Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>April</strong> <strong>15</strong>, <strong>2016</strong> BUSINESSLINK<br />
<strong>15</strong><br />
Is a tipping<br />
point here?<br />
Kamil Lakshman<br />
Many articles later we are still on<br />
the same topic.<br />
Ethnic chefs are being targeted,<br />
and management degree holders<br />
are lurking in the back. Many have joined<br />
the bandwagon.<br />
They have caught wind of a nasty smell<br />
that is here to stay,but they do not really<br />
understand the extent and complexity of all<br />
of this.<br />
The norm that operates for a job offer,<br />
how it works and who all are involved.<br />
Disconnectedness and interconnectedness<br />
are at play but not obvious to many.<br />
Tinkering with policy<br />
Should we tinker with this international<br />
student policy? Is it possible that the income<br />
stream of a potential $ 5 billion industry is<br />
too lucrative to substantially alter?<br />
What has not been appreciated, which<br />
slowly is being, is the wide reaching consequences<br />
and issues.<br />
A drastic overhaul is needed. The current<br />
platform and environment has to go. A<br />
fresh start is needed. This is a big ask. The<br />
platform has to attract the student being<br />
recruited wanting an education outcome.<br />
As long as immigration outcome remains an<br />
incentive the breeding ground will prosper.<br />
Behaviour Pattern<br />
A certain behaviour pattern has become<br />
the norm. The consequences are portrayed<br />
daily in our newspapers, in the courts, in<br />
the number of companies unable to survive<br />
because of competition from unscrupulous<br />
operators who run unsuccessful businesses<br />
on paper, pay little taxes but lead a very<br />
comfortable lifestyle, have an outward<br />
appearance of success funded by such<br />
dealings.<br />
Those who have started out in this country<br />
as victims can potentially see this as an<br />
acceptable mode of behaviour and can go<br />
on to victimize another. A cycle given birth<br />
to which has a long life span cannot be<br />
encouraged!<br />
The bit that has concerned me greatly<br />
from the outset is the normality of it all and<br />
how acceptable it is. Some now see it as a<br />
norm. There is a certain level of resignation.<br />
It is the way it is and within the confines of it<br />
a solution is needed usually paying for a job.<br />
If the intention was for New Zealand to<br />
provide a superior education platform,then<br />
we would attract those seeking such a<br />
qualification. Education outcome would<br />
have been the focus.<br />
Export earner<br />
New Zealand now sees the international<br />
student market as an export earner. The<br />
business model and focus is no longer the<br />
provision of a world class education system<br />
but income. The international student policy<br />
is drafted so that the immigration outcome<br />
carrot enables to be dangled. This ensures<br />
a flow of international students. As long as<br />
this carrot is in place, associated with the<br />
need for a job offer, the drama will continue.<br />
One unfortunate outcome will be that<br />
good business operators who fit a certain<br />
profile will become subject to suspicion and<br />
likely to be smeared by the reputation of<br />
unscrupulous operators in their industry.<br />
New Zealand’s entire lifestyle is potentially<br />
endangered. There is so much at stake than<br />
is truly being appreciated! This appreciation<br />
will come with time. As they say, time is a<br />
great teacher.<br />
Supplied content<br />
Kamil Lakshman is a Lawyer & Principal of Wellington<br />
based law firm Idesi Legal Limited. She can<br />
be contacted on (04) 4616018 or 021-<strong>15</strong>98803. Email:<br />
kamil.lakshman@idesilegal.co.nz; The opinions<br />
expressed in her article above are her own and not<br />
that of Idesi Legal Limited or the New Zealand Law<br />
Society, or its Wellington Branch, or its affiliated<br />
bodies and committees or <strong>Indian</strong> <strong>Newslink</strong>.<br />
Readers can send their comments (names can be<br />
withheld) to editor@indiannewslink.co.nz<br />
Tax Loophole puts New Zealand to shame<br />
Dr Deborah Russell<br />
Loopholes in New Zealand’s<br />
trust law, highlighted by the<br />
so-called ‘Panama Papers’<br />
makes this country complicit<br />
in schemes to avoid tax.<br />
The massive document leak from<br />
Panamanian law firm Mossack<br />
Fonseca sheds light on New Zealand’s<br />
role as an international tax haven.<br />
It is shameful for New Zealand to<br />
be caught up in international tax<br />
avoidance.<br />
Inaction irritates<br />
The loophole in our laws that<br />
allows New Zealand foreign trusts<br />
to escape taxation has been known<br />
about for years, but nothing has been<br />
done to shut it down. This makes us<br />
complicit in schemes to avoid tax.<br />
While there is nothing illegal about<br />
minimising tax, there can be ethical<br />
implications.<br />
Taxation is the price of civilisation,<br />
and very wealthy people and companies<br />
who use extreme measures to<br />
minimise their tax are free riding on<br />
ordinary taxpayers.<br />
I believe that it would be comparatively<br />
easy to shut the loophole down.<br />
The loophole relies on New Zealand<br />
tax authorities not collecting and<br />
sharing basic information about<br />
foreign trusts.<br />
New requirements<br />
Trustees of New Zealand foreign<br />
trusts should be required to disclose<br />
the identities of the people putting<br />
property into the trusts, and benefiting<br />
from the trusts, and Inland<br />
Revenue should be authorised to<br />
share this information with other<br />
countries’ tax authorities.<br />
This would enable other countries<br />
to pursue people who are sheltering<br />
property and income in New Zealand<br />
foreign trusts.<br />
The only people in New Zealand<br />
who benefit from the foreign trusts<br />
loopholes are the tax consultants and<br />
trustee companies collecting fees<br />
from providing trustee services.<br />
Shutting down the loophole might<br />
reduce these fees, but it would also<br />
restore New Zealand’s reputation for<br />
being corruption free.<br />
Dr Deborah Russell is a Taxation<br />
Specialist at Massey University<br />
School of Accountancy. Picture<br />
Courtesy: Massey News.