nawili II administraciuli saqmeebi

2011 wels saapelacio sasamarTloebis mier administraciul saqmeebzeganxiluli 2567 saapelacio saCivridan administraciuli organoebis sasargebloddamTavrda 1553, anu 60,5%, fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebis sasargeblod ki –1001, anu 39,0%. sagadasaxado davebze ganxiluli iyo 243 saapelacio saCivari,aqedan sagadasaxado organoebis sasargeblod gadawyda 173 saqme, anu 71,2%,fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebis sasargeblod ki _ 70 saqme, anu 28,8%.saqarTvelos uzenaesma sasamarTlom 2011 wels sakasacio saCivriT ganixila1845 administraciuli saqme, aqedan administraciuli organoebis sasargebloddamTavrda 947 saqme, anu 51,3%, fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebis sasargeblod ki_ 869 saqme, anu 47,1%. sagadasaxado davebze ganxiluli iyo 254 sakasaciosaCivari, aqedan sagadasaxado organoebis sasargeblod damTavrda 95 saqme, anu37,4%, fizikuri pirebis sasargeblod ki _ 152 saqme, anu 59,8%.4

administraciul saqmeTa moZraoba davis saxeebismixedviT (2011 weli)MOVEMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASES ACCORDING TO THE CATEGORIES OF DISPUTE (2011)maT Soris:Among them:davis saxeebiCategories of Disputesul administraciuli saqmeebiTOTAL NUMBER OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASESgansaxilveli iyoCases were filed for trialm.S. Semovida saangariSo periodSiAmong them filed in the period of reportdamTavrdaCompleteduari eTqvaRejictedganxilulia gadawyvetilebisgamotaniTExamined through delivering of decisionm.S. sarCelis dakmayofilebiTAmong them by satisfying the claimSewyvetilia warmoebiTTerminateddatovebulia sarCeliganuxilveladClaim left unexamined1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101791616683110311235774757554341052gadaeca sxva sasamarTlosTransferred to other court563I. davebi administraciul-samarTlebrivi aqtiskanonierebis Taobaze, maT Soris:2856238823722331396691154353236Disputes on legality of Administrative Acts, amongthem:1. normatiul-administraciuli samarTlebriviaqtebiNormative-Administrative Legal Acts2. individualur-administraciuli samarTlebriviaqtebi maT Soris:Individual-Administrative Legal Acts Among them:a) SromiTi urTierTobebidan gamomdinarea) Based on labor relationsb) sajaro informaciis gacemasTan dakavSirebiTb) In relation to the disbursement of public information62850715814238464363623666516312321811313935403269148191549813522912123555g) licenziebis Taobazec) About licensesd) adgilobrivi TviTmmarTvelobisa dammarTvelobis aqtebis Taobazed) About act by local self-governance and governmentactse) saarCevno urTierTobebidan gamomdinaree) Due to election relationsv) garemos dacvis sakiTxebTan dakavSirebiTf) Related to environment protection issuesz) inteleqtualuri sakuTrebidan gamomdinaremaT Soris:g) Due to intellectual property, among thema) sasaqonlo niSnebis Taobazea) On the trademarksb) monopolist agentad cnobis Taobazeb) On recognition as an agent monopolistT) reestris CanawerebTan dakavSirebiTh) With regard to the register recordsi) sxva aqtebii) Other acts956153230309454728 4 2444 471 634 531 32 226 22 126 22 177738875736186491265323161633917468644774635122693019522221387113411125377

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10II. administraciuli samarTaldarRvevebisTaobaze gamotanili individualuriadministraciul-samarTlebrivi aqtebiskanonierebis SesaxebWith regard to lawfulness of individualadministrative-legal acts issued regardingadministrative violations249 214 225 46 111 35 20 27 21III. davebi administraciul-samarTlebrivi aqtisgamocemis TaobazeDisputes concerning the issuance of administrativelegalactsIV. davebi administraciuli organos qmedebisganxorcielebis an qmedebis ganxorcielebisganTavis Sekavebis TaobazeDisputes regarding the performance of an action orrefrainment thereof by an administrative bodyV. aRiarebiT sarCelTan dakavSirebiTmaT Soris:In relation to recognition claim, among them:administraciuli samarTlebrivi aqtis araradaRiarebis TaobazeOn the recognition of administrative legal act voidVI. administraciul xelSekrulebebTandakavSirebuli davebi, maT Soris:Disputes related to administrative agreement,among them:1. privatizaciis Taobaze, maT Soris:About privatization, among them:a) sacxovrebeli binebisa) of residential apartmentsb) sxva saxelmwifo qonebab) other state property2. saijaro urTierTobebidan gamomdinareDue to lease relationship3. sajaro SesyidvebTan dakavSirebiTDue to lease procurements4. sxva davebiOther disputes25455950461011523319531888820646333298814024164213786190458413792144251949178112411277314226318100226181573825171919771076381188 3315207638340797746946 1 1 3688623212325826112122683314447VII. administraciuli organos valdebuleba _zianis anazRaurebis TaobazeObligation of administrative body - on therestitution of damageVIII. sagadasaxado urTierTobebidanwarmoSobili davebi, maT Soris:Disputes emerging from tax relationship, amongthem:201483175355184427121141501891244932487711238

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101. sabaJo sagadasaxado urTierTobasTandakavSirebiTIn relation to customs taxes relations2. saerTo saxelmwifo da adgilobrivgadasaxadebTan dakavSirebiTWith regard to common state and local taxesIX. miwis kanonmdeblobidan gamomdinareDue to land legislationX. davebi socialuri dacvis TaobazemaT Soris:Disputes on social protection, among them:294542396827143412156792293982081114311125499131761424625441635732111184732011861710171. sapensioPension2. SeRavaTebi da daxmarebebiBenefits and assistance3. sarCoAnnuity4. sxva davebiOther disputesXI. saaRsrulebo urTierTobebidan warmoSobilidavebiDisputes emerging from enforcement relationsXII. samSeneblo urTierTobidan warmoSobilidavebi, maT Soris:Disputes emerging from construction relationship,among them:1. jarimebiFine2. nagebobis demontaJiDismantlement of a construction3. mSeneblobis nebarTvis gacemaPermission for building4. sxva davebiOther disputesXIII. samewarmeo saqmianobis kontrolTandakavSirebiTRelated to entrepreneurial activityXV. ojaxSi Zaladobis aRkveTis, ojaxSiZaladobis msxverplTa dacvisa da daxmarebasTandakavSirebiTIn connection with curbing violence in a family,protection of family violence victims and assistance74484670128417732611128305334604436685240141213101073053326633210132261392951095305333534914123411834922139073841727583023202510322123122983032214189211511105110243216111326116512113XIV. aranebayoflobiTi fsiqiatriulidaxmarebis mizniT piris stacionarSi moTavsebisSesaxebAbout involuntary placement of a person in apsychiatric institution68568568567967351XV. yadaRadadebuli qonebis realizaciasTandakavSirebiT2659260926131 2389 2167 72 122 29In connection with the realization of seized propertyXVI. sxva saxis davebiOther types of disputes743649590643682832378579

Semosuli da damTavrebuli saqmeebis dinamikaDYNAMIC OF FILED AND COMPLETED CASES2007 2008 2009 2010 2011SemovidaFiled13587 9236 10689 12329 16683damTavrdaCompleted13452 10102 10494 13231 110311800016683135871345212329132311200092361068910102 104941103160000wlebiYaers2007 2008 2009 2010 2011SemovidadamTavrdaFiledCompleted10

sasamarTloadministraciul saqmeTa moZraoba I instanciis sasamarTloebis mixedviT (2011 weli)MOVEMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASES ACCORDING TO THE COURTS OF FIRST INSTANCE (2011)gansaxilveli iyoCases were filed for trialm.S. Semovida saangariSoperiodSiAmong them total filed in theperiod of reportdamTavrdaCompleteduari eTqvaRejectedganxiluliagadawyvetilebisgamotaniTExamined throughdelivering a decisionmaT Soris Among themgadaeca sxvasasamarTlosTransferred to othercourtdaumTavrebel saqmeTa %sul gansaxilvel saqmeebSi% of uncompleted cases amongones to be heardsaqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme% %%%%%case case case case case case1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17sul saqarTveloSi 17916 16683 11031 61.6 1235 11.2 7747 70.2 434 3.9 1052 9.5 563 5.1 38.0 TOTAL FOR GEORGIAmaT Soris:Among them:Tbilisis saqalaqo 10882 10251 4629 42.5 978 21.1 2678 57.9 208 4.5 449 9.7 316 6.8 57.1 Tbilisi CityozurgeTis gs 312 279 286 91.7 2 0.7 249 87.1 11 3.8 21 7.3 3 1.0 7.1 Ozurgeti GClanCxuTis ms 3 3 3 100.0 3 100.0 Lanchkhuti MCCoxatauris ms 7 7 7 100.0 3 42.9 1 14 3 43 Chokhatauri MCsul guriissasamarTloebi322 289 296 91.9 2 0.7 255 86.1 11 3.7 22 7.4 6 2.0 6.8 Total for GuriaquTaisis saqalaqo 648 611 616 95.1 40 6.5 483 78.4 31 5.0 51 8.3 11 1.8 4.5 Kutaisi Citytyibulis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Tkibuli MCwyaltubos ms 4 4 4 100.0 4 100.0 Tskaltubo MCbaRdaTis ms 3 3 3 100.0 3 100.0 Baghdati MCvanis rs 50 48 47 94.0 2 4.3 44 93.6 1 2.1 6.0 Vani DCzestafonis gs 187 172 154 82.4 7 4.5 122 79.2 16 10.4 6 3.9 3 1.9 17.6 Zestaponi GCTerjolis ms 3 3 3 100.0 3 100.0 Terjola MCxaragaulis ms 3 3 1 33.3 1 100.0 67 Kharagauli MCsamtrediis rs 117 117 110 94.0 3 2.7 80 72.7 1 0.9 22 20.0 4 3.6 5 Samtredia DCsaCxeris gs 110 102 91 82.7 2 2.2 74 81.3 4 4.4 10 11.0 1 1.1 17.3 Sachkhere GCWiaTuris ms 2 2 2 100.0 2 20.0 Chiatura MCxonis rs 593 593 591 99.7 1 0.2 587 99.3 3 0.5 0.3 Khoni DCsul imereTissasamarTloebi1721 1659 1623 94.3 55 3.4 1401 86.3 52 3.2 93 5.7 22 1.4 5.5 Total for ImeretiSewyvetiliawarmoebiTTerminateddatovebuliasarCeliganuxilveladRemained unexaminedName of Court11

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17Telavis gs 252 216 233 92.5 11 4.7 163 70.0 14 6.0 36 15.5 9 3.9 7.5 Telavi GCaxmetis ms 5 3 5 100 1 20.0 2 40.0 2 40.0 Akhmeta MCgurjaanis ms 52 52 24 46.2 2 8.3 18 75.0 3 12.5 1 4.2 53.8 Gurjaani MClagodexis rs 37 32 37 100.0 20 54.1 2 5.4 15 40.5 Lagodekhi DCsagarejos rs 64 62 55 85.9 5 9.1 42 76.4 2 3.6 5 9.1 1 1.8 14.1 Sagarejo DCsiRnaRis rs 61 53 50 82.0 1 2.0 40 80.0 1 2.0 7 14.0 1 2.0 18.0 Sighnaghi DCyvarlis rs 22 17 22 100.0 1 4.5 12 54.5 1 4.5 4 18.2 4 18.2 Kvareli DCdedofliswyaros rs 133 113 123 92.5 2 1.6 85 69.1 36 29.3 7.5 Dedoplistskaro DCsul kaxeTis626 548 549 87.7 22 4.0 381 69.4 20 3.6 93 16.9 33 6.0 12.3 Total for KakhetisasamarTloebimcxeTis gs 244 228 222 91.0 13 5.9 154 69.4 15 6.8 25 11.3 15 6.8 8.2 Mtskheta GCduSeTis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Dusheti MCTianeTis msTianeti MCyazbegis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Kazbegi MCaxalgoris msAkhalgori MCsul mcxeTa-mTianeTis 246 230 224 91.1 13 5.8 155 69.2 15 6.7 25 11.2 16 7.1 8.1 Total for Mtskheta-Mtianetiambrolauris gs 30 29 25 83.3 23 92.0 2 8.0 16.7 Ambrolauri GConis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Oni MClentexis rs 14 14 14 100.0 1 7.1 11 78.6 2 14.3 Lentekhi DCcageris rs 13 13 12 92.3 12 100.0 7.7 Tsageri DCsul raWa-leCxumisTotal for Racha-58 57 52 89.7 1 1.9 47 90.4 2 3.8 2 3.8 10.3sasamarTloebiLechkhumi and KvemofoTis saqalaqo 211 206 202 95.7 4 2.0 169 83.7 9 4.5 16 7.9 4 2.0 4.3 Poti Citysenakis gs 111 110 108 97.3 3 2.8 77 71.3 7 6.5 20 18.5 1 0.9 2.7 Senaki GCabaSis ms 12 11 12 100.0 4 33.3 1 8.3 1 8.3 6 50.0 Abasha MCmartvilis ms 61 58 55 90.2 3 5.5 35 63.6 10 18.2 7 12.7 9.8 Martvili MCzugdidis rs 208 196 206 99.0 5 2.4 176 85.4 7 3.4 10 4.9 8 3.9 0.5 Zugdidi DCmestiis rs 2 2 2 100.0 2 100.0 Mestia DCwalenjixis rs 44 43 41 93.2 1 2.4 34 82.9 6 14.6 6.8 Tsalenjikha DCCxorowyus rs 24 22 24 100.0 1 4.2 23 95.8 Chkhorotsku DCxobis rs 66 62 62 93.9 53 85.5 1 1.6 5 8.1 3 4.8 6.1 Khobi DCsul samegrelosa dazemo svaneTissasamarTloebi739 710 712 96.3 17 2.4 573 80.5 25 3.5 68 9.6 29 4.1 3.5Total for Samegrelo andZemo Svaneti12

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17axalcixis gs 191 182 171 89.5 11 6.4 119 69.6 17 9.9 23 13.5 1 0.6 10.5 Akhaltsikhe GCadigenis ms 3 3 3 100.0 3 100.0 Adigeni MCaspinZis msAspindza MCborjomis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Borjomi MCaxalqalaqis gs 63 54 55 87.3 1 1.8 36 65.5 4 7.3 11 20.0 3 5.5 11.1 Akhalkalaki GCninowmindis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Ninotsminda MCsul samcxe-javaxeTisTotal for Samtskhe-259 241 231 89.2 12 5.2 160 69.3 21 9.1 34 14.7 4 1.7 10.4sasamarTloebiJavakhetigoris gs 372 321 355 95.4 12 3.4 268 75.5 11 3.1 43 12.1 21 5.9 1.9 Gori GCkaspis ms 9 7 20 222.2 13 65.0 2 10.0 3 15.0 2 10.0 22.2 Kaspi MCxaSuris gs 163 141 136 83.4 101 74.3 10 7.4 15 11.0 10 7.4 8.0 Khashuri GCqarelis ms 6 3 6 100.0 2 33.3 3 50.0 1 16.7 Kareli MCsul Sida qarTlissasamarTloebi550 472 517 94.0 25 4.8 373 72.1 21 4.1 64 12.4 34 6.6 4.0 Total for Shida KartlirusTavis saqalaqo 527 443 480 91.1 19 4.0 395 82.3 17 3.5 37 7.7 12 2.5 8.7 Rustavi Citybolnisis gs 317 304 275 86.8 17 6.2 235 85.5 3 1.1 10 3.6 10 3.6 12.9 Bolnisi GCmarneulis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Marneuli MCdmanisis msDmanisi MCgardabnis rs 144 133 131 91.0 2 1.5 113 86.3 7 5.3 5 3.8 4 3.1 9.0 Gardabani DCTeTriwyaros rs 29 29 29 100.0 2 6.9 24 82.8 3 10.3 Tetritskaro DCwalkis rs 26 26 25 96.2 10 40.0 1 4.0 14 56.0 3.8 Tsalka DCsul qvemo qarTlissasamarTloebi1044 936 941 90.1 40 4.3 778 82.7 28 3.0 69 7.3 26 2.8 9.7 Total for Kvemo KartlibaTumis saqalaqo 880 756 733 83.3 38 5.2 540 73.7 20 2.7 94 12.8 41 5.6 16.3 Batumi CityqobuleTis ms 3 1 2 66.7 1 50.0 1 50.0 33.3 Kobuleti MCxelvaCauris gs 306 289 281 91.8 17 6.0 208 74.0 10 3.6 19 6.8 27 9.6 8.2 Khelvachauri GCxulos ms 9 9 9 100.0 3 33.3 3 33.3 3 33.3 Khulo MCqedis msKeda MCSuaxevis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Shuakhevi MCsul aWarissasamarTloebi1199 1056 1026 85.6 58 5.7 752 73.3 31 3.0 113 11.0 72 7.0 14.1 Total for Adjarasoxumis saqalaqo 194 161 155 79.9 12 7.7 118 76.1 20 12.9 5 3.2 20.1 Sokhumi Citygali-gulrifSis rs 76 73 76 100.0 76 100.0 Gali-Gulripshi DCsul afxazeTissasamarTloebi270 234 231 85.6 12 5.2 194 84.0 20 8.7 5 2.2 14.4 Total for Abkhazia13

saqarTvelos I instanciis sasamarTloebis mierganxiluli administraciuli saqmeebiADMINISTRATIVE CASES HEARD BY THE COURTS OF OF FIRST INSTANCE1 sul ganxilulia saqme,234Heard cases in totalmaT Soris sarCeli Setanilia:Among them claims filed by:administraciuli organoebis mierAdministrative bodiesfizikuri pirebis mierNatural persons and legal entitiesdamTavrda administraciuli organoebissasargeblodAppeals resolved for the favor of administrativebodiesdamTavrda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodAppeals resolved for the favor of natural persons andlegal entitiesdamTavrda morigebiTWere resolved through settlement2011 weli 2010 welisulsul%TotalTotal%8244 96083876 47.0 4475 46.64368 53.0 5133 53.45822 70.6 6345 66.01965 23.8 2797 29.148 0.6 42 0.414

saqarTvelos I instanciis sasamarTloebis mier ganxilulisagadasaxado davebi1 sul ganxilulia saqme,2Total number of cases heardmaT Soris sarCeli Setanilia:Among them claims filed by:sagadasaxado organoebis mierTaxation bodiesTEXATION DISPUTES HEARD BY THE COURTS OF OF FIRST INSTANCEfizikuri da iuridiuli pirebis mierNatural persons and legal entitiesdamTavrda sagadasaxado organoebis sasargeblodWere resolved for the favor of taxation bodiessulTotal3 damTavrda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodWere resolved for the favor of natural persons and legal459entites4 damTavrda morigebiT 3Were resolved through settlement262125224062011%83.7sulTotal2873 381091.28.816.0327353728898672010%85.914.175.822.815

# sasamarTloadministraciul saqmeTa saapelacio wesiT gasaCivrebadamTavrdasaqmeCompleted casesgasaCivrdaFiled(2011 weli)APPEAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASES%administraciuliorganos mierby administrativeorgansmaT Soris gasaCivrda Among them filed:%fizikuri an iuridiulipiris mierby natural and legal entities1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9sul 10468 2580 24.6 705 6.7 1874 17.9 Total1 Tbilisis saqalaqo 4313 1192 27.6 129 3.0 1063 24.6 Tbilisi City2 baTumis saqalaqo 692 194 28.0 68 9.8 126 18.2 Batumi City3 quTaisis saqalaqo 605 164 27.1 68 11.2 96 15.9 Kutaisi City4 goris gs 334 137 41.0 103 30.8 34 10.2 Gori GC5 Telavis gs 224 58 25.9 32 14.3 26 11.6 Telavi GC6 rusTavis gs 468 33 7.1 14 3.0 19 4.1 Rustavi City7 xelvaCauris gs 254 136 53.5 48 18.9 88 34.6 Khelvachauri GC8 ozurgeTis gs 283 85 30.0 43 15.2 42 14.8 Ozurgeti GC9 mcxeTis gs 207 59 28.5 12 5.8 47 22.7 Mtskheta GC10 zugdidis rs 198 50 25.3 5 2.5 45 22.7 Zugdidi DC11 gardabnis rs 127 26 1.0 10 7.9 16 12.6 Gardabani DC12 axalcixis gs 170 61 35.9 30 17.6 31 18.2 Akhaltsikhe GC13 xaSuris gs 139 39 28.1 25 18.0 14 10.1 Khashuri GC14 bolnisis gs 265 60 22.6 13 4.9 47 17.7 Bolnisi GC15 foTis saqalaqo 198 40 20.2 40 20.2 Poti City16 zestafonis gs 151 33 21.9 23 15.2 10 6.6 Zestaponi GC17 senakis gs 107 10 9.3 10 9.3 Senaki GC18 sagarejos rs 54 14 25.9 9 16.7 5 9.3 Sagarejo DC%Court16

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 919 saCxeris gs 90 11 12.2 5 5.6 6 6.7 Sachkhere GC20 samtrediis rs 106 29 27.4 23 21.7 6 5.7 Samtredia DC21 dedofliswyaros rs 123 10 8.1 1 0.8 9 7.3 Dedoplistskaro DC22 ambrolauris gs 25 2 8.0 2 8.0 Ambrolauri GC23 kaspis ms 5 Kaspi MC24 vanis rs 47 19 40.4 10 21.3 9 19.1 Vani DC25 siRnaRis rs 49 20 40.8 7 14.3 13 26.5 Sighnaghi DC26 xobis rs 59 11 18.6 4 6.8 7 11.9 Khobi DC27 axalqalaqis gs 52 15 28.8 1 1.9 14 26.9 Akhalkalaki GC28 wyaltubos ms 4 TskaltuboMC29 xonis rs 591 29 4.9 3 0.5 26 4.4 Khoni DC30 martvilis ms 48 3 6.3 3 6.3 Martvili MC31 cageris rs 12 Tsageri DC32 walenjixis rs 41 6 14.6 6 14.6 Tsalenjikha DC33 xaragaulis ms 1 Kharagauli MC34 gurjaanis ms 23 1 4.3 1 4.3 Gurjaani MC35 abaSis ms 6 2 33.3 2 33.3 Abasha MC36 qobuleTis ms 2 2 100.0 2 100.0 Kobuleti MC37 walkis rs 25 1 4.0 1 4.0 Tsalka DC38 tyibulis ms 1 Tkibuli MC39 TeTriwyaros rs 29 7 24.1 2 6.9 5 17.2 Tetritskaro DC40 yvarlis rs 18 6 33.3 6 33.3 Kvareli DC41 lagodexis rs 22 2 9.1 1 4.5 1 4.5 Lagodekhi DC42 Cxorowyus rs 24 6 25.0 5 20.8 1 4.2 Chkhorotsku DC17

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 943 baRdaTis ms 3 Baghdati MC44 Coxatauris ms 4 Chokhatauri MC45 soxumis rs 150 Sokhumi DC46 qarelis ms 5 Kareli MC47 lanCxuTis ms 3 Lanchkhuti MC48 duSeTis ms 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Dusheti MC49 axmetis ms 3 Akhmeta MC50 marneulis ms 1 Marneuli MC51 WiaTuris ms 2 Chiatura MC52 borjomis ms 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Borjomi MC53 adigenis ms 3 1 33.3 1 33.3 Adigeni MC54 galis rs 76 1 1.3 1 1.3 Gali DC55 lentexis rs 14 Lentekhi DC56 ninowmindis ms 1 Ninotsminda MC57 onis ms 1 Oni MC58 mestiis rs 2 2 100.0 2 100.0 Mestia DC59 xulos ms 6 1 16.7 1 16.7 Khulo MC18

administraciuli davebis intensivobis maCvenebeli mosaxleobis 10000 kaczegaangariSebiTINTENSITY INDEX OF ADMINISTRATIVE DISPUTES ACCORDING TO THE CALCULATIONOF 10000 CITIZENSregioniRegion2002200320042005200620072008200920102011sul saqarTveloTOTAL FOR GEORGIATbilisiTbilisiguriaGuriaimereTiImeretikaxeTiKakhetimcxeTa-mTianeTiMtskheta-MtianetiraWa-leCxumi da qvemosvaneTiRacha-Lechkhumi andKvemo Svanetisamegrelo-zemo svaneTiSamegrelo-Zemo Svanetisamcxe-javaxeTiSamtskhe-JavakhetiSida qarTliShida Kartliqvemo qarTliKvemo KartliafxazeTis a/r*17 35 27 27 27 2944 92 57 36 35 383 11 24 37 28 2310 23 12 15 18 1813 18 14 21 28 197 16 12 16 17 1713 16 16 8 10 94 12 29 13 21 277 13 15 17 15 106 12 13 14 20 1210 14 20 43 24 20192814261010571088233816241216891111112854212318141010914103788212413211215111519Aphkhazia Aut. Republic*aWaris a/rAchara Aut. Republic12 16 17 25 36 4221233527* mosaxleobis raodenobis ararsebobis gamo, mocemuli maCvenebeli gaangariSebuli ar aris* Due to the absence of quantity of population, the given index isn't calculated19

sasamarTlosul raionulida saqalaqosaqme % saqme % saqme %case case case1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19maT Soris:damTavrda saqme saapelacio saCivriTCompleted with appellate claimsaapelacio da kerZo saCivrebiT Semosul administraciul saqmeebzegadawyvetilebaTa gadasinjvis Sedegebi (2011 weli)RESULTS OF REVIEW OF DECISIONS ON ADMINISTRATIVE CASES FILED BY APPELLATE AND PRIVATE CLAIMSmaT Soris Amongthemdatovebulia ganuxilveladRemained unexamineddarCa ucvleladRemained unchangedgauqmda sulTotal terminated2567 266 10.4 1831 71.3 470 18.3 41 48 13 368 945 112 141 692 13TOTAL FOR DISTRICTAND CITY COURTSTbilisis raionebi 9 1 11.1 4 44.4 4 44.4 1 1 2 Tbilisi CourtsTbilisis saqalaqo 1161 148 12.7 855 73.6 158 13.6 6 25 1 126 412 57 37 318 7d/s xelaxali ganxilvisaTvisReturned to the court for re-hearingmaT SorisAmong themSewydaTerminatedAmong them:ozurgeTis gs 89 1 1.1 66 74.2 22 24.7 6 3 13 22 1 4 17 Ozurgeti GClanCxuTis msLanchkhuti GCCoxatauris msChokhatauri GCsul guriissasamarTloebi89 1 1.1 66 74.2 22 24.7 6 3 13 22 1 4 17 Total for GuriaquTaisis saqalaqo 151 13 8.6 105 69.5 33 21.9 2 1 3 27 59 12 8 39 Kutaisi Citytyibulis ms 1 1 100.0 1 Tkibuli MCwyaltubos ms 1 1 100.0 Tskaltubo MCbaRdaTis msBaghdati MCvanis rs 15 1 7 9 60.0 5 33.3 1 4 4 1 2 1 Vani DCzestafonis gs 27 16 59.3 11 40.7 1 10 16 1 1 14 Zestaponi GCTerjolis msTerjola DCxaragaulis msKharagauli DCsamtrediis rs 21 16 76.2 5 23.8 1 4 8 1 5 2 Kharagauli MCsaCxeris gs 13 8 61.5 5 38.5 5 1 1 Samtredia DCWiaTuris msSachkhere GCxonis rs 8 4 50.0 4 50.0 4 17 1 16 Khoni DCsul imereTissasamarTloebi237 14 5.9 159 67.1 64 27.0 3 3 3 55 105 15 17 73 Total for ImeretidamTavrda morigebiTResolved through settlementgamotanilia axali gadawyvetilebaDelivered a new decisiondamTavrda saqme kerZo saCivriTCompleted with private claimdatovebulia ganuxilvelad LRemained unexaminedmaT SorisAmong themdakmayofildaSatisfieduari eTqvaRejectedsaCivari mewarmissaqmianobisSemowmebis brZanebisTaobazeClaim regarding thecontrol of order aboutthe activity ofentrepreneursul ganxiluliaTotal heardm.S. dakmayofildaAmong them satisfiedName of Court20

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19Telavis gs 95 6 6.3 74 77.9 15 15.8 3 3 9 14 2 1 11 Telavi GCaxmetis msAkhmeta DCgurjaanis ms 2 1 1 Gurjaani DClagodexis rs 4 3 75.0 1 25.0 1 3 1 2 Lagodekhi DCsagarejos rs 13 1 7.7 9 69.2 3 23.1 3 1 1 Sagarejo DCsiRnaRis rs 16 2 12.5 12 75.0 2 12.5 2 8 1 7 Sighnaghi DCyvarlis rs 8 8 100.0 1 1 Kvareli DCdedofliswyaros rs 10 2 20.0 4 40.0 4 11.1 1 3 10 2 8 Dedoplistskaro DCsul kaxeTissasamarTloebi146 11 7.5 110 75.3 25 17.1 3 4 18 39 5 3 31 Total for KakhetimcxeTis gs 61 7 11.5 43 70.5 11 18.0 1 1 9 24 4 4 16 1 Mtskheta GCduSeTis msDusheti MCTianeTis msTianeti MCyazbegis msKazbegi MCaxalgoris msAkhalgori MCsul mcxeTamTianeTissasamarTloebi61 7 11.5 43 70.5 11 18.0 1 1 9 24 4 4 16 1Total for Mtskheta-Mtianetiambrolauris gs 6 3 50.0 3 50.0 3 Ambrolauri GConis msOni DClentexis rs 1 1 100.0 1 Lentekhi DCcageris rsTsageri DCsul raWa-leCxumisada qvemo svaneTissasamarTloebi7 3 42.9 4 57.1 1 3Total for Racha-Lechkhumi and KvemoSvanetifoTis saqalaqo 19 1 5.3 8 42.1 10 52.6 10 36 4 2 30 Poti Citysenakis gs 1 1 100.0 8 1 1 6 Senaki GCabaSis ms 2 1 50 1 50.0 1 1 1 Abasha MCmartvilis ms 5 3 60.0 2 40.0 2 1 1 Martvili MCzugdidis rs 30 3 10.0 13 43.3 14 46.7 1 1 12 23 3 3 17 1 Zugdidi DCmestiis rs 1 1 100.0 Mestia DCwalenjixis rs 7 1 14 3 42.9 3 42.9 3 Tsalenjikha DCCxorowyus rs 6 2 33.3 4 66.7 1 3 1 1 Chkhorotsku DCxobis rs 5 5 100.0 6 3 3 Khobi DCsul samegrelosa dazemo svaneTissasamarTloebi76 6 7.9 36 47.4 34 44.7 2 1 31 76 8 10 58 1Total for Samegreloand Zemo Svaneti21

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19axalcixis gs 62 4 6.5 46 74.2 12 19.4 4 1 7 19 1 5 13 1 Akhaltsikhe DCadigenis msAdigeni DCaspinZis msAspindza DCborjomis msBorjomi DCaxalqalaqis gs 12 2 16.7 7 58.3 3 25.0 1 2 6 2 4 Akhalkalaki GCninowmindis msNinotsminda MCsul samcxejavaxeTissasamarTloebi74 6 8.1 53 71.6 15 20.3 5 1 9 25 1 7 17 1Total for Samtskhe-Javakhetigoris gs 136 14 10.3 112 82.4 10 7.4 1 9 26 8 18 1 Gori GCkaspis msKaspi MCxaSuris gs 45 1 2.2 41 91.1 3 6.7 3 9 3 6 Khashuri GCqarelis ms 1 1 100.0 1 Kareli MCsul Sida qarTlissasamarTloebi182 15 8.2 153 84.1 14 7.7 1 13 35 11 24 1 Total for Shida KartlirusTavis saqalaqo 71 8 11.3 46 64.8 17 23.9 1 1 15 8 8 Rustavi Citybolnisis gs 30 4 13.3 15 50.0 11 36.7 2 2 7 43 4 14 25 2 Bolnisi DCmarneulis msMarneuli DCdmanisis msDmanisi DCgardabnis rs 14 1 7.1 10 71.4 3 21.4 1 1 1 22 1 4 17 Gardabani DCTeTriwyaros rs 6 1 16.7 5 83.3 1 1 Tetritskaro DCwalkis rs 1 1 100.0 1 1 Tsalka DCsul qvemo qarTlissasamarTloebi122 14 11.5 77 63.1 31 25.4 3 4 1 23 75 5 19 51 2 Total for Kvemo KartlibaTumis saqalaqo 232 25 10.8 162 69.8 45 19.4 3 1 3 38 96 12 15 69 Batumi CityqobuleTis ms 2 1 50.0 1 50.0 2 1 1 Kobuleti DCxelvaCauris gs 155 13 8.4 106 68.4 36 23.2 6 5 2 23 34 4 13 17 Khelvachauri DCxulos msKhulo DCSuaxevis msKeda DCqedis msShuakhevi DCsul aWarissasamarTloebi389 39 10.0 269 69.2 81 20.8 9 6 5 61 132 16 29 87 Total for Adjarasoxumis saqalaqo 13 3 23.1 3 23.1 7 53.8 1 1 5 Sokhumi Citygali-gulrifSis rs 1 1 100.0 Gali-Gulripshi DCsul afxazeTissasamarTloebi14 4 3 21.4 7 54 1 1 5 Total for Abkhazia22

administraciul saqmeebze saapelacio saCivrebis moZraoba saapelacio sasamarTloebis mixedviTSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardsasamarTloCourtsulTOTALTbilisiTbilisiquTaisiKKutaisiaWaraAAcharaafxazeTiAAbkhaziaMOVEMENT OF APPEALS ON ADMINISTRATIVE CASES ACCORDING TO THE COURTS OF APPEAL2003 20042526 1415 2372 2383 3407 1920 2619 1827 2189 1838 1861 3265 2308 2185 2787 2893 2386 25671714 907 1603 1421 2506 1176 1614 940 1604 1224 1207 2639 1568 1463 2046 2177 1615 1768598 369 536 711 616 546 1005 887 585 614 654 626 740 722 741 716 771 799211 137 225 243 278 1953 2 8 8 7 32005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011administraciul saqmeebze kerZo saCivrebis moZraoba saapelacio sasamarTloebis mixedviTMOVEMENT OF PRIVATE CLAIMS ON ADMINISTRATIVE CASES ACCORDING TO THE COURTS OF APPEAL2009SemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardSemovidaFiledganixilesHeardsasamarTloCourt2003 200420052006 2007200820102011sulTOTAL436 385 472 426 652 425 914 638 894 949 774 965 857 872 1074 1079 918 958TbilisiTbilisi339 302 382 335 488 306 704 445 684 764 528 729 635 656 768 776 580 622quTaisiKKutaisiaWaraAAcharaafxazeTiAAbkhazia74 64 44 47 44 65 210 193 210 185 246 236 222 216 306 303 338 33623 19 45 43 116 521 1 4 223

administraciul saqmeebze saapelacio saCivrebis ganxilvis SedegebiRESULTS OF APPEALS HEARD ON ADMINISTRATIVE CASESdamTavrda saqme saapelaciosaCivriTCASES COMPLETED WITH APPELLATECLAIMmaT Soris gadawyvetileba:Among them decisions:datovebulia ganuxilveladremained unexamined2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme%%%%%%%%case case case case case case case case case%1415 2383 1920 1827 1838 3265 2185 2893 256752 3.7 135 5.7 200 10.4 158 8.7 129 7.0 212 6.5 202 9.2 299 10.3 266 10.4datovebulia ucvleladremained unchanged53037.5102042.883343.486347.289048.41716 52.61300 59.51850 63.91831 71.3daubrunda sasamarTlos xelaxaliganxilvisaTvis1148.11044.4954.91045.71769.62327.184 3.864 2.241 1.6were returned to the court for re-hearingSewydawere terminated966.81355.71256.51045.71176.42347.269 3.2116 4.048 1.9damTavrda morigebiTwere resolved through settlement141.0271.1100.590.560.315 0.55 0.28 0.313 0.5gamotanilia axali gadawyvetilebawas delivered a new decision60943.0962 40.4 657 34.2 589 32.2 520 28.3 85626.2525 24.0556 19.2368 14.324

saqarTvelos saapelacio sasamarTloebis administraciulsaqmeTa palatis mier ganxiluli saapelacio saCivrebiAPPEALS HEARD BY THE CHAMBER OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASES OF THE APPELLATECOURTS OF GEORGIAsulTotal2011%sulTotal2010%1234sul ganxilulia saapelacio saCivari,Total number of appeals heardmaT Soris Setanilia:Among them filed by:administraciuli organoebis mierAdministrative bodiesfizikuri pirebis mierNatural persons and legal entitiesdamTavrda administraciuli organoebissasargeblodAppeals resolved for the favor of administrative bodiesdamTavrda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodAppeals resolved for the favor of natural persons andlegal entitiesdamTavrda morigebiTWere resolved through settlement5dabrunda I instanciaSi xelaxla ganxilvisaTvisWere returned to the first instance for re-hearingmaT Soris:Among them:gadawyda administraciuli organoebissasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of administrative bodies41121.629.3gadawyda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of natural persons and legalentities25671007 39.21560 60.8154160.0972 37.913 0.529 70.728931138 39.31755 60.71754 60.61067 36.98 0.364 2.221 32.843 67.225

saqarTvelos saapelacio sasamarTloebis administraciulsaqmeTa palatis mier sagadasaxado davebze ganxilulisaapelacio saCivrebiAPPEALS HEARD ON TAXATION DISPUTES BY THE CHAMBER OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASESOF THE APPELLATE COURTS OF GEORGIA1 sul ganxilulia saapelacio saCivariTotal number of appeals heardmaT Soris Setanilia:Among them filed by:sagadasaxado organoebis mier2Taxation bodiesfizikuri da iuridiuli pirebis mierNatural persons and legal entitiesdamTavrda sagadasaxado organoebis sasargeblodWere resolved for the favor of taxation bodies3 damTavrda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodWere resolved for the favor of natural persons and legalentites4 damTavrda morigebiT5Were resolved through settlementdabrunda I instanciaSi xelaxla ganxilvisaTvisWere returned to the first instance for re-hearingmaT Soris:Among them:gadawyda sagadasaxado organoebis sasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of administrative bodiesgadawyda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of natural persons and legalentities20112010sulsul%TotalTotal%243 39467 27.6 139 35.3176 72.4 255 64.7171 70.4 275 69.868 28.0 113 28.74 1.6 6 1.52 50.0 5 83.32 50.0 1 16.726

administraciuli saqmeebis sakasacio wesiT gasaCivrebisdinamikaDYNAMIC OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASES FILED BY THE RULE OF CASSATIONwlebiYYearsdamTavrda apelaciaSi(saapelacio saCivari)Resolved at the court of appeals(appellate claim)Semovida kasaciaSi(sakasacio saCivari)Was filed to the Cassation(cassation claim)gasaCivrebis%of claims2007 1772 985 55,62008 3246 1672 51,52009 2144 1305 60,92010 2893 1805 62,42011 2567 1319 51,4uzenaesi sasamarTlos administraciul da sxva kategoriissaqmeTa palataSi sakasacio saCivrebis dasaSvebobisSemowmebis SesaxebREVIEW OF CASSATION CLAIMS FOR ADMISSIBILITY AT THE CHAMBER OFADMINISTRATIVE AND OTHER CASES OF THE SUPREME COURTdamTavrda saqme sakasacio saCivriTCases completed with cassation claimdasaSveboba Semowmebulia (sssk 391-e muxli)Cases reviewed for admissibility (Article 391 ofCivil Procedural Code of Georgia)cnobilia dauSvebladCases recognized inadmissibledaSvebulia gansaxilveladCases admitted for hearing2011 weli 2010 welisaqme saqme saqme%Case Case Case1845 14411615 100,0 1209 100,01458 90,3 1080 89,3157 9,7 129 10,727

administraciul saqmeebze sakasacio saCivrebis ganxilvis SedegebiRESULTS OF CASSATION CLAIMS HEARD ON ADMINISTRATIVE CASESdamTavrda saqmesakasacio saCivriTCASES COMPLETED WITHCASSATION CLAIMmaT Soris:Among them :datovebulia ganuxilveladremained unexaminedcnobilia dauSvebladwere recognized inadmissibledatovebulia ucvleladremained unchangeddaubrunda sasamarTlosxelaxali ganxilvisaTviswere returned to the court forre-hearingSewydawere terminateddamTavrda morigebiTwere resolved through settlementgamotanilia axaligadawyvetilebawas delivered a new decision2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 20102011saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme% %%%%%%%%case case case case case case case case case667 1046 1380 829 915 117119 2.8 42 4.0 95 6.9 146 17.6 85 9.3 109 9.3X X X X X X 295 35.6 480 52.5 725 61.9347 52.0 602 57.6 768 55.7 166 20.0 105 11.5 90 7.7197 29.5 270 25.8 403 29.2 140 16.9 149 16.3 108 9.216 2.4 18 1.7 23 1.7 17 2.1 14 1.5 14 1.22 0.3 9 0.9 6 0.4 7 0.8 5 0.5 3 0.386 12.9 105 10.0 85 6.2 52 6.3 77 8.4 122 10.41586148 9.31061 66.9108 6.8137 8.623 1.55 0.3104 6.61441148 10.31845162 8.81080 74.9 1458 79.053 3.7 53 2.981 5.6 69 3.727 1.9 22 1.212 0.8 14 0.840 2.8 67 3.628

administraciul saqmeebze gadawyvetilebaTa stabilurobismaCvenebeli saapelacio sasamarTloebis mixedviTSTABILITY INDEX OF DECISIONS ON ADMISNITRATIVE CASES ACCORDING TO THECOURTS OF APPEAL2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011saqarTveloGEORGIA73.9 73.2 78.9 83.0 88.9 90.7TbilisiTbilisiquTaisiKKutaisi77.6 75.4 80.7 82.8 89.0 91.369.3 70.4 73.4 83.8 88.7 88.9%10073 3.977.669.373.275.470.478.980.773 3.483.082.883.888.989.088.790.791.388.9500wlebiYears2006 2007 2008 2009saqarTveloGeorgiaTbilisiTbilisi2010 2011quTaisiKutaisi29

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos administraciul saqmeTapalatis mier ganxiluli sakasacio saCivrebiCASSATION CLAIMS HEARD BY THE CHAMBER OF ADMINISTRATIVE CASES OF THESUPREME COURT OF GEORGIAsulTotal1sul ganxilulia sakasacio saCivari,Total number of cassation heard1845maT Soris Setanilia:Among them filed by:administraciuli organoebis mierAdministrative bodies7622345fizikuri pirebis mierNatural persons and legal entitiesdamTavrda administraciuli organoebissasargeblodAppeals resolved for the favor of administrative bodiesdamTavrda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodAppeals resolved for the favor of natural persons and legalentitiesdamTavrda morigebiTWere resolved through settlementdabrunda saapelacio instanciaSi xelaxlaganxilvisaTvisWere returned to the court of appeal for re-hearingmaT Soris:Among them:gadawyda administraciuli organoebis sasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of administrative bodiesgadawyda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of natural persons and legalentities10169242011 2010%41.3823 44.6146923460.8sulTotal144165955.1 74050.1 6863.733.366.765612813942%45.751.447.645.50.85.648.151.930

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos administraciul da sxva kategoriis saqmeTa palatismier ganxiluli sakasacio saCivrebi(2011 weli)CASSATION CLAIMS HEARD BY THE CHAMBER OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND OTHER CASES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF GEORGIA(2011)damTavrda morigebiTResolved through settlement0,8%(14 saqme/cases)gadawyvetilia fizikurida iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodResolved for the favor ofnatural persons and legalentities47,1%(869 saqme/case)gadawyvetiliaadministraciulimns organos sasargeblodResolved for the favor ofadministrative body51,3%(947 saqme/case)31

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos administraciul saqmeTapalatis mier sagadasaxado davebze ganxiluli sakasacio saCivrebi1 sul ganxilulia sakasacio saCivariTotal number of cassation heardmaT Soris Setanilia:Among them filed by:sagadasaxado organoebis mier2Taxation bodiesfizikuri da iuridiuli pirebis mierNatural persons and legal entitiesdamTavrda sagadasaxado organoebis sasargeblodWere resolved for the favor of taxation bodiessulTotalsulTotal3 damTavrda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodWere resolved for the favor of natural persons and legalentites137 53.9 101 45.54 damTavrda morigebiT 2 0.8 1 0.55CASSATION CLAIMS HEARD ON TAXATION DISPUTES BY THE CHAMBER OFADMINISTRATIVE CASES OF THE SUPREME COURTS OF GEORGIAWere resolved through settlementdabrunda saapelacio instanciaSi xelaxlaganxilvisaTvisWere returned to the court of appeal for re-hearingmaT Soris:Among them:gadawyda sagadasaxado organoebis sasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of administrative bodiesgadawyda fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebissasargeblodCases resolved for the favor of natural persons and legalentities25411911993172152011%46.946.936.66.711.888.22221002010%45.0108 48.6100 45.015 6.89 60.06 40.032

uzenaesi sasamarTlos administraciul da sxva kategoriis saqmeTa palatis mier sagadasaxado davebzeganxiluli sakasacio saCivrebi davis sagnis Rirebulebis mixedviTCASSATION CLAIMS HEARD ON TAXATION DISPUTES BY THE CHAMBER OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND OTHER CASES OF THE SUPREME COURT ACCORDINGTO THE VALUE OF THE SUBJECT OF THE DISPUTESmaT Soris davis sagnis Rirebulebis mixedviT (larebSi)Among them - according to the value of the subject of the dispute(in GEL)50000-mdeup to 50,00050000-dan 100000-mdeFrom 50,000 to 100,000100000-dan 500000-mdeFrom 100,000 up to 500,000500000-dan 1000000-mdeFrom 500,000 up to1,000,0001000000-is zeviTOver 1,000,000dava araa Tanxobrivi anTanxa araadakonkretebuli Either thesubject of the dispute is notthe money, or it is notspecifiedganxilulia sakasacio saCivari254 150 23 37 13 6 25m.S. Setanilia:sagadasaxado organos mier 119 93 6 12 1 7 the taxation bodyCassation claims heard, among themfiled by:fizikuri da iuridiuli pirebis mier 119 48 16 21 11 6 17 a natural person or a legal entityorive mxaris mier 11 5 1 4 1 both sidesorive mxare administraciuli organoa 5 4 1 both sides are administrative organssaqme damTavrda:The case is resolved:sagadasaxado organos sasargeblod 93 30 12 19 10 5 17 for the favor of taxation bodyfizikuri an iuridiuli pirissasargeblod137 102 8 17 2 1 7for the favor of the natural person orthe legal entitydamTavrda morigebiT 2 1 1 Were resolved through settlementdabrunda xelaxla gansaxilveladm.S.:gadawyda sagadasaxado organossasargeblodgadawyda fizikuri an iuridiuli pirissasargeblodsul ganxiluliaTotal heard17 14 2 12 1 115 13 1 1was returned for re-hearing,among them:was resolved for the favor of taxationbodywas resolved for the favor of a naturalperson or a legal entity33

administraciul pasuxismgebloba dakisrebul pirTa raodenobaadministraciuli samarTaldarRvevebis saxeebis mixedviTNUMBER OF PERSONS CHARGED WITH ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSIBILITY ACCORDING TO THE TYPES OF ADMINISTRATIVEVIOLATIONSadministraciuli samarTaldarRvevebis (as) saxeebi Nameof Administrative Violations2006daekisraadministraciulipasuxismgebloba2007daekisraadministraciulipasuxismgebloba2009daekisraadministraciulipasuxismgeblobaCharged with Charged with Charged with Charged with Charged with Charged withadministrative administrative administrative administrative administrative administrativeresponsibility responsibility responsibility responsibility responsibility responsibilitypiri piri piri piri piri piri%%%%%Person Person Person Person Person Person%1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 132008daekisraadministraciulipasuxismgebloba2010daekisraadministraciulipasuxismgebloba2011daekisraadministraciulipasuxismgeblobasul administraciuli samarTaldarRvevaTOTAL as Sromis dacvisa da mosaxleobis janmrTelobisdacvis dcv dargSiOther administrative violations in labor, health protection andcompulsory social insurance fieldm.S.: narkotikul saSualebaTa mcire odenobiT,daniSnulebis gareSe ukanono SeZena, Senaxva anxmareballegal purchase, keeping, use of small amount ofnarcotic substances saxelmwifo sakuTrebis xelmyofi asOther administrative violations related to the encroachmentof state propoertym.S.: saxelmwifo an sazogadoebrivi qonebiswvrilmani datacebaMinor misappropriation of state or public property as garemos dacvis, bunebaTsargeblobis, istoriisa Ada kulturis ZeglTa dacvis dargSiOther administrative violations related to the encroachmentof state propoertym.S.: tyis ukanono gaCexva da tyiT sargeblobiswesebis darRvevaViolation of rules of forest and the use of forest fund lands35835100.09381 26.221361536.0921325183608302725.70.070.0510.18.437841 100.0 28267 100.01309339272570222234.60.10.16.811592 41.01150531181640.70.010.006.427693100.07208 26.07106 25.19 0.039 0.033486 12.6268405.9 1298 4.6 2971 10.7 3606100.07571 28.227436 27.7171 0.6168 0.64141 15.413.422574 100.05817 25.85717 25.3321 1.42297 1.32645 11.71457 6.534

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 as mrewvelobis, eleqtronuli da Tboenergiisgamoyenebis dargSiAdministrative violations in the use of industrial,electric and thermal energy as soflis meurneobaSi; veterinarul-sanitaruli Awesebis darRvevaAdministrative violations in agriculture. Violationof veterinary sanitary rules as transportze, sagzao meurneobisa da AkavSirgabmulobis dargSiOther administrative violations in transport,road economy and communication as moqalaqeTa sabinao uflebebis, sabinaoAkomunaluri meurneobisa da keTilmowyobis dargSiOther administrative violations in the sphere of citizen'shousing rights, housing communal economy and organizationm.S. sazogadoebrivi adgilebiT sargeblobisSezRudva nebarTvis gareSeRestriction of use of public places without relevantpermit as vaWrobisa da finansebis dargSiOther administrative violations in trade and finance spherem.S.: mewarmis mier vaWrobis wesebis darRvevaVaiolation of trade (service) rules by an entrepreneur2182235753407491153756.10.11.62135611710.9 12050.225.41.01947365595.60.023.13.20.112.51.52347 8.3294930.1831 2.93571211.70.012.00.073985 14.455 0.21256 4.5372 1.3100.04739 2.727 0.11372 5.121 0.11740 6.5368 1.413 0.05514 1.922 0.084 0.0215 0.11140 5.1680 3.08 0.04871 3.924 0.11entitysoflis meurneobisproduqtebiT vaWrobis wesebis darRvevaViolation of the rules of trade with food and non-70.02120.0360.024 0.0116 0.066 0.03consumable itemsnavTobis ... distilatebis realizaciisada Senaxvis wesebis darRvevaViolation of rules of sale, transportation andstorage of oil… distillates1089 3.0 217 0.6550.181 0.397 0.421 0.135

gagrZeleba continued1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13samewarmeo saqmianobis wesis darRvevaViolation of rules of entrepreneurial activity894 2.5 616 1.6 223 0.8 360 1.3 172 0.6 581 2.6gadasaxadebTan dakavSirebulisamarTaldarRvevebiViolations related to the payment of taxes sazogadoebrivi wesrigis xelmyofi asOther administrative violations infringing public orderm.S.: wvrilmani xulignobaMinor hooliganism mmarTvelobis dadgenili wesis xelmyofi as39 0.1 13 0.033329 9.3 6925 18.32750 7.75481 14.5Other administrative violations of infringement of established 7257 20.3 5439 14.4 4687 16.6 5442rule of governancem.S.: savaluto operaciebis wesebis darRvevaViolaton of rules of currency transactionscecxlsasroli iaraRis SeZenis, Senaxvisda ... wesebis darRvevaStorage of weapons and ammunition andviolation of the rules of salesaqarTvelos moqalaqeebisa da ucxoelebisregistraciis wesebis darRvevaLiving in violation of established registration procedures27589845300.120.916.04 0.015141 18.64043 14.619.7346 1.21 0.002 0.015347 19.93736 13.95595 20.8150 0.4 55 0.1 8 0.03 3 0.01 1 0.0055828901.68.172351.90.013061.1874 3.35 0.025 0.025138 22.83611 16.05943 26.3786 3.5by Georgian citizens and foreigners living in Georgiasamxedro valdebulebasTan dakavSirebulisamarTaldarRvevebiViolations related to military obligations15314.323566.221637.72140 7.71688 6.31440 6.436

ganxiluli administraciuli samarTaldarRvevebis raodenobaI instanciis sasamarTloebis mixedviTNUMBER OF HEARD ADMINISTRATIVE VIOLATIONS ACCORDING TO THE COURTS OF FIRST INSTANCEmaT SorisjarimaAmong them:fineraodenoba piri piri% %Quantity Person Person1 2 3 4 5 6 7sul saqarTveloSi 24405 100.0 22574 100.0 18055 TOTAL FOR GEORGIAmaT Soris:Among them:Tbilisis saqalaqo 7335 30.1 6268 27.8 5415 Tbilisi CityozurgeTis Ggs 407 1.7 403 1.8 349 Ozurgeti GClanCxuTis ms 77 0.3 74 0.3 72 Lanchkhuti MCCoxatauris ms 83 0.3 82 0.4 69 Chokhatauri MCsul guriis sasamarTloebi 567 2.3 559 2.5 490 Total for GuriaquTaisis saqalaqo 1332 5.5 1294 5.7 1050 Kutaisi Citytyibulis ms 105 0.4 102 0.5 80 Tkibuli MCwyaltubos ms 522 2.1 520 2.3 446 Tskaltubo MCbaRdaTis ms 156 0.6 155 0.7 128 Baghdati mCvanis rs 135 0.6 131 0.6 115 Vani DCzestafonis gs 398 1.6 357 1.6 317 Zestaponi GCTerjolis ms 155 0.6 134 0.6 118 Terjola MCxaragaulis ms 148 0.6 137 0.6 126 Kharagauli MCsamtrediis rs 282 1.2 266 1.2 217 Samtredia DCsaCxeris gs 100 0.4 97 0.4 80 Sachkhere GCWiaTuris ms 175 0.7 171 0.8 119 Chiatura MCxonis rs 140 0.6 136 0.6 94 Khoni DCsul imereTis sasamarTloebi 3648 14.9 3500 15.5 2890 Total for ImeretiTelavis gs 914 3.7 877 3.9 641 Telavi GCaxmetis ms 124 0.5 87 0.4 87 Akhmeta MCgurjaanis ms 198 0.8 194 0.9 160 Gurjaani MClagodexis rs 340 1.4 331 1.5 312 Lagodekhi DCsagarejos rs 242 1.0 236 1.0 201 Sagarejo DCsiRnaRis rs 165 0.7 161 0.7 137 Sighnaghi DCyvarlis rs 232 1.0 217 1.0 161 Kvareli DCdedofliswyaros rs 166 0.7 160 0.7 128 Dedoplistskaro DCsul kaxeTis sasamarTloebi 2381 9.8 2263 10.0 1827 Total for KakhetimcxeTis gs 488 2.0 433 1.9 352 Mtskheta GCduSeTis ms 145 0.6 102 0.5 100 Dusheti MCTianeTis ms 99 0.4 84 0.4 78 Tianeti MCyazbegis ms 12 0.0 9 0.0 9 Kazbegi MCaxalgoris mssasamarTlosul mcxeTa-mTianeTissasamarTloebigamovlenilisamarTaldarRvevebiViolationsAkhalgori MC744 3.0 628 2.8 539 Total for Mtskheta-Mtianetiambrolauris gs 54 0.2 53 0.2 41 Ambrolauri GConis ms 63 0.3 61 0.3 30 Oni MC2011daekisra administraciulipasuxismgeblobaCharged with administrativeresponsibilityCourt37

1 2 3 4 5 6 7lentexis rs 14 0.1 13 0.1 10 Lentekhi DCcageris rs 55 0.2 52 0.2 51 Tsageri DCgagrZeleba continuedsul raWa-leCxumisa da qvemosvaneTis sasamarTloebi186 0.8 179 0.8 132Total for Racha-Lechkhumiand Kvemo SvanetifoTis saqalaqo 338 1.4 334 1.5 236 Poti Cityzugdidis rs 981 4.0 953 4.2 651 Zugdidi DCsenakis gs 606 2.5 606 2.7 234 Senaki GCabaSis ms 166 0.7 162 0.7 120 Abasha MCmartvilis ms 180 0.7 180 0.8 165 Martvili MCmestiis rs 49 0.2 59 0.3 39 Mestia DCwalenjixis rs 173 0.7 137 0.6 63 Tsalenjikha DCCxorowyus rs 210 0.9 205 0.9 162 Chkhorotsku DCxobis rs 266 1.1 255 1.1 199 Khobi DCsul samegrelosa da zemosvaneTis sasamarTloebi2969 12.2 2891 12.8 1869Total for Samegrelo and ZemoSvanetiaxalcixis gs 309 1.3 296 1.3 229 Akhaltsikhe GCadigenis ms 177 0.7 164 0.7 140 Adigeni MCaspinZis ms 115 0.5 106 0.5 95 Aspindza MCborjomis ms 494 2.0 443 2.0 404 Borjomi MCaxalqalaqis gs 117 0.5 103 0.5 97 Akhalkalaki GCninowmindis ms 54 0.2 53 0.2 36 Ninotsminda MCsul samcxe-javaxeTissasamarTloebi1266 5.2 1165 5.2 1001 Total for Samtskhe-Javakhetigoris gs 815 3.3 807 3.6 490 Gori GCkaspis ms 126 0.5 147 0.7 136 Kaspi MCxaSuris gs 515 2.1 490 2.2 385 Khashuri GCqarelis ms 57 0.2 54 0.2 53 Kareli MCsul Sida qarTlissasamarTloebi1513 6.2 1498 6.6 1064 Total for Shida KartlirusTavis saqalaqo 765 3.1 677 3.0 582 Rustavi Citybolnisis gs 179 0.7 170 0.8 144 Bolnisi GCmarneulis ms 319 1.3 313 1.4 259 Marneuli MCdmanisis ms 102 0.4 96 0.4 84 Dmanisi MCgardabnis rs 593 2.4 585 2.6 199 Gardabani DCTeTriwyaros rs 109 0.4 104 0.5 89 Tetritskaro DCwalkis rs 64 0.3 63 0.3 45 Tsalka DCsul qvemo qarTlissasamarTloebi2131 8.7 2008 8.9 1402 Total for Kvemo KartlibaTumis saqalaqo 973 4.0 937 4.2 813 Batumi CityqobuleTis ms 231 0.9 231 1.0 205 Kobuleti DCxelvaCauris gs 175 0.7 172 0.8 156 Khelvachauri DCxulos ms 114 0.5 113 0.5 106 Khulo DCqedis ms 71 0.3 64 0.3 62 Keda DCSuaxevis ms 90 0.4 88 0.4 81 Shuakhevi DCsul aWaris sasamarTloebi 1654 6.8 1605 7.1 1423 Total for Adjarasoxumis saqalaqoSokhumi Citygali-gulrifSis rs 11 0.05 10 0.04 3 Gali-Gulripshi DCsul afxazeTis sasamarTloebi 11 0.05 10 0.04 3 Total for Abkhazia38

gamoyenebuli administraciuli saxdelebiUTILIZED ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES2005 2006 20072008200920102011saxdelebis saxeebi raodenoba raodenoba raodenoba raodenoba raodenoba raodenoba raodenoba%%%%%%%Types of PenaltiesQuantity Quantity Quantity Quantity Quantity Quantity QuantitygamovlenilsamarTaldarRvevaTa 23008 40718 44591 32158 32007 32963 24405 Quantity of violationsraodenobapirTa ricxvi, romelTamimarT gamotaniliaNumber of personsdadgenileba (ganCineba) 22573 40357 44332 31936 31430 32526 24309chargedmaT Soris: among them:Sewyda 3618 16.0 4522 11.2 6491 14.6 3669 11.5 3737 11.9 3071 9.4 1124 4.6 terminateddaekisraadministraciulipasuxismgebloba18955 84.0 35835 88.8 37841 85.4 28267 88.5 27693 88.1 26840 82.5 22574 92.9with administrativeresponsibilitymaT Soris: among them:gafrTxileba 148 0.8 225 0.6 522 1.4 175 0.6 2213 8.0 215 0.8 57 0.3 preventionjarima 18088 95.4 32155 89.7 32172 85.0 23132 81.8 21008 75.9 22225 82.8 18055 80.0 finekonfiskacia 15 0.1 41 0.1 1 0.0 1 0.00 3 0.01 1 0.00 confiscationgamasworebelisamuSaoebi1 0.04 0.01correctional labouradministraciuli administrative703 3.7 3454 9.6 5102 13.5 4959 17.5 4471 16.1 4397 16.4 4461 19.8patimroba imprisonmentdakisrebuli Tanxaimposed amount5159.57 12030.59 13924.01 11332.17 10376.37 9716.23 8860.94(aTasi lari)(thousand GEL)amoRebuli Tanxawithdrawn amount222.76 1319.29 2186.06 3471.08 2174.04 2788.93 2708.36(aTasi lari)(thousand GEL)39