Development Assessment Panel Meeting Minutes - City of Burnside

Development Assessment Panel Meeting Minutes 03 April 2012Category 3 Development Applications under ConsiderationCity Of Burnside – Report No. PR 5660.2DA No.: 180\1412\11Location:Kingsley Avenue Reserve (4 Kingsley Avenue), GlenungaProposal:Two tennis courts including tennis court fencing (3.3m highmesh)Recommendation: Development Plan Consent be grantedp. 35The following people were heard by the Development Assessment Panel:• Louise & Gregory Reid – 71 Sydney Street, Glenunga• Cath & Rob Caon – 75 Sydney Street, Glenunga• Pasquale & Gabriella Versace – 73 Sydney Street, Glenunga• Janet Brough – 3/40 Windsor Road, Glenunga• John Draper (COB) & Marcus Rolfe of URPS on behalf of COB – ApplicantP6826The Development Assessment Panel resolved that:1. Development Application 180\1412\11, by City Of Burnside is deferred toprovide the Applicant with the opportunity to consider and/or address thefollowing:Reasons1. Amend the proposal to one (1) tennis court.2. Amenity of adjoining residents.3. Parking on Kingsley Avenue and Sydney Street.4. Retention of the regulated/significant tree.5. Installation of a community garden in the area proposed for the second tenniscourt on the rear boundary of the Sydney Street residents.Category 2 Development Applications under ConsiderationA D'andrea & Associates Pty Ltd – Report No. PR 5660.3CARRIEDDA No.: 180\0643\11Location:5 Russell Avenue, Hazelwood ParkProposal:Two-storey detached dwelling including garage and alfrescoRecommendation: Development Plan Consent grantedp. 175The following people were heard by the Development Assessment Panel:• Chris Lebbon – 3 Russell Avenue, Hazelwood Park• Pamela E Reid – 12 Moore Avenue, Hazelwood Park• Deborah Floyd & Robert Hawkes – 4 Russell Avenue, Hazelwood Park• Rob McBride of Parmac House on behalf of A D'andrea & Associates Pty Ltd –ApplicantP6827The Development Assessment Panel resolved that:1. The proposed development is not seriously at variance with the policies in theDevelopment Plan.2. Development Application 180\0643\11, by A D'andrea & Associates Pty Ltd, isrefused Development Plan Consent for the following reasons:Minutes – Public -2-

Development Assessment Panel Meeting Minutes 03 April 2012Reasons1. Fails to comply with the requirements of Residential Policy Area 22 Objective 1regarding low scale, single storey and low density residential character.2. Fails to comply with Residential Policy Area 22 Principle of DevelopmentControl 1 regarding bulk, scale and siting and conservation and enhancementof the character of the policy area.2. Fails to comply with Council Wide Principle of Development Control 27regarding set-backs and streetscape character of the locality.3. Fails to comply with Residential Zone Principle of Development Control 2(d)regarding building materials, mass and proportion.4. Fails to comply with Principle of Development Control 124 regarding set-back ofthe upper storey on the eastern boundary.Andrew Papageorgiou – Report No. PR 5660.4DA No.: 180\1167\11Location:4 North Street, FrewvilleProposal:Front fence (masonry pillar and plinth) and side fence(masonry)Recommendation: Development Plan Consent be grantedp. 275No person was heard by the Panel.CARRIEDP6828The Development Assessment Panel resolved that:1. The Manager, Development Services is delegated the power to grantDevelopment Plan Consent to the application, effective upon him receivingwritten confirmation from the applicant that the proposal is amended to includeonly the front proposed fence and that the side fence is deleted from theapplication, subject to the following conditions:Conditions1. The development granted Development Plan Consent shall be undertaken inaccordance with the stamped approved plans, drawings, specifications andother documents submitted to the Council ( other than the side fence) that arerelevant to the consent to the reasonable satisfaction of the Council.Reason:To ensure the development is undertaken in accordance with the plans anddetails submitted.City Of Burnside – Report No. PR 5660.5DA No.: 180\0108\12Location:Council Road Reserve – adjacent 6 Grant Avenue,Rose ParkProposal:Removal of one regulated street-tree – Sydney Blue gum(Eucalyptus saligna) adjacent 6 Grant Avenue, Rose ParkRecommendation: Development Approval be grantedp. 307CARRIEDMinutes – Public -3-

Development Assessment Panel Meeting Minutes 03 April 2012No person was heard by the Panel.P6829The Development Assessment Panel resolved that:1. The proposed development is not seriously at variance with the policies in theDevelopment Plan; and2. Development Application 180\0108\12, by City Of Burnside is grantedDevelopment Plan Consent subject to the following conditions:Conditions1. The development granted Development Plan Consent shall be undertaken inaccordance with the stamped approved plans, drawings, specifications andother documents submitted to the Council that are relevant to the consent to thereasonable satisfaction of the Council, except where varied by conditionsbelow.Reason:To ensure the development is undertaken in accordance with the plans anddetails submitted.2. The removal of the regulated tree shall be subject to the planting of tworeplacement trees in a suitable position greater than 10m distance from anyexisting dwelling or in-ground swimming pool. The replacement trees must beindigenous to the local area, not be an exempt species listed under regulation6A clause (5)(b) of the Development Regulations 2008, or a tree belonging to aclass of plant declared by the Minister under Chapter 8 Part 1 of the NaturalResources Management Act 2004. The trees shall be planted within threemonths of the substantial removal of the regulated tree and shall be maintainedin good condition at all times and replaced if necessary.Reason:To provide amenity through the provision of landscaping as part of thedevelopment.Category 1 Development Applications under ConsiderationAlexander Symonds Pty Ltd – Report No. PR 5660.6CARRIEDDA No.: 180\0450\11Location:12-14 Royal Avenue, BurnsideProposal:Land division (Community) creating four (4) allotments fromone (1) existingRecommendation: Development Plan consent be grantedp. 321No person was heard by the Panel.P6830The Development Assessment Panel resolved that:1. The proposed development is not seriously at variance with the policies in theDevelopment Plan; and2. Development Application 180\0450\11, by Alexander Symonds Pty Ltd, isgranted Development Plan consent subject to the following conditions:Minutes – Public -4-

Development Assessment Panel Meeting Minutes 03 April 2012Conditions1. The development granted Development Plan Consent shall be undertaken inaccordance with the stamped approved plans, drawings, specifications andother documents submitted to the Council that are relevant to the consent to thereasonable satisfaction of the Council, except where varied by conditions below(if any).Reason:To ensure the development is undertaken in accordance with the plans anddetails submitted.2. In accordance with the written confirmation received on behalf of the owner ofthe land, namely an email from the owner’s agent Mr Chris Vounassis ofConnor Holmes, dated 15 March 2012, forming part of the documentationsubmitted to the Council in relation to this application, the owner shall enter intoa Land Management Agreement with Council regarding the future developmentof the land in the terms agreed between the parties as set out in the draft LandManagement Agreement, as revised on or about 06 March 2012 and the ownershall note the said agreement against the Certificate of Title to the land prior tothe Council advising the Development Assessment Commission that acertificate may be issued pursuant to Section 51 of the Development Act 1993.Reason:To ensure the Land Management Agreement is entered into and registeredagainst the created Certificates of Title.3. The financial requirements of SA Water shall be met for the provision of watersupply and sewerage services.• For further processing of this application by SA Water, to establish the fullrequirements and costs of development, the developer will need to adviseSA Water of their preferred servicing option. For further information orqueries, please contact SA Water Land Developments on 7424-1119.• The developer must inform potential purchasers of the community lots ofthe servicing arrangements and seek written agreement prior tosettlement, as future alterations would be at full cost to the owner/applicant.Reason:To satisfy the requirements of the SA Water Corporation4. Payment of $16,881 into the Planning and Development fund (3 lot(s) @$5,627/lot). Cheques to be made payable and marked “Not Negotiable” to theDevelopment Assessment Commission and payment made at Level 5,136 North Terrace, Adelaide, or sent to GPO Box 1815, Adelaide SA 5001, orvia the internet at www.planning.sa.gov.au.Reason:To satisfy the requirements of the Development Assessment Commission.5. Two copies of a certified survey plan being lodged with the DevelopmentAssessment Commission for Certificate purposes.Reason:To satisfy the requirements of the Development Assessment Commission.Minutes – Public -5-

Development Assessment Panel Meeting Minutes 03 April 2012Other BusinessReserved Matters1 Pursuant to Section 33(3) of the Development Act, the applicant shall submitdetails of the following reserved matters requiring further assessment by theCity of Burnside, prior to the issue of Development Approval. :1.1 Adequate management of stormwater from the common property.NilOrder seeking the exclusion of the public from the Meeting to debateConfidential MattersCARRIEDP6831It was the consensus of the Development Assessment Panel, that, pursuant toSection 56A(12) of the Development Act, 1993, the public be excluded from this partof the meeting of the City of Burnside Development Assessment Panel meeting datedTuesday 03 April 2012, (with the exception of members of Council staff who arehereby permitted to remain) to enable the Panel to receive, discuss or consider legaladvice, or advice from a person who is providing specialist professional advice.CARRIEDConfidential MattersClosure10.1 Legal Matter AppealPX Tran – Report No. PR 5660.7DA No.: 180\0540\11Location:98 Allinga Avenue, GlenungaProposal:Habitable outbuilding, fence (masonry) and tennis courtincluding lighting and fencingp. 375The Meeting came out of confidence at 10.36pmMeeting closed at 10.36pmCARRIEDCONFIRMED THIS .................................................. DAY.................................................... 2012....................................................................................Presiding MemberMinutes – Public -6-