Mr. Chairman, just before Mr - The Tribunal of Inquiry into Certain ...

1211:07:081 MR. LAWLOR: I just conclude on the point that it shouldn't be waiting for me2 to raise it to have it discovered. It had should be part of the investigation.3 I won't take it further411:07:175 CHAIRMAN: Mr. Lawlor the Tribunal would make these orders in any event.67 MR. LAWLOR: We'll leave it that Mr. Gilmartin seems to have got special8 treatment on the orders.911:07:2510 CHAIRMAN: Mr. Lawlor, he didn't get special treatment. Now please continue11 with your cross-examination.1213 MR. LAWLOR: We'll revisit this matter Chairman.1411:07:4415 Q. 1 Mr. Gilmartin, we were just finishing off on the Lichfield report and I am not16 going to dwell on it and pass on from it, but just that the conclusions was17 that the provision of Westpark would require the downgrading of Tallaght and18 Blanchardstown, do you agree with that recommendation?19 A. No, I didn't.11:08:0320 Q. 2 You didn't. Okay. If we can just go on to, I don't know whether we have21 established who produced the report at 2445 yesterday afternoon, we were just22 dealing with a response to the Lichfield report by some other expert that is23 you had advising you and I think you were going to try and establish overnight24 who was the author of that report, and it starts at 2446.11:08:4025 A. I still can't recall.26 Q. 3 Okay that's fine Mr. Gilmartin. It's not -- all I want to just put to you by27 way of paraphrasing the contents is that they are very serious reservations,28 would you agree, in this retail assessment, than what was in the Lichfield29 report?11:09:0030 A. Well it seems that way.Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 474