172 • BOOK OF LISTS <strong>2013</strong> Edition
Property and casualty insurance companiesRanked by net total nationwide direct premiums writtenRankPrev.rankCompanyAddress2011 net totalnationwide directpremiums writtenTop local executiveTitleWebsitePhone2011assetsliabilitiesF-T/P-T local employeesLocal/total locationsHeadquartersYear established locallyA.M. Bestfinancial ratingsize categoryPremium lines carried11 PENN NATIONAL INSURANCE2 N. Second St., P.O. Box 2361Harrisburg, PA 17105-2361$551.03millionKenneth R. ShuttsPresident and CEOwww.pennnationalinsurance.com717-234-4941800-388-4764$1.35 billion$897.53 million578/21/5Harrisburg1919A-IXBusiness insurance for small and midsizedaccounts; personal auto,homeowners/umbrella22 DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO.1195 River Road, P.O. Box 302Marietta, PA 17547-0302$217.42millionDonald H. NikolausPresident and CEOwww.donegalgroup.com717-426-1931888-877-0600$333.83 million$158.15 millionDNR/DNR1/1E. Donegal Twp.1889AIXFull property and casualty lines33 EASTERN ALLIANCE INSURANCE GROUP25 Race Ave., P.O. Box 83777Lancaster, PA 17608-3777$155.75millionMichael L. BogusiPresident and CEOwww.eains.com717-396-7095855-533-3444$301.67 million$204.8 million129/41/6Lancaster1997AVIIWorkers' compensation44 ATLANTIC STATES INSURANCE CO.1195 River Road, P.O. Box 302Marietta, PA 17547-0302$130.68millionDonald H. NikolausPresidentwww.donegalgroup.com717-426-1931888-877-0600$509.2 million$335.69 millionDNR/DNR1/1E. Donegal Twp.1986AIXFull property and casualty lines55 AEGIS SECURITY INSURANCE GROUP2407 Park Drive, P.O. Box 3153Harrisburg, PA 17105-3153$79.55 million Darleen J. FritzCEOwww.aegisfirst.com717-657-9671800-233-2160$85.45 million$41.92 millionDNR/DNR1/2Susquehanna Twp.1977AVIFire, manufactured homeowners, inlandmarine, motorcycle, auto, surety, accidentand health67 GOODVILLE MUTUAL CASUALTY CO.625 W. Main St.New Holland, PA 17557-0489$76.65 million Herman D. BontragerPresident and CEOwww.goodville.com717-354-4921$156.21 million$62.29 millionDNR/DNR1/1New Holland1926AVIIHomeowners, farmowners, personal auto,commercial, commercial auto, fire, liability76 PMSLIC INSURANCE CO.1700 Bent Creek Blvd.Mechanicsburg, PA 17050-1865$64.22 million Scott DienerPresident and CEOwww.pmslic.com717-791-1212800-445-1212$452.62 million$245.41 million85/01/1Silver Spring Twp.1978AXPr<strong>of</strong>essional liability88 MILLERS CAPITAL INSURANCE CO.805 N. Front St., P.O. Box 1246Harrisburg, PA 17108-1246$53.88 million Robert L. LyonPresident and CEOwww.millersinsurance.com717-232-3211800-745-4555$120.97 million$67.71 million47/21/1Harrisburg1890A-VIICommercial multiple peril, businessowners, workers' compensation, comm.auto, other liability99 LITITZ MUTUAL INSURANCE CO.2 N. Broad St., P.O. Box 900Lititz, PA 17543-7007$49.81 million Henry H. GibbelChairman and CEOwww.lititzmutual.com717-626-4751800-626-4751$181.65 million$65.81 millionDNR/DNR1/1Lititz1888AVIIIHomeowners, commercial, farmowners,liability, umbrella, fire, inland marine1010 WINDSOR-MOUNT JOY MUTUAL INSURANCECO.21 W. Main St., P.O. Box 587Ephrata, PA 17522-0587$25 million Michael R. KlinefelterCEOwww.windsormountjoy.com717-733-8648800-233-0228$53.66 million$18.93 millionDNR/DNR1/1Ephrata1982AVIFire and allied lines, farmowners,homeowners, comm. multiperil, ocean andinland marine, general liability, commercialauto physical damage1111 DAILY UNDERWRITERS OF AMERICA1076 Harrisburg Pike, P.O. Box 39Carlisle, PA 17013$13.09 million Robert F. LongPresidentwww.duoa.com717-243-5757800-788-5188$36.01 million$13 millionDNR/DNRDNR/DNRDNR1978AVTruck insurance1212 FARMERS FIRE INSURANCE CO.2875 Eastern Blvd., P.O. Box 20189York, PA 17402-0140$12.24 million Richard A. ReesePresident and CEOwww.farmersfire.com717-751-4435800-537-0928$25.62 million$12.57 millionDNR/DNR1/2Springettsbury Twp.1853A-VHomeowners, dwelling fire, commercialfire, commercial multiple peril, inlandmarine1316 EASTERN ATLANTIC INSURANCE CO.5300 Derry St.Harrisburg, PA 17111$7.81 million George A. ParmerPresident717-561-4495 $53.24 million$19.66 millionDNR/DNRDNR/DNRSwatara Twp.1986A-V1Surety1415 REAMSTOWN MUTUAL INSURANCE CO.20 S. Reamstown Road, P.O. Box 477Reamstown, PA 17567$7.12 million Matthew SchnaderManagerwww.rmins.com717-733-1221888-764-7232$6.13 million$4.15 millionDNR/DNRDNR/DNRE. Cocalico Twp.1895NRDNRHomeowners, mobile homeowners,farmowners, commercial lines, liability,umbrella1517 ELIZABETHTOWN INSURANCE CO.56 N. Market St., P.O. Box 228Elizabethtown, PA 17022-0228$4.23 million Brande BriggsAssistant VP andgeneral managerwww.e-townins.com717-367-1817800-736-8112$6.75 million$3.42 millionDNR/DNRDNR/DNRElizabethtown1843NRDNRHomeowners, fire, inland marine,commercial liability, farm liability1618 PENN CHARTER MUTUAL INSURANCE CO.2 N. Broad St., P.O. Box 900Lititz, PA 17543$408,943 Henry R. GibbelPresident and COOwww.pennchartermutual.com717-626-4751$8.22 million$1.08 millionDNR/DNR1/1Lititz1860A+VIIIHomeowners and fireDBA-doing business as DNR-did not respond NA-not applicable NR-not rankedThe Central Penn Business Journal's list <strong>of</strong> property and casualty insurance companies is limited to those based in or having a member entity based in or near Adams, Cumberland, Dauphin, Lancaster, Lebanon, Perry or York counties. Informationcame from the individual companies, Pennsylvania Department <strong>of</strong> Insurance, A.M. Best, the National Association <strong>of</strong> Insurance Commissioners and other Business Journal research. An A.M. Best rating is an independent third-party evaluation <strong>of</strong> aninsurer's financial strength that ranges from A++ (superior) to NR-5 (not formally followed). To access the Business Journal's online database, visit www.CPBJnow.com/ListCentral. Surveys available at www.CPBJsurveys.info; follow@CPBJListCentral on Twitter. Published July 20, 2012; updated Jan. 3, <strong>2013</strong>; next published July 19, <strong>2013</strong>.Researched by Alaine KeislingWhen it comes toDisaster Restoration,getting youback in businessis our business.AVAILABLE 24 HOURS A DAY, 7 DAYS A WEEK.EMERGENCY WATER MITIGATION • FIRE/SMOKE RESTORATIONON-SITE CARPET/WOOD FLOOR DRYING • ODOR REMEDIATIONCOMPLETE CONSTRUCTION & REPAIR NEEDSTRAUMA SITE RESTORATION • MOLD TREATMENTOWNED AND OPERATED BY THE MELLOTTS, SERVING CENTRAL PA FOR OVER 28 YEARSRestoring Peace <strong>of</strong> Mind.ServiceMaster <strong>of</strong> Greater Harrisburg & West Shore • 2506 Boas Street, Harrisburg PA 17103 • www.smharrisburg.com • (800) 545-8929BOOK OF LISTS <strong>2013</strong> Edition • 173