12, 40, 41). However, it<br />
was difficult to accurately measure the influence of this programme in relation to the<br />
adoption of positive maternal <strong>and</strong> child health promoting practices. The impact<br />
appeared in our study to be associated with the support the television show brought<br />
to what community members learned through IPC. The influence of audience<br />
involvement on IPC showed an overlap of mass media <strong>and</strong> IPC reported by Sood<br />
(42). The present study also found that though few of the community people had<br />
access to watch television programmes <strong>and</strong> mothers-in-law <strong>and</strong> husb<strong>and</strong>s of the<br />
women were not seen the television programme mostly. So community television,<br />
where more individuals gather around, can be one of the way to broadcast health<br />
related programmes. MNCH programme should consider the distribution of DVDs.<br />
Though radio <strong>and</strong> television are not widely available in our communities, folksong is<br />
also an effective mass media. Community people have eagerness for entertainment<br />
education. This kind of low cost <strong>and</strong> low tech communication systems may be<br />
effective for promotion of any social <strong>and</strong> behaviour change. Folk song as reported<br />
was a good way to quickly disseminate messages to the community. Memorization<br />
was easy as people can watch, hear <strong>and</strong> interpret the story at the same time. If the<br />
folk song is properly organized in a systematic manner any intervention has<br />
opportunities to quickly share messages.<br />
It was also reported in several studies that using traditional media as a BCC method<br />
may be effective (11, 12, 43). In Tanjania, traditional singing <strong>and</strong> dancing<br />
performance called mamanju is held as part of a three-day festival on the theme of<br />
skilled care. Incorporating music, singing <strong>and</strong> traditional dancing, in Burkina Faso, the<br />
performances dramatized different scenarios to promote use of facility-based skilled<br />
care. This medium can work more fruitfully if it is used more strategically. The<br />
performances should be staged in conjunction with the community events, such as<br />
holiday, village market day (hat bar), traditional day, special open days at health<br />
facilities, community-level meetings, etc. Besides the local drama troupes, TBAs<br />
could play an important role in disseminating the messages. TBAs in the remote rural<br />
district of Pallisa in eastern Ug<strong>and</strong>a play a significant role through some simple songs<br />
where they are able to teach mothers about ANC, birth preparedness, newborn care,<br />
also cite the major local killers of women in childbirth such as, anemia, cephalo-pelvic<br />
disproportion, maleria <strong>and</strong> facilitate early identification <strong>and</strong> referral. It was seen that in<br />
these villages without doctors <strong>and</strong> hospitals, TBAs <strong>and</strong> community members<br />
themselves are solving the most serious health problems through the teaching power<br />
of songs <strong>and</strong> stories (44).<br />
Our findings reveal that in Nilphamari these media were used rarely <strong>and</strong> messages<br />
could not reach to the community properly due to unsuitable time <strong>and</strong> place of<br />
organization. But research confirmed that entertainment educations are highly<br />
acceptable in communicating maternal <strong>and</strong> child health information <strong>and</strong> influencing<br />
26 RED Working Paper No. 21
community to behaviour change. As we found they have had emotional engagement<br />
with the materials (stories, lyrics, languages, plays, artists) of street theatre. Women<br />
could identify <strong>and</strong> evaluate the situation in terms of their own lives <strong>and</strong> perceived<br />
realities. Research identified that when characters express their feelings, the audience<br />
responds emotionally (42, 45). Though the community people had limited education,<br />
communication materials were easily understood by them. It was accepted due to its<br />
traditional popularity <strong>and</strong> easy way of communication. In India, street theatre was<br />
effective for HIV/AIDS programme although had limited formal education <strong>and</strong> also the<br />
audience due to its traditional popularity <strong>and</strong> cost effectiveness (42). For maximum<br />
audience coverage <strong>and</strong> rigorous dissemination this media performance should be<br />
arranged regularly with especial focus on the specific issues.<br />
Combining interpersonal, mass media <strong>and</strong> community-based communication<br />
channels like local song, street theatre <strong>and</strong> puppet show can help maximize the<br />
effect of a BCC programme. But the programme should identify the right way to mix<br />
channels considering time, place, gender, story, <strong>and</strong> availability of mass<br />
communication channels. Because, individuals vary in levels of motivation <strong>and</strong> are at<br />
different points in the process of change they can benefit from different interventions<br />
(40). One method is not effectively sustainable without support of other methods. It<br />
is, therefore, important to segment the audience <strong>and</strong> apply a suite of communication<br />
methods that reinforce one another.<br />
Many countries undertook interventions applying the mixed method strategy for<br />
behaviour change. In Egypt ‘The Mabruk’ initiative offers a comprehensive package<br />
of messages using a mix of different channels <strong>and</strong> strategies (46). In Taiwan the field<br />
workers transfer knowledge <strong>and</strong> adoption of family planning practice to newlyweds<br />
through posters <strong>and</strong> community meetings. With the addition of mass media<br />
intervention, the programme was recognized as one of the first family planning<br />
successes (47). One of the poorest countries of Asia, Timor-Leste has also<br />
developed mix communication strategy for child health development including IPC,<br />
advocacy, community mobilization, E-E <strong>and</strong> mass media. The Soul City experience in<br />
South Africa used several forms of media (television, radio <strong>and</strong> comic strip) each<br />
carrying a different storyline (40). Using the E-E approach, the SUMATA initiatives are<br />
also developed including radio spots <strong>and</strong> dramas, print materials, a television drama<br />
<strong>and</strong> community-based street theatre performances (38). Thus, this combined<br />
process of health education can play a fundamental role in continuing education.<br />
Then a programme can achieve long-term sustainability of health promotion efforts.<br />
In conclusion, overall we found that the MNCH messages were acceptable; for the<br />
most part comprehensible <strong>and</strong> were reported to have begun to effect change in the<br />
behaviours of all types of respondents, including, the health workers themselves.<br />
Some of the materials need to be revisied to improve comprehensibility. Although<br />
there is evidence that a programme with a BCC component can produce effective<br />
results but it was not clear that how much value the BCC component contributes.<br />
Besides these limitations, findings suggest that within the <strong>BRAC</strong> MNCH<br />
communication strategy, there should be more application of differentiated messages<br />
for segmented audiences <strong>and</strong> ongoing use of multi-media communication. Ongoing<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
27
monitoring should identify how best to combine IPC, traditional <strong>and</strong> mass media in<br />
different field situations.<br />
Implications of findings for programme:<br />
This study recommends some specific actions to improve MNCH-related<br />
communication. These are as follows:<br />
• Improve training on message content <strong>and</strong> communication skills of SSs, SKs <strong>and</strong><br />
MNCH Committee members, particularly on the preventive <strong>and</strong> promotive<br />
aspects of MNCH <strong>and</strong> specifically on the newer messages (safe birth planning,<br />
danger signs of pregnancy, delivery, newborn care <strong>and</strong> danger signs).<br />
• Increase number of SK visits during pregnancy <strong>and</strong> post-natal period.<br />
• Revise illustration in flip charts, posters <strong>and</strong> stickers in accordance with the study<br />
findings.<br />
• During home visits, SKs should emphasize <strong>and</strong> explain in detail using local<br />
terminology, the pictures that difficult to underst<strong>and</strong> (bleeding during pregnancy,<br />
delivery <strong>and</strong> post-partum, prolong labour, retained placenta, <strong>and</strong> maternal<br />
headache). CHWs can tell practical stories at the time of showing posters or<br />
flipcharts.<br />
• Participatory group meeting headed by senior officers (PO/BM/RM) can be useful<br />
to reinforce messages communicated by junior SSs <strong>and</strong> SKs.<br />
• Improve communication with key decision-makers such as the elderly <strong>and</strong> male<br />
members of the household not only the mother alone. Design <strong>and</strong> pre-test<br />
specific messages for men <strong>and</strong> mothers-in-law. For example, include the role of<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> mother-in-law in messages.<br />
• Align delivery of messages to annual patterns of pregnancy <strong>and</strong> birth (Annex 4).<br />
• The growing popularity of entertainment education, programme should<br />
concentrate on developing the characters of drama which the community<br />
members can relate with them. And the characters have ability to elicit emotional<br />
reaction which would be positive towards the performing the new behaviour.<br />
Street theatres <strong>and</strong> local songs should be arranged in market place for children<br />
<strong>and</strong> elderly people at times suitable for them.<br />
• Programme may start to employ some small format of community media such as<br />
loudspeakers or megaphones-stationary (those in mosques <strong>and</strong> connected to<br />
vehicles)’, organize participatory drama; test SMS messaging, quiz etc. to SSs,<br />
SKs <strong>and</strong> interested community peoples <strong>and</strong> MNCH committee members.<br />
• Hence many women <strong>and</strong> mothers-in-law were not able to enjoy street theatre<br />
<strong>and</strong> folk song due to their household work a video drama about change focused<br />
on gender, women’s status, household work sharing, husb<strong>and</strong>s, mother-in-laws<br />
<strong>and</strong> other family member’s responsibility, delivery preparedness etc. <strong>and</strong> that can<br />
be arrange in a pregnant women’s house.<br />
28 RED Working Paper No. 21
References<br />
1. NIPORT, ORC Macro, Johns Hopkins University, <strong>and</strong> ICDDR,B. Bangladesh maternal<br />
health services <strong>and</strong> maternal mortality survey 2001. Dhaka <strong>and</strong> Claverton: NIPORT, ORC<br />
Macro, Johns Hopkins University <strong>and</strong> ICDDR, B, 2003.<br />
2. NIPORT, Mitra <strong>and</strong> associates, <strong>and</strong> Macro International. Bangladesh demographic <strong>and</strong><br />
health survey 2007. Dhaka <strong>and</strong> Claverton: NIPORT, Mitra Associate <strong>and</strong> Macro<br />
International, 2009.<br />
3. Bhuiya A <strong>and</strong> Streatfield K. Feeding home-remedy practices <strong>and</strong> consultation with<br />
healthcare providers during childhood illness in rural Bangladesh. J Diarrhoeal Dis<br />
Res1995;13(2):106-12.<br />
4. Goodburn EA <strong>and</strong> Gazi R. Maternal morbidity relating to delivery <strong>and</strong> the puerperium:<br />
beliefs <strong>and</strong> practices in rural Bangladesh. (unpublished) Dhaka: <strong>BRAC</strong>, 1993.<br />
5. Adebiyi A, Ganesan PA, Prasad RNV. Papaya (carica papaya) consumption is unsafe in<br />
pregnancy: fact or fable scientific evaluation of a common belief in some parts of asia<br />
using a rat model. Br J Nutri 2002;88:199–23.<br />
6. Darmstadt GL, Syed U, Patel Z, Kabir N. Review of domiciliary newborn-care practices in<br />
Bangladesh. J Health Popul Nutr 2006;24(4):380-93.<br />
7. Gurung G. Practices on immediate care of newborn in the communities of Kailali district.<br />
Nepal Med College J 2008;10(1):41-4.<br />
8. Winch PJ, Alam MA, Akther A, Afroz D, Ali NA, Allis AA, Baqui H, Darmstadt G, El Arifeen<br />
S, Habibur RSM. Local underst<strong>and</strong>ings of vulnerability <strong>and</strong> protection during the neonatal<br />
period in Sylhet district, Bangladesh: a qualitative study. Lancet 2005;366(9484):478-85.<br />
9. Mohan P, Lyengar SD, Agarwal K, Martines JC, Sen K. Care seeking practices in rural<br />
Rajasthan: barriers <strong>and</strong> facilitating factors. J Perinatol 2008;28(suppl 2):S31-7.<br />
10. Jalil F. Perinatal health in Pakistan: a review of the current situation. Acta Paediatrica<br />
2004;93(10):1273-9.<br />
11. Piotrow PT <strong>and</strong> Rimon JG. New directions in family planning communication: 12<br />
predictions for the 1990s. Asia-Pacific Popul J 1988;3(4):17-32.<br />
12. Hornik RC. Public health communication: evidence for behavior change.<br />
http://books.google.com/booksid=0SaSVp3BMzYC&dq=public+health+communication<br />
&printsec=frontcover&source=in&hl=en&ei=L9RLTOPQHpf80wTXiOWECw&sa=X&oi=bo<br />
ok_result&ct=result&resnum=12&ved=0CEQQ6AEwCw#v=onepage&q&f=false<br />
(accessed 17.02.2011).<br />
13. Pulmgreen P, Donohew L, Lorch EP, Hoyel RH, Stephenson MT. Television campaigns<br />
<strong>and</strong> adolescent marijuana use: tests of sensation seeking targeting. Am J Public Health<br />
2001;91(2):292-6.<br />
14. Farelley MC, Devis KC, Havil<strong>and</strong> ML, Messei P, Healton CG. Evidence of a doseresponse,<br />
relationship between “truth” antismoking ads <strong>and</strong> youth smoking prevalence.<br />
Am J Public Health 2005;95(3):425-31.<br />
15. Niederdeppe J, Farreley MC, Havil<strong>and</strong> ML. Confirming truth. more evidence of a<br />
successful tobacco counters marketing campaign in Florida. Am J Public Health<br />
2004;94:255-7.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
29
16. Sood S, Ch<strong>and</strong>ra U, Mishra P, Neupane S. Measuring the effects of behavior change<br />
interventions in Nepal with population based survey results. Johns Hopkins Bloomberg<br />
School <strong>and</strong> Public Health. Center for Communication programme, 2004.<br />
http://www.jhpiego.org/resources/pubs/mnh/mnhSurveyRpt_Nepal.pdf(accessed<br />
16.02.2011).<br />
17. Vaughan PW, Regis A, Catherine F. Effects of an entertainment-education radio-soap<br />
opera on family planning <strong>and</strong> HIV prevention in St.Lucia. Int Fam Plann Perspectives<br />
2000;26(4):148-57.<br />
18. Lantican CM: Behavioral change communication <strong>and</strong> advocacy <strong>and</strong> information <strong>and</strong><br />
communications technology as tools for population <strong>and</strong> development <strong>and</strong> poverty<br />
reduction; selected papers of the fifth Asian <strong>and</strong> Pacific Population Conference.<br />
http://www.unescap.org/esid/psis/population/popseries/apss158/part2_4.pdf(accessed<br />
22.02.2011)<br />
19. Afsana K, Rashid SF. Discoursing birthing care: experiences from Bangladesh. Dhaka:<br />
The University Press Limited.2000;128p<br />
20. Banu M, Nahar S, Nasreen HE. Assessing the manoshi referral system. addressing<br />
delays in seeking emergency obstetric care in Dhaka slums. Dhaka: <strong>BRAC</strong>, 2010.20p<br />
(Manoshi Working Paper No.10).<br />
21. Salam SS, Khan MA, Salahuddin S, Choudhury N, Nicholls P, Nasreen HE. Maternal,<br />
neonatal <strong>and</strong> child health in selected northern districts of Bangladesh. findings from<br />
baseline survey 2008. Dhaka: <strong>BRAC</strong>,2008.<br />
22. Guin LA. Triangulation: establishing the validity of qualitative studies.FCS6014, Institute of<br />
Food <strong>and</strong> Agricultural Sciences, University of Florida, 2002. http://www.raymanbacchus.net/uploads/documents/Triangulation.pdf(accessed<br />
22.02.2011).<br />
23. Oliver DG, Serovich JM, Mason TL. Constraints <strong>and</strong> opportunities with interview<br />
transcription: towards reflection in qualitative research. Soc Forces. 2005;84(2):1273-89.<br />
24. Shrivastava A, Thomson AB. Framework analysis: a qualitative methodology for applied<br />
policy research. JOAAG 2009;4(2):72-9.<br />
25. Rabiee F. Focus group interview <strong>and</strong> data analysis. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society.<br />
2004;63:655-60.<br />
26. Graneheim UH <strong>and</strong> Lundman B. Qualitative content analysis in nursing research:<br />
concepts, procedures <strong>and</strong> measures to achieve trustworthiness; Nurse Edu Today<br />
2004;24:105-12.<br />
27. Burnard P. A method of analysing interview transcripts in qualitative research. Nurse Edu<br />
Today 1991;11:461-6.<br />
28. Community based interventions that improve newborn health outcomes: a review of<br />
evidence in south asia. Evidence review series-5 2008.<br />
http://www.intrahealth.org/~intrahea/files/media/maternal-neonatal-<strong>and</strong>-childrenshealthfamily-planning/ER_Brief_NBC%205.pdf<br />
(accessed 25.7.10).<br />
29. Mosquera M, Obregon R, Lopez R. Behavior change communication strategy for child<br />
health 2008. http://www.basics.org/documents/12-Timor-Leste-BCC-Strategy-for-Child-<br />
Health_Draft.pdf (accessed 22.02.2011).<br />
30. Leventhal H. Changing attitudes <strong>and</strong> habits to reduce risk factors in chronic disease. Am<br />
J Cardiol 1973;31:571-80.<br />
31. Cassell MM, Jackson C, Cheuvront. Health communication on the internet: an effective<br />
channel for health behavior change J Health Communi: Int Pers 1988;3(1):71-9.<br />
30 RED Working Paper No. 21
32. Tanjanias elderly coming out from the darkness.<br />
http://www.rapidfundingenvelop.org/pdf/SuccessStories/0507_KINSHAI.pdf (accessed<br />
18.8.2010).<br />
33. Kozara KM. Reproductive health <strong>and</strong> behavior change communications: situational<br />
analysis/existing interventions in Bangladesh. James P. Grant School of Public Health<br />
Dhaka, 2008. 12p. (Monograph Series No.8).<br />
34. Afsar HA, Qureshi AF, Younus M, Gulb A, Mahmood A. Factors affecting unsuccessful<br />
referral by the lady health workers in Karachi, Pakistan. J Pak Med Assoc<br />
2003;53(11):521-8.<br />
35. Soloman AW, Akudbillah J, Abugri P, Hagan M, Foster A, Bailey RL et al. Pilot study of<br />
the use of community health workers to distribute Azithromycine for trachoma control in<br />
Ghana. Bull WHO 2001;79(8-14).<br />
36. Flip Charts: Trachoma health education materials library.<br />
http://www.cartercenter.org/health/trachoma_education/flipcharts.html(accessed<br />
22.11.2010).<br />
37. The Maternal & Neonatal Health Program: Nepal.<br />
http://zambia.jhuccp.org/asia/nepal/maternal.shtml(accessed 27.10.2010).<br />
38. Daly P, Taylor M, Tinker A. Integrating essential newborn care into countries policies <strong>and</strong><br />
programs. Policy perspectives on newborn Health. 2003.<br />
http://www.prb.org/pdf/integratessentcare_eng.pdf (accessed 17.02.2011).<br />
39. The Henry J Kaiser Family Foundation (2004). Entertainment education <strong>and</strong> health in the<br />
United States.<br />
http://www.kff.org/entmedia/loader.cfmurl=/commonspot/security/getfile.cfm&PageID=<br />
34381(accessed 8.7.2010).<br />
40. UNFPA (2002). Communication/behavior change tools; Program Briefs No-1<br />
Entertainment-Education. http://ceae.colorado.edu/meedc/pdf/Behavior%20communication%20change%20tools.pdf<br />
(accessed 23.05.2010).<br />
41. INFO Reports (2008): Entertainment-education for better health.<br />
http://info.k4health.org/inforeports/E-E/E-E.pdf (accessed 21.06.2010).<br />
42. Sood S. Audience involvement <strong>and</strong> entertainment-education. Communi<br />
Theory;2002;12(2):153-72.<br />
43. Knippenberg R, Lawn JE, Darmstadt GL, Begkoyian G, Fogstad H, Walelign N et al.<br />
Systematic scaling up of neonatal care in countries. Lancet 2005;365(9464):1087-98.<br />
44. Silver D. Songs <strong>and</strong> storytelling: bringing health messages to life in Ug<strong>and</strong>a; education for<br />
health: change in learning <strong>and</strong> practice. Edu Health. 2001;14(1):51-60.<br />
45. Kincaid DL. Drama, emotion <strong>and</strong> cultural convergence. Communi Theory<br />
2002;12(2):136-52.<br />
46. Communication initiative network. http://www.comminit.com/en/node/276306/38<br />
(accessed 7.19.2010).<br />
47. Freedman R <strong>and</strong> Takeshita JY. Family planning in Taiwan: an experiment in social<br />
change. Princton: New Jersey, Princeton University Press 1960.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
31
Annexes<br />
Annex 1. Process of data analyzing using framework analysis technique 1<br />
Familiarization<br />
Immersed an overview of the collected data through listening<br />
the audio tapes, reading the transcripts <strong>and</strong> thinking about<br />
issues <strong>and</strong> made a note.<br />
Identifying a thematic framework<br />
Filtered <strong>and</strong> classified the data according to key issues,<br />
concepts <strong>and</strong> themes.<br />
Indexing<br />
Identified the portion or sections of the data that correspond to a<br />
particular theme.<br />
Charting<br />
Data was lifted from its original textual context <strong>and</strong> placed in<br />
charts that consist of the headings <strong>and</strong> subheadings. For clarity<br />
each cases was kept in the same order in each chart.<br />
Mapping <strong>and</strong> interpretation<br />
Analyzed key characteristics as laid out in the charts.<br />
32 RED Working Paper No. 21
Annex 2. Name of Flipchart: Care of pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating mother<br />
Chart name Chart No Exact messages in the flipchart<br />
Nutrition during<br />
pregnancy<br />
1 Eat extra food in each meal, drink 8 glass of water<br />
every day, take 1 iron tablet every day, take iodized<br />
salt<br />
Safety during<br />
2 Do not do heavy work<br />
pregnancy<br />
Rest during<br />
3 Everyday take rest at lay down on the bed<br />
pregnancy<br />
Delivery<br />
4 In case of emergency keep contact with van driver to<br />
preparedness<br />
Antenatal check<br />
up<br />
Danger sign<br />
(convulsion)<br />
Danger sign<br />
(excessive fever)<br />
Danger signs of<br />
pregnant mother<br />
Danger sign<br />
(convulsion)<br />
Danger signs of<br />
lactating mother<br />
Nutrition of<br />
lactating mother<br />
Danger sign<br />
(excessive<br />
bleeding)<br />
go to the hospital <strong>and</strong> save money.<br />
6 Do antenatal check up for 4 times at the health centre<br />
<strong>and</strong> take advice from SK. Take TT vaccine during 5th<br />
-<br />
8th<br />
month of your pregnancy<br />
10 In case of convulsion during pregnancy take woman to<br />
the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
11 In case of excessive fever during pregnancy take<br />
woman to the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call to<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
12 In case of any danger during pregnancy take woman<br />
to the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
provider.<br />
17 In case of convulsion of lactating woman take to her to<br />
the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
18 In case of any danger of lactating woman take to her<br />
to the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
provider.<br />
19 Eat extra food in each meal, drink lots of water every<br />
day, <strong>and</strong> especially drink 1 glass of water before <strong>and</strong><br />
after each breast feeding. Take 1 vitamin-A capsule<br />
within 14 days of delivery.<br />
21 In case of excessive bleeding within 42 days of<br />
delivery take woman to the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone<br />
call to <strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
33
Annex 3. Misinterpretation of the messages<br />
Name of Flipchart: Care for pregnant <strong>and</strong> lactating mother<br />
Chart name<br />
Chart<br />
no<br />
Actual messages in the<br />
flipchart<br />
Interpretation <strong>and</strong> perception of<br />
messages<br />
Nutrition<br />
during<br />
pregnancy<br />
Birth<br />
preparedness<br />
Delivery<br />
assistance<br />
Cleanliness<br />
during<br />
pregnancy<br />
Danger sign<br />
of pregnancy<br />
(bleeding)<br />
Danger sign<br />
of pregnancy<br />
(Headache,<br />
blurred vision,<br />
oedema)<br />
Danger sign<br />
of delivery<br />
(prolong<br />
labour)<br />
Danger sign<br />
of delivery<br />
(bleeding)<br />
1 Eat extra food in each meal, Women should take ‘<strong>BRAC</strong> SALT’<br />
drink 8 glass of water <strong>and</strong> take during pregnancy<br />
one iron tablet every day, take<br />
iodized salt<br />
4 Keep contact with van driver in<br />
case of urgency <strong>and</strong> save<br />
money<br />
5 During delivery <strong>BRAC</strong> trained<br />
TBA <strong>and</strong> Shebika should<br />
present<br />
7 Let take bath regularly <strong>and</strong><br />
clean your breast.<br />
When a pregnant mother have<br />
obstructed <strong>and</strong> prolonged labour, then<br />
arrange the van <strong>and</strong> have to break the<br />
mud bank.<br />
- Shebika is examining the woman’s<br />
body to see whether she is alright or<br />
not. It is the time of delivery. Who is<br />
she (another women with green color<br />
saree) Whether mother or mother in<br />
law cannot underst<strong>and</strong>.<br />
- A mother in law is seeing her<br />
daughter in law<br />
Participants could not underst<strong>and</strong> what<br />
is being done to the breast. Some think<br />
it is a navel<br />
8 In case of bleeding during<br />
pregnancy lets’ take to woman<br />
to the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a<br />
phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
- It is not underst<strong>and</strong>able whether the<br />
woman is pregnant or not<br />
- this is the picture of abortion. When<br />
she (pregnant women) is 3-4 month<br />
of pregnant it is happened.<br />
9 In case of headache, blurred - A pregnant woman is thinking what<br />
vision, oedema during she will do<br />
pregnancy lets’ take to woman - She is in same problem. Thus she is<br />
to the hospital <strong>and</strong> make a thinking.<br />
phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong> provider. - Her husb<strong>and</strong> is making a phone call<br />
to the family planning office.<br />
13 In case of labour pain more<br />
than 12 hours during delivery<br />
lets’ take to her to the hospital<br />
<strong>and</strong> make a phone call to<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
14 In case of excessive bleeding<br />
during delivery lets’ take the<br />
woman to the hospital <strong>and</strong><br />
make a phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
provider.<br />
- Maybe she (pregnant women) has<br />
completed her pregnancy period (in<br />
Bengali mash purse) <strong>and</strong> Shebika is<br />
examining her.<br />
- Participants’ could not underst<strong>and</strong><br />
the symbols representing 12 hours.<br />
- It is not clear whether the woman is<br />
going to deliver the baby or not.<br />
- The woman has bleeding during<br />
delivery. Now Shebika Apa feed her a<br />
tablet (misoprostol)<br />
(Annex 3. cont……)<br />
34 RED Working Paper No. 21
(cont…….. Annex 3)<br />
Danger sign<br />
of delivery<br />
(retained<br />
placenta)<br />
Danger sign<br />
of delivery<br />
(convulsion)<br />
Care of<br />
lactating<br />
mother<br />
Danger sign of<br />
post partum<br />
(Headache,<br />
blurred vision,<br />
oedema)<br />
Danger sign of<br />
post partum<br />
(convulsion)<br />
Danger sign of<br />
post partum<br />
(excessive<br />
fever)<br />
16 If placenta is not delivered<br />
within 30 minutes after child’s<br />
birth lets’ take to her to the<br />
hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call<br />
to <strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
17 In case of convulsion during<br />
delivery lets’ take to her to the<br />
hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call<br />
to <strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
20 Use clean pad (cloth), use lot of<br />
water after defecation <strong>and</strong> keep dry<br />
delivery place<br />
22 In case of headache, blurred vision,<br />
oedema during post partum lets’<br />
take to her to the hospital <strong>and</strong><br />
make a phone call to <strong>BRAC</strong><br />
provider.<br />
23 In case of convulsion during post<br />
partum lets’ take to her to the<br />
hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call to<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
24 In case of excessive fever during<br />
post partum lets’ take to her to the<br />
hospital <strong>and</strong> make a phone call to<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> provider.<br />
A mother should feed colostrums to her<br />
newborn baby as early after birth.<br />
It is not underst<strong>and</strong>able whether the<br />
women is going to deliver the baby or<br />
not<br />
- She said (about it) but cannot remember<br />
- she is cleaning her h<strong>and</strong> after defecation<br />
- cannot underst<strong>and</strong> what it is (the picture<br />
of sanitary napkin)<br />
- An woman is thinking what she will do<br />
- A newborn baby should be in the pictures.<br />
- A newborn baby should be in the pictures.<br />
- A newborn baby should be in the pictures.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
35
Annex 4. BCC messaging timetable<br />
Seasonal BCC related to MNCH in Bangladesh<br />
Month Event FP Mat health Mat health 2 NBC (If baby is<br />
ulta palta<br />
delivery at<br />
hospital)<br />
January<br />
February<br />
March<br />
April<br />
May<br />
June<br />
July<br />
August<br />
September<br />
Cold<br />
season<br />
approaches<br />
Monsoon<br />
starts<br />
Use FP<br />
October<br />
births<br />
start use<br />
of FP<br />
Discuss<br />
FP with<br />
partner<br />
Procure<br />
<strong>and</strong> use<br />
FP<br />
commodi<br />
ties<br />
February<br />
births<br />
start use<br />
of FP<br />
Unwanted<br />
pregnancy<br />
First ANC -<br />
birth plans<br />
introduction<br />
4th ANC<br />
Check that<br />
birth plans <strong>and</strong><br />
savings are<br />
ready<br />
Use a skilled<br />
birth attendant/<br />
early referral for<br />
danger signs<br />
Bleeding in Postnatal<br />
pregnancy is check<br />
a danger sign<br />
Birth plans -<br />
savings<br />
2nd ANC -<br />
diet <strong>and</strong><br />
danger signs<br />
Messages for<br />
men <strong>and</strong><br />
elders<br />
3rd ANC -<br />
Select birth<br />
attendant,<br />
danger signs<br />
Want a<br />
pregnancy<br />
improve diet<br />
esp folic acid<br />
Unwanted<br />
pregnancy<br />
First ANC -<br />
birth plans<br />
introduction<br />
Finalize birth Bleeding in<br />
plans - pregnancy is a<br />
memories danger sign<br />
telephone no.<br />
4th ANC<br />
Check that<br />
birth plans<br />
<strong>and</strong> savings<br />
are ready<br />
Birth plans -<br />
savings<br />
Keep newborns<br />
warm<br />
Maternal diet/<br />
play with <strong>and</strong><br />
talk to baby<br />
EPI <strong>and</strong> Breast<br />
feeding info<br />
Actively play<br />
with <strong>and</strong> talk to<br />
baby<br />
Maternal diet<br />
Breast feeding<br />
info<br />
If baby is<br />
ultapalta<br />
delivery at<br />
hospital<br />
Child health<br />
reduce<br />
smoke in<br />
house<br />
H<strong>and</strong><br />
washing <strong>and</strong><br />
cleanliness<br />
esp crawling<br />
babies<br />
Treat<br />
diarrhoes<br />
quickly<br />
Treat<br />
diarrhoea<br />
quickly<br />
H<strong>and</strong><br />
washing <strong>and</strong><br />
cleanliness<br />
esp crawling<br />
babies<br />
Treat<br />
diarrhoea<br />
quickly<br />
(Annex 4. cont……)<br />
36 RED Working Paper No. 21
(cont…….. Annex 4)<br />
October<br />
November<br />
Cold<br />
season<br />
approaches<br />
Discuss<br />
FP with<br />
partner<br />
Use a skilled<br />
birth<br />
attendant/<br />
early referral<br />
for danger<br />
signs<br />
Postnatal<br />
check<br />
2nd ANC - diet<br />
<strong>and</strong> danger<br />
signs<br />
Messages for EPI <strong>and</strong> Breast<br />
men <strong>and</strong> elders feeding info<br />
December<br />
Procure<br />
<strong>and</strong> use<br />
FP<br />
commodi<br />
ties<br />
Want a<br />
pregnancy<br />
improve diet<br />
esp folic acid<br />
3rd ANC -<br />
Select birth<br />
attendant,<br />
danger signs<br />
Keep newborns<br />
warm inc breast<br />
feeding info<br />
reduce<br />
smoke in<br />
house<br />
** This programme is based on the normal peaks of births 9 months after the cold season <strong>and</strong> beginning<br />
of the monsoon. There is also a smaller peak 9 months after Eid-Ul-Azha festival,<br />
** Diarrhoea also often increases at the time of the Eid festival because of people travelling <strong>and</strong> food<br />
purchased from outside the home,<br />
** For child <strong>and</strong> maternal health pay special attention to the 'lean months' for nutrition communication.<br />
These months vary from place to place.<br />
Behaviour change communication tools: experience from MNCH programme<br />
37