Joint Steering Committee for Revision of AACR

More documents

Recommendations

Info

Term statement of responsibility Parallel title Part Definition (draft AACR3 where given, or AACR2) The title proper in another language and/or script. 1. One of the units into which a resource has been divided by the publisher, manufacturer, etc. It is distinguished from a fascicle by being a formal constituent unit rather than a temporary division of a resource. 2. As used in the technical description area, one of two or more physical units intended to be bound several to a volume. See also Fascicle, Issue (2), Part (Music). Comments In AACR2 5JSC/Chair/11 18 September 2006 Table 1 - 43 In draft AACR3 TEXT √ √ ALA: Some ALA members expressed confusion with the phrase “one of two or more physical units” in definition 2. We suggest that “formal constituent unit” isn’t the right term to distinguish fascicles from parts. Even the distinction between temporary and permanent divisions of the resource won’t always be clear. Both parts and fascicles may be numbered, and both parts and fascicles may later be bound together into volumes. A fascicle may be considered just a special kind of part, the main distinction being that the publisher or distributor calls it a fascicle! ALA is concerned that the Glossary (in definition 2) is attempting to go down the road of individual library binding policies. Some libraries may bind these individually for some specific reason, while others will bind several together. “Constituent” is not defined in the Glossary, but “component” is. Is there a reason “component” does not work here (e.g., “… formal component unit” LC: Add definition Required in Glossary √ √ YES
5JSC/Chair/11 18 September 2006 Table 1 - 44 Term Part (Music) Definition (draft AACR3 where given, or AACR2) 1. The music for one of the participating voices or instruments in a musical work. 2. A part or component part of a resource containing one or more (but not all) such parts for the use of one or more performers, designated in the technical description area as part. Comments LC: Revise definition to: 1. The music designated for a voice or instrument (e.g., soprano part, 1st violin part) in a musical work for two or more performers. 2. In the technical description area, a component consisting of the music from which one of two or more instrumentalists called for in a work performs. In In draft Required in AACR2 AACR3 Glossary √ √ YES ALA on LC: MLA notes that the second definition inaccurately restricts “part” to the music of a single instrumentalist, unlike the proposed definition in AACR3. It is not uncommon to find “parts” in “score format” (i.e., more than one instrument included on a “part”), nor is it unusual to have a soprano part, as noted in the first definition for this entry. We therefore make the following recommendations for change: Part (Music). 1. The music designated for a voice or instrument (e.g., soprano part, 1 violin part) in a musical work for two or more performers. 2. In the technical description area, a component consisting of the music from which one of two or more instrumentalists called for in a work performs. for the
Page 1 and 2: 5JSC/Chair/11 18 September 2006 1 T
Page 3 and 4: 5JSC/Chair/11 18 September 2006 Tab
Page 19 and 20: Term Disk (Digital resources) Distr
Page 23 and 24: Term Definition (draft AACR3 where
Page 37 and 38: Term Model Definition (draft AACR3
Page 43: 5JSC/Chair/11 18 September 2006 Tab
Page 55 and 56: Term Definition (draft AACR3 where
Page 73 and 74: Term Comment Proposed Definition (w
Page 87 and 88: 5JSC/Chair/11 18 September 2006 Exc
Page 89: 5JSC/Chair/11 18 September 2006 Exc

Joint Steering Committee for Revision of AACR

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?