Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Nanophotonics to Combat Climate Change and<br />
Energy Problem<br />
ADOPT<br />
Winter School 2010<br />
Romme Romme, , Sweden<br />
March 11 11-14, 14, 20 2010 10<br />
Nanophotonic Solutions for High-Quality Solid State Lighting<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering<br />
Department of Physics<br />
National Institute of Materials Science and Nanotechnology<br />
Bilkent University, Ankara<br />
Semiconductor Lighting Research Center<br />
Nanyang Technological University University, Singapore<br />
volkan@bilkent.edu.tr | hvdemir@ntu.edu.sg<br />
volkan@stanfordalumni.org<br />
TÜBA
Outline<br />
• Climate change, greenhouse gases<br />
• Solid So d state lighting g t geenabled abedby by nanophotonics<br />
a op oto cs<br />
– White LEDs involving nanophosphors<br />
– for indoors lighting (warm color temperature, high color rendering index)<br />
– for tuned color chromatictiy operation (tuned tristimulus coordinates)<br />
– Nonradiative energy transfer in nanophosphors<br />
– FRET enhanced color converted LEDs<br />
– FRET converted light emitting structures<br />
– color tuning with FRET<br />
– Plasmonic nanophosphors<br />
– plasmon coupling using metal nanoparticles<br />
– selective plasmon coupling of white luminophors<br />
• Conclusion<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
… a very unfortunate unfortunate, upsetting fact<br />
Our World is being POLLUTED POLLUTED…<br />
[1] IPCC Climate Change 2007 2007, Human and Natural Drivers of Climate Change, Change Summary for Policymakers Policymakers, pp pp. 2 (2007). (2007)<br />
[2] Donald Kennedy, Climate Change and Climate Science, Science, 304, 1565 (2004).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Global warming?, climate change<br />
IPCC Climate Change 2007, “Is the Current Climate<br />
Ch Change UUnusual l CCompared d tto EEarlier li Ch Changes iin<br />
Earth’s History?,” (2007),<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
What factors determine earth’s climate?<br />
[1] J. T. Kiehl and K. E. Trenberth,” Earth’s Annual Global Mean Energy Budget,” Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 78, pp. 206 (1997).<br />
[2] Also in IPCC Climate Change 2007, “What Factors Determine Earth’s Climate?,” chapter 1, pp. 96 (2007),<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
• Natural causes<br />
Greenhouse gases<br />
– Natural greenhouse gas effect (water vapor)<br />
– Radiative forcing and forcing variability from natural changes (i.e., solar<br />
changes)<br />
• Anthropogenic (human‐related) causes<br />
– Increase of greenhouse gases<br />
• Carbon dioxide<br />
• Nitrous oxide<br />
• Methane<br />
• Halocarbon (a group of gases containing fluorine, chlorine and bromine)<br />
• Ozone<br />
Anthropogenic causes must be taken under control …<br />
IPCC Climate Change 2007, “How do Human Activities Contribute to Climate Change and How do They Compare with Natural Influences?,”<br />
FAQ chapter, pp. 100 (2007).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Carbon dioxide<br />
IPCC Climate Change 2007, “How Do Glacial-Interglacial Variations in the Greenhouse Gases Carbon Dioxide, Methane and Nitrous Oxide<br />
Compare with the Industrial Era Greenhouse Gas Increase?,” Chapter 6, pp. 448 (2007).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Climate change<br />
Drought Acid rain<br />
Flood<br />
Global Warming<br />
Ice melt
CO 2, temperature change, and<br />
sea level<br />
Relation between estimated atmospheric<br />
CO2 and the ice contribution to sea level<br />
[1]<br />
An example: Changes in key global climate parameters since<br />
1973, compared with the scenarios of IPCC (shown as<br />
dashed lines and gray ranges) [2]<br />
Measurements taken at Mauna Loa (Hawaii)<br />
[1] R. B. Alley, et al., “Ice-Sheet and Sea-Level Changes,” Science, 310, 456 (2005).<br />
[2] S. Rahmstorf, et al., “Recent Climate Observations Compared to Projections,” Science 316, 709 (2007).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Changes in snow, ice, and frozen ground and rising sea level<br />
Rate of ice mass loss from all<br />
GIC (glaciers & ice caps) since<br />
1995.<br />
“This acceleration of glacier<br />
melt may cause 010to 0.10 to 025 0.25<br />
meter of additional sea‐<br />
level rise by 2100.”<br />
Ma. F. Meier et al., l “ “Glaciers l Dominate Eustatic Sea‐Level l Rise in the h 21st Century,” ” Science, 317, 1064‐1066 ( (2007).<br />
)<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Problems in ecology<br />
• According to Thomas’ work, some species<br />
have the risk of becoming extinct due to the<br />
effects of global warming. Between 15% ‐<br />
37% of known species will be extinct by<br />
2050. [1]<br />
• “The synergism of rapid temperature rise<br />
and other stresses, in particular habitat<br />
destruction, could easily disrupt the<br />
connectedness among species and lead to a<br />
reformulation of species communities,<br />
reflecting differential changes in species,<br />
and to numerous extirpations and possibly<br />
extinctions.” [2]<br />
[1] C. D.Thomas et al., Extinction risk from climate change, Nature, 427, 145-148 (2004)<br />
[2] T. L. Root et al., ‘Fingerprints’ of global warming <strong>Hilmi</strong> on wild <strong>Volkan</strong> animals <strong>Demir</strong> and plants,” Nature, 421, 57-59 (2003).
Why do we produce so much CO 2?<br />
• The largest source of CO2<br />
emission is globally the<br />
combustion of fossil fuels (e.g.,<br />
coal, oil, and gas in power plants<br />
and industrial facilities).<br />
• The main reason of CO2<br />
emission is the need for energy.<br />
• Lighting uses ~19% of global<br />
electricity generation.<br />
• In homes and offices, up to 50%<br />
of total energy consumption is<br />
due to lighting.<br />
References: EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency) U.S.<br />
Greenhouse Gas Inventory Reports 1990 – 2005, Carbon Dioxide<br />
Emissions, Executive Summary, pp. 6-7, 2007<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
1997<br />
2009<br />
How are we doing?<br />
Kyoto Protocol (United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change)
Let’s Let s Combat Climate Change…<br />
• Decisions made to halt<br />
climate change<br />
• e.g., European Union<br />
Göteborg agreement<br />
8 Sustainable healthy life<br />
� Reduction in energy consumption<br />
� Increase in alternative energy sources<br />
� Decrease in polluting emission<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Can nanotechnology help to combat climate change?<br />
• … the answer is YES (but a cautious yes).<br />
• For example,<br />
– Spectrally p yppure lighting g g<br />
– Photovoltaic technology<br />
– Batteries and supercapacitors<br />
– IImproved di insulation l ti ffor houses h and d offices ffi<br />
– Fuel additives to increase the efficiency of diesel engines<br />
– …<br />
• Nanoparticles already in use<br />
– Functional nanocomposite coatings (e.g., (e g Innovnano Innovnano, Innovcoat)<br />
Nature Nanotechnology, “Combating Climate Change”, 2(6), 325 (2007).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
How can we combat climate change using<br />
NANOPHOTONICS?<br />
• Can we help to reduce global energy<br />
consumption by high high‐quality quality<br />
semiconductor lighting?<br />
• Can we seek ways to improve efficiency in<br />
solar energy conversion?<br />
• Can we help to reduce the amount of<br />
greenhouse gases?<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
How can we combat climate change<br />
using NANOPHOTONICS?<br />
• Can we help to reduce global energy<br />
consumption?<br />
– Light generation<br />
• Solid state lighting using nanophosphors<br />
– for the generation of high‐quality white light<br />
– using nonradiative energy transfer<br />
• Can we help to convert solar energy more<br />
efficiently?<br />
– Light harvesting<br />
• Quantum dot integrated solar cells<br />
– for the extension of spectral response<br />
– also using nonradiative energy transfer<br />
• C Can we help h l t to reduce d the th amount t of f<br />
greenhouse gases?<br />
– Photocatalytic nanoparticle integrated systems<br />
• ffor massive i environmental i t ld decontamination<br />
t i ti<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
GREEN<br />
NANOPHOTONICS<br />
current (mA)<br />
* 2 patents pending<br />
voltage (V)<br />
0<br />
0 02 0.2 04 0.4 06 0.6 08 0.8 1 12 1.2 14 1.4 16 1.6 18 1.8 2<br />
-2<br />
-4<br />
-6<br />
-8<br />
PL Intensity (a.u.)<br />
* 1 patent p<br />
* 3 patents<br />
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
λ (nm)<br />
wihout nanocrystals<br />
with 3.42 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals<br />
with 10.40 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals y<br />
with 20.80 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals<br />
with 52.00 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals<br />
with 67.60 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals
Outline<br />
• Climate change, greenhouse gases<br />
• Solid state lighting enabled by nanophotonics<br />
– White LEDs involving nanophosphors<br />
– for indoors lighting (warm color temperature, high color rendering index)<br />
– for tuned color chromatictiy operation (tuned tristimulus coordinates)<br />
– Nonradiative energy transfer in nanophosphors<br />
– FRET enhanced color converted LEDs<br />
– FRET converted light emitting structures<br />
– color tuning with FRET<br />
– Plasmonic nanophosphors<br />
– plasmon coupling using metal nanoparticles<br />
– selective plasmon coupling of white luminophors<br />
• Conclusion<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
How does solid state lighting (SSL) help in combating<br />
climate change?<br />
• Artificial lighting uses about 19% of the global<br />
electricity generation worldwide.<br />
• Th The IInternational t ti lEEnergy A Agency (IEA) hhas<br />
estimated that the energy needed to produce<br />
lighting induces approximately 1900 Mt CO2 emission per p yyear, which is equivalent q to 70% of the<br />
emissions from the world’s passenger vehicles.<br />
•The energy consumption used for LEDs lighting<br />
could be reduced by 50%, if the target performance<br />
is met met.<br />
•This is equivalent to carbon emission reduction of<br />
many hundreds of million tons per year.<br />
LED‐based luminescence system will<br />
be the next generation of lighting<br />
source!<br />
Source: International Energy Agency, “Light’s labour lost: Policies for<br />
energy‐efficient lighting, in support of the G8 plan of action,” p.558<br />
(2006).
Luminous efficacy e<br />
η (lm/We) 10 3<br />
10 2<br />
10 1<br />
1<br />
10 ‐1<br />
10 ‐2<br />
Efficiency of artificial lighting<br />
CoL ($/Mlmh) ≃ CoE/η<br />
1<br />
10 1<br />
10 2<br />
FSU 2000<br />
CN 2005<br />
CN 2006<br />
US 2001<br />
UK 2000<br />
AU+NZ 2005<br />
WRLD-NONGRID<br />
1999<br />
10 3<br />
10 1.5<br />
WRLD-GRID 2005<br />
JP+KR 2005<br />
OECD-EU 2005<br />
CN 1993<br />
10 4<br />
UK 1950<br />
UK 1900<br />
UK 1850<br />
10 5<br />
100%<br />
Efficiency<br />
1 101 102 103 104 105 1 101 102 103 104 105 CoE ($/MW eh)<br />
UK 1800<br />
UK 1750<br />
UK 1700<br />
10 2.8<br />
SSL<br />
HID<br />
Fluorescent<br />
Incandescent<br />
Gas<br />
Kerosene<br />
Candles<br />
Source: Tsao and Waide, “The World’s Appetite for Light: Empirical Data and Trends Spanning Three<br />
Centuries and Six Continents,” Sandia National Labs, USA<br />
Artificial lighting has made an incredible<br />
progress from candles, gas and kerosene<br />
lamps to incandescent, fluoroscent and<br />
high‐intensity discharge electric lighting.<br />
• 28 2.8 orders d of f magnitude it d decrease d in i the th<br />
generation 2.8 orders cost of light.<br />
•1.5 orders of magnitude decrease in cost of<br />
energy. 1.5 orders<br />
• Th The overall ll operating ti cost t of f light li ht has h been b<br />
reduced by 4.3 orders of magnitude since<br />
1700s. 4.3 orders
Motivation for white LEDs (WLEDs) inSSL<br />
For developed and developing countries<br />
TODAY<br />
Current lighting g g technologies g consume:<br />
19% of the global electricity production<br />
WLEDs provide:<br />
For under-developed part of the world<br />
FUTURE<br />
TODAY FUTURE<br />
Fuel based lighting provides<br />
>1B people who does not have access to<br />
electricity:<br />
Unhealthy<br />
Costly<br />
Low light quality<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
50% reduction in electricity consumption<br />
Reduction in carbon emission by 100s M tons<br />
per year<br />
WLEDs provide:<br />
Healthy<br />
Affordable<br />
High-light quality
The Earth at night from a satellite<br />
• We consume lots of light!<br />
• And this h costs us llots of f energy …<br />
Source: C. Mayhew and R. Simmon (NASA/GSFC), NOAA/ NGDC, DMSP
Potential market of LED‐based products<br />
The market size of LED‐related business is<br />
expected to be about USD USD 4 billion 4 billion for 2015,<br />
with the annual demand growth of of 14%
White LEDs<br />
Two most common methods for WLEDs<br />
� RGB LEDs: using 3 different<br />
(red-green-blue) LEDs<br />
� Color conversion LEDs: using<br />
luminescent materials (luminophor)<br />
on LEDs<br />
typically phosphors: EL of LED and<br />
PL of luminophors collectively generate<br />
white light<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Thin-Film Flip Chip (TFFC)
Phosphors vs. Nanophosphors<br />
Broad emitters, difficult to control precisely<br />
Yellow phosphors, color rendering index (CRI) ~ 70<br />
Cool white appearance due to high correlated color<br />
temperature (CCT)~4000 -8000 K<br />
Red-green phosphors, CRI / CCT can be improved, but<br />
this comes at the cost of reduced luminous efficacy of<br />
optical radiation.<br />
Problems: stability, granularity, source of rare earth<br />
elements<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Narrow emitters, possible to control precisely<br />
PL Intensity(a.u)<br />
I<br />
1.0<br />
0.8<br />
0.6<br />
0.4<br />
0.2<br />
0.0<br />
500 550 600 650<br />
wavelength(nm)<br />
Cyan<br />
Green<br />
Yellow<br />
Red<br />
Using combinations of semiconductor<br />
quantum dot nanophosphors, It is<br />
possible to achieve warm white light<br />
CCT300 lm/W. l /W<br />
Superior photometric performance.<br />
Problem: Quantum efficiency is being<br />
improved. Further improvements required.<br />
Our focus: high optical quality WLEDs using quantum dot<br />
nanophosphors with specific spectral content of emission
White light generation<br />
Color matching function<br />
Color-rendering index (CRI)<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
[1] E. F. Schubert, Light Emitting Diodes, [2] Audi<br />
C.I.E. chromaticity diagram<br />
Correlated color<br />
temperature p (CCT) ( )
Important photometric properties<br />
Figure of merit Explanation Unit<br />
Chromaticity locus of the perceived color<br />
coordinates<br />
(x,y)<br />
Color rendering<br />
index (CRI)<br />
on the chromaticity<br />
diagram<br />
ability to render true colors<br />
from illuminated objects<br />
index (CRI) from illuminated objects -<br />
Correlated color<br />
ttemperature t<br />
(CCT)<br />
Luminous efficacy<br />
of optical<br />
radiation (LER)<br />
temperature of the planckian<br />
bl blackbody kb d radiator di t K<br />
closest in color<br />
usable radiation for human<br />
eye per optical power<br />
-<br />
lm/W<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Color chromaticity<br />
• Colors are defined using color matching functions and chromaticity<br />
diagram diagram.<br />
E. F. Schubert, “Light Emitting Diodes,”<br />
Cambridge University Press (2006) 28
Luminous efficacy (LE<br />
Luminous<br />
(LE or LER)<br />
• Optical efficiency of the light source perceived by the human eye<br />
Incandescent sources: 1 16 lm/W<br />
Fluorescent lamps: 1 Fluorescent lamps: 71 lm/W<br />
Phosphor based WLEDs: 2 274 lm/W<br />
1: Navigant, U.S. Lighting Market Characterization Volume I:<br />
National Lighting Inventory and Energy Consumption (2002).<br />
Estimate<br />
2: M. R. Krames et al., J. Disp. Technol. 3, 2 (2007).<br />
www.theoremeinnovation.com/revo<br />
lution-en.html<br />
29
Color rendering index (CRI)<br />
• A measure of how good the light source can render the real colors of the<br />
illuminated objects<br />
• Maximum value is 100, minimum value is ‐100<br />
• Developed by International Commission on Illumination (CIE)<br />
• The calculation is based on<br />
� The reflection of the test light from test samples<br />
�� Th The reflection fl ti of f the th reference f light li ht from f test t tsamples l<br />
� Reference light is in general a blackbody radiator<br />
� A good source should have a CRI >80 to start competing with other conventional<br />
sources<br />
http://www1.eere.energy.gov<br />
/buildings/ssl/measuring_cri.<br />
html<br />
30
Correlated color olor temperature (CCT)<br />
• Illustrates the temperature of the closest Planckian black black‐body body radiator to<br />
the operating point on the chromaticity diagram.<br />
• As opposed to common usage in thermodynamics<br />
• High CCT → bluish light → cold white<br />
• Lower CCT → reddish light → warm white<br />
• Warm white light is more desirable<br />
• CCT < 3000 K<br />
http://www.answers.com/topic/colorttemperature<br />
t<br />
Warm<br />
white<br />
31
Conventional white light sources<br />
Incandescent lamp spectrum<br />
http://www.gelighting.com/na/business_lighting/education<br />
_resources/learn_about_light/distribution_curves.htm<br />
Fluorescent<br />
lamp spectrum<br />
32
Nanocrystal quantum dot emitters<br />
525 585 605 655<br />
nm nm nm nm<br />
increasing size<br />
• Narrow emission (spectral purity)<br />
• Size tuneability (quantum size effect)<br />
• Broad absorption<br />
• Reasonable quantum yield in collaboration<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
co abo at o<br />
with A. Eychmüller<br />
TU Dresden
PLL<br />
Intensity (a.u.)<br />
Principles of QD nanophosphor embedded<br />
WLED WLEDs<br />
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
λ (nm)<br />
�Quantum efficiency<br />
>90% in solution, >70% in film demonstrated by<br />
other groups (and further improvements are in<br />
progress)<br />
�Adjustable optical spectrum, easy to tune<br />
�High quality white light:<br />
high CRI, high LER, low CCT<br />
34
Working principle<br />
energy transfer<br />
Physical mechanisms:<br />
Optical absorption<br />
Reabsorption<br />
Photoluminescence<br />
Dipole-dipole interaction<br />
(Förster-type energy<br />
transfer)
Design, epigrowth and fabrication<br />
– Epidesign p g<br />
– Epigrowth<br />
– Standard semiconductor fabrication<br />
• Photolithography<br />
• Thin film coating<br />
• Reactive ion etching<br />
• Rapid thermal annealing<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Experimental achievement<br />
• Successful demonstration of<br />
– High ihquality li of f white hi light li h generation i tuneable bl<br />
by design<br />
• using multiple (e (e.g., g triple, triple quadruple) combinations<br />
of nanophosphors<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
White light generation tuned with nnano<br />
anocrystals crystals<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
S. Nizamoglu, T. Ozel, E. Mutlugün, H. V. <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Nanotechnology 18, 065709 (2007)
High‐quality, warm white LEDs integrated with<br />
nanocrystal y emitters<br />
• Warm white light (CCT< 3500 K)<br />
• Color rendering index (CRI~ (CRI 80)<br />
Indoors lighting (homes, offices, schools …),<br />
S. Nizamoglu, G. Zengin, H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>, Applied Physics Letters, 92, 031102 (2008).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
x= 0.4625<br />
y= 0.3255<br />
CCT= CCT 1982 K<br />
CRI= 79.55<br />
x=0.3881<br />
y=0.3177<br />
CCT= 3190 K<br />
CRI =81.00<br />
x=0.3799<br />
y=0.3018 03018<br />
CCT= 3228 K<br />
CRI=82.38
High High-quality, quality, warm white LEDs integrated<br />
with nanocrystal y emitters<br />
Sample # x y LER (lm/W) CRI CCT (K)<br />
1 0.37 0.30 307 82.4 3228<br />
2 0.38 0.31 323 81.0 3190<br />
3 046 0.46 032 0.32 303 79 79.66 1982<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
S. Nizamoglu, G. Zengin, H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>,<br />
Applied Physics Letters, 92, 031102<br />
(2008).
Photometric modeling<br />
• Aim: What is the maximum feasible photometric performance achievable<br />
with nanophosphor‐integrated WLEDs?<br />
• NCs emission spectra and blue LED spectrum: Gaussian<br />
• 4 colors –blue – green – yellow – red<br />
• Parameters:<br />
� Peak emission wavelength<br />
� Full width at half‐maximum (FWHM)<br />
� Factors of Gaussians<br />
Total number of cases: 237,109,375<br />
•High g quality: q y CRI ≥ 90, , LER ≥ 380 lm/W, , CCT < 4000 K<br />
�Only 0.001% of the spectra satisfied these conditions<br />
•Obtaining highly efficient white light sources requires spectra<br />
that are controlled and tuned very carefully.<br />
41
• CRI vs. CCT relation:<br />
� Boundary behavior between<br />
1500 K and 2200 K is due to LER<br />
≥ 300 lm/W restriction.<br />
�� BBoundary d bbehavior h i after ft 2200<br />
K is fundamental behavior.<br />
• CRI vs. LER relation:<br />
� Boundary behavior is<br />
generated by combination<br />
of the trade-off between<br />
CRI vs. LER at different<br />
CCT values.<br />
Parametric study<br />
• LER vs. CCT relation:<br />
� Cooler white light sources<br />
are required to obtain<br />
optically efficient white<br />
light.<br />
� Boundary is shaped by the<br />
CRI ≥ 80 restriction.<br />
T. Erdem , S. Nizamoglu, X. W. Sun, H.V. <strong>Demir</strong>, Optics Express 18, 340 (2010).<br />
42
Photometric trade‐offs<br />
T. Erdem , S. Nizamoglu, X. W. Sun, H.V. <strong>Demir</strong>, Optics Express<br />
18, 340 (2010).<br />
CRI vs. LER at CCTs<br />
a) between 2450 and 2550 K<br />
b) between 2950 and 3050 K<br />
c) between 3450 and 3550 K<br />
• CRI vs. LER relations:<br />
� High CRI comes with the cost of reduced<br />
LER at all correlated color temperatures<br />
� Increasing CCT permits obtaining higher<br />
CRIs<br />
� Increasing CCT allows higher LER values<br />
�� Change of CRI with respect ot LER slows<br />
down at high CCTs<br />
43
• Full width at half-maximum<br />
(CRI ≥ 90 and LER ≥ 380 lm/W)<br />
� Blue: Average: 44.4 nm, St.<br />
DDev: 88.3 3 nm<br />
� Green: Average: 43.3 nm, St.<br />
Dev: 8.4 nm<br />
�� Yellow: Average: 44.0 440nm nm,<br />
St. Dev: 8.3 nm<br />
� Red: Average: 32.1 nm, St.<br />
Dev: 3.5 nm<br />
Parametric study<br />
Intensity (a.u. .)<br />
14000<br />
12000<br />
10000<br />
8000<br />
6000<br />
4000<br />
2000<br />
0<br />
CRI=91.3<br />
LER=386 lm/W<br />
CCT=3041 CCT 3041 K<br />
400 450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
Wavelength (nm)<br />
T. Erdem , S. Nizamoglu, X. W. Sun, H.V. <strong>Demir</strong>, Optics<br />
Express 18, 340 (2010).<br />
44
Multilayered heteronanocrystals<br />
1<br />
0<br />
1<br />
0<br />
1<br />
0<br />
1-1<br />
1-2 1-3<br />
2-1 2-2 2-3<br />
S. Nizamoglu and H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>, "Onion-like (CdSe)ZnS/CdSe/ZnS quantum-dot-quantum-well heteronanocrystals<br />
for investigation of multi-color emission," Optics Express 16(6),3515-3526 (2008).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
3-1<br />
1<br />
0<br />
3-2<br />
r<br />
1<br />
0<br />
3-3
Optical Poower<br />
(a.u)<br />
1.0<br />
0.8<br />
0.6<br />
0.4<br />
0.2<br />
0.0<br />
WLEDs integrated with onion‐like heteronanocrystals<br />
In solution<br />
Photoluminescence<br />
450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
S. Sapra, S. Mayilo, T. A. Klar, A. L. Rogach, and<br />
J. Feldmann, Adv. Mater. 19, 569 (2007).<br />
S. Nizamoglu, E. Mutlugun, T. Özel, H.<br />
V. <strong>Demir</strong>, S. Sapra, N. Gaponik, A. Eychmüller<br />
Applied Physics Letters 92, 113110 (2008).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
White light emitting diode<br />
(x, y)=(0.36, 0.30), CRI=75.1, and CCT=3929 K<br />
in collaboration<br />
with A. Eychmüller<br />
TU Dresden
WLEDs tuned with onion‐like heteronanocrystals<br />
H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>, , S. Nizamoglu, g , E.<br />
Mutlugun, T. Özel, S. Sapra, N.<br />
Gaponik, A. Eychmüller<br />
Nanotechnology, 19, 335203 (2008).<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
WLED x y<br />
1 0.26 0.23<br />
2 0.31 0.29<br />
3 0.34 0.30<br />
4 0.37 0.36<br />
Applications: spectral‐content<br />
specific illumination, e.g., shop<br />
lighting, museum lighting, green<br />
house lighting, refrigerator long‐ long<br />
term storage, algea growing for<br />
bio‐fuel, etc.
White nano‐luminophor surface state emitting<br />
CdS nanocrystals l<br />
CB<br />
VB<br />
Intensity (a.u.)<br />
Absorption<br />
Emission<br />
350 400 450 500 550 600 650<br />
λ (nm)<br />
S. Nizamoglu, E. Mutlugun, O. Akyuz, N. Kosku Perkgoz, H. V.<br />
<strong>Demir</strong>, L. Liebscher, S. Sapra, N. Gaponik, A.<br />
Eychmüller, New Journal of Physics<br />
10, 023026 (2008).
Optical Power P (a.uu)<br />
Surface state emitting CdS nanocrystals hybridized on n‐<br />
UV InGaN/GaN LEDs<br />
• Tuning white light properties<br />
1 8<br />
0<br />
1 7<br />
0<br />
1 6<br />
0<br />
1 5<br />
0<br />
1 4<br />
0<br />
1<br />
3<br />
0<br />
1<br />
2<br />
0<br />
1 1<br />
0<br />
400 500 600 700<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Outline<br />
• Climate change, greenhouse gases<br />
• Solid state lighting enabled by nanophotonics<br />
– White LEDs involving nanophosphors<br />
– for indoors lighting (warm color temperature, high color rendering index)<br />
– for tuned color chromatictiy operation (tuned tristimulus coordinates)<br />
– Nonradiative energy transfer in nanophosphors<br />
– FRET enhanced color converted LEDs<br />
– FRET converted light emitting structures<br />
– color tuning with FRET<br />
– Plasmonic nanophosphors<br />
– plasmon coupling using metal nanoparticles<br />
– selective plasmon coupling of white luminophors<br />
• Conclusion<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Förster‐type energy transfer (FRET)<br />
• FRET: nonradiative transfer of excitation energy from an<br />
excited molecule (donor) ( ) to a gground‐state<br />
molecule<br />
(acceptor)<br />
0.8<br />
R<br />
(a.u)<br />
Absorbance<br />
0.6<br />
0.4<br />
0.2<br />
0.0<br />
400 500 600 700<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
2 − 4<br />
R 0 = 0 . 211 ( κ n Q D J ( λ<br />
k<br />
ηη<br />
6<br />
1 ⎛ R0<br />
⎞<br />
T ( r)<br />
= ⎜ ⎟<br />
τ D ⎝ r ⎠<br />
ET<br />
= 1− τ<br />
1<br />
τ<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
DA_<br />
amp−ave<br />
D _ amp−ave<br />
))<br />
1 / 6<br />
Energy transfer<br />
rate<br />
Energy transfer<br />
efficiency ffi i<br />
Förster<br />
radius<br />
T. Förster, Ann. Phys. VI 2, 55 (1948).
Recycling of trapped‐excitons<br />
Photoluuminescencce<br />
1.0<br />
0.8<br />
R 0.6<br />
0.4<br />
0.2<br />
00 0.0<br />
500 550 600 650<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
Absorbance (aa.u)<br />
0.8<br />
0.6<br />
0.4<br />
0.2<br />
00 0.0<br />
400 500 600 700<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
Spontaneous Spo ta eous emission e ss o<br />
enhancement using recycling<br />
of trapped-excitons<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Hybrid WLEDs enhanced enhancedwith with nonradiative energy<br />
transfer in CdSe CdSe/ZnS ZnS core/shell nanocrystal solids<br />
Energy transfer between nanocrystal emitters (exciton funneling): e.g., see<br />
S. A. Crooker, J. A. Hollingsworth, S. Tretiak, and V. I. Klimov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 186802 (2002).<br />
TA T. A. Klar Klar, TT. Franzl Franzl, AA. L. L Rogach Rogach, and JJ. Feldmann Feldmann, Adv Adv. Mat. Mat 17 17, 769 (2005) (2005).<br />
WLEDs enhanced with energy transfer between nanocrystal emitters:<br />
u.)<br />
l power (a.<br />
Optica<br />
energy gradient ~ 160 meV
Relative quantum efficieny enhancement by<br />
recycling y gtrapped pp excitons<br />
S. Nizamoglu, O. Akin, and H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>, Applied Physics Letters 94, 243107 (2009).
Time‐resolved kinetics at donor emission<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Phooton<br />
count<br />
Time‐resolved kinetics at acceptor emission<br />
10000 10000 @ 612 nm<br />
1000<br />
100<br />
Photoon<br />
count<br />
1000<br />
100<br />
0 10 20 30 40 50<br />
time (ns)<br />
0 100 200<br />
ti time (ns)<br />
( )<br />
300 400<br />
E<br />
1 τ<br />
= 1 −<br />
τ<br />
amp _ av _ DA<br />
amp _ av _ D<br />
Förster Energy<br />
transfer efficiency<br />
=<br />
55.58 %
Kinetics of energy transfer<br />
S. Nizamoglu and H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>, "Resonant nonradiative energy transfer in CdSe/ZnS core/shell nanocrystal solids<br />
enhances hybrid white light emitting diodes," Optics Express 16, 13961-13968 (2008).
Energy transfer enhanced WLED<br />
Emission enhancement of large dots residing in the mixed energy gradient assembly<br />
with respect to the emission of only large dots: 46%<br />
Enhancement in the quantum efficiency of large dots in the presence of the small<br />
dots, compared to the large dots alone: 13.2%<br />
(because of recycled excitons)<br />
(x,y) = (0.44,0.40)<br />
CCT= 2872 K
Green gap: green/yellow range<br />
J. M. Phillips et al., Laser & Photon. Rev., 1, 307–333 (2007).<br />
M. R. Krames et al., IEEE Journal of Display Technology 3, 2 (2007).
(mW)<br />
Opttical<br />
power p<br />
3<br />
2<br />
1<br />
0<br />
Color‐Converted LED<br />
Optical poweer<br />
Relative<br />
800<br />
600<br />
400<br />
200<br />
30 mA<br />
20 mA<br />
10 mA<br />
0<br />
525 550 575 600 625 650<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
LE<br />
Optical<br />
⎛ lm ⎞<br />
= ⎜683<br />
⎟<br />
⎝ W ⎠<br />
⎛ lm ⎞<br />
LE Electrical = ⎜ ⎜683<br />
⎟<br />
⎝ W ⎠<br />
0 10 20 30 40 50<br />
Current (mA)<br />
∫ P<br />
∫<br />
∫<br />
optical<br />
P<br />
optical<br />
( λ)<br />
v(<br />
λ)<br />
dλ<br />
( λ)<br />
dλ<br />
Poptical(<br />
λ ) v(<br />
λ)<br />
dλ<br />
VI<br />
S. Nizamoglu … H.V.<br />
<strong>Demir</strong>, IEEE Journal of<br />
Selected Topics in Quntum<br />
Electronics Electronics, 15, 15 4, 4 July/August<br />
2009.
Phhoton<br />
Count C<br />
1000<br />
100<br />
10<br />
Time‐resolved dynamics y at acceptor p emission<br />
Intensity<br />
PL<br />
0.020<br />
0.016<br />
0.012<br />
0008 0.008<br />
0.004<br />
• 3.4 nmol cyan-emitting NCs<br />
• 4.9 nmol green-emitting NCs<br />
I ( t)<br />
∝<br />
kA<br />
25 50 75 100<br />
Time (ns)<br />
Green-emitting NCs<br />
Mixed cyan- and green-emitting NCs<br />
0 50 100 150 200<br />
time (ns)<br />
k FRET ⎛ ( k + k ) t k t<br />
⎜⎛<br />
e<br />
−(<br />
kD<br />
+ k FRET ) t<br />
− e<br />
−kAt<br />
⎞⎟<br />
⎞<br />
− kD<br />
−k<br />
FRET ⎝<br />
⎠
powerr<br />
(a.u)<br />
Optical O<br />
4<br />
3<br />
2<br />
1<br />
Color‐converted FRET‐enhanced LED<br />
Relativve<br />
optical powwer<br />
(a.u)<br />
1000<br />
800<br />
600<br />
400<br />
200<br />
0<br />
30 mA<br />
20 mA A<br />
10 mA<br />
540 560 580 600 620<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
0<br />
0 10 20 30 40 50<br />
current (mA)
FRET LEDs<br />
Color converted LED FRET-enhanced color converted LED<br />
In our FRET-NC-LED, NCs reach a quantum efficiency level as high as 55%.<br />
By using a near-UV LED with an external quantum efficiency of 40%,<br />
this implies that it is possible to obtain color-converted color converted FRET FRET-enhanced enhanced LEDs<br />
with an expected external quantum efficiency of 22% and<br />
a predicted luminous efficiency of 94 lm/W.<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
S. Nizamoglu … H.V. <strong>Demir</strong>,<br />
IEEE Journal of Special Topics<br />
Quantum Electronics<br />
15, 4, July/August 2009.
2 nm<br />
FRET‐converted light‐emitting structures
White light generating rresonant<br />
esonant nonradiative energy transfer<br />
from epitaxial InGaN InGaN/GaN GaN quantum wells to colloidal CdSe CdSe/ZnS ZnS<br />
core/shell core/shell quantum quantum dots<br />
dots<br />
Photon P count c<br />
4000 QWs+QDs<br />
3500<br />
only y QDs<br />
3000<br />
2500<br />
2000<br />
1500<br />
1000<br />
500<br />
0<br />
450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
The white light is generated by the luminescence of quantum wells and quantum dots,<br />
where the dot emission is further increased by 63% with nonradiative energy transfer,<br />
while setting the operating point in the white region of CIE chromaticity diagram.<br />
S. Nizamoglu … H.V. <strong>Demir</strong>,<br />
New Journal of Physics (2008).
PDDA (+)<br />
Layer by layer assembly of quantum dots<br />
Water<br />
CdTe<br />
NC (-)<br />
Corniing Glass (-)<br />
Water<br />
These steps are the basic<br />
construction sequence q for the<br />
simplest film architecture<br />
<strong>Demir</strong> Lab, Bilkent University
Architectural tuning of color chromaticity with Förster<br />
resonance energy ttransfer f (FRET)<br />
Modified donor emission Modified acceptor emission<br />
N. Cicek … H.V. <strong>Demir</strong>, Applied Physics Letters, 061105 (2009)<br />
modified emission<br />
kinetics<br />
by y controlling g FRET<br />
in layer layer-by by-layer layer assembled<br />
CdTe nanocrystals<br />
in collaboration<br />
with A. Eychmüller<br />
TU Dresden
Inter<br />
spacing<br />
(MLs)<br />
Average decay lifetime<br />
(ns)<br />
@ 595<br />
nm<br />
donor<br />
emission<br />
@ 645 nm<br />
acceptor<br />
emission<br />
FRET analysis<br />
Total relative emission<br />
(eV)<br />
Donors Acceptors<br />
η<br />
Using PL intensities<br />
FRET<br />
= 1<br />
FRET efficiency (η FRET )<br />
−<br />
F<br />
F<br />
DA<br />
D<br />
UUsing i lif lifetimes ti<br />
η = 1 −<br />
5 881 8.81 824 8.24 260 260.11 11 63 63.09 09 027 0.27 032 0.32<br />
3 7.41 10.63 219.69 346.02 0.39 0.43<br />
1 2.96 14.57 164.75 447.44 0.75 0.57<br />
Control 12.05 3.68 384.44 59.67 -- --<br />
FRET<br />
τ<br />
τ<br />
DA<br />
D
Precise tuning of color with FRET<br />
Color tuning by FRET efficiency tuning<br />
x(η)= 0.086 η+ 0.573,<br />
y (η)= ‐ 0.085 η+ 0.426
Broad tuning of color with cascaded FRET<br />
Cascaded FRET<br />
with one set of starting<br />
power distribution<br />
Cascaded FRET<br />
including different<br />
power distributions<br />
N. Cicek et al. (2009)<br />
<strong>Demir</strong> Group
Ph.D. – Piled Higher and Deeper<br />
3/17/2010 <strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong> 71
Outline<br />
• Climate change, greenhouse gases<br />
• Solid state lighting enabled by nanophotonics<br />
– White LEDs involving nanophosphors<br />
– for indoors lighting (warm color temperature, high color rendering index)<br />
– for spectrally enhanced lighting (high S/P ratio, high color rendering index)<br />
– for tuned color chromatictiy operation (tuned tristimulus coordinates)<br />
– Nonradiative energy transfer in nanophosphors<br />
– FRET enhanced color converted LEDs<br />
– FRET converted light emitting structures<br />
– color tuning with FRET<br />
– Plasmonic nanophosphors<br />
– plasmon coupling using metal nanoparticles<br />
– selective plasmon coupling of white luminophors<br />
– plasmonic nanocomposites of nanophospors<br />
– Targeted self‐assembly of nanophosphors on LEDs using<br />
smart linkers<br />
– with specific binding<br />
• Conclusion<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Localized plasmons<br />
• Collective ll i oscillations ill i of f<br />
conduction band electrons<br />
in metal particles and<br />
metal structures<br />
– with dimensions much smaller<br />
th than the th wavelength l thof f optical ti l<br />
excitation<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Physical explanation of localized plasmons<br />
• Mie theory (1908):<br />
– complete electromagnetic<br />
solution<br />
• Quasi‐static approximation:<br />
– Particle size comparable to the<br />
penetration depth<br />
– E‐field is formed along the<br />
particle<br />
– Electrons are transported with E‐<br />
field<br />
– Dipole formation<br />
– RRestoring i fforces<br />
– If restoring frequency matches<br />
excitation frequency =><br />
resonance condition<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Source: K. Sönnichsen, Plasmons in Metal Nanostructures,<br />
Ludwig-Maximilians University of Munich, 2001.
Physical explanation of localized plasmons (cont’d)<br />
• Extinction cross section of spherical metal nanoparticles<br />
according to Mie Theory (neglecting higher order modes)<br />
σ<br />
ext<br />
=<br />
9Vε<br />
3 /<br />
m<br />
c<br />
where V is the spherical particle volume,<br />
ε = + i<br />
2<br />
( )<br />
[ ( ) ] ( ) 2<br />
ωε 2 ω<br />
[ 2<br />
εε<br />
( ωω<br />
) + 2 2εε ] + εε<br />
( 2 2ωω<br />
)<br />
1<br />
+ m<br />
ε i ε , ε metal 1 2 m is the dielectric constant of the<br />
medium,cis the speed of light in free space and ω is the angular<br />
frequency<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
2
Use of localized plasmons<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Lycurgus cup (4th Century AD),<br />
British Museum
Dependence of resonance wavelength on<br />
different particle p and medium pproperties p<br />
• NNanoparticlesize ti l i => > Rd Red shift hift<br />
• Dielectric constant of the medium => Red shift<br />
Blue shift<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Red shift
Metal‐enhanced luminescence<br />
• Emission of materials in the close vicinity of<br />
metal nanoparticles, metal nanostructures or metal<br />
films<br />
QD<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Source: http://www.nanoigert.umn.edu
Plasmon‐coupled nanocrystals<br />
• Previous work on plasmon‐coupled emission of nanocrystals<br />
– Using flat films<br />
• emission of CdSe/ZnS nanocrystals could not be enhanced 1<br />
– Using gold colloids<br />
• emission of CdSe/ZnS nanocrystals enhanced 5 times2 emission of CdSe/ZnS nanocrystals enhanced 5 times<br />
– Using patterned metal nanostructures<br />
• emission of CdSe/ZnS nanocrystals enhanced 30‐50 times 3,4<br />
– Using metal island films<br />
• emission of CdTe nanocrystals enhanced 5 times 5<br />
• Previous literature focuses only on plasmon‐enhanced<br />
luminescence<br />
– However, there are other important features of luminescence<br />
• including emission linewidth and emission peak<br />
1 Ok Okamoto, K., K et al., l JJ. OOpt. Soc. S Am. A B. B 2006 2006, 23 23, no. 88. 4 SSong, JJ-H., H et t al., l NNano LLett. tt 2005 2005, 55, no. 88.<br />
2 Kulakovich, O., et al., Nano Lett. 2002, 2 , no. 12. 5 Ray, K., et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2006, 128.<br />
3 Pompa, P. P., et al., Nature Nanotech. 2006, 1.<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Metal Enhanced Fluorescence
Metal Enhanced Fluorescence<br />
Pompa et al. Nature Nanotechnology 1, 126 ‐ 130 (2006)
Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images<br />
of our silver island films<br />
Evaporation rate: 0.1-0.2 Å/sec<br />
20 nm, not t annealed l d<br />
20 nm, annealed at 300 ºC for 10 min.<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of<br />
our silver il il island dfil films ( (cont’d) ’d)<br />
6 nm, ,<br />
annealed at 150 ºC for 1 min.<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Nanoisland formation<br />
AAg evaporation ti<br />
(0.1 A/s) on quartz<br />
Annealing at 300 0 Annealing at 300 C<br />
under N2 purge<br />
Nanocrystal<br />
integration<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Plasmon resonance tuning<br />
with lateral vertical dimension
Our absorbance spectra of different silver island<br />
fil films<br />
Absorbance<br />
(a.uu.)<br />
1.0<br />
0.8<br />
0.6<br />
0.4<br />
0.2<br />
0.0<br />
4 nm Ag, 300 0C, 20 min.<br />
2nmAg,1500 2 nm Ag, 150 C, 2 min.<br />
6 nm Ag, 150 0C, 2 min.<br />
6 nm Ag, 150 0C, 2 min.+10 nm Si O x y<br />
300 400 500 600 700<br />
Resonance wavelengths:<br />
426 nm<br />
452 nm<br />
488 nm<br />
515 nm<br />
Larger thickness => Red shift<br />
Annealing => Blue shift<br />
Larger dielectric constant<br />
at the interface => Red shift<br />
wavelength (nm)Tunable, controllable and reproducible<br />
llocalized li d plasmon l resonance bbehavior h i<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Resonance wavelengths g of our metal island films<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Interactions between plasmons p and luminescent materials<br />
• Physical mechanisms affecting metal‐ metal<br />
enhanced luminescence performance<br />
1. Local field enhancement close to plasmons<br />
2. Increased radiative recombination rate of luminescent<br />
material (Förster energy transfer)<br />
33. QQuenching hi<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Quantitative expressions of metal enhanced luminescence<br />
2 ( ) QYmetal = L<br />
Z(<br />
) metal<br />
ω<br />
( ) 2<br />
ω ( ) and<br />
Y ω<br />
exc Z<br />
Γ<br />
Γ+<br />
k<br />
flu<br />
flu =<br />
QY<br />
QY<br />
Γ + Γ<br />
where and<br />
m<br />
QQY0<br />
=<br />
QYmetal<br />
=<br />
Γ + Γm<br />
+<br />
nr<br />
Γ iis the h radiative di i recombination bi i rate<br />
Γm is the radiative recombination rate due to the presence of metal<br />
knr is the nonradiative decay rate<br />
Also, the photon lifetime decreases by the factor<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
F<br />
P<br />
0<br />
k<br />
nr<br />
Γ + k nr + Γ<br />
=<br />
Γ + k<br />
nr<br />
m
Spectral design of plasmon‐coupled nanocrystals<br />
• Resonance wavelength<br />
matching<br />
0<br />
• λ(Ag)=457 nm<br />
λ(Ag+SixOy)=476 nm<br />
λ(Emission)=493 nm<br />
0.8<br />
• Red shift with the<br />
addition of nanocrystals y<br />
0.6<br />
taken into account<br />
0.4<br />
• Nanoisland size: avoided<br />
very small nanoislands<br />
(
Structural design of plasmon‐coupled nanocrystals<br />
Quenching: effective in 5 nm<br />
Increased field: effective in 15 nm<br />
Increased decay rate: effective in 25 nm<br />
Distance < 5 nm => quenching<br />
Di Distance t > 20 nm=> > almost l t iisolated l t d<br />
J. R. Lakowicz, “Radiative decay engineering: biophysical<br />
and biomedical applications,” Anal. Biochem., vol. 298, 2001, pp. 1-24.<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Photoluminnescence<br />
(couunts)<br />
30000<br />
25000<br />
20000<br />
15000<br />
10000<br />
5000<br />
Localized plasmon coupled nanocrystal<br />
emitters<br />
NC+Si O +nanoAg<br />
x y<br />
control NC<br />
1.0<br />
control t l NC+nanoAg<br />
NC A 08 0.8<br />
NC+Si x O y +nanoAg: NC: NC+nanoAg<br />
15.1:1.0: 0.7<br />
0<br />
400 450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
Normalized photolumines<br />
p scence<br />
0.6<br />
04 0.4<br />
0.2<br />
492 nm 506 nm<br />
NC+Si x O y +nanoAg<br />
control t l NC<br />
NC NC+Si O +nanoAg<br />
x y<br />
λ : 492 nm<br />
PL<br />
FWHM: 45 nm<br />
506 nm<br />
35 nm<br />
00 0.0<br />
400 450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
wavelength (nm)<br />
CdSe CdSe/ZnS ZnS nanocrystals closely closely-packed packed in the proximity of Ag nanoisland films:<br />
1) 1)enhancing 1.) enhancing the PL intensity by 15 15.1 1 times compared to the same nanocrystals<br />
without nano-Ag nano Ag (no plasmonic resonance)<br />
and 21.6 times on the average compared to the same nanocrystals with nano-Ag nano Ag<br />
but no dielectric spacer (when quenched)<br />
2.) shifting peak emission wavelength (by 14 nm) and<br />
3.) reducing emission linewidth (by 10 nm FWHM, corresponding to >22 %)<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
I. M. Soganci, S. Nizamoglu, E. Mutlugun and H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>, Optics Express 15(22), 14289 (2007).
Plasmon coupled surface state emitting nanocrystals<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Surface‐state emission is<br />
8.9 weaker than the<br />
bband‐edge d d emission. i i<br />
Plasmon resonance tuned<br />
to match the peak surface state emission:<br />
Vertical film thickness: 10 nm<br />
Lateral size distribution: 25‐75 nm
Material<br />
on quartz<br />
substrate<br />
Only SSE<br />
NC<br />
SSE NC<br />
with 10 nm<br />
Ag<br />
Selectively y plasmon p enhanced surface state emission<br />
Band-edge<br />
emission<br />
λ 1 (nm)<br />
Surface-state<br />
emission<br />
λ 2 (nm)<br />
λ 1 peak<br />
intensity<br />
(counts)<br />
λ 2 peak<br />
intensity<br />
(counts)<br />
Intensity<br />
ratio<br />
@λ 2 /<br />
@λ 1<br />
Highlighted in<br />
Introduction to Nanophotonics<br />
by Sergey V. Gaponenko,<br />
Cambridge University Press<br />
(2009)<br />
EEnhancement h tiin th the ratio ti of f<br />
surface‐state peak emission to<br />
band‐edge peak emission of<br />
plasmon‐coupled p p film sample p<br />
compared to that in solution:<br />
12.7 folds<br />
Total<br />
number of<br />
photons<br />
415 545 1388 290 0.21 67,885 , T. Ozel, I. M. Soganci, S. Nizamoglu, I.<br />
O. Huyal, E. Mutlugun, S.<br />
415 531 672 960 1.43 122,055<br />
Sapra, N. Gaponik, A. Eychmüller,<br />
H. V. <strong>Demir</strong>, New Journal of Physics<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
10, 083035 (2008).
Outline<br />
• Climate change, greenhouse gases<br />
• Solid state lighting enabled by nanophotonics<br />
– White LEDs involving nanophosphors<br />
– for indoors lighting (warm color temperature, high color rendering index)<br />
– for tuned color chromatictiy operation (tuned tristimulus coordinates)<br />
– Nonradiative energy transfer in nanophosphors<br />
– FRET enhanced color converted LEDs<br />
– FRET converted light emitting structures<br />
– color tuning with FRET<br />
– Plasmonic nanophosphors<br />
– plasmon coupling using metal nanoparticles<br />
– selective plasmon coupling of white luminophors<br />
• Conclusion<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
How can we combat climate change<br />
using NANOPHOTONICS?<br />
• Can we help to reduce global energy<br />
consumption?<br />
– Light generation<br />
• Solid state lighting using nanophosphors<br />
– for the generation of high‐quality white light<br />
– using nonradiative energy transfer<br />
• Can we help to convert solar energy more<br />
efficiently?<br />
– Light harvesting<br />
• Quantum dot integrated solar cells<br />
– for the extension of spectral response<br />
– also using nonradiative energy transfer<br />
• C Can we help h l t to reduce d the th amount t of f<br />
greenhouse gases?<br />
– Photocatalytic nanoparticle integrated systems<br />
• ffor massive i environmental i t ld decontamination<br />
t i ti<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
GREEN<br />
NANOPHOTONICS<br />
current (mA)<br />
*2 patents pending<br />
voltage (V)<br />
0<br />
0 02 0.2 04 0.4 06 0.6 08 0.8 1 12 1.2 14 1.4 16 1.6 18 1.8 2<br />
-2<br />
-4<br />
-6<br />
-8<br />
PL Intensity (a.u.)<br />
*1 patent p<br />
* 3 patents<br />
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700<br />
λ (nm)<br />
wihout nanocrystals<br />
with 3.42 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals<br />
with 10.40 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals y<br />
with 20.80 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals<br />
with 52.00 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals<br />
with 67.60 nanomol/cm2 nanocrystals
Flashback – in 2005<br />
• Future perspective: We proposed and envisioned that these<br />
p p p p<br />
hybrid nanphosphor white LEDs are promising candidates for future<br />
solid-state lighting applications.
Today – in 2010<br />
• Nanocrystal based light emitting diodes are<br />
commercially y available today. y<br />
• However, high‐quality nanophosphor LEDs<br />
are not commercialized yet.
Single to few nanoparticle devices<br />
• Our on‐chip integration from macro to micro to nano scale:<br />
15 mm<br />
CC. UUran, EE. UUnal, l RR. Ki Kizil, il and d HH. VV.<br />
<strong>Demir</strong>, IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in<br />
Quantum Electronics Vol. 15, 5, 2009<br />
Fully integrated chip with macroprobes<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
Microfabricated electrode array<br />
20 nm<br />
Aligned and clamped<br />
nanowires<br />
Captured<br />
nanoparticles
Conclusions<br />
• Climate change is a major problem. Solid state lighting potentially offers<br />
substantial reduction in energy consumption and greenhouse gas<br />
emission.<br />
• Nanocrystal emitters outperform conventional phoshors in white light<br />
generation in certain optical aspects with<br />
• warm color temperature and high color rendering index<br />
– for day vision (indoors applications)<br />
• tuneable operating point (tuned tristimulus coordinates)<br />
– for application‐specific spectral illumination (niche applications)<br />
• Nanocrystall LEDs bbenefit fi ffrom<br />
– nonradiative energy transfer between nanocrystals<br />
– nonradiative energy transfer from epitaxial quantum wells to nanocrystals<br />
– plasmon coupling<br />
• Nanostructured white LEDs of nanocrystal emitters hold promise for high<br />
quality lighting.<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Bilkent Devices and Sensors Group<br />
• Dr. Nihan Kosku Pekgöz (project coordinator)<br />
• Dr. Olga Samarska (postdoctoral fellow)<br />
• Dr. Mehmet Şahin Ş (visiting ( g scholar) )<br />
• R. Eng. Özgün Akyüz (lab manager engineer)<br />
• R. Eng. Müh. Emre Ünal (technıcal learder engıneer)<br />
• Rohat Melik (phd)<br />
• Evren Mutlugün (phd)<br />
• Sedat Nizamoğlu (phd)<br />
• Emre Sarı (phd)<br />
• Can Uran (phd)<br />
• Gulis Zengin (phd)<br />
• Aslı Ünlügedik (phd)<br />
• Akın Sefunç (phd)<br />
• Neslihan Çiçek (ms‐phd)<br />
• Onur Akın (ms‐phd)<br />
• Gürkan Polat (ms‐phd)<br />
• Tuncay Özel (ms)<br />
• Ilkem Özge Huyal (ms)<br />
• Sina Toru Refik (ms)<br />
• Talha Erdem (ms)<br />
• Burak Güzeltürk (ms)<br />
Previous members<br />
• Dr. Gülşah Yaman (postdoc)<br />
• Dr. Yang Zhang (postdoc)<br />
• Eng..Aslı Koç (research engıneer)<br />
• İbrahim Murat Soğancı (ms)<br />
• Sümeyra Tek (ms)<br />
• Mustafa Yorulmaz (ug)<br />
Acknowledgements<br />
Collaborators:<br />
• TU Dresden (N. Gaponik, S. Sapra, S. Hickey,<br />
A. Eychmüller) y )<br />
• Belarus National Academy of Science (S. Gaponenko, M.<br />
Artemyev)<br />
• KOPTI (I. Lee, J. Baek)<br />
• NTU (XW Sun, K. Pita)<br />
Funding and support:<br />
• ESF EURYI<br />
• EU Nanophotonics4Energy<br />
• EU MOON 021391<br />
• ESF COST MP0701<br />
• NIH 5R01EB010035-02<br />
• KRF- TUBITAK 1070297<br />
• NASB - TUBITAK 107E088<br />
• BMBF-TUBITAK 109E002<br />
• T UBITAK 106E020<br />
• INNOVNANO<br />
• NRF RF 2009-09<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Device and Sensors Group<br />
<strong>Demir</strong> lab 2008-2009 SCI Publications:<br />
1. Applied Physics Letters 92, 031102 (2008).<br />
2. Applied Physics Letters 92, 201105 (2008).<br />
3. New Journal of Physics y 16(2), ( ), 1115 (2008). ( )<br />
4. Optics Express 16(6), 3515 (2008).<br />
5. Applied Physics Letters 92, 113110 (2008).<br />
6. Optics Express 16(6), 3537 (2008).<br />
7. J. Materials Chemistry 18, 3568-3574 (2008). <strong>Demir</strong> lab 2008-2009<br />
8. Optics Express 10, 023026 (2008).<br />
Patent Applications:<br />
99. EEuropean FFebs b JJournal l 275 275, 97 (2008) (2008).<br />
1. Zizgag InGaN quantum<br />
10. Nanotechnology 19, 335203 (2008).<br />
11. New Journal of Physics 10, 083035 (2008).<br />
modulators, pending.<br />
12. Optics Express 16, 13391-13397 (2008).<br />
2. LED-MOD-Detector diodes, pending.<br />
13. IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 55, 3459-3466(2008). 3. Photovoltaic nanocrystal<br />
14 14. JJ. Micromech Micromech. Microengineering 18 18, 115017 (2008) (2008). scintillators scintillators, pending pending.<br />
15. Optics Express 16, 13961-13968 (2008).<br />
4. PFA white emitters, pending.<br />
16. New Journal of Physics 10, 123001 (2008).<br />
5. High s/p solid state lighting, pending.<br />
17.Applied Physics Letters 95, 011106 (2009).<br />
6. Nanophosphors efficiency<br />
18. Applied Physics Letters 95, 033106 (2009).<br />
enhancement, pending.<br />
19. IEEE JSTQE , 15 4), ) 1163 (2009). ( )<br />
77. Bilkent DYO photocatalytic<br />
20. Journal of Applied Physics106, 043704 (2009)<br />
synergy, pending.<br />
21. Applied Physics Letters 94, 061105(2009)<br />
8. Bilkent DYO Arçelik photocatalytic<br />
22. Journal of Applied Physics 105, 083112(2009)<br />
nanocomposite, pending.<br />
23. IEEE Journal of Special Topics in Quantum<br />
Electronics15, 5, 1413 (2009).<br />
9. Bilkent Innovnano<br />
24 24. AApplied li d Ph Physics i Letters L tt 94 94, 211107 (2009)<br />
composite composite, pending. pending<br />
25. Applied Physics Letters 94, 243107 (2009)<br />
10. Bilkent Synthese<br />
26. Applied Physics Letters (in press)<br />
bioimplant, pending.<br />
27. IEEE Journal of Special<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong><br />
Topics<br />
<strong>Volkan</strong><br />
in Quantum<br />
<strong>Demir</strong><br />
Electronics (special issue on Metamaterials) (in press).
Our research program<br />
• High‐quality light emitting diodes (LEDs)<br />
– Nanocrystal y hybridized y white LEDs ( (NC‐LED) )<br />
– Nonradiative energy transfer converted white LEDs (FRET‐LED) Plasmonically<br />
enhanced white LEDs (plasmon‐LED)<br />
– High‐brightness LEDs (InGaN/GaN HB‐LED)<br />
– Nanostructured LEDS (nano‐LED)<br />
• High High‐efficiency efficiency photovoltaic devices (PV)<br />
– Nanocrystal integrated photovoltaic devices (NC‐PV)<br />
– Plasmonically enhanced photovoltaic devices (plasmon‐PV)<br />
– Nanowire photovoltaic devices (NW‐PV)<br />
• Nanocrystal Nanocrystal, metal nanoparticle and nanowire embedded devices<br />
and systems<br />
– Field‐assisted self‐assembly (dielectorphoresis)<br />
– On‐chip integrated nanowire device platform<br />
– Single g nano‐particle p devices<br />
– Photocatalytic nanocomposite systems<br />
• Quantum modulators / Photonic switches<br />
– Visible quantum electroabsorption modulators (InGaN)<br />
– UV quantum electroabsorption modulators(InAlGaN)<br />
– Quantum dot luminescence modulators/photonic switches<br />
– Nanorod modulators<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Our research program<br />
• Biomimetic optoelectronic devices<br />
– Peptide decorated nanocrystal emitters.<br />
– Targeted self‐assembly of nanocrystals/nanoparticles<br />
/<br />
– Layer‐by‐Layer templated nanocrystals using biomineralization<br />
– Nanohybrids assembled with genetically engineered peptides<br />
• Innovative RF and optoelectronic sensors<br />
– CCompact thi high‐Q h Q RF rezonators t<br />
– Wireless RF‐MEMS sensors<br />
– Bioimplant sensors<br />
• Novel nanophotonic devices<br />
– Polymer nanoparticles<br />
– Organic nanodevices<br />
– Novel nano‐device fabrication<br />
• Physics and applications of nano‐structures<br />
– Quantum structure modeling<br />
– Local plasmon modeling<br />
– FRET modeling<br />
– Modification of photoluminescence kinetics (modified time‐<br />
resolved fluorescence, modified lifetime)<br />
– RF characterization h t i ti of f nanostructure t t assemblies<br />
bli<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong>
Thanks…<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
…. towards sustainable Earth<br />
semiconductor lighting for energy efficiency …<br />
<strong>Hilmi</strong> <strong>Volkan</strong> <strong>Demir</strong><br />
“Let our light shine!”